The Saad Truth with Dr. Saad - October 01, 2026


Dr. Randy Wayne - Cornell Plant Biologist and Champion of Academic Freedom (The Saad Truth with Dr. Saad_1054)

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
Problems Between the Two Sexes with Host Jesse Watters (The Saad Truth with Dr. Saad_1053) On the Inefficacy of Sending Dick Pics to Women - Lack of Theory of Mind (The Saad Truth with Dr. Saad_1055)

Episode Stats


Length

58 minutes

Words per minute

139.13

Word count

8,127

Sentence count

538

Harmful content

Toxicity

9

sentences flagged

Hate speech

17

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 I'm delighted to report that I have joined as a visiting professor the Declaration of Independence
00:00:06 Center for the Study of American Freedom at the University of Mississippi. The center offers
00:00:12 educational opportunities, speakers, internship, and reading groups for the University of Mississippi
00:00:18 community. It is named in honor of the United States founding document which constitutes the
00:00:25 nation as a political community and expresses fundamental principles of American freedom,
00:00:31 including in the recognition of the importance of Judeo-Christian values in shaping American
00:00:37 exceptionalism. Dedicated to the academic and open-minded exploration of these principles,
00:00:44 the Center exists to encourage exploration into the many facets of freedom. It will sponsor a
00:00:50 speaker series, and an interdisciplinary faculty research team. If you'd like to learn more about
00:00:56 the center, please visit Ole Miss, that's O-L-E-M-I-S-S dot E-D-U slash independence slash.
00:01:05 Hi, everybody. This is Gatsad. Today, I've got a fellow Cornelian straight from Cornell University,
00:01:12 which is my alma mater. I was also a visiting professor there for a while. I've got Professor
00:01:18 randy wayne a plant biologist at cornell how are you doing randy i'm great and it's so terrific to
00:01:25 be on here with you gad oh likewise you know and i don't say this because i'm trying to as they say
00:01:32 forgive the spicy term blow smoke up your proverbial behind i rarely have met an academia
00:01:39 people that are both truly gentlemen and scholars, but I have the distinct privilege of having
00:01:48 you on the show, and you certainly exemplify both.
00:01:51 So welcome on the show.
00:01:53 This is your inaugural appearance on The Sad Truth.
00:01:55 Hopefully, you'll come back many more times.
00:01:59 What's going on at Cornell?
00:02:01 What is happening, Randy?
00:02:02 Tell us about it.
00:02:04 Well, okay.
00:02:06 Let me let me start with the bad news so we can get past that.
00:02:12 And so because I don't know the facts.
00:02:16 So there was or was not a rape that occurred in 2024.
00:02:26 The first complaint that was filed with the police said that everything was consensual.
00:02:35 So we don't know if that was true or not then. And I'm willing to believe it may or may not have been true then. And there's some unknown aspects to me of how Cornell contacted the Ithaca Police Department.
00:02:57 Did they share all the information they had or not? It's not clear to me. And the Ithaca Police Department decided that it wasn't a criminal case.
00:03:11 So the case that we hear about now was essentially seven men were involved in raping a woman for seven hours.
00:03:23 And there's a Snapchat picture of some of the talk that was going on during or next to.
00:03:36 And it's not complimentary to anybody.
00:03:39 and who knows who had that evidence when.
00:03:45 So from what I hear, this is about the biggest story in the country now.
00:03:52 And it is horrible.
00:03:57 It really is horrible.
00:03:58 And I hope actually we get to the truth of it.
00:04:02 Of course.
00:04:03 And if people need to be punished, so be it.
00:04:07 If people need to be exonerated, so be it. Just beforehand, there's no telling. Is it the woman
00:04:17 or the man that's not telling the truth? Right. Okay. So that's the, of course, the dreadful 0.98
00:04:25 sort of gang rape accusation. But there are other wacky things happening at Cornell.
00:04:32 We had Hassan Piker invited to Cornell. We had Alexandra Ocasio-Cortez. I call her Occasional Cortex. She's been invited to Cornell. Now, you and I have discussed previously because of our love and appreciation of Cornell, you're a professor there.
00:04:55 I was a doctoral student there and a visiting professor, that, you know, Cornell has gone very much the way of many of the other elite prestigious universities becoming super woke.
00:05:06 Is there something unique about Cornell in terms of it platforming these people?
00:05:13 Or is this just part and parcel of the realities of the Ivy League?
00:05:19 No, I think this is part and parcel of the realities of the Ivy League.
00:05:22 and unfortunately and i went to see hassan piker right because i i think i have a different view
00:05:30 than many people i think everybody has if somebody's invited to speak they can speak
00:05:39 i'm a free speech absolutist in terms of that however i came to i came prepared to ask him a
00:05:47 question based on his talk. And he didn't take questions from the audience, because that's where
00:05:53 free speech begins to really matter when he says something and is ready to see if perhaps he's in
00:06:01 error, which I believe his facts were completely wrong. And I would have liked to hear his
00:06:08 explanation. What was, if you don't mind me asking, what was the thing that you were going to post?
00:06:14 Yeah. So he talked about how hypocritical and how horrible and how, let me say, hypocritical and horrible the West is, and all the billionaires in the West, particularly. 0.97
00:06:35 And so I wanted to ask him, does he see Islam in the same fair light? Has Islam, did they peacefully take over Northern Africa and the Middle East and Europe? And are they continually to peacefully take over England, for example? 0.96
00:07:01 So is it a peaceful religion in that terms and not imperialistic, like he says Western culture is?
00:07:10 Do the billionaires share their money and build schools in Gaza?
00:07:15 I think not. 0.78
00:07:17 Just so every criticism he had for the United States, I think you can make the same criticism in spades against Islam. 0.94
00:07:26 What would you have predicted would have been his answer?
00:07:29 you know i didn't predict that he would be too cowardly to take questions right so um i guessed
00:07:39 he would have just um brushed it aside brushed it aside yes thank you and um because i can't
00:07:47 imagine i can't even imagine um what an answer could be an honest answer well i'm going to give
00:07:54 you a few that he would likely say you're ready yes uh any manifestation of so-called violence
00:08:02 that islam might be accused of it's only because they were taking a defensive strategy against
00:08:09 you know american imperialism and therefore so for example october 7th itself from his
00:08:17 perspective would have been perfectly justified because you've got these noble peaceful freedom
00:08:22 fighters that have been under a open border open air prison where there's a daily genocide being
00:08:30 committed against them and so is it not natural for them to then go and gang rape 1200 people and 0.53
00:08:36 chop off their heads because those babies ultimately are going to in the future be 0.98
00:08:40 you know evil zionists and so i think that there's almost no amount of evidence that you could have 0.96
00:08:47 offered in the prelude to your question that could have unshaken his belief that America bad, 0.89
00:08:54 Islam good. But maybe I'm wrong. Gee, you almost had me convinced. 0.57
00:09:00 Because I've had so much experience dealing with those dishonest interlocutors that I could almost
00:09:07 predict with my eyes closed exactly what they're going to say. They truly are impenetrable to
00:09:14 reason to evidence to to anything that we might call logical okay so and then did you did you get
00:09:19 a chance to did you have the distinct pleasure to also hear the pontification of uh alexandra
00:09:26 cortez no i did i i saw her on tv but i didn't go you didn't go to her rally hassan was enough
00:09:33 for you you couldn't have plenty that's uh all right so let's let's so i want to tell people
00:09:40 how we originally met uh you and i had been invited we had gone to uh stanford for a conference
00:09:48 on academic freedom in 2022 and i think we were on a bus that would take us from the hotel to the
00:09:57 venue we sat next to each other and we started talking about all kinds of things i think if i
00:10:02 remember correctly we mentioned our mutual admiration for evil wilson is it okay there's
00:10:09 some light? My light's on a timer. So let me, I can't control. Here we go. Oh, okay. All right.
00:10:17 Yeah. So, so we, I think we spoke a bit about E.O. Wilson. We spoke maybe a bit about evolution
00:10:23 in general, but, and maybe I think you had mentioned very briefly, I'm not sure if I
00:10:28 understood all the intricacies about your specialization in, in, in your academic research.
00:10:34 And you mentioned the very long specialization term. Let's see if I can remember, if I can get 100% on the exam, Professor Wayne. You are a biophysical plant cell biologist that I-
00:10:52 A plus.
00:10:53 Thank God.
00:10:54 100% on the final exam. All right. Unpack that for us. I have a sense of what plant biology
00:11:03 might mean. How do we apply physics to it? Without getting into too many technical details,
00:11:09 because obviously we have a general audience, tell us what keeps you up in your academic work.
00:11:14 Yeah. So I choose to work on single cells as opposed to larger organisms,
00:11:22 because I want to choose the simplest system that represents life.
00:11:27 So an amoeba would be one.
00:11:28 So an amoeba would be one.
00:11:29 I work on a single cell of CARA to study gravity,
00:11:37 work on a single cell of Donaliella to study light,
00:11:41 or a single cell of those are two algae, or fern spores.
00:11:48 so um i try to reduce the complications by by starting with organisms actually that are single
00:11:56 cells they're both organisms and single cells and the fact that the fact that you're studying
00:12:02 gravity and light that's where the physics comes in you are going to now be applying
00:12:08 physics-based principles to study these biological organisms is that roughly correct
00:12:14 Yes. Actually, I can give an example of that. So inside plant cells, there's starch grains, the things that add weight to us. And those starch grains are thought to fall down when you turn a cell from horizontal to vertical. And when they hit the bottom of the cell, that causes the cell to say, okay, that's the bottom, and the other side must be the top.
00:12:42 However, if you calculate the energy in a falling starch grain, there's not enough energy to actually do anything.
00:12:51 It's a million times two less.
00:12:53 The water molecules hitting any receptor have a million times more energy than this falling starch grain.
00:13:01 And it actually doesn't fall like this.
00:13:04 Like a feather falling, sort of.
00:13:07 Pretty much, because the cytoplasma is very, very viscous.
00:13:12 So, it does fall like a feather.
00:13:15 Like a feather through air, these starch grains fall through cytoplasm.
00:13:20 And so, I said there must be another way that they're sensing gravity.
00:13:27 So, I chose to work on cells that actually don't have starch grains to begin with.
00:13:34 And so, those are the carousels.
00:13:38 And if you irradiate the ends of the cells, they won't sense gravity.
00:13:44 They're normal in every other way, but they won't sense gravity.
00:13:48 And if you put the cells in a medium that's very dense, the protoplasm will actually go up instead of falling down.
00:13:59 So it's like you in water versus you in air.
00:14:02 and when you put the protoplasm in a dense medium it actually thinks that that's down
00:14:09 and this is up right so it senses the opposite so we've done some work on the photoreceptors
00:14:17 that i mean the receptors that are involved in sensing gravity what they bind to in the wall
00:14:23 just outside the membrane we use electrical methods to see what they may be doing once they
00:14:31 sense gravity and that's that's the biophysical part and is does does that sensorial mechanism of
00:14:38 you know sensing gravity what are the downstream consequences as a function of how the cell senses
00:14:45 gravity it then orients itself in the appropriate manner for mobility for like what's the mechanism
00:14:53 that is important once I'm able to sense gravity or not?
00:14:58 What's important is that the roots go down
00:15:04 and the shoots go up.
00:15:07 If it did the opposite, that's the end of the plant.
00:15:11 The roots won't find nutrients and water
00:15:13 and the top of the plant won't find sun for photosynthesis.
00:15:18 Got it.
00:15:18 And now in your work,
00:15:21 because i mentioned in the introduction that we had you know briefly talked about eo wilson who
00:15:26 is obviously an avowed evolutionist we talked about evolutionary theory
00:15:29 as you probably know there's a distinction in well in by for any biological phenomenon
00:15:37 between proximate and ultimate explanations right the proximate are the how and what of a phenomenon
00:15:43 the ultimate i'm not explaining this to you i'm explaining it for our audience and then the
00:15:49 ultimate is the darwinian why why would that phenomenon have evolved to be of that form and
00:15:54 you really need both levels of explanations to fully explain a biological phenomenon when i hear
00:16:02 you speaking i i hear you navigating in proximate world you're explaining the mechanisms does that
00:16:11 mean that you can do your work completely bereft of the ultimate lens or does the ultimate lens
00:16:19 still inform your proximate stuff?
00:16:23 Actually, you asked one of the most interesting questions in the world.
00:16:26 Oh, wow.
00:16:27 And that is, what's the relationship of the part to the whole?
00:16:31 Right.
00:16:32 And I'm really working on the laws of nature on these things.
00:16:37 And there's two ways to get to the laws of nature,
00:16:39 sort of building bricks up little bit by little bit from the foundation.
00:16:44 or say the law came from above, but that's a little hard to work with in the lab.
00:16:52 So how can we look at it from a systems approach?
00:16:58 So the systems approach gives it meaning so that anybody should be able to understand
00:17:04 and that the scientists themselves should be able to understand it better.
00:17:10 So I think the telos is important.
00:17:12 I think when science said, let's not look at purpose and telos, it was a mistake.
00:17:18 Right.
00:17:19 But in fact, my proximal interest is working on the proximal causes, that the Gravi receptor senses a certain amount of tension on the top and compression on the bottom.
00:17:34 And there's enough energy in that to open a calcium channel.
00:17:39 But that's as far as we've gotten, essentially.
00:17:42 Are you able to, and before I even ask my question, I don't mean to imply that for basic scientific research to have value, we have to somehow find an application to the human condition, but I'm someone who, as you know, thinks very synthetically, where can I build bridges?
00:18:03 How can I create consilience, to use E.O. Wilson's famous term?
00:18:08 Are you able to take, even if it's in the abstract, even though you may not have done
00:18:14 it yet, are you able to take some of the insights based on, stemming from your basic research
00:18:20 and say, here is a trajectory where I see this having some application to the human
00:18:26 context?
00:18:28 Okay, stop me if I get too long here.
00:18:31 Okay, go ahead.
00:18:32 Okay. And so I'm going to take this from how cells sense light to can Elon Musk get to Mars?
00:18:43 Wow, that's a big one. Okay, go.
00:18:45 So, all right. So the physicists make three assumptions right from the beginning. Assume
00:18:54 that there's no friction, assume that elementary particles are mathematical points, and time goes
00:19:03 forward and backwards. So, those three assumptions, I just can't buy as a biologist. So, for example,
00:19:13 if when a nerve fires, ions move through the channels, and the ions move through the channels
00:19:23 such that their velocity is proportional to the force,
00:19:27 that is, the current is proportional to the voltage.
00:19:31 So it's the velocity that's proportional to the force,
00:19:34 not the acceleration, which is Newton's second law.
00:19:38 Right.
00:19:38 And that means that there's friction.
00:19:40 As the ions go through, they hit things.
00:19:43 So they go, stop, go, stop.
00:19:45 So actually, they go at constant velocity on the average.
00:19:52 So, or when chromosomes are going to the pole, if you stop the motor, they don't just glide a little bit, they just stop.
00:20:01 So, I have to introduce friction into the way I look at things.
00:20:08 Secondly, the physicists say that elementary particles are mathematical points.
00:20:16 And when Robert Hooke began using a microscope in 1665,
00:20:21 he thought he should begin as a geometer.
00:20:23 So he looked at a point, and he stuck a needle under the microscope.
00:20:27 But he saw the tip of that microscope wasn't much of a point.
00:20:31 It was very, very blunt.
00:20:33 So I think when you say an elementary particle is a mathematical point,
00:20:39 maybe it's a good first assumption, but it's something you should get past.
00:20:45 And the third thing is that assuming time goes forward and backwards.
00:20:52 Okay, I've just never experienced it.
00:20:55 So I think maybe there could be another way to introduce that negative sign for positive time and negative sign.
00:21:05 And that other thing that I do is I allow for negative mass.
00:21:11 So I do three things.
00:21:14 allow for friction, make elementary particles a little bit bigger than a mathematical point,
00:21:21 and only allow time to go in one direction, which allows those particles to have negative mass.
00:21:28 So the difference between matter and antimatter in standard physics is if you change, if you
00:21:38 start with matter. You change the charge. You reverse it. So positive to negative or negative
00:21:44 to positive. You change the parity, which means the direction it's spinning. Although it's not
00:21:51 actually spinning because it's a point and a point can't spin. So the quantum mechanics people,
00:21:55 there's just a number. There's nothing there to understand, but I allow things to spin.
00:22:00 And the third thing that antimatter is matter that goes backwards in time.
00:22:05 So since I only allow time to go in one direction, I have to say antimatter is matter that has negative mass.
00:22:13 So negative mass is like your kids.
00:22:16 When you're pulling them, say, you got to go to the dentist, they sort of go in the other direction against the force.
00:22:24 So it's actually an allowed concept in physics, but it's not appreciated very much.
00:22:32 so um so to pull this back to um i worked on how cells sense light but when biology got rid of the
00:22:43 logos in biology they wanted to get rid of the academic sound but they really did at the same
00:22:49 time get in my field get rid of the logos the meaning the reason the word and turned it into
00:22:57 omics, which sounds more like economics. And you've heard of genomics, transcriptomics.
00:23:04 So instead of looking at one, two, or three variables at a time, they're looking at 40,000
00:23:10 variables at a time. And there's actually no way to do those controls. So the way to succeed
00:23:18 in an experiment is just to be incredibly lucky. And you get that one gene that may
00:23:24 cure disease or feed the world. But most of the work, I think it doesn't help us understand the
00:23:34 world at all. So anyhow, I went from how cells perceive light and sense and respond to light
00:23:44 to what is light itself. So I've made a model of the photon based on changing these three
00:23:52 assumptions. And I can tell you the experiments I did at another time. So I come up with a photon
00:24:00 that's made out of two particles, one particle of matter, one particle of antimatter. So one has a
00:24:07 positive mass, one has a negative mass. So the sum of the two masses is zero. So it's a massless
00:24:13 particle. And when you apply Newton's gravitational law to positive and negative mass, you find out
00:24:21 the positive mass runs away from the negative mass, and the negative mass chases it. So, in fact,
00:24:29 if you were ever to ask anybody, why does light move, they wouldn't have an answer, because that
00:24:36 mathematical point can't do anything. But actually, the gravitational force makes the light move.
00:24:43 So, the positive particle moves, and the negative catches up. And actually, like a slinky, you can
00:24:49 see the particles and the wave. You don't have to say light's a particle on Monday, Wednesdays,
00:24:55 and Fridays, and a wave on Tuesdays, Thursdays, and Saturdays. Those particles also, because they
00:25:02 have extension, also rotate. And that rotation gives them a certain amount of angular momentum,
00:25:09 which describes the polarization of light and other physical properties. But let's get back
00:25:16 to something that's useful, the Elon Musk.
00:25:18 Yeah, I was waiting for the Elon Musk.
00:25:20 Now, so we have these particles that are moving and moving.
00:25:25 Now, light can exert a force.
00:25:27 It has linear momentum.
00:25:30 And so if you can isolate the two particles of matter and antimatter,
00:25:38 which is just as difficult in space as isolating hydrogen and oxygen
00:25:43 to have them fuse um but if you can do that you essentially have an endless source of
00:25:51 very high and high powered energy or hence the power intergalactic travel i see yeah so the
00:25:59 trouble is making enough matter and antimatter um that you can now let come together and um
00:26:06 cause a force very interesting so as you were talking about the tension between what the
00:26:13 physicists are using as their sort of three you know assumptions versus what you are describing
00:26:20 in in the actual real world it reminds me of the tension say in economics where economists will
00:26:29 build these theoretical models so the black box now the black box might descriptively be invalid
00:26:38 In other words, it doesn't accurately describe human behavior. So, for example, homo economicus, the definition of what constitutes an axiom of rational choice that the classical economist says that we should be adhering to, is not adhered to, hence the work of Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky.
00:27:00 But then the economist will say, I don't care that the descriptive validity of the black box is wrong, because I simply care about being able to predict behavior at higher than random chance level.
00:27:15 So is that the exact same tension that is happening with the physicist and what you're saying?
00:27:20 He's saying, I want to achieve a theoretical parsimony, a coherent, elegant thing.
00:27:27 I don't really care whether it is descriptively valid.
00:27:31 It sounds to me like the two are analogous.
00:27:33 Am I right or am I off?
00:27:36 You're right.
00:27:37 But it's even more and has little to do with free speech.
00:27:40 Okay.
00:27:42 So can you imagine here's two electric plates?
00:27:48 This one is negatively charged and this is positively charged.
00:27:51 And you're going to press a switch that's going to make a current flow
00:27:54 from the negative side to the positive side.
00:27:57 so the electrons are going to flow. The longer you press that switch, the faster the electrons
00:28:03 are going to go. They're going to accelerate. And if you do it for eight hours, they'll accelerate
00:28:11 linearly. Another eight hours, well, maybe they'll slow down a little, as if you only work for seven
00:28:17 hours. And then the next eight hours, well, maybe they'll accelerate just a little bit, like you
00:28:24 only work for seven seconds, et cetera, et cetera. So you see a curve of acceleration of velocity
00:28:30 that looks like this. And those electrons asymptote at the speed of light. So what
00:28:39 Einstein says, each of those electrons has a little watch, and the faster it goes, the slower
00:28:45 the watch goes. So it was not going that fast in the beginning. So you said you worked eight hours,
00:28:52 it said you worked eight hours. But the next set of eight hours, it thought you only worked for
00:28:57 seven hours. And then for seven seconds, et cetera, et cetera. So it only accelerated what
00:29:05 it thought was appropriate for how long it thought you worked. And that's what actually everybody
00:29:10 believes. So Einstein only had two free parameters he can use to model this, that space and time.
00:29:19 But as a biologist, I know that everything that moves, moves through something.
00:29:27 So I ask, what are those electrons moving through?
00:29:31 And actually, right now in front of you, surrounding you, surrounding me, is a black body distribution of photons.
00:29:39 Planck's black body distribution of photons.
00:29:42 So those photons are surrounding it.
00:29:45 The photons that hit the front of the electron actually push the electron back a little bit.
00:29:50 The ones that hit the back push it forward a little bit.
00:29:54 So you have the ones that hit the side push it to the side.
00:29:59 The electron actually moves by Brownian motion.
00:30:02 If it wasn't moving, it would move like this.
00:30:06 And Robert Brown was a botanist, discovered it when he was looking at pollination and the pollen grains broke at his microscope.
00:30:13 and Einstein did his PhD thesis on Brownian motion.
00:30:18 So again, there's a botany phys.
00:30:20 Oh, no, let me turn a little light on.
00:30:23 Okay, so I've been demolishing my lab
00:30:29 to renovate the buildings.
00:30:31 So I got moved into this room,
00:30:33 which is actually incredible for the experiments I'm doing,
00:30:36 except it has that light feature.
00:30:39 Okay, so, but when the electron's moving,
00:30:43 It will see the light that comes towards it as being Doppler-shifted, so of a higher frequency.
00:30:49 So it'll push it back more, just like an ambulance coming towards you.
00:30:53 That sounds higher frequency.
00:30:56 And the photons that hit the back of the electron will be red-shifted, so they'll hit it less frequently.
00:31:04 So if you add up those two forces, what it makes is a drag force or a viscous force
00:31:09 that goes in the opposite direction of the electron.
00:31:13 And the faster the electron goes,
00:31:15 the bigger this force slows it down.
00:31:19 So what you have is light itself
00:31:23 prevents the electron from going faster
00:31:26 than the speed of light.
00:31:28 So I thought that was pretty good.
00:31:30 And the equations work out to be the same
00:31:32 as the Lorentz transformation,
00:31:34 all the relativity equations,
00:31:36 except you're just saying the light
00:31:37 is what's slowing down the electron, not time and space getting warped.
00:31:43 So I went to David Merman, who's taught special relativity here for 50 years.
00:31:48 And I said, I got something that I'd like to run by you.
00:31:53 And I ran it by.
00:31:54 He said, wow, that's great.
00:31:58 I never thought of that before.
00:32:02 Drop it instantly, because special relativity is so good,
00:32:05 and Einstein's so wonderful.
00:32:07 and then he stopped talking with me.
00:32:11 Yikes.
00:32:13 So he succumbed, and we'll come back to this.
00:32:16 So he succumbed to the Semmelweis reflex.
00:32:20 Yes.
00:32:22 We'll talk about that in a second.
00:32:23 He washed his hands of me.
00:32:26 Well played, sir.
00:32:29 For those of you who are wondering what we're talking about,
00:32:32 if you missed the reference, we'll unpack it in a second.
00:32:35 Okay, but finish your point.
00:32:36 And so your relationship is broken.
00:32:40 Yes.
00:32:41 And then I started working on general relativity.
00:32:45 So I'll explain it kind of the same way I just did.
00:32:50 So if you have a photon of starlight going by sun, the sun will bend it.
00:32:55 The mass of the sun will bend it.
00:32:58 So the telescope tilts this way, and you look and you see the star here displaced.
00:33:05 And Einstein predicted that the displacement would be twice as big
00:33:09 as someone who used Newton's laws to predict the displacement.
00:33:14 So I want to say, if the photon itself had infinite translational energy,
00:33:22 it would never be bent by the sun.
00:33:24 If it had no translational energy, it would fall into the sun.
00:33:29 So the fact that you get this double bending may mean it only has half the translational energy than you expect it to have.
00:33:40 So what's the other possible energy?
00:33:43 And I'd say that's rotational energy because the photon is actually rotating.
00:33:49 And that gives the exact same results as the warping of space-time.
00:33:55 But you just have normal space and normal time. So when I started working on that, I actually got blacklisted from the archive that's founded here at Cornell. So I wrote to the two professors that oversee it. I say, I don't want to be wrong. So how about if I take you out for a cup of coffee and you tell me why I'm wrong?
00:34:17 and they didn't answer. I wrote back one more time to be polite, just in case, you know,
00:34:25 they were too busy when they got the email. But again, no answer. So actually, the relativity
00:34:31 and quantum mechanics crowd is where I cut my teeth for learning about free speech.
00:34:38 I was just going to say, actually, because as you're sort of describing this, I was going to
00:34:44 ask you is this where you then suddenly realize oh there are some academic freedom issues here
00:34:51 that i might want to get involved so that you just answered that question so so you started
00:34:56 with the classic sort of semelweiss reflex and let me mention for those of you don't know semelweiss
00:35:03 is some by the way our esteemed guest today is cited in suicidal empathy uh precisely because
00:35:12 as you and I were geeking out over all kinds of topics
00:35:16 when you kindly invited me to deliver some lectures at Cornell,
00:35:20 we talked about Samuel Weiss, and then you mentioned, I think it was
00:35:24 Kurt Vonnegut, right, who
00:35:28 gave some commencement speech. It was about
00:35:32 Samuel Weiss and so on. Samuel Weiss, by the way, is the gentleman who, the physician
00:35:36 who basically argued that the fever
00:35:40 that new, you know, women who had just given birth, they were dying of this perperal fever
00:35:47 was due to the fact that the physicians who were, you know, delivering the babies had previously
00:35:53 worked on, you know, doing autopsies. And of course, all of the physicians said, how dare you,
00:36:00 sir? How dare you question our God-like abilities in healing? Surely we can't be the culprits.
00:36:08 And he was shunned, he was hated, and so on. And then eventually, it turns out that he was right. And so when you earlier said, I wash my hands of him, you're referring to that. So okay, so that was your original foray into the world that I have inhabited for a long time. But then did you extend it to broader issues beyond the academic debate stuff?
00:36:35 I, you know, I grew up in Boston, and the American Revolution was just part of me. And all those things, I'm thrilled that this year is the 250th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence.
00:36:51 And liberty, freedom, the First Amendment, everything it means, discussions about how do you best serve freedom and prevent hurt at the same time, but in a legal way, consistent with the First Amendment and its interpretation.
00:37:14 I just love this stuff.
00:37:16 I just, I'm a real patriot and proudly.
00:37:22 So you must, if I can shamelessly plug my current center,
00:37:28 as you know, Randy, I recently joined
00:37:31 the Declaration of Independence Center
00:37:33 for the Study of American Freedom at Ole Miss.
00:37:36 So we maybe need to invite you down here
00:37:41 if we've got the necessary funding
00:37:42 for you to talk about how what started off as a standard academic fight between competing camps
00:37:50 led you down and you know the foray of the broader issues of freedom yes yes beautiful yes uh do you
00:38:00 have hope i mean you and i have discussed you know certainly some of my work parasitic freedom
00:38:06 So it's out of empathy and so on. Do you have hope that the universities can be purged of this nonsense and we can return to the edifices of reason? Or are you of sort of the more cataclysmic band? We need to nuke the rotting bodies and start afresh. Where do you stand on that debate?
00:38:27 You know, the reason I have hope is the Cornell Library has actually let me research everything that I think about right down to the original document.
00:38:42 So I so love this library.
00:38:45 Yeah.
00:38:46 I used to go there, by the way.
00:38:48 Forgive me for interrupting you.
00:38:49 When, you know, at the time, you know, I did my Cornell PhD from 90 to 94.
00:38:55 there wasn't yet you couldn't access things online and so on and so i would go to those archives and
00:39:01 i would just sit there for i mean oftentimes i wasn't searching for something in particular
00:39:07 i would just see whatever journal of abnormal psychology and here i go for the next four hours
00:39:13 looking through the stuff there is something truly magical about sort of inhabiting the ecosystem of
00:39:19 a really powerful library, but go ahead.
00:39:22 Oh, I so agree.
00:39:24 So although I became a pariah to the library,
00:39:28 I take my class to the rare manuscript collection
00:39:32 every semester because what I talk about
00:39:36 in terms of texts really become real for them
00:39:41 when they can hold it themselves.
00:39:42 When they read the first edition
00:39:44 of The Origin of Species from 1859.
00:39:48 You've got one at Cornell?
00:39:49 Oh, yes. We have several, actually.
00:39:52 Wow.
00:39:52 So when you're here next time, we'll go.
00:39:54 Yes, please.
00:39:56 So actually, in that first, in Origin of Species, Darwin talks about the slave-making instinct of ants.
00:40:05 And I give a lecture called Charles Darwin, Samuel Wilberforce, and How We See the Color of Ants.
00:40:11 So Samuel Wilberforce wrote a review of the origin of species, and he said, nobody can describe nature like Darwin can.
00:40:27 For example, any quotes Darwin, there's the red clover, and the nectar is very deep in the red clover.
00:40:33 So you need an insect that has a long proboscis to pollinate it.
00:40:38 And that insect is the humble bee.
00:40:41 So before the early 1900s, when Beatrix Potter made the Humblebee Goes Buzz and called it the bumblebee, it used to be called the Humblebee.
00:40:51 Oh, wow.
00:40:51 So the Humblebee is now pollinating the red clover.
00:40:55 The more Humblebees you have, the more red clover.
00:40:58 But mice happen to love to eat the nests of Humblebees.
00:41:03 So if there's too many mice, then you don't have enough humblebees, and the red clover's population goes kaput.
00:41:12 But if you're near a city, there's cats.
00:41:15 So Darwin writes all about this, and it's beautiful.
00:41:19 And then he goes on to other behaviors, like the slave-making instinct of ants. 0.77
00:41:25 So there's some species of ants that are not black that have slaves.
00:41:32 The masters actually, by themselves, would never feed themselves.
00:41:37 They would never feed their larvae.
00:41:40 They have a slave that will feed them.
00:41:45 Even when they move to another nest, the slave puts them in the jaws and moves them to another place.
00:41:52 The only thing that the master ants do is hunt for slaves. 0.97
00:42:01 And Darwin has a line in there, the slaves are black. They're always black, no matter what color 0.98
00:42:08 the masters are. So now Samuel Wilberforce has an interest in thinking about slavery. So at the time, 0.73
00:42:18 he was thinking if this scientific theory was solid enough, then that would justify slavery,
00:42:25 especially since Darwin thought that psychology would be replaced by biology
00:42:31 and we would inherit the instincts of lower organisms.
00:42:38 So Wilberforce looked at Darwin's scientific evidence in terms of the fossil record
00:42:43 in terms of forming new species.
00:42:47 He didn't believe in the progressivism part of Darwinian evolution,
00:42:52 that things keep getting better.
00:42:54 He believed in compensation, that if you made, for example, a dog go faster, he wouldn't be so strong.
00:43:03 Or if you made a dog stronger, like a bulldog compared to a greyhound, the fast one won't be strong and the strong one won't be fast.
00:43:12 So he believed not in always improving, but compensation.
00:43:16 conversation so um i asked my students so why was samuel wilberforce so interested in this
00:43:25 it turns out his father was william wilberforce a member and i asked my students actually a week
00:43:32 before the class does anybody know the name wilberforce a question my amy you know my wife
00:43:38 amy great question amy asked me 15 years ago which got this whole lecture going wow so um
00:43:46 No, nobody knows Wilberforce. Okay, so now I tell them about William Wilberforce was
00:43:53 Samuel Wilberforce's father. He spent his whole life in Parliament to get two bills passed,
00:44:01 one to abolish the slave trade, and the others to abolish slavery in the British Empire.
00:44:07 So he decided he was going to do that when he realized he was just being like any other
00:44:13 politician and not, you know, just taking the perks, that he really should do something
00:44:17 important. And he remembered hearing John Newton speak when he was younger, and he went to see
00:44:26 John Newton. So John Newton was a slave trader, a captain of a slave ship, and a very good one or
00:44:32 a very bad one, depending on your outlook. But one day he thought all men are created in God's
00:44:38 image. And if that's true, slavery is wrong. So he quit. He went back to England, became a pastor
00:44:45 in the Anglican Church and wrote hymns. One hymn was about his own life. It's called Amazing Grace.
00:44:51 I once was lost and now I'm found. And so as a matter of fact, I have the complete works of
00:45:01 John Newton. Actually, I have him right here. I just gave that lecture. And I have my students
00:45:07 read the hymn and it's the place goes silent it's just amazing although last year last spring i had
00:45:15 a student no more hi no more if you're watching uh that sang an amazing grace as she was reading
00:45:22 um so um i mean that speaks to your to the term that we mentioned briefly earlier consilience
00:45:32 Right. Because you're you're taking all of these evolutionary principles, linking them to real historical phenomena, including slavery, linking it to a spiritual narrative and all of those bridges that you are building to to otherwise connect these disparate phenomena is exactly what the beauty of consilience is.
00:45:54 right? Yes, yes. So let me connect it a little more. So I take my class to see, you know,
00:46:02 the original origin of species and a number of other things that really are amazing.
00:46:08 And there used to always be a bust of Abraham Lincoln right next to the room where we met.
00:46:14 And one day it was missing. And I asked somebody, what happened to the bust of Abraham Lincoln?
00:46:20 And that person said, someone complained, and it was gone.
00:46:25 Oh, no.
00:46:26 I knew that that's where we were going.
00:46:28 Okay, go on.
00:46:29 Okay.
00:46:29 So I thought, this is crazy.
00:46:33 You know, if anybody has freed more slaves than Abraham Lincoln, I'm willing to listen
00:46:38 to their point that Abe should be canceled.
00:46:41 But other than short of that, I'm not.
00:46:43 So I really fought to bring back the bust of Abraham Lincoln.
00:46:48 It's an incredible bust. 1.00
00:46:50 It was done by Vinnie Rean, a poor female. 0.94
00:46:56 And she had a friend that knew Abraham Lincoln. 0.56
00:46:59 And she asked the friend, do you think Abraham Lincoln would sit for me?
00:47:03 And Abraham Lincoln said to her friend, I'll sit for her.
00:47:07 I don't know why she wants to sculpt me.
00:47:09 I'm so homely. 0.93
00:47:10 But because she was poor and female, Abraham Lincoln sat for her. 0.86
00:47:15 Wow.
00:47:16 So she sculpted him, made this beautiful sculpture.
00:47:23 You can see it online at the Cornell Library.
00:47:26 And it was the last sitting, last live sitting that Abraham Lincoln did before he was assassinated.
00:47:40 Incredible.
00:47:40 How did Cornell, what's the, do you know the genesis of why Cornell?
00:47:45 got it so Ezra Cornell knows knew both Abraham Lincoln and went to one of the inaugurals I'm not
00:47:52 sure and Vinnie Rehm and I believe um that in our founder's room the two sculptures of Ezra Cornell
00:48:01 and his wife were also done by Vinnie Rehm amazing uh yes so it's beautiful so in this
00:48:09 bust abraham lincoln sort of looking to the right um and down and it's whichever side you
00:48:16 look at him there's a different feeling it is beautifully done and it's the same like i said
00:48:23 same sitting that vinnie rehm did to make the lincoln statue in the rotunda of the capital
00:48:31 incredible and there you can see what he's looking at with his right hand
00:48:37 He's looking at the Emancipation Proclamation.
00:48:42 And actually, the bust is more beautiful, I have to say, because you get to use your imagination.
00:48:47 All the information isn't there for you.
00:48:50 So because I made such a big stink about the Lincoln bust disappearing, and Fox News covered it, I became such a persona non grata in the library.
00:49:04 To this day.
00:49:06 So actually, I'm retiring at the end of the year when I was negotiating with the associate dean on retirement.
00:49:14 I said, there's one thing that I really want to get done before I retire.
00:49:18 I want a plaque to be set up next to the Lincoln bust that has either the last paragraph of the second inaugural or just the words, if they don't have that much room, with malice towards none and charity for all, which comes from that paragraph.
00:49:36 So she just actually melted and thought that was a great idea.
00:49:40 She went to the library and they said, oh, there's no way we could put a plaque on the wall.
00:49:44 Believe me, there's plenty of plaques on the wall.
00:49:46 And with, you know, Trump being president and we having to save so much money that's been cut, there's no possible way.
00:49:54 So, well, I'm still going to try to get that plaque there.
00:49:59 Oh, we're not there yet.
00:50:00 No, we're not there yet.
00:50:04 I actually wrote another essay. It's not easy being red, white and blue at Cornell to tell that story.
00:50:11 It's very easy to be red, white and blue at Ole Miss. Let me tell you this. Yeah. Thank you. So I wasn't aware. I don't think you had shared with me privately that you were retiring at the end of this year.
00:50:23 So, but now that you've shared it publicly, what are your plans post-retirement?
00:50:28 Do you plan to keep writing?
00:50:29 Do you plan what, what, what are the, what, oh yeah, the, the lights went off.
00:50:34 What are you planning to do next?
00:50:36 Other than spending all of your time with your lovely wife, Amy.
00:50:41 Oh, most of my time.
00:50:44 Yes.
00:50:45 Because actually that's, that's the real plan is all the time that I didn't get to spend
00:50:51 with Amy.
00:50:52 Right.
00:50:53 I'll make up travel, read books. Yes. Yes. Did you plan on? I'm sorry, go ahead.
00:51:00 Eat her delicious cooking. But I, but I do plan to write. So this course that I teach called
00:51:07 Light and Life, which brings in all the issues of free speech, frankly,
00:51:14 He tells the Wilberforce and Darwin story and the ants.
00:51:22 It's a great course.
00:51:23 I love it.
00:51:24 I also just recently wrote an essay on that course.
00:51:27 It's called, Is It Final?
00:51:29 And in the 150th anniversary of the Declaration of Independence, Calvin Coolidge talked about the Declaration of Independence.
00:51:38 He says, when it says, all men are created equal, that's final. 0.84
00:51:43 Well, I think actually the Seneca Declaration improved that a little bit by saying men and women, but I get his point. And I said, I teach science like things aren't final. There's still question. Science is never settled. 0.52
00:51:58 But Fauci explained to us that it is settled. So isn't he the ultimate benchmark of science?
00:52:09 Fauci, you mentioned Calvin Coolidge. Are you aware of the real scientific term in evolutionary
00:52:18 psychology coined as the Coolidge effect? Do you know what that is?
00:52:23 Never heard of it.
00:52:24 Oh, so here's a story for you. So I'm sure this is a story that I discuss in this book right here in The Consuming Instinct. It refers to the penchant for sexual variety. I mean, which could apply to both men and women, but certainly the greater penchant of men for sexual variety and its evolutionary roots.
00:52:47 Now, why is it called the Coolidge effect? Because, and forgive me if I slightly butchered the story, but the general point will be clear. So President Coolidge and his wife are going around some farm and the wife says, oh, who is sort of going with all of these hens?
00:53:13 And they say, well, there's a there's a rooster, whatever. And then she so then she says, well, you know, hopefully you can tell that to President Coolidge so that he can raise his vigor.
00:53:24 And then later, President Coolidge comes along and says, oh, or is it is the is the rooster sleeping with a single hen?
00:53:34 He goes, no, no, no, with many hens. And then he goes, well, tell that to Mrs. Coolidge, meaning that sexual vigor is much more likely to be maintained if you introduce variety, which, by the way, the research has been done in zoology where you take, for example, a male rat.
00:53:55 You introduce a female, he'll mate with her. You take her out, you introduce another female, he'll mate with her. And he will literally mate until he dies, as long as you keep introducing a new female rat. And so that became known as the Coolidge effect. So here you go, linking a story about an American president with a fundamental driver of human sexuality.
00:54:20 Of course, what you're saying doesn't apply to you and me because our wives are so wonderful.
00:54:25 That is absolutely true. Will Chamberlain was once told, to your point, he was purported to
00:54:37 have slept with, I don't know, 20,000 women. And some guy said, you are such an amazing stud,
00:54:43 whatever. And then Will Chamberlain stops and corrects him and he goes, it takes a lot more
00:54:48 of a man to sleep with the same woman 20,000 times than to sleep with 20,000 women. Now,
00:54:55 I think in your case and mine, we have such exemplary wives that it is hardly a feat to be
00:55:02 with the same woman over and over again. And frankly, as someone who understands the evolutionary
00:55:08 reasons why people would want to stray, nothing brings greater happiness to a person than to find
00:55:14 that special person build a family build a life with them regrettably too few people in the west
00:55:20 are doing so because we are falling way short of the replacement rate but inshallah people will
00:55:26 start having sex again soon yes uh randy anything you want to promote uh before i could sit here and
00:55:34 speak to you for hours but i know your time is valuable anything you want to promote some project 0.92
00:55:39 you're working on, a book, a post-retirement, this is your time to tell us about it.
00:55:44 Oh, yeah. Let me say something. The 18 Cornell faculty put together the Future of the American
00:55:54 University report. And I begged them for a year to say the mission of the university
00:56:02 is the search for truth. And they just couldn't do it.
00:56:09 They just couldn't do it.
00:56:10 And, you know, I look at science as a free speech issue, actually.
00:56:18 You're having a conversation with nature.
00:56:21 And nature doesn't lie to you.
00:56:24 Nature doesn't make it easy.
00:56:26 You can make mistakes.
00:56:27 You can be fooled.
00:56:29 But nature doesn't lie to you.
00:56:31 And you have to have the same integrity when you're doing experiments and making observations.
00:56:36 And that integrity, that honesty, if there's no such thing as objective truth, why would anybody be honest, necessarily?
00:56:50 And, you know, if we're only selected to have many, many progeny, search for truth wouldn't be something that's selected.
00:57:07 The search for truth, I think, has to be accepted as a truth has to be accepted as a self-evident truth, I guess.
00:57:18 And so I'm really disappointed with the future of the American University Committee's report.
00:57:24 Our president, Mike Kotlikoff, just received the Courage and Education Award from the Steamboat Institute.
00:57:33 And his speech, which is online, is very good.
00:57:37 And he mentions the importance of truth several times in his speech.
00:57:42 And I hope he has the courage to not accept the faculty's report, because I think the faculty can't change the university from the inside.
00:57:57 I think we need a strong leader.
00:57:59 I think Mike Kotlikoff can be that strong leader.
00:58:03 If it's not him, we'll have to search for one outside the university.
00:58:07 That means the federal government.
00:58:10 Thank you for that.
00:58:12 Randy, so lovely to finally have you on the show.
00:58:15 Stay on the line so we can say goodbye offline
00:58:17 and come back anytime that you'd like.
00:58:20 Thank you so much.
00:58:20 Thank you so much, Gad.
00:58:21 It was a joy, a complete joy.
00:58:23 It really was.
00:58:24 Thank you.