Ali Dawah - ARE NASHEEDS REALLY HARAM？？ ALI DAWAH

00:00:00.000 Assalamualaikum warahmatullahi wabarakatuh

00:00:01.720 Brothers and sisters and dear friends

00:00:02.780 Welcome to this controversial video

00:00:04.180 Which has been quite controversial

00:00:06.140 Not this video but the video we're going to talk about

00:00:08.300 Before we start we want to praise Allah

00:00:10.260 The most merciful, the most just

00:00:11.860 Or praise His glory and gratitude belong to Him

00:00:13.860 For the works that we do

00:00:15.020 Now obviously as you guys know we released a Nasheed video

00:00:17.800 And in this Nasheed video

00:00:19.480 A lot of people start getting a panic attack

00:00:21.680 Or should we call it a piety attack

00:00:23.040 Basically saying it's not permissible

00:00:26.120 You know it looks haram

00:00:28.080 You know you guys are imitating the kufar 1.00

00:00:30.340 With your hand movements

00:00:31.300 You know Omar Issa's voice is sound

00:00:34.520 He's trying to make his voice sound like a woman 0.98

00:00:36.760 That's imitating a woman 1.00

00:00:37.680 Which is backbiting

00:00:38.760 Because you don't even know if he's doing that

00:00:40.860 Just because his voice is a certain way

00:00:42.060 And all these kind of madness has been going on

00:00:45.040 Like you use music

00:00:46.020 Blah blah blah blah blah

00:00:47.340 So basically what we did

00:00:49.140 We said you know what let's look into this

00:00:50.380 Yeah let's look into this

00:00:51.320 Without being biased

00:00:52.540 Because we don't do Nasheed as a living

00:00:53.860 Yeah you know what I'm trying to say

00:00:55.280 Like you could say okay Omar Issa's going to be biased

00:00:57.380 But us

00:00:58.180 So we looked into the matter

00:00:59.980 And also to do the video

00:01:01.380 We paid out of our own pocket

00:01:02.300 So we're not gaining anything

00:01:03.260 So

00:01:04.160 Musa actually looked into the matter

00:01:05.860 In depth

00:01:06.380 Because I've been quite busy

00:01:07.200 He's been speaking to a brother in Medina

00:01:09.440 And he's been in contact with him

00:01:11.140 Not in Medina but yeah

00:01:12.360 He's in Riyadh

00:01:13.640 Yeah

00:01:14.020 Riyadh same thing

00:01:14.900 Did you just say Riyadh and Medina

00:01:18.000 The same thing

00:01:18.680 Yeah anyway

00:01:19.280 So basically

00:01:20.820 He's been in contact with them

00:01:22.520 To be honest

00:01:23.740 Before I go into a moral tantrum

00:01:24.960 Because I've got a lot

00:01:25.600 To get out of my chest

00:01:26.660 We're going to let Musa 0.80

00:01:28.240 Elaborate

00:01:29.480 On what he found out

00:01:30.440 Musa

00:01:30.660 What did you find out

00:01:31.280 Yeah so

00:01:31.940 Bismillah

00:01:32.600 Alhamdulillah

00:01:33.160 Salatu wassalam 0.99

00:01:34.060 A'la Rasulullah

00:01:34.860 Sallallahu alayhi wasallam

00:01:36.040 Firstly

00:01:38.060 You know the reason for us

00:01:40.600 Doing the video

00:01:41.500 I want to structure the video

00:01:43.300 A little bit

00:01:43.840 Firstly

00:01:44.700 I want to say why we chose

00:01:46.940 To do the video

00:01:47.640 As Ali mentioned

00:01:49.160 We have no benefit

00:01:52.460 In terms of income

00:01:53.520 From this

00:01:53.940 Actually

00:01:54.360 It really put a hole in my pocket

00:01:56.040 A little bit

00:01:56.940 But

00:01:58.080 We actually paid out of our pockets

00:02:00.760 To do it

00:02:01.320 And

00:02:02.360 Omar Issa

00:02:03.260 Actually paid

00:02:04.160 Hundreds of pounds

00:02:05.800 Hundreds of pounds

00:02:07.020 Nearly to a thousand pounds

00:02:08.240 In total

00:02:09.520 To actually get the production

00:02:10.880 Of this video

00:02:11.720 It might have even been

00:02:12.780 Over a thousand pounds

00:02:13.840 So a lot of brothers

00:02:14.900 Seem to think that

00:02:15.780 We're getting some sort of

00:02:16.620 Benefit from this

00:02:17.440 We're not

00:02:18.420 Frankly

00:02:18.860 We are not

00:02:19.340 Nasheed artists

00:02:20.040 Me and Ali

00:02:20.640 We make videos on YouTube

00:02:22.460 To try and benefit the youth

00:02:23.640 So this is not our field

00:02:25.180 But Omar came to us

00:02:26.620 And said

00:02:27.140 Brothers

00:02:27.460 There's an issue at hand

00:02:28.540 I want you guys

00:02:29.660 To help me address it

00:02:30.520 Because you're very outspoken

00:02:31.640 In these things

00:02:32.380 And we were like

00:02:33.280 You know what

00:02:34.300 It does seem like

00:02:35.500 There's an issue

00:02:36.040 And we should address it

00:02:37.060 Inshallah

00:02:37.440 So that's why

00:02:39.060 We done the Nasheed

00:02:39.760 You agree that

00:02:40.600 That's the reason

00:02:41.080 We done it right

00:02:41.680 Yeah

00:02:41.980 So now

00:02:43.220 After we done the Nasheed

00:02:45.440 As Brother Ali mentioned

00:02:46.520 We had a lot of brothers

00:02:47.900 Showing their concern

00:02:49.160 Was there music

00:02:49.980 Used in the Nasheed

00:02:50.880 Firstly I'd like to clarify

00:02:52.460 That there was no

00:02:53.320 Musical instruments

00:02:54.380 Used in the making

00:02:55.700 Of that Nasheed

00:02:56.520 A few other issues

00:02:57.460 Started coming up

00:02:58.280 As well

00:02:58.660 Amongst other brothers

00:02:59.900 Saying that

00:03:00.460 Nasheeds are impermissible 1.00

00:03:01.800 You can't do Nasheeds 1.00

00:03:03.480 Whether it's got music

00:03:04.560 In it or not

00:03:05.360 A lot of brothers

00:03:06.060 Started saying

00:03:06.680 That we are

00:03:07.320 Imitating the Kuffar 1.00

00:03:08.600 And we are doing

00:03:10.300 You know

00:03:10.920 A lot of wrong things

00:03:12.680 And the Nasheed

00:03:13.420 In the first place

00:03:14.060 Is haram

00:03:14.700 La dee da dee da

00:03:15.740 There was a lot of

00:03:16.380 Reasoning given

00:03:17.320 So you know what

00:03:18.440 I know a brother

00:03:19.780 Personally

00:03:20.680 So does Ali

00:03:22.220 Who's studying

00:03:23.220 In Imam Saud

00:03:24.600 University

00:03:25.220 In Riyadh

00:03:26.060 He's a very close

00:03:27.360 Brother of mine

00:03:27.960 I speak to him

00:03:28.600 Nearly every single day

00:03:29.760 He's really really close

00:03:31.340 I'm considering

00:03:31.900 One of my best friends now

00:03:33.100 And I spoke to him

00:03:36.040 And he has access

00:03:37.000 To some of the

00:03:37.740 Kibar Ulama

00:03:38.580 Over there in Saudi Arabia

00:03:40.040 And the Kibar Ulama

00:03:40.980 For anyone that doesn't know

00:03:42.120 Who they are

00:03:42.660 What does Kibar Ulama mean?

00:03:44.040 Maybe there's people

00:03:44.480 That don't know

00:03:44.700 I'm about to clarify

00:03:45.960 Sorry

00:03:46.400 So the Kibar Ulama 0.90

00:03:48.840 Are actually

00:03:49.680 A select few

00:03:52.040 Around

00:03:52.760 30

00:03:53.620 40 Ulama

00:03:54.540 That are

00:03:55.740 Very very big

00:03:56.760 So they are scholars

00:03:57.480 That have been around

00:03:58.280 In Saudi Arabia

00:03:58.980 For some time

00:03:59.760 They've studied

00:04:00.680 Extensively

00:04:01.620 And they are actually

00:04:02.640 Picked

00:04:03.220 Handpicked

00:04:04.560 To actually serve

00:04:05.500 In the council

00:04:06.020 Of judiciary scholars

00:04:07.060 Currently I think

00:04:08.700 If I'm not mistaken

00:04:09.420 There's 21 of them

00:04:10.560 So he has access

00:04:11.640 To people like that

00:04:12.540 So I said to him

00:04:13.320 Bro

00:04:13.560 Here's the video

00:04:14.620 Please find out for us

00:04:15.940 Is it halal?

00:04:16.960 Is it haram?

00:04:17.600 What's wrong with it?

00:04:18.540 If it was haram

00:04:19.360 Me and Ali

00:04:20.480 And Omar

00:04:21.420 We're fully willing

00:04:22.560 To take it down

00:04:23.340 And never do any of this again

00:04:24.720 So

00:04:25.960 You know

00:04:26.720 Because we don't have

00:04:27.340 Benefit in this

00:04:28.040 So

00:04:28.940 The brother done his research

00:04:31.220 And he came back to me

00:04:32.520 But hold on a second

00:04:33.700 When you say

00:04:34.400 He done his research

00:04:35.320 Now there might be

00:04:36.340 People out there

00:04:36.780 Saying you know what

00:04:37.300 You just went

00:04:37.840 And told him

00:04:38.980 How you wanted to tell him

00:04:39.880 What this about

00:04:40.540 Did we go and just

00:04:42.880 Tell him

00:04:43.260 Or did he hear it?

00:04:44.740 So basically

00:04:45.320 What I told him to do

00:04:46.340 Is I told him

00:04:47.360 To explain the content

00:04:48.540 Of the Nasheed

00:04:49.680 To the scholars

00:04:50.400 That he asks

00:04:51.080 I asked him to ask

00:04:52.520 About the permissibility

00:04:53.560 Of a Nasheed

00:04:54.320 In the first place

00:04:55.160 And I also asked him

00:04:56.900 To ask about

00:04:58.280 The sound of the Nasheed

00:05:00.080 Does it sound like music?

00:05:01.460 Did they hear it?

00:05:02.460 Yes they heard it

00:05:03.440 These scholars heard it?

00:05:04.500 These scholars heard it

00:05:05.640 So the scholars

00:05:06.580 That I'm about to mention to you

00:05:07.660 Not that they heard about it

00:05:08.400 They heard it

00:05:08.940 They heard the Nasheed

00:05:09.800 It was played to them

00:05:10.540 And they actually

00:05:11.540 Called other people

00:05:12.300 Okay come and listen to this

00:05:13.700 What do you think of this?

00:05:14.400 So they actually

00:05:15.280 Even asked other people's

00:05:16.320 Opinions who were there

00:05:17.200 Now

00:05:18.220 Firstly

00:05:19.380 I want to put a statement

00:05:22.280 Of Shaykh bin Baaz 0.92

00:05:23.180 Out there

00:05:23.580 Shaykh bin Baaz

00:05:25.080 This is the translation

00:05:26.140 He said

00:05:27.280 Islamic Nasheeds differ

00:05:28.620 If these Nasheeds are good 1.00

00:05:30.720 And there's nothing in them

00:05:32.200 Except calling towards goodness

00:05:33.780 And reminding people of goodness

00:05:35.680 And also to the obedience

00:05:37.360 Of Allah

00:05:37.880 And the messenger

00:05:39.600 Then there's no problem with this

00:05:42.780 But if it calls towards sins

00:05:44.620 And free mixing

00:05:45.440 Between men and women 1.00

00:05:46.580 Or it calls towards any corruption

00:05:48.740 Then this is not permissible

00:05:50.480 Islamic Nasheeds 0.95

00:05:51.980 Such as poetry

00:05:53.080 If it's okay

00:05:54.140 Then it's okay

00:05:54.840 If it contains munkar

00:05:56.100 Then it is munkar

00:05:57.640 So basically

00:05:58.560 What Shaykh bin Baaz

00:05:59.480 Is saying

00:05:59.880 Is that

00:06:00.820 If there is a Nasheed

00:06:01.780 That's calling towards goodness

00:06:02.900 Calling towards worshipping

00:06:04.480 Allah alone

00:06:05.240 Calling towards worshipping

00:06:06.600 Allah in His oneness 0.56

00:06:07.540 Then that is fine

00:06:08.640 If it is calling towards goodness

00:06:10.520 It's fine

00:06:11.040 If it's calling towards bad

00:06:12.300 And free mixing

00:06:13.000 Then it's not good

00:06:14.420 So but the question here is

00:06:16.200 Does that mean

00:06:17.440 You're doing Dawah 0.99

00:06:19.420 From Nasheed

00:06:19.880 Isn't that Bidah 0.74

00:06:20.440 Well technically

00:06:22.240 It can be classed as Dawah

00:06:24.940 And the reason

00:06:26.360 That it is not classed as Bidah

00:06:28.560 And the reason why

00:06:29.680 Shaykh bin Baaz

00:06:30.300 Did not mention it as Bidah

00:06:31.560 Is because

00:06:32.640 It's very very clear

00:06:34.080 That even at the time

00:06:35.580 Of the Prophet

00:06:36.080 Sallallahu alayhi wa sallam

00:06:37.080 Hassan bin Thabit

00:06:39.660 Was a poet

00:06:41.060 And the Prophet

00:06:42.260 Sallallahu alayhi wa sallam

00:06:43.280 Allowed him

00:06:44.200 To do this poetry

00:06:45.200 Like

00:06:45.920 You know this is poetry

00:06:55.720 Describing the Prophet

00:06:56.700 Sallallahu alayhi wa sallam

00:06:57.560 So can we say that's Dawah 0.77

00:06:58.520 Of course that's Dawah 1.00

00:07:00.200 Of course

00:07:00.540 If I was a non-Muslim

00:07:01.540 And I heard someone

00:07:02.760 Doing nice poetry

00:07:03.740 About someone

00:07:04.380 That's attractive

00:07:05.420 What is Dawah 0.91

00:07:06.240 Dawah is calling to Islam 1.00

00:07:07.820 Dawah is calling towards 0.75

00:07:09.100 Allah subhanahu wa ta'ala 0.81

00:07:10.140 Calling towards the messenger

00:07:11.460 Of the Prophet Muhammad

00:07:12.420 Sallallahu alayhi wa sallam

00:07:13.340 So if he's calling towards

00:07:15.120 The Prophet

00:07:15.440 Sallallahu alayhi wa sallam

00:07:16.080 And he's saying

00:07:16.620 Attractive words about him

00:07:17.740 What is that technically

00:07:19.540 So I feel like

00:07:21.240 A lot of brothers

00:07:21.740 Get into the issue of

00:07:22.700 Was it Dawah 0.80

00:07:23.340 Was it not Dawah 0.71

00:07:24.200 I feel like that's a

00:07:25.620 That's a whole

00:07:26.320 You need to define

00:07:27.080 What is Dawah 0.91

00:07:27.640 Yes

00:07:28.040 In the first place

00:07:28.900 What do you define as Dawah

00:07:30.620 Do you get what I'm trying to say

00:07:31.300 Because you have Mishari 0.98

00:07:32.900 Who says

00:07:33.320 Ar-Rahman

00:07:34.340 Ar-Rahman

00:07:34.780 You're talking about Allah 0.96

00:07:35.820 Tawheed

00:07:36.400 But even though we do know

00:07:50.500 Is there a difference

00:07:51.100 Opinion on this matter

00:07:51.780 There is

00:07:52.800 And we'll go into that

00:07:54.040 Okay

00:07:54.340 Now

00:07:54.760 To further go on

00:07:56.980 In Saudi Arabia

00:07:58.000 In certain masajid

00:07:59.140 The shayyukh 1.00

00:08:00.200 They have their offices

00:08:01.060 In certain masajid

00:08:02.420 So there's one sheikh 1.00

00:08:04.800 Who was in the council

00:08:06.940 Of judiciary scholars

00:08:08.080 He's one of the

00:08:09.080 Kibar ulama

00:08:09.840 In Saudi Arabia

00:08:10.480 He's very very big

00:08:11.580 He's very very known

00:08:12.780 Amongst the students of knowledge

00:08:13.960 And shayyukh 0.99

00:08:14.980 In this country

00:08:15.780 In Saudi Arabia

00:08:16.560 He's very big

00:08:17.160 His name is

00:08:18.120 Sheikh Sa'ad

00:08:18.760 Ibn Turki

00:08:19.360 Al-Khathlan 0.94

00:08:19.960 The nasheed was played

00:08:21.960 To him directly

00:08:22.760 So the nasheed was played

00:08:23.800 To Sheikh Sa'ad

00:08:24.480 Ibn Turki

00:08:24.980 Al-Khathlan 0.94

00:08:25.580 As I mentioned

00:08:26.200 He's a very very big scholar

00:08:27.240 In Saudi Arabia

00:08:27.940 And the funny thing is

00:08:29.980 While he was actually

00:08:30.700 Playing it

00:08:31.280 He called the imam

00:08:33.060 Of the masjid he was in

00:08:34.100 He called other people

00:08:35.060 Come come listen to this

00:08:36.220 So they were all

00:08:37.560 Listening to it

00:08:38.220 And after it was played

00:08:39.660 He said

00:08:41.100 He said

00:08:42.020 There's no music in this

00:08:43.220 And he also said

00:08:45.040 That there's nothing wrong with it

00:08:46.280 He said

00:08:46.780 Alhamdulillah

00:08:47.220 There's nothing wrong with this nasheed

00:08:48.520 And he gave us advice

00:08:50.860 That the brothers

00:08:51.580 You know

00:08:52.580 You need to be careful

00:08:53.900 What you do put in the nasheed

00:08:55.140 Because you know

00:08:56.180 Certain people might speak bad about you

00:08:57.860 So he was like

00:08:59.080 But Alhamdulillah

00:08:59.680 The nasheed

00:09:00.120 There's nothing wrong with it

00:09:01.160 So that's Sheikh Sa'ad

00:09:02.180 Ibn Turki

00:09:02.620 Al-Khathlan 0.94

00:09:03.120 Now there's another sheikh 1.00

00:09:04.500 Who is in the council

00:09:05.400 Of Jidrushri's college

00:09:06.280 Sheikh Abdullah Rukban

00:09:07.440 He's or was

00:09:08.540 No he is

00:09:09.540 He is

00:09:09.920 As far as I know

00:09:10.660 He is

00:09:11.120 Wallahu alim

00:09:12.520 He actually mentioned

00:09:15.180 That nasheeds 0.95

00:09:16.320 In general

00:09:17.680 They are permissible

00:09:18.620 Nasheeds are permissible 1.00

00:09:19.700 To do

00:09:20.180 And

00:09:21.720 Yeah that's what he mentioned

00:09:23.420 There's another sheikh as well 1.00

00:09:24.820 Who is very very

00:09:25.700 Very popular

00:09:26.760 Sheikh Sa'ad

00:09:27.960 Ashitri

00:09:28.840 Sheikh Sa'ad

00:09:29.420 Al-Nasir Ashitri

00:09:30.260 He is in the council

00:09:32.720 Of judiciary scholars as well

00:09:33.880 So he's one of the

00:09:34.560 Kibar ulama as well

00:09:35.540 And he actually mentioned

00:09:37.320 That nasheeds are permissible 1.00

00:09:38.600 But there's a few conditions

00:09:40.020 To them

00:09:40.440 The conditions should be

00:09:41.840 That there's no

00:09:42.360 Kufr and shirk in them 0.98

00:09:43.480 That there's no swearing in them

00:09:45.800 That the nasheed 0.84

00:09:47.080 Has no bid'ah

00:09:48.920 You know

00:09:49.640 There's no music in it

00:09:51.260 And that the nasheed

00:09:53.160 Is not called an

00:09:54.120 Islamic nasheed

00:09:55.080 And the reason he said that

00:09:56.540 Is because a lot of people say

00:09:58.060 That if you call something

00:09:59.260 An Islamic nasheed

00:10:00.140 Then you're inventing

00:10:01.120 Something new in Islam 0.97

00:10:02.100 So brothers and sisters

00:10:03.720 In a nutshell

00:10:04.660 I don't want this to get too long

00:10:06.600 This is the opinion

00:10:08.420 That we follow

00:10:09.060 This is the opinion

00:10:09.980 That we feel

00:10:11.880 Right to follow

00:10:13.560 Because we've looked

00:10:14.700 Into the evidences

00:10:15.480 I looked into the evidences

00:10:16.760 And for me

00:10:17.480 I'm convinced at this

00:10:18.800 Because the fact of the matter is

00:10:20.500 We live in an age

00:10:21.360 In a society

00:10:21.980 Where there's a lot of brothers

00:10:23.820 Subhanallah

00:10:24.820 Using music

00:10:25.740 Doing a lot of haram things

00:10:27.240 In their videos

00:10:27.780 Dancing and what not

00:10:28.940 And us as brothers

00:10:30.880 We feel that it's right

00:10:32.700 To support people

00:10:33.600 Like Omar Isa

00:10:34.320 Who are doing

00:10:35.260 The halal option 1.00

00:10:36.200 Where they're not using music

00:10:37.180 They're not putting bid'ah 0.98

00:10:38.100 They're not putting

00:10:38.600 Kufr and shirk

00:10:39.300 And the nasheeds

00:10:39.840 And they're using an alternative

00:10:41.600 For the youth to listen to

00:10:43.320 Now

00:10:44.020 It's easy to use music

00:10:46.180 What makes

00:10:47.020 Brother Omar Isa

00:10:47.500 The difference is that

00:10:48.180 He abstains from that

00:10:49.320 And brings a halal alternative 0.98

00:10:50.580 And we should support

00:10:51.940 The brother in what he does

00:10:53.080 Yes exactly

00:10:53.860 Now that's our opinion

00:10:55.500 That we follow

00:10:56.160 The reason that I'm mentioning

00:10:57.780 This is our opinion

00:10:58.720 Is that we have a lot of

00:10:59.780 Excited brothers out there

00:11:01.120 That

00:11:01.860 I love the word haram

00:11:03.200 And brothers

00:11:03.720 Please

00:11:04.200 Pay heed to what I'm about to say

00:11:06.800 Inshallah

00:11:07.160 You're very excited

00:11:09.100 To say that

00:11:09.860 Things are haram

00:11:10.780 Or things are

00:11:11.500 No this is haram

00:11:12.720 And you monopolize the religion 0.98

00:11:14.080 And you say

00:11:14.660 My opinion

00:11:15.560 Is the opinion

00:11:16.580 My way

00:11:16.980 And there is no other scholar

00:11:18.660 That says otherwise

00:11:19.640 You see

00:11:20.440 What you have to understand is

00:11:21.600 When you see a Hanafi brother 1.00

00:11:23.160 Praying

00:11:24.240 With his hands

00:11:25.540 Below his chest

00:11:26.680 You can't go up to him

00:11:28.100 And say

00:11:28.340 Ah look at you 1.00

00:11:29.280 You stupid idiot 1.00

00:11:30.140 You can't do that 1.00

00:11:31.180 Because he's got a valid opinion

00:11:32.820 Behind him

00:11:33.420 Imam Buhu Hanifa

00:11:34.560 Was a great Imam

00:11:35.540 So you have to understand this

00:11:37.060 In the same way

00:11:38.040 We are not like certain people

00:11:39.620 That are taking one opinion

00:11:40.780 From some random shirk 0.99

00:11:41.900 In Egypt

00:11:42.340 Sitting there in some hut

00:11:43.760 Saying

00:11:44.180 Pre-mixing

00:11:46.340 Halal

00:11:46.620 Music is halal 0.77

00:11:47.940 We're not doing that

00:11:49.040 We have gone to

00:11:50.120 Kibar Ulama

00:11:51.140 Brothers and sisters

00:11:52.020 Now this is the opinion

00:11:53.300 We choose to follow

00:11:54.040 And it's a valid opinion 0.75

00:11:55.180 It is a valid opinion

00:11:56.660 Now there are

00:11:57.860 There is another opinion out there

00:11:59.580 That because the Sufis do Nashids 1.00

00:12:01.300 You should avoid them

00:12:02.460 And certain scholars

00:12:03.680 Have even said that

00:12:04.360 They are haram

00:12:05.040 In their opinion

00:12:06.000 Scholars like

00:12:06.800 Sheikh Salih Al-Fawzan

00:12:07.760 So

00:12:08.360 He's also in the

00:12:09.640 Council of Judiciary Scholars

00:12:10.800 Now his reasoning for it

00:12:12.300 Is that

00:12:13.020 The Sufis do it 1.00

00:12:13.940 And he believes

00:12:15.600 That it's wrong

00:12:16.080 For that reason

00:12:16.700 He believes that

00:12:17.500 He believes that

00:12:18.360 It's something people

00:12:19.000 Should avoid

00:12:19.560 And that's his opinion

00:12:20.860 Brothers and sisters

00:12:21.600 I respect and love

00:12:22.980 Sheikh Salih Al-Fawzan

00:12:23.820 For that

00:12:24.220 And I'm not saying

00:12:26.120 That he's jahil 1.00

00:12:26.880 Allah forbid 0.99

00:12:27.800 Astaghfirullah

00:12:28.580 I'm not saying

00:12:29.280 That he's someone

00:12:29.740 You shouldn't take knowledge from

00:12:30.440 Take knowledge from him

00:12:31.300 He knows more than me

00:12:32.160 But there's also

00:12:32.980 Other scholars that have said

00:12:33.900 Otherwise as I've provided to you

00:12:35.340 And big scholars

00:12:36.300 So

00:12:36.880 This is what I'm saying

00:12:38.160 This is our opinion

00:12:38.960 What we're saying is

00:12:39.940 We've got justification

00:12:40.680 Have respect

00:12:41.440 You know

00:12:42.220 Because I'm sorry

00:12:42.780 But I've been like kind of bullied

00:12:44.080 By one brother

00:12:45.640 You know

00:12:46.160 Cyberly

00:12:48.100 Cyber

00:12:48.720 The cyber attack

00:12:49.720 Online

00:12:50.460 You know

00:12:50.760 You know

00:12:51.420 The brother just

00:12:52.060 He doesn't understand

00:12:53.080 And this is the issue

00:12:53.820 Narrow mindedness

00:12:54.820 It's just like

00:12:55.980 No

00:12:56.280 This is how it is

00:12:57.240 Blah blah blah

00:12:57.860 You know

00:12:58.440 No reason

00:12:59.140 No nothing

00:12:59.800 Just because you have an opinion

00:13:01.780 I don't have to follow it

00:13:04.340 I don't

00:13:05.540 You can't come

00:13:06.680 I can't come to you and say

00:13:07.660 Why do you think it's haram?

00:13:09.460 Why do you think it's haram?

00:13:10.100 You think it's haram?

00:13:11.000 You have to say it's haram

00:13:12.100 It's oppression

00:13:13.080 It's like

00:13:13.880 Ignorance

00:13:14.600 You know what

00:13:15.000 It's like us coming and saying 0.99

00:13:16.460 Shut up 0.97

00:13:17.540 It's haram 1.00

00:13:18.800 Okay

00:13:19.340 It's haram

00:13:19.900 That's it

00:13:20.360 It's haram

00:13:20.860 We're not even saying that

00:13:22.140 Brothers and sisters

00:13:23.720 Allah tells us in the Quran

00:13:25.840 That he has made us what?

00:13:27.700 Ummatun wasata

00:13:28.640 The balanced nation

00:13:30.700 The balanced nation

00:13:32.360 We are supposed to be a balanced people

00:13:33.880 No people that are extreme

00:13:35.360 Okay

00:13:35.760 No people that go extreme to one side or the other side

00:13:38.280 So brothers and sisters be balanced

00:13:39.800 You have your opinion?

00:13:40.980 Khalas 0.89

00:13:41.240 We have ours

00:13:41.840 Khalas 0.89

00:13:42.280 That's it

00:13:42.960 No that's what it is

00:13:44.100 And it's sad

00:13:45.300 That there's brothers out there

00:13:47.320 That are genuinely trying to make it haram

00:13:50.020 Like we're saying

00:13:50.940 This scholar

00:13:51.420 That scholar

00:13:51.820 But was it explained properly to the scholar

00:13:54.340 This that

00:13:54.720 I'm sorry it's not fair

00:13:55.940 It has been clearly explained

00:13:57.380 Not only clearly explained

00:13:58.240 Let's listen to it

00:13:59.000 Let's listen to it

00:14:00.460 Yeah

00:14:00.880 So this is

00:14:01.860 Some people are so extreme

00:14:03.100 I bet you

00:14:04.060 After they watch this video

00:14:05.100 I will not be surprised

00:14:06.100 If they come and say

00:14:06.640 Oh those scholars are misguided

00:14:07.620 I will not be surprised

00:14:09.480 Because sometimes you need to understand

00:14:11.260 Are you worshipping Allah 0.96

00:14:12.480 Or are you worshipping your ego?

00:14:14.160 Seriously

00:14:14.520 Just because of that

00:14:16.200 I believe what brother Omar is doing is good

00:14:18.680 There's a lot of people out there

00:14:20.140 Who I've worked with even as well

00:14:21.900 You know

00:14:22.360 And now I don't

00:14:23.220 They've gone down the road using music

00:14:25.000 You know

00:14:25.400 And it's sad

00:14:26.640 You know

00:14:27.140 And can I ask you a question

00:14:28.120 Every single brother

00:14:29.760 That we have asked

00:14:31.360 Or that has said to us

00:14:32.460 Haram, haram

00:14:33.360 This is haram

00:14:33.960 Yeah

00:14:34.140 Do they have a struggle with music?

00:14:36.560 No

00:14:36.860 By the looks of it

00:14:38.060 Do they struggle with music?

00:14:39.000 No

00:14:39.140 Mashallah

00:14:39.680 Are they practising brothers?

00:14:40.880 Yes

00:14:41.080 Mashallah

00:14:41.520 Are they on point?

00:14:42.520 Yes

00:14:42.780 Mashallah

00:14:43.140 Very on point

00:14:43.760 From what we can see

00:14:44.720 Yeah

00:14:44.920 From what we can see

00:14:45.780 Yes mashallah

00:14:46.400 Guys

00:14:46.800 It's not for you

00:14:47.820 I'm not surprised you're saying it's haram

00:14:49.460 Exactly

00:14:49.860 It may not benefit you

00:14:51.820 But bro

00:14:52.340 This might be benefiting some sister out there man 0.97

00:14:54.520 Or some brother

00:14:55.420 I'm sorry

00:14:55.840 Most of these brothers and sisters

00:14:57.600 They're in their bubble

00:14:58.940 Yeah

00:14:59.480 I'm sorry

00:15:00.360 I have to be real

00:15:01.060 You're in your bubble

00:15:02.280 Yeah

00:15:02.580 Your bubble is

00:15:03.460 You are

00:15:04.180 You have no

00:15:05.220 You don't know what's going on

00:15:07.040 You have no idea

00:15:09.140 What on earth is going on

00:15:11.200 They are in their own bubble

00:15:12.460 When you're in your own bubble

00:15:13.700 Look in my country

00:15:14.540 Well they say

00:15:15.620 A person with a full stomach

00:15:17.140 Will never understand the person that's hungry

00:15:18.400 Yeah

00:15:18.640 It's true

00:15:18.920 Now this doesn't mean you make

00:15:20.320 Just because

00:15:21.140 Oh you don't understand them

00:15:22.480 You make it permissible for

00:15:23.460 No one's saying

00:15:24.060 Hey you don't understand how hard is zina

00:15:25.740 Make zina halal 1.00

00:15:26.400 Nobody's saying that

00:15:27.440 We're saying you have no idea

00:15:29.360 Music is the biggest fitna out there

00:15:31.400 And if there's a halal alternative 1.00

00:15:32.940 We will support the brothers

00:15:34.460 Yeah

00:15:34.680 The brothers that don't use music

00:15:36.560 We will support them

00:15:38.080 And there's opinion behind it

00:15:39.400 It's not like we're coming and saying

00:15:40.060 We're going to support it

00:15:40.760 Just because people are doing music

00:15:42.100 No

00:15:42.280 There's a valid reason behind it

00:15:43.660 We're just asking for you guys to respect it

00:15:45.800 And we've brought evidence

00:15:47.000 If after this

00:15:48.180 You carry on

00:15:49.340 I'm sorry but from what I can judge

00:15:51.640 You have an ego issue

00:15:53.060 No

00:15:53.380 If you carry on

00:15:54.320 I'm telling you straight to your face right now

00:15:56.060 Any brother out there

00:15:57.180 Whether I know you

00:15:58.120 I don't know you

00:15:58.720 I'm ignoring you

00:15:59.520 Yeah

00:15:59.760 I'm ignoring you 0.99

00:16:00.680 Because who the hell are you 0.99

00:16:01.980 Yeah 0.84

00:16:02.280 I'm very sorry

00:16:02.980 Forgive me for my crudeness

00:16:04.580 Forgive me if this is rude

00:16:05.940 What credentials do you have

00:16:06.540 No no no

00:16:06.900 Who are you

00:16:07.640 Yeah

00:16:08.280 I have Sheikh Saad

00:16:09.540 Ibn Turkiya Al-Khaslan

00:16:11.480 I have Sheikh Abdullah Rukban

00:16:13.040 Sheikh Saad al-Shitri

00:16:14.260 Statements from Sheikh Bin Baz

00:16:15.820 Multiple statements

00:16:17.620 And I can see

00:16:19.080 I get messages

00:16:20.740 I can see

00:16:21.960 That there's a fitna out there 1.00

00:16:23.280 And I can see people benefiting

00:16:24.720 From the brother Umar Isastap

00:16:26.420 Who are you

00:16:27.460 To come and tell me

00:16:28.540 No this is haram

00:16:29.520 Because you feel it's haram

00:16:31.200 And you know some of these brothers

00:16:32.280 Subhanallah yeah

00:16:33.100 They need to be very careful

00:16:34.720 Because their brothers

00:16:35.740 Who subhanallah come out

00:16:37.340 And say something is haram

00:16:38.300 They literally give a fatwa 0.61

00:16:39.680 Yeah yeah yeah

00:16:40.300 Do you know what a fatwa is 0.98

00:16:41.200 A fatwa is an Islamic ruling 1.00

00:16:42.720 You're making what Allah has made 1.00

00:16:43.920 Halal haram

00:16:44.580 It's like me sitting here

00:16:45.700 In front of you brothers and sisters

00:16:46.760 This is halal

00:16:48.080 I have no qualification

00:16:50.360 Whatsoever

00:16:51.440 To tell you this is halal

00:16:52.860 That's why I'm giving you evidence

00:16:54.460 Yes

00:16:54.780 These same brothers

00:16:55.740 It's haram bro

00:16:56.820 It's haram

00:16:57.860 Yeah

00:16:58.040 And if these scholars came and said

00:16:59.340 It's haram

00:16:59.840 We would put our hands up

00:17:01.320 We would put our hands up

00:17:02.000 Yeah

00:17:02.140 But are you brothers ready

00:17:03.340 To do the same and say

00:17:04.040 No okay

00:17:04.440 They said okay we accept

00:17:05.480 There you go

00:17:06.300 Anyway let's not long it out

00:17:06.660 We accept you have a reason

00:17:07.780 Let's not long it out

00:17:08.680 We respect your opinion

00:17:09.680 Respect our opinion

00:17:10.420 We will carry on doing what we're doing

00:17:11.700 You can do back flips

00:17:12.680 Yeah you can do front flips

00:17:13.880 Do somersaults if you like

00:17:14.980 Yeah

00:17:15.460 We will

00:17:16.160 We've got evidence behind it

00:17:17.180 We will carry on supporting brother

00:17:18.340 Omar Issa

00:17:19.120 And we would

00:17:20.820 Inshallah

00:17:21.540 Be maybe

00:17:22.560 Next on the sheet

00:17:23.580 You never know

00:17:23.980 No joking

00:17:24.360 No joking

00:17:26.100 Featuring 50 cents

00:17:27.240 Anyway guys

00:17:29.120 If you've enjoyed it

00:17:29.900 Don't forget to subscribe to

00:17:31.220 Musa's channel

00:17:31.800 And watch our

00:17:33.100 Muslims Like Us video

00:17:34.360 To find out the double extremes

00:17:35.840 One extreme and the other extreme

00:17:37.180 You know we react to that

00:17:38.080 Check it out

00:17:38.680 I need to go goodbye

00:17:39.480 Thank you

00:17:39.840 Alright

00:17:40.060 Salam

00:17:40.640 Thank you

00:17:53.480 Thank you

00:17:53.760 Thank you

00:17:54.060 Thank you

00:17:54.920 Thank you

00:17:55.880 Bye

00:17:56.460 Bye

00:17:56.800 Bye

00:17:57.140 Bye

00:17:57.920 Bye

00:17:58.860 Bye

00:17:58.980 Bye

00:17:59.000 Bye

00:17:59.700 Bye

Ali Dawah - January 10, 2017

ARE NASHEEDS REALLY HARAM？？ ALI DAWAH

Episode Stats

Summary

Transcript