The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters - September 29, 2026


PREVIEW: Brokenomics | Elites don’t understand their own system with James Cox

Topics
Hosted by
Guests
Mentioned
Breakfast With Beau | Monday 28th September 2026 The Podcast of the Lotus Eaters #1517

Episode Stats


Length

25 minutes

Words per minute

152.11

Word count

3,954

Sentence count

88

Harmful content

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Proconomics. Now in this episode I am absolutely delighted to be joined
00:00:18 by James Cock, a very successful trader and money manager who has now produced something
00:00:25 that we all need which is a coherent philosophy. James, thank you so much for coming on.
00:00:30 dan thanks so much uh for having me on just by the way my name is james cox
00:00:34 with an s oh yes sorry yes uh yes i get it the other way around everyone calls me dan tubs but
00:00:41 i am singular um but yes yes you are legion sir um so um tell us a little bit about yourself in
00:00:49 your background and how is it that you came to um distill down this into a into a philosophy
00:00:54 sure so i'm british um i however i grew up in the middle east as a boy and as an adult i've
00:01:02 lived most of my life in in the far east um so i've sort of watched british uh history unfold
00:01:10 from far away um and it was during the 2008 crisis that i realized that there was something
00:01:17 wrong with money uh i was a history teacher at the time and sort of worked out that you know
00:01:23 this looks pretty inflationary, what they plan to do to help bail out the banks.
00:01:28 So I took an interest in the history of money, Austrian economics, which I believe you're
00:01:33 interested in. Perhaps we can discuss that later. And I took up trading and went down the sort of
00:01:41 gold bug rabbit hole, followed by the Bitcoin rabbit hole, and ended up going full time with
00:01:48 the trading, launched a fund in Singapore. But then COVID came. And, you know, that era was
00:01:56 pretty crazy. I ended up renting a farmhouse in rural Portugal, and just sort of sitting there
00:02:02 thinking, what on earth is going on? I believe I've watched, I mean, I've watched quite a lot
00:02:08 of your shows. And I know that you were also sort of disturbed by government overreach during
00:02:14 COVID um but one thing that really sort of perturbed me and I'd already experienced it
00:02:22 when trying to explain to people how the monetary system works that they're just sort of not
00:02:27 interested and I always thought that was a little bit odd given that you know most of us have to 0.94
00:02:33 work for money um but during COVID I remember in particular you had that BLM episode during COVID
00:02:40 And you had over a thousand US scientists, many respectable guys from the CDC, stating that if a protest was in a cause of social justice, it couldn't spread COVID.
00:02:55 And I just remember thinking, OK, you know, whatever this is, I'm I'm kind of done and started sort of trying to go through history, look through philosophy to explain why is it that there's so many people who are willing to not only abandon truth, but, you know, willingly blind themselves to to what's going on.
00:03:21 um and amongst all of this you still have the the financial problems and other such problems
00:03:27 cranking away so that inspired me to look into philosophies for some answers and what struck me
00:03:35 as a historian is that you had philosophies since the 17th century since Descartes um about every
00:03:43 17 years which I would suggest is a healthy and vibrant culture in which people are challenging
00:03:50 each other's ideas and that went on you know almost like clockwork for centuries until
00:03:57 ballpark 1970 where philosophy itself appeared to have stopped and you know being a historian
00:04:05 I love my timelines that might come out later in this interview but I just thought how can this be
00:04:13 especially given access to technology these days, it's never been easier to read new material and
00:04:21 share ideas. So I started sort of getting more interested in philosophy and ended up writing my
00:04:28 own. And, you know, it should cover all of the different domains, but I'm not aware that you're
00:04:35 more interested in the sort of economics end of um of the discussion just fyi i've been a big fan
00:04:44 of the lotus eaters cole benjamin and also our own show for a good couple of years now so well
00:04:51 we know you have excellent taste then that's encouraging no very good um i mean i suppose
00:04:56 one pushback that i could make is you know maybe um philosophy is the domain of the sort of you
00:05:03 know 130 iq plus anglos um and and the phenomena in um the phenomena during sort of covid and the
00:05:11 blm stuff is that for a lot of people it's it's a sort of biological base tier that you know the
00:05:17 standing up against a crowd is something that generally only high testosterone men do
00:05:22 a lot of human beings they simply decide um what is everybody else doing and it's all about not
00:05:30 getting outside of the herd yeah i mean you've really hit the nail on the head i i would i would
00:05:37 suggest you know it's not just for anglos if you look at the ancients most of the philosophies
00:05:43 actually came from the east principally india and china we were somewhat of a backwater for the first
00:05:50 cut two three thousand years um but to your point um yes it does require quite a lot of guts to
00:05:59 stand up and say something different and one of the things that i've really dwelt on you know
00:06:06 with this pursuit of truth that ever since the trial of socrates in athens uh when you went up
00:06:13 against the sophists who are their calling card is that send us your son it's expensive but we'll
00:06:19 will educate them in the ways of winning debates and he can go up the greasy pole but you've
00:06:24 essentially got only two pursuits in any given debate one is the pursuit of truth and the other
00:06:30 one's the pursuit of power um and i would add a little bit of nuance to what you were saying
00:06:37 in agreement and support is that most people aren't psychologically predisposed to chase
00:06:44 power for themselves, but most people are predisposed to align with power so they don't
00:06:50 get hurt. And so during the COVID years, it was crystal clear to me that most people weren't
00:06:58 considering what's true, but rather what does everyone else think? And then I'll form my
00:07:03 opinion from there so that I fit in. And I've got a theory as to why perhaps you escaped
00:07:11 that um if probably personally that would that be the high testosterone levels well it's the
00:07:18 high testosterone and manliness but also intellectually you've had a career in private
00:07:24 equity and finance and so for decades you've had it drummed into you the importance of the truth
00:07:33 and if you had to choose between looking cool in a meeting and making or making a or losing a
00:07:40 million dollars it's definitely the latter and if that involves putting up your hand and saying
00:07:45 actually chaps I think I'm wrong on this one it appears to be x then you're just going to
00:07:51 follow reality but you know a lot of professions don't have that engagement with reality anymore 0.99
00:08:01 you know if you're a farmer or a sailor or something that you're hard up against the
00:08:06 coalface of nature you cannot stick your guns and you know wonder what everyone else thinks you're
00:08:14 just going to have to run with it gets very expensive if you if you if you do just double
00:08:19 down all the time and at least with finance is and i think you're right to talk about things like
00:08:24 sailors and and farmers because at least with with finance you know the worst that happens is you end
00:08:28 up losing all your money and all your investors money but you know if you're a sailor and you
00:08:32 stick to your guns and you're wrong yeah i mean that's that's a little bit more existential
00:08:35 that makes perfect sense to me so your book um and i've i've seen um i've seen good chunks of it
00:08:41 and and and had a read um and that obviously led to to wanting to talk to you um is it out yet i
00:08:47 believe it's called the the fourth axiom um now as i i sort of loosely understand it an axiom is a
00:08:54 sort of fundamental principle that you just accept and then you move on from so in mathematics for
00:08:58 example if if this thing and that thing are equal to a third thing then the first two things must
00:09:04 also be equal to each other i mean i think that's my understanding of an axiom so if your book is
00:09:08 called the fourth axiom what what are the first three before we get on to the fourth sure so
00:09:14 there are different types of axioms most of them are mathematical um mine is with reference to
00:09:21 philosophy um so the first three would be aristotle's law of non-contradiction uh which
00:09:29 is a cannot be not a at the same time in the same way uh then descartes 1637 which is i think
00:09:37 therefore i am which is possibly the most famous cogito ergo sum and then in my humble opinion the
00:09:43 third would come in the 1670s with a dutch jew called spinoza um and his his whole work is
00:09:52 axiomatic but underpinning it is whatever exists exists in itself or something else
00:09:58 which probably sounds a little bit mysterious um axioms um you know there's no hard and fast
00:10:07 law about what an axiom is i've got sort of five different definitions that uh might be acceptable
00:10:13 um but my axiom if it is an axiom and maybe it's not is truth is beauty and it's pursuit
00:10:21 an act of faith now that might sound a little bit mysterious the first time that you hear it
00:10:28 um and it comes in in two parts truth is beauty pursuit is faith um anything that you want to
00:10:37 to do will require any pursuits will require faith that there is a way to do it and you have
00:10:43 to do that thing that could be finance or it could be maths or getting fit or playing the piano
00:10:49 and the other aspect is you're going to have to believe that truth is beauty that there is some
00:10:55 point in pursuing truth that there is a way to speak french or learn the piano or what have you
00:11:02 that will be worthwhile so like any axiom there is some sort of metaphysical conceit
00:11:11 now that sort of probably goes off into you know more theoretical realms that won't be interesting
00:11:19 to listeners who i believe are more interested in the economics angle but those would be the
00:11:25 axioms so far as i can see right obviously i i don't dare put myself in the same dizzy
00:11:33 house as dacott or aristotle well i mean why not i mean they started somewhere they started with
00:11:39 the first book so why not um one of the things i did like about it is um you you you write this
00:11:46 philosophy the way that connects for me because you you write it as a you know sort of modern man
00:11:51 and a finance man and so on so it's it's connectable um and in particular you've got this
00:11:56 equation in there which is if i'm remembering it correctly i mean um known reach plus future reach
00:12:02 um divided by idea cost uh plus belief cost i think it was i mean you're probably a little
00:12:09 bit more fluid on it than i am on that um but but let's pick up on that what what makes one
00:12:14 explanation better than another yeah so by the way you've got the equation exactly right
00:12:20 oh good right so i started off um thinking through in terms of when you're doing history
00:12:29 uh you're you're doing something that's uh called abductive logic so deductive logic would be maths
00:12:36 two plus two equals four and then you've got inductive logic which would be science the
00:12:42 litmus paper was blue i can't remember why the litmus paper was blue um but abductive logic is
00:12:48 somewhere in the middle in that you don't have all the evidence and you can't run tests so what
00:12:56 you're going to have to do is take the scraps of evidence that you you do have and try to create
00:13:03 the hypothesis that's going to fit the best you can so in in this manner we're doing something
00:13:11 that's far more like being a detective or a historian or an archaeologist and what you're
00:13:19 trying to do is compare different theories or hypothesis or explanations so the next question
00:13:27 if you're going down that route is so how would we determine what idea is better than another
00:13:33 how is hypothesis B superior to A and I came up with the the truth equation which is exactly as
00:13:42 you describe it and that's idea value equals known reach plus future reach as in how much
00:13:50 explanatory power does it have divided by idea cost as in how much do you have to grasp in order
00:13:58 to grasp the idea and belief cost how much of what you already believe would you have to abandon
00:14:04 so essentially new assumptions so in short idea value would be explanatory power divided by
00:14:13 new assumptions now in the book i do this through a story about astronomy how for one and a half
00:14:24 thousand years we believed in the the way the planets moved could be explained by a book called
00:14:31 the algamest written by a greek in ancient egypt called ptolemy and even when copernicus
00:14:39 pointed out that actually i think the the sun is the center of the universe and not the earth
00:14:46 nobody believed him in fact the vatican wasn't happy at all but then you've got kepler then
00:14:52 you've got Galileo with his telescope and slowly in the 17th century people started to believe that
00:14:58 the earth was not the center of the universe but the sun was and it wasn't until Sir Isaac Newton
00:15:05 that the matter was kind of settled. Nevertheless I'm pretty sure that your readers are and listeners
00:15:11 aren't so interested in astronomy but more interested in economics so what I was thinking
00:15:17 might be quite fun is if we apply the truth equation to something that you're more familiar
00:15:24 with which is economic theory um i believe you're quite a fan of the austrian school yeah so
00:15:31 what i was thinking might be fun i'm a fan of the austrian school as well but what i was thinking
00:15:36 might be quite fun is if i go into bat for marx and marxism and you go into bat for the austrians
00:15:45 and have a sort of truth equation penalty shootout.
00:15:50 The listeners can judge for themselves
00:15:52 who they think has got the better idea.
00:15:56 Oh, I'm nervous now. All right, then.
00:15:58 Oh, Crikey, I'll put you on the spot.
00:16:00 Okay, shall I go first?
00:16:02 Oh, go on then.
00:16:03 Right, okay, so Marxism.
00:16:06 So when we're talking about Marxism,
00:16:07 we're talking about Marx and his chum, Engels.
00:16:11 They wrote the Communist Manifesto in 1848.
00:16:15 And then Marx went on to write the Das Kapital in 1867,
00:16:21 outlining a theory that we now call communism.
00:16:26 So those are sort of the key people.
00:16:30 Can you remember who would be some sort of key players
00:16:32 for the Austrian school? 0.95
00:16:35 Oh, Hayek, Mrs.
00:16:39 Those sort of characters.
00:16:41 Yeah, okay.
00:16:42 So Menger in the 1870s
00:16:45 And then his student, Bon Buerk
00:16:47 His student, again, Mises
00:16:50 Hayek, I'm a fan of Rothbard
00:16:52 So you've got these dudes who are mainly Austrians
00:16:57 Thus, you know, the Austrian school 0.96
00:16:59 Versus the Germans of Marx and Engels 1.00
00:17:05 So a decent footballing analogy so far, I hope 0.98
00:17:08 So in terms of idea cost
00:17:12 Marxism is not the simplest of things.
00:17:16 It's good at slogans, but if you actually read the text,
00:17:21 there's quite a lot to unpack.
00:17:22 So there's two things going on.
00:17:24 Yeah, but the people who follow Marxism, it is very cheap for them.
00:17:28 It is very low belief cost because they do only listen to the slogans.
00:17:32 None of them actually read Das Kapital.
00:17:35 Yeah, okay.
00:17:37 We'll hold off on belief cost just for a minute.
00:17:39 Oh, okay.
00:17:39 And just cover the idea.
00:17:43 So in order to understand Marxism, you've got a theory of history, which is materialism and stages.
00:17:49 So that would be hunter-gatherer, followed by feudal, followed by bourgeoisie, and communism would be the end state.
00:17:58 So history goes through stages.
00:18:01 And secondly, within that process, you've got class struggles.
00:18:04 So there's always the oppressor and the oppressed.
00:18:07 So in feudal times, that was the baron. And in Marx's time, that baron and peasants, Marx's time would be the industrialist and the factory worker.
00:18:19 And then you've got the economics angle, which is labor theory of value.
00:18:24 The reason this glass case has value is because the labor that went into it.
00:18:29 and then secondly um value surplus which is extracted from the worker in favor of the
00:18:40 oppressor so you've got two parts uh you've got history and you've got economics each of which
00:18:47 have you know some machinery in there so that there's sort of four key ideas that you would
00:18:52 need to comprehend to really understand Marxism.
00:18:58 So with that in mind, your turn now.
00:19:01 What would be the sort of core idea of Austrian thought economics?
00:19:08 Oh, yeah, I should have a ready answer for this.
00:19:11 I'm going to look at that now.
00:19:12 The core idea.
00:19:14 I mean, normally it's set up, the way that I interact with it,
00:19:18 it's set up in sort of opposition to the status quo.
00:19:22 So this is going to sound awfully lefty now, but a deconstruction of why the current system isn't working.
00:19:28 But I suppose you can take it back to a whole series of fundamental principles as well.
00:19:33 And you can build it up from, well, you know, you can start off with a sort of seashells example of two people trading fish on a desert island.
00:19:42 And you can logically build it up at every individual step.
00:19:46 and and in response to something like um you know marxism of where where it's only the sort
00:19:53 of labor that matters it's like well how you how useful is that labor being applied i mean if you're
00:19:58 farming in the year seven it's a lot different to um farming in in 1977 when somebody's invented
00:20:05 tractors because there has been innovation and there's been capital investment and so on and
00:20:11 actually that capital investment raises the level of which your labour can be applied and that has
00:20:17 to be compensated as well and thus it is appropriate that there is a split between capital and labour
00:20:24 and you don't just simply assume that all capital is a sunk cost and then not going to develop from
00:20:29 that point and therefore you only need to factor in labour. Sure, so in terms of idea cost you've
00:20:36 got marxism with uh the two components of history which is uh historical materialism and also class
00:20:44 oppression and also theory of value which comes from labor and the extraction of value from labor
00:20:52 versus all you have to really remember for uh austrian economics is subjective theory of value
00:21:01 really that something is worth what someone is willing to pay for it that's what i was trying
00:21:09 to get at but yeah yeah and into that goes all sorts of uh different um calculations and
00:21:18 um one of them is the the time value of capital accumulation you talked about tractors um but
00:21:26 also the decentralization of information and knowledge and that's something that Hayek
00:21:33 wrote about the use of knowledge in society in 1945 that you know the farmer knows best what
00:21:41 his soil is going to produce next year than a central planner so in terms of idea cost
00:21:49 Austrian economics is actually pretty simple compared to Marxism.
00:21:55 Okay, yes. Okay.
00:21:57 If you get beyond the level of slogans,
00:21:59 if you start looking at the underlying ideas,
00:22:01 I'll give you that. That's true.
00:22:03 Marxism is actually quite complex.
00:22:09 But then we've got to...
00:22:10 So if we remember that's the denominator,
00:22:13 we've now got to look at explanatory reach,
00:22:15 which is two halves,
00:22:16 which is the known reach as in what does it explain and what does it predict so in terms of
00:22:22 marxism marx was to be fair pretty good when it came to class conflict he could explain unions
00:22:29 pretty well he could explain poor factory conditions especially in 19th century manchester
00:22:35 london pretty well um and when it came to future prediction being a materialist he was very sort
00:22:45 precise about what would definitely happen and what would definitely happen would be
00:22:50 and in 1848 there were revolutions in in germany and in europe but he said this is the bourgeois
00:22:55 revolution it's going to be followed by the communist proletariat revolution and he said
00:23:02 it would happen in the industrialized countries that would be britain germany and france he's
00:23:07 good in that he did make falsifiable predictions and he's good in that or marxism is good in that
00:23:14 it did explain, you know, class relations and class struggles pretty well. But in terms of
00:23:22 predictive value, it didn't really predict very much. For the Austrians, they can explain quite
00:23:29 a lot about price formation, capital structure, decentralized knowledge, that's Hayek again.
00:23:37 and they didn't really make so many predictions as such in the cast iron manner that Marx did
00:23:45 but Meises pointed out that you've got to have price if you don't have price you don't have a
00:23:51 signal if I'm the farmer and there's no price of wheat then how would I know how much fertilizer
00:23:58 to to buy if I'm a sailor or a fisherman and there's no price for fish should I buy more nets
00:24:05 or not. And Hayek built on this with information. And so the Austrians predicted that central
00:24:13 planning wouldn't work out, but they didn't give any sort of precise timelines or which
00:24:19 countries or what have you. So essentially, you've got the explanatory reach of Marx versus
00:24:28 the explanatory reach of the Austrian school divided by how much you have to remember in
00:24:35 order to grasp them so it's explanatory power divided by new new ideas is this helping yes i
00:24:43 think i see where you're going with this okay so if we believe that austrian economics is simpler
00:24:52 to grasp in its core components the marxism and explains more than marxism yes you know marx
00:25:01 Marx is pretty poor at explaining why is beachfront property so much more expensive than three roads
00:25:08 back? How does it do two, three times the price? Why is your wife's engagement ring, the diamond,
00:25:15 why is that worth so much? Whereas for the Austrians, this is simple, it's because that's 0.99
00:25:20 what people are willing to pay. It's no more complex than theirs. People like beachfront property
00:25:26 and you can't explain this via Labour.
00:25:30 So I would submit that Austrian economics
00:25:33 has a superior idea value to Marxism
00:25:37 because it's simpler to understand and explains more.
00:25:41 Yes.
00:25:42 If you enjoyed that content,
00:25:44 and of course you did because you are a smart person,
00:25:47 then why don't you go over to lotuseaters.com
00:25:49 where you can watch the whole episode
00:25:51 for as little as £5 a month,
00:25:54 which really is not much money at all and you get loads of really good content.