Bannon's War Room - July 06, 2026


Episode 5496: Charlie Kirk's Assassination Trial Begins

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
WarRoom Battleground EP 1044: BRUTAL: “Birmingham Antifa” Goons Call Harnwell “A Recently Exhumed corpse” In Savage Attack Episode 5499: Day 2 Of The Charlie Kirk Assassination Trial Cont.

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 54 minutes

Words per minute

149.12

Word count

17,019

Sentence count

1,126

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Summary

Summaries generated with gmurro/bart-large-finetuned-filtered-spotify-podcast-summ .

In this case, the defense argues that the medical examiner's report regarding the autopsy of Mr. Kirk should not be admissible in court because it is hearsay. The prosecution argues that it falls under the doctrine of hearsay and should be dismissed.

Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 to lay more foundation. That's certainly your choice. So you are aware that the medical
00:00:04 examiner's office did conduct an autopsy? I am, yes. Okay. And did you receive a report
00:00:10 from the medical examiner's office? I did, yes. Okay. Detailing the autopsy that was performed?
00:00:19 Yes. Prior to receiving the report, myself and Agent Davis visited with the doctor.
00:00:26 Okay. You visited personally with the doctor that conducted the autopsy?
00:00:28 that's correct okay and then subsequent to that and did you discuss the autopsy with the doctor
00:00:34 at that point in time when you're meeting with him personally yes agent davis and i had a fairly
00:00:38 in-depth conversation yes and where did that conversation take place at the medical examiner's
00:00:43 office okay do you recall the date and time that that personal visit took place i don't i don't
00:00:49 recall was it was it was soon it was soon after within within a few days of the incident of the
00:00:56 autopsy yes okay and and subsequent subsequent to that visit um did you receive a a report from that
00:01:04 that doctor that you visited with we did yes okay and that's the Dr. Wajardo that you're trying you're
00:01:11 struggling to pronounce his name is that yeah I apologize but yes that's who it is and the report
00:01:16 that was sent to you um do you recall when you received that report I don't recall the specific
00:01:22 date okay um have you reviewed that report yes have you reviewed have you again you stated earlier
00:01:33 that this is not the first murder investigation you've worked correct okay this is i take it this
00:01:39 is not the first medical examiner's report you've received correct okay they do the reports typically
00:01:46 look the same yes they're they're in a standard format that the medical examiner uses okay and
00:01:52 this report that you received yes from who you believe was the doctor you spoke to yes that
00:01:57 conducted the medical exam um was there anything peculiar about that particular report that stood
00:02:03 out to you no it appeared to be a standard form as used by the medical examiner when they send
00:02:08 those reports okay on your monitor exhibit 11 i'm going to have displayed uh what's been marked
00:02:19 states exhibit number 11 judge for identification right i believe there's nine pages so let me know
00:02:28 you see that on your your screen it's on the screen all right what i'd like you to do is just
00:02:33 look at this as it scrolls down through the nine pages and wait till we get to the very end and if
00:02:40 you need us to pause or stop or slow down let us know i want you to be able to look at all nine pages
00:02:45 Thank you.
00:03:15 Okay.
00:03:16 Okay.
00:03:17 Okay.
00:03:18 Okay.
00:03:19 Okay.
00:03:20 Okay.
00:03:21 Okay.
00:03:22 Did you get a look at that?
00:03:23 Yes, sir.
00:03:24 Okay.
00:03:25 Do you recognize what that is?
00:03:40 Yes.
00:03:41 What is that?
00:03:42 That's the medical examiner's report of examination for Mr. Kirk.
00:03:48 Do you recall, you don't recall exactly when you received that?
00:03:52 I don't, unfortunately, remember the specific date when I received it.
00:03:55 Do you remember how you received it?
00:03:57 Then provided to us electronically.
00:03:59 Okay, via email?
00:04:01 Sometimes via email, also on disk, compact disk.
00:04:05 Okay.
00:04:06 And does there appear to be anything in the exhibit before you?
00:04:11 Has that report changed at all, or does it accurately depict what you received initially from the doctor?
00:04:21 It accurately depicts it.
00:04:23 Does the state would seek to admit Exhibit 11?
00:04:28 Ms. Nester.
00:04:29 Your Honor, this is an expert report without the expert being present, being offered by an individual who's not an expert in this field.
00:04:38 If they're presenting him as an expert in this field, based on the limited questions about his experience and seeing previous medical exam records, I'd like to voir dire him on his qualifications to opine about it.
00:04:53 This is hearsay.
00:04:55 It's highly technical.
00:04:57 It should be presented only through an expert.
00:04:59 It could never come in and trial in any other way.
00:05:02 We submit that it is hearsay.
00:05:05 And to the extent they're going to ask this individual about any opinions about it, that would be improper.
00:05:12 He's not qualified to do that.
00:05:15 And furthermore, we just think that this is clearly falling under our constitutional concerns about the absence of our ability to be effective, to cross-examine, to question the –
00:05:26 We can't even question the expert's experience or CV or anything that we would normally do
00:05:31 to determine if this should even be accepted or considered by the court.
00:05:35 And so we strenuously object to its admission and for all those reasons to its publication as well.
00:05:42 There is also, there's some really personal things in there that should never be published
00:05:47 that deal with Mr. Kirk's medical condition history is the condition of his body.
00:05:57 It shouldn't be published, Your Honor.
00:05:58 Thank you.
00:06:00 To this state.
00:06:01 Judge, this is clearly a reliable hearsay admissible under Rule 11 of 2 of the Utah Rules of Evidence.
00:06:09 I would direct you specifically to subsection B5 for purposes of, and I'm quoting the rule,
00:06:20 for purposes of criminal preliminary examinations only, reliable hearsay includes subsection
00:06:25 5 specifically states medical and autopsy reports and records.
00:06:30 Again, that is supported by Article 1, Section 12 of the Utah Constitution, which states
00:06:35 that reliable hearsay can be relied upon
00:06:37 at preliminary examination in whole or in part.
00:06:41 And to the second part in regards to publication.
00:06:43 As far as the publication, Judge,
00:06:45 we agree with Ms. Nestor.
00:06:49 This is a document that does contain
00:06:52 very sensitive information
00:06:53 and information that Mr. Kirk's family
00:06:56 would appreciate it not being published.
00:07:00 So although we seek to admit it,
00:07:01 we'd ask that it not be published
00:07:03 here in the courtroom
00:07:04 or that it be published in any fashion or way that the public can see it by virtue of a camera.
00:07:10 Ms. Nestor.
00:07:11 Your Honor, I just want to point out that even though 1102 has a provision about exams,
00:07:18 I mean, the court still has the overarching mission under 1102 to make this reliability finding, right?
00:07:24 And it's just completely in a vacuum being offered by someone who's a police officer.
00:07:29 So, again, we would just argue that you're just not – it's hampering you for making the analysis you need to make to admit it, and we object to it.
00:07:38 All right.
00:07:38 Anything further from the parties?
00:07:41 No, Your Honor.
00:07:41 No, sir.
00:07:42 All right.
00:07:43 So, again, relying upon the analysis, Utah Constitution Article 1, Section 12, as it relates to reliable hearsay, and then turning to Utah Rules of Evidence, Rule 1102, B-5, specifically notes medical and autopsy reports and records.
00:08:08 The court is going to overrule the objection and admit state's exhibit, I believe it's 11.
00:08:16 11, yes, sir.
00:08:20 Citing to Utah Constitution Article 1, Section 28, Dignity, Portion, Respect and Dignity.
00:08:29 it will not be published either in the courtroom or viewable on media by the the camera for the
00:08:38 reasons previously stated as it relates to the video and so the court will receive it
00:08:44 and it is admitted into evidence and that concludes that portion Mr. Sturgill is this
00:08:53 a good point to stop to take our 15 minute afternoon break I think it'd be a great idea
00:08:58 Judge, I've just got one last question with respect to the medical examiner's report.
00:09:05 Agent Hole, in that report, does the doctor relate cause and manner of death?
00:09:12 He does, yes.
00:09:13 And in that report, what is the stated cause of death?
00:09:17 It was stated as a murder.
00:09:20 And manner of death?
00:09:22 It was a gunshot wound to the neck.
00:09:23 i object it's not stated as a murder i believe it's stated as a homicide which
00:09:31 is an important distinction just i'll i'll go back and correct that all right so so i'm going
00:09:37 to sustain well first of all let me look at the report i need to see that session i need to be
00:09:42 able to draw my own conclusion uh so okay i i see ms nester are you referring to page one of this
00:09:51 report? Sorry, Your Honor. Could you repeat that? I apologize. As it relates to your objection for
00:09:56 the misstatements, are you looking at page one of the report? Yes. All right. Your Honor, I also
00:10:08 need to make an objection on the best evidence rule, too. Thank you. All right. So I'm going to
00:10:13 sustain the objection as it relates to the manner of death. It does not say murder, but in regards
00:10:19 to their best evidence rule again under 1102 and the utah constitution that permits uh reliable
00:10:27 hearsay and it is state's exhibit 11 is uh admitted mr sergil agent hole i'm going to ask
00:10:37 you to look at the first page of uh exhibit 11 no yes see that yes okay so let me let me ask you
00:10:46 again um and you can look at it yeah and would you mind relating uh what the doctor reports is
00:10:53 the matter of death yes i misspoke it does say homicide and then the immediate cause of death
00:10:59 gunshot wound of the neck nothing further judge well at this moment i think it'd be a great idea
00:11:06 that we take a 15 minute break right we'll go ahead and go on break we'll come back at uh 3 25
00:11:11 and resume with this witness at that time.
00:11:16 Court is in a brief recess.
00:11:22 Now the man accused of killing Charlie Kirk is in a Utah courtroom
00:11:26 as prosecutors present evidence against him.
00:11:29 The hearing, a critical one for suspect Tyler Robinson,
00:11:31 who was accused of fatally shooting the conservative activists last September.
00:11:34 This week the judge will determine what evidence will be permissible in the trial,
00:11:39 including a recorded statement by Robinson's former roommate who is seen as a key witness.
00:11:45 Some of Kirk's family members are attending today inside that courtroom.
00:11:49 Those are his parents arriving earlier.
00:11:52 His widow, Erica Kirk, also there.
00:11:55 Okay, I'm going to take you back to September 10th, 2025.
00:11:59 You mentioned you were on campus.
00:12:01 You had a particular assignment.
00:12:03 Mr. Gernander, I'm sorry.
00:12:05 We're just going to pull down the exhibits.
00:12:07 Okay.
00:12:08 Thank you.
00:12:09 You may continue.
00:12:10 Would you like me to take this exhibit down, Judge?
00:12:12 Are you referring to it in your line of questioning right now?
00:12:16 Not right now, I'm not.
00:12:17 Okay, let's go ahead and take it down.
00:12:18 So you were securing the Hall of Flags walkway, correct?
00:12:40 Yes.
00:12:40 On the south end?
00:12:41 Yes.
00:12:41 um what was happening that morning that day on campus at uvu i i came in to do a shift for a
00:12:53 special event that where we had a guest speaker come in and was going to talk to the students
00:12:57 and people around the neighborhood do you know who the guest speaker was i do and who was that
00:13:02 it was charlie kirk did you see mr kirk that day i did when did you first see him when he arrived
00:13:09 On campus, just behind the west side of the Hall of Flags, I saw him pull up.
00:13:18 And can someone access the courtyard through that area?
00:13:22 Yes, they can.
00:13:22 How so?
00:13:23 Where he pulled up underneath the Hall of Flags is an opening to where you can drive a car underneath.
00:13:30 So there's access right there.
00:13:31 You can walk or drive underneath the Hall of Flags.
00:13:34 And you saw him arrive?
00:13:36 Yes.
00:13:36 Okay.
00:13:39 Can you describe what you were seeing?
00:13:42 What did you observe?
00:13:44 On that day, I observed Charlie going back, doing some meet and greet with some people, getting some photos taken.
00:13:52 He then came underneath the hall flags and went to his tent,
00:13:56 and he was there answering questions and talking to individuals that would ask him questions.
00:14:02 The tent you're referring to, is that the tent that we see when it was set up in the courtyard?
00:14:07 Yeah, that Y-square tent.
00:14:09 The white top.
00:14:09 Yes, he was under that.
00:14:12 Fast forward to about 1220 or so, so a little bit after noon, the noon hour.
00:14:18 What happened?
00:14:19 What did you see and what did you hear?
00:14:22 I heard an individual talking to Charlie,
00:14:24 and I happened to kind of glance over the edge of the railing about that time.
00:14:29 I could see the right side of Charlie's shoulder, so not his whole body,
00:14:33 because he was underneath the tent, so I could only see probably the right side of his body.
00:14:36 He was answering a question
00:14:39 Kid asked him a question
00:14:40 And then I heard a shot fired
00:14:42 Do you know what time that was?
00:14:45 Yes
00:14:45 What time was that?
00:14:47 12.23
00:14:47 What did you see?
00:14:51 At that moment I saw him lean to the left
00:14:54 When you say him, you see Charlie
00:14:56 So I saw him go to the left
00:14:59 Because I could no longer see the right side of his body
00:15:01 So he went further underneath the tent
00:15:03 To the north side of the tent, so left
00:15:06 Okay.
00:15:07 Can you describe the reaction of others that were there?
00:15:11 Yeah, so then everybody started getting up and starting to run in more of a chaos kind of situation.
00:15:20 Before you continue, can you describe a little bit?
00:15:22 So you mentioned Mr. Kirk was answering questions, talking to individuals.
00:15:27 Yes.
00:15:27 Were there others present?
00:15:29 Yes.
00:15:30 Any idea about approximately how many?
00:15:33 How would you describe it in your terms?
00:15:34 In my terms, I'd say when I was up there looking down, I'd say there were several thousand people
00:15:38 because you had it on the grass that was jam-packed in the amphitheater sitting on the grass.
00:15:43 You had people standing on the back up along the cement.
00:15:46 You had people that were on the second level, the Sorensen, and over by the Woodbury building.
00:15:51 There's another level there where a lot of people were standing and watching.
00:15:54 So it was pretty packed, several thousand people.
00:15:57 So you mentioned you heard something.
00:15:59 What did you hear again?
00:16:00 I heard a gunshot.
00:16:01 Okay. And can you describe Mr. Kirk's reaction? Was that simultaneous to hearing the gunshot?
00:16:10 Yes, it was.
00:16:11 When he fell to the left?
00:16:12 Yes.
00:16:13 Did you see the reaction from the crowd?
00:16:15 Yes.
00:16:15 What was that?
00:16:17 Everybody kind of got up. A lot of people were screaming, standing up, and starting to run in all different directions away from the center of the tent.
00:16:25 Okay. You're a police officer helping to secure the area, correct?
00:16:29 Yes.
00:16:29 What did you do?
00:16:31 At that moment, I recognized it as gunfire.
00:16:35 I left my post, which was right there on the south end of the Hall of Flags.
00:16:39 I proceeded to, right where the fugal and the Hall of Flags meet,
00:16:43 there's some outside stairs that I was starting to run down.
00:16:46 As I was trying to get down to the bottom of the stairs, people were running up.
00:16:49 People were laying down on the steps.
00:16:51 I'm trying to jump over people to get to the bottom of the stairs
00:16:53 so I can help stop an individual that was probably shooting.
00:16:59 What happened next?
00:17:01 By the time I got to the bottom of the stairs, I was informed on the radio that we had a shooter in custody.
00:17:08 So I thought at that moment, I was like, oh, that was kind of fast.
00:17:11 Obviously, it was close range probably because we had an individual in custody.
00:17:14 Another officer came on and said we had an individual in custody.
00:17:17 So I decided to, since the threat is gone, now I can assess for anybody that's injured
00:17:24 and start looking for any medical needs that's needed at that moment.
00:17:27 But I started canvassing the area.
00:17:31 As I canvassed the area, I was looking for anybody that was injured.
00:17:33 I saw a kid on the ground that was on about the second or third tier in the grass next to a wheelchair,
00:17:40 and he was almost convulsing.
00:17:42 I thought he'd maybe been shot.
00:17:44 I talked to the dad as I was running over there.
00:17:46 He said that he was just having a seizure, that he was fine, he was not injured.
00:17:49 So then at that moment, I observed that there was no other injuries that I could see at that moment.
00:17:54 Okay.
00:17:55 Okay. Was your attention drawn to anything else at that time?
00:17:59 Yeah, so after we got some people kind of cleared away a little bit,
00:18:03 I thought I needed to start preserving the scene because we had a crime scene.
00:18:07 And with some of my experience and training to that effect,
00:18:10 I decided now we need to contain the scene and help preserve as much evidence as we can.
00:18:14 So I started pushing people off the grass out of the courtyard area
00:18:18 because I knew that was where the crime scene was.
00:18:21 As soon as we started pushing those guys out, my chief, Chief Long, that was right next to me,
00:18:27 I looked down and saw an empty pistol holder that was sitting just on top of the grass.
00:18:34 And at that moment, things had died down just a split second.
00:18:37 I realized that the shot I heard was more of a rifle shot and not a pistol shot.
00:18:41 Our producer who is inside, she says that Donald Trump Jr. is inside that courtroom,
00:18:47 along with Erica Kirk, Charlie Kirk's parents, a few supporters with them,
00:18:53 listening to, as you say, emotional testimony.
00:18:56 Erica Kirk has been very emotional already.
00:18:59 She's been seen crying when one witness talked about just the sound of the gunshot.
00:19:04 We're not even talking about how it looked, just the sound.
00:19:09 This witness described the rifle shot being more violent than a pop you would get from a handgun.
00:19:14 At this point, Erica Kirk had to leave the courtroom.
00:19:18 So this, as you say, is a probable cause hearing.
00:19:21 It's not a trial.
00:19:22 It looks a bit like a trial in that there are witnesses and cross-examination, but it's not.
00:19:26 It is the prosecution trying to say we have probable cause, trying to persuade the judge to take this to a full trial, scheduled to last all week.
00:19:36 one of the key pieces of evidence that we believe the prosecution is going to put forward, guys,
00:19:41 is a deposition, a taped deposition from Tyler Robinson's roommate slash romantic partner.
00:19:47 And that there was communications between Robinson and this partner after the shooting
00:19:53 that the prosecutors basically say is tantamount to a confession.
00:19:57 The roommate asked Tyler Robinson, was it wasn't you that did it right?
00:20:01 And the reply from Robinson was, yeah, I'm sorry, it was me.
00:20:06 Charlie Kirk was spreading too much hate.
00:20:10 If things move forward with this preliminary hearing as expected, how soon can we expect the trial to begin?
00:20:19 Well, that is unclear. This judge has been very methodical.
00:20:24 Now, we expect he might give a ruling on Friday as to whether the trial will proceed.
00:20:28 But judging by his previous performance, I would say that he might delay that.
00:20:33 But that is his decision to make.
00:20:35 All the evidence goes to him. It's presented to him. He decides, yep, we've got enough for trial or no.
00:20:40 So far, you see on the stand there, if you're still showing that picture, that is a man who was a Utah Valley University campus police officer on the day of the shooting, September 10th last year.
00:20:52 And he described hearing this pop, this gunfire that I mentioned just before, this rifle pop.
00:20:58 He said he could tell where it was coming from. He said after he heard that gunshot, he went down.
00:21:04 He surveyed the scene to see if there was anybody injured who he could help.
00:21:07 There wasn't.
00:21:08 He then went to the roof where he believes the gunshot came from.
00:21:12 And up there, he found a screwdriver on that roof, which is part of the prosecution evidence.
00:21:17 They say Tyler Robinson's DNA is on that and also on, for example, the rifle.
00:21:23 Now, the defense will say there's a bunch of DNA on that rifle.
00:21:27 And that is why probably they are calling three forensic evidence experts to testify at this preliminary hearing.
00:21:35 So it's going to go on all week. It will be emotional. It's been emotional already.
00:21:40 And, you know, you've got Donald Trump Jr. and Erica Kirk in there watching the prosecution try and prove probable cause, try and get to probable cause.
00:21:50 And don't forget, the prosecution has said in this case, guys, that they will be seeking the death penalty against now 23-year-old Tyler Robinson.
00:22:00 OK, fascinating testimony. Remember, not remember, in the state of Utah, this takes the place, this evidentiary hearing takes the place of essentially a grand jury.
00:22:17 So you're like sitting in almost like a grand jury that you can view and weigh and measure.
00:22:24 And there's been some fascinating testimony already.
00:22:31 We've got a couple of experts that when we have time here in Real America's Voice, we will get in.
00:22:38 Jack Basobik is in the courtroom.
00:22:40 Can't stop it.
00:22:40 The courtroom is on a short break.
00:22:42 It's supposed to commence in about four minutes,
00:22:46 and we will go back, obviously, to our live wall-to-wall coverage of this.
00:22:51 We think, as a channel, Real America's Voice, and, of course, The War Room,
00:22:55 that it is very important for this audience to see it all and to hear it all.
00:22:59 And, obviously, it's generated a lot of interest so far
00:23:01 because Charlie Kirk was not only a great man and so important to her cause,
00:23:07 but was a great American and was a role model for so many people throughout the world,
00:23:10 particularly young people, that you've got to get to the bottom of this.
00:23:14 And so that is what this is today, an evidentiary hearing.
00:23:16 The judge has been very, I think you can say that, methodical.
00:23:20 They're going to go now, just for your own planning purposes,
00:23:23 they're going to go, and I'll do this on East Coast time,
00:23:26 they're going to go from 11 o'clock in the morning,
00:23:29 of which we will turn our coverage over to 11 o'clock in the morning
00:23:33 until approximately 7 p.m. Eastern Daylight Time every evening.
00:23:38 There'll be a lunch break around 2 p.m., ironically, when the Jack Posobiec show is supposed to go.
00:23:45 And, of course, we get Kevin Posobiec out there.
00:23:46 Jack's in the courtroom.
00:23:50 Then there's going to be at least, I think, one break in the afternoon.
00:23:53 They're taking that break right now.
00:23:54 We're going to go back, I think, in a few minutes to the courtroom and to continue to listen and hear and view whatever evidence they feel that they're going to allow.
00:24:07 the public to actually see.
00:24:09 So we're going to go to that.
00:24:11 So much other breaking news today.
00:24:14 The most important,
00:24:15 it looks like a woman has come forward,
00:24:17 I think a former girlfriend
00:24:20 or former romantic partner
00:24:22 or partner of,
00:24:23 or at least somebody dated,
00:24:25 of the nominee.
00:24:27 So really the nominee
00:24:28 because the governor dropped out
00:24:30 or suspended her campaign
00:24:32 in the Senate race,
00:24:34 U.S. Senate race
00:24:35 in the state of Maine, Platinar.
00:24:37 the former Marine, quite controversial.
00:24:40 She said that against her consent,
00:24:42 he forced himself upon her.
00:24:45 There were pretty dramatic sexual allegations.
00:24:49 He's put out a videotape that he was drunk
00:24:51 and didn't know what he was doing.
00:24:52 However, they have a deadline,
00:24:55 I think by next Monday the 13th,
00:24:57 they have to declare that there could be
00:24:59 somebody else coming to the race, et cetera, 0.87
00:25:02 and or the governor renew her contest.
00:25:05 Remember, Platner right now,
00:25:07 or at least on the polling, is up six or seven points.
00:25:13 At least that's what certain polls are saying.
00:25:14 So this is the entire mainstream media, which CNN and MSNBC are not covering the trial.
00:25:20 They kind of dip in and out.
00:25:23 But they have people out there covering it, but they're not showing it so that you can watch it.
00:25:27 And I think that's the only way to view it is just to do this, just to hunker down and get into it to the entire day.
00:25:32 I want to thank our sponsors because we're going to hone them in advance for the next couple of days, particularly Birch Gold.
00:25:39 I want to thank Birch Gold.
00:25:41 They've got the special.
00:25:44 It runs through the 10th, and that would be take your phone.
00:25:49 I think the easiest thing to do is text Bannon, B-A-N-N-O-N, 989898.
00:25:53 You get direct access to Philip Patrick's team.
00:25:56 Talk to them with a qualifying purchase.
00:25:58 right now qualifying purchase you can um get a free one ounce silver round it's not a coin but
00:26:05 a round uh that's to i think july 10th so let's make sure we get on top of that and that you can
00:26:12 um and that you can get that with a qualifying purchase talk to philip patrick and team
00:26:16 also allfamilypharmacy.com slash bannon uh make sure you go check it out slash bannon
00:26:23 And they have a buy one, get one free.
00:26:26 That goes to July 7th.
00:26:28 So let's get on top of that.
00:26:29 I think I told you this morning it was the 10th.
00:26:31 It's actually the 7th.
00:26:33 So that is buy one, get one free.
00:26:35 You get access to, you know, licensed professionals, pharmacists, licensed medical professionals.
00:26:42 Get you the prescriptions that you need when you need them.
00:26:45 They get overnight in the mail.
00:26:47 So make sure you check out the team.
00:26:49 Allfamilypharmacy.com slash Bannon.
00:26:51 Buy one, get one free.
00:26:53 very special 4th of July 250th anniversary offer.
00:26:58 And we want to make sure all America's health share.
00:27:02 This is a very different way to think about your health insurance.
00:27:06 And obviously with this fiasco of Obamacare,
00:27:10 there are many Americans who can no longer afford
00:27:12 or feel they can afford health insurance.
00:27:16 Go to freedomforhealth.org.
00:27:21 slash bannon that's freedom for health dot org slash bannon you get a free month uh if you sign
00:27:27 up this is one you're going to do a little due diligence but i think quite some you'll be quite
00:27:31 surprised at the coverage you can get uh for the amount of money uh severely discounted what
00:27:39 health care is so make sure that you uh you go check it out and check that out today
00:27:42 uh like i said let's go back to the coverage of charlie kirk obviously very disturbing uh erica
00:27:49 Kirk is in the audience, Charlie's, I think Charlie's parents are there, that's fine,
00:27:56 Don Jr., we're going to go to break, we're going to take a break here in a moment, the
00:27:59 court hasn't come back, if they come back, we will cut right out a break, Don Jr. is
00:28:04 there, okay, they're filing back in right now, our own Jack Posobiec is actually in the courtroom,
00:28:09 very restricted on what he can do, we were trying to get Jack to step out during these
00:28:13 breaks, that's just not possible, people are filing back in, of course, the judge,
00:28:19 Let's go and go. They're speaking. I think we go to the let's go to the courtroom right now.
00:28:23 Live. What, if anything else, did you do on the 10th of September, 2025?
00:28:30 Primary focus was to identify the individual who'd been seen on the roof with the preliminary footage.
00:28:39 And. So there was a big effort to review as much of the video that we had available to us from both the public,
00:28:47 but predominantly from Utah Valley University in an effort to follow that individual both forward and backwards from the time of the shooting.
00:28:57 Okay. So if I understood you correctly, the priority was to identify the shooter.
00:29:03 Yes.
00:29:03 And to that end, you started reviewing even more UVU video than you've already described?
00:29:08 Correct, yes.
00:29:09 Okay. What, if anything else, either did you do or happened initially that helped you identify who that shooter was?
00:29:26 So there was hundreds of hours of video that was reviewed,
00:29:30 but the predominant focus, again, was on tracking the individual from the roof
00:29:36 either after the shooting had occurred
00:29:38 or trying to trace the steps of the individual prior to the shooting.
00:29:42 And we were able to do that through a combined effort of individuals,
00:29:50 and the focus was having people reviewing video identify people
00:29:55 who could fit the original description of the individual that jumped off the roof.
00:30:02 At that point, so at this point, approximately how many hours of UVU video
00:30:09 do you think you personally had seen or watched?
00:30:12 Myself, maybe 10 or 20 hours of video being called in to look at different camera angles
00:30:21 and different views of individuals.
00:30:23 um but there were a there was a large team of people reviewing video reviewing video
00:30:29 yeah from the view or some of them sbi agents yes correct and combined uh how much video do you
00:30:38 think you watched that first day on the 10th it would be in the tens or hundreds of hours of video
00:30:44 was reviewed okay uh did anything else come along that that helped you identify who that shooter
00:30:50 might be? Yeah, eventually on the evening of the 11th, we received word from Washington County
00:30:59 that an individual in that area had reached out to law enforcement and was wanting to turn
00:31:09 themselves in for the incident at UVU. Okay. And did you, at that point in time, did you receive
00:31:14 a name from Washington County? Yes, we did. And what was that name? Tyler Robinson.
00:31:20 So what, if anything, did you do with that information, the name, Tyler Robinson?
00:31:25 That information was given to our SIAC or our state information and analysis group,
00:31:31 and they put together what would be called a workup.
00:31:34 So they would look at driver's license records, DMV records to determine addresses,
00:31:40 obtain pictures of individuals, and then any associated vehicles or things like that.
00:31:46 So was that done with Mr. Robinson?
00:31:48 It was, yes.
00:31:49 driver's license record was pulled yes did that include if you remember or do you know did that
00:31:54 include a photograph of mr robinson it did include a photograph of mr robinson yes how about an
00:31:58 address and date of birth there was an address and a date of birth and i believe a dmv record
00:32:04 for an associated vehicle all right so that dmv record did include a vehicle that was associated
00:32:10 with mr robinson correct okay um do you remember uh what the make and model of the vehicle was
00:32:18 that was tied to Mr. Robinson?
00:32:20 The Dodge Challenger.
00:32:22 Anything else beyond that that you remember?
00:32:25 It was silver in color,
00:32:26 and I believe there were two registered owners of the vehicle.
00:32:30 Okay, and who were the registered owners?
00:32:32 Mr. Robinson and then his mother.
00:32:35 Do you recall whether or not a date of birth was included
00:32:38 in that driver's license information that you got initially?
00:32:41 Yeah, I believe the actual driver's license record was shared,
00:32:44 so it would have included a date of birth.
00:32:46 All right.
00:32:48 uh with mr uh well with tyler robinson's personal information
00:32:53 were you able to expand uh your search at all yes once we knew a vehicle that we were looking for
00:33:03 and we had an actual uh image of the individual then we were able to use that video footage to
00:33:11 to try and track that specific individual okay and and i'm sorry let me clarify so when i said
00:33:16 expand your search i'm referencing uh the uvu surveillance video uh yes we were able to okay
00:33:25 and were you able to identify uh in that expanded search or did you believe you located that that
00:33:33 challenger uh we did yes okay uh were you able to determine uh at what time or times mr robinson
00:33:44 visited the UVU campus on September 10th?
00:33:48 Yeah, we were able to establish that Mr. Robinson had been on campus
00:33:52 approximately four times throughout the day, twice before the shooting,
00:33:59 the time of the shooting, and then after the shooting,
00:34:03 later in the evening into the early hours of the 11th.
00:34:05 you um you said that you initially tracked the shooter forward and backward
00:34:17 with with uvu surveillance video correct okay uh did you do the same thing with that vehicle
00:34:24 we did yes okay tracked it forward and backward yes using the uvu footage and and additional
00:34:31 information that was obtained, yes. And I believe you said that in total Mr. Robinson visited the
00:34:40 UVU campus four times that day. Yes, that's correct. And let's just be clear, that's all
00:34:44 based on UVU surveillance video, is that fair to say? That's correct, yes. Okay. Have you
00:34:51 have you reviewed what's been marked State's Exhibit 12.1 for identification? I have, yes.
00:34:59 Okay. And before we go there, of the video that you have personally watched, does the video include the 10th and the 11th or just the 10th?
00:35:15 The video I've seen includes the 10th and then a very small portion, I think, about 030 of the 11th.
00:35:21 Okay. And I think you said initially you watched about 20 hours of video.
00:35:25 Yes.
00:35:26 Since that time, have you watched additional video?
00:35:29 Yes.
00:35:29 UVU surveillance video?
00:35:31 Yes.
00:35:31 Okay.
00:35:32 And who provided the UVU surveillance video to you?
00:35:37 It was part of the collection of videos that was provided by Mr. Olson and his team that we already discussed previously.
00:35:44 Okay.
00:35:45 of the uh of all the hours of video that you've watched um do you have an idea of how many hours
00:35:55 include uh mr robinson or his vehicle uh just with uvu or just with uvu i'm sorry just with uvu
00:36:06 will probably be about 16 hours and and let's be clear this is someone you believe to be
00:36:15 tyler robinson correct okay and this person that you've identified as tyler robinson that you've
00:36:22 been investigating and that you viewed in the the numerous hours of video from uvu
00:36:27 would you recognize that person if you were in the courtroom today yes is he in the courtroom
00:36:32 today he is yes would you point him out and describe something that he's wearing
00:36:36 i know we object to um unduly suggestive in court identification for constitutional grounds
00:36:43 do you wish to specify an unduly constitutional i'm trying to understand your objections i want
00:36:56 to make sure i fully understand your honor i think there's some you know deferred to to
00:37:01 to Mr. Byrd if he wants to jump in.
00:37:03 But I believe there's a long line of case law that says
00:37:06 when you ask someone to identify the defendant
00:37:10 when they're the only person sitting at the table
00:37:14 with defense counsel, that that's unduly suggestive
00:37:16 and taints any future or past, well, definitely future identification.
00:37:25 So we object to that happening in this fashion at this time.
00:37:29 Mr. Sturgeon.
00:37:30 Well, Judge, Agent Hull has testified that he has watched numerous hours of video.
00:37:36 Well, take a step back.
00:37:38 He has looked at personal identifying information of an individual by the name of Tyler Robinson.
00:37:45 He's looked at the driver's license record, and he's also looked at the DMV records
00:37:49 and has been able to determine what car that person drives.
00:37:53 He's also looked at surveillance video that he believes depicts this Tyler Robinson.
00:37:58 and i've simply asked him if that person that he has seen both in driver's license
00:38:06 photos and the surveillance video if that person is here in the courtroom today
00:38:11 and i don't know that that's unduly prejudicial or suggestive it's the routine i don't know of
00:38:19 any other way to do it other than the way i just did it judge well i wanted to verify that the
00:38:24 format of the question i would remember it in my mind but uh to ms nester was that was that an
00:38:31 accurate portrayal of the question that was asked yes okay mr sturgill anything further before i
00:38:38 issue my ruling well no other than judge i i believe it's it's worth noting that mr robinson
00:38:44 is in plain clothes well he's yeah counsel please approach the bench
00:38:51 Thank you.
00:39:21 All right.
00:39:51 So based off of what's been presented in court, I'm not finding that particular question as previously posed as suggestive.
00:40:01 I find for the purposes of this hearing only that in-court identification by Agent Hull of Mr. Robinson has been made.
00:40:10 Again, this only relates to the preliminary hearing, and you may proceed.
00:40:14 Thank you, Judge.
00:40:15 agent hole have you reviewed what's been marked states exhibit 12.1 for identification i have yes
00:40:22 and where did you review that video uh it was provided to me um i reviewed it on my computer
00:40:31 in my office okay and and is that the first time that you've seen this particular video footage
00:40:38 this particular version of the footage yes okay so this particular version the first time but have
00:40:44 Have you seen the video that comprises, I guess, Exhibit 12.1?
00:40:54 I have seen the original videos, if that's your question, yes.
00:40:58 So what states Exhibit 12.1?
00:41:01 How would you describe it?
00:41:03 I would describe it as a compilation of the video that we obtained from Utah Valley University
00:41:09 during the course of the investigation that depicts the movements of the individual,
00:41:16 I believe to be Mr. Robinson, moving around the campus on September 10th, 2025
00:41:20 into the morning of September 11th, 2025.
00:41:24 Did you prepare this video compilation?
00:41:27 I did not.
00:41:28 Okay. Do you know who did?
00:41:30 Yes, Utah County Attorney's Office.
00:41:32 I believe Ms. Durfler is the one that produced the video.
00:41:34 Okay. Do you know Ms. Durfler's first name?
00:41:36 Kimberly.
00:41:37 Okay.
00:41:38 What, if anything, did you do to authenticate the video in this compilation?
00:41:44 I reviewed the video to make sure that it was a reflection of what I understood the original videos to show.
00:41:51 Okay.
00:41:51 What, if anything, else did you do?
00:41:57 I reviewed it.
00:41:59 I know that there were some zooms and some changes to the footage.
00:42:04 Okay.
00:42:05 Did you meet with Mr. Olson with regards to this particular video?
00:42:08 Yes.
00:42:09 This video was also part of that original meeting with Mr. Olson for the prior exhibit, yes.
00:42:14 Okay.
00:42:14 So at the same time, you sat down with Mr. Olson and discussed the prior exhibit.
00:42:21 And let's just be clear which exhibit that is.
00:42:23 so i believe the well the the 1102 statement that you gathered from him is exhibit 12.3 correct
00:42:35 yes all right so at the same time that you gathered that 12.3 or that that written statement
00:42:41 that is stakes exhibit 12.3 you talked to him about this specific exhibit as well yes mr olson
00:42:47 was shown this exhibit.
00:42:49 And did he include that in that 1102 statement?
00:42:53 Yeah, I believe he specifically referenced the exhibit by name,
00:42:57 stating that it was a true reflection of the footage from the campus.
00:43:09 And let's just go back to what you were stating earlier.
00:43:13 To you, it appears to be a compilation of videos that you've already seen.
00:43:17 Correct.
00:43:18 That you received as a mass dump, I guess, for lack of a better term, if you view video.
00:43:23 Is that fair to say?
00:43:23 Yes.
00:43:24 Okay.
00:43:25 And the exhibit 12.1, does it appear to be the same as the raw video that you've seen previously?
00:43:38 It does, yes.
00:43:38 Are there any additions or anything different about this particular exhibit?
00:43:45 There are some portions of the video where a zoom is initiated, which wasn't a function of the cameras.
00:43:51 I believe some specific individuals have been blurred from the footage.
00:43:55 And I believe there are some red circles to show poignant information or individuals within the footage itself.
00:44:02 Okay.
00:44:02 So other than the red circles, the blur, and the zoom, does it appear to accurately depict what you've seen in the raw video footage?
00:44:11 I believe so, yes.
00:44:15 On your screen, I'm going to have displayed an image.
00:44:25 Let me know when you see it.
00:44:44 That image is there now.
00:44:45 Oh, it's gone again.
00:44:49 Is it there?
00:44:51 We're back, yeah.
00:44:51 Okay, we're back.
00:44:53 So do you recognize what this is?
00:44:56 Yeah, this is the first frame of the video compilation that we just referenced.
00:45:01 And again, this video portrays what you believe is Mr. Robinson visiting campus that day?
00:45:08 Correct.
00:45:09 Okay, and is it throughout the day?
00:45:10 It is, yes.
00:45:11 And then I believe you said into the early morning hours of the 11th, is that right? 0.98
00:45:15 Correct.
00:45:15 Okay.
00:45:24 Justice State would move to admit what's been marked State's Exhibit 12.1.
00:45:33 Ms. Nestor.
00:45:36 Your Honor, we have objections to its admissibility.
00:45:42 um the this is a compilation video that was put together from a bunch of different sources by
00:45:49 the county attorney's office um this individual did not create this compilation um can't testify
00:45:58 to the um accuracy of the actual um materials that it was taken from and furthermore um
00:46:09 And Mr. Olson himself is just referred to by Agent Hall.
00:46:15 He specifically says people have altered these recordings.
00:46:19 They've zoomed in when the actual recording isn't zoomed.
00:46:23 They've added little circles to people they want you to pay attention to.
00:46:26 They've blurred people's faces out.
00:46:28 So, I mean, it's been clearly altered.
00:46:30 And it's not, I mean, they admit it's been altered.
00:46:34 So we have real concern about authenticity of it.
00:46:37 Furthermore, this particular video should be protected,
00:46:41 and so that deals with the admissibility factor.
00:46:43 As far as the publication factor of it,
00:46:47 the video should be classified as protected under UCJA 4-202.02 subsection 5J as in Jelly Bean
00:47:00 and then little I and little double I
00:47:04 because this is going to interfere with the defense's ongoing investigation,
00:47:08 with Mr. Tyler's ability, I mean, with Mr. Robinson's ability to get a fair trial.
00:47:14 This is basically putting together photos that are clear with photos that aren't clear,
00:47:23 putting them all together in such a format that it makes the case that it's all one person.
00:47:30 It would be extremely prejudicial for people that may ultimately serve on this jury to watch this video before this case goes to trial.
00:47:39 We don't believe a proper foundation's been laid, which would make it admissible at this point.
00:47:45 So the fact that it would be shown to the public would be extremely damaging to the ability to put on a defense at trial.
00:47:51 And so we object to its publication both in the courtroom and to the media, Your Honor.
00:47:57 Mr. Sturgill.
00:48:00 Judge, Ms. Nestor is correct.
00:48:01 This is a compilation of a series of videos.
00:48:04 The videos as Detector, as Sergeant Hull has testified to, is a compilation of raw videos
00:48:16 that he has received from Utah Valley University.
00:48:20 And he has not only seen this video, but he has seen all the raw footage.
00:48:24 and by his estimation or according to his testimony these are all videos that that are
00:48:32 accurate and they depict what the raw footage depicts other than those minor additions judge
00:48:38 if you refer to mr olson's written statement it's plaintiff's exhibit 12.3 he too has reviewed this
00:48:47 video. And he has also identified this video as being accurate with the exception of those
00:48:55 additions. In his words, it's the zooms and the red highlights. They weren't part of the original
00:49:00 recording, according to Mr. Olson. But other than that, as he states, the same as Agent Hull,
00:49:09 these videos are accurate. And they were captured by UVU surveillance video.
00:49:17 Do you have a version of this video that does not have alterations such as zooming or circling?
00:49:27 My concern is that if the 1102 says what it says about the videos, these were the videos, but then it was altered.
00:49:38 And typically an exhibit which has been altered, and if it wasn't done by the person who supplied the 1102, that that can become problematic.
00:49:47 And so do you have a version of this exhibit that does not have the zooming in or the circling?
00:49:54 Again, I don't know all the alterations that were made, but that seems to fall outside the 1102
00:49:59 because you don't have a person testifying 1102 saying, I made the alterations.
00:50:06 And so that's the concern of what Ms. Nestor was talking about as it relates to the state's evidence.
00:50:14 I have that concern about those alterations.
00:50:17 I don't, again, I don't know when they were made, what they were made, how much was done to manipulate the video.
00:50:24 And I say manipulate to, not saying in a nefarious way, but I don't know what the scope of that is and how much it deviates from what was the original form.
00:50:37 Judge, to answer your first question, do we have a version of this particular video that has not been altered?
00:50:44 We don't, not right now, not today.
00:50:47 So, I guess there's a, well, there's a couple of things I'd simply like to point out, Judge,
00:50:53 and that is that we have two witnesses who have watched the raw footage.
00:50:57 And Agent Hull here today on the stand and Mr. Olson in the form of his written statement.
00:51:04 They have both said that this video, with the exception of these alterations,
00:51:08 accurately depicts the video that was captured by UVU surveillance video.
00:51:14 Judge, I will proffer that those changes made to the video were not done by either.
00:51:20 I know who that person is.
00:51:21 We could actually call that person as a witness if that would cure that.
00:51:26 And we're prepared to do that if necessary.
00:51:29 But, Judge, I think that our burden is to simply authenticate what this is.
00:51:38 And it is a video that, with only a few exceptions, alterations, that really don't change the substance of the video or the content of the video, they're accurate.
00:51:50 They depict what the cameras captured on September 10th and the 11th.
00:51:54 And we have two people who have seen that raw footage, and they've explained that's the only difference between what we have originally in the original videos and what you're seeing here today.
00:52:05 And the additions, I will submit, Judge, were only added to make it easier to view.
00:52:12 All right.
00:52:13 Anything further from the parties?
00:52:15 No, no.
00:52:17 I'm going to go ahead and I'm sustaining the objection.
00:52:21 Typically, when exhibits are admitted to the court, it is without alteration.
00:52:26 If a party circles an exhibit, a photograph, that's not the original format.
00:52:31 And I do not have the person who made the alteration, an 1102, to substantiate that.
00:52:39 And what I have is the original video and Mr. Olson saying, this is the video minus the alterations.
00:52:47 And we have Agent Hull saying, this is the video and there are alterations, but I'm missing a link.
00:52:53 And it may be minor, but in this type of case, I want to be thorough.
00:52:58 And I want to make sure that what is minor is still important.
00:53:03 And for those reasons, I'm going to sustain the objection and leave it to the parties on how you wish to handle the video.
00:53:09 In the future, I don't want to provide guidance either way.
00:53:12 But as it stands today, this exhibit, state's exhibits, 12.1 is not admitted.
00:53:20 Okay.
00:53:21 Judge, could I have just one moment?
00:53:22 You may.
00:53:28 Thank you.
00:53:58 Thank you.
00:54:28 agent hole you testified that there were four visits to campus that day correct yes and it
00:54:46 the the first three visits um based on what you have observed um is your opinion that those videos
00:54:54 were captured by UVU surveillance video.
00:54:56 Is that correct?
00:54:57 That is correct, yes.
00:54:57 Okay.
00:54:58 The fourth visit, well, the fourth visit, too,
00:55:09 was captured by UVU surveillance video.
00:55:10 Is that correct?
00:55:11 Correct.
00:55:11 Okay.
00:55:13 Was there any other video that was collected
00:55:15 either on the 10th or the 11th that you believe
00:55:23 might be important or relevant to today's hearing?
00:55:27 There was a large amount of video.
00:55:30 I'm going to be a little bit more specific.
00:55:33 Was there, other than UVU surveillance video,
00:55:38 was there any other video that you collected
00:55:43 and subsequently gathered an 1102 statement for?
00:55:49 Yes, we collected ring doorbell footage from the surrounding neighborhoods.
00:55:52 Okay.
00:55:53 Let me ask you this.
00:55:55 Did that include video from a residence located at 680 West, 925 South Orem?
00:56:13 Yes, that's in the Horseshoe area.
00:56:15 Yep.
00:56:16 Okay.
00:56:18 That's in Orem?
00:56:19 Correct.
00:56:20 And close to campus?
00:56:21 It is, yes.
00:56:21 Okay.
00:56:22 Okay. And what can you tell us about that video?
00:56:26 It was a ring doorbell video that was provided that showed a vehicle consistent with the one we had identified as belonging to Mr. Robinson parking in front of the residence across the street.
00:56:39 Okay. And what can you tell us about the timing and the, well, the timing of that parked vehicle?
00:56:45 If I recall, that vehicle parked approximately 0.38 hours on the morning of the 11th.
00:56:55 Okay.
00:56:56 So 0.38 hours, what time is that to regular people?
00:57:01 Just after midnight.
00:57:03 At 12.38 a.m.?
00:57:04 In the morning, yes.
00:57:05 Okay.
00:57:08 So how did this video come to your attention that you're talking about, this doorbell or whatever?
00:57:15 This footage was obtained as part of the canvas of the area
00:57:19 that was conducted as part of the investigation.
00:57:22 Were you able to identify the owners of that residence?
00:57:26 Yes.
00:57:27 Where that video was collected from?
00:57:28 Correct.
00:57:29 Okay.
00:57:29 And do you know who it was collected from and by whom?
00:57:32 It was Mr. and Mrs. Noble.
00:57:34 I believe Agent Davis collected the video directly from them.
00:57:38 Okay.
00:57:40 And do you know what date it was collected?
00:57:42 if i can refresh from my notes if referring to your notes we'll refresh your memory
00:57:48 go ahead and look at that don't read it out loud
00:57:51 i don't have the specific date but i do know that myself and agent davis returned to the address
00:58:10 as we had done with previous videos
00:58:14 and had the owners of the video verify that it was from their system.
00:58:19 And we did have them complete an 1102 statement, which would be dated.
00:58:23 Okay.
00:58:24 Do you know, so let's talk about this.
00:58:28 What does this video look like?
00:58:32 It's a nighttime view looking from the front porch of the residence across the street.
00:58:37 Okay.
00:58:38 And what about that video?
00:58:39 Why was this particular video significant to you?
00:58:42 Why do you think it was related to this case?
00:58:46 We know from the UVU footage that the person we believe to be Mr. Robinson
00:58:51 had an interaction with law enforcement.
00:58:54 And a short period after that, the vehicle comes to that house.
00:59:02 And some additional evidence that was collected from cell phone data and things
00:59:07 indicated that Mr. Robinson was in the area and we were able to locate the footage of his vehicle
00:59:13 on that ring doorbell camera. Or at least what you believe is his vehicle.
00:59:17 The vehicle we believe to belong to Mr. Robinson, yes. And is there something about this particular
00:59:21 video and this vehicle that was captured that leads you to believe that it was Mr. Robinson's
00:59:28 vehicle? Yeah, the vehicle has very distinct wheels. I won't say that they're wholly unique.
00:59:37 But in terms of the video footage that we were reviewing, the wheels on the vehicle are fairly unique and stand out on the video footage.
00:59:46 So, again, this is video that you received early on in the investigation.
00:59:51 Yes.
00:59:52 And then in preparation for the preliminary.
00:59:54 Buy gold and put some silver in your pocket.
00:59:57 I know what you're thinking.
01:00:00 Everything's expensive right now.
01:00:01 How am I going to buy gold?
01:00:03 Pull your head out of the sand.
01:00:05 And one thing you can control right now that doesn't cost you anything out of pocket is diversifying your retirement savings.
01:00:12 Birch Gold Group will help you convert an old 401k from a previous employer or an IRA into a physical gold IRA.
01:00:21 Let me repeat that. Birch Gold will help you now convert an old 401k from a previous employer or an IRA into a physical IRA in gold.
01:00:33 You know something that's a hedge against inflation.
01:00:36 Listen to this right now.
01:00:37 Birch Gold is going to give you a special America 250,
01:00:41 one-ounce silver round for every $10,000 you purchase by July 10th.
01:00:47 I'm going to repeat this.
01:00:49 With every $10,000 purchase, you get a free one-ounce silver round,
01:00:54 America 250 commemoration, a special.
01:00:57 Think about this.
01:00:57 Ten years ago, an ounce of gold was about $1,200.
01:01:00 dollars. Today, it's around $4,500. Where will it be in 10 years from now? Text Bannon, B-A-N-N-O-N,
01:01:09 989898, to take advantage of free America 250 silver with qualifying purchase before the 10th
01:01:16 of July. Again, text my name, Bannon, B-A-N-N-O-N, to number 989898 today. Take advantage of this
01:01:25 Offer. With qualifying purchases, you get a silver round, a one-ounce silver round.
01:01:34 Check it out. Qualifying purchase. You got to do it before July 10th. Do it today.
01:01:38 Why wait till you're down to your last pill, stuck traveling, or dealing with a packed pharmacy
01:01:43 when you can already have your medications on hand? Seriously. You know what you normally take.
01:01:49 You already know what your family could need. That makes no sense. Smart families don't operate
01:01:54 like that. That's why I love All Family Pharmacy. They're built a better, simpler system to get your
01:02:01 prescription medications. You go online, fill out a quick medical form, licensed doctors review your
01:02:07 requests, prescribe if appropriate, and your medications are shipped directly to your door.
01:02:13 No waiting rooms, no pharmacy lines, no insurance nonsense. People are traveling more, schedules are
01:02:18 getting crazier, and have your medications already on hand just makes your life easier because being
01:02:24 prepared isn't paranoia. It's common sense. Go visit my friends at allfamilypharmacy.com. That's
01:02:30 one word, allfamilypharmacy.com slash Bannon, and use code Bannon10 to save 10% on your next order.
01:02:39 Again, that's allfamilypharmacy.com slash Bannon, and use code Bannon10.
01:02:46 Everyone's focused on how the conflict in the Middle East is raising oil prices,
01:02:49 but there's another grim reality to this contention.
01:02:54 Oil isn't the only resource being constrained.
01:02:56 About one-third of global fertilizer trade happens through this region.
01:03:01 And with spring planting season on top of us,
01:03:04 American farmers are sounding the alarm,
01:03:06 with some saying they can't afford to plant their fields.
01:03:09 When one piece of the supply chain gets hit this hard,
01:03:12 you know what comes next, higher fruit prices, reduced availability,
01:03:17 maybe even panic buying.
01:03:19 That's why having an emergency food supply at home makes so much sense.
01:03:24 And that's where our friends at MyPatriotSupply come in right now at preparewithbannon.com.
01:03:30 That is preparewithbannon.com.
01:03:33 We've set up an entire just site for the War Room Posse.
01:03:37 You go to preparewithbannon.com.
01:03:40 That's all one word, preparewithbannon.com.
01:03:43 You get a three-month emergency food supply.
01:03:46 They'll include a free mega protein upgrade, an incredible $200 bonus you don't want to miss.
01:03:53 It's a simple way to protect your family from whatever comes next.
01:03:59 Go to preparewithbannon.com.
01:04:01 That is preparewithbannon.com to get your emergency food supply today.
01:04:05 That's preparewithbannon.com.
01:04:08 Do it today.
01:04:09 Go check it out.
01:04:11 What did you meet with about this video?
01:04:12 Met with Mrs. Noble.
01:04:13 And what did you do with Mrs. Noble?
01:04:16 We did what we had done before.
01:04:18 We had a specific file that we wanted, or files that we wanted her to verify.
01:04:23 The footage itself is broken into, I believe, 10-second segments.
01:04:28 So we had specific files that we had her view and confirm that they were actually from her system.
01:04:35 Those were written on the 1102 as they have been before.
01:04:39 Okay, and who wrote those file names on this particular statement?
01:04:42 I believe it would be my handwriting on the 1102.
01:04:45 All right, what did you do next?
01:04:48 We had a view the videos and then complete a statement
01:04:51 verifying the authenticity of those videos on an 1102.
01:04:55 Was this also prepared on a State Bureau form?
01:04:58 I believe this was on a State Bureau
01:05:00 investigations form, yes.
01:05:01 And in this particular form,
01:05:03 on which Ms. Noble provided her statement,
01:05:05 does it have the advisory that it would be used
01:05:07 in lieu of her testimony here today?
01:05:09 It does, yes.
01:05:10 Does it also contain a warning
01:05:11 that if she gave a false statement,
01:05:13 she would be punished or it's punishable by a class A misdemeanor?
01:05:16 Correct.
01:05:17 Okay.
01:05:24 I'm gonna have displayed on your monitor
01:05:26 what's been marked state's exhibit number 13 identification.
01:05:31 Let me know when you see that, would you?
01:05:32 I can see that.
01:05:33 Okay, and I'm gonna have my assistant
01:05:37 scroll through that slowly.
01:05:43 Okay, do you recognize that?
01:05:58 I do, yes.
01:05:59 What is that?
01:06:00 It's the 1102 that myself and Agent Davis collected from Ms. Noble.
01:06:05 Okay, and it appears, does it appear to be in the same condition as when you collected it?
01:06:09 It does, yes.
01:06:10 This is a copy, right?
01:06:11 Yes.
01:06:12 yes okay and the personal identifying information appears to be redacted is
01:06:22 that right it has been redacted yes it wasn't redacted when you collected it
01:06:27 right no no the original form was not redacted so other than the redactions
01:06:30 it appears to be in the same conditions it was when you collected that that is
01:06:33 correct state would move to admit exhibit 13
01:06:36 Ms. Nassar. I know we renew our concern about unconstitutional hearsay being
01:06:44 admitted. We also have the same concerns about the fact that the Agent Hull amended
01:06:55 this himself and there's no foundation as to when he filled that in if it was
01:07:00 before or after she signed it and due to all those reasons we object to its
01:07:05 admission and
01:07:07 object to its publication as well.
01:07:09 Mr. Sturgill. Judge,
01:07:11 again, it was collected in compliance with
01:07:13 Rule 1102 of the Utah
01:07:15 Rules of Evidence,
01:07:18 specifically
01:07:19 subsection B8.
01:07:21 It's in writing.
01:07:23 It's on a form. It includes both
01:07:25 the advisory and the warning.
01:07:27 And it was collected
01:07:29 by Agent Hull.
01:07:32 It's also
01:07:33 collected in compliance and being
01:07:35 introduced as reliable hearsay which is lawful to do here in Utah under the
01:07:41 state constitution article 1 section 12 do you wish to lay more foundation about
01:07:46 when the statement was written whether it was before it was signed or not I
01:07:49 can do that judge I appreciate that yes agent hold do you recall when you
01:07:54 collected this written statement from Miss Noble yes it was in April in April
01:07:59 do you know what day April 6th I believe okay and you collected that did you go
01:08:04 her home i think is that what you said yes myself and agent davis went to the residence okay and
01:08:09 did you sit there while she prepared it i did yes and did you witness her sign it i did yes okay
01:08:15 there's at this point i'd move to admit
01:08:19 uh exhibit 13. all right and to the state representative could you scroll down
01:08:23 okay all right pursuant to the Utah rule of evidence 1102 and article 1 section 28
01:08:38 I'm sorry article 1 section 12 which allows for a reliable hearsay I'm going to move it into it's
01:08:49 going to be admitted into evidence over the objection of defense I note in
01:08:55 particular it states that I confirmed that the above files were taken from our
01:09:01 nest doorbell videos and are accurate and in right before that's a statement
01:09:11 is the notations that were allegedly made by agent whole and so for those
01:09:18 reasons court finds proper foundation has been laid and that this and exhibit
01:09:24 in its entirety is admitted into evidence as it relates to publication I
01:09:31 will authorize publication in the courtroom and by the media if they so
01:09:37 wish to capture it in that form again following the same formats have it on
01:09:42 that first portion of the screen for about 10 seconds and then scroll down to
01:09:48 the written portion for about 15 seconds and then scroll to the very bottom to ensure that
01:09:53 the full exhibit has been displayed.
01:10:18 All right, that concludes the publication of State's Exhibit 13.
01:10:24 Okay.
01:10:25 Thank you, Judge.
01:10:31 The video that you took with you that day when you visited with Noble, or Miss Noble,
01:10:38 had you previously, well, you've stated that the videos that you showed, the Nobles,
01:10:47 were actually more than one video correct okay and I believe you said they
01:10:51 were like 10-second clips if I recall correctly short clips and and you showed
01:10:56 Miss Noble all of those all of those videos that are identified in that
01:11:02 statement the one shown on the on the statement were shown to Miss Noble yes
01:11:08 have you had a chance to review what's been marked state's exhibit number 12.2
01:11:16 yes okay and when did you have a chance to review that exhibit
01:11:21 i believe that was reviewed last week i believe okay with with yourself okay and and does that
01:11:31 video is it a single video that you watched uh no i believe it's four separate short videos
01:11:38 Okay. And as far as, and I understand that, but as far as 12.2 is concerned, what does that exhibit consist of?
01:11:47 It shows the vehicle believed to be driven by Mr. Robinson arriving in front of the residence,
01:11:55 an individual exiting the vehicle and moving away from it,
01:11:59 followed by an individual returning to the vehicle and unlocking it.
01:12:03 And then it shows the vehicle a short time later starting and leaving the area.
01:12:07 and and those are the videos that you showed miss noble yes what I have
01:12:20 displayed on your monitor was been marks plaintiffs or states exhibit 12.2 for
01:12:24 identification let me know as soon as you see should be a still image I can
01:12:31 It's there. Do you recognize what's depicted there? Yeah this is the view
01:12:37 looking what would essentially be west across the street from the Nobles
01:12:42 residence. Okay at 1238 a.m. I guess or 038? Yes. Okay and
01:12:53 what what is depicted in this I think you've already described that so judge
01:13:03 I would move to admit exhibit 12.2 miss Nester
01:13:12 your honor we renew our objection to allowing in the evidence without the
01:13:17 sponsoring witness I do have some concerns because I'm not totally sure if
01:13:22 this compilation if this is a compilation or if this is just one of the one two three four five
01:13:29 at least six videos they took from the nobles so if we could have that clarification i think that
01:13:37 that concerns me about authenticity that i don't understand if this is just a portion or if this
01:13:42 is the whole thing or is this is all of them or none of them and for those reasons we object to
01:13:48 the admission and to publication. Thank you. Mr. Sturgill. That's a good point. And I'll ask
01:13:53 additional questions before I re-seek to admit it. Agent Hull, this particular video, you've
01:13:59 described taking several videos to Ms. Noble and having reviewed them. Yes. Okay. This particular
01:14:04 exhibit, 12.2, have you watched it in its entirety? Yes. Does it consist of either some or all of those
01:14:12 videos that you showed Ms. Noble? It does, yes. And is it a single video? Is it a compilation
01:14:17 that is to say or is it four different videos or a number of different videos be a number of short
01:14:25 videos sequenced okay a number of short videos in sequence I believe that's how this one plays yes
01:14:33 okay just again I seek to admit it anything further from the parties
01:14:41 All right. Given my previous rulings on exhibits, I applied the same analysis and find that
01:14:51 State's Exhibit 12.2, I believe, is admitted over the objection and may be published in the
01:15:01 courtroom and by the media, if so chosen.
01:15:04 Okay, so before we play this video, again, what is it that leads you to believe that this is Mr. Robinson's vehicle?
01:15:19 The shape of the vehicle can be clearly seen as it pulls up, and the distinctive wheels on the vehicle also.
01:15:26 And what, well, let's go ahead and play it.
01:15:30 Is there any sound associated with this?
01:15:32 there is judge but it's it's night sounds it's crickets chirping and um okay i just wanted to
01:15:40 see if there was i just wanted to see if there was sound or not okay all right you may play the video
01:16:02 Thank you.
01:16:32 So, in the first part of that video, what do you see?
01:17:01 The vehicle we believe to be driven by Mr. Robinson pulling up and parking across the street but in front of the residents.
01:17:08 And then in the next video, what do you believe is displayed in that video?
01:17:13 There's an individual who gets out of the vehicle. You can hear the door close and then that individual moves away from the front of the vehicle.
01:17:22 There's actually two reflective panels on a dumpster and you can see the individual past those reflective panels.
01:17:30 panels. And in the last of those series of videos? The second to last one the
01:17:38 individual comes back across those reflective panels to the vehicle unlocks
01:17:41 the vehicle and gets into it and then in the last video the vehicle is started
01:17:46 and individual drives away.
01:18:00 Just one moment, Judge.
01:18:09 Yes.
01:18:30 Judge, can we approach?
01:18:51 You may.
01:19:00 .
01:19:30 .
01:20:00 All right, everybody, welcome into this very special edition of Just the News, No Noise.
01:20:30 As you're watching, this is the trial of Tyler Robinson.
01:20:33 The judge is set to determine whether the full trial is going to move forward based on the evidence for alleged Charlie Kirk assassin Tyler Robinson.
01:20:42 So joining us now to break all of this down and everything that has happened thus far is former prosecutor and career trial attorney, Wendy Patrick.
01:20:49 Wendy, thanks so much for being here.
01:20:51 Thank you for having me.
01:20:53 This might be a very brief convo because the council has approached the bench and they might go back to the proceedings.
01:20:58 But what have been some of the biggest takeaways for you today so far?
01:21:02 One of the biggest takeaways is the record that this group is making.
01:21:06 And I say group because I mean both the prosecution, the defense and the judge.
01:21:10 This is one of those cases where you do not want anything going wrong because you're preserving this transcript for potential appeal.
01:21:17 And that's really one of the things they're focused on, including this hearing they're having right now.
01:21:21 So it seems to me that, you know, as a layperson, they're going through the evidence, trying to figure out what can be admitted.
01:21:27 Is there anything that stands out to you as, oh, my goodness, this could be the nail in the coffin for Tyler Robinson or the other side of that?
01:21:36 Yes, that's a great question, because one of the things that makes a huge impact is the actual footage of the assassination.
01:21:42 I mean, that has to be one of the most damning pieces of evidence in any type of a trial like this.
01:21:47 And unfortunately, for those of us that saw it, it is absolutely triggering.
01:21:51 So that's the kind of evidence that's explosive in nature.
01:21:55 So you bet the defense is going to do everything they can to make a record that indicates they've done what they can to keep it out.
01:22:02 On the other hand, that's a big piece of evidence for the prosecution.
01:22:05 And while they're justifiably also concerned about the re-traumatizing effect of it, it's a big part of the case.
01:22:13 So this is the fine line both sides are watching when it comes to what is the most important pieces of evidence to litigate.
01:22:20 So that is one of the reasons why we're seeing so much about that here.
01:22:24 Authentication, I have to say, is another big deal at the preliminary hearing, because
01:22:28 although you don't carry the same standard of proof, I mean, the judge just has to find
01:22:32 probable cause to move the case forward till trial.
01:22:35 You also want to make sure that all the evidence is reliable.
01:22:38 So you have authentication, admissibility, publication, relevancy, reliability.
01:22:43 All of those things that are important at a trial are, to some extent, also important
01:22:47 at a prelim.
01:22:48 And one more thing I'll add, because I used to be a defense attorney before I was a prosecutor,
01:22:53 The defense is testing the waters to see how much of what type of evidence the judge is going to admit, because that's going to inform their trial strategy.
01:23:02 They don't have to show their hand at a prelim.
01:23:05 Prosecution has to show a lot more evidence.
01:23:07 The defense doesn't have to show any, but they do have an opportunity to test some of these objections here, as you see that they're doing.
01:23:14 Do you see thus far, because you hear in courtroom terms all the time about preponderance of evidence, have we reached that point yet?
01:23:23 Well, it's even less than that at a prelim. It's a slight suspicion. They call it different things in different jurisdictions. But probable cause basically means there has to be enough evidence to proceed to trial. Now, we have enough evidence in the court of public opinion. And given that most of that will be recreated here, you are going to meet that quantum of evidence.
01:23:42 But even though everyone knows that's where we're headed, it still has to be done on the record.
01:23:47 And that is one of the reasons we have so many questions asked.
01:23:51 A big foundation is being laid.
01:23:53 Any non-legal observers would be saying, why are we going into all of this?
01:23:56 It's just a probable cause hearing.
01:23:58 But there's no room for mistakes in a case this high profile and with all the different types of evidence.
01:24:04 And as you're seeing, given the judge actually just sustaining one of the defense objections, we can't take anything for granted.
01:24:13 And that's why, even though you only need that small quantum of evidence, they're going over and above, crossing the teeth and dotting the eyes to make sure no mistakes are made.
01:24:23 Yeah. I mean, I think of all of the high profile trials out there where there have been just procedural errors, things that, you know, not even intentionally tainted the case, but ultimately ended up having the case or not.
01:24:36 I mean, we're looking at Harvey Weinstein.
01:24:39 I'm trying to think of the NXIVM guy.
01:24:41 But over and over and over again, you see this.
01:24:43 So I absolutely hear what you're saying because I shudder to think that for Charlie Kirk's millions and millions of fans
01:24:50 and people who, by the way, since his death have become supporters of his because they had one view of him.
01:24:57 And then when he died, they watched clips and they actually informed themselves.
01:25:00 But for those people, I shudder to think what would happen if something went haywire in this case
01:25:05 and it got thrown out. And let me add to that. That was excellent. I agree with everything you
01:25:10 just said. And in addition to all of that, think about the high profile this case has in terms of
01:25:17 who's currently in the courtroom. Can you imagine Erica Kirk, Charlie's parents, all having to sit
01:25:22 through a second trial because something went wrong? So there's a lot riding on this going right.
01:25:27 Absolutely. And it's been heartbreaking. And I think that for a lot of people,
01:25:31 people, but also women out there observing what Erica Kirk is going through, what she went through,
01:25:38 what she continues to get dragged through. There's definitely that heartstring element to this, 0.92
01:25:43 which I understand in court of law, that is not something that hinges a case of whether it goes
01:25:48 forward or whether it doesn't in the case of today's proceedings. Control room, do we have
01:25:55 those clips that you guys had initially? Can we show those? Okay. Okay. Awesome. All right. So for
01:26:01 those of you who haven't been tuning into this trial because it has been on all day and we're
01:26:04 going to be watching it and following it as it goes on throughout the week. But Officer Bagley
01:26:09 at one point says that he actually saw the markings of someone in a prone position,
01:26:15 a shooting ready position on the rooftop where Charlie was allegedly shot from. Check this out.
01:26:22 I'm on top of the Lossie building, which is where the gravel is on towards the bottom center.
01:26:26 I'm looking west towards the tent which is in the upper center that you got a white tent
01:26:32 You can see the grass down there in the amphitheater
01:26:35 You got the hall of flags that's more towards the top center
01:26:38 And behind that you've got I-15
01:26:41 But what I'm looking at is in the disturbance of the gravels what I saw that day
01:26:46 Okay, and what can you describe for the record that disturbance?
01:26:50 To me when I got up there and I could see this disturbance of gravel
01:26:55 To me, it looks like a sniper pad, a person that has been laid in a prone position, and you've got markings of elbows, knees, and feet to where somebody was in the line of sight of where Charlie's tent was.
01:27:10 And for our audience, just FYI, the reason we haven't gone back into that courtroom is because the councils approached the bench and had a conversation, and then it appears that they went on break.
01:27:18 So as soon as they come back from that break, we will dip straight back in.
01:27:22 But I want to ask you, you know, it's not supposed to matter what the emotions are surrounding this.
01:27:30 But I can't help but think that, I mean, unless you are just a stone cold, concrete hearted person, it's got to play into this at some point, even if you don't want to admit it.
01:27:42 It's true. And here's what's interesting about that point.
01:27:45 It is definitely always a jury instruction that they have to make their decision without passion or prejudice.
01:27:50 You can't let your emotions at all color your view of the evidence.
01:27:53 You would be amazed how seriously jurors take that admonition.
01:27:57 I mean, I've been trying cases for 30 years and they will always admit afterwards that,
01:28:02 you know, there was a big disagreement in the jury room because if there's any indication
01:28:06 somebody is using emotion instead of fact, they'll make sure they go overboard to prevent
01:28:10 that.
01:28:11 We're all human beings and it's even tougher for the bystanders in the courtroom to sit
01:28:15 through some of this testimony.
01:28:16 And if anybody has to walk out in tears, I know Erica Kirk already left at least once today, the jurors have to also make sure they don't let that emotion color their judgment.
01:28:26 So if it's something they take seriously, I'm optimistic.
01:28:29 I believe that, especially working as a group, most of the time they're able to do it.
01:28:34 Wendy, is there a larger picture in all of this that, again, I know, just like the emotion thing, I know it's not supposed to be in their mind.
01:28:43 But there to me is an overarching principle here, and it's that political disagreements and grievances should not be solved, I suppose, with violence.
01:28:53 Because you look at a case like this and what it says to the American people about the left and the right and the way that each side handles disagreements compared to the other.
01:29:03 And I have to think that in this day and age, when we see people constantly trying to kill the president of the United States, shooting up congressional baseball games, shooting up ice facilities, time after time after time, you see this happening.
01:29:16 It's frankly, just as an observer, it's coming from one side going towards the other.
01:29:21 But there's got to be a piece of this.
01:29:23 There's got to be a layer on top of all of this that's informed by the news that we continue
01:29:29 hearing, which is that one side carries out violence to try to silence the other.
01:29:35 And that partisan viewpoint is also something that jurors will be screened for before they're
01:29:40 ever allowed to sit on the case.
01:29:42 Because simply by admitting what side you're on, you're also admitting ideology much of the time, not all the time.
01:29:49 But that is something both sides are going to have an opportunity to explore.
01:29:52 And by the way, that is such an important point.
01:29:54 It was actually one of the rationales the judge used in letting the media have access to the proceedings we're watching in real time.
01:30:02 The defense didn't want cameras in the courtroom.
01:30:04 They didn't want anything live streamed.
01:30:06 The judge reminded everyone that we can investigate partisan politics, judicial overview, viewpoints that potential jurors might have and then how to contain those before a jury is selected.
01:30:18 Because what you exactly said, it does seem to be one sided.
01:30:21 If you look at this administration, they're going to worry that that's going to color the judgment and you're going to have jurors sitting there that are going to be deciding the case based on something other than the testimony and the evidence provided in the courtroom.
01:30:34 That is the litmus test. No matter who they are, what emotions they feel, what politics they hold, they can only judge Tyler Robinson based on what comes off the witness stand and what's presented as evidence.
01:30:47 Wendy Patrick, thank you so much for this analysis. And this this is going to be ongoing throughout the week unless it ends in the next few days.
01:30:54 So we will definitely have to get you back on to break it all down for us. Wendy, thanks so much for being here.
01:30:59 Thank you for having me.
01:31:00 absolutely all right everybody we're going to have more from the tyler robinson hearing on
01:31:05 the other side of this break so don't go anywhere
01:31:07 the promise of this country has been the freedom to build something of your own and for millions
01:31:17 of families that dream begins with owning a home built in a blink of an eye that american dream
01:31:22 can turn into a nightmare with just some public information and a ford signature criminals can
01:31:27 legally transfer your home ownership into their name. You won't find out about it until you start
01:31:31 getting foreclosure notices that show up in the mail. Getting it back, it could be months, even
01:31:36 years. Thousands in legal fees just to reclaim what's already yours. That's why we trust the
01:31:41 experts at Home Title Lock. With 24-7 title monitoring, urgent alerts, and a 100% fraud
01:31:46 restoration success rate, they fight for property owners and their loved ones against this growing
01:31:51 crime. And to celebrate America's 250th birthday, they're giving us all 25% off for up to two years
01:31:58 in title fraud protection, plus a free title history report to ensure you're not already
01:32:02 a victim. Use my promo code JTN25 at hometitlelock.com and get protected today. That's
01:32:09 hometitlelock.com, promo code JTN25.
01:32:21 Welcome back, everybody. That hearing is set to return in just a few moments. But in the meantime,
01:32:28 I want to squeeze in a few more questions with Wendy Patrick, our guest right now. She's former
01:32:32 prosecutor and career trial attorney and has a great perspective on all of this. Wendy, I want
01:32:36 to ask you about the timeline. As I was just telling my audience, we're going to be carrying
01:32:40 this through the end of it today, which I think is supposed to end in about 30 minutes. But
01:32:44 it is scheduled to go on throughout the week. Is this the type of thing, the pace that you are
01:32:50 seeing today, is that an indication that it will take the whole week? Or do you think that
01:32:54 everything will be presented and the hearing will wrap up sooner than that?
01:32:59 You know, it's a great question. Judges always ask that question. Counsel, are we really looking
01:33:03 at five days or are you going to get everything done in three? When we, had you asked me that
01:33:07 question four hours ago, I would say, let's block out next week too. But then we really did seem to
01:33:13 pick up the pace and that's as it should be because the defense is getting some idea as to
01:33:17 what kind of objections are going to be overruled, what are going to be sustained.
01:33:22 They're lodging what we call standing objections to certain types of evidence,
01:33:26 which means they don't have to keep reciting them again and again.
01:33:29 That's going to cut down on the anticipated amount of time.
01:33:33 And there also is an element of the judge at some point will know for a fact he has enough evidence,
01:33:38 and it'll be interesting to see if he behaves as many of his peers do
01:33:42 and begins to signal to the parties that he's heard enough and there is plenty to go to trial.
01:33:47 Now, the key for the defense when we get to that point is they have to make sure they've made all the right objections to try to keep out all the evidence they're going to argue makes it make sense not to move forward.
01:33:59 The prosecutor has to do the same thing, except they always go much further than the defense in putting in as much evidence they need and then some in a case of this magnitude.
01:34:08 So having said all that, I think we're definitely going to be done this week, possibly before Friday.
01:34:13 All right. I want to ask you to give a performance review thus far of each side, the council on each side.
01:34:24 Does it seem to you and do they have a reputation?
01:34:27 Is there a reputational information that you can give us about each of these sides that tells us, hey, these people are the top of their game.
01:34:34 It's going to be a dogfight till the end or maybe not.
01:34:36 Uh-huh. Well, because I don't practice in that jurisdiction, I would say I have an even more
01:34:42 objective assessment of their performance in the courtroom today. You know, one of the things I
01:34:46 would say characterizes this hearing so far is civility. You have both sides standing up,
01:34:52 you know, making their objections. They don't raise their voice. Their demeanor is right.
01:34:55 And I don't think it's simply because there are television cameras, because what happens is we
01:35:01 tend to forget about the cameras when passions sort of take over objectivity. I haven't seen
01:35:06 this today. They are being very polite to one another. The judge is very polite. They're even
01:35:12 keeled. Their tone is adequate. There is no reason for them to go over the top at a prelim. There's
01:35:17 no jury there to rate them. I think they're doing very well. And I think that objective analysis,
01:35:23 if it carries through to trial, is going to result with the judge at the end saying it's
01:35:26 been a pleasure to work with all of you. The judge also does not seem to be treating either party as
01:35:32 if there's some foreknowledge that there's a problem attorney in the bank. Now, maybe there's
01:35:37 a Utah lawyer that's going to come in and prove me wrong. But I can tell you what I'm seeing is
01:35:41 what the jury is going to see. Because remember, one of the other questions they're asked at the
01:35:45 beginning of Wadir is, do you know the parties or any of the attorneys? So there'll be an opportunity
01:35:51 to vet that as well. But so far, so good. Okay, Wendy, let me ask you this, because
01:35:56 there have been trials out there where there is just absolutely brutal and grotesque video
01:36:03 and photos and things like that. And this one, there was a shocking element to the video that
01:36:10 we saw of Charlie Kirk. I remember that day vividly. I mean, it was almost a surreal day
01:36:17 in our newsroom. We're all shouting at each other from across the newsroom, trying to get the latest
01:36:22 information, trying to verify it with two or three sources before we put anything out there.
01:36:27 But one thing we knew was that we saw that video and we saw something extremely shocking and frankly
01:36:32 evil happen before our eyes. Does that play into this? Is this the type of situation where that
01:36:39 gets played in the courtroom over and over and over again so that that makes an impression
01:36:45 in those jurors' brains? It won't be played over and over again. It's another great point you make.
01:36:51 A judge won't allow that, but it's going to be just as triggering, just as traumatic and just as surreal as it was for all of us when we first saw it.
01:36:59 And I'll add, not only is it re-traumatizing for everybody in the courtroom, but remember that assassination really had a worldwide reverberation.
01:37:09 There were people that weren't even Christians that were coming up to me.
01:37:13 One of the other hats I wear is as a Christian minister and basically admitting they felt like they'd lost a family member.
01:37:19 And they weren't yet even people of faith.
01:37:22 So understanding the Charlie Kirk effect,
01:37:25 no judge is going to allow it to be played over and over again.
01:37:28 And I honestly, it seems like once is all you need with footage that shocking.
01:37:34 And it's one of those pieces of video where it's not that it's so graphic in terms of blood and gore.
01:37:40 It is just so shocking in terms of the way it happened.
01:37:43 Surreal is a great word to use.
01:37:45 I think we all felt that way.
01:37:46 But I believe the jury will be able to see it.
01:37:49 Yeah. And, you know, there was this other aspect of it because, you know, so often the
01:37:54 left tries to argue on one side of a debate issue and they say, well, you know, you guys
01:38:01 just need to come at us with facts. You need to come at us civilly. You need to come at
01:38:04 us, you know, in a calm manner. There wasn't anyone out there on the conservative side
01:38:09 who came out with more facts, with more civility and with more calmness than Charlie Kirk. 0.70
01:38:16 So if they're willing to kill Charlie Kirk to silence him, my goodness, the rest of us, especially hotheads like me, I mean, we're screwed when it comes to their opinion of us.
01:38:25 You know, we are hopeful that cooler heads prevail on both sides.
01:38:31 You know, there are plenty of people on the left that absolutely decry acts of violence like this or any kind of violence or any type of egging anybody on towards violence.
01:38:40 But you are correct. It's a vocal minority and it's a small sliver that really is the problem here.
01:38:47 And this is what this trial is about as well. You know, it's not just about an assassination.
01:38:51 It's also about the larger political issues that you describe, which is another reason we're going to see a long preliminary examination is that everyone understands what's riding on this.
01:39:01 So I have to say, I hope it's a wake up call as the remember the baseball game.
01:39:06 And that was a wake up call for both sides for a while.
01:39:09 This will be another wake up call that reminds everyone that political violence is never the issue.
01:39:14 And that's a bipartisan statement that both sides of the aisle can get behind.
01:39:19 Absolutely. Wendy Patrick, always appreciate your analysis.
01:39:21 We're going to dip back into the courtroom and hopefully we'll have you on later on in the week to re-up on that on that wisdom.
01:39:28 All right, everybody, here we are. Here we are.
01:39:31 Sorted out these few questions. We were all in agreement that we want to break through the day.
01:39:35 Is that right, Miss Nester?
01:39:36 You may proceed with your questions and we'll take it from there.
01:39:46 All right. Agent Hole, I asked you earlier after you had testified about all the video that you've watched
01:39:56 and video that you believe depicts Mr. Robinson from the UVU surveillance
01:40:02 and that combined with the driver's license and the DMV records whether or
01:40:09 not you believe that that person that you have seen in the video and on the
01:40:12 driver's license record is in the courtroom today and I believe your
01:40:15 answer was yes yes that's correct and then I asked you if if you wouldn't mind
01:40:22 pointing him out and describing something he's wearing and I don't
01:40:27 believe that I allowed you to do that okay would you do that right now yeah
01:40:31 Senator, just for the record, we would impose an objection based on the 14th Amendment for due process due to an unduly suggestive in-court ID.
01:40:39 Also, we believe there's a lack of foundation establishing his ability to interpret the surveillance video.
01:40:49 And based on that, we would object.
01:40:51 All right. I note that, well, to the state, do you wish to be heard on what was just stated?
01:40:57 Well, Judge, I think we had this discussion, and I think you ruled on that specific objection.
01:41:02 And then after you ruled, I just neglected to come back and follow through with the question and the answer.
01:41:08 That's my recollection of the bench meeting.
01:41:11 I believe I stated for the purposes of this hearing that identification by Agent Hull of Mr. Robinson was made.
01:41:18 I could be wrong, but...
01:41:20 Well, I just wanted to clarify that, Judge, because there was some question about whether that in fact did happen.
01:41:25 and so if that's your recollection of what happened is if you're willing to
01:41:31 put on the record that agent Holt has identified the defendant I think we're
01:41:34 done does the defense want to be heard
01:41:45 of course
01:41:49 well if for the for the benefit of the record and for thoroughness if you wish
01:41:58 to re-ask that question you certainly well we can see what happens if I could
01:42:06 judge I'd like to would you please point him out and identify something that he
01:42:12 is wearing yeah I believe that mr. Robinson is between miss nester and
01:42:17 of the council wearing a gray suit jacket with a dark tie and a light
01:42:21 colored shirt. I would ask that the record reflect that Agent Holt has
01:42:25 identified the defendant.
01:42:38 I mean I made my objection already. Okay I just wanted to check. Thank you. For the
01:42:45 purposes of this hearing I find that agent Hall has identified mr. Robinson
01:42:49 again this is only for the preliminary hearing you may proceed because I think
01:42:55 for today with agent Hall we're we're done for today we'd ask that at this
01:43:04 point we take a break until tomorrow all right so are you saying that you're
01:43:09 you're you're gonna recall agent well we're gonna resume with mr. Hall
01:43:14 tomorrow morning morning and let me explain to and I was gonna explain this
01:43:18 but let me explain why because our intent is to prepare an an original
01:43:23 version of the video that has been in dispute today without the circles
01:43:28 without the blur and without the zooming in and our intent is to introduce that
01:43:34 tomorrow as a different exhibit and we just can't prepare that in the next hour
01:43:40 or so so we're going to need this evening uh to prepare that exhibit and we'd like to return with
01:43:46 that judge what i would also suggest well let's i guess let me get your your take on that judge
01:43:54 all right does the defense wish to be heard about ending for the day we have about 19 minutes until
01:44:00 five o'clock what is defense your honor we're happy to accommodate the state on that all right
01:44:06 So for today, Agent Hall, you may step down, and we'll resume with your testimony tomorrow morning.
01:44:14 Anything further, Mr. Sturgill?
01:44:16 Well, Judge, just one other thing, and it's a suggestion.
01:44:20 Agent Hall, can you wait just one second? I'm sorry. Go ahead.
01:44:24 I'm sure Ms. Nestor may have a position with regards to this,
01:44:27 but Judge, we would invite you to review the exhibit that we've been talking about today
01:44:35 it is 12.1 we suggest that you look at it between today and tomorrow because our intent is to seek
01:44:47 to admit the version where it doesn't have the circle or the blur or the zoom in and if that is
01:44:53 admitted we do intend to to introduce that exhibit 12.1 as well and I think it would be helpful if
01:45:02 you saw that in advance and you can compare that to the the version that
01:45:07 doesn't have the circle the blur and the zooming in I would ask that you do
01:45:15 that I don't know if the semester has a different opinion about that but I think
01:45:20 it would be helpful in determining whether or not that particular exhibit
01:45:24 12.1 is admissible.
01:45:27 Ms. Nester.
01:45:33 I don't have anything to add to that.
01:45:36 I defer to what the court prefers to do on that.
01:45:40 I do have another matter before Agent Hull's release that I do want to address with the court,
01:45:44 but I don't have any concern if the court wants to look at it in advance.
01:45:48 It's kind of a little bit of a long video.
01:45:51 I think it's just about five minutes, maybe.
01:45:53 it's not very long so if you if you want to wait until tomorrow it's not going to slow the matter
01:45:59 down very much but it's up to the court on that all right i appreciate the parties what i'm going
01:46:05 to do is i'm going to wait until it's properly before me and a motion has been made for either
01:46:10 of the videos and then i'm i'm happy to entertain the motion to review both of them uh or however
01:46:18 the parties i i don't want to issue a pre-ruling so i'll wait till it's properly before me and i
01:46:23 can take it from there and being that it's about five minutes um i i'm not not too concerned about
01:46:30 how much time is needed i also want to be thorough so i'll i'll wait till it's brought before me and
01:46:37 we can address it from there and turn to miss nester as it relates to your request um thank
01:46:44 you your honor your honor i i recognize that agent hole is the case agent and is working with the
01:46:50 state in preparing for this um but he is still on the stand and i would ask that he be instructed
01:46:57 that he can't discuss his testimony even though he's the case agent i don't think it's proper for
01:47:02 him to discuss his testimony while he's excused for the night mr sturgill all right so agent uh
01:47:11 from this moment on until we come back in court you're instructed not to discuss your testimony
01:47:18 with anyone uh as you are still on the stand for all intents and purposes and we'll uh if the state
01:47:25 recalls you this tomorrow morning then we'll proceed okay all right may this witness be excused
01:47:32 for today all right thank you agent hall anything further from the parties or do either party need
01:47:38 the benefit of the record before we adjourn not from the state judge all right noting uh neither
01:47:45 party wishes to, wishes the benefit of the record. Court is in recess until 9 a.m. tomorrow
01:47:51 morning. All right, everybody. So at 9 a.m. tomorrow, we are going to pick back up the
01:48:02 coverage inside that courtroom. But for now, I want to bring back on Wendy Patrick. Wendy,
01:48:08 Tyler Robinson has been charged with aggravated murder. That is a capital offense. I do believe
01:48:14 prosecutors are seeking the death penalty. As you see the evidence thus far today, obviously,
01:48:20 we have many more days of this. What do you anticipate will come of their seeking of the
01:48:25 death penalty? Do you think we'll reach that? Yes, because, you know, they don't charge it
01:48:30 unless they believe they can prove it beyond a reasonable doubt. And that's not even the standard
01:48:33 at a preliminary hearing. So, you know, part of a preliminary hearing is, you know, to basically
01:48:39 put on all the evidence that's already in the court of public opinion, make it official, have
01:48:43 a judge rule on it. It's also an opportunity to test the value of certain pieces of evidence.
01:48:49 You know, it's one thing to say, oh, we have camera footage, video footage that captured the
01:48:53 incident. We have a sniper pad. We saw somebody in a sniper stance. It's quite another thing to
01:48:58 prove it was the man you have in court. And you saw that dynamic illustrated when there was even
01:49:03 an objection made to identifying the defendant in the courtroom. So if you think about all of
01:49:08 the ways in which the defense is making a case for appeal, you have to think about all those
01:49:13 procedural hurdles about admitting what might seem like obviously incriminating evidence
01:49:19 actually into the record if there's any grounds not to admit it or not to admit it yet until a
01:49:25 proper foundation is laid. It is true you don't need to lay as much of a foundation at prelim as
01:49:30 you do at trial, but you still have to pass the relevancy authentication. Not the same hearsay
01:49:36 objections are going to fly at a prelim, but you still have to present a reliable amount of double
01:49:42 hearsay or triple hearsay, whatever it is, to make sure that a judge has enough to work with.
01:49:47 So to that extent, yes, also with respect to what qualifies this fact pattern for the death penalty
01:49:52 will have to be presented. They're well on their way.
01:49:57 Okay, Wendy, before I let you go, I want to ask you one more thing, because
01:49:59 back in December at a hearing then, he reportedly laughed. This happened again today. Erica Kirk
01:50:07 left the courtroom. Those types of antics, him chuckling with his attorney, does that have any
01:50:12 bearing on anything that happens? It shouldn't, but it does. Absolutely. It has bearing on the
01:50:19 judge. Nobody likes to see that. The defense doesn't like to see that. Here's where it gets
01:50:22 really dangerous. If the jury sees that, there'll probably be a request to have the judge admonish
01:50:29 the jury there not to take anything the defendant does or says at the witness table, at the
01:50:33 defendant's table of evidence, but that may be just drawing attention to the problem. So there
01:50:38 will be an extended sidebar or a conference if that happens in front of a jury. And if it's
01:50:43 happening now, the question would be, is this defendant going to be able to clean up his conduct
01:50:49 and sort of keep control of his emotions when the jury's in the courtroom? With a trial that's going
01:50:54 to last as long as this one, that'll be a challenge. Well, and my question too is where
01:51:00 are his attorneys on this? Shouldn't they be keeping him reined in, including his chuckling?
01:51:04 I'm sure they are doing their best. Again, having been a criminal defense attorney earlier in my
01:51:09 career, you do everything you could possibly do. You remind your client as much as you possibly
01:51:14 can. Things come out on the witness stand that are sometimes unexpected. They're awkward. They're
01:51:20 triggering whatever ends up happening. Sometimes a defendant inadvertently sort of transmits
01:51:26 emotion from counsel table. In fact, it's more often the rule than the exception that you have
01:51:31 a defendant in either emoting something, writing something, appearing to laugh that they end up
01:51:37 not being able to control. But a jury sees it. And yes, jurors hold that against criminal
01:51:42 defendants. They have to do everything they can in the deliberation room to make sure that doesn't
01:51:46 happen. Yeah. I mean, like the emotions that we were talking about earlier, in a perfect world,
01:51:52 you would be able to wipe a jurist's mind from something that they saw or heard,
01:51:56 but were human, and that stuff just sticks in there,
01:51:58 especially if you see something as appalling as a defendant laughing at the misery and the grief
01:52:03 and the horror of what Erica Kirk and the children and everyone else has gone through because of what happened.
01:52:10 Whitney Patrick, thanks so much for being with us tonight.
01:52:13 Thank you for having me.
01:52:15 Absolutely. All right, everybody, we're going to take a very quick break,
01:52:17 but we're going to have much more for you on the other side.
01:52:22 most americans are forced to spend too much money on health care and getting too little in return
01:52:31 if you're one of the millions frustrated by traditional health insurance i want to tell
01:52:36 you about america's health share go to freedom for all health that's freedom for all health
01:52:43 dot org slash Bannon. Now that's a mouthful. Freedom for health dot org. That's freedom
01:52:50 for health dot org slash Bannon. And discover why tens of thousands of patriots are joining
01:52:57 America's health share. America's health share reduces your health care costs by an average of
01:53:03 60 percent. And it's accepted everywhere. In other words, say goodbye to out of network limitations.
01:53:09 They make health care affordable, transparent, and aligned with your values, free from surprise bills or skyrocketing premiums.
01:53:18 For as low as $68 a month, an individual can get great health care coverage minus the complications and price gouging from health care providers.
01:53:27 You can completely scrap your current insurance or use America's HealthSphere to supplement your existing policy, even with Medicare.
01:53:35 Simply go to freedomforhealth.org
01:53:39 That's freedomforhealth.org
01:53:41 slash Bannon to learn more
01:53:43 Right now, new members get their first month free
01:53:46 with promo code Bannon
01:53:47 It's time to make America healthy
01:53:50 Join the community of patriots
01:53:52 taking back control of their health care
01:53:54 That's freedomforhealth.org slash Bannon
01:53:57 freedomforhealth.org slash Bannon
01:54:00 promo code Bannon
01:54:01 Make sure you go check it out
01:54:03 Immerse yourself in the details
01:54:05 of America's health share.
01:54:06 You will not regret it.