00:29:23.520like if you look at i look at us right or look at anybody in our circles and we're worried about
00:29:28.460getting caught up it's like oh so and so said that you should literally nuke israel and feed0.94
00:29:34.180every indian to a crocodile or something like that these guys are just saying like hey hey rape0.99
00:29:40.960the word rape hey yeah rape just rape lmao not even about a specific person just like the word0.98
00:29:48.680rape like i mean i've seen excerpts here these are pretty good riffs if i'm being honest well0.63
00:29:54.740the one they've got on screen here they got a collage of these messages one just says yo
00:30:01.000i mean i don't know what do you think that's code for that guy should be fired this guy this guy
00:30:07.940says and they edited it as well right because they won't actually print they said but it says0.98
00:30:11.500this girl is fully retarded oh he didn't oh no he didn't you call the woman dumb0.99
00:30:17.880ah buddy who's this written by jason jason beeferman what the hell buck status what the1.00
00:30:25.700sigma that's a solid name that's a solid american name do you think girls aren't regular girls0.81
00:30:31.400liberal girls aren't calling their friends retarded right now in america they do it's all0.75
00:30:36.240they do someone said uh they love watermelon people which is inconclusive hey i love watermelon
00:30:45.660people yeah i mean look as a republican you must you're trying to get the watermelon people vote
00:30:52.700this is the nature of democracy so i don't know i don't understand what they're so upset about
00:30:57.800why do you oh oh i get it so slate.com doesn't like watermelon people right is that what we're
00:31:04.020saying okay the hill you wonder what an offensive thing is but because they're looking at this like
00:31:11.540this is the worst i'll tell you here's something i posted the other day to give you some grounding
00:31:16.560i saw there's this image posted by positive black content i just get served these now right nice
00:31:24.480and it was a it's one like a facebook style image i assume the story's fake but it's like 16 year
00:31:30.780old alana pollard graduated two years early from college was accepted to 60 colleges and received
00:31:37.240over one million in scholarships she enrolled at louisiana state university to major microbiology1.00
00:31:43.720with aspirations of becoming a surgeon it just shows this like fat black girl with the weave0.97
00:31:47.960and i just posted she drowned in a watermelon attempting to dive after a crack rock0.96
00:31:58.280that's an offensive thing to say because it's not only a crack and watermelon reference but it's a
00:32:04.360blacks can't swim reference it's got everything it's a cornucopia of racism so use that as your0.74
00:32:12.040north star that is that's the cipher to tell if something's offensive but um uh look what you're0.99
00:32:20.760giving nationals too much credit expecting the jew to be honest all right if they're just saying jews
00:32:25.240are dishonest you see what i'm saying like this ain't the worst thing in the world here goes
00:32:29.720leaders of young republican groups throughout the country worried that what would happen if
00:32:33.880if their telegram chat ever got leaked but they kept typing anyway uh that's that's a good point
00:32:39.660i'd say like two percent of messages in all group chats are discussing what would happen if the
00:32:43.900group chat was ever leaked yeah ironically saying hi to the feds in the chat but they're not going
00:32:48.920to post that are they yeah because maybe they're because if you did that and if you if they kind of
00:32:56.420do at the top here like they're granting that they're probably infiltrated so that kind of
00:33:00.440calls everything into question like maybe they're performing for the feds you know i mean um which
00:33:05.380is some people there um so the story here is that there was a i mean okay first of all this whole
00:33:14.080thing just sucks that's my position i don't like that it happened i the story that i was told was
00:33:21.080The man who leaked it was a Jewish man, a young Jewish Republican, and it seems that the people in the young Republicans, that the heads, the leadership, are throwing all these guys under the bus because all their names are associated with these messages.0.97
00:33:41.920they know who they are they were kicked out they're being dragged through the mud right now
00:33:48.000and all the leadership is on side with it and they're identifying you know there's this one
00:33:52.240woman who's like one of the chairs and if you look at her messages like she's very she's talking about
00:33:57.840how much she loves abortion rights how much she loves you know blm and she like these are just0.96
00:34:06.000feminist leftist women what the are they doing involved with young republicans of course i ask1.00
00:34:10.720that we know what the answer is because you know they're not actually you know having any women in1.00
00:34:16.720these organizations they're all going to have basically the same politics but uh this would0.76
00:34:21.680have been such a good scenario for the republicans to actually have some balls for once i will say
00:34:31.200the only person i've been impressed by is jd vance because these chat logs are going wide
00:34:36.960everyone is trying to say see look trump has normalized hey jd vance came out and said
00:34:44.240who cares this is nothing hey look here's a chat message i have some text message with like
00:34:50.240a democratic congressperson who is say who's advocating for violence you know i mean like
00:34:56.160he's the only guy in the administration who's like who cares this is nothing the reality is1.00
00:35:02.800that kids do stupid things especially young boys they tell edgy offensive jokes like that's what1.00
00:35:09.360kids do and i really don't want us to grow up in a country where a kid telling a stupid joke1.00
00:35:14.800telling a very offensive stupid joke is caused to ruin their lives yeah it's banter yeah and i i0.99
00:35:23.280expected more people to come to their aid and then they didn't it's kind of wild that it was the0.99
00:35:27.680vice president of all people i i'm honestly i'm not you know i don't like the i don't fucking like0.71
00:35:32.960trump and jd but good good on him honestly that was that's solid yeah and they're they're referencing0.83
00:35:39.340hitler they're referencing gas chambers to me i read this and they all are clearly jokes um i know
00:35:46.500i saw a tweet here where it'll if you just isolate their message it looks like they're endorsing
00:35:53.040hitler but you know i mean dave green's got one here where if you look at the entire chat log
00:35:58.040there's the the chain of the messages yeah i had some back and forth the bc in michigan the current
00:36:04.820chairs a deer in the headlights uh many agree he said my delegates and i will bring will vote for
00:36:11.660the most right-wing person and the guy says great i love hitler you know so that could also just be
00:36:17.780sarcastic like oh the most writing person great yeah let's get hitler and ha ha ha like
00:36:21.600that could be just a kind of milquetoast young republican thing to say so it's not i don't even
00:36:28.840think they're that extreme in in the aggregate here but uh if i i hate to give any advice because
00:36:37.540i don't think this should have happened i think you should be able to talk like this they were
00:36:40.760on telegram um it sounded like they were doing this at cpac or something but if i could give
00:36:48.460one piece of advice it would be uh don't have this group chat associated with the young republican
00:36:55.520brand which is what i think happened my advice was everyone right now change the title of your
00:37:02.060group chat to things democrats would say just create the plausible deniability it's like we're
00:37:08.500just no we're talking like democrats it's a bit it's a work we're we're workshopping a bit0.73
00:37:17.140Now, Your Honor, my client, was clearly trying to be a Kamala voter when he said that there's no bussy in the gas chambers.1.00
00:55:36.260Now, I had a couple of different groups of people give me different reasons why this is.
00:55:41.900so i had some people and the reason i'm saying this is because i think this represents
00:55:47.900a growing divide between various people in our sector you know i mean like there there's a lot
00:55:55.180of fundamental issues that are being revealed right now and i think this is one of them
00:56:01.260because okay one defense i heard he was like it's not a big deal don't worry about it and i just
00:56:07.980that i think it's a big deal i think this is this should be called out and i don't care yes he got
00:56:14.380some libs in trouble that's fine but this should still be on the table and then i had someone else
00:56:21.180jump in one of i believe the friends of the show taking a very serious approach and he was trying
00:56:28.380to make the argument that just because the and he was saying oh it's just a fetish this remnant
00:56:34.780guy it's like it's just a fetish but that doesn't mean he's actually doing it and i reject that
00:56:38.220entirely like we know that's not we've been around long enough to know that's not true
00:56:42.620it's actually an argument pedophiles make pedophiles say like i i just collect it it's not
00:56:47.900that i'm doing it it's literally the number one cope from the pedophiles themselves right it's
00:56:54.060the other thing is this whole thing with like lolly uh manga porn or whatever like when you0.95
00:56:58.780essentially it's it's child porn but it's child porn that's a cartoon so it's a cartoon right0.97
00:57:04.300guys nobody got hurt so it doesn't matter right it's totally fine guys it's just a fetish like no
00:57:09.420it's the same thing and it isn't it isn't because a child was abused in making the material
00:57:15.180it's because of you you personally are dangerous do you not understand that yeah like you know what
00:57:22.620i mean like is the pedophile if if you if here's you know for comparison if you caught a pedophile
00:57:29.340and they promised you that they'd never abused another child and all they were ever going to do
00:57:33.740for the rest of their lives is just dream of abusing children they're just going to dream
00:57:37.660about it and jack off about it every night but they're i swear to god i'll never abuse another0.99
00:57:41.660child are you not going to hang them are you going to let them go no you're not going to let0.99
00:57:46.060them go you're going to you're going to hang them right and you should all know this by now because1.00
00:57:51.580there's been so much you know popular culture about this like your average person knows more0.98
00:57:57.180about pedophilia now than they ever have in the past so you know these people are lives you're
00:58:00.540and they're everywhere you should like this you have no excuse to not understand this at this
00:58:04.440point you should be aware of their arguments one of the top arguments that pedophiles use
00:58:08.880to justify their actions is that the children themselves are highly sexual uh female predators
00:58:15.880in particular love this they love acting like they were seduced by the child they'll use this
00:58:21.620in court sometimes but the men will say like oh they're just very developed like children are
00:58:26.740sexual creatures that's why they're trying to lower the edge of consent um because they're
00:58:30.800trying to say like oh god what am i supposed to do they're trying to seduce me it's a lie of course
00:58:35.220but that's why so much of this material involves like a seducing child or like a pregnant child
00:58:42.840like that if you are aware of the arguments that pedophiles have been making for decades and this
00:58:48.800goes back to nambla is when they were saying this like the argument hasn't changed and this is what
00:58:54.960one individual was explaining to me he was like there's no relationship between exposure to media
00:59:02.640and actually acting on what's depicted in that media that's what he was saying
00:59:08.080and that's kind of a popular idea and he was relating it to violence and he was quoting uh
00:59:13.440lieutenant grossman who wrote a book on killing which we covered on the show and he was like i
00:59:19.120think this is kind of the study he didn't find a direct correlation between exposure to violent
00:59:23.200media and making someone more violent and just i'll say i reject that out of hand entirely
00:59:29.760because if that were true uh we wouldn't care about depictions of anything in the media would
00:59:36.160we right if there was no correlation between exposure and media and normalization of ideas
00:59:43.840why would we care about trans stuff being pushed on tv why would we care about miscegenation being
00:59:48.800pushed on tv why why would you care about anything it would be a non-issue because it doesn't matter
00:59:55.040but it turns out that if you expose people to things through multiple forms of media it does
01:00:01.360normalize it and it does even incrementally increase their uh likelihood of doing it now
01:00:08.240that's not to say that if you play a violent video game you are going to go shoot up a school however
01:00:13.280here's not how statistics work that's not how an aggregate works yeah here's here's an interesting
01:00:18.720statistic that you know after columbine uh school shootings skyrocketed like 900 i'm not saying that
01:00:26.560everyone who was exposed to it wanted to do a school shooting i'm just saying there there is
01:00:32.680a correlation between exposure in media and the glorification of what is being depicted
01:00:37.140and the likelihood of it increasing in the future that's just that's that should be obvious and
01:00:42.860And that's why, you know, one of the tactics pedophiles use with children is early porn exposure.0.65
01:00:49.660That's why if you are a parent and you notice that there's a kid in your child's class or play group or whatever, that a little kid that knows what a blowjob is or they're doing highly sexual things, odds are they are, if not currently being abused, then groomed to abuse.0.68
01:01:09.220because one of the things you do is you expose them to porn at a young age that has i don't know0.61
01:01:14.740if you call it a traumatizing effect but that does jumble up a bunch of things in their head and you
01:01:19.760know you're not supposed to do that so if media didn't have like we're making the argument that1.00
01:01:24.320media doesn't have an effect on the mind or the mass mind like that's fucking stupid that should0.99
01:01:30.460read as insane to any sensible person but we're still stuck in sort of like these gamer gate0.99
01:01:35.600arguments or like comic books from the 90s arguments like violent media doesn't make you
01:01:40.100more violent like it won't make everyone more violent but it might increase violence by like
01:01:43.82010 and that's and and to me like the argument would be like are you saying that this type of0.97
01:01:51.320like pregnant 10 year old shit was similarly popular 20 years ago or is it more popular now0.94
01:02:00.120because if it's more popular now then something happened you understand what i'm saying like it0.99
01:02:06.580it's it's ridiculous to make the argument otherwise like if you went back 10 years
01:02:13.440and told the most far-right person you could find that in the future we'll be having debates
01:02:20.620about the validity of pregnant 10 year olds they would think you're insane how did we get here
01:02:27.040This is one of dozens of fronts on which CSAM is now essentially coming out into the open and is being argued in public spaces and has a huge groundswell of support.
01:02:42.620It seems to have the majority of the radical left.
01:02:45.780And somehow it has the right like normies are like the only ones who just balk at it and don't get involved.0.99
01:02:50.720but you even have quote-unquote right-wingers like the greupers some of these fucking people0.94
01:02:56.500who are on you know who are making arguments in favor of it like solely an athlete and these guys0.96
01:03:01.340so like and like you said 20 years ago 20 even 15 years ago but certainly 20 years ago or before
01:03:09.380can you imagine this not just landing you in a pit socially for the rest of your life0.98
01:03:15.040you arguing in favor of like look if i want to masturbate to pregnant 12 year olds that's my1.00
01:03:20.300business i'm not hurting anybody like those words would be a would be a death sentence for you0.99
01:03:26.360especially if you're a public figure christ these aren't even like random lol cows somebody found0.99
01:03:31.860on tiktok these guys are talking heads we're all supposed to follow and quote fuck off man yeah and0.97
01:03:38.340i refuse to accept the strategy that we just do this for the anti-memetic qualities of scaring0.98
01:03:44.560the normies i'm like no you're not like like if you actually look at what it is they're saying
01:03:49.020that's ridiculous if they're saying it in group chats amongst themselves how is it scaring the0.99
01:03:55.340normies you morons and if you look at it's never that they're trying to scare regular people with0.99
01:04:02.060it it's like they're saying it to their friends even in public even on in in the few instances1.00
01:04:06.700that i saw it was just no they're saying it and all the comments are supportive
01:04:10.780they're like someone's posting uh an image of like a horny child and it's all the comments
01:04:19.100based patriot this is what i'm talking about you know i mean so it's like it just seems that it's
01:04:25.220a bunch of guys who are into this fetish supporting each other and to argue the contrary
01:04:32.380would be to say that normalization does not exist do you believe such a thing as normalization
01:04:37.860exist and does this seem like something that has become more normalized that's all i'm trying to
01:04:43.240say and i'm contrasting it against what we just talked about which is like okay you're dimes you
01:04:49.440think this type of offensive thing is tolerable joking about gas chambers and hitler and things
01:04:56.980like that but this how can this be any different i'm like you know what it's fundamentally different
01:05:01.680i i do here's the thing and maybe we're guilty of this more than most we're already pretty
01:05:08.560fucking permissive about who we let into the space there's not there's not a lot of filters
01:05:15.440that have kept most people out of the the far right let's just say that racially even sexually0.99
01:05:23.840you know we used to keep women out we used to keep a lot of people we don't do that anymore
01:05:27.840we should and all i'm saying is like we need to have a line somewhere there has to be1.00
01:05:35.760and it can't just be based on people who agree with your ideas there has to be something about
01:05:40.560them their behavior or their beliefs that you wouldn't just tolerate because they momentarily
01:05:46.560don't like mass migration or they think that woke has gone too far or they think democracy's
01:05:54.720overrated i don't yeah i don't know why this even has to be said like uh like i was saying to you
01:06:00.160earlier off mic sometimes with this stuff i'm i'm i'm less concerned about the guy doing it
01:06:05.520and i'm more concerned about the fact that it keeps happening over and over and random people
01:06:09.680keep bubbling up and using the same arguments like it's organically it's everywhere
01:06:14.800people people talking this way and i i mean i'm at the point where i do think we should just
01:06:20.000be removing people we should be fighting i think we should almost be fighting amongst ourselves
01:06:25.360earlier and more than we do with our real opponents because we're not going to be able
01:06:31.280to have that long fight if when we go to do it we look to the left and look to the right1.00
01:06:37.920and it's brown pedophiles and gay women that's kind of what we're what we're getting to right0.98
01:06:44.560now yeah we are getting to there and we've talked about this at length as well and just to return0.98
01:06:50.320to a word that i'd used earlier moral fagging i was accused on x give me a break give me a
01:06:57.040any look right there so here's the thing sorry sorry to interrupt you on this no no go ahead
01:07:02.160from where i come from or like the time period where we came from we're older millennials
01:07:07.440we came into this you know 2011 2012 was when we started getting red-pilled but like to us the
01:07:16.160concept of morality is foundationally what separates us from the radical left they are
01:07:23.920post-moral they're post-modernist not they don't believe in anything right it's a melange
01:07:30.480to them it's hyper strategic for you as a quote unquote ostensible right winger to come at me0.52
01:07:37.920about moral fagging you just identified yourself buddy the moral fagging is a left-wing shibboleth0.96
01:07:44.560if you don't want to get banned don't use the phrase okay because we are the moral fags that0.99
01:07:50.400and we're proud of it we will always nail you to the wall we will crucify you over principle1.00
01:07:55.760and morality because it is what defines us how dare you what the fuck we are loud and proud0.99
01:08:01.360moral fags but i just wanted to just um expand on that by saying okay what do we mean by that0.98
01:08:08.380because people can interpret that in different ways to me moral fagging the way i've seen it
01:08:13.080used it's it's not that what they're let's say okay someone's making the 10 year old who's0.91
01:08:19.400pregnant joke and you have a problem with it they're calling you moral fag when they say that0.65
01:08:23.320to you it's not that they're saying that the person who posted that is lying or trolling or0.98
01:08:30.320doing a bit they're accepting that a it's they really posted and they really believe in it or
01:08:36.600they really like it but you caring about that is the problem so let's break that down morals okay
01:08:43.180morality what they're trying to say is that you are letting the morals your personal morals get
01:08:48.580in the way of something that is strategically expedient they're saying that hey maybe i don't
01:08:53.560like it but we should allow it or we should permit it in this rare case and don't don't don't get in
01:09:01.540the way how very liberal of you well and here's the thing i'm like but let's focus on the world
01:09:07.420morality because they make it sound like morality itself is not strategic you're letting some like
01:09:14.540your feelings get in the way of real political strategy but like what is morality morality is
01:09:20.040just a set of in my opinion it could be adaptive eugenic strategies that have been used for so long
01:09:28.220that have been codified in morals their behavior sets their behavioral norms that we just do we
01:09:34.260don't even question them because across time they've been proving to be the most beneficial0.96
01:09:39.320to society like this is just we're identifying a behavior that you just don't fucking permit
01:09:45.640and you shouldn't need to justify it and if you're using that behavior as a strategy it
01:09:50.600should seem reprehensible but make no mistake the morality itself is also strategic that's how0.78
01:09:56.760fucking became a morality it didn't it's not just feelings and so i i reject it it's not an arbitrary0.85
01:10:03.720rule the point is is that by following those rules that's how we regain society right we can't you0.98
01:10:09.080You can't, like, the morality is itself the goal.
01:10:12.880You can't reach the goal by compromising it out of the deal on the first move.
01:30:53.800I actually, like philosophically, I have a huge amount of respect for the importance of games.
01:30:58.660I'm a big game head, so maybe I will like this.
01:31:01.520actually we're a couple of gamers he starts by trying to get to the mom what a game is
01:31:09.760and when many people hear a game they think of something frivolous it's something children do
01:31:15.240it's something you do to kill the time um or it's it's fake you would see i'm thinking of
01:31:22.220the matrix right you would hear you know a trench coat type guy in high school say you're a bunch
01:31:29.360of sheep playing a game man it's an arbitrary game as if there's something more pure or more
01:31:37.760sensible outside of the game they can simply stop playing the game and access real life that's kind
01:31:42.620of what the matrix is about in a lot of ways and the matrix is also about how you keep stepping
01:31:47.820back and revealing more and more about the game that you're playing that you didn't know that you
01:31:52.680were playing but the book's really about how and this is my interpretation games aren't frivolous
01:31:59.540they're not random and they're not stupid in fact you know by the end of the book he agrees that the
01:32:06.340assertion is true we are all playing a game but games are highly important um and games are kind
01:32:12.940of and this does relate to utopia and it relates to the idea of work like games are separate from
01:32:20.500work and he's trying to actually merge those two things together so he sets it up here early on
01:32:28.260and i'm not going to just read the dialogue between these two insects i'm going to capture
01:32:32.420some segments from what they're saying but because this really is just a philosophical
01:32:37.460text a lot of the author a lot of it's just them explain what the author's thinking so it's it's
01:32:42.900just written in a singular voice anyway more or less he says rather it's the logic of my position
01:32:49.940which is at issue and that's logic shows that prudential actions which we can call work like
01:32:56.460work actions are self-defeating in principle for prudence may be defined as the disposition one
01:33:02.660to sacrifice something good which is leisure if and only if such sacrifice is necessary for
01:33:09.800obtaining something better like survival and what he's describing there is this idea that
01:33:14.220look there's work that you do just because you got to survive and then there's what you really
01:33:18.580want to do which is leisure which is nothing and you're sacrificing leisure to work and he's kind
01:33:24.400of challenging that idea there he says and two to reduce the number of good things requiring
01:33:29.740sacrifice ideally to zero the ideal of prudence therefore like the idea ideal of preventative
01:33:36.680medicine is its own extinction for if it were the case that no sacrifices of goods needed to ever be
01:33:42.420made then prudential actions would be pointless indeed impossible so he's kind of talking like
01:33:46.900okay the purpose of work is to mat your sacrifice is something you want to do to for survival and
01:33:55.780that you should reduce the number of good things requiring the sacrifice of work so your idea of
01:34:01.940utopia is what almost eternal infinite leisure right but in utopia by that metric there wouldn't
01:34:11.300be any work at all right utopia is imprudent yeah it's improved and you're just seeing1.00
01:34:17.140work as a sacrifice in fact that might very well be what animates many of the marxists he's
01:34:22.900challenging that idea and uh and i right away i had to this is kind of buried in some other stuff
01:34:28.660i'm like okay i think i'm getting this now and he says uh here's here's the grasshopper's dream
01:34:34.740that's described me he says then let me tell you that i've always had a recurring dream which is
01:34:38.580revealed to me though how it's revealed i cannot say that everyone alive is in fact engaged in
01:34:44.900playing elaborate games while at the same time believing themselves to be going about their
01:34:49.380ordinary affairs carpenters believing themselves to merely be pursuing their trade are really
01:34:55.060playing a game like politicians philosophers lovers murderers thieves and saints whatever
01:35:00.900occupation or activity you can think of is in reality a game then i awaken to the joyful
01:35:06.020knowledge that the world is still teeming with sentient beings after all and that it was only
01:35:10.340a dream i see the carpenter and the philosopher going on with their work as before but is it i
01:35:16.100asked myself just as before is the carpenter on his rooftop simply hammering nails or is he making
01:35:21.540some move in an ancient game whose rules i have forgotten and so not long after this the grasshopper
01:35:28.420dies and curses every other insect to just mull this over until they die as well
01:35:37.460um now he kind of spends quite a bit of book like defining what work is the back and forth
01:35:45.180it's all about okay yes i accept that games describe these things but not all things then
01:35:50.220it kind of expands expands until eventually he explains that everything is a game by the
01:35:56.140way to define the game which is this he says he says let us now baldly characterize work as
01:36:02.200technical activity by which i mean activity in which an agent seeks to employ the most efficient
01:36:06.920available means for reaching a desired goal since games too evidently have goals and since means are
01:36:13.900evidently employed for their attainment the possibility suggests itself that games differ
01:36:18.920from technical activities and that the means employed in games are not the most efficient
01:36:22.860which is what some people would say it's like well you know work is trying to get from point
01:36:27.160a to point b but games it's it's there's all these rules to over complicate it is it let us say then
01:36:33.100the games are goal directed activities in which inefficient means are intentionally chosen the
01:36:40.080belief that working and playing games are quite different things is very widespread you know we
01:36:44.560seem obliged or obliged to say that playing a game is just another job to be done as competently as
01:36:51.120possible before giving up this thesis that playing a game involves a sacrifice of efficiency
01:36:56.580therefore let's consider one or more example suppose i make it my purpose to get a small
01:37:02.560round object into the hole in the ground as efficiently as possible placing it in the hole
01:37:06.680with my hand would be a natural means to adopt but surely i would not take a stick with a piece
01:37:11.620of metal on one end of it walk three or four hundred yards away from the hole and then attempt
01:37:15.380to propel the ball into the hole with a stick that would not be technically intelligent he's
01:37:20.220describing golf of course but such an undertaking is extremely popular game and thus foregoing
01:37:25.200foregoing way of describing evidently shows how games differ from technical activities
01:37:29.820thus if my end were simply to get a ball into a number of holes in the ground i would simply not
01:37:35.440likely use a golf club in order to achieve nor would i stand at a considerable distance from
01:37:40.080the hole so he's talking about like okay what makes a game a game some people think is that it
01:37:46.040just over complicates things and introduces rules just to make things purposefully inefficient
01:37:52.160let me just jump ahead and explain what i think he's getting at with this which is that
01:37:58.580the most efficient way to achieve most things in this life might very well be criminal and there's
01:38:08.480a reason we don't permit criminality that is such an amazing spin i didn't even think that
01:38:15.260because like like work is efficient it's technical it's it's not over complicated but
01:38:20.240arguably insider trading or like we were talking talking about earlier with the pedophiles like
01:38:25.560the most efficient way to have tons and tons of kids is to impregnate nine-year-olds like1.00
01:38:29.960biologically that's the most efficient way to rape to just rape a bunch of in fact to rape as1.00
01:38:35.340many of them as you can to rape hundreds of them right wouldn't that be the most efficient way to0.98
01:38:39.600reproduce if we're just talking about mechanical efficiency yeah so obviously there are reasons
01:38:44.740there are reasons and so it's like okay a game just introduces a random obstacle not necessarily
01:38:52.440because the obstacle that is introduced could be to the benefit of something else because the
01:38:58.140purpose of golf isn't just to get a ball in a hole it's to get you to master wind resistance
01:39:05.440and distance and topography and all these other things so you're at coordination yeah you introduce
01:39:11.880an obstacle in the interest of arguably a more beneficial social act so yes it would be technically0.94
01:39:19.180expedient and maybe even the most efficient to just rape 14 year olds to have the most children
01:39:26.640but that causes all kinds of other negative effects so we introduce the obstacles to that
01:39:33.420and it turns out that those obstacles the game that we have to play this courtship game what is
01:39:39.560courtship courtship is a game with rules that we play that you can win or lose at but if you
01:39:45.240and there are age limits and time limits and you can only try so many times and if you win you
01:39:50.520can't play again like there's and and these rules work how do we know because we built the greatest
01:39:55.400empire on earth following these rules exactly and so almost everything that works in that sense is
01:40:03.240a game and once i figure that i'm like okay again now also like economically you're not allowed to
01:40:09.320insider trade however insider trading almost makes intuitive sense it's hyper efficient like what if
01:40:16.280i got some information no one else has i'll be honest with you i think 50 or 100 years from now
01:40:21.000fractional reserve banking will be on that list that it's something that we do now simply because
01:40:25.640it's hyper efficient and we haven't realized because it's recent that it's it's incredibly
01:40:30.760bad in the long run and it actually go by the wayside and we'll say no that's that's essentially
01:40:35.320it's the financial version of child rape we can't do that anymore you make you add so many obstacles0.98
01:40:41.000that sociopathic retards can't win at it and because you don't want them to win you actually1.00
01:40:47.400want them on the fringes of society so they are sorted out of the game because they're not equipped1.00
01:40:52.440to play the game because they keep fucking cheating at it um so that that to me was what0.87
01:40:57.560i really took from this and i'll just keep kind of going into this point a bit further here he says0.94
01:41:02.120the main point is that the end here in question is not the end of winning the game there must be
01:41:08.300an end which is distinct from winning because is the restriction of means this other end which
01:41:13.280makes winning possible but also defines what it means to win in defining a game we shall therefore
01:41:18.540have to take into account these two ends and as we will see as we shall see a third end as well
01:41:24.560first there's the end which consists of simply a certain state of affairs a juxtaposition of
01:41:30.000pieces on the board saving a friend's life crossing a finish line then when a restriction
01:41:35.320of means for attaining this is made with the introduction of rules we have a good second end
01:41:39.640which is winning so there's like accomplishing the goal but then if you add an impediment and
01:41:46.480you overcome that then you have a different type of victory there which is an interesting idea
01:41:50.420finally with the stipulation of what it means to win a third end emerges the activity of trying to
01:41:56.360win that is playing the game so that's interesting it's like okay the most efficient thing would be
01:42:01.620to accomplish a task but if you introduce an arbitrary instruction then it's not it's
01:42:07.500accomplishing the task plus winning and then the third end is like if you go into it knowing it's
01:42:13.340there it's like you are purpose-driven to win that game not just to accomplish the task because0.92
01:42:18.820hitting a ball in a hole serves no fucking function you act you're doing it because you want to
01:42:24.720dominate the obstacles themselves which is a kind of interesting way of looking at too0.93
01:42:30.380to play a game you can use on here says to play a game is to attempt to achieve a specific state
01:42:37.600of affairs using only means permitted by rules where the rules prohibit use of more efficient
01:42:43.120behavior in favor of less efficient means and where the rules are accepted just because they
01:42:48.880make possible such activity i also offer the following simpler more portable version of the
01:42:55.040above playing a game is the voluntary attempt to overcome unnecessary obstacles i think that's a
01:43:00.720good baseline definition of it and maybe if you just said that to someone they'd be like yeah0.93
01:43:06.480that sounds stupid and i think that's in so many instances what leftists are trying to do away with0.88
01:43:12.880they see these things as inefficiencies because what they're trying to access is this utopian0.99
01:43:18.080realm they assume is lurking behind everything the the trick i think is the phrase unnecessary
01:43:24.240it's the voluntary attempt to overcome unnecessary obstacles but the the obstacles are necessary in
01:43:29.440order to get the the prize right and the reason that leftists are mad about it is because they
01:43:34.000want the prize without having to play and win the game they don't want to play and they don't
01:43:37.760want to have to win because they always lose because they're mutants but they want the prize
01:43:41.280which is a civilized society where everything is done for them and their socks are clean
01:43:45.120and their food is good but you can't have that unless you overcome the obstacles so the obstacles
01:43:49.840are actually they are necessary right the obstacles are necessary if you want to have if you want to
01:43:55.360have a dollar for a dozen eggs i'm so happy that you're like on the same wavelength i might have
01:44:01.280actually read this book a long time ago i think it's a known high school i read tons of this like
01:44:07.600heady you know like ged or was it go to lesher bach and a bunch of like this kind of stuff
01:44:12.560allegorical philosophy okay that escher bachwin is that good because i used to see that oh man
01:44:18.000i have it on my shelf still i haven't read i think i was like 16 when i read it i didn't
01:44:21.440understand it i gotta read it again i was the same way like i'm a young guy in a bookstore
01:44:27.600and i see that book and it's like a tone it's so big and i'm looking at it and you know i haven't
01:44:34.240read any other philosophy i haven't read anything else so i'm looking at this like i don't know
01:44:37.920what this is like the the cover doesn't even make sense to me you know it's called it's called
01:44:43.920godel escher bach and eternal braid or something like that and so i'm like i don't i can't even
01:44:50.000begin to conceptualize what this is even about so it's always sat on top of my mind like man that
01:44:55.360must be the smartest book in the world i just remember it playing around with a lot of like
01:44:59.120the philosophical relationships between reality and mathematics and like recursion and things like
01:45:05.360that like it's just a lot of play playing around with mathematical patterns and the way that they
01:45:10.320relate to sociology and civilization and it's fun no it's it's just a fun book but most people don't
01:45:16.640do that and um you're i think when you read something like that you can feel you reshaping
01:45:24.960your own mind like i remember one of those books for me when i was like 14 15 or something i might
01:45:32.000have the date wrong but it was stephen hawking's the universe in a nutshell and i'd read no other
01:45:38.560physics books or theoretical physics books but it sounded interesting i was just compelled to get
01:45:44.320it at the hardcover copy i remember reading it over and over again like 12 times because it was
01:45:51.040just using this language and concepts i had never seen before it's a it's a crazy book just to jump
01:45:57.200been to if you if you're that your brain isn't equipped to unpack this yet i just remember like
01:46:03.240reading something and then flipping to the glossary yes and then like yeah i don't know what this like
01:46:08.380what is string theory again but i it's hard i spent a lot of time looking stuff up and you know
01:46:14.220we're old enough that you know there was a time when i was going back and forth depending on how
01:46:18.900bad my internet was to an actual paper dictionary to look things up to understand these books and0.97
01:46:23.840I'm fine with admitting that I'm too fucking dumb and uneducated to understand this because in the process of looking it up, you are actually learning more than you would if you're skimming over something which is below your level.0.82
01:46:35.000Yeah, it's the wildest feeling where it's like, I have an interest in knowing this, but I'm also very aware that my brain isn't processing what I'm reading.0.99
01:46:44.620So you have to read it again and you slowly start to get it.
01:46:47.000but then you get this higher level of awareness that oh like the tool that i have needs to like
01:46:53.340advance just to encapsulate all this stuff because this is like it's getting into mathematics is
01:46:57.680getting into just imagining time in a way that i never envisioned before so hell yeah it's like
01:47:04.700doing like lsd or something for the first time like it's like it unlocks something in you and0.88
01:47:09.080you're like literally some pbs shit dude reading books is like doing lsd well also art adventure0.77
01:47:15.580well the funny thing is like it sucks at the time because it's like it's work it's not fun0.99
01:47:20.680like it's kind of interesting but you are still like alone reading something and you can't talk0.84
01:47:25.660about it to people because you don't even understand it yet because they'll call you gay1.00
01:47:29.080because they'll call you a fucking nerd trying and also your parents are dumb as shit also1.00
01:47:33.220yeah also that yeah also like no everyone in your life sucks and you're the only one who's like i1.00
01:47:41.120found a new nobody understands me your fucking parents like you want to read a book don't you1.00
01:47:46.960just want to sit in your room and be quiet don't you want to jack off don't you want to fucking1.00
01:47:51.880don't you want to get caught by the police doing something don't you want to get caught jacking1.00
01:47:55.860off by the police i'm like i guess it's like you're getting a fight then they're like okay
01:48:01.640just two more bites just go get jack off at the bus station or something you got to come out of
01:48:06.420your cave come on look who came down from his cave like i'm i'm trying to understand physics
01:48:11.660up there i'm actually trying i'm trying to be smart i i just i came online and realized that0.62
01:48:18.880i'm not smart son i'm worried about you the other boys your age are cunny posting
01:48:22.700you're reading books that's son judas it's me your aboriginal father0.98
01:48:51.780they say the universe is in a nutshell just only having read the first page
01:49:02.600reading the subtitle to him yeah um so he continues on here it says uh i would define an
01:49:09.800open game generically as a system of reciprocally enabled moves whose purpose is the continued
01:49:15.740operation of the system then as you suggest various species can be found within this larger class
01:49:21.720open athletic games perhaps would make up such a species because all the moves of such games would
01:49:26.980be bodily maneuvers like soccer hockey or something games of make-believe then would
01:49:31.640also be another species for in all of them the moves would be dramatic performances um here
01:49:37.780shrek thus correctly specified a game of make-believe as being a reciprocating system of
01:49:43.800role performance maximization is that the distinction between closed games like chess
01:49:49.440and open games cuts across the distinction between games like baseball and games like cops and
01:49:54.540robbers thus both a ping pong rally and cops and robbers are open games even though one involves
01:50:00.900performance of dramatic roles and the other does not and baseball and charades are both
01:50:06.580closed games even though again one involves performance and the other does not so here's
01:50:12.340he's introduced the idea it's not just you know it's not just golf it's not just playing solitaire
01:50:17.060it's also an agreed upon interaction of performing roles and kids do this all the time and i used to
01:50:24.740think back on being a kid like when you go play you know playing cops robbers cowboys and indians0.93
01:50:30.260or whatever fucking comic book you're reading and you're just running around the park you're0.94
01:50:35.060like i have powers i have ice powers and so well i actually have fire powers so that cancels out0.99
01:50:40.500your five spreads okay it cancels out and i just uh i have laser vision too no you can't have laser
01:50:45.060vision you know i mean like you're negotiating just made up stuff as kids you know and there's
01:50:51.780no like rule book for that but it's interesting how that still emerges and if one kid refuses
01:50:58.180he's like oh i actually have all the powers i have the most super powers and so i defeat you
01:51:02.180i'm like well then i'm not playing with you because you just wanted to cheat you know
01:51:08.260and uh i i guess we in some ways continue that to this day um now he continues on here and he
01:51:14.420relates this to utopia and what he's really into utopia is indeed the the idea of work at the start
01:51:21.780and he brings her in work as his performance of doing these roles of completing something in
01:51:28.120perhaps less efficient way just because that's the way you do it to justify the system but also
01:51:33.880the justification of that system is in a sense morality itself he says well then if no evil can
01:51:39.800befall anyone in utopia there will simply be no demand for the performances of good deeds i mean
01:51:46.720in a world of no evil why would you need to do good things there will in fact that will or they
01:51:52.840will in fact be quite impossible and therefore not a means for gaining approval morality is
01:51:58.920relevant relevant only to the extent that the ideal has not been realized but there's no room
01:52:05.360at all for morality in the ideal itself just as there's no room for revolution in the ideal which
01:52:11.120inspires revolutionary action then it seems that there is nothing one can do in utopia
01:52:16.160in order to gain approval but we're talking about approval only to try and discover whether such
01:52:21.620things as love and friendship could exist in utopia i believe that utopia is intelligible
01:52:28.300and i believe that game playing is what makes utopia intelligible what we've shown thus far
01:52:33.240there doesn't have to be there doesn't appear to be anything to do in utopia precisely because in
01:52:39.400utopia all instrumental activities have been eliminated so in utopia this would be the post0.95
01:52:46.780scarcity gay race communism paradise no one needs to work no one needs to do anything there's only0.96
01:52:54.300we've we've we've perfected everything and then all you have left is leisure but i think0.94
01:53:00.100at the end of this you realize that life isn't just a leisure life isn't just because why
01:53:06.620net he wrote this in the 70s could he predict where we are in 2025 when you could hook yourself0.96
01:53:13.640up like in the owen cyclops comic hooked up with an iv of wine with an auto masturbation machine
01:53:20.720a vr headset and you know dopamine on the other arm it's like yeah why not that is that not utopia
01:53:26.780or does that seem abhorrent explain to me why it's one and not the other you know what i mean
01:53:32.440yeah yeah so um he says i am i am truly the grasshopper that is a dumberation of the ideal
01:53:41.080of existence just as the games we play in our non-utopian lives are imitations of things to come
01:53:47.400for even now it is games which give us something to do when there's nothing to do we thus call
01:53:52.680games pastimes and regard them as trifling fillers of the inter interities of our lives
01:53:58.600but they are much more important than that they are clues to the future and their serious
01:54:03.640cultivation now is perhaps our only salvation that is if you like it the metaphysics of leisure time
01:54:10.260and this is the last segment here and here after this we can get going or get your closing thoughts
01:54:15.520he says i saw time passing in utopia and i saw the strivers and seekers coming to the conclusion
01:54:22.640that if their lives were merely games, then those lives were scarcely worth living.
01:54:28.060Thus motivated, they began to delude themselves into believing that man-made houses were more valuable
01:54:33.140than computer-produced houses, and that long-solved scientific problems needed resolving.
01:54:39.180Then they began to persuade others of the truth of these opinions,
01:54:42.280and even went so far as to represent the computers as the enemies of mankind.
01:54:46.840Finally, they enacted legislation prescribing their use.
01:54:50.320Then more time passed, and it seemed to everyone that the carpentry game and the science game were not games at all, but vitally necessary tasks which had to be performed in order for mankind to survive.
01:55:02.520Thus, although all the apparently productive activities of men were games, they were not believed to be games.
01:55:09.040Games were once again relegated to the role of mere pastimes useful for bridging the gaps in our serious endeavors.
01:55:15.300and if it had been possible to convince these people that they were in fact playing games they
01:55:20.380would have felt that their whole lives had been as nothing a mere stage play or an empty dream
01:55:25.880the message of the dream now seems perfectly clear the dream was saying to me come now grasshopper
01:55:31.100you know very well that most people will not want to spend their lives playing games
01:55:34.600life for no most people will not be worth living if they cannot believe they're doing something
01:55:38.780useful whether it's providing for their families or formulating a theory of relativity
01:55:44.720so there at the end um you know what i was interpreting this as it's like we are playing
01:55:50.280games people can't believe they're playing games because they need to believe what they're doing
01:55:54.620is more important but it creates this strange dichotomy where the important thing becomes0.99
01:56:02.820something they would rather not do or they believe and this is what so many baby boomers do it's like0.79
01:56:07.580i spent my whole life working i hate working and i just want to live for my leisure time that's0.67
01:56:12.520what retirement is and they see even retirement as their true life this other life this life of
01:56:19.740work was like a false life or a life lived in miserable service to access the real life which
01:56:28.200is just leisure time and i don't think it's ever what they think it's cracked up to be you know
01:56:33.600what i mean like if you understand that everything is a game but games are important games are more
01:56:41.220than just you know trifling time wasters that then you can fit morality into that because
01:56:48.980it's like that that's sort of like the the glue between all these different things and it's not
01:56:54.120it's not arbitrary i think once he ends this is like these rules and these games are not
01:56:59.240completely arbitrary and they're not just to kill time or fill the void sorry i think i cut you off
01:57:05.580there i was just thinking about it that um because i wonder how much of the comments about i forget
01:57:10.720really uh how the comments about morality were from the text or whether that was something you
01:57:15.040and i were just talking about something you added in but it seems like uh their concept in the book
01:57:19.520of prudence and morality which in this context is a game are are um you know they're in opposition
01:57:27.440you know you can't be prudent and moral because in you know prudence is prudence is breaking
01:57:33.360morality in order to reach something in a more efficient way and then morality is a game it's
01:57:37.840it's setting artificial rules and i'm thinking about the like this is a very christian thing
01:57:41.760right like to me this is this is the protestant work ethic it's catholic as well but um thinking
01:57:46.560about like kind of like calvinism like the diligence and and discipline and frugality and
01:57:52.480and like that that way of living that to a lot of people seems like a totally artificial state
01:57:58.320of deprivation but yeah no i wanted to say oh that's just like a bizarre faith but like
01:58:03.760it's a game it's a game that calvinists or protestants more broadly play and they play it
01:58:11.520in order to achieve something else you know their morality is in they recognize that the morality
01:58:19.040can be found within the rules of the game which is the work ethic and that's why so many uh marxists
01:58:25.440and leftists struggle and hate that because to them working for the sake of work is slavery
01:58:31.280their entire goal is to liberate people from having to work and that the desire to work is
01:58:37.820a sucker's game they'll tell you that to your face and they can't understand the the purpose
01:58:44.620of playing these games it's not just a subversion it's not just propaganda from the powers that be0.94
01:58:51.760it's it is everything that we do so it's a much more complex idea because to them everything is
01:58:58.100is a pyramid of conspiracy really anyway i'm so happy that you like this um when i was first
01:59:04.800reading it i was like i'm not sure if i like this but the more i thought about it as you were saying
01:59:07.980i was relating it to the morality discussion only because i was drawing those conclusions as we were
01:59:13.960talking about it as we're talking about i relate to this like oh this is okay now it makes even
01:59:18.840more sense to me at least i i feel like the i don't know anything about the author but this
01:59:22.480doesn't feel like a hands-off social theory like he's got to be christian or at least like a
01:59:27.300traditionalist of some stripe this guy didn't even look at him at all let me look um
01:59:33.000okay this is interesting i'm looking at the university the university of waterloo do you
01:59:40.040work at waterloo no way he's a local bernard suits is known for his contribution to the
01:59:45.820philosophy of sport so he's like a cool philosopher um suits his philosophic inquiry
01:59:52.620to games and gaming has been seen in the publication actually born in detroit suit
01:59:57.660served in the navy before serving receiving his phd in philosophy from university of illinois uh
02:00:05.580yeah maybe it didn't go into his entire career here i want to know he might very well have had0.66
02:00:11.500more practical hands-on knowledge um maybe he i hope he just wasn't sucking and his way across
02:00:17.900the navy oh no i think yeah i think he ended up at the university of waterloo though i'm seeing a lot
02:00:25.900of uh uh publishing here about uh him getting distinguished teacher awards and stuff so yeah
02:00:31.900he found his way to water waterloo that's the one in canada right yeah it's not another waterloo
02:00:37.660waterloo no university well i mean it's that's a big university too that's a good one
02:00:42.220oh here's how i know it's in canada because there's a land acknowledgement at the end of the
02:00:46.060website he said takes place in traditional territory of the new the neutral there's no
02:00:52.780neutral is there a tribe called the neutral people the national part
02:00:59.580the territory of the neutral anishabeg and hasurani peoples okay honestly0.56
02:01:05.500this one school camping on the land of three different peoples that's just silly that's a0.61
02:01:11.420non-serious that's a non-serious race to be if i'm even on the list they let me see no come on
02:01:21.320that's a that's a hate crime not even a lowercase w0.73
02:01:26.220wiggers are the real n-word i don't mind saying it by the way
02:01:32.160all right this has been a grandpa's and i'll let you go yeah man i'll talk to you later
02:01:37.000welcome back film cells to episode 26 i am joined for this episode by dimes how are you doing sir
02:02:01.760i'm doing great i'd ever uh seen one of these from you before i didn't know about film cells
02:02:07.200that's fucking brilliant you know it's hard to get i get i get so self-conscious at just how i i0.62
02:02:14.660just even greet the audience because i feel so many people like morgoth has hello folks i can't0.96
02:02:20.160say hello folks i sound like i'm doing a morgoth impression uh oran mcintyre has hey everybody
02:02:26.440so hey everybody's out and it's so weird because these are just completely generic platitudes
02:02:31.540but somehow they become catchphrases and now i um yeah so then i know i just struggle and i've
02:02:38.120landed on you know greetings film cells for the the film festival at least yeah i wanted a couple
02:02:43.800live streams coming in hot with what's up sluts and then people got really mad at me0.86
02:02:48.720just try to keep it keep keep people awake you know keep it interesting i gotta stop bombing
02:02:57.460into places yeah uh but dimes before we get to um your selected film uh would you want to just
02:03:05.260take take a few minutes um i'm of course familiar with with blood satellite um but do you want to
02:03:10.500just tell the folks a little bit about you your um your your your channel uh what you're about
02:03:17.000uh absolutely thank you um i am the co-host of a show called blood satellite with my co-host judas
02:03:25.340who is my equal half and um i would say check out bloodsatellite.ca to find all of the episodes
02:03:35.380and the clips and all the stuff that's probably the quickest way to go about it i don't want to
02:03:38.780drone on too long about this because i have a tendency to but it's a show um topics familiar
02:03:45.020to a lot of people who would be in the scene i would say tilts more towards comedy as well as
02:03:51.960covering interesting books at the same time um i think people find it really really rewarding
02:03:57.280it's essentially the best show out there right now and i welcome people to come prove me wrong
02:04:03.020give it a shot um and i just want to say thank you for having me on by the way oh yeah absolutely
02:04:12.140and um blood satellite is is great everybody should definitely um check out uh their content
02:04:19.020and I'll, I'll, I'll make sure to have some links in this video below. Um, so dimes, you sir, have
02:04:26.980chosen a David Lynch film. And I have to say, I'm, I'm a, like a diehard Lynch fanatic. Um,
02:04:35.500a lot of people know this about me and I kind of, I had faith when I had the idea for the film
02:04:41.040festival and I started the film festival, I, I knew just sort of intuitively, like one person
02:04:47.460was going to pick a Kurosawa film. It's just inevitable. And at least one person was going
02:04:54.860to pick a David Lynch film. Did not have to worry about getting those on the roster. But you did
02:05:01.980surprise me in that you have chosen to discuss Inland Empire. And I have to say that this would
02:05:09.120have been my last guess as to what Lynch film would be discussed. Because amongst Lynch films,
02:05:15.220this is probably i think the least talked about at least at least in my experience um this is true
02:05:22.720so what what then dimes the question of the show what what made you want to discuss
02:05:28.780inland empire above above any other film and above especially any other david lynch film
02:05:35.620it's a big question and i'll try and uh sharpen as much as i can um not only is it the least
02:05:42.040talked about david lynch movie i would say it's the least popular and maybe even the least liked
02:05:47.680probably tied with fire walk with me uh from twin peaks the the movie which i also really like
02:05:54.680which isn't to say i dislike any of his other movies but i'm such a lynch fan that i have to
02:06:00.340be pretentious about it i think you're afforded the privilege of being pretentious if you like
02:06:04.740david lynch like it's not an obvious movie and it has the least i think meme capital in our culture
02:06:11.900like there's a lot of people who share memes about uh blue valentine or like twin peaks is
02:06:17.680getting a whole second wind in our scene but no one even references inland empire even though
02:06:23.980it's one of his more recent movies i would say i think it's actually his most recent aside from
02:06:29.560twin peaks the return and that short he did for netflix uh what jack did or the one with the
02:06:35.080monkey it's like 20 minutes long um yeah which i didn't i didn't catch yeah it's it's really funny
02:06:41.620you'd like it i recommend people watch that it's just fun um and this is something we'll talk about
02:06:46.180i'm sure that david lynch i think a lot of people have the wrong idea of david lynch they think he's
02:06:52.460just this spooky guy um but i think if you watch his movies with the right eyes you won't see
02:06:58.540anything like a horror movie you'll see violence but you'll see mysticism and you'll see a lot of
02:07:05.780comedy like even in inland empire like the first hour of this is almost just straight comedy but
02:07:12.260this movie um i i don't know i just have a very deep appreciation of it i saw it right when it
02:07:18.260came out um and this would have been around 2006 and i just loved it from the first time i saw it
02:07:24.900i had the dvd tube and it was really really expensive and this was a movie that i would put
02:07:30.180on for people and they get really mad at me and my wife can attest to this like this is i had this
02:07:36.580thing where i'm like it's almost like a litmus test for people like we're gonna watch in the
02:07:40.420empire and i'm so autistic i don't know that this isn't something you watch in a room with a bunch
02:07:46.340of like stoned people or whatever it is with a girl like it's a very challenging movie it's a
02:07:51.260dense movie it's a movie that'll make you uncomfortable it'll make you it's very tense
02:07:56.800and you don't know why it's tense but there's um the imagery there's and if you look about the
02:08:02.060story of how this movie came to be there's a lot of background that i found interesting as you know
02:08:09.280i'm a pretty creative person i'm not saying i'm great at it but i like to write um i was into
02:08:14.420filming when i was younger like a lot of listeners i'm sure and right around when this movie came out
02:08:19.880it was exciting for a couple of reasons one is that david lynch was filming all in digital so
02:08:26.080was all handheld cameras and that comes through in the imagery so that was cool and exciting there
02:08:31.400was a fluidity and electricity to that and also around this time david lynch um prior to the movie
02:08:38.020being released he had his website where he would release content and this is very common for people
02:08:44.820right now to just release content in an ecosystem you control but there was a time when that was a
02:08:49.460really interesting cutting edge idea of that a filmmaker would have this direct relationship
02:08:55.320with his fans and you pay a fee and get access to all this stuff and parts of inland inland
02:09:00.580empire were actually released on his website before they made it in the movie but it was from
02:09:03.960this time that was really profound to me where like here's this auteur director maybe one of the
02:09:09.480last good auteurs uh in american cinema and he's doing something new it's exciting it's exciting
02:09:16.220not only in how it's filmed but how it's distributed and not only how it's distributed0.87
02:09:20.260but how it's edited like this he shot it himself he edited himself in fucking final cut pro in his0.90
02:09:27.360office over six months like he just did it and he and and the story of how he filmed this movie0.91
02:09:32.700and you don't need to know this to appreciate it but if you have a creative mind at all this is
02:09:37.020what i appreciate that he didn't really have a script he he came up with ideas and he filmed
02:09:42.900them which for a lot of people if you write books or screenplays that's how you might write it on
02:09:49.300the page you'll have a constellation of scenes things you're passionate about and you don't know
02:09:55.360how they fit together but it'll make sense on the page he's got it off the page and said just
02:09:59.140film it cut it print it and i'll get it in editing i just i'm going to follow this feeling and this
02:10:05.460is the apex of david lynch's filmmaking ethos which is he likes to dream his autobiography is
02:10:12.740called room to dream and it's how he makes films he just wanders through and lets and it's this
02:10:17.920constant negotiation with his inner creativity and sure it's planned sure he has a story in mind
02:10:24.340but he tries to capture that electricity that really came through in the uh third season of
02:10:29.880Twin Peaks I'm sure Prudentialist will probably talk about this at some point um because he does
02:10:35.040want he's chomping at the bit to talk about Twin Peaks it's true it's Twin Peaks is a tall order
02:10:40.120and I like him I'm sure he'll do a credit but but if you tell if you talk about David Lynch
02:10:44.700one of his movies it's there's a through line to a lot of his movies and also i'll say this now
02:10:51.380in case i forget i know this is a rambling answer but um this inland empire is almost the
02:10:58.420film negative shadow version of mulholland drive and mulholland drive will be uh i think even that
02:11:06.740has some like memes about people will be familiar with it especially the character of the man behind
02:11:11.800the winkies but there's a lot of parallels between these two movies it's just inland empire
02:11:17.720is a lot denser it's non-linear i would argue it's far more complicated if you want to really
02:11:26.640dwell on it but anyway just to wrap up this answer the imagery of this movie stuck with me
02:11:34.720more than anything else like even blue valentine arguably blue valentine oh blue velvet sorry blue
02:11:39.900velvet um different movie blue valentine also good but blue velvet you know there's a lot of
02:11:45.740amazing performances amazing scenes but nothing haunted me like this movie haunted me it was hard
02:11:53.460to describe why it's just the dialogue it gets you it's the electricity captured in those scenes
02:11:59.360it's how disjointed it is but it feels like um like a dream and not a not necessarily a nightmare
02:12:06.280but it's something you want to unravel and i would always think about it more than here's the
02:12:12.240thing in this talk will probably explain to people what inland empire is about and once you know what
02:12:18.680it's about you still want to dive into it but once you figure out what mulholland drive is about
02:12:23.940you're you're done with it i get it now it's a good movie i can return to it anytime i want
02:12:29.220but it's it's done and inland empire it's not done you know the more you look at it the more
02:12:36.020it reveals especially if you look at the there's over an hour of deleted scenes that adds all kinds
02:12:41.820of weird other stuff on top of it so anyway that's a i tried to keep it short and i failed but
02:12:46.820that's okay no no that's fine it's uh it's a lynch movie nobody's going to be able to keep it short
02:12:53.580if we're trying to discuss this um i mean before we maybe dive into the guts of of inland empire
02:13:01.760dimes you mentioned um how the movie got made or the story behind how it got made i mean is there
02:13:09.180more to it other than the fact that lynch had this completely kind of intuitive ad hoc approach
02:13:17.100to the filming of it or is there any stories related to like funding or its production
02:13:23.500kind of kind of well uh most of it was financed through himself and i'm noticing more as i look
02:13:30.640into his incomplete projects that it's somewhat difficult for him to find funding especially these
02:13:36.160days i i don't know even though he's a legendary filmmaker i think he probably struggles with that
02:13:42.560which he shouldn't um i don't know the full story there but this is a lot of his finance and then
02:13:47.060there's studio canal who came in they got their fingerprints on everything that's fucking weird
02:13:50.900in this whole culture but um and then even when he was campaigning for laura dern the star of this
02:13:57.400movie he wanted her to win an Oscar and she
02:25:14.000i forget her name but she's in a bunch of shit she's she did great yeah i love i i go i watch0.97
02:25:19.400that scene a lot i just love it love the delivery um unfortunately that scene looks very much like0.97
02:25:24.940it was shot on digital camera there's scenes in this movie that look very cinematic there's0.93
02:25:30.500scenes that just kind of look cheap because it's just david lynch with a fucking handheld camera0.74
02:25:34.560i'm not sure that works for or against it but you know once you get into the thick of it
02:25:39.120you kind of forget that's there um but you know again there's sort of an electricity to that
02:25:44.700um anyway does that set it up enough like that's where it starts off i don't want to go i think so
02:25:50.920all the crazy shit but that we'll probably get to that eventually yeah yeah i guess um you know
02:25:56.500it's it's it's interesting that you that you contrasted to to mulholland drive uh dimes and0.88
02:26:03.220i i think a lot of people do not just because i these what this was a subsequent film right after
02:26:08.560that um i think there's a lot of obvious parallels um but i maybe i want to take even a step
02:26:16.720back further and consider this you could almost consider mulholland lost highway mulholland drive
02:26:25.100and inland empire a loose trilogy in a sense i'm glad you mentioned that that is 100 correct
02:26:32.320yeah and i and i mean tell me if if you're going in the same direction that i am dimes but
02:26:38.500I guess one element that all three of these films share, and it's an aspect of his films that Lynch first began to explore in Mulholland Drive, which is these characters, a protagonist who, there are two worlds in Mulholland Drive.
02:27:01.700There's a world that you begin with where Bill Pullman is the main character who's clearly having kind of issues with his marriage to Patricia Arquette.
02:27:13.700um but all of his problems are kind of internal and and complicated and sort of un-cinematic
02:27:23.640and kind of tragic and and bourgeois and and pedestrian even though it's you know it's a
02:27:30.960surreal bizarre lynch film there's something much much less exterior and easily graspable
02:27:37.300to his problems. Um, and then, you know, he winds up killing his wife, uh, goes to jail and
02:27:45.460transforms into this sort of younger, uh, version of himself. Uh, I forget the name of the actor who
02:27:52.440plays his, his transformed self, but he's suddenly in a universe where all of the, his wife is alive
02:27:58.600again. It's still, she's still played by Patricia Arquette, but now she's this blonde instead of a0.78
02:28:03.540brunette and the only thing that's standing in his way of of her like she before his wife was0.57
02:28:10.100very sort of sexually aloof and indifferent about him and now she really desires him and the only
02:28:14.840thing that's standing in her way is this mob boss who's um her her boyfriend and he had it becomes
02:28:23.480much more of a kind of ease his problems are easily not easily but but straightforwardly
02:28:32.220confronted um he can be a hero he can face problems that are um exterior to his own
02:28:39.420kind of consciousness he can assert himself on the world more easily and that's the same kind
02:28:46.320of duality that's set up in mulholland drive you start out with with betty naomi watts's character
02:28:52.240who's this um i guess it starts out in the opposite direction though she she starts out
02:28:58.160in this world where again all of her obstacles are exterior they're much more cookie cutter it
02:29:04.260seems like um the plot is is is a lot more straightforward you know she's this sweet
02:29:11.300good-hearted girl it seems it seems like the world seems a lot less real people seem more
02:29:18.220plastic and wooden but all of the adversity is things that exist with within a degree of simplicity
02:29:26.800and externality to herself and then just like the conspiracies that you see like all the
02:29:33.500conspiracies but who gets these acting jobs it's almost like a metaphor for you know who
02:29:38.920she would imagine runs hollywood in a sense yeah yeah like she's this she's this breathtakingly
02:29:46.080brilliant actress and the only reason she doesn't get cast by justin theroux who plays the director
02:29:51.640in that film is, is there's this cabal of very mysterious men that are pulling all the strings.
02:29:58.020And again, just like, um, in Lost Highway, this, this is, there's this fantasy life of Bill Pullman's
02:30:06.760that he begins to inhabit. You realize that Betty is this fantasy character living this fantasy
02:30:14.080life of a woman who has a much more probably real and visceral and squalid, depressing
02:30:23.300story of like, you know, came to Hollywood, thought she was going to be the next it girl
02:30:30.720got chewed up and spit out by the system, had had an unsuccessful gay love affair and0.95
02:30:37.660has just sort of wound up destitute and and miserable and again is is is driven to kill0.97
02:30:44.460um so these and i'll admit i guess inland empire is playing with this same inner world outer world
02:30:53.880um psyche of its its characters right so you have him exploring it in lost highway you have
02:31:02.560exploring it again in mulholland drive and that's something at play in inland empire as well i guess
02:31:08.740i will say it's it's a bit more multifaceted and and maybe the more more more complex than just the
02:31:16.840the simple duality of the previous two films because you have i mean you have you have nikki
02:31:24.120and sue and you've got old poland and the lost girl you have i guess a bit more a few different
02:31:31.500worlds here it's it's more of a multiverse whereas mulholland drive and lost highway i think each of
02:31:37.420those films respectively have two universes yeah what i find interesting about mulholland drive
02:31:44.060is the same thing i find interesting about inland empire it's that i don't want to call david lynch
02:31:49.880literal because he's not but when he crafts these worlds he kind of smears the demarcations between
02:31:55.680them like even in twin peaks like let's say the black lodge is above a convenience store
02:32:00.520like it's a literal place but like you go there to get to the other world you don't conjure it
02:32:06.140like in a portal and similarly here like what is fantasized might as well be real like when0.95
02:32:13.360Naomi Watts Betty is getting confronted at the end of Mulholland Drive by like I guess the boomers0.65
02:32:18.580that represent her naivete that drive her to suicide like it's all essentially real to her0.95
02:32:24.980and within the world of the movie it's all essentially real as well and that's taken to an
02:32:29.760extreme in inland empire because um let me just say there's a few ways to interpret the movie
02:32:35.620the one i think is correct i was pulled from a website that i discovered many many years ago
02:32:42.480right around the time when i saw the film when it provided the best explanation i think of what
02:32:47.500happens um it was called like half born which is a reference to dialogue in the movie which is a
02:32:53.500part of dialogue that i love describing the and she like a little girl lost in the marketplace
02:33:01.680as if half born i just i love that that delivery there too but uh it provides the best explanation
02:33:10.840that makes the most sense to me and the way to understand it is the entire first hour of that
02:33:15.620movie the entire character of nicky grace the successful starlet uh is the fantasy of sue blue
02:33:22.480it completely inverts it it's not real people becoming fictional characters the movie is reality
02:33:29.660and it it was sue blue the character the real person projecting this other life of the actor
02:33:35.880so completely inverts that but then it layers on top of that the story of almost like trauma across
02:33:43.920time this idea that you're watching a love affair in the current era between sue blue
02:33:50.460and billy side who's played by uh justin through which is his character in the film
02:33:55.020having a assorted love affair and which leads to murder which leads to like the jealous husband
02:34:02.000and like three people end up killed including themselves that story itself in modern era is
02:34:08.720what you're also seeing in like 1940s poland with the exact same actors playing different people
02:34:15.460so you're introduced to this idea and this is why i think it's almost a step up which is you
02:34:20.380not only have the complete smearing of fantasy and reality because the fantasy like during the
02:34:26.560beginning of the movie when she is inhabiting her fantasy because sue blue lives in hollywood as1.00
02:34:31.800well and she's just hanging out with whores on hollywood boulevard which you see at the end1.00
02:34:36.040um you see like the reality pierce into her fantasy that's the old polish woman delivering1.00
02:34:42.420the dialogue like there's always these tendrils reaching into her fantasy and her fantasy reaching0.95
02:34:48.200out into the real life it's this complete interplay between the two and both are reality
02:34:53.600and and that that is the end of the movie um just jumping ahead when because the end of the movie
02:35:00.000actually doesn't make any sense at all if you accept the premise that oh it's just a real woman
02:35:05.880getting lost in a movie and then the movie ends and she's out of it because how do you explain
02:35:10.060all the other shit that happens after that no it's like she she dies in real life and this is her0.94
02:47:34.760begzinski he did a lot of these really famous horror oh yeah begzinski i know exactly what
02:47:40.620he often gets um confused with um hr geiger but yeah yeah because i i like begzinski quite a bit
02:47:49.620more actually i think he's more interesting as well but he you know in the last couple of years
02:47:56.440of his life um it was right around when these sort of like computer software programs were
02:48:04.880coming out and he basically abandoned doing these spectacular bizarre oil paintings to start
02:48:12.040experimenting with the these new mediums and you know you can look at him it kind of looks like
02:48:17.380he made a few like radio head album covers it's it's not as interesting it's not as evocative
02:48:23.580It was a terrible mistake. And I applaud him for remaining an artist and wanting to experiment with the new medium. I don't think that the technology was there yet. And compared to his other stuff, it just looks really banal.
02:48:44.240And I'm afraid to say that I think the same thing happened to Lynch when he went digital.
02:51:52.840I'm like this isn't a 4K fucking movie0.85
02:51:54.860like this is this is shot like it would have been better if it was shot on an iphone so i don't0.91
02:52:00.080know what you can do to make it look better and it didn't look much better really and it's like0.97
02:52:05.040you can't you can't make the audio sound better if the audio is just recorded on the fucking mic0.88
02:52:09.480on the thing you know he didn't he didn't like have a boom mic in anything like those that first0.98
02:52:14.720scene in the mansion you're just hearing like acoustic audio of them speaking in a room you
02:52:19.800can't do anything with that unless you dub it later and you're not going to because i think
02:52:24.300one of the actresses is dead but anyway that's a tangent yeah and you know it's it's hard to like
02:52:30.340hold lynch that responsible or hold this against him because as you just said dimes i'm sure that
02:52:36.660there were a ton of budgetary concerns and i i mean i i know enough about lynch to know that
02:52:43.400he's always kind of struggled with with um with funding and he decided that he wanted to be sort
02:52:49.700of the king of the small independent film as opposed to the slave to hollywood especially
02:52:54.840after after dune and so so yeah i can can completely understand why he did not want to
02:53:03.540have to suffer the indignities of you know raising millions of dollars he's got this great line
02:53:10.640sorry i just want to say he's got this great line uh because he made an appearance a cameo appearance
02:53:15.200in steven spielberg's uh the fablemans yes that's come up on a few different uh interviews actually
02:53:21.660yeah it was just this great line yeah john ford and someone was like oh you should work with
02:53:25.820spielberg you know and he was like i have a lot of affection for spielberg we're very similar guys
02:53:33.400he's a man with a vision when he shares his vision millions of people love it and when i
02:53:42.160share mine hundreds of people love it so he's aware like he gets it but you know yeah it was
02:53:51.520disheartening to hear like part of it's rebellion part of it's like i just i didn't think a guy of
02:53:57.440his stature would still struggle like that and maybe that they gave him all everything he wanted
02:54:03.340with twin peaks but like for a new independent feature i don't know that's that's the bad ending
02:54:09.280i don't know yeah yeah the um the i guess the other things it's just i i guess a lot of times
02:54:19.780it feels to me like and let me say let me let me take a step back two times so i saw this
02:54:25.380went right when it came out when it premiered in like 2006 i actually like flew across the country
02:54:31.380to portland oregon i was on the east coast at the time to like go and see it in a like portland
02:54:36.240theater with with a buddy of mine i didn't know that it's so cool you have like the same experience
02:54:40.560with this as i do because no one else does oh yeah no i was like i mean to me like a new lynch
02:54:47.340movie coming out was like the second coming to me like i was just i could not be more excited i was
02:54:53.980thrilled that this was happening and i watched the movie and i have to say i was just sort of
02:55:03.880flummoxed and i think i think a couple more things to say about it one is it just it often
02:55:11.100feels to me like a student film version of of mulholland drive like it's like this is what
02:55:19.660mulholland drive would look and feel like if you had a hundred grand to do it um you know even if
02:55:27.280if we kind of forgive the fact that he's working with a digital camera there are there are other
02:55:32.140aspects like for example the you know there's a lot of doubling of characters in inland empire
02:55:41.340the same way there's a lot of doubling of characters in mulholland drive but you have
02:55:45.420that's done with such delicacy and finesse um in mulholland drive like he hires these other
02:55:53.520actresses who look just like very very close but kind of askew different in in a in key ways from0.96
02:56:02.120Naomi Watts and you have her and the brunette actress uh um whose name I can't remember playing
02:56:08.680opposite Naomi Watts who began to look at one another and look look more similar to one another
02:56:14.380they trade wigs and things like that but you have Laura Dern here and her doppelganger who's clearly
02:56:22.220the lost girl right I mean we didn't get into that but they're sort of considered you know by
02:56:27.880some to be twin links, the same soul, the same person, but they look absolutely nothing like
02:56:34.440one another. You know, there's no, there's no attempt to rhyme, uh, Laura Dern with this woman
02:56:42.620who's supposed to be sort of her, her spiritual doppelganger, you know? So there's less visual
02:56:48.300fidelity in the way that there is with earlier Lynch movies where it's like, I'm going to try0.99
02:56:53.780i'm probably gonna have to interview 200 actresses to find one that looks like maybe she's naomi
02:56:58.620watts's sister and i can put her in the scene what's interesting is like her doppelganger is
02:57:06.180is the creation she makes of herself and that's what's so fascinating about it too
02:57:10.980and like the the doppelganger for um devon and uh billy's side would have similarly been like a
02:57:18.500different person so like there's again i'm not saying this was planned but this is why like the
02:57:23.980movie let me just also i i agree with everything you're saying by the way nothing you have said
02:57:28.740is like is i agree that everything would have been made better probably with these changes
02:57:33.940but give me give me my my third this is my third and final blow yes i will never say anything else
02:57:40.140cruel or mean about david no this is on it's all valid so continue i think that the other thing
02:57:47.460that like that wounds me about inland empire is that i think that it it lee i watch inland empire
02:57:55.280and this sound this is sounds more brutal than i meant i mean for it to sound dimes but like
02:57:59.600i feel like i'm what i i say to myself this is what my less intelligent friends experience when
02:58:08.660they're watching mulholland drive that's interesting just like it i think it opens it
02:58:15.980the the typical kind of midwit critiques of lynch are much more like inland empire is left
02:58:26.280wide open for them in a way that is i think not true it's more easily assailed and um i think it
02:58:35.620it kind of in some in some moments feels like a parody of a lynch film um well that's why i think
02:58:44.020you need to watch it back to back with mahal and drive because i do think there's sort of
02:58:48.520refractions of each other you know i mean like i i think having watched mahal and drive
02:58:55.260deepens your appreciation of this film or at least it did for me because i saw the tools he
02:59:01.720was working with because like i said we agree on they're very very similar stories but this one is
02:59:07.080is far more unhinged in that sense it's it takes the dreamy aspects and makes them dreamier it
02:59:14.260takes the violence and makes it more violent um it's it's non-linear in a way way more extreme way
02:59:21.500and uh and the cast of characters is a lot more bizarre but also the funny thing is it's way more
02:59:30.660hopeful and optimistic like i would say this one has a happy ending and mulholland drive
02:59:36.340has an incredibly dark and tragic ending like within this within inland empire like there's
02:59:43.400seemingly more comedy it takes everything and dials it up to 11 and that's why people
02:59:49.280probably don't like it but to me that so the things that you don't like are heightened and0.53
02:59:54.820that might make it you know it's like it's like the irishman it's like some people can't get past
03:00:00.200the cgi of the de-aging and that's always going to be a roadblock for people i understand that
03:00:06.600but if you can make it past that and take the bad with the good there's so much brilliance in that
03:00:13.580movie just within uh joe pesci's character alone you know i mean like like the good the good in
03:00:20.640inland empire stays with me what i like about it and and you see um sort of the the development of
03:00:28.560david lynch's very distinct cgi aesthetic here more than ever like especially at the end where
03:00:36.160the phantom gets shot where that's that's absolutely horrifying that that scared that
03:00:42.100scared the shit out of me yet again when i and you see exactly like there's something there like
03:00:47.180arguably that's not the best special effects that seems cheap that imprinted my mind in a way that0.66
03:00:54.940still stays with me more than anything i've seen you know you might see like the man who lives
03:00:59.500behind the winkies yeah and again i'm not denying that the film doesn't have these flashes of
03:01:05.360brilliance or just like this lynchian imagery that's that's fantastic i also think like the
03:01:10.220the prostitutes doing the locomotion with like the flashlight the the strobe light like that's also0.99
03:01:17.620perfect classic lynchian yeah just like random shit there's random shit in there too there's0.98
03:01:24.280stuff like the ending the credit sequence a great example of what you're talking about which is once0.98
03:01:29.020the credits roll you start seeing characters that are only mentioned and there's a guy sawing wood
03:01:34.720you know like yeah the credits again like that's that's the part where like my friend that i dragged
03:01:40.560to the lynch film looks at me and is like yeah bro yeah yeah well first of all i hope that person's
03:01:48.460not your friend anymore by the way uh second of all you know the funny thing is like david lynch
03:01:53.740everyone's like why'd you have a guy saw wood he's like i like the smell of wood i find it
03:02:00.000thrilling and i wanted to have and there's a story of lord dern um there's a new producer
03:02:07.220on the movie and then the producer was like yeah david lynch he asked me for a woman with
03:02:13.100one leg and a monkey and a guy's song would in like by 3 p.m and then that's the scene they shot
03:02:20.520like but that was that's the scene that's the end credits it's just like a bunch of he's just
03:02:24.720having fun like who gives a shit he's going where his creativity takes him and i don't know like i
03:02:30.500that is the behind the scenes story that i like and as um a creative individual myself i i just0.71
03:02:38.060i know that might sound pretentious i'm trying to sound as least pretentious as possible but uh
03:02:43.760like i i love that story there's an energy to that where he he was probably scared at some
03:02:49.180point it's like i don't know if this is going to come together like i kind of know where i'm going0.94
03:02:52.200the actors don't know laura dern and justin theroux are like taking bets on what the fucking0.78
03:02:57.680movie's about he would write scenes of dialogue and every day and hand it to them they don't know0.80
03:03:03.840they weren't given a script they're just given scenes that day and then they had to okay like
03:03:08.820how does this make any sense you know but i don't know like to me that's that's there's some magic
03:03:14.960to that still there's the magic do a bad polish lady accent but if people watch the opening
03:03:22.820monologue you'll get it yeah yeah you know i don't know it's it's it's also i mean i i know
03:03:28.800you know i've read lynch's book like catching the big fish uh and like when i when i was in
03:03:33.540my 20s i was obsessed enough with him that i even like um looked into transcendental meditation for
03:03:40.320a while i have a very bizarre story i'll tell you someday about that dimes i mean i i can stay for a
03:03:46.280bit longer if you wanted to tell now because i was interested in that because transcendental
03:03:50.640meditation seems to sit at the center of his being like he has this whole foundation and i don't know0.90
03:03:59.160anything about this shit i don't know what i don't know if it's like a scientology thing well0.91
03:04:03.660my story is actually quite brief like if you go it's it is probably a bit like scientology i think0.97
03:04:09.460if you like there are different chapters and if you if you if you call a number there's people
03:04:14.980that will you know will meet you within a you know your your county or city or what have you
03:04:21.400i wound up calling this calling the number and going out it's david lynch's patriot front sorry
03:04:27.400this is this is what you're not going to believe this nobody will believe this but like i met i
03:04:31.540saw it they they told me to meet them in an old church and they come uh and like they show you
03:04:37.280kind of this introductory video and it's like eventually you're going to have to pay like
03:04:40.480two thousand dollars to get your mantra or whatever but the point that's that's important
03:04:45.840is that i went down into this old church and it was the most lynchian setting on the planet because
03:04:54.360there was this guy in a yellow jacket there was this heavy set man in a mustard jacket
03:05:01.260who stuttered there was one folding chair that was unfolded in the middle of the room
03:05:09.240with one lamp shining down on the chair and and 10 feet from the chair was a television
03:05:17.200and i was just like i'm in a david lynch film
03:05:21.280david lynch has no business i'm about to be i'm about to be murdered
03:05:26.720it's a david lynch movie so being murdered would be the good ending you're going to find yourself
03:05:33.380in some mind-bending chrysalis yeah david lynch has no business projecting his essence on a
03:05:41.340reality like this but you know what one thing another thing i will say though is like i you
03:05:46.040know i i understand that he's interested in mysticism i'm uh he's somebody who's i mean
03:05:52.280And then clearly, I think transcendental meditation, however kooky it is, has done a lot for him to unlock his creativity.
03:06:00.280But, you know, I don't feel like in watching Mulholland Drive and watching Lost Highway and watching Blue Velvet, I don't think I need to have like read the Kabbalah or like know everything about Zoroastrianism to have like the church key to the symbology of the movies.
03:06:17.860And I'm sure people have written many a paper on exactly how, you know, if you're going to understand this film, you have to read this, you know, the Bhagavad Gita or whatever or whatever the hell.
03:06:30.700but i i think that inland empire gets i don't know it it's his his new way his his fascinated
03:06:41.260with new age spiritual spirituality even if he feels like that has inspired his movies
03:06:47.940and that it's informed them that's not something that his audience necessarily needs to
03:06:54.900take take hold of to appreciate them and i did feel that that's less the case with inland empire
03:07:05.200like you do kind of need to figure out his cosmology a little bit in order to understand
03:07:10.180yeah well first of all i like that you mentioned this uh no one has read the bag of avida0.99
03:07:16.420um and if you find someone that claims that they have you shoot them in the head
03:07:22.960now secondly um you do make a good point that um like there is something to be said about0.97
03:07:28.860transcendental meditation about like shared consciousness and this sort of pool of awareness
03:07:35.440and maybe there's something to that with inland empire i don't like i'm not sure there is or
03:07:42.620there isn't although you know there's this movie have you seen that movie by guy richie revolver
03:07:49.600uh no this would have been after snatch but maybe before he started doing all those like
03:07:58.420movies for other people this is like what his last uh jason statham movie for a while this
03:08:03.780is when he was married to madonna and it's this odd duck of a movie um you know fittingly it's
03:08:11.020probably one of my favorites he's ever done but it is the weirdest um a lot of people hate it
03:08:16.500um there's actually two different versions of it one's better than the other the longer one's the
03:08:21.640better version um but it's apparently it was heavily influenced by the kabbalah because
03:08:27.560uh madonna was is i'm not sure but at very least was weirdly into kabbalah at the time he was
03:08:34.500married to her i have her so i don't know it supposedly is i don't know anything about the
03:08:39.140kabbalah but it's like his one weird fucking movie so it could be that as david lynch has gone0.93
03:08:45.720more metaphysical maybe that is the transcendental meditation coming through0.95
03:08:50.020but you know i i like to just think of i think you've said it best that it's almost the end of
03:08:56.520a trilogy and it's the loudest of the trilogy and fittingly you know the third is the least
03:09:02.660popular part of the trilogy everyone loves the second one so i get what people maybe this is
03:09:06.540the godfather three of his trilogy yeah i mean that's might be a good analogy yeah i'm trying0.94
03:09:11.500to beat a drum for godfather three say ignore fucking sofia coppola there's a there's some0.96
03:09:17.680good shit in here uh yeah you can you can edit around her um but but i i like it it's a story0.99
03:09:27.600about hollywood it's a story about a very a very acute human problem it's about human relationships0.99
03:09:35.680and sex and marriage and i think that that's the beating heart of a lot of david lynch's stuff like
03:09:41.940like we were talking at the very top of this to circle it around a lot of like like cubism he's
03:09:47.760showing you a simple um image from so many angles that seems more confusing than it is
03:09:54.500um but like i think what what you can grab onto in each and every one of his movies is a human
03:10:00.460story like in Twin Peaks it's it's an actual affection for Agent Cooper and it's it's a love
03:10:07.800of small towns and you know me and my friends were joking like imagine anyone else making Twin Peaks
03:10:13.700imagine Jordan Peele making Twin Peaks all of a sudden it's a story of small town bigots it's a0.99
03:10:20.160story like no one has love for small town America in Hollywood except for fucking David Lynch and0.96
03:10:26.860it's that optimism and it's that like beating heart that comes through and i really think0.77
03:10:34.060that's what makes him a good director and not just like a a harmony kareen who i like for0.92
03:10:40.940different reasons but harmony kareen where it is cynical he does want to fuck with the audience he0.98
03:10:45.380is just trying to do some dumb art house dogma 95 shit you know right there's something more0.93
03:10:53.860you can dive into this stuff and i think and again that's why i it's um it's one of his movies i love0.96
03:10:59.140to dive into the most aside from twin peaks but with twin peaks it's just the lore and how it
03:11:04.820always just keeps getting bigger and bigger and stranger yeah well well said dimes um and yeah
03:11:14.560no i hope i didn't come down too hard on on inland empire and and i will um you know i will i will
03:11:20.480light a candle and, and say my, um, uh, prayers and forgiveness to Lynch tonight before I go to
03:11:27.520bed. But, uh, cause again, he's my favorite director. He really is. And even, even something
03:11:33.240that I think was a bit of a cinematic failure for him, um, was, uh, there's still things to
03:11:41.620get out of it. You're absolutely right. Um, I also think that just the fact that he, to my knowledge,
03:11:46.600this is the first time he did anything which was uh as spontaneous as like literally writing this
03:11:55.840down as he goes and that that's another thing where it's like that's an accusation that it's
03:12:01.520it's a midwit accusation where like a midwit watches blue velvet and they're like i think
03:12:06.440he just wrote that down on a three by five card um and handed it to dennis hopper on the morning
03:12:14.520of the shot and then i can i can uh humiliate that person and deride them but and but then
03:12:25.000lynch went and made a truly quote-unquote experimental spontaneous film where he he
03:12:32.320wrote everything down the night before it just seems like you know like he there are a lot of
03:12:36.300sins in this movie that he had been accused of his entire career and he wasn't guilty of them until
03:12:42.700he made inland empire and that was kind of the feeling i remember having when the you know
03:12:49.620the house lights came up at the end of the movie uh when i saw the premiere i was just like yeah
03:12:56.520well that's the thing this movie made you feel like a midwit and mr things i'm here to tell you
03:13:02.100you're not a midwit you are you're smart enough to love inland empire that's what i'm here to0.51
03:13:08.080tell everyone everyone listening to this this isn't a show for dummies this isn't a show for
03:13:12.980stooges this is for uh the thinker this is a thinking man's show yeah and everyone here is0.98
03:13:19.620genius enough to be like me and like this film and uh i was gonna say something fuck i forget0.98
03:13:26.960what it was anyway it's probably just some horse shit oh yeah i was gonna talk about those midwits0.99
03:13:32.700those people who fucking i hate that look oh i he looked like he was uh writing it as you know0.99
03:13:37.960it's like oh well yeah you know the best movie scripts are obviously 900 pages and filled with1.00
03:13:42.400stage direction you piece of shit like no you don't know how films are made you don't know0.98
03:13:47.920about the interplay between improvisation and planning and building a scaffolding of a story1.00
03:13:52.860and giving yourself room to dream and creating these arenas where you can play around in you
03:13:58.860know like like nothing is completely scripted but nothing is completely improvised either that's you
03:14:05.200people like oh you know my kid can paint that well you should do it you should do it and make1.00
03:14:09.360you a millionaire what's that you live a failure of a fucking life and your kid sucks well i guess1.00
03:14:14.800he couldn't do it then could he could your retard kid make a jackson pollock well you should you1.00
03:14:21.640should go do it you should you should go do a david lynch we were right now faggot i dare you1.00
03:14:26.380make a million dollars i dare you right now sorry i just i can't i can't i can't i can't shoot a1.00
03:14:32.380rifle right now so i'm just gonna spit at my computer um dimes let's so i'm gonna get
03:14:42.260why don't we end it here i'm gonna go go and watch inland empire for the third time
03:14:47.340right now actually go go watch um what did jack do uh it's like a 17 minute short film
03:14:57.460he released on netflix david lynch i love anything where david lynch acts i just like him as a guy
03:15:04.400so watch that yeah yeah his cameos are always great um and your cameo has been great how about
03:15:12.640that for a segue on the last picture shows film festival so dimes we have to have you back uh
03:15:18.320next year but but you and i should find an excuse to do a stream um between now and then um and
03:15:25.060thank you for being my my lynch man uh i knew i knew you'd come through and uh really appreciate
03:15:33.460it i really appreciate being asked i had a fantastic time um i love talking to people
03:15:38.820who really really know what they're talking about and you've obviously revealed that you do so i had
03:15:44.700a fantastic time awesome man all right well take care when we'll be in touch soon all right thanks
03:15:51.040Hey, baby, I hear the blues are calling