Blood Satellite - September 18, 2026


Getting My Sh*t Ruined For Borrowing Too Much Money From Xenu and Yakub

Ay Tone4CERN Not for Nothin but this Feels Like Biocalvinism

Episode Stats


Length

2 hours and 14 minutes

Words per minute

168.65

Word count

22,628

Sentence count

382

People

Hosts:
Also mentioned:

Harmful content

Misogyny

77

sentences flagged

Toxicity

300

sentences flagged

Hate speech

243

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.000 as far back as i can remember i always wanted to be
00:00:07.720 blood satellite what i want is a fluid chilled stream okay i want a relaxed stream we can do
00:00:26.540 i want to have a good time okay so i was reading a story here i'm going to pull this up on screen
00:00:36.300 the mayoral candidate in winnipeg canada he's an indian man this is a man who seems by all
00:00:45.820 accounts to be illiterate great big fat i don't know what like if you can have hair physiognomy
00:00:53.420 By the way, someone really 0.91
00:00:55.320 Crawled down my gullet the other day
00:00:57.380 Because I've been calling it physiognomy
00:00:59.320 Yeah
00:01:00.020 And he's saying dimes
00:01:01.580 He's begging me
00:01:02.600 Dimes is physiognomy
00:01:04.780 And I said in Canada we pronounce the G's
00:01:07.340 And I think that fooled him
00:01:09.480 And of course he said what a fake country 1.00
00:01:12.340 What a bullshit made up country you live in 1.00
00:01:14.460 And I'm like I know 1.00
00:01:15.320 But we pronounce the G's
00:01:17.020 So I'm sorry everyone, physiognomy
00:01:19.380 That's new for me as well 0.99
00:01:21.800 So fuck 0.99
00:01:23.020 This is a man named Umar Hayat. 1.00
00:01:25.180 He's running for mayor while posting.
00:01:27.720 Let's have a look at this poster here.
00:01:29.300 This is what got, I don't know if you can see that on screen.
00:01:32.960 So he's got a poster here, himself,
00:01:36.560 dead-eyed scowling, of course, 0.99
00:01:39.340 fat head, regular body, 1.00
00:01:42.040 very Indian situation. 0.56
00:01:45.600 And it appears that he designed this poster with AI.
00:01:49.980 It doesn't look like it was proofread.
00:01:53.020 And he was advocating for, let's read it here.
00:01:58.540 Do you support making sex legal for the disabled?
00:02:01.880 The implication being that it's currently illegal in Winnipeg for disabled people to have sex. 0.93
00:02:08.720 And this man is coming in with a sledgehammer. 0.88
00:02:11.860 Also as if he would have the power to change that. 1.00
00:02:16.380 Mr. Gorbachev, tear down these retard's pants. 1.00
00:02:23.020 i don't fuck with it not at all this this man i i get theater of the mind 1.00
00:02:31.180 he has got his head is the shape of a pear yeah hair shaped head and let's just read the let's 0.99
00:02:39.260 just read the poster someone sends this to me and some they say certified blood satellite story
00:02:44.380 here we go yes i support dignity choice and equality uh adults with disabilities deserve
00:02:50.960 the same rights respect and opportunities as everyone else including the right
00:02:54.400 amazing companionship safe consensual legal which is like good question
00:03:05.040 is rape more likely if you're disabled and i mean that in a few ways yeah i can think of
00:03:11.680 a couple of them already has there ever been a person in a wheelchair that has claimed to have
00:03:18.560 been raped in a conventional sense not in a dream not uh you know demonically but just in the street
00:03:29.360 by which i mean you know what does it become more consensual because they are
00:03:36.160 more powerless or are they just not targets at all i think the intersectionals would say it's
00:03:42.640 less consensual and consensual because they're more powerless but yeah there's whether or not
00:03:46.560 their targets they're maybe they're lower down on the target list but they're also easier prey
00:03:52.480 they're the low-hanging fruit of rape victims and this is going to baffle and trouble all
00:03:57.280 of our listeners but i am not in fact a rapist wow and so i i can't get in the mind of a rapist
00:04:06.320 but i do wonder if they see that as damaged goods now you've got me thinking about it
00:04:11.680 deeply i wasn't really engaging but now yeah i wouldn't have to consider because it's like
00:04:18.160 we're what we're talking about is like the adjacency to rape is just you know qualifying
00:04:24.160 sexual desire desirability right like who could you get and who do you want but that's not what
00:04:29.760 rape is rape is a whole other thing and i i think i'm on the same page as you i don't actually know
00:04:35.040 whether they would be more or less likely to be raped i'm i yeah you would have to kind of see
00:04:40.080 into the mind of a rapist and what is it that they're actually
00:04:42.200 trying to achieve you know
00:04:44.040 I don't know I actually don't
00:04:46.040 they'll say dimes this is a golden
00:04:48.120 opportunity to open up a dialogue and they
00:04:50.220 say no I say I have no
00:04:52.140 interest in speaking to these people 1.00
00:04:53.840 gotta get big rape on the podcast
00:04:58.160 and big 1.00
00:04:59.340 big big rape 1.00
00:05:02.300 hey 0.92
00:05:04.340 everybody it's me 0.96
00:05:05.860 big rape 0.90
00:05:07.260 oh yeah
00:05:10.080 we've got opinions did you come up with a totally new a bit character called rape romano
00:05:17.920 something fresh and original honestly like i gotta i think it's time we retire rape
00:05:26.800 aside you know say what you will yeah about the storied and you know zigzagging history of rape
00:05:36.420 Is it not enough?
00:05:38.260 Yeah, he's got to go away to come back.
00:05:39.880 We can reboot him in a few years.
00:05:41.700 You've got to go away to come back.
00:05:43.700 Yeah.
00:05:44.340 That's what I always say.
00:05:45.740 You just said that, right?
00:05:47.120 Yeah, that's what I said.
00:05:48.180 I was going to say it, but you said it.
00:05:49.820 Well, I got it from you.
00:05:50.740 That's one of yours.
00:05:51.720 It's this one.
00:05:54.640 Okay, so I don't want to spend too long on this guy.
00:05:57.020 But the second thing that we got here is that he's,
00:06:01.480 just to prove that this is a real person,
00:06:03.240 he's on the streets of winnipeg interviewing a fentanyl addict about fentanyl and i'm going to
00:06:10.260 pull this up uh make sure the volume is here this thing we just put it right here this is opiate
00:06:17.680 no no no we can't no no we can't take it like that no so you know people confused he's crouching
00:06:25.980 down at some street urchins he's grabbing a glass pipe and what is this how how it work
00:06:31.300 Oh, he's got, like, a crack pipe.
00:06:32.900 And now he's got a little baggie of, like, fentanyl or something.
00:06:35.300 He's just about to put it in his mouth.
00:06:36.900 He's about to just take a shot of fentanyl.
00:06:42.180 First of all, is this how you do?
00:06:45.280 Let's say it was.
00:06:47.180 Go for it, buddy.
00:06:48.740 Let's say it was.
00:06:49.980 You would do that even less.
00:06:52.520 And just grabbing a glass pipe and saying, how'd this work?
00:06:56.960 It's wild.
00:06:58.760 First of all, not knowing how a pipe works. 1.00
00:07:00.480 well do you think he's like with a lot of time with the indians with this attitude i think they're 0.96
00:07:04.720 trying to be condescending or they're trying to they're i don't know what you say lampooning like 0.99
00:07:10.640 he's trying to he's just you know he's like playing baby bird like he's asking a bunch of
00:07:15.520 questions he has an idea of what these things are but he's just trying to get them to talk about it 0.99
00:07:19.840 but in the in the process he's looking like a much bigger idiot which is so well because you know 0.98
00:07:24.960 know this is not what the people need to see we know what fentanyl is everyone kind of gets it 0.99
00:07:30.680 yeah it's a drug i'm gonna i'm gonna crack the story on what how do you take fentanyl
00:07:35.880 in the middle of the day is this it who is this for as we is it for other indians because indians
00:07:42.060 are big into heroin i don't know if a lot of people know that i've been confronting them on
00:07:46.280 that online anytime you run into an indian because they say the same they get the same
00:07:50.680 script, upload every time, and make 0.98
00:07:52.680 fun of white people for being 1.00
00:07:54.280 drug addicts. I've looked 0.99
00:07:56.760 at the numbers. You guys love heroin.
00:07:58.620 You just call it something else. You have an
00:08:00.760 Indian word for it, but you're
00:08:02.720 into opium. 1.00
00:08:04.340 Because of course you would be.
00:08:06.740 Of course you would be. Do you think
00:08:08.580 Indians are the least likely to take
00:08:10.620 drugs? Have you seen them? 0.91
00:08:13.540 They're the most likely to do 1.00
00:08:14.720 every dumb shit. They're the most likely to put whipped 1.00
00:08:16.640 cream on a light bulb. You think they're
00:08:18.700 not smoking meth and shooting 0.98
00:08:20.620 heroin yeah think of a dumb thing and i guarantee you that they're doing it these are the people 0.94
00:08:26.580 that stand on train tracks see and it's just it is a race thing because we had a crack smoking 0.97
00:08:34.120 mayor in toronto for a while and he was great his name was rob ford yep and he put a stop to
00:08:41.980 the gravy train this guy's out here swallowing fentanyl you think he's putting us up to any
00:08:46.820 gravy train, the gravy
00:08:48.840 will flow.
00:08:50.440 I think the gravy train is how he arrived in
00:08:52.680 Winnipeg. It's just called
00:08:54.780 Indian immigration at the gravy 1.00
00:08:56.820 train. Yeah, it's just brown slop on 1.00
00:08:58.800 the train. These gravy
00:09:00.700 men. Gravy men.
00:09:03.020 And the bad gravy too, like the package
00:09:04.780 gravy. It's the new re-migration 1.00
00:09:06.920 slogan is stop the gravy train. 1.00
00:09:09.960 I was
00:09:10.820 thinking about this today.
00:09:13.740 There was a debate
00:09:15.080 going on in our chat about Donald Trump
00:09:17.680 and the number of people he's actually deported,
00:09:21.620 the level of deportation that he's arrived at
00:09:23.860 and where he could be going from there. 0.94
00:09:25.660 And someone was making a pretty valid point
00:09:28.260 about how he seems to be focusing on Hispanics and Mexicans,
00:09:32.420 but he's not doing anything about Somalis, Muslims, Indians,
00:09:38.040 any of that, and there might be some reasons for that.
00:09:40.800 It's an H-1B visa problem.
00:09:42.600 It's a different thing than just illegal immigration
00:09:46.200 and tied up with different visa rules.
00:09:48.460 Okay, I kind of get that.
00:09:50.280 And they actually pulled up the numbers
00:09:51.720 that like 70% of the deportations
00:09:54.940 are South American and Hispanic.
00:09:56.500 There's still 3%.
00:09:58.340 Like how many Somalis are actually in America? 1.00
00:10:00.320 Okay.
00:10:00.860 Yeah.
00:10:01.380 But I started thinking about that.
00:10:03.400 It is wild that in America,
00:10:07.040 there's no...
00:10:08.880 Like if you show disdain or hostility towards Muslims,
00:10:12.040 it's islamophobia if it's against jews as anti-semitism there's no actual word an easily
00:10:19.960 apprehendable word for when you just don't like hispanics and mexicans and you think there would 0.98
00:10:25.240 be it's it's like everyone has the same idea that of course we want them out you know i mean like 0.99
00:10:31.720 it's not even treated for despite the amount of them that there are and the open targeting
00:10:39.720 and deporting of them. I think it's justified.
00:10:41.940 Some people don't, but you think there would be a
00:10:43.940 dash phobia applied to that.
00:10:45.940 There's just not. I just thought that was strange.
00:10:48.840 It's not even
00:10:49.680 treated as a racial thing. 0.87
00:10:51.520 Is there one for blacks? 1.00
00:10:55.620 Black people are obsessed with 1.00
00:10:57.560 the idea of white people being 1.00
00:10:59.400 obsessed with them.
00:11:01.160 They don't want to even say it's a phobia.
00:11:03.720 It's like, you love
00:11:05.680 us, and that's why you hate
00:11:07.580 us. They got a strange psychology
00:11:09.700 like how they explain this but that's another thing there's no phobia is it just muslims and
00:11:17.860 jews right yeah and i always kind of thought it was to do with it was like a faith thing right
00:11:24.460 like everything else is just racism but the islamophobia and antisemitism antisemitism is
00:11:30.760 weird because it's a nationality uh uh ethnicity and a religion but with islam it's just a religion
00:11:38.620 so if you're an islamophobic then you just are afraid of muslims it just so happens that most 0.98
00:11:44.880 of them are brown people it's something going back to this mayor i bet they're going to be 0.95
00:11:51.000 testing out hindu phobia i think i might say hindu phobia or in indian phobia i can't imagine 0.93
00:12:01.200 them trying that and every white person regardless of political affiliation like laughing in their
00:12:07.260 face yeah like it's just a funny thing if you're in you're indian phobic no shut up because of
00:12:16.220 course because everyone is like everyone's kind of on the same page with that have you met you 1.00
00:12:22.060 like of course we are have you know what do indians look in mirrors have they been known to do that
00:12:28.860 no they might not have ever looked at themselves how much would that explain 1.00
00:12:34.140 yeah a lot because they certainly can't look into a clear reflecting pool where they're from
00:12:41.380 there's looking in the dark dank muddy waters that's out mirrors no like there's there's nothing
00:12:50.740 in india that reflects right now you must understand this everything's dirty everything
00:12:57.200 it's a one big black hole light doesn't escape these walls or anything so it might be the case 0.99
00:13:03.340 the indians don't know what they look like well each indian gets to see all of the you know inbred 1.00
00:13:09.380 cousins and whoever he spends his time with so he must have some kind of idea for the bloods out 1.00
00:13:14.820 there i would say vote for this man yeah there's ever been a man that we have not in canada maybe
00:13:23.140 in america but we've never had a mayor or any elected political official that's ever died by 1.00
00:13:31.720 walking into a train you're an idiot this could be the first he'd be the first just imagine the 0.99
00:13:41.100 guy running your city just walks into a train should we very briefly return to the lindsey 1.00
00:13:49.440 clancy trial because that is it's wrapped up it it's it's it's unresolved but i think we can put
00:13:58.800 a pin in just that
00:14:00.900 coverage we were doing
00:14:01.840 so there's a couple updates and I
00:14:04.900 can't even remember what we said
00:14:06.560 concerning this trial on the last episode
00:14:09.140 but just the big
00:14:10.960 pieces of news was that
00:14:12.800 the mistrial
00:14:14.100 and so everyone went home
00:14:17.100 I don't know if you've been following
00:14:18.240 I don't think I've ever seen this before
00:14:21.020 I'm trying to think if this happened
00:14:22.780 during the OJ Simpson trial
00:14:24.200 but they've been parading around the jury
00:14:26.880 specifically these like four women that's been so strange yeah i've no i have not seen that in
00:14:31.740 my lifetime i don't remember a time when the jurors became their own characters do you think
00:14:38.240 this case should just go away be dismissed no our verdict that the 11 of us had decided on
00:14:45.860 was not guilty by reason of a mental illness and we really feel that lindsey needs to get the help
00:14:55.980 she needs to give some justice to the children that her mother loved her and didn't know what
00:15:07.660 she was doing when she did that and to get justice for them the medical community needs to
00:15:15.180 acknowledge that this exists and everybody can manifest it in a different way like every women 1.00
00:15:22.380 woman can have it in a different way it may not last one time it may not last 10 times it could
00:15:28.620 come and go that's all that's all the evidence that we looked at woman alert and then talking
00:15:36.780 about other jurors and then telling everyone to look at this one guy that ruined it i didn't
00:15:42.460 think they were legally allowed to do that not not during the case i think you can do it afterwards 1.00
00:15:47.660 right i mean look they must be able to otherwise these bitches are all going to prison exactly but 1.00
00:15:52.620 it seems like there if every there's so many laws around juries i thought there would be one where 1.00
00:15:58.860 it's like yeah you're not allowed to go to the press and say that juror ruined it either got
00:16:04.540 someone convicted or got them off because especially for a high profile case like that
00:16:09.020 that could be a death sentence if they found who the guy is and now he's got a hundred million women 1.00
00:16:15.420 after him yeah but so and these women looked exactly as you would imagine they were hags of 0.92
00:16:20.620 the highest order and they're telling stories about how funny the defense was like just falling 0.99
00:16:27.340 in love and they're nurses too so they're doing what nurses do they get down there and they say
00:16:33.080 well she kind of done it and listen to me i'm a nurse it's impossible that they could have done 0.99
00:16:37.600 this hoping that we don't know that nurses are all full of shit i'll listen to a doctor maybe 0.98
00:16:44.320 maybe it depends on the day and the doctor nurse is like nurse i don't think like not everybody 0.99
00:16:50.600 has clued into this yet but just being a nurse it's like okay it's not i was about to say it's
00:16:56.780 like being a pedophile it's not quite to the level of being a pedophile but it is in our society i
00:17:02.180 should narrow this at the very least in north american society being a nurse is is inexcusable 0.92
00:17:07.760 Being a nurse is inexcusable
00:17:14.120 There's no excuse
00:17:16.240 If you're a nurse 1.00
00:17:18.060 Fuck off 1.00
00:17:18.980 Why does every nurse act 1.00
00:17:22.180 We don't know what nurses are 1.00
00:17:23.640 So they're in here doing
00:17:25.000 Again a thing I thought was illegal
00:17:27.220 Which is saying I'm an expert
00:17:29.180 So you have to listen to me
00:17:30.420 And everyone was posting images
00:17:33.580 Of what this lone male juror looked like 0.83
00:17:36.280 he was a chad he was the norman rockwell painting guy standing up turns out he's black 0.86
00:17:44.620 yeah turns out he was a black man and so every everyone's jumbled up because we know it was
00:17:53.000 nine women three men what was the age range what was the racial makeup i haven't heard any of that
00:17:57.520 what was it? 70-ish to 22. And one person of color and then everybody else was white.
00:18:08.420 A lot of the jurors had children. One person of color was a person of color, a woman or a man?
00:18:14.080 A man. A man. Is a holdout juror a person, a black man? Yes. A black man is a holdout juror? Yes. 0.95
00:18:21.600 well i have to sit with that for just a second was there um everyone's just in a pretzel over
00:18:31.460 this i hear he was actually a black man the whole time actually you think so yeah the the entire 0.72
00:18:38.320 time is a big a big whoopsie on the part of the media and then sure it was i'm sorry he's a black
00:18:44.740 man's whole life i'm his whole that's what i mean his whole life yeah this was not like for him this
00:18:49.540 wasn't a new experience he's always been there's a non-zero chance that he hasn't been black his
00:18:56.360 whole life right but it might be a rounding error yeah i wasn't there we'd have to take it to the
00:19:01.100 jury and i don't know his life story i don't know i'm not god i don't know what's in his heart
00:19:04.920 i don't know how long he's been black i don't know what's in his heart i i don't know what
00:19:10.720 his destiny is not in my clutches mind you so we we have to presume beyond reasonable doubt
00:19:19.200 has been black for most of his life yes and then everyone's saying that this was a principled stand
00:19:24.660 taken by again this man standing up to the long house standing up to the witches it could have 1.00
00:19:33.560 been a retarded nigger yeah it could have been a black guy who didn't take off his headphones 0.98
00:19:39.540 it could have been a lot of stuff he could have been really cool or it could have been something 1.00
00:19:45.120 that shatters our entire narrative, which it did. 1.00
00:20:15.120 Fuck out of my face with your little masterpiece, illegalese 1.00
00:20:18.640 We're here a week, I'll never speak 1.00
00:20:21.880 You got your eyes and cross your tees
00:20:24.120 And grit your teeth and stomp your feet 1.00
00:20:27.180 I say this bitch is never free 1.00
00:20:29.080 You kill your kids, you go to hell 1.00
00:20:42.000 And I don't need to fucking read 1.00
00:20:43.320 Women ain't have no agency 1.00
00:20:44.420 So mental illness, flagrancy 1.00
00:20:45.920 One more dyke gets in my face 1.00
00:20:47.200 And she could take a cloud of weed 1.00
00:20:48.460 I always gotta take a shit 1.00
00:20:49.760 And ain't no judge be stopping me 1.00
00:20:51.220 Probable, caspacopita, nigga 0.97
00:21:02.860 All these words be mocking me 1.00
00:21:04.080 This polity's a robbery
00:21:05.180 And I will no longer be a party 1.00
00:21:06.480 Be y'all bitches wanna kill your kids 1.00
00:21:08.060 Then you gonna have to barge through me 1.00
00:21:09.260 I ain't never even seen a thought 1.00
00:21:10.640 And by the way, I'm fucking gay 0.99
00:21:12.040 I would say 0.99
00:21:13.680 good for him but in a sense i'm i'm reaching for the lather to wash my hands of this like i don't
00:21:20.800 know because if he wasn't there there's other white men on the jury that just fell in line i
00:21:28.160 said oh dimes that could have been jews are we surprised though i mean are we really surprised
00:21:35.380 i don't know i'm not i'm not i'm not extremely surprised i would love us to be on a jury do
00:21:41.620 we could do that i think we could request to be on the same jury now that we've recorded this
00:21:48.260 probably not i think just like any case like i think just you and me on a jury that would be fun
00:21:53.460 yeah it'd be good i'd like to pay for it you get sandwiches wait you get paid do you get sandwiches
00:21:58.900 you get a set amount i don't think oh nice oh well you have to skip work though so i guess that's
00:22:05.060 kind of the point they got to give you something i think again legally they're not allowed to fire
00:22:09.780 you if you did you're doing but you know they could be mad at you yeah you get free lunches
00:22:16.500 oh nice that's a trial in itself imagine imagine being in that court and trying to 1.00
00:22:23.140 figure out what they're eating for lunch imagine those women what are they having 1.00
00:22:29.140 we're gonna do the dance and say who wants a salad yeah sweet water and 1.00
00:22:34.260 and cobb salad.
00:22:36.200 You're going to get a big
00:22:38.260 honking sandwich. 1.00
00:22:40.780 You big bitch. 1.00
00:22:42.100 Yeah, nigga. Every big bitch 1.00
00:22:44.400 in there got a fat sandwich. 1.00
00:22:48.440 My man's got it all figured out.
00:22:50.460 He's getting chicken and grits
00:22:52.380 every single day.
00:22:54.040 It's like your last meal.
00:22:56.020 They have to give you whatever you ask for.
00:22:58.800 It's your last meal. 1.00
00:23:01.540 I want ham hocks and you to go on a ass. 1.00
00:23:04.260 he's just becoming a member of three six mafias i'm telling them just like a fucking man from 1.00
00:23:12.520 memphis like this guy's awesome never take these master p just never taking his shades off 0.98
00:23:19.160 love it that's how i would go to the jury room i'd come in with a real memphis energy
00:23:26.140 whatever jury i'm on yeah snakeskin boots a couple things to say before we move on because
00:23:32.440 we don't need to spend a lot of time on this but if i didn't establish this last time the question
00:23:38.400 is of course why do we care about this why are we still talking about this and uh i was just so
00:23:43.820 convinced that this wasn't even necessarily about this case there's other things that were on trial
00:23:50.680 and uh there's some speculation that okay they'll ask why now why this case because this event
00:23:58.620 happened two years ago why is it the forefront of our minds right now and uh it's not an exceptional
00:24:07.160 case and that wasn't what people were saying but if you know anything about this you can look up
00:24:12.820 news stories where this thing has happened before so you might say it's suspicious that we picked
00:24:19.320 this one but i'm saying it's suspicious that you didn't do any of the others either okay maybe some
00:24:25.000 suspicious but it's it's not uncommon for this to happen that that indeed is the problem and someone
00:24:31.760 was circulating a newspaper clipping from like the 60s and the 50s like if you go back to every
00:24:39.000 decade you can find a notorious child murdering woman that was treated the same way yeah they
00:24:46.560 become every time and we just forget about it because we don't revisit the past but even at
00:24:50.940 the time these stories would have been front page news here's a woman who drowned her three kids and
00:24:56.300 became a feminist icon also if you if you take that pattern of women getting a free ride while 1.00
00:25:03.440 men get the book thrown at them and you map that outward then the next ring out beyond um women who 1.00
00:25:11.620 are obviously child killers but get kid gloved are women who are obviously child killers but are
00:25:17.460 are released and then beyond that are women who should be obviously child killers but are never
00:25:22.700 even arrested and and there's probably millions of those like the whole thing about SIDS right
00:25:29.220 so um yeah I mean I think it's it's interesting people talk about this in the context of
00:25:34.060 women losing the right to vote but I think also just re constantly rehashing the conversation
00:25:39.880 about how it's that women it's not that women aren't violent but women have their own way of 0.92
00:25:45.280 being violent and demonic when they want to be like yeah men men will beat you with a bottle 1.00
00:25:51.120 and punch you and throw you down the stairs but women will strangle a child and spit in its eye 0.53
00:25:56.320 like and they'll do it and this is what's so difficult for a lot of people to understand 1.00
00:26:00.640 look they are capable of doing that to spite the husband yeah i've seen stories where they killed
00:26:05.920 the kids because the husband cheated on them or some of some financial malfeasance and it's like 0.98
00:26:12.480 i'm killing your kids that's what they start to say like you're i've killed your kids so their 0.98
00:26:17.680 own kids stop being their kids they become their husband's kids and that psychologically allows 1.00
00:26:23.920 them to do these heinous things um and so like i said throughout history i've seen documentaries 0.87
00:26:32.560 about this of women who have just done this because they commit suicide sometimes they want to take 0.95
00:26:38.320 the kids with them but that's always at the forefront of their mind and that's strikes at
00:26:43.360 the core of a very important civilizational and social belief that we hold which is that women
00:26:49.520 are better with children i believe i said that on the last episode as well but that's what really
00:26:54.400 is on trial here and that's why it was so important because there's a claim made that this is all
00:27:00.080 being funded by a pro-abortion lobby or in some way algorithmically being boosted okay i don't know
00:27:09.440 about that but seems to make sense to me are the jews involved or the other groups who's
00:27:17.360 involved in this yes let's say let's say it's all of them it is jews whatever but this is as i said 0.94
00:27:23.360 before an ancient problem we've had to deal with which is women killing their kids and so 0.94
00:27:30.080 Someone had posted something that I had to check up and verify, and I did.
00:27:35.440 In Canada, the infanticide laws and mothers specifically killing their children.
00:27:43.240 This might be different in the U.S., but this is me looking it up online. 1.00
00:27:49.680 A mother who willfully, willfully kills their children can receive a maximum of five years in prison. 1.00
00:27:57.260 No way. 1.00
00:27:58.220 yeah so maximum penalty five years so it's downgraded like first degree murder if you
00:28:03.820 murder like your neighbor it could be life but if you only murdered your own children that's only
00:28:08.720 five years i mean see it's we understand yeah and then um here's here's written change yeah so so 0.88
00:28:17.300 to me the dimes what are they trying to push well they're trying to push acceptance of mothers
00:28:22.500 killing their kids and this is all tied into the abortion debate and let me just say that it sounds 0.56
00:28:29.360 like we're singling out white women here and i'm not this is all women this is a huge problem all 0.98
00:28:36.880 throughout asia africa it's more we just care more about white women the thing is it's more 0.94
00:28:41.900 accepted there and they don't care here they still do it but women white women especially 0.85
00:28:48.500 So you need to justify it with all this theory and legal jargon to justify it. 1.00
00:28:56.740 And in the black community, they don't give a fuck. 1.00
00:28:58.800 They just kill their kids and mistreat them and no one cares. 1.00
00:29:02.660 In most countries in the world, they just throw kids in the trash and it's not even seen as a problem.
00:29:07.640 So that's why we're focusing on this, just because there's so much strange justification because they can't just do it. 0.94
00:29:14.840 um but it's in the interest of pushing the normalization of mothers killing their kids
00:29:21.480 and just giving the canadian example they treat a mother killing their children under the age of one
00:29:28.440 that's the rule has to be under the age of one uh you get five years maximum that's maximum that's
00:29:34.940 not minimum there is no minimum sentencing you could get zero days but it's like you cannot go
00:29:41.720 beyond five at the absolute worst so to me it's like that's part of the movement to say that well
00:29:47.480 you're just for that first year you're not even you have no agency right we get it it's society
00:29:54.580 saying we get it just like you said with the sids thing there's this implicit understanding that if
00:29:59.900 a kid just dies well you know they cry a lot and mothers you know they like we're at one saying 0.96
00:30:07.380 that mothers aren't up to being mothers for many years and they you can't like that's what they're 0.98
00:30:13.220 saying like you can't just leave your kids alone with a mother like they'll kill them of course
00:30:17.740 that shouldn't and they're trying to make that not against the law post-birth abortions and so to me 0.58
00:30:24.020 that's what that's that's why these women care it's because we're closer to getting that than
00:30:29.260 ever before so that's why i care about it because i don't know like this is again we already have 0.96
00:30:36.240 that in the rest of the horrible world we inhabit and like it it's troubling that that's being 0.59
00:30:42.600 normalized here and and if you talk to these women long enough it does get to that aside from them
00:30:48.480 just you know speaking i don't know if you've ever spoken to these lindsey clancy supports i've done
00:30:53.060 it a few times oh really online and they all see the same thing first of all they're convinced that
00:31:00.140 the husband did it and framed her and then which is not even up for dispute from a legal standpoint
00:31:06.180 it's like incontrovertible that she did it okay we have video of him at the store when this was
00:31:11.940 happening like no that's that's you didn't you do watch the trial that's what they say i've had
00:31:17.400 five of them say me just watch the trial they poked holes in that i said who how and they're
00:31:23.380 like just it's in the trial and i said okay just give me an example of what what are you talking
00:31:28.040 about and they never answer i'm like you've you've learned all this from not even what none of you
00:31:32.640 watched the trial none of you you've watched women on tick tock women on tick tock doing like their
00:31:38.960 bird hands and then looking bug-eyed to the camera i'm like i don't know i think this might mean
00:31:44.560 something in stopping the normalization of all that but uh you wonder what's related to that
00:31:50.400 i saw this the other day um so when people heard about this guy they said oh reasonable black man
00:31:59.440 and they're sharing this meme that was circulating like for years it's allegedly from uh some book
00:32:07.920 and there's a wikipedia page wikipedia reasonable black man this is supposed to be a man that
00:32:12.400 existed and he was uh held up as one of the earliest examples of an african in europe and
00:32:20.880 he was a business owner in london and we just kind of accept that you know and it's kind of funny but
00:32:28.720 then someone was looking into
00:32:30.720 that on Substack. I'm looking at this one called
00:32:32.880 The Genealogian
00:32:34.620 and this was published
00:32:36.780 this year. It says, Reasonable Black Man, we hardly
00:32:38.720 knew ye. The guy's name alone should 1.00
00:32:40.820 be sufficient clickbait.
00:32:42.760 So anyway, they looked this guy up. I'll
00:32:44.660 spare you the entire article. This
00:32:46.700 was made up by one just bitch author. 1.00
00:32:49.860 Some 1.00
00:32:50.300 old Jewish 1.00
00:32:52.820 lady made it up. 0.95
00:32:55.000 This guy didn't exist. Of course.
00:32:56.840 Of course.
00:32:57.360 because they said this came out in like the 2010s when everyone was trying to find black
00:33:04.200 people throughout history this was peak woke woke 1.0 so yeah this is a woman that they said it was
00:33:11.880 i'm reading it here uh the the last name was probably black more you know like that's this
00:33:19.000 there's a person that exists whose last name is black more this woman looked at and said oh black
00:33:23.380 more that must mean black person because black and more means black that that must have been them
00:33:28.900 trying to say that this was a black guy like just based on nothing um it could have been black more
00:33:37.060 you know it could have just been written right and then more more like a like a location right
00:33:41.700 and black like the color like he's from the black moor like you know you know a two days ride west 1.00
00:33:47.300 from here the black moor yeah he's from there that's so stupid man yeah and they they they've 0.99
00:33:52.180 He's got screenshots here from what the alleged sources are supposed to be. 0.97
00:33:57.340 And there's a screenshot here from like a baptism certificate from 1579.
00:34:03.540 It says, a son is born.
00:34:05.160 John Blackmore, son of reasonable Blackmore.
00:34:09.180 Or Blakemore.
00:34:11.200 John Blakemore, son of reasonable Blakemore.
00:34:13.900 Oh, so it's Blakemore.
00:34:15.620 Yeah.
00:34:15.900 But there's like all these evidences that she just merged into one thing.
00:34:20.580 But these are like five different people.
00:34:22.180 right there's there's a black moor over here and a blake more over here and there's like oh that
00:34:25.900 that must be there must have been a really cool black guy who lived in london if this were true
00:34:31.460 it'd be so notable that it would not be difficult to find a record of it right because it's an
00:34:36.960 oddity yeah exactly yeah first of all it's the case that we found one it's like turns out you
00:34:43.140 found zero you didn't even find one and you had to dig and make shit up yeah um so anyway i just 0.82
00:34:52.740 wanted to point to that so next time you hear a story about this black guy saves day ah another 0.99
00:34:59.600 instance welcome back reasonable black man i say welcome to the fucking void because it wasn't one 0.99
00:35:07.340 there's actually no historical precedent for a reasonable black man 0.99
00:35:13.580 there's never been a reasonable black man you thought you had one
00:35:19.000 you want to you want to talk more about reasonable black man i have another one here this was
00:35:25.720 unintentional i just had a well hold on the problem with this is we just talked about the
00:35:30.700 juror so there is one reasonable black man and he was the juror on he was the juror on the lindsey 0.67
00:35:36.160 clancy trial like he it could have been that he's really retarded and it wasn't a principal 0.87
00:35:41.360 saying it's like yeah but she killed the kids oh well that's what i was going to say earlier about 0.93
00:35:45.040 like you know are we uncomfortable with the fact that it was a black man that stood up and not 0.97
00:35:49.300 whites like no i'm i'm comfortable enough to say that whites are more cucked on this specific issue 0.94
00:35:57.140 than blacks right liberal whites even some conservative whites are liable to rush to the 0.99
00:36:04.500 the fence of the woman before hearing the whole story whereas blacks are much more likely to just 1.00
00:36:09.640 say fuck that bitch not because they hate women but because they don't care about anything and 1.00
00:36:14.060 they hate everybody and they love watching shit burn so i mean yeah it doesn't have to be a 1.00
00:36:18.380 principled stance but of course it's going to be that fucking i probably did have his headphones 1.00
00:36:22.220 in the whole time yeah white men especially we've got this previous position where when we learn 0.99
00:36:31.880 that there's a nurse in the room
00:36:33.980 or we learn
00:36:35.960 just through
00:36:37.540 exchange of words
00:36:39.440 the art of conversation that we're speaking
00:36:41.980 to a nurse, we don't just immediately 0.99
00:36:43.860 flip the fucking table over 1.00
00:36:45.540 and just launch over it at them 1.00
00:36:47.860 and start just... Well, you and I do, but most whites 0.93
00:36:50.200 don't. But most whites don't, 0.53
00:36:51.940 that's what I'm saying. But a black guy might... 0.92
00:36:53.860 A black guy, they'd say, oh, the legacy 1.00
00:36:55.320 of medical malpractice 0.99
00:36:58.180 that they deployed upon
00:37:01.720 in their community. He's one of these conscious
00:37:03.740 black guys with like the 1.00
00:37:05.080 flat top. He's one 1.00
00:37:07.860 of those conscious black guys from the 1980s.
00:37:11.360 Exactly. 1.00
00:37:13.160 Fucking DJ 0.99
00:37:14.080 Jazzy Jeff is in there with his arms 1.00
00:37:16.000 crossed.
00:37:20.240 Yeah, I don't know.
00:37:22.240 It's a quagmire
00:37:23.560 this entire case. 1.00
00:37:25.520 And I'm putting black people on 1.00
00:37:27.880 trial. And let's jump over to this story. 1.00
00:37:29.820 going over to africa we're looking at the unfortunately we're looking at the bbc here
00:37:37.220 this is culturally shooting dice in the cum slump the crowd shouted that we'd stolen someone's
00:37:43.480 genitals deadly rumors spread on social media so this is from the author's name uh mungai
00:37:51.320 nginge from is reporting from africa pronunciation you do pronounce the g in that one
00:37:59.140 Yeah.
00:37:59.860 You get nothing!
00:38:01.600 More than 80 people were killed between October 2025 and July of this year, 2026,
00:38:07.280 following false accusations about what is termed genital theft.
00:38:12.000 The killings are linked to rumors that a simple tap on the shoulder can cause a man's...
00:38:18.080 Sir, we start over.
00:38:24.640 It's a bit much.
00:38:25.760 the killings are linked to rumors
00:38:27.940 that a simple tap on the shoulder
00:38:29.820 can cause a man's genitals to shrink 0.91
00:38:31.860 or disappear 0.93
00:38:32.640 because this
00:38:36.020 sounds like something that we would just riff on
00:38:37.960 on the show
00:38:38.700 what if he could just tap a guy on his shoulder 1.00
00:38:41.740 and his penis disappears 0.99
00:38:43.760 would he use the power for good or evil 1.00
00:38:47.800 he would say how could you use it
00:38:50.040 for good
00:38:50.540 like
00:38:53.480 it would only succeed in turning an evil person
00:38:55.640 more evil they're being fueled by widespread disinformation on social
00:39:01.400 media is I'm quoting someone here says they were shown that we'd stolen some
00:39:08.660 of the genitals and we didn't have any way to escape because there was a huge
00:39:12.140 crowd Tanzanian mechanic Boniface Galta but bone bond that can't be the same
00:39:20.000 Boniface that we would use that must be a twist of bone face his experience was
00:39:29.060 similar to those in videos seen by the BBC men claim that their general organs 0.97
00:39:32.760 penises and testicles for the folks at home have vanished or shriveled after 0.92
00:39:37.460 coming in contact with strangers and a mob then demands that alleged perpetrators 0.98
00:39:41.220 return where they'd supposedly stolen which begs the question if it's not 0.99
00:39:46.220 completely absent if it's just shriveled let's say you've lost 30 to 60 percent of your penis 0.93
00:39:53.740 what form does that take in that person's possession because you're going to their 0.99
00:39:58.360 house and give me my penis meat back right not the entire thing just get it put give it to me 0.98
00:40:05.600 so i can just mash it back in right maybe it's a tap like another tap on the shoulder like they 0.99
00:40:13.560 can perform it perform voodoo or something to do it because yeah if you think about it
00:40:18.400 mechanistically it makes no sense but it doesn't it doesn't make sense to begin with so this is
00:40:24.200 africa's version of covid 0.98
00:40:26.440 african covid is penis that everyone's gonna be keeping six feet apart no one's gonna be 0.98
00:40:36.560 getting within anyone's zone right now because they're afraid of i mean you can lose your life 1.00
00:40:42.360 there's no female equivalent 1.00
00:40:47.340 that'd be so much more funny 1.00
00:40:48.640 you still have my vagina 1.00
00:40:50.200 you still have my vagina 1.00
00:40:51.780 these witches feeling 1.00
00:40:56.300 hunks of your vagina 1.00
00:40:58.080 that was the woman version of that would be 1.00
00:41:02.200 she tapped me on the shoulder and made my vagina bigger 1.00
00:41:04.280 the woman version is you add vagina 1.00
00:41:09.200 a lot of this I don't know if they're clever enough 0.99
00:41:11.380 but if some of this may just be them playing games like oh um no i wasn't always this small it was 0.93
00:41:17.800 the voodoo man or i wasn't always this loose it was the voodoo man tapping on the shoulder
00:41:21.560 but but so much laser because you don't need to even bring up a medicine man or a conspiracy
00:41:26.860 there it's like oh he used to be so much bigger but that guy yeah you point you point out the 0.79
00:41:31.680 window oh he did well we better go kill him all right he's like 0.98
00:41:35.520 Like, he's really got himself into a dilly of a pickle. 0.99
00:41:43.300 At the start of every African mob is a man in a dilly of a pickle. 1.00
00:41:49.080 Generally. 0.98
00:41:50.580 I'm looking at a map here, and this is happening in the Congo, Zambia,
00:41:54.800 Malawi, Tanzania, Kenya.
00:41:56.500 This is, like, a huge...
00:41:59.660 This is taking place on a landmass the size of Europe.
00:42:03.380 continental europe imagine if everyone in europe started believing this it is like all of central
00:42:11.820 africa that's wild i would love it if that's something like that happened here do they have
00:42:15.740 phones i guess they have i want to say they have flip phones but they probably have like
00:42:21.600 i bet they're the first people to get the new foldable iphone i'll bet i'll bet they have
00:42:27.020 our phones from literally five years ago right like where do they all go you know do you throw
00:42:32.800 your phones out i do but but i like i nuked them and smashed them with a hammer before i do
00:42:39.920 so which would be very funny if they had the same phones and they're just smashed and microwaved
00:42:47.440 just not working i think we still have every phone just about every phone we've ever had and
00:42:51.840 i'm not sure why we have a drawer full of old phones we got to figure out something to do with
00:42:55.200 i was the same way and before we moved i was just wanting to get rid of them and i just uh
00:43:00.560 I had to dispose them but you have to what you can of course wipe them but that never gets it
00:43:06.280 also they say no you need to destroy it so I actually just went to my garage and then just
00:43:12.940 wiped a big fucking magnet and smashed it with hammers nice which nice cathartic if I and I
00:43:20.740 thank god I had safety glasses on because I underestimated how much like silica and 0.98
00:43:27.200 microchips start flying like i don't know why i didn't think there was a computer in there but
00:43:32.180 i'm like no this is like it's it's shards of glass like sand like it gets so bad i'm like
00:43:38.600 oh no i'm breathing this in this was ill-advised can we take a break one one second i gotta take 0.69
00:43:44.700 a piss yeah go ahead go ahead all right thanks buddy i don't think you washed your hands nope 1.00
00:43:54.980 Fuck that. 1.00
00:43:56.360 I know. 1.00
00:43:57.180 Why do you have to wash your hands? 1.00
00:43:59.120 My wife will say shit like that from time to time. 1.00
00:44:02.140 She's like, wash your hands, you touch your penis. 1.00
00:44:04.120 She's like, you think I wash my hands. 1.00
00:44:06.280 Every time I touch my penis? 1.00
00:44:07.800 Yeah, I don't know. 1.00
00:44:08.880 That's a great point.
00:44:10.020 I never rolled that one out. 0.99
00:44:11.420 You know how many times I scratch my balls on a given day? 0.97
00:44:13.900 I wash my hands and waste water and waste soap. 0.98
00:44:19.080 We're conservative. 1.00
00:44:21.300 God, women are so fucking annoying. 1.00
00:44:24.980 you shouldn't have to i do i figured out a way to do it where i'm i'm not 0.99
00:44:30.720 it's not it's not irradiated uh just a couple of things i wanted to mention uh one is that
00:44:38.700 there's a new article up on the vanguard's journal which is the place where i publish
00:44:44.460 articles that are pulled from what we discussed on the show this one was a piece that i'd written
00:44:51.160 for a magazine that didn't end up materializing i don't even know if the magazine ended up launching
00:44:58.840 it's kind of stuck in limbo it's called the roman revolution of the flesh and it was going to be a
00:45:04.760 book review of christianity and classical culture which is a book that we cover on the show before
00:45:10.360 and then i characteristically took that into a strange direction and i was mentioning a bunch
00:45:15.320 of other shit but i'm really proud of it it's pretty interesting so check that out
00:45:19.480 And we just announced, and we haven't mentioned it on the show officially, but something we've been working on for a while, is this November, November 7th, I'm going to Dallas, Texas to host a live recording of our sister show, Do You Even Read?
00:45:39.860 which i host with the prudentialist so november 7th dallas texas check uh my x profile at legally
00:45:47.600 ironic or you know we'll be bringing it up on the next episode do you even read which is this monday
00:45:54.920 um the tickets are on eventbrite so you can search it up on there look up do you even read you'll
00:46:00.600 find it uh you can buy them now and we're going to be covering this book called self-made creating
00:46:07.760 our identities from da vinci to the kardashians by tara isabella burton and uh the event space
00:46:14.840 that we got it took us a while to find an adequate event space it's really interesting it's like a
00:46:20.660 theater it's a theater in an art center and i'm really happy with it but it's not going to be 0.97
00:46:27.020 a catered event it's just going to be like you're going to see a show yeah so don't expect fucking
00:46:33.760 snacks it's not going to be a bar or anything like that like some of the other events we've 0.74
00:46:37.080 had in the past um but yeah i'm very very excited about it never been to dallas texas
00:46:42.680 and i'm not going to be spending a whole lot of time down there but very happy to go and tickets
00:46:48.340 have been selling pretty well so far so there's an early bird special on right now it's where
00:46:53.360 tickets are 15 off so if you're interested in going if you're in the texas area if you want
00:46:57.040 to fly down and meet us be sure to do that it's it is worth pointing out you joke about this
00:47:02.660 sometimes like we always stress when a show goes up and you can't sell tickets right away
00:47:06.340 correct me if i'm wrong but every single show that you've run in the past two years
00:47:10.100 including the recent big one that we talked about was sold out more than a more than a week before
00:47:16.380 the event yeah that's just how people are too like we try and it helps to buy tickets early
00:47:22.600 it helps us pay for the venue it helps us kind of recoup the investment because you have to pay a
00:47:29.320 certain amount of front there's a lot of investment um involved in this and so it makes our lives
00:47:35.640 easier and if people can buy it early but some people like to leave to the last minute and we've
00:47:41.320 held events where people wait to the last minute it's too late there's a few people for the april
00:47:45.940 event that wanted to get in and we couldn't sell them anymore so if they think they can just wait
00:47:51.960 until the day of nope you know like and it's not we're not flexing it's just like it's they're not
00:47:57.900 big events like we don't have the money to run huge events so they're limited in number you can't fit
00:48:02.420 like the april event you sold as many tickets as you could it was essentially
00:48:05.720 like there were how many there must have been 15 of us standing at the back doors listening
00:48:10.020 through the doors because there were so many people there so yeah yeah we try and do what
00:48:14.740 we can but even for that one the vetting was so important so like anyone and people should know
00:48:20.280 this generally if you're the type of person that wants to wait to the last minute depending on the
00:48:24.340 event that you're going to you may be viewed with suspicion because if someone's trying to
00:48:29.380 be an infiltrator that's what we'll try and do get in the last minute sneak in don't have time
00:48:33.640 to check the email usually there's no information they're not doing a background check on you but
00:48:38.120 they just try and see you know is this person on the level who knows this person and you know you
00:48:43.660 might just be complicating your own you know enjoyment if you don't if you go down that road
00:48:48.360 so i'm saying this out of love buy a ticket now you freak and tell me good place in town to get
00:48:55.440 some brisket yes that's that's it for now uh we didn't have an interview the last episode we're
00:49:02.420 not going to have an interview this time i've got a few lined up for the next episodes from
00:49:07.020 from now on but uh you know i'm not doing as many interviews as i used to i'm really only doing it
00:49:15.520 if it's an individual i'm really really excited about doing and i've got something i want to do
00:49:20.480 Mike Maxwell from Imperium Press.
00:49:22.160 Again,
00:49:22.560 there's a lot of people that we interviewed early on years ago when we first
00:49:27.680 started doing that,
00:49:28.160 they want to have back on.
00:49:30.160 So like Mike Maxwell was like the third one we ever did,
00:49:34.800 you know?
00:49:35.160 And,
00:49:35.360 and so there's a lot of those,
00:49:36.260 those guys I would really love to have back on.
00:49:38.720 And there's some people I was trying to get on and can't get on,
00:49:41.740 but I know I've got Alexandra Cormier-Dennis.
00:49:45.380 Oh, 1.00
00:49:45.560 nice.
00:49:46.240 Yeah.
00:49:46.480 I'm going to be doing a prerecorded one with him next week.
00:49:50.480 and um just yeah just a few others so you'll see but you know don't expect one every single episode
00:49:56.800 it's just time constraints right now we've mentioned this before this is why we had to go
00:50:01.580 down to two episodes of blood sally it's just that the workload of our regular lives has become
00:50:06.700 insurmountable and i just signed out another couple of clients and uh we're doing it out of
00:50:12.540 love but it's it's just it would be an inferior product if you had to really just race one out 1.00
00:50:18.540 every week there might not be enough jews to complain about that's my fear 1.00
00:50:24.220 what happens when you run out of jews you start talking about the same old jews can we manufacture 0.93
00:50:32.180 some can we manufacture some can we vertical integration of the jews supply can we create
00:50:37.900 synthetic jews i think that's like the uh that's the right stuff dot biz that's like how you get
00:50:43.960 into you control the supply chain right like you manufacture the jews you manufacture the 0.79
00:50:48.200 outrage and then you uh yeah this is what i was made fun of geo for saying where like he calls 0.75
00:50:53.800 everyone zionist and jewish he'll call this person jewish and i'll say are they actually
00:50:59.240 jewish and say i don't know well spiritually i guess and he's i'm like you can't just call
00:51:06.160 whatever jewish like i i demand a standard like just tell me if they're fully jewish
00:51:14.380 michelin quarter whatever but don't i don't want to get into this like well i mean they're kind of
00:51:20.920 they're serving the interests in an indirect way so they're kind of spirit like that's not what
00:51:25.420 spiritually means you know i'm not trying to just get on him but like i've heard people say that
00:51:30.600 where i'm like you should afford yourself the freedom to dislike something that isn't explicitly
00:51:37.500 jewish yeah you can hate something for being irish you're allowed to not like the irish
00:51:42.920 i like the irish but you don't need to start saying that the irish are jews
00:51:47.900 you can just like them on the on their demerits
00:51:52.700 you can just like the irish i don't know anyone who just likes the scottish
00:51:58.660 interesting hmm there's not a brown's living in scotland maybe
00:52:04.620 yeah you know i i can't imagine i can't imagine like a brown existing in scotland 0.82
00:52:11.620 really that the terrain just seems no it's bad there now it's as bad as the uk yeah yeah yeah 0.92
00:52:19.380 this is more of a sponsored by the shadow government really i imagine it's very hill
00:52:24.220 i imagine it is as like what do i imagine just mostly cliffs and hills and sheep there's a lot
00:52:32.080 of that there's definitely a lot of that it's beautiful countryside it's difficult for me to
00:52:37.580 imagine an indian in a field like most terrain like i can imagine them close my eyes city yes 0.99
00:52:47.660 yes okay jungle yes but you know a nice pasture standing on on a hill in in kind of a blue gray 1.00
00:52:59.000 sky i'm like i don't know what what are you doing there i don't know yeah god god would swallow you 0.62
00:53:05.400 up not enough hustle and bustle so speaking of synthetic jews i just want to talk about this
00:53:12.020 because i want to know what you think so do you saw this story about this former anthropic
00:53:19.960 employee that was doing a tour of the mainstream media outlets being a whistleblower that's what
00:53:26.920 he called himself about here's the headline from nbc news anthropic whistleblower says congress
00:53:33.220 should let ai companies police themselves until a regulatory board is established his name is
00:53:38.500 jacob coxson and he was just out there saying he worked at ai development at anthropic and he left
00:53:48.820 because he was scared about how ai was being developed and he was out there
00:53:56.100 telling a story about how it's going to kill us in a few years
00:53:59.220 how exactly do you think ai will actually carry out the action of destroying all of humanity 0.84
00:54:06.020 yep honestly when i talk to my friends and family about this i find it easier to or people seem to
00:54:12.500 actually get more of a sense for it if they're further away from technology because i honestly
00:54:16.120 think it sounds more like science fiction than real technology or like people who are very used
00:54:20.620 to computers might think it's kind of crazy that a computer could could wipe them out but it doesn't
00:54:25.620 look that different from say terminator or from science fiction films it really is just if you
00:54:29.540 have a super advanced intelligence it could it will be smart enough to to kill us and concrete
00:54:35.740 examples might be it could we can't just unplug it because it could be copying itself over to
00:54:40.120 other computers and people ate it up and then it he was saying that he was like the head of
00:54:47.100 development and it turns out later that he was only there for six months and his job was pretty
00:54:53.040 unimportant and he left that job completely just to switch over to working for like an ai watchdog
00:55:01.600 group like he's out there crafting a narrative that serves his interests but he was like he
00:55:07.600 exists to try and handicap ai development and that became clear and a lot of people like elon musk's
00:55:16.000 and the sam altman's word saying that who is this guy this sounds made up it turns out it
00:55:22.360 mostly was he was just making shit up but first of all what do you think about this story did 0.86
00:55:29.000 you hear about this story i don't get the headline because it's saying that they should regulate 0.96
00:55:33.100 themselves which depending on how you interpret that it could mean they should be regulated more
00:55:38.280 than they are it could also mean the government should stay out of it and let them do whatever
00:55:42.600 they feel right because like quote unquote self-regulation within the private sector
00:55:46.360 is deregulation i mean right like they don't have the you know what i mean they don't have
00:55:50.440 the legal authority to regulate each other which means it'll just be a race to the bottom uh yeah
00:55:55.640 because really like even if you had a cartel which is kind of what he's advocating for holding each
00:56:02.360 other to account all it would take is one ai developer not even just in america well even
00:56:08.840 in a cartel like cartels don't hold themselves to account cartels spiral right like cartels fight
00:56:14.320 each other until one kills the other and they're always upping the ante versus what he's describing
00:56:19.360 or what i'm assuming what he's trying to say is we need to put a clamp on this and prevent it from
00:56:23.840 growing well like cartelizing it won't do that cartelizing it will just make everything even 0.80
00:56:28.360 worse than it already is so like how the fuck do you expect these companies who are competing with
00:56:33.860 other for market share if they're the only ones regulating themselves to to clamp down on it
00:56:40.260 they're going to do the exact opposite and he says here here's a quote from him the people building
00:56:44.660 ai earnestly believe that could kill us all by the end of the decade that is not a marketing stunt
00:56:50.180 if anything many executives and senior researchers will couch their phrasing in the press to sound
00:56:55.380 sensible but i hear people express fear privately no other human activity poses this level of danger
00:57:02.100 which is something that it seems that the heads that is that him or is that dario that that's
00:57:07.460 dario that's okay that is just like oh he looks jewish that's just so jewish very jewish you get
00:57:14.020 to a level of being jewish that you get the funky colored glasses yeah it like shows up one morning
00:57:20.660 and then you have them yeah he's on the brink of having orange frames but so there's a few things
00:57:29.380 going on here and i've gotten into some debates with people the other day i had a legendary crash
00:57:36.660 out on sean wyland in one in a group chat sean wyland who we've had on the show before but like
00:57:43.220 i had to leave i was getting because he's of the mind he's he's an older he's gen x not that much 0.96
00:57:49.060 older highly skeptical of ai he's one of these people that says his phrase is it's a pig and a
00:57:54.980 poke he's always saying it's a pig and a poke a pig and a poke which just me it what it means is
00:58:01.460 something is being accepted without any evidence like it's just you're being sold a bill of guns 0.99
00:58:08.420 you're it's bullshit he's saying it's bullshit saying it's all a scam he's saying that all it 0.99
00:58:14.020 does is like repeat what you say back to you you get it like what is intelligence and i'm trying 1.00
00:58:20.820 to build this into what we're just talking about and a lot of people are talking about this interview
00:58:25.700 with sam altman who runs open ai and uh he he was people were misquoting him or at least i believe
00:58:34.980 they were because they were saying that he was saying we can lose control of ai in the next few
00:58:42.740 years it's that ai doomerism it's going to be skynet it's going to be it's going to go rogue
00:58:49.380 can destroy all of our systems but if the actual quote was we will lose control of the future of
00:58:55.800 ai which is a purely political point and it makes sense if you know where he's coming from and he
00:59:02.340 in subsequent questions and answers he says you know we're the good guys by we he means
00:59:09.900 the west and specifically silicon valley technocrats he says we're on the side of humanity
00:59:15.960 we can't let the future of ai be dictated by the bad guys who are the bad guys well he could be in
00:59:23.560 china he can mean russia he actually could mean anyone that's the point how about how about he
00:59:27.320 means people with home servers people with you know yeah yeah yeah this is the same as any other
00:59:33.220 industry when they they're you know first to market and they build a moat the very next thing
00:59:38.020 they do is they petition the government to make sure that no competitors can ever approach them
00:59:42.380 Yeah. And some people are saying that they are inflating the concerns of an AI going rogue because that legitimizes it.
00:59:52.280 It makes it seem scarier than it is. But if it's scary, it's more real. And I understand that.
00:59:58.320 So a few posts have been put out by your team this week.
01:00:01.660 And one of them was from a new nonprofit board member on your safety and security council who basically said,
01:00:06.440 if we build superintelligence without more robust alignment, I expect we will permanently lose control of it.
01:00:11.600 And if that happens, then most people could die.
01:00:14.080 This is your new nonprofit board member who's now on your safety and security council saying that if things don't change, that could be problematic.
01:00:21.140 No one knows what alignment means.
01:00:22.340 No one knows what control means even.
01:00:24.460 What is this moment that Paul is saying that about?
01:00:26.380 I think a key principle that we should all agree on is that we cannot take actions that would risk losing control of the future to AI.
01:00:35.900 And then this is a point that even Sean made.
01:00:38.300 Amazing.
01:00:38.660 And to his credit, it's like, don't just listen to what these guys are saying.
01:00:42.940 And I'm like, fair enough.
01:00:44.580 If they're saying it to a reporter and it's in the news,
01:00:47.860 it's because they want you to know what it is, right?
01:00:50.300 I get that, right?
01:00:52.060 But I'll give you, there's this one story that happened just this week,
01:00:56.460 where the story was that, again, an AI went rogue.
01:01:03.300 An unprecedented AI security incident.
01:01:06.020 The chat GPT creator, OpenAI, says two of its models
01:01:10.660 escaped controls and successfully hacked
01:01:13.200 into another AI company.
01:01:14.960 OpenAI says they are, the way they describe it,
01:01:17.460 is responding accordingly.
01:01:19.180 But they also say this involves state-of-the-art technology
01:01:21.780 and is unprecedented. 0.97
01:01:24.300 Some people were saying that was all fucking made up. 0.97
01:01:26.560 It was all PR to legitimize AI. 0.96
01:01:29.860 And I read the story and I said, well, it's not fake.
01:01:32.420 Here's what happened.
01:01:34.380 The cyber attacks did happen, and there was an AI agent doing it.
01:01:41.360 They're saying the reason was because they were running a test of some kind,
01:01:46.260 and then they gave it a prompt to try and hack within the sandbox,
01:01:50.960 and it took it literally and broke containment and did it for real.
01:01:55.280 So it was down to human error.
01:01:57.600 It didn't go, it kind of went rogue.
01:02:00.440 But what do you mean by going rogue?
01:02:02.020 see what i'm saying when the objective that you gave it was to perform a crime but a crime within
01:02:08.800 the box and then it got smart enough to get out of the box well i mean it's like you told it you
01:02:14.820 told it to do that you know you train train your dog to bite people and then there's a hole in the 1.00
01:02:18.860 fence and it bites the neighbor oh who could have predicted this maybe you don't train your fucking 0.99
01:02:22.380 people to bite people it's like it didn't act on its own a hundred percent but it kind of did like 0.99
01:02:28.180 40%. See what I'm saying?
01:02:30.220 So it's like when we talk about intelligence, this is a debate
01:02:32.300 we got into. We're talking about
01:02:34.120 AGI. That's what they're
01:02:36.420 working towards.
01:02:38.020 Artificial general intelligence. What is
01:02:40.280 that? We really need to have a conversation
01:02:42.560 about what intelligence is.
01:02:44.640 And the problem is that
01:02:45.740 most of these CEOs and anyone
01:02:48.300 involved in this conversation
01:02:49.500 has a different definition of what it
01:02:52.360 is. And the ultimate question is
01:02:54.280 how would you
01:02:56.220 know you've achieved
01:02:58.020 agi from looking at it how do you actually know because some people again define it just as skynet
01:03:05.140 we won't know that we've achieved agi until it's god-like and threatening our existence okay that's
01:03:12.980 one definition sam altman's definition is i want to create a robot assistant for you that can kind
01:03:19.620 of think like a person they're a helper so his is very restricted but then everyone else has
01:03:24.580 something in between those two my definition of agi you have to we just did all this work on
01:03:31.540 hermeneutics here's here's a tangent and this is something i got into it with sean about which is
01:03:38.180 he was saying that okay look at how llms work all an llm does is like it kind of it runs a
01:03:45.300 probability matrix on what the next word is going to be and it runs a predictive model like it's
01:03:50.180 guessing what the next thing in the sequence is going to be and then waiting against what happened
01:03:54.940 before and i said okay i know to a lot of people that sounds strange and random but listeners of
01:04:02.080 blood satellite will know that as the hermeneutic cycle that's actually how all human beings read
01:04:08.360 process and understand information there's kind of a predictive model that we all use to anticipate
01:04:13.660 what's coming and then we internalize it like we're and this is sort of like uh heidegger's
01:04:19.400 Dasein like there's something ahead of us that's anticipating and dry anyway I won't get into it
01:04:24.160 but it's just ironic that it seems to me that they designed these AIs to think in a profoundly
01:04:33.080 human way but everyone thinks it's just random but if you actually look at me this is how human
01:04:39.180 beings think and then the question was like can I like what is intelligence okay so they think what
01:04:47.080 these companies are trying to do is make a human intelligence i don't think they've ever really
01:04:51.480 said that i don't think that's possible i don't think they want to i think what they're trying to
01:04:57.240 do is is ask the question what is what does isolated intelligence look like like what is that
01:05:02.040 how you define that it has no sensory inputs that is not embodied in the world it's just a 0.98
01:05:06.760 fucking mind in a box how will you know what's intelligence and you can talk about rationality 0.98
01:05:12.520 but to me what separates you know human consciousness it's the ability for a mind to 1.00
01:05:19.440 consider itself can't does it possess the ability to independently think about itself and think about
01:05:25.880 how it thinks and just be extremely contextual based on that and almost like ruminate on how it
01:05:33.040 ruminates like that's that's that's distinct to humans i'm like i think you'll know you achieved
01:05:38.220 agi when it can do that when it has self-awareness and it can sort of consider itself and there's an
01:05:43.740 inwardness that develops like that's it now is that achievable i think so i don't think you're 0.94
01:05:50.720 asking people ask will it have a soul it doesn't need to have a fucking soul we're asking if it 0.90
01:05:54.500 can just be isolated intelligence that has the capability to like self-awareness that alone is 0.98
01:06:01.960 that possible i i think so what do you think i look i don't know the self-awareness thing will
01:06:08.860 always be elusive i don't i can't imagine a way that we could determine that as far as as agi goes
01:06:15.340 i think we've already forgotten where the standard was 10 years ago because any llm like gpt2 was agi
01:06:24.820 to somebody in 2005 right i think it's kind of a god of the gaps thing where
01:06:30.260 we could like 10 years from now we might have stuff that's on many metrics is way smarter and
01:06:36.820 way more capable than a person but there's certain specific things that it can't do that
01:06:41.820 we can do and we're going to be redefining being like well if it could do this it would probably
01:06:46.260 be more human but this is not right so you're right that comparing it to human intelligence
01:06:51.040 is already kind of playing the wrong game it's interesting to hear that the guys are attempting
01:06:56.720 to their day like if they want to make it or if you you believe they want to make it an isolated
01:07:01.520 like utilitarian intelligence i would under i would understand that like you know in terms of
01:07:07.200 just pleasing your shareholders that makes sense and also that's what they have been building like
01:07:12.420 they haven't they haven't actually been building age like i i work with a company that is using
01:07:18.120 artificial intelligence in industry and i'm assuming other other companies doing it the
01:07:22.280 same way we are we are which is it's extremely narrow it's extremely narrow like anybody if
01:07:27.320 the extent that it's general it's because you want to generalize externalities to the very narrow
01:07:33.240 set of tasks that you have a job or you know what i mean like we're doing a certain task
01:07:39.560 and we want to build around that task so i get it that yeah i don't know man i don't know i wish
01:07:45.720 they would honestly i wish that i like the i like the uh uh the the leaker guy who's 0.55
01:07:52.740 the fucking guy's name the guy that we're just talking about yeah jacob cox or something i wish 0.59
01:07:59.920 we had somebody come out to tell us what they are actually doing rather than to come out and say oh 0.99
01:08:06.180 my god guys i'm scared i'm scared you wouldn't believe what's behind the curtain okay dude tell
01:08:10.020 us what's behind the curtain because we actually want to know then what do you what do you actually
01:08:14.360 scared what do you see tell me tell us what you saw tell us what it is what does it look like
01:08:17.940 because to me that's the tell that this is part of somebody else's game not necessarily that he
01:08:23.180 works for anthropic or or open ai but that he's part of some other large party that has a motive
01:08:29.300 and they're trying to tell you what they want you to hear because if you were really afraid of
01:08:33.100 something like you're trying to tell me that there's a dragon right you're going to tell me
01:08:36.740 what the dragon looks like and when it's coming and where it's coming from and what it you know 0.96
01:08:41.720 what i can do they're like no something terrifying like it's the fucking king of vague posting over 0.77
01:08:46.740 here yeah because even with conspiracy theory stuff when we were reading behold of a pale 0.85
01:08:52.440 horse by william cooper i paid close attention to how specific he was in recounting certain
01:08:58.980 anecdotes and he would conveniently gloss over the details of them the parts where aliens were
01:09:04.340 involved so it's like these exact executives are scared like okay tell me a conversation you had 0.63
01:09:10.900 or one you heard when you were in the men's room taking a piss
01:09:14.200 and you heard a guy on a phone, like, put me there.
01:09:16.460 What are you talking about?
01:09:18.200 Dude, they're scared.
01:09:19.240 It could kill us all in 10 years.
01:09:21.540 I'm like, I mean, it could, but not indirectly.
01:09:23.880 This is what I was saying.
01:09:25.020 And by the way, I'd love to hear your thoughts on this
01:09:26.900 because when we talk about the future, the state of play in 10 years,
01:09:33.580 we always talk about AI, but we don't really talk about robotics.
01:09:38.020 And to me, those are part and parcel.
01:09:39.920 yeah i mean even the whole skynet thing like skynet's from terminator the scary part about
01:09:46.060 skynet was not skynet it was that skynet enabled robots to do bad things right that it's the 0.89
01:09:53.160 combination of skynet and robots but we don't have the fucking robots we almost do but we don't
01:09:58.520 and ai is enabling us to make robotics faster that's the trade that i'm in right now but 0.75
01:10:03.560 we're not at the point where if skynet like people were joking about it there was there
01:10:08.220 was some date to do with the terminator movies like last week or something um the date that
01:10:11.880 skynet became active and they're joking but like oh tonight's the night like well it's not the
01:10:16.580 night because we don't have like armies of robots that are physically capable of standing up that
01:10:22.860 date it's not like it was nostradamus it was james cameron who wrote that and he's alive
01:10:28.540 and you can ask him hey did that mean anything no he's a pretty fucking well-spoken direct guy like 0.89
01:10:37.280 just go ask him it's not fucking like a myan calendar you assholes exactly but like to me 0.97
01:10:43.520 i was talking to these people and we're talking about ai and how disruptive it is because it has 0.98
01:10:48.240 revolutionized every workflow from everyone that's in my world right now and like it's put a lot of
01:10:55.320 people that i know out of work we talked about this on the show before we were looking at that
01:10:59.220 report from like the canadian construction alliance where there's blue collar workers
01:11:04.780 who think that this won't touch them and it might not touch them as deeply as white collar work but
01:11:13.960 it seems that the leadership in your world is trying to integrate ai they would love for the
01:11:21.500 same reason like i look at ai as just the latest link in a long chain of just automation yes it's
01:11:28.520 automation it's a drive to do everything faster and cheaper this is just a way to do that now 0.64
01:11:33.240 but that's been the way it's been trending for fucking and again what i said a minute ago 0.53
01:11:37.820 we're viewing ai as revolutionary and it is revolutionary but don't act like it's special 0.87
01:11:42.380 because automation generally when we got the first automated factories 50 60 years ago people were
01:11:49.240 saying this is the end of the factory worker and to some extent it was you know like it got took
01:11:53.420 away a lot of factory jobs but there were limits to what it can do and and even those machines were
01:11:58.420 dumb they're all pre-programmed so you have the quote-unquote edge computing of a human brain
01:12:02.680 that's still able to solve problems that the machine that's pre-programmed can't. 0.99
01:12:06.160 Well, if the only difference between AI and a dumb robot is that it can think on the fly,
01:12:11.540 we've had AI since the late 80s. 0.99
01:12:13.680 It's all over the fucking place. 0.98
01:12:15.300 It's just an algorithm that allows it to react to stimuli. 0.98
01:12:18.700 It's not on Rails.
01:12:19.480 It has a couple of options it can choose.
01:12:20.980 The thing with LLMs is the options it can choose are such a big array of options
01:12:26.340 that it becomes a black box to a human operator.
01:12:28.880 we can't look at its array of options and understand it's inscrutable to us that doesn't 0.91
01:12:33.820 mean it isn't just a fucking arrayed list of options it essentially is it's actually pretty
01:12:37.420 easy to make animal level intelligence and someone like sean or others would deny that they say they 0.74
01:12:43.660 can't do that but i'm like no boston dynamics does that they can make a robot that can behave like a
01:12:49.300 fucking deer right you know and the problem is would be equating it directly to a deer or to a 0.92
01:12:54.420 dog like if you want to look at boston amex you know you know little dog or whatever like spot 0.99
01:12:58.320 and just say oh well yeah but a little dog would lick me and it would slip sleep with me and it 0.99
01:13:02.860 would it would fetch a but well no but this isn't a fucking dog it's an animal with equivalent 0.99
01:13:06.920 isolated intelligence yeah that can reason and take new information and contextualize information 1.00
01:13:14.260 with llm edge computing on a spot you're a thousand times smarter than a fucking golden 0.98
01:13:18.700 retriever so don't make that argument like it's apples and oranges i was explaining to people 0.97
01:13:22.800 like how disruptive it is as i was saying and like i might not have a job in two three years
01:13:27.640 and i'm trying to get ahead of that right now but it's it's blue collar workers will laugh
01:13:32.620 at white collar guys being out of a job but i'm thinking it's if they can make it come for your
01:13:39.080 job they will because it's just this larger conversation we've been having about effectively 0.92
01:13:44.700 attacking labor about putting people out of work that don't need to fucking be there anymore 0.98
01:13:49.000 and that's that's your boss that's that's old white guys too it's not just jews that's the 0.99
01:13:54.660 unfortunate reality here i know you happen to know a few guys who would you know fucking 1.00
01:13:59.880 heritage canadian white guys who would love to fire half their fucking crew if they could 0.99
01:14:06.440 if that technology existed and they're agitating whoever they can to give that to them but i said 0.99
01:14:12.820 here's an example it's not going to happen all at once let's talk about parking enforcement officers
01:14:18.760 that's a job how many parking enforcement officers are there tens of
01:14:23.440 thousands in Canada America wherever so let's say they get a $300 drone with
01:14:30.160 rudimentary AI and 360 degree camera and it just takes photos of license plate
01:14:37.080 flies along the side of the road of any urban area takes photos it can tell if
01:14:42.700 you have a ticket and if it doesn't then it assigns it signs you a fine a
01:14:46.660 penalty and you just put 40 000 people out of work for a relatively cheap drone i i said look
01:14:53.180 at the look at the proliferation of drones in warfare that happened fucking fast and there's 0.99
01:14:58.940 many different types of drones there's the high altitude drones that could fuck when you talk 0.98
01:15:04.540 about a drone strike that's what you're talking about then there's all these in russia and ukraine
01:15:09.100 all these you know more haphazardly designed drones there's a lot of different types of drones and 0.97
01:15:14.760 and some of them have AI, some of them fucking don't.
01:15:17.760 But just imagine all the jobs that can be completely replaced 0.96
01:15:22.520 with minimal investment on the robotics front
01:15:25.900 and minimal investment on the AI front.
01:15:27.720 And here's what I was trying to get at,
01:15:29.200 I just talked about blue collar and white collar.
01:15:31.720 There's no unity amongst us. 0.95
01:15:34.340 Every blue collar guy or most of them would laugh 0.87
01:15:38.400 if all these white collar people were out of a job. 0.64
01:15:41.280 They would love nerds to be homeless. 0.65
01:15:43.900 probably laughing at it right now just fantasizing about it and i ask you if they said every single
01:15:51.060 government employee just got replaced by a couple robots and mostly ai i bet we would all celebrate 0.90
01:15:59.000 yeah of course yes haas but it's like we're everyone hates everyone's job you white man you
01:16:07.300 father mother would you march to defend the dmv would you the ministry of transportation
01:16:13.660 you know you wouldn't but that's the same for everyone everyone kind of wants everyone to have 0.98
01:16:18.220 a fucking job and that's how this thing nudges its way there at the basement level of that though 0.94
01:16:23.640 that's just the that's just like the bones of the label labor market right like if you think of the 0.99
01:16:29.520 idea that fucking i'll lose lose my thought here but like people are people um people want to make
01:16:38.440 their own work worth more they want to talk about how indispensable they are and they want to make 0.89
01:16:43.920 everybody else's work worth less just just very generally right i don't think that will ever
01:16:49.960 change and i think that's playing into the same attitude here yeah but i was more saying like this
01:16:55.980 is how it happens i was telling them i'm like it starts small starts with jobs like the the nudge
01:17:01.100 units of the system as we know it getting rid of a few here and there and by the time and then it
01:17:06.740 doesn't need to be 100 let's say you automate 40 of jobs right that's cataclysmic like with
01:17:14.100 the parking meters maybe you need to have a few officers that can talk through the drones right
01:17:18.200 but you don't need a thousand officers now you have a hundred of them yeah and they just are
01:17:22.080 drone operators and and that's pretty fucking significant just for the labor market for people
01:17:26.560 who can put a roof over their family's heads like that changes a lot just changing every industry by 0.55
01:17:32.940 30 percent is a tectonic shift and and that's where it's had and it seems to me that everyone
01:17:40.300 involved in the decision-making process here wants it across every field across every industry
01:17:46.560 they just they want more so it's forget the tech companies themselves they're of course involved 0.72
01:17:54.360 but it seems that they've got buy-in from fucking everyone right at the director executive or 0.65
01:18:01.180 ownership or founder level so it's like you know it's because one of my friends tr hudson he was 0.79
01:18:07.260 like i would expect some pushbacks there's got to be some kind of resistance i'm like i'm so far
01:18:12.440 past expecting any resistance and i just you know this will out me as a cold head old droon
01:18:20.280 but not long ago maybe it was long ago 10 years edward snowden came out and gave you
01:18:29.340 firm evidence explicit evidence that your government is spying on you through your
01:18:35.880 phones your phone is a spy machine for the government and no one did anything no one 0.85
01:18:42.520 cared every schizophrenic from decades past was proven right you said the government's spying 0.91
01:18:48.440 on you through your phone and they would get laughed at they were all proven we live in a 0.96
01:18:53.160 schizophrenic society no one did anything that would have been the time there's so many rubicons
01:18:59.040 that were crossed like i i call it blackpilled or whatever you want but i'm like no one's 0.75
01:19:04.480 if they if they start like destroying the jobs no one's gonna do anything
01:19:09.440 they're just so apathetic they don't know what to do they people have been primed to accept
01:19:14.400 this sort of thing and that's why you have even conservatives now entertaining universal basic
01:19:20.000 income like this this is so bad people don't even want to look at it i don't think most people can
01:19:26.720 even glance at how huge
01:19:28.860 this problem is and how 1.00
01:19:30.680 fucked up it is. Just look at the politics 1.00
01:19:32.620 of this. How many young Republicans
01:19:34.780 or conservatives are like, well, I don't see
01:19:36.700 a way out of this except for free money
01:19:38.620 because there's going to be no jobs.
01:19:40.380 These aren't just skit freaks like us.
01:19:43.500 There's one thing that
01:19:44.560 doesn't get talked about a lot is whether
01:19:46.540 or not, like they're charting this
01:19:48.640 course where
01:19:49.580 AI has begun
01:19:52.640 to take over people's roles and you're
01:19:54.660 just plotting that into the future with a straight line
01:19:56.640 and saying it will continue forever
01:19:58.160 to take over everybody's roles
01:19:59.540 until nobody has work anymore.
01:20:01.300 Without looking at the exponentially increasing cost
01:20:04.780 and weight and stress on the economy,
01:20:07.320 on the supply chain, on social cohesion, 1.00
01:20:10.080 there will be black swans.
01:20:11.580 There will be other breaks in that line.
01:20:13.240 I'm not saying it won't happen,
01:20:14.760 but it's kind of silly to look at
01:20:16.880 how rapidly it has started to change things.
01:20:19.920 And look, obviously it's changed
01:20:22.120 as much as it's changed right now.
01:20:23.500 And there's already this much stress socially.
01:20:25.480 imagine how much stress there will be when it does replace 20 of us or 30 of us or 40 of us 0.99
01:20:31.280 and then beyond that this whole thing about hyperscalers sucking down every three and four
01:20:35.880 nanometer chip in the universe 10 years into the market right 10 years into the future and then
01:20:42.420 the water and the chemicals and the construction equipment and them having to buy off entire
01:20:47.140 communities like i don't i'll be my prediction majority of the hyperscalers will never complete
01:20:53.500 their projects and if there is any kind of crash it will take ai it won't stop ai but it's going
01:20:59.900 to back it off to a reasonable level and you're i was one thing i'll predict is i think i think
01:21:05.840 you'll see a time in the near future where it's no longer possible for chuds like you and me to
01:21:11.280 use it and it's essentially it's an enterprise platform and it costs 15 times more because
01:21:17.080 you're paying the actual price because these companies are no longer living on credit and
01:21:22.180 dreams right yeah i was thinking about this the other day it's almost too good right now
01:21:27.520 the amount to get everybody hooked on it the amount you can accomplish even with just video
01:21:33.300 editing video production creating animations for an astonishingly low cost and low time
01:21:41.340 commitment like you can produce very good looking stuff if you've got a bit of sense there's a lot
01:21:46.880 of people who make slop but if you know what you're asking for and you got the time you can
01:21:50.620 make some really cool shit for not that much money which is i can't imagine that let's do that 0.95
01:21:57.120 forever like like they're gonna eventually close it's it's too easy for people to make cool shit 0.89
01:22:02.580 right now it kind of feels like the early internet and they haven't figured out how to lock the wrong
01:22:07.820 people out which which is what they are talking about doing well and like i said i think what's
01:22:12.560 going on right now you know remember the initial models were essentially free like they i mean they
01:22:16.720 are still free right like you can log in and use this stuff for free it's just they're using the
01:22:20.180 old models like that there's no reason for them to do that other than it's a fresh you know it's
01:22:25.860 a blue ocean market and they're trying to gobble up as much market share before the whole earth is
01:22:32.220 painted right once the whole earth is painted with one color or another then they're gonna
01:22:37.060 clam up on it it was funny there's that famous paul krugman line that everyone you know refreshes
01:22:44.940 every so often about and paraphrasing here he says people within a few years people realize that the
01:22:50.740 internet was about as consequential as a fax machine this is saying this in 1998 1999 people
01:22:57.800 like to laugh at him but i've never seen that of course he was incorrect with that but i was also
01:23:04.420 thinking was the fax machine not important to business like i think when the fax machine came
01:23:10.380 out that in itself was a pretty big revolution the ability to send documents instantaneously across
01:23:16.780 the world yeah yeah i was just thinking about that where it's like even now we laugh at a fax
01:23:20.680 machine but i'm like no keep this all within context a lot of the stuff what changed how we
01:23:25.600 do business forever when it happened so yeah like the ai thing like we will be dealing with
01:23:31.820 the ramifications of this look at it this way the fax machine was so revolutionary that the only
01:23:37.100 thing that could ever unseat it was the fucking internet yeah yeah it got us used to that's how 0.73
01:23:43.860 we got memes yeah back in the day and i think you talking about like the early like the cowboy years 0.97
01:23:48.520 of the internet is probably pretty accurate i think we're gonna look back on these days 0.77
01:23:53.000 you know with rose tinted glasses about how nice it was to be able to fuck around and make memes 0.62
01:23:58.620 um it's not that ai is going away it's not going anywhere pandora's box is open but i think it's 0.99
01:24:04.520 going to get hobbled and it's going to get clamped and it's going to get way more expensive
01:24:07.820 and it's going to become something that dominates your life but you no longer are a part of right
01:24:13.600 now we're all part of this conversation we all get to use it we're all making money off of it
01:24:17.460 or we're doing productive things at least i hope most of us are but i think the the years of that
01:24:22.960 are limited we're probably halfway through that period already yeah as i talk about a bubble
01:24:28.260 bursting that's and here's the thing about bubbles is that that only really that's only transitory
01:24:36.020 for financiers people getting their money in and out usually when a bubble bursts we're left with
01:24:41.620 the consequences of it bursting forever like nothing's been the same since the financial
01:24:47.060 crisis of oh wait right that changed everything forever like every time there's a bubble burst
01:24:52.660 like everything gets kind of worse and worse also sorry no no keep on keep on i was gonna say like
01:24:58.340 i keep thinking about the supply chain side of it like you know it's for us we view it as just
01:25:03.540 it's an application that you open on your computer so you've installed something you put your credit
01:25:07.380 card number in and then you can use it right but there is an enormous physical and energy
01:25:11.940 infrastructure component to this industry and it's not doing well right they're they're papering over
01:25:18.340 the problems with it as it exists today so if you expect that this thing is going to increase
01:25:23.740 a hundredfold in the next 30 years without any hiccups i think you've got another thing coming
01:25:29.760 and i think it's if there were any major geopolitical black swan like for example who
01:25:34.280 fucking knows what's going on right now with iran and ukraine russia and taiwan like if there were 0.98
01:25:39.460 a major supply chain disruption and i mean trump's doing it to himself with the fucking tariffs 0.99
01:25:44.160 uh like if there's if there's a if there's stress on the u.s energy grid for example 0.98
01:25:49.880 you're gonna have you're gonna have fucking outages then you're gonna have like the like
01:25:55.000 i forget what it is but like the amount of energy that these the existing data is not future ones 0.88
01:25:59.140 existing data centers use of the u.s grid is already enormous so like based on what i've heard
01:26:05.680 from anarchists and other revolutionary minded people the power grid is the easiest pain point
01:26:14.200 to strike like they always tell you like you can take down a city's electricity if you just attack
01:26:20.440 one little substation the americans are nuking their own power grid trump is rather the trump
01:26:26.000 administration is by blowing up trade relationships with other third parties on whom they depend for
01:26:33.980 transformers and power transmission
01:26:36.460 technology and all kinds of things.
01:26:38.280 Look, I know they're in a push right now to
01:26:40.240 reshore everything, but they're
01:26:42.280 in the middle of that. They haven't actually completed
01:26:44.280 it yet. As it stands, most of this shit 1.00
01:26:46.380 but the majority of their fucking power 1.00
01:26:48.160 infrastructure comes from abroad. Not from us, 1.00
01:26:50.280 but like from China and wherever.
01:26:53.660 China.
01:26:54.500 China. Now, we don't 0.99
01:26:56.160 have a lot of time to cover this book, unfortunately.
01:26:58.700 There's actually two books on one.
01:27:00.240 One book and one
01:27:02.340 paper.
01:27:03.980 that I thought was a book when it was sent to me and I got ready, you know, I'm licking my chops
01:27:10.660 and it was just like a three-page paper. But I wanted to talk about double entry accounting.
01:27:16.340 You're an entrepreneur. I'm sure you know all about accounting. I'm talking about sort of the
01:27:23.060 psychological and spiritual consequences of the development of money in the early Greek world.
01:27:29.060 and we're sort of telling the story of capitalism in a sense i don't even like using that word
01:27:36.540 although i wouldn't deny that capitalism exists it's not in the form that a lot of marxists now
01:27:42.760 would claim that it is but um it's like the many many episodes ago we talked about the history of
01:27:49.540 stock market and specifically stock speculation and you know what's the history there what does
01:27:57.120 mean how to develop over centuries and I wanted to take a look I don't know much about double
01:28:03.800 entry accounting but just like the previous coverage we did on money and the early Greek
01:28:09.220 mind it's about the knock-on effects and the reverberations that happen all throughout society
01:28:16.960 when these economic not even theories but these economic innovations occur so how how does this
01:28:27.100 change you know let's see how does this affect the understanding of debt and a
01:28:34.480 more advanced understanding of debt might impact the spirituality of the
01:28:41.220 city-states and you know a recontextualization of someone being
01:28:45.760 owed something are you being in debt to someone like these ideas don't just 0.93
01:28:51.160 stop at economics you know if someone says it's the economy stupid i'll say it's not just the
01:28:57.960 economy it's nothing just the economy this is all intertwined and so there's this idea of double 0.92
01:29:04.140 entry accounting and i'm getting this out the way at the start was if i had to just summarize what
01:29:11.340 we're going to talk about very briefly i would say that it's this interesting idea about
01:29:16.000 accountability it's about how bad accounting was for most of human
01:29:23.140 history especially in Europe is very sloppy. I set out to write a book about
01:29:27.760 how accounting and states worked and I ended up sort of writing a book about
01:29:32.320 that but also how it constantly failed over and over again I thought this might
01:29:38.380 be a cultural tradition and so I sort of kept digging and I went to Louis the
01:29:45.800 14th and it was the same thing he became fascinated by accounting he learned accounting he had his
01:29:51.080 minister colbert um create golden account books for more than 20 years that he kept in his pocket
01:29:57.560 but when uh you know his accounts went bad during the wars in the building of versailles
01:30:02.760 he stopped it too so this was a sort of amazing thing you know we talked about this in a previous
01:30:08.280 book i think it might have been the transformation of the public sphere and it's talking about the
01:30:13.080 development of the bourgeoisie throughout all throughout europe and how living in in a feudal
01:30:19.800 society what that was like you know being a subject of a manner and uh there it was speaking
01:30:27.240 about how like and we would hear that people back then these peasants these these workers 1.00
01:30:34.280 these laborers like they they worked less than we work now they paid less taxes that is true
01:30:40.280 like you would pay not that much to the owner of the estate and further that you know the lord
01:30:49.800 would constantly lie about here's how much i produced on the farm and i'll give you my taxes
01:30:56.680 and based on that and like it was just bad accounting and everyone was in it for themselves
01:31:01.400 everyone was lying all the time and there was no check or balance there it was just as long as
01:31:05.880 stuff was being sent towards the center of power they they'd you know they can probably send they'd
01:31:11.960 send tax collectors but no one's going over books what books the books are whatever you write in
01:31:17.240 them right so we didn't have these more complex transactions like we do right now a lot of it was
01:31:24.840 just based on your word and maybe you just don't want to pay taxes that month you could just do
01:31:29.720 that right now then you could just stab people and not pay taxes and now we that all we all we
01:31:37.160 yearn for is that wouldn't be great to stab people and not pay taxes that's all i care about
01:31:42.200 politically nice um so anyway it's about the change of markets and the development of trade
01:31:47.640 and in a future episode we're going to get into the story of this book called global calvinism
01:31:53.960 about the fusion of religion and economics in in that instance in the form of calvinism and
01:32:02.120 so the the birth of this like the protestant work ethic like you have this this synergizing
01:32:08.840 of economics and like labor and the development of labor theory and how spirituality justifies
01:32:15.960 that because at one time accounting was seen as like a lesser thing and so it was rare that it
01:32:22.440 it was taken seriously um anyway so i'll just start by here so there's this paper i had called
01:32:28.040 markets and the spontaneous emergence of double entry accounting he says markets had languished
01:32:36.760 in europe following the fall of the western roman empire in the fifth century most europeans lived
01:32:42.600 and worked the land in small manners which were largely self-sufficient albeit at a low standard
01:32:48.280 of living. Serfs were bound legally to the land and traveled by peasants outside the manors was
01:32:53.920 rare as was trade. The 10th century marks the beginning of a long period of almost unbroken
01:33:00.080 economic expansion of the Mediterranean peoples, an expansion of production and consumption in
01:33:06.860 the home market of overseas trade to the commercially advanced regions and of land
01:33:12.820 commerce over formerly stagnant areas. It says, in the European manorial system that preceded the
01:33:20.920 remarkable surge in market activity in the Middle Ages, manorial law gave peasants and serfs
01:33:25.920 fundamental rights such as protection, the use of land, and housing. Many such rights were
01:33:31.280 enforceable in the manorial courts. There was no return obligation for the manner to fulfill
01:33:36.640 at the time of receipt and none to record these were one-sided conscriptions not market transactions
01:33:44.000 uh this guy named littleton commented that many antecedents antecedents uh that would need be in
01:33:51.740 place for double entry recording to be practiced these include the development of reading writing
01:33:57.060 arithmetic and an accepted currency in the existence of private property rights commerce
01:34:01.000 and merchant class so he's basically saying that you didn't see the emergence of proper record
01:34:06.920 keeping because no one most people didn't know how to keep records some many of them were literate
01:34:12.680 they didn't have an accounts book a lot of this was duty bound and even when we were talking about
01:34:18.840 money in the early greek mind we were talking about like the idea of a transaction was a bit
01:34:24.520 different you know it was based it was more of a barter system it was more duty bound there
01:34:29.080 were different types of transactions but the transactions were originally defined as forms
01:34:34.440 of gift giving and but it wasn't the idea of like i want to pay you money for something it was more
01:34:40.120 like here's a reward for a thing you did or here's a tribute or things like that and you started to
01:34:46.760 see with the emergence of money and currency the development of oh i can use this the idea of an
01:34:53.320 exchange of just like a pure transaction it was like a new thing so anyway like he's saying that
01:35:00.040 the idea the desire for record keeping just simply didn't exist for most of human history
01:35:07.080 um you would see it in like ports in a very rudimentary form like you had very very basic
01:35:13.080 arithmetic but the idea of accountability was you know like you you would want to just record kind
01:35:24.360 of what happened but that was the consequence for your recording it wrong you know there was no way
01:35:29.240 to prove it so there's like you were just doing a thing to prove that things are happening right
01:35:34.120 or someone might get you in trouble if you lie about sending the wrong amount of something but 0.59
01:35:38.360 But other than that, there's no fucking reason to, like, keep accurate records at all.
01:35:42.700 Like, the idea of having accurate records was itself an innovation. 0.70
01:35:48.020 I just thought that was interesting.
01:35:50.160 Yeah, it was only as accurate as you needed it to be for your own purposes.
01:35:53.780 It wasn't something people were going to check.
01:35:56.640 Yeah, and where the book goes is we start, especially whoever the monarch or emperor or king was at the time,
01:36:05.000 they would have like a court accountant and they started finding that if you were able to keep good
01:36:12.280 records you you were able to thrive more economically like they just by trial and error
01:36:20.040 the class what we're discussing are the two financial bubbles of 1720 the mississippi
01:36:25.400 bubble in france and the south sea bubble in mainland like today they were sort of pyramid
01:36:30.280 schemes and what happens is that one society is able to reform itself financially and that's
01:36:36.580 England and a lot of that is because they have a very active accounting culture and
01:36:41.420 even in the executive branches of the government, the Prime Minister Sir Robert Walpole is a
01:36:46.180 skilled accountant and he comes up with these schemes to do what I call the first bailout.
01:36:51.740 Walpole allows a few people to get the blame for this but mostly he protects the elite
01:36:58.280 and protects people's investments,
01:37:00.060 and he stabilizes the markets.
01:37:02.440 Beautiful, okay?
01:37:04.640 But Walpole's also an accountant, he's a wily guy.
01:37:07.760 But here you have this great accountant prime minister
01:37:09.960 who saves Britain, pulls it out of its first financial crisis,
01:37:13.620 and then uses those same skills
01:37:15.620 to start doing backroom slush funds
01:37:18.220 and undermining accountability and transparency.
01:37:21.320 And also there was, you see with the French Revolution,
01:37:24.540 like there was more of a demand from the people
01:37:27.760 for the aristocracy or the uh the throne as it were to to reveal their books like people just
01:37:35.960 wanted to know like what are you what are you spending your money on and for a long time they
01:37:41.040 didn't do it then you saw the french revolution that's what that was about and but you saw other 0.99
01:37:45.840 you know dissident movements going on throughout europe at the time like just open your fucking 0.98
01:37:51.260 books where's this money going where are you spending how are you spending our money 0.99
01:37:55.320 And then they would do it, and they'd say, I hate this. 0.99
01:38:00.460 Glad I asked, because this sucks. 1.00
01:38:02.680 Yeah, this sucks. 0.98
01:38:03.260 So the book that I'll talk about now is called The Reckoning, Financial Accountability and the Rise and Fall of Nations. 0.94
01:38:11.980 So that's really the story that he's trying to tell here, going from the ancient world and Athens and the Norman Conquest,
01:38:23.100 and goes goes through the french revolution goes into london it goes all over the place and shows
01:38:30.220 you know historical precedent for what he's talking about here but uh it's it's like the
01:38:34.700 psychological development of accountability and therefore agency and you know even nietzsche
01:38:42.860 talked about this in the book the genealogy of morals which is what we're going to be
01:38:48.540 covering on do you even read next week but it's like the idea of he's like he he said you can't
01:38:56.380 really separate the idea of doing something good from debt like at the base of this it's it's the
01:39:03.100 evolution of this concept of debt you owe someone something you do something you owe them something
01:39:08.140 in return and the shame that's associated with that and the punishment that's associated with
01:39:13.500 that but underneath all this is like the changing understanding of what debt is and and the
01:39:20.620 increasing severity of being in debt to someone and the consequences of that and what and what
01:39:27.740 does that understanding cause as a result so moving on here he says for thousands of years
01:39:33.680 the ancient world was steeped in accounts but there was almost no innovation and few used the
01:39:38.220 tools at their disposal as augustus did single entry accounting existed in ancient mesopotamia
01:39:44.220 israel egypt china greece and rome the greeks potomac egyptians arabs reached marvelous heights
01:39:51.600 of civilization and mastered numbers for geometry and astronomy but they did not manage to create
01:39:57.400 double entry accounting so essential for the exact calculation of profit and loss
01:40:02.780 i see and this is what was hobbling so many empires they just didn't know where the money
01:40:13.180 was going there was money there the money was vanishing was being stolen he's being skimmed
01:40:18.820 off the top it was being lost it'd be wasted they just didn't know how to track it because
01:40:23.000 Because, you know, you see Marxism emerge at the culmination of our, not collective, but I guess, or decentralized understanding of what profit is.
01:40:37.060 We've always had a concept of profit, but I don't think it was systematized.
01:40:41.560 Like, I have $5. I pay $3 for this. I'm selling for $5. I get a little bit extra. That's profit.
01:40:48.140 but a more advanced understanding of profit that's really what Marx was
01:40:52.940 getting too much surplus value in capital but as I said you're like you
01:40:59.140 don't you are suffering because you're losing money but you don't know it's
01:41:03.800 because you're losing money you don't know how it's being lost you do you 0.99
01:41:07.220 don't have any mechanism to tell where it's fucking going which is an 0.93
01:41:12.600 interesting problem for like an empire to have um so continuing on here says accounting was for 0.98
01:41:20.120 inventorying but also for calculating surpluses of grain the very dust of civilization that brought
01:41:25.880 it brought with its sedentary villages farmers farming and markets the sumerians created clay
01:41:31.960 tokens for accounting in 3500 bce as in athens state accounting in rome was haphazard and fraud
01:41:39.640 was common cicero complained of bad accounts and his attacks on mark antony known for his debts and
01:41:46.000 shady financial dealings he claimed mark antony had kept bad account books and in doing so has
01:41:51.440 squandered a countless sum of monies stolen from caesar and even forged accounts and signatures
01:41:57.340 although cicero denounced bad books vice counsel mark mark antony did not go to jail which is funny
01:42:04.460 Which is like, I can prove he committed financial fraud, but no one cared. 0.98
01:42:08.920 It's like, yeah, so what are you, fucking lying about money? 1.00
01:42:13.280 What are you, a fucking Jew? 1.00
01:42:14.680 Which is what we would still say. 1.00
01:42:16.260 But it's like, you could just be robbed blind. 0.99
01:42:18.060 It's like, it's just fucking, what? 0.99
01:42:19.200 It's a book. 0.99
01:42:19.860 What are you going to, it's a number.
01:42:21.200 What are numbers?
01:42:23.620 At the turn of the millennium, as trade increased, so did writing, records, legal transactions, and the importance of accounting.
01:42:29.740 When William the Conqueror invaded England in 1066, he was presented with a novel opportunity.
01:42:37.040 Taking over the whole country in one fell swoop, he could write all feudal documents from scratch,
01:42:42.180 giving himself dominion over the entire country without the inevitable complications of the more conventional feudal model.
01:42:49.800 The dynastic inheritances and marriages that broke up the land holdings over time,
01:42:53.920 leaving hodgepodge of disputed territories.
01:42:56.680 The Norman conquest of England then, with its opportunity to centralize its own administrative system, brought a proliferation of new feudal land contracts requiring both secular and ecclesiastical rulers to keep clear financial records.
01:43:12.760 and now by the 12th century
01:43:15.580 northern Italy had emerged as the
01:43:17.560 richest and most populous place in
01:43:19.580 Europe dominated by the merchant run 0.88
01:43:21.560 city republics such as
01:43:23.520 Florence, Genoa and Venice
01:43:25.320 without kings and with
01:43:27.460 its nobles urbanized and recognized
01:43:29.280 in the authority of city governments northern Italy
01:43:31.380 became something entirely new
01:43:33.400 a patchwork of rich city
01:43:35.540 states ruled by patrician merchants
01:43:37.580 whose wealth came from trade
01:43:39.560 it was here that multi-partner firms
01:43:41.660 banking and long-distance trade developed and with them concepts of capitalistic profit and
01:43:47.820 double entry bookkeeping so you know that's one of the big takeaways from these books which is
01:43:53.080 i don't say how recently because the 12th century isn't recent but you you really didn't yeah this
01:44:01.860 was what brooks adams was talking about in the law of civilization and decay and he was speaking
01:44:08.280 about rome and he said the martial man who usually founds whatever the nation or city state or tribe
01:44:16.920 is you know like a warrior type farmer type they tend to be supplanted by the economic man
01:44:26.040 though you could say merchant you could say you know but the intellectual man and this has always
01:44:32.440 been the case it seems to be inevitable that and when you say merchant class i don't actually
01:44:37.640 just mean as a synonym for jews it is true that jews gravitate towards the merchant class
01:44:45.860 and there's been lots of jews within the merchant but i don't want people to make the mistake of
01:44:50.520 thinking it's just a jewish thing to be into economics you know even within we talk about
01:44:58.160 the dutch east india company we talk about in the next book global calvinism yes there was jews
01:45:04.260 involved in the east india trading company but you know the very first like international
01:45:10.560 corporation at that level for the purposes of trade was dutch and it wasn't just a jewish
01:45:17.880 enterprise you know i mean like yes there's a disproportionate amount of them involved in this
01:45:24.000 but they didn't just invent being a merchant class or being a right tile city state and if you
01:45:30.400 love to wax
01:45:32.380 about the success
01:45:34.660 of western civilization
01:45:36.520 you can't do it without
01:45:38.240 looking at international trade
01:45:39.740 like we only like even
01:45:41.720 North America was only colonized
01:45:44.360 essentially for the purposes of
01:45:46.360 expanding international trade
01:45:48.040 and that wasn't the Jews that was us we did that
01:45:50.280 he goes into here this
01:45:51.780 a lot of our audience were like this he says
01:45:54.020 although it is hard to imagine today
01:45:56.000 guilt weighed heavily on medieval
01:45:58.280 bankers and merchants
01:45:59.980 St. Ambrose had warned that usury, or lending at interest, was taken more than one was given, which was a sin.
01:46:06.740 The Third Lateran Council of 1179 denied Christian burial to usurers.
01:46:13.540 Usurers tied to the capital of sin, of greed, and considered the same as robbery.
01:46:18.340 Dante characterized moneylenders as thieves who reduced honest folk to poverty. 0.94
01:46:22.880 Jews were allowed to lend money to interest
01:46:25.520 but the Old Testament limited them to lending
01:46:27.420 to those only outside of their community
01:46:29.640 Thomas Aquinas had made exceptions
01:46:33.460 with the concept of the just
01:46:35.480 price, which allowed merchants
01:46:37.280 to charge for damages, whatever those
01:46:39.620 might be
01:46:40.740 but you actually see this with Muslims too 1.00
01:46:43.260 they'll say we don't have usury
01:46:45.480 in Islam
01:46:47.420 with their banks, but
01:46:48.760 they do, but they just
01:46:50.720 just build it to the beginning so it's like usury is like you pay interest later it's like no we're
01:46:56.440 going to calculate how much extra you owe and you pay for that chunk at the start like they still
01:47:01.820 the idea of i want to give you a hundred dollars but you gotta give me like five dollars just for
01:47:08.260 my trouble like they will build that five dollars in either at the end or the middle or the beginning
01:47:12.740 but it's like it's in there then no one seems to do it out of the goodness of their heart
01:47:17.720 or they can just call it damages.
01:47:19.980 It's like, I'll owe you money, but you've got to pay me for damages to do it.
01:47:22.720 But it just turns out to be the $5 anyway. 0.85
01:47:27.520 With the fusion of Hebrew, Greek, and newly Christian traditions,
01:47:31.340 St. Matthew brought the culture of accounting into Christianity.
01:47:35.660 Yet Matthew's message is not entirely clear either.
01:47:39.540 He claimed that the righteous should keep good, honest books and not waste money,
01:47:43.220 but he also advocated a rejection of mammon and his earthly temptations.
01:47:47.720 Matthew, also known as Levi, was a Jewish tax collector for King Herod and the Romans.
01:47:52.980 Jesus invited Matthew to follow him from the tax booth to the feast at a conversion.
01:47:58.060 Everyone's getting into the story of Matthew here, who became one of the 12 apostles of Jesus.
01:48:05.120 And the patron saint to this day of bankers, tax collectors, accountants, and perfumers.
01:48:11.160 Perfumers, there you go.
01:48:12.400 Yeah, you should, I think you should be the opposite of that.
01:48:16.660 like if you're like i used to be a tax collector now i'm one of the 12 apostles i'm the anti-banker
01:48:22.680 right can't just be their guy that that does seem jewish but the 13 we're all jews by the 1300
01:48:31.420 faith good works and sin had been placed squarely in an accounting metaphor interesting the debt
01:48:39.480 owed as dante put it could be paid for the church began to devise ways to charge the tallies in
01:48:45.200 god's books even before one had begun to climb the mountain of purgatory true believers had to
01:48:50.340 confess their sins and once the tally was made they would have to balance their moral books by
01:48:55.120 penance paying god's debt either with good works or paradoxically as luther will air complain with
01:49:02.400 money the church was everything the font of spirituality but one was always tightly intertwined
01:49:09.120 spiritual legal and ethical concerns accountants filled the halls of the papal palaces where
01:49:14.840 numeracy became a measure of holiness as true believers paid cash sums for indulgences for
01:49:21.800 their sins now a lot of people who are not fond of catholics will find that you know damnable
01:49:28.000 but again it's like there was a time where they didn't do that when there was no
01:49:33.760 currency-based transaction involved in this at all but you started to see
01:49:39.080 as a way to resolve that just like in money with the early greek mind
01:49:43.560 currency enters stage as a way to just make make this business a bit easier but still
01:49:51.840 but still have the the cosine of some divine authority that it still counts
01:49:58.580 sorry i think i cut you off there no no that's all
01:50:01.120 he goes um there's this guy a banker for the catholic church and master of the exchange
01:50:07.600 routes of foreign trade, Cosimo de Medici was the richest man in Europe and his bank the most
01:50:13.140 influential. The Neoplatonic ideal of human glory based on artistic, cultural, and political
01:50:21.720 achievement did not always leave a place for the gritty practical matters of business. Cosimo did
01:50:27.620 not want his sons to share in the vulgar world of medieval business and the noble bloodsport of
01:50:33.260 renaissance politics would be their preserve accounting the very tool that helped him fund
01:50:39.100 the renaissance began to be seen as a lower and even immoral discipline in his quest for power
01:50:45.540 and prestige cosmo turned not only turned not only to banking and politics he also used artistic
01:50:51.820 and religious patronage to cement his power so here's a banker who was funding a lot of the
01:50:58.440 artists at the time or in some ways involved but he mentions this a few times it's sort of the the
01:51:04.920 rise of neo-platonism which was like in the renaissance era and perhaps even now are we
01:51:14.920 focusing on art culture achievement vigor martial prowess these very vital aspects and seeing
01:51:24.680 anything to do with business or economics as as subservient to all that that that's vulgar
01:51:31.160 that's useless that's not strong and so i just loved his story because here's a guy the richest 0.94
01:51:37.000 man in europe yeah at the time just believing like this is this is so fucking embarrassing 0.93
01:51:42.520 like it's so embarrassing i'm so rich i don't want my sons accidentally became the richest man 0.71
01:51:47.960 I need to fund more art 0.99
01:51:51.700 otherwise people will think I'm fucking gay 0.99
01:51:53.560 which is so different 1.00
01:51:58.500 it's awesome actually
01:51:59.400 you're embarrassingly rich
01:52:02.460 my sons must become broke sculptors
01:52:07.300 and I'll keep them alive
01:52:08.700 in secret
01:52:10.420 Pacchioli is considered the father of accounting
01:52:15.060 and his manual is its founding work
01:52:17.360 All major manuals on accounting from the Renaissance to the modern age are based in part of Paclioti's publication, making him the central author of the history of accounting.
01:52:29.480 Paclioti's treatise came late in the game when accounting and his culture were losing prestige.
01:52:35.080 It did not become one of the great books of the Renaissance with a hallowed place in humanism.
01:52:40.100 a tuscan franciscan friar this guy was a franciscan friar an expert in geometry and algebra and a
01:52:46.980 student of neoplatonism pecleoli came from the same world of cosmo dimici in which business was
01:52:53.940 the basis of political power the basics of accounting have changed little since he printed
01:52:59.180 his summa more than 500 years ago so i was really interested like just the the whole development
01:53:07.240 of accounting being forwarded by guys who hated it or saw it was embarrassing like here here's a 0.95
01:53:14.020 franciscan friar who's just amazing at math and being like okay guys guys i know this is stupid
01:53:19.060 i know this is a sin but i think we should keep accurate books of what we're spending and like
01:53:25.960 they're being fought every step of the way but it but it's the entire step of the way
01:53:31.940 they have to make different arguments for they need to make humanist arguments they need to
01:53:36.940 make spiritual arguments they need to make like every conceit they need to encircle it 0.99
01:53:42.300 to convince everyone because they just think anything to do with that is is a stupid waste
01:53:48.800 of time right but but the nature of these empires of these kingdoms of these city-states meant that
01:53:53.480 they didn't need to track trade there's of course trade but it wasn't the level it is right now
01:54:01.060 so it could you could have as long as you had self-sufficient communities cities or locations
01:54:09.400 territories you didn't need to worry about this that much because you can just tell when people
01:54:13.160 are starving and when they're not you can tell here are the peasants revolting they're not okay
01:54:18.640 i guess everything is okay right so it wasn't until you tried to pursue more monumental goals
01:54:27.000 that this becomes apparent.
01:54:30.240 You know, like when you're trying to build
01:54:31.800 a machine in space,
01:54:33.920 every speck of dust matters.
01:54:36.660 You need to account for
01:54:38.600 how sterilized everything is 0.99
01:54:41.260 because one mistake could collapse fucking everything. 0.99
01:54:45.220 He says, 0.99
01:54:46.100 The moral conundrum was that kings needed bankers
01:54:48.560 and merchants to raise revenues
01:54:50.060 for their armies, navies, palaces, and courts.
01:54:53.860 The sometimes vile act of accounting
01:54:55.960 was an ever more necessary administrative tool kings needed it but they most often did not have
01:55:01.600 the knowledge or skilled administrators so common to merchant republics the lack of an accounting
01:55:07.480 culture would strain the financial administration of many states and even the spanish empire by the
01:55:12.940 late 1530s the holy roman emperor charles v had every reason to see himself as the first among
01:55:19.620 gentlemen of the world ruler of the spanish and habsburg empires he defeated the french taking
01:55:25.220 over the papacy and ruled italy through the kingdom of naples outward to milan he had secured
01:55:31.060 his new world holdings and set out the habsburg administration across south america the problem
01:55:36.740 of empire is that it's a source of unimaginable wealth but good accounts often show that it costs
01:55:42.020 more than it earns to hold regions ports and colonies across the globe see like this is like
01:55:48.020 the first i mean not not the first but one of the rare empires of that size going across
01:55:55.060 different continents and then you know look you only see it in hindsight it's like oh i was losing
01:56:02.500 money the entire time which this was a and that's what britain learned like the thing about colonies
01:56:08.340 is you're not making money hand over fist really as much as the third world thinks that you do it's
01:56:14.820 It's like, no, you need to invest a lot of money into getting them, keeping them, developing them, maintaining them, and holding them.
01:56:24.800 You wouldn't know that unless you had the proper account books.
01:56:29.280 This was Charles' problem.
01:56:30.860 It would be the enduring legacy of the great imperial dynasty he founded.
01:56:34.500 Bankers were in short supply in Spain.
01:56:36.320 So Charles put his fate in the hands of bankers from Germany, Italy, Holland, and Spain.
01:56:41.800 And he set out to reorganize Spanish financial administration.
01:56:44.820 Now, by the early 16th century, the Netherlands, the richest European province of the Habsburg Spanish Empire, had replaced northern Italy as the center of the international economy.
01:56:57.600 In 1567, a Florentine trader described the staggering wealth of Antwerp's rich merchants, the beautiful shops, fine tapestries, grand houses, 42 churches, stock exchange, etc.
01:57:11.200 It was, the Florentine noted, the richest and most beautiful city in the world.
01:57:16.840 For all its riches, the Netherlands in 1567 was not a free state, but instead ruled by King Philip II of Spain.
01:57:23.800 Although Flemish and Dutch subjects of the Habsburg King prospered with international banking and trade, they also had to survive Spanish taxation.
01:57:30.920 and you know building on that with the proliferation of business to every level of
01:57:37.620 dutch society there was a general consensus that double entry accounting was necessary knowledge
01:57:42.480 from street vendors to even prostitutes to merchants and nobles the dutch needed to know
01:57:48.660 double entry accounting to navigate their little oasis of commerce and tolerance with publicly
01:57:54.900 traded multi-partner firms organizing worldwide seaborne commerce holland's riches became legendary
01:58:01.220 so that's one thing you see throughout the book it's that in these merchant republics or these
01:58:08.100 city states that embrace mercantilism you saw double entry accounting and accounting
01:58:15.700 at a basic level being taught more in schools in fact entire schools are created just to teach this
01:58:22.340 and you don't see that anywhere else in the world right which is an interesting idea that you had
01:58:26.740 certain city states where that's the only place in the world you could go to learn this type of math
01:58:31.940 it just it just wasn't out there in the world without that it sounds like obvious knowledge
01:58:38.100 now but back then it's like you would have to go to like a one of the few financial centers 0.97
01:58:44.500 like there's one place in europe you can learn this shit um he makes a point here which is 0.98
01:58:52.180 interesting because people will think that oh this is just you know your jewish trickery but you know 0.99
01:58:58.660 things like central banking as a concept and you know currency and double entry counting
01:59:05.860 and stock exchanges like you can look at their history and again yes jews are involved but
01:59:10.980 but I'd say it's disproportionately non-Jews
01:59:15.540 because it follows the development of international trade.
01:59:18.740 I don't think Jews invented international trade. 0.79
01:59:21.600 And also you wouldn't want to grant them that. 0.99
01:59:24.260 You know what I mean? 1.00
01:59:25.460 You don't want to grant Jews 1.00
01:59:28.680 into introducing financial accountability. 1.00
01:59:33.220 That makes us sound like retards. 1.00
01:59:35.360 It actually does. 0.98
01:59:37.500 So it says here,
01:59:38.820 The Dutch fondness for accounting did not derive only from a merchant ethic.
01:59:43.660 It also came from an older tradition in Dutch culture, water management.
01:59:47.840 If the dikes broke and the water came in, Holland would be lost.
01:59:51.880 Good municipal management therefore became a matter of life and death, 0.73
01:59:55.220 and this provides one reason the Dutch took accounting and accountability so seriously.
02:00:00.900 It might also explain why municipal accounting had to be good and relatively transparent.
02:00:05.740 local audience were communally recognized as part of a pragmatic consensus necessary to guarantee
02:00:12.620 good municipal administration and dry land trust developed from a consistently good civic financial
02:00:19.520 management and that was one reason why the dutch had faith to buy shares and were able to create
02:00:23.600 the first publicly traded company which is that's an interesting angle that the idea of selling
02:00:31.800 shares to a to a company a publicly traded company again there was a time when that didn't
02:00:37.820 exist and then there was a time after that existed but just imagine like the high trust society you
02:00:43.900 would need for people to want to do that yeah that's a wild thing to ask people to do unless
02:00:49.500 they really implicitly trusted the people who were organizing it and just have faith and buy
02:00:56.280 shares in something which is wild
02:00:58.120 and he also
02:00:59.880 there on the transparency and one of the demands
02:01:02.180 placed on having these accounts
02:01:04.280 was demand that whoever was in charge
02:01:06.360 of the community or the nation
02:01:08.380 or whatever they would be
02:01:10.300 transparent about the books as well
02:01:12.280 it wasn't
02:01:14.240 enough just to take their word for it
02:01:16.260 that they kept them like you have to make this public
02:01:18.020 you need to see what it is you're doing
02:01:20.400 with all this so it's
02:01:22.340 there's
02:01:23.780 a case we made there that it's
02:01:25.880 reinforcing or establishing a higher trust society you know the demanding power at least
02:01:33.320 let the populace know what it's doing so it says here uh in 1661 louis the 14th of france came of
02:01:41.080 age and took possession of the largest kingdom in europe and possibly the richest in the world
02:01:45.960 it was a time of great hope after a century of war revolt and violence france had a brilliant
02:01:50.600 young king louis came to the throne of a country impoverished for a king of his stature he needed
02:01:56.520 to build a fortune that would allow him to master not only france but the world 17th century france
02:02:02.200 however was not renaissance italy and bourgeois patricians did not become the princes of their
02:02:07.320 cities in a culture dominated by wealthy nobles and increasingly centralized by monarchy in the
02:02:12.920 tradition of philip the second the primary avenue of social ascension for the ambitious financier
02:02:18.360 or merchant was through service
02:02:20.300 to a great aristocrat.
02:02:24.320 Louis mixed his traditional late
02:02:26.380 humanist education with
02:02:28.380 the practical legal knowledge of
02:02:30.500 this guy he brought in,
02:02:32.160 a banker by the name of Colbert.
02:02:34.920 Colbert, in his House of Scholars,
02:02:36.640 intendants and agents provided him.
02:02:38.220 Humanist education was clearly useful,
02:02:40.700 but it was not enough to run a state
02:02:42.440 effectively. For the first time,
02:02:44.160 the administrative project of King
02:02:46.180 Louis XIV and Jean
02:02:48.100 baptiste colbert accounting and traditional learning were used together to manage a large
02:02:53.780 government so here's the first time you see an accountant a financier working alongside a king
02:03:02.340 whereas before they were kept at a distance and this was in the interest of getting a lot of money
02:03:07.720 for the empire because you know you started seeing with france and throughout europe more wars more
02:03:14.760 famine, more, just the coffers are drained in a way that might not have happened as much
02:03:21.900 historically. The French can't collect taxes from their elite. This, I know this one is crazy,
02:03:29.580 okay, but the nobles, very small group, between one and three percent, and they're not allowed
02:03:38.600 to be taxed. It's called privilege because they're supposed to defend the king. That goes back to
02:03:43.100 the Middle Ages. They can't be taxed. They have more than 50% of the wealth. Again, 0.53
02:03:49.000 I mean, you know, never could this happen in a rational universe, right? So they can't be taxed.
02:03:55.880 So, but England, they can actually tax a lot of their gentry. They don't have the same noble
02:04:02.340 system. Not only do they have a better tax system, they have a national bank. They're borrowing at
02:04:06.440 3%. So these
02:04:08.440 guys both have these massive public
02:04:10.400 debts, all right? 1.00
02:04:12.360 But the French can't pay theirs back. 1.00
02:04:14.840 They don't have a system to do it. 0.99
02:04:16.440 So Necker comes in. He's Swiss 1.00
02:04:18.320 and he's Protestant. And in 0.92
02:04:20.400 France, that doesn't make you the most
02:04:22.380 popular person at a dinner party.
02:04:24.420 Okay? Depends. It depends.
02:04:26.300 I know a lot of wonderful Swiss, Protestant people
02:04:28.460 that I like to have dinner with, but back then
02:04:30.440 there were certain prejudices
02:04:32.420 against them. Why is Necker
02:04:34.200 coming in? He had been head of the East India
02:04:36.300 company he also could raise money from his friends in switzerland and just keep taking out more debt
02:04:42.780 but he also does something else he comes in to do financial reform he tries to collect taxes
02:04:49.980 which aren't being collected the tax collectors have lifetime jobs they basically keep the money
02:04:56.380 they don't keep books so what necker says is look every tax collector has to learn how to do double
02:05:02.540 entry bookkeeping um now what's interesting is after colbert's death no minister under louis
02:05:09.580 the 14th would again have as much power as much financial information even more louis began playing
02:05:15.260 the great ministerial families of colbert and his rival against each other by breaking colbert's
02:05:19.820 system that he had established up until his death louis hobbled the french state in the long run
02:05:25.100 without financial data going to a central state register which is what colbert was in charge of
02:05:31.020 france continued the tradition of the middle ages a minister's financial records were seen as a
02:05:36.380 valuable piece of private property and not that of the state the endless failures of 18th century
02:05:42.460 french governments were due not only to the secrecy and folly of royal fiat and terrible
02:05:47.900 financial management but also louis splintering of the state apparatus so that was his failure
02:05:53.980 to keep up the demands
02:05:56.800 of making these
02:05:58.900 of keeping proper accounts
02:06:01.000 and without that
02:06:02.540 all of the little parts
02:06:04.800 all the little nobles, all the individuals
02:06:06.880 they would have their accounts
02:06:09.060 books but they were kept as a little secret
02:06:10.980 thing, which is so funny
02:06:13.140 to me, it's like I have an account book
02:06:14.640 but no one's allowed to see it 1.00
02:06:16.240 you might as well just live in your fucking head 1.00
02:06:18.540 you might as well just have lies then 1.00
02:06:20.320 and then
02:06:23.400 i mean i know we need to get stopping soon but the story goes that this this continues to evolve
02:06:32.040 unimpeded up until you get to america which was founded with a profound understanding especially
02:06:39.960 represented by benjamin franklin of the importance of accounts and you know and from
02:06:46.840 this development you get
02:06:48.520 your libertarianism
02:06:50.960 you get the spirit of capitalism
02:06:53.120 you get Adam Smith
02:06:54.740 you know Adam Smith
02:06:56.420 traced the movements of the invisible hand to
02:06:58.740 mark the traces
02:06:59.620 moving beyond
02:07:02.740 profit oriented accounting British
02:07:04.720 Protestant thinkers tried to budget
02:07:06.620 productiveness as well as happiness
02:07:08.860 in 1781
02:07:10.560 the utilitarian philosopher Jeremy
02:07:12.600 Bentham tried to account for the greatest
02:07:14.920 happiness principle
02:07:16.120 with a which was a double entry method of valuing pleasure right so you have like
02:07:23.360 the overall story is you have the normalization of accounting and that is changing how people
02:07:33.660 even treat spirituality now some people may disagree with that i think that's a i think it
02:07:38.540 is all interconnected um i i do think the more you normalize accounting thinking the more you
02:07:45.500 start to change other aspects of your philosophy of your spirituality it is undeniably changed
02:07:54.860 religion you know it changed the catholic church it changes anything that has power and authority
02:08:02.060 right i think i think that's that's that's obvious uh ian's hearing says from the renaissance to the
02:08:07.980 19th century great artists and philosophers painted and discussed accountants and their
02:08:13.260 complex role in society but great artists don't paint accountants anymore it's not surprising in
02:08:20.140 the wake of fiascos like enron accounts have come to be perceived not only as boring but also as
02:08:26.300 venal and inexpert few political and financial commentators discuss accounts or accounting
02:08:33.500 from renaissance italy to the great monarchies of spain and france to the commercial societies
02:08:38.140 of holland britain and america accounting arrives on the scene with great effect only to retreat
02:08:44.140 into dangerous obscurity considering that there have been centuries of struggles over financial
02:08:49.660 accountability our own recent inability to effectively audit and hold companies and
02:08:55.020 governments accountable seems incomprehensible that's an interesting way to end the book and
02:09:02.060 i don't think it's gone better you know he mentions enron that might have dated the book somewhat but
02:09:08.620 if accounting is all about accountability it in my view i i don't think our opinion of
02:09:18.380 accounting has improved that much it is still seen as as boring um and many of the technocrats
02:09:24.300 that we see they think accounting gets in their way and that's what he was saying with uh the
02:09:29.340 emergence of like the tycoons the great tycoons of america the rockefellers you know the carnegies
02:09:36.460 they see accounts as just getting in their way they had a very nichian approach to it they're
02:09:41.840 like i'm doing i'm a great man doing great things and you want to stop me with your numbers you want 0.96
02:09:47.140 to slow me down fuck you and so but you know that causes problems and i i think that's still the 0.98
02:09:55.460 case now people think it just gets in the way it pours cold water on whatever it is that we're doing 1.00
02:10:01.080 what do you even fucking need it for all you need is momentum that's why so many startups play fast 0.77
02:10:07.920 and loose with accounting too like we're just gonna make it up we're gonna lie about it until 0.97
02:10:12.480 we get rich and then it won't matter anymore that that to me is the prevailing sentiment
02:10:16.740 in our society and i think he's making a case that if you keep doing that if if you don't
02:10:24.080 prioritize accounting and transparency of accounting you destroy accountability from the
02:10:31.380 these great people from the people who want to control and direct society you know you should
02:10:38.040 actually want to hold them account to see if they're just lying about everything you know and
02:10:43.580 that that's that's crypto that's startup culture that's ai as well we talked about you know open ai
02:10:51.060 You want to go public?
02:10:52.620 Does open AI want to do an IPO?
02:10:55.440 Let's have a look.
02:10:56.200 But the problem is most people, once they see the books,
02:10:58.760 they don't know what to make of it.
02:10:59.760 They say, oh, I'm seeing a lot of red, a lot of negative.
02:11:03.760 I'm like, well, that's because everything's debt now.
02:11:05.920 And that's another.
02:11:06.620 That's what accounting reveals.
02:11:08.880 Our entire society is run on incredible debt.
02:11:13.940 And to an ancient mind.
02:11:16.940 I thought you want to do accounting so that you're in the black.
02:11:21.060 you know we're like no no we don't like accounting because it just reveals that
02:11:24.760 nothing nothing nothing is profitable nothing makes any money
02:11:29.780 anyway what do you think about that we can stop there yeah um i never thought about it in that
02:11:39.000 sense but um it reminds me a lot like the comment we made earlier about the internet and fax machines
02:11:44.780 it's one of those like you kind of take for granted double entry accounting but yeah there
02:11:49.000 was a time before it when shit just essentially wasn't done it was a total sea change yeah and
02:11:55.880 as accounting changes it's everything's changing along that like and this is something i would get
02:12:00.540 into in a future vanguard journal article it's changing our conceptualization of what authority
02:12:06.380 is of what accountability is but what what do you do to hold people accountable about trans
02:12:11.480 should you expect transparency you know there's a time where we didn't expect that anyone in power
02:12:18.300 is culpable or deserves to speak to us about anything you know that was a new idea at some 0.51
02:12:25.000 like all this is fucking new um and caring about this stuff and i don't know there's there's a 0.81
02:12:32.720 development of a metaphysics here in a sense and and the economics-minded people may lay too much 0.92
02:12:41.240 at the feet of of economics of saying that no everything follows economics i'm not sure about
02:12:47.000 i'm not sure economics drives all of this however it does seem to me that philosophy for sure
02:12:57.560 follows technological development i don't think there's any debate about that i i think philosophy
02:13:05.960 largely as reactionary like it seems to radically change in step with technology
02:13:14.280 right like but it but does not pioneer on its own it's it's very inward looking it's very
02:13:20.520 contemplative reactions to these things which are necessary but you think about technology
02:13:28.280 and economics and war and other material things and and religion you know they can they're
02:13:35.640 intertwined and driving a lot of this stuff but uh yeah i i it is interesting also that
02:13:41.640 that accounting has been suppressed for so long.
02:13:45.620 You can get pretty far without it.
02:13:48.440 That's a flip side to this. 0.99
02:13:50.380 You could also have a fucking kingdom without any books. 1.00
02:13:53.980 Fuck that. 1.00
02:13:55.840 That's the other takeaway. 1.00
02:13:58.600 Let's see how far we can get without accountants.
02:14:01.940 You can still have a pretty good life.
02:14:05.020 Anyway, I'll let you go.
02:14:07.380 Good one.
02:14:08.140 Good one, buddy.
02:14:08.900 Talk to you soon.
02:14:09.520 Take care.