"Are You A Christian?" - Jordan Peterson's Jubilee Debate BACKFIRES On Faith & Marriage
Episode Stats
Words per Minute
205.41122
Summary
In this episode, Rob and Adam discuss Jordan Peterson's controversial interview with a young man who asks him if he's a Christian. Adam and Rob discuss what they think about the interview and if they think Jordan should have said yes or no.
Transcript
00:00:00.000
Jordan Peterson, Rob, if you got this clip, I just want to get your reaction to it.
00:00:03.320
Jordan Peterson, over the last 10 years, has gotten billions of views online.
00:00:11.460
Thousands of people will show up and pay to watch this man speak.
00:00:14.600
He's had a lot of influence over young men, wrote 12 Rules for Life that sold millions
00:00:19.220
on top of millions of copies, has been very successful, made a lot of money.
00:00:22.800
But they do this Jubilee thing that he sits down with this other young man.
00:00:26.980
And, you know, look, kudos to anybody that goes here because you're being targeted by 20 people
00:00:31.580
that have all been researching to put you in your place and have an opportunity for a video like this
00:00:36.760
that we don't know who you are and all the eyeballs come and you get a bunch of attention, right?
00:00:45.580
Because you go to a Catholic church, don't you?
00:01:09.980
Because I won't talk to you if you're a smartass.
00:01:14.320
I could be either of them, but I don't have to tell you.
00:01:18.680
I was under the impression I was invited to talk to a Christian.
00:01:26.160
I think everyone should look at the title of the YouTube channel.
00:01:41.820
I mean, if I'm being real, I'm really disappointed.
00:01:44.700
We got a guy who's helped millions to see value and order, discipline, family, tradition.
00:01:50.920
And then you pull back on the one foundation that you come from, okay?
00:01:55.580
He's lectured on biblical stories like he's Moses.
00:01:59.020
And then the guy just asks you, are you a Christian?
00:02:04.840
Protestant, are you a Christian because you've been claiming and you're preaching it that you are?
00:02:16.180
You can't talk about the power of the Bible and logos and Christianity and Jesus Christ and claim all this.
00:02:22.480
And then when the moment happens, and I think that kid, whoever this kid is, won this freaking debate to where you have to say, I don't want to talk to you anymore.
00:02:34.280
Well, what's funny is because originally when they uploaded this video on Jubilee, it was, the title was One Christian versus 20 Atheists.
00:02:42.380
Then they changed the title to Jordan Peterson versus 20 Atheists.
00:02:49.420
So originally it was One Christian, which is who?
00:02:54.740
And then they changed it to Jordan Peterson versus 20 Atheists because he said, how do you know if I'm a Christian?
00:03:03.380
But Adam, how did you see this between Jordan Peterson and this young kid?
00:03:07.360
Yeah, only in the modern day of the internet and soundbites can a kid who's likely done nothing with his life, nothing with his life, probably in college so far,
00:03:18.980
come in and own one of the greatest philosophers, speakers, doctors of our time, Jordan Peterson.
00:03:26.960
Now, Jordan Peterson probably should have had a better answer.
00:03:35.920
But this kid has gone famous now for owning Jordan Peterson.
00:03:41.700
I would have loved to have seen the rest of the discussion.
00:03:44.460
I would love to see if there was any productivity of having a conversation like this.
00:03:49.500
But for Jordan Peterson's his entire career to be, you know, stompled on by this kid who just wants to basically dunk on Jordan Peterson and say, you stand for nothing or whatever he said, is just sort of testament to where we're living today, where a kid can go famous and viral for basically dunking on a great thinker when a great thinker doesn't necessarily want to argue with a meaningless child.
00:04:16.200
But you're assuming it, Adam, because Jesus Christ didn't mince words.
00:04:20.620
In Matthew, Tom, chapter 10, verse 33, he said, but whoever denies me before men would also deny him before my father who was in heaven.
00:04:30.540
You can't play neutral when it comes to Christ.
00:04:32.860
And I don't care what moment he's having or how philosophical.
00:04:37.620
But Jesus Christ didn't suffer and die so he could treat faith like a philosophy class, because that's not how it is, Adam.
00:04:44.000
Either you're all in or you're one of these sideline poop talkers.
00:04:51.580
If he's not a Christian, then he doesn't have to.
00:04:56.480
But when you're on the spot and you're saying it, why not say it?
00:05:01.620
So I think Jordan Peterson missed a wonderful opportunity because, you know, what's interesting is if you're going to do a debate with people on anything, right, anything, you know, baseball people 10 years ago debating about designated hitters, should it be in both leagues?
00:05:17.560
If you go into a debate on anything at all and you hit the other person on the head, you're going to get nowhere.
00:05:25.140
And in when sharing about faith and when talking about faith, he missed an opportunity because this young man told them what he was thinking.
00:05:38.440
Are you familiar with some of the doctrines of Catholicism?
00:05:41.020
And all you have to say is, yes, I'm a Christian and I understand the teachings of Jesus Christ and I know why I believe them.
00:05:46.940
Can you share with me what your foundation is and why you believe that?
00:05:51.460
That's a non-offensive question asking the other person to level set.
00:05:54.620
And then you can walk into apologetics and talk about the very beautiful message that is present.
00:06:00.720
And there are many examples given in the Bible of how to debate this.
00:06:07.900
And when he was in Rome, he walked around and he found an altar.
00:06:12.100
And it was the Romans that that age were very superstitious.
00:06:18.280
And they had gods for why there was thunder and why there was rain and all kinds of other things.
00:06:24.820
And because they're superstitious, maybe they missed one.
00:06:31.780
So they're saying, and just in case we missed one, we don't want you to be upset.
00:06:37.640
And he said, might I tell you about one you don't know?
00:06:41.880
And the people were curious and they engaged in debate.
00:06:47.060
So when you have an opportunity like this, I think Jordan Peterson missed the boat.
00:06:52.600
What is the problem in saying, yes, I'm a Christian and here's why I believe what I believe.
00:07:04.160
And the curiosity I had, was it set up as a kind of an internet debate roundtable to get sparks and to bring on views?
00:07:13.560
I'm not the producer and I haven't really studied it.
00:07:16.060
But this could have been done so much better for the benefit of the young man that was sitting there so that he could have understood.
00:07:37.520
And he's probably sitting there profiling this kid and is like, dude, what are you talking about?
00:07:41.460
You know how many tens of thousands of conversations I've had with someone like you?
00:07:44.520
However, if you've got a position, take the position.
00:07:47.440
Rob, is this another one clip that happened from the same episode?
00:08:01.220
Do you believe in the all-knowing, all-powerful, all-good notion of God?
00:08:13.460
Because you added no content to the answer by substituting the word true and believe.
00:08:22.960
So if you believe something, you stake your life on it.
00:08:32.780
So you're saying that you don't believe something if you wouldn't die for it?
00:08:41.560
I could believe it is the case that this pen exists, but if someone threatened my life,
00:08:45.560
I would lie in order to be able to save my life.
00:09:01.240
Would you lie to save your children, your mom, your dad?
00:09:06.160
Can there ever be a circumstance, logically, that lying could save someone's life?
00:09:09.620
Yeah, and if you're steeped in sin, you're likely to live in circumstances like that.
00:09:14.520
If you're in Nazi Germany, and it is the case that there's Jewish people in your attic,
00:09:18.780
and you're trying to protect them, would you lie to the Nazis?
00:09:21.720
I would have done everything I bloody well could, so I wouldn't be in that situation to begin with.
00:09:29.600
No, I can't answer a hypothetical like that, because it's fine.
00:09:36.420
I just told you I would do everything that I could to make sure that I'm never in that situation.
00:09:43.920
By the time you've got there, you've made so many mistakes that there's nothing you can do that isn't a sin.
00:09:50.160
Being born in Nazi Germany and trying to protect people that you care about,
00:09:53.680
like there could be a Jewish friend that you have, and you want to protect them.
00:09:56.160
I think you should just give up on that line of questioning.
00:09:59.060
But like, again, you're not answering this hypothetical,
00:10:01.260
because you know it shows that you clearly would lie to save someone's life.
00:10:03.060
I'm answering it in a manner of you don't find,
00:10:19.500
let's say you were a German person in Germany, during Nazi Germany,
00:10:23.440
and you're harboring a Jewish family to save them.
00:10:34.540
He's saying, what if you were that German family?
00:10:37.660
If you're, it doesn't make, he's not making any sense in that argument.
00:10:40.820
Tom, did you understand the argument he was making?
00:10:42.520
Yeah, what the kid was trying to do was basically called the sin entrapment.
00:10:47.440
And he's trying to get him to admit that he would lie.
00:10:50.840
And he said, oh, so lying is a sin, so you have to lie to do this or that.
00:10:55.620
Whereas you're talking about being faced with great evil.
00:11:02.920
there is an example of a woman who lied to Pharaoh's hitmen
00:11:09.620
so that other people could proceed on God's mission over here.
00:11:14.220
And so, would I have lied about people being in the attic?
00:11:19.420
Yeah, you have Schindler and you have Anne Frank
00:11:21.320
and you have all the stories of everything and what happened over there.
00:11:24.020
And the kid was, I feel like, trying to put this in a corner.
00:11:26.980
But then Jordan Peterson was almost kind of losing his composure
00:11:32.900
And I kind of agree with what you said a few minutes ago, Pat.
00:11:38.340
And I have seen so many of you kids who are example number six
00:12:03.180
It means he was tired and there's a lot going on in life.
00:12:07.340
it appeared that Jordan Peterson was out of patience.
00:12:15.300
And at a time where you really need to call into the peace of God
00:12:19.080
so that you can present these things to people who are doubters
00:12:23.400
and see if you can win, you know, not win a point.
00:12:29.760
but maybe bring them to a level of understanding
00:12:34.380
because they came in armed to kind of point you
00:12:46.080
this moral question of whether you should lie to save a life,
00:13:05.060
Yes, you lie, cheat, and steal to save your kid's life,
00:13:09.360
to save your wife's life, to save your own life.
00:13:16.440
Just like Oskar Schindler lied thousands of times
00:13:28.500
I don't know if this is a good look for him or a bad look.
00:13:34.700
for someone who's basically made a name for himself over decades
00:13:40.980
by a group of young, pompous, freaking atheists.
00:13:55.780
And they're going to find out about his speeches.
00:13:57.280
They're going to find out about what he believes.
00:14:12.040
So Jordan is a very smart, but also emotional man.
00:14:17.420
I've seen him cry on camera too many times to mention.
00:14:21.300
EBD, I know you've had an experience with this.
00:14:23.160
So I don't know what he's dealing with right now,
00:14:28.460
especially in the modern internet podcast culture.
00:14:37.260
And number one, you know what you're getting into.
00:14:48.040
And if you're going to claim you're a Christian,
00:14:56.440
And I'm sorry, I'm not trying to be preacher guy.
00:15:12.720
I'm not as smart and philosophical as Jordan Peterson.
00:15:27.440
oh, well, these people, I'm going to hang out with them.
00:16:04.320
Because typically, faith is a experience of life.
00:16:12.540
that talks about Joe Rogan's been going to church.
00:16:14.840
What do you mean Joe Rogan's been going to church?
00:16:18.440
You know, I think this happened after, you know,
00:16:22.080
Wes Huff, you know, you were telling me yesterday
00:16:23.920
with ex-atheist, Joe Rogan makes major life changes
00:16:37.980
You think Joe's had a lot of deep conversations
00:16:43.940
You think the best podcasts Joe Rogan's ever done
00:17:05.180
It's not like he is, you know, going through something.
00:17:09.240
everything's good, and you're going through that.
00:17:11.180
So this process of a person thinking they know it all
00:17:15.200
when they're 23 years old, coming out of college,
00:17:19.620
with the little, you know, I don't know if you saw
00:17:23.080
You know, you see these types of things that happen
00:17:39.600
Because my unit at 228 Fort Jackson was called the Cobras.
00:17:53.940
I would have been sitting here explaining myself why.
00:17:57.100
Yeah, but you know what the moral of the story is?
00:18:04.340
And sometimes it takes life to really beat the living crap out of you
00:18:07.540
to grow up and say, maybe I got to start looking at some of this stuff.
00:18:11.200
Maybe I have to realize that, you know, how did this kid happen?
00:18:15.720
Go watch a couple deliveries and see what takes place and what God does.
00:18:18.940
Go through life and experience some of the things.
00:18:23.120
Maybe this whole thing about the only thing I know is that I know nothing.
00:18:27.640
Like the more you're growing up, I think Socrates said that on his deathbed,
00:18:32.520
We're all getting better, just like these 20 people,
00:18:37.680
And you know, who knows what he's going through?
00:18:39.100
But this definitely, when you do something like this,
00:18:56.500
Whoever's the speaker that's speaking to guests and clients today,
00:19:00.460
no one go tell him bad news before he hits the stage.
00:19:05.360
Like let's just say something very bad happened.
00:19:13.600
Something bad could have happened literally 30 minutes before he went in there.
00:19:16.900
That pissed him off and mom called him, wife called him,
00:19:18.460
somebody called him and he got pissed off going in there like,
00:19:27.260
I think, Adam, you were going to ask something?
00:19:29.200
I just want to get, I know this, we'll go real quick,
00:19:31.220
but one of the greatest things PBD has ever done to me is say,
00:19:37.020
And whatever religion you are, you know, I love what you say about, you know,
00:19:55.300
My question is this, because I've moved in this direction.
00:19:59.400
And I know Tom has changed lives for, for followers of Christ.
00:20:05.500
My question is this, you remember when I went to the Jerusalem and I went to
00:20:10.600
the Armenian church and I sent you those videos and I got you the gifts from
00:20:17.840
It had me thinking, I said, man, like, all right,
00:20:21.400
what's the difference between the Armenian church and the, the Vatican and the
00:20:29.400
And, and, you know, I went to high school in Miami and it was a Presbyterian
00:20:34.200
And then I have friends who are Mormon and Protestant, evangelical, Lutheran,
00:20:41.280
Neither is the names I'm thinking of Jehovah's witness in Egypt.
00:20:49.620
Isn't it all just, you have to be a follower of Christ.
00:20:54.080
why are there so many different sects to Christianity?
00:20:59.780
I'm asking just the general question is maybe Jordan Peterson isn't a quote
00:21:07.580
So my, that's my question to the, to the group.
00:21:10.360
What's the difference with all these religions and does do it, does it have to be
00:21:17.260
Aren't you just supposed to be a follower of Christ?
00:21:21.040
I think now you're going to, you know, we believe the baptism is under what we believe
00:21:28.880
No, we believe it's this and we believe it's these, you know, changes that they make on
00:21:37.600
And there's a very much of a high retention rate to a organization that causes their members
00:21:44.500
to have rituals versus those who don't, because if it's rituals, you're thinking about it more
00:21:50.400
So the other faith that's not thinking about it, the other sect that's not thinking about
00:21:55.160
And if you notice Muslims, you know, no matter what's going on, they're praying.
00:21:59.540
God knows how many times a day that forces you to be more disciplined, to be thinking
00:22:03.500
about your God, to be thinking about your faith.
00:22:08.160
That's a two, three hour podcast that I don't think.
00:22:12.000
I don't think it's something we need to get into, but I think.
00:22:15.000
But maybe that's what Jordan Peterson was thinking is don't define me by a specific.
00:22:19.980
But if you're sitting with that audience, if you're sitting with that audience, you have to sit
00:22:24.940
there and like, let's just say if I sat down and there's 20 of the guys and we're talking
00:22:28.240
business, well, you know, capitalism, all they care about is this.
00:22:39.740
So you're kind of going through that moment of conversation versus who, do you have a
00:22:52.480
You think that person went through some challenges?
00:22:53.820
I think it's got to be that giving the perspective versus automatically jumping to conclusion,
00:22:59.100
losing patience to not allow them to be sitting there saying, wow, you know, I like the way
00:23:05.780
he handled me, that he got me to think about it.
00:23:09.240
What is that one video we show where this man keeps going to this man that's talking about
00:23:18.860
Did we show this on a podcast a couple of weeks ago?
00:23:25.580
Oh, I almost don't want to even show it because he's disrespecting him the entire time.
00:23:32.920
He does a couple, but they might have bleeped it all.
00:23:35.860
And then all of a sudden, you see, he asks him, hey man, can I just pray for you?
00:23:45.180
And then eventually, the white man is probably in his mid-50s, the mid-40s.
00:23:54.820
If you can't find it, maybe Humberto's texting us saying that he found it.
00:23:58.880
Let me see if that's the one that he's texting.
00:24:03.900
Anyways, the moral of the story is, at the end of it, the guy says, can I just pray for you?
00:24:11.700
I appreciate the fact that he just dropped a prayer for me.
00:24:15.120
Rob, can you show us the new gear we have with Valuetainment merch for those that go to the gym and work out?
00:24:55.380
And anybody that places an order, you get a I love VT keychain being sent your way.
00:25:00.140
If you enjoyed this video, you want to watch more videos like this, click here.
00:25:02.980
And if you want to watch the entire podcast, click here.