TRIGGERnometry - November 20, 2026


Jensen Huang Resignation & Trump-Xi-Putin Summit Nothingburger - Off the Fence

Democrat Activist: "Anti-Semitism Is a Cancer Spreading in the Democratic Party" – Brianna Wu Big Short Investor: Is the AI Bubble About to Burst? - Steve Eisman

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 8 minutes

Words per minute

169.19

Word count

11,544

Sentence count

320


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Save big at the Black Friday Super Sale at Shopper's Drug Mart.
00:00:04 Shop November 20th to 27th and enjoy big savings on the products you love.
00:00:09 Plus, for three days only, November 20th to 22nd, open your PC Optimum app and get $20
00:00:15 or $30 in PC Optimum points when you spend $60 or more.
00:00:19 So head to Shopper's Drug Mart for the Black Friday Super Sale.
00:00:23 Save big, leave happy.
00:00:25 Conditions apply.
00:00:26 Details in store.
00:00:30 Behind our nation's defense is a powerful network of Canadian communities, supported by Lockheed Martin Canada.
00:00:36 It's a network of over 1,300 employees and over 1,000 local suppliers, from small family businesses to major tech firms.
00:00:44 Together, we've delivered a $3.6 billion boost to the Canadian economy over the past five years.
00:00:50 That's money that goes to securing our skies, our oceans, and the place we call home.
00:00:55 Learn more at LockheedMartin.com slash Canada.
00:01:00 Welcome back to this week's Off the Fence with me, Constance and Kissin, my trigonometry co-host, Francis Foster, Winston Marshall of the Winston Marshall Show, and of course, Tom Slater from Spike.
00:01:11 Gentlemen, we missed last week. It feels like it's been a very long time, but we're back with four absolutely top stories this week.
00:01:18 It is, of course, the resignation and possible return of Jensen Huang, the NVIDIA boss, who stepped down after admitting an affair with a woman U.S. intelligence suspects of spying for China.
00:01:30 We've got the APEC summit and the first ever three-way meeting between Trump, Putin and Xi.
00:01:35 The anti-DEI academic and, of course, former trigonometry guest Nathan Kofnus went to Oxford and was met with some pretty aggressive, you might even say violent, protesting.
00:01:45 also people who couldn't spell anything on placards we will talk about that
00:01:49 and finally uh house prices in britain real house prices that is uh have fallen to where they were
00:01:55 24 years ago and in central london in particular house prices even uh in uh inflation including
00:02:04 inflation are absolutely plummeting as well so we'll talk about why and what that means for you
00:02:09 watching and listening at home welcome back everybody let's crack on with what i cannot
00:02:15 call but anything other than the story the strange and miraculous story of jensen's wine francis take
00:02:21 it away well this is a story that has actually gripped both the front uh the front pages in both
00:02:30 america the uk and all over the world because it is the downfall of arguably the most important
00:02:37 businessman in the world, Jensen Huang, co-owner, co-founder, and boss of NVIDIA, and he has
00:02:46 resigned. And one of the interesting things about Jensen Huang is that he's in many ways the
00:02:51 personification of the American dream. A man born overseas in Taiwan, started, well, legend has it,
00:03:00 the company in a denny's that's what he got his idea and nvidia then went on to become a multi
00:03:07 trillion dollar company now a lot of people will go well why does nvidia matter and i'll go through
00:03:13 it very quickly because it makes the chips that power ai chat gpt claude gemini are all trained
00:03:20 and run on them they own or they have roughly 80 to 90 percent of that market think about it like
00:03:28 this for people like me who don't understand tech if ai is the new gold rush then nvidia is basically
00:03:35 selling the picks and shovels and nobody else comes close they have practically total market
00:03:43 domination at its peak last month it was the most valuable company on earth worth 5.8 trillion
00:03:53 dollars and that is more by the way than meta amazon and amd i don't know what amd by the way
00:03:59 it's an ai company it's massive but all of them combined so this is a very very real national
00:04:05 security issue whoever leads in ai is going to be number one not only economically but militarily
00:04:15 And this is a reason why the US has banned its best chips from going to China and why China wants them so badly.
00:04:27 So this is a major security issue. It's not about one man's Wang getting wet.
00:04:32 Do you see what I did there, guys?
00:04:34 Anyway, this is the timeline of what happened.
00:04:38 On the 29th of October, the New York Times reported that Jensen had a close relation with Alice Wang.
00:04:45 No relation. Remember, he's from Taiwan, not Dorset.
00:04:49 He's a Chinese. She's a Chinese businesswoman who helped run Singapore for mega speed.
00:04:57 Now, U.S. officials suspect she works for Chinese intelligence.
00:05:02 Now, Dino, can we please get the story up from the Wall Street Journal?
00:05:06 we can see here that her husband actually has been linked with running data centers in china
00:05:17 dean have we can we get that story up per favore there we go so alice huang's husband built a data
00:05:24 center empire backed by the chinese state so already there were this story became much much
00:05:34 much murkier. On the 6th of November, the Times reports a classified memo naming her as a spy
00:05:41 for China's Ministry of State Security. Now, it's worth bearing in mind that this has not been
00:05:47 confirmed. These are accusations which are still at this story, which are alleged. On the 8th of
00:05:56 November, Huang emailed staff admitting he was unfaithful to his wife for 40 years without naming
00:06:02 her quote my family bears no responsibilities for my choices i do now at this point the board
00:06:11 investigated him but they also backed him on the 11th of november the times reported a second
00:06:19 affair with kimberly powell an nvidia vice president who reports directly to him of course
00:06:25 she does 12th of november huang resigns hours later reuter reports a third relationship with
00:06:34 another nvidia employee and the and this person has not been named and this is a reason why this
00:06:44 is more than just a sex scandal mega speed who as i said before alice huang worked for bought nearly
00:06:52 $5 billion of NVIDIA hardware in about two years. Megaspeed is under criminal investigation by the
00:07:00 U.S. Justice Department, and it is suspected of funneling banned chips to China via Malaysia.
00:07:09 U.S. officials have reportedly found NVIDIA kits still sealed in boxes at a Malaysia data center.
00:07:18 Now, again, it's worth bearing in mind Megaspeed denies any wrongdoing.
00:07:24 And there's a lot of people going, well, actually, Huang is also slightly contaminated here because he spent years lobbying Washington to sell more chips to China.
00:07:37 In May 2025, he actually said that China is going to win the AI race.
00:07:46 and this month he has had a very public clash with Anthropic boss Dario Amadeo who wants a
00:07:54 total ban on selling advanced chips to China. That is not Jensen's position. He wants to sell
00:08:01 them to China because he believes that the potential good that can come from AI when it
00:08:10 comes to things like cancer, technological improvements, is worth the security risk.
00:08:16 Now, that's a rather simplified way of putting Jensen's position, but that's, I think, pretty
00:08:21 accurate. Now, this is a fallout. When he resigned, shares fell as much as 14%, with about $600
00:08:32 billion wiped off at one point, which is one of the biggest one-day falls in stock market history.
00:08:38 Nvidia stocks are now down 30% from their peak and this is where it's I didn't actually know
00:08:48 this but Nvidia is about 6% of America's main stock index so this doesn't just hit the investors
00:08:56 this hits pensions and savings all of this this affects everything practically everything and
00:09:05 everyone now what has actually happened is he's now trying to come back make a comeback
00:09:15 he released this tweet do you know if we can get it up please
00:09:19 in which he basically says that he's been overwhelmed by love and support he talks
00:09:27 about his journey about creating nvidia and also how he let people down not only nvidia
00:09:34 but he let his family down as well and this is where he also says that actually
00:09:41 if he would be if people want him back as CEO of NVIDIA he would be delighted to return
00:09:49 there's also been a campaign with a petition which has been which has so far got 175,000
00:09:59 signatures. One of them is Elon Musk. So, what's next? He has now been asked to attend.
00:10:10 Sorry? Was that a campaign to bring him back? Yeah, that's a campaign to bring him back.
00:10:18 Yeah, 175,000 signatures so far. NVIDIA have said, however, that they're not interested
00:10:23 at this moment. So what is coming next for Jensen is on the 1st of December, he has to attend
00:10:32 three House committees, Intelligence, Foreign Affairs and China. On the 3rd of December,
00:10:40 the Senate Banking Committee wants to see him too. And although he's admitted the affair,
00:10:49 he has denied everything else the spying the smuggling and the other two relationships
00:10:57 and that is really where we are with this particular story i think this is a story that
00:11:03 is going to run and run and run not only for the economic impact it has but also because of
00:11:11 the spying allegations and one thing to also remember is that the we like i said before
00:11:19 there has been no confirmation that Alice Wang is actually a spy. At this point, these are all
00:11:26 allegations. And we're going to see, like I said, on the 1st of December, him attending the House
00:11:33 committees, one of three, possibly one of four. So I guess the questions that I'm going to put
00:11:42 to the panel are, what do we think this means for America? What do we think this means for
00:11:48 America-Chinese relations? What do we think this means for the stock market long-term and NVIDIA
00:11:54 itself and the AI boom? Is this the start of the AI tech bubble bursting?
00:12:03 Well, can I just start by the one thing I disagree with, and you're very well put out
00:12:09 description of the story, is about whether or not Alice Wang is a spy.
00:12:13 Now, I actually don't think that this being a spy story is the crux of this story, and
00:12:20 I'll get to that, but she is a spy.
00:12:23 And the reason she's a spy is if you are a Chinese citizen, you are bound not just by
00:12:30 the United Front, but by the National Intelligence Act of 2017.
00:12:35 Basically everyone is obliged legally to work with the CCP to gather intelligence and to
00:12:43 work with them. I cover this so much on my show so it's something I struggle to convey
00:12:49 but I need to convey. A spy does not mean James Bond. It doesn't mean Robert Patterson
00:12:54 coming along or Tintin with a newspaper with sort of holes cut out for his eyes. A spy
00:13:01 just means intelligence gathering. If you have a Chinese passport and you wish to see
00:13:07 your grandma and grandpa again, you are a spy. Everyone should be considered a spy in
00:13:12 that scenario. And in that sense, she is a spy. It's not just that this Singapore company
00:13:19 with a Chinese CEO. The company itself was a Chinese company called Seven Word, a gaming
00:13:27 company. It's basically a shell company for that Chinese company. So the idea that she's
00:13:32 not a spy is, to me, absurd. I want to get that out. And if you guys want to challenge
00:13:37 me on that please do um before i go into why i don't think it's a spy story necessarily well the
00:13:43 only thing worth adding is i think you're right to say that not everybody uh when we think of the
00:13:48 word spy i do think we think of a james bond or jason born style situation but uh for the purposes
00:13:55 of what we're talking about all that would really need to happen is she would need to pass on
00:14:00 information or persuade him in the post in the post-coital moment to make certain you know to
00:14:08 think about things in a particular way that might be helpful to china or her company or whatever
00:14:13 on the other hand i do think it's worth saying the reporting that was published on which this
00:14:19 entire situation is based is based on completely anonymous sources and we've got to keep that in
00:14:26 mind for the sole reason that we have been all i think burnt time and time again by a mainstream
00:14:32 media uh campaign against people that was eventually proven to be a lie i do take your
00:14:38 point of course which is if you're a ceo of a major company and you're someone who's subject
00:14:43 to the chinese jurisdiction you're likely to at least be in a position where you can be
00:14:48 forced to give information uh the other thing perhaps before you go and that's also worth
00:14:54 adding is um part of the reason i think he he resigned from nvidia is that his relationship
00:15:00 with the other woman the vp for health uh of of nvidia that was explicitly forbidden by nvidia's
00:15:09 own rules so there's quite a log on it's not just about the spy story it's also about just
00:15:16 general conduct but by all means carry on one other thing to add on the spy section is that
00:15:22 there's much deliberation and speculation about this four-year gap that Alice Wang has got in her
00:15:28 CV and whether she got MSS training in that period and that is in the realm of the
00:15:33 speculative and it's the difference between her privately or coercively working with the CCP
00:15:42 intelligence on some sort of operation and feeding information back or whether she's
00:15:47 When your man's in the toilet, she grabs his phone and puts a chip in, and so they're gathering
00:15:54 even more information on her, so there's levels of being a spy, which that is in the realm
00:15:59 of the speculative.
00:16:00 But it's also, if you think about it from the Chinese point of view, these are very
00:16:05 brilliant people.
00:16:07 They are the antithesis of everything I believe in, but of course they have a strategy when
00:16:12 it comes to these AI chips, this type of GPU.
00:16:17 have to be. It would be massive negligence for them not to, and this is the perfect plot. So,
00:16:25 even if it didn't start as an actual mission, you know, get to Jensen Wang, as soon as they
00:16:31 worked out that she was dating him, they would have been straight on it. Right, you're doing this,
00:16:35 you're doing that, you're working with us. So, I assume the Chinese are extremely intelligent
00:16:41 and they know what they're doing. So, I think it's fair to say she's a spy.
00:16:45 and compromise if nothing else as well is something that's clearly um part of the picture
00:16:51 here because not least is it the chief executive position in her own company which has been
00:16:56 pretty credibly accused of funneling nvidia chips into china via malaysia and other countries as
00:17:02 francis was explaining there also the fact that her husband is also part and part of this state
00:17:07 backed to certainly since state funded push within china to build up their ai infrastructure and to
00:17:13 kind of catch up with the americans one detail which we have skated over is that her husband
00:17:17 is called kang so this is huang putting his wang in huang with the potential knowledge of kang
00:17:23 which is the whole cascade of this story really it summed up but this is something which clearly
00:17:28 had like national security implications even if it's beyond the question of was she trained is
00:17:32 she an agent is she a spy um because of the fact that there's been so many cases now in america
00:17:37 you've had um california tech execs being arrested on suspicion of selling hundreds of millions of
00:17:44 dollars worth of chips to china you've had people like the kind of driver of the late senator diane
00:17:49 feinstein who was basically found to have been a potential china asset and also the fact that
00:17:56 the nature of the ai boom is that it's so concentrated in this handful of companies that
00:18:03 you have if not a kind of single point of failure then just a handful of points of failure points
00:18:08 of entry points in which people can be compromised if you think joel copkin wrote a piece about this
00:18:13 for spikes for us last week and he made the point that given the fact that the ai boom has been
00:18:18 responsible for kind of a third of that accelerated gdp growth that the us has seen um recently all
00:18:24 it would take is a few of these jenga blocks to be removed or compromised or what have you for it to
00:18:29 to have this huge impact not just on u.s economy but obviously the global economy as well of course
00:18:34 china are going to take an interest in all of that and there is also questions to ask about the u.s
00:18:39 as to how alive they were to this particular threat there was a report in cbs which was pointing
00:18:45 out that the authorities in singapore where this company was based huang's company was based where
00:18:50 um they had back in 2025 i believe um interviewed her uh seized her passport were looking for the
00:18:57 cooperation of the american authorities and that wasn't forthcoming so there's clearly questions
00:19:02 to answer there about security and particularly because of how essential ai has become to not
00:19:08 just the u.s economy but the global economy you would think that there would be much greater
00:19:12 strenuous interest in keeping that kind of meddling out well very much on that point tom i think that
00:19:17 the context that we should uh add here is you talked about there's maybe not one point of failure
00:19:22 maybe there's several actually when it comes to the chip there literally is one point of failure
00:19:26 and that is video and the thing worth explaining for uh for uh our listeners and viewers is if you
00:19:34 think about ai i think ai is fair to say will be likely to be a more significant development in
00:19:40 human history than even the manhattan project which produced the first nuclear weapons and in
00:19:46 fact produced the technology itself uh ai is likely to have a much more significant impact
00:19:52 and the chips are effectively the enriched uranium and plutonium in this example and
00:19:59 as francis laid out up to 90 percent of that material is being produced by this one company
00:20:06 so jensen huang as the ceo of that company was in a position where him having any sort of
00:20:14 relationship with anyone that potentially exposes him to blackmail to bribe or even to
00:20:20 frankly just influence you know the fact that you have a girl from a particular a girlfriend
00:20:25 from a particular country that you might not want to have that revealed if you're married and all
00:20:30 the rest of it means that you have effectively somebody who's responsible for the production
00:20:36 and distribution of 90 percent of the world's effectively enriched uranium uh being put by his
00:20:43 own actions into that position which is why it's a bigger story you know initially when you hear
00:20:48 this story you're like well okay look i don't personally approve of marital infidelity you know
00:20:54 etc etc but ultimately this guy built this company from scratch through years and years of hard work
00:21:01 is now created this gigantic company that's benefiting millions of people around the world
00:21:06 billions of people around the world with the technology that's being created does it really
00:21:11 matter well it matters because as you pointed out this is a national security issue and it's
00:21:18 it of the highest level of the highest level this is worse than nuclear material being uh
00:21:25 siphoned off or nuclear secrets being shared because of the potential impact on the scale
00:21:31 of what we're talking about here so it is a massive story and what it highlights is
00:21:36 the way that private companies that are doing this are now effectively holding the future of
00:21:41 of humanity in their hands and one man's extramarital affair can now put the entire
00:21:48 global order in jeopardy and i think one of the uh a point to actually talk about here is
00:21:55 where does nvidia go from here because jensen wang is the man who co-founded it he is widely
00:22:02 acknowledged to be the brains behind nvidia the singular talent the driving force the fact that
00:22:09 he is no longer at the helm of this company have they lost their edge we all know that look you
00:22:16 know people are important when it comes to companies they are the most important thing
00:22:21 at a company but sometimes you have one talent whether it's in a sporting team whether it's in
00:22:29 a business organization that is so singular and special they can transform an industry and from
00:22:37 everything that I've been reading about Jensen he might be that person does this now mean that
00:22:43 Nvidia from being a company that has up to 90% of its share now that they've lost the main man
00:22:50 it's sort of like the Rolling Stones losing Mick Jagger are they going to be the same and does
00:22:57 that mean other companies are now going to have the edge in the market now that they've lost
00:23:02 their leader and possibly as well their creative fulcrum.
00:23:08 Well this is I think why so many people are calling for Jensen to be brought back in but
00:23:12 just to tie your point Francis with Constantine's point is that actually he needs to there needs to
00:23:19 be due process and it needs to be and we'll see this now in the various hearings he's going to
00:23:23 go through did he break the National Defence Authorisation Act if he will if he knew if he
00:23:30 had willing knowledge that those chips, which were forbidden to get to China, were getting
00:23:38 to China through this company, through Megaspeed, then he would be guilty of that. And so that's
00:23:46 what we need to wait and see. And I think rushing to bring him back in without seeing
00:23:52 whether that was the case feels to me to be foolish. I think we need to know the answer
00:23:59 to that question and there are the other thing sorry go ahead no i said there are i was just
00:24:06 gonna say so i'm sorry sorry just one point very quickly because this is a very short one
00:24:11 we interviewed uh steve eisman on uh trigonometry and that interview hasn't come out yet
00:24:17 and we conducted that interview before this scandal broke in uh a few weeks ago now and he
00:24:25 actually said nvidia was always fragile anyway because they only have five customers now of
00:24:33 course those customers are very high paying and they make a lot of money out of them but if your
00:24:38 business is dependent on five customers then it's not diversified so this was always fragile to
00:24:46 begin with anyway i just thought i'd make that point and just to tackle on to that because i
00:24:51 think that going back to this point about nvidia being the kind of one point of failure where
00:24:55 the chips are concerned it also means that it wouldn't even take china to influence compromising
00:25:01 what have you even just to discredit him kind of take him out of the game as it were and the impact
00:25:05 that was going to have not just nvidia's share price but also on the broader american economy
00:25:11 would have been worth it in effect so there's all of these huge risks and um potential pitfalls
00:25:18 which are created when you have this enormous concentration not just of wealth but as um
00:25:22 constantin was talking about this incredibly transformative and therefore quite dangerous
00:25:27 technology certainly in geopolitical terms um and especially because of how um central it is just
00:25:33 to the us economy um and the fact that obviously the ai bubble the ai boom depending on how you
00:25:39 want to um portray it is so based not on um its customers and what have you but the investment
00:25:46 and the stock and so on uh even just a kind of temporary blip a sort of loss of faith in some of
00:25:51 these companies is going to have a really outsized and significant impact um the one thing we'll say
00:25:57 maybe as a side point is it was uh maybe somewhat heartening to find out that at least one of these
00:26:02 tech oligarchs uh was a bit of a shagger i mean there is something at least slightly humanizing
00:26:07 about this story in given the kind of parade they're all shaggers but not in a non-creepy
00:26:15 fashion they're all these other people well no sam altman is is gay married with kids i believe
00:26:21 uh daryl amaday i'm not so sure about the google guys i'm not sure elon's obviously a top level
00:26:27 shagger um yeah i i think you do them a disservice tom not that i necessarily approve of these
00:26:32 particular lifestyles um but yeah so tom the one thing your defense of jensen wang is that at least
00:26:40 he's a shagger no my point was that there was something oddly humanizing about just a classic
00:26:46 infidelity scandal whereas normally the sorts of strange things these people get up to is uh you
00:26:51 know he's reached it's all typical it's all there he's got to a certain age he's bought a leather
00:26:56 jacket he's had a bit of a glow up and his eyes have wandered elsewhere that's not to condone the
00:26:59 behavior nor to dismiss any of the broader national security or geopolitical implications
00:27:04 Tom, you're thinking, Jensen Wang's just like me.
00:27:07 He's having extramarital affairs.
00:27:09 I can relate to this dude.
00:27:10 That's your response.
00:27:12 You just think, real bit of me.
00:27:13 I didn't say related.
00:27:18 Tom, is that the reason you bought that leather jacket, mate?
00:27:21 I told you that in confidence.
00:27:26 Anyway, we best start moving on, guys.
00:27:28 But one thing I will say is, I will give my prediction,
00:27:32 is i don't think this will have a major impact on nvidia in the long run just because they're they're
00:27:39 such a huge monopoly and the fundamentals of their business model are so strong it's very very
00:27:46 difficult to see that even losing such an inspiring ceo as jensen huang will affect them unless of
00:27:53 course and this is something that's been talked about if he is not reinstated i think he will have
00:27:58 no shortage of the ability to raise lots of money to start a rival business of his own and whether
00:28:04 that then becomes the next story is hard to see but nvidia in and of itself i would argue is in
00:28:09 a very strong position and unlikely to start immediately losing ground just given how dominant
00:28:15 they are because it's not like the rolling stones losing mick jagger it's like there was only one
00:28:20 banned in town and they lost Mick Jagger. It's a little bit different.
00:28:26 Can I add one possible thing to keep an eye on on this story, which is that I think it could
00:28:33 end up being a big corruption story with the commerce secretary, Howard Lutnick, being not
00:28:40 just China Dove, I think, but a very good friend of Jensen Wang. And whether he allowed this to
00:28:48 happen, whether he was knowing it was going on. There's an aspect that NVIDIA cooked the books,
00:28:56 or was it Megaspeed cooked the books on their one of the two? I think NVIDIA cooked the books on
00:29:01 their sales from Q4 and in 2025 onwards, so we don't know exactly how much they're selling where.
00:29:08 So it might be the case that they were hiding something, that's to be seen. But Lutnik has
00:29:15 a huge stake in Nvidia, not directly, he used to be chairman of Cantor Fitzgerald, it's an investment
00:29:22 firm, but his shares went to his kids and they still had a stake in Nvidia. So there's something
00:29:29 going on there, which I have a hunch this might end up being a corruption story rather than a spy
00:29:36 story. Yeah, and if Nvidia's libel and defamation lawyers are listening, I'd just like to add the
00:29:42 the word allegedly before everything that Winston said. Anyway, because of my concerns about rising
00:29:51 inflation and the coming economic crisis, I've been investing heavily in gold. For me, one of
00:29:57 the best ways to safeguard your wealth is by investing in gold. Diversify your investments,
00:30:02 protect your savings, or just gain the security of owning a real physical asset. We highly
00:30:08 recommend the Pure Gold Company. That is the broker I use to buy my gold. If you're in the UK
00:30:14 and want to protect your savings with physical gold, scan the QR code on the screen right now,
00:30:20 click the link in the description, or go to pure-gold.co.otf to get your free copy of their
00:30:27 Guide to Buying Gold. And remember, the price of gold can go down as well as up. Gold is not
00:30:33 registered by the FCA and past performance is not a guide for future performance. The site again is
00:30:38 pure-gold.co slash o t f moving swiftly on uh winston you are in japan right now and not that
00:30:48 far from me i mean geographically it's quite far yeah don't don't do that on camera
00:30:53 you know what i'd love you to see you do that on question time imagine you on question time
00:31:00 Theona Bruce is like, Winston, you've just come back from Japan.
00:31:03 It's pretty funny here. I got stuck in a bow spiral. I didn't realize the Japanese
00:31:12 absolutely love to bow. So when you say thank you and you say, I'm saying it wrong, but
00:31:20 they have to bow when you say thank you. And when someone bows to you, I then say, oh,
00:31:24 thank you for the bow. So, and then what happened is I, and then he bowed for the second thank
00:31:29 you. And we just ended up bowing and thanking each other. And then I realised he was bowing
00:31:33 every time I said thank you, so I kept saying thank you because I thought it was funny.
00:31:36 Anyway, the reason why that's relevant is because, as you said, we've got APEC.
00:31:41 Yeah, how I segway from that to APEC, I have no idea, mate, but you crack on.
00:31:46 I'll tell you what, so everyone in Japan is, I've seen the news back home, everyone's
00:31:52 talking about Putin, Xi, and Trump doing this trilateral meeting together. And there's a question,
00:32:01 is this the new Yalta? Is this the three great powers of the future coming together? Or is this
00:32:06 a nothing bugger, which I think we should discuss? But whilst we're in Japan, it's the case that
00:32:11 the Japanese Prime Minister went down to China for the APEC, and she's been massively snubbed.
00:32:20 And there's basically been a lot of drama and snubbing between all these parties, and
00:32:25 it's been very dramatic.
00:32:26 So I'm going to bring up my assets.
00:32:30 Dino, may I have the assets, please?
00:32:36 So this is Xi Jinping welcoming Trump.
00:32:39 Look at the hoo-ha he is putting on here.
00:32:42 They absolutely love it.
00:32:43 This is, they're making a big effort and I think that that's worth keeping in mind,
00:32:51 particularly with our previous conversation about NVIDIA, given the implicit adversarial
00:32:59 nature of the American-China relationship that we're speaking about.
00:33:03 This is how they're greeting each other, so this is Trump arriving, and what's our
00:33:10 next asset?
00:33:12 There's Trump. Oh, yeah. Okay, so this is Prime Minister Sanei Takeichi. Now, she was
00:33:27 completely snubbed. No hoo-ha, but what's really interesting is that the staircase there
00:33:35 was not the right height, so they embarrassed her by she has to do this awkward step to
00:33:41 to come off the plane.
00:33:44 Now, the Japanese and the Chinese
00:33:46 are really not getting on.
00:33:47 In 2025, Takaichi said that they would defend Taiwan,
00:33:54 the Japanese, and that escalated badly.
00:33:58 You've got to keep in mind that the Japanese territory,
00:34:02 the Riku Island, stretched all the way down to,
00:34:06 very close to Taiwan.
00:34:08 So it's a national security threat for the Japanese,
00:34:10 The idea that China would try and take Taiwan, not just the oceans, but very likely because
00:34:16 of the American bases on Japanese soil, if they had to do it, it's very likely that there
00:34:21 would be escalation and fighting on Japanese territory.
00:34:24 So it's front of mind for everyone here in Japan.
00:34:27 They're very anxious about it.
00:34:29 Everyone I speak to is just China, China, China.
00:34:31 They're completely worried about it.
00:34:33 They're worried that America won't help them in the event that there is a play on Taiwan.
00:34:40 And as you can see, they're not just snubs, so whereas Xi went to greet Trump, they sent
00:34:47 a complete non-entity to pick up Takeuchi.
00:34:51 And Xi, we don't know the woman that she's there to pick her up.
00:34:58 So that's one of the snubs.
00:35:00 Then you have another snub, which is Xi snubbing Putin, and…
00:35:06 Who is he?
00:35:08 Well, this is Trump greeting Putin.
00:35:17 So this is also triggering all the people.
00:35:18 Actually, I'm going to stop here and ask you guys about this.
00:35:21 So Trump greeting Putin and saying, here's my friend.
00:35:26 Do you think that Trump really thinks Putin is his friend?
00:35:30 No.
00:35:31 Look, Trump...
00:35:33 No.
00:35:34 no look trump is very very like and francis and i are aware of this particularly spending as much
00:35:41 time as we do in the united states more broadly american business culture is incredibly transactional
00:35:47 so everybody's your friend and everybody's is great and wonderful and this is what people will
00:35:52 say to your face how they then act behind your your back is totally different and what trump
00:35:57 is doing is he recognizes that in order to do deals with people it's better if you're polite
00:36:03 to them and respectful to them and if you're nice to them then if you talk about them all the time
00:36:08 we saw with british politicians who while having very little power to influence events would
00:36:14 nonetheless be very critical of others around the world and this achieves nothing and it makes you
00:36:20 weaker in terms of your ability to get things out of them that you want for your citizens so
00:36:25 i don't think trump thinks that putin is his friend and i think this is a talking point that
00:36:29 a lot of mainstream media love because they're still stuck in this idea that you know trump
00:36:35 russia gay trump was elected by putin and all this other stuff trump is a business guy who's
00:36:40 trying to do deals he's trying he's got a lot of things to try and resolve and actually one thing
00:36:46 that got uh somewhat concealed by the apex summit that we're talking about is at the very same time
00:36:52 jared kushner and steve whitkoff were in europe talking to european leaders about finding ways
00:36:59 to bring the ukraine war to a close and there's actually for the first time in a very long time
00:37:05 some rays of hope that that war may be brought to an end but you know one of the things that trump
00:37:09 clearly wants is a way to bring the iran war to an end one of the things they talked about in
00:37:14 the trilateral uh conversation with putin and xi is producing more uh refined petroleum products so
00:37:21 this is obviously a way to mitigate the problems caused by the iran war and that's ultimately where
00:37:29 where trump is clearly coming in all of this and he will say whatever he needs to say to get what
00:37:34 he wants without meaning any of it do you guys agree i also yeah of course look i think the way
00:37:44 that we talk about politics particularly when it comes to the way that politicians of the size or
00:37:52 and i should i should i say caliber of donald trump and people could say that oh he's overly
00:37:59 friendly to so and so and whatever i just think it's just so basic it's basically primary school
00:38:09 level analysis of geopolitics has to be friendly with him i mean what do people expect him to do
00:38:20 just walk up to him and just snub him or give him a wedgie it's so ridiculous
00:38:25 and the fact that we celebrate politics i would pay to see that
00:38:30 country people like i actually think a lot of people would to be fair but uh but the fact that
00:38:38 you know that we that you know that there's certain parts of our political class who applaud
00:38:44 the likes of david lammy because he criticizes trump openly and then has to do almost a sniveling
00:38:54 apology when he gets re-elected look if you want things to happen on the global stage just like in
00:39:03 any other form of business you need to have good relationships with the people around you
00:39:08 even if on a personal level you might not like them that's just basic human relations
00:39:15 and the fact that people are talking about this to me it's it's just completely ridiculous
00:39:22 it's one of those things where the nature of these summits is that so much of it is about
00:39:25 the symbolism there was a lot of that excited talk going into this as you were saying winston
00:39:29 it's going to be yalta 2.0 um it was much closer to a giant photo opportunity and i think when it
00:39:35 comes to the symbolism and the the mood music far more significant was the sort of sly digs i would
00:39:41 say between xi and putin rather than trump referring to putin as his friend i mean that's
00:39:47 one thing that was really notable you pointed to the fact that xi jinping um greets donald trump
00:39:51 when he comes off of the plane whereas it was some sort of chief of staff who was sent to welcome
00:39:57 putin when it came to the big dinner that they had trump was at his right hand meanwhile putin was
00:40:03 relegated to another part of the table oh matthews and spectators on a really good piece um pointing
00:40:07 to all of this and even things like this um you know in this meeting in which they just deliver
00:40:12 their pre-prepared statements um china somewhat improbably posing as the great symbol of peace
00:40:20 and talking specifically about the need to basically get um bring an end to nuclear weapons
00:40:27 despite the fact it's building up its own nuclear arsenal desperately trying to catch up with not
00:40:31 just america but also russia that again seems to be a sort of as many people have interpreted a kind
00:40:36 of coded jibe at russia and a constant kind of reminder that we may have agreed to this trilateral
00:40:41 all summit but at the same time we don't see you as an equal which is something that obviously if
00:40:46 we are talking about the realms of symbolism and what vladimir putin is trying to get out of this
00:40:49 it's something that's desperate to sort of bask in the idea that he's one of these three superpowers
00:40:54 who can command equal respect i thought it was quite telling that in those kind of small ways
00:40:59 and large ways china was quite keen to put its kind of junior partner if you like back in its
00:41:04 box to a certain extent yeah and this is why i think i come back to what winston said which is
00:41:10 the idea that ultimately, especially this trilateral meeting, was a bit of a nothing
00:41:15 burger. And, Dean, we have this declaration. I read about this great declaration that they
00:41:20 came out of this meeting with. If you're looking at the screen now, that's the entire declaration.
00:41:26 That's it. Four paragraphs. One which says that they're looking forward to reforming
00:41:31 the UN Security Council and the United Nations so it works better. They're planning to increase
00:41:37 production of refined petroleum products uh they recognized that the international criminal core is
00:41:44 uh you know going too far and uh they basically agreed the nuclear weapons are bad that's it
00:41:50 like that's that's the entirety of this great declaration so it's not as if anything massive
00:41:57 appears to have been achieved in all of this and maybe that's not what these meetings are for
00:42:01 exactly um and just before winston you you take back over the conversation i just wanted to
00:42:07 emphasize how much i agree with what you said tom because russia people don't understand this but
00:42:13 russia really is a country that does not belong very much in this conversation in one sense russia
00:42:19 is not a major global economy it has a smaller economy than italy or maybe it did until one
00:42:25 point but now it's slightly overtaken it's not it's not one of the top three economies in the
00:42:30 world. What it does have is a hell of a lot of nuclear weapons, most of them built in 60s, 70s
00:42:36 and 80s. So a lot of them very outdated, but it does have huge stockpiles and therefore it has to
00:42:42 be taken somewhat seriously. But there is no question that neither America nor China see
00:42:47 Russia remotely as an equal. And so in some ways for Putin to even be around that table was a big
00:42:53 achievement. Yes, I agree with that. And I do think it's a bit of a nothing burger. I kind of
00:43:02 agree with the consensus here. I also agree with the idea of Trump greeting Putin like that.
00:43:09 For me, actually, that's because I don't think Trump has much leverage over Putin. And when I'm
00:43:13 watching, and so I'm thinking about the Ukraine war, when I'm watching this also, I'm thinking
00:43:17 about the Iran war, and it is the case that China is actually in a position to really
00:43:24 accelerate to the end of the war because they're the ones buying all of the oil off Iran.
00:43:29 So actually, in a way, Trump, you could, maybe he's trying, he's kind of there because he's
00:43:36 trying, he realized it's important if he can persuade, he's tried many times to persuade
00:43:41 the Chinese in this domain, but they won't do anything, partly because it's in the interest
00:43:45 of the Chinese, I think, to keep the Ayatollahs in power. I mean, as adversaries of, you know,
00:43:52 the Ayatollahs aren't saying that China is big Satan. They're saying America is big Satan. So,
00:43:57 it's just trouble for America. So, I can see that. And it would hurt China to actually stop buying
00:44:05 the 90% of Iran's oil. So, I can see why Xi wouldn't, you know, it's not really in his
00:44:13 interest, not least because it would also hurt oil prices within China. So that being said,
00:44:19 that's what I sort of see going on. And maybe Trump is doing behind the scenes something.
00:44:25 He's trying to push the needle and nudge things forward on those issues. But we can only speculate.
00:44:32 All right. Well, moving on to our third story. Tom, take it away. Nathan Kovnas was invited to
00:44:40 give a lecture or a speech at Oxford about how DEI is bad for universities and as always he was met
00:44:47 by welcoming acceptance of his right to speak freely. Yeah should we have a little look at that
00:44:53 welcoming acceptance and reception that he got at Oxford University. I believe we've got a clip here
00:44:58 of the kind of scenes that greeted him. Wow. This is everything you need to know really. As you were
00:45:05 saying there, Konstantin, Nathan Kofnas was invited by the university's Reform UK Society
00:45:11 to give this speech at Oriel College on the subject of DEI in universities as a consequence
00:45:17 of the role that Kofnas played in exposing Jason Arde. He was the first to go public,
00:45:22 although they'd long been circulating in private, with the quite clear-cut examples of fabulism,
00:45:27 academic fraud, plagiarism. And since Arde's tragic death, found dead at his own home back
00:45:34 in august has essentially been reflexively to my mind despicably blamed for his downfall along with
00:45:40 a lot of other journalists who kind of rode in behind after those initial facts were put out
00:45:44 there um so it's a combination of that but also of course the fact that to put it lightly um
00:45:49 kofnass's reputation is pretty radioactive given the fact that as he um explained on your show is
00:45:54 a self-described race realist um someone who refers to himself as a hereditarian believes that
00:45:59 there are genetically derived differences in IQ between racial groups and so on and so forth and
00:46:05 believes that needs to be accepted and for society to be kind of governed and shaped with that in
00:46:09 mind so as a result of that you saw this concerted effort first of all to try to get the event pulled
00:46:14 full stop which didn't happen which in the midst of all of this is a bit of a win for freedom of
00:46:19 speech to a certain extent it's kind of inconceivable to me that if this had happened even
00:46:23 five years ago the Oriel College wouldn't have found some reason some you know phony health and
00:46:29 safety or security concern in order to pull the event they did hold firm and one of the reasons
00:46:35 for that excuse me is um this new legislation which has been in place since 2023 the higher
00:46:40 education freedom of speech act which has put new pressure on universities and in this case this
00:46:45 Oxford College to ensure that freedom of speech is upheld uh the issue is and we see it in those
00:46:50 protest is that the culture on university campuses where free speech cancellation is concerned is
00:46:56 still as bad as it ever was i think um the way this form the the form this took on the night was
00:47:02 the fact that they couldn't get the talk shut down they couldn't get to kofnas himself so they
00:47:06 basically just blockaded um all of the entryways and stopped people who had tickets from getting
00:47:12 there i understand that people ended up having to arrive more than an hour early in order to
00:47:17 potentially get in and even then it was only about a third full by the time that um the actual planned
00:47:23 event rolled around so when it um this is both a kind of a good free speech story as far as it
00:47:30 actually was physically allowed to take place but again shows how that culture of intolerance is so
00:47:34 pronounced the university campuses and does even though this isn't a new point i think point to
00:47:38 how that kind of mix of like menace and also infantile patheticness if that's even the right
00:47:46 phrase that the campus left now demonstrate um i don't think even if they got into that room they
00:47:52 would be able to take kofnas to task they've so kind of like intellectually disarmed themselves
00:47:56 they even in the face of someone who seems to stand against everything that they stand for
00:48:00 all they can do is really screech from the sidelines and stop people from getting in but um
00:48:06 it's um particularly given the fact that i think kofnas is re newfound um influence shall we say
00:48:14 is a good example of that is that they really don't seem to understand that it's precisely
00:48:17 these tactics which have elevated individuals like nathan kofnass as well i mean his entire career
00:48:22 as i know that he's spoken to you about spoke to many other people about has kind of been forged
00:48:27 in cancellation it was back in 2024 he had a position at the university of cambridge where he
00:48:32 was um essentially hounded out because of a blog post that he put a sub stack post that he put up
00:48:38 about um his call for a hereditarian revolution as he put it um in the wake of the jason arday
00:48:44 scandal not only does it become a kind of full-blown folk devil um in relation to that
00:48:49 particular story but also um was temporarily kind of stood down from his position at ghent university
00:48:54 he was only able to stay in that particular post because of the intervention of the us ambassador
00:49:00 to belgium and now has this newfound platform so you know if these are the tactics it's really not
00:49:05 working and i think also given the fact that now you have sections of the rights particularly the
00:49:10 young right who are starting to look at new uh ideas like race realism which were one really
00:49:15 kind of confined to the fringes shows that if um people really do take issue if not with what
00:49:21 nathan kofnass is saying the worst thing they could possibly do is behave in this fashion
00:49:24 and yet they continue to do it over and over again so it's a it's a bit of a throwback story
00:49:29 in a sense it's kind of reminiscent of the campus wars that we might have had 10 or so years ago but
00:49:33 I think it also shows that there's a radicalization which is going on, even as the legal framework for free speech is getting a bit better.
00:49:40 Tom, and you used the phrase campus left a couple of times.
00:49:43 Are we certain that this was students protesting?
00:49:47 Because from the images I saw, it looked fairly organized, the same placards.
00:49:53 I mean, there were some very badly spelled placards, which made me suspect it's probably not Oxford University students.
00:50:00 Although God knows these days, right?
00:50:01 um yeah there we go perfect from what i can tell it's about i about 50 50 so there were
00:50:09 kind of organic student protests and but there was also stand up to racism which is this right
00:50:15 very long-standing left-wing anti-racist quote-unquote group who also called their own
00:50:21 demonstration had their own rally and it seems to be a sort of mix of the two but i i do think
00:50:26 it's fair to say that you know an event like this was always going to generate some kind of response
00:50:31 from the more organised sections of student politics,
00:50:34 even absent the involvement of kind of outside agitators.
00:50:38 But it did seem that there were quite a few people involved,
00:50:40 particularly in the blockades and the more kind of physical aspect to it,
00:50:43 who might be stretching credibility to assume that they were students.
00:50:47 Connie Shaw from the Free Speech Union was there
00:50:49 and she almost had her way blocked to getting into the event
00:50:52 by a man in a balaclava who, from our own estimation,
00:50:55 seemed to be at least in his 30s.
00:50:56 So as ever, a kind of mix of the students just kind of rising up
00:51:01 out of their own reflexive, impulsive intolerance,
00:51:04 but also the kind of organised Antifa-ish sections of the anti-racist left
00:51:09 who were definitely there in force as well.
00:51:13 The part of this story that pissed me off maybe more than anything
00:51:17 was the BBC coverage of it where they just say,
00:51:21 oh, there are protests outside this race realist speech at Oxford.
00:51:26 not mentioning the violence, not mentioning the hounding, not mentioning that they're
00:51:31 not letting people in. And this is not a one-off, of course. We missed this, and we would have
00:51:35 talked this last week if we'd had an episode last week, but there was a horrendous terrorist
00:51:40 attack in Krakow two weeks ago, and the BBC reported it as a far-right terrorist. Now,
00:51:47 the alleged killer, all the evidence that's emerged is that it's a far-left guy. He's
00:51:52 with sort of various classic left-wing paraphernalia
00:51:57 on his social media.
00:51:58 They haven't changed it.
00:51:59 That's still up, by the way.
00:52:00 BBC Verify haven't kicked in
00:52:02 to put down the disinformation
00:52:07 they themselves are spreading.
00:52:09 And in fact, six weeks ago,
00:52:12 the BBC put out a piece,
00:52:15 which they've now taken down,
00:52:16 describing me as a wannabe commentator.
00:52:20 And I mean, little they know, I have a bit part role now on trigonometry, but so a wannabe,
00:52:27 I think, not anymore, but they also call me a right-wing agitator. And like, it's fine,
00:52:33 and like, who cares? But at the same time, these guys pretend they're impartial. They pretend that
00:52:40 they like to think that they're this institution that is truly fair. Now, I'm not actually saying
00:52:46 that they should be completely impartial. They weren't impartial in the Second World War. They
00:52:50 They weren't giving the Nazis a fair hearing.
00:52:53 What annoys me is that they pretend to be impartial,
00:52:55 but then they completely misrepresent what's going on.
00:52:58 And so if you are not on X,
00:52:59 if you are not following on social media,
00:53:02 if you're not getting different news sources
00:53:04 and you're just following the mainstream media,
00:53:05 like the BBC, you just get this impression
00:53:08 that the far right are on the march
00:53:10 and they're speaking at Oxford.
00:53:13 When you can actually, it's the far left
00:53:14 who are literally on the march.
00:53:16 I mean, they're literally hounding, mobbing
00:53:18 and violently attacking and harassing people.
00:53:21 And in the case of Poland, killing people.
00:53:24 And the BBC are just telling a completely different story.
00:53:27 Of all the things, I think that's the thing
00:53:29 that winds me up the most.
00:53:32 I think one of the things to bear in mind-
00:53:34 Francis, I'm so sorry.
00:53:35 I just, I was a little bit struck, Winston.
00:53:38 I just went on Venice AI and I looked at the story
00:53:40 of the Krakow terrorist.
00:53:42 And I said, was the Krakow terrorist left wing?
00:53:45 Venice says, no, the evidence points the other way.
00:53:48 The Krakow gunman is generally assessed as a far-right,
00:53:51 ultra-nationalist type, so there's been a political fight over it.
00:53:55 Poland's justice minister said investigators found very strong traces
00:53:59 of right-wing extremism, including his search history,
00:54:02 including Anders Przewik, who's, of course, the famous far-right.
00:54:05 Terrorist officials described him as fascinated by far-right ideologies
00:54:10 and ultra-nationalistic.
00:54:12 So that perhaps is one we can give the BBC a pass on.
00:54:15 But your broader point, I think, is actually...
00:54:17 I'm happy to take the loss on that if I'm wrong. I'm happy to say that that was wrong.
00:54:22 I think my point would still stand. I will say, though, that the evidence I've seen on that is
00:54:26 that he was on far-left marches, he was pro-communist stuff on social media, and he
00:54:32 was doing stuff in line with that. Now, if I'm wrong, I'm very happy to say I got that wrong,
00:54:39 and the BBC are right on that situation. But I think my point still stands, certainly with
00:54:44 the Kofnus thing which is that oh yeah they are not reporting this as as um uh uh what really
00:54:52 happened which is which is their duty agree I I think one of the things is actually so we
00:55:01 interviewed Nathan and you know his ideas are controversial but I think what people forget
00:55:06 about Nathan is in many ways he's an equal opportunities offender this is a man who did
00:55:11 a study into political, you know, people who identify as left wing or right wing and IQ
00:55:20 and found that people on the right tend to have lower IQs than people on the left, which
00:55:26 actually really pissed off the people on the right.
00:55:29 And also, I have a personal bone to pick with Nathan because I matched with a girl on Hinge
00:55:35 and it was going very well.
00:55:37 And then she asked me what I do.
00:55:38 I told her about trigonometry because one should be honest.
00:55:41 She looked into it, found Nathan Kosmanus, called me a white supremacist because we've interviewed him and blocked me.
00:55:49 So maybe I don't. Basically, what I'm saying is I'd probably attend those protests after that.
00:55:54 Nathan has ruined your dating experience. Well, I'm sorry to hear that.
00:56:00 Anybody wants to have one final word on this before we move on to our final story?
00:56:04 i mean what one thing i think would be worth just bearing in mind it does seem that on the
00:56:10 left on the whether we want to call it the campus left as a kind of broader woke left
00:56:14 first of all it hasn't gone away that's a theme that we're all returning to so week after week
00:56:18 it might have been pushed back it might be knocked out of certain institutions it might be a bit
00:56:22 harder for them to cancel someone on a university campus or elsewhere but they're still very much
00:56:25 there but also whilst it's not as if it descended into kind of widespread violence the other night
00:56:30 The kind of intensity of these protests is something to keep an eye on, I think, because it does.
00:56:35 Well, we're nowhere near the kind of levels of radicalization and sort of political violence that you're seeing on the left in America at the moment.
00:56:42 I think we'd be lying if we didn't see at least indications of that level of menace in a lot of what's been going on recently.
00:56:49 So something to watch out for, I suppose.
00:56:54 Perfect. Well, final story for this week.
00:56:57 i thought we could have talked about the release of grand theft auto which uh you know all smirking
00:57:02 aside i actually think is a massive story because this is one of the few truly massive global
00:57:09 products that britain has produced in recent memory uh i haven't had a chance to play i'll
00:57:14 probably wait until it comes out on the pc by which point the culture war debate around it will
00:57:19 be old and stale uh but nonetheless uh that was an interesting story but i actually think
00:57:24 there's a genuinely important story that has been going largely uncovered uh in these sorts of shows
00:57:31 that that we do and elsewhere which is about what's happening to britain's housing market now
00:57:37 obviously all of us where i think we're of a similar age we have lived through a period of
00:57:41 time when buying a property getting on the housing ladder has been getting more and more and more
00:57:48 and more difficult over time and increasingly i think it's fair to say our generations which
00:57:54 is millennials and gen z gen z as we call them have been locked out of being able to get on the
00:58:00 housing market entirely well one of the things that is happening and this is kind of a sad irony
00:58:05 of of the labor government which is you know all of us i think have made the point that it's very
00:58:11 important for young people in particular to be able to get on the housing ladder and be able to
00:58:16 buy housing and the way that i always envisaged for that to happen was to scrap the regulations
00:58:22 that are preventing house building and to encourage massive house building while also
00:58:26 restricting mass immigration so you basically catch up the housing stock to the number of
00:58:32 people who are currently in the country you know if you've increased the population of your country
00:58:36 by 10 million people in in you know however long it's been i don't think it's you know in the last
00:58:41 couple of decades you're going to have a housing shortage and i thought the solution was always
00:58:46 well you build more houses turns out that's not what you do what you actually need to do is cause
00:58:50 rampant inflation tank the economy i increase interest rates um and also introduce the renters
00:58:58 rights act and the mansion tax which squeeze the market from both ends we can talk about those
00:59:03 those things in detail but housing prices today in britain in real terms are now back to where
00:59:09 they were in 2002 and in inner london housing prices even in absolute terms not in real terms
00:59:18 but in absolute terms are genuinely plummeting with people unable to sell homes and especially
00:59:25 flats for what they bought them for i i know from uh the the town where i live during the summer
00:59:32 there was a rent, a landlord exodus. Lots and lots of people were selling flats that they owned,
00:59:40 that they rented out. And because of this, rents are now rising rapidly. And the reason they were
00:59:45 all selling them is the Labour government introduced legislation, which effectively means
00:59:49 your tenants can effectively just live in your house or in your flat, not pay any rent,
00:59:55 take the piss. They can give you a two-month notice. And if you now take possession of the
01:00:00 new legislation, if you take possession of the flat you own in order to try and sell it,
01:00:07 you then can't put tenants back into it for 12 months after you did it, which is effectively
01:00:13 making it very, very difficult for even more difficult than it already was for landlords.
01:00:18 So what this has done is loads and loads of people sold flats at a discount. There's now
01:00:24 less rental stock for people to rent so the price has gone up and shortly after that the government
01:00:31 introduced the mansion tax which has compressed the price of property at the very top combine
01:00:37 that with rising interest rates and uh rapid inflation uh you now have a housing market that
01:00:44 is going in the other direction but it's not going in the other direction for the right reason which
01:00:49 is there's now enough housing it's going in the other direction because the affordability of
01:00:54 of housing is now uh now under threat uh even more than it has been in previous times so even
01:01:01 though things had improved in terms of affordability for the last few years we're now at a point where
01:01:06 despite the fact that technically in real terms house prices uh in certain parts of the country
01:01:12 are falling actually it's nonetheless very very difficult for people to buy and on top of that
01:01:17 this government has made it much harder for people to find somewhere to rent and so rents are going
01:01:22 to keep going up as well. I also think that this story, it's a housing story, but there's a tragic
01:01:32 element to it, which is it's also the story of Britain. It's the story of the fact that we are
01:01:38 a declining nation. We're declining economically. We're declining socially. We're declining
01:01:43 politically. We're declining culturally. And as a result of that, fewer and fewer people want to
01:01:50 live here. Fewer and fewer people want to actually rent a house or they want to buy a property or
01:01:56 they want to stay in the UK. We're hemorrhaging high net worth individuals. A lot of young people
01:02:02 graduating from universities, coming out of college, out of training schemes, are looking
01:02:08 around at the UK and thinking to themselves, do I actually want to live in this country?
01:02:13 and the unfortunate answer for people like me and everybody else is it's a resounding no
01:02:19 and every time so I'm currently in New York at the moment and one of the things that I always
01:02:25 get reminded about when I'm in America and when I'm in New York is look this country has a lot
01:02:30 of problems of course it does but there is an energy here and a dynamism and an optimism in
01:02:36 this country that unfortunately is just lacking in the UK and I think part of this story as well
01:02:44 is the people who can leave who feel that they are ambitious and they have something to offer
01:02:51 are simply thinking to themselves that their future no longer lies in the UK which is really
01:02:58 sad for our country no so i suppose i should uh immediately declare an interest here as far as
01:03:06 reading that um people who the house prices and the flat prices have not only been eroded by
01:03:13 inflation over time but also that there is this particular problem in london and the southeast
01:03:17 of particular interest to me because i bought a flat i'm broadcasting to you now for a flat
01:03:21 that i bought in in london about four years ago and uh therefore even those of us of my slash our
01:03:27 generation who managed to just about get over the line in terms of being able to buy somewhere even
01:03:32 if it's in less than ideal sort of leasehold form the fact that you hammered again is just so
01:03:38 frustrating but also the fact that as you say that how warped the whole market has become because
01:03:42 you know ordinarily particularly if we're talking about first-time buyers and people who are looking
01:03:46 to make that move at the moment house prices going down would potentially be good news but because
01:03:50 of course the cost of borrowing is so out of control unless for some reason they were cash
01:03:54 buyers and were just handed the cash from the bank of mum and dad or someone else or what have you
01:03:59 in order to make that purchase then they're even more scupper than they were before just how out
01:04:05 of control warped it's become now of course that's going to have political consequences you know it's
01:04:09 a it's a tired line by this point but it's obviously it's obviously correct which is that
01:04:13 you wonder why so many younger people particularly those who feel themselves to be sort of downwardly
01:04:19 mobile are being so attracted to absurd ideas whether that be wealth taxes rent controls or
01:04:24 what have you it's because they feel like anything that might give them some kind of reprieve is
01:04:30 welcome um and it's this is such a core issue i think particularly um for parties and politicians
01:04:36 of the right which is to provide a kind of answer to those young people which um make sense to them
01:04:42 and to make that argument to them that know the kind of solutions which are being presented by
01:04:46 this sort of new populist left um are only going to make matters worse but at the same time something
01:04:50 which does genuinely give them a stake in the future.
01:04:53 Otherwise, without wanting to play into this,
01:04:55 all young people are so hard done by trying to make everything generational,
01:04:58 which I don't think gets us very far.
01:05:00 There's clearly a big issue there that needs to be addressed
01:05:02 if anyone's willing to address it.
01:05:06 It's interesting comparing the situation in Britain
01:05:10 with other countries, particularly America.
01:05:12 So the media framing has been, of course,
01:05:16 that the inflation that has been one of the drivers for this problem is because of the Iran
01:05:23 war and the Russia war. And obviously, there's some truth to that. But America, which has the
01:05:32 same sort of problems, but an even higher mortgage rate, and they do have property problems, but
01:05:37 they're not in the situation we are. And I think it's ultimately because it's an economy that's
01:05:43 actually more productive and growing in a more healthy way. So we just have this,
01:05:49 and I'm just echoing the point you've already made here, is fundamental problems with our economy
01:05:56 that mean the best young people can do is if they're ambitious, they're entrepreneurial,
01:06:06 they're going to look to other countries and they're going to want to leave. It's a big old
01:06:11 mess. And I think it's a problem just all the way to the bottom in the way that our leaders have
01:06:19 built this economy. So it's going to take a big clean up to sort out this problem. It's not as
01:06:25 simple as the war ending, I don't think. Well, what's interesting to me as well, I actually
01:06:31 think part of the solution to Britain's economics problems was always up to and including government
01:06:38 intervention in the housing market by creating more house building because the building of houses
01:06:43 creates jobs it's economic activity and then it brings through housing that can be sold to people
01:06:49 that you know tapers off the rapid rise in house prices that we have seen
01:06:54 uh perhaps i'm acutely sensitive to this in that i i bought a house only a few months ago and so
01:06:59 to see house prices going down is not particularly delightful but i actually have always said this
01:07:05 i don't really care i don't care about the value of my house i think it's really important that
01:07:10 housing becomes more affordable for people in our country and the fact that it isn't is a gigantic
01:07:16 problem so uh i would love to see house prices continue to go down actually i just like it to
01:07:22 go down because we have more houses instead of because people can afford them even less than
01:07:28 they could before um which is which is seemingly what's happening now particularly as we talked
01:07:33 about with rising interest rates. But that is where we are for this week. Gentlemen,
01:07:40 thank you so much for being here. We will be back next week, as always, and we will see you then.
01:08:03 TC Optimum Points when you spend $60 or more. So head to Shoppers Drug Mart for the Black Friday
01:08:09 Super Sale. Stay big, leave happy. Conditions apply. Details in store.