00:04:04are you serious okay have a nice day he's breaking the law he's breaking the law what am i supposed
00:04:12so we have an increasing breakdown of police forces we have a breakdown of the financial
00:04:18feasibility of cities as the population gets older and more and more money goes into uh you
00:04:24know people who are not putting money back into the tax system and then on top of that you also
00:04:30have the cities becoming more aggressive in the way they spend look at the zorha mandami stuff
00:04:35uh look at what we're seeing in in these woke cities uh and so the idea is is that eventually
00:04:41we are going to need self-organizing micro communities for any semblance of a civilization
00:04:49moving forwards and a lot of people expect these to start with the ultra rich and then go down
00:04:55right like the ultra rich are going to have their gated communities but that's not necessarily the
00:05:00case i mean many of the ultra richest communities are some of the wokest uh most infighting most
00:05:06care any communities on earth i mean imagine having many of them will fall apart more quickly
00:05:12it has to be more of the resilience of it now that's one of the reasons why i was interested
00:05:16in this one because again founded in 2001 it is 25 years old wow yeah that's the thing is this
00:05:25this is again it's a flagship elite homeless community it is is actually very impressive
00:05:30and you're absolutely right some pictures of it yeah i i i i provided some for the class
00:05:37so this is the entrance um of the beautiful flagship village um it is called dignity village
00:05:44you can see these like homemade tiny houses this is their guard building where you have to check in
00:05:51if you want to come in you can kind of see how it is it looks kind of like a you if you squint
00:05:59your eyes and can't see the detail well you might think it's like a campground entrance building
00:06:04a bit rustic looking you know but then you look more closely and you can see how like the woods
00:06:11falling apart in some places it was clearly made with found materials and donated materials there's
00:06:16weird stuff hanging from it so homeless people self-organize this yeah yeah i'm gonna go through
00:06:22the whole backstory see there's a donated couch on it but it has a wheelchair ramp it's accessible
00:06:26all here's their their bathroom and shower area they don't have plumbing keep in mind so everything
00:06:34has to be brought in you know this is again this is a radically independent community and of course
00:06:38that's what's going to fall apart when everything goes to crap right like there will be no electricity
00:06:44there will be no plumbing okay hold on i'm going to stop showing my screen
00:06:48stop stop okay um but yeah so as you can see it's real it is organized people go and they'll do
00:06:57tours and so we're going to learn more about this community we're also at the end going to analyze
00:07:02why this community has survived for 25 years whereas other attempts obviously including the0.88
00:07:07high profile chop chas also in the pacific northwest what is wrong with you people has0.56
00:07:12failed so rapidly. And then I actually have some takeaways that can help us personally prepare
00:07:19for when we and our children have to join self-governing communities ourselves,
00:07:24because it's only a matter of time, Malcolm. Our days are numbered. Anyway, I learned about this
00:07:30from this New York Times article called The Homeless Community That Became a Self-Governed
00:07:35Village. Portland's Dignity Village has been a place for people without housing for more than
00:07:3925 years i mean in this article journalist brian barth explores this growing community and here's
00:07:47uh here's how he opens it one evening a few months ago the awkward details of a love triangle spilled
00:07:52out in a humble plywood structure next door to a municipal composting facility in portland oregon
00:07:57the building known simply as the commons serves as the communal kitchen living room and courtroom
00:08:03of Dignity Village, a community approximately 60 people living in hand built tiny homes on the
00:08:10site. All previously homeless, they managed the place on their own, likely the only such community
00:08:15in the country that is not just city sanctioned, but fully self-funded and self-governed. The
00:08:21village council had gathered that evening in the cluttered dimly lit commons to adjudicate a
00:08:25disagreement between a woman, her boyfriend, and an ex. The ex had filed an incident report with
00:08:31the village's security department, which had stated that the current boyfriend had been
00:08:36harassing and intimidating them. The meeting was a curious blend of bureaucracy and bickering
00:08:41friends, much like the village itself, part homeless camp, part homeless services agency.
00:08:46After some debate, a compromise emerged. The ex-boyfriend pledged to stop sending the woman
00:08:50a constant stream of texts, and the two men agreed to avoid each other for the foreseeable future.
00:08:56the words of village elders seal the deal and yes they are referred to technically and in the
00:09:02handbook which i did read as village elders so the weird thing is hearing about this honestly
00:09:09malcolm this sounds a lot more efficient and desirable than a normal court hearing
00:09:13like in a normal city if you and your your your partner are being harassed by an ex like what do
00:09:22you do you have to go to the police department file a restraining this is why we did that last
00:09:25video about like the sovereign citizen courts and stuff like that is eventually we're going to need
00:09:29something like this and it's kind of better than what we have now already which is kind of crazy
00:09:35right because there are people always who are violating restraining orders or you can't even
00:09:40get one or the paperwork gets lost and here everyone knows each other everyone's like dude
00:09:46if they if they see the guy violating it he's out you know it everyone has eyes on him it's like
00:09:52it's like a it's a surveillance state with high tech except not really because everything's
00:09:58biological super interesting to me um but anyway if i were living in this community or a community
00:10:02that was governed like this i would feel a lot more like there would be people out there watching
00:10:07over me and making sure that the rules were enforced than literally the community we live
00:10:11in now which is crazy anyway continuing from the article welcome to our radical experiment
00:10:17in collective self-empowerment and homelessness exclaims the village manual residents are
00:10:22expected to contribute 10 hours of work each week to maintain the village substance use must
00:10:26be confined to private spaces and disputes are resolved by an elected council and i linked in
00:10:32the show notes which are on patreon and substack to their full entrance agreement and manual
00:10:37preview online it includes a medical questionnaire like they're really watching out for you they want
00:10:42to know your food allergies they want to know what meds you're taking they want to know your
00:10:45primary care physician like it's crazy like i feel like we filled out less paperwork to put
00:10:51our kids at daycare so wild and here are their five basic rules to kind of give you a picture
00:10:57of what they're asking of their members so one no violence to yourself or others i think that
00:11:04to yourself part is really cool they really care about the people there two no theft three no
00:11:10public use of intoxicating substances allowed except cannabis in designated areas between the
00:11:16guard shack and the computer lab responsible use of substances allowed inside personnel personal
00:11:22structures no inappropriate behavior in public spaces due to substance use no pushing or sales
00:11:27allowed on site i think that's so interesting this example of what apparently sustainable
00:11:34governance is around basically free use of drugs so like if the u.s were to theoretically enforce
00:11:42rules like these maybe would kind of kind of work out i don't know i i just find that really
00:11:47interesting they're not saying no hard drugs well i mean the drug fighting the cartels is a real
00:11:52issue and you could remove them if you industrialize the process yeah that's the thing and
00:11:57also there would be far fewer overdose deaths because people would know the dosage and also
00:12:02i think there would just be fewer incidents in general like there was someone adjacent to our
00:12:06general world who recently got in a car accident then tested positive for drugs turns out he was
00:12:12on fentanyl he didn't think he was taking fentanyl he thought he thought he was taking
00:12:15something totally different but it was illegal and so of course there was fentanyl in it so like
00:12:19i'm just saying i will tell you offline not not anyone directly in our circle we're talking
00:12:28okay at a remove okay um anyway uh let's see number four no constant disruptive behavior
00:12:38I also like that. It could be intermittent disruptive behavior. They're not asking for
00:12:43the world here. And then five, everyone must contribute at least 10 hours per week to the
00:12:50operation and maintenance of the village unless show proof of school or work to obtain an exception.
00:12:58I will say that there are lots of grammatical errors in this. They do not use AI for spell
00:13:02check or anything like that. And it kind of makes it feel more genuine, which I super dig.
00:13:07I didn't include this in the photos that I showed, but in the New York Times article about this place, they literally include a picture of the manual that's sitting in the commons.
00:13:28They just had a binder of the printed out rules that you can also read online and are linked in the show notes.
00:13:32There are some other parts of the manual that I read that I thought were interesting because it gives you a picture on how they govern.
00:13:40They write, self-governance is the cornerstone of the village model.
00:13:43Each member has a vote and is responsible to participate.
00:13:47We are a membership-based 501c3 nonprofit community organization providing a shelter program.
00:13:52The village council is elected by vote of the membership and responsible for 501c3 nonprofit operations, including election of the board of officers.
00:14:02The board of officers consist of the chair, vice chair, secretary, and treasurer.
00:14:07Membership may select no less than three or more than 25 counselors to serve a one-year term.
00:14:13Keep in mind, this is a total of like 60 people.
00:14:16Most decisions require a membership vote, including adoption of new rules,
00:14:20and decisions made by council may be overturned by membership vote, except an exclusion for violence.
00:14:26All villagers are solely responsible for attending meetings and requesting minutes to keep up on new rules.
00:14:31democracy is a core value of dignity village and i'll get into it but they also have a
00:14:36program non-compliance and grievance procedure that's also quite detailed i mean i won't get
00:14:41into it um i wanted to get in but then i it got too detailed but anyway like they're
00:14:45very ready for all of this um and the elders will will rule over your personal squabbles if they
00:14:54have to they also give you a hint at the slice of life there just to not glorify it you know in case
00:15:00are getting too excited about moving into this flagship city of the future in the guard shack
00:15:05a telephone and personal message board are provided phone and other messages are pinned
00:15:11to this board meeting notices or other official village business are posted in the comments
00:15:16code of conduct for the guard shack as follows only the officially appointed mail deliverer or
00:15:22board officer chair vice secretary treasurer may touch the mail so they have someone who's their
00:15:27mail person like the mail truck will like drop it off at the guardhouse and like slowly back away
00:15:32but then like the person who's responsible for the mail will go through this 60 person village
00:15:37and deliver the mail to every tiny house which is kind of cool okay while the phone is in use
00:15:41no yelling profanity or otherwise inappropriate discussions are allowed in the vicinity people
00:15:46may be making calls to family children jobs courts donors etc courts which is interesting
00:15:51like someone high off their mind or something like yelling in the corner while you're like
00:15:55trying to on the one landline to the court phone calls are limited to 10 minutes unless official
00:16:02village business or by special arrangement which is also interesting because it's like people all
00:16:07sharing this phone number in this village i can imagine in the future like everyone trying to
00:16:11share like a 3d printer or um you know an internet connection or like access to their jobs you know
00:16:17they can live in these camps and we'll live in the ai fortress yeah i mean we'll see um no leaving
00:16:24guard shack unattended if you are on shift except doing rounds must wait until the next person
00:16:30shows automatic seven day out i didn't find out what a seven day out was i didn't look that up
00:16:35yet no sleeping on guard shack duty automatic seven day out what is 70 how do you get kicked
00:16:40out of the village or something there's leave the guard shack cleaner than you found it very
00:16:45classic campsite rule as you know and then here's how they describe the bathroom situation because
00:16:52i was also very curious about that seeing as they don't have the name of this community i'll look
00:16:56up what seven day out means oh thank you um i'll just send you a link to their rule book
00:17:00and then you can um use your browser to ask ai questions about it i i was actually just i was
00:17:07enthralled malcolm i was enthralled and reading it and i didn't want to stop uh because but then
00:17:11i had to because i have work to do people to take care of it's horrible it's horrible um okay
00:17:17bathroom situation here we go portable toilets are provided and serviced twice a week
00:17:22to not throw trash other than toilet paper or paper seat covers in toilets close the lid when
00:17:29you finish to prevent flies from spreading diseases in our food i don't know wait do they
00:17:35share food do they do communal meals yes they all cook in the same kitchen use trash containers for
00:17:41trash only no buyer biohazardous waste such as needles urine feces or vomit needle disposal
00:17:47containers are available in the guard shack if you miss the toilet or urinal do not leave your
00:17:52mess for others to clean up disinfectants bleach and a hose are available from the housekeeping
00:17:57coordinator if needed hand sanitizer is provided in the portable toilets and antibacterial hand
00:18:03soap at the sink please use them to prevent the spread of illness the shower and sink are located
00:18:08next to the portable toilets i'm sure it smells great showers are strictly limited a seven day
00:18:13out means they expel you from the village for seven days who shunned shunned i thought so okay
00:18:19great i guess while you're homeless like yeah it's not so bad because i was like how do they
00:18:23where do you live and it's like well they're homeless anyway so yeah but like y'all your
00:18:28stuff's there it's it's tough you know it's tough and a normal outage is being kicked out for 24
00:18:32hours okay fair enough yeah you gotta wander the streets busk a little i guess from wealthy tech
00:18:38workers showers are strictly limited to 30 minutes because there's only one shower for 60 plus people
00:18:44to share the water is heated by individual propane tanks you must provide your own or borrow a propane
00:18:51tank day guests may use the shower between 10 a.m to 10 p.m leave the shower in a tidy and sanitary
00:18:56manner after use isn't that interesting that you have to so the the way they do hot showers okay
00:19:01actually need a hot shower is you bring your own propane tank isn't that fascinating yeah
00:19:07that is interesting yeah i'm just trying to think of how it's going to play out in the end times
00:19:11okay i'm just i'm trying to get ready for it i'm stealing my mind okay hold on i'll do i'll do a
00:19:17screen share because i found better pictures than you did okay okay okay let's give me a show give
00:19:21me a show all right so you can see um let's go let's go to the top here you can see some of the
00:19:28different buildings here right i mean like when you squint it looks really nice and then you
00:19:33realize this is a bunch of junk tape together yeah but when you squint and again when you squint
00:19:38oh it looks like like a normal neighborhood this looks like tell your ride i'm gonna be honest
00:19:43for those unaware as i was before i met malcolm telluride is one of the most expensive places in
00:19:50the entire world most elite and limited places it feels like if you've got a bunch of ski bums
00:19:57that sometimes live in shacks everyone is incredibly wealthy there it feels like the the0.70
00:20:02show eureka i think this one yeah really shows uh well like what it looks like to live there
00:20:09like getting it in profile yeah like a lot of shacks on on what appears to maybe be a parking
00:20:14lot yeah paved an area piece of of paved in yeah um and then uh that you can see what's interesting
00:20:23is is the people don't look they look kind of young a lot of them do i guess there's some
00:20:27some of them are young yeah some are young some are young and some are older yeah village elders
00:20:32village elders uh then we have another one there and then we've got like a little picture of what
00:20:38it's meant to look like which is i like it i like it okay of course keep in mind it's it's surrounded
00:20:44by the uh the composting plant uh it's uh it is surrounded by a composting plant yeah don't smell
00:20:50good okay look they got it because no one will no one wanted to be on this government like that's
00:20:56where i want to put my homeless oh next to come this is the great thing to do with the homeless
00:21:01and then the ones they got away out you put them in radical games for their life
00:21:07i think that's you know the tubes right that's what those are for
00:28:52and micro-businesses such as a landscaping operation and firewood sales.
00:28:56according to the city taxpayer costs for the project are minimal mainly for annual safety
00:29:02checks by the fire marshal so once a year some dude from the fire department stops by and is
00:29:11like hmm hey can you uh i don't know like put a fire extinguisher here like and then he leaves
00:29:17and the city's like that's it that that's our yeah somehow that's a cost that's not a cost
00:29:23the fire marshal's salary is a fixed cost how did how did how do you even say that's a cost anyway
00:29:29i have had it with these cities um continuing again from the article what we're here trying
00:29:35to do is help people and when we do that we help ourselves and everybody rises says mr layman
00:29:40that's the theory anyway and what he's describing to me and why i wanted to read that part is this
00:29:46is a community in which people are responsible for each other and themselves which is profoundly
00:29:50more sustainable than whatever's going on outside this village. And then when I thought about that
00:29:55more, I realized in our modern society, people aren't even really considered responsible for
00:30:01themselves. Yeah. Well, I mean, you couldn't get a self-organization like this from a group of
00:30:06far progressives. Like every time they try to set up one of those commune cities or something like
00:30:10this, they all turn on each other within like the first week. Well, and God forbid they help
00:30:14someone else because oh my pots is acting up again i can't i have to attend my therapy session
00:30:22no but it's it's very much like oh i have a whatever i need you to handle everything and
00:30:30then you get the leeches in the community and you get the and the leeches always feel like
00:30:34they're being victimized and then the struggle sessions and the blah blah blah blah blah um
00:30:39and like uh it ends up choking you know if you accept any of them into the community which is
00:30:44why i understand they have to do uh you know such a egregious vetting um it destroys the possibility
00:30:51of doing something like this but we built a society where we forget truly or we've made it
00:30:57impossible to truly let these people fail totally it's it's crazy okay also from the article current
00:31:03infrastructure includes a guard shack computer lab communal bath house and a greenhouse that
00:31:07doubles as an overnight shelter for people who show up needing relief the individual tiny homes
00:31:12lack running water but since 2025 have been powered by roof mounted photovoltaic panels
00:31:18a gift from a local solar energy company which is cool of them and this even accounts for the
00:31:25potentiality of key infrastructure failing which is another reason why i wanted to talk about this
00:31:29because the big thing that we cannot expect from many cities and towns is working plumbing and
00:31:36electricity keep in mind and this is something we've talked about in other episodes that many
00:31:40cities were built as like sort of private equity projects where someone fronted the money to put
00:31:46in the all this basic infrastructure the roads the sewers etc and then the cities came in and
00:31:51like the houses were sold and the land was sold and then these cities exist but they've they've
00:31:56now found out oh wow we now have to completely replace the cheaply made plumbing it's not going
00:32:02to work soon but they don't have they literally don't have the money to replace it um so this is
00:32:07more of a serious issue than i think people are aware of and you can go to what is it called
00:32:11strong towns the strong towns movement to look like learn more about these issues but anyway
00:32:17um brian barth notes that the city didn't originally want this permanent community to exist
00:32:22like the city of portland but basically what happened is there was this homeless encampment
00:32:27that quote settled on city-owned land next to the composting facility where the government
00:32:32has reluctantly allowed them to remain and quote under an obscure state law the city designated
00:32:38the place as an urban campground allowing some flexibility around building codes so basically
00:32:44to keep the bureaucrats at bay they're like oh well i guess and we'll just call it a campground
00:32:48and it's okay and like that's interesting i think that's interesting um it's important it's gonna
00:32:53it's gonna become important in like the final section of this discussion where i talk about
00:32:57the lessons you can take away from sustainable self-governing cities going forward anyway about
00:33:03the governing structure quote the community's governance structure issues hard and fast rules
00:33:08in favor of strategies to maintain community cohesion and well-being people are expected
00:33:13or sorry people are expelled only in extreme instances usually involving violence rules
00:33:19meant to keep the place clean discourage hoarding and prevent fires are enforced to the extent
00:33:24necessary to satisfy the fire marshal and environmental regulators. Transgressors tend
00:33:29to be met with peer pressure, formal incident reports, and collective kindness. Your peers
00:33:35hold you accountable if you're slacking or engaging in negative behaviors, which hits a lot
00:33:40different than if a staff member of a traditional shelter nags you or gets you in trouble,
00:33:47said Victory LaFara, a social worker and longtime advocate for the community.
00:33:51It means more and actually motivates people to make the changes they need to make.
00:33:56And just as we talk about complex religions collapsing into super soft religions and folk beliefs, Malcolm, I feel like this might be the natural, organic, instinctual way human communities form when there's nothing else.
00:34:10um like it it's not capable of building insanely cool things on a governing or societal level
00:34:17but this kind of tight-knit community where everyone knows each other and and just enforces
00:34:22norms does seem to be something that's eminently sustainable if not something that's powerful
00:34:26to do anything beyond survive what do you think um sorry explain the question again
00:34:33you created in the pragmatist guide to crafting religion this concept of super soft
00:34:39religions kind of like what what shows up in the complete absence of a religion right i think what
00:34:46we're seeing here is the concept of super soft governance which is a tight-knit small community0.86
00:34:52where everyone just kind of enforces norms and it somehow functions it's not gonna do great things
00:34:57but it's gonna enable survival is that kind of what you're seeing here too
00:35:02i mean not really i think what we're seeing here is the benefits of a high exclusivity community
00:35:11which is functionally what this is yeah and we see even if you're dealing with the lowest pool
00:35:17in the worst circumstances if you are high exclusivity you can make society work the the
00:35:24key to a society working is who you keep out not necessarily um having the best starting stock to
00:35:32begin with. That's a really good point that exclusion is the key to sustainability and
00:35:38something thriving. And yet it's so demonized, but being able to tell people, no, not you
00:35:47is what's necessary to make this work. Yeah. And to like be very strict about kicking people out.
00:35:52Okay. Okay. Let's talk about how this is catching on, how people are really excited about this
00:35:58concept. From the article, tiny home villages for the homeless have spread rapidly across the
00:36:04country in recent years. Many without housing still reject them in favor of the relative freedom
00:36:08of the street. Numerous unhoused communities across the country have attempted to become
00:36:13permanent and self-governing, but they are typically shut down quickly. Several have
00:36:17emerged in Portland in recent years, including Right to Dream 2 and Hazelnut Grove. And while
00:36:24the city has not evicted them it also hasn't encouraged the approach i checked out right to
00:36:30dream 2 and that's t-o-o it has a page with video tours i didn't check them out i don't like it
00:36:35didn't look as good it didn't look like it was actually a thing and then hazelnut grove has just
00:36:40an instagram that doesn't really show much like there's even anything there i don't even know if
00:36:45it's real like if it exists anymore and then they have a link tree that goes to petitions and old
00:36:51defunct live stream things. And so I think they just kind of failed. They tried and they failed.
00:36:57Resistance is based on a belief that somehow cities will have a working infrastructure.
00:37:05Like when you read from the article, you'll see it's super clear. The city of Portland does not
00:37:09believe independent villages are scalable, replicable models, said Alison Perkins, a city
00:37:14spokesperson, noting issues with sanitation, fires and water pollution that pose a life,
00:37:20safety and health and equity infrastructure issues for both residents of the self-operated
00:37:25shelter and the surrounding community end quote the important thing again she thinks these things
00:37:31are going to keep working in her city and i know this is like she's discussing this just for
00:37:36homeless people and just now it's just that in the future cities aren't going to be able to make
00:37:42that argument they're not going to be like oh this self-governing city like they don't because
00:37:46they're not going to be providing water to anyone at that point. Anyway, here's an alternate format
00:37:51which Portland is trying to push. Quote, Portland's formal alternative is a network of seven city-run
00:37:57tiny home communities called safe rest villages that are heavily rule-based with a 120-day limit
00:38:04on length of stay. In contrast, Dignity Village's lack of time limits draws criticisms from this
00:38:10city. Brian, the author, later notes that stays range from one to two years, but a higher percentage
00:38:15graduate from them 60% than those in the city-run communities.
00:38:22So around 40% of people who stay in the city-run tiny home communities actually make it out