TRIGGERnometry - October 07, 2026


Everything You Know About Napoleon Is Wrong – Historian Andrew Roberts

Hosted by
Mentioned
Never Go Full Tucker - Konstantin Kisin France is on Fire & Is Zionism Racism? - Off the Fence

Episode Stats


Length

2 hours and 1 minute

Words per minute

147.32

Word count

17,925

Sentence count

1,175

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

28

sentences flagged

Hate speech

50

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 He was very keen for it to return to its former glory.
00:00:06 Make France great again.
00:00:07 Make France great again, exactly that.
00:00:10 Napoleon then imposes a peace in which he essentially splits up Europe between Russia and France.
00:00:19 How does it begin to unravel from there?
00:00:21 When the Russians in 1811 decided that they were going to resume trade with Britain,
00:00:27 He invaded Russia to try and force them back into the continental system.
00:00:30 Of the 615,000 that go into Russia, only 93,000 come back.
00:00:37 So he gets exiled now, huh?
00:00:39 He was there 10 months, and he escaped.
00:00:42 He lands with only 300 men.
00:00:44 If you add the 150,000 Austrians and the 350 Russians,
00:00:48 you've got half a million men who are marching.
00:00:51 So even if Napoleon had won Waterloo, he'd have found it impossible to enter Paris.
00:00:56 Do you have too many friends? Then head over to our merch store where you'll be able to buy
00:01:03 hoodies, t-shirts, caps, stickers, posters, and of course, the world famous Trigonometry mug.
00:01:10 Grab a few of those and all your woke friends are guaranteed to cancel you right away.
00:01:15 Go to shop.triggerpod.co.uk. That's shop.triggerpod.co.uk and become part of the show.
00:01:24 Lord Andrew Roberts, welcome back to Trigonometry.
00:01:26 Thank you so much, Konstantin. It's great to be back.
00:01:28 What a pleasure it is for Francis and I to have you back.
00:01:31 I was saying before we started, our first interview, which was about Winston Churchill,
00:01:35 to me, it's a definitive interview about the great man.
00:01:39 Still people watching it in their tens of thousands.
00:01:42 I know it had a huge impact on book sales for you, for Walking With Destiny.
00:01:47 And it's a pleasure to have you back to talk about another great man,
00:01:51 but sort of slightly in inverted commas, because obviously, you know,
00:01:54 He was a bit of an enemy of this country, a bit.
00:01:56 Napoleon and his marshals, which your latest book is about.
00:02:01 So let's get straight into it.
00:02:02 Let's do that.
00:02:03 Napoleon, who was he?
00:02:05 Where did he come from his early life?
00:02:07 Perhaps let's start with that.
00:02:09 He was born in Corsica in 1769.
00:02:12 He was an aristocrat, but really Corsica didn't have an aristocracy.
00:02:17 So they didn't have any money, but they had a grand background.
00:02:21 and they had a sense of themselves as aristocrats.
00:02:27 His father was a lawyer.
00:02:28 He spent a lot of time in his father's extensive library
00:02:31 and took on the ideas of the Enlightenment.
00:02:35 He read Voltaire and Diderot and so on.
00:02:37 And he joined the army quite early
00:02:39 because they didn't have enough money to send him to the grand schools.
00:02:44 But if you were an aristocrat,
00:02:46 you could get free education at military academies.
00:02:48 And so he went to two military academies
00:02:50 and winded up being an artillery officer in 1794.
00:02:57 And tell us about France in this period of time.
00:03:00 This is before the French Revolution,
00:03:02 which I imagine therefore necessarily means
00:03:04 there's quite a turbulent time.
00:03:06 There are lots of things going on,
00:03:08 various social movements going on.
00:03:10 What is the environment in which he is sort of culturing
00:03:13 and growing into a man?
00:03:16 He was... Actually, he very much agrees with that.
00:03:20 concepts. He said that if you show somebody what they were like at 20, what the world was
00:03:28 going on there and happening in the world when you're 20, you can understand the whole of the
00:03:33 rest of the man's life. And there's a lot to that, I think. And when he was 20, of course,
00:03:38 as you mentioned, the French Revolution broke out. And so he was still a cadet at that stage,
00:03:44 an army cadet, but he was very ambitious. He was extremely well-read because of that time he spent
00:03:51 in the library. He was very hardworking. And he suddenly saw an opportunity for himself and for
00:03:59 all the other army officers who weren't going to be guillotined, essentially, of which hundreds
00:04:05 were, indeed thousands. And so there was going to be an opportunity for driven young men like him to
00:04:12 get into the very top eshnals of the army early, as it were. And he took huge advantage of that.
00:04:19 And he was a general by the time. He was 24.
00:04:23 Wow. So it's very much that Game of Thrones called Chaos as a Ladder.
00:04:27 Yes, absolutely.
00:04:28 Interesting. And did his ambition, you know, obviously the level of ambition he had is,
00:04:35 you know, unusual to say the least. But was it partly driven by this,
00:04:40 I am an ability, but I am impoverished situation?
00:04:43 Or was it just something that, you know,
00:04:44 some people are just born like that?
00:04:46 And a sense of his own capacity, his abilities.
00:04:50 He had a wonderful, I mean, he had a very high opinion of himself,
00:04:54 but he was tremendously talented.
00:04:56 He was a hardworking, as I say, intelligent man
00:04:59 who felt that he could do really well
00:05:02 and get absolutely to the top.
00:05:04 And in the initial fighting that took place in Toulon,
00:05:09 because the Royalists and the British and various other navies
00:05:15 managed to take the centrally most important Mediterranean port,
00:05:22 naval port of Toulon, and the French needed to get it back.
00:05:27 The revolutionaries needed to get it back,
00:05:29 and Napoleon was extremely successful with that in 1793,
00:05:33 and that's how he became a general in 1794.
00:05:36 Mm. And just painting the broader picture a little bit, Andrew, obviously, in the modern
00:05:42 world, we have this meme about France being, you know, cheese-eating surrender monkeys. But of
00:05:46 course, throughout history, it's actually one of the great powers, military powers in Europe,
00:05:52 and in fact, the world. What was the military position of France at this time that Napoleon
00:05:57 is coming through? Weak. It had lost the Seven Years' War in 1763. So six years before he was
00:06:05 born, France had lost its primacy in Europe, which as you're right in saying, absolutely over
00:06:12 the previous hundred years, it had been the great military power of Europe. Louis XIV brought it up
00:06:18 to that stage. But by the time he was growing up, it had been humiliated in this war on four
00:06:27 continents. So he was very keen for it to return to its former glory. Make France great again.
00:06:35 And made France great again, exactly that. And he hoped that he would be part of that.
00:06:41 Just to complicate that, though, of course, he was also a Corsican nationalist. And the Corsicans,
00:06:47 for the early part of his life, wanted independence from France. So he was torn emotionally and
00:06:53 intellectually, and certainly politically, between his father's dream of an independent Corsica
00:07:00 and his own dream of a very powerful France.
00:07:03 Because what's really interesting about Napoleon is that he had this meteoric rise.
00:07:09 And partly, I think, and correct me if I'm wrong,
00:07:12 it's the fact that he proved himself indispensable to the Republic through his talents.
00:07:17 He did, and also through his ruthlessness.
00:07:19 And this, Francis, is a tremendously important aspect because in October 1795,
00:07:25 he was appointed by the government to crush a rebellion in Paris, a royalist uprising in Paris,
00:07:32 which he did using what Thomas Carlyle later called a whiff of grapeshot. He got a large
00:07:40 number of cannon, 40 plus cannon, from outside Paris. This was actually done by someone called
00:07:46 Joachim Murat, who was to become tremendously important as one of his leading marshals.
00:07:51 And they used these cannons to kill about 300 Frenchmen as they crossed the bridges over the Seine and tried to take over the central part of the Tuileries Palace, which is where the government was at the time.
00:08:06 He just cut them down. He used grapeshot, lots of very small little musket balls inside a canvas bag that explodes as soon as it leaves the cannon's mouth and so kills the maximum number of people.
00:08:21 And what's interesting about that is that we see, I think, the rise of Napoleon where he becomes more and more indispensable, which means that he becomes more and more powerful, doesn't he?
00:08:33 That's right. And actually, one of the people who's in the government at the time says that there's a statement he makes to a cabinet meetings where he says, as soon as a general considers himself to be indispensable, that's the time we must dispense of him.
00:08:48 And they don't. They allow him, after the whiff of grapeshot, to go and fight in Italy.
00:08:55 They don't give him enough troops or money or ammunition or supplies or anything.
00:09:01 But nonetheless, he manages, through a series of brilliant victories at the beginning of the Italian campaign,
00:09:08 to win that campaign against the Austrians in northern Italy.
00:09:12 And I want to delve into what made him so special as a general, because he was someone who was truly great because he was an innovator, tactically and strategically.
00:09:22 So let's explore that. What was it about tactics and the strategies that he used that made him so brilliant?
00:09:30 He ripped up the rulebook completely. There were actual rulebooks that were written about what armies needed to do. And he just took no notice of them, or he took on ideas of the new younger thinkers who were writing revolutionary radical new ideas.
00:09:48 The first is you don't stick your army outside cities and besiege cities.
00:09:55 You go round the cities, leaving enough men to make sure that the people in the city don't rally out.
00:10:01 But nonetheless, you keep moving. Speed and manoeuvre is vital.
00:10:06 You don't wait for your baggage train. You live off the land.
00:10:09 So you basically just take whatever's there and push on.
00:10:13 You employ something called the core system, which means breaking up your divisions into armies, sort of mini-armies essentially, which can hold the enemy in place while your other cores go around the outside and envelop them, in some cases in the Italian campaign, double envelopment.
00:10:34 So you have this new form of warfare. He was very lucky as well. He was in his mid-20s
00:10:41 and some of these Austrian generals were in their 70s and 80s. So he was much more
00:10:48 energetic then. He also had a superb eye for his lieutenants. He did choose people who were very
00:10:58 good, very trustworthy, very brave and so on. And so you all have all of these things come together
00:11:04 and he used to plunder cities and therefore pay his men, who a lot of them after the French
00:11:11 Revolution hadn't been paid for years. And that obviously made him popular and brought the morale
00:11:17 of the army up. And yeah, there were sort of 10 or so, I list them in the book, new aspects of
00:11:26 soldiering, which he brought to bear. And let's explore that. Which ones do you think were the
00:11:31 most important, the most innovative, and also the ones that are the most impactful?
00:11:37 I think the speed, this whole idea of speed. He also had an idea that, which is later written
00:11:45 about by Carl von Clausewitz, who watched Napoleon very carefully. And he calls it the
00:11:52 strategy of the central manoeuvre, which means that if you have two enemies, and he very often
00:12:01 did in the Italian campaign, he had Piedmont and Austria, what you do is you strike at the hinge
00:12:07 between the two and push the stronger one off, defeat the less strong one, and then you turn
00:12:17 on to the other ones. So it's a thing that you see many times. The interesting thing actually
00:12:25 is that the Allies, the coalition forces against France, are very, very slow at working out what
00:12:31 Napoleon's manoeuvres are. They don't really come up to understand the strategy of the central
00:12:38 manoeuvre until 1813. They don't adopt the core system until 1812. They still indulge in very long
00:12:47 costly sieges right the way up through to 1813, 1814. So actually, they take a decade virtually
00:12:56 more to work out what Napoleon's doing.
00:12:59 Andrew, and where does this young man get both the confidence and the knowledge to be able to,
00:13:09 as you say, rip up the rulebook?
00:13:11 study. He spends an enormous amount of time, both at home, of course, but also in his two
00:13:19 military academies, discussing, debating, learning, reading every book on strategy and so on,
00:13:28 and working out for himself what he thinks is going to work and what isn't. So he's tremendously
00:13:33 professional. And all of the people who commanded him in these various academies
00:13:39 write about how good he is basically at all of this. He's a deep thinker and he works out also
00:13:47 just the practical side of how to put these intellectual theories into practice on the
00:13:52 battlefield. Wow, that's really interesting. And just before we move on with the chronological side
00:13:57 of things, if we stick with the revolution aspect of it, is he ideological? Does he have a view of
00:14:04 how society domestically ought to be structured? Does he think that getting rid of the monarchy
00:14:10 is the right thing? Not because it gives him a chance to then become the ultimate leader,
00:14:15 but for other reasons. Does he have a vision of how society ought to be?
00:14:20 Yes. In 1793, he and his family that summer are expelled from Corsica because he's a Jacobin, 1.00
00:14:31 he's a supporter of the French Revolution, and they are chucked out off the island
00:14:35 because the island is going down the independence route. Not for very long because independence is
00:14:42 crushed. But nonetheless, he is an ideological supporter of Maximilien de Robespierre. He
00:14:49 supports the guillotining of Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette. He is a really sort of harsh,
00:14:57 radical revolutionary, until the fall of Robespierre on the 28th of July 1794, when he then
00:15:05 is arrested down in the south of France, put in jail for 10 days, is in fear of his life because
00:15:11 he doesn't know whether or not the anti-revolutionaries are going to execute him as well as the 30 or
00:15:18 so people that they executed back in Paris. And there he seems to have a major conversion where
00:15:25 he recognises that the dreams of Jean-Jacques Rousseau and the other encyclopaedists and so on
00:15:33 actually are, they're just utopian ideals
00:15:39 and not something that's going to actually work on the ground.
00:15:42 And he turns against that kind of politics,
00:15:45 still embracing the Republic
00:15:47 and willing, of course, a year later
00:15:50 to cut down the enemies of the Republic
00:15:52 in the streets of Paris with 300 dead.
00:15:55 But he's no longer that kind of ideologue.
00:15:58 Wow. So in the modern parlance,
00:16:00 he sort of nearly gets cancelled
00:16:01 and realizes the woke one went a bit far.
00:16:04 We say he sees the light.
00:16:06 Yes.
00:16:07 That's, I mean, that's an extraordinary thing
00:16:09 for somebody to change their views to that extent.
00:16:12 Well, he's still only in his mid-twenties.
00:16:14 And I think that's a time when you can be quite fluid
00:16:17 in your ideological convictions.
00:16:19 That's really interesting.
00:16:20 And so having gone through the French Revolution
00:16:24 as a keen supporter,
00:16:25 then having this moment when he sees
00:16:28 that maybe the extremism was less appropriate
00:16:31 than he thought. What is left at that point in terms of how he sees the world?
00:16:37 A fierce French nationalism is there. A belief that the royals, the Bourbons, should not be
00:16:46 allowed to come back. A very strong sense of meritocracy. And this is a very important aspect
00:16:53 of the martial art when we come on to that by 1804. He actually does believe, even though he's
00:17:00 an aristocrat himself, of course, that the best men must be allowed to rise, especially in the
00:17:05 army. That talent must be allowed to be harnessed for the good of the country. And that means that
00:17:11 all of the assumptions made for the last thousand years in France, whereby you could not rise above
00:17:18 the rank and status of your grandfather and father, has to be done away with. So that's arguably one
00:17:24 of the most revolutionary ideas. In the modern world, until quite recently, we thought meritocracy
00:17:30 was a sort of self-evident, obvious, best way to do things. But actually, in that moment,
00:17:37 this is a revolutionary way of looking at it. And is that part of the bedrock of his success
00:17:43 as a commander and general and ultimately leader of France?
00:17:47 Undoubtedly, because when it comes to choosing his marshal, so his most important
00:17:52 lieutenants, what he's trying to do, as well as obviously get good soldiers,
00:17:57 is to recreate a form of aristocracy in France that has got nothing to do with birth.
00:18:04 And it's all to do with talent, especially military talent, and governing talent as well.
00:18:10 Several of these marshals were very fine administrators. But what he's trying to do,
00:18:16 therefore, is to unleash the incredible energies of all Frenchmen who suddenly learn that they can
00:18:25 get to the top by their talents rather than just have to spend their entire time staying where
00:18:31 they are. So it's a fantastic, there's a quotation that was said about him that he allowed the French
00:18:40 army to understand that inside every soldier's knapsack is the baton of a marshal of France.
00:18:48 And that was the case. Of the 26 marshals, about half of them were the sons of innkeepers and 0.51
00:18:55 barrel coopers and peasants and domestic servants and people who had never, whose children had never
00:19:01 been able to get to the top of society before. Like most people, I want more energy, better focus,
00:19:08 and to still be sharp and strong years from now.
00:19:10 But every time I've gone in for my annual checkup, it's the same thing.
00:19:14 Wait weeks to get an appointment, sit in a waiting room,
00:19:17 and then you're in and out in 10 minutes.
00:19:18 Everything looks fine, they say.
00:19:20 Drink more water, sleep a bit more.
00:19:22 No real insight, no plan, just vibes.
00:19:24 That's why every time I visit the US, I use Superpower.
00:19:28 Members get 150 plus biomarkers tested every year across two separate tests.
00:19:33 One to set your baseline and one later to see what's actually changed.
00:19:37 That's a different category information to what you get standing in a doctor's office once a year.
00:19:42 It covers heart, liver, thyroid, hormones, metabolism, vitamins, and mineral levels,
00:19:48 gut health, and even environmental toxins.
00:19:50 Superpower turns all of that into a personalized health plan
00:19:53 rather than a printout you never look at again.
00:19:56 Members using it are catching early risk factors for disease
00:19:59 that a standard checkup would have missed entirely.
00:20:02 Take control of your health with Superpower.
00:20:04 For a limited time, our listeners and viewers get $50 off their membership at superpower.com slash trigonometry.
00:20:10 That's superpower.com slash trigonometry for 50 bucks off your superpower membership.
00:20:15 And after you sign up, they'll ask you, have you heard about superpower?
00:20:19 Tell them Trigonometry sent you to support the show.
00:20:22 And that was one of the things that was truly revolutionary about Napoleon is the relationship he had,
00:20:29 not only with his marshals, but with his men on the ground.
00:20:31 They truly loved and adored him, didn't they?
00:20:34 They certainly did. It's the marshals who actually don't. I'm sure we'll come on to that later on.
00:20:42 Oh yes, the way in which he was able to inspire his men was partly through his charisma, partly
00:20:49 through his writing ability. He would write his orders of the day, proclamations, bulletins and
00:20:54 so on, which would really get the men excited. There's the moment before the back of the pyramids
00:21:00 when he says, 40 centuries look down on you. So you are being watched by 4,000 years of history
00:21:08 and how you fight today, essentially, is more important than just you. It's your taking part
00:21:15 in history. And that was a part of what he said was about trying to electrify the soul.
00:21:22 If you can electrify the soul of your men, you can get them to do things that otherwise
00:21:28 normal soldiers wouldn't necessarily do.
00:21:31 And that was obviously because at that time,
00:21:33 well, armies have always been hierarchical,
00:21:36 but there was this attitude at the time
00:21:38 that the men were basically peasants
00:21:39 and then you had the people at the top
00:21:41 and they were the brains and they were in charge
00:21:43 and there was this huge disconnect.
00:21:46 But with Napoleon, you read these stories about how
00:21:49 if a man was fighting bravely on the front line,
00:21:51 he would ride up to them and take off his legion d'honneur
00:21:54 and put it round his neck.
00:21:55 out. I mean, listening to that hundreds of years on, it doesn't fail to be moving.
00:22:01 And of course, if you did get the Légion d'Honneur because of your bravery, that also,
00:22:07 as well as making you tremendously respected by your fellow soldiers, you also got a pension.
00:22:13 And so you didn't have to worry about working after you left the army for the rest of your life.
00:22:18 So there was a real sort of added practical side as well as the glory. But overall, yeah,
00:22:25 you're right. I mean, this lust for glory is something which does grip the French army.
00:22:32 And it becomes a problem with the Marshals later on because it turns into such an obsessive lust
00:22:39 for glory that they start starting battles early in order to grab glory, you know, before they're
00:22:45 actually supposed to be attacking. And that obviously isn't a good thing. But overall,
00:22:51 that esprit de corps, the allon that you have in the French ranks, that does come very much from
00:22:58 a deliberate policy of Napoleon's to adopt meritocracy. So let's go back to the story.
00:23:05 So this is the, well, it wasn't Italy at the time, but let's just call it the Italian campaign.
00:23:10 Yeah. I mean, stunning success. Victory after victory after victory after victory.
00:23:16 comes home to a hero's welcome.
00:23:20 So it starts to go a little bit wrong afterwards
00:23:23 with the Egyptian campaign.
00:23:25 What happens in the interim? 0.61
00:23:26 Well, in the interim, he makes a plan to invade England.
00:23:32 And actually, they go quite far with this.
00:23:37 Andrew, I'm sorry to interrupt.
00:23:38 Just for my clarity, when you say he makes a plan,
00:23:41 is he the leader of France already?
00:23:42 No, no, no.
00:23:43 No, absolutely not.
00:23:44 He is the successful general who's returned from Italy, garlanded with honours.
00:23:49 But he has no, other than his military rank, he has no political power.
00:23:54 So how is he making this planning?
00:23:56 Because the Ministry of War want to know what to do with him next.
00:24:00 They recognise...
00:24:01 They know if he stays around, he's going to cause problems.
00:24:05 Yes, they want to get him out of the country.
00:24:08 Wow.
00:24:08 Either on an expedition to England or, as Francis mentioned, going off to Egypt, which will very comprehensively take him out of Europe, of course.
00:24:20 And when they realise that they're not ready to try and cross the Channel
00:24:29 because, of course, the Royal Navy is the strongest in the world
00:24:33 and able to protect England, they then think seriously about Egypt.
00:24:40 And so he moves into Egypt and reading about his story,
00:24:47 it seems to me, and correct me if I'm wrong,
00:24:49 But it seems the most tenuous of reasons, doesn't it, to actually go into Egypt?
00:24:54 There are the public reasons that they're trying to cut off British trade in the Mediterranean, 1.00
00:25:00 which is perfectly true. 1.00
00:25:02 They did want to sort of stop the increase in British influence in the Near East.
00:25:07 And then there is his private reasons that he only vouchsays to a few friends,
00:25:14 including some of the marshals, when he talks about how he wants to wear a turban,
00:25:21 hold the Qur'an as he enters Delhi on an elephant. Delhi's 1,800 miles away.
00:25:30 It's all sort of pretty nutty stuff, frankly. But in the short term, yes, he wants to take Cairo
00:25:37 and makes sure that that becomes part of the French Empire and denies trade routes.
00:25:45 But his secret plan is to become a new Alexander the Great.
00:25:49 But it also comes with a fascination of Egyptology, doesn't it?
00:25:53 Yes.
00:25:53 And he's a lover of ancient history.
00:25:56 Yes.
00:25:56 So let's talk about that, and the Rosetta Stone in particular.
00:25:59 The Rosetta Stone. He takes with him on this big expedition, 30,000 men in over 300 ships. He takes 167 intellectuals, what were called savants. And the savants were going to map out Egypt.
00:26:19 They were going to look at all of the ancient pyramids and the Philae, and they were going to visit all of the great places, Memphis and so on, and actually make a 21 volume, what's called The Description of Egypt, which is published years later, which is still one of the great cultural and intellectual achievements of the Western world, effectively.
00:26:49 It's an extraordinary thing.
00:26:52 The volumes now cost half a million pounds each,
00:26:55 so we'll all have to save up to own them.
00:26:59 But they're beautiful, utterly beautiful.
00:27:02 And page after page, the amount of work that's gone into these
00:27:05 as they note down all the hieroglyphics,
00:27:08 and essentially they start modern Egyptology.
00:27:14 Now that's not, of course, one of the primary reasons
00:27:16 for him to have done this.
00:27:17 That was all about strategy and politics and so on.
00:27:22 But it's an amazing by-product.
00:27:25 And it also shows an aspect of Napoleon, which surprised some of his marshals.
00:27:29 Because, you know, up until now, conquering was conquering.
00:27:33 It wasn't sitting down and making incredibly detailed illustrations of everywhere that you've seen.
00:27:41 And the Egyptian campaign starts off very successfully, doesn't it?
00:27:46 And then with Alexandria. So let's talk about that. It starts up successfully and then it starts to go awry the further it goes.
00:27:55 Yes. But the people in France don't know this. This is the key thing.
00:28:00 You know, there's a huge difference between what's happening on the ground and propaganda back home.
00:28:05 So he starts off, as you say, he lands without loss. He marches to Cairo and takes Cairo after the Battle of the Pyramids, which is a huge victory.
00:28:19 virtually no French killed thousands of Mamelukes who were the people who ruled 0.94
00:28:26 Egypt at the time, nominally in the name of the Turkish Sultan, but actually they were a sort of
00:28:33 warlord race that dominated Egypt for hundreds of years. Well, they were former warrior slaves 0.98
00:28:39 weren't they? Yes, exactly that, they were. But they built themselves up into this warrior caste,
00:28:45 which for hundreds of years ruled over Egypt. So for the ordinary Egyptian, it was basically a
00:28:52 choice between the French and the Mamelukes, and they considered both of them to be foreigners.
00:28:58 What you get after the fall of Cairo is this terrible news which comes, which is that Admiral
00:29:07 Nelson has sailed his British fleet into Abilkir, which is where the French fleet was
00:29:14 was at anchor. And in a totally brilliant manoeuvre where he managed to get ships
00:29:21 between the coastline and where the French were moored, he essentially sank the French fleet.
00:29:29 So there was no way home. And this, as you can imagine, was devastating news as far as the
00:29:35 morale of the French army was concerned. It didn't hold Napoleon back. He decided then to invade
00:29:42 Syria, or at least what is in modern day Israel and Syria. And so he gets all the way up to Acre,
00:29:51 he goes through Gaza and gets up past Haifa to put Acre under siege and then can't take Acre, 0.83
00:30:04 because it's defended as well as by the Turks,
00:30:08 also by the British and some French royalists as well.
00:30:14 And so I want to just go back to the naval battle with Horatio Nelson,
00:30:20 because this might be very simplistic, and correct me if I'm wrong,
00:30:25 which I'm sure that I might be, but there is this image of Napoleon
00:30:28 that he was a brilliant land general, strategist, military expert.
00:30:34 But when it came to the naval aspect of warfare, he was deficient.
00:30:38 Yes, I think that's very fair.
00:30:40 And it's extraordinary, really, because it's not as though he wasn't...
00:30:45 He didn't understand the sea. He came from an island.
00:30:50 He was later, obviously, exiled to another island and died on another island.
00:30:54 You know, he wasn't just a landlubber, but he never really, as a soldier, he never really looked into what admirals and sailors were doing.
00:31:05 He often sent his admirals letters asking them to do things that were actually just technically impossible.
00:31:12 It was said that he didn't know the difference between Wynwood and Leawood, which obviously is going to be a major problem if you want to.
00:31:19 So it is a huge lacuna in his knowledge and understanding, everything to do with the naval aspect.
00:31:28 Now, whether he could have stopped Admiral Nelson, who obviously was a great genius, from sinking his fleet anyway.
00:31:35 He was in Cairo at the time, hundreds of miles away.
00:31:37 But his Admiral, Admiral Brees, ought to have been able to have moored his ships in a way that was more intelligent and wouldn't allow Nelson to do what he did.
00:31:50 But don't you find it fascinating, Andrew, that this is a man who was intellectually curious, fascinated by all aspects of history, military strategy.
00:32:00 Yet when it comes to something as essential as naval warfare, particularly when your main enemies are the Brits, you're going to be incurious at best?
00:32:12 Yes, and especially as, of course, as I mentioned earlier, the thing that drove him was the desire to avenge the Seven Years' War. And the Seven Years' War was, to quite a large degree, a naval war. I mean, obviously, yes, you do have big battles like Minden and so on in Central Europe.
00:32:29 But otherwise, what's going on all around the world in the West Indies and the East Indies and the Mediterranean and so on, these are naval battles.
00:32:39 And so, yes, as I say, it's a big lacuna in his understanding.
00:32:43 Then again, to be fair to him, I mean, I don't know if I'm right about this, but I imagine people in history who are able to be geniuses at land warfare and naval warfare in one human being are quite unusual.
00:32:57 Very, very. I mean, one can think of a few from the ancient world, but otherwise, yes. I mean,
00:33:03 the two do bifurcate, don't they, as areas of expertise, certainly by the time of the 18th century.
00:33:11 Well, that's what I mean. The more specialized these fields become, the more difficult it is
00:33:15 for one person to know everything about both. So the campaign stalls, the Egyptian campaign
00:33:22 in store as well. He's not Egyptian anymore. He's out in Syria. What happens from there?
00:33:27 Well, he comes back into Cairo and brings back his army, having not been able to capture Acre,
00:33:37 and decides that he is going to go back to France. And there's some debate amongst historians about
00:33:45 whether or not he intends to overthrow the government of France and set himself up as
00:33:51 First Consul. The government in France then known as the Directory was corrupt, inefficient and
00:33:59 unpopular. There was huge inflation and the war hadn't been going well back in Europe. So he,
00:34:09 I believe, did have plans to return and overthrow the government, especially if he found enough
00:34:16 supporters in Paris, which he certainly did do. So he returns. How does he return? He's got no
00:34:25 ships. He manages to get on board a frigate, which comes after the Battle of... What happens
00:34:31 to his men? His men all stay back in Egypt to tremendous fury and resentment from them.
00:34:39 I'd imagine. But their resentment isn't communicated back to France because you can't
00:34:49 get the British in control of the Mediterranean, essentially. And apart from this ship that does
00:34:55 manage the mural, does manage to get back to first Corsica and then to the south of France, 0.65
00:35:05 you really there are no communications and this works hugely to his advantage of course
00:35:10 because the people of france have heard about the victories and not about the defeats
00:35:16 rich first sponsored this show nearly six years ago i've still got one of their wallets in my
00:35:23 pocket right now and i promise nobody told me to say that rich makes wallets power banks luggage
00:35:28 the stuff that actually ends up in your pocket or your bag every single day not sitting in a drawer
00:35:34 somewhere. This year, Ridge is running their sweepstakes for the sick time, and they've gone
00:35:39 bigger than ever. It's live now, running until the 8th of September, and Tony Hawk is fronting it,
00:35:46 so you know they've taken this seriously. Two winners are going to get to choose between a
00:35:51 Lamborghini Huracan Starato, a Hennessy Velociraptor, a custom-built Ford Bronco wrapped in
00:35:58 kevlar armor or a hundred thousand dollars in cash the lambo alone is one of only 1500 in existence
00:36:05 and naturally aspirated v10 with 610 horsepower built to go off-road which sounds like a
00:36:11 contradiction until you see it the velociraptor is a twin turbo with 558 horsepower basically an
00:36:18 american muscle car that's been let loose on a truck take your pick you can enter completely
00:36:24 free at Ridge.com, no purchase necessary. But if you're already planning on picking up a wallet or
00:36:30 a power bank, every order during the sweepstakes earns you extra entries. So there's genuinely no
00:36:37 reason not to. Head to Ridge.com and use the code Trigonometry at checkout for 10% of your first
00:36:43 order. And a shot at the biggest giveaway Ridge has ever run. A Lamborghini Huracan Starato,
00:36:49 a Hennessy Velociraptor, a Ford Bronco, or $100,000 in cash.
00:36:54 Every dollar you spend gets you more entries,
00:36:57 but you don't need to spend anything to enter.
00:37:00 That's ridge.com code trigonometry.
00:37:04 After you check out, they'll ask you where you heard about them.
00:37:07 Tell them we sent you.
00:37:09 I think this is a very important point now to talk about the idea of myth-making.
00:37:15 Yeah.
00:37:15 Which Napoleon was, again, a genius at.
00:37:18 He was almost Trumpian in the way that he could have a terrible outcome in Egypt, yet portray it as this huge success.
00:37:30 Some say the greatest victory. I wish I could do the accent.
00:37:34 Yes, that's right. And also, he didn't just manipulate the news, although he was very good at that.
00:37:41 He was the first person, for example, to bring along a printing press on his campaigns with him so that he would be able to put his point of view out to the army, but he knew that it would get wider traction.
00:37:57 But also he had painters like David who would paint wonderful portraits. The most famous one, of course, is him crossing the Alps on his horse. He, in fact, crossed the Alps on foot and sometimes on a donkey.
00:38:16 But you look at that painting where he's on this wonderful sort of speed
00:38:21 and he's pointing towards Italy and so on.
00:38:25 So he had a great form of sort of mouse for propaganda.
00:38:31 And it's interesting because I don't know if you saw the movie
00:38:35 that came out a couple of years ago.
00:38:39 I did, I did.
00:38:40 You're not a fan?
00:38:41 No, it was a terrible movie.
00:38:43 It was such a tragedy.
00:38:44 300 million Ridley Scott had to work on that. He had Napoleon bombarding the pyramids.
00:38:53 He puts the Battle of Austerlitz, the victory at Austerlitz, down to putting cannonballs through
00:38:59 the ice and the coalition forces sort of falling into it and drowning. He has Napoleon having sex 0.98
00:39:08 under the table at the Tuileries, whereas in fact Napoleon was very, very keen on the dignified 0.96
00:39:13 court. The idea of him having sex with Josephine when there were sort of attendants and courtiers
00:39:20 present is just ludicrous. He has Napoleon and Wellington meeting in Klymouth. I mean, 0.98
00:39:28 it just basically seems to almost go out of his way to get everything wrong. And when he was asked
00:39:34 about this, and various historians, including me, criticised him, he said his exact words were,
00:39:41 effing historians, what do they know?
00:39:44 They weren't there, were they?
00:39:47 Which is true, you know, we weren't there.
00:39:49 However, loads of people were
00:39:51 and they wrote down what happened
00:39:52 and we've read it.
00:39:55 Yeah.
00:39:55 Well, the reason I bring it up,
00:39:58 but it's interesting that you say that, of course,
00:40:00 from people who've watched the film
00:40:01 and so may have drawn conclusions that are inaccurate,
00:40:05 is you almost don't see him communicating with anyone
00:40:09 in any way.
00:40:10 Yeah. And he's portrayed as this very aloof character. And from what little I know about
00:40:15 leadership and those are not compatible. You can't be someone who's not capable of inspiring people
00:40:21 and communicating with them. And also, like Francis alludes to propaganda and managing
00:40:27 the sentiments of the nation. Yeah. You can't do that and be an effective leader for very long at
00:40:32 all, if ever. And so that aspect of his portrayal, I imagine, is also greatly inaccurate. Yes.
00:40:39 Yes, he comes over, the Joachim Phoenix character of Napoleon is glowering and ill-tempered and you wouldn't follow him anywhere.
00:40:51 No.
00:40:52 And yet this, the actual Napoleon was somebody who people were willing to follow across the deserts to Cairo and through the snowy wastes of Moscow and across every country you can think of in Europe.
00:41:07 It just doesn't compute at all.
00:41:12 And that's why I think it was great.
00:41:13 Yeah, there's this weird scene in that movie, isn't there,
00:41:15 where he sort of, he comes back
00:41:17 and the men who are sent to stop him
00:41:21 immediately turn to his side.
00:41:24 But watching that scene, you're going,
00:41:26 why did they do that? 1.00
00:41:27 This grumpy twat is turned up. 0.99
00:41:28 We're like, where's the inspiration here? 0.99
00:41:33 You know what I mean?
00:41:34 Yes, exactly.
00:41:34 So was he a great orator?
00:41:37 No, interestingly not.
00:41:39 He was a very good writer, as I mentioned,
00:41:42 with the proclamations and orders of the day and so on.
00:41:44 But in fact, he wasn't a great orator.
00:41:48 And that's partly because he had a Corsican accent,
00:41:51 which the French laughed at.
00:41:54 You know, they... 0.97
00:41:55 Doesn't sound like them.
00:41:56 They mimicked and generally that didn't give him...
00:42:02 Also, he had a slightly high-pitched voice as well,
00:42:04 which is a surprise.
00:42:05 And he was very short, was he not?
00:42:07 No, no, no, no.
00:42:08 No?
00:42:08 No, this is a...
00:42:09 The lies are all getting debunked here.
00:42:11 This is a myth.
00:42:12 He was five foot six, which was the average height for a Frenchman in those days.
00:42:18 And I also like to point out exactly my height.
00:42:22 So I don't like it when people call him a midget.
00:42:28 I hope. 1.00
00:42:30 Understandable. 0.86
00:42:30 Well, somebody as tall as you, Constantine, might think I'm, or at least Napoleon was a midget, but he wasn't. 0.52
00:42:36 The reason that that comes about is also propaganda, but in this case, British propaganda. 0.51
00:42:40 Because the genius, I mean, he was unfortunate in a sense that his time in power also coincided with the three great geniuses of British political caricature, Gilray, Rowlandson and Cruikshank.
00:42:56 And those three made him out to be tiny.
00:43:00 but at the same time dangerous.
00:43:02 It's interesting.
00:43:03 Usually, you know, you can have one or the other,
00:43:06 but they managed somehow to make him into a physical small person
00:43:11 at the same time a threat to England.
00:43:14 But there's a history of that. 0.73
00:43:16 If you think about, you know, the old...
00:43:17 It's not a meme, but to use modern parlance, 0.90
00:43:20 it is, you know, Hitler's only got one ball.
00:43:23 Do we know that that's not true, though? 0.63
00:43:25 Well, we know that the other is not in the Albert Hall.
00:43:30 So, it's a bit of a segue, but coming back to our story from that.
00:43:39 So, he comes back from Egypt, and what happens when he returns?
00:43:45 He's managed to keep his defeats out of the public eye.
00:43:48 Yes. 0.89
00:43:48 The government is corrupt and vapid and not working. 0.93
00:43:52 What happens from there?
00:43:53 He stages a coup, a military coup, and several of the people
00:43:58 who are going to become his marshals, are in key positions to help him. He has one friend,
00:44:06 Murat, who takes care of the cavalry. Jean Lannes takes care of the infantry. Marmont takes care of
00:44:16 the artillery. And his friend Berthier organises the staff. And what they do, the general staff,
00:44:23 What they do is to have a two-day essential uprising. The first forces the parliament to move out of Paris to Saint-Cloud. And then he, on the second day, he goes to Saint-Cloud and tries to persuade the parliament to adopt him as dictator, essentially, which it doesn't do.
00:44:46 It's furious and very resentful. And so he has to then go outside the Parliament building, or at least the Saint-Cloud Palace, and send grenadiers with fixed bayonets in to arrest the opponents and to essentially get rid of the Parliament.
00:45:08 they have to climb out of the window of the orangery at Saint-Cleu.
00:45:13 And they're all wearing, in those days,
00:45:15 the parliamentarians were wearing great big red togas.
00:45:19 And so they jump out of the windows and run away.
00:45:23 And of course, every state opening of parliament in the House of Lords,
00:45:28 I wear essentially a red toga, these sort of cloaks.
00:45:33 The idea of climbing through a window and running away, wearing one.
00:45:37 Just next to impossible. So as you can imagine, quite a lot of them are arrested and they're exiled, and Napoleon takes power as First Consul of France.
00:45:46 And is this a purely intra-elite battle, or are the French people with Napoleon?
00:45:55 The ordinary citizens of Paris don't mind that the Directory's been overthrown.
00:46:01 They have only ever heard good things about Napoleon since the Italian campaign.
00:46:05 They recognise that he's essentially, in this case, he argues that he's saving the Republic from this sort of, he makes up terror plots as well, says that the British are planning terror plots.
00:46:22 pots. He also thinks that he's under threat of assassination, which there's no evidence
00:46:28 of. So he creates a sort of security fear. And through it all, he grasps power. And the
00:46:37 French people do nothing. They seem to be perfectly happy with this. And then he appoints 0.99
00:46:46 two other consuls. So the three of them are supposed to rule France. He then brings in
00:46:52 a reformed parliament, which is essentially full of his own cronies. And he's done it.
00:46:59 And sort of touching on the marshals aspect, but also cronies, there are lots of people who clearly
00:47:05 he can trust. He can trust someone to run the artillery. He can trust someone to run the staff.
00:47:10 He can trust someone to be the other two consuls. Where does he get all his friends from?
00:47:15 Well, partly they are people who've been with him since the beginning.
00:47:18 So Berthier, who runs the general staff and becomes minister of war in his new government, was with him from the first day, indeed before the first day of the Italian campaign.
00:47:31 Murat, who was the man who brought the cannons from outside Paris to put down the uprising back in October 1795, and the following year becomes his, in 1800, becomes his brother-in-law.
00:47:45 These are sort of really close part of the family, essentially.
00:47:50 And then, of course, as there always are whenever power is shifting,
00:47:54 there are the ambitious people who want to be on the side of the rising sun
00:47:59 rather than the setting sun.
00:48:00 This is the boat to jump in if you want to make way.
00:48:04 So he's been through the wars with a lot of these guys that are around him.
00:48:09 And some of the opponents.
00:48:11 The interesting thing is that there are some people who he appoints as marshals later.
00:48:15 who actually opposed the Brumaire coup on political grounds,
00:48:20 because they were still Jacobins.
00:48:21 They wanted a republic, and they feared that if Napoleon takes over the country,
00:48:26 he might bin republicanism.
00:48:30 And sure enough, of course, he does.
00:48:31 Because he wants to be dictator.
00:48:33 Yeah.
00:48:34 And so he has overthrown the republic.
00:48:38 He's got himself and the two other councils.
00:48:41 Does he immediately turn his eyes on war again?
00:48:45 externally? Yes. He puts in a few popular measures. He makes sure that bread stays cheap,
00:48:55 which of course is absolutely vital if you're not going to be overthrown yourself. He institutes
00:49:01 the Bank of France, which tries to get inflation under control and very quickly actually does
00:49:05 very successfully. He brings in various reforms, enlightenment reforms that are popular with the
00:49:12 with the people. And then he goes off and crosses the Alps and tries to recapture Italy, which had
00:49:19 been lost in the time that he was in Egypt. I can't remember which historian. It may even
00:49:26 have been John Meiersheimer, with whom obviously I probably have a few disagreements. Same here,
00:49:30 by the way. I imagine. But he did describe Napoleon and Hitler, I think, as two congenital
00:49:37 aggressors, as he put it. Is this true about Napoleon? Is this just a guy who loved war so
00:49:41 much that he was just going to invade everyone until someone stopped him? No, he deeply believed
00:49:47 in the Enlightenment. In a sense, he was the Enlightenment on horseback. He wanted to bring
00:49:53 French revolutionary ideas, including meritocracy, to the rest of Europe. And secondly, he had many
00:50:01 more wars fought against him than he fought against others. The one that I mentioned, the 1800
00:50:07 campaign. Yes, he went off to fight it, but that was only after war had been declared against him.
00:50:13 And that was true in 1805, 1809. There were seven wars of the coalitions, they're called,
00:50:21 between 1792 and 1815. And of those, Napoleon only started two, and the other five were started
00:50:29 either against him or revolutionary France by the coalition powers, who hated the concept of
00:50:34 meritocracy because, of course, it put their own positions and thrones in danger.
00:50:40 I see. So he's almost like, as you know, in the Soviet Union, there were two types of
00:50:46 communists, those who believed in communism within one country and those who really saw
00:50:49 communism. The only way communism would work is if you exported it everywhere.
00:50:53 He was the exporting type.
00:50:55 Very, very much.
00:50:56 And the other powers were very aggressive and hostile to him because I guess they would
00:51:02 have seen effectively what they saw the French Revolution being, which is the great unwashed
00:51:07 overthrowing and upending the existing order. And killing the king. And obviously all of these
00:51:13 other countries, Prussia, Russia, Austria, Britain, are monarchies. And so they strike absolute terror
00:51:20 into the idea of... He sets a terrible example for their own citizens. Precisely. And another way,
00:51:28 Whilst we're on the Merseimer equation of Napoleon and Hitler, I think it's also worth 0.65
00:51:35 pointing out that actually these two men have nothing in common. Apart from the fact that 0.79
00:51:41 they fight wars, but then so do all sorts of democracies as well. When the French armies
00:51:51 entered places in Germany and Italy and elsewhere, one of the first things they did was to open
00:51:57 up the ghettos and let the Jews have religious and civil liberties for the first time, you know,
00:52:03 since before the Middle Ages. So you have this sense of the French Revolution being an enlightened 0.84
00:52:09 thing that was, in this case, very good for the Jews. Completely opposite, obviously, to what 1.00
00:52:16 you get from the Nazis. Let me say this because I know I'm not alone. At some point, your body
00:52:23 just stops bouncing back the way it used to. You train hard, you travel, you push yourself and
00:52:28 suddenly recovery takes longer. You wake up stiff, joints complain, skin, hair, nails, things don't
00:52:34 look or feel quite right anymore. So many people listening to this know exactly what I'm talking
00:52:39 about. What surprised me is that this isn't just getting older in some vague sense. A huge part of
00:52:45 it is collagen. Your body starts producing less of it from your mid-twenties onwards. Collagen is
00:52:50 basically the glue that holds everything together so when your levels drop you feel it everywhere
00:52:55 that's why i started using bubs naturals collagen peptides and i've stuck with it since i've added
00:53:01 it to my routine recovery is noticeably better joints feel stronger and my skin and hair have
00:53:06 improved i genuinely feel better now than i did a few years ago and that's not a placebo effect
00:53:12 it's fixing something fundamental it's also effortless i put it in my tea coffee or any drink
00:53:19 No taste, no smell, no clumps. You forget it's even there. And Bubz isn't just another supplement
00:53:24 brand. It was created in honor of Glenn Bub Doherty, a former Navy SEAL who was killed
00:53:30 saving Americans in Benghazi. The brand is built around discipline, self-improvement,
00:53:35 and doing things properly. They also donate 10% of all profits to charity through the Glenn
00:53:40 Doherty Memorial Foundation. The product itself is clean. No sugar, no fillers, third-party tested,
00:53:47 NSF certified for sport. Whole30 approved. Sustainably sourced from grass-fed pasture-raised
00:53:54 cattle. Over 100,000 people use it and it was named best collagen of 2024 by health.com.
00:54:02 If you recognize yourself in what I've just described, this is worth trying. Live better,
00:54:08 longer. For a limited time, get 20% off your entire order at bubsnaturals.com with code TRIG
00:54:15 or click the link in the description of this episode. That's B-U-B-S naturals.com,
00:54:22 code TRIG. And when they ask where you heard about them, tell them Trigonometry sent you.
00:54:27 Once more for 20% off, use code TRIG at bubsnaturals.com.
00:54:34 And also as well, there's the private aspect of Napoleon. And one of the things that I found so
00:54:40 interesting is, on the one hand, you have this military and strategic genius. And on the other
00:54:45 hand, you have this relationship and marriage with Josephine, which is, shall we just say,
00:54:52 chaotic, to put it mildly. It certainly was chaotic, not least because when he was out in
00:55:00 Egypt, she was unfaithful to him with a cavalry captain called Hippolyte Charles. And he
00:55:09 found out about it. And so when he came back from Egypt, they had this almighty row, and he had
00:55:16 all her stuff put out into the courtyard, and she begged him, and then the stuff was brought back 0.68
00:55:24 again, and they obviously had fabulous sex, and it was all alright. But he did embark on the first
00:55:32 after he heard about this infidelity,
00:55:36 the first of 27 affairs with mistresses.
00:55:40 So it's a...
00:55:43 He believed in meritocracy everywhere.
00:55:46 It's a complicated story.
00:55:49 But you see, also his marshals were,
00:55:53 I mean, their sex lives were like something,
00:55:55 like the Rolling Stones tour 1969.
00:55:58 I mean, they were absolutely,
00:56:00 there were lots of them tremendously handsome they were rich they were made into counts and
00:56:05 dukes and princes and kings and um and they were very attractive to women and and you know one
00:56:11 thing led to another well you talk about it in the book like the early stages it kind of sounds like
00:56:16 it just sound like a band really they're going around like having these and i can't remember
00:56:21 the name of one of the marshals wrote these post-humors or it was released post-humorously
00:56:27 and he was eulogising about how it was the greatest time of his life,
00:56:31 just lads on tour.
00:56:32 Yes, exactly, and that they thought nothing for anything
00:56:36 apart from glory and lust and fame.
00:56:40 Yeah, no, it was a very exciting time for them, of course,
00:56:44 until it went wrong.
00:56:46 Right, so let's come back to the story.
00:56:48 He becomes dictator, he goes off to Italy, you said?
00:56:53 Yes, he crosses the Alps into Italy
00:56:56 and fights and wins the Battle of Marengo in the June of 1800,
00:57:02 which essentially totally stabilises his rule back in France.
00:57:07 He pushes the Austrians out of Italy again for the second time. 0.53
00:57:13 And then he comes back to France.
00:57:15 And this is the period where he does all the big sort of popular stuff.
00:57:21 He creates the Code Napoleon.
00:57:23 He builds four bridges over the Seine.
00:57:26 he entirely changes the education system, he organises the administrative system of France
00:57:32 as well with the Conseil d'État and the Cours de Comte and so on. He gets the financial system
00:57:37 under control, he invents the Légion d'honneur. That is the period where he does all this.
00:57:43 So he's truly a great ruler.
00:57:45 Yes, he's a visionary figure when it comes to creating what is essentially the building
00:57:53 blocks of modern France. There are criticisms, you know, the Code Napoleon was tremendously
00:57:58 sexist. Tell us about the Code Napoleon. Well, France had at the time of his what's
00:58:04 called the Brumaire Coup, the coup that took place at the Palace of Saint-Cloud, France
00:58:10 had a series of overlapping and competing legislative codes, laws essentially, which
00:58:19 Some of them go back to Roman times. Others were Bourbon and they were complicated. Some parts
00:58:28 and regions of France adopted one set of codes and others others. So what he did was to standardise
00:58:36 the entire thing into one book called The Code Napoleon. He didn't actually put that much of
00:58:42 his own work into it. He oversaw it. It was done by committees of lawyers and it simplified the
00:58:48 entire French legal system, basically. But it was very sexist. The entire, all power essentially
00:58:57 in the family resided with the patriarch and not the wife. So it's very unpopular now,
00:59:05 but it has, it's survived into the legal systems of many European countries.
00:59:12 Wasn't one of the laws, if you found your wife cheating on you, you could have her killed? 0.99
00:59:17 No, I think you had to kill her yourself. 1.00
00:59:19 Oh, OK. 1.00
00:59:22 You've got to have some, you know.
00:59:23 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
00:59:24 You've got to do it.
00:59:26 Because otherwise, you know, all hell would break this.
00:59:28 Yeah, exactly.
00:59:29 Clearly speaking from experience, he took her quite personally, I take it, with Josephine.
00:59:34 OK, so this is an aspect that, frankly, I'm just being honest here about my own ignorance,
00:59:38 is I really hadn't appreciated the extent to which his domestic achievements were significant.
00:59:44 Huge.
00:59:44 And hugely contributory to the history of France.
00:59:47 Roads, reservoirs, drinking fountains that you can still see around Paris,
00:59:54 which were, to bring clean water into the centre of Paris
00:59:57 meant that you basically got rid of cholera,
01:00:00 which killed tens of thousands of people.
01:00:03 So that was useful.
01:00:05 Everything to do with killing the inflation was tremendously popular
01:00:09 because you actually got rid of that terror
01:00:13 that anything that you owned and possessed would be worthless.
01:00:18 So he was very good at that.
01:00:21 He provided mass employment, obviously also in his armies.
01:00:25 But he was a really efficient, hardworking,
01:00:32 but also visionary man who wanted to and did change France forever.
01:00:39 And where is he getting the money for all of this, Andrew?
01:00:41 Because the French Revolution, as I understand it, happens because the country is basically bankrupt, partly because they helped the Americans so much with their revolution.
01:00:50 So he inherits this poor country, fighting wars, which are expensive.
01:00:54 And then you're telling us within a decade or two, the country is flourishing, is spending money, building this, building that.
01:01:01 How does that happen?
01:01:03 Partly through the increase in trade that takes place when he signs a peace treaty with Britain in 1802.
01:01:10 So it's called the Peace of Amiens.
01:01:12 It doesn't last terribly long, but it allows the French to trade
01:01:16 because up until then, of course, the Royal Navy had entirely blockaded all French ports.
01:01:22 Partly also because he encouraged things like trade fairs.
01:01:28 He encouraged luxury goods, which the French have always been very good at.
01:01:33 Lyon, during the French Revolution, was devastated by the fact that people didn't buy silk and lace and velvet
01:01:39 it, because if you did, you looked like an aristocrat, you could have your head chopped 0.98
01:01:42 off. So he started up the luxury trades as well. And also stealing. That was the other 0.94
01:01:50 massive way in which he injected huge amounts of cash. When he went to Rome, for example,
01:02:00 he insisted on the Vatican handing over hundreds of manuscripts and lots of paintings and so on,
01:02:08 but also cash. And he would do this to town after town, city after city. He would impose,
01:02:14 outside France, obviously, he would impose these, what were called, dotations.
01:02:20 So somewhat civilised pillaging of the conquered territories.
01:02:22 Yes. And you can still today actually see in the Louvre, there are still paintings that were
01:02:28 stolen from Italy in the Italian campaign. And so this is essentially peak Napoleon, 0.58
01:02:36 really? Yes. Some historians would argue 1806, 1807, but certainly by 1805, you've got
01:02:46 Pete Napoleon. Pete Napoleon. And Pete Napoleon really is the Battle of Austerlitz, isn't it?
01:02:51 Yes. So let's talk about that. Why did it happen? Who was it against? And why was it such a
01:02:57 magnificent victory? Well, what was the war, in fact, perhaps? Tell us. Yes, it's called the
01:03:01 War of the Third Coalition. And it takes place when the Austrians, rather stupidly, invade 0.99
01:03:10 Bavaria, which is Napoleon's ally. And Napoleon at that point has his entire army on the Channel 0.95
01:03:21 Coast, looking out towards Britain and waiting for a moment that the Royal Navy can be tricked 0.72
01:03:27 away from England, and he can then cross the Channel and march on London, which is one
01:03:34 of his great dreams. And that doesn't take place. The Admiralty in Britain knows exactly
01:03:42 what he is trying to do. But the core system, which we mentioned earlier, of each of these
01:03:53 sort of mini-armies, are by that stage commanded, each of the corps are commanded by a marshal,
01:04:00 and they have headquarters all the way along the coast. And at the moment that he hears that
01:04:12 Bavaria is about to be invaded, i.e. before it is actually invaded, because he has spies all over
01:04:17 Europe. He turns, it's called the pirouette of Boulogne, he turns the entire army round and
01:04:29 marches straight towards Bohemia. And it's an extraordinary, and still today is taught actually
01:04:39 in military academies, extraordinary genius of this man Berthier, Alexandre Berthier,
01:04:46 who was an aristocrat. He was the chief of staff, and many people, many historians think he's still
01:04:53 the greatest chief of staff in military history. And what he did was to plot the entire army,
01:05:00 right the way down to the last man, how they got 600 miles across Europe without overlapping,
01:05:07 managing to keep all the supplies and food and everything going with them. This time,
01:05:14 they actually brought everything with them and it didn't slow them down because this man was an
01:05:20 absolute genius at manoeuvre. And they managed to free Bavaria and then do a pirouette inside
01:05:32 the Black Forest. So as the Austrians, who were being supported by the Russians, 0.56
01:05:38 thought they were coming in one direction, actually in the middle of the Black Forest,
01:05:42 They changed directions, 90 degrees, which you can do under the core system, because you just move the units around.
01:05:51 And then came south and captured Vienna.
01:05:57 And then after that, they met the huge, much larger Austro-Russian army at the Battle of Austalitz on the 2nd of December 1805,
01:06:09 which coincidentally was, not entirely coincidentally, was the first anniversary of the coronation of Napoleon as Emperor of France.
01:06:20 And it's an extraordinary set-piece battle, Auslitz.
01:06:26 When you go, I do recommend you, if you're ever in that part of the world, near Bruna in Bohemia, in the Czech Republic, you can see the battle from the place where Napoleon was, a little hill called Zoran.
01:06:43 And you can look down and see the way in which he, first of all, hid an entire corps under Marshal Salt in the valley, which was covered in mist.
01:06:57 So the coalition troops couldn't see that it was there.
01:07:01 And as the sun burnt off the mist, he sent the salt in a sort of surprise attack up the Prats and Heights.
01:07:09 At the same time that he was using Bernadotte and Davout, these great marshals of his, to hold the left hand of his line.
01:07:21 And then he had a very powerful right flank manoeuvre as well.
01:07:26 And frankly, the Austrians and Russians, who weren't very good at coordinating between them either, didn't know what hit them.
01:07:33 And they were pushed off the Pratsen Heights. 0.76
01:07:35 and in just a series of absolutely brilliant manoeuvres
01:07:41 entirely coordinated by him
01:07:42 but which he had explained to the marshals
01:07:45 the night before the battle
01:07:46 he managed to win easily the greatest victory of his career
01:07:51 which ended the Third Coalition
01:07:57 knocked them out
01:07:58 and essentially left him master of Europe.
01:08:03 And this was an essential part as well of the myth-making
01:08:05 because this was essentially one man against two armies.
01:08:09 Well, and also this myth that you see, in fact, in the movie
01:08:13 where he supposedly fired the cannonballs onto the lake
01:08:18 and the Russians and Austrians who are marching
01:08:21 all fall through the holes in the lake and drown and everything.
01:08:25 They've dredged those lakes.
01:08:26 There are a couple of cannons.
01:08:28 There are a few breastplates.
01:08:29 You know, there's the odd lance there.
01:08:32 But nothing significant.
01:08:34 That was not how he won Auslitz. He won Auslitz, not by some kind of clever trick, but by a series of brilliantly coordinated attacks.
01:08:44 And the way he was able to do that was through the use of this thing, the core system.
01:08:49 So each core would have its own artillery, cavalry and infantry, but also its own staff, its own supplies, its own medical.
01:09:00 It was essentially a mini-army, and each of them were commanded by marshals, and he had created this thing.
01:09:08 Maybe this is a good time to talk about the marshall, because it had been created the previous May, in May 1804.
01:09:17 This idea of he appointed 18 of his best generals, both to be, they were called marshals, the history of the marshall, it goes back to the 13th century in France,
01:09:28 But a few of them have been guillotined and there weren't any by 1804. He announced this new rank of marshal and gave it to his 14 top generals in the field and an extra four senatorial marshals who were heroes of France.
01:09:48 And over the next 11 years, up until Waterloo, he appointed another eight.
01:09:55 So you get up to 26 marshals in all.
01:09:58 And so the way in which he did that was partly because they were the best soldiers,
01:10:04 but also partly because he wanted to sort of set up a new meritocratic aristocracy.
01:10:10 Which is fascinating, particularly because the marshals, they were so different in their characters.
01:10:16 that Berthier was incredibly loyal, essentially a right-hand man,
01:10:22 and there were others that proved to be a little bit more disloyal.
01:10:26 Yes, that's right.
01:10:28 And actually people who had opposed the coup, the Brumaire coup,
01:10:34 like Marshal Bernadotte and Marshal Jourdan and Marshal Augereau,
01:10:41 these people actually were hardline Jacobins. 0.52
01:10:43 Jacobins. But he appointed them because he needed to have people from right the way across the
01:10:50 political spectrum. He also needed to have people from the army of Italy, as well as the army of
01:10:56 Germany and various other previous French revolutionary armies. So it didn't seem that
01:11:01 he was favoritizing. He, as we mentioned earlier, had people who came from incredibly lowly
01:11:08 backgrounds. Then there were some aristocrats like Davout and Berthier. And so with educational
01:11:14 qualifications, there's everything from Marshall Ney, who was virtually illiterate,
01:11:20 hardly went to school at all, to some really highly intelligent people who were very good
01:11:26 writers like Marmont and Davout. And so you have this really broad spectrum, but they did have,
01:11:33 they all have one thing in common, which was extraordinary raw courage. The 26 of them,
01:11:41 added together, suffered no fewer than 94 wounds in their lives. They averaged 3.6 wounds
01:11:49 per marshal, and five of them weren't wounded. They emerged unscathed. So you can imagine
01:11:54 Some people you had, Lan was wounded 11 times, Grouchy 14 times, and Marshal Nicola Udeno was
01:12:06 married, sorry, married, was wounded no fewer than 32 times. He was nicknamed the...
01:12:13 Interesting Freudian slip there, Andrew. Wounded and married.
01:12:16 Yes, for that. But isn't it amazing to think that one person, there were bayonet thrusts,
01:12:23 There were, he was hit by ricochet and cannibal.
01:12:28 Cannibal, he was very nearly killed on any number of occasions
01:12:33 by sword thrusts and by bullet wounds and everything.
01:12:36 He had so many holes in his body that his nickname was The Sieve.
01:12:40 Wow.
01:12:41 But what's really interesting is how he inspired that devotion and loyalty,
01:12:49 yet at the same time there was, I mean, this is modern vocabulary,
01:12:52 but there was a toxic element to it, wasn't there? Yes, that's right, because he was
01:12:58 attempting to create a band of brothers, but he wound up really creating a nest of vipers because
01:13:04 what really happened was that because they all got the same martial arts, the same rank,
01:13:12 they were desperate to outdo each other. The sense of competitiveness between them
01:13:18 absolutely was to wreck campaigns. There were four occasions when they drew swords on one
01:13:24 another or they wanted to fight duels against one another. The hatreds between them were
01:13:29 extraordinary. There were some friendships. Marshal Victor and Salt had mistresses who
01:13:35 were sisters, and that helped them get on with one another. Could have gone either way, that one.
01:13:40 But it was something that he soon found that this lust for glory and also having the same rank was to prove disastrous.
01:13:56 And would you say that's a failure of leadership on Napoleon's part, failure to contain that, to channel it correctly, to organize that in such a way that it was towards the common good as he saw it rather than the internal fighting?
01:14:08 or do you think that was just the inevitable reality?
01:14:11 I think it has to be put ultimately down to him. 0.91
01:14:15 You know, he's the person who created the Marshallette 0.95
01:14:16 and who tried to keep these guys in order.
01:14:20 He deliberately encouraged competition between them.
01:14:25 He was to say, after the Treaty of Tilsit,
01:14:27 which ended the War of the Fourth Coalition in 1807,
01:14:31 when he was negotiating with the Tsar Alexander I,
01:14:34 He said, I never let my generals know what I'm thinking and I encourage them to perform one another and I therefore can sort of stay above it and see what they're up to.
01:14:51 And so that was a deliberate attempt to encourage, to foster what was ultimately to be an unhealthy form of competition.
01:15:03 And it's really interesting, you mentioned the fourth coalition now.
01:15:07 I mean, after Austerlitz, is there no one, you know, the Russian emperor and others in Europe who go,
01:15:12 no, we've had our asses handed to us, maybe we should just let this guy crack on with it. 0.85
01:15:17 Yeah, you'd have thought, wouldn't you? 0.97
01:15:18 But the people who don't do that are the Prussians, who in the autumn of 1806, i.e. less than a year after Austerlitz, they think that they can take on France on their own. 0.87
01:15:34 They do get support from the Russians later on, but they reckon that their army, which of course was trained under Frederick the Great, but nevertheless Frederick the Great was long dead by then.
01:15:48 And they're well-drilled and all that, but they're a small country.
01:15:50 They're a small country, and what they don't have is universal conscription.
01:15:56 And the French, of course, since 1792, when they brought in universal conscription,
01:16:01 have much, much larger armies.
01:16:03 Plus, you know, they should have had a look and see what Napoleon had done, as you say,
01:16:07 not just at Auslitz, but in earlier campaigns, in the Marengo campaign, in the Italian campaign, and so on.
01:16:13 And they didn't.
01:16:14 They were mad, really, to have started that war.
01:16:19 And within two weeks of the war being fought, Napoleon was in Berlin.
01:16:25 And why would...
01:16:27 Look, Prussia is militaristic culturally.
01:16:30 Frederick the Grey has created this well-disciplined army
01:16:33 that outperforms others, etc.
01:16:36 But why are you invading?
01:16:38 What are they trying to achieve?
01:16:39 They are trying to essentially stay as the most important power in Central Europe.
01:16:52 They recognise Austria has been defeated badly, and they want to be as important as France, essentially,
01:17:03 which isn't going to happen under Napoleon,
01:17:07 at least not under Napoleon at this stage
01:17:10 when he's riding high
01:17:12 and he's got this incredibly talented bunch of marshals
01:17:16 who did very well
01:17:17 and they hadn't fallen out by the time of the Auslitz campaign.
01:17:22 A couple of them had Ney and Murat at a shouting match
01:17:24 but other than that they were working very well together.
01:17:28 The core system was working very well.
01:17:29 So, you know, the Prussians were sort of mad to have declared war. 0.50
01:17:35 And when they did, soon after doing that,
01:17:38 and Napoleon was expecting them to,
01:17:39 and his spies were telling him that this was about to happen,
01:17:42 it was actually the Queen of Prussia
01:17:44 who is thought to have put pressure on her husband
01:17:47 to have started this war.
01:17:50 She hated Napoleon and... 0.97
01:17:53 That's a good reason.
01:17:56 It seems to have been enough.
01:17:59 And you get this extraordinary, um, double battle on the 14th of October, 1806, um, called Jena
01:18:07 Auerstadt. And at Jena, the, um, the, um, Napoleon and Ney and various other marshals,
01:18:16 um, fight against what they think is the main Prussian army. But actually the main Prussian
01:18:22 army is just the rear guard. The main Prussian army is eight miles away. Um, and, uh,
01:18:29 And that has been taken on by Marshal Davout.
01:18:33 It's Davout's greatest victory.
01:18:34 He somehow fights a force that's over twice his size,
01:18:39 and he manages a double envelopment.
01:18:41 Wow.
01:18:42 Crushes it.
01:18:43 And when Napoleon finds out, he makes Davout a prince
01:18:49 and appreciates that this is incredible.
01:18:52 At that point, the whole of the French army
01:18:56 then just sweep across Prussia.
01:18:59 led by Murat and the cavalry. Murat is the finest cavalryman of the era and followed up by Marshal
01:19:07 Lan and Marshal Bernadotte. And they capture city after city after city and they capture
01:19:14 entire garrisons and some cities they capture 60 cannon and they push the Prussians right the way
01:19:22 up to the Baltic Sea, which is in fact Kaliningrad, now, you know, Russian territory, isn't it?
01:19:31 And that's when the Prussians and Russians come together to fight these two massive battles
01:19:38 at Ailao and Friedland in mid 1807. And by the way, before we get on to that,
01:19:45 the one thing I thought it'd be worth coming back to your point about courage and the wounds that
01:19:50 so many of these marshals had suffered. Is this because they're all meritocratically created and
01:19:57 therefore in order to become a marshal you've had to have fought for 10, 15, 20 years in lower ranks
01:20:03 and or is it also because as marshals they are sometimes leading from the front and still taking
01:20:09 wounds while in these high positions? Very much both of those, exactly that. So yes, they've been
01:20:14 fighting most of them since 1792. They have therefore had to come up the ranks often by
01:20:25 sheer bravery. Lan, who is wounded 11 times, is at the forefront all the time of his grenadiers
01:20:34 in the many battles, 14 major battles in the Italian campaign. And then he's wounded very
01:20:41 badly also in Egypt. But they have to be at the front because in order to be able to spot what
01:20:50 is going on, it's so different from the First World War where a general can sit in a chateau
01:20:56 five miles behind the front. They absolutely have to be there because they need to work out the
01:21:02 timings of everything that they're doing. And also, of course, they're getting orders sent by
01:21:07 aide-de-camp on horseback from Napoleon, and they have to carry out his orders as well. So it's not
01:21:14 surprising that quite so many of them get hit by shot and shell, and Lann loses his life when his
01:21:21 kneecaps are taken off by a cannonball at the Battle of Aspen, and he dies of gangrene.
01:21:27 Yeah. And so they've got the Prussians and the Russians pushed up against the Baltic Sea. 0.62
01:21:33 Yeah.
01:21:34 Well, how do those battles go?
01:21:35 He wins both of them. He's about to lose the Battle of Ilau when he unleashes Muirah, who makes the largest cavalry charge in history. I think it still is the largest cavalry charge in history. 16,000 is the maximum number. Some historians argue it's a bit less than that, but it's a huge number and certainly the biggest one of the Napoleonic Wars. 0.98
01:22:02 and he basically just drives them through the centre of the Russo-Prussian army.
01:22:12 And once they punch through the centre, they're able basically to split the armies in two.
01:22:19 So he wins that battle. Huge losses on both sides, but much bigger losses on the Russo-Prussian side.
01:22:26 And then there's the Battle of Friedland a little bit later, which is another huge victory where they managed to trap the Russians in a town, the town of Friedland, which has the river Alla going behind it.
01:22:46 And there are only two bridges to get over. And once they force them into the town, the enemy can't get over the bridges in time. And they're massacred and lots of them surrender. 0.78
01:23:00 So the war ends with these two big victories and Napoleon then imposes a peace in which
01:23:09 he essentially splits up Europe between Russia and France at the Treaty of Tilsit, which
01:23:16 is negotiated on a barge, a sort of raft in the middle of the River Neiman.
01:23:22 So wonderful.
01:23:24 He's doing great.
01:23:26 Yeah.
01:23:27 How does it begin to unravel from there?
01:23:29 It's sort of slightly begun to unravel already because in the December of 1806, when he's still in Berlin, he passes what's called the Berlin Decrees, which are the start of the continental system, which is a massive protectionist measure that is intended to cover the whole of Europe and which is intended to force Britain to the negotiating table.
01:23:58 because no merchant in Europe is allowed to trade with Britain, and that's what he also gets
01:24:05 Tsar Alexander I to agree to in the Treaty of Tilsit. So actually protectionism is the major
01:24:13 thing, I think, that brings him down, because it's in order to impose the continental system
01:24:18 that he goes to war against Portugal, which is a long-standing ally of Britain and ignored the
01:24:26 continental system in 1807, and then ultimately against Russia, which turns against the continental
01:24:34 system in 1811, which leads to his catastrophe of 1812. Before we get on to that, was one of
01:24:42 the signs that his grip was starting to lessen and weaken is that the fact that even though the
01:24:49 French won significant battles, they were starting to get more and more casualties inflicted
01:24:56 upon them. Especially at Ilau. That was really heavy. What happened was that Marshal Ogerow,
01:25:04 who's an amazing character, and we must talk about him at some stage, his Seventh Corps
01:25:12 was ordered to attack the Russians. There was a blizzard, and the blizzard came down.
01:25:20 He carried on marching, and it turned out that he marched straight into the guns of the Russians.
01:25:26 artillery. And the first they knew about it was, as the snow was swirling around them,
01:25:32 they suddenly saw the flashes of the Russian guns. Do you remember that bit in Master and
01:25:36 Commander at the beginning of the movie, the Russell Crowe movie, Master and Commander,
01:25:40 where they can suddenly see the flashes in the mist, and then they start exactly like that,
01:25:47 and it wiped out Seven Corps.
01:25:51 So Napoleon couldn't sustain that kind of series of losses forever,
01:25:58 especially if he's fighting the whole of Europe.
01:26:00 So at that point, why was it that he decided to invade Russia?
01:26:07 Well, he was forced to, in a way,
01:26:12 if he wanted to defend the continental system.
01:26:15 Instead of doing what we now, I think, especially people from the kind of political background that we've got, we'd have allowed free markets to deal whether or not you wanted to trade with whoever.
01:26:30 That would have actually been the way to have gone about it.
01:26:33 But he instead imposed what was called Colbertian economics, which was all about closing down free markets and free enterprise as much as possible.
01:26:44 And so when the Russians in 1811 decided that they were going to resume trade with Britain,
01:26:50 because they really needed to, he invaded Russia to try and force them back into the continental
01:26:56 system. And of course, by then also, he had invaded Portugal and then went on also to invade Spain,
01:27:03 even though Spain wasn't threatening the continental system. And so he had a war on two
01:27:09 France. He had a massive war in which he was to lose a quarter of a million men in the Peninsular
01:27:14 War in Spain and Portugal, and he lost half a million men in Russia in 1812. And by the way,
01:27:21 just to jump in, from what I understand, the Spanish and Portuguese campaign was largely
01:27:25 so brutal and painful and so many losses because of the British involvement.
01:27:30 No, no, no, no. The actual, the Portuguese and Spanish, a good deal of work's been done on this
01:27:38 historically. And that assumption was true until believed widely, including by me, I hasten to add,
01:27:45 until 10 years ago or so. But now a lot of work's been done on quite the number of Frenchmen killed
01:27:50 by Spanish regular troops, but also partisans. And what the British did was constantly to allow
01:27:58 the Spanish and Portuguese to stay in the war. There was no point at which they sort of gave up
01:28:05 because the Duke of Wellington in Spain
01:28:10 was constantly able to attack the French
01:28:16 and it was very good for morale and so on. 0.99
01:28:18 But actually, if you look at each individual Frenchman who dies, 1.00
01:28:22 the Spanish and Portuguese kill more than we do. 1.00
01:28:24 And it's interesting that we talk about Wellington 1.00
01:28:26 because this was obviously the first time
01:28:28 these two great military minds encountered each other.
01:28:32 Well, no, they didn't.
01:28:32 I mean, they encountered each other in the strategic sense in that they knew what the other was doing, but the only time they actually faced each other across a battlefield was at Waterloo, absolutely, yeah.
01:28:43 Because Napoleon didn't spend enough time in Spain.
01:28:46 He went over just for three months in 1808, 1809, just January 1809.
01:28:53 And then he went away and fought the Austrians again and got married and so on, and never concentrated on what he should have done, which was to close down the Peninsular War.
01:29:06 And so he left it up to his marshals, who, as I mentioned earlier, all hated each other and refused to help each other. 0.52
01:29:13 And Masséna had to sack Ney. Marmont didn't help Masséna.
01:29:18 Masséna. Their salts didn't help anybody. He just stayed in Andalusia and refused to help anybody.
01:29:26 There were massive, there were 18 marshals who served in Spain and Portugal, and only one of
01:29:33 them, Suchet, emerges with any credit. So at this point, the marshals had, it had worked,
01:29:41 and it worked spectacularly well in Austerlitz, but we see now the royal fractures starting to
01:29:48 appear and the various personalities start to fragment. Particularly in Spain where they all
01:29:56 fell out with one another but also in Russia because although it went well at the beginning
01:30:02 by the time they got to Moscow and then started to retreat from Moscow and the weather turned
01:30:07 they all argued about which route to take back and viciously you know there's one moment where
01:30:15 Davout and Murat, have to be physically restrained from fighting one another over this.
01:30:21 So, and one can understand, you know, the passions are high, the testosterone is running,
01:30:26 it's matters of life and death. And so, of course, they really, and they deeply believed
01:30:33 their own strategic thinking. So you can understand why there were these clashes.
01:30:39 But Napoleon, all too late, ever steps in to try and stop it from happening.
01:30:45 And in Spain, he never appoints somebody who is sort of top marshal.
01:30:50 And that's a disaster for him.
01:30:53 But it's also as well, and it's a really powerful one,
01:30:55 it's literally the last line in the book where you basically say
01:31:00 he gave them everything except the one thing they craved, which was respect.
01:31:04 Yes, his respect they wanted, but instead he was incredibly transactional with them.
01:31:10 He gave them princedoms and two of them became kings.
01:31:17 He gave them huge amounts of just sheer cash.
01:31:20 They also got beautiful estates in the country.
01:31:23 They got these wonderful Parisian townhouses.
01:31:27 But they wanted more than that.
01:31:29 They wanted to feel that he admired them.
01:31:31 And instead, he just slapped them down the entire time. 0.98
01:31:34 The letters, he wrote 40,497 letters that are published in the correspondence volumes, and they are full of him slapping them down, saying, I'm disappointed, I'm disenchanted, you've failed, you're useless.
01:31:53 You know, I mean, he was incredibly, although he was a wonderful man-manager when it comes to his soldiers, he was a terrible one when it came to the leadership techniques that he used to his marshal.
01:32:05 And why?
01:32:07 Partly because when things had started to go wrong, he was genuinely extremely irritated by any reverse.
01:32:15 But he was also such a massive micromanager and essentially a control freak that he would exaggerate things that were going wrong.
01:32:27 And he tried to involve himself into the minutiae of absolutely every decision.
01:32:34 And this meant that the marshals weren't able to use their own initiatives.
01:32:40 And very often there were some very good marshals. Davout, Masséna were first-class strategists.
01:32:47 But they were being deluged all the time with blizzards of letters from Napoleon,
01:32:54 telling them even things that they really knew about,
01:32:57 like how fast men should march to get from A to B and so on.
01:33:01 There were four marshals who were actually officers in the army before Napoleon was born.
01:33:07 and he was telling them where bread kilns should be made
01:33:11 and how tents should be put up and things like that.
01:33:15 So he didn't really, even though he had the system of meritocracy
01:33:18 which promoted the best, he nonetheless was so convinced of his own greatness
01:33:22 that he couldn't let them make some of the decisions at a lower level.
01:33:27 Exactly, and this was all the more weird when it came to Spain
01:33:31 because in Spain you have this situation where he can't get a message to them and back
01:33:37 for sometimes three months.
01:33:39 Because the partisans would intercept the Aide-de-Cart,
01:33:42 you had to send these messages with huge amounts of troops
01:33:47 if they're going to get through to Paris.
01:33:51 And it takes weeks and weeks.
01:33:52 And then to come back also takes weeks and weeks.
01:33:56 So he really needed a man on the spot and never appointed one.
01:34:00 And so that was a major failure.
01:34:02 Why didn't he?
01:34:03 Was he just, he believed in the system so much
01:34:05 because it had been so successful?
01:34:07 At one point, he...
01:34:09 Well, first of all, it is he believed in himself so much
01:34:11 and thought that he would be more likely to be right,
01:34:15 even though it was a long time behind the times, as it were,
01:34:20 with regard to how long messages got there.
01:34:23 The other thing was a straightforward political one.
01:34:26 He didn't want to have another general
01:34:31 who was in charge of a quarter of a million of his men.
01:34:34 And he made that clear.
01:34:35 He didn't want to give any marshal that kind of power.
01:34:42 And was he right to worry about that?
01:34:44 Well, he'd himself taken power in a military coup.
01:34:48 So that was the only way that he was likely to be overthrown.
01:34:53 But were there hatching plots against him
01:34:56 before the very late stages?
01:34:58 Were his marshals genuinely thinking,
01:35:02 oh, I'll get a quarter million troops
01:35:04 and then I can be Napoleon?
01:35:05 Or were they loyal to him?
01:35:06 One of them was.
01:35:08 Bernadotte was always thinking about how he could become king or emperor of France.
01:35:14 And some of them, especially Augereau, after the loss of his division,
01:35:19 he turned against Napoleon, wasn't helpful to Napoleon pretty much at all after that.
01:35:25 And then Marmont surrendered Paris in 1804,
01:35:29 even though he was Napoleon's closest friend from school.
01:35:32 and that was particularly painful for Napoleon.
01:35:36 And Murat, after the retreat from Moscow,
01:35:38 joined the Allies and betrayed him completely.
01:35:41 And even though he was married to Napoleon's sister,
01:35:43 in fact, she, Caroline, was the person who was behind this
01:35:47 and thought that they needed to jump ship
01:35:50 in order to stay King and Queen of Naples.
01:35:53 So as things started to go wrong,
01:35:56 a lot of the marshals started to jump ship.
01:36:00 So we got in the story about as far as Russia.
01:36:05 So he invades Russia. 0.92
01:36:07 Initially, it's going well. 0.77
01:36:09 And then the famous General Winter comes into effect.
01:36:13 And as someone who is from Russia, it always surprises me reading history books.
01:36:16 And this may be a very superficial reading of it.
01:36:18 But, you know, these great military commanders don't realize there's winter in Russia.
01:36:22 And it's quite bad.
01:36:23 Is that actually what happens?
01:36:24 Or is it more complicated than that?
01:36:26 It's a bit more complicated than that.
01:36:27 But overall, Napoleon, he owned almanacs, which said what the winter was like in Russia.
01:36:36 And when the snow started to fall, he'd studied Voltaire's history of the campaigns of Charles XII of Sweden in Russia when the catastrophe at Voltaire.
01:36:51 So, yeah, he knew that this was going to happen.
01:36:53 And in fact, he did plan to be able to get back to Smolensk in less time than it had taken him to get from Smolensk to Moscow.
01:37:02 But on the 25th of October, 1812, at Malayaroslavets, which is about 75 miles southwest of Moscow,
01:37:15 he suffered a reverse, or at least his nephew suffered a reverse,
01:37:23 and then he took the wrong sort of long dog leg back via the battlefield of Borodino.
01:37:31 And he did this because he was advised to by some of his marshals.
01:37:35 It's virtually the only time that he actually takes his marshals' advice,
01:37:38 and it turns out to be catastrophic advice, because that's when the blizzards hit.
01:37:43 And it's also, we talk about a Russian winter,
01:37:46 but what we also need to talk about is a Russian summer
01:37:48 and the effect it has on troops and disease.
01:37:51 So let's discuss that.
01:37:52 Yes, well, typhus in particular hit the 100,000-strong central thrusting force
01:38:00 of the French army and killed tens of thousands. Actually, it's interesting, quite recently there's
01:38:07 been a mass grave that's been found in Vilnius, and they've done a lot of testing of the bones
01:38:14 of the soldiers in that grave, and they've discovered 14 different viruses and illnesses
01:38:21 and sort of diseases, including typhus, that can kill people.
01:38:26 So it's a, you know, the army was horribly,
01:38:31 and these are people going into Russia rather than coming out.
01:38:33 You know, once you're coming out,
01:38:36 then Marshal Ney, who's in charge of the rear guard,
01:38:41 who's nicknamed the Bravest of the Brave,
01:38:43 is tremendously, extraordinarily brave.
01:38:46 But he's unable, really, to save many more than a few thousand.
01:38:52 And in all, of the 615,000 that go into Russia, only 93,000 come back.
01:38:59 And that really is the beginning of the end, isn't it?
01:39:02 That's it. That's it.
01:39:03 I mean, it's not it, finally, because you still need the Battle of Leipzig in 1813,
01:39:10 which is also a huge catastrophe for him.
01:39:13 when a bridge explodes and Marshal Poniatowski is drowned
01:39:18 crossing over the river.
01:39:19 Marshal MacDonald does manage to get over.
01:39:22 But that's really the...
01:39:26 It's pretty much all over.
01:39:28 Although he does fight a very successful series of battles in 1814.
01:39:33 In the 1814 campaign, what's called the six days fighting,
01:39:39 he wins five battles in six days.
01:39:41 And there are many scholars actually who think
01:39:42 that those are his greatest achievements militarily.
01:39:45 As good as Italy.
01:39:47 Yeah.
01:39:47 And why is that?
01:39:49 Because he's going back to the original things, really,
01:39:54 speed, strategy of the central position.
01:39:58 He's got quite small forces who are winning
01:40:03 very good tactical victories day after day.
01:40:07 And, of course, he's fighting in France,
01:40:09 which gives him some added sort of home team, home turf advantage.
01:40:15 So just coming back to the chronological side of this, Andrew,
01:40:20 so he flees Russia effectively with a fraction of the men that he entered it with.
01:40:26 What happens from there?
01:40:28 Well, he then goes all the way back to Paris
01:40:31 and he leaves Murat in charge of the army.
01:40:34 And Murat doesn't want to be there
01:40:35 because he wants to go back to Naples to try and protect his kingdom.
01:40:39 And so he hands over, and Berthier is running the army anyway, along with Davout. And so together they try and turn the army into something worthwhile, but the Russians are coming.
01:40:54 And then at the key moment in December 1812, the Prussians changed sides.
01:41:02 And then halfway through the next year, the Austrians changed sides.
01:41:06 So suddenly these marshals, who are far too far east, have to bring themselves, get themselves back.
01:41:16 Sometimes they leave people in important places like Dresden and Hamburg.
01:41:21 But otherwise, they pull back.
01:41:24 for the great sort of reckoning in 1814.
01:41:29 And it's 1814. What year does he abdicate?
01:41:33 In April 1814.
01:41:35 In April 1814.
01:41:36 As the result of the Marshals coming together at Fontainebleau
01:41:39 and insisting on it.
01:41:42 Because by that stage, Marmont has surrendered Paris
01:41:45 at the end of March 1814.
01:41:48 And you've got to make the decision at Fontainebleau,
01:41:52 his palace there, his hunting lodge,
01:41:54 do you try to recapture Paris?
01:41:58 And the men are all up for it.
01:42:00 The guard, the ordinary squaddies,
01:42:04 these guys are up for the fight.
01:42:06 The marshals by that stage are not.
01:42:09 They've seen the size of the Allied armies that are coming.
01:42:14 They're sick of war by then, actually, a lot of them anyway.
01:42:17 They want to go back to their estates and their families.
01:42:20 They haven't seen their families for many months,
01:42:23 years, in a couple of cases.
01:42:24 And they've gone through the 1812 campaign, which has seen frostbite and cannibalism and appalling losses and drownings and so on.
01:42:36 And they just, by that stage, they want peace and they impose it on Napoleon.
01:42:44 Now, there's a big historical debate, and I come down very strongly on one side,
01:42:48 about quite how rude people like Ney and Udineau and others were to Napoleon's face.
01:42:56 I don't believe they were. I think they treated it like a council of war.
01:43:00 But nonetheless, there was no way out for Napoleon by then.
01:43:05 And this is where it gets really, really interesting,
01:43:07 because the fact that he was emperor kind of saved his bacon a little bit, didn't it?
01:43:12 Yes, because he went off to the Isle of Elba rather than, he was in charge of Elba.
01:43:20 He was the sovereign prince of Elba and he kept the title emperor.
01:43:24 And he wasn't just sort of, you know, imprisoned.
01:43:28 Because, and the reason was, is because he crowned himself as emperor, he was treated like royalty.
01:43:34 Whereas if he wasn't, the punishment would have been somewhat harsher, wouldn't it?
01:43:39 Also, he did have the loyalty of the soldiers, and they didn't want any more fighting.
01:43:47 And if he called upon them to, they probably would have.
01:43:50 He just wouldn't have had his marshals with him.
01:43:53 And the other reason, of course, is that in the meantime, in 1810,
01:43:56 he married the daughter of the Emperor of Austria.
01:44:00 And so in that sense, he was definitely royal by marriage, if not obviously by birth. 0.89
01:44:07 And so killing him or executing him would have been out of the question at this point. 0.94
01:44:10 Yes. 0.98
01:44:11 So he gets exiled to Elba.
01:44:13 There's one point as well, because everybody agreed, actually, that this was a great idea. 0.66
01:44:19 Apart from the Brits, who were like, um...
01:44:21 Well, they had the frigates that would keep an eye on him in Elba.
01:44:30 And they recognized that it was quite a difficult thing to do.
01:44:32 It wasn't helped by the fact that the British governor kept going off to Florence
01:44:39 to visit his eye doctor and his mistress.
01:44:45 In that order.
01:44:47 You want to make sure you can see. 1.00
01:44:50 The mistresses play a heavy role in all of this.
01:44:52 We're talking about the French, well, and the British in this instance.
01:44:56 So he was then on Elba, and he actually, when he was emperor of Elba,
01:45:01 which is a grandiose title, but he made a pretty good fist of it, didn't he, for a while?
01:45:05 Oh, yeah. If you go to visit Elber now, you can see the fountains that he built,
01:45:09 and he organised street lamps and new forms of mining and things like that.
01:45:19 No, he was, I mean, this is what he did.
01:45:21 When he went to a city, he imposed Enlightenment ideas and reforms.
01:45:28 But Elber turned out to be a little bit too small for his ambitions.
01:45:30 Yes, and he was there 10 months, and he escaped, and unfortunately, over the next year or so, it was much less than that, really.
01:45:43 He landed on the 1st of March, and the Battle of Waterloo was on the 18th of June.
01:45:48 So in that period, tens of thousands of people were to be killed and wounded.
01:45:54 So he comes back in March, must as an army?
01:45:59 Must as an army, yes, absolutely.
01:46:01 He lands with only 300 men.
01:46:03 By the time he gets to Paris,
01:46:05 Marshal Messina has essentially let him get away.
01:46:09 Marshal Ney has said that he will bring Napoleon,
01:46:12 has told King Louis XVIII that he will bring Napoleon
01:46:17 back in an iron cage and then goes off and changes sides
01:46:21 and actually joins Napoleon.
01:46:23 Marshal Salt, who's the Minister of War, also changes sides.
01:46:28 And why do they do this, Andrew?
01:46:29 Seeing their old leader back again,
01:46:32 bring the band back together.
01:46:33 There's an element of the Blues Brothers.
01:46:37 But much more seriously,
01:46:41 the Bourbons have, even in those short ten months,
01:46:44 managed to irritate everybody.
01:46:47 So you've brought back the monarchy. 0.96
01:46:48 The monarchy is just as useless as it was before. 0.87
01:46:51 Yes. 0.87
01:46:51 Everyone realises it's a failed experiment.
01:46:53 Let's give Napoleon another go.
01:46:54 Yes.
01:46:55 And also the army is all on half pay, which they don't like.
01:47:01 The return of Napoleon means that they're going to be paid properly.
01:47:04 You have people like Davout who have never taken an oath of allegiance to the Bourbons and weren't about to.
01:47:14 So he's absolutely fine to fight back.
01:47:17 And yeah, so there's this.
01:47:19 But the interesting thing is that of the 26 marshals, by the time he lands in France, there are, well, three of them have died.
01:47:31 Lann, who I mentioned earlier, his great friend Bessier took a cannibal to the chest in 1813, and Poniatowski drowned in the Battle of Leipzig.
01:47:40 And then a couple of weeks later, Berthier dies on the 1st of June.
01:47:46 We don't know why.
01:47:48 It's a mystery.
01:47:48 he either fell from the window or he jumped from the window
01:47:51 or he was pushed from the window, I come up. 0.98
01:47:55 Sounds like modern Russia.
01:47:56 Yeah, well, the Russians were actually marching through the town at the time.
01:48:01 And so would it have been so difficult for the Russian commanders to think,
01:48:05 we don't want Berthier at the battlefield of,
01:48:08 we wouldn't have known it as Waterloo,
01:48:10 but we don't want Berthier helping Napoleon again.
01:48:12 Let's just send a squad round to chuck him out the window.
01:48:16 And this is where we come to Sir Arthur Wellesley,
01:48:20 the Duke of Wellington.
01:48:21 Yeah.
01:48:21 And how does he compare with Napoleon
01:48:25 in terms of military expertise, brilliance, genius?
01:48:29 Are they equally matched?
01:48:30 Is one better than the other?
01:48:32 Well, on the day of Waterloo,
01:48:35 Wellington is his best self
01:48:38 and he outmanoeuvres, outgenerals Napoleon.
01:48:42 But Wellington hasn't lost a battle in his life.
01:48:46 He's never lost a gun, even.
01:48:48 I mean, he's had to retreat from Burgos.
01:48:49 But otherwise, he has a completely unblemished record when it comes to fighting battles.
01:48:54 Some have been very heavy.
01:48:56 He's lost a lot of men, like at Tanavera.
01:48:59 But otherwise, I mean, he is a proper military genius.
01:49:02 And so is Napoleon.
01:49:04 But Napoleon's fought, whereas Wellington's fought sort of 35, it depends how you define a battle, obviously,
01:49:11 but 35 engagements, significant engagements.
01:49:15 Napoleon's fought 60.
01:49:17 And by the end of it, he had won 47, drawn six and lost six.
01:49:24 And there was a fascinating part of this story where,
01:49:28 didn't Wellington have the chance to get rid of Napoleon
01:49:31 right at the very beginning of the battle,
01:49:34 but thought it was ungentleman.
01:49:35 This is a great story, by the way.
01:49:37 Yes, one of his artillery commanders,
01:49:41 saw Napoleon on the other side of the battlefield. And it's quite easy to see because of the
01:49:47 distinctive hat and the grey coat, and also the fact that he's followed by these marshals.
01:49:54 And marshals wear the most extraordinary uniforms, fantastic plumes in their hats and
01:50:01 enormous brocaded collars and gold all over them and everything like that. And he's also
01:50:07 followed by Aide de Combes, other members of the staff. And so the artilleryman said,
01:50:13 you know, shall we take potshots at Napoleon? And Wellington wouldn't have it. He said,
01:50:21 he's supposed to have said at least, that gentlemen do not take potshots at one another.
01:50:26 How things have changed in more ways than just war. But Andrew, he's mustered the army in March.
01:50:34 I just want to understand how we get to Waterloo.
01:50:36 Is the reaction to him coming back to France,
01:50:39 okay, we've got to deal with this guy now?
01:50:41 From the coalition?
01:50:43 Yeah.
01:50:43 Yes, I mean, it's very fortunate for them
01:50:45 that they are in Vienna,
01:50:49 at the Congress of Vienna,
01:50:51 all talking to one another.
01:50:53 They're trying to decide the world order.
01:50:56 World order post-Napoleon.
01:50:59 And then they all hear on the 6th of March
01:51:01 that he's back.
01:51:03 On the 13th of March, they declare him an outlaw and they organize huge armies, 350,000
01:51:12 Russians, 150,000 Austrians, and then there are this Anglo-Prussian army up in the Netherlands.
01:51:23 So, again, sticking to his strategy of the central position, Napoleon decides in early
01:51:34 June to go north and to strike at the hinge between the Prussian army and what's called
01:51:42 the Anglo-Allied army, as well as the British army, there are lots of other soldiers, German,
01:51:48 in Belgium, Dutch and so on. And that's how the Battle of Waterloo happened. Yes. And how does it
01:51:55 go? Well, I see it, of course, through the eyes of the marshals, because he's come back. He only
01:52:03 has six marshals declare for him. And he leaves Davout, perhaps his greatest soldier, and the
01:52:12 man who had done the double envelopment at Auerstadt leaves him in Paris, which is an
01:52:18 insane mistake. You need to have your best men on the field with you. He gave some very
01:52:23 important jobs in Paris, governor of Paris and minister of war, head of the National
01:52:29 Guard and so on. But he should have been on the battlefield. He takes with him Marshal
01:52:33 Ney, who he only warns that they're going on campaign the day before the army actually
01:52:40 leaves. And he also takes Marshal Salt, who hadn't been a Chief of Staff for 15 years
01:52:48 since the Siege of January in 1800, but makes him Chief of Staff, which he shouldn't have
01:52:54 been because he was actually a very good defensive general against Wellington in the Peninsular
01:52:59 War latter stages. Suchet, who's another very good soldier, he leaves down in the middle
01:53:05 of France, then he was going to have Monsy in charge of his imperial guard, but Monsy
01:53:11 got sciatica the day before and so wasn't able to be at the battle. So one of the great questions
01:53:19 actually that I ask in this book is, how is it that of the 26 marshals, he only actually enters
01:53:27 the battle of Waterloo with two, Ney and Soult, who are both in the wrong positions and they hate
01:53:33 each other. And the other marshal who he has created since he landed from Elba, Marshal Grouchy,
01:53:40 he's sent off to, after a victory two days before Waterloo, sent off with 33,000 men and 93 guns
01:53:50 that could have made all the difference at the Battle of Waterloo. And Grouchy wasn't able to
01:53:56 get back in time for the battle. So do you really think that the reason he loses Waterloo is that?
01:54:01 is, I think it's, I think the lack of marshals is, I mean, he fought Battle Borodino with 10
01:54:08 marshals. He's down to two. And as I say, they're in the wrong position and they don't get on with
01:54:13 one another either. I think that Wellington, one must never take away the fact that Wellington
01:54:19 out-generaled and out-maneuvered Napoleon. His defence at Hougamont was superb, holding on to
01:54:28 the Haysaint farmhouse in the centre of the battlefield until 6.30 was also crucial. The
01:54:35 way in which the Dernon's central attack up the centre was turned back and then heavily punished
01:54:45 by the charges of the Union and Housegold Brigade. Lots of things are going on at the Battle of
01:54:50 Waterloo. But I think it's, what this book tries to argue at least, is that the lack of marshals
01:54:59 is a serious problem for Napoleon. Because there's a lot of people, Andrew, who think, you know,
01:55:05 obviously the battle of the Waterloo was the end of Napoleon, but if it hadn't have been Waterloo,
01:55:09 it would have been another battle, such were the French outnumbered. Exactly. Well, as I mentioned,
01:55:14 If you add the 150,000 Austrians and the 350 Russians, you've got half a million men who are marching.
01:55:21 So even if Napoleon had won Waterloo, he'd have found it impossible, I think, to have defended Paris.
01:55:29 And from there, he gets exiled to St Helena, where he meets his, well, kind of very peaceful end, right?
01:55:37 Not that peaceful in that he had cancer.
01:55:39 He had very bad cancer, so it was painful, painful for him.
01:55:44 But he doesn't sort of threaten the peace of Europe between 1815 when he lands on St. Helena and 1821 when he dies.
01:55:55 Why don't they just lop his head off the second time?
01:55:57 Because at this point you must be thinking, come on, this guy's gone too far now. 0.87
01:56:04 Well, he... 1.00
01:56:05 Very Russian question of me, I appreciate it.
01:56:08 First of all, he surrendered.
01:56:11 And so there's that.
01:56:14 Secondly, the Prussians could, they possibly would have shot him, but he very sensitively surrendered to the British, who considered that that was a bad idea.
01:56:27 There were political reasons why not, too, in that it would have probably started civil war amongst Frenchmen.
01:56:36 As it was, the Marshal Ney was shot by the Bourbons.
01:56:40 Marshal Murat was shot by the Neapolitans. 0.52
01:56:44 Marshal Brun was ripped to shreds by a royalist crowd in Avignon.
01:56:52 And years later, Marshal Mortier was assassinated in the streets of Paris.
01:56:56 So you do have a strong sense, I think, that the bloodshed should end.
01:57:02 and killing Napoleon wouldn't have done that.
01:57:06 And to wrap it up, what is the legacy of Napoleon?
01:57:09 Because some people say, well, a lot of his vision and his ideas
01:57:13 were inspiration from creating the European Union.
01:57:17 There's a left-wing version in France of people,
01:57:20 how they look at Napoleon.
01:57:21 There's a right-wing version.
01:57:22 How do you see this man and his legacy?
01:57:24 I think he was very important for a lot of the aspects of modern France
01:57:31 that are positive.
01:57:35 I'm not including the European Union in that kind of way.
01:57:39 The battles and the wars and the campaigns,
01:57:45 which is ultimately the reason that we think of him
01:57:48 as a sort of conqueror,
01:57:50 actually are not the most important things,
01:57:52 ultimately, about Napoleon.
01:57:54 What he did was to expand the Enlightenment
01:57:58 the Enlightenment into Prussia and Poland and Italy and so on. And the Code Napoleon, 0.69
01:58:06 for example, was still in effect in the Rhineland in 1900. And so, yes, I think one sees his
01:58:16 educational reforms, the Lyce, the Sorbonne and so on, the people still crossing the bridges
01:58:23 that he built over the Seine,
01:58:26 I think these are the sort of blocks of granite
01:58:30 that have survived of Napoleon's legacy.
01:58:32 Because it's very interesting,
01:58:34 because when we were talking,
01:58:36 when I was taught about Napoleon,
01:58:40 from the way that I was taught,
01:58:41 it was like, well, you know, he had his moment,
01:58:44 but then it all ended in failure.
01:58:46 But reading your book, doing the research for the interview,
01:58:50 I mean, this was a man who changed history,
01:58:52 particularly European history. And therefore can't be seen as a proto-Hitler figure.
01:58:58 You know, it's completely ridiculous. I think largely that was because a lot of the British 0.72
01:59:03 historians of the previous generation had grown up during the Second World War and were pretty
01:59:11 obsessed with Hitler and wanted to sort of look back in history and try and find Hitler equivalents.
01:59:17 Napoleon was emphatically not one of them. Well, I actually came here thinking
01:59:22 that you might have a grudging admiration,
01:59:25 but I don't think it's that grudging in your case.
01:59:27 I do think you respect Napoleon.
01:59:28 I do, but unfortunately with this Napoleon and his Marshalls book,
01:59:34 I have seen a side of him which is the micromanager,
01:59:41 the control freak, the person who denounces his Marshalls.
01:59:46 He doesn't show...
01:59:49 Ten years ago when I wrote my Napoleon biography,
01:59:52 I thought of his compartmentalization of his brain as being one of the best things about him.
02:00:00 But now I actually see, especially as I've been able to read all of the letters that have been published by the Fondation Napoleon that weren't there for my original book,
02:00:11 I now see a much more nuanced but sort of negative side of him
02:00:17 where he wasn't good at inspiring and leading his top team.
02:00:23 He was very, very good all the time, right to the end.
02:00:25 You remember, the men were willing to march on Paris in 1814.
02:00:30 But when it came to his top team,
02:00:33 he wasn't very good at mobilising his left talents.
02:00:37 Lord Andrew Roberts, what a pleasure it's been to have you back.
02:00:40 I hope everybody gets Napoleon and his Marshalls victory, rivalry and betrayal.
02:00:44 Great title.
02:00:45 We're going to head over to triggerpod.co.uk where our supporters are going to ask you
02:00:50 a few of their questions.
02:00:51 Thank you again for coming on.
02:00:53 Thank you so much.
02:00:54 I really enjoyed it, Constantine and Francis.
02:00:59 France seems to have difficulty maintaining any form of democratic government for a long
02:01:03 time.
02:01:04 Are they due for another change in their form of government in light of the rise of populist
02:01:09 dissent?
02:01:10 We'll be right back.