TRIGGERnometry - August 21, 2026


Woke is Back and It's Worse Than Before

Hosted by
Mentioned
The Warning Signs Britain Ignored - Colin Brazier True History of the Middle East with Simon Sebag Montefiore

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 10 minutes

Words per minute

186.34

Word count

13,173

Sentence count

—

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

22

sentences flagged

Hate speech

21

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hello, everybody, and welcome to a very special new show that we are doing, rounding up the news of the week.
00:00:07 Joining me, of course, is Francis Foster, but also a very good friend of the show, Winston Marshall of the Winston Marshall Show and editor of Spike Tom Slater.
00:00:15 Great to have you guys. Looking forward to having this chat with everybody.
00:00:19 We've got three stories that we're going to focus on this week.
00:00:23 We've got Jason Hardy and the fallout from his tragic taking of his own life.
00:00:28 We'll talk about the debate about illegal immigration,
00:00:32 particularly there's the conversation,
00:00:34 the Home Office has very helpfully put out a leaflet saying it's wrong to,
00:00:38 it's illegal, in fact, to rape.
00:00:39 I don't know if you guys were aware of that.
00:00:41 Also, benefits for foreign nationals, we'll talk about that. 0.99
00:00:44 And finally, has the right, particularly in the U.S., gone full retard? 0.97
00:00:47 We'll talk about the Candace Owens, 0.97
00:00:49 the great debate between Candace Owens and Andrew Wilson.
00:00:52 All of that coming up very shortly.
00:00:55 But first of all, let's start with Jason Ardy.
00:00:57 uh he this was a cambridge academic clearly a fantasist made all sorts of claims he was a
00:01:03 top level marathon runner he didn't speak until he was 11 didn't read until he was 18 but went
00:01:08 to cambridge became a phd uh and when all of this stuff was revealed uh he got a lot of media
00:01:15 attention let's put it that way in fact he'd had a lot of media attention before this uh but now
00:01:20 the media attention turned negative and he tried to show his media attention indeed and he tragically
00:01:26 took his own life and now apparently uh the media killed them tom you've obviously covered this
00:01:32 story as are you responsible well apparently so i mean i woke up on the day after to find out that
00:01:39 i was actually guilty of murder um there's been lists doing the rounds on social media has anyone
00:01:44 seen this because there's nothing sinister is there about throwing up lists of journalists you
00:01:48 dislike and they're actually openly calling for embarrassing professional or personal information
00:01:52 about us in order to um give us a taste of our own medicine yeah i found the the meltdown after
00:01:58 jason arday's tragic death to be almost much more revealing and disturbing than the whole jason
00:02:04 arday scandal in general like people will be aware of the of the amount of lies that he told
00:02:09 the plagiarism accusations a lot of questions were asked about how the hell did someone like
00:02:13 this end up at cambridge university why did no one notice that all of these wild claims about
00:02:18 kind of herculean athletic achievements as well as you know a remarkably um a remarkable kind of
00:02:25 string of personal crises which wouldn't really have passed the sniff test but what's happened
00:02:30 since is first of all the idea that just reporting on or criticizing public figures is like tantamount
00:02:35 to driving them up to the bridge and pushing them off which i think is really really disgusting
00:02:40 and also just a complete rewriting of history i went to that vigil in trafalgar square on monday
00:02:45 night and it's as if these people either haven't been paying attention or just doubling down on
00:02:49 this kind of myth of saint jason in order to bash the press so it's we we like to think that we'd
00:02:54 escaped like peak blm a few years ago peak woke a few years ago but it's back with an absolute
00:02:59 vengeance now and they've chosen as their champion again a man whose story ended in very tragic
00:03:05 fashion but isn't hardly the sort of unimpeachable victim of a racist press that he's been made out 0.77
00:03:10 winston oh how many people i mean these claims with 30 000 are to be frank complete rubbish i
00:03:20 mean everyone knows that there is a kind of inflation of numbers at every demonstration
00:03:24 every organizer does it regrettably um i think someone pointed out that you couldn't even fit
00:03:29 30 000 in the entirety of trafalgar square and we were just up on the area just outside the steps of
00:03:34 the national gallery i in my very unscientific kind of method thought maybe we're in the low
00:03:39 thousands there i'm not 100 sure but it wasn't 30 000 that much i can tell you i think the official
00:03:45 capacity for trafalgar square is 10 000 you can't fit more than 10 000 people in that in that space
00:03:52 yeah so the stand up for racism all these people on the ardy side of the argument claiming there's
00:03:58 30 000 is absolutely lucrative and kind of fitting in this whole story i've covered the show i had
00:04:04 Nathan Kofnas, who was the former Cambridge fellow who revealed the story on Substack. Actually,
00:04:11 there's people who've revealed this story about Ade as early as when he started at Cambridge. And I
00:04:17 point to Simon Webb here, who's a YouTuber who goes under the name History Debunked. So
00:04:22 this has been covered for some time. And there have been journalists like, at the Times,
00:04:26 Jack Grove, and there's a professor at Plymouth University who was also covering this
00:04:32 um for called dr david harris and um before we sort of you know this story is crazy because it
00:04:39 sort of it's pulled down a whole infrastructure not just cambridge but individuals like simon
00:04:46 baron cohen uh like navara media and we're going to get into that but i think it's just
00:04:50 worth pointing exactly what the tragedy is and because you mentioned tragedy constant
00:04:55 this is a man who spent his entire life lying and his lies caught up with him he was a career con
00:05:04 man he was a fraudster now I don't take any joy in saying that we all fought short of the glory
00:05:10 of God I don't purport to be without sin the the real villainous thing though the thing which I 0.91
00:05:17 think is actually an evil thing was what happened at the end it's not just that he committed suicide
00:05:23 is that rather than face the consequences of a lifetime of lying and fraud fraud which by the
00:05:29 way he might have had legal um pushback against you know i don't know and we can't tell now but
00:05:35 i think technically some of the stuff he's done is illegal and he could have faced consequences
00:05:39 there but instead of doing that he decided to abandon his children and so it now there are two
00:05:46 children who are going to be fatherless and and that for me is a terrible thing and and a real
00:05:52 that's the real tragedy for these two children. And that's where my personal sympathies and
00:05:56 empathy lies. And that's the core of this story, which has now become a saga. A saga so much that
00:06:04 even yesterday, Nathan Kofnass, who has moved from Cambridge to Ghent University, was then suspended
00:06:11 at Ghent University, not just by anyone though, by a trans gynecologist professor and rector,
00:06:19 who was formerly called Dave de Sutter and is now Petra de Sutter
00:06:23 and was also a member of the Green Party in Belgium.
00:06:27 So it's just the most absurd saga that never seems to end.
00:06:32 I mean, by the time this episode goes out, I'm sure there'll be new developments.
00:06:37 Francis?
00:06:39 So I think one of the things that's really actually interesting about this case
00:06:43 and one of the things that people don't discuss about enough
00:06:46 is that a lot of people on the left of people who are pro Jason Arde will make the claim that
00:06:53 it was exposed by a racist professor Nathan Kofnast or a racist academic. And we can talk
00:07:00 about that whether Nathan is or isn't later on. But what's really interesting is, well,
00:07:05 the mainstream media wanted to expose this, yet they had a pervert, well, a literal knock on the
00:07:11 door from the police effectively silencing them and by the way this isn't not that it would matter
00:07:18 in the slightest this isn't the daily express that we're talking about this isn't even the daily mail
00:07:23 this isn't really the times this is the times educational supplement and everyone can drink
00:07:29 now as somebody who used to be a teacher and actually used to read the times educational
00:07:33 but you know as somebody used to read the times educational supplement week in week out pretty
00:07:46 much cover to cover it's not exactly the most right wing of publications and this is a very
00:07:52 very powerful example that if you can silence the press what you ultimately cannot do is silence the
00:07:59 truth because eventually the truth will get out and if it's not going to be legitimate sources
00:08:06 quote unquote then it's going to be somebody speaking about these sources that you do not like
00:08:12 ultimately the truth about Jason Arday who also he wasn't just a professor he had a professorial
00:08:19 chair possibly the highest achievement in academia that is the role and that is the position that
00:08:26 that man had and when you are on at that level and you do not deserve to be at that level
00:08:33 and you are a fabulous it will come out and unfortunately it came out in the manner that
00:08:41 it did but it wouldn't have happened in this way if we hadn't have silenced the press
00:08:46 last year and in the years before that i think the real reason it wouldn't have happened is if this
00:08:53 uh guy uh you know people say he's a vulnerable guy and i there's no way for us externally to
00:08:59 judge that uh perhaps he was perhaps he wasn't if he wasn't uh promoted way beyond his remit way
00:09:06 beyond his station and if we didn't live in a world in which people are given things by virtue
00:09:11 of the skin color they have the various abilities of disabilities and so on and putting him in that
00:09:18 position seems to me set him up for this not least because as stephen edgington who we've had
00:09:23 on the show who everybody uh will be aware of he he wrote a great article detailing how for six
00:09:28 years the mainstream media pushed jason ardy into this position into the position of being this
00:09:35 media star like if he'd just been an obscure cambridge academic who thanks to dei got pushed
00:09:41 into a position where he taught apparently very badly and and people didn't feel that they were 0.92
00:09:45 getting their money's worth okay no one would really give a shit right but the problem is once 0.92
00:09:50 you elevate this person into question time appearances into appearance on all sorts of 0.97
00:09:54 media platforms into being held up as this great bastard i mean there's there's this great clip we
00:09:59 we're not going to play today but of jason ardy talking to james o'brien which he absolutely does
00:10:05 o'brien like a kipper and just tells him how amazing o'brien is and how brilliant he is and
00:10:11 how wonderful he is and a brian is sitting there you know and i think he says oh it's great that
00:10:15 it's the end of the episode because otherwise i'd be crying so he went around getting all these
00:10:19 opportunities and then people go why has he got so much media scrutiny look to be honest with you
00:10:25 i think winston myself and actually all of us have been on the end of media scrutiny um you know and
00:10:31 it's not necessarily super pleasant when people are saying things about you invariably when you
00:10:36 are in the in the limelight in this way a lot of the things people say about you are not accurate
00:10:41 and not entirely fair that just tends to be what happens but if there's substantial basis for the
00:10:49 claims that people are making that's sort of the thing that really matters and the one other thing
00:10:55 i wanted to add is as well it seems to me like one thing that has happened since his taking of
00:11:01 his own life is we've actually built an incentive structure which encourages people in that
00:11:07 situation to do what he did. That's what I see here. Because if you're someone who is caught
00:11:13 out doing something in public that you shouldn't be doing, and you get a lot of negative media
00:11:18 attention, then you have this now, apparently, this one trump card where people who've been
00:11:25 covering your story fairly fair accurately and fairly will then come out and say oh my god i was
00:11:32 so wrong and we actually have a clip of aaron bastani who you know we respect and he's been on
00:11:37 our show many times from navara media and and there was someone else from navara media as well
00:11:42 who did this mea culpa struggle session and it's just worth seeing what this incentive structure
00:11:50 creates in the reaction of the media.
00:11:53 I wish I could ask Jason for his forgiveness for what I said, but I can't.
00:11:58 What I can do is ask for the forgiveness of his friends, colleagues, and family.
00:12:01 Now, they might not want to forgive me.
00:12:04 That's their right.
00:12:06 That's the point.
00:12:07 Forgiveness is theirs to give, not mine to take.
00:12:10 It's about them, not me.
00:12:12 Professionally, I erred, but ethically, and that's what I really care about, I really
00:12:17 screwed up.
00:12:18 I can't make amends, obviously, but I'm going to reflect on my behavior in all of this and how I can use my energies more productively, more productively to cover those issues our audience really care about, those stories that really matter, and how I can make a difference for the better, not the worse.
00:12:37 it's interesting i do wonder if if say a story about a right-wing academic say nathan kofnas
00:12:46 for example if nathan kofnas was involved in plagiarism and fabrication of of claims etc
00:12:52 would that be a story of interest to navara viewers and would would aaron have that same
00:12:58 reaction do you think tom no not at all i mean also it's worth pointing out that despite the
00:13:04 that we've seen these kind of hostage video style apologies i mean all aaron blessing was missing
00:13:08 there was a copy of today's newspaper and a reassurance that he was being treated properly
00:13:12 by his captors and i like aaron he's a smart guy um and he's also someone who's kind of reliably
00:13:19 interesting on the left which is quite a rare thing if we're being honest these days um but
00:13:24 not only is that kind of spectacle so pathetic it's also so out of whack with what it is they
00:13:28 supposedly actually did navara didn't cover that story particularly extensively i mean aaron there
00:13:33 there if i'm right in saying is apologizing for one tweet that he posted in which he referred to
00:13:39 our day as a con man which to be honest is more or less an accurate description that's one of the
00:13:44 things about all of this which is really concerning to me is that there's often kind of spasms of anger
00:13:50 with the press there's some kind of scandal there's some kind of horrific tragedy press intrusion
00:13:55 might be brought up um the occasions on which the press will just not tell the truth this is you
00:14:02 know hardly knew what's happening now is that the press are being accused of murder demonized smid
00:14:08 for telling the truth for doing their jobs for doing what cambridge and simon and schuster and
00:14:14 all the other kind of elite institutions that are they had any contact with should have done
00:14:19 which is to do a basic sniff test to look into the claims about his life and his academic record
00:14:25 that he had been making and that's what makes it so so sinister i think i mean you've got
00:14:30 activists saying that there was misinformation posted about jason arday there wasn't it was
00:14:35 just information which is put out there and it's often being presented as if this was kind of
00:14:40 scandal-mongering like there were just rumors about jason arday and that the press with no
00:14:44 thought to his state of mind were just circulating it if you look at just the reporting that went
00:14:49 into jack grove's times higher education piece he put together a 97 page dossier he had academic
00:14:56 experts pour over it he had people run it through software all the kind of different steps this was
00:15:01 a really overwhelming case and i think bless them but at navara media i don't know what's going on
00:15:06 there other than is this audience capture or is this just being caught up in the middle of one
00:15:11 of these sort of moral panics basically that we find ourselves in but um some of the details are
00:15:18 different you know to maybe to steel man their position you know if you if you feel that you've
00:15:23 contributed to someone taking their own life and you genuinely feel responsibility i mean there is
00:15:28 this kind of slightly moronic in my opinion view uh online which is like never apologize well no
00:15:35 like if you've done something wrong definitely apologize because it's a decent thing to do 0.74
00:15:40 but the problem that i see is like you said i don't think aaron or no i mean did anything wrong
00:15:46 aaron did talk about this story but he was right to talk about this story so to then apologize this
00:15:52 This is what I mean by saying you're giving people a trump card
00:15:55 by encouraging them to effectively take their own life
00:15:58 in a situation where they're facing fair scrutiny.
00:16:01 Because I think that's a really important point
00:16:03 because we are presenting the taking of one's own life
00:16:07 almost as a rational response to public criticism.
00:16:09 That's a really dangerous road to go down.
00:16:12 Really dangerous.
00:16:13 It's naturally going to chill the press as well.
00:16:15 Are we saying that you can't go after a politician
00:16:16 or a prominent person in public life, public intellectual,
00:16:20 because of what might happen?
00:16:22 I mean, that's a really chilling precedent to set.
00:16:24 I don't know why more people don't recognise it. 0.98
00:16:26 Well, listen, you've had your fare of shit from media and online and all the rest of it. 0.97
00:16:30 What do you think about this? 0.98
00:16:31 And I've issued public apologies.
00:16:33 I've definitely got opinions.
00:16:35 I can speculate about what's happening behind the scenes in Navarro media.
00:16:40 I'd add to just on what Aaron Bastani seems to be apologising for,
00:16:45 which is, as Tom rightly says, it's not necessarily even an opinion.
00:16:49 but let's take for the sake of argument it's an opinion that he had that Arde was a con man
00:16:56 does that mean that Aaron Bastani is no longer going to publish op-eds is that it are Navarro
00:17:02 media now only going to publish facts no more opinion I mean fantastic I'm thrilled if that's
00:17:07 the case but uh I thought you were pro free speech mate I'm pro free speech but uh even
00:17:16 navara media test my uh patience a little bit there um but uh uh it's put himself in a situation
00:17:23 i'm not sure how he can get out of it professionally at what point can he and can't he
00:17:29 report on things he's kind of created a trap for himself i i it's going to be very curious to see
00:17:34 how that plays out and as for um the apology now i i did issue an apology and i this is five years
00:17:43 ago now it's about i tweeted about andy no's book when i was still in mumford and sons and i upset
00:17:51 everyone around me because they were of the mindset that this was sort of evil and i was
00:17:57 contrite because i was like maybe i don't know everything here and i was sorry that the people
00:18:01 around me had been hurt now it might of course speculating here about bastani but it might be
00:18:07 the case that a lot of people at navarra media are very hurt and upset and and it might not be
00:18:13 reasonable that they're hurt and upset they might be hurt and upset but for completely the wrong
00:18:16 reasons and he probably is their friend and not only that it'd be a component that the core fan
00:18:23 base of navarro media won't be happy with the position that he took because it seems to be that
00:18:28 they are from that it's it's coming from the kind of far left you know these are openly socialist
00:18:33 communist woke people there's another curious thing about navarro media which is that they
00:18:38 spent the last six months repositioning themselves as against identity politics and against woke
00:18:43 but now they're doubling down now they're going like full woke and because it's not just Bastani
00:18:49 the editor as well was literally crying giving an apology so uh Navarra Media what they do next is
00:18:57 is extremely curious well I think the thing that's really interesting about this as well
00:19:03 is that whenever somebody dies in these types of circumstances they get elevated and they no longer
00:19:10 become a person anymore they become a political symbol not only they become a political symbol
00:19:14 but they sort of achieve sainthood which is how you talk about how people talk about jason arday
00:19:20 like he was this decent honorable man who was hounded to his death he did nothing wrong and
00:19:27 then this is ultimately tragic and all responsibility no responsibility is at the
00:19:33 hands of Jason Arde because he is a saint he did nothing wrong and all of the responsibility is at
00:19:40 the hands of the press and the thing that's also really interesting about this is you see these
00:19:46 apologies coming from Novara media and the reason is is because this shows that there is still a
00:19:55 civil war happening at the left in the left where you have the more rational actors like
00:20:01 Aaron and you have the hyper progressives the more radical and I thought that the more sane
00:20:10 members of the left in the UK like people like Aaron were starting to gain some traction were
00:20:16 maybe even starting to win that particular war but what we've seen with that abject capitulation
00:20:22 at navara is that the lunatics unfortunately are still very much running the asylum
00:20:29 indeed i think tom made a really interesting point about um well what about mine
00:20:37 yours was a bit
00:20:46 tom's point about the example and frankie's point about the example that uh of what are they
00:20:50 responsibility this is here. As a counterexample, I was thinking of Jonathan Aiken, who was a member
00:20:57 of John Major's cabinet, who was convicted of perjury, and he was sentenced to 18 months. I
00:21:03 think, I'm not sure exactly how much of that he served, but he certainly went to prison and came
00:21:08 out of there. I think he then became a vicar, a prison rector or something like that. Anyway,
00:21:13 that's the sort of redemption. I believe in redemption, and I also believe there was
00:21:17 possible possibility for redemption for our day and to do that he should have apologized because
00:21:23 he was the one who did the wrong thing and sorry wrong thing countless wrong things i mean i've
00:21:29 counted well in 60 plus occasions of unverifiable or verifiable lies that he he said so i mean
00:21:35 they're absolutely outrageous there was a way out for him who was it who was around him saying
00:21:40 you know stick in there you did nothing wrong the press are evil no they should have said 0.96
00:21:44 sorry you've actually screwed I love you mate you've screwed up here you shouldn't have lied
00:21:50 there's a way out though you can apologize and actually that would have been a great story and
00:21:55 unfortunately what's going to happen instead is he's going to be held as some sort of martyr for
00:21:59 the left you can say them at the vigil what were they saying they were saying rest in power and
00:22:05 they've lynched him I mean the people on stage DEI grandma Diane Abbott was saying stuff like you
00:22:10 know he's been it's a racial murder or whatever no they're making him to a victim and there was
00:22:16 another redemption an actual christian redemption way out of this that could have been the example
00:22:21 for society it would have been so healing it would have been great yeah i think that's a really
00:22:25 important point perhaps to wrap the segment up on which is suicide is a temporary permanent
00:22:30 solution to a temporary problem and the answer in the situation where you find yourself under fair
00:22:36 scrutiny for something you've done or a series of things you've done there's always another way and
00:22:40 that way is to admit fault apologize and by the way francis and i were joking about it you know
00:22:47 before this tragic uh end to the story his book if he'd wrote a book after all of this whatever the
00:22:53 book was about would have sold millions of copies you know like your life isn't over just because
00:22:58 you're being criticized in the media and i think that's a really important thing to say it's like
00:23:02 there is always a better way and taking your own life is just never the right answer and
00:23:07 you know if you aren't in that situation for whatever reason ask for help talk to people
00:23:12 don't just sit there bottle it up and and then uh do the thing that he did uh in summary though i
00:23:18 think it's interesting because um as we discussed it feels like the the woke movement really petered
00:23:24 out and like francis was saying he did make a good point uh as grudgingly i will admit which
00:23:30 was about the fact that actually it felt like the bastanis of the left were winning of and i read
00:23:36 aaron bastani tweets most of the time oh this is a solid point you know it's a very reasonable
00:23:41 logical point he's made there but we are now back to where we were in the summer of 2020 not scale
00:23:47 wise but in terms of the framework which is you've basically got a black person who's done wrong who
00:23:53 is a saint and now we talked about nathan kovnas the person who was one of the people who exposed
00:23:59 this who is now being fired and hounded by the very same people that say hounding somebody
00:24:04 is wrong and that seems to me like we've actually gone full circle and we're back
00:24:09 where we started but anyway let's move on by the way if you want no let's not move on winston would
00:24:15 like to say something else so i think we should actually just focus on nathan kofnas because
00:24:19 sure what's happening to him now is actually a big deal um so he's been suspended and there's
00:24:25 significant questions about him and the thing that was most curious to me was jk rowling
00:24:30 coming out and saying no he's a racist now i had nathan on the show i really drilled into this he
00:24:36 calls himself a race realist which is which would be interesting to ask you guys whether you think
00:24:42 race realism is racist and jk rowling certainly thinks it is but she hasn't explained why she
00:24:49 thinks it is what did it and that's curious from jk rowling because she's a gender realist right so
00:24:54 gender and race are not the same thing you can't change gender you can't change your chromosomes
00:25:00 race obviously you can't change race but over several generations you would
00:25:06 races are diluted whereas you can't dilute out of a of your sex right so they're not the same thing
00:25:13 but it's it's fair to say that there are differences in different races and most famous of
00:25:23 proponents of this is charles murray and his famous book the bell curve and it's also the
00:25:27 case that politicians most famously lee kuan yu have referred to this in making policy and in
00:25:34 with the case of singapore it was relevant to treating malays differently because they 1.00
00:25:40 had different results compared to other ethnic groups like the chinese and so he was like right
00:25:44 we need to we need to invest more in education for the malays and and so that's basically what
00:25:51 Kofnus' point of view is now having interviewed him and you can watch my interview of him you can
00:25:55 tell me if you think he's racist I didn't think he was going into the interview I was had generally
00:26:01 been of the of opinion that race realism isn't probably technically racist but most of the
00:26:07 people who engage in it seem to be a bit icky to me so my sort of feeling was I it's just a topic
00:26:13 I'm not really interested in I don't see the point in in why curiously Kofnus was actually arguing
00:26:20 where he thinks affirmative action or uh you might call it sort of positive discrimination
00:26:27 or as the woke call it dei might actually be preferable because there are different outcomes
00:26:33 for different groups because of uh differences in iq differences in in various things and whether
00:26:39 it's genetic whether it's cultural there's there's mo it's multivariate anyway i wanted to ask you
00:26:45 whether you think race realism is racist and that that's a the question here over to you tom
00:26:53 i will make it i will make it because i know we do want to move on i like you winston whenever
00:26:59 you see someone particularly preoccupied with this topic the red flags go up to a certain degree
00:27:03 it's not something that i've put loads of thoughts or reading into i've been pretty kind of persuaded
00:27:08 by a lot of the criticisms of that perspective people like wilfred riley i know you've had him
00:27:12 on the show guys as well as he writes for spikes has talked about how much this is actually just
00:27:17 sort of cultural which is then transposed onto this idea of race and people make this like neat
00:27:21 comparison between those of us who are kind of trans skeptical why aren't you interested in this
00:27:26 race and IQ stuff I think they are quite fundamentally different things for the reason
00:27:29 that you say I mean gender isn't a spectrum race is it's one example but there's so sometimes at 0.98
00:27:35 the very least I'll say that um I remain to be convinced by those kinds of people I do sometimes
00:27:40 wonder about their motives although I wouldn't speak to Nathan Coughness particularly having not
00:27:43 sat down with him or not read his work in any detail one thing I will say is that having been
00:27:48 at that vigil he was the only one who's being named from the platform over and over again so
00:27:53 I'm not surprised at all that he's faced these professional ramifications I think they could
00:27:56 easily also be kind of personal security ramifications as well he has become the kind
00:28:01 of central villain of this story even though it's also the the press in general being dragged into
00:28:06 it so um if i were him i would be pretty concerned at this moment uh yeah i've so nathan engaged with
00:28:13 me over my uh fandom of thomas soul and he disputes a lot of the claim that thomas soul makes about
00:28:20 the importance of iq and the hereditary nature of iq uh i've read a lot of the stuff that he's
00:28:26 written my understanding is it's a fairly contested area of scientific research so
00:28:31 nathan represents a world view within that and you're right to say i think that people who like
00:28:37 to talk about this stuff are invariably dodgy but there are exceptions and i actually suspect nathan
00:28:42 is he strikes me as a sort of aspergy uh you know just obsessed about the black and white truth of
00:28:48 the matter type of thing and somebody can be interested in the truth to the point where
00:28:55 it's kind of that autistic people tend to get very often into this position but this is actually one 0.70
00:29:00 one of the ironies of the case because he's actually more autistic than our day yeah and
00:29:05 he's getting but i have to say i just think it's while it's an interesting conversation and we can
00:29:10 talk about it it's not my impression that nathan is racist and i think the answer to is race
00:29:16 realism racist is not necessarily but often is adopted by racist people uh and there are you
00:29:22 know measurable differences in iq but we don't necessarily fully understand what they're down to
00:29:27 nathan would argue it's overwhelmingly hereditary other people would point to you know jews arriving
00:29:33 in america having very low iqs and within a generation or two having pretty above average
00:29:38 iqs again nathan will have his own explanation for that but to me i actually think we're playing
00:29:44 the woke game here which is we're saying well if you're criticizing jason ardy it's it really
00:29:50 matters what your views are no what matters is was jason ardy a fantasist or was he not was he lying
00:29:56 or was he not that's what matters here and if it turns out that nathan kofnas told the racist joke
00:30:02 in a pub 33 years ago or whatever uh then that doesn't really matter and it's not relevant to
00:30:08 this discussion is my view i disagree it's absolutely the case that when it comes to the
00:30:13 story of our day that stands on it on its own two feet and should be right deliberated and
00:30:20 thought out and understood in its own two feet but there are many offshoots to this story which
00:30:25 are themselves important stories and the treatment of Nathan is an important one and I don't
00:30:31 particularly want to do episodes on race realism but it's a it's a side story that's now being
00:30:37 talked about because of of this and it's important to understand why the left are villainizing him
00:30:43 there's other sides of this story for example Simon Baron Cohen you've had him on the show
00:30:47 Cambridge University friend of Jason Arde he was also he's also the the director of the
00:30:54 Autism Institute or whatever it is called at Cambridge he was defending Arde fiercely now
00:31:03 it seems to me that that itself is a story right because Simon Baron Cohen should know that Arde
00:31:10 was not telling the truth he's indefensible and not only that it seems almost certainly the case
00:31:18 that Arde didn't have autism at no point as Simon Baron Cohen said in his various BBC interviews
00:31:24 I've heard that he himself diagnosed Arde it was it seemed that it was on his CV or self-diagnosed
00:31:31 but he's laying down his reputation at the feet of Jason Arde it's it's done unbelievable damage
00:31:38 to go away from your point of disagreement with me here though you my point was they're going to
00:31:44 attack nathan kofnas no matter what because they can attack him to blame him and others for covering
00:31:52 the story instead of blaming themselves for elevating jason ardy to to his position yes
00:31:57 that's all i'm saying let's move on though because i don't think this is super super important to
00:32:01 carry on more importantly lads we're all men here and i don't know if you know but rape in britain
00:32:06 is illegal uh this is a leaflet yeah it is well francis looks very surprised man your
00:32:12 teaching is coming into a whole new light here with that revelation guilty on all charges thank
00:32:17 you not guilty doesn't is not the same as innocent but anyway um so uh i don't know if you know this
00:32:25 but the it's it's illegal in the uk also mutilating the genitals of children apparently is as well
00:32:31 uh this is a leaflet we can probably throw it up on the screen that's been issued to asylum seekers
00:32:36 in the uk which has understanding behaviors and expectations for asylum seekers and some of the
00:32:42 guidance is stuff like you probably shouldn't rape people and this is absolutely fascinating
00:32:48 because we have for a very long time of course been told that there is absolutely no reason to 0.97
00:32:54 suggest that uh people coming here from other countries which uh basically i think it's fair
00:33:01 to say treat women sort of as a you know a second class cattle um they may have a slightly different
00:33:08 attitude to sexual uh behavior and in fact some of the crime statistics of course do bear that out
00:33:13 but what this leaflet is showing is while they are telling us that diversity is our greatest strength
00:33:18 and uh you know no human is illegal and all the rest of it they actually know that there's a
00:33:24 problem and they always did i think that's so clear for why it's probably tempting to think
00:33:29 that they were just blind to this that when they rebuffed the suggestion that if you imported
00:33:34 thousands upon thousands upon thousands of men from a country like afghanistan entrenched culture
00:33:40 misogyny rampant sexual violence that all those issues would just like melt away as soon as they
00:33:44 stepped foot on the white cliffs of dover it was tempting to think they were just like really
00:33:47 naive this proves that they knew all along and they just let it happen anyway and it's a it's a
00:33:53 grim kind of progress that we've witnessed over the course of the past 24 hours because after
00:33:57 years and years of whenever you would raise these concerns whenever victims would raise these
00:34:02 concerns you would have like an establishment which would just say shut up that's not true
00:34:07 this is misinformation you're being racist now i think because we've had this like steady drumbeat 0.72
00:34:12 of stories in the press there was one just this week of two afghans who raped a woman at knife
00:34:17 point in a park when she was on a first date with someone absolutely horrific story now they can't 0.91
00:34:23 really get away with that so the answer is okay okay i hear what you're saying let me have a word
00:34:27 with them that seems to be the kind of plan here like the idea that you can just even producing
00:34:32 this leaflet doing the graphics for it coming up with these nifty little one-liners did no one in
00:34:36 the room think we could just not let them in we could just send them back when they come i don't
00:34:42 want to sound simplistic but surely that thought passed their mind at some point so yeah it's
00:34:48 confirmed a lot of what we knew already but bloody hell in what fashion
00:34:52 i think also i mean look kemi badenoch has spoken many times about talking right and
00:35:01 governing left which is effectively gaslighting the conservative government over the period of
00:35:07 14 years gaslighting the nation on many things but particularly when it comes to immigration
00:35:12 promising the immigration would be lowered it wasn't lowered not only was it not lowered
00:35:16 it increased. Illegal immigration increased. Keir Starmer talking about smashing the gangs.
00:35:23 The gangs weren't smashed. Not only were the gangs not smashed, it looks like they're even
00:35:28 more profitable than they have ever been. And this is just another example of government
00:35:33 lying to us. And my concern is, number one, these horrendous crimes that are happening up and down
00:35:39 the country and the fact that this type of leaflet would need to be produced. But there's
00:35:45 is something far deeper going on here which is this is damaging our institutions and our trust
00:35:52 in government what is going to happen to our democracy when people go you know what what's
00:35:57 the point in even voting you're not going to do anything that you say you're going to do all you're
00:36:02 going to do is not do the thing and even worse going to lie to us and as a result of your lies
00:36:09 and your actions innocent people are going to be hurt and have had the most heinous crimes
00:36:14 inflicted upon them so why should i vote for you and then once that happens which we're pretty much
00:36:22 really close to we're in a very very very dangerous place societally and it's terrifying
00:36:29 you know when we decided to do the show francis said i'm going to be the comedic voice i'm just
00:36:35 going to keep up light-hearted and do the banter thanks for that mate
00:36:39 what were your thoughts i i was just looking up some facts before about the propensity for crime
00:36:50 amongst foreign nationals now foreign nationals about one in five in britain are foreign nationals
00:36:55 uh they are sorry i make uh so that's 10 they're sorry they're about 10 to 15 sorry 10 to 14 percent
00:37:03 the adult population what's actually this is a side point but amazingly difficult to get accurate
00:37:08 numbers on foreign nationals in britain like we actually don't know who's in our country
00:37:12 we don't know how many they deliberately don't collect that data yeah well we don't know how
00:37:17 many illegals there are there's as little as a million as many as two million but if we take
00:37:23 the rough uh projections foreign nationals uh account for 14 to 15 of known convictions of
00:37:30 sexual offences they are account for 26 to 28 percent of convictions when it comes to sexual
00:37:38 assault on a female and 21 to 22 percent of rape on a female age 16 or over so way higher proportion
00:37:48 uh convicted let alone perpetrating and and you know those who are not being convicted
00:37:54 than the actual proportion of the population that they represent but also it's more specific to some
00:37:59 nations I don't hear much about sort of German rapists but we do hear a lot about Afghans you
00:38:05 know was it Wayne Broadhurst the guy in Uxbridge who was murdered by an Afghan there was the
00:38:10 Rhiannon White the woman who was murdered by a migrant and it's very specific countries they're
00:38:16 coming from the UK specific evidence on Afghan crime and this is from the MOJ it's that they're
00:38:25 20 times higher than a brit likely to um commit uh sexual offense than a british national 20 times
00:38:32 higher and in germany uh the rates are not as high as that but eight to ten times higher but the data
00:38:38 is better in germany so um of afghans recorded uh suspect rates of roughly 1700 to 2500 per 100 000
00:38:49 compared with 160 to 270 per 100 000 for german nationals so eight to ten times basically certain
00:38:55 countries there is a higher propensity for this kind of crime and of course they don't talk about
00:39:03 that they they the labor left they can't talk about that instead they say all men it's a problem
00:39:07 with all men but actually though it's specifically it's much worse for these people from these certain
00:39:13 specific cultures because not all cultures are equal believe it or not and we actually have a
00:39:18 clip of jess phillips the the labor politician talking about this uh in exactly the way you
00:39:23 described i understand that it's interesting because it's to asylum seekers we also run an
00:39:29 enormous uh enough campaign teaching men in the country uh about how their behaviors uh were uh
00:39:37 could could be uh perceived uh whether that's stalking behaviors and harassment behaviors
00:39:42 harassment in public. That was to everybody in the country. We also have started a process
00:39:48 of ensuring that boys and girls in schools undertake education around the expectations
00:39:55 of happy, healthy relationships and actually the dangers of a lack of consent, for example.
00:40:01 So this is just one example of a preventative measure. I understand people are interested
00:40:05 because it's asylum seekers at the exact same time the home office uh ran uh ran a multi-million
00:40:12 pound scheme for men across the entirety of the country what is this like yeah i don't get it
00:40:23 yeah go ahead sorry go ahead was that jess phillips is a repeat offender where this is
00:40:28 there's that clip there back in 2015 2016 in the wake of those horrific sex attacks in
00:40:34 cologne committed by very recently arrived north african and arab migrants you know thousands upon
00:40:41 thousands of cases and she likened it to women getting catcalled in birmingham for friday or
00:40:46 saturday night so this kind of pivot that always takes place it's like the left's version of all
00:40:51 lives matter to a certain extent you're trying to talk about something very specific and then
00:40:55 they have to generalize they have to kind of shift the goalpost they have to pretend that there aren't
00:41:00 specific problems with specific groups and specific cultures you know when you see those signs up
00:41:05 on the tube saying if you press your genitals against a woman at rush hour that's not okay
00:41:10 who do we think that is for it's not for British citizens it's not for people who might have been
00:41:15 of migratory background but have been here for a couple of generations it's for people who are 0.91
00:41:19 coming in from cultures which again in any other context people would willingly admit have backward
00:41:25 reactionary attitudes towards women i mean the treatment of women in afghanistan for instance
00:41:30 is something that a few years ago you would be accustomed to reading a kind of panicked amnesty
00:41:35 international press release about it because of the ingrained culture of misogyny child marriage
00:41:40 forced marriage the likelihood that if a woman is raped she's she's more likely to be punished than
00:41:45 the perpetrator all of those kinds of things it comes like dead last georgetown university did a
00:41:50 kind of table for women's equality of a hundred and something countries they looked at it comes
00:41:55 last for every conceivable measure of women's well-being and yet again the idea is that that
00:42:00 will just disappear upon contact with terra firma in the uk and it's particularly strange because
00:42:05 everyone remember about 10 years ago there was this really frankly dumb conversation that was
00:42:10 going on about rape culture in the uk so there was this idea that lads mags page three dapper laughs 0.77
00:42:17 were essentially creating a permissive attitude amongst British people but white working class
00:42:23 Brits in particular towards sexual violence and yet when you're confronted with something like 0.92
00:42:27 Afghanistan which I think is fair to say has a rape culture or a permissive attitude or 1.00
00:42:31 certainly very backwards attitudes towards this particular issue suddenly you get crickets so in 1.00
00:42:38 some case I think it just it shows the hypocrisy but also shows the the desperation that even when
00:42:42 this stuff is staring them in the face they have to pivot you just think if they could just let
00:42:46 this go particularly the labor party would have so much more credibility they wouldn't be hanging
00:42:50 on to power in the way that they have been but they they can't let it go and the psychology of
00:42:55 why is really interesting to me well yeah it violates their sacred dogma doesn't it because
00:42:59 what they will always want to do is a pretend that all cultures are the same but even more
00:43:05 importantly when they're invariably forced to admit that some cultures are different they can't
00:43:09 quite make the connection between a culture being different and the people who come from that culture
00:43:14 being different so we can admit that afghanistan is a patriarchy because we hate patriarchy but
00:43:19 we can't admit that men young men who come from a patriarchal society will tend to have sexist
00:43:26 misogynistic and frankly rapey attitudes to women uh some of them that's not to say that all of them
00:43:32 are like that but in terms of the prevalence of those types of views and that type of behavior
00:43:37 it's incredibly more uh incredibly obvious and winston was talking about the crime statistics
00:43:43 of foreign nationals i actually think it's really important to make the distinction that he then went
00:43:47 on to make because you will have lots and lots of places around the world from which people have
00:43:52 come here but i don't imagine the new zealanders or like he said germans or you know people from
00:43:58 other societies that have similar attitudes to women's rights and so on are likely to massively
00:44:04 ramp up sex offensives in the uk but you do see that for people from certain regions of the world
00:44:10 and it's not by accident it's because the places from which they come have a different attitude
00:44:16 to women and if you are a woman who's ever traveled alone to those parts of the world
00:44:21 you will know this from your direct experience and it opens people's eyes and when they do that
00:44:26 in a very obvious way there's another also look no i was just going to say like do this little
00:44:34 thought experiment imagine those stats applied to white men what do you think the guardian headlines
00:44:40 would be. I would guarantee they would run that story all day, every day, three times at breakfast
00:44:47 time. But they simply can't do it. And do you know why? It's because anybody who talks, let's
00:44:53 imagine Aaron Bastani decided to talk about that story openly and honestly on Navarra Media.
00:45:00 Aaron would have to release a video every day apologizing. Because that's what happens in the
00:45:07 left when you go against your own team or one of their supposed mantras. You can't do it. Even
00:45:14 when you tweet something as innocuous as saying Jason Arday was a con man, you can't do it. And
00:45:22 if you do do it, you've got two options. You either apologise or you get kicked out by your
00:45:26 own side. What's it going to be? And that's the dilemma everybody on the left faces.
00:45:32 One last word on this before we run. 0.80
00:45:33 there's another logic fallacy or contradiction which is that if all men it's a problem for all
00:45:40 men in britain already not just foreign nationals then that implies that it is our culture to
00:45:47 sexually abuse women and so actually these people don't need a pamphlet because they are just the
00:45:53 same as all the other men so it's like not necessarily not necessarily in in the first place
00:45:57 uh well the other issue of course with immigration there's been a big debate this week
00:46:03 is finally after many years and i've been advocating for this obvious policy for for years now uh there
00:46:10 is uh apparently a debate in the uk i don't know why it's a debate it's a self-evident thing that
00:46:15 needs to be done about the fact that foreign nationals in britain should not have access to
00:46:20 the benefit system and uh the reform party and also i think restore have both uh been talking
00:46:26 about this i believe the tories have now adopted it as well so effectively the entire center center
00:46:31 right is now come to around to this position which as i say i think is eminently sensible
00:46:36 but there's now a debate we're having a debate about people from whether people from other
00:46:41 countries should get taxpayers money in the uk and i'm just i don't really we we seem to just
00:46:48 this is the thing that seems to happen in our country now every week where we just have some
00:46:53 sort of moronic debate about something that is incredibly obvious and i say this i'm going to
00:46:59 use my privilege you know immigrant privilege here as someone who lived in this country as a 0.82
00:47:04 foreign national for many years it would never have occurred to me to even attempt to claim
00:47:09 benefits not least because the visa you get in your passport when you come here says no recourse
00:47:16 to public funds but apparently once you get on indefinitely to remain or once you get onto other
00:47:22 forms of of visas that you can have in this country you now have access to the benefit system 0.94
00:47:27 you can live in social housing if you're an asylum seeker we just pay for you to to do whatever it
00:47:31 is you need to do dental appointments and so on how is this even a debate no it is yeah isn't it 0.99
00:47:38 because when you talk to people if you said kind of thought experiment you move to another country
00:47:43 could be somewhere in europe could be somewhere more far flung would you expect in relatively
00:47:47 short order to be able to just go on the dole they would be like of course not the assumption
00:47:50 would be if you couldn't support yourself you might go back to the country that you came from
00:47:54 you might find some other way of supporting yourself it's uh particularly kind of british
00:47:59 mania we have in this particular area and it does speak to the fact that just the idea of
00:48:04 citizenship has just been so diluted and degraded it should mean something of course it should also
00:48:10 mean that people are able to join it provided that they've contributed provided that they've
00:48:13 integrated all of those all of those things that basically everyone agrees with but um the fact
00:48:19 that just by being here or just by being here for a certain amount of time that this kind of
00:48:23 automatically kicks in. It's such a casual way to think about joining a country or being part
00:48:29 of a country. And it's also just completely destroying any sort of faith or support in
00:48:34 the welfare system. People need to feel like when state funds or when taxpayers funds really
00:48:40 are being doled out, that they're being doled out for the right reasons into people who you can
00:48:44 kind of think of as part of the we of a country. As soon as that breaks down, and this is why I
00:48:50 think Labour should recognise this being they are the kind of premier welfarist party the whole
00:48:55 basis on which that kind of system has public support just corrodes I think that the one
00:49:02 wrinkle in all of this is because people got so used to indefinite leave to remain there probably
00:49:05 will be a lot of people who for all intents and purposes are integrated are part of the
00:49:10 national community have got kids with a British partner just never bothered to make that extra
00:49:15 step towards citizenship who might get kind of caught up in the mix of all of that but broadly
00:49:20 speaking i completely agree citizenship has to mean something yeah and i have friends like that
00:49:24 sorry to interrupt but i have friends like that and there is an obvious solution there which is
00:49:30 okay look we understand you maybe wasn't weren't that keen for whatever reason it takes a bit of
00:49:35 money it takes a bit of time etc in the situation our country finds itself in we're going to have to
00:49:40 be a little bit more strict about how this is done so please apply for a british nationality
00:49:45 would be happy if you've lived here for 20 years and fully integrated go for it that's fine uh
00:49:50 winston francis thoughts well uh so just on some details because this is this is worth uh just
00:50:00 highlighting so there's about 1.26 to 1.3 million people in britain and in in the uk uh on universal
00:50:08 credit they are claiming over 10 billion pounds a year and uh so those are non-uk uh or irish
00:50:18 nationals right so of the 7.5 to 9 million foreign nationals in the uk 1.26 1.3 on universal credit
00:50:27 another 620 000 are on other benefits which means that there's something like one in four foreign
00:50:34 nationals in the uk are on some sort of benefits and i mean it's extraordinarily high and they're
00:50:41 claiming over 10 billion pounds a year in a country where with three three million three
00:50:46 trillion pounds worth of debt and we're spending 100 billion on debt interest each year right so
00:50:51 just for some context there as for how this came about i'm trying to understand this like did we
00:50:57 become more relaxed like why is it that this is has become the case and actually we've actually
00:51:02 always been quite strict on who can claim such benefits and this goes all the way back to the
00:51:11 poor laws where you had to have legal settlement in a parish if you wanted to claim benefits it
00:51:17 goes through the old age pension act in 1908 and and it continues what's changed is not that the
00:51:22 law on who can claim it it's changed is how many more people have become within the defined
00:51:32 defined as settled and so as you say whether it's asylum seeker indefinitely for remain
00:51:37 or various different settlement where they can apply this has jumped that's what's actually
00:51:41 changed and it's jumped massively since 2020 in 2022 there were only 900 i mean i say only 900
00:51:47 000 is extraordinarily high number but they're 900 000 so 400 000 more people on universal credit
00:51:54 since 2022 so it's because of the how they can uh claim to be settled and so they pass through
00:52:02 the hoops that way so that's the the big uh change as far as i've understood it now where there's
00:52:08 i think maybe a debate is if they're playing national insurance rather than if they're paying
00:52:15 just their taxes uh income tax um national insurance like is there an argument there that
00:52:22 they should have some sort of claim on on the pension that would come from from that i think
00:52:27 that there is an argument i would take the same position was that if you're a foreign national
00:52:31 you don't you still have to pay for the privilege of being in our country but you don't get to enjoy
00:52:37 the benefits unless you become a citizen so there's an incentive to become a citizen actually
00:52:41 buy into the system and and probably be a part of it but there's also i guess the argument is that
00:52:46 maybe employers would should be given a relief where they don't have to pay for the pension
00:52:51 of employees if they they are foreign nationals and that might ease these things for employers
00:52:58 i i don't know so that seems like a small detail to like get bogged down in the big headline though
00:53:03 is that we've just let anyone in and become uh settled and well this is this is really the
00:53:10 problem with mass immigration right is you can have a very relaxed posture towards many many many
00:53:16 things until you bring in millions of people in a very short space of time in which case the entire
00:53:22 system completely breaks down not because the rules were actually bad necessarily in and of
00:53:28 themselves but because they're incompatible with a fraying society with plummeting levels of social
00:53:34 trust and and all of the other consequences that ensue when when you have you know millions and
00:53:40 millions people are not by the way tom made the point about the labor government let's be honest
00:53:44 this all happened under the conservative government this is not a left versus right 0.99
00:53:49 thing it's a stupid versus not stupid thing and i'm glad finally that there are some non-stupid 0.99
00:53:55 people in the politics are waking up to this reality what do you think francis well i think 0.99
00:54:00 what this what this is is look let's put it in real world terms we're broke this country is
00:54:08 absolutely broke. In real terms, since 2020, our currency has lost 40% of its value. We've got
00:54:16 100% debt to GDP ratio. We can't afford to do this anymore. It really is that simple. So we either
00:54:25 deal with the fact that a few people are going to start kicking and screaming, calling everyone
00:54:29 racist, or we're going to do essentially things that are bringing in policies that are needed
00:54:35 to prevent us from going bankrupt as a country. That is where we are. And the reason we are
00:54:43 bankrupt as a country, and we spoke about it with Peter Hitchens on our interview in
00:54:48 Trigonometry, is because we have been delusional for far too long. We've been delusional about
00:54:55 immigration. We've been delusional about public finances and public spending. We've been delusional 0.55
00:55:01 about the issue of men and women and there's a whole host of subjects that we have been delusional
00:55:06 about and you know what you can be delusional for a bit you can you know have the occasional
00:55:12 period of your life where you know what you go reality doesn't matter i'm gonna kick back and
00:55:17 relax you know and just live a life where reality doesn't apply to me but the problem is is when
00:55:25 you're doing that eventually you're going to be like that bloke who's in his mid-40s goes you
00:55:30 what don't need the wife mate don't need the kids gonna go to the strip cup i'm gonna live life
00:55:35 i'm gonna be who i am it's gonna be great well eventually you're gonna wake up one day realize
00:55:40 you lost your house the wife and the kids and all of a sudden realities come home to roost and
00:55:45 unfortunately the uk at the moment is in danger of living in a bedsit with a bottle of whiskey
00:55:51 for company it's not based on my own life by the way you should have an intimate knowledge of this
00:55:58 situation man exactly uh well guys we're gonna overrun a little bit because i do want to cover
00:56:06 this final story before we do though i just wanted to say if you're watching this and you've enjoyed
00:56:11 it uh there's two things we needed to do number one we haven't got a name for this show uh so give
00:56:16 us your funniest most outrageous ideas and we'll play around with them and see if we want to run
00:56:21 with them number two if you've enjoyed it tell us in the comments tell us what you thought what you
00:56:25 liked what you didn't like what you'd like us to improve obviously smash the like button obviously
00:56:30 subscribe anyway gentlemen speaking of delusions one of the things that i've been covering for a
00:56:35 long time is the ongoing derangement on what i think is mostly the american center center right
00:56:43 basically you have in america sort of normal rational right-wing people and conservatives
00:56:49 and then you have the sort of andrew tate nick fuentes tucker carlson uh candace owens wing
00:56:56 which are increasingly becoming these rabid conspiratorial lunatics and you saw this i 1.00
00:57:01 don't know if you watched the great debate uh it was very popular between candace owens and andrew
00:57:06 wilson in which they discussed who really did murder charlie kirk now obviously the trial
00:57:11 hasn't happened so we can't make any factual claims and one thing i will say about our beautiful
00:57:16 country is one of the things i have really appreciated during this time is mortising that
00:57:22 we have laws which prevent people from commenting on ongoing trials and thinking me what a great
00:57:27 idea this has turned out to be because if you look at what's happening with the charity case
00:57:31 over there you're going oh my god but anyway setting aside the factual stuff there is just
00:57:36 this now thing in america on the right where it's like uh israel is the new russia now so if anyone's
00:57:42 done anything if you know someone's got elected they don't like it's israel if something which
00:57:46 used to be russia of course you know 10 years ago um and and and so and you saw andrew wilson
00:57:52 asking candace owens in this debate you know what is your evidence for these things that you're
00:57:57 saying that erica kirk is complicit in the murder of your husband and her evidence was basically
00:58:02 well my audience likes it that is you know in the summary of what she said she said i'm entitled to
00:58:07 think this and clearly my audience is engaging with this what do we think is going on that's
00:58:13 incredible isn't it I think you more than anyone else Constantine have been instrumental in not
00:58:18 just pointing out but mocking the brain rot that is Candace Owens at this point so you're doing
00:58:22 God's work but that is concern but it has been grimly fascinating hasn't it watching a sort of 0.95
00:58:27 spiral into conspiratorialism naturally what's at the end of every conspiracy theory the Jews 0.98
00:58:32 loosely dressed up as Israel these days but we know what it is they're talking about I just found 0.99
00:58:37 it was like kind of stare watching that debate was like kind of staring into a parallel universe
00:58:41 um where up is down left is right what is the basis of evidence for any particular claim
00:58:47 doesn't really matter she would talk about intuition gut feeling anonymous sources that
00:58:52 you just have to take as read i mean she was claiming what the not only did would was israel
00:58:57 and potentially erica kirk complicit or involved in the murder of charlie kirk but also that the
00:59:02 french foreign legion were trying to kill her presumably because of a campaign against that
00:59:07 bloke that emmanuel macron married like all of this stuff is just totally unmoored in the way
00:59:11 in which we usually think about things um and it's uh it's kind it would be uh funny if it wasn't so
00:59:17 tragic because it does seem to have a constituency now and one thing that i think is really interesting
00:59:21 about the kind of conspiratorial mind as you see summed up in someone like candy zones is that it
00:59:26 presents itself as very questioning i'm just asking questions is the cliche i'm entitled to
00:59:31 my opinions i'm entitled to dissent but it's also it's based on a level of kind of certainty that
00:59:35 you don't get in normal life i mean most times when a court case makes its way through and
00:59:40 someone is convicted it's a beyond reasonable doubt broadly speaking people think even though
00:59:44 there is some doubt there we we've come to the conclusion that the evidence weighs in a
00:59:49 particular in a particular direction at the beginning of that debate she said that she was
00:59:53 zero percent convinced that tyler rogerson was the killer and that's its own form of blind faith in
01:00:00 a strange kind of way so yeah i think we are going to get more of it we're probably going to get more
01:00:02 of it over here in the uk it just hasn't quite filtered over just yet it seems like do you know
01:00:08 what when i was watching it number one my primary thought was i want every minute that i've spent
01:00:14 watching this and i want it reimbursed to me number one number two you look through the
01:00:20 comments the comments are fascinating because you're going all right literally doesn't matter
01:00:25 what candace would have said her audience would have backed her to the hill yeah they were utterly
01:00:29 delusional and number three i kept thinking this this would not have been anywhere near as popular
01:00:36 before covid i think covid basically gave an entire generation of people brain rot where nobody
01:00:45 trusts institutions nobody trusts government nobody trusts the law or the police and as a 0.94
01:00:51 result everyone's like well the obvious thing can't be the obvious thing i mean it's the french
01:00:56 foreign legion i mean that's mental i mean who knows where was the last time you heard about the
01:01:04 french foreign legion it's insane i mean israel i'll be like all right that's a bit hacked i mean
01:01:12 give her credit mate at least she's come up with some new theories yeah some new material exactly
01:01:17 yeah she's she's she's gone up a level but it's just an interesting thing you say you know post
01:01:22 covid people have lost faith in institutions that's understandable and look there's good and
01:01:28 bad and there's some institutions that are good and bad etc but how do you go from having no faith
01:01:34 in institutions to now having faith in the intuitions and dreams of candace owens because
01:01:39 you don't have to go there right you could just say well clearly you know we will lie to about
01:01:44 the origins of the virus clearly in their attempt to prioritize public health they downrank the
01:01:51 importance of truth and therefore misled us about you know the side effects of the back or whatever
01:01:56 whatever it is but you don't then have to go into the derangement on the other side
01:02:00 but a lot of people seem to be making that leap winston i just want to start by saying actually
01:02:06 my resentment on this issue is that you constantin for choosing this topic uh this four hour long
01:02:14 video that i suffered through two hours of generally a horrible experience it reminded
01:02:21 me of all the negative experiences with women i've had in relationships but without any of the 0.88
01:02:27 positives bundled into one and sort of a woman who doesn't at any point engage with the logic
01:02:33 of the argument but does everything to sort of run circles and just so you have this wilson lad who's
01:02:39 shaking and frustration i i was shaking in frustration it's so insufferable uh uh listening
01:02:45 to her and uh in in that particular uh conversation and i'd also note that this is a woman who has 0.97
01:02:51 been doing medieval blood libel uh for the last as early as uh summer 2024 so this is this is a
01:02:58 woman who's a bit nuts but if i can push back against all of you uh tom you're saying there's
01:03:03 there's a sort of increased constituency 0.68
01:03:04 for this kind of thought.
01:03:06 Actually, at the political level,
01:03:09 these kind of people don't seem to be that popular.
01:03:12 Or people who are adjacent in their thinking.
01:03:16 I think of Fishback in Florida, who is not done well.
01:03:20 I think of Thomas Massey.
01:03:22 I think of Marjorie Taylor Greene.
01:03:25 They might not actually think the same as Candace
01:03:28 on these specific issues,
01:03:29 but there's a bundle of people
01:03:30 who have a sort of similar type of view.
01:03:32 And actually at the polls, it's not working.
01:03:36 And so then we come to think of who is actually engaging with this stuff.
01:03:40 Is it actually Americans?
01:03:41 I mean, I'm sure there's a considerable amount of people in America,
01:03:43 but is it people around the world?
01:03:46 Is it, when it comes to the anti-Israel stuff,
01:03:50 is it actually people in the Middle East?
01:03:52 Is it, you know, there's no doubt that there's worse anti-Semitism in Britain
01:03:57 in my lifetime.
01:03:59 I'm not denying for a second that it's terrible here.
01:04:02 But how popular it really is, it's not.
01:04:05 Have you guys actually got a sense of that?
01:04:07 Like, can we actually say legitimately this is a mainstream thought
01:04:10 or this is a really popular thought in America right now?
01:04:14 I think it's hard to deny that there are a lot of people in America
01:04:17 who are interested.
01:04:18 I mean, when Joe Rogan says he's interested in Candace's perspective on this,
01:04:22 you kind of go, Joe loves conspiracies.
01:04:25 He always has done, etc.
01:04:26 And this was the other point I was going to make.
01:04:28 By the way, I think you're right.
01:04:29 you know a lot of tucker's audience has been demonstrated to be from muslim countries not
01:04:34 in america and a lot of candace's own audience as well but a lot of it is in america you're right
01:04:39 that it hasn't had the impact uh politically um but i've forgotten what i was going to say about
01:04:47 the the yeah i've forgotten what i was going to say about what i forgot what i was going to say
01:04:53 um yeah good but no it is especially especially because of the fact that um we've got conspiratorial
01:05:01 thinking everywhere now though i mean if you made the point tom i'm sorry this is what i was going
01:05:06 to say this is what i was going to say to winston's challenge sorry mate it's not new though is it
01:05:10 because look how big alex jones was at one point talking about stuff like this and sandy hook and
01:05:15 whatever there's something in the american psyche and you guys know how much francis and i love going
01:05:20 into america but i think i've said this before i think it's the flip side of the american dream
01:05:24 which is if you live in a society where like anything is possible and it's amazing well
01:05:28 like anything is possible you know maybe the french foreign legion did kill charlie kirk
01:05:32 together with erica kirk for the benefit of benjamin netanyard do you know what i mean like
01:05:36 and and maybe maybe the one thing we probably don't appreciate enough is how exciting and
01:05:43 enjoyable it is to engage in this sort of thinking because it makes life special it makes you special
01:05:50 you have this unique insight francis has made this point very often that this is often what
01:05:55 drives a lot of these conversations sorry to interrupt tom no not so and off the back of that
01:05:59 i think that's one part of the appeal certainly of alex jones when he was really at the height
01:06:03 of his pomp and before he got kicked off of various platforms was that there's an element
01:06:07 of this which is enjoyed as a form of performance as well i mean he's a particularly kind of
01:06:11 pyrotechnic spectacular example of this you know the turn in the frogs gay etc but um even with
01:06:17 Candace Owens when you see her actually on her own show it's a kind of there's an element of drama to
01:06:23 it there's an element of performance and as you say there is also it maps on to something which
01:06:28 has always existed in American society certainly in the 20th century which is this appetite for
01:06:34 conspiracy theory to a certain extent it's almost recreational for some people you notice like they
01:06:39 kind of get into it get into a particular theory move on to another one so sometimes it's not taken
01:06:44 literally but it is by many people taken quite seriously maybe it's because of that hostility
01:06:49 to the state that they have on a much higher level than certainly a lot of european countries have
01:06:53 it's hard to work out where it sort of comes from but also it goes across the political spectrum now
01:06:58 which is the point i was going to make which is that you make the point constant about how we've
01:07:02 gone from everything that goes wrong every assassination every murder it suddenly becomes
01:07:08 russia's fault we've now flipped to israel but you know the russiagate scandal showed that that
01:07:12 was just liberal left conspiracy theorizing and yet and the thing was much more dangerous about
01:07:17 it was that it passed like the math the Martha's Vineyard dinner table test whereas what Candace
01:07:22 Owens is talking about or certainly what Alex Jones is talking about is going to get you laughed
01:07:26 out of the room if you're at a newspaper or on Capitol Hill so I think there is still that the
01:07:31 extent to which you've got conspiracy theories and you've got the kind of acceptable conspiracy
01:07:34 theories and in a way it's that it's the latter camp which can be more dangerous because it is
01:07:38 taken with a lot more credence it looks like well also america is the country of cults if you think
01:07:44 about a lot of the most famous cults there are a lot of them were in america and what does every
01:07:50 cult have it has a charismatic leader who basically talks bollocks and but does it in a charismatic
01:07:55 fashion and everybody goes along with them whatever the cult is and whatever the message is
01:08:01 and basically candace is an online version of that she sits there she talks about bollocks but
01:08:06 because she does it in a way that is engaging and people find it entertaining they go along with it
01:08:12 i think that's a really good point simple that's a really good point what's interesting to me though
01:08:17 is the embrace of the stuff i mean hunter biden to me is an incredible conundrum not him himself
01:08:24 there's nothing super interesting about him but he's now sort of being embraced as like this voice
01:08:30 of and i just you take for some reason there's this thing about where you take some of the most
01:08:36 personally reprehensible human beings on the planet and then they go on these conservative
01:08:42 massive shows and are presented as being like a valid person to talk to i mean hunter biden is 1.00
01:08:49 famous for slapping around hookers while snorting cocaine off their asses like what is what what is 0.98
01:08:55 that why is that why are we listening to him maybe we should interview him trigonometry is what i'm 0.99
01:09:00 saying you should definitely do yeah yeah i look i think charisma is is is a we don't talk about it
01:09:10 enough charisma is so important it's so important for spreading a message it's so important if you
01:09:18 are a public person in any sphere and if you are very charismatic you can basically sell what's
01:09:27 famous adage he's so you know he's so good at selling he's so charismatic he can sell ice to
01:09:32 the eskimos i mean that's what that's what candace is doing sometimes the most obvious explanation
01:09:39 is the correct one well and also cult leaders like making money candace was paid something like 300
01:09:46 grand for this interview i i don't know how much andrew wilson was being paid they were certainly
01:09:51 doing ads throughout it i have my money i think i think it was like he kind of threw the gauntlet
01:09:56 he is paying her he paid her 300 grand yeah yeah and by the way the stream like you said
01:10:03 sorry to interrupt just to just to add to your point the stream has now got five and a half
01:10:07 million views and there's youtube ads all the way through it yeah excellent well next week
01:10:13 it won't be winston and tom it will be candace owens and andrew wilson joining us on this show
01:10:18 because clearly that is that is what the people want and it is our job to deliver it gentlemen
01:10:24 It's been an absolute pleasure.
01:10:25 Thank you for your time.
01:10:26 We have overrun massively, which is a great strong start.
01:10:30 Thanks all for being here.
01:10:31 Make sure you subscribe to The Winston Marshall Show.
01:10:33 Make sure you subscribe to Spike.
01:10:34 And, of course, subscribe to Trigonometry.
01:10:36 And we will see you next week while we will all try to be slightly more cult-like and charismatic.