00:09:59We want people to kind of just speak plainly about what's going on, and we're pragmatic people.
00:10:05But one of the things that I think is most dangerous about this political moment is that whether it's east or west, whether it's team red, blue, or orange, we have a very dangerous tendency to treat this public, this public that's willing to put its hands up in the air, leap into action, help a neighbor out, do something constructive.
00:10:27we have a tendency to try and push them out of politics, to treat them more like a risk than a
00:10:34resource. Now, I think that the crux of a more participatory, more engaged, more responsive
00:10:41democracy is one where we start tapping into the talents and capabilities of people and stop
00:10:48telling us defeatist stories, to stop telling each other defeatist stories about us all being
00:10:56too divided and too apathetic to make a difference. And I think that's a challenge that actually sits
00:11:03with our political parties, to recognize that people can do more and want to do more than just
00:11:09knock doors and write checks. But that means they have to share some of the power with us
00:11:14so we can make better decisions closer to home that government can then use.
00:11:20And what I'm getting, Peter, is just how passionate you are about this project that
00:11:24you're engaged in and i'm wondering how it is that you find yourself doing this work like what's your
00:11:29story well i i suppose now having written a book that that gathers up a lot of what i've been
00:11:35learning over the last 20 years i might have easily have called it lessons from canadians
00:11:39because anything that i'm communicating to you is just what's been taught um to me by folks in every
00:11:46corner of the country and and you know this is part of the problem too right we all talk about
00:11:51the public as though we've ever met it right like we see folks you know in the grocery store and
00:11:58on main street and you think you have a sense of things but the reality is that this quote
00:12:03unquote public is always a representation right it comes to us through public opinion research
00:12:10like polls and polls are actually a a really devious way of trying to uh to tell you what
00:12:18somebody wants or likes or thinks because so often we say well do you want jobs or do you want climate
00:12:25action as though those two things are diametrically opposed right a lot of people would support clean
00:12:31jobs for instance but we then say oh well the public they only want this party and they only
00:12:37want the other party no no i mean you know from sitting around with friends over a cup of coffee
00:12:42people are a little bit more thoughtful about these things and they often hold contradictory
00:12:48views as well. So, you know, we talk about ourselves being a modern democracy, but we
00:12:54actually have very simplistic ways of understanding the public, much less reaching into and creating
00:13:00problem-solving publics that can help us. I got into this work because I was very fortunate
00:13:07when Ontario, just because I know you guys are keeping score, when Ontario copied British
00:13:13Columbia and replicated its own citizens assembly. I was very skeptical. I thought this was some
00:13:20flaky gimmick and, you know, was probably as skeptical as many might be about whether the
00:13:28public could ever find that common ground that seems so elusive. But, you know, I had a good
00:13:34former professor who was involved in the process. He said, Pete, you need to come and see this thing.
00:13:40I walked into the room and I tell you, it didn't sound like question period. It didn't feel like a
00:13:46legislature. First of all, it was half women and that was a really great thing. There were a lot1.00
00:13:51more young people in that room as well because it matches the demographics of the community it
00:13:55represents. People weren't sitting two sword lengths across from each other. They were sitting
00:14:02side by side and they'd really rolled up their sleeves and they were listening carefully and
00:14:06they were learning. And I thought, boy, wouldn't it be great if more of our democracy felt and
00:14:12sounded like these folks? And that's when I created this organization that would try and
00:14:17take this model, build it, make it part of our democratic culture. And what I never expected to
00:14:24see was a way in which other jurisdictions like Ireland would get inspired from Canada.
00:14:30You know, they've changed their constitution three times using citizens' assemblies that came out of our country.
00:14:38And if you ask someone in Dublin, what do you think about a citizens' assembly?
00:14:42It's one of the few cities in the world that's going to give you a clear answer.
00:14:45Folks understand that democracy can work in new and better ways, and they want to be a part of it.
00:14:53I mean, it's cool that Canada is actually exporting that to the world.
00:14:58And I think it's also the opportunity is because I think so many Albertans will buy into this that perhaps Alberta can lead the charge of transitioning Canada to being who they are, as you said, Peter.
00:16:32and say what you might about Atlantic Canada, but it's the good people of Nova Scotia,
00:16:37who in 1848 achieved responsible government in the first elections in this country. And the
00:16:43other British colonies would then follow in pre-confederal times. But, you know, we have
00:16:49spent the better part of three or 400 years building the current architecture of representative
00:16:56democracy and basically everybody understands they get a vote and that vote is going to go
00:17:04towards somebody who will speak for them in the legislature make decisions on their behalf
00:17:08but there's something that the system of representative democracy doesn't do as well
00:17:14as you know one of canada's great political theorists charles taylor uh describes to us he
00:17:22says, recognition, recognition is as important. It's one thing to be seen. It's another thing
00:17:32to feel heard. And too many people don't feel heard by our politics as usual right now. They
00:17:38don't feel recognized. They don't feel like they have standing and voice and agency. And the way
00:17:45that we've designed our democracy, I think, is something that every Canadian in every corner of
00:17:50country should be proud of but it's an inheritance that we build on top of it's like every other
00:17:57piece of software in our lives yet you have to upgrade it yeah and that upgrade ought to be one
00:18:03that gives people more voice and more occasion not just to have their say and get their way
00:18:11but to actually treat democracy as a way that we learn together and we care for one another
00:18:17that it's not a winner-take-all game and pushing the people we don't like to the corner.
00:18:22The idea of a more participatory democracy is one where you just keep building a bigger tent.
00:18:29And far too many people feel excluded right now.
00:18:32And that, again, I think we have to put some real responsibility on our political leaders and political parties
00:18:39for not making a bigger tent that gives people real opportunities to learn and to grow and to care for each other.
00:18:45I would be thrilled if the entire country moved to participatory democracy, but I don't think we should impose it upon them.
00:18:53But, you know, it's one of the best parts about this country, the fact that we have these 10 provinces and three territories where we can have lots of different experiments underway in how to do things differently and better.
00:19:08And, you know, one of the things that I think is a bit mystifying and certainly disappointing is our parochialism and our refusal to learn lessons from each other.
00:19:21We are more likely to go down to Washington or over to London to get good ideas than we are to look to the province next door or to the region across the way.
00:19:32You know, Canada can be trying and learning within itself faster and more effectively than just about any other country in the world.0.85
00:19:42But we have to stop with the parochialism.
00:19:45We have to recognize and respect each other and realize that, yes, we're going to do things differently.
00:19:50And some of us are going to do them better.
00:19:52And those are the things worth borrowing and building from.
00:19:57It's interesting you say that, Peter, because one of the things we're going to talk about guilds here in a moment.
00:20:01But one of the things we talk about is that one of the guilds and the federal government should be looking at best practices and should be measuring the activities of all the different provinces and then talk about what had the best results, what was the best practices of all the different ones.
00:20:22The great thing about having a federation is that you give different parts of the country the opportunity to sort of try things out, see what happens.
00:20:50So I just was wondering, like, you have such a beautiful vision and such an inspiring way of looking at the possibilities inside of participatory democracy.
00:21:02And so what I'm wondering is, in an ideal world, is there anything else you'd like to say about where you see this all going?
00:21:11You know, I think we all have a tendency to look at our legislatures and parliament.
00:21:16we see these old stone buildings and we think they've been around forever. And the way we do
00:21:22things is the only way to do them. I think when we look outside our country right now,
00:21:30we can see that it's not as friendly a world as any of us might hope for, and that we are being
00:21:37challenged in some pretty profound ways. And Canada has no excuses not to be the world's
00:21:43most successful, high ambition, most caring and effective country in the world. We have
00:21:49all of the resources that we need. I think when the prime minister calls for a strong country,
00:21:55we also need to remember it's our democracy that makes us strong. But right now that democracy is
00:22:00not performing the way we need it to. And it's going to require creativity and innovation just
00:22:05like every other sector. And that's going to mean bringing new voices with new ideas
00:22:11into the mix. So Canada can look to its proud legacy of citizens' assemblies, but they're being
00:22:18done better already by other countries than here at home. In Ontario, in a few weeks' time,
00:22:25two municipalities are going to give their voters two ballots. This is a wonderful idea
00:22:30we've cooked up. It connects voting and volunteerism. So why not at the same time as you
00:22:36vote for your mayor and council, you also indicate whether you would be willing to volunteer to join
00:22:41a committee, respond in an emergency, help out with Little League. Let's get some of that local
00:22:47civic energy connected. There are so many things that we can do beyond increasing the partisanship
00:22:57in our society that can make democracy more effective and ultimately deliver more public
00:23:04value for all of the people of this great society. Well, at a moment in Alberta where I feel that
00:23:12things are particularly polarized with all of the discussion about separation, I'm really grateful
00:23:17that you spent some time with us today, Peter, because I'm feeling more inspired about the
00:23:22potential for our province and our country than I have in a while. Thank you so much.
00:23:27Thank you, Peter. What inspires me about what you said is that it's actually happening.
00:23:31This is not some far-off dream, which, frankly, I kind of get into sometimes.
00:24:28But, you know, we're going to be talking about some volunteer guilds and how people can volunteer to that, how they can be active, how they can advance our political structures and our politicians and advance the country.
00:24:45So it starts off with the Charter of Rights and Responsibilities,
00:24:51and that needs to put the sovereignty right on the individual
00:24:54and say that the individual is the be-all and end-all.
00:25:02they give rights and responsibilities to the government process.
00:25:06So that's to the government itself at each of the levels,
00:25:09each of the three levels, and then the bureaucracy.
00:25:12and the point is is that all of those entities the mechanisms of state are in service to the
00:25:20people and they understand it and the people can change it as as things don't work out they can
00:25:25change it through peter's process uh and that they're the people are in control absolute most
00:25:30important part so you're talking about something like the principle of duty absolutely yes that is
00:25:37like a idea in and of itself that we have a duty to one another. I know there's a new book out,
00:25:43Anti-Civilization, from a pundit from Quebec, actually, Etienne Beauregard, and he's talking
00:25:51about this idea, and he's Gen Z, and he's talking about the need for us to express ourselves in
00:25:56responsible duty to one another. Say more about your version of that. Well, that's a responsibility.
00:26:02so when we talk about charter rights and responsibilities uh included in that is the
00:26:08responsibility the duty that we have to each other you know and that is to you know view your life and
00:26:15on a principled based process to help out each other to you know in calgary to open you know
00:26:21open the door for the person that's you know behind you keep a hold hold it open and and so
00:26:27this is about being who we are anyway this is just incorporating it into our foundation structure
00:26:35so that everybody knows everybody remembers and everybody participates i mean but that's sort of
00:26:40the the always the issue with this with you know getting into how a government might incorporate a
00:26:46sense of duty in the citizenry and you know and your example is a perfect one because we wouldn't
00:26:51necessarily want a law saying that you have to open the door for the person behind you because
00:26:55then there would have to be people enforcing the law. And I don't, it sort of takes away from the
00:27:01whole gesture. So what, how do we do that? How do we create something like this and have it not run
00:27:07totally amok? Well, it's about the foundations. So in a regular constitution, what it does,
00:27:14and take the American constitution and the Canadian constitution is the same,
00:27:17it defines the relationship between the government and the individual. And as I said,
00:27:21In the United States, the individual surrenders the sovereignty to the state and then the state in turn is obliged to protect certain individual rights.
00:27:33And so in our constitutional structure, I want to propose that instead of creating a nation state, we specifically define the nation as a trust so that Canada will be a trust for the people of the country
00:27:49and that the crown will hold all of the assets
00:27:54and take all of its actions in trust for the people.
00:27:58And so to humanize it, rather than having this, you know,
00:28:01organic entity that nobody really knows what it is
00:28:18And through his appointee or his representative in Canada, the Governor-General, that he maintains, he or she, maintains that sovereignty at the individual level and maintains our participation in our democracy.
00:28:34And so creating Canada as a trust rather than a nation state, I think, is a fundamental step.
00:28:41really interesting and again inspiring to think of whole new ways that things could be structured
00:28:47and that they could happen here in our country so many possibilities and one of the possibilities
00:28:53that you've already spoken about is the possibility of citizens guilds so randy can you i know there's
00:28:59a few and there's probably a ton of detail in all this but just for today can you quickly go over
00:29:03the idea of guilds and and what guilds you would suggest well i mean the idea is that it's very
00:29:10simple, that this is a formula for how people get engaged. So just as what, as Peter was talking
00:29:16about, that the one city asks for what would you like to do? Great idea. You know, people can line
00:29:22up and put down, these are the ones that I'm interested in. And what I'm thinking is that
00:29:27there should be some sort of advantage for them, like, you know, a tax write-off or something like
00:29:32that to create an incentive. But it will also kind of form social groups. So if you're part of a
00:29:39guild you know these are the people that you get to know you work together you know it's above and
00:29:44beyond it's fulfilling your duty to the community and and it actually forms a little bit of a social
00:29:48group for people so um i'm i'm proposing 10 and i'll just read them off quickly uh so i'll bear
00:29:55me well bear with me while i'm reading them uh so number one is an electoral guild uh and that
00:30:01would you know keep in reviewing our electoral processes working with the parties to make sure
00:30:08There's not, you know, interference from outside of Canada.
00:30:12And then, and also I propose that they would look at the requirement to vote.
00:30:18So, you know, 100% requirement, a duty of citizenship.
00:30:22Now, part of that is we would have to have none of the above on the ballot.
00:30:26But the Electoral Guild will be teaching people their responsibility