TRIGGERnometry - November 21, 2026


Big Short Investor: Is the AI Bubble About to Burst? - Steve Eisman

Jensen Huang Resignation & Trump-Xi-Putin Summit Nothingburger - Off the Fence

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 27 minutes

Words per minute

160.2

Word count

14,037

Sentence count

915


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Save big at the Black Friday Super Sale at Shopper's Drug Mart.
00:00:04 Shop November 20th to 27th and enjoy big savings on the products you love.
00:00:09 Plus, for three days only, November 20th to 22nd, open your PC Optimum app
00:00:14 and get $20 or $30 in PC Optimum points when you spend $60 or more.
00:00:19 So head to Shopper's Drug Mart for the Black Friday Super Sale.
00:00:23 Save big, leave happy.
00:00:25 Conditions apply.
00:00:26 Details in store.
00:00:30 Behind Our Nation's Defense is a powerful network of Canadian communities, supported by Lockheed Martin Canada.
00:00:36 It's a network of over 1,300 employees and over 1,000 local suppliers, from small family businesses to major tech firms.
00:00:44 Together, we've delivered a $3.6 billion boost to the Canadian economy over the past five years.
00:00:50 That's money that goes to securing our skies, our oceans, and the place we call home.
00:00:55 Learn more at LockheedMartin.com slash Canada.
00:01:01 Is this one giant bubble, the entire AI industry?
00:01:04 I don't know yet.
00:01:06 How not profitable are they?
00:01:07 Insanely unprofitable.
00:01:09 Like, nuts!
00:01:11 Will they even be allowed to fail?
00:01:13 Oh, God. I sure as hell hope so.
00:01:16 I really don't want to go through this again.
00:01:18 It's so dependent upon these two companies,
00:01:21 and I think the U.S. economy would go into a recession immediately.
00:01:24 Let's pick on the French.
00:01:26 Please. Excellent.
00:01:27 Excellent.
00:01:28 You're British.
00:01:29 You're totally too happy to do that.
00:01:31 Finally.
00:01:32 Something we can all agree on.
00:01:34 France is...
00:01:35 Oh, my God.
00:01:36 They are deep doo-doo.
00:01:37 You guys have a real problem.
00:01:39 We had an empire.
00:01:40 You did.
00:01:41 And it's gone.
00:01:44 Andy Burnham is saying things like,
00:01:45 we're in hock to the bond markets, etc.
00:01:47 Too bad.
00:01:48 You don't want to pay back?
00:01:49 Good.
00:01:50 Don't pay back.
00:01:51 You're dead.
00:01:52 But it seems...
00:01:54 It's a wonderfully new way of putting it.
00:01:56 Do you like to tell the world that you like problematic podcasts?
00:02:02 Do you want to do it while drinking a tasty hot beverage?
00:02:05 And what you need is Trigger Fuel, our coffee brought to you by First Cup.
00:02:09 Just like our conversations, it's warm, earthy, and has that little kick to get you going
00:02:13 and p***ing off all the right people while you're at it.
00:02:16 Trigger Fuel is available using the link in the description, or go to fuel.triggerpod.co.uk.
00:02:23 Steve Eisemann, welcome to TriggerNometry.
00:02:25 Thank you. Happy to be here.
00:02:27 Oh, it's fantastic to have you.
00:02:28 For people in our audience who are not familiar with you,
00:02:31 you were the person on whom the big short movie is based.
00:02:36 Partially based. Let's be fair.
00:02:38 Yeah. You're the central character. Let's be fair.
00:02:41 I think that me, Steve Carell and Christian Bale.
00:02:44 That's true.
00:02:45 And Steve Carell played me.
00:02:47 Yeah, that's right.
00:02:48 Christian Bale, indeed, he's the other big character in the movie.
00:02:51 But the thing about that is you saw the great financial crisis coming before other people did, and you acted on that.
00:02:58 And now the reason we're delighted to have you on is there's obviously a lot of conversation about AI.
00:03:04 Is there?
00:03:07 On all sorts of different levels.
00:03:10 And one of them is the bubble part of it.
00:03:12 I also want to talk about the Duma part of it and the non-Duma spectrum.
00:03:17 We'll talk about that first.
00:03:19 But first of all, for people who are really just general, normal people who are not into investment or AI or anything like that, what's going on?
00:03:28 If you had to explain AI, the AI world to a five-year-old, what would you say is going on?
00:03:33 You know, there's a line in the movie Finding Forrester with Sean Conray, where he's teaching a young man how to write.
00:03:43 and um he's the kid asks him a very very very complex question while he's eating soup
00:03:51 and he looks at the kid and he says it's not exactly a soup question so your question you
00:03:56 just asked me is not exactly a soup question um let's let's start like just pure fundamentals
00:04:04 like what is ai so ai is really composed of two different types of software models one is
00:04:13 called an LLM, Large Language Model,
00:04:16 and the other one is what's called an agentic AI.
00:04:20 So an LLM, now, some people like to say that LLMs actually
00:04:24 think.
00:04:25 It's nonsense.
00:04:27 They do not think.
00:04:29 What they are is very complex predictors of the next word.
00:04:37 So basically what happens is, I mean,
00:04:39 I'm going to oversimplify, is you type in a question
00:04:43 into an LLM like Gemini or ChatGPT, it doesn't matter.
00:04:49 Now let's say the question is, we'll make up a question.
00:04:52 Why did the Roman Empire fail?
00:04:56 Click.
00:04:58 So now what happens is the LLM looks at why
00:05:02 did the Roman Empire fail.
00:05:06 And then it predicts the next word.
00:05:09 Based on all its data, that next word
00:05:12 the beginning of an answer and let's say the next word is the and then it goes back and it goes
00:05:19 through the entire chain again and predicts the second word and then it goes back and it predicts
00:05:23 the third word and eventually you get a little essay about why did the roman empire fail
00:05:28 that's an llm to oversimplify it's very very good at answering questions like that it's good at
00:05:36 producing software code um and that's what lms at at least at this point are good for
00:05:43 now notice that every time it it goes through the process it has to basically go through the
00:05:50 to the beginning again and again and again and again and just think about how much computing
00:05:55 power you need to do that so that's an llm an agentic ai takes an llm and makes and soups
00:06:05 it up so and with energetic AI can perform tasks so for example my wife
00:06:14 Valerie uses Meta's Muse and she downloaded the app and she asked Muse I
00:06:21 want to go to a broad this following Broadway play on such-and-such a date
00:06:28 get me the best tickets at the lowest price click and it starts thinking and
00:06:35 thinking and thinking and thinking and thinking and it comes back with with some answers and then you
00:06:39 you you give it some more guidance and then it comes back for some more answers and that's
00:06:43 agentic ai and so so agentic ai can perform tasks llm basically answers questions that's what ai is
00:06:53 and how or less how does the agentic ai work it uses the llm model to perform tasks so it it
00:07:02 predicts what the next what the next what then what you you gave it a task and it basically
00:07:07 predicts how to how to perform that task right and how is that different from thinking you said
00:07:11 it's not thinking it's not thinking at all you it has no ability to
00:07:19 it can quote unquote analyze if you ask it a question right but all it's doing is predicting
00:07:24 the next word it's not doing any of the things that you and i would associate with being
00:07:29 of critical thinking or making moral judgments it can make moral judgments no but what it has
00:07:35 it has access theoretically speaking i don't believe the internet is the total sum of human
00:07:40 knowledge and actually it's very deficient but let's assume that that was yes it has access to
00:07:45 the sum of total human knowledge and then it goes based on the sum of total human knowledge the
00:07:50 answer to the question is this way then this way then this way correct then this way but that's
00:07:56 not what you would think of as thinking nor does anybody else nobody really seriously thinks that
00:08:02 lms or agentic ai think when they when they say when you hear somebody say that it's thinking
00:08:10 it's nonsense because i'm trying to understand why though because you're saying it's not
00:08:15 generative it's not creating something new well it's more than just not creating it has no ability
00:08:20 really to think critically it doesn't think it's just it's just a software it's just a software
00:08:25 program predicting the next word i know but if it has access to the total sum of human knowledge
00:08:32 then it predicts the next word very well that's not the same thing as thinking um i'm not being
00:08:38 difficult i promise no no i understand or maybe i'm being stupid i don't know this is very subtle
00:08:42 yeah so so what does thinking exactly mean in your definition what does thinking mean
00:08:48 what's critical thinking well it's uh you know we go back to socrates and think about that but
00:08:52 But what do I think critical thinking is?
00:08:56 I think critical thinking is making moral judgments,
00:09:01 making critical judgments about things,
00:09:04 using the information that you have.
00:09:07 And it doesn't discover anything.
00:09:10 It can't create.
00:09:14 It predicts the next word.
00:09:15 Right, so it's not generative.
00:09:17 Believe me, predicting the next word
00:09:19 is going to have very, very powerful implications
00:09:22 to the global economy.
00:09:24 So let's not understate it,
00:09:27 but I don't want to overstate it.
00:09:29 Yeah.
00:09:30 Okay.
00:09:30 And now we know what AI is.
00:09:34 More or less.
00:09:35 More or less.
00:09:36 In a simple way.
00:09:38 What is happening in the business side of it?
00:09:42 Like, who are the players?
00:09:43 What are they doing?
00:09:44 How does a company make money doing AI?
00:09:48 or how does it get big the make money part is interesting here but what's going on so just
00:09:55 simplistically like for agentic ai for muse um maybe you'll pay a subscription to participate
00:10:03 in muse and if if not maybe people will advertise on muse um people pay llm create providers to use
00:10:16 their models now we will have a whole discussion about whether they're paying enough and how
00:10:22 expensive it is but they pay for it what has happened is that the people who run the tech
00:10:32 world have very quickly concluded that this new science is going to change the world
00:10:39 and that they cannot allow themselves to be left out
00:10:46 because if they're left out, they will get destroyed.
00:10:50 So they have all decided that they must participate.
00:10:54 It turns out that participating is extremely expensive.
00:10:59 And it's partially because of what I said.
00:11:03 You know, the way the LLM works is it constantly goes back to the beginning
00:11:07 and so the computation costs by its very nature are huge just because of that.
00:11:16 If all that happened was you had 10 words and then from those 10 words
00:11:21 it was able to predict the next 2,000, that would be a lot less expensive
00:11:25 than having to go back every time to the beginning and go right through the chain.
00:11:30 So everybody in the tech world wants to participate.
00:11:33 and the business model is very simply you convert computational power into the ability to predict
00:11:41 the next word and sell that to the consumer correct which which could be a person like you
00:11:47 and me yeah or it could be a company an enterprise that would that would pay for the same for the
00:11:52 service in a different way except none of these companies are profitable now are they
00:11:57 well let's let's take a step back there are a lot of companies involved here yeah so if you
00:12:05 I mean I would divide them up into kind of four groups there would be
00:12:10 the equipment providers oh yeah they'll be profitable they're profitable so and think of
00:12:19 it as like a gold rush the most profitable people in the gold rush is the guy who provides the picks
00:12:25 and shovels not the people who dug for the gold right because they quickly had to pay it was so
00:12:31 much and you know back in the gold rush in california what happened was it was so expensive
00:12:35 to live in the area that you you you got the gold then you had to pay for lunch and by the time you
00:12:41 finished paying for lunch your gold was gone but the guy who sold you the picks and shovels he made
00:12:45 a lot of them so you have all the people who sell the chips like nvidia which is the king because
00:12:52 is they sell a chip called a GPU, which
00:12:54 is the chip needed to do these type of computations.
00:12:59 Then you have all the other types of equipment makers,
00:13:01 Arista, Cisco, who provide all the connections, et cetera.
00:13:07 That's one group.
00:13:09 Then you have what's called the hyperscalers.
00:13:12 And to make this all work, we've always had data centers.
00:13:17 Not always.
00:13:18 We've had data centers for a very, very long time.
00:13:20 But because the computation needs of this are so huge,
00:13:25 the current data centers aren't strong enough
00:13:31 to provide the services needed for AI.
00:13:34 So what's happening is that we are building all over the country
00:13:37 huge, I mean, data centers that are five times bigger
00:13:40 than all data centers to provide the computation power.
00:13:46 That is a very, very expensive enterprise.
00:13:49 Literally, every one of these data centers
00:13:51 costs at least $30 billion, every single one,
00:13:55 in some cases more.
00:13:58 So the companies that are building most of the data
00:14:01 centers are what are called the hyperscalers.
00:14:03 And that would be Amazon, Google, Microsoft,
00:14:08 and I'd include Oracle in there as well, big, big, big,
00:14:14 wealthy tech companies.
00:14:17 And what has happened to them, because they are now involved
00:14:21 in building these very, very expensive data centers.
00:14:24 So for example, this year alone, those companies,
00:14:28 just those hyperscalers, are going
00:14:29 to spend $850 billion to build AI data centers all over
00:14:34 the country.
00:14:35 Next year, they'll spend over a trillion.
00:14:41 Those companies used to be capital light models
00:14:46 that generated tremendous amounts of cash flow.
00:14:50 But because of all the money that they're now spending,
00:14:53 they're now capital intense models,
00:14:56 and they're basically not generating any cash flow.
00:15:02 That's a big change.
00:15:04 So that's group two.
00:15:06 Group three, which is probably the most controversial right
00:15:09 now, are the companies called the NeoCloud companies.
00:15:14 So the neocloud companies are basically trying
00:15:16 to do the same thing as the hyperscalers,
00:15:18 build AI data centers.
00:15:21 They're just much newer and much smaller.
00:15:23 They don't have the same type of balance sheets.
00:15:26 This would be a company like CoreWeave
00:15:28 and a company like Nebius.
00:15:30 To build the data centers, they have
00:15:32 to raise tremendous amounts of debt,
00:15:35 and the market is starting to lose confidence in them
00:15:38 right now.
00:15:39 And so, for example, CoreWeave, which six months ago
00:15:43 raised debt at 9%, which is expensive.
00:15:46 That debt is currently priced at 15%, which is prohibitive.
00:15:50 So that's the neoclouds.
00:15:52 That's what's making the market very, very nervous right now.
00:15:56 And then you have all the LLM providers.
00:15:59 So you have Anthropic and OpenAI, which I'm sure your viewers
00:16:03 have heard their names.
00:16:04 Now, some of the hyperscalers are also LLM creators,
00:16:08 like Google, Microsoft, Meta,
00:16:11 which is not a hyperscaler,
00:16:14 but is a creator of LLMs and agentic AI.
00:16:19 And then you have the Chinese,
00:16:22 what's called open weight models,
00:16:24 which are also LLM models,
00:16:26 but are much, much cheaper.
00:16:27 They're not as good,
00:16:29 but they're much, much cheaper
00:16:30 than the expensive American models.
00:16:33 And those are the players.
00:16:34 And, Steve, there's a lot of people
00:16:37 who are listening to this who are very, very worried
00:16:40 about this technology, regular people.
00:16:43 Is this an unjustified worry?
00:16:46 Is this a justified worry?
00:16:47 Or is it kind of somewhere in between?
00:16:50 I think it's unjustified.
00:16:51 Now, I'll tell you why they think that,
00:16:55 but let's just talk about what I actually think.
00:16:58 It's a word prediction thing.
00:17:03 It doesn't think.
00:17:04 it does have the ability to hack so one of the things that's happened and and is that
00:17:14 the people who run these LL models have sent their LL models into the world
00:17:19 let's see what happens and they've hacked certain companies and now I don't think that's
00:17:28 necessarily the way it has to be I think it's because Anthropic and OpenAI are just not the
00:17:33 most well-run companies in the world,
00:17:34 and they haven't put protections in to make sure
00:17:37 that their models don't hack.
00:17:39 But the worst that anything has happened is hacking.
00:17:44 Now, there have been two predictions
00:17:49 made in the last year.
00:17:50 The first prediction was that AI would destroy all jobs.
00:17:56 And that proved to be completely untrue.
00:17:58 I mean, unemployment rate in the United States
00:17:59 is as low as it's been in a century, maybe,
00:18:03 something crazy and then the other prediction is that a I will end will
00:18:09 destroy planet Earth in other words Terminator by the way I rewatched
00:18:17 Terminator 1 and Terminator 2 recently just for the hell of it it's still good
00:18:21 great movies great great and then the funny thing is that the why did you
00:18:27 believe it's not gonna happen
00:18:30 in the movie is not as good as it used to be,
00:18:31 but it's still great.
00:18:32 Yeah.
00:18:35 What I think is going on is, let's go back to the players
00:18:40 again.
00:18:42 So remember when I was talking about this Anthropic
00:18:44 and open AI, and they make the expensive models.
00:18:48 And then you have the Chinese open weight models, which
00:18:50 are roughly more or less one-tenth the cost.
00:18:54 So if you're an enterprise and you use an open weight model,
00:18:58 It's going to cost you one-tenth.
00:19:01 It may not be as good, but a tenth is a tenth.
00:19:05 And so what's happening is Anthropic and Open Eye
00:19:08 are losing a lot of market share.
00:19:10 And there's a risk here of a price war.
00:19:12 And they don't have the balance sheets
00:19:14 to withstand a price war because they lose money.
00:19:19 So what I think they've done is create hysteria.
00:19:25 And why would you create hysteria?
00:19:28 create a stereo because you're inviting regulation and by inviting regulation your hope is you can
00:19:35 manipulate the regulators to throw the chinese open weight models out of the country so that
00:19:40 you can create a duopoly that's what i think is going on here's the part of the ai hype nobody
00:19:47 mentions a model can be brilliant and still have no idea how your organization actually works
00:19:53 because inside a company what makes ai useful isn't just a clever model it's context who knows
00:19:59 what what got decided already and where the latest version of that document actually lives
00:20:04 that's what glean does it's built for businesses not individuals it connects your company's
00:20:09 knowledge people decisions and workflows across every system your teams use so your staff and
00:20:15 your ai agents can actually get on with the work and if you run an organization here's the part
00:20:20 that matters. Glean keeps your existing permissions and security exactly where they are. The intern
00:20:26 doesn't get to read the board papers. Your company's knowledge stays under your control.
00:20:30 The result is that everyone draws on the best of what your organization knows,
00:20:34 teams spend less time chasing each other, and the plan leadership signs off actually gets carried
00:20:39 out. I'm skeptical of most AI pitches, but I have to say Glean is great for a business drowning in
00:20:46 its own information. It makes a lot of sense. Go take a look at glean.com slash trig. Glean,
00:20:52 the context platform for enterprise AI. Visit glean.com slash trig to unlock an exclusive offer
00:20:58 just for listeners of our show. That's glean.com slash trig. Terms and conditions apply.
00:21:05 So you think the stories that are being released and the whistleblowers and all of that is just
00:21:10 It's kind of like a marketing exercise almost.
00:21:13 Exactly.
00:21:14 Totally.
00:21:15 I think it's utter nonsense.
00:21:18 Okay.
00:21:19 And what about, let's look at the first claim is that it's going to get rid of jobs.
00:21:23 But it's already doing that, isn't it, Steve?
00:21:25 I mean, a lot of entry white collar jobs are going by the wayside.
00:21:28 A lot of companies are thinking to themselves, why are we going to have researchers, have all these types of people, legal clerks, when we can just get AI to do it?
00:21:38 That's happening, isn't it?
00:21:40 It is and it isn't.
00:21:42 You know, man, I'll give you an example.
00:21:43 There was a period a while ago where people thought you wouldn't need radiologists
00:21:48 because, you know, you'd enter the scan or whatever it was,
00:21:53 and AI would read it, and that would give you whatever answer you needed.
00:22:01 Turned out it doesn't work that way.
00:22:03 That really what happens is it helps the radiologist read the scan,
00:22:07 but you still need the radiologist to read the scan.
00:22:09 But because of that story, fewer people went into radiology.
00:22:19 So now there's a shortage of radiologists in the United States.
00:22:22 Now people want more radiologists.
00:22:24 So, yes, you know, you hear these things about how you're not going to need this,
00:22:29 you're not going to need that, and then it turns out you still need them.
00:22:31 It just, it just, it's the job description is going to change.
00:22:35 And, okay, the counter argument is, well, look, we're talking about this is 2026.
00:22:39 But 2029, you know, 2030, this could be a very, very different landscape because the way the technology is moving forward.
00:22:48 That's true. I can't predict the future. I don't know what's going to happen.
00:22:52 But I think I do think AI is going to be eventually transformative.
00:22:58 But the Internet was transformative and, you know, people were still employed.
00:23:03 What do you mean by transformative?
00:23:05 Well, the Internet changed the world. I mean, it changed the way we do everything.
00:23:09 Is there mass unemployment because of the internet?
00:23:12 There's not mass unemployment because of the internet.
00:23:14 It's just jobs changed.
00:23:16 You know, what people do and how they do it changed.
00:23:20 But there was no mass unemployment because of the internet.
00:23:23 I don't see why there'll be mass unemployment because of AI.
00:23:25 And so take the example, the final one is the driving jobs.
00:23:29 You know, if we're going to get self-driving cars, self-driving lorries,
00:23:33 I mean, that's an industry which employs millions of people in this country.
00:23:38 I mean, that's a very serious problem, isn't it,
00:23:40 if an entire sector is just wiped out, or the majority of it?
00:23:45 My view on autonomous driving is it's going to take a lot longer than people think.
00:23:49 I think eventually that's going to be a problem.
00:23:51 I think it's way down the road.
00:23:54 So there are two critical things we're talking about.
00:23:57 One is the jobs thing, which I am actually less doomerish about,
00:24:00 and then there's the other, which is AGI.
00:24:02 We'll talk about AGI in a second, but let's just stick with this for a moment.
00:24:05 I mean, we just had Andrew Yang here, who I'm sure you're aware of, and his argument is sure the unemployment rate is low, but the labor participation rate is very, very low.
00:24:15 Like one out of three men, young men, is basically not even trying to be employed, which is why they don't show up in the unemployment statistics.
00:24:24 And logically, as we all look around at how we use AI, I can see in my own life AI replacing human beings that I used to go to for certain things, right?
00:24:33 And now I take your point. In every great technological transformation, historically speaking, people have always had this fear.
00:24:40 Right. You know, 98 percent of people are employed in farming.
00:24:43 Suddenly mechanized farming comes along, but people still have jobs.
00:24:46 They just do different things. But we've never created a thing that can be agentic.
00:24:53 It can do things instead of a human being, as in like it's basically another being effectively in terms of its ability to do things.
00:25:02 Right?
00:25:03 That's a concern here, isn't it?
00:25:05 Meh.
00:25:06 I just don't think so.
00:25:08 You've got to give me more, though.
00:25:10 I want to hear the rationale behind the men.
00:25:12 That's the most New York thing I've ever heard in my life.
00:25:15 I want to hear the rationale behind the men.
00:25:18 I want you to persuade me, but I need you.
00:25:20 I don't need to persuade you.
00:25:22 You don't need to.
00:25:23 I need you to, because otherwise I think this is kind of scary.
00:25:26 As far as I can sell, there's been no new technology that has ever really been a net destroyer of jobs.
00:25:32 ever it's it's eventually you know we adjust and we move on the u.s economy is the most dynamic
00:25:39 economy probably on planet earth um i have some very negative things about to say about ai and
00:25:48 the way it might impact the market over the next year or two um but i just don't worry about it i
00:25:55 just i just don't think at the end of the day it's just going to be that big a concern i mean you
00:26:00 You know, Andrew Yang, you know, people like Andrew Yang love to predict the end of the world.
00:26:04 They just love it. They get high on it.
00:26:08 And I got news for you.
00:26:09 You know, I did predict the end of the world and I was right.
00:26:13 And I have absolutely no interest predicting it again unless I absolutely think it's going to happen again.
00:26:18 So I just don't take it seriously.
00:26:21 OK, let's talk about AGI then.
00:26:26 Explain to people what AGI means.
00:26:29 Yeah.
00:26:30 And I'm guessing if you don't think AI is thinking,
00:26:32 then you don't think AGI is possible.
00:26:34 Is that fair?
00:26:35 I never said I don't think AGI is possible.
00:26:38 So AGI basically means a machine that thinks.
00:26:41 Right.
00:26:41 And so the reason why, you know,
00:26:44 people get so nervous about AI is they say AI is going to become AGI,
00:26:50 which is going to mean Skynet Terminator,
00:26:53 as in Terminator 1 and Terminator 2,
00:26:55 nuclear bombs are going to fall over the end of the world.
00:27:00 so one of the reasons why i don't so i as i am a thousand percent convinced that right now
00:27:07 ai is not agi it doesn't think i agree now maybe at some point in the future that's going to happen
00:27:13 i don't think given this technology where what what you are as a word predictor that you that
00:27:20 that you could take that and become agi that's just my view and i am no expert but that's my
00:27:26 opinion about it so i was right when i said you don't think it's possible i i would bet it's not
00:27:31 possible given this technology that doesn't mean one day we won't have agi we had it in star trek
00:27:39 but i love star trek okay right i'm not bet you didn't see that one coming no i didn't
00:27:46 And, well, I'm not reassured, I must say,
00:27:50 because this is why I was trying to tease out
00:27:55 what you mean by the word think in the beginning.
00:27:59 Because...
00:27:59 By the way, none of the people who say
00:28:02 that we're going to AGI, they don't define it either.
00:28:06 They don't have, like, some, like, definition
00:28:08 about what AGI really means in terms of thinking.
00:28:11 Yeah.
00:28:12 And so that you could say, oh, now...
00:28:14 We have reached AGI.
00:28:14 We have reached that.
00:28:15 Okay.
00:28:15 They just say it's going to happen and the world's going to end.
00:28:19 Oh, by the way, the other reason why I think it's nonsense is if I was Dario Omode and I seriously thought, I mean, really thought honestly that what I was doing could destroy planet Earth, would I go public?
00:28:39 No, I mean, I would not go public.
00:28:41 I would make sure, first, that my technology was safe.
00:28:45 Instead, he's pontificating, yeah, my technology can destroy the world.
00:28:50 By the way, what type of allocation would you like in my IPO?
00:28:54 I just can't take it seriously.
00:28:56 Well, sure, except this has always been my concern about all of this.
00:29:03 AI is inevitable, right?
00:29:05 It's going to happen whether Dariy Amadei does it.
00:29:07 He's AGI.
00:29:08 Well, no, the continued development of AI.
00:29:11 Yes, that's fair.
00:29:11 And what is happening now is inevitable.
00:29:14 So if you're in charge of one of these companies
00:29:16 and you think there's a 10% chance it could destroy humanity,
00:29:20 you go, like you said, I don't want to be involved in this, right?
00:29:25 It's not that I don't want to be involved in it.
00:29:26 I would make sure that my technology was completely safe before it went public.
00:29:31 What if you believe you can't make it safe?
00:29:33 Because what it will eventually...
00:29:35 I think I would shut it down.
00:29:36 Right. Okay.
00:29:37 And here's my point.
00:29:38 You'd shut it down.
00:29:39 Yeah.
00:29:39 and someone else less scrupulous than you would take your place okay right and if you in this
00:29:47 country let's say america which is leading the world on this if you had a president who said
00:29:52 you know what uh this is going to kill all life on earth shut it down then we know that other
00:29:57 countries will fill that space so the collective action problem is why the ceo of a company who
00:30:03 has a genuine fear that the technology he's developing has a risk for humanity could well
00:30:09 nonetheless continue to do for that very reason okay right i don't believe it why not i just don't
00:30:15 believe it i think these guys lie all the time i know sam altman does sure i i i don't know sam
00:30:23 altman i i have heard bad things about him but it's not a sam altman thing the i most people
00:30:29 like i said there's no evidence that this thing thinks or that it's even close to thinking so on
00:30:36 what basis would you predict that the world's going to end on a technology where you're not
00:30:41 even close to even getting to the thing that maybe hurts you i just think it's ridiculous
00:30:46 let's flesh it out if you don't mind if you're happy to play this thought experiment because i
00:30:50 really want you to explain to me what i'm missing and be as convinced as you are that everything is
00:30:54 going to be fine because i'm really not so please d d by the way you should know something about me
00:30:59 i never feel an obligation to convince anyone of anything i just don't no no no and you're
00:31:04 people should be entitled to think what they want to think no no no no but what uh i see you as
00:31:09 someone who who has clearly insight into these things understands them in some in many ways way
00:31:15 better than i do certainly with them don't all of us here do so i'm looking uh i'm trying to tease
00:31:21 out i'm no expert in this but i think i've spoken to enough people who are so i have an opinion so
00:31:26 i'm interested in the mechanics of your opinion that's why i'm digging if that's okay with you
00:31:30 Sure. Yeah. So what I think people think about when they think about AGI is essentially a thing that has agency that is independent of human beings. Right.
00:31:42 I think that's fair. Right. So the question is not can it think by a philosophical standard that we are going to struggle to conceptualize with words.
00:31:51 the question is, are we inventing something that is capable of making rapid calculations
00:31:56 that has agentic power that eventually will be independent of us and not under our control?
00:32:03 And it may even be well-intentioned, whatever that means for a computerized thing. But the
00:32:10 question is, are we creating something that has tremendous power and is not in our control?
00:32:15 that's the that's what we mean when we mean AGI has the potential for us because it's not hard
00:32:21 to go from there to it's not about nuclear weapons um AGI that is an agent that thinks
00:32:27 faster than we do basically oh doesn't think sorry let's take that back makes calculations
00:32:32 and analyzes and is able to make decisions better and faster than we do it's hard to separate the
00:32:37 two yeah just because of language exactly but that's why I took back the word thinking and
00:32:42 places with calculations that thing even well intentioned could destroy all humanity or could
00:32:49 put us in a position of subjugation for our own good or could do all sorts of other things
00:32:54 that's what people are thinking about when they're thinking about the risk of agi
00:32:59 right yes why is that wrong
00:33:01 given the people that i've spoken to this model is a word retriever model
00:33:12 and given the way this in the the person who like has been the biggest critic is a guy named gary
00:33:18 marcus who i've interviewed multiple times and i think if gary were here he'd say something like
00:33:25 that LLM is a word is a fancy word retrieval model given that type of technology you're never going
00:33:38 to get to AGI unless many many many other things happen first mm-hmm well that's true sure because
00:33:46 no one's saying we're AGI now some people are well they're wrong Jensen Wong said we're here
00:33:52 Really?
00:33:53 Well, he knows more about it than I do.
00:33:55 And I just think he just made that up for a nice publicity stunt.
00:33:58 That's possible, but it's also possible that that's true
00:34:02 and we will get to AGI over the next five years.
00:34:06 I mean, if it happens in my lifetime,
00:34:08 if you have kids, for example, it's kind of worrying either way.
00:34:11 But what I don't understand is the skepticism
00:34:15 because if we already have agentic AI,
00:34:18 then all it has to do is get better at calculating quickly.
00:34:25 I don't think that's thinking.
00:34:27 Sure, fine.
00:34:28 It's not an independent agent.
00:34:30 That's true.
00:34:31 That's true.
00:34:32 I mean, what happened in Terminator was you created this machine that thought,
00:34:36 and then it went into the Internet, and you couldn't control it
00:34:41 because it was everywhere.
00:34:42 That was the concept.
00:34:45 Could that happen?
00:34:45 I mean, I suppose it could happen, but I just don't see anything that's happening right now that's going to lead to that right now.
00:34:52 The people who watch this show have generally done more thinking about how governments operate the most.
00:34:57 But there's a difference between understanding the problem and having actually built insulation against it.
00:35:04 That's the world Mikhail Thorup operates in.
00:35:06 He's been living as an expat for over 25 years, visiting more than 110 countries and calling nine of them home.
00:35:12 He founded Expat Money nearly a decade ago to help others do the same.
00:35:16 When he helped someone build an international plan B, the knowledge he brings is entirely
00:35:20 firsthand.
00:35:21 Every recommendation comes from something he has already done himself.
00:35:26 Expat Money works specifically with freedom-minded families and investors who want to reduce
00:35:31 their exposure on any one government or any one system.
00:35:35 Second residencies, second citizenships, offshore banking, international real estate, legal
00:35:40 structures that spread your life across borders. Mikkel has put together a free report called
00:35:44 Plan B Residencies and Instant Citizenships. It covers five routes to a second passport,
00:35:50 including one that almost never gets discussed. Our foreign residency functions as genuine
00:35:55 political insurance, which countries actually make sense depending on what you're trying to protect
00:36:00 and what it realistically costs. Go to expatmoney.com slash trigger or click the link in
00:36:06 the description of this episode to download the report. There's no charge, no catch. That's
00:36:11 expatmoney.com slash trigger. It's not happening right now, I agree, but I don't think it's that
00:36:19 difficult to make the leap from where we are today to, say, you have a Gentic AI that currently
00:36:25 books your wife's Broadway shows, right? That, if it's bigger and more powerful and faster and
00:36:31 better able to analyze and compute quickly. You could have an agentic AI that runs a country or
00:36:41 runs a business or whatever eventually, right? So you say to President AI, this is the outcome
00:36:50 we'd like, and President AI goes and makes it happen. And it's not constrained by some of the
00:36:55 things that human beings are constrained by and is therefore prepared to do things.
00:36:58 Like ethics?
00:36:59 Right.
00:37:00 Right.
00:37:01 Because, as you said yourself, it doesn't have morality.
00:37:03 Right.
00:37:04 Right?
00:37:04 A lot of people don't have morality.
00:37:07 True.
00:37:07 Also.
00:37:08 True.
00:37:09 But some people do have morality.
00:37:11 That's true.
00:37:11 We're not aware.
00:37:13 We are not going to solve this debate.
00:37:15 That is for sure.
00:37:17 I mean, look, at the end of the day, given where the technology is today, I'm not worried.
00:37:23 Come back to me in a year, maybe I'll be worried.
00:37:26 But right now, I don't see anything in this technology that makes me work.
00:37:29 The reason I think about it, not to continue a discussion you don't want to continue,
00:37:34 is I was looking at the prediction markets.
00:37:36 Calci, the prediction is a company will develop AGI by 28.
00:37:42 That's two years.
00:37:43 28.
00:37:44 In the next two years.
00:37:45 Two years.
00:37:45 In the next two years.
00:37:46 Okay.
00:37:47 I'll take the other side of that bet.
00:37:49 Okay.
00:37:50 All right.
00:37:51 We'll have to have...
00:37:52 We'll come back in two years.
00:37:53 We'll come back to this portion of the conversation in two years.
00:37:56 So, Steve, you've been very positive throughout this entire interview.
00:38:00 This is something we don't do at Trigonometry.
00:38:02 So we haven't depressed people enough, I feel.
00:38:05 You said that you had concerns over this technology.
00:38:09 What are your concerns when it comes to this tech?
00:38:11 My concerns are business concerns.
00:38:13 Tell us about those.
00:38:14 Tell us about your business concerns.
00:38:15 The technology itself, I think, is great.
00:38:21 I certainly enjoy using it.
00:38:23 um i mean the first time i used it i just i figured i'd ask it a very difficult question
00:38:29 just this is this is a year and a half ago the first time i used it i there was a philosophy book
00:38:35 that was very complicated that i read in college and i said to gemini summarize this book for me
00:38:44 and five pages there was and I read it it's like wow that's unbelievable so I
00:38:53 think the technology is great you know what which parts of the economy will
00:38:59 change the most nobody knows there's nobody even predicting because nobody
00:39:04 knows the issues from a business perspective are not the same thing is is
00:39:11 technology good thing so example literally every sentence other than the
00:39:20 AGI stuff that is being uttered about this technology was uttered about the
00:39:25 internet in the late 90s meaning it's transformative it's going to change the
00:39:31 way we do everything etc etc and that all proved to be true and yet the first
00:39:38 generation of all the internet companies went bankrupt or take the railroads for example the
00:39:44 railroads transformed the global economy half the railroads went bankrupt so the fact that a
00:39:52 technology is great doesn't necessarily mean everybody makes money a lot of people are going
00:40:00 going to lose money.
00:40:02 So that's just the first, like, Uber point.
00:40:07 So here's how I sort of think about the risks.
00:40:11 Like, we'll start at the top with NVIDIA,
00:40:14 and we'll work our way down to Anthropic and OpenAI.
00:40:18 So NVIDIA reported its most recent quarter
00:40:21 about a month and a half ago.
00:40:26 Revenue growth was over 100%.
00:40:30 Now think about that for a minute.
00:40:32 The largest company on planet Earth
00:40:35 had revenue growth of over 100%.
00:40:39 Insane.
00:40:39 I mean, this is not a billion market cap company
00:40:42 that grew its revenue by over 100%.
00:40:43 This is a 5 1⁄2 trillion company
00:40:45 that grew its revenue by over 100%.
00:40:48 So that tells you the power of this whole thing
00:40:50 that's happening, that people are just spending money
00:40:52 like crazy.
00:40:54 There's a lot of picks and shovels being solved.
00:40:55 A lot of picks and shovels.
00:40:57 Because you're building these data centers that
00:40:59 need to be filled up with all these very, very
00:41:02 expensive things.
00:41:04 Then, but if you go into the 10Q,
00:41:09 there's a very interesting sentence.
00:41:11 And the sentence is, 70% of NVIDIA's,
00:41:17 this quarter of NVIDIA's accounts receivable,
00:41:20 which is like a proxy for revenue, 70% was from five
00:41:23 customers.
00:41:26 Now, that's a little alarming.
00:41:29 Forget about NVIDIA.
00:41:32 If you were running a company, you
00:41:35 wouldn't want to be running a company where you only
00:41:38 had five customers.
00:41:40 Because if you lost one customer, that'd be really bad.
00:41:44 So the fact that the largest company in the world
00:41:47 has over 100% revenue growth, but it's mostly
00:41:50 just with five customers, that's like an alarm bell.
00:41:54 So then let's move down one level to the hyperscalers.
00:41:58 Microsoft, Google, Amazon, and Oracle.
00:42:04 So if you just look at Microsoft, Amazon, and Google,
00:42:09 70% of their AI revenue is just from Anthropoc and OpenAI.
00:42:19 Now, 70% of their AI revenue is equal to about 25%
00:42:27 of their entire cloud revenue, which is basically
00:42:31 huge division within the company.
00:42:34 Oracle is even worse, because Oracle
00:42:39 has a backlog of about $600 billion.
00:42:43 Over half of it is just from OpenAI.
00:42:46 So tremendous concentration.
00:42:50 And then you go down a level, basically,
00:42:55 If you go NVIDIA, the five customers
00:42:58 are probably the hyperscalers.
00:43:00 The hyperscalers are dependent upon OpenAI and Anthropic.
00:43:05 Anthropic and OpenAI lose money.
00:43:09 So the entire chain is basically dependent upon two companies.
00:43:15 The risk to these two companies right now is two vectors.
00:43:21 Number one, there are no moats around these LLM businesses.
00:43:28 Explain to people what a moat is.
00:43:30 So a moat is basically like a barrier to entry in your business.
00:43:34 So there can be a regulatory barrier to entry or a business barrier to entry.
00:43:38 So a regulatory barrier entry would be something like, let's say I'm in a small town and I own the grocery store.
00:43:45 And I got the mayor of the town to create an ordinance that said no other grocery stores are allowed to open in this town.
00:43:53 That would be a barrier to entry.
00:43:57 A non-barrier to entry, a business barrier to entry would be something like, take Google search.
00:44:05 Who on planet Earth doesn't use Google search?
00:44:08 And not only do we all use Google search, we can't even think about using anything other than Google search.
00:44:14 until recently because of AI.
00:44:17 So for 20-some-odd years, Google, the search business,
00:44:22 had this insurmountable moat that just everybody used Google Search
00:44:26 and nobody was going to use anything else.
00:44:27 Yeah, it literally became a verb to Google.
00:44:29 Right, a verb.
00:44:30 When you're a verb, you know you've got something.
00:44:34 So, you know, the way this sort of LLM thing works
00:44:39 is somebody's using Claude to create software.
00:44:44 And then somebody else shows up with another model
00:44:50 that you hear is really good.
00:44:52 And you switch, and you use their model.
00:44:55 And so people are switching all the time.
00:44:57 There's no moat.
00:44:59 That's a very long-term problem.
00:45:03 But the other problem, which is even more pressing,
00:45:07 is that these Chinese open weight models
00:45:09 are just much cheaper.
00:45:10 They're not as good.
00:45:11 But you don't need to have a Mercedes-Benz
00:45:13 drive around the block so for many tasks you'll use the open weight model and what i'm hearing is
00:45:20 that um anthropic and open ai are starting to cut price because they're losing share now
00:45:28 that wouldn't be so terrible if they were very profitable companies but they're not profitable
00:45:33 at all how not profitable are they insanely unprofitable like nuts so uh let's see in the
00:45:42 In the most recent quarter, I'll be maybe a little bit off, OpenAI had about $6.5 billion
00:45:51 in revenue and $12 billion in costs.
00:45:57 That's just current.
00:45:59 But what they have done is, because they see, in their opinion, that they're going to grow
00:46:05 forever they need more and more compute power to deal with all the business that
00:46:16 they think they're going to get so they have signed hundreds upon hundreds of
00:46:22 billions of dollars of commitments to data centers so it's not just that
00:46:30 they're unprofitable right now they have committed to spend insane amounts of
00:46:34 money so essentially what you're saying is that they're probably over leveraged aren't they
00:46:39 i don't know what leverage well there's leverage and there's leverage there's balance sheet
00:46:44 leverage which you know shows up on the balance sheet that's not what we're talking about if you
00:46:49 have a commitment to spend i'll make up a number 500 billion dollars over the next six seven years
00:46:56 that doesn't show up on your balance sheet that's in a footnote wow but we could think about it just
00:47:02 and that it's really debt.
00:47:04 I mean, it's your commitment.
00:47:05 You wrote a con, you signed a contract.
00:47:07 But it technically isn't leverage.
00:47:09 It's a commitment, but it's leverage.
00:47:11 So is this an, is this a bubble?
00:47:15 Is this one giant bubble, the entire AI industry?
00:47:18 I don't know yet.
00:47:20 I mean, it just, if tomorrow or within the next year,
00:47:28 one of these two companies, and OpenAI is the weaker company,
00:47:30 One of these two companies failed.
00:47:32 I think the entire AI complex would slow to a crawl
00:47:37 because it's so dependent upon these two companies.
00:47:41 And I think the U.S. economy would go into a recession immediately.
00:47:46 It's not a financial crisis.
00:47:48 It's a plain vanilla recession.
00:47:52 It'd be like the dot-com bubble, and you eventually come out of it.
00:47:56 if one of these companies fails in the next four or five years you know probably things will be
00:48:02 much more diversified and it'll be fine so i don't know yet i'm keeping very close track on
00:48:08 the pricing situation is there a price war and um you know anthropic supposedly is going to go
00:48:15 public soon and at least we'll have some numbers we could look at because the way you're describing
00:48:22 it and maybe i'm reading too much into it is it kind of sounds inevitable that this thing is going
00:48:27 to go pop just through the sheer numbers of it nothing's inevitable i mean the the the demand
00:48:35 for all this stuff is still very is growing very rapidly um but there are things under the surface
00:48:42 that are that uh that i find alarming but i'm not ready to make a bubble call yet other people are
00:48:48 they're making that call i'm not ready to make that call yet well historically as you
00:48:52 talk about the internet, new technology tends to attract more and more and more capital and
00:48:59 eventually FOMO kicks in. That's how bubbles happen, right? People think something is the
00:49:06 next gold rush. They go for it. They think now is the time to get in and eventually the music
00:49:10 stops, right? So historically speaking, it would be logical to expect a bubble at some point.
00:49:17 The question is more about where we are.
00:49:20 Right now, like as we speak, what's making people nervous is now Corweave and Nebius.
00:49:32 So Corweave, if you remember, were those neocloud companies that are competing with the hyperscalers.
00:49:37 They're just not nearly as big as the hyperscalers are.
00:49:40 So Corweave's debt went from 9% to 15% as freaking people out.
00:49:45 It's freaking them out because you're not building a data center when your debt costs 15%.
00:49:51 It does not.
00:49:53 So everybody's starting to worry about all the CapEx and how much debt is being raised
00:49:58 and what's the interest rate that's going to be charged on that debt
00:50:01 and the fact that interest rates have gone up a lot in the last few months.
00:50:04 That hurts, too.
00:50:05 That's what everybody's focused on right now.
00:50:07 They're not focused on is the technology good.
00:50:10 I think everybody comes to the conclusion that technology is good.
00:50:14 And helpful.
00:50:15 Absolutely good and helpful. Externalities also exist, but we've already talked about that.
00:50:23 So with the market side of it, are you saying it's hard to say because the companies aren't public,
00:50:30 so we don't have good data on what's going on inside of them?
00:50:33 That's part of the problem. And we also don't have great data on how much of a price war is happening right now.
00:50:39 we have some data but it's not great a lot of it's anecdotal um but it'll come out sooner or later
00:50:49 a while back i pushed myself in training because i'm a legend but ended up with a strain that took
00:50:55 far longer to recover from than it ever used to nothing dramatic just one of those moments where
00:50:59 you realize your body isn't snapping back the way it once did and as you get older those moments
00:51:05 start adding up. Turns out there's a reason for that, and it's not just getting older,
00:51:09 it's something specific happening at the cellular level. That's the idea behind Qualia Senolytic,
00:51:15 a science-backed formula built around a fairly new area of research called senolytics. Your body
00:51:21 accumulates what researchers call senescent cells, sometimes nicknamed zombie cells. Cells that have
00:51:28 done their job and are just sitting there using up resources instead of clearing out. The theory
00:51:33 is is that this buildup is a big part of what people describe as feeling middle-aged, lower
00:51:39 energy, slower recovery after exercise, and general joint discomfort. Qualia Senolytic uses nine
00:51:45 vegan plant-derived compounds designed to support your body's natural processes for clearing out
00:51:51 these cells. And you only take it two days a month. It's vegan, non-GMO, and developed with
00:51:57 input from research scientists working specifically in this field. Since I started taking it,
00:52:02 Mornings feel easier, workouts don't take as long to bounce back from,
00:52:07 and I generally have more left in the tank by the afternoon than I did a year ago.
00:52:11 Experience the science of feeling younger.
00:52:14 Go to qualialife.com slash trig for up to 50% off your purchase and use code trig for an additional 15%.
00:52:23 That's Q-U-A-L-I-A, life.com slash trig for an extra 15% off your purchase.
00:52:32 Your oldest self will thank you.
00:52:34 And thanks to Qualia for sponsoring this episode.
00:52:38 And I was going to say, just moving on,
00:52:41 a lot of people have said that we are in an AI tech race with China.
00:52:46 Yes.
00:52:47 Do you see that as being a real thing?
00:52:49 No, no, I do see that as a real thing.
00:52:51 Certainly the Chinese do.
00:52:53 That's clear as day.
00:52:55 Why is that clear as day?
00:52:57 Well, they've created all these open-weight models.
00:52:59 They're pouring tons of money.
00:53:00 The difference between China and the U.S., this is sort of funny, is that in the U.S., we build the bigger models, but we have trouble building the data centers because you've got to get permits.
00:53:14 Not everybody wants a data center in their backyard.
00:53:17 In China, their models are weaker, but they can build data centers right into the desert.
00:53:23 They don't care.
00:53:24 They could care less about any environmental concerns that's relevant to them.
00:53:28 Okay. And so what does this mean for society as a whole and also the economy that we are in a AI race with China and China is essentially being funded by the government, by the CCP, whereas ours, well, the U.S.'s is kind of self-funded, invested as a classical capitalist model.
00:53:54 I'm rooting for us.
00:53:55 that's really ruined for our team um you know the chinese economy is not good
00:54:03 it really isn't they're still dealing with the fact that they way over built uh housing
00:54:09 um i think their gdp is slowing their market is down this year um i don't know i'm just rooting
00:54:18 for our side well that's a good thing uh what i was going to ask you actually on in terms of
00:54:23 You mentioned that so much of this industry is contingent on two companies.
00:54:27 One of them is a little bit stronger than the other.
00:54:30 And historically, when bubbles burst, you lose a bunch of companies.
00:54:36 Every time.
00:54:37 But then the survivors become hegemonic.
00:54:41 And then new people show up.
00:54:42 And new people show up.
00:54:43 For example, if you think about the Internet bubble, Google was the second generation.
00:54:48 and they took advantage of all the internet infrastructure
00:54:55 that had been created by all those companies went bankrupt.
00:54:58 Right.
00:54:59 So that happens, but given the potential impact
00:55:02 on the American and certainly global economy
00:55:06 that would happen in this,
00:55:07 will they even be allowed to fail?
00:55:09 Oh, God.
00:55:11 I sure as hell hope so.
00:55:12 I really don't want to go through this again.
00:55:15 Right.
00:55:15 Well, that's why I'm asking.
00:55:16 i i think and i could be a hundred percent wrong on this that there'll be a lot to fail
00:55:25 there's a big difference between a a regular company or tech company failing and jp morgan
00:55:32 sure you know when when a regular company fails fails it goes out of business or reforms it lays
00:55:42 off people you know all the all the other companies that are that are supplying it have trouble maybe
00:55:47 they have layoffs maybe some of them fail you know maybe you have a recession that's typical when
00:55:54 when people are worried about getting their money out of the bank that's the end of the world it's
00:55:58 the end of the world so that's why they had to bail out the banks i don't think they have to
00:56:03 they definitely do not have to bail these people out whether they'll get bailed out or not is a
00:56:07 a separate question that's a political question I can't answer that I don't know I just kind of
00:56:12 have this feeling and maybe this the layman in me that this is unsustainable at some point
00:56:18 something is going to happen now I don't know what that is but but it just the way you've
00:56:23 expressed to explain it you've done it beautifully and the numbers I get a feeling of dread because
00:56:28 I go well this can't carry on then I've done my job yeah I agree I more likely than not
00:56:37 we have a bubble and it bursts.
00:56:40 I don't want to say that I'm 100% certain that that's the case.
00:56:43 Well, you can't be a bubble.
00:56:44 I was 100% certain in 08.
00:56:46 So what's missing?
00:56:47 That was a different game.
00:56:48 What's missing?
00:56:48 I had a database that I don't have here.
00:56:50 Uh-huh.
00:56:51 Tell me more.
00:56:53 So Moody's had a securitization database
00:56:56 where literally every single type of securitization,
00:57:00 from credit cards, auto loans, mortgage loans,
00:57:03 subprime mortgage loans,
00:57:04 literally every single securitization will report all its credit data every month and so when you're
00:57:13 analyzing to see like you you you knew anecdotally that mortgage underwriting standards had
00:57:18 deteriorated but how did how would you see it in numbers the way you would see it as numbers you
00:57:23 would take a look at the more recent securitization like let's say a securitization that was done in
00:57:30 June of 2006 and you would look at let's say month four and you would say what are the delinquencies
00:57:38 in month four for this new securitization and then you would go back and you would look at
00:57:44 older securitizations and you would say what were the delinquencies in month four of those
00:57:48 older securitizations if and I'll make up a number let's say the delinquency in the most
00:57:54 recent securitization was 2% for 30 days.
00:57:58 If a year ago or two years ago it had also been 2%,
00:58:03 you'd say, oh, the underwriting centers are consistent.
00:58:06 But if it's 2% here and it's 25 basis points over here,
00:58:11 you know something's wrong.
00:58:13 And then you would track it every month
00:58:14 and see how much deterioration there would be.
00:58:17 That was the richest possible database imaginable.
00:58:21 And you got that data every single month.
00:58:25 You don't have that here.
00:58:26 You just don't.
00:58:27 You know, there are certain people who put out data
00:58:30 about pricing.
00:58:31 It's helpful.
00:58:33 I don't know if I completely trust it yet.
00:58:36 But otherwise, everything's anecdotal.
00:58:39 Can we talk about macroeconomics a little bit?
00:58:41 Sure.
00:58:42 The US, Britain, France.
00:58:46 Oi, France.
00:58:49 A bunch of major, pretty much most of the major economies,
00:58:53 have a debt to GDP that's way over 100% now.
00:58:56 Yes, they certainly do.
00:58:57 And that's carrying on.
00:58:58 What do you think about that?
00:59:00 Well, let me just start off by saying, with respect to the U.S.,
00:59:03 it would be nice if the debt level was lower.
00:59:05 Yeah.
00:59:06 Okay, but let's leave that aside.
00:59:07 We are where we are.
00:59:09 We're all basically at 120%, more or less.
00:59:14 The U.S. is in a much better position than all these other countries.
00:59:18 France is, oh, my God, they are deep doo-doo.
00:59:22 And I'm not just talking about the riots.
00:59:24 Say more?
00:59:25 I'm about to.
00:59:28 So you're the U.S.
00:59:30 You have certain things that no other country has,
00:59:32 which are the dollar is the reserve currency of the world.
00:59:35 But even more important than that is that the global financial system
00:59:42 functions on treasuries.
00:59:44 meaning there's something called the bank repo market this is a four trillion dollar market
00:59:52 where banks all over the world lend to one another overnight that entire market is executed
01:00:02 via short-term treasuries if you are a large institution and you and i mean large like like
01:00:11 like, you know, the sovereign wealth fund of Norway.
01:00:14 I mean, big.
01:00:16 And you need to park money for five years.
01:00:23 Where are you going to park it?
01:00:24 You're going to buy treasuries.
01:00:26 So there is an entire audience of fixed income investors
01:00:36 of one kind or another who must own treasuries.
01:00:40 They don't even think about it.
01:00:41 They just push a button, buy more treasuries.
01:00:44 Now, that percentage is lower than it used to be,
01:00:46 but it's still about 45% of the whole treasury market
01:00:49 is just that.
01:00:52 That means that until there is a liquid, big alternative
01:01:00 to treasuries, the US has a luxury
01:01:03 in terms of carrying debt loads that other people don't have.
01:01:07 If you're France, let's pick on the French.
01:01:11 Please.
01:01:11 Excellent.
01:01:12 You're British.
01:01:13 You're totally too happy to do that.
01:01:15 Finally.
01:01:16 Something we can all agree on.
01:01:19 If you're France, there is no fixed income investor
01:01:23 on planet Earth that needs to own French sovereign bonds
01:01:27 other than some French banks.
01:01:30 That's it.
01:01:31 So if the market starts to lose confidence in French sovereign bonds, which seems to be rapidly in the process of doing, the only thing the French can do is cut their debt loads, which right now, politically, they don't want to do.
01:01:49 Or they can't do, maybe.
01:01:51 Well, at some point, if the world doesn't want your bonds, you have no choice.
01:01:57 You know, that's what Millet of Argentina basically faced.
01:02:00 It's like, you know, interest rates were over 30%.
01:02:02 He came in and he said, look, I know you're not going to like what I want to do here,
01:02:06 but we don't have a choice because the whole country is going to go bankrupt.
01:02:11 So that's kind of the road France is on.
01:02:13 And that's the mechanism by which it happens,
01:02:16 just explaining for normal people who are not financial experts.
01:02:20 What happens in these types of situations is people who would lend you money
01:02:25 don't believe that you're going to pay it back.
01:02:27 Correct.
01:02:27 They see it as a much higher risk.
01:02:29 So interest rates go up because interest rates are the price that is matched.
01:02:35 Or another way to think about it is interest rates on bonds are inversely related to price.
01:02:41 If the price goes down, the yield goes up.
01:02:44 So if everybody's freaking out about French bonds, what does that mean?
01:02:49 They're selling it.
01:02:50 So if they're selling it, the price is collapsing.
01:02:52 If the price is collapsing, the yield's going up.
01:02:54 Right.
01:02:54 And so ordinary people and businesses then have to pay 30% tax, 30% interest rates on their mortgage, which they can't.
01:03:02 They can't.
01:03:03 Pretty much nobody can.
01:03:04 Right.
01:03:04 Right.
01:03:05 At which point, as you say, the whole country goes bankrupt.
01:03:08 At which point, what happens is the government has to reassure potential lenders that it has a credible way of bringing down the debt.
01:03:17 And the only way to do that is to cut.
01:03:18 To cut spending.
01:03:19 Cut spending.
01:03:20 Which in France is like anathema.
01:03:22 Right.
01:03:23 Oh, yeah.
01:03:23 All of Europe, right?
01:03:24 Yeah.
01:03:24 Well, here, too.
01:03:26 I mean, let's not...
01:03:27 I don't want to get on the soapbox of the United States.
01:03:29 We don't want to cut either.
01:03:31 But, you know, just for example,
01:03:32 Marie Le Pen, who's probably going to be the next president to France,
01:03:35 is talking about reducing the retirement age from 62 to 60.
01:03:40 I mean, that's a big deal in France.
01:03:42 Huge!
01:03:43 Last time they tried that, they burned down Macron's favorite restaurant.
01:03:46 Well, Macron tried to raise it.
01:03:47 Right.
01:03:48 She's trying to cut it.
01:03:49 Yeah.
01:03:49 And that's the right-wing.
01:03:51 at it. And she's the right winger
01:03:53 and she's talking about cutting the retirement
01:03:55 age. The anecdote I always give people
01:03:57 about trying to raise the pension
01:03:59 age, which all our countries are going to have
01:04:01 to do because of this, is
01:04:03 Vladimir Putin tried
01:04:05 to raise the pension age in Russia
01:04:07 and there was such a rebellion. And even he could do it.
01:04:09 He backed down. Right. And he
01:04:11 kills people. Right. He just
01:04:13 couldn't throw that many people out of windows.
01:04:15 Right. Exactly. You'd have to throw a lot
01:04:17 of people out of windows.
01:04:19 You'd kind of feel bad.
01:04:20 But I come back to that word again, which I've used time and time again through this interview, is that sustainability.
01:04:30 This isn't sustainable.
01:04:31 Which is not. What is not sustainable?
01:04:33 Well, the current trajectory that it's on with, it's dead.
01:04:37 I could, Europe, I mean, Europe, you guys have a real problem.
01:04:42 You, and I'm just talking about the all of Europe generally.
01:04:46 You're over-regulated.
01:04:47 I mean, people like to say they love Europe because the social welfare system is great.
01:04:55 It's much stronger than the United States.
01:04:57 All true.
01:04:59 The problem that you have, before we even get to the economy, about the social welfare system is that your population is aging very, very rapidly.
01:05:07 and and the entire premise behind the economics of your social welfare system
01:05:14 is I've got this number of retirees and this number of young people and now I've
01:05:20 got this number of retirees and this number of young people the math doesn't
01:05:24 work anymore but nobody wants to admit it that's that's the problem the other
01:05:29 part of the problem is that for whatever reason the EU just loves to regulate and
01:05:36 And they love to regulate tech, for better or worse,
01:05:41 mostly worse.
01:05:42 And so there's very little tech in Europe.
01:05:44 And tech is the growth engine of the economy.
01:05:47 So just as an example, in the US,
01:05:52 Infotech is 40% of the entire S&P 500.
01:05:58 If you then add Google and Amazon, which are actually
01:06:03 not in Infotech.
01:06:05 They used to be, but they got moved out.
01:06:08 But they're tech.
01:06:09 And a whole bunch of other companies
01:06:11 also that are outside of tech, but are actually tech.
01:06:15 You're at 50%.
01:06:17 In Europe, I think tech is like 15%, 16% of the euro stocks.
01:06:24 And I can't even name a tech company.
01:06:27 I can't name one other than SAP.
01:06:32 And if you look at the biggest companies
01:06:35 In Europe, they're kind of old-school companies that have been around for a very, very long time.
01:06:41 And you look at the U.S. companies, and none of them have been around for more than 25 years.
01:06:45 So there's a lack of dynamism there in the market.
01:06:47 Complete lack of dynamism in the economy.
01:06:50 Yeah. Okay. So, but let's go back to, you know, the debt situation.
01:06:57 How long do we kind of have before the proverbial sh** hits a fan in Europe?
01:07:03 It's impossible to know.
01:07:04 i mean you know greece was there then one day and the next day it wasn't i mean these things
01:07:09 have a way of cascading and you can never predict it um you know if the riots keep going on in
01:07:16 france for a lot longer well this thing will get accelerated and what happens when that happens
01:07:21 what does that look like you know the bond markets yeah you know french bonds are now
01:07:27 five ten years like five percent it'll go to six it'll go to seven it'll go to eight and then
01:07:32 and people, they're going to freak.
01:07:34 That's going to freak out.
01:07:35 They're not going to buy French sovereign bonds.
01:07:37 Then you're going to hear Macron,
01:07:39 I don't know what Macron's going to do.
01:07:41 Macron's not going to know what to do.
01:07:43 I don't know anyone knows what to do.
01:07:45 Well, you cut.
01:07:47 You have a choice.
01:07:48 At some point, the bond market.
01:07:50 Again, the problem is that nobody has to own French sovereign bonds.
01:07:53 Right.
01:07:54 And nobody had to own Argentinian bonds.
01:07:56 It's the same problem.
01:07:57 But the worry is, it seems to me that a lot of the leaders
01:08:02 particularly in the UK with Andy Burnham
01:08:05 saying things like we're in hock to the bond markets, etc.
01:08:08 Too bad.
01:08:10 He's right.
01:08:11 Too bad.
01:08:13 Nobody needs to own UK bonds either.
01:08:16 You are at the whim of the bond market.
01:08:19 You just didn't know it.
01:08:20 Well, the thing is,
01:08:21 when Andy Burnham says you're at the whim of the bond market,
01:08:25 like the bond market is some sort of external evil,
01:08:27 well, no, you took their money.
01:08:29 Right. You borrowed.
01:08:30 You borrowed.
01:08:31 you borrowed money from these people and you owe them money that's not being in
01:08:35 hock like you should if you didn't the problem is Andy Burnham is basically a
01:08:38 Marxist so he thinks he doesn't have to pay the money back right but guess what
01:08:43 try that try not paying the money back okay play that out you don't want to pay
01:08:50 the money back we're not gonna pay the money back okay we're never gonna lend
01:08:53 you another penny now now go fund your country i mean there we i mean you're you're at the whim
01:09:03 of the bond market no matter how you look at it you don't want to pay back good don't pay back
01:09:07 you're dead right but it seems it's a wonderfully new way of putting it i guess the thing you do
01:09:16 sound like an upset lender at this point yeah i am how dare he say such a thing right yeah i know
01:09:22 You know what?
01:09:23 It's actually worse than that.
01:09:24 Even saying that hurts the price of his bonds.
01:09:28 Of course.
01:09:29 Yeah.
01:09:29 Because you are diminishing your credibility.
01:09:32 You're basically having underlying threat.
01:09:33 Right.
01:09:34 We're not going to pay you back.
01:09:34 OK, don't pay back.
01:09:36 All right.
01:09:36 But here's the thing.
01:09:37 By the way, the fixed income markets, you know, people like BlackRock, they're bigger
01:09:45 than the UK now.
01:09:46 it's it's the these governments are smaller than some of the players in the fixed income markets
01:09:52 right you don't want to tangle with these people we had an empire you did and it's gone
01:09:59 by the way you know where that line is from it's there's a wonderful episode of south park
01:10:06 about the financial crisis yeah and it's called margaritaville you have to watch it it's amazing
01:10:12 and there's a scene where this little kid goes into a bank it's right during the middle of the
01:10:17 crisis and he walks up to the to the gut to the bank officer and he says my stupid father made
01:10:25 gave me this money because he wants me to learn how to save here's the money i'm going to put it
01:10:29 in the money so i can save the money in the bank and so the the guy takes the check and he says
01:10:34 that's wonderful young man we'll just take this money and invest it in a money market fund that
01:10:39 invest in subprime mortgages and it's gone and it's gone speaking of the the financial crisis
01:10:45 obviously the the mechanics of the financials and the market and all that's been you know litigated
01:10:50 over and over and over i was curious what you there's a line in the big short or a point in
01:10:55 the big short in which the character that's you talks about fraud and greed and what did you learn
01:11:01 about human beings through that whole thing like what is it that most people don't understand about
01:11:08 how human brains work that you love?
01:11:09 If I had to boil it down to a sentence, which I have,
01:11:14 it's that incentives trump ethics every time.
01:11:18 Right.
01:11:19 So if you think about mortgage lenders, Wall Street,
01:11:26 all those people who were part of the origination process,
01:11:30 every single person in that chain
01:11:32 was compensated on volume, not quality, volume.
01:11:37 so they kept reducing and lowering underwriting standards so they could produce more volume
01:11:46 and they did that basically until planet earth burned they were never going to stop
01:11:51 it's so interesting because one of the things that we often think about is
01:11:56 new media which there was a hope at one point that new media would be a place where the narratives of
01:12:03 the mainstream media could be effectively challenged they would be a place for truth
01:12:07 seeking whatever well once the incentive structures kicked in you can see now how so many people
01:12:14 are incentivized to say things that they know aren't true to talk about things that don't matter
01:12:19 because that's what the incentive structure is taking them even if they had ethics at some point
01:12:23 they're getting absolutely smashed by the realities of the incentive structures of this industry give
01:12:28 me an example candace owens oh yes of course right and megan kelly megan kelly less so but less so
01:12:36 But but but in the same direction. Right. I could give you more. I mean, you can keep going down the list.
01:12:41 So that's fascinating. So incentive structures will trump morals and ethics every time on a scale.
01:12:50 There'll be individual holdouts, but on the scale of it. Yeah. So you have to have the right incentive structures.
01:12:55 Otherwise, the whole thing goes. Yeah. Do you think we've recovered from the O.A. crash?
01:13:02 let me introduce you to the people i work with to protect my family against financial instability
01:13:08 inflation and turmoil for me one of the best ways to safeguard your wealth is by investing in gold
01:13:14 and that's why i trust the pure gold company here's a smart tip if you buy uk minted gold coins
01:13:21 like sovereigns you won't pay vat when you buy them or capital gains tax when you sell
01:13:25 all the profit is yours to keep and the best part gold is a completely private investment
01:13:31 It's outside the banking system so it can't be manipulated by governments or anyone else.
01:13:37 Unlike digital assets, it's yours in the truest sense. The Pure Gold Company is trusted by first
01:13:42 time investors and seasoned professionals alike. What I really appreciate about them
01:13:46 is a knowledgeable, pressure-free approach. They explain everything clearly so you feel
01:13:51 confident about your decisions and they never push you to buy. Physical gold has stood the
01:13:56 test of time as a store of value and it offers peace of mind that other assets can't match.
01:14:01 it's reassuring to know that even if the banking system falters, your gold and its value remain
01:14:07 safe. Whether you're looking to diversify your investments, protect your savings, or just gain
01:14:11 the security of owning a real physical asset, we highly recommend the Pure Gold Company. Click the
01:14:17 link in the description or go to pure-gold.co slash trigger to get your free copy of the
01:14:22 investor guide. That's pure-gold.co slash trigger. Take control of your financial future today.
01:14:29 Do you think we've recovered from the 08 crash?
01:14:33 Oh, dramatically.
01:14:35 So, you know, Dodd-Frank, which was this legislation that got passed in late 2010,
01:14:46 and probably the most important thing that it did was it created a new position in the Fed
01:14:51 called Vice Chair of Financial Supervision,
01:14:54 which was basically a fancy term for chief bank regulator of the united states so you know when
01:15:00 you think about it the united states never had a chief bank regulator how insane is that
01:15:04 um so that position was occupied by um fed governor daniel tarullo who did an unbelievable job
01:15:13 um you know the banks he basically took the leverage and he cut it in half
01:15:20 and then not only did he do that he made them reduce their risk and so i actually think the
01:15:26 banks in the united states are safe for the first time ever really ever that's so interesting
01:15:32 because that doesn't mean that bad stuff can't happen i'm saying we're not gonna we wouldn't
01:15:38 they are not levered enough they don't have enough risk for there to be any serious problems in the
01:15:43 banks in the banks it seems that 08 was this moment where there was a real fork in the road
01:15:49 between America and between Europe.
01:15:51 I would argue, and you can push back on me all you want,
01:15:55 I don't think we've recovered in Europe.
01:15:58 If you look at wages, wages haven't recovered.
01:16:01 If you look at...
01:16:03 But I don't think that's a financial system issue.
01:16:05 I think that's the way you regulate your economy
01:16:08 and it's just much, much less dynamic.
01:16:11 I mean, to your point, I think just before the financial crisis,
01:16:15 the GDP of the U.S. and the GDP of the EU was more or less roughly the same.
01:16:21 And now I think the U.S. is like 60% bigger.
01:16:25 But that is a testimony just to how dynamic the U.S. is
01:16:28 and how into technology it is, as opposed to Europe.
01:16:32 You think that it's entirely that?
01:16:35 Yes. Take Germany, for example.
01:16:38 I had a great... One of my first podcasts,
01:16:42 I interviewed a guy who wrote a book called Kaput.
01:16:45 the end of the German economic miracle.
01:16:48 And his argument was basically that for a long time,
01:16:54 you know, Germany ran this industrial policy
01:16:56 where the government and the companies
01:16:58 were all in bed to one another,
01:16:59 and they chose certain industries, autos, chemicals,
01:17:04 and Germany did very well for a long period of time.
01:17:07 And then basically what happened was the world passed it by,
01:17:09 and they never built up a technology sector,
01:17:12 and German GDP hasn't grown in the last five years.
01:17:15 five years it's astonishing no growth in gdp in germany for five years well because they have no
01:17:23 tech sector so your point is basically that if you live in an age in which prim so much of the wealth
01:17:30 of the future is being created through this particular type of technology and you create
01:17:34 an environment in your countries where pursuing that kind of innovation doesn't make sense is
01:17:40 or just harder or just harder well you're not competitive then all of it's going to go elsewhere
01:17:45 which is by the way what we see in britain we see very talented people developing cool stuff
01:17:49 but the moment it comes to we've got to go to the next level they leave they leave right
01:17:54 that's not just britain and it speaks to and it's one of the things that i love the most about
01:18:00 america is not is the the dynamism that you have here with the people it's a can-do attitude
01:18:06 whereas when you go to europe or the uk as much as i love the uk when you've got an idea they're
01:18:12 You're like, ah, that's probably not going to work.
01:18:14 Right.
01:18:14 You come here, they're like, yeah, sure, give it a try.
01:18:16 You're like, what?
01:18:17 Are you insane?
01:18:17 What do you mean?
01:18:18 Yeah, and by the way, here's a million dollars to do.
01:18:20 Yeah, yeah.
01:18:21 Right.
01:18:21 Yeah.
01:18:22 And do you need two?
01:18:23 Yeah.
01:18:24 Well, that's the attitude.
01:18:25 Right.
01:18:26 To people in Europe, this sounds funny
01:18:27 because they don't believe this,
01:18:28 but this is genuinely true here.
01:18:30 Right.
01:18:30 Right.
01:18:30 Great idea.
01:18:31 Here's a check.
01:18:32 Right.
01:18:32 Call me when you need more money.
01:18:34 That's what we need more of.
01:18:36 No, I was just going to say, it's, to me, look,
01:18:40 We can talk about regulation and all of those things,
01:18:42 but that all comes down to culture.
01:18:45 It's the culture of the country.
01:18:47 It's the culture of the people that creates a society
01:18:49 that therefore creates the outcomes.
01:18:51 Right. Yeah.
01:18:53 All right, Steve, on that happy note,
01:18:54 we'll ask you questions from our supporters.
01:18:56 But before we do, our final question is always the same.
01:18:59 What's the one thing we're not talking about
01:19:01 that we should be as a culture, as a country,
01:19:03 as a nation, as a world, whatever?
01:19:04 I'm very nervous about the reemergence of Marxism.
01:19:10 in the West. I find it astonishing, actually. I mean, you wouldn't know this about me, but I have
01:19:21 read literally everyone on this topic, from the pros to the cons, and I just find it astonishing
01:19:31 that anyone, take a step back for a second, I believe in statistics. Here's the most important
01:19:41 statistic. A hundred million people died because of Marxism. What else is there to say? I just
01:19:50 don't get it. I do not understand the attraction other than stupidity. Let me try. Now I have to
01:19:58 be one of the most publicly anti-communist people alive yes I knew that right I've written a book
01:20:04 about it I've talked about it there's other things I can't say what they are yet but I'm
01:20:10 doing on that subject whatever I have to say though that you you don't believe that future
01:20:18 is coming but let's just for the sake of argument say that a lot of people do believe that it's
01:20:24 coming what's coming what i'm about to say okay which is that a huge amount of wealth is built
01:20:32 by llms and agentic a lot of work is done by those things the wealth is concentrated in the
01:20:41 hands of a very small number of people at the same time as the people who used to have a job
01:20:49 Now, you might say, and I kind of agree with you,
01:20:52 over time maybe you will have a transition
01:20:55 exactly like the kind you've had in the past
01:20:57 where it's not that jobs disappear as a thing,
01:21:01 but the jobs that currently exist disappear.
01:21:03 They get replaced by other jobs.
01:21:04 Some of those jobs are actually better jobs.
01:21:06 But in the interim, it's going to be pretty rough for a lot of people.
01:21:10 So you have five people becoming gazillionaires
01:21:13 while most of society,
01:21:17 which by the way already young people
01:21:19 is kind of locked out of asset owning
01:21:22 at the basic level.
01:21:23 The first asset most people would own
01:21:25 is their home.
01:21:26 That's become very difficult for young people.
01:21:29 And when I say young,
01:21:30 I mean anyone under 40.
01:21:32 No, I agree.
01:21:32 Right?
01:21:34 Add on top of that
01:21:35 a situation in which AI comes
01:21:38 and takes your job.
01:21:40 Let's say you eventually might have a chance
01:21:42 of getting a different job.
01:21:43 And you watch, I don't know, Mark Zuckerberg or Dario Amadei or Sam Altman building his house out of gold, right?
01:21:54 And driving gold. Well, not driving, but having self-driving cars made out of platinum.
01:22:00 I don't know what they'll spend their gazillions on when they do.
01:22:04 In that situation, I am literally, like I say, the most anti-communist person you'll ever find.
01:22:09 and I completely agree with you.
01:22:11 But in that situation,
01:22:13 if I was one of these gazillionaires,
01:22:14 I'd be thinking,
01:22:15 how do I give my money away
01:22:16 as quickly as possible?
01:22:18 Because otherwise,
01:22:19 I'm going to end up
01:22:20 with my head on a spike.
01:22:21 That's what I'd be thinking.
01:22:23 Do you see where I'm going with this?
01:22:23 I see where you're going.
01:22:25 If I was one of those guys,
01:22:26 I wouldn't be worried.
01:22:27 Because?
01:22:29 It just never happens.
01:22:31 You know,
01:22:31 you know the slogan
01:22:32 that people like to do
01:22:34 when they march,
01:22:36 which is,
01:22:37 the people united
01:22:38 can never be defeated?
01:22:41 That was bullshit.
01:22:42 The people united are defeated all the time.
01:22:45 Right.
01:22:46 Right.
01:22:48 Sure.
01:22:48 But wasn't...
01:22:49 I mean, York, you just said
01:22:50 Marxism killed 100 million people.
01:22:52 It did.
01:22:52 I'm saying it probably will again
01:22:55 unless we really change something here.
01:22:58 That's what I'm saying.
01:22:59 Oh.
01:23:00 So when you say it's never happened,
01:23:02 I actually...
01:23:02 I mean, I'm just worried about the fact
01:23:04 that it's re-emerged.
01:23:05 And I don't know when it's going to stop.
01:23:08 I certainly hope it stops.
01:23:09 Well, I'm hinting to you what I think is happening,
01:23:12 which is the conditions that are emerging
01:23:15 are not that different to the...
01:23:19 Okay, this is way too much of a comparison,
01:23:22 but the conditions are trending in a direction
01:23:25 that is not dissimilar to the conditions
01:23:27 that have caused a Marxist revolution.
01:23:30 See, I disagree with that.
01:23:31 Okay, why?
01:23:33 So I interviewed...
01:23:34 I'll go back to my podcast.
01:23:35 Sure.
01:23:36 We'll plug it for a second.
01:23:38 The Real Eisman Playbook.
01:23:40 I interviewed, it was a wonderful interview,
01:23:41 it was a guy who was an author, John Cassidy.
01:23:44 And he wrote a book called Capitalism and Its Critics.
01:23:50 It's like an 800-page book, and it was like one after another
01:23:54 of all the great critics of capitalism.
01:23:56 And I really enjoyed the book, because it
01:23:57 was like visiting old friends, who I always hated,
01:24:01 but liked to read about.
01:24:03 But at the beginning of his book was a table.
01:24:09 And I said to him, you know, because he was left wing,
01:24:13 which is fine, and I said to him, you know,
01:24:17 your entire book is belied by the table on page four.
01:24:22 And the table was global GDP per capita
01:24:30 from the year zero to the current date,
01:24:35 basically from the time when Jesus was born until today.
01:24:39 And basically, this is what the graph looked like,
01:24:41 until 1830, complete and utter flatline, and then straight up.
01:24:47 So basically, all human wealth is only like 120 years old.
01:24:55 That's because of capitalism.
01:24:58 I agree.
01:24:58 So, now, you want to have an argument about how we can divide up some of the eggs?
01:25:05 I'm all for that debate.
01:25:07 But you don't want to destroy the golden goose.
01:25:09 I completely agree with you.
01:25:11 What I'm saying is the reason I think you're seeing the rise of Marxism is,
01:25:15 it's about lots of things, partly it's what's been happening in the education system.
01:25:18 I mean, your kids being brainwashed by...
01:25:22 Mine were not, thank God.
01:25:24 Right. Well, you've done well, and congratulations to you.
01:25:26 But I have friends whose kids feel like they've lost them.
01:25:30 Right.
01:25:31 And that's because when I said you, I meant your country's kids were brainwashed by people of that ideology.
01:25:37 But also the conditions on the ground.
01:25:40 Elite overproduction is another hypothesis about this, by the way.
01:25:43 Rob Henderson has talked about this, which is when you send everybody to college and then they come out and they don't have jobs that are commensurate with their investment.
01:25:51 It's trouble.
01:25:52 Well, yeah, you get a lot of disgruntled middle class people.
01:25:54 Yes.
01:25:55 That's fair.
01:25:56 Right.
01:25:56 And then on top of that, I can tell you from speaking to lots of people who are not thinking about, you know, where do I invest my money because they have nothing to invest.
01:26:07 The thing that bothers people is not how much wealth in total is the economy.
01:26:12 What bothers them is how that's distributed.
01:26:15 And that feed, that runaway housing unaffordability thing is a big deal.
01:26:22 I, I didn't say the system's perfect.
01:26:25 but I know that that's not the answer right then we agree on that all right
01:26:31 head on over to triggerpod.co.uk where Steve is going to answer your questions
01:26:35 will any individuals at any banks or financial institutions ever be held
01:26:41 personally accountable for what they did in the run-up to the financial crisis
01:26:55 Save big at the Black Friday Super Sale at Shopper's Drug Mart.
01:27:14 Shop November 20th to 27th and enjoy big savings on the products you love.
01:27:19 Plus, for three days only, November 20th to 22nd, open your PC Optimum app and get $20 or $30 in PC Optimum points when you spend $60 or more.
01:27:29 So, head to Shoppers Drug Mart for the Black Friday Super Sale.
01:27:33 Stay big, leave happy.
01:27:35 Conditions apply.
01:27:36 Details in store.