00:01:49.800on whether that's a good thing or not, right?
00:01:51.780Like, I think that, you know, I heard your take on it, Drew, and I think it was basically the same take as my take on it, which I think was also-
00:01:59.080But you were more enthusiastic, I thought.
00:02:01.960You were more enthusiastic, I thought.
00:02:03.120I like Nolan better than you guys like Nolan.
00:02:06.680Yeah, I mean, but as a piece of morality, what he was trying to do thematically is obviously he was taking sort of the ghost of Christian morality and pouring it into the vase of a Greek story.
00:02:19.380because, I mean, and I think we all sort of agree with that.
00:02:22.400I thought that that's like kind of a good thing
00:02:24.480because again, if you wanted, I think, well, listen,
00:07:56.880And this is a matter of tactics, which I think will appeal to you, Noles, because you're
00:08:00.020very big into, you should launch wars that you can win.
00:08:03.320You should not launch wars that you're going to lose.
00:08:05.460okay like this movie was always going to make a fortune because it is beautiful to look at
00:08:09.720and the last one hour of it is actually incredibly well done and exciting even if you think that the
00:08:14.460first couple hours are slow the last hour of it is really compelling and the and and it's
00:08:18.380Christopher Nolan and he's got every major star in the world in this film it was always going to
00:08:21.520do big business and so this kind of bizarre thing that the right did which is like Ellen Page's in
00:08:25.560it therefore will do no money and therefore anyone who even says that they kind of like it must be
00:08:29.820cast out must be thrown out of the like what are what are you doing like just on a tactical level
00:08:34.760It's a category error though, because it's not like putting that clown trans guy on a beer can, which is essentially endorsing the fact that he's wearing woman face and really disrespecting women by pretending to be one. These are actors. They're all nuts. They all have like weird lives and all that. They go on and they pretend to be someone else. That's part of the arts. I mean, the women, men were playing women in Shakespeare's day. You know, they've done it before. It's like,
00:09:04.760it's part of the arts the arts are weird and they're crazy it's not the same thing as selling
00:09:09.300beer or selling some object so the entire thing is ridiculous what is is ellen page because she's
00:09:15.080got problems she's never supposed to work again i don't care if she's in a movie as long as she's
00:09:18.600i didn't think she was very good in this but i think you know i don't mind her working what's
00:09:22.900that what's that got to do with me why i also i have a kind of straussian take on this and it's
00:09:29.460like that the esoteric reading is always the line between that and wish casting is very very thin
00:15:35.700that's actually a pretty complicated legal question
00:15:37.420because the question is sort of what the Fifth Amendment is for.
00:15:39.840The typical idea is that you do not have a right
00:15:42.580against self-incrimination for a crime
00:15:44.120that you cannot be convicted of, right?
00:15:46.660So can you take sort of a preemptive fifth,
00:15:48.880meaning that he knows that the whole thing here
00:15:51.480is going to be what he considers to be perjury traps, right?
00:15:53.460People asking him questions to get him to conflict
00:15:55.340with testimony that he gave at other times.
00:15:57.420Does his pardon cover his testimony from other times or testimony that he gives now that conflicts with testimony that he gave at other times?
00:16:06.040The chances that you get a successful prosecution for perjury or for violation of the use of the Fifth Amendment,
00:16:13.120you get a contempt that amounts to jail time, congressional contempt, probably difficult, I think.
00:16:19.560I feel like that's a bit of a stretch.
00:16:21.400So I don't think the calcium markets are wrong on that one.
00:16:23.560it does go to show you that this is not a man who is eager to speak exactly with the Senate.
00:16:29.260I understand why he's suspicious that every Republican is chomping at the bits, put him in
00:16:33.160jail. I think that it does say something that he's unwilling to answer literally any of the
00:16:38.520questions, given the fact that his diaries are out there. And we now know that many of the
00:16:42.740suspicions that people held about him for years have been now fully justified by the insane stuff
00:16:47.880that's in his diaries. Those diaries are crazy, by the way. That's wild stuff.
00:16:50.440they're delightful they're really funny i i love the i love julia likes me you know
00:16:55.740i'm saying i'm saying to those it's like watching a 14 year old girl in a pink fluffy pink dress
00:17:02.080dancing around the room going i'm so beautiful i'd be the prince will love me i'm going to the
00:17:05.680well because the diary did i mean it was things like i got a really beautiful picture on the
00:17:10.200washington post today my hairline was looking really really good love gossip girl or whatever
00:17:15.940You know, and it was like all of it was the whole diary. But nothing's going to happen.
00:17:20.540The one thing I want to see, though, Knowles, I want to see I want to see I don't care whether he goes to jail.
00:17:25.160He's an old man. I don't I really don't care what happens to him.
00:17:27.760I want to see a reckoning for what the media did and how they contributed to this incredible disaster.
00:17:34.420Really the worst failure of leadership since World War I that killed the economy, that sent these poor poor children, these poor poor children into a tailspin in their education that will never be caught up with.
00:17:48.880And every time Donald Trump opens his mouth about the election that he feels he won, the press reports, oh, you know, this unfounded claim is always unfounded in the reporting of Trump talking.
00:17:59.640But what about the unfounded claims about Hunter Biden's laptop? What about the unfounded claims about where the virus came from? What about the unfounded claims of Russian collusion? The reckoning that we have had for the utter failure of our media class and our leadership class and our elite class just hasn't come.
00:18:16.440is kind of dribbling out over time because people saw it. They're not going to be lied to.
00:18:21.640And so the trust in our institutions has vanished as it should have vanished. Our institutions
00:18:26.000failed us. But why can't we just bring it out into the open and talk about it so that it like
00:18:31.060rip the Band-Aid off and have the reckoning and fire the people who need to be fired, rejigger
00:18:35.000the press that needs to be rejiggered instead of this kind of slow bleed where the press is
00:18:39.500pretending, is hoping it's all going to go away. It's not going to go away. As Ben was just saying
00:18:44.140in a show. It's a new world where they're not going to be able to hide.
00:18:47.860Here's the thing. I think that the press already paid the price. I think that the press
00:18:50.720is basically a defunct institution. That doesn't mean that they can't have impact.
00:18:55.520But what has happened to the press over the course of the last three years is catastrophic.
00:18:59.880I mean, truly catastrophic. The ratings do not exist on CNN. Many of the major institutions
00:19:04.480have been taken over by people who the press disagrees with overtly. Here, I'm thinking of
00:19:08.300CBS News, obviously. There have been some significant change. Jeff Bezos has reshifted
00:19:13.480even the editorial page of the Washington Post.
00:19:16.880I think there are two things that, to me, are the dogs that never barked.
00:19:19.860One is, how is it that we are still playing ball with China?
00:19:23.120I mean, like, the real story about COVID, I understand that we botched it.
00:19:26.980So did pretty much everybody else on Earth.
00:19:28.840Okay, like, the only country that didn't really botch it particularly badly was Sweden.
00:19:32.920And pretty much everybody else botched this thing pretty horribly.
00:19:35.740And on a state-to-state level, people botched it at sort of different levels.
00:19:38.660But you understand that, you know, dealing with a once-in-a-century pandemic where nobody
00:19:42.520knows what to do. People make mistakes on both a governance level. The thing with Fauci is that
00:19:46.220he knew what he was doing, right? That's what makes what Fauci did so terrible, is that he
00:19:49.360knew exactly what he was doing when he was going after Jay Bhattacharya and the Great Barrington
00:19:53.460Declaration, or when he was shutting down investigations into Wuhan. How China has been
00:19:57.860able to get away with unleashing a virus on the planet that killed legitimately 5 to 10 million
00:20:01.380people planet-wide. And somehow, they just keep on trucking, and nobody says anything about it.
00:20:06.440And the president even said they're trying to steal our election. He's still not really doing
00:20:09.140anything about it. That's one dog that didn't bark. And the other dog that didn't bark,
00:20:11.800I got to say it because it just happens to be true. One of the reasons President Trump lost
00:20:16.100the 2020 election is because he really did not handle this well. Anthony Fauci was a Donald
00:20:21.600Trump appointee. Hey, Donald Trump could have fired Anthony Fauci at any minute. And he would
00:20:25.660go on Truth Social or X at the time because he wasn't banned yet. And he would rip into Anthony
00:20:30.240Fauci. But he worked for President Trump. If President Trump wanted to fire him, he could
00:20:35.180have fired him. And so I think that because he didn't. And again, I understand why he didn't.
00:20:39.040There are all sorts of political cross. I get all of that. But in the end, if you're the president and the guy works for you, it is very difficult for you then to be the lead attack point against the guy who you kept employed the entire time and you were using as sort of your figurehead as you tried out COVID policy.
00:20:53.440I think the argument you made before, though, about the leaders who didn't see it coming and they didn't quite know what it was and they were afraid and they panicked, all of that applies to Trump a lot more than it applies to Fauci and a lot more than it applies to the press, whose job it is to ask questions and to say, is that true and how do we compare these two ideas?
00:21:13.560and instead hounded Jay Buttigieg from pillar to post.
00:21:16.820I mean, what they did to him was absolutely disgusting.
00:21:20.580Look, I agree that the minute Trump won the second time, the press was doomed.
00:21:24.740And I think that never happened to a nicer institution.
00:21:28.300But I do think, like, we still have not had the conversation at the level of, like, you know, this is what went wrong.
00:21:34.640This is what we ought to do next time.
00:21:36.880I'm ashamed of the churches that let themselves be shut down,
00:21:40.040Especially, you know, those Catholic churches that let them be shut down, that denied the host, you know, to people, that denied the body and blood to people and didn't have the guts to just say, as what his name did in California, I'm staying open, I don't care what you do to me.
00:21:54.780And a lot of failure around the board, and I just don't think we've really discussed it on a national level yet.
00:22:00.340It was amazing to see, especially for the non-sacramental shades of Christianity, they can say, well, it doesn't matter, the church isn't a real place, it's just kind of in the air and we can watch it on TV or whatever.
00:22:13.440But for those who have sacramental theology, notably including the Catholic Church, you need the sacraments.
00:22:18.860And I remember in L.A., when some of the churches were going real weak-kneed and shutting down or trying to change things, there was this old, he was kind of a left-winger, but he was this really old Dominican priest who, it was 92 or something, he was still hearing confessions from the side door of the church because he knew that you can't do that.
00:22:38.660You know, he was of a certain generation that just understood you need to be there for people, especially at moments of crisis.
00:22:44.640And I think you're right, Drew, that we've had this national and international trauma that we're recovering from still.
00:22:51.520And that's why you need the reckoning.
00:22:52.620It's just the problem is, OK, we're going to go humiliate Tony Fauci on Capitol Hill.
00:23:01.480Well, you know, one of the things that I think that has been under discussed is is the failure of forget about the reckoning from, you know, people like us who many of us were critical of Fauci very early on.
00:24:09.820Which is not the same proposition, right?
00:24:11.740We should be skeptical of the experts, and we should ask them difficult questions, and we should force them to wall-in-demand, all those things for sure.
00:24:17.860But the contrapositive of that, to distrust the experts, is not trust the non-experts, which is, I think, where so many people ended up going.
00:24:25.600And that really is kind of a dangerous thing.
00:24:27.720And I think that if the scientific community wishes to get back on the horse here, they're the ones who need to do this.
00:24:35.660It doesn't need to be Republicans who are grilling Anthony Fauci.
00:24:37.820It needs to be members of the scientific community who are grilling Anthony Fauci, as opposed to doing what they are doing today, which is relighting their Anthony Fauci votive candles.
00:24:47.120I mean, over at MSNBC, they really were.
00:24:49.440They were doing this whole, like, we're in mourning.
00:24:51.140It was so terrible how Anthony Fauci was treated.
00:24:53.380If you guys had asked those questions, maybe we could have come back to some sort of scientifically-based rigor.
00:24:58.100But you're not asking those questions.
00:24:59.640So, you know, the consequences are a complete reactionary shift in a direction that, frankly, I don't think is universally wonderful.
00:25:06.420And, you know, by the way, when Anthony Fauci, hold on one second, Drew, I want to hear what you have to say, but I just want to point out that when Anthony Fauci was lying down on his bed, kicking his feet in the air, writing down, Dear Diary, I'm still beautiful.
00:26:34.740Yeah, you know, especially with this uprising from the DSA, I was talking to Molly Hemingway
00:26:39.740last night, and she and I are the only two people who say, you know, the only difference
00:26:43.700between the DSA and the Democrat Party is the DSA, the socialists are honest.
00:26:48.060They're like, we hate your country, we're going to destroy it, where the Democrats run
00:26:51.220on the policy that they're going to be moderate, and then they hate the country.
00:26:54.080Then when they win, they hate the country and they want to destroy it.
00:26:56.380But the lack of information about socialism and what it does and how it works, there is now no source in the country that young people can trust or feel they can trust to become educated.
00:27:10.580They don't, you know, the guys, most of these kids who are voting for socialists, they have no idea what they're voting for.
00:27:15.120They've never read a book about socialism.
00:27:17.900They've been taught in college if they went to college that socialism is great.
00:27:21.620The level of induced ignorance in the country is so high.
00:27:26.040And now, who can you turn to to get just an honest, here's the news, this is what happens, this is what happens when you have socialism?
00:27:33.160I know who you can turn to, Drew, if you want to get the promotion of socialism.
00:27:37.740Well, you can turn to us, but if you want to get the kind of pro-socialist side, you can turn to Evan Barker, our guest, who is the author of Nothing Left.
00:27:46.420Yeah, we have a socialist on the show.
00:33:52.480Those are actually the features that we on the right will say things like, well, you know, Mondani's only popular.
00:33:58.180You see Jon Stewart do this, and he's not on the right, but he's sort of more traditionally left.
00:34:01.580He'll say, you know, the reason Mondani's popular among DSA types is because of his talk about affordability and all the rest of this stuff is just sort of the chaff.
00:34:09.600The real wheat is the affordability argument.
00:34:11.920And I've been saying for a while that that's nonsense, that actually the affordability is the stuff that allows dupes like Jon Stewart to swallow the medicine.
00:34:18.140But but the actual thing that most people who are sort of DSA aligned are into is the grievance politics.
00:34:23.400It is the anti-Americanism. It is the sort of radical victim victimized or oppression matrix.
00:34:30.040Yeah, I think I I think that is I could not put that more aptly.
00:34:34.440I think that's exactly right. It's just it's just it's grievance politics.
00:34:42.400You know, I actually I lost my brother on the USS John McCain in 2017.
00:34:48.860That was actually another little thing that I that I read about in my book actually was huge thing.
00:34:54.760But it was, you know, I when I went to AOC's office for the first time in 2018 to visit her, it was about a month after she won her election against Joe Crowley.
00:35:07.580and I went in and I found these like American flag uh stickers and I know this might seem this
00:35:14.760might seem insignificant to some it was they were crumbled up it's like somebody intentionally took
00:35:20.740them and crumbled them up and just threw them at the bottom of the garbage can and I remember
00:35:25.900reaching down I was about a year after I'd lost my brother and I was like I was about to go visit
00:35:31.560his kids. And I pulled them out of the trash can. And I was like, you know, it was it was just it
00:35:37.540was a constant thing. You know, I would be behind the scenes on campaigns. And, you know, they would
00:35:42.640be so reactive to Donald Trump that they would want to just like immediately blast out emails,
00:35:47.680you know, anytime Trump, you know, did any sort of military action in the Middle East. And I
00:35:55.100remember one time there was a threat actually towards U.S. troops abroad. This was back in
00:36:01.340I think it was around 2019, 2020, and they were sending out fundraising emails. And I was like
00:36:08.040the only person around that was like, you guys, you don't know what's going on with our troops
00:36:14.040right now. What are you doing? Why are you trying to make money off of this? You should just be
00:36:19.940saying that you're praying for them and nothing else. And they don't love America.
00:36:25.700Yeah, they're open about it. And I think all of these things.
00:36:27.880If you, like, speak to them directly, like, if you get them after a drink or so, they are pretty candid.
00:36:32.500I don't think we're slandering them at all here.
00:36:51.480Heāthat 31,000 number went up to almost a million New Yorkers.
00:36:55.920And not only did he say he's going to take their property, he doxed them.
00:37:00.280After whipping up the mob against these people, he put out their names and addresses and more or less said, go get them.
00:37:07.440And you just think, oh, wow, this is not about helping poor people.
00:37:10.840It's really just about hurting rich people.
00:37:13.360It's not, you know, it is like just profoundly unpatriotic.
00:37:17.780What drives me nuts about this, by the way, is that, you know, my family back in the Midwest, my mom, like she's really struggling right now.
00:37:25.220I've had to pay for her rent or help her with her rent the last couple of months.
00:37:30.000And, you know, if I asked her about Zora Mamdani and like what she thinks of his policies,
00:37:34.640what she thinks of free grocery stores, she hates it.
00:37:37.300Even if she's like struggling to pay for her groceries right now, like she thinks government
00:37:42.140run grocery stores are like an absolutely terrible idea.
00:37:45.320If you ask her like what she thinks about Elon Musk or Jeff Bezos or any of those guys,
00:39:34.580like these days, they're all in for Abdul El-Sayed
00:39:36.860and think that Haley Stevens is terrible.
00:39:39.440So I think that the base of the Democratic Party is honestly just really fed up with the establishment. And they have a reason to be mad at the establishment. The establishment has lost many times now to Donald Trump and has lost pretty key elections.
00:39:56.580But I think because the progressives, the DSA wing, are the only built-in alternative that they have, unfortunately, it means they are looking to them as their answer to countering Donald Trump.
00:40:11.800But I think that this is completely misguided and will actually push them in an even worse direction.
00:40:17.440Evan, you know, one of the things I started out as on the left, too, and one of the things that
00:40:22.080changed my mind was that just the revelation, the one thing all liberals know is that right-wingers
00:40:26.500are evil. And when I started to realize, oh, they're not evil and start to question their
00:40:30.060ideas, their ideas were pretty good. Is there anyone on the right that you think, yeah,
00:40:33.740I would vote for this guy? Here's a conservative or Republican that I would vote for.
00:40:38.980So, okay. So I do consider myself an independent now. I did vote for Trump in 2024.
00:40:45.020Let's go. I've already done it. Love that. I voted for Trump in 2024. I, you know, I like he's a moderate in policy. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I'm from Missouri. I really like the center of Missouri, Josh Hawley. There's still some Democrats I like to, though. So, you know, it really it just depends on the person.
00:41:08.720I just, I think that the Democrats have,
00:41:10.960you know, they've just gone so far to the left.
00:41:13.820Like if Kamala Harris is the nominee in 2028,