Western Standard - November 17, 2023


Churchill was a war criminal

Topics
Mentioned
CORY: CTV and other outlets understating Hamas murders and crimes Conservative Demands for Trudeau's Mini Budget

Episode Stats


Length

2 minutes

Words per minute

249.0

Word count

667

Sentence count

129

Harmful content

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

Rabbi Shmuley and Rabbi Shrader argue over whether or not Winston Churchill was a war criminal. Rabbi Shmuel argues that Churchill did not deserve collective punishment for the Nazi's indiscriminate killing of civilians in World War II.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 As Rabbi Shmuley correctly said about what Churchill did in World War II.
00:00:03 Churchill was wrong. Churchill was wrong.
00:00:05 Was he a war criminal? Yes, he was. Yes, he was. Churchill was a war criminal.
00:00:08 Yes, he was. Churchill was a war criminal. 0.83
00:00:09 For all the British people, Churchill was a war criminal.
00:00:11 And George VI? Was George VI a war criminal?
00:00:13 All of them war criminals. 0.90
00:00:14 Yes, of course.
00:00:16 Hang on, hang on. Rabbi Shmuley, let me ask you, let me get this straight.
00:00:20 Absolutely. Collective punishment.
00:00:21 You think Winston Churchill was a war criminal, yes.
00:00:23 In standing up to the Nazis, who killed 12 million people,
00:00:28 I believe he was a war criminal. That by doing what he did was a war criminal.
00:00:31 By killing in Dresden and Hamburg.
00:00:32 By indiscriminate killing. Collective punishment. 0.98
00:00:35 My morality says that's impossible.
00:00:36 Okay, that means the British people who supported him and voted him in.
00:00:39 My morality says that's impossible.
00:00:40 Just a second, just a second.
00:00:41 That's what I believe.
00:00:42 But the British people.
00:00:43 You believe he was a war criminal?
00:00:44 Yes.
00:00:44 So therefore, your belief is that no retaliatory action.
00:00:49 No, you can retaliate to the man, not to the babies.
00:00:51 Tell me a war in history.
00:00:53 Yes.
00:00:54 Where civilians haven't been killed.
00:00:56 No, I'm not saying civilians haven't been killed.
00:00:57 Just war or otherwise?
00:00:59 It's about the ratio.
00:00:59 It's about the ratio.
00:01:00 What is the ratio?
00:01:00 What's the ratio?
00:01:01 100 to 100 is unacceptable.
00:01:02 What is the ratio?
00:01:02 100 to 100 is unacceptable.
00:01:03 100 to 100 is unacceptable.
00:01:03 100 to 100 is unacceptable.
00:01:03 100 to 100 is unacceptable.
00:01:04 100 to 100 is unacceptable.
00:01:04 Okay.
00:01:05 101 is an invention.
00:01:06 Rabbi Shrulli, so let me give you a ratio.
00:01:08 Yeah.
00:01:08 How many people did the Nazis kill?
00:01:10 I don't know.
00:01:11 You don't know.
00:01:11 We know they killed 6 million Jews. 0.94
00:01:13 They killed 12 million people.
00:01:14 I don't know.
00:01:14 We don't know.
00:01:15 They killed 6 million Jews.
00:01:16 Sure.
00:01:16 Right?
00:01:17 Sure.
00:01:17 So how many died in Dresden?
00:01:20 How many civilians died in Germany?
00:01:21 Do you know?
00:01:21 I don't know exactly.
00:01:22 Right.
00:01:22 So you don't actually know what you're talking about.
00:01:24 I do know what I'm talking about.
00:01:24 Because I know in Dresden and Hamburg.
00:01:26 You said it's about.
00:01:27 Nis, I'm wrong.
00:01:28 Yeah, go ahead.
00:01:28 Nis, I'm wrong.
00:01:29 You said it's to do with the.
00:01:31 Ratios.
00:01:31 The ratios.
00:01:31 Yes.
00:01:32 But you don't know the ratios.
00:01:33 No, no.
00:01:34 I know for a fact.
00:01:34 You call Winston Churchill a criminal.
00:01:36 What are the numbers in Dresden and Hamburg?
00:01:37 What are the numbers in Dresden and Hamburg?
00:01:37 Wait a minute, Rabbi Shrulli.
00:01:39 When you call Winston Churchill a criminal.
00:01:41 Yeah, I believe they were a criminal.
00:01:41 You're basing it on ratios.
00:01:42 You don't even know what they are.
00:01:44 No, I know.
00:01:44 No, there's difference of opinion among the scholars.
00:01:46 No, there isn't.
00:01:47 There is difference.
00:01:47 Tell us the opinions.
00:01:48 What are they?
00:01:49 Tell us what they are.
00:01:50 Hold on.
00:01:51 How many in Dresden?
00:01:51 Excuse me.
00:01:52 Stop speaking for a minute.
00:01:53 How many in Dresden?
00:01:53 Am I speaking to him or are you?
00:01:54 How many in Dresden?
00:01:55 Whatever the number.
00:01:56 You don't know at all.
00:01:57 If it's indiscriminate, I'm against it.
00:01:58 No, he doesn't.
00:01:59 That's why I'm all right.
00:02:00 Dresden's about 25,000.
00:02:02 And at the time, the Germans were saying 250,000.
00:02:05 We know it's about 25,000 today.
00:02:06 Let me be clear.
00:02:07 Winston Churchill was the greatest statesman of the 20th century.
00:02:09 He saved the world from Nazi terror. 0.80
00:02:13 That you could live in a country that is only around today because of the bravery of that
00:02:17 man showing no gratitude is the height of...
00:02:21 Stick on topic.
00:02:23 Stick on topic.
00:02:24 And to call all the British people who defeated the Nazis, who defeated the Nazis,
00:02:28 stop interrupting me.
00:02:30 Who defeated the Nazis, war criminals, his parents, all the other people with war criminals. 0.56
00:02:35 It's wrong.
00:02:37 No, no, no.
00:02:37 Let me be clear.
00:02:38 Off topic.
00:02:39 Off topic.
00:02:39 Don't interrupt each other.
00:02:40 Let me be clear.