Western Standard - October 02, 2026


Is Danielle Smith betting Alberta’s future on Carney’s promises?

Topics
Mentioned
"They were very bad": Trump says to Canadian leaders during a White House speech CORY MORGAN SHOW: The Kamloops child burial issue is a hoax!

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 3 minutes

Words per minute

149.92

Word count

9,569

Sentence count

280

Harmful content

Misogyny

11

sentences flagged

Toxicity

9

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to Marty Up North.
00:00:29 My name is Josh Andrus. Marty is off hunting this week, so he couldn't handle coming into the office.
00:00:37 Handle probably being the wrong word there.
00:00:39 He's doing more enjoyable things than sitting here with us at the Western Standard.
00:00:46 So, yeah, my name is Josh Andrus. I'm the director of operations at the Western Standard and occasional guest show host.
00:00:52 Today's episode is all about Mark Carney.
00:00:55 And in particular, it's the fact that Danielle Smith is all in on Mark Carney.
00:01:02 Our jobs, our investment, and our ability to build an economy that we can hand off to future generations
00:01:08 have all been pushed to the middle of the table as Smith bets our entire future
00:01:13 on a prime minister that shapeshifts on a regular basis.
00:01:17 If you haven't read his books, don't.
00:01:19 Apparently, he meant absolutely nothing by any of them.
00:01:23 It almost feels like we lost Danielle Smith the day Mark Carney came to Ottawa after the election and promised her the moon.
00:01:30 She bought it. Hook. Line. Sinker.
00:01:36 That's right. The premier who was supposed to make Ottawa answer to Alberta became deeply invested in convincing Alberta to trust Ottawa.
00:01:45 I, for one, will not be convinced to mistake her optimism for our security.
00:01:50 we were supposed to be addressing the conditions that made Alberta vulnerable in the first place.
00:01:56 The uncertainty, the political interference,
00:02:00 the endless requirement to negotiate our way through federal obstacles
00:02:04 before we can turn our own resources into prosperity.
00:02:08 The structural deficiencies in Confederation that continue to create these conditions.
00:02:15 Now the sales pitch revolves around what Mark Carney might approve.
00:02:20 Today, Carney designated the proposed Pacific Link Pipeline a project of national interest.
00:02:28 That advances it through a, quote-unquote, faster federal process, with the government targeting September 2027 for the remaining approvals.
00:02:38 This faster federal process will cost taxpayers approximately $4 billion.
00:02:44 Apparently, they're going to get that back once the oil starts flowing through it.
00:02:47 But, I mean, that is if the oil starts flowing through it.
00:02:53 And we'll give that its due.
00:02:55 Moving the project forward does matter.
00:02:58 But listen carefully to what we are celebrating.
00:03:01 Just another step towards getting a pipeline built.
00:03:05 The designation does not mean that construction is complete, financing is settled, or oil is flowing.
00:03:12 Consultation, permits, and financing still have to be addressed and ultimately approved by Ottawa.
00:03:19 And it certainly does not settle the larger question of Alberta's place in Confederation.
00:03:24 The people paid to defend Alberta are now selling Albertans on Ottawa's promises.
00:03:30 Look at all the things we get.
00:03:31 Project here, an agreement there, another announcement that we're making progress.
00:03:36 Meanwhile, where does this leave the next project?
00:03:40 And the one after that. Does every major investment in Alberta need its own political bargain with our savior, Mark Carney?
00:03:49 If this pipeline gets built, celebrate the pipeline.
00:03:52 But do not tell me that securing special treatment for one project has fixed the conditions that made the special treatment necessary.
00:03:59 No shovels are in the ground. Nothing's been built.
00:04:01 The fiscal imbalances grow with every federal spending announcement that a ribbon-cutting cabinet minister gets to announce.
00:04:11 Federal liberals are still federal liberals, no matter how desperate the Alberta legislature is to fold the entire government into Mark Carney's open arms.
00:04:20 I understand why she wants an agreement.
00:04:22 Any premier should pursue new markets for Alberta energy.
00:04:26 If she gets a pipeline built to the Pacific, like I said, she deserves credit. 0.53
00:04:30 but Albertans are entitled to demand something more substantial
00:04:34 than confidence in her relationship with the Prime Minister.
00:04:37 What happens when that relationship stops being useful to Mark Carney?
00:04:42 Smith recently defended staying at the negotiating table
00:04:45 by asking why Alberta would walk away when it was finally winning.
00:04:49 In that same appearance, she acknowledged that a future federal government,
00:04:53 or maybe even this one,
00:04:56 could undo the progress, quote-unquote, with the stroke of a pen.
00:05:00 Premier, that is the entire problem.
00:05:05 If this or another federal government can simply reverse your victory, then it's not really a victory.
00:05:10 You haven't fixed the problem, you just became the problem.
00:05:14 You can't acknowledge a vulnerability and then expect everyone to relax
00:05:17 because the current prime minister is currently being constructive.
00:05:21 Currently.
00:05:22 Alberta's future extends beyond Mark Carney's time in office, and it extends behind your time in office.
00:05:29 Businesses making investments that take decades to pay off need a foundation that lasts longer than what could be an unproductive meeting between two politicians.
00:05:39 And look at what it actually is on paper.
00:05:41 The May Implementation Agreement sets out Alberta's industrial carbon pricing commitments through 2040.
00:05:46 On the pipeline, it describes conditional designation, further assessment, and best efforts to deliver a conditions document by September 2027.
00:06:01 It also makes pipeline construction and the Pathways Carbon Capture Project mutually dependent.
00:06:07 Alberta has accepted a detailed policy framework, while the pipeline still has consequential hurdles ahead.
00:06:13 The province's own project page says the construction has not started and could begin as early as, again, September 2027, once consultation and the required approvals and permits are complete.
00:06:26 There may be progress here, but there is also a considerable distance between progress and oil reaching a new customer.
00:06:34 Albertans have every right to withhold the victory parade until that distance has been covered.
00:06:39 And Carney does not have to secretly be plotting against Alberta for this arrangement to become a problem.
00:06:44 He only has to behave like a politician.
00:06:47 He has his own voters, his own caucus, his own electoral calculations.
00:06:51 If keeping Alberta happy becomes more politically expensive than disappointing us, what protects our interests then?
00:06:58 What happens when the elbows-up trade war with Donald Trump starts to have real economic implications in Ontario?
00:07:04 It's already starting. Factories are closing.
00:07:07 despite Doug Ford's efforts to prop them up with taxpayer money,
00:07:10 which, you know, real conservative look there, Dougie.
00:07:13 But what happens if the political conditions, you know,
00:07:16 the ones attached to Carney upholding his end of this unholy Ottawa-Edmonton bargain,
00:07:21 become more expensive?
00:07:22 What happens if the timelines slip?
00:07:25 What happens if Alberta fulfills its commitments
00:07:27 and the promised market access remains over the horizon?
00:07:31 What happens if Carney caves to the pressure from the Laurentians
00:07:34 and adds an export tax on oil and gas?
00:07:36 If you expect the bureaucrats in Edmonton to have a detailed answer to that question,
00:07:40 well, you'll be sadly disappointed.
00:07:42 We, on Monday, reached out to Brian Jean's office and asked if they had a contingency plan.
00:07:47 He's the Minister of Energy.
00:07:49 We got nothing.
00:07:50 No explanation of how Alberta would respond.
00:07:53 No reassurance that our interests would be protected if this arrangement falls apart.
00:07:57 And yet we're supposed to share their confidence.
00:08:01 Yeah, that's right.
00:08:02 Hook, line, sinker.
00:08:06 The entire economic philosophy of the Alberta government relies on the decisions of Mark Carney. 1.00
00:08:13 How long are we expected to keep playing this idiotic game? 0.99
00:08:16 Because even a completed pipeline would leave a larger question. 1.00
00:08:20 How much control does Alberta really have over its own future?
00:08:25 I will not confuse Danielle Smith's confidence in Mark Carney with the long-term economic security of this province.
00:08:32 I believe Alberta's future requires a better guarantee.
00:08:36 I think that Alberta should receive something durable
00:08:38 before everyone declares the country fixed
00:08:42 instead of being asked to provide the confidence up front
00:08:46 and hopefully the results will come.
00:08:49 Smith has identified nine bad federal laws
00:08:53 and policies as obstacles to Alberta's prosperity.
00:08:56 What has actually been repealed?
00:08:58 What has actually been amended?
00:09:00 what has merely been suspended what depends on this government continuing to honor an agreement
00:09:07 keep in mind that a suspension always comes with the possibility of a reinstatement
00:09:12 a concession can carry conditions an individual approval only gets an individual project through
00:09:20 where is the lasting change that gives the next investor confidence without another round of
00:09:26 political bargaining. And please, spare me the suggestion that asking these questions means
00:09:31 wanting Smith to fail. I want the pipeline built. I want investment pouring into Alberta. I want
00:09:37 workers earning good money and families believing their children can build a future here.
00:09:42 That's precisely why I refuse to accept political goodwill as the foundation for all of it.
00:09:49 Like I said, Carney has his own interests, his own coalition, his own reasons to offer Alberta
00:09:56 enough progress to keep this relationship working. My concern is that she has put on so much of her
00:10:02 credibility into this relationship that admitting its limitations has become politically painful.
00:10:08 Every little concession we get from Ottawa is used as a platform for Danielle Smith to announce
00:10:13 that her strategy is working. Every objection becomes an inconvenience to the story that she
00:10:19 is trying to sell us. If all we get is a better relationship with the people who can still tell
00:10:24 us know, she has settled for far too little. It's almost as though after another conservative
00:10:31 defeat federally, Danielle Smith lost faith that Alberta could get the change it needed
00:10:36 and started lowering her expectations on our behalf. That is what troubles me. I can accept
00:10:43 the Premier changing tactics after an election. She does have to work with whoever occupies the 1.00
00:10:48 Prime Minister's office, but Albertans deserve to know whether the objectives have changed along
00:10:53 with the tactics. When did secure lasting, and I'm going to say it again, lasting protection
00:10:59 for Alberta become securing whatever Mark Carney is prepared to offer? When did the premier's job
00:11:05 become persuading us to be satisfied with the status quo? The federal election did not make
00:11:11 Alberta's grievances disappear. It did not make our demands unreasonable, and it certainly did
00:11:16 not give our premier a mandate to bargain down our expectations. If anything, another federal
00:11:22 conservative defeat made her responsibility greater. Albertans needed someone prepared
00:11:27 to defend their interests through another government they did not choose.
00:11:31 Instead, I increasingly feel that we are being asked to accommodate Ottawa's political reality
00:11:37 while Ottawa faces less pressure to accommodate ours. I cannot tell you whether Danielle Smith
00:11:43 has lost the will to fight. I can tell you that her enthusiasm for this relationship
00:11:47 leaves me questioning what she is still prepared to fight for mark carney winning an election was
00:11:54 a reason for us to reassess our strategy not to reduce our ambitions there was absolutely no 0.98
00:11:59 reason to bet alberta's economic future entirely on liberal red danielle smith has gambled her
00:12:06 political reputation on mark carney and we deserve to know why our future had to be part of the wager
00:12:12 that brings me to the end of the monologue uh so i have not yet asked for callers uh but you can
00:12:19 join the conversation please call us at 866-479-9378 extension 711 go through the comments
00:12:27 here oh rosanne hutchins says always a treat when josh shows up thank you rosanne uh what have we
00:12:34 got uh the snake oil man lies and now the girl must have been compromised somewhere or following
00:12:40 along then next year another vote um the marty show with josh isn't josh the boss uh
00:12:48 i got a lot of respect for marty so i'm not going to change the name of his show just because i
00:12:55 take it over for a week uh what else have we got again uh you can call in um
00:13:01 carney made a pro make made a promise a promise that he won't keep says tml fan 0.96
00:13:08 uh 8708 carney was at the oiler game and refused to stand for a veteran scumbag yeah i saw that
00:13:17 um i'm not i haven't independently verified whether that image is accurate but
00:13:22 i mean to me national pride should be very veteran-centric like i don't go when i'm standing
00:13:33 for the national anthem at a calgary flames game or a stampede's game wherever i am i'm not standing
00:13:38 because i love the song i'm standing to show support for the troops the the people who signed
00:13:48 up to put their lives online if we ever have our sovereignty legitimately threatened and uh i i
00:13:55 don't necessarily think trump is that threat but uh carney might disagree with you um bashing 0.86
00:14:02 danielle will only lead to nancy taking the next election i don't think you want that either
00:14:07 criticize her but how about some solutions yeah i got some solutions like let's have a conversation
00:14:14 about why we're in this position like we can't claim that this mou solves all our problems if
00:14:21 the nine bad laws are only given one time exemption and we have another like the political
00:14:26 calculus in ottawa changes we are entirely exposed i mean smith is gambling everything on this deal
00:14:33 but we aren't getting i think we need concrete solutions to the problem not just like one-off
00:14:40 goals like i think the issue that the ucp has and i've said this in previous videos is that
00:14:46 smith's kind of occupying this dangerous middle ground and it's a narrow middle ground she's
00:14:52 trying to convince federalists who i'm not saying that they are all status quo federalists but there
00:14:58 are a lot of them that think that you know we don't need to really fix anything canada's great
00:15:03 but the federalists who aren't prepared to leave the country in the separate or the independent
00:15:08 supporters that want to leave tomorrow and what she's doing is she's trying to appeal to all of
00:15:13 them by taking both sides of it i think what she needs to do is find you know what what would what
00:15:22 would canada look like if if we wanted to get rid of the independent sentiment like what is the what
00:15:27 What is your vision for Canada?
00:15:29 I mean, if the vision is like one-off agreements for a pipeline here or there, that's fine.
00:15:34 But say that.
00:15:36 I mean, but I think that we need to have a real conversation about the structural deficiencies in this confederation.
00:15:43 I haven't heard Jason Nixon use the word equalization once since he became the finance minister.
00:15:49 And again, I challenge anybody watching to find me a quote where Jason Nixon,
00:15:53 the finance minister of the government of Alberta is talking about this fiscal imbalances in
00:15:59 confederation actually you know what let's expand that to the entire cabinet have any of the 24
00:16:04 cabinet ministers commented on that in the last six months or are they too afraid to inflame
00:16:09 tensions like this is a party that is running away from itself we're not standing up for anything
00:16:17 we're just taking whatever we can get from Ottawa and selling it to the membership and to the
00:16:21 conservative bases if it's the solution doesn't um okay sorry about that went off on a bit of a
00:16:32 rant but you know what yeah i do not want mark i don't want nahid nenshi to win at all i want i
00:16:40 want smith to solve the problem i mean and it's not an easy fix it's been 120 years we've been
00:16:49 going through this. I mean, you could go back to, you know, before we even became a province,
00:16:55 you know, Senator Lougheed, James Lougheed, was writing articles in the Calgary Herald. I think
00:17:00 R.B. Bennett, who went on to become prime minister, a Calgary lawyer at the time, was writing articles
00:17:06 explaining how the way that Alberta was being accepted into the confederation without control
00:17:12 of our natural resources, which was something that was granted to the original provinces,
00:17:15 would create tension it took us 25 years to negotiate that then came the well we had the
00:17:25 national energy program but uh what was pierre trudeau and fighting for constitutional jurisdiction
00:17:33 of those natural resources we've had to fight for everything we get we have to fight like crazy
00:17:39 like but these are the structural deficiencies equalization started in 1957 and it's become the
00:17:46 biggest bane in albertans pockets and it's not equalization it's just one program every single
00:17:53 federal transfer they take more money out of your pocket to give you that money back
00:17:58 like we albertans pay on average 15 percent of all federal tax collected and yet the federal
00:18:06 government on average spends about 11 because that's the percentage of the population national
00:18:11 population that lives here we over contribute i mean health care is a prime example of that
00:18:17 again massive federal transfers back billions of dollars coming in to pay for health care in this
00:18:23 province money that the federal government taxes you for like they take that money and then they
00:18:28 they dribble it back you don't get it all back these are real real issues a one pipeline isn't
00:18:36 gonna solve that still no callers what have we got here what has uh what has carney got on smith
00:18:51 Yeah, well, I, you know, I don't think he's got any dirt on her.
00:18:55 I think that's a stretch.
00:19:00 I just, for whatever reason, think that she has been charmed by Mark Kearney.
00:19:06 And that despite his track record, despite his public positions,
00:19:12 the books he's written on climate change and how we have, like, all of that.
00:19:17 Is everything that he's done up to this point completely bunk?
00:19:20 Well, I don't know. And I also think that there's internal pressure, that there are senior government officials who hate the concept of independence, even as a leveraged threat.
00:19:33 They just hate it. They are so proudly patriotic that the concept of being called a separatist makes them freak out.
00:19:44 and they also sit at the cabinet table so they have a voice in every decision that this government
00:19:51 makes i think there's 24 cabinet i think there's too many anyways we have a call on the line
00:19:57 how are you today good how are you
00:20:02 good good uh rick i'm a governor nice to meet you rick thanks for calling in what do you got
00:20:08 what's on your mind and you know that i've got a list but we can go through a few things a time
00:20:14 as far as the things that I'm thinking
00:20:16 of what you're talking about right now.
00:20:18 The first thing I was wondering
00:20:19 was what Jeremy Park is doing right now.
00:20:22 You know, every single time
00:20:23 he can get in front of a microphone,
00:20:26 he's got something to say,
00:20:28 and he's pushing this narrative
00:20:29 about the fear and the fear-mongering
00:20:32 and this report came out
00:20:36 and look at this, how bad it's going to be.
00:20:39 And if we leave, this is what's going to happen.
00:20:41 And then there's a side issue of, say, crew members taken down 1.00
00:20:49 Let Alberta Decide boards.
00:20:52 You notice that they didn't accidentally take any Forever Canadian boards down.
00:20:58 I will comment on that.
00:21:01 Do I believe that it was an accident that the independent signs were taken down
00:21:07 and that the no to the nine signs are still up is a accident no but um i think it's hard to i 0.98
00:21:16 i think it's hard to point that one directly at farkas because like it very easily could have
00:21:21 just been some city worker that took it upon themselves to take the signs down that vehemently
00:21:28 opposes it but farkas has you know contributed to that attitude he has definitely that's right
00:21:35 Um, I mean, he, he's, he's creating more tension there than is necessary. And yeah, I don't believe every report that comes out that says that independence will be economically devastating. I do believe that we have to take some time to develop institutions that have longevity. 0.59
00:21:58 uh we do uh one of the things that we need to do is become less reliant on the federal government
00:22:04 for basic services and and the key way to do that is to just you know do them ourselves like
00:22:11 we should like the health the canada health act we can get into that um but that's that's like
00:22:17 like i talked about that earlier like it's another example where the federal government
00:22:21 sends us money for health care but they've taxed us way more and but we still take the money we
00:22:27 need that money to spend it on the health care but if they were out of our pockets i think that
00:22:31 would be a lot easier so i i think that there's a significant constituency of establishment figures
00:22:40 in this city right and left that have congregated around this concept that we have to defeat the
00:22:47 independence question damn the consequences it doesn't matter we take whatever we can get right 0.99
00:22:54 now say whatever you can right now let's kill this thing and what it's going to do is it's just 0.99
00:23:00 going to embed the structural deficiencies at a level that makes it harder for them to fix it and
00:23:09 another thing too is is economically speaking yes our population has grown substantially faster than
00:23:17 it should and that is a federal immigration issue and smith has put these referendum questions on
00:23:25 the ballot and i think that she's correct to do so but the fact is that we are going our economy
00:23:33 and i'm just gonna say it our economy has typically grown faster than the rest of the
00:23:39 country and that requires a lot of young workers and they come from the rest of the country and
00:23:44 they they they get jobs that's why we consistently have the youngest population in the country
00:23:49 and if we have public officials like farkas and and others that are slamming the that are like
00:23:56 refusing to acknowledge the structural deficiencies because it could weaken this fragile agreement that
00:24:04 we have with mark carney i mean we're jumping through hoop after hoop after hoop to get a
00:24:07 single pipeline and by the way the hoops are costing billions of dollars to jump through
00:24:11 why it costs four billion dollars to get a pipeline approved is beyond me
00:24:15 i mean i'd like to see that costed but it's we have it it's the the establishment the
00:24:23 establishment is so fundamentally against this concept that they are doing whatever they can
00:24:28 to crush it you've got the the mainstream media i mean globe and mail is hammering it uh ctv news
00:24:36 i can't watch global news like i watch like shows on global sometimes and as soon as the news comes
00:24:41 on it's like this like you know when you're just sitting there scrolling you're not really watching
00:24:45 but i have to change channel because something annoys me like you're preaching to the choir on
00:24:50 that yeah yeah it's frustrating and you you it gets to the point where you just people even my
00:24:56 mom who's a 72 and a cbc watcher goes no i've listened to all points of view and i'm like i
00:25:02 know but you're just kidding so you know but we have good discussions but back when the health
00:25:07 If you were talking about health transfers, there's something there that is a real significant issue.
00:25:13 It seems like it's something you're keenly interested in.
00:25:15 And you talk about those transfers.
00:25:17 Yes, they give us 11% of the, you know, based on our population because it's per capita.
00:25:24 But what it doesn't account for is the structures we need.
00:25:28 That is a provincial expense.
00:25:30 Oh, and also...
00:25:31 and the facilities and so we fall we're falling behind because of that rapid uh growth of our 0.90
00:25:40 we should like they like every single fact like danielle smith when she was shortly after she
00:25:49 was first elected but it was like very early in her term uh her government passed the provincial
00:25:54 priorities act the provincial priorities act was designed to look at every federal agreement that
00:25:59 we have whether it be the health act agreement i don't know what they call that but we did sign
00:26:04 something like every agreement that we have to just to see how much we get back and how much we
00:26:11 spent but if you add all of them up that's where you get the massive uh fiscal imbalance numbers
00:26:18 like equalization i think only accounts for like seven and a half billion a year but it's it is
00:26:23 it's the it's that four i guess more than four percent on the fiscal imbalance side like again
00:26:29 we pay 15 16 in federal taxes again i haven't done the numbers in a couple years so this
00:26:34 has probably changed but like the attitude from the political establishment is that right now
00:26:43 it's all all pushing to try and crush the independence movement like that's all they
00:26:50 care about and i she made a statement the other day that you know if we vote yes to the other nine
00:26:57 that she will have leverage and i i'm not there i think that the independence vote is
00:27:06 a the biggest chip that we had in the negotiation and i think by crushing that number
00:27:13 and but and i'm i will comment on the polls like the polls don't look good but they're
00:27:18 also fluctuating wildly like i'm seeing 35 i'm seeing 22 like if you've got two numbers coming
00:27:23 out that are that different within two weeks of each other either your methodology is completely
00:27:28 wrong or nobody knows what's going on so that might be a lot of times we're both yeah i think
00:27:34 a lot of times we're both both i mean which you know that the people that do those polls
00:27:39 more often generally are closer to center or left yes i do know most of us typically there's like a
00:27:47 Yeah, so that's a contributing factor, but I also know that there's been a chilling, a cooling on people wanting to step up and say, yes, I am, because think about Freedom Convoy and even people who just donated and their bank accounts frozen and so forth.
00:28:08 So that really impacted people willing to stand up publicly and say, yeah, yeah, I'm for this.
00:28:13 And I know that the people just I talk to in Calgary and I have property up near Gull Lake, so in the Penelope County area, it doesn't matter if I'm rural or if I'm in the urban area.
00:28:26 I know the numbers are a lot higher.
00:28:29 Now, I find of all kinds, you know, lots less in the rural areas, obviously very much support there.
00:28:35 but yeah and i think there's a cooling of that and that's why i think honestly like my feeling
00:28:41 not like this is scientific or anything is that it's probably going to be about a 35 to 37 percent
00:28:50 and i think that's a good number actually i i do too i mean realistic like if you get if you get
00:28:56 over 30 uh like you got to look at the last provincial election i think smith had like 53
00:29:03 percent like if 31 of that 53 is voting to start the process of leaving the country and you're
00:29:10 standing there like promoting this deal like and this is the way i don't understand like i don't
00:29:16 understand the vision that the establishment has right now i don't understand how you're going to
00:29:22 put the genie back in the bottle because look i'm not the most full-throated uh supporter of
00:29:28 independence like there are the cory morgan would take the cake on that like i am supporting
00:29:34 the referendum i am going to be voting option two um but i've seen things in group chats online
00:29:45 by conservatives things said to people that support independence that if somebody said that
00:29:52 to me i'd never talk to you again like that is the rhetoric that's coming out of the establishment
00:29:59 right now and yeah if you get 31 if you get 37 even 25 it's about half your base right if those
00:30:09 people feel like they're not motivated to support you and the other side feels that the government
00:30:19 is in the wrong by putting the referendum on the table in the first place i don't know how you get
00:30:24 those two groups to get back together unless you do something where you're putting a path on the
00:30:32 table that focuses on dealing with the long-term impacts of this vote mainly you have to deal with
00:30:41 the root cause and i don't think that there's an appetite for it i think there's a lot of people
00:30:46 that just say we'll never be able to fix this this is the best we can do and you know what the
00:30:52 voters of calgary shaw said that is not good enough and i don't think that's because calgary
00:30:58 shaw has morphed into some moderate ndp constituency and that nahed nenshi is doing a fantastic job of
00:31:07 coming off as a moderate not a socialist i just think it's because there's two sides here the
00:31:13 independent side and the federalist side that are neither one of them are believing that the current
00:31:22 direction of the government captures their voice and if you're in that kind of a position in
00:31:30 leadership where you're not selling both sides you're gonna have your your people that show up
00:31:35 just because of just pure hatred to the NDP.
00:31:38 And I love those people.
00:31:41 But it's the...
00:31:44 You need all three groups to win.
00:31:48 My favorite meme this week actually was,
00:31:53 you're a big fan of Orange Man Bad,
00:31:57 and it was a picture of...
00:31:59 Orange Man Bad.
00:32:01 Yeah.
00:32:03 Well, and that's like...
00:32:04 We do need to have a message that the people can do with it.
00:32:09 It's unfortunate that Polio cannot get the support in the East that would be necessary to form a government.
00:32:16 His message yesterday is that the answer is that it is that we can fix it from within.
00:32:23 We can't unless you can get the support down there.
00:32:27 It's that simple, and that's the whole point of this entire thing.
00:32:30 Now, you were mentioning something earlier about Daniel Smith saying about the voting the nine and even voting for option one, and then it would give her the leverage.
00:32:40 The question I have about, on the first five questions, she doesn't need any leverage.
00:32:47 Those are all provincial things, and they have the authority to do those things if you want to do anyway.
00:32:53 She put those out there just to grant cover
00:32:56 Because they want to do those things
00:32:58 But they want cover so they can do those things
00:33:00 The other four require
00:33:02 Cooperation with other provinces
00:33:05 But the first five
00:33:07 Are all in her purview already
00:33:09 And she has the power to do those things 0.99
00:33:11 And prevent them 1.00
00:33:12 And the majority government 0.89
00:33:13 She can vote them all in
00:33:15 I think part of it was
00:33:16 I think part of it was to try and get
00:33:20 And we got another call waiting
00:33:22 uh so uh appreciate you taking the time what was your name it's rick rick thanks for calling in
00:33:28 rick um yeah i i i can touch on that a little bit um
00:33:34 smith my frustration is especially right now i don't there was a point uh when when she was early
00:33:50 on uh where she can be like decisive like you know when she makes a decision and it's a good 0.88
00:33:58 decision and she she just sticks to her guns and and she's made a decision to gamble everything
00:34:05 on this this mark carney deal and and i'm gonna also comment on uh polyev because again
00:34:15 it's it is unfortunate it's it's it's rough i mean the last poll came out and there's this i
00:34:22 think it's 16 17 point gap like things haven't been this bad since before joke like i don't
00:34:28 think we've ever had such a dominant liberal party but pierre was better before he became
00:34:38 the establishment. I think the problem is the establishment. I think there's too many people
00:34:45 that jump from Jason Kenney's government to Pierre Polyev's leadership campaign and are now
00:34:55 working their way back into the Alberta legislature. Some of them have moved on to
00:34:59 the BC conservatives with the shotgun campaign. I think they're the problem. So anyways, I got a
00:35:04 call on the line um can you hear me good afternoon marty it's uh rimby john from rimby alberta how
00:35:13 are you sir well i'm good i'm not marty but i'll uh i'll consider myself an almost as good looking
00:35:18 version how's that i'm josh well no it's all good sure um josh um i just tuned into your show
00:35:27 um thank you for your show thank you for your calling i appreciate it sir i appreciate you
00:35:33 call it in do you have a comment or a question well my comment would be sir um i'm from rimby
00:35:41 alberta i'm a freehold all mine and mineral owner 21 of the province is owned privately
00:35:50 by mineral owners some of us uh about eight or nine percent um you know wait 11 is owned by
00:36:01 indigenous you know my comment would be sir um i am for um separation in alberta i think we've
00:36:10 been abused for far too long sir um i think anybody in alberta sir i think all we ever wanted
00:36:20 was for 50 years now we just wanted a fair deal we want to be treated fairly sir i agree with
00:36:29 equity with equity integrity and that goes for my indigenous friends in hovima um all my
00:36:37 friends in alberta um we just want to be treated fair with equity we pay all the bills in canada
00:36:45 that's okay we just want to be treated fair my friend and we haven't been and that's why we have
00:36:51 the referendum vote on october the 19th i am voting number two on question 10 um and i gotta
00:36:59 to say my friend I'm an immigrant sir I'm from Norway my family came from Norway in 1895 to
00:37:09 America to Hender Minnesota we prospered very well there sir I'm I'm a part American yeah a lot of
00:37:17 people in Canada a lot of people sir and I could just cry on the phone call my grandfather who
00:37:26 came from ontario he lied about his age as a kid he's like 16 years old he went into world war one
00:37:34 he fought for the dominion of canada sir he fought for this country and people in alberta call me
00:37:43 i'm a traitor i'm i'm a racist i'm a this and that because i i want alberta to be better
00:37:51 independence i'm not a traitor my my family fought for the dominion of canada sir my grandfather was
00:38:00 gassed with mustard gas in 1917 and yet mark carney sits down during the veteran ceremony
00:38:10 at opening night at rogers center or rogers place last night again that's alleged but
00:38:16 no i mean that's i i'm the same way like my all four of my grandparents were born in this province
00:38:21 but all four of their families came up through the united states from another country whether
00:38:26 it be sweden or well actually not all yeah like well half not all of them but like enough um they
00:38:33 all came up through the states from places like sweden or germany or you know france like that
00:38:41 we're all like that is the the genesis of what this province is and and and and with that like
00:38:49 the migration patterns especially when we developed as a country we brought a lot of
00:38:54 the ideals from the americans up with that migration people were just they like there
00:39:00 wasn't enough room in pennsylvania and so instead of working in the mines they came up for an
00:39:05 opportunity to have a farm in you know innisfail or ecville or rimby um like that's that is what
00:39:13 has been the genesis and i think that gives alberta a different culture i do i believe that
00:39:18 we are a province and pierre said it the other day like we are an innovative province we've had
00:39:24 to be innovative the federal government's 3 000 kilometers away from 2000 or from 1883 when we
00:39:32 started calling or settling out here to probably when when did airplanes uh 1940s airplanes became
00:39:41 kind of a bigger thing like we were three it took three days to get across the country
00:39:45 like we've had to to stand on our own we can't historically rely on the federal government and
00:39:52 and i think that has established us as as our own kind of a culture like we are pioneers and and and
00:39:59 that pioneering spirit shows up in every industry that we create uh look at the wildcatters uh that
00:40:06 were drilling for oil in the 40s that struck black gold and we now have a downtown calgary core with
00:40:13 office buildings in a skyline that really rivals any other city in this country and and many in
00:40:19 the united states um alberta should have fair treatment but we don't and simply signing an
00:40:28 agreement for a single pipeline to get approved by the major projects office does not deal with
00:40:34 destructural deficiencies in this province that that pioneering spirit and entrepreneurial and
00:40:41 innovative thought process that has been ingrained in generations of Albertans has created this
00:40:50 economy that the federal government then takes way more than we pay in or doesn't give us like
00:40:58 the services that we pay for I think that's the issue like and I the thing that worries me about
00:41:07 this this this deal with Carney is that Smith can't even talk about the grievances without
00:41:13 making this deal look like it's less than it than she says it is she says this deal is the reason
00:41:20 that we look at we can show that you know Canada works for Alberta we got one pipeline that might
00:41:28 be built in September of next year that's what we got but she can't say anything about the
00:41:35 structural deficiencies. Like that's the frustrating part I have. I, I, I, and I don't
00:41:41 think she's completely cooked, but she, if, if this deal doesn't happen, like if Mark Carney
00:41:49 finds a reason to wiggle out of it, she's, she's put all of her eggs in this basket. Like she needs
00:41:56 this unholy agreement to hold and produce more than it is. It can't just hold for the next
00:42:04 three weeks it has to hold through september of next year and it has to lead to more
00:42:11 it's we need more like this is a frustrating situation to be in um what does um oh why can't
00:42:24 mark boucher says why can't conservatives take yes for an answer i don't know what the question is 0.93
00:42:31 you dumbass but but sir god has blessed alberta with the third you can argue about it the third 0.91
00:42:42 or largest third or fourth largest oil reserves in the world and we want to share that with 0.99
00:42:50 everybody sir you cannot meet more generous people in the world than albertans we want to
00:42:59 share our wealth we want to share it with everybody we're not greedy but you can't hold us back
00:43:05 like let us go let us prosper the other thing sir do you realize um Ralph Klein a lot of people
00:43:14 don't know this sir Ralph Klein when he was in the premiership in Alberta there are six seats
00:43:22 on opec alberta has one of those seats invited i don't know if we're still there or not sir
00:43:29 we are so wealthy what god gave us these resources sir to help everybody in the world
00:43:39 every albertan that i know cowboys oil men real alberta and we've been here my family crummy
00:43:47 sturdow when be 118 years we are very generous family people christians we help everybody and
00:43:57 we love to share the wealth and we're not able to do that because of i think there's a difference
00:44:05 between willful philanthropy and uh forced redistribution um i agree with you i
00:44:17 I love the fact that we can contribute. I think the issue is that there's a lot of federal policies that create areas in which we as a province need to address the fiscal imbalances.
00:44:31 I think Smith pointed out that the federal immigration policies that have brought, I don't know how many people into Alberta, but they cost about a billion dollars in taxpayer-funded services.
00:44:42 So, you know, health care, education, so on and so forth.
00:44:45 And they contribute about $150 million in tax revenue.
00:44:50 Now, the issue that we have is that when we pay our federal taxes, we don't get all of it back in the province.
00:44:56 And when we grow faster than the rest of the country, we need to build services that everybody can rely on.
00:45:04 And, yeah, I am voting to support options one for, I'm probably going to vote yes to the 10.
00:45:12 Actually, maybe that should be a slogan, yes to the 10.
00:45:15 But we're in a position here.
00:45:19 Well, sir, sir, are you voting option two?
00:45:21 I'm voting option two.
00:45:22 On question 10.
00:45:23 Yes, I'm voting option two on question 10.
00:45:23 Oh, thank you, sir.
00:45:24 Just want to clarify that.
00:45:25 Yes, I am.
00:45:26 Yep.
00:45:26 so yeah like i think i think the issue that we have as a province is that we don't have anybody
00:45:36 that's presenting a vision of how we're going to fix the structural deficiencies we've got
00:45:41 smith pounding the drum on this uh one-off agreement that's not a long-term solution to
00:45:49 the issues maybe that's the pivot after the referendum but i mean i well i'm worried that
00:45:55 the deal being in place severely restricts her political maneuverability here can can i interrupt
00:46:03 you for one moment yes absolutely daniel smith jason nixon whether you're an ex-politician we
00:46:11 call him fat stall and jason kenny rachel nothead notley if you leave politics i'm sorry you've
00:46:18 left okay to me our sitting government in alberta and i voted for her i love her
00:46:25 daniel smith our current government whether it be ndp liberal whatever currently when you have a
00:46:34 vote sir for all albertans worldwide on a referendum on a question you should stay neutral
00:46:42 sir you should not open your mouth about i'm going to vote yes i'm going to vote no i'm not
00:46:48 going to vote you should be neutral put the question to albertans and put it to them and
00:46:55 let them vote don't influence them with four million dollars in campaign funds yeah which
00:47:01 on my oil money page for i'm just saying with all due respect sir if you're an ex-politician
00:47:07 or sitting in your current government, don't comment.
00:47:10 Just please let your constituents vote yes, no, or don't vote at all.
00:47:17 That is a democratic – you know what I've got to say, sir? 0.54
00:47:20 My grandfather fought in World War I, and he came back with mustard gas.
00:47:25 And the one thing he said to my family was, he said to me,
00:47:30 Wendy John, a glass of water has more value than a human being.
00:47:35 That's sad. That's sad.
00:47:37 We've learned nothing over a lot of years, my friend.
00:47:40 These politicians, okay, put the vote forward.
00:47:44 If you're, just put the vote forward, sir.
00:47:47 Let it stand on its own.
00:47:49 Let people answer the question in the ballot booth.
00:47:53 Yes, no, or abstain.
00:47:54 That's okay.
00:47:55 That's called democracy.
00:47:58 I'm an off-balance, sir.
00:48:00 Yep.
00:48:01 No, you're dead on.
00:48:02 That's why I let you talk for so long.
00:48:03 But I do have to move on to other callers.
00:48:06 join the conversation thank you very much for taking time um i hope jason nixon uh watches
00:48:12 this at some point that is one of your voters so uh i don't think he's the only one in your riding
00:48:17 that uh is thinking this and again like there are way too many establishment figures that
00:48:25 completely disregard the structural deficiencies here that have led us to the point where we are
00:48:29 voting on whether or not we are going to remain in the country like that is something that i i
00:48:35 found very frustrating when i worked in that building i'm glad i'm not there anymore because
00:48:40 i i think i would i would have lost my mind by now but it's just so frustrating the fact that
00:48:47 we continue to go down these paths and this if let's we're i'm just gonna if we vote to stay
00:48:55 which i the polls indicate that that's gonna happen i mean i again hope to god that's not the
00:49:03 case but that's the way it looks like it's going and if the rest of the country says you know good
00:49:10 work you know pats us on the head glad that's over let's move on and and just says like this
00:49:17 is a win for the status quo that's what I'm worried about that this is a win that this will
00:49:23 be framed as a win for the status quo that's 55 65 75 percent of Albertans voted to not bother
00:49:31 fixing any of the problems and that's going to be the the takeaway from the establishment figures in
00:49:36 ottawa and edmonton with whether it be within the conservative movement or without it and now we've
00:49:42 got federal politicians who are you know whether it be candidates for nomination or uh conservative
00:49:48 mps that are making the case that we will fix it that we have if you trust us we'll fix it i'm
00:49:55 sorry you've had 120 years there are people that are running for office that were involved in the
00:50:00 the reform party in 1988 that are now candidates for the conservative party of canada that
00:50:06 accomplished absolutely nothing in the last 30 40 years 40 years absolutely nothing and they're
00:50:14 telling us yeah trust us to fix it well you did a good job in 1988 and i don't mean to pour cold
00:50:21 water on the efforts of the reform party because at the time it was a movement and this is the
00:50:29 antithesis this is the the not the antithesis the the evolution of that movement we have got to the
00:50:37 point where we are no longer asking whether we want in we are asking whether we want out this
00:50:42 needs to be addressed the fundamental underlying issues that lead to the fiscal imbalances that
00:50:51 lead to the power imbalances we only have 37 out of the 341 seats in the house of commons
00:50:59 Ontario and Quebec combined have over 200.
00:51:02 Like, that's enough just alone to make a majority.
00:51:04 Carney doesn't need us.
00:51:05 The Liberals don't need us.
00:51:06 And I think the issue that we have is right now, of course, we're going to get the full red carpet.
00:51:13 Canada is great.
00:51:15 Alberta, we're happy to be a part.
00:51:17 We're happy that you are a part of it.
00:51:19 Here's your pipeline.
00:51:20 Here's your little agreement.
00:51:22 Here's your MOU.
00:51:23 We'll give you one.
00:51:23 We'll give you two, maybe.
00:51:25 I think it's only one.
00:51:26 and then on october the 20th there is absolutely no reason to continue this conversation that
00:51:34 canada alberta voted to stay in the country and that you know that's just it that's what i'm
00:51:42 worried about and we again we reached out to brian gene's office and we asked him the minister
00:51:49 of energy whether they had a contingency plan in place that was monday it's thursday at noon and
00:51:55 they haven't got back to us they don't have one they are entirely convinced this is the bureau
00:52:04 this is the top of the food chain in that government has no plans if mark carney turns
00:52:11 around and says yeah we're gonna hit trump with an export tariff on oil and gas and there's
00:52:16 nothing alberta can do about it because they just voted to stay in the country yeah how are you
00:52:23 gonna look then but they don't care because the only thing they're thinking about is surviving
00:52:28 the next three weeks they don't have a long-term vision they don't have a long-term strategy and
00:52:33 that's what they need if you're gonna keep the united conservative party together you have to
00:52:38 provide a unified vision what are what's gonna keep these two factions in the same tent because
00:52:46 simply going around and promoting a single pipeline that might be built in 11 months is not
00:52:52 going to solve the problem it's going to make it worse it's going to make nobody believe it it's
00:52:57 going to burn all your credibility and maybe it's already over maybe we're already in the position
00:53:02 like i mean look danielle smith and her team are capable the most capable people in the politics
00:53:12 in this province of pulling rabbits out of hats i mean they're great at it the sovereignty act i
00:53:18 think is a prime example of that. But sometimes the rabbit they pull out of the hat is dead,
00:53:27 like it was in 2014 when she and nine MLAs that all seemed to be working in high levels of the
00:53:34 Alberta legislature crossed the floor to the PCs and decimated their own careers. But then
00:53:42 She had the Sovereignty Act 1.00
00:53:45 She became the Premier of this province
00:53:48 She maintained the support of the coalition
00:53:52 Won an election over Rachel Notley
00:53:56 And then watched the establishment Conservatives
00:54:01 Crumble in the federal election
00:54:03 And I don't know
00:54:06 It's almost like it was just complete panic
00:54:09 I don't get it
00:54:12 i don't understand it anyways we got five minutes left um
00:54:18 we can go through some of the comments let me pop some up on the screen there john
00:54:24 and if anybody wants to call in i'll take one more call but not as long as the last two i am
00:54:29 i am gonna put the foot down on the next caller although i appreciate rick and i forgot the
00:54:34 other gentleman's name but thank you very much for calling um we're just getting the uh format
00:54:42 up there I actually saw one on Keith Wilson let's close on that I don't know
00:54:56 if it was it's in there somewhere
00:55:00 Phillips Debb, 137.
00:55:03 Can I do it?
00:55:04 No, I can't do it.
00:55:08 137 p.m.
00:55:10 Scroll down.
00:55:12 I'll read it.
00:55:14 Phillips Debb says,
00:55:16 we need Keith Wilson as premier.
00:55:20 Keith has done a fantastic job.
00:55:24 I'm going to chat about a little bit of a background.
00:55:27 So I've known Keith Wilson for a very long time.
00:55:29 i've known danielle for quite a while as well um but keith and danielle have a very similar
00:55:36 story in a way where they before the wild rose party became the wild rose party keith wilson
00:55:44 and danielle smith uh worked loosely together they may have worked closely together than i know
00:55:49 but they loosely worked together fighting the pc government on the land stewardship act which
00:55:56 was an act that was passed in the Alberta legislature,
00:56:00 giving the government the ability to expropriate farmlands
00:56:03 and other lands, any lands,
00:56:05 for projects that were in the province's infrastructure interests.
00:56:12 Daniel Smith used that platform to move in
00:56:18 and take over as leader of the Wildrose Party,
00:56:22 then crossed the floor, then was out of politics for a bit,
00:56:25 The radio show, by the way, I listen to that every morning.
00:56:28 That was top-notch content.
00:56:31 I don't think Global News has recovered from her exit.
00:56:35 But Keith is an absolute dog.
00:56:40 I think the question is, does he want the job?
00:56:42 Oh, well, would Keith take the job?
00:56:45 I don't know how angry Keith Wilson is going to be on October the 20th.
00:56:50 I don't know how motivated he's going to be.
00:56:52 I don't know if an opportunity will present itself where maybe the MOU collapses and Smith just looks like a clown and approval ratings are worse than they are now and the leadership is open and your options are, I don't know, Jeff Rath running or Keith Wilson running.
00:57:15 Does that change his mind?
00:57:18 I think that right now he is the most credible option.
00:57:21 I think he's the biggest threat to the Premier because he is capable.
00:57:28 But I think in FHawk595, I'm not going to read the usernames
00:57:35 because I'm always worried that somebody's going to put something dirty in there
00:57:41 and I'm not going to catch it.
00:57:43 So that one almost caught me.
00:57:45 Thankfully, it wasn't Mike.
00:57:47 The UCP needs some hard reflection on how they are serving the people of Alberta.
00:57:53 That is essential.
00:57:56 The establishment, the activist class, the decision makers,
00:58:05 the riding presidents from Calgary, Beddington, to Highwood, to Acadia, to wherever you are.
00:58:13 yeah we need to we need to seriously reflect on what's going on here and how we're treating each
00:58:20 other that's the worst part of it like i mean two constituency associations have voted to have a
00:58:29 leadership review other constituency associations are voting to not have a leadership review
00:58:33 although i don't think that has any standing in the constitution if you hit 22 you hit 22 even if
00:58:39 65 vote to not do it i mean that's the rule um but i think it's one of those things where like
00:58:46 the issue that they may have moving forward is not the situation they are in now it's the way
00:58:54 that they react to it if they react to it by using procedural controls manipulating processes
00:59:01 uh create doing like some production at the agm to make it look like things are much better than
00:59:08 they really are uh it's just gonna make it worse people aren't gonna people aren't gonna buy it
00:59:13 like that that was the issue with Kenny like Kenny probably could have survived it until they started
00:59:20 messing around with the process every time they did it created a new subsection of frustrated UCP
00:59:29 members that's how that happened David Parker came in at the end and take back Alberta but
00:59:37 take back alberta would have never had any success if the if those elements weren't there
00:59:42 and here we are and it's the same people
00:59:47 i'm hearing the same arguments that i heard in 2022 about why we should not have a leadership
00:59:56 review and also uh they're going to keep saying that we can't change the leader now because
01:00:03 we've got an election in a year i i mean on october 24th the bc conservative party will
01:00:10 determine whether or not that argument holds any standing if the bc conservatives can throw the
01:00:14 leader out with the bathwater and install some insider candidate and still win an election
01:00:20 well i mean what's to say we can't do that here i don't want to see that i want smith to be better
01:00:25 I want the team to do something, save yourself.
01:00:33 But every egg you have is in that basket.
01:00:39 Mark Carney controls your fate, and you have signed up for it.
01:00:47 So I don't know what happens after the referendum.
01:00:51 I can guess.
01:00:53 i think they're going to take the result and say that you know what the grievances aren't that bad
01:00:59 obviously that's the way i think they're going to take and i think that's going to create more
01:01:05 issues there's a lot of people that are voting for this referendum there are a lot of people
01:01:10 that are voting to stay that that do not want to become politically subservient to ottawa no matter
01:01:14 how many one-time projects, approval waiver periods, or whatever bureaucratic hoops you
01:01:26 got to jump through are waived. So, yeah, I'm going to leave it on that. We need, the
01:01:37 The United Conservative Party needs to develop a vision of how we can deal with the true underlying grievances in Confederation to fix these problems that have existed for 120 years.
01:02:04 because if not we're going to be right back here there's going to be just as much
01:02:09 vitriol from the both sides the entire national establishment will line up against
01:02:15 against the independence supporters like it's going to be the same thing but
01:02:19 every wave is larger than the last we've never had an independence referendum in this province before
01:02:25 when i for one don't think that this will be the last one but the province and the government that
01:02:33 was elected to represent it have to take legitimate steps to fix it but they won't
01:02:42 i'm telling you right now i have zero faith that the existing political establishment in this
01:02:48 province will take any steps to resolve the underlying difficulties i believe wholeheartedly
01:02:55 in this moment that the political establishment will take the results of the referendum if it
01:03:00 fails and they will decide that the national status quo is the way to go anyways that's all
01:03:09 for me i've been josh anders covering marty up north today please visit us at www.westernstandard.news
01:03:16 subscription subscriptions options are ten dollars a month uh our standard membership is a hundred
01:03:22 dollars for a year you can also get the editor circle if you want regular uh access to our
01:03:28 insider calls we do those uh oh we were doing it once a month but people aren't really showing up
01:03:32 so we're thinking about going one once a quarter uh that is a i probably shouldn't have said that
01:03:36 on the air but uh that is what we're having conversations about uh in the background uh
01:03:41 again thank you for everybody for watching and have a wonderful afternoon i've been josh i've
01:03:47 I've been Josh Andrus and this is Marty Up North.