00:04:37But he's using it to describe all sorts of people, not just artists, not just writers, but basically every manner of white-collar professional, highly educated professionals are quote-unquote creative, and they're this dominant elite.
00:04:54But because they're creative, we're supposed to look up to them, respect them, admire them, and do these massive public favors for them.
00:05:02And this was the upshot of that book and that theory.
00:05:06And by the way, it's still going. There's cities all over America that are building, you know, constantly doing this, building special tax districts for creatives and special, you know, supporting all kinds.
00:05:19Well, you just think of all the things they did, building bike paths, you know, encouraging coffee shops, you know, doing all this stuff to lure, to bring creatives to your city.
00:05:29Because once you did that, then you would have prosperity.
00:05:32Well, then wouldn't the arts flourish? But the arts have withered.
00:05:40I mean, so the irony that hangs over this book is that while at the very same time that we have worshipped at the shrine of creativity and also of innovation, that those things have been dying in this country.
00:06:31and he was telling me that or I think he wrote this somewhere that um he now earns less in a
00:06:39year you know from the streaming services that he got for you know for for a song that gets played
00:06:43thousands and thousands and thousands of times that he would get for selling a single 45 record
00:06:48back in the day but it's like that all over the place this is what is happening to musicians you
00:06:53can't earn a living at it and you look at uh liberal arts academia you know which is what I
00:06:58wanted to spend my life doing, history. It's in a state of collapse. And this is before Trump
00:07:04came along and declared war on it. It was in a state of collapse already. This is across the
00:07:10board, the creative occupations are dying. And this is going on at the same time that we're
00:07:16putting quote unquote creative people on a pedestal. And we have various presidents and
00:07:22other public figures who talk about innovation constantly. I mean, constantly.
00:07:26Well, it's sort of the same way we started to revere the American Indians the second we put them on reservations and they posed no real threat.
00:07:34It's like they became museum pieces and now we can say how awesome they are.
00:07:38I don't know. I'm not ready for that yet. I'm not a museum piece. I mean, actually, I kind of am.
00:07:44No, I guess, but the fundamental tension between the people in charge and the creative class, which has existed forever, I mean, in Athens it was real.
00:09:21Another one is there's this tremendous example during the war of the Manhattan Project, of the atomic bomb, which shows the lesson that it taught the world.
00:09:33I mean, one of many lessons, but one that was taken to heart was that scientific genius was from now on the most important quality in the world.
00:09:46And many of the people who write about creativity refer to that event, to Hiroshima.
00:09:57But I think it's a combination of those things.
00:10:01The big corporations were setting up these, you know, enormous R&D divisions.
00:10:05The government was subsidizing scientific research.
00:10:09And so, naturally, they, you know, and meanwhile, during the war, the Army and the Navy had both done psychological studies of the people that, you know, that they had taken in from the population.
00:10:21And so, all of these things come together and this idea of creativity explodes.
00:10:27They did psychological studies on draftees.
00:14:02Yeah, well, so you see this across the board, these arguments used for the worst. These arguments which should be, you know, which seem very humane and seem like they should be helping civilization have been used across the board for the worst purposes imaginable.
00:14:20But what happens is – so then the self-help literature explodes after the war and then right on its heels comes the psychological literature.
00:15:21Adlai Stevenson wrote the introduction to some book back then, and he said, we need innovators, not organization men.
00:15:29So it's this very interesting moment where America turns away from the Red Scare, from McCarthyism, and decides what we really need is the opposite of that.
00:18:08Not sure where he picked it up, probably in his General Electric days, but he actually wrote a book of – he compiled a book of speeches in the late 60s, and the title he gave to it was The Creative Society.
00:18:21And when he went to do his big tax cuts in the 80s, if you go back and look at the text – by the way, you talk a lot about labor being taxed more than wealth.
00:19:45And one of the many things that seemed to go wrong was innovation had appeared to have slowed down in America.
00:19:52And this was not, you know, this is not me going back and like reading between the lines.
00:19:57This is in the New York Times at the time.
00:19:59There's an innovation crisis in America, mid-70s.
00:20:03The Washington Post ran stories about it. There were congressional hearings about it. The Carter administration issued a 300-page report on how to get innovation going in America again. This is in 78. And Carter didn't – you know, Carter was a very innovation-minded guy. He had been an engineer, this sort of thing.
00:20:22He was very concerned about this, but he didn't have any answers for it.
00:20:27But the sort of nascent supply-side wing of the Republican Party did have an answer.
00:20:50By the way, in the grand sort of, what would you call it, progression of tax cuts, which we're still doing to this day, this was the first one, 1978 capital gains tax cut.
00:21:50Yeah, well, they did. And then Reagan did it again. They did. And they do it all the time. They talk about this all the time. We got to cut capital gains taxes to get creativity moving in this country again. They do it all the time. They're still doing it somewhere today.
00:22:03the uh i'm but but then when reagan did the kemp roth tax cut in 81 if you go back and look at the
00:22:09text it was explicitly done to encourage creativity in america this is to get us out of these doldrums
00:22:16of the 1970s it was uh it turns out so i didn't know this when i went into writing this book i
00:22:23was just going to write a history of this idea i had no idea what i was you know the can of worms
00:22:28I was opening up, but it is present at each of the great steps in the sort of, what would
00:23:16The thing about creating things, Thomas, is just not creative.
00:23:20You would be astonished at how little ice that argument cut.
00:23:23Driving for the holidays, Thanksgiving, Christmas, New Year's means spending a lot of time in a cramped car or train or stuffed into an airplane seat.
00:23:33And the net effect is a stiff and tight back.
00:23:38There's no better solution to that than getting a restful night's sleep on an excellent mattress, which is why we recommend Brooklyn Bedding.
00:23:44Brooklyn Bedding has been assembling excellent mattresses for over 30 years, and they do it right here in the U.S.
00:23:50There are no middlemen or gimmicks, just the best mattress you can buy, made by American workers in the state of Arizona.
00:23:57So if you think made in the U.S. means not many options, untrue.
00:24:02Brooklyn Bedding offers over 15 mattress models, so there's something for every sleep style, every body type.
00:24:07They have temperature-regulating materials to help keep you cool and comfortable all night.
00:24:12And if you're still unsure, you should know they include a risk-free 365-night trial and warranty.
00:24:18So if you don't like it, no problem, but you will.
00:24:22Visit brooklynbedding.com, use the code TUCKER at checkout for 30% off the whole site during the Black Friday sale.
00:24:45book a loved by guest property with verbo and you get a top-rated vacation rental that's love
00:24:52for all the right reasons uh i love my verbo for the location good reason oh and for the pool
00:24:57because pools are cool i feel the love book a verbo that's loved by guests if you know you verbo
00:25:02i would never nothing nothing is i'm post astonishment because because creativity is
00:25:08the property of a group of people. And it's not our people. It's the white collar.
00:25:18Well, it's also pretty hard to measure. Actually, I am white collar and highly educated. But I mean,
00:25:21it's not the people that I care about. It's not my people in the Midwest.
00:25:24May I ask, so for most of human history, the measure of success, prosperity, the goal was
00:25:30not creativity. It was productivity. Like how many bushels a week can we grow? And the thing
00:25:35about productivity, whatever you think of it as a goal, it's easily measured. Like you can actually
00:25:39count the bushels. Creativity, harder to measure. In fact, impossible to measure. So they use
00:25:45proxies and one of them is productivity growth. And I'm going to ruin the whole interview here
00:25:51and give away the secret. But since we started worshiping at the shrine of creativity and
00:25:57innovation and doing all of these massive public favors for these people, productivity growth in
00:26:02america it's it's gone through the roof right tucker no i've noticed it's half it's half of
00:26:09what it was in the 50s and 60s is that true yeah and gdp growth is the same so i was born in 65
00:26:15uh economy grew it was over five percent i think it was six percent that year
00:26:19if it gets to three percent now they're like popping champagne corks and stuff
00:26:24you know it never gets that high anymore ever so it can't yeah of course it can it did when
00:26:32we were children. No, but it can't on the basis of this kind of economy that we have. It's based
00:26:36on finance and real estate. Yeah, when you do, yes. When you offshore, you know, a huge part of
00:26:41your manufacturing base. Your actual productive economy? Yes. Yeah, it's, by the way, you said
00:26:46a fascinating thing a minute ago, and we're going, I feel like we're moving too fast through all this
00:26:52material, but you said a fascinating thing, which is manufacturing is obviously creates. That just
00:26:58seems so obvious to me when I'm reading this stuff. And can I, oh, can I back up a second
00:27:04and tell you how I figured all this out? Yes. So I was driving in my car one day and I had NPR on
00:27:12as per usual, as is my want. And they've got a guy and he's complaining about the Trump tariffs.
00:27:18This is a couple of years ago. And he's complaining about the Trump tariffs. And he
00:27:21says it's going to make it more expensive for him to import whatever manufactured good he sells in
00:27:28America, it's going to be more expensive for him to import that from China where he has it made.
00:27:32But then he clarifies right away. He says, but we keep the creative work here in America. We just
00:27:36do the manufacturing work in China. But he says this as though we all know that that's how it
00:27:43works. And so I go back and dig into it. And that is the theory. That is what these guys believe.
00:27:50So do you remember, designed by Apple in California, assembled in China. They used
00:27:57to put that on everything they made. I think they still do. Because the creative work was kept here
00:28:02at home, and that was supposed to matter, the quote-unquote creative work. But the making of
00:28:06things was not creative. So, that can go overseas. That doesn't matter. We don't care about that.
00:28:10Well, that's like saying if— And by the way, it's false. It's wrong.
00:28:13Well, it's insane. Actually, if I order my housekeeper to make my bed, I can't take credit
00:28:18for a made bed, can I? Do you know what I mean? That's good. Good, good point.
00:28:22No, but it's true. I mean, like, I made my bed this morning. Actually, no, your housekeeper did.
00:28:26So I don't know if you followed my writing over the years, but in the old days, I used to write a lot about labor.
00:28:31And one of the things you realize real quickly when you talk to guys that work on a shop floor is that they do innovate and they innovate all the time.
00:28:39And they're constantly – it's always – the engineers are not infallible.
00:28:45You know, the engineers have designed all the machinery.
00:28:47But no, the workers deal with the machinery.
00:28:50They know the product in a – sometimes a very intimate way.
00:28:53They know a lot more about it than than anybody over in the office building.
00:28:57They often, you know, they have they have this granular knowledge about what they're doing that is lost when you ship all that overseas.
00:29:06And the idea that they're because they didn't go to college, they're not creative is absurd.0.93
00:29:18Yesterday morning at seven, I watched a friend of mine with a high school education move by himself a garage off its foundation and load it onto a dump trailer and drive it five miles to his house.
00:32:27And he proceeds to give a speech, a very good speech.
00:32:31one of the like Obama classics where he talks about the decline and fall of the middle class
00:32:38in these Midwestern towns. You know, and you go to any town in Kansas and Missouri and you see
00:32:43what he means. The main street is empty. The stores are all boarded up. It's a way of life
00:32:48has died. And he laments this way of life and he did it in a spectacularly eloquent way. I mean,
00:32:55I wish I could. I wish I could talk that. I mean, it's my subject. That's why it hits close to home.
00:33:00I wish I could do it as well as he did. And he evokes this beautifully. But then he goes to the solution. What's the solution? And he talked about this a lot that year. The solution is we have to, you know, there's nothing he can do for those people. There's nothing the government can do for those people whose way of life is ending. We have to have more innovation.
00:33:20And the way we get more innovation is we have to have more people go to, you know, go to university and get STEM degrees, study the STEM.
00:33:27You remember that was his thing, the STEM subjects.
00:33:30And so you're looking at this and it's like, that is just a, it's not an answer.
00:33:44And by the way, just for the record, there's all sorts of things that the federal government could do to keep blue-collar people from being thrown out of the middle class, which is what's happening.
00:34:29It's a corporate – it's the corporate word, par excellence.
00:34:32And then the third thing is it gets him off the hook for actually doing anything.
00:34:37There's nothing the government can do. The best the government can do is encourage us to be innovators. But since all progress and all economic growth comes, this is the theory, comes from innovation, the best he can do is encourage us to innovate, you know.
00:40:07But wait, you put your finger on another really important element of this, which is that the word innovation and the word creativity, too, I think even more so.
00:40:17One of the reasons that they're used for these absolutely obnoxious schemes is they are what I call thought-stopping cliches.
00:44:05So you have a kind of a Republican-flavored version where it's all about entrepreneurs, and you have a Democratic-flavored version, which comes mainly from Daniel Bell, which is it's all about the university.
00:44:15But in both cases, it's not about manufacturing.
00:45:15And so like this conversation two years from now will be even more painful because I think it'll be obvious that it was just like one of the great failures ever.
00:45:24Well, can I just say that what I am talking about is that we have, in this country, we have misunderstood the idea of progress, you know?
00:45:51Yes, resources. You have regulation, you have labor unions, you share the resources in this way and that, all that sort of thing. Then in the 1950s and 60s, we say, no, there's this other factor. And that factor is creativity and innovation. And it inheres in a social class, if you're Republican entrepreneurs, if you're a Democrat, the highly educated. And we have to do, or I mean, and then why not both, right?
00:46:18And then we have to do these spectacular favors
00:48:46I'm saying that sarcastically, of course, but I don't think people understand the degree to which the rise and fall of various groups is the product of government policy.
00:48:59I mean, we think that we live, yeah, in some kind of organic state where nature gave it to us.
00:49:05And we also, when I was a kid, I especially encountered this, people who thought that government intervention in the economy through regulation or, I don't know, pure food laws or whatever, making labor unions legal, that that was artificial somehow.
00:49:20But it's all, I mean, everything we do is more or less artificial.
00:49:24Everything we do is part of a, you know, the unfolding of a civilization.
00:49:59We were all going to be part of the middle class and it was – Johnson wasn't wrong about that. It was a cliche of the time that you could have a blue-collar person living next door to a white-collar person and the only difference would be in their tastes and their brand names like this guy drove a Chevy, that guy drove a Buick.
00:50:17you know and that was a cliche of the society i was growing up in and and it was i mean it was
00:50:25it was mass affluence and i i constantly talk to um young audiences and they have trouble
00:50:33believing that this existed i grew up in it and i grew up in a rich area among rich people who
00:50:38thought of themselves as upper middle class and who stayed in motels when they traveled to their
00:50:43weekend houses by car yes so i literally grew up that way yeah me too and i i am here to tell you
00:50:51this actually this existed now it wasn't perfect there are lots of people that hadn't been brought
00:50:56into it yet but that that was the goal in the 60s and that's why you was to bring everybody in well
00:51:03but it also was a very calm society relatively speaking despite all the turmoil of the 60s and
00:51:0770s people looked at even liberal people looked at like groups like the sybdney's liberation army
00:51:51So in 1978, one of the interesting, I was reading an obituary for a guy, and it mentioned that in 1978, it's an obituary from 1978, there were two billionaires in America.
00:52:04And they were regarded as kind of eccentric, you know, strange people.
00:52:08today there's like close to a thousand you know were they and do you know in 1970 yeah i do
00:52:15actually one was one was um uh john r macarthur you know the macarthur foundation and the other
00:52:21was daniel ludwig shipping fortune um hey we get look what we got here sorry we got some spaniels
00:52:29in the uh in the studio yeah and uh uh and it was it was macarthur's i was so i i did a whole lot
00:52:36research on the macarthur foundation because it's it's it's it's goal is what they call it
00:52:41extraordinary creativity they give the genius grant every year to people but i i wound up not
00:52:45using any of it but i was reading macarthur's um obit he died in 78 that same year as the first
00:52:51the first big capital gains can we detour into the um if you don't mind into the condition of
00:52:57the creative class so since i've lived in that class my whole life um the thing that i notice
00:53:03This is just how little creativity there is, how much tighter the boundaries are of acceptable thinking, how much more banal the work product is.
00:54:05And every time I see one of those brilliant guys, I think, even if I don't agree with them, I'm like, well, that's really smart or that's really original.
00:54:10I think, what the hell are you doing on Twitter?
00:54:13Shouldn't you be like building a new society?
01:03:40And I think they could raise the price much higher and people would continue to pay it.
01:03:44There's also a really gross explanation, which is there's a liberal version of this too,
01:03:51where they had a model that they'd come up with.
01:03:53They called it high tuition, high aid, where they would be a welfare state unto themselves.
01:04:01Yeah. And they would decide who gets, you know, everybody has to pay this enormous price tag, but we're going to let some people off. And so they get to sort of, you know, play government all on their own. And this was a lot of really well-meaning, that was a lot of well-meaning people that thought this was a good idea.
01:04:20and it has been, it is, and now they'll basically all tell you that that was a disaster that didn't
01:04:26work. Instead, we've put generations of students into incredible amounts of debt, you know.
01:06:15Another gift of innovation, of the innovation philosophy, the innovation ideal of the post-industrial society.
01:06:24How much innovation has the actual innovation?
01:06:27Well, they have invented a lot of drugs, but you'd be surprised at how, I mean, there has been.
01:06:33Look, we're living in the age of the Internet, the smartphone, you know, the revolution and AI is coming.
01:06:41There's been all of these revolutions in technology.
01:06:45But truth be told, they're not even – they're not – they pale besides the really amazing, like really earth-shattering innovations of, say, late 19th century to the 1970s.
01:07:01There's an economist at Northwestern, Robert Gordon, has written his whole book about this.
01:07:06And it's quite a long book, but it's an excellent book about, you know, the history of invention in America.
01:07:13And basically things like the electric light, the car, the indoor plumbing and airplanes, these revolutionized life in a way that, you know, the internet for all of its, you know, all of the amazing things that you can do with it doesn't even come close.
01:07:35So what you see is that innovation in these sort of physical things, things that we make and systems that we build and that sort of thing has really slowed.
01:08:16It is true, but they say that the modern ones are designed to conserve fuel.
01:08:21They don't use as much gasoline, and that's true.
01:08:23So – but no, the – but the upshot of all this is that innovation outside of the internet, outside of computers and telecommunications seems to have slowed down.
01:08:48This is sort of where we started that, you know, productivity statistics, economic growth every year is way below what it was in the in the 50s and 60s.
01:08:59So I always think if we're, you know, so brilliant and innovative, why don't we innovate a way out of people dying of drug ODs in public parks?
01:09:16I was wondering when we were going to get there.
01:09:17I'm not even arguing against that, though I could.
01:09:21But I'm just saying, like, as long as we're paying for all this innovation, how about, like, I don't know, reducing the suicide rate a little bit?
01:09:33And by the way, the downsizing, the sort of the rolling back of the ambitions of government was also part of the innovation brief.
01:09:42So do you remember in the Clinton years? This is something, by the way, that people traditionally looked to and still do look to the Democratic Party for. But in the Clinton years, they were deciding, you know, we don't want to be, we don't want to do that anymore. And they had a plan. It was there. They had a sort of manifesto. It was called Reinventing Government. Do you remember this? And the idea was you outsource everything. And that was, you guessed it, innovation.
01:11:04And we had to prove to them that we cared about the least among us, that we, that everybody was, you know, in America, everybody had a shot that we were a decent society.0.58
01:11:15We were a society that your country could look to and admire and want to be like, and that pressure is all off.
01:11:22And, I mean, it's one of the, that's one of the big sort of explanatory reasons that people give for why we just, we just gave up on it all.
01:11:30the great society, you know, organized labor and, you know, having a decent society for working
01:11:38people to live in. And we gave up on it. Completely. And you think that part of the
01:11:43answer is because we had no one to impress anymore? We no longer had the competition from
01:11:46the Soviets. That's a way of putting it. Yeah. That's certainly part of the answer. But the
01:11:53answer, it's much bigger because all of this begins, you know, while the Cold War was still
01:16:10They're from, you know, all the industries that we've been talking about. Silicon Valley Bank fails. And they're like, oh, no. And, you know, this is it's the kind of people who actually have their money there. They bailed it out. The U.S. government bailed it right out, like immediately.
01:19:14And they're pretty explicit. And someone sent me last night, actually a big tech guy in Silicon Valley, who's very pro-human and a decent man, sent me the anthropic constitution for AI that grants the AI, the machine it is building, rights as an individual and says that we're not going to make any decision without running it by the AI.
01:19:36And if the AI disagrees, then it's invalid.
01:19:40Treating the AI as a living thing, in fact, is a superior thing to whom it genuflects.