00:29:51The British and the French invented a new word for empire because they had to deal with President Woodrow Wilson.
00:30:00And President Woodrow Wilson, who created Wilsonian foreign policy, which is that everyone should have self-determination
00:30:07and that American foreign policy should be essentially a kind of moral,
00:30:12it should support human rights, it should be moral,
00:30:14it should support self-determination for everybody.0.99
00:30:17As soon as President Wilson, who was a tremendous hypocrite,0.97
00:30:20he was a Democrat, he went from the head of a university to president0.98
00:30:26in literally two years, extraordinary rise.
00:30:29And he was highly intelligent, but he actually had a higher conception
00:30:36of his genius than everybody else did. And when he came to Europe, he found out that it was
00:30:42actually incredibly hard to manage the Middle East and Europe. And he had to deal with Lloyd
00:30:48George and Clemenceau, who was the French leader, who were determined to get empires in the Middle
00:30:55East out of the Ottoman Empire. And dealing with Clemenceau and Wilson, Lloyd George said it was
00:31:04like sitting between Jesus and Napoleon, which is quite funny. So when he got there, he said
00:31:12everyone has to have self-denomination. But what does that mean? So out of this, the French and
00:31:18the British said, well, we totally agree with you about the empire thing, but we'll call them
00:31:22mandates instead. So mandate was just a new word for an imperial province until the people were
00:31:27ready to rule themselves. It actually says that in the League of Nations, in the clauses about
00:31:31the mandates. So, the French got mandate for Greater Syria, which we discussed a little bit
00:31:37earlier, and the British got a mandate for Iraq, which was originally called Mesopotamia, just to
00:31:42confuse your listeners, which means the land between the rivers. They renamed it Iraq,
00:31:48and they also got Palestine. And Palestine included what is today Israel and the West Bank
00:31:55and Jordan. And this was a completely invented entity. It wasn't that the word Palestine wasn't0.99
00:32:03ancient. Palestine is a very ancient name that goes all the way back to Philistia and the
00:32:08Philistines and was used at various times by the Romans as a net provincial name.
00:32:17they had Palestina Prima, Seconda, and so on. But in modern times, the Ottomans for 400 years
00:32:26had ruled this region, and they divided into provinces that they called Viliyets,
00:32:32ruled by a valley. And each one, you know, ruled from a certain city, ruled a certain area.
00:32:39So what is now Palestine, Israel, Jordan, was then ruled from Damascus and from Beirut.
00:32:47or, you know, and so that's how they called it. But Westerners had always used the word
00:32:53Syria and Palestine, which were nice, good old Roman names. And so Britain got Palestine and0.57
00:33:01Jordan, but almost immediately, they faced a problem because in World War I, they had promised
00:33:06this one family, the Hashemite family, that they would support their independence in the Middle
00:33:12East. And we were talking earlier about the promises that everybody made in World War I.
00:33:17The key thing about these promises are they made promises to everybody, not just the Arabs and the
00:33:22Jews in this sort of cliche history version, but also as we saw the Greeks, the Italians,
00:33:26the French, the Russians, I could go on, the Kurds, the Armenians. They made promises to
00:33:31everybody because they were desperate to win the war. They wouldn't have made these promises at
00:33:35any other time in the whole of human history, but they made them then because they were losing
00:33:41hundreds of thousands of men on the Western Front. Anything to try and get away to stop
00:33:47the slaughter on the Western Front. And so they made these promises. As we've seen,
00:33:54the Armenians and the Kurds didn't get theirs. The Turks destroyed the promises made to the
00:34:00Greeks and the Italians. And then, so now the British have to deal with the Arab and the Jewish1.00
00:34:06promises. Well, the Jewish promise was easy initially, because it was just like a homeland,0.98
00:34:12you know, in Palestine, not of Palestine. So whatever, it just meant we can allow more Jews0.93
00:34:18into this province, basically. Simon, may I interrupt you just there, because I think it's
00:34:23really crucial. How are the Jews there at this point? The history of the Jews is inextricably
00:34:32linked with Judea. And it's always important to realize that the word Jew comes from Judea,0.65
00:34:40which is the kingdoms of Judea which ruled what is now Israel, also known as Palestine.
00:34:49And so it's often said that Zionism was invented in the 1890s and it had never existed before.
00:34:57The opposite is true. Zionism was just a modern name for a specific political movement with many branches and mindsets and approaches, but which was a new name for an ancient, an absolutely ancient, 2,000 years ancient belief that the Jews were linked to Judea, hence the name, and that they were linked to Jerusalem.
00:35:24and they were virtually always Jews living in Judea, Palestine, whatever you want to call it.
00:35:34And even when they were expelled from Judea in 586 BC, in other words, 2,500 years ago,
00:35:45they were taken to Babylon and they dreamed of getting back to Judea, hence the famous song
00:35:51by the rivers of Babylon, beautifully performed by Boney M, among others.
00:35:58So that went right through the history. And there were other times they went back. In the Roman
00:36:04times, there'd been the Maccabean kingdom and the Herodian kingdoms of Judea. And King Herod,
00:36:11a Judean Jewish king, had built the second temple in all its glory. And that was the building0.93
00:36:17that was seen by jesus when jesus threw out the money changes etc that was the building that was
00:36:23the place he prayed in as a young jewish a young jewish man from from galilee the people who watch
00:36:31this show have generally done more thinking about how governments operate the most but there's a
00:36:36difference between understanding the problem and having actually built insulation against it that's
00:36:42world Mikel Thorup operates in. He's been living as an expat for over 25 years, visiting more than
00:36:47110 countries and calling nine of them home. He founded Expat Money nearly a decade ago to help
00:36:53others do the same. When he helped someone build an international plan B, the knowledge he brings
00:36:58is entirely firsthand. Every recommendation comes from something he has already done himself.
00:37:04Expat Money works specifically with freedom-minded families and investors who want to reduce their
00:37:09exposure on any one government or any one system. Second residencies, second citizenships, offshore
00:37:15banking, international real estate, legal structures that spread your life across borders.
00:37:20Mikkel has put together a free report called Plan B Residencies and Instant Citizenships. It covers
00:37:26five routes to a second passport, including one that almost never gets discussed. How a foreign
00:37:31residency functions as genuine political insurance, which countries actually make sense depending on
00:37:37what you're trying to protect and what it realistically costs. Go to expatmoney.com
00:37:42slash trigger or click the link in the description of this episode to download the report.
00:37:47There's no charge, no catch. That's expatmoney.com slash trigger.
00:37:53So it remained the home of the Judean people, all the Jewish people, and Judean and Jewish
00:37:59are entirely interchangeable. But Judea is useful because it reminds us of the land where they came0.66
00:38:06from. And in 66 AD, the Jews rebelled against Emperor Nero, the Romans. There was a huge Jewish
00:38:15revolt. It was crushed by the new Roman emperors, Vespasian and Titus. And they crushed the Jews,
00:38:22they crushed Jerusalem, and they destroyed the temple and the city of Jerusalem. And0.97
00:38:28the money was so vast that they got from the temple that they were able to build a Colosseum,
00:38:34which you can still see. That is the prizes. That's the prizes of the conquest of the temple.
00:38:41And you can see the picture of the triumph on Titus's arch, if you've been to Rome.
00:38:46And if you haven't, you should go and see it. But there was one more Jewish revolt, again,0.89
00:38:52in about 130 to 35. And that was the revolt of Simon Bar-Copper, Prince of Israel. And he
00:39:02they again defeated the Romans under Hadrian. Hadrian sent an army, and this time they really
00:39:08destroyed. They killed hundreds of thousands of Jews, and they changed the name of the land0.91
00:39:14from Judea to Palestina, which was also an ancient name, but the point was it was no longer
00:39:21belonged to the Jews. And it was then that the Judeans became Jews, and many, many hundreds of
00:39:28thousand started to live around, dispersed around the Roman Empire and in Persia and what is now0.64
00:39:35Iraq. And many communities started them. And the ones that lived in the Arab world were known as
00:39:41Sephardics or Mizrahi. And the ones that lived in Europe became known as Ashkenazi mainly. And
00:39:48the Jews that lived in the Arab world or the Islamic world, the Mizrahi, I mean, my family's
00:39:57descended from them, the Seabags and the Montefiores. And, you know, they had multiple
00:40:03identities. And one of the themes of the cauldron is understanding that the Middle East is full of
00:40:09multiple identities. We think everybody is a, you know, is a Palestinian or Israeli. No,
00:40:15it's actually very complicated. And, you know, you've got Syrian Druze, you've got Iraqi Kurds,0.73
01:22:45that many of the monarchies were created by generically, organically, such as Saudi Arabia
01:22:53and the Gulf States and Morocco, rather than created by Britain and France. But that's an
01:23:01interesting debate. But anyway, the British said to King Abdullah, why don't you just take the
01:23:08Arab bits of Palestine? The Jews will take the Jewish bits that they've been assigned, which0.96
01:23:13they've accepted. And you can take that and you can rule it and make a much bigger kingdom of1.00
01:23:19Jordan. And he agreed to this. And there were many meetings with the Jewish leaders.
01:23:25And this actually, it's a tragedy this didn't work, because again, this would have worked.
01:23:31He also said to the Jewish leaders, don't declare independence, because I'd love to create a big
01:23:37Jordanian, Palestinian, Jewish state. And I will make sure you're safe within it. And by this point,
01:23:47the Jews had been through the Holocaust. They'd been through the Arab revolt. And they were
01:23:52convinced that they needed an independent state. A view they'd come to later, come to quite late.
01:23:59We were talking earlier about what did Zionists want? Well, some of the Zionists wanted to be0.93
01:24:03part of an Arab state and learned Arabic and went to see King Faisal and King Abdullah to discuss it.
01:24:09Other ones just wanted farming communities where they would rule themselves, but be part of a
01:24:16larger sort of Palestine state. Other of them had much more, like Jabotinsky, had much more
01:24:22nationalistic viewpoints. And Jabotinsky created a militia, the Irgun, which was about to become
01:24:32part of this story. But even their views were surprising. I mean, Jabotinsky is now regarded
01:24:39as the precursor of Netanyahu and Likud. But he was an interesting character. And he said,
01:24:46what I want is not one Arab should be removed from Palestine. And I want to create a state
01:24:53where the Jews are safe, but no Palestinian Arabs are removed. And in fact, I want a state where
01:24:59when the Prime Minister's Jewish, the Deputy Prime Minister should be Arab. And when the0.93
01:25:03Arab's Prime Minister, the Deputy Prime Minister should be Jewish. In other words, in many ways,0.83
01:25:09a one-state solution, but one where there was real coexistence. So what Zionism meant is
01:25:15completely different from the view now being propagated in demonstrations by activists in
01:25:21Britain. Yeah, not to sidetrack you again, but reading the book, I kind of... Correct me if
01:25:29this is wrong, because you're the expert here, but it sort of felt like there's a process of
01:25:33mutual radicalization going on. Of course. Where the extremists on both sides always win out. At
01:25:39every juncture, it's the extremists that kill some of the civilians on the other side, and then they
01:25:44go, this is what they're all like. And it just, that's been going on the entire time. That's right.
01:25:49Yeah, it is. And actually, it does make you, you know, it makes you wish for a responsible
01:25:54imperial power or responsible supranational organization that actually could have managed
01:26:00this. Because the tragedy of 1947-48, which we're getting to, actually is relevant to this. It's
01:26:06like, United Nations agrees control of this. Britain completely abdicates any responsibility.
01:26:14An appalling act, by the way. And the plan that's offered and agreed by the United Nations,
01:26:20Yes, it offers a Jewish state for the first time,
01:26:23and it specifies this is a Jewish state, this is an Arab state.0.95
01:26:27And the problem is that it's absolutely unworkable, unworkable.
01:26:32And that, as I said, there are seven different kind of segments,
01:26:36all of them, half of them not properly joined.
01:26:39And there's no one to oversee how this would happen.
01:26:45So, of course, what happens is a drive to violence.
01:26:49And almost immediately, even though King Abdullah had secretly agreed with the British and the Jews that he would take over the Arab vets, which, as I said, would have been ideal, he is under massive pressure from the Arab League, which is a new organization just formed in Egypt.0.62
01:27:13and he's under massive pressure not to do this deal.
01:27:17But if the deal had gone according to plan,
01:27:21it would have solved the entire Israel-Palestine problem.0.67
01:27:27But instead, what happened was that militias,
01:59:13all of them. And because the Shah has alienated all of this rainbow of opinion, they all coalesce0.84
01:59:20around Ayatollah Khomeini. So of course, what do the liberal Democrats think? They think that he's
01:59:25really just going to be a kind of constitutional monarch, maybe like a Pope. And then there's
01:59:32the people, the extreme clergymen around in his inner circle, they hope that he will somehow rule.
01:59:40And in between, there are all these Marxists and liberals and socialists, and they all have
01:59:44different views. But Khomeini offends none of them. He remains entirely enigmatic. All he says
01:59:51is he wants to restore the constitution. What constitution? What does he mean by that? No one
01:59:57knows. He meets with the Americans. He tells them that he won't persecute the Jews in Iran and he
02:00:03won't exclude America. He'll still sell oil to America. He only will exclude Israel. Though if0.59
02:00:08you read his writings, he regards the Jews as an inherently evil people. And I quote what he wrote1.00
02:00:16in the book. But the point is, he plays this brilliantly and it gets better because crowds
02:00:24are now gathering in Iran in a momentum that becomes millions of people protesting. And
02:00:31constantly, things go so wrong and the Shah is blamed. There's the famous cinema that is lit on
02:00:39fire actually by Islamist terrorists, but the Shah is blamed. And the Shah is incapable of regaining0.81
02:00:48the initiative, the control of the narrative of what we would now call.
02:00:54And he's just unsure what to do. He sacks his prime minister and then appoints another one.
02:00:59That's a disaster. He sacks and then finds another one. Soon he can't find any prime
02:01:03ministers and he's unclear what to do. The crowds get bigger and bigger. The police and military
02:01:09fire into the crowds. There are funerals. And all the time, Ayah Khaled Khamenei is waiting.
02:01:14And so, ultimately, the Shah loses control and he leaves the country and he flies out of Tehran, hoping one day to return. And to his credit, he has refused really to allow massacres of the people.
02:01:36And of course, this is one of the problems of being a monarch. If you make yourself a bloody
02:01:42ruler, your son, you may destroy the throne for your son. And he wants his son to succeed ultimately.
02:01:48But it's important to realize how few people have been killed by the Shah. The Shah, again,0.98
02:01:56there's a narrative of the Shah as the brutal autocrat. He was certainly an autocrat. He was0.87
02:02:02certainly vain. There was certainly corruption. Clearly, he made a lot of mistakes. But the
02:02:10numbers of people killed are actually tiny. It's something like a little over 2,000 people
02:02:18die violently at the hands of the state during a 40-year rule. I'll repeat that, during a 40-year
02:02:26rule. And the great majority of those 2,000 are killed in the build-up to the revolution.
02:02:33And so, yes, the Shah had a secret police, the SAVAC. Yes, they tortured hundreds of people.0.52
02:02:40Yes, terrorists were killed in shootouts. And yes, they did fire into crowds at various times.
02:02:46But the numbers compared to the Islamic Republic are literally tiny. In one day in January this
02:02:55year, one day, which is the 8th of January, they killed thousands more people than the Shah killed0.94
02:03:04in 40 years. Now, that's an extraordinary figure. The Islamic Republic itself admitted to killing0.99
02:03:146,000 people between the 7th and 8th of January, 6,000. That is a vast understatement. The real
02:03:23numbers are something like 42,000. But that's 6,000 on that one day, which even the Iranians1.00
02:03:30lying in the completely mendacious Iranian Republic has admitted, is three times as much0.93
02:03:37as were killed under the Shah, under the autocracy of the Shah during 40 years. And by the way,0.74
02:03:44you know, this was the Shah that people were demonstrating all over the West about the evil
02:03:49of this man. So the story of the Shah is a fascinating one. But now the Shah has left,0.64
02:03:57and now there's this amazing moment when Ayatollah Khomeini flies back in. And when he gives a
02:04:04speech in chaotic scenes, he says, you know, I am the authority, and we are just going to punch in0.88
02:04:11the mouth, the present government. And what happens between now, 1979, and about in the next
02:04:20two years, between now and 1981, is a sort of masterclass in how to assemble absolute power.
02:04:28And he's helped by events. But what he gradually does is he appoints a prime minister,
02:04:35Bazargan, who is a sort of a suit-wearing, tie-wearing, a moderate Islamist. And by the0.81
02:04:42way, the sort of Islamist from one of the Islamist parties that in the 60s would have been happy to
02:04:47work under the Shah, but was alienated by the Shah. So he appoints him prime minister, but at the same
02:04:56time, he appoints a shadow government, an Islamic committee, which is run by his top people, who
02:05:02include Ali Khamenei, who became the supreme leader who was assassinated this year. And they
02:05:08set up a sort of committee in the school, in a school which becomes the real government of Iran
02:05:14that undermine the prime minister's government. And gradually, because a series of things happen,
02:05:21there's a rebellion by the Marxist opposition militias, and they put that down. They start
02:05:31to execute all the Shah's ministers and anyone they can find who's been involved in the Shah,0.71
02:05:36they start to execute. Then Saddam Hussein invades. And this is the key moment because0.75
02:05:43Saddam Hussein invades, hoping to reverse everything that the Shah had achieved in the0.96
02:05:48Straits of Hormuz, the Shat al-Arab, and the borderlands, and to conquer the oil fields0.93
02:05:55of the mainly Arab areas of Western Iran. And that enables Ayatollah Khomeini and his people
02:06:07to create the Revolutionary Guards Corps, to absolutely radicalize the regime,
02:06:16to crush all the national peoples, like the Kurds, who had hoped to achieve autonomy,
02:06:23and to destroy all the factions and militias that had helped them make the revolution,0.55
02:06:30including all these Marxist militias. And they kill all of them in astonishing kind of blood0.98
02:06:38purge. And out of this emerges something that no one had taken seriously. And the Americans
02:06:44had said, like, the Americans had said, he's a Gandhi-like figure. There's a famous, there's a
02:06:49famous, um, very ultra-liberal, um, sort of decolonialist professor, Professor Falk, who
02:06:56typically in the New York Times, nothing has changed, writes an article saying that, you know,
02:07:02Khomeini is going to be the great liberal humanist, humanitarian of our time. And you can read that
02:07:07article. We can all make simple mistakes. Yeah, simple mistakes. So, so he has pulled off this
02:07:13amazing confidence trick and this brilliant leger de main of political, I mean, almost
02:07:20political genius. And out of it, he creates a new constitution in which there is a president
02:07:25elected, there is a parliament, a magistrate elected, but actually they are all under a
02:07:33supreme leader, this jurist in power, a jurist in law. And that is which we call the supreme
02:07:41leader, but is in fact much more than that name gives. And it is basically a sacred monarch for
02:07:48life, pointed for life, and with absolute authority. And that is the system that we've
02:07:55inherited today. When he was dying, his own chosen heir, another very senior ayatollah,
02:08:05denounced his massacre of the opposition and said that he was much worse than the Shah,
02:08:09by the way, which he was by many, many, many multiples. And he dismissed him and had him0.52
02:08:16arrested. He couldn't quite execute him. And he appointed Ali Khamenei as his successor.
02:08:23And Ali Khamenei succeeded him after 10 years in 1989. And he ruled for almost 40 years,
02:08:31was almost as long as the Shah. And he plied a very radical path. He made a few concessions,0.62
02:08:42mainly the deal with the Obama deal, nuclear deal, which was a concession. But basically,
02:08:50he stuck to Khomeini's ideology and path, which was to ensure absolute Islamist control and0.83
02:09:00theatric control of the people of Iran. But at the same time, he added a new idea, which Khomeini0.77
02:09:07had also fostered, which was to exploit weakness in the rest of the Middle East and to create
02:09:15a web of militias that would take control of states and which would be what one of his top
02:09:23Generals, General Soleimani called the six armies so that Iran could be defended against America or
02:09:32whoever threatened it with Arab blood, with Arab militias, and without having to fight on Iranian
02:09:39soil. And this is the system that he was able to create thanks to the mistake possibly of the
02:09:46Iraq War, the America's Iraq War. Because in 2003, President Bush knocked out Iraq out of the
02:09:56power structure of the Middle East. And in doing that, he just removed the main counterbalance to
02:10:03Iran. Iraq is a sort of massively powerful country, and it's been removed from power there
02:10:09ever since. So for the next 25 years, or whatever we are, 24 years, Iran is removed as a power.0.83
02:10:16And Iran, Iraq is a rule of power, and Iran succeeds and is able to create what I call the0.91
02:10:23informal empire or the six armies empire. And this enables them to control essentially Iraq0.94
02:10:30for the last 24 years, 23 years. And then Syria under the assads, which by the way,0.82
02:10:38is the slaughterhouse of Syria. And I mean, 600,000 people were killed under that regime.
02:10:42and Lebanon through the paramilitary Hezbollah and Hamas in Gaza through Hamas and Palestine
02:10:52and Palestinian Islamic Jihad, which is their other little entity there, their faction that
02:10:58they control. And so that actually created a sort of informal Iranian empire that was really the
02:11:06most powerful Iran had been, you know, since Nadir Shah in the 18th century. Nadir Shah was the Shah
02:11:12who actually took Delhi. So he was a pretty effective conqueror. And before that, the most0.98
02:11:20powerful since the Sassanid Empire in the 4th, 5th centuries, 6th centuries. So, I mean, in a way,
02:11:29an amazing achievement. But all the time, they were also preparing, A, to try and get nuclear
02:11:36weapons, which so far, in the Islamic world and the Arab world, only Pakistan had achieved nuclear
02:11:44weapons, which they called the Islamic bomb. Iran also sought one, as we now know. And at the same
02:11:53time, the top commanders there, people like Vahadi, Soleimani, had created an idea which was
02:12:01of defense, which they called mosaic defense, which is that if they ever went to war with
02:12:08America, they would sort of divide up the country and everyone, according to a preordained plan,
02:12:16would defend their parts separately. So that if the command structure, the leadership was knocked
02:12:22out, the war could go on even more effectively in some ways. And at the same time, the other part
02:12:29of it was to destroy the hated Arab kingdoms, which they hated, and the moderate kingdoms in
02:12:35the Gulf. And one of the reasons that the big reason they hated them, when obviously they're0.73
02:12:40Sunni, the Iranians are Shia, but the big reason they hated them was that the lifestyle in places1.00
02:12:46like Riyadh or Abu Dhabi or Dubai is a sort of living reproach to the sort of economic disaster0.99
02:12:53and the dictatorship of Iran. But they would also take control of the Straits of Hormuz,0.90
02:13:00which is exactly what's happened. And they'd practiced that during the Iran-Iraq war in the
02:13:0580s. And so that's exactly what's happened. And so we reach where we are today, which is that in
02:13:16the end, they had said repeatedly, and their generals have said repeatedly, I quote them in
02:13:21the book, their big dream is a sort of apocalyptic war with America. Because in the 80s against
02:13:28the conventional army of Iraq, and also even more during the Iraq war where they organized
02:13:38the insurgency against the Americans, they had worked out how Americans so strong in technology,
02:13:45so vast in their grandeur and their majesty and their forces had this great weakness that they
02:13:51hated to lose men, and that their attention span was incredibly short, and that their political
02:13:57system was incredibly inconsistent and constantly changing. They could never have imagined they'd
02:14:03have such an erratic president as they have today. But all of these things convinced them
02:14:10that in an apocalyptic struggle, they could beat America in this way. And that's exactly what0.58
02:14:15they're trying to do now. It's that saying that I think is very popular in the Middle East. In
02:14:21the West, you have all the watches. In the East, we have all the time. Yes. Which brings us sadly
02:14:26to the end of our conversation, because we have, unlike the Iranians, run out of time. We have.1.00
02:14:31We've talked for over two hours, barely scratched the surface, it feels like to me,
02:14:35even though you've done a fantastic job laying it all out. So it means we must have you back
02:14:39to talk about this in more depth again at some point. I hope you'll come back. I'd love that.
02:14:43And thanks for giving my book a bit of a moment in the sun. And thanks for having me. It's been
02:14:48really interesting. For the listeners, it's called The Cauldron. Before we wrap up, Simon,
02:14:52what is the one thing that we're not talking about that we really should be?
02:14:55The one thing that we aren't talking about is something which I feature a lot in the book.
02:15:00And that is the beauty of Arab poetry. And what I wanted to do in the book,
02:15:07The Cauldron, was make sure that it wasn't just a book about endless wars and dictators.
02:15:15And I also wanted to celebrate the culture of the Middle East. And by that, I mean
02:15:19in history books, there's a real tendency just to have one bloody thing after another.
02:15:25And you don't get a feel of life passing. So this book, The Cauldron, the making of the modern
02:15:31Middle East, it tells you how the modern Middle East was made. But I also wanted some feel of
02:15:36how people live and have lived and will live in the Middle East. And the way I've done that is to
02:15:41use all sorts of Arab poetry, Iranian poetry, Hebrew poetry in the book. And I think the most
02:15:49moving to me are the famous suspended odes of pre-Islamic Arabia. And I've quoted them a lot
02:15:57in the book. And I just hope people enjoy them and understand that this should give a feel