00:07:44But it doesn't require an automatic response.
00:07:46But what you're saying is that this treaty that was signed, where Ukraine gave up its nuclear weapons, was entirely pointless.
00:07:52Well, of course I'm not saying that at all.
00:07:53What I'm saying is that there have been many subsequent agreements since, including a verbal agreement, which has been testified to by people who are present, that the United States would not expand NATO to Russia's borders, which is an understandable concern of Russia.0.79
00:08:07You don't want nuclear weapons controlled by another country on your borders.
00:09:38And I'm afraid what the West did towards Russia was project weakness that the agreements made over the Crimea by Germany and France made it look to Putin that he could do what he wanted.
00:09:52He then miscalculated with Ukraine and found that the West was not going to go along with that.
00:09:59And it's very important that you don't allow dictators to miscalculate.
00:23:42Do you think that the average Briton, if given the choice between food and housing assistance or unemployment benefits, would instead choose to forego those in favor of more bombs?
00:23:51I think the country at large is deeply fed up with people on welfare who have made it a lifestyle choice.
00:33:18That's why what's happening in Gaza is wrong.
00:33:20It's always wrong to kill people who did nothing wrong.
00:33:23And if we don't think that, then on what basis are we administering our own justice systems that take such exquisite care to punish only the guilty?
00:33:30I don't even understand what you're saying.
00:33:33I think it's very difficult to have fought the Second World War without innocent people being killed.
00:34:11Except, except, except the Polish borders had been cut up by Russia and Russia and Austria.
00:34:17I'm just saying the idea that Hitler just randomly rolled into Poland is a lie, and everyone believes it because they know nothing about the actual facts.
00:36:43But they're part of defending our shared interest, which we have.
00:36:48And our shared interest is the nation state and maintaining its integrity and not having people thinking because there was a treaty some hundreds of years ago and Poland once had a bit of it that was Germany, we can now say we're going to take it.
00:37:20I was on your side there and I feel so sad about what happened.
00:37:23But my point is, if you don't have sovereignty, if you can't make decisions that are rooted in the core interests of your own population, then how are you a nation state?
00:37:32But we do make interests that are in the core interests of our population.
00:37:35Well, you're just telling me that you may need to prepare for a war on behalf of the territorial integrity of Ukraine.
00:38:15If you're so willing to commit military force and lives of Britain to defending Ukraine, why not commit them to defending your own country?0.71
00:38:23Because the small boats is a civil matter rather than a military matter.0.66
00:48:28They attacked Belgium with whom we had a treaty on their way through to attack France.
00:48:33But can't you take a big picture of you and answer the question, was it worth losing everything?
00:48:38I'll happily come to that question, but I'm trying to make a point that you seem to refuse to allow me to make.
00:48:43That had we, in 1914, been projecting strength, had the Kaiser thought there was a big British army and the British will take this seriously, he would not have gone through Belgium.
00:48:56And if you had not gone through Belgium, we would not have gone to war.
00:48:59And it is the projection of strength that avoids war.
00:53:11But there's a great difference between seeing why things happen and viewing that as a justification.
00:53:19I think the critical difference is being willing to apologize for mistakes.
00:53:23We would have avoided the Second World War if we had been strong and if we had rearmed earlier.
00:53:30And that's my worry now, is that we aren't learning the lessons of how we got into those two world wars
00:53:35because we are weak and we do not have the defense expenditure that we need.
00:53:38I mean, not to get crazy with alternate history or whatever, but you've just described two wars that killed millions and millions and millions of people, tens of millions of people, and totally destroyed your country and depopulated it in some places.
00:53:51And both of them were initiated in the defense of small, basically irrelevant countries that are not contiguous to Britain.
00:53:58You had no cultural history with you, no connection to whatsoever.
00:54:02And on the basis of some theory that you keep repeating 80 years later, you destroyed your entire country and got millions of people killed.0.90
01:00:47And the freedom of the United Kingdom is certainly worth my rather elderly life, which won't be much use to anybody.
01:00:53But you cannot say this country must be strong and must be ready to go to war without thinking that if it came to a bomb dropping on your house, that is a bomb you would have to accept.
01:01:03I just don't understand, given what you've already just conceded, that the government of the United Kingdom is punishing and prohibiting people and ideas it doesn't like.
01:01:31Russia has poisoned people in this country.
01:01:33Russia has put fewer people in jail in the last year for social media posts than the UK has.
01:01:43They just accidentally fall out of windows in Russia.
01:01:46And nobody dares say anything in Russia because they get bullied in there.
01:01:49If you're a Brit, neither of us live in Russia, but if you're a Brit, if you live in this country and your ancestors have lived here for thousands of years,
01:01:55the threat to your freedom comes from your government, not Russia.
01:01:59I'm not in favor of the way free speech is being policed in this country.
01:02:04So why not try to overthrow your government?
01:02:06Well, I hope to stand at the next election.