The National Telegraph - Wyatt Claypool - November 08, 2026


Carney Falls in Polls as Bad Economy Hurts Liberals Ahead of By-Elections!

Nenshi's Political Career IS OVER!

Episode Stats


Length

16 minutes

Words per minute

170.33

Word count

2,795

Sentence count

101

Harmful content

Toxicity

6

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.000 There is a lot of drama surrounding one of the six by-elections coming up on December 7th.
00:00:06.440 Brantford-Brant-South is the riding of former MP Larry Brock, who resigned just a couple months ago,
00:00:12.800 and the narrative around this by-election is, if the Conservatives cannot hold Brantford-Brant-South,
00:00:19.480 Pierre Polyev's leadership could be at risk.
00:00:22.440 But good news for the Polyev Conservatives, the Kearney Liberals are starting to see significant declines in their popularity,
00:00:30.000 in the latest abacus data survey for the past three months the carney liberals have been
00:00:35.520 artificially popular after carney walked away from the trade negotiating table and starting
00:00:40.880 fighting with donald trump again it's just true that the trump issue is really good for the carney
00:00:46.240 liberals so carney walked away from the table back in august making him like the hero of the day for
00:00:53.120 at least a few months but now economic reality is starting to catch back up to the liberals and
00:00:58.880 after multiple bad job reports the liberals are starting to decline by quite a bit and that is
00:01:04.960 even before the survey takes into account the federal budget as well as the spiking immigration
00:01:10.880 numbers check out the latest national numbers from abacus data here yes the carny liberals are still
00:01:18.000 significantly ahead of the poly of conservatives but the trend line is clear here that the liberals
00:01:24.560 are starting to slough off large chunks of the lead they had over the poly of Conservatives.
00:01:30.100 In the latest poll, the Liberals are at 45%, Conservatives are at 34%, NDP at 9%,
00:01:36.340 Bloc Québécois at 8%, Greens at 3%, and People's Party at 2%. My general rule is if the PPC are
00:01:42.960 above 1%, give whatever is above 1% to the Conservatives because they're just not going
00:01:48.280 to achieve that level of support in the next election. Anyways, yes, the Liberals are leading
00:01:53.940 by 11%, but what you'll notice on the right side of the screen here is the change since their last
00:01:59.840 survey in late October. The Liberals have fallen 3% since late October, and the Conservatives have
00:02:06.840 gained 2%. The Bloc Quebecois have also gained 2%, which is highly significant because, as we all
00:02:12.740 know, the Bloc Quebecois only run in the province of Quebec. So between the Conservatives and the
00:02:18.400 Liberals, that's a five-point swing. And if you're not aware, this survey that just came out was
00:02:24.580 conducted between October 30th and November 4th, meaning that it did not take into account the
00:02:31.280 release of the October job numbers, and it also didn't take into account the federal budget that
00:02:36.960 has been absolutely going up like a lead balloon. The massive deficit attached to it, as well as
00:02:43.380 the spiking immigration numbers are not going to make the liberals more popular. In fact,
00:02:49.460 it's actually giving a lot of ground over to the poly of conservatives to be pushing their
00:02:54.100 economic agenda as well as their newly discovered more hawkish anti-immigration positions. The
00:03:01.200 liberals are actually hurting a lot on the immigration issue these days. It's always been
00:03:05.380 a more conservative leaning issue. It's basically immigration is to the conservatives what Trump is
00:03:11.820 to the liberals the conservatives are wildly more trusted on immigration just as the liberals are
00:03:18.940 wildly more trusted on the issue of dealing with donald trump and his administration
00:03:24.060 but remember the midterm elections just happened on november 3rd and the democrats swept both the
00:03:30.540 house and the senate meaning that trump as an issue to most canadians is going to decline
00:03:36.060 significantly meaning that it's going to move over to issues like the cost of living even more
00:03:42.140 and things like housing health care as well as immigration all issues where the conservatives
00:03:49.020 actually have a big advantage except for something maybe like health care which is an issue that
00:03:53.820 usually splits multiple different directions in just a second here we're going to go into some of
00:03:59.260 the some more of the numbers especially on individual issues but first i just want to
00:04:04.140 to remind you guys if you like the show make sure to leave a like on the video subscribe if you are
00:04:09.520 not yet a subscriber and if you want to support the show more by giving a few dollars a month
00:04:13.880 you can always hit the join button below and sign up to become a member of the channel that
00:04:19.020 contributes a little bit each month to make the channel more sustainable for me but now let's
00:04:23.960 jump over to some of the issue polling because it's really interesting just how much Carney and
00:04:29.380 liberals have declined in terms of their popularity on individual issues even before some of the
00:04:35.300 biggest shoes just dropped a few days ago this is the result that really got my attention and
00:04:42.820 it was something that david coletto the man who leads abacus data also highlighted when he released
00:04:48.820 his polling numbers check out these trend lines for government approval on these different issues
00:04:54.980 Now, Canada-U.S. relations, and remember, all of these percentages are overall net approval.
00:05:02.080 So when it's a negative, it's because there is more people disapproving than approving.
00:05:05.740 And if it's a positive number, it's because after you add together approval and disapproval, approval is still above water.
00:05:13.320 But look here at just to give you a basically a consistency or a constant.
00:05:18.260 Canada-U.S. relations, Carney and the Liberal government's approval had slipped from 29 to 26.
00:05:24.980 Not really significant. These polls usually have between 2% to 4% margins of error, especially on issues like this.
00:05:33.080 There'll probably be a little bit of a higher error rate than not.
00:05:36.500 So we could say, effectively, that's not a big change.
00:05:39.800 You can see back in August 2026, the Liberals were at 18% net approval on Canada-U.S. relations.
00:05:51.040 And after that, which is after Mark Carney walked away from the trade negotiating table and started fighting with Trump again, he jumped up to 30.
00:05:59.080 And since then, it's been only a very sluggish decline because, overall, it is a good issue for Carney and the liberals.
00:06:05.620 But that's not the one that's interesting.
00:06:07.620 That's just our constant demonstrating that, yes, it is still a liberal-friendly crowd.
00:06:12.920 We're not only surveying conservatives here.
00:06:14.940 If anything, the poll's probably leaning a bit more liberal than reality at the moment.
00:06:21.040 But check out some of these other results.
00:06:23.440 The green line under the red line is jobs and the economy.
00:06:27.660 The Liberals have been going up each month up to this point from August, September, and October, going from positive 8% up to positive 15%.
00:06:37.940 But now they've gone down from 15% back down to 8% in a single month, a change of 7% on jobs and the economy.
00:06:47.840 The blue line under that is the federal deficit and government spending.
00:06:50.720 And now remember, this poll was conducted before the federal budget even came out that's demonstrating that we are now spending more money paying for the interest on the national debt than we actually are in terms of our health care transfers to the provinces.
00:07:06.800 The Liberals back in October were at a 2% net positive approval rating on the federal deficit and government spending.
00:07:16.540 They've declined at 7% as well on this one, down to negative 5%, so they are now below water on that issue.
00:07:24.000 Back in October, the Liberals were at negative 3 on the housing issue, and now they are negative 10, also dropping by 7 points.
00:07:32.720 And on cost of living, they've gone from negative 15, already not a good issue for them, to negative 19%.
00:07:40.720 That's absolutely disastrous for the liberals, considering this was before the latest October job report came out.
00:07:48.540 It may have technically came out the same day, but information coming out the last day of a survey isn't really going to affect the numbers too much.
00:07:57.380 Watch for these, the next Abacus Data report that comes out, to drop even more.
00:08:02.720 Now, on Canada-US relations, the Liberals are probably remaining pretty good, but the problem is, it's not that can Conservatives convince Canadians that they should trust them more on Donald Trump and his administration, it's more how many Canadians make that a big issue.
00:08:19.180 It's an issue the Conservatives will never beat the Liberals on in this lifetime, and nor do they have to because Trump's only president for another two years now.
00:08:28.000 What the Conservatives want people to do is move their top issue away from President Trump and his administration and towards things like immigration.
00:08:39.040 Check out this chart of Canadians' top issues.
00:08:41.960 And the way Abacus Data does it is that you pick three issues as your top issues, and then you will see in this chart the percentage of Canadians who made that issue a top three issue for them.
00:08:52.500 So right now we are seeing rise of cost of living is chosen by 63% of Canadians as a top issue for them, probably often occupying somebody's number one or number two issue based on how front of mind it is for some Canadians.
00:09:08.640 Second is sort of a similar answer.
00:09:11.080 The economy, 38% of Canadians choose the economy as one of their top three.
00:09:14.900 And this is out of lots and lots of options.
00:09:17.320 I actually believe the options are even more than on this chart, but some things barely
00:09:20.680 get mentioned by people, so it doesn't even make the chart.
00:09:23.620 But after the economy, Donald Trump and his administration is chosen by 38% of Canadians
00:09:29.560 as one of their top three issues.
00:09:31.380 And no doubt, there are a lot of retired CBC watchers who make it their number one issue
00:09:37.220 because they don't really care about the job market or the economy.
00:09:40.640 They're living perfectly comfortably. 0.98
00:09:42.660 And so they're able to indulge in these dumb luxury views 0.96
00:09:46.340 about whether or not Donald Trump is going to invade Canada 0.95
00:09:49.720 or is he calling it Lake Ontario or Lake America?
00:09:53.060 There are sort of political hobbyist voters who watch mainstream news all day
00:09:57.440 who really obsess about Trump,
00:09:59.500 even though he doesn't really have that much impact
00:10:02.380 when it comes to Canadian politics other than their histrionic reactions to him.
00:10:06.840 But back when the liberals in the advocacy data surveys were only leading by like 2% or 3%, or even back in December 25, they were actually trailing the conservatives by 1% or 2%.
00:10:18.860 The Trump and his administration issue was only cited by people as, you know, maybe 24%, 23% of people are making it one of their top three issues.
00:10:29.060 So 38% is a significant, how do you say that word?
00:10:36.600 Why am I forgetting the word?
00:10:38.140 It's extremely elevated right now compared to what it was a year ago.
00:10:42.640 But you then go down to housing affordability and accessibility, 32%, healthcare, 31%.
00:10:49.220 And very, very surprising to see immigration at 24% of Canadians saying it's a top three issue.
00:10:57.680 A year ago, or even six, eight months ago, that was maybe rated by 13% or 14% of Canadians as one of their top three issues. 0.96
00:11:06.900 It's gone from 14% to 24%, which is reflecting why the Polyef Conservatives are hammering on it so much. 0.85
00:11:14.520 It's a bit of a sort of a both-and sort of reason why it's elevated. 0.90
00:11:20.060 It's elevated because it's just naturally become a bigger issue for Canadians,
00:11:24.280 and it's also elevated because the poly of conservatives have really picked up that issue
00:11:29.100 and pushed back on the liberals hard on their mass immigration plans and the new federal budget
00:11:34.700 makes it even worse for the liberals remember this survey came out before the federal budget
00:11:40.960 was tabled where they're going to be increasing permanent residencies handing out 200,000 permanent
00:11:47.360 residencies to tfws and all this other garbage that's going on that is going to hurt the liberals
00:11:52.780 a lot. Now, the conservatives in somewhere like Brantford, Brant South, they are going to do
00:11:58.940 really well if they really push on both cost of living as well as immigration. It's a riding with
00:12:04.980 a lot of trades workers, a lot of people who have gone, you know, done college, but not sort of like,
00:12:10.740 you know, liberal arts university. So pushing on these populist, pushing on the sort of populist
00:12:17.280 position on immigration will pay dividends in that riding i do want to show right now
00:12:23.840 if an election were to happen today based on 338 projections which i don't put too much weight into
00:12:30.160 but we should at least look at it as a potential alarm bell here in brantford south the liberals
00:12:36.960 currently based on the national polling and regional polling for ontario have a 67 chance
00:12:43.040 of taking the riding and the conservatives only have a 33 chance of taking it despite the fact
00:12:48.960 that larry brock in 25 had won this riding by above 10 percent that this is a bit of a do or
00:12:57.680 die situation for pier poliev do i personally think polio should step down if the conservatives
00:13:02.960 lose this by-election i would just say it doesn't really matter if the caucus's perception is that
00:13:09.280 he can't stick around if you've lost brantford brant south that kind of ends things caucus can
00:13:14.720 vote in order to basically remove him as leader if enough people end up signing a letter requiring
00:13:21.360 a vote in caucus to be held i believe it's like 12 or 18 it's some percentage like that of people
00:13:27.520 who have to sign the letter before you actually trigger an internal caucus uh vote if the
00:13:33.200 conservatives hold on to this writing i think it gets rid of any more leadership challenges for
00:13:37.520 If he loses, it's really up to caucus at that point of how hard they're wanting to push in order to maybe change leaders. That is why I do want to plug, if you live in Brantford, Brant South, please get a lawn sign for Kevin Davis. I am putting a link to the lawn sign sign up for that riding pinned at the top of the comments as well as in the description below.
00:14:00.820 And I'm going to say this right now. The Conservatives did mess up the nomination process in this area. They came in and they appointed the mayor or the former mayor of Brantford when they should have held a nomination. And one of the guys who was kind of messed over by that decision is running as an independent here.
00:14:19.460 I can't blame him.
00:14:20.560 I'm not going to condemn him for doing that.
00:14:22.220 He was wronged, and he's wanting to run as an independent.
00:14:25.820 At the same time, I don't think it's going to be very helpful for the conservative movement in general to throw at Pierre Polyev right now.
00:14:33.400 So, at the same time, I'm saying get a lawn sign for Kevin Davis, the conservative candidate in that riding.
00:14:40.040 Also, shame on the conservatives for bungling this process so badly that you now have an independent challenger.
00:14:46.920 Maybe he would have won, maybe he wouldn't have won a nomination process.
00:14:50.320 But have a nomination process.
00:14:53.520 You cause yourself so many extra problems by not having nominations and ticking off your local support base.
00:15:00.840 This guy might be able to pull off 6%, 7%, 8% as an independent candidate.
00:15:05.120 Is that going to be helpful for winning the riding?
00:15:07.540 Well, we thought Kevin Davis was going to be more likely to win.
00:15:10.100 Well, how is that working out now?
00:15:12.620 I want Kevin Davis to win this riding.
00:15:14.680 And frankly, as long as the person wasn't a liberal, I'd want the conservative candidate
00:15:18.940 here to win.
00:15:19.980 But now it's causing a bunch of headaches that they weren't willing to have a nomination
00:15:23.740 and they appointed people after promising that they were going to have a nomination
00:15:27.980 previously.
00:15:29.480 Don't do this in the future, guys.
00:15:32.480 Come on.
00:15:33.340 This is what I experienced when I tried to run for federal nomination.
00:15:36.580 I was artificially kicked out of the race because they didn't want me to win and they
00:15:39.820 wanted another guy to win and it caused a bunch of dumb drama on the ground rather
00:15:44.460 than either being up front with with who you want or just letting the process take place it's all 0.98
00:15:51.180 stupid but i will still say if you're in the writing please get a lawn sign because at this 0.68
00:15:57.100 point it is just true that we don't have time for the drama at the moment even though i'm still 0.99
00:16:02.540 acknowledging that exists and people are right to feel pissed off if they do anyways so with all
00:16:08.620 that being said thank you guys for watching this video like share subscribe do all that fantastic
00:16:14.220 stuff and i'll see you all later