The National Telegraph - Wyatt Claypool - October 14, 2026


Liberals Blow Themselves Up on US Trade And Steel - Carney's Approval Drops!

Hosted by
Mentioned
"He Failed" - Carney SLAMMED For Trump Trade Deal Promise! Carney BLEW IT For Canada - CBC Ramps Up Trump Fear Mongering Again!

Episode Stats


Length

18 minutes

Words per minute

172.15

Word count

3,241

Sentence count

128

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

11

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:01.000 Right now, the Mark Carney Liberals still significantly lead the Poly of Conservatives in the polls,
00:00:07.220 but I think over the next few months we are going to see the national polls tighten significantly
00:00:12.120 because the Liberals' political narratives are falling apart.
00:00:16.460 You see, you can only blame Trump and the Americans for so many things for so long
00:00:22.200 until Canadians start to get annoyed with the tactic,
00:00:25.260 especially if they or a family member start to lose their jobs.
00:00:30.360 You can't blame Trump for everything when you're also doing nothing to actually fix the problem,
00:00:36.340 especially if you're Mark Carney and you marketed yourself as the Trump whisperer who is going to get a trade deal with him.
00:00:43.540 Carney has walked away from the trade negotiating table multiple times now.
00:00:49.260 Unlike Mexican President Claudia Scheinbaum, who's always muscled through and tried to get the best deal for her country,
00:00:56.300 Carney, every time he gets slightly annoyed about something or asks for something last minute and it gets rejected,
00:01:02.380 rather than saying, okay, let's meet again next week and we'll try and keep hashing out the problems,
00:01:07.440 he just walks away to benefit his own personal approval ratings and the polling numbers of the liberals.
00:01:14.160 But it now looks like all that's wearing off.
00:01:16.220 And a canary in the coal mine issue was the way they tried to throw Stelco Steel under the bus.
00:01:22.880 They tried to go after this company for temporarily laying off 500 steel workers.
00:01:28.720 I can't really blame the company.
00:01:30.480 There is a 50% tariff on Canadian steel.
00:01:33.640 A lot of Canadian steel mills have a significant amount of their business in producing steel for the United States.
00:01:40.080 So if you're not doing that anymore, you're not just going to keep people employed for fun.
00:01:44.320 and that's not because we don't care about those workers, it's just business.
00:01:48.720 You just cannot simply have people being paid to not produce anything.
00:01:53.380 If Carney really cared about these jobs,
00:01:55.480 he would have been actually trying to push for a trade deal
00:01:58.360 that would significantly lower or eliminate the tariffs on steel.
00:02:02.980 Except instead, he cares about letting the Chinese government dump steel in Canada
00:02:08.220 rather than actually try and sideline China
00:02:11.540 in order to get a good deal exclusively with the United States. 0.99
00:02:16.060 Here today, we had Melanie Jolie at a press conference 0.99
00:02:20.000 where she had to walk back her insane lawsuit threats against Stelco
00:02:24.880 because despite the fact Canada lost 110,000 jobs over the last two months,
00:02:31.440 19,000 jobs in manufacturing alone,
00:02:34.740 they tried to make this entire situation about Stelco not being patriotic enough.
00:02:39.800 They were going to go through years of litigation over a temporary layoff
00:02:45.040 that is mostly due to the fact that they refused to actually deal with the Trump issue properly.
00:02:51.180 Check this out.
00:02:54.080 What's going on with Stelco now?
00:02:56.060 They say they're going to proceed with the layoffs,
00:02:58.020 and they don't believe they've broken any undertakings.
00:03:00.060 You talked about full force of the law.
00:03:01.820 So what are you going to do now that they're basically calling your bluff?
00:03:04.540 Well, first and foremost, we expect Stelco.
00:03:09.800 to follow the undertakings uh that they've committed to uh uh to the government of canada
00:03:15.960 and um right now a business decision or even a change in market conditions cannot be used
00:03:25.800 to not follow their commitment so we're reviewing the stelco letter but let me be clear they were
00:03:31.480 supposed to by the way it's wednesday they were supposed to take them to court on tuesday
00:03:35.320 The Stelco CEO, I believe it's a different company that's the, you know, the umbrella corporation that he's the CEO of, but, you know, by proxy, he's also the head of Stelco.
00:03:45.000 He went out and said that, no, we've never signed a commitment that we had to ever keep a certain level of employment.
00:03:52.120 And the idea that that, even if they did, that you wouldn't be able to lay people off if market conditions change is absolutely ridiculous.
00:04:00.560 As Mark Warner, the trade lawyer on the CBC, pointed out, then the Canadian economy is basically a suicide pact if you ever invest here.
00:04:09.580 If you invest here, if a significant tariff hits your industry for a major export hub for you and you cannot produce goods for them anymore or sell to them, no, no, no.
00:04:19.380 You must keep every employee that you have.
00:04:23.180 Nobody is allowed to be laid off. 0.92
00:04:24.720 It's like, that's obviously ridiculous.
00:04:27.340 but she is walking back here because clearly they talked way too tough about an issue that they 1.00
00:04:32.900 didn't understand and they look like a bunch of hypocrites and they look like they're just making 0.81
00:04:37.640 excuses by going after Stelco while every other area of the economy is also losing jobs. By the 0.98
00:04:43.600 way they even laid off a bunch of education and health care workers publicly so what are we
00:04:49.060 talking about? Are you guys not supposed to keep those people employed but Stelco is?
00:04:54.140 Under Section 40 of the Investment Canada Act, a few possible outcomes of a court process can lead to financial penalties towards the company, forcing them to abide by the commitment, and also a forced divestiture.
00:05:15.040 So, forcing them to sell their Canadian assets.
00:05:19.280 Everything is on the table.
00:05:20.380 Oh, everything's on the table.
00:05:23.580 they're actually going to do the NDP thing and try and nationalize Stelco over 500 temporary layoffs
00:05:31.600 because Carney is too scared to negotiate with Trump.
00:05:35.240 That is what all of this comes back to. 0.98
00:05:37.520 Carney is a intellectual coward who doesn't want to negotiate with Trump 0.88
00:05:42.680 because Carney sees himself as this sophisticated world leader of the European elite. 0.95
00:05:51.320 And him negotiating with Donald Trump, this rube from New York City development, that is just lowering himself too much.
00:05:59.840 And he doesn't want to talk to Trump.
00:06:01.300 But we're going to take Stelko to court and potentially threaten to nationalize them, force a divestment of their company,
00:06:09.600 and sell it to the Canadian government or some other partner of the Canadian government,
00:06:13.580 because they won't keep people employed despite the fact that much of their production cannot be sold right now because of the tariffs.
00:06:20.720 This is just economic fascism. The government starts quotas, tells you how many employees you must hire, how much you must produce, and what you can sell it for and how much profit you can keep.
00:06:31.280 But it's still a private firm in name only, but the government tells you exactly what you have to do every step of the way.
00:06:37.780 Therefore, I'm always open to sit down with the company and find a solution, but we're looking at everything that is possible to keep jobs in Canada.
00:06:49.840 I'm saying that what Canada's actions are, they are tantamount to election interference.
00:07:04.000 You briefly said in there that you didn't want to comment, but he did call you out by name.
00:07:08.240 So I want to ask, is it fair for him to say that what Canada's doing is election interference?
00:07:12.500 Absolutely not. And we'd never do that. And we'd never accept that also being done to us in Canada.
00:07:20.420 Indeed, I've been to the U.S.
00:07:22.540 Basically, what the question was there was that the American government has called out the Canadian government.
00:07:28.000 I actually believe that was Howard Lutnick saying that the Canadian government is interfering in American elections by through many of the actions of their own of their own government officials,
00:07:40.000 including people like Anthony Housefather, who literally campaigned directly on the ground with a Democrat, that they are interfering in American elections,
00:07:47.260 which is far more significant than the recent claim the Americans are trying to interfere in the Alberta independence referendum
00:07:54.680 because some independence guys went to Michigan to talk to a GOP strategist and it went absolutely nowhere.
00:08:01.000 In the past months, as many of my colleagues, I've been to Boston engaging with the governor there.
00:08:08.740 I've been also to Illinois and also engaging with the governor, J.P. Pritzker, there.
00:08:19.080 I've been also to NASA in Florida, engaging also with the administrator at NASA
00:08:27.880 and meeting with state representatives.
00:08:30.720 I've engaged with Democrats and Republicans.
00:08:34.140 Fundamentally, what I've done in the U.S. is to attract investments.
00:08:36.960 and i but how many investments have we gotten we've literally still been losing more investment
00:08:42.340 dollars from canada than we've been bringing in and as mark warner and other people point out
00:08:46.940 what is the sense in punishing stelco right now for bad economic conditions that mark carney and
00:08:53.940 the liberals are significantly responsible for because outside of the trade conflict
00:08:58.780 canada was already not a great investment because of the terrible taxes and regulations in this
00:09:04.020 economy. The tariffs were just a cherry on top of what was not a very good Sunday to begin with.
00:09:11.940 The liberals think that they can keep blaming everything on the Americans while they're not
00:09:16.660 actually trying to do anything to solve the problem. And I've been very happy to see the way
00:09:21.000 that that that Pierre Polyev has been dealing with this issue. I think he's been getting a lot
00:09:26.380 more aggressive on it recently. And then we're going to jump into some polls that show how much
00:09:31.260 this sort of, uh, the Trump issue is now sliding for, uh, Mark Carney. So, here, Polly over here
00:09:36.980 says, Trump is tough to deal with, but Mark Carney should have known that when he made a promise in
00:09:41.980 the election to get a good deal with the U.S. He made the promise, he broke that promise. The U.S.
00:09:47.160 tariffs have more than doubled and broadened on Canadian businesses since Carney took office,
00:09:52.200 promising he could handle Trump. Everything is worse. Canadians can eat, can't eat speeches or
00:09:57.640 pay rent with his political theatrics. It's time for results. And I think this is a good moment
00:10:02.780 for the conservatives to stiffen their necks. Anyone who goes after you for defending the
00:10:07.660 Trump administration, that can easily be waved off. Because you're saying, I'm not saying I
00:10:12.520 like the tariffs. I'm not saying that Trump's right in any way. I'm saying he said he could
00:10:17.140 solve it, and he's not even in the room trying to do anything. He's just sitting here saying,
00:10:21.800 oh man, that Trump guy's really tough to deal with. It's like, really? Maybe you should let
00:10:26.780 poliev be prime minister instead right now because at least you'd actually try and focus on the
00:10:30.960 things that matter not walking away from the table over the u.s apparently rejecting a exemption on 0.92
00:10:38.040 tariffs for evs just the sort of product that carney started letting the chinese dump into the 0.77
00:10:43.320 canadian economy to the tune of tens of thousands of chinese evs per year and then like it's just 1.00
00:10:50.400 ridiculous why would they want to sign a deal on lower steel tariffs right now while we are letting 0.99
00:10:56.420 the Chinese dumps a cheap steel into our economy that if there was no tariff on Canada could start 0.95
00:11:02.440 getting shipped over the border into the United States even if the Americans had a direct tariff
00:11:08.480 on China because it would just be relabeled a Canadian product once it hits our shores. It's
00:11:13.280 not saying I like the tariffs from the United States. Obviously not. I'm saying these are their
00:11:18.680 red lines and we need to deal with them. But Carney's red lines are like opposite and delusional
00:11:24.860 that he wants to be able to do as much with China as possible
00:11:28.140 despite calling them a national security threat
00:11:30.640 he wants to protect our censorship laws
00:11:33.680 and then he wants to maintain our supply management system
00:11:37.500 absolutely despite the fact that it only kind of benefits
00:11:41.180 a small minority of farmers in Canada
00:11:43.560 but now I want to move on to some of these polling numbers
00:11:46.240 because this was quite interesting
00:11:47.600 in the recent abacus data polling
00:11:51.400 the liberals are still ahead by 12 points
00:11:54.560 I actually believe that. It's probably a little overheated these days because of the Trump issue,
00:11:59.380 but the Trump issue does help Carney whenever it's in the headlines.
00:12:03.220 The problem is, the Trump issue is cooling off quite significantly.
00:12:09.260 David Coletto here points out,
00:12:11.120 One of the most interesting findings in our new poll, concern about Trump is fading slightly.
00:12:16.300 46% have identified Trump as top issue in early September, 44% late September, today 40%.
00:12:24.080 Still a major concern, but no longer quite as dominant.
00:12:27.220 And I think in the next couple of months, we could see this being in the low 30s, if not the high 20s.
00:12:31.840 And then it's not really a great environment anymore for Mark Carney.
00:12:36.880 Whenever he can get the Trump issue into the 40s or higher, he's doing well.
00:12:41.060 When it starts slipping, that's when the polls start tightening significantly.
00:12:45.660 And here's another interesting finding from the next, from the poll from Abacus Data.
00:12:52.240 Again, despite the fact that Liberals are still doing well, which is, again, just kind of a holdover from what the current news cycle is and all the Trump stuff,
00:12:59.640 but as the job numbers and all the failures on the domestic economy front start hitting,
00:13:05.020 I think you're going to start seeing the polling numbers for the Liberals decline significantly.
00:13:09.600 David Cleto here points out,
00:13:11.180 Mark Carney remains Canada's most positively viewed federal leader, but the gap is narrowing.
00:13:16.180 Net impressions.
00:13:17.420 Carney is at a plus 26 net approval rating, but that's down 5% since the last one they did in late September.
00:13:25.240 Polyev has actually increased by 4, and he's now at a negative 8, and Avi Lewis is at negative 11.
00:13:30.820 I actually think Avi Lewis is also going to start seeing an uptick in his approval rating over time,
00:13:35.880 because despite being the NDP leader and being anti-Trump, Carney is viewed as not Trump.
00:13:41.660 And if you're not Carney, then you are somehow pro-Trump, even if you're Polyev or Avi Lewis.
00:13:48.860 Now, neither of them are like pro-Trump tariffs, obviously, but because they're not Carney and Carney's the one being viewed as fighting Trump, that is what hurts their approval rating significantly.
00:13:58.980 It's not because people actually dislike Polyev.
00:14:01.060 This whole narrative that, oh, Canadians just hate him.
00:14:03.740 Yes, hardcore liberals hate him.
00:14:05.260 Most people just trust Carney on Trump, and anyone who's not him rubs people the wrong way.
00:14:12.360 But if it starts kind of getting out there and more people start absorbing the fact that Carney's doing absolutely nothing significant to actually get a deal or to fight for Canada,
00:14:21.780 and he's actually been enabling Trump's tariffs over time, that will start to dig at his approval ratings and start boosting Polyev, Lewis, and the polling numbers for both the Conservative Party as well as the NDP.
00:14:35.020 Anyways, I believe there was something else I wanted to hit on here.
00:14:37.840 I just had to quickly find it.
00:14:40.240 Okay, yes, I found it, and I thought this was just another really good attack line on Mark Carney right now.
00:14:46.360 Pierre Polly here highlights this chart that I saw Kirk Lubomov put out yesterday,
00:14:50.760 and it says,
00:14:52.300 Food bank demand in Toronto is up 300% since Carney became the economic advisor to the Liberal government.
00:14:59.620 It was worse since he became Prime Minister.
00:15:01.580 he says affordability is the best it's been in over a decade he's out of touch canadians are out
00:15:06.160 of food so check this out he's pointing out in 2021 he became the economic advisor to justin
00:15:13.280 trudeau these are visits to the toronto food bank or to the food banks in toronto since 2021
00:15:19.600 or it actually goes back to 95 but we're seeing like you know 2015 when harper uh was still the
00:15:26.120 prime minister you know the visits to the food bank are probably around 800 000 a year or so
00:15:31.420 in 2021 it was around you know probably 1.25 you know one and a quarter million and now as of the
00:15:41.120 year 2025 at the end of the year 2025 and it's probably gotten worse since then 4.1 million
00:15:47.380 visits of the toronto area food banks since mark carney and mark carney is now prime minister
00:15:54.160 the financial wizard the guy who knows how to do business and worked at goldman sachs and
00:15:59.920 Brookfield Asset Management. It's like, yes, he's good at accepting subsidies, but once he's
00:16:07.340 actually the Prime Minister, there's no way of subsidizing an economy into success. He's off
00:16:12.920 in India right now trying to sign some sort of economic deal with them, but all these things
00:16:18.000 that they're running on, or the Liberals are trying to do, is things that are not going to
00:16:22.320 happen for years at the very least, and the actual impact in shifting Canada's overall trade or
00:16:28.700 export mass the portion of our exports is very very minimal you're just not going to replace
00:16:35.960 america with india or china or europe it's just not possible we have them over our southern border
00:16:43.020 why are we not bending over backwards to try and get a trade deal that does not mean you sign
00:16:48.540 anything but what it means is that you focus on the things that you want i.e low tariffs and you
00:16:54.880 drill on that that is what you do you just focus on the low tariffs and you don't get distracted
00:17:00.560 by anything about the french language or censorship laws or china figure out those things later i don't
00:17:07.780 even like the censorship policies get rid of bill c11 and bill c18 in my opinion but if you did care
00:17:13.340 about them figure it out later first secure people's jobs because no doubt by the end of
00:17:19.740 August we're going to see more significant layoff numbers in the Canadian economy and at that time
00:17:26.100 I don't think Canadians are going to be in the mood for another speech over Mark Carney's desk 0.95
00:17:30.940 on YouTube about how you know remember the war of 1812 man those Americans suck don't they it's 0.90
00:17:36.860 like okay sure maybe I don't really care what are you doing to fix it because obviously you cannot 0.88
00:17:43.740 subsidize us out of this problem how are you going to achieve a trade deal he can't say well
00:17:49.520 I don't want to put that out publicly. It could hurt our trade negotiating strategy. We're not
00:17:54.640 negotiating, so how are we hurting your strategy? Because it seems like doing it all privately
00:17:58.660 hasn't been working up to this point. I would actually like things to be done in public so we
00:18:03.600 know what each side is walking away from the table for over, what they object to, what they approve
00:18:09.940 of, because I have no clue where Mark Carney is on any of this, and he seems to not be taking it
00:18:15.200 very seriously, although his minister, Dominic Leblanc, in charge of U.S.-Canada trade, is
00:18:21.360 suddenly starting to speak more nicely about the Americans again, signaling they probably do want
00:18:25.680 to get back to the table. But before we do that, let's have a coherent list of things we actually
00:18:31.260 want and things we don't necessarily need if we're trying to get something signed.
00:18:36.580 Anyways, with all that being said, thank you guys for watching this video. Make sure to like,
00:18:42.200 share, subscribe, consider hitting the join button and becoming a monthly contributing
00:18:45.980 member of the channel, and I'll see you guys all next time.