Western Standard - August 21, 2026


What if the West really does want out?

Topics
Mentioned
Western Standard News Update | Ontario child sex assault suspect hunted | 20 Aug 2026 CORY MORGAN SHOW: Jason Arday was the tragic victim of his own BS

Episode Stats


Length

22 minutes

Words per minute

166.66

Word count

3,723

Sentence count

108


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Good evening, Western Standard viewers, and welcome to Hannaford, a weekly politics show
00:00:20 of the Western Standard.
00:00:22 With me today is Randy Royer and Natalie St. Hilaire.
00:00:26 Mr. Royer is a Calgary-based entrepreneur, author, and Western Standard columnist
00:00:32 focused on Alberta-Western Canadian issues, democracy, provincial autonomy.
00:00:37 And with Randy comes Natalie.
00:00:39 Natalie St. Hilaire, also an entrepreneur and a columnist for the Western Standard
00:00:44 and, I dare say, others.
00:00:46 She's the host of their podcast, Nation of People.
00:00:50 Randy, Natalie, welcome to the show.
00:00:52 Thank you.
00:00:53 Lovely to have you.
00:00:55 So let me start with you, Randy.
00:00:58 You wrote a book called Alberta Should Lead, Not Leave.
00:01:03 So I guess that makes you a federalist.
00:01:06 Well, I don't think of myself as a federalist.
00:01:09 The way I view myself is I'm a people first kind of person.
00:01:12 And I believe that whatever we end up doing, and I think that there's flexibility in that,
00:01:18 but whatever our political geography turns out to be,
00:01:21 what i really want is i want the people to be in charge and the government institutions and
00:01:26 our elected and judicial people responsible to us rather than the other way around that's my dream
00:01:32 all right natalie um i mean you've run a podcast together i'm i'm assuming that that's more or less
00:01:40 how you see things as well i mean i i do see things a little bit differently than randy but
00:01:46 You know, I think how I characterize myself is as a concerned citizen.
00:01:51 And I don't necessarily have the answer about, you know, what we should do.
00:01:55 I think we're in the middle of a process that's really important and that a lot of other concerned citizens have started.
00:02:01 And I'm what I found in speaking with Randy and in understanding Randy's perspective on particularly the Constitution is that there are some serious issues that really find themselves rooted in that document.
00:02:14 And so it's been such a learning curve for me. And I think that adding that information and knowledge to the echo chamber or the ecosphere, the ether, is really, really important for us right now.
00:02:27 Well, let's talk about those issues then.
00:02:29 The phrase you used, you wanted to see government responsible to the people
00:02:33 rather than people responsible to the government.
00:02:36 Yes.
00:02:37 I mean, I think that's something that anybody who pays attention can see
00:02:40 has evolved over quite a long period of time,
00:02:43 but certainly that's the way the government would like to imagine it.
00:02:49 But now you're talking about the issues that surround new constitutional arrangements.
00:02:55 let's just name it separation independence what is it specifically that you want to change
00:03:03 who wants to go on that well i'll jump in if i may um so my primary thesis that i proposed to
00:03:10 natalie and in our podcast is that the 1982 constitution was a government-based document
00:03:17 that that concentrated power further into the hands of the government and we didn't even have
00:03:22 a say in it. There was no referendum on it. I actually voted against it because I was at a
00:03:29 convention in the Liberal Party where the question was put forward. And I was one of the few people
00:03:34 that voted against it. And the reason is because I knew that that was going to change Canada. It
00:03:40 was going to concentrate power. It was going to create a larger bureaucracy. So you are actually
00:03:44 a reformed Liberal. Well, the story in our podcast that I tell is that I entered national politics
00:03:51 to figure out what was going on how could we have western alienation in a democracy and so i with a
00:03:58 bunch of other people uh decided we were either going to join the the what was the wcc at the time
00:04:03 or the federal liberals because we said you know there's lots of good people in the conservative
00:04:08 party uh let's do something contrary so i ended up being in the in the liberal party and quite
00:04:13 honestly i came to understand what the problems were at the national level and i don't want them
00:04:19 If we have a separate Alberta, I don't want them to infect Alberta
00:04:24 the way it's infected Canada.
00:04:26 Well, Randy, what were the problems?
00:04:28 Once you had infiltrated the Liberal Party, what did you find?
00:04:32 Concentration of power is probably the biggest one.
00:04:36 The Prime Minister's office, for example, in the first Trudeau's era,
00:04:42 it was a scandalous 115 people in the PMO and the Privy Council.
00:04:47 Now it's 1,500 people.
00:04:50 And so what I understand now is that in the later stages of the Trudeau era,
00:04:55 this last Trudeau era, no one in the bureaucracy would do anything
00:04:58 without checking in the Prime Minister's office.
00:05:01 So the concentration of power is incredible.
00:05:04 That's number one.
00:05:05 Number two is that we have all these entrenched things that keeps the power
00:05:10 in their hands.
00:05:12 And that just fundamentally has to change in order to give the power
00:05:16 back to the people.
00:05:17 So, just supposing, and I know that you are not here to advance the independence cause,
00:05:25 but there are many Albertans who do want to take Alberta out of Canada.
00:05:32 Yep.
00:05:33 All right, let's say they succeed.
00:05:36 Are they not going to run into the same kind of dynamics where power tends to flow towards the middle?
00:05:42 What would you say to them?
00:05:45 I wouldn't use the term towards the middle.
00:05:47 i would say that the power tends to get concentrated and that's the problem and and the
00:05:52 same issues that we have at the national level it basically replicated at the provincial level
00:05:56 the good thing about in alberta is that we have this history of populism and of interaction between
00:06:04 you know the ralph klein was a good example he mean he went and talked to people average people
00:06:10 on a daily basis so it's a little closer so it's less of a problem but even in an independent
00:06:15 in Alberta with the same institutions, it will eventually get worse and worse and worse.
00:06:20 Natalie, do you think that's something that's peculiar to Alberta and Canada, or is this kind
00:06:25 of the way politics works all over the world, or at least in what we might call the liberal
00:06:30 democratic world? Well, I think what's changed for me is that the story I was told about a
00:06:36 constitution is that it was well thought out and decided upon by people that have education and
00:06:43 have spent time understanding how institutions should work together, what the balance of power
00:06:47 should be, checks and balances, really an American story about the Constitution. And I thought that
00:06:53 we had a similar structure. I knew it was different, but I thought it was similarly well
00:06:58 conceived of in Canada. What I've come to learn by talking to Randy, who was actually there when
00:07:04 Pierre Elliott Trudeau proposed it, and who, you know, really, you witnessed how the premiers
00:07:09 negotiated about the constitution was that we have this foundational document now that is really
00:07:15 about solving a political problem at the time for the liberals and not about how our country is going
00:07:21 to run in the long run with appropriate checks and balances that would hopefully stop this sort
00:07:27 of cascading of power into a centralized body. And that's what I'm hopeful for is a structure
00:07:35 and a foundation that actually has checks and balances.
00:07:38 Well, what do you think was the problem
00:07:40 that the Liberals were trying to solve in 1982?
00:07:43 Well, I think Quebec was trying to separate.
00:07:46 I think that, and ultimately, I do think that
00:07:50 what had become clear over the 70s
00:07:53 is that Alberta had a lot of natural resource wealth,
00:07:56 particularly in terms of oil.
00:07:59 And they had, I think that foundationally in Canada,
00:08:04 we need to wrestle with what do we do with our natural resource revenue especially who's the we
00:08:10 who's doing the wrestling here well between the west and the east between the west and the east
00:08:14 i mean we would like to be in complete control of our natural resource revenue but there seems to
00:08:19 be some tension right between alberta and ottawa about who really gets the the benefit of that
00:08:26 uh natural resource extraction of course in the original original constitution randy you're going
00:08:31 to correct me if i'm wrong here is the provinces have it but since the 70s i think it's become
00:08:37 apparent to ottawa and people out east that we might be profiting off of something that they
00:08:42 can't control or profit off similarly from well i think you're certainly speaking for a lot of
00:08:48 people when you when you couch it in those terms that brings us back to equalization and the
00:08:56 distribution of wealth and so on but we were talking earlier and we were talking about how
00:09:02 there is a set of values that seem to be entrenched in the politics of eastern canada
00:09:08 that we're not really sympathetic with in alberta and you know you might characterize it as like
00:09:18 you don't have the money but stay out of our face you know and how is it that
00:09:24 Ottawa gets in Alberta's face well Nigel thanks very much for setting this up because that is
00:09:30 exactly what we talk about in episode three of our podcast and we go back to the very roots that
00:09:36 the you know the populating of eastern Canada was a very different process than the populating of
00:09:41 western Canada and so we talk about how there's very different characters you know not neither is
00:09:48 right or wrong it's just they're different and uh and we talk about uh eastern canada and to some
00:09:54 degree the pacific uh you know vancouver and victoria they were colonies of britain they were
00:09:59 direct colonies of britain so when the people came there they came there to support well actually
00:10:05 the european king including uh including quebec and so they their character is is really uh
00:10:11 continuity loyalty and deference to authority when alberta and the west were colonized
00:10:18 They didn't have enough loyal British citizens to colonize the West,
00:10:22 so they opened it up to people from all over Europe and a bunch from the United States.
00:10:26 And those people came to the West seeking freedom, democracy, and a right to build new life.
00:10:32 Which is a different suite of values, isn't it?
00:10:35 Totally different suite of values.
00:10:38 And the 82 Constitution was built on the Eastern values,
00:10:43 and it viewed the West's values
00:10:47 as something that needed to be extinguished over time.
00:10:49 But you know, Randy or Hillary,
00:10:51 if you want to get, sorry, Natalie,
00:10:53 if you want to get right into it,
00:10:55 I don't think that that's the stuff,
00:11:01 the deferential, fall-up, tugging,
00:11:05 set suite of values that we're objecting to here.
00:11:09 We see things like the encroachment on personal liberty
00:11:13 that has come from a whole batch of legislation
00:11:17 that's before us at the moment.
00:11:19 They want to read your email, for heaven's sake.
00:11:22 If you object to some of the social values
00:11:27 that they're promoting, let's name them,
00:11:29 I mean, the trans and this kind of thing,
00:11:33 that's not the only one, but that's a common one
00:11:36 that gets brought up in conversation.
00:11:38 Well, then they trash you.
00:11:39 so that's i think what rubs a lot of people the wrong way or am i wrong and no you're not wrong
00:11:47 you're absolutely right uh but what we're describing is that the character is foundational
00:11:52 and from character comes culture from culture comes the way you think and then the decisions
00:11:58 that you make the actions you take and then the net results so at the very base at the very character
00:12:04 we have two very different ways of thinking and so those issues that you just brought up
00:12:09 to eastern canada they defer to authority and the authority says well we need to read your emails
00:12:15 in western canada we want it we want freedom we want to not be hindered by an intrusive government
00:12:22 and so those things are absolutely offensive to us and so that is the primary divide and so
00:12:28 So if we are to remain as a country, my position, and Natalie supports me on this one,
00:12:35 at least helps me draw it out, is that we have to have a constitution
00:12:40 that enables, allows, and encourages both sets of characters.
00:12:45 Is that possible?
00:12:46 Well, it is possible.
00:12:47 It would be sort of black and white at the same time?
00:12:49 Well, one of the ways to do it is to push sovereignty down.
00:12:54 to push sovereignty you know we talk about the two-nation policy where you know the ottawa and
00:13:01 quebec views the country as two nations one a sovereign quebec and the other english canada
00:13:06 that's a unitary state well english canada is not a unitary state the west is very different than
00:13:11 ontario and so let's one solution is to push the sovereign the the you know power down so that the
00:13:19 provinces can make those decisions not just the federal government i imagine at some point you've
00:13:24 been to halifax oh yeah yeah i love so well as a matter of fact so do i it was a great place
00:13:29 some good times there um when you go to halifax there's the fortress on the top of the hill and
00:13:35 the big old cannons there from 200 years ago pointing out over the over the water and the
00:13:43 old town is just tucked in close they got as as close as they could to protection because they
00:13:51 saw the government as their friend and their provider and their protector that's why they left
00:13:57 the 13 colonies because that was not the kind of government that was forming there
00:14:03 and you come out to west western canada and where is our old town clustered under the fort
00:14:12 you know we don't have one people got as far away from government as they possibly could
00:14:18 And out in the freedom of the prairies, they built their own lives the way they wanted to build them.
00:14:23 I see that as a picture of the difference between the Eastern mindset and the Western mindset.
00:14:31 What do you say?
00:14:32 Sorry, I'm going to jump in here if you don't mind, Natalie.
00:14:35 But what's very interesting is that going backwards and taking a broader perspective,
00:14:42 what's happening is there's a slight trend towards alberta's way of thinking that you know
00:14:49 government has become too intrusive and so you've taken this is happening back east this is happening
00:14:54 i think of ontario yes and even in quebec you know the the way they look at at uh at their
00:15:00 nationalism now is it's not it's not as strong as it's really more you know individualism is
00:15:06 gaining power and and as you said we're steeped in it deeply here in the west and it's just
00:15:13 starting to emerge and so that's why my view of this nation of people thing is is that
00:15:19 if you empower people it will encourage the blossoming of individualism in eastern canada
00:15:25 but you have to recognize that they they need to have the right in their province to you know to
00:15:32 have collectivism and and and you know the good thing about the collectivism you're talking about
00:15:37 you know at the bottom at the base of halifax is it's also a social um uh social glue and so you
00:15:44 know the the as we change and as we become more nationalist sorry more individualistic we also
00:15:51 want to maintain the social glue that which is the strength of the east so um but you're you're
00:15:57 quite right the united empire loyalists i mean literally they fled freedom and democracy and
00:16:01 And that populated much of Ontario and Atlantic Canada.
00:16:05 And somehow those ideas, go ahead, you're going to remark on that?
00:16:08 I agree.
00:16:09 I mean, I grew up in Ontario until grade eight.
00:16:13 And when I got to Alberta, I felt like I could finally breathe again.
00:16:16 And I realized it's because of this individual sovereign spirit, this pioneering and entrepreneurial idea that anybody can make something of themselves in their lives.
00:16:26 And you need a strong sense of individualism, I think, to feel that energy that we have here.
00:16:31 And it's quite different than Ontario, where it's sort of like it's who you know.
00:16:35 It's where you're positioned in society.
00:16:38 Everybody follows the general construct of things and knows their spot and follows along or tries to climb a ladder that way.
00:16:48 And I prefer to feel like I could make something of myself regardless of who I know or where I come from.
00:16:53 i've just been given the five minute signal so i'm going to ask you both to summarize what it is
00:16:59 that you are trying to achieve through your podcast nation of people uh where do you want
00:17:08 if you if you're king for a day where would you want to albertans to land when they go and vote
00:17:16 in this referendum on october the 19th you want to go ahead yeah well i mean i want people to vote
00:17:23 in a way that they feel really well informed about and with a deep understanding of the issues
00:17:28 that we're facing. I don't have a preference about, you know, people want to vote to stay or
00:17:34 they want to vote to leave. I think they have to look at the moment that we're in, the opportunity
00:17:38 to have leverage to change things. And, you know, what they choose to do, I just hope that I just
00:17:46 hope they all go out there and vote because it is a very consequential referendum. Oh, yeah,
00:17:51 absolutely so what specific structural reforms would you want to see to keep alberta within
00:18:01 confederation and happy to be there um do you mind if i go back and ask you answer your first
00:18:06 question first about king of the day yeah sure because i have an answer that i really want to
00:18:10 get out so if i were a king for that for a day the first thing i would do is sign a massive magna
00:18:16 card to say to everyone you have the power don't look to the king and if you have the power you
00:18:24 also have the responsibility so responsibility requires engagement and information and a wise
00:18:30 decision and i would say as king i believe in your wisdom i believe that you can think this
00:18:36 through and come up with the right answer and the right strategy and and so i would i think the most
00:18:42 important thing is empowering people and that's what we want to do on nation of people all right
00:18:47 okay well looking past october the 19th then um what sort of an what does success look like
00:18:57 what would be the kind of outcome i'm talking about the percentage support perhaps uh but
00:19:06 regardless of the final numbers how do you how do you hope that this settles out because somebody
00:19:14 is going to be disappointed someone's going to be disappointed and i'm hoping that we can find
00:19:20 something that replicates what has happened in alberta's history which is that we find common
00:19:27 ground amongst the people not a political common ground but a common ground for the people and
00:19:32 that we can have a massive movement towards that that's that's my aspiration i don't exactly know
00:19:37 what that is and it's part of our process they have to be i have a mechanism to express it and
00:19:42 that's where you run into the well cynical central government uh well this i mean i think that this
00:19:49 referendum is it could potentially i'll put it that way be that mechanism because we saw that
00:19:56 through the quebec separatist movement canada changed and uh there's two scenarios where that
00:20:03 we're looking at one is where alberta starts its march out of the country or alternatively
00:20:08 canada might say this is our time to grow up and to actually start thinking and i'm seeing it right
00:20:16 across the country right now this movement is alberta is causing people to say well what have
00:20:20 we done wrong and that might be it are they really asking themselves that i think there will
00:20:26 there's some that are or are they just oh there goes alberta again there's some that are doing
00:20:30 that too um no but you what you want to do is is again if you look at the entrepreneurial class
00:20:35 in in ontario they're questioning because they're a little bit sympathetic you look at the
00:20:41 individualists in in quebec they're questioning because they want individualism to rise so i
00:20:49 think that it's not everybody but there are those that are questioning so i think that if we decide
00:20:54 to stay in canada i'm hoping it's a cathartic moment that canada can come to life and to start
00:21:00 being what it actually could be and and i think alberta separatism could be the catalyst for that
00:21:07 last question to both of you how strong will the yes vote be not elite i think it's going to be
00:21:13 stronger than people think i think that a lot of people are going to be a number a number i think
00:21:20 there's a good chance they win. Really? Yeah, I do right now. Okay. How about you, Randy? I have
00:21:25 no idea. Oh, come on. I think, you know, it's all going to unfold with what happens, what the
00:21:31 leaders decide to do. Right now, I think, I mean, I just go with what the polls are saying, 30% in
00:21:36 favor. But I think what Natalie is thinking is that the no side, the remain side may not show up
00:21:43 because they message you and say, oh, this is a silly question. And I think it's dangerous to not
00:21:48 be engaged and that really is your message isn't it it is yes yeah thank you very much thank you
00:21:54 both natalie and randy thank you for joining us here today it's been great to talk to you i think
00:21:59 we may need to have you back i look forward to it thank you very much you're very welcome
00:22:04 for the western standard i'm nigel hannaford
00:22:18 You