The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters - September 30, 2026


Reform Is Going Down

Hosted by
Mentioned
PREVIEW: Brokenomics | Elites don’t understand their own system with James Cox Breakfast With Beau | Thursday 1st October 2026

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 12 minutes

Words per minute

191.58

Word count

13,937

Sentence count

—

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

15

sentences flagged

Hate speech

38

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hi folks, welcome to our latest political chat. I'm joined by Dan and we're going to be talking about how Reformer just going down.
00:00:06 This is a plane that has had severe damage to its engines and is just waiting to finally land. I don't think it's going anywhere.
00:00:15 I mean, it would be dark for me to point out, but that's the second time Farad has been in that situation with a plane that's going down.
00:00:21 That is quite dark. I hadn't even thought that way. Will for us survive twice.
00:00:26 yes uh anyway so let's let's begin with the polls and they're not great for anyone except
00:00:31 restore britain weirdly enough who are up to five percent in the poll of polls which is uh i think
00:00:37 not is it the new high or oh yeah this because there was one poll back here yes that had them
00:00:42 on six percent but there are many more polls now where restore britain are polling and that's been
00:00:46 going up as you can see the greens and the limb dems have been going down and andy burnham has
00:00:51 been eating the greens up labor are on 26 on average reform on 23 and conservatives
00:00:57 struggling away on 19 so the interesting thing with the the sort of political system we've got
00:01:03 at the moment we've got we've got a two-party political system with six seven parties in it
00:01:06 yeah and and basically it just doesn't work so increasingly these numbers are telling you a lot
00:01:12 less and i'm sure you're going to come on to the youtube data so not youtube the uh you gov data
00:01:16 yes i saw that got a bit excited downloaded all the underlying tables and started having a proper
00:01:22 look at them and running a few regression analysis on it in my own modeling and interestingly when
00:01:27 you're in this sort of situation with it being split across so many parties you'd be surprised
00:01:31 the minimum number of votes you actually need to win an election at this point
00:01:35 in fact i worked it out go on you can win an election with this setup with 8.4 percent of the
00:01:42 vote yeah because for anyone doesn't know britain has a first pass the post system where we've got
00:01:47 650 constituencies uh that each each is its own independent universe when it comes to voting
00:01:53 so if you won say if if there were five different parties that were vying for this constituency and
00:02:00 each one won about 15 of the vote if you got like 17 of the vote you could win yes and that could
00:02:08 happen in enough constituencies for you to form a government of 350 plus uh mp i mean on my
00:02:15 analysis i i assumed perfect efficiency so basically that means that you don't get any
00:02:21 votes at all in 324 seats and the other 326 seats you get a majority of one vote yeah and and for
00:02:29 actually you need a tiny amount of votes to win an election in this kind of thing yeah i mean
00:02:33 realistically 20 could be a government in waiting well i mean the key thing is it no longer really
00:02:41 i mean it matters to an extent who's got the biggest number actually the thing that matters
00:02:46 more is where concentrations yes and this has been i mean this is why the liberal democrats
00:02:52 are on 70 mps despite never really breaching what was it 14 in the polls something like that
00:02:57 yeah there we go 14 in the polls we go back three years let's see yeah we go back to the last
00:03:02 election yeah i mean yeah oh there we go the last election so yeah you can see it there so
00:03:06 the liberal democrats got a lower vote share than reform um but reform got significantly less seats
00:03:14 than the lib dems because the lib dems are more efficient in their vote yeah uh because they're
00:03:18 they're deeply concentrated in mostly the southwest of england so anyway uh going going back to where
00:03:23 we are um the burn and bounce has put them above the reform party presumably because they've
00:03:29 siphoned away uh people from the greens yeah and i think honestly a lot of this i'm not going to
00:03:34 focus on the greens today we can do another thing about the greens another day but it seems to be
00:03:38 zach polanski himself that is actually now the lead weight around the greens neck which is
00:03:45 interesting because his personal popularity and i said this at the time all we need is for the
00:03:51 public to learn who zach polanski is and have some interaction with zach polanski i mean
00:03:55 unfortunately has he has a twitter account exactly and so yeah and that's a great point
00:04:00 at first his twitter account was the thing that was lifting the greens up yeah that's only because
00:04:06 wide-eyed impressionable young women were actually watching what he had on it as soon as he got the
00:04:10 slightest bit of attention no no but also because his opponent was kissed armor right it was it was
00:04:15 that but it was also okay he he can't convert the unconverted but what he can do is gather the
00:04:20 faithful from kirstama because kirstama was the right wing of the labor party uh zach polanski
00:04:25 was just running on full lefty nonsense okay that works if you're having an internal left-wing
00:04:30 debate about which party you should join when that's when the wider country is exposed to 0.95
00:04:35 zach polanski and his lunatic opinions oh no i do not like this guy at all of course you don't
00:04:41 and so the greens uh i mean 11 is not bad or anything like that so you know it's not not the
00:04:45 worst it could be but it's not great and i don't see how whilst we have a left-wing labor party
00:04:51 the greens can make any further headway um anyway right so let's let's let's move on
00:04:57 this is what uh you gov found as you said uh it would look like if an election were held tomorrow
00:05:03 and this is why and we've called it we've said it repeatedly we don't think annie burnham is going
00:05:07 to call an election because i mean not only every time annie burnham is asked he says no i don't
00:05:11 one election but at the moment he's got 410 MPs he will not be able to replicate that success
00:05:18 when we get into I mean because you very kindly let me add a couple of graphics uh in a bit of
00:05:23 this when we get into what the coalition building would actually look like on the other side of an
00:05:27 election like this it would be absolute torture so I mean look at that just look at that map
00:05:32 why what kind of coalition could you build from this well that's the question I come ready to
00:05:37 answer and it's a really painful one i bet it is i bet it is i mean wait does anyone have
00:05:45 enough like so if you've got labor and the liberal democrats that's only uh 312 seats so basically
00:05:53 you need to add up all of the all of the nominee left-wing ones so i think conservative reform get
00:05:59 you to 253 yeah to be sure of passing everything you need labour lib dems s&p play cum ray and
00:06:08 green you need all of them god or i mean there are some alternatives i'll get into it in a bit
00:06:13 but there are some alternatives but it is that is a brutal map though if you're andy burnham you
00:06:18 don't want that no no no god no a massive majority yeah but it's a massive majority that you inherited
00:06:25 from keir starmer yeah it's far more preferable god you get nothing done like this no you wouldn't
00:06:31 and actually there is there is some um i mean some some deeper underlying points that are worth
00:06:35 picking out on this i mean for a start a third of all the constituencies that were modeled
00:06:40 are within five points yes meaning that very small changes from here let's assume that you
00:06:47 got this 100 accurate that is actually what britain is today and i hate to tell people this
00:06:52 but you go on one of the most accurate pollsters in the country so yeah if you get very small
00:06:58 shifts in behavior and we're talking about the five percent level of five percent of people in
00:07:02 the country changing their mind a little bit a third of those seats just go sideways yeah to
00:07:08 something completely different and two-thirds of reform constituencies are within five points
00:07:13 so they so they are doubly elastic when it comes to small movement in polls so let's say we get a
00:07:20 general election three years time and we only shifted from this only six percent of people
00:07:25 have changed their mind it i mean it could look like anything yeah i mean you could get if you
00:07:31 got just a few more percentage points of people who previously didn't vote coming into the vote
00:07:37 yeah all that yeah this whole thing shifts and and and significantly so i mean the point is as
00:07:43 we keep saying uh our two-party political system was not designed for six seven parties it just it
00:07:49 goes completely sideways yes so for anyone wondering this is this is the worst kind of
00:07:54 hung parliament um the uh the the by the way they're still not prompting for restore britain
00:08:00 on you go polls yeah as basil here uh checked out but there was another interesting one from
00:08:05 more in common which uh they gave their assessment which is not terribly dissimilar
00:08:12 to uh you gov i mean it's it's still the same sort of shattered map they have a little more
00:08:19 reform i think yeah a few more reforms the only difference with the more in common one is that
00:08:23 instead of a third of seats being within five points they've got half of seats being within
00:08:27 five points so everything is absolutely razor thin at the moment yeah and i i think it's fairly safe
00:08:33 to assume that is actually the case i mean just judging by the mood of the country from our own
00:08:39 personal experience it seems that way um brutal but again absolutely brutal uh and then you have
00:08:45 another one from electoral calculus
00:08:47 which has the much more
00:08:49 favourable to the Conservatives on this one
00:08:51 but what do
00:08:52 what's the notable thing about electoral calculus here 0.98
00:08:55 they put reform in third
00:08:57 place
00:08:58 yeah
00:08:58 that is rough
00:09:02 I mean for a guy who thought that all he had
00:09:05 to do was tread water for five years
00:09:07 and then he would be Prime Minister to be reduced
00:09:09 to this I mean what and and we were talking
00:09:11 about this before we before we went on air
00:09:13 we've called out the errors as he's been making them on the podcast on this particular show
00:09:18 it's quite obvious when he's making a mistake but he keeps on making them and he just can't
00:09:23 stop doing it i don't know why he's not quite seeing the picture well i mean going back to
00:09:28 the polar polls second uh it'd be nice to have an extra five percent in the polls well yeah nigel
00:09:34 five percent in this setup is everything i mean it literally literally is absolutely everything
00:09:41 as well as we've been saying these are all within literally margins of a few percentage points and
00:09:47 this would have kept reform comfortably ahead in all of the polls if he just hadn't kicked
00:09:55 rupert low out yeah this unforced error and and the thing is right i mean we we know lots of people
00:10:01 in this sphere and there's people that and last election we were in this sort of slightly
00:10:05 difficult position where you know we wanted uh farage to win because he's the great hope for
00:10:10 the right but at the same time we kind of knew loads of people who he treated really poorly over
00:10:15 the years i mean kathleen lebraith we've had on the show uh your friend joel batten yes stephen
00:10:20 wolf who's a presenter here and literally dozens and dozens of other people but and we have this
00:10:28 weird um discontinuity in our mind it's like okay well we kind of want him to win because we need
00:10:33 we need a right winger to win but at the same time it's like why does he keep treating people
00:10:37 like this and and when he did that to rupert who was kind of impeachable unimpeachable unimpeachable
00:10:43 yeah it it just it just broke the straw and it's like no he's he's gonna keep being a snake forever
00:10:50 yes and also he's gonna be he's gonna keep being like a soft lefty forever as well yes which is
00:10:56 very frustrating i mean his he frames everything in the left's yeah world view yeah i mean we know
00:11:02 what a welshman is thank you yeah someone who's lived there for five years exactly yeah paid taxes
00:11:07 for five years which means your welsh children aren't welsh but and actually an interesting
00:11:12 an interesting case study of this came up recently that i mean we still don't know the details so so
00:11:16 maybe the picture by the time this video comes out tomorrow the picture would have changed radically
00:11:20 or when or we won't know anything for six months whatever it was um but that case of that raf base
00:11:25 that got vandalized yeah and then the media came out and they said about 30 times in all the
00:11:30 mainstream media broadcast these are british nationals yes and and then all the left came
00:11:35 out they got very excited by that and said aha they're not immigrants yeah they're british
00:11:39 nationals now from farage from me from our frame it's like well what does a british national mean
00:11:44 yeah literally nothing i mean this actual rudy cabana was a british national i mean exactly
00:11:50 right obviously they're foreign men who have been given british citizenship they may have even grown
00:11:54 up here who cares jacob rees mogg nigel farage all of the conservatives are like well they're 0.78
00:11:59 just as english as you are yeah you know they're just as mongrel as the rest that that guy in kent 0.66
00:12:03 who plays cricket at the weekend is exactly as british as these guys yep and and that's what 0.61
00:12:08 british uh civic nationalism will get you into you can't make a sort of distinction where there
00:12:14 obviously is one yes anyway so what's interesting is uh you gov did this uh poll in june 2026 and
00:12:23 this this was really interesting to me um because it shows that basically um heterosexual men and
00:12:28 women thankfully the overwhelming majority uh basically vote the same and in fact women were
00:12:35 more likely to vote for restored britain than men were which i think is fascinating so i mean you
00:12:40 can see at the top maybe bisexual um men and women i mean that's not a very large constituency and
00:12:46 homosexual men and women not a very large constituency so in absolute numbers this is
00:12:50 very small but of course the people who are on the lgbtq ideological reservation completely for
00:13:00 the greens basically or weirdly uh strangely like reform uh i'm getting weird uh but the
00:13:07 heterosexual people are much more in line with basically what the actual polling is showing
00:13:12 so essentially you don't need to worry about any other constituency i remember i remember this when
00:13:17 it when it came out and yeah i mean the key taker is exactly what you say actually the um sex
00:13:22 difference isn't doing much heavy lifting here at all no the important thing is what you do for a
00:13:27 living yes if if you actually do something useful if you move things around connect things you're
00:13:32 basically you're you're much more likely to vote for reform if you're retired you're much more
00:13:36 likely to vote conservative if you have an email job you're much more likely to vote labor and if
00:13:41 you don't have a job you're much more likely to vote green i mean the the the you know the working
00:13:45 distinction is is the key one not actually the gender one at this point absolutely anyway so
00:13:50 let's get on to your uh analysis of the mrp data yeah so basically what i'm trying to show here is
00:13:55 let's assume the mrp data um was the result of the general election yeah um the only way it's
00:14:03 going to work is well actually there is another way you can make it work which is labor and
00:14:07 conservatives form a coalition that would work sorry it's almost inconceivable yeah it almost
00:14:14 is but but saying that well i don't know like i mean the greens are so far to their left
00:14:19 reform and restore are on the conservatives right it's not inconceivable they feel besieged and go
00:14:26 well we're each other's last well the the right wing of the labor party and the left wing of the
00:14:30 conservative party are the same anyway yes so you would you you would just actually be i mean it's
00:14:35 like lego blocks they would connect together continuously peter hitchens zombie party but
00:14:40 You would have just a very broad coalition.
00:14:42 So Labour and Conservative would do it,
00:14:44 but I assumed, OK, fine, that's not going to work.
00:14:46 Assume they can't do it.
00:14:47 Assume that they just can't bring themselves to do it.
00:14:49 The only thing that actually works
00:14:51 is a Labour and Lib Dem governing coalition,
00:14:55 but that doesn't get you a majority.
00:14:57 That only gets you 312.
00:14:59 What you then need is you need the SNP, Plaid and Greens.
00:15:04 Well, I mean, technically you only need the SNP,
00:15:06 so 352 would be a majority.
00:15:09 Not if the Platt or Greens go against you.
00:15:12 I don't believe.
00:15:13 Yeah, well, you need 352 to create a government, don't you?
00:15:19 326, isn't it?
00:15:20 Oh, is it?
00:15:20 Oh, OK.
00:15:21 Well, then they could have...
00:15:24 Well, I mean, put it this way, OK.
00:15:25 So if Labour and Lib Dems come up to 312
00:15:29 and then the Conservatives and Reform come up to 253,
00:15:35 the remaining 64 votes is the swing bit
00:15:38 because if you add those
00:15:39 on to the conservative and reform,
00:15:41 you basically get 317,
00:15:43 which is bigger than 312.
00:15:44 Yeah, okay.
00:15:45 The other factor is the Northern Ireland voters,
00:15:48 but you can kind of count them out
00:15:49 because they don't really get involved in it.
00:15:51 So the working day-to-day government
00:15:54 would have to be Labour and Lib Dems,
00:15:56 and then you'd need some sort of arrangement
00:15:58 with the SNP, Plaid and Greens,
00:16:00 which is your backers on the King's speech
00:16:03 and a budget.
00:16:06 but otherwise we basically just need you to to abstain or negotiate on an individual basis
00:16:13 do you know the the horror situation though is essentially they all believe the same thing
00:16:18 to an extent well to quite a large extent yes i mean they're all they're all divorced
00:16:27 from reality in the same way in in the same way some of them even more so than others though
00:16:33 and the the only thing they would really argue about is the degree to which yes leftism could
00:16:38 be implemented yes so reality could be suspended it's not the most impossible thing to think that
00:16:43 a coalition could be established on the left i'd be surprised if such a thing could happen on the
00:16:48 right but yeah possibly um but i mean what what the takeaway from this though is is that um
00:16:55 you start off with an arrangement which is labor and lib dem and relying on basically
00:17:02 you just need one of those three,
00:17:06 the SNP, Platt & Greens, to abstain
00:17:08 and not to vote against you.
00:17:09 If you can just get them to abstain.
00:17:11 So it doesn't sound that difficult
00:17:13 because what you can kind of do
00:17:14 is run a reverse auction.
00:17:15 You can say, look,
00:17:16 we're trying to get this bill through.
00:17:18 What would it cost?
00:17:19 Go to three of them.
00:17:20 And if you're burning,
00:17:21 what you want to do
00:17:22 is you want to have that negotiation
00:17:23 three times in private.
00:17:25 You want to say to the SNP,
00:17:26 what would make you abstain or vote for us? 0.83
00:17:29 Either one works.
00:17:30 And the SNP might say,
00:17:31 oh, we want a new airport.
00:17:32 in glasgow or whatever and you might go to the greens and you say what would it make cost to
00:17:37 make you abstain or vote for us on this occasion and they might say okay we want a four million
00:17:40 pounds into trans newts in norwich or something whatever it is right yeah and and you go okay
00:17:47 well a four million pound study is a lot cheaper than an airport so i'll basically just you know
00:17:51 i'll just i'll just run this reverse auction every single time so the incentive actually for
00:17:56 smp plaid and greens is to get wise to that and form a cartel this is why burnham is not going
00:18:03 to call yeah yeah i mean as i'm describing you can just see how painful this will be for burning
00:18:09 so so smp plaid and greens they form a cartel and they agree to only ever meet with the governing
00:18:16 coalition labor and lib dems in the same room at the same time and to extract something that they
00:18:22 all want every time so what would happen almost certainly is for the first year or two you actually
00:18:28 get a labour lib dem government which is supported by confidence and supply arrangement with snp
00:18:34 plaid and greens after a couple of years at most those guys figure out if we form a cartel
00:18:40 we basically become the government we can extract from labour and lib dems whatever we want because
00:18:45 otherwise everything they do fails yeah they can't do anything if if those three stick together
00:18:49 they get to be the deciding vote as to whether it goes through or not so they can basically steer
00:18:54 all legislation going forward so if we were to actually get this you're basically getting an
00:19:01 smp plaid and green coalition running the country by by virtue of the fact them having the swing
00:19:06 votes so so i mean yeah i mean uh fascinating coalition building and it'll give us plenty
00:19:11 to talk about if it were to actually happen great for the content creators and then let's see if i
00:19:16 can get to the next one right and then i thought okay um what happens if reform and restore
00:19:23 revive their pact idea well it's rupert's pact idea yeah and nigel basically shot it down yeah
00:19:30 thought he didn't need it and interestingly at the time that rupert made the offer
00:19:36 nigel would have been straight back in leading position he would have been prime minister on
00:19:41 those numbers okay with the all the finance stuff that has come out he's managed to erode even more
00:19:47 support since when that offer was made and now he doesn't get to be prime minister even with
00:19:53 restore support so all those people saying you know restore you need to get on board otherwise
00:19:56 nigel won't be prime minister it's like well yeah but you've you've actually pissed away so it looks 0.73
00:20:01 like it's too late for that anyway yeah it doesn't even get you there but it is significant it is
00:20:06 still significant so let's say um reform said to restore look we won't contest you in your 10 best
00:20:12 seats so you're basically going to get 10 seats yeah and in exchange you say to all your supporters
00:20:17 in all the other 640 seats or however many they're contesting you tell your guys to back us
00:20:22 because there's no longer that wasted efficiency between people trading off between the two the
00:20:27 efficiency of the reform vote goes up and suddenly they become the official opposition
00:20:31 if there's a pact they kind of lead it and now on the flip side it is no longer an option to have
00:20:38 the smp plaid and greens on a confidence and supply basis you need to have them in the coalition
00:20:44 otherwise you're not getting anything done yeah and so what that would do is is is and if you look
00:20:50 at what i've done there look labor lib dems smp plaid and greens all in one governing coalition
00:20:54 you know how that works out because we're seeing in germany right now you get the oh what is it the
00:21:00 i can't remember all the bloody acronyms for the german parties but that you're getting a whole
00:21:05 range of german parties who have completely um incoherent governing philosophy because they can't
00:21:12 form a uh a set of governing principles that they can all ascribe to yeah you've got the center
00:21:18 right mixed in with the with the right the the far left communists and stuff and what it's doing
00:21:23 is it's massively eroding german politics because they look incoherent to everybody including their
00:21:28 own supporters i mean at least in in the case of germany they have a kind of monolithic party
00:21:32 in opposition whereas reform are not that monolithic party in opposition no like so in
00:21:37 the saxony anhalt election where they won was it 44 percent of the vote there's no way reform
00:21:43 are getting 44 percent of the vote in britain or anywhere really well i mean i mean there might
00:21:49 be some northern assuming assuming lower down you've got farage's popularity i mean we i do
00:21:54 yeah we can knock that one out the park now he's not getting he he isn't the monolithic
00:21:58 alternative to the entire establishment no that he tries to portray himself as being exactly he's
00:22:04 got too many unfavorables yeah but still reform still want to go back to restore and say actually
00:22:11 if that pact is still on the table we take because it suddenly makes them the largest opposition
00:22:16 party and now you will force the left into forming such an incoherent block um that it that it that
00:22:22 it simply won't function and then i thought okay well let's take this one step further
00:22:26 because as soon as you end up in that situation effectively you've got a right wing block versus
00:22:31 a left wing block and the massive incentive then becomes you notice how much better it got for
00:22:37 reform when the efficiency between restore was reduced the friction yeah what if one of these
00:22:42 actually does form a block and that's what it looks like if the left wing form a block
00:22:46 but the right wing remain fractured the efficiency of the left wing block basically goes perfect
00:22:52 well i've got some bad news for you yeah because if there are anyone in if there if there is a
00:22:57 constituency in britain that is happy to tactically vote it's the left and if there's a constituency
00:23:02 in britain who basically refuses to tactically vote it is the right that is true but also the
00:23:08 left is very fractious that is true but for anybody who's listening but hang on but you know
00:23:12 it is but when the rubber has met the road in actual like individual by-elections we've got
00:23:16 examples of this was it was it yeah yeah uh and um uh gorton and denton and uh makefield right
00:23:25 yeah no they they have voted for their guy they've chosen the guy yeah it's played cymru it's labor
00:23:30 it's the greens boom we've got those it's like well you don't get that with reform and restoring
00:23:35 the conservatives no you don't and but so just for anybody listening if the left form a basically
00:23:41 merge into a single party which they essentially are by the way yeah but they're not formally so
00:23:46 you get that inefficient yeah you get that inefficiency in the vote when you go to the ballot
00:23:49 because you you you know you might win your um labor seat but a lot of a lot of votes you know
00:23:55 got wasted on the greens or the lib dems or whatever um if yeah if the left were to ever
00:23:59 form a bloc and the right were to stay fractured um the left would win 575 seats i mean i'm sure
00:24:06 that's the worst case scenario it is but and then just to be fair i thought okay what happens if
00:24:11 the left remained fractured and the right former block same thing their efficiency goes through
00:24:17 the roof you've now got a right wing block 445 seats so it's not quite as high but we could get
00:24:22 the right wing to be one bloody party it it would move the dial yes the problem is we'd then be 1.00
00:24:30 sharing a governing coalition with wets and that would irritate us yes but better to be irritated 0.96
00:24:35 with a bunch of wets in government than to be irritated by a bunch of wets out of government 0.91
00:24:41 and and so you can see what's going on you can see what's going on here is we used to have a
00:24:45 two-party system but both of them became internally incoherent so they fractured they came apart they
00:24:53 resorted amongst themselves but inevitably the logic is that they do have to get back together
00:24:58 at some point it is going to come and then finally i'll just show you on the mrp poll
00:25:02 what it would look like if both of them formed a block at the same time and on the mrp data it
00:25:07 would be a left-wing majority and you might think okay is this because there was a left-wing
00:25:11 majority in the country like owen jones keeps on saying it's actually not that bad what this is
00:25:16 actually this is fast first past the post bias in this the actual underlying numbers is 52 percent
00:25:22 left versus 48 percent right still a lot of bloody left yeah but are all lib dem voters and all smp
00:25:31 voters actually left wing well this has been my thesis for a long time hasn't it the lib dems
00:25:36 might be being misallocated to the left, which is possible.
00:25:40 Yeah, very true.
00:25:41 And if we actually form two blocks,
00:25:43 one is explicitly a right-wing block
00:25:45 and one is explicitly a left-wing block,
00:25:46 I reckon a load of SNP and Lib Dem voters would come out.
00:25:50 And that 2%, well, 4% difference,
00:25:52 but that 2% advantage on their side that they've got
00:25:54 might actually go.
00:25:56 And what you'd actually get back to is perfectly balanced elections,
00:25:59 just changing hands again.
00:26:01 But the key thing, right,
00:26:03 is whoever goes first has a massive advantage.
00:26:06 whoever could whoever can coalesce first they would and obviously the dream scenarios is the
00:26:14 previous one that i showed which is the left remains fractured yeah and the right does some
00:26:19 sort of deal yeah then they just win everything forever god well if only yes if only the right
00:26:28 wasn't dominated by certain individuals with extreme personalities that can't stand anyone
00:26:33 else with strong personalities around them yeah we are where we are anyway speaking of people with
00:26:40 extreme personalities who don't broke any other strong personalities around them let's talk about
00:26:45 nigel farage and his 72 million um this i i made the point last time we discussed this i think this
00:26:51 was a poison chalice and i i actually don't think this has been something that's been very helpful
00:26:57 in at least the short term
00:26:59 and Peter Walker
00:27:02 at the Guardian has arrived at the same position
00:27:04 as me very recently
00:27:05 there are downsides to this
00:27:07 that are not good
00:27:09 and can't easily be overcome
00:27:11 with just throwing money at things
00:27:13 because actually the money itself
00:27:15 was the issue
00:27:16 whether you like it or not
00:27:18 Britain has become
00:27:21 a nation 0.95
00:27:23 of 0.91
00:27:24 resentful penny pinchers we don't like it when someone else is doing very well
00:27:33 and we have this very deep running streak of envy yeah and and it's different axis that
00:27:43 you're trying to solve for so on the one hand you solve all of their organizational concerns
00:27:48 yeah they could now put as we talked about in the previous episode they can now put a regional
00:27:53 organizer they could probably put a constituency level organizer in 72 million they've got enough
00:27:58 money but for everything they gained on the um resource constraints they've now got reputational
00:28:05 constraints that have been added to it and actually that's the top of the funnel that's
00:28:09 where the votes come yeah and that weirdly enough um it's actually been shown i mean uh the great
00:28:16 example was in the new york elections where bloomberg put 100 million dollars into it yes
00:28:21 came with like four percent um you you it's very useful to have lots of money
00:28:27 but you can make progress without money you just have to ultimately you've got to remember that
00:28:34 politics is genuinely about how people feel it's genuinely about what people think how you're
00:28:38 perceived uh reputation management is incredibly important in this game and it doesn't mean
00:28:44 not having an old tweet that people don't like or something like that it means making sure that
00:28:51 people don't feel your party is in some way corrupt or poisonous i mean and a perfect example is is
00:28:58 the first trump victory yep he looked like an underdog and the democrats did out raise him
00:29:03 and you know he he gave this impression of the whole system is against me i'm having to fight
00:29:10 i mean actually he did raise quite a bit of money sure but all the same you know he had this
00:29:14 perception of being up against the system yeah farage is engineering himself into a situation
00:29:20 where he looks so establishment what i mean he has he as we covered last time he he has raised
00:29:28 more money than the entire system did in an entire election cycle yes right the the only time the
00:29:34 system entirely was more than what reform has taken in here was in 2024 in that election year
00:29:41 but in a standard year he is dominating every every political party which okay sounds like a
00:29:46 very useful thing to have if it were organic donations from people organic small small
00:29:54 donations that would be incredible and that would be you know an unimpeachable democratic endorsement
00:30:01 that he would have well speaking of unimpeachable didn't rupert lowe get offered money by elon
00:30:05 and he said no yeah he i mean he thought about it for a bit because oh it would solve a lot of
00:30:09 problems but no i can't but it creates a lot of problems as well and it creates a very big stick
00:30:15 that the media can use to and this goes back to our point about judgment is whenever um you know
00:30:21 rupert comparing rupert judgment against nigel's judgment is rupert consistently says okay now
00:30:26 actually we've got to take the harder path yes but the correct path yes and nigel every single time
00:30:32 between the hard path and the easy path chooses the easy path and it's it's good for five minutes 0.87
00:30:37 and it comes back on you and that is exactly the problem we've spoken about before nigel's
00:30:42 money-grubbing nature has always um been a thorn in his own side i mean as peter points out but
00:30:50 when there are two crypto billionaires living overseas who are going to give you tens of
00:30:57 millions of pounds even if they are british citizens which they are it still doesn't look
00:31:03 good and crypto itself i mean i personally don't care about crypto at all but the average person
00:31:09 in the general public doesn't know anything about crypto they don't know how it came about they don't
00:31:13 know how it represents value or chancellor definitely doesn't know anything about it
00:31:18 absolutely and in fact they they spend a lot of time stigmatizing it um and so to them it's got a
00:31:23 kind of sleazy city vibe that doesn't itself um promote a very wholesome atmosphere when the
00:31:32 subject comes up so even though Farage here has done nothing wrong there is the air of having done
00:31:38 something wrong about it i think it's less about the crypto and more about the fact that he just
00:31:43 took an extraordinary amount of money from very few individuals that that feels like it's both i
00:31:48 mean if it if it was say you know bill gates or richard branson or someone donating the money to
00:31:54 him okay but at least you understand how they made the money right how did um was it harbourn
00:31:59 whatever his name is yeah yeah harbourn and delo who the hell are these guys how did they make their
00:32:04 money you're saying if it was i don't know jim rat i mean he's jim ratcliffe has also moved away
00:32:10 now because everybody with money is getting out of the country but i see your point if it was
00:32:14 richard branson or something yeah richard yeah you'd be like okay well he owns virgin there's a
00:32:18 massive series of companies it's understandable that through the regular mechanisms of capitalism
00:32:25 richard branson became a very rich man so you you wouldn't think i think there'd still be pushback
00:32:30 just not as much i do i do see of course there would absolutely be pushback but there at least
00:32:35 wouldn't be the air of this is a grift this is a there's theft around this but and i'm not saying
00:32:41 that is the case but i'm saying people i think perceive this to be the case it's sleazy and it
00:32:46 has this kind of it's almost got the same sort of coding as um like like wall street's gordon geckos
00:32:54 types yeah i mean well this i mean this blew up for well i don't want to say blew up but it
00:32:58 this impacted labor back in the 70s when all of their funding and the big the big wigs behind
00:33:05 the scenes steering things were just a handful of labor union guys and the public knew that
00:33:09 actually you could have a room with the prime minister and five or six other guys behind closed
00:33:14 doors where they would basically sort things out between them and you the voter would get very
00:33:19 little say on it well it's exactly the same when kirsten had his meeting with blackrock yes that
00:33:23 looks awful atrocious faraj is recreating that by taking a handful of individuals money and again
00:33:29 it conjures in your mind this image okay if he's prime minister could we have a room a closed room
00:33:34 with a handful of individuals in it who get to decide everything yes very obviously and so when
00:33:41 faraj is like well everyone knows i can't be bought no yeah everyone everybody knows that
00:33:46 you can though that's the problem it's very evident that you can be bought i mean you know
00:33:52 Everyone remembers your cameo.
00:33:54 Although, as you can see,
00:33:57 he did have the dignity of at least shutting his cameo down.
00:34:01 So you see Nigel Farage...
00:34:02 If only recently...
00:34:03 Exactly.
00:34:04 It was only recently that Nigel Farage became currently unavailable.
00:34:07 I don't exactly know when he did it,
00:34:09 but it was obviously not very long ago.
00:34:10 I know that it wasn't that long
00:34:11 because we've been making this show for not that long now
00:34:14 and we did a number of shows where we could go live to this and play it.
00:34:19 And we always made fun of him.
00:34:20 so maybe some of his guys maybe maybe nigel watches this maybe dan dukes was like look yeah 0.93
00:34:24 nigel is my last act just shut your cameo down yeah giving you 72 million mate you don't need 0.72
00:34:29 any more you know you don't need to spend 60 pounds from the maybe that's what the 72 million
00:34:33 was for to shut down that's their inside influence maybe cameo so i i couldn't i i was gonna i was
00:34:38 gonna commission nigel for us to do a cameo for the show what would you have made him say i i don't
00:34:43 know but i i did find someone whose cameo was operative so uh i i asked count binface to tell
00:34:51 us why he thought nigel farage lost in uh won in clacton but is uh getting it in the neck from
00:34:56 you commissioned this yeah i did
00:35:13 to say it ain't a galactic hello to Dan, and now this isn't just about me, now I have
00:35:19 called a galactic alliance with Al, and together we want to say a big Al's hello, and also
00:35:26 to help answer a question, because apparently Dan, you are bewildered that Nigel Farage
00:35:34 would receive not just 5 million, not just 36, but 72 million quid, well I mean 77 really,
00:35:43 If you incur the 5 personal million and a 70 silver political one, and it's probably more as wealth, as I understand it, I don't know.
00:35:52 Why is he getting that money? Well, of course, a 5 million is an unconditional gift.
00:35:57 You can spend that on Ferrari, if you want, but he's such an anti-establishment guy.
00:36:02 He probably needs it for all those oysters and champagne.
00:36:06 Well, he's definitely not after no good, but I just have a job to eventually make that absolutely fair.
00:36:13 And after the 72 million, maybe he needed to catch up because the latest polls say that even with reform funding, they're going to come behind Labour and the story, which is very funny indeed.
00:36:26 And maybe then, oh no, maybe they need the 72 million to have a recruiting drive for a new leader for four old guys to get shoved out in practice after the second by-election. 0.67
00:36:38 What's this hyperspace in a charity?
00:36:41 Anyway, well, I mean, you know, that's as savvy as money could be, that's politics for you.
00:36:47 I'm here to show, you don't need any of that, so we look at this for thousands.
00:36:51 And I hope I'm asking your questions there.
00:36:53 And may you watch the skies for fire elections near and far.
00:36:58 And when you're taking the votes, what are you going to do?
00:37:01 Make your votes.
00:37:02 Thank you for that, Carl.
00:37:05 £60 well spent there, wasn't it?
00:37:08 So it was about the same price as Nigel's, wasn't it?
00:37:10 It was, yeah, yeah.
00:37:11 But you get a whole two minutes, whereas you've only got like 30 seconds with Nigel,
00:37:14 or even less than that.
00:37:15 So that's good value, that.
00:37:16 But at the end of the day, though, what does Count Binface represent? 0.99
00:37:20 the kind of libtard establishment what you you could hear that i mean it started off quite amusing 0.92
00:37:25 but sure he got so left-wing coded as he started going for ferraris and oysters but it's but it's 0.96
00:37:31 all real that's the problem that farage has here is yeah he went on nick ferrari's show and was
00:37:36 like i could just spend that money on ferraris he did get stung in clacton eating oysters meeting 0.86
00:37:43 with a foreign billionaire and the issue is is okay this is ridiculous it's a man in a bin suit
00:37:48 doing your number yeah he's got your number night yeah and this is but the issue is is it was is it
00:37:54 was absurd when farage was doing it as well yeah even though he wasn't wearing a bid on the face
00:37:59 he was still doing cameos and he wants to be prime minister but also the narrative that
00:38:04 count bin face here has given us is just the stock narrative you hear on sky news it's the
00:38:09 stock narrative you hear on the bbc well he took five million from chris harbourn he took another
00:38:14 32 from these from harbourn and this other guy and oh you know look at the look at the the sting
00:38:19 that channel 4 did i think he's like a bbc comedy writer or something so so he he's fashionable
00:38:25 lefty yeah yeah but but you're right those things actually matter to the fashionable leftists and
00:38:31 they're all true and they will say them repeatedly on tv everywhere until you've basically just got 0.72
00:38:36 that narrative that bin face has given us being the narrative of the general stench of corruption
00:38:41 around yeah there's nothing original in there no but it permeates because the bbc is a bloody big
00:38:47 platform and they can just repeat it endlessly and millions of people sounds bad yeah none of
00:38:53 it seems to have actually been bad like christopher harbourn can give nudge for us as much of his
00:38:57 money as he wants i don't care about any exactly and i don't i don't care if he does spend the
00:39:00 five million dollars on ferrari's and oysters there are loads of billionaires who give labor
00:39:04 figures like look at all the expenses scandal that kia slama had and all the donations that
00:39:09 he had to be like okay i'm going to stop taking political donations yeah that lord alley guy
00:39:13 kept on buying him underpants yeah yeah he kept getting you know like all these free goodies and
00:39:17 stuff yes right at the beginning of his premiership it's like okay they all do this it's just that
00:39:22 nigel farage happens to be the villain of the week for these people and so that's why binface
00:39:28 is giving us that narrative right so anyway the point is that of course farage has got no good
00:39:34 answers to any of this and he looks like he's on the defensive when he's responding i mean this is
00:39:41 an interview he did with sky news
00:39:43 so nigel farage has been here in edinburgh for meetings with his scottish team the party is
00:39:55 pretty flush with cash at the moment after two massive donations 36 million pounds of
00:40:01 I'm sorry.
00:40:11 Absolutely.
00:40:17 I haven't seen theseised cases there.
00:40:22 I think I've never been actually.
00:40:26 The government did not do legislation that would go back.
00:40:33 Well, if they do that, they may as well be used to.
00:40:40 We may as well be used to.
00:40:44 There's a point of principle, isn't it?
00:40:46 What a principle, what?
00:40:48 If someone is going to be influencing democracy,
00:40:52 see look how weak his response is that's it he looks like a small child in the headmaster's 0.99
00:41:10 office yeah he looks defensive when the sky news guy is just giving the bim face narrative yes 0.53
00:41:15 and it's just okay well now and and there's different ways to have you could have pushed
00:41:20 back on the trumpian way would be to say well that makes me smart what why can't i do this 0.62
00:41:25 you're just jealous because you didn't get it you're losers i'm a winner that's how trump would
00:41:29 have this is how the system works and i was just using the system as you already use it yes and
00:41:33 and as we've already covered rupert lowe would have not got himself into this situation in the
00:41:37 first place which is the smartest i'd imagine rupert lowe probably could come back with a
00:41:40 better answer but he just sidesteps it by not getting into that situation in the first place
00:41:45 was was nigel here he fundamentally accepts the left's worldview and cannot push back against it
00:41:53 without feeling you can tell that he feels guilty yeah he looks guilty yeah and what's more is and
00:41:59 then it's like well we're just east germany it's like yeah we've been east germany for a long time
00:42:03 now knowledge you know this has been very self-evident you can't appeal to a sense of
00:42:09 fair play with these people because they don't think your existence is fair i mean you you try
00:42:13 being a you know a white male zoomer in this country i mean try being a white male of any age
00:42:19 yeah but i mean everything is stacked against you it's just like oh okay well you know this
00:42:25 is going a bit far no it's gone a bit far for a while yeah we don't want we don't want to just
00:42:29 unwind back to well basically you know where conservatives were under um cameron or something
00:42:37 and the thing is this is not the only thing that the only problem that reform have been grappling
00:42:41 with i mean for example you've got durham council right oh yes durham council oh by the way before
00:42:47 we continue though i mean this is the number of councillors that since the local elections have
00:42:51 left reform uh as you can see 45 have resigned 60 have become independent 24 have joined restored
00:42:58 nine joined tories five joined advanced two have been disqualified one joined the sdp
00:43:01 one started their own party and that's since may 2025 but durham county council was called by
00:43:08 nigel ferrari's their flagship council because they won loads and loads of seats on durham council
00:43:14 65 out of 98 i think it was huge i can't remember exactly how much it was but it was huge and so
00:43:19 it's like right we've got total domination of the council what's going on well it turned out they
00:43:23 had a massive hole in their finances 83 million pounds um and it's just been i mean i don't even
00:43:32 have a good metaphor to describe it but it just seems awful uh the culture of the council has
00:43:40 been really really bad and so you've got the councillors coming out and saying look i'm
00:43:45 resigning you're all betrayers you've all like you've all been acting in very very dramatic ways
00:43:53 and this has become as you can see the bbc thrilled to be reporting on this yeah this is
00:43:59 oh incompetence now as well so it's but not just incompetence it is a negative culture in reform
00:44:06 itself i think this one largely comes down to a lack of experience what's going on because
00:44:12 actually council finances are incredibly difficult to do everything with yeah from the outside you
00:44:17 always assume that they're just very wasteful organizations yeah actually they're not most of
00:44:24 their spending and it's and it varies between 70 to 90 depending on what time type of council is
00:44:29 of their spending is mandated from government so they get the money in and then they have to pass
00:44:33 it out and a lot of it's on things like adult actually the bulk of it is on adult social care
00:44:38 and so when it comes to the things that they've actually got discretion over it's actually a tiny
00:44:44 amount of the budget and actually you don't find wasting councils what you find is that it's got a
00:44:49 whole bunch of departments and they've all been cut so many times but they exist but they they
00:44:56 can't actually do anything because they don't have any money you need to start chopping functions
00:45:01 and more importantly you need to revisit the mandatory spending things like adult social care
00:45:04 that's where you need to go and and i think the reason they're getting into difficulty with this
00:45:08 is because let's say you become a conservative council or a labor council you know you you've
00:45:13 just won your election you go in there you you speak to some guy and it's like how long have
00:45:16 you been a council he's all 37 years i'll take you under my wing and i'll and i'll show you how
00:45:21 this stuff works and you're and you'll kind of get absorbed into it so if you're a right winger
00:45:25 you go well why can't we cut money and it's like and he basically saying something like i've just
00:45:29 central government will literally demand that you spend yeah it's just it's just all possible but
00:45:34 reform have come in and they've got no hierarchy everybody was hired at the same time nobody's got
00:45:39 any experience for how it works and nobody realizes how useless councillors actually are and how they
00:45:44 don't actually have any power and and there's just no coordination going on and and it could be the
00:45:49 same if you suddenly get almost almost with any new intake of politicians right and it'll be the
00:45:56 same for westminster absolutely if they get 200 300 mps it's going to be like herding cats yeah
00:46:01 and and this isn't even like a way of attacking reform here no no yeah i i'm not i'm just saying
00:46:08 this is what the narrative being presented to the public is right i actually i'm sure that people
00:46:13 on reform council uh the durham council the reform uh people have done their best but
00:46:19 it's been as you say a sort of jostling for position because all of them are new
00:46:23 so it's been very difficult i think they're down to a majority of foreign yeah it's been brutal 1.00
00:46:29 it's been brutal um but the the point is it's not really farage's fault but he's one who's
00:46:35 holding the bag for it at the end of the day because again uh sky news and this is the sort
00:46:41 thing. All he can come out and say is, I don't know.
00:47:11 look how look it's the same defensiveness but look how eager this guy is to drive in the knife
00:47:29 look how much he's enjoying this right now i'm not saying this is farage's fault or anything like
00:47:35 that i don't know what i would have done differently in his position but this is the
00:47:40 circumstance you find yourself in right and now if you if you can't do anything other than look
00:47:45 defensively and say well i don't know i don't know well okay but there are other people who get a
00:47:51 favorable response from the media and who don't get this kind of daggers out investigation yeah
00:47:57 like you're like andy burnham who just get a free ride and they they come out and will give you a
00:48:01 positive message and it's like well sorry night yeah you know i can't i think he should know as
00:48:06 well he should he should have a briefing i mean i i don't know what's on the slate when you when
00:48:11 you pull it up but i mean i i knew at least a bit about what's going on in durham council i at least
00:48:15 knew the numbers i don't think nigel farage even knows that i don't think he knows the outline
00:48:20 well he's not a details guy is he i'm a details guy either i mean but you'd need to know this
00:48:25 but things i'm not leader of reform yeah and he is yeah so i mean where where is his time going
00:48:32 that he can't he can't be at least on the surface level top line details of what's going on in his
00:48:37 flagship council i mean you bloody well should be to be honest if if you can't be why accept an
00:48:42 interview like this why would you accept an interview from this sky news you think donald
00:48:46 trump would have accepted this interview well yeah and donald trump would have told him get out of
00:48:49 the room and and i think you go back a year before we kind of fell out with uh reform you know we
00:48:55 invited them on yeah you can come on whenever you like guys yeah i gave you a favorable hearing but 0.96
00:49:00 they didn't want to know no you you online scum instead who watches who watches the internet 0.99
00:49:05 laughs the boomer instead Nigel Farage gets picked apart yeah by these little you know dagger 0.99
00:49:11 interviews with Sky News anchors it's like okay well why would you want to do that again you're
00:49:17 being interviewed by Count Binface here Nigel I mean it might actually be Count Binface well yeah
00:49:22 we don't know in my mind that is exactly what Count Binface looks like under the bin is they're
00:49:27 all going to be the same type absolutely and it's like okay well you accept an interview with count
00:49:30 bin face but you wouldn't accept an interview from anyone from the right yeah and so now they're just
00:49:34 picking you apart and this is just showing in the approval ratings right andy burnham's got an
00:49:40 approval rating of plus 10 which is pretty good uh kevin bay not plus 1.5 ed davie minus 4.6
00:49:45 rupert load minus 11.6 zach polanski minus 24.1 the nigel ferrari's at the lowest at minus 24.6
00:49:52 I mean, Rupert Lowe's issue here is that, unfortunately,
00:49:54 not enough people know of him yet.
00:49:56 Sure, and he's going to get nothing but negative press.
00:49:59 Yeah.
00:49:59 But the negative press will be, Rupert Lowe is an extremist
00:50:03 and wants to deport millions of people.
00:50:06 That said, that we do have a case study of people
00:50:08 who actually do know who he is, and it's reform supporters.
00:50:12 Yes.
00:50:12 And reform supporters actually think quite highly.
00:50:14 They do.
00:50:15 It doesn't go the other way around.
00:50:17 So, basically, the only people who like Nigel Farage
00:50:19 are some reform supporters but not all reform supporters yes but that doesn't but that doesn't
00:50:26 go the other way around so the tories for example tory supporters hate farage yes and obviously the
00:50:31 greens yeah we've got we've covered this in previous episodes um but isn't that interesting
00:50:35 the only other person who comes near to be as disliked as nigel farage is zach polanski who
00:50:41 is a nutter yeah he's completely bonkers so it's remarkable how like i said the british public 0.98
00:50:47 just need exposure to polanski to realize oh this guy's evil yeah he wants to destroy everything 0.98
00:50:52 about britain and this as we showed last time has been going on for a while and for us is now down
00:50:58 to just sort of net favorable 24 unfavorable 69 from you gov i mean there's two different trackers
00:51:04 and and that's a real problem so in in vc we had in venture capital we have something called um
00:51:09 your total addressable market your time it was a standard thing you looked at what is the total
00:51:13 market you can go after 31 yeah 69 is off the table for him yeah i mean and and this is the
00:51:21 problem with haraj he has spent decades getting to where he is by being a snake and backstabbing
00:51:26 other people who got even remotely close to him you can do that once or twice if you need to
00:51:30 if you make a political habit of that over 26 year political career plus you add on so so the
00:51:37 right is alienated from him lots of the right you alienate the left with a bit of money stuff which
00:51:42 we don't consider an issue like just like the left doesn't consider the backstabbing rightoids
00:51:46 a problem but but remember you're not like you're not speaking to zach polanski in his constituency
00:51:50 no what you're speaking to the kind of softy left types who have always voted labor yeah
00:51:54 marge from leeds or something yeah and and they don't really follow politics very closely yes
00:51:58 you know they they know who you are they know who labor is they know the tories are and they're
00:52:02 going to pick one exactly and and so the right the right people on the right have enough reason
00:52:06 not to like him because people on the right think he's a snake and people on the left think he's
00:52:10 sleazy but interestingly this this tracks really well with the general poll polling decline of
00:52:16 reform come back to uh yeah there's august 2025 reformer on about 31 nigel farage's personal
00:52:24 favorability rating was about 32 there we go and it's just been a downswing ever since
00:52:30 down to 24 which is really close to what they're currently on the party is him because he won't
00:52:36 let anyone else outshine him exactly him and the party are the same thing and it's the same with
00:52:40 the greens if the party rises and falls on the popularity of one chap and he becomes very
00:52:45 unpopular when you made your bed you know this is what you get um and worse for nigel farage
00:52:53 is that people are going to tactically vote against him now yeah when it's like reform versus
00:52:59 labor as you can see people are way more inclined to vote for labor than reform when it comes to
00:53:06 reform versus conservative as you can see people are way more inclined to vote conservative than
00:53:10 reform and the same goes for liberal democrats when it comes to voting labor or conservative
00:53:14 there's a lot less in it when it comes to lib dems conservatives a lot less in it
00:53:19 but no when it's farage they're like no just don't like him well this goes back to our point
00:53:26 that we started on about having a a two-way political system with six parties in it yeah
00:53:30 that is why reform is looking as good as it is even though it's now dropped third in many polls
00:53:35 it's because it benefits from a very split system as soon as the split system starts to go away
00:53:40 reform's comparative advantage disappears with it they're not capturing the imagination of the
00:53:47 people as a whole but also like polanski one of reform's greatest weapons was keir starmer
00:53:53 keir starmer hates the country he hates the far right he hates people he was clearly dead set
00:54:00 against all of this and farage looked like a strong alternative in the same way that zach
00:54:05 polanski looked like a strong alternative andy burnham doesn't seem hateful yeah i think andy
00:54:10 burnham is massively misguided he follows the wrong ideology he's a bumbling david brent type
00:54:15 figure yes but i don't think he hates me no i don't think he wants my children to be stabbed 0.92
00:54:20 by a somalian yeah and i don't think he's going to come to the somalian's defense if he does
00:54:24 yeah right but keir starmer would literally be that somalian's human rights lawyer yes you know
00:54:29 so it's like
00:54:30 again you can say
00:54:31 whatever you like
00:54:32 about Andy Burnham
00:54:32 he isn't going to
00:54:34 generate the kind of
00:54:35 visceral hatred
00:54:37 loathing
00:54:38 that Keir Starmer
00:54:39 I don't know
00:54:39 don't loathe him 0.99
00:54:40 I just think he's a prat 0.96
00:54:41 I just don't want him 0.98
00:54:42 in government
00:54:43 I don't hate him
00:54:44 I'm sure he's a lovely
00:54:45 guy when you're down
00:54:45 the pub and whatnot
00:54:46 but that
00:54:47 this kind of perception
00:54:49 is important
00:54:49 God can you imagine
00:54:50 being stuck in a pub
00:54:51 with Keir Starmer
00:54:52 that'd be
00:54:52 I mean I would make
00:54:54 the best of it
00:54:55 because as a
00:54:56 political commentator
00:54:57 I would like to ask
00:54:58 those cold dead
00:54:59 macro eyes staring at you i'd like i'd like to ask him you know so what was your favorite
00:55:03 human rights experience kit you know what what are you most proud of the guy doesn't dream i
00:55:08 doubt he has a favorite anything oh it'll be getting child murderers off the death penalty
00:55:12 i'm sure that's what he'd say anyway i would have some opinions on that anyway so um as as we've
00:55:19 seen before as you mentioned in fact reform voters actually do have a very favorable view
00:55:23 yeah low uh only less than half of reform voters don't know where he is and almost half of reform
00:55:29 voters think he's great so basically nine in ten reform voters are up for grabs for a store
00:55:34 yeah so as soon as and it will happen we've been saying it for ages reform is going to unwind i
00:55:39 know a lot of people don't want to hear that they want to hold on to it um but as soon as it does
00:55:44 unwind the store goes through the roof yeah and and actually another thing right there's a whole
00:55:51 bunch of shows that basically watch this show and then comment on it yeah and their argument
00:55:57 because i don't i don't generally watch them because they're too long-winded and unfocused
00:56:00 and they're not very good at it and all that kind of stuff but the arguments that they do make
00:56:04 are basically well reform is higher in the polls therefore support reform because you have to
00:56:10 support whichever right-wing option is highest in the polls i bet they've shut up why wouldn't i
00:56:14 vote the conservatives now because the conservatives exactly are being reform in the polls yes exactly
00:56:18 reasons i don't support these parties beyond the polls exactly and now it as it starts to look
00:56:25 because the clock is ticking yeah or when when nigel farage decides i'm going to america yeah
00:56:31 i'm going to make two million pounds a year more than that probably actually no he's making a
00:56:35 million a year on gb news he can make 10 to 20 million in america clock is ticking on when he
00:56:41 just buggers off and does that yeah and then 90 straight over yeah anyway so let's let's uh talk
00:56:47 about reform then uh restore sorry and how things are going because i mean to be honest with you
00:56:52 seems that things are going pretty well here's a very recent poll from um more in common uh
00:56:59 that had them on six percent which is only a couple of points behind the green party
00:57:03 which is a significant step up from well only a couple of weeks ago frankly with 90 90 percent
00:57:12 about 22 percent in play but also the other thing about restorative i'm pretty sure they get a lot
00:57:17 of they activate a lot of people who hadn't voted before that's correct i actually forgot to include
00:57:22 that i think it's 38 of their it was about 40 of the support that yeah literally is people who
00:57:28 didn't vote previously so when rupert lowe was saying oh yeah and great yarmouth i mean great
00:57:31 yarmouth is a great example of it of course we were saying we're bringing people into the political
00:57:34 uh experience that previously checked out that is true that is a correct uh point um so not only
00:57:41 are reforms uh voters up for grabs but a huge number of otherwise uninvested voters are up
00:57:48 and also they don't it's not impossible they get plenty from the conservatives and even a few from
00:57:54 from labor and certainly the lib dems as well well i suspect that a lot from labor could actually
00:57:59 come across and we'll get into that more from the lib dems than we would expect um this was a very
00:58:05 interesting one everyone was complaining about this because luke from more in common had broken
00:58:09 down a bunch of numbers here but as you can see men for some reason are most likely to vote for
00:58:14 labor women for some reason most likely to vote for conservatives um but interestingly women were
00:58:19 more likely to vote the the number of women versus men supporting restore was at seven percent
00:58:25 compared to six percent so why are women and we saw this in the previous poll as well um why are
00:58:30 women more likely to vote for restore well they're the ones who stand to benefit the most i would
00:58:35 like to public safety i'd like to immediately retract what i've been saying for the last two 1.00
00:58:39 years that women shouldn't vote i've changed my mind yeah i know it looks like women are going
00:58:42 put rupert lowe in government yeah good old women i've always said women great yay very interesting 0.76
00:58:50 uh anyway the next one is a bmg poll which had restored seven percent and as we saw in the poll
00:58:56 of polls they'd um ticked up to five percent on average and a couple of polls have had them
00:59:03 quite again one point behind the lib dems two point behind the greens like this this is becoming
00:59:09 a serious national party.
00:59:10 And they're not even a year.
00:59:11 When did they come up on their year?
00:59:12 It was about seven months old.
00:59:13 Seven months.
00:59:14 Maybe eight months.
00:59:15 I can't remember.
00:59:15 But it's not even a year old
00:59:17 and already it's 7%.
00:59:19 I mean, you've just never seen a party,
00:59:21 not that I can think of.
00:59:22 I mean, maybe the SDP,
00:59:24 but that didn't really count back in the 80s
00:59:25 because it just took a whole load
00:59:26 of existing Labour MPs.
00:59:28 Yeah, I mean, probably not in our living memory.
00:59:30 I can't think of a political,
00:59:32 not in the last hundred years.
00:59:33 I mean, maybe the Labour Party back in 19...
00:59:36 Yeah, probably the creation of the Labour Party
00:59:38 or something like that but this this is this is a lot and it's very interesting how despite the
00:59:46 attempt of obviously the mainstream media and the other parties to bury restore there has been this
00:59:52 slow and incremental growth where people have clearly come to the conclusion it's got to be
00:59:57 something serious when i listen to the mainstream podcast because unfortunately i have to yes um
01:00:02 it's regularly happening now where they'll be talking about reform or labor or something and
01:00:07 then the guest panelists will be and you've got to consider restore and you can see the host is
01:00:11 like really annoyed it's like oh please stop bringing up restore but but look at this it's
01:00:16 statistically significant it's very significant i mean reform on 23 percent would be in the lead
01:00:22 if they had the restore votes yeah they don't okay well that's a bit of bad news for nigel
01:00:28 but he's always he's always making his own bed and now he's being forced to lie in it
01:00:32 so restore britain did their own polling and the through bmg uh and this was an interesting result
01:00:41 where they found that um 29.6 percent would consider voting for restore britain uh or restore
01:00:48 britain candidate at the next election uh that slightly beat out whether they'd consider voting
01:00:52 for a reform candidate this goes back to my earlier tan point the total addressable market
01:00:58 i mean to be getting a third well not quite a third but almost 30 percent of people yeah who
01:01:04 are willing to say i i would consider voting for restore it doesn't mean this isn't the same as
01:01:08 it's not a poll because they might consider several options yeah exactly this is not a poll
01:01:13 but it's again what what it what is the constituent in potential as things stand now
01:01:19 and that's as things stand as bad as it's the potential addressable market yes and the potential
01:01:24 addressable market for his seven month old party is already exceeding reform yeah and despite the
01:01:31 fact that they're um the the knowledge of well the penetration yeah of reform is way greater than
01:01:40 the penetration of restore and already they're getting results like this so again that's it's
01:01:47 just indicative of a very strong direction of travel for restore britain and a weak direction
01:01:52 of travel for reform and i think i think he's blown it i just and the thing is well let's just
01:01:57 be clear that's terrible for labor too when starmer came in he was on 52 percent in the polls
01:02:03 yes that is abominable for labor like it's just to be clear that's if if labor's total market
01:02:11 share it caps out at 32.5 percent okay you might be able to form a government but it explains why
01:02:18 we're looking at all of these shattered hung parliaments yeah right that's not good and that's
01:02:23 again that's just i would consider it two-thirds people i would not consider labor yeah two-thirds
01:02:29 people i would not consider reform yeah like okay star moon his dead fish eyes yeah have just
01:02:35 this is andy burnham's 20 this is andy yeah well yeah but this is yeah this is andy burnham's
01:02:41 labor as well so isn't that interesting and uh as uh they pointed out so restore britain were
01:02:47 polling at 10 over 118 constituencies because as we were saying earlier it's about concentration
01:02:51 yes right now that is very interesting uh again a huge number and that that lines up with what we
01:02:59 were seeing in the by-elections uh what was the the most recent by-election where they got 10
01:03:04 percent i can't remember the name of it now was it the manchester one of them but the point is
01:03:09 there have been a bunch of recent by-elections yes and like manchester where restore britain
01:03:14 have come well above their national polling and okay it's not a win don't get me wrong but it was
01:03:20 what is it seven cent in makefield and i think it was nine percent in the manchester mayoral
01:03:26 something like that and it's just okay this is that's a chunk and the way it works past the post
01:03:32 is is nothing nothing nothing nothing nothing a handful of seats wins hundreds of seats yeah and
01:03:38 that's what nigel farage was relying on in 2024 i mean he literally said well this is gonna be our
01:03:43 beachhead from which we conquer parliament yeah and and he he was on that knife edge he was on
01:03:47 nothing nothing nothing five seats and then he was projected to go to like something like 350 seats
01:03:52 oh and then like 400 seats yeah you know like you know the following election yeah but he's he's just
01:03:57 managed to sink it through his grasping ways that's what this all comes down to it's the sense
01:04:04 of corruption that people have and the sense of unreliability sleazy miscalculations and and i
01:04:11 remember when we started this show and and he was absolutely storming ahead in the polls right yeah
01:04:17 and and we were showing the constituency maps where it's just all turquoise we're like my god
01:04:21 yeah yeah you could see the turquoise glow from mars yeah and and one thing that i said at the
01:04:27 time is is internally because obviously we get people from inside these parties from all of them
01:04:32 whisper things to us from time to time and and the phrase being used inside reform was we got
01:04:38 to carry this Ming vase across
01:04:40 the ice rink and we've got to tread
01:04:42 carefully and Nigel Farage
01:04:44 interpreted that to mean is
01:04:45 what we've got to do is
01:04:48 basically people are rejecting the 0.99
01:04:49 Uniparty so we need to carry this Ming
01:04:52 vase over to the Uniparty, fill it up 0.53
01:04:54 with Tories and then
01:04:55 presumably that will be how we
01:04:57 get across the line. We need to break apart
01:05:00 the right wing coalition to beat the
01:05:02 Uniparty. It's like no that's wrong
01:05:04 and we beat them by hiring them all 1.00
01:05:06 Yeah, it was...
01:05:07 And actually, that MRP poll... 0.70
01:05:08 But also by salami slicing our own supporters off. 0.97
01:05:11 Yes, and that. 0.99
01:05:12 It's like, no, that was silly.
01:05:13 Another thing I should have said on the MRP poll is that,
01:05:16 and this will make you laugh, right,
01:05:18 is that, how was it,
01:05:21 Suella Braveman and Robert Jenrick...
01:05:24 Will lose to the Conservatives?
01:05:25 Yes, lose to the Conservatives.
01:05:28 They jumped out of the Conservatives
01:05:30 to go to reform to maintain their seat,
01:05:32 and now they're going to lose it to their old parties
01:05:33 who don't even have the incumbency effect
01:05:36 of being an existing MP.
01:05:38 Yeah.
01:05:38 A series of mistakes have been made.
01:05:41 And remember, Nigel Farage,
01:05:42 the downswing began by taking in the Tory MPs.
01:05:45 Yes.
01:05:46 That's where it began.
01:05:47 And you probably would have got away
01:05:49 with Braverman and Jenrick.
01:05:51 Yeah.
01:05:51 Because there are...
01:05:53 Taking loads of terrible mistakes.
01:05:54 I mean, they took that weird vaccine guy. 0.99
01:05:57 Zahawi. 0.91
01:05:57 Yes. 0.96
01:05:58 Yes.
01:05:59 Nadine Dorries, Boris Ponson,
01:06:01 and various others.
01:06:02 and it's just okay you didn't need to do nigel you didn't need to do that it definitely hasn't
01:06:07 helped um anyway so here here are um a list of the very good ones from rupert lowe obviously
01:06:13 great yarmouth no surprise ashfield which is um is that uh
01:06:20 reform jumped from the tories to reform the guy who posts bacon sandwiches on twitter why
01:06:28 can't remember his name um lee lee anderson yes right i think that's lee anderson's one okay um
01:06:34 but you've got a lot of the ones in the north you know and then you've got a lot of them in
01:06:38 the south wolverhampton that's good a quick football fact england has never won a world
01:06:42 cup without a wolverhampton player on the squad that is yeah but how many world cups have we ever
01:06:47 one one still true i'm sure it's still true anyway plymouth the clacton yeah yeah well there we go
01:06:59 yeah yeah there we go clacton plymouth oh that would be funny well that's the thing right that's
01:07:05 the thing there's going to be a second by-election in clacton yes because parliament are probably
01:07:11 going to call them back and say well that's okay we might have to rally the troops get some people 0.89
01:07:15 down there well it might actually be worth going and fighting that now oh yeah you know nigel
01:07:19 farage has exhausted himself fighting the first one i mean you know we'll get count bin face on
01:07:24 maybe um but the point is maybe it's actually worth us going and contesting clangton who knows
01:07:29 right but again like mertha tidfil in uh wales that's you know that's probably not familiar
01:07:36 with that one it's a it's a welsh constituent my wife used to live near right it it's probably
01:07:41 voted Labour forever since democracy was invented well I'm bloody sure that Hull has always voted 1.00
01:07:46 Labour yeah yeah Wigan I'm looking at this list they're a weird mix aren't they they are a weird
01:07:55 mix they're a very weird mix and it's it what's interesting about Restore and Pontypreet wife
01:08:01 before me and my wife married she lived there for a bit as well again Labour forever just very
01:08:06 standard hartley paul was um oh the disgraced um friend of jeffrey epstein was a was a u.s
01:08:14 ambassador um oh um he was controlling the labor party don't get old guys because this is what 0.88
01:08:23 now what's his bloody name um oh why is it escaping my memory anyway prince of darkness
01:08:30 yes mandelson mandelson that was so he he i'm pretty sure he was hartley paul wasn't he 0.86
01:08:36 i can't remember now actually but um but what a weird mix it's like coastal tory towns and it's
01:08:42 bristol northeast hard left towns rural welsh towns makerfield okay that's on there yeah so
01:08:49 literally the prime minister's seat yeah um isn't that a really eclectic mix of places across the
01:08:56 country so it's not just any one thing and in fact we have a map right so here's a map now
01:09:02 obviously 20 to 35 percent the only one that registers there is great yarmouth um but that's
01:09:09 very interesting now i kind of notice we're a bit light on the lib dem areas so we need to start
01:09:15 thinking about those they're the zero to fives um but that's that's very interesting that the heart
01:09:21 of england and wales are just like oh no we need to do something about this like no no things are
01:09:27 going to have to go quite right wing before we're satisfied with the situation in this country
01:09:32 that's not bad that's not bad at all i mean it's an i mean what you don't want to be is a party 0.58
01:09:39 that can only win in well i mean it's not like plav kumrai it's not like the snp it's not people
01:09:44 who can only win in a particular area this is a i mean it sounds bad to make this comparison but
01:09:50 this is like bread going moldy and the spores are popping up across the whole loaf well i guess it
01:09:55 is i need a better analogy if i'm ever going to use that again but you see where i'm going with
01:09:59 this yeah i like the coastal seaside towns who are getting it as well yeah all of these places
01:10:03 are like ah yeah you know what we've had enough of this interesting how the welsh is just like
01:10:08 yep got it we we message received loud and clear and of course in the diversified areas those bits
01:10:13 that remain english and yeah they get it it's not the inner city it's the bit that has to live
01:10:19 around them yeah yeah oh no we're gonna we're gonna need something quite serious about this
01:10:23 again the southwest of england where the lib dems all live and come from
01:10:28 cotswolds area yeah okay that that's not feeling the pain at the moment so we've
01:10:32 got a lot of work a bit like your video about your reminiscences on winchester
01:10:35 they're just not feeling the pain they're not don't get it but like i said
01:10:39 i was getting recognized a lot so they are paying attention
01:10:41 so and i and i said this in the previous chat
01:10:45 if anyone could win over the lib dems onto the right
01:10:48 it's oh yeah it's either kemi badenock or rupert low
01:10:52 it's not nigel farage no no he's he's the thing that basically is keeping them lib dem i i think
01:10:58 his peak we we we are past peak reform well past well past and i and what what's worse though is i
01:11:04 don't i don't see any method for them to claw it back right the the the stains that have been put
01:11:10 upon them are too lasting like nigel would have to have some crazy you know saw of tarsus moment
01:11:18 where he's on the road to damascus and gives up all of this money so he's like no i can't be 0.51
01:11:23 taking this money i give it back i give all this back all right give it to charity is there any
01:11:26 speech that nigel farage could give that would make you go yeah actually i trust him now well
01:11:31 because just once trust is gone it doesn't and and for nigel farage again 30 years in politics
01:11:37 a lifetime of being we know what we're getting exactly you know exactly what you're getting so 0.59
01:11:41 if you like him you like him if you hate him you hate him and the country has decided on nigel
01:11:45 farage character and i find it unlikely that's going to change i mean there is only one scenario
01:11:50 that i can think of but it's a bit it's a bit out there well go on labor conservatives and
01:11:55 libdem merge and appoint keir starmer as their leader i mean that is pretty i think that's the
01:12:00 only scenario i can see which which raj is going to win the next general election at this point
01:12:05 i don't see it i don't see any any way out for farage but this does mean there's fertile ground
01:12:12 for restore britain which of course if you're wondering we are supporters of uh so anyway i
01:12:16 guess we'll leave that there but like i said and we've said this prior i think it's i think it's
01:12:21 bad for reform and i think we are on a ticking clock until i'm saying nigel fray to retires
01:12:28 it's only marriage i mean let's compress this entire episode into two very simple points
01:12:32 one burnham's not going to call a general election so therefore we have three years
01:12:37 and the second part of the podcast
01:12:40 is that everything is going in the right direction
01:12:42 Oh yeah, for us anyway
01:12:44 Yeah