01:00:26.020They are exhausted by efforts to use the Holocaust or Jewish suffering generally as a moral obligation to support Israel.
01:00:33.240They are completely unmoved by accusations of anti-Semitism and any hardline approaches to disavow and shame Israel's critics and even those who soberly advocate for a more restrained foreign policy.
01:00:45.020These conversations cannot be off limits.0.54
01:00:47.160So, he's instructing all the Jews there, like, here's how to engage with America.
01:00:54.920We can't be, others, I'm looking at another one right here.0.65
01:13:29.880you want a bunch of canadian dollars no i'm going to put it all in fart nigga coin and hollow points0.89
01:13:39.160that's my that's my and i'm going to be like 47 when this happens great great strategy perfect0.74
01:13:44.520strategy that's my retirement strategy anyway so there's some things i wanted to cover
01:13:51.400that i didn't get to especially this one might as well talk about this since i don't think i'll get
01:14:01.020to the article i want to review at this place called hard pressed north it's called selling
01:14:09.040the sovereignty lie uh it's about how the breakdown of kuzma cleared the field for global
01:14:16.240megafunds it's about canada it's about mark carney um it's about carney when carney is first elected
01:14:26.480some close friends of mine colleagues we'll call them were banking on something they termed the
01:14:32.400carney pivot which was that hey he's had a liberal party but it's a new day for the liberal party
01:14:39.520after justin trudeau and it seems that he's gonna be pivoting on a lot of issues that are in favor
01:14:47.600of our principles you know he seemed to be taking a different approach to energy and and the alberta
01:14:55.600oil sands and he's making appeals to heritage canadians and things like that i said okay
01:15:01.600look he might be one of us and those very same people were just recently saying it seems that0.98
01:15:10.720the carney pivot was short-lived um i'm not gonna name anyone specifically because who gives a shit0.88
01:15:18.940but it uh just sets the the frame here for how i want to discuss mark carney which is i've been0.90
01:15:27.040hot and cold on him in the past i see him as a competent political operator but i think we've
01:15:34.020always been skeptical about who he is and what he represents and what his true agenda is without0.97
01:15:39.440getting into any city of london bank of england shit which is shady and nefarious on its own of0.85
01:15:47.620course but i'm looking at an article here in the cbc carney wants canada to join europe's0.95
01:15:53.880erasmus plus program what is it and this is all about canada i don't i haven't even looked that
01:16:01.240deeply into this it just seems so ridiculous on its face how we're trying to join the european
01:16:08.760union but as like an associate like we're part of uh like a special designation to be like in spirit
01:16:20.520part of europe you've heard about this right yeah yeah of course yeah it seems like it's simply to
01:16:28.200spite trump of course but it is humiliating for canada to me just in principle like yeah we're0.99
01:16:35.940gonna spiritually join with you we're not in europe what the fuck are you talking about this0.99
01:16:41.820this is stupid but one of the consequences of that is that we're going to join this or he wants to0.99
01:16:49.360join this erasmus program which um i'll just read it here one of the many details of the suggested0.99
01:16:54.560new partnership are left to be ironed out carney specifically pitched canadian involvement in
01:16:59.300erasmus plus when he which he delivered at a speech in the european parliament in strassburg
01:17:04.700france on thursday uh canadian membership of erasmus plus and this is quoting carney
01:17:10.460would give your your students and ours more opportunity to learn some of the world's top
01:17:15.060universities to broaden their horizons and to build those lasting ties which will sustain our
01:17:20.660alliance in the future so what it is it's a open doors uh student sharing program so it's it's
01:17:29.000allowing uh students university college students to just immigrate freely to canada as they would
01:17:36.540throughout europe which to me is just opening the doors for more mass migration because why would
01:17:42.200why would we want that is there is there any way to interpret that are there a lot of people at
01:17:48.800oxford that are desperate to come over here that haven't already come to canada like i thought we
01:17:55.060already had a special you know partnership with with the anglosphere largely the irony is is the
01:18:03.000only people that we have a cultural relationship with are the uk and they're no longer a part of
01:18:05.980the eu anyways that's actually a great like why like i wouldn't why would we want this you know
01:18:11.460carny you pitched this deal to us which i'm not totally against by the way the idea of becoming
01:18:15.720closer to the eu not against it on its face but you pitched it as an economic plan but the very
01:18:20.840first thing we hear is like oh we're gonna make sure that students studying across the eu can0.97
01:18:26.220freely come to canada no no no no no no no fuck you buddy we want steel and copper we want you to1.00
01:18:33.020buy our cars what else can you like can we trade beer recipes maybe come on we don't want fucking1.00
01:18:39.320bodies leave the bodies out of it unless you're going to take unless you're going to take some0.98
01:18:42.580of the indians we can sell you the indians we're going to get more indians this way that that's0.99
01:18:46.840the only thing that happens like that that's what's in it for them what's in it for us this
01:18:52.320deal is we get distance from america but specifically trump what what does america what
01:19:00.140does europe get out of this at all right what does any partnership with china what do they get out of0.96
01:19:05.440it well china gets to dump a bunch of their fucked up evs into our market and flooded what does europe0.93
01:19:11.560get probably a place to send all their indians otherwise i actually don't know what they get0.99
01:19:16.640out of this about letting us in with such expediency right we haven't made it clear what0.99
01:19:23.700the continent of europe is getting out of this and also there's to my understanding there's no
01:19:28.840details on any of this yet right this is all just you know announcements and and fluffy talk at
01:19:33.520conferences it's not like there is even a deal with any kind of there's no numbers on a page
01:19:39.040right and are there i don't think so uh i don't like my point is it could be this all could be
01:19:45.420nothing like this could roll and then we'll just forget about it in mid-2027 and then it was
01:19:49.700nothing because it seems like it's moving quickly but every time that i hear an article they're0.86
01:19:53.680like oh we're still working out the details okay so nobody has actually agreed to a single fucking0.70
01:19:58.180number yet it's just we all love to talk about it because we all hate trump absolutely and then0.57
01:20:05.320there was this article which it's very very long we're not going to get a chance to cover right now
01:20:10.320but um i'll just read the last part here it says whether viewed as an international or sorry rather
01:20:17.900whether viewed as an intentional strategy or the unintended friction of a geopolitical breakdown
01:20:22.860the ultimate destination of this shift remains remarkably consistent while private players like
01:20:27.520Brookfield is trying to make huge profits from buying up struggling Canadian businesses along
01:20:31.920the way, the bigger story goes well beyond any single investment firm. Instead of relying on
01:20:37.160open, low-cost trade of the United States, Canada, under Carney's leadership, is moving towards a
01:20:42.380system where the government and massive global investment funds team up to run national economic
01:20:47.720strategy. Not surprising, while still chairing Brookfield, Carney helped shape the, quote,
01:20:56.300maple fund a leaked 50 billion dollar pitch to blend 36 billion in canadian pension money
01:21:03.12010 billion from ottawa and 4 billion from brookfield into quote the largest ever private
01:21:10.220pool of capital dedicated to investing in the canadian economy with brookfield running it and
01:21:15.800collecting the fees the pitch landed one week after trudeau named carney his economic advisor
01:21:21.020prompting the logic to flag the conflict of interest in print before the fund even had a
01:21:26.580chance to close now as prime minister the 25 billion canada strong fund mirrors that exact
01:21:34.460same blueprint giving him the power of state to build the very system he tried to construct from
01:21:40.260the corporate side eight months earlier by stepping back from traditional low-cost trade
01:21:45.420of the United States, Canada isn't just reacting to tariffs, it's executing Carney's life's work.
01:21:51.820Taxpayers absorb the initial financial risks, while mega funds and global investors
01:21:56.460step in to build and run the country's core industries. His current strategy would seem
01:22:01.640to be the ultimate real-world test of the stakeholder capitalism model he championed
01:22:06.860for years on the World Economic Forum's Board of Trustees. A managed economy where government
01:22:13.060policy sets the direction public money de-risks the deal and global asset managers run the show
01:22:20.000which would be completely in line with what we know about carney his career his history what
01:22:25.940he's tried to do before and where he's taking the country what we think about all that do you think
01:22:32.900that's realistic absolutely absolutely i think i think that's been in the cards even before carney
01:22:38.540I think that's I mean, look, there's there's an element of Canadian history with the way that we have our I mean, we don't call them state owned enterprises, but they're, you know, crown corporations, right? There's an element of this. Canada's kind of always been run this way. And so there's always going to be an element in the Laurentian elite that's going to be pushing in that direction. So, of course, and as you say, he was part of the WEF pushing stakeholder capitalism for decades. So, of course, he's going to be the guy who finally does it.
01:23:04.440yeah and so the article is selling the sovereignty lie on hard oppressed north
01:23:10.060that's the substack this would have been published in august of this year 2026
01:23:15.320um so just the role of global mega funds in the economic future of canada and and that's
01:23:24.220the sovereignty it's sovereignty from the united states which is great news for some0.59
01:23:33.400but it comes at a cost breaking from america to run into the arms of china better or worse0.84
01:23:41.820i tend to say worse what about all the basically siding with the world economic forum
01:23:47.580is that is that better or worse or the same as america you know what i mean like it's i don't
01:23:53.760know like it's it's a what none of this is is sovereignty i want us to stop using that word
01:24:00.500yes yes like it's it's it that's to enliven people like us but just a heritage canadian
01:24:09.980that doesn't work on me anymore nothing nothing you people say works on me anymore
01:24:14.580the jig is up i got it we're all hip to you all right um before we move on to the book review
01:24:25.300I just wanted to remind people that this November the 7th, we will be hosting a live recording of Do You Even Read, our sister show.
01:24:36.800Me and the Prudentialist will be in Dallas, Texas.
01:24:40.420And you can find tickets for that on our Eventbrite page that was posted on our social media.
01:25:09.340I'm trying to get a setup where there's a mic that people can use in the audience so they can just get the live chat experience and just yell shit out as like a form of super chat or something.
01:25:23.960and interact with the show um yeah and that that's the main news there are you excited to hear about
01:25:32.220dallas in the show i am yes i am i got buddies that are going everybody's telling me about it
01:25:37.260exciting once people see the venue i think they're going to be pretty impressed we have not released
01:25:43.100the venue location at present you know um some people even the people we know in dallas they're
01:25:50.560Like, oh, I'm in the section of town you're in.
01:39:18.660After 1902, he focused on teaching strategy to naval officers
01:39:22.820and forming statesmen in shaping national doctrine.
01:39:26.240His uneasiness about the future was widely shared. The Boer War disasters of Black Week in 1899 shook the foundations of Victorian complacency, prompting the remarkable transformation of British power that provided the opportunity for him to serve.
01:39:43.400Corbett's teaching would be dominated by the deflection of strategy by politics,
01:39:48.640and his politics were liberal imperialist, powerfully predisposed to see power as culture and identity,
01:39:56.980an amalgam of democracy, progress, free trade, self-determination, and the rule of law, including at sea.
01:40:05.220So that's where he was coming from, we might say ideologically.
01:58:25.260but then we ended up picking these movies that
01:58:28.660no one talked about yet but they deserve to be talked about they're screaming out to be discussed
01:58:34.900more in this political milieu we're in and uh i realize we haven't even teed up what we're
01:58:42.040going to be talking about so maybe you could do that but uh yeah no no problem dimes has selected
01:58:47.540for his episode the 1976 comedy drama network yeah i think i know why you picked it yeah i'd
01:59:01.200also say it's a satire in the truest sense of the word not in the sense that you know it's a
01:59:07.560serious movie that people misunderstand it has the tone and tenor and rhythm of a satire for
01:59:14.500better or worse because there are some issues i would have the movie but it would be more in league
01:59:20.520with uh the death of stalin which is a more recent one but you know it is funny it is everything is
01:59:27.120heightened i find in these films there's not a lot of room for character development but you don't
01:59:34.740need that right but it's like people represent things and you're watching representations of
01:59:41.880concepts or spaces kind of manifest but i think this is um you know what i i interrupt you because
01:59:49.480you're about to say i think you know why i picked this i do yeah and i mean obviously we're going
01:59:54.680to draw some parallels here to our our current moment but i think you dimes like i think you
02:00:01.780like this movie because i think that you channel howard beale every time you record a blood
02:00:06.060satellite well he's your spirit animal as we'll get to in a little bit and maybe we can start
02:00:13.180with this i find that highly offensive um let me just uh cue this up a little bit because
02:00:22.620i saw this film and this was made in the 70s and this is what was it sydney lume yes sydney
02:00:30.260yeah that's correct uh the director not the writer however and so if you are into screenwriting at all
02:00:38.080or if you're just into filmmaking the screenplay for network is described as one of the best if
02:00:44.740not the best screenplay ever written this is what you'll hear and i believe it won the academy award
02:00:50.280that year for best screenplay um it's very very popular people love this film and i saw it when i
02:00:57.520was younger i saw when i would have been in my early 20s and it had a different effect on me
02:01:02.160then than it does now so this is the second time i've seen it um and i'm curious to hear did you
02:01:07.120see it more than once or is this your first oh yeah no i've seen it i probably saw i've seen it
02:01:11.120a number of times probably in my 20s and then again in my 30s you don't need to have a media
02:01:17.840literacy certificate to watch this movie but it does help it's it's enjoyable and i think it's
02:01:23.840best appreciated in the areas released in because you can watch it with the modern eyes and appreciate
02:01:30.560it for what it is it's a very well-made movie but try to imagine what it was like in the 70s
02:01:34.880when this dropped and it's people have said it predicted a lot of the media landscape right now
02:01:41.760because the main uh network in there is things called ubs or ubn ubs and uh it doesn't exist
02:01:48.880that's not a real network but it could be interpreted as a stand-in for fox you know
02:01:55.120you wouldn't need to do that if you made the movie now you could just make things that are
02:01:57.840called the name of whatever the it is but um yeah i i think if you watch it in the context
02:02:05.280of when it was released it will it's a landmark film i don't think it's a perfect film i don't
02:02:11.920think it's a perfect screenplay i think there's a lot of people who especially if they're younger
02:02:18.240now they watch this and it can be seen as a revelation to them but uh i watch it very
02:02:24.100differently with older eyes now and we can get to that in a second but i before i just go off on
02:02:30.820this i wanted to get your view what what's your big take what's your reaction to this film yeah
02:02:37.720yeah well a couple of things you know it's it's interesting i have this um i have i find it
02:02:45.400difficult to watch movies and this goes in two two different directions i find it difficult to
02:02:52.080watch movies where people the the characters are talking but it's not in a way that i think that
02:03:00.460people actually speak so like one example like sometimes an example of this is that it's just0.88
02:03:06.360a really dumb screenplay written by a really dumb person so like an example of this is like an
02:03:12.540earlier like red red hawk this year picked grand torino and he and i both tore it apart but it's0.99
02:03:18.360because like the writer does not know what like a 70 year old angry right-wing boomer sounds like
02:03:27.160and so the dialogue is is tinny and bad and every scene i'm just like oh that's not how people talk0.63
02:03:33.420or that's not how men relate to one another yeah what do you jigger's up to but the the so that's
02:03:41.160when it goes when the the the uncanny dialogue goes in a downward direction in network the
02:03:48.520uncanny dialogue goes in this upward direction where like these guys are and i'm not just talking
02:03:53.540about howard beale like howard beale's has these monologues which seem sort of like too too scripted
02:03:59.280to be spontaneous but the way that everybody talks everybody talks in these like soliloquies
02:04:05.720like when you have the like the romantic fight scenes between uh if they done away and william
02:04:12.500holden it's just like the most crisp like perfect dialogue on the planet yeah that's where it almost
02:04:19.680gets meta and that's what took me out of it like there's scenes of great sincerity almost ripped
02:04:25.980from a different film we'll get to those in a second but then i know exactly what you're talking
02:04:29.080about like their romantic uh you know tension everything like it's almost nobody ever stumbles
02:04:35.640over what they're trying to say they just come out with the most perfect sentences imaginable
02:04:41.380and it's weird because like it's hypocritical it's strange that i mind this in movies because
02:04:47.720like i don't mind it when i watch a shakespeare play or like i i don't mind it when i read a
02:04:53.120greek tragedy and obviously those are things that like i accept it if it's on stage and it's
02:04:59.540tennessee williams but something about like the medium of film unless there's a very obvious sort
02:05:05.660of um like if there's there's some obvious thematic element to a movie where where the
02:05:14.120characters are not supposed to be talking the way real human beings yeah and and the sleight of hand
02:05:20.440that this film does and again of in this era this was probably seen as very novel but it gets very
02:05:26.780meta this is people who work in television specifically aware that they work in television
02:05:33.460and they're commenting on their situations as if they were television that becomes a plot point
02:05:39.240later where uh max schumacher played by william holden is speaking to diana played by faye dunway
02:05:46.340seeing he's older she's younger he says she basically represents tv she's not real and
02:05:52.840we'll get into his character because i don't love his character that much in this but
02:05:56.760because she's an unreal person she speaks in an unreal way but so do all the tv people in this
02:06:02.960and you're locked into this world they're speaking in like tv jargon and we're all used to it now
02:06:09.720but back then it was about ratings there's a q scores there's what all this other stuff and
02:06:14.060bantering back and forth about that but so the movie is almost telling you that you're watching
02:06:22.320this sort of like meta analysis of media by fake media people who are aware that they're being
02:06:29.020meta about you know i mean so you know that that like i get it i get like there's like as i'm
02:06:34.940watching this film i'm like okay i get it none of this is lost on me it's not unskilled and maybe
02:06:40.720i'm just not wowed by it just like i'm watching this and i don't love what i'm seeing but is it
02:06:46.420bad no like would i remove any scenes i don't i don't as i'm watching it i'm watching it with a0.90
02:06:54.480fucking you know scalpel in my hand saying what would i remove from this movie to make it better0.96
02:06:59.260i'm not sure i would remove anything every scene's pretty essential to what's going on if anything0.98
02:07:06.320it could use a bit more it could use a bit more especially in the back third of it or maybe they
02:07:12.440spend a bit too much time between because i was thinking like maybe we could remove the relationship
02:07:17.720between the character max and diana but i'm like well he can't because that represents it's it's
02:07:23.620an a it's a commentary on age and within the medium and so i don't know if i could remove
02:07:28.700anything but it's just there's when i watch these satirical movies it may i want to see what you
02:07:34.920think about this but when i watch this like even death of stalin or any of these sort of black
02:07:38.700comedies they never know how to end i don't i don't think i like the ending to this it's too
02:07:45.800it's very abrupt yeah it's very abrupt it's abrupt and it feels like it's missing something
02:07:52.780it wasn't something that wasn't tied up like it fits together well it's orchestrated well
02:07:58.540everything it's set up earlier and then it pays off at the end it's very well timed but i'm just
02:08:04.380there's like a emptiness after you watch this movie maybe i'm i'm demanding too much right i'm
02:08:10.700looking at this saying this is the academy award winning scripts well this doesn't feel like a
02:08:16.780legendary script but like maybe my expectations i don't know it's just that there's a certain
02:08:21.580hollowness to it that even in terms of the plot it just needed a bit a bit of something like
02:08:28.400max schumacher's character maybe we should even just explain what the movie's even about before
02:08:32.580i get too deep into it yeah we can do that um i mean it's basically about a tv news anchor going
02:08:40.140insane that would be howard beale the man who who threatens to kill himself on live television he's
02:08:47.380like a old news anchor he's basically been let go towards the end of his career because his ratings
02:08:53.700are beginning to decline also keep in mind his wife passed away not long before this and he is
02:09:00.200developing a drinking problem that's correct yeah that's all part of it because it's i think it's
02:09:07.000important to say and i didn't catch this when i watched it when i was younger the first time so
02:09:12.240this is an aging newsman and his ratings were already declining this was a guy being put out
02:09:18.220to pasture just because he was generally uninteresting i think they expressed that very
02:09:24.760early on and then he's let go and he's drunk and part of it was inspired by the case of
02:09:32.760christine chubbock so this was a woman from the uh in this this happened in the 70s
02:09:39.800um i think it would have happened when was this movie released like okay two years before the
02:09:45.480movie came out this was the woman who blew her brains out on tv that never happened before she1.00
02:09:51.560she was just a news anchor her life sucked fem cell and she kills herself and so that that was0.74
02:09:59.300like a big moment in american tv and um so that that's kind of what he starts with he goes on tv0.79
02:10:06.740and he says well um this is gonna i'm gonna be gone in a week uh tune in a week from now i'm
02:10:12.980gonna blow my brains out everyone's freaking out his best friend and so just so people know
02:10:18.180we're following howard beale he's kind of set up as the main character but he's not really his
02:10:22.480the main character i would say is a guy named max schumacher who's similar these are old men
02:10:28.020these are veterans of the television industry in the 70s and uh he's his i guess the station
02:10:35.900director i don't know what his job would be he's he's like his boss basically or direct report
02:10:40.500and then but they're friends they've come up together and then so howard beale's about to get
02:10:47.280fired but then the big wigs at the network robert duvall plays one of them um there's a few other
02:10:55.940people in there but they said oh hey the ratings are pretty good you know that's interesting then
02:11:01.800you know beale says okay let me back let me give a real farewell speech so he said they they his
02:11:08.880friend helps him out max helps one he says okay go on do it right and then he takes back the0.99
02:11:14.760suicide base says you know what i'm just i'm sick of the bullshit my whole life has been bullshit0.99
02:11:19.660i just can't bullshit anymore and he gets into this sort of straight talking confessional space0.99
02:11:26.520and then people respond very well to that the ratings start to go up that's interesting0.63
02:11:31.600and so i i cut you off and just jump right into did you want to build on that
02:11:36.580no no you're doing you're doing fine but yeah it's basically the the i mean the the
02:11:42.860ultra quick synopsis of the film is like the network capitalizing off of a man's
02:11:50.440mental breakdown right and discovering that yeah it's more that that's more captivating than
02:11:57.420the you know walter cronkite objective news source that we've all yeah apologized at this
02:12:04.700point so yeah the real heart of the story there's a couple things that happen so howard beale as
02:12:10.520this raving truth teller um he becomes attractive because there's this woman young woman a young
02:12:19.080program director named diana christensen who works at the station she's got all kinds of
02:12:24.200radical new ideas on how this network ubs it's like number five in the rankings and they're just1.00
02:12:32.620this like known this bullshit network no one gives a shit about she wants to be number one0.98
02:12:37.060she wants to go counterculture she wants to go radical she wants to one of the recurring themes0.99
02:12:44.020in this is the um ecumenical liberation front which are based on the symbionese liberation
02:12:50.220army which is a real black radical group in that era so they just found the idiom directly compares
02:12:56.900like do you mean the symbionese i mean nope we mean this other one but they're just by the way
02:13:02.020the stuff with the black revolutionary militia is the only times that i laughed that i actually
02:13:08.220laughed out loud or chuckled during this movie yeah i know this is a comedy but it's it's a very
02:13:12.680bleak movie yeah that's a good b plot in the film that i quite like but she's like i want to get
02:13:18.780them we're going to call it the mao zedong hour and we're going to follow them as they rob banks
02:13:23.600they send us footage of them robbing banks kidnapping heiresses which is what they did in
02:13:28.180real life and we'll air it and just groundbreaking stuff and she's the one who advocates for Howard
02:13:34.080Beal said put this guy on the air have him tell the truth the entire time Robert Duvall's character
02:13:39.780he wants to get rid of everything but he's he's got a game plan in the background as well because
02:13:44.920he wants to be the boss his boss ends up dying now he's in charge now he can clear house
02:13:49.840in the background of that we get to later there's a big sale of the network that's going to happen
02:13:55.900to saudi arabia but we're getting ahead of ourselves so diana chris there's something
02:14:00.960of like a thriller going on in the background like almost a conspiracy thriller which is0.89
02:14:05.900legitimate and interesting but anyway so max being like i don't know fucking 95 years old0.81
02:14:13.920starts up an affair with diana christensen and and there you get this plot line where it's like0.84
02:14:19.260he's the old guard she's new he's infatuated with her she represents something new and fresh0.91
02:14:25.100and exciting he's been married for fucking 900 years but in this really great scene like this0.80
02:14:32.360is what we're talking about before so he leaves his wife for her and their scenes are very kind0.86
02:14:38.380of phony very meta but there's this one great scene like i said it was almost plucked from a
02:14:44.200different movie and dropped into this where he's telling his wife that he's been having an affair
02:14:49.020and he's leaving what should i do should i move out and she's like very understanding is that do
02:14:55.780you love her you know this isn't just a secretary she's you know this isn't just you know a one
02:15:01.920night stand this and she's got it's it's very emotional very evocative and she's got this one
02:15:08.680line where she says you know this this is just like if this is a winter romance you know i'm
02:15:13.880your wife why can't i have a winter romance and if you can't give me a winter romance why don't i
02:15:20.460deserve respect and it's like it's really good and then you you switch over to like this fake0.99
02:15:26.720bullshit but just to say this before i before i lose it i just felt like max schumacher's character0.85
02:15:32.560never received any sort of comeuppance you know i mean like he kind of like he left it he didn't0.98
02:15:38.160i don't know like he needed something else like he blows up his marriage you know seemingly very
02:15:43.640suddenly to you know be infatuated with this woman that represents like new modernity represents the
02:15:51.960revolution that's taking place in the streets and in the process he kind of learns that he's a hack
02:15:58.320because here's the let me just i'm all over the place right now but one thing i noticed in this0.84
02:16:03.140film that i found somewhat frustrating was it was it's a movie calling tv bullshit saying that tv's
02:16:12.600ruining america tv ruins everything but it you know obviously directed by cindy lume but0.93
02:16:18.580to that i would say well movies aren't much better you know i mean it it's it's a very arrogant type
02:16:26.080film and this is what movies had thought for the longest time like we're real art you're just0.76
02:16:30.440fucking tv but they both accomplished a lot of the same thing propagandistically culturally0.63
02:16:36.520whatever you want to call it so it was always looking down on tv and then you also have the0.99
02:16:41.960character max schumacher you know the old fucking dinosaur talking about diana christianship that he0.92
02:16:47.380says at one point like you are tv you're a generation raised on tv you are tv and i say0.99
02:16:51.700you're tv too everyone in this fucking movie is tv like you you're part of the same fucking machine0.98
02:16:58.480i don't like this pretentiousness that he gets and i don't think that pretentiousness0.99
02:17:04.480is reconciled i don't think that pretentiousness really gets its comeuppance later like he's always
02:17:10.380he's he remains above everything and outside of everything right at the end but i'm like
02:17:15.820you're just a hack like you are just like you realize you're a hack but there must be something
02:17:20.700more that happens to your character because everyone else kind of suffers in this thing0.61
02:17:25.660except him he gets to have a wry smile and his little romance like oh yeah i'll be fine i'll go1.00
02:17:31.500back to my wife like just fuck you you tv hack you know yeah but you're no you're no better than her1.00
02:17:38.380not really she's just got the volume turned up you you produce like shitty1.00
02:17:43.500new like you're not obsessed with ratings you're above rings shut the0.98
02:17:48.060up i'm talking to him like he's a real person
02:17:52.860no the movie wanted me to believe that he was like something else and that's
02:17:56.300where i was like i'm not i don't think so anyway yeah it's strange i think the
02:18:01.500movie kind of goes i don't know it vacillates between creating this sort of
02:18:07.660passing of the generations and i don't know venerating that the old guard as this kind of
02:18:16.700lost camelot or this golden era of respectability but at the same time showing what kind of flawed
02:18:25.900creatures these are it is funny you mentioned grand torino as this sort of boomer fantasy but
02:18:31.740this in another way is a boomer fantasy because you got the older generation saying i don't
02:18:36.460understand you you're raised on tv you're something else i'm like yeah raised on the tv you created0.99
02:18:43.300motherfucker you see what i'm saying like that's such a boomer sort of thing to think like what0.99
02:18:47.920happens like the tv made it yeah but you make tv you you made her yeah yeah she she she says that1.00
02:18:54.600she was obsessed with you in college you were her hero she read all your shit she listened to all0.98
02:18:59.780your speeches you fucking made her and i just like all boomer moralism tales i i think they've1.00
02:19:06.160removed his responsibility from it it's like i'm a boomer i i created this now i get to fuck it0.99
02:19:12.000and now i'm done fucking it so i want to go home because i'm scared i want to you know what i mean0.99
02:19:17.840fuck max schumacher anyway but i'm saying this because that's most of the movie0.98
02:19:24.040right a lot of people it's like eyes wide shut when people think of eyes wide shut they think of0.99
02:19:29.780the uh you know the scene at the mansion the orgy scene like everyone thinks of this way they think
02:19:35.140of howard beale's rants but like most of the movie is like those two that relationship howard
02:19:42.040beale like isn't even in it that much it's true yeah yeah and it's it's hard to know what to make
02:19:49.420of it because as you said they are they're both having to operate as these like generational
02:19:55.280symbols and the i mean the script is actually quite heavy-handed when it's saying you are
02:20:00.180television diana um yeah and that's like it's satire so like i guess it needs to have that but
02:20:07.780i would have appreciated a bit more subtlety there's like a lecture there's a few lectures
02:20:14.100that go on at the end one is very good it's the one everyone's thinking of uh you know the the
02:20:20.500big one in the boardroom that one's yeah we gotta talk about that yeah and maybe maybe we'll get to
02:20:25.460that next just so we don't run out of time but there's other sort of lectures later on where i'm
02:20:30.440like okay this you were complaining about this at the start like this kind of takes me out of it i
02:20:34.660feel like we're spinning our wheels right now this could have been a show don't tell a moment
02:20:38.920well i guess that i mean the the the movie kind of goes in two directions because like on the one
02:20:47.580hand it's being very cynical about kind of the audience and going down the ladder to the consumer
02:20:56.020right to the recipient of the television and exposing us all as just these sort of you know
02:21:02.340dopamine addled beasts who uh you know will or like you know we're just like barking seals and
02:21:10.080we'll we'll take whatever we can get we just want the most um you know exciting television
02:21:18.420but as that's happening you sort of um also are creeping your way up the ladder and it offers
02:21:25.820this critique of power um and you know the the idea and that's where i think max the character
02:21:35.160of max is problematic because he's he's the closest thing that the film has to like a walter
02:21:41.140cronkite right or like some sort of you know ultra dignified old newsman but um as we go as
02:21:50.160like you know howard beale kind of as we move up the chain of command and we see the inner workings
02:21:55.720of the network and how they're about to see it to sell you find out they're about to sell to some
02:22:00.180sort of like arab conglomerate and you know there's no credibility to the audience and there's
02:22:07.700no real credibility to the up the hierarchy or down the hierarchy i guess that's what i'm trying
02:22:13.320to say yeah and um just building on that when i first saw this film that was completely lost on
02:22:21.300me because there's a few rants in this film that people have probably seen clips of if they looked
02:22:26.400it up the big one is you know i'm mad as hell i'm not going to take it anymore so that would have
02:22:31.900been the third speech that he gives in the film it kind of builds up to it he's soaking wet he's
02:22:38.200coming in from the rain and at this point he's almost like he's possessed and the film is very
02:22:46.460clear on this because you see a scene of howard beale laying in bed alone laying awake staring
02:22:54.160at the ceiling and he's talking to voices in his head and you don't hear what the voices are saying
02:22:59.800you just see him responding to it so the film is telling you like this guy's either out of his mind
02:23:05.420or he's commuting with some sort of otherworldly entity that isn't god because he tells this story
02:23:12.740in a future speech i think that that happens after this speech i'm talking about but
02:23:17.800anyway he basically talks about the voice he was hearing in his head and he says that the voice
02:23:24.880wasn't god so you're talking to a demon you're talking to another intervention and if if we're
02:23:31.880going with you down that path but by this point like he he has lost his mind the film is clear0.89
02:23:37.460this guy's just fucking insane okay so let's start with that secondly let's look at the substance of
02:23:43.820what howard beale actually said in these revolutionary populist speeches and to a young0.92
02:23:51.700person like when i watched this i just thought it was kind of cool and interesting and here's a
02:23:57.420funny thing you can do at home go on letterbox go on reddit and watch the film but then look at what
02:24:05.080people are saying about it because that whole speech he does like i'm mad as he gives this0.94
02:24:11.180fucking rant of platitudes just vagaries it actually means nothing right he goes on there0.98
02:24:18.340like the fish is too expensive there's war in the middle east the government is lying to you just0.99
02:24:25.140like billy joel's we didn't start the fire yeah and again this is the 70s this was not an era
02:24:31.140where this was unheard of there was people criticizing society and the government since0.56
02:24:35.720the fucking beat generation right so it's not like society at large wasn't aware of this it0.95
02:24:42.300wasn't a massive pressure release or wouldn't have been within that world but he's just giving0.98
02:24:47.420these platoos and say i want you to go outside and say i'm mad as hell and i'm not gonna take
02:24:53.620it anymore and then people do it they and then max is there and he looks out his window and there's
02:25:01.060people out of the window and they're screaming it in the streets and it's this massive and within
02:25:06.680this world in the 70s like when you're a top show you're getting like nine million people watching
02:25:12.460it so there's people there's thousands and thousands of people doing this in the world of
02:25:16.540this film but i remember max has this look on his face as he's watching these people just taken up
02:25:22.860in the moment and electrified by it he's almost uh disappointed and ashamed and i looked at that0.97
02:25:28.580i read on his face like you understand this is bullshit you you don't know what these people are0.95
02:25:33.140doing they're swept up in something but there is no substance to it and really if you look at all0.99
02:25:38.660the speeches it's the same sort of fire and brimstone nothing it's fucking nothing but
02:25:44.420people it's it's and very quickly becomes a commoditized revolution they're almost immediately
02:25:51.060the network the corporation sees it tries to make money off and diana is a instrumental in that
02:25:58.580because she sees and says let's make let's build a show around him just him instead of you know the
02:26:03.720news little segment and there's going to be a soothsayer and there's going to be a like all0.98
02:26:09.200the kooky shit we're going to make a show of kooky future predictions and counterculture shit0.95
02:26:14.800and so like very cynically trying to like capture and market that energy and maybe put him above his1.00
02:26:24.000pay rate put him in a place where he shouldn't have that responsibility what the fuck is he doing0.97
02:26:28.820he's out of his mind and he's saying nothing he's he sounds like a homeless man if you really0.98
02:26:34.560listen to it um later on there's one last speech that gets him in trouble and we can talk about
02:26:40.560that but i wanted to hear what your thoughts there or what i interpreted this movie doing with
02:26:48.240more mature eyes it was like it was because i haven't seen every movie from the 70s or 60s
02:26:55.260but this seemed like one of the original films that was like critiquing populist
02:27:00.860not conspiracy culture but like populist revolutionary action like it portrays the1.00
02:27:07.440people as going along with it maybe the people are kind of stupid and howard beale is insane0.96
02:27:13.540and it works like so it's like a critique on that it's really the movie and if you look at the0.99
02:27:20.100ecumenical liberation army like it is a critique on populism and revel the revolutionary fervor
02:27:27.140of that era and i think i don't think it gets credit enough for satirizing that like it wasn't
02:27:32.880even necessarily it was satirizing tv in corporate america but more than anything it was satirizing
02:27:39.020populist revolutionary action yeah i i think that beale beale is the most uncomfortable part
02:27:49.200of the film for me because i just find it almost cruel the depiction that the film has of him and
02:27:55.620the attitude that the film has towards him because i agree with you i think he is just objectively
02:28:01.760like a sad old insane man this is a guy who's going to kill himself at the start right
02:28:08.880Yeah. And it's it's you know, there's no he's not a holy fool. He's not shown to have much of any. He's not like Moses coming down from the mountain. He's not. He's not like a purveyor of truth, capital T truth in any real sense.1.00
02:28:29.580it really is just somebody who's lost their mind and we see that he's easily manipulated when he
02:28:36.120has his run-in with um i can't remember the name of like the president or the ceo yeah like the
02:28:44.200main guy the top guy and um maybe we should set up i don't know if you want if you want to get
02:28:50.480into that right now or we can do that next but if you wanted to finish up that thought because
02:28:54.480that almost deserves to be its own thing yeah yeah no i mean i think that's that's all i had
02:29:00.140to say about him but it's just um it's just such a cruel everything that happens to him i mean but0.56
02:29:06.380that's also the point right like he is this pathetic creature and diana and everybody at
02:29:14.020the network have no pity for him at all i mean the only person that does have pity is max um and0.96
02:29:21.480the only one who kind of points out like i think this man needs medical intervention when he calls
02:29:27.720him out he says you are taking my friend you're making a mockery of him you're this guy he's he's
02:29:33.400having a breakdown he uses that word and uh you don't get the sense that howard beale has any
02:29:41.400desire for fame either like he's not doing it to be manipulative like he really believes0.97
02:29:48.200what he's doing and so in a sense he could be seen as something of a holy fool but maybe not holy
02:29:53.880he's just uh some kind of something's happening that he's swept up in i would have liked it if
02:30:00.840we followed him a bit more you know what i mean like i think we need to get in get inside his
02:30:06.280experience a bit because he dies at the end you know spoiler alert um in in a very sort of um
02:30:13.800darkly humorous but cynical way you know very very bitter it's got it's a bitter ending
02:30:22.140um but let's discuss the what you were just talking about the meeting with arthur jensen
02:30:29.640played by ned beady who's like portrays like the top guy the ceo the as high as you can get what
02:30:36.940happens is one night i have a fight of him but maybe i don't there's like when people see it
02:30:45.260there's like a famous scene in the boardroom it's amazingly well lit um but uh howard beale
02:30:53.180go just one night goes on his show and instead of just the sort of apocalyptic vision he's saying
02:31:00.460that this network ubs is being sold to this to a corporation to a holding company and that holding
02:31:08.860company is being sold to the saudi arabians and he's just going out there almost like alex jones
02:31:15.660but saying that look this is this is a this is a corporate sale and you're letting foreigners into
02:31:21.660this country which you know you wouldn't even be able to have that narrative right now but0.99
02:31:26.300But in that film, it's like, do you want a bunch of fucking Saudis owning your network?0.98
02:31:32.060And he's going off on stuff that you would hear from any podcast in our scene.0.98
02:31:35.620He's like, the Chinese own a port in Chicago or like in Louisiana.1.00
02:31:41.980And the fucking Russians own this.1.00
02:39:56.520you know we i talked about dehumanization but is dehumanization so bad and we're talking about
02:40:04.560nick land that line more than anything but is dehumanization so bad like there's you can watch
02:40:11.640this with 21st century eyes and pick some of these lines and and they would have sounded good at the
02:40:18.760time but there's a lot of depth to them now and then what happens is his ratings start to go down
02:40:24.940people don't want to hear it they can't it's too depressing it's too weird and up and
02:40:30.940he starts to become less popular while delivering this while delivering the actual truth this is
02:40:37.180the truth of it this is what people can't accept it and he suffers for it but yeah so and then
02:40:44.060that's the movie telling you once again what these people were being delivered previously was not the
02:40:49.420truth it was just this sort of sensationalist blather here here's the real here's the real
02:40:56.700dirt on what's happened like i i can't take this bring me back to i'm mad as just screaming out
02:41:02.780the window i'm mad as hell and i won't take it anymore but what does that accomplish what does
02:41:06.140that mean telling people you're mad like shut the up that's nothing you know and then0.62
02:41:12.620they're going to keep howard biel doing that and this comes from arthur jensen he's like
02:41:16.940like just keep delivering the message and you wonder if there's another plan at play there or
02:41:21.620if they're actually trying to deliver the truth but you don't know because then the movie just
02:41:25.520kind of ends but anyway what did you think of all that yeah i don't i mean the thing that sticks
02:41:31.580with me most of all too is that speech that gets delivered to beal it's um i mean one it's i mean
02:41:38.440if you if you assume that this guy is kind of he's sort of brilliant the the the ceo because
02:41:46.620he's presenting that he's delivering this message in the exact perfect style that he needs to
02:41:53.060deliver the message to beal in order to get this to sink in like he's he's more beal than beal
02:41:59.040right which is the way that that probably the only way that he was going to listen
02:42:03.740to somebody or get reprogrammed but um i guess that's also but that's what i'm talking about
02:42:10.140when i say that like it's just the movie is so acidic and it annihilates because like
02:42:18.140you know you would if if the boomer news anchor generation of max and howard has more kind of
02:42:26.360dignity and credibility that would be because there's they're closer to god in some way they're
02:42:32.720closer to the truth right the capital t truth um that god bestows on us but they're just but what's
02:42:40.640the only thing that's standing behind them or standing above them so to speak in this kind of
02:42:45.280hierarchy of um the truth is this man who's you know giving this completely and utterly nihilistic
02:42:54.820speech about you know countries are not real you know national identities are not real
02:43:03.040the only thing that is real is the flow of capital so there's not anybody in this movie that i mean
02:43:10.120i guess maybe he is the one character that has credibility um only because he's the one that
02:43:17.340uh can face up to that kind of total nihilism and annihilation um so yeah that's why i just i find
02:43:28.460the movie so terribly dark if you look at the expression on howard beale's face he's in awe
02:43:35.140of what he's hearing he's terrified but he is receiving the message and then you understand
02:43:41.360that well this is a guy that's just been looking for a message it's the exact same eyes he had
02:43:46.680when he's laying in bed communing with whatever entity he's convinced he was communing with so
02:43:52.220it's like here's a man in search of a god and in neither case does he find one but he wants to be
02:43:58.620a follower he wants to help the people he wants to be a good shepherd and so you've got this
02:44:03.200you know at the core of it this good shepherd archetype that's just used and abused by this
02:44:09.780system and at the very end he's he's sacrificed to get the uh ecumenical liberation army to just
02:44:18.380shoot him live on the air um yeah and then he gets shot and then he dies and the final
02:44:25.180line you get is and that's the story of howard beald the only man in the history of america who
02:44:30.800was killed for low ratings because at this point his his ratings were kind of low and that's kind
02:44:36.280of like a pithy funny little way to end it but right i don't know after all that stuff we just
02:44:41.880talked about happens in the last like 25 minutes there's a lot it's a pretty long movie but it's
02:44:48.080boom boom boom boom boom done and then i just that's kind of like the the roller coaster going
02:44:54.200down it's very exciting and then you just boop there we go right right to the end and i'm just
02:44:59.600i would have liked a little bit of something more i don't know you know you know what i mean like
02:45:04.820did it feel like something was was missing because it gives you a lot it gives you
02:45:10.740like we're saying that speech of the system of systems is dealing with very heady ideas that
02:45:15.460you're not expecting from a film like this like that whole back half it hits you with so much
02:45:21.540depth that it's almost like you're watching a different movie because you don't know where
02:45:26.340it's going to go the entire time there's so many ways this film could have played it safe and it
02:45:30.580didn't but then i know you're kind of hoping that it gives you a little bit more maybe that's the
02:45:36.420joke that's the comedy of all it's like not that he died then the the system survives that's it
02:45:43.060yeah you know a slightly more humanitarian message and something that would have kind of tied up the
02:45:49.460loose end of max's plot line because yeah i think i agree with you it just sort of seems like he
02:45:55.140he gets off light but like if max kind of abducted beal in some way or like took him away from the
02:46:02.940network before they were trying but before they succeeded in his his assassination and just like
02:46:09.100i don't know like drove off with him or got him the kind of like help that he needed and there0.98
02:46:15.400was just this final gesture of like you know well maybe we've been full of shit our entire careers0.95
02:46:19.940maybe we're no better than than diana and it's all junk but like you were my friend howard and0.97
02:46:27.260i'm going to like take care of you or something like that that would have been like a bit of
02:46:31.480humanity that the movie could have left left the viewer with but it that but it did it did not do
02:46:39.060that yeah it's i keep coming back to the conflict that emerges at the end where it's like howard
02:46:46.280beale is becoming less popular so as a result the entire network because he had the number one show
02:46:52.340in the nation and now the entire network is hurting because he's losing share and he's the
02:46:56.800lead-in to the mouse a dung hour the black radical show and they're pissed off about it too because0.75
02:47:02.820like you were saying earlier there's like a b plot following them in negotiations so they're
02:47:08.020obviously marxist revolutionaries but that they're in contract negotiations with the execs and
02:47:14.720they're more concerned about the profit sharing and syndication like it's it's very you know
02:47:20.480that that is funny watching them just betray their principles and and once again the movie's
02:47:26.440screaming at you that these revolutionaries are just sellouts and manipulators just like anyone
02:47:32.720else even though they they do what they say they do they do rob bangs they do kidnap people they
02:47:37.780did shoot howard beale at the end but that was only in a way to protect their time slot
02:47:43.680you know to get him off the air so they get better ratings or something this is all coordinated by
02:47:49.840diane this is all coordinated by the executives because they can't they can't fire him they can't
02:47:56.300fire him for delivering the truth and this hurts diane's strategy of selling people on commoditized
02:48:04.200revolution the corporatization of revolution so in that sense it's like a conflict between the
02:48:10.940actual truth and like the entertainment counterculture and i guess the entertainment
02:48:17.980counterculture wins and then the truth loses because the people weren't ready to hear it
02:48:23.900um and then they shoot howard beale just to protect their ratings to protect their savings
02:48:28.540to protect future deals um yeah so that that's that to me is the most interesting conflict like
02:48:36.380Like it almost, it gets away from the past versus the present in the form of Max and Diane saying, you know, this is the future of TV and I'm the past and here's my commentary on that.