Full Comment - October 05, 2026


Don’t wait up for history’s costliest hypothetical pipeline

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
What was B.C.’s David Eby thinking by calling the maddest Canadian election ever? The ‘disruptive’ professor who refuses to be censored

Episode Stats


Length

49 minutes

Words per minute

162.33

Word count

8,023

Sentence count

459

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 visit betmgm casino and check out the newest exclusive the price is right fortune pick
00:00:06 betmgm and game sense remind you to play responsibly 19 plus to wager ontario only
00:00:12 please play responsibly if you have questions or concerns about your gambling or someone close to
00:00:16 you please contact connects ontario at 1-866-531-2600 to speak to an advisor free of charge
00:00:23 betmgm operates pursuant to an operating agreement with i-gaming ontario
00:00:28 Millions of people win with OLG
00:00:31 Over 200 million wins last year alone
00:00:34 Common side effects of winning with OLG
00:00:36 Shock
00:00:37 Disbelief
00:00:39 No way
00:00:39 And laughter
00:00:40 It's what happened to Tristan from Hamilton
00:00:42 When he won the $1 million Lotto 649 gold ball draw
00:00:46 Shock and awe
00:00:47 All on his lunch break
00:00:49 Play at olg.ca
00:00:51 And the next person sitting stunned in the break room
00:00:53 Could be you
00:00:55 With OLG winning happens here
00:00:57 Before you knew what a stock was, you traded snacks, cards, turns.
00:01:04 That instinct to trade didn't disappear.
00:01:07 It just grew up.
00:01:08 With no minimums, no monthly fees, and 100 free trades,
00:01:11 TD Easy Trade taps into that instinct.
00:01:14 Because you are made to trade.
00:01:16 And TD Easy Trade is made to help.
00:01:20 The Canadian taxpayer is going to make a lot of money off this pipeline.
00:01:24 Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney announcing a new pipeline, sort of, kind of, in Fort McBury, Alberta last week.
00:01:32 Hello, welcome to the Full Comment Podcast. My name's Brian Lilly, your host.
00:01:36 This pipeline announcement, part of a process that's been going on for about a year now,
00:01:41 trying to find out if the federal government can declare this pipeline from Alberta to BC's West Coast a project of national interest.
00:01:51 Today, we're ready to move forward for Albertans, for Canadians.
00:01:57 And I'm proud to announce that the government of Canada is officially listing the West Coast Pipeline,
00:02:03 now known as Pacific Link, as a project of national interest.
00:02:10 You can hear Danielle Smith clapping in the background there.
00:02:13 Alberta's premier, clearly someone who was happy.
00:02:16 One year ago, this project was a vision.
00:02:19 Today, it has a clear path forward.
00:02:21 Today, we will make Canada an energy superpower.
00:02:24 What is that path forward?
00:02:26 And is it a clear path forward?
00:02:28 Joining me to talk about this are two fellow columnists with Post Media.
00:02:32 Lauren Gunter is with the Edmonton Sun.
00:02:34 He's been covering politics since Moses was in short pants, and so was Lauren.
00:02:39 Chris Varco has been covering the energy industry since the 1990s and knows it well.
00:02:43 So since you covered the energy industry, Chris, let me start with you.
00:02:48 What is this announcement and what isn't it?
00:02:52 Well, that's a good question because what it is, is it's a fast track for approvals at the end of the day.
00:02:59 What the government here has done is basically said that they will set the conditions or the regulators will set the conditions for this new pipeline to the West Coast by September 2027.
00:03:11 which is a fast track compared to where we've been in the previous years where it's taken two
00:03:16 three four years to get to that point in time so presumably by september 1st 2027 they will know
00:03:23 what the conditions are to get this project going what it isn't is it's not an approval it's not a
00:03:30 final investment decision by the proponents which are the governments of canada the government of
00:03:35 alberta and pamina pipeline it also is not a commitment by producers to put oil in the pipeline
00:03:40 yet. So there's a lot of road here to be traveled before we even get to a final investment decision.
00:03:47 Can you give us a quick description of what this commitment document that they talk about,
00:03:57 that they have to get to by the end of the year, what that is all about? Because when I looked it
00:04:02 up. Northern Gateway, when it was approved in November or December 2013, it had a list of 209
00:04:11 conditions. Sorry, it's a conditions document. You could end up with a list that makes it impossible
00:04:18 to build as of next September. I don't think that's the government's intent, but if bureaucrats
00:04:24 are involved, who knows? So what exactly is the conditions document that they have to get to?
00:04:29 Well, what the regulators will do, and in this case, this will be the Canada Energy Regulator, along with the Major Projects Office.
00:04:35 They will do an environmental review.
00:04:37 They will look at the routing.
00:04:39 They will look at all the economic and environmental conditions.
00:04:42 They will also do consultations with landowners, with Indigenous communities, with other affected stakeholders.
00:04:48 Then, presumably, we will see a list of conditions that will say, you can build it if you meet all of these various criterias.
00:04:57 And that's what we saw with Northern Gateway, which you referenced. Trans Mountain saw the same thing with the expansion project. So these are the conditions that you have to meet in order to build it. And then at that point, presumably, the proponents will make a decision. Do you go or no go?
00:05:13 So, Lauren, that doesn't sound to me like what Mark Carney promised during the last election and said he would deliver in his victory speech on election night when he said we will need to think big, act bigger.
00:05:29 We will need to do things previously thought impossible at speeds we haven't seen in generations.
00:05:34 Chris is right.
00:05:35 It's speeding it up.
00:05:36 But this is still an incredibly long process.
00:05:39 It's it's almost a year and a half since Mark Carney won that election saying, let's do fast things.
00:05:47 And we're only at the point where we're saying, OK, in 11 months, we'll tell you, here's the conditions for you to do it.
00:05:55 Yeah. And, you know, this is just one more stack of paper in the process.
00:06:00 So last November, you had the prime minister and Alberta premier, Danielle Smith, sign a memorandum of understanding.
00:06:08 Oh, my goodness. Wow, this is wonderful. There's going to be a pipeline because we have a memorandum of understanding. And then in June, the provincial government put forward its outline of what the pipeline would look like and presumably what it would cost.
00:06:24 And, oh, isn't that marvelous? Now we have more concrete paper on this.
00:06:31 And this is, to me, it's just yet another paper affirmation that the pipeline will be built at some time, maybe.
00:06:41 That's the best we have right now, though, is maybe, isn't it?
00:06:44 Yep. And, you know, there are some significant parts of this that are pleasing.
00:06:51 For instance, it's the first project declared in the national interest by the major projects office.
00:06:58 Who would ever have guessed that a liberal federal government would approve a pipeline as their number one national interest project for Alberta?
00:07:10 That's staggering, but there's still, there isn't a shovel in the ground.
00:07:15 I think if I went out to Bruderheim, which is just north and east of Edmonton here where the pipeline will start, and I started digging around, the Mounties would be there fairly quickly to say, what in heaven's name are you doing?
00:07:27 Because there isn't any real construction happening yet.
00:07:33 Chris, once we get to that conditions document, let's say that they do get approval, they get the conditions document, Premier Smith was saying she's hopeful that, you know, we could start construction next year, even with a short list of conditions.
00:07:51 Do you have an estimate, a best guess on how long it might take to actually start putting those shovels in the ground after the document is released in September of 2027?
00:08:06 When I spoke with her yesterday, she said, you know, they would like to see shovels in the ground almost immediately.
00:08:13 So we're talking the fall of next year.
00:08:16 That seems like a very rapid timeline.
00:08:18 As I said, there's a lot of other things that have to happen here.
00:08:21 Like we're talking about the regulatory approval process.
00:08:24 But we haven't actually gotten to the economics of this yet.
00:08:27 And that's the question of how much does it actually cost to build another pipeline from Bruderheim all the way down into southern British Columbia?
00:08:35 The last time that happened was with the Trans Mountain expansion.
00:08:37 And that cost a lot more money than anyone ever anticipated, right?
00:08:41 $34 billion.
00:08:43 This project, estimated, is supposed to cost $35 to $44 billion.
00:08:49 So now you have to figure out, well, what are the tolls for the shippers?
00:08:52 There's companies here that have to actually make long-term 20, 25-year commitments
00:08:57 based upon what is the cost to build that project
00:09:00 and what does it cost to move the oil through that pipeline.
00:09:03 So we can talk about the politics or the regulatory approval all day long,
00:09:07 but the economics at the end of the day have to make sense
00:09:10 or nobody's going to put their oil in that pipeline.
00:09:12 I guess it might help that at the moment, Western Canadian Select is trading at $80.52, which is quite a bit higher than it was, say, in the spring of 2025 when the province was looking at an absolute shattering of their budget and deficit.
00:09:34 But I'm not sure that's a long-term sustainable price. How much of the cost increase on Trans Mountain was a result, though, of endless consultations, protests, the government of the day not really caring that those protesters were getting in the way, that they were blocking construction.
00:09:59 This government doesn't seem like, you know, if it goes forward, that they're going to be willing to sit there and say, you know what, keep blocking that bulldozer.
00:10:07 We'll tell the RCMP to stand down.
00:10:10 There were a lot of reasons why that project went over budget, and maybe one of the biggest ones was the endless delays.
00:10:16 You may remember that the federal government botched the consultation process and then had to go back and redo it.
00:10:24 That took an entire year out of the schedule, at which point money had already been spent.
00:10:28 There was also delays that were connected to COVID, to workforce.
00:10:31 There were all kinds of delays.
00:10:33 That project took more than a decade from the time that it was proposed to the regulator to the time that it was actually built.
00:10:39 So there were lots of reasons why that project ran over budget.
00:10:43 What are your thoughts on the politics of that side, Lorne?
00:10:47 One of the other reasons there were delays is that the federal government entertained every cork challenge there was from environmentalists and indigenous groups.
00:10:57 and through almost every case. They didn't make their best arguments. They sometimes would take
00:11:04 a lower court judgment to appeal. And the whole process just dragged out because the
00:11:10 environmentalists and the First Nations who were opposed. And it's always very important in these
00:11:16 pipeline discussions to understand that there are First Nations who like the project and are quite
00:11:21 happy to be involved in it as equity partners. And there are First Nations that don't like it.
00:11:26 So by entertaining all of these lawsuits from environmentalists and First Nations who are resistant, that added probably another year and a half.
00:11:42 You talk about First Nations groups opposed and in support.
00:11:46 I know with the rain of fire here in Ontario, the media keeps focusing on the one group, which happens to be the furthest away from the actual rain of fire.
00:11:55 so the the one that will receive the least economic benefit but we've also seen over the
00:12:02 years lauren um greenwashing of different groups foreign money coming in do you when russia was
00:12:11 doing that over a decade ago they weren't distracted by a war with ukraine that they're
00:12:15 not doing particularly well in do you see the saudis or the russians or anybody else saying
00:12:22 you know what, we can fund some groups up there, or maybe Tides Foundation and Tom Steyer
00:12:27 decide that they're going to do it. Do you expect to see that kind of opposition being foreign 0.95
00:12:33 funded yet again? Yeah, sure, I do. Now, I don't think it will go as far as it did last time,
00:12:39 because it kind of caught everyone off guard. I think the people who are behind this in the
00:12:45 provincial and the federal government are much more aware that those tactics are going to be
00:12:50 attempted. And I hope they'll be ready for them. I can't guarantee they'll be ready for them.
00:12:56 But, you know, I think that the biggest opposition will come from foreign-funded First Nations, 0.93
00:13:04 because as soon as a First Nation says, oh, my goodness, you're going to destroy our 0.74
00:13:09 traditional hunting grounds, there's a reporter and a crew from CBC in particular who rush out
00:13:17 and hear them. If you remember the coastal gas leak, which was the LNG pipeline that was running
00:13:23 from northeastern BC down to the central coast of BC, there were lots of protests against and
00:13:33 there were several chiefs who were opposed to it. But it turned out that every elected chief,
00:13:38 most of the First Nations along the route had an elected chief and a hereditary chief. And all of
00:13:43 the elected chiefs had signed on, and it was only hereditary chiefs, many of whom were not really
00:13:49 hereditary. They'd been simply appointed to their positions. They were opposed, and yet Trudeau
00:13:55 went out and he met with the hereditary chiefs, and there were endless reports from the Globe and
00:14:01 Mail and Toronto Star and the CBC about how these poor First Nations people were being jobbed by
00:14:08 big oil companies. That's what they have to worry about. That's what they have to fight against.
00:14:13 chris let me ask you about the economics of um the pathways project to me this was when the
00:14:23 industry was going along with the idea of capturing carbon capture and storage a few years ago
00:14:28 you know you would hear people say yes well the industry supports this project or the industry
00:14:34 supports a carbon tax my view was always they didn't really support it but they tell you they
00:14:41 would if you would approve their project it was a bit like the dane geld they'll pay it if they
00:14:46 have to what's industry telling you now in terms of the economics of still going forward with
00:14:54 pathways to get this pipeline approved well i think the industry first off is not in favor of
00:15:03 an industrial carbon tax and they've made that pretty clear over the last six months
00:15:07 So that's sort of the starting point.
00:15:09 The separate point is that they are willing to go ahead, I think, with the Pathways project,
00:15:14 particularly if the economics are there for them to increase their production into the oil pipeline.
00:15:19 Remember, these two projects have been linked by the Kearney government that they both have to go ahead.
00:15:24 In other words, you get no pipeline if you don't get Pathways.
00:15:27 So that basically means that you need to have the production to fill that pipeline.
00:15:31 And both the federal government with some of its tax incentives and the provincial government,
00:15:36 which is going to change the royalty rules, are going to try and incent that production.
00:15:40 So these things will all kind of work together as a sort of as an economic sort of tie in.
00:15:47 But I don't think you can separate one from the other.
00:15:49 This is all part of a big basket.
00:15:51 And so the industry views it as a basket.
00:15:53 And that's what they're willing to proceed with.
00:15:56 I mean, but they were lobbying to try and get pathways dumped.
00:16:01 I think if they they know that the Kearney government is linking it.
00:16:04 But am I incorrect to believe that if they had their druthers, it would just be a pipeline and not a carbon capture and storage project attached to it?
00:16:14 Oh, absolutely. I agree with that.
00:16:16 I think they see pathways as an additional cost that they're going to face that virtually no other industry other than maybe in Norway will face.
00:16:24 They also think that if there was no pathways, they could invest money in the pipeline.
00:16:31 But one of the things that wasn't mentioned yesterday in the Fort McMurray announcement is that there are no private investors yet for the Pacific Link pipeline.
00:16:41 And it could cost $44 billion.
00:16:43 I think it would cost more than $44 billion.
00:16:45 If Trans Mountain costs $34 and we're now further down the road inflation-wise, this could easily cost $55 billion.
00:16:53 And you might get some private investment for that if they weren't also being required to put $20 billion into carbon capture.
00:17:02 But when you put those two together, there's an oil company in the world that wants to put that kind of money into something.
00:17:09 Let me ask you both about that part of this.
00:17:13 So they didn't spell it out in the news release that I read, but they said the government of Canada, government of Alberta, will jointly own it.
00:17:20 10% will go to First Nations communities along the route.
00:17:24 So, you know, I'm taking it that it's going to be 45% federal, 45% provincial until I know otherwise.
00:17:34 There was a time when private sector companies lined up.
00:17:38 Is it just what you were talking about, Lauren, the Pathways Project?
00:17:41 or is it that we haven't done the regulatory work to make this oil patch and this pipeline
00:17:51 attractive as an investment? Because I'll tell you, when the investment summit was here in Toronto,
00:17:57 people were saying great things and they're saying, yeah, we love the new attitude. We love
00:18:02 the fresh approach. It's a lot nicer than the last guy. It's very interesting. And then there
00:18:09 was a but. And the but was Canada has not yet done the regulatory requirements, and this is across
00:18:16 all business, not just the oil and gas industry. You haven't done the heavy lifting to make things
00:18:22 attractive. Right. I mean, the companies that were involved in Energy East, Northern Gateway,
00:18:30 Keystone XL, all put in more than a billion dollars in getting through the regulatory process,
00:18:35 only to have all three of those pipelines canceled.
00:18:39 You're sitting in a CEO's office in a tower in Calgary,
00:18:45 and somebody's trying to get you to put money in.
00:18:48 You're going to think, no, we already did this once,
00:18:51 and we are not going to risk our shareholders' capital again
00:18:55 on a project that the next government or this government,
00:19:01 if it gets into trouble with its base, is going to cancel.
00:19:04 So there has to be some real proof that this is going to take place.
00:19:10 And I think that means that taxpayers, not shareholders, on the hook for all this.
00:19:16 I thought it was funny that Carney said in Fort McMurray, taxpayers are going to make a lot of money from this.
00:19:22 Yeah, maybe after a 30-year amortization of the costs.
00:19:26 I mean, there will be revenues coming in from transporting oil, as there is with Trans Mountain.
00:19:33 Trans Mountain's bringing in a couple billion dollars a year for Ottawa and similar amounts for Alberta and B.C.
00:19:43 But, you know, that doesn't include making payments on the pipeline.
00:19:50 So because governments don't have to make payments.
00:19:52 They already paid for it. 0.99
00:19:54 They jacked up taxes.
00:19:56 They took money from ordinary Canadians and they paid for the pipeline.
00:19:59 So I think they're thinking of the same model for this one.
00:20:03 And, you know, this could have been perhaps the most expensive week for taxpayers in Canadian history because also this week, Danielle Smith and Ontario Premier Doug Ford said that they wanted to rush ahead with the Northern Shield pipeline, which gets Canadian oil to Ontario without having it to go through Minnesota, Wisconsin, and Michigan.
00:20:26 and that's maybe $33 billion.
00:20:31 So I don't see any private investors lined up for that one either.
00:20:35 So what we're talking about here could be $80 billion
00:20:38 to taxpayers to build these two pipelines.
00:20:41 Given the ongoing threats from the Democratic governor of Michigan,
00:20:49 the court cases in Michigan, and everything else,
00:20:52 Ontario may have no choice but to build that pipeline eventually.
00:20:56 Because it appears that, you know, we're all worried about what the Republican resident of the White House is doing to Canadian trade.
00:21:03 And in Michigan, where we've long had really tight economic relations, they just want that pipeline gone.
00:21:12 They want line five done.
00:21:15 The government and her Democratic core want it done because they've convinced themselves it's a huge environmental danger.
00:21:24 But I don't think the average Michigander wants it gone.
00:21:28 I don't think they care one way or the other. 1.00
00:21:32 Chris, what were your thoughts on that Northern Shield announcement?
00:21:36 Because you were there when Premier Smith and Premier Ford were chatting about it in Calgary last week.
00:21:44 Does it feel to you like it's something real?
00:21:47 Were the people in the business audience taking it as real?
00:21:50 I know from speaking to Premier Ford that he's quite serious about it, but do people take him seriously in Calgary?
00:21:59 I think people in the industry take the Ontario Premier seriously, but I think you have to remember where this project is.
00:22:06 This was just floated as an idea that was going to have a feasibility study back in July during Stampede Week when Premier Ford and Premier Smith met here in Calgary.
00:22:15 and now they're basically moving that process along but they're still waiting for a feasibility
00:22:20 report so we don't have a really have a route we don't have obviously any proponents like this is
00:22:24 very early in the process and there are a number of other projects you know that are looking to
00:22:30 move ahead whether it's an expansion of the trans mountain system an expansion of the
00:22:34 enbridge mainline system there's another line which is basically going to sort of revive
00:22:38 parts of the old keystone excel project and then of course this west coast project so
00:22:43 So I think everyone in industry would view that this one is the furthest back in the planning process.
00:22:48 It's also probably got the most challenging economics.
00:22:51 I mean, if you think about the cost, that $34 billion to go to the West Coast with Northern Gateway, that was 1,200 kilometers.
00:22:59 This would be 3,300 kilometers, a lot of it going through Shield.
00:23:04 So the cost, I think, would probably be well in excess of that, probably in excess of $50 or $60 billion by the time that you got it built.
00:23:11 So the economics would be really challenged. Then you get into the question of, OK, who's going to pay for it and what are you paying for? Are you just looking at this as an economic prospect or are you investing in this for some other reasons, for national security, energy security reasons? And that's where sort of the risk calculus changes.
00:23:29 Yeah, well, I think it's all of the above for Ford. He doesn't like the idea that the Michigan governor is going to hold a gun to his head. And what did they say? Pearson would run out of jet fuel within seven days if the line was completely shut down and they didn't have an alternative.
00:23:49 Yeah, well, and think of all those dairy barns in Quebec that would be unheated in January because they don't have propane.
00:23:56 You still found a way to bring it back to supply management, Lauren.
00:24:00 That's amazing.
00:24:02 All right, we need to take a break.
00:24:04 When we come back, I do want to talk about some of the many wins that Ontario,
00:24:08 that Alberta Premier Danielle Smith has gotten over the last little while
00:24:12 and bring in the separatist angle to this.
00:24:15 We've talked about how Indigenous groups will oppose.
00:24:18 Well, how does the Alberta separation argument, vote, factor into this?
00:24:23 But first, don't forget, we've got merch.
00:24:25 you want to get your National Post, your Calgary Herald, your Edmonton Sun,
00:24:30 hats, totes, hoodies, T-shirts, you can get them all.
00:24:34 It's postmedia.store.
00:24:36 Show your support for great journalism and look good while doing it.
00:24:39 Postmedia.store.
00:24:43 Visit BetMGM Casino and check out the newest exclusive,
00:24:46 the Price is Right Fortune Pick.
00:24:49 BetMGM and GameSense remind you to play responsibly.
00:24:51 19 plus to wager.
00:24:53 Ontario only.
00:24:54 Please play responsibly.
00:24:55 If you have questions or concerns about your gambling or someone close to you,
00:24:58 please contact Connects Ontario at 1-866-531-2600 to speak to an advisor.
00:25:04 Free of charge.
00:25:05 BetMGM operates pursuant to an operating agreement with iGaming Ontario.
00:25:11 Millions of people win with OLG.
00:25:13 Over 200 million wins last year alone.
00:25:16 Common side effects of winning with OLG?
00:25:19 Shock.
00:25:20 Disbelief.
00:25:20 No way.
00:25:21 And laughter.
00:25:22 It's what happened to Tristan from Hamilton when he won the $1 million Lotto 649 gold ball draw.
00:25:28 Shock and awe.
00:25:30 All on his lunch break.
00:25:31 Play at olg.ca and the next person sitting stunned in the break room could be you.
00:25:37 With OLG, winning happens here.
00:25:39 Winner.
00:25:40 Ganyo.
00:25:41 Sorry.
00:25:43 Investing.
00:25:44 Trading.
00:25:44 That isn't a personality.
00:25:46 You don't need the voice.
00:25:48 You don't need the jargon.
00:25:49 You don't need the podcast.
00:25:50 you already know how to trade
00:25:52 you've done it your whole life
00:25:54 and TD Easy Trade taps into that instinct
00:25:57 so you can build something real
00:25:59 no minimums, no monthly fees
00:26:01 24 hour support
00:26:02 no investor personality required
00:26:05 because you are made to trade
00:26:07 and TD Easy Trade is made to help
00:26:10 download it now
00:26:11 you're a political junkie, right?
00:26:13 I mean, that's why you're listening to this podcast
00:26:15 but if you're not in the loop
00:26:18 With PostMedia's VIP political hack, then you're not getting even close to the whole politics story.
00:26:25 I'm Stuart Thompson, Parliamentary Bureau Chief.
00:26:28 And I'm political analyst Tasha Carradine.
00:26:31 We head up the team that brings political hack members the exclusive political intel that goes so much deeper than the news.
00:26:37 With inside stories, sharp analysis, and behind-the-scenes scoops from Parliament Hill and beyond.
00:26:43 With our twice-weekly newsletters, exclusive reports from Washington, D.C., early access to John Iveson columns, and subscriber-only videos and events,
00:26:54 PAC members get insider insight into the minds of the strategists, policy gurus, and power brokers shaping Canada's political future.
00:27:03 You don't want to miss all that, do you?
00:27:04 I sure don't.
00:27:06 And you can get all now for less than a dollar a week.
00:27:10 Just go to NationalPost.com slash newsletters to sign up.
00:27:16 That's NationalPost.com slash newsletters.
00:27:20 So much is happening in politics right now.
00:27:23 Rising tensions with the U.S. on trade and defense.
00:27:26 Not one, but two provincial separatist movements gaining real ground.
00:27:30 The liberals trying to hang on to a razor-thin majority
00:27:33 as the economy stumbles and with the cost of living still rising.
00:27:38 It's exciting.
00:27:39 Extremely exciting.
00:27:40 But the only way to get behind the scenes and right into the source code of what politicians and the people around them are really thinking is to get political hack.
00:27:48 Go to nationalpost.com slash newsletters.
00:27:52 And join us.
00:27:53 This is Tristan Hopper, the host of Canada Did What?
00:27:56 where we unpack the biggest, weirdest, and wildest political moments in Canadian history you thought you knew and tell you what really happened.
00:28:04 Stick around at the end of the episode to hear a sample of one of our favorite episodes from season two.
00:28:09 And if you missed it, there are even more episodes from last season.
00:28:13 So make sure you subscribe to Canada Did What?
00:28:16 Everywhere you get podcasts.
00:28:17 Alberta Premier Danielle Smith was clearly happy, as I said earlier,
00:28:21 when it came to the announcement in Fort McMurray.
00:28:24 Not a pipeline, but moving forward with one.
00:28:26 While she was giving her speech, though,
00:28:29 she took the time to list off all the wins that she's received over the last while,
00:28:34 and it's substantive.
00:28:35 So here she is talking about them.
00:28:37 Unfortunately, what you can't see is Mark Carney looking, well, uncomfortable behind her.
00:28:42 That agreement has delivered major wins for Alberta, including, of course, an agreement to advance an oil pipeline to Asian markets,
00:28:51 a commitment from the federal government not to proceed with a federal oil and gas emissions cap so that our energy producers can thrive again,
00:28:58 abeyance of the federal clean electricity regulations in Alberta, which would have placed our electrical grid at serious risk of failure
00:29:05 and limited our industry's ability to grow in the future,
00:29:09 an impact assessment agreement to streamline project reviews,
00:29:13 reduce duplication, and reinforce provincial jurisdiction,
00:29:16 suspension of the federal zero-emission vehicle mandate,
00:29:19 and, of course, removal of the greenwashing provisions in the Competition Act.
00:29:23 I mean, that's a lot of Ws for Premier Smith there.
00:29:26 She's done well out of this agreement.
00:29:29 Who wants to go first?
00:29:30 We can all agree that, you know, it's a good thing that the pipeline proposal, at least, is moving forward.
00:29:37 We can agree that it may take too long.
00:29:40 We can agree there should be public sector money behind it.
00:29:44 But I did not expect, even with Mark Carney saying things were going to change, that all the things the premier just listed would ever happen with a liberal government.
00:29:55 Did either of you expect what she listed off to be the current reality?
00:30:00 Well, I'll jump in first and just go back to the MOU last November. I think everyone was pretty surprised at the scope of all of the things that were included in that. The oil and gas emissions cap was obviously a big deal. The methane regulations, the Impact Assessment Act.
00:30:16 I think one of the sleeper ones in all that was the clean electricity regulations.
00:30:21 Those being put into abeyance means that the Alberta government can actually move forward on building or having industry build natural gas, fire, power plants.
00:30:30 That allows you to build an entirely new industry built around data centers.
00:30:35 So there were a lot of things in that aside from the pipeline and the pathways project.
00:30:39 And I think a lot of people in the industry were really surprised at how many items got included in that MOU.
00:30:47 Explain why that was important, Chris, the clean energy regulations.
00:30:53 And isn't Alberta's electricity grid mostly natural gas already?
00:30:58 I mean, I know you don't have the big hydro of BC or Quebec, but what powers the Alberta grid now?
00:31:06 Yeah, it used to be primarily coal-fired power going back about 10 years ago.
00:31:11 And the industry has been moving over to natural gas primarily, along with some renewables over the last 5 to 10 years.
00:31:19 Alberta's got a lot of natural gas, and that is going to continue to power the grid for years.
00:31:24 But with the clean electricity regulations that the Trudeau government put in, they basically had put a sunset period over when those projects had to stop operating.
00:31:32 And so that meant that industry wasn't prepared to build new gas plants.
00:31:37 So you were going to end up in this period where you were going to have some older plants come off, and then what was going to replace it?
00:31:42 That was a giant question for industry, and industry wasn't prepared to make an investment until they got some clarity on that.
00:31:48 So that's why it's important that the clean electricity regulations were included in that MOU, and that allows industry to build new gas firepower plants in the province.
00:31:57 Y'all got to go nuclear.
00:31:59 Finally, Saskatchewan is.
00:32:00 Just as an aside.
00:32:01 But after decades of digging the uranium out of the ground but refusing to build a nuclear plant, they're going to move forward with it, which is, I think, smart on their part.
00:32:12 Lauren, your thoughts on the long list that Premier Smith had.
00:32:17 You've been skeptical of the liberal government in Ottawa a long time.
00:32:21 Did it surprise you?
00:32:24 Oh, yeah.
00:32:25 Oh, absolutely.
00:32:26 And, you know, the reason it surprised me is that there aren't that many different faces in caucus than there were when Justin Trudeau was the prime minister.
00:32:38 And they were all behind, at least they all claimed to be behind, all of his green regulations.
00:32:45 And Stevanjibo was still in the caucus under Carney when most of this was announced.
00:32:52 And he was, of course, the big driver behind a lot of this.
00:32:56 He's now gone because of all these wins for Daniel Smith.
00:33:00 Exactly. And he tried very hard to take other people with him and they wouldn't go.
00:33:04 So politically, this has been easier to undo a lot of the Trudeau damage than I expected.
00:33:12 I think, as you said, Brian, we're still looking at an awful lot of companies that aren't prepared to invest until they know with certainty what's going to happen.
00:33:23 But, you know, the whole idea, we spent billions of dollars in the 20 teens in Alberta converting coal-fired power plants to natural gas.
00:33:35 And then Stevan Jibo comes along and says, no, no, no, no, no, natural gas is a dangerous fuel source.
00:33:43 So you have to go to wind turbines and solar farms and bug burps or whatever it is that, you know, he decided was going to work.
00:33:52 And it would never have worked.
00:33:53 We'd have ended up here.
00:33:55 We had two winters ago, we had a time when we had sustained temperatures of minus 30 or below.
00:34:03 And the wind farms all shut their turbines down because the blades can break at that temperature.
00:34:09 And so here we were with reduced energy, sort of brownouts.
00:34:15 It's not a big percentage of Alberta's energy production yet.
00:34:18 But it was big enough that when everyone was heating their homes, these wind turbines not working had an obvious effect.
00:34:30 The provincial energy regulator recommended to Albertans that they go around their house and turn off all the unnecessary systems.
00:34:37 Don't run your dishwasher at six o'clock in the evening.
00:34:40 Don't, you know, don't turn your lights on outside.
00:34:44 All of that stuff.
00:34:45 We were all supposed to, we were so worried there'd be these huge blackouts.
00:34:48 that the energy regulators said, oh, run around your house and flip down all the switches you can.
00:34:55 So that has been a big relief that natural gas is no longer a toxic substance with this government.
00:35:05 And, you know, with the Impact Assessment Act, which we had dubbed out here the No More Pipelines Act,
00:35:11 it's still there, but it's been gutted.
00:35:15 So Carney can say to his environmental caucus, oh, no, no, no, we still have the Impact Assessment
00:35:20 Act.
00:35:21 But you can also take a look at the fact that the major projects office can override much
00:35:26 of what's in the Impact Assessment Act.
00:35:29 The Impact Assessment Office cannot hold things up as long as they used to.
00:35:34 I think all of these have been very, very big wins.
00:35:36 But I think they're joint wins.
00:35:39 I think they're joint wins between Danielle Smith and Mark Carney.
00:35:42 I don't think Danielle Smith would have gotten very far with any of these, unless Mark Carney was the prime minister, and he's pro-development.
00:35:52 Chris, in terms of the, you know, I think Lauren's correct, and the Impact Assessment Act is in some ways gutted.
00:35:59 I think also just a different vision of how to implement it.
00:36:04 I know it's called the No More Pipelines Act in much of the country.
00:36:08 Stephen Gaubeau tried to make it the No More Highways.
00:36:10 He tried to get involved in local road decisions here in Ontario, saying, no, no, you can't build that road there, to which the federal government had never been involved in that sort of thing.
00:36:20 They told Scott Moe he couldn't build a renewables electricity plant because it had gas backup.
00:36:28 I mean, he was trying to shut down everything. And this is a different mindset, which I think really shows up in the one project, one review, one year. How welcome is that to the industry?
00:36:43 I think that's hugely welcome. I think that's always been a concern. And I know that when Gibo was the minister, they talked about using the Impact Assessment Act to look at things like SAG-D, thermal oil sands projects, projects which are completely within the boundaries.
00:36:58 the province of alberta but they were going to look at uh doing you know assessments on those
00:37:04 kinds of projects so that would have thrown a huge element of risk into those kinds of investments
00:37:09 along with you know what the impact assessment act would have done on cross-border pipelines which
00:37:14 obviously we didn't see a lot of cross-border pipelines being proposed during that period of
00:37:18 time so i think the industry uh was certainly welcoming of the changes to the impact assessment
00:37:23 act all driven by one change in leader because as you said lauren so many of these people are
00:37:29 the same ones around the table yeah absolutely and and um so far i i hate to be a skeptic i
00:37:38 hate to throw cold water i still haven't seen anything from carney of a concrete nature as
00:37:46 you said when he was having his investment summit in toronto people were so excited about the change
00:37:52 in tone, the change in approach. But I don't see an awful lot of investment coming out of that
00:37:58 because there haven't been a lot of changes in taxation, regulation, all of the things that
00:38:05 incentivize companies to invest. So we'll wait. We'll see. We'll see if Mark Carney goes the next
00:38:13 step and becomes a concrete reformer a concrete business developer so chris it what what would
00:38:22 the asks be from the industry on that front well what would be their shopping list the shopping
00:38:27 list of things that they want to see would start with i think that pipeline i think to lauren's
00:38:32 point there is an element of skepticism here about the ability to get projects done because
00:38:37 the past has told us that it's been an inability to get projects done which has put a huge risk
00:38:43 premium into any kind of investment decision. So there are going to be a lot of people watching
00:38:49 this pipeline project to see whether it gets done. And it is primarily being proposed and
00:38:55 it's going to be paid for by taxpayers. Pembina pipeline has got a 10% stake, a non-binding stake,
00:39:00 and they can make it 20% if that project goes through. But the fact is that the governments
00:39:06 are having to build it because private industry is not willing to take on the risk. So they're
00:39:09 going to be watching to see whether that project can get through if that project gets through
00:39:13 then i think you're going to see people go okay this process does work but it's got to actually
00:39:19 happen all right let's talk about the politics of this because i i know they said in their mou that
00:39:27 they would make an announcement by october 1st but they waited until october 1st they could have
00:39:32 announced this a while ago we've we've all known it was headed this way they waited until october
00:39:37 first and i think a certain vote happening on october 19th on the future of alberta and do you
00:39:45 want to have a referendum on whether you want to have another referendum on whether to separate
00:39:52 from canada it's a convoluted way but you know keith wilson who is uh one of the uh the most
00:40:00 thoughtful and uh engaging guys on the leave side and i've debated keith because i told him
00:40:07 well, I like you, but you're wrong. He put out a video in response to the Pacific Link
00:40:14 announcement. And I'll play you part of what he said, but it's framed within the
00:40:21 parameters that he put forward, which said, it's kind of like one of those marriages where the
00:40:28 husband is a deadbeat, doesn't do anything until the wife decides she wants to look at better
00:40:34 options and then he shows up with a a bouquet of flowers so obviously in his mind uh canada and
00:40:42 the federal government is the deadbeat spouse and alberta is the abused spouse and here's how he
00:40:48 framed the arrival of this pipeline announcement well i'm encouraged that this that there's some
00:40:55 glimmer of hope of market access we need to remember that the concerns that many albertans
00:41:03 have about our relationship with Ottawa was never just about a pipeline.
00:41:08 And on October 19th, if you accept the bouquet, you are and vote option one,
00:41:17 you're basically saying, yeah, the bouquet is good.
00:41:19 We're good, honey.
00:41:21 You can do the abusive relationship for as long and as much as you want.
00:41:26 That's the message you're sending to Ottawa by voting option one, that status
00:41:31 quo is fine. Everything's okay. I don't love the battered spouse analogy. I get the grievances,
00:41:38 but I don't love that analogy. But politically, Lauren, does this whole issue factor into
00:41:46 the pipeline decision? Does it alter the vote on October 19th now that Carney's made it?
00:41:52 What's your read? Two separate questions. Yes, the Alberta government and the federal government
00:42:00 announced this when they did in a hope of swinging more votes over to the remain side,
00:42:09 the no side, as it's known here. So the timing is not coincidental. But will it have much impact?
00:42:18 No, I don't think so. I think people's minds were made up. Janet Brown, who is a highly esteemed
00:42:24 Alberta pollster took a look at this a while ago, and she said most of the people who were voting
00:42:33 yes or no, who were voting separatism or confederation, had made up their minds months
00:42:40 ago, and they knew what they were going to vote. Thankfully, so far, she's found, as most pollsters
00:42:48 have, that Albertans are split about 70% in favor of staying and about 20% to 25% in favor
00:42:56 of leaving.
00:42:57 And Keith is right.
00:42:59 I mean, I like Keith Wilson a lot.
00:43:01 Very, very smart guy, as you said, and a very tempered guy.
00:43:05 The other two people who run the Alberta Prosperity Project, who started this whole
00:43:10 separatist thing, Keith Rath and what's his name?
00:43:16 Jim R.
00:43:17 Sylvester.
00:43:17 Yeah, Sylvester
00:43:19 They're wacky
00:43:21 They're over the top
00:43:24 They turn more people off than they turn on
00:43:28 But Keith has the ability to talk to people at a rational level
00:43:32 And maybe make them change their minds
00:43:34 But I still think that so long as there is a good turnout
00:43:39 On October 19th
00:43:41 And Elections Alberta is expecting an 85% turnout
00:43:46 We have never had 85% turnout for anything like this.
00:43:51 If there's an 85% turnout, the separatists lose big time.
00:43:56 Now, they have promised they're not going to go away anywhere, but at least they lose some credibility if the vote is 65-35 or if it's 70-25.
00:44:08 Whatever it is, if they get trounced, they don't have the same leverage than if there's a low turnout, and they won't win with a low turnout either, I don't think.
00:44:18 But they could end up with 40% of the vote, which then lets them say, aha, see, there are lots of people who agree with us, and so therefore you have to listen to us going forward.
00:44:29 But no, I don't think the announcement yesterday makes an enormous difference in the outcome, because I think the outcome was already set in stone months ago.
00:44:41 You know, I keep seeing people say, including, you know, smart folks that I like, like Norman Spector, former top bureaucrat in Ottawa, former top bureaucrat in B.C., and he says, based on his experience with how Quebec's been able to use it, Alberta should have a strong vote for option two so they can hold the knife to the throat in Ottawa and get what they want.
00:45:04 And I just look economically at what has happened to Quebec.
00:45:09 And Quebec, when I was born, Montreal was the business center of Canada.
00:45:15 By the time I was leaving high school, Montreal was no longer the business capital.
00:45:22 Their economy was utterly depressed.
00:45:25 They have never recovered.
00:45:28 So, Chris, looking at the Quebec example, are people in Alberta saying,
00:45:33 hmm, you know what? Flirting with this separatism thing, this could be really bad for business.
00:45:38 This could hurt the industry. This could drive away investment instead of attracting it.
00:45:44 Yeah, I would say the business community was pretty quiet on this issue for a number of months.
00:45:49 But in the last few weeks, maybe the last couple of months, they've started to, I think, become a little more vocal.
00:45:55 I was at a Calgary Chamber of Commerce news conference this week where they brought out a report that was done by
00:46:00 a university of calgary economist trevor toome and they talked about the economic consequences
00:46:04 of what separation could do to the economy in terms of to the gdp loss this is a province that
00:46:11 i think everybody knows is really contingent you know really bases its economy upon trade
00:46:16 both trade abroad and to other provinces so it would have big consequences the other thing is
00:46:22 this is a province that has a lot of major projects that are moving ahead or either planning to move
00:46:29 ahead or in the middle of moving ahead, like the $10 billion Dow project that's going on up in the
00:46:34 Edmonton region. And anything that creates uncertainty is a problem or an issue for
00:46:40 investors. So that is, I think, the overriding concern is that this drags on beyond, you know,
00:46:47 the next few weeks or even a few months, that this could actually start to have an impact upon
00:46:51 investment. I don't think it has yet, but I think it could if this drags over time.
00:46:57 Well, gentlemen, thank you very much for your time today.
00:47:00 I don't think we've solved all the problems of the world,
00:47:02 but we know what this pipeline announcement is and what it isn't,
00:47:05 and I think that's important.
00:47:07 So thank you both.
00:47:08 You're welcome. Thank you.
00:47:09 Thanks for having us.
00:47:10 Full Comment is a post-media podcast.
00:47:12 My name's Brian Lilly, your host.
00:47:13 This episode was produced by Andre Pru, theme music by Bryce Hall.
00:47:17 Kevin Libin is the executive producer of the show.
00:47:20 Thanks for listening.
00:47:21 Make sure that you hit subscribe wherever you get your podcasts,
00:47:23 share this on social media, and tell your friends about us.
00:47:26 Thanks for listening. Until next time, I'm Brian Lilly.
00:47:30 Here's that clip from Canada Did What? Season 2 that we promised for you.
00:47:35 Let me take you back to the night of October 30th, 1995,
00:47:39 to the hours right after that likely fatal bullet was dodged.
00:47:44 We're awaiting the reaction from the Quebec Premier at the time, Jacques Barizeau,
00:47:48 who was championing separatism and had just narrowly lost the vote he had held to try and get it.
00:47:54 Did I say narrowly? It was a razor-thin loss. 49.42% of voters said yes to Quebec independence, 50.58% said no.
00:48:07 The difference was just above half a percent, less than 55,000 votes out of nearly 5 million.
00:48:15 Now there's a generally accepted protocol for what a politician is supposed to do when they lose a vote.
00:48:21 You come out, concede defeat, congratulate the victor,
00:48:25 kiss your spouse, and thank your supporters.
00:48:27 But every once in a while, a politician comes out and says what they really think.
00:48:33 They just let it all out in front of news cameras.
00:48:35 The bitterness, the disappointment, the recriminations, 1.00
00:48:39 a no-filter tirade about how the voters are idiots, and vowing revenge. 1.00
00:48:45 That's what happened on the night that Parisot lost the referendum for Quebec independence. 1.00
00:48:49 If you don't speak French, that's Parizeau saying that although they lost the referendum,
00:49:00 Quebec's French speakers voted 60% for independence.
00:49:04 The implication being that if they simply ignored the non-French Quebecers,
00:49:09 those who weren't real Quebecers, that is immigrants, Jews, indigenous people,
00:49:13 McGill University students, they would have won this referendum in a walk.
00:49:17 if you want to hear the rest of the story
00:49:20 make sure you subscribe to Canada Did What
00:49:23 everywhere you get your podcasts