Full Comment - September 21, 2026


It’s showy, it’s insubstantial, but Carney’s EU scheme is slick politics

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
How Conservatives can get their groove back What was B.C.’s David Eby thinking by calling the maddest Canadian election ever?

Episode Stats


Length

49 minutes

Words per minute

161.11

Word count

7,911

Sentence count

418

Harmful content

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Recently, our company's softball team lost the big game by one run.
00:00:04 Then Dale tried to console us with the quote,
00:00:07 winning isn't everything.
00:00:09 Well, Dale and I are very different.
00:00:12 I get early payout from Bet365.
00:00:14 If my team goes up big, I get paid out instantly,
00:00:17 even if they blow the lead later.
00:00:19 Sound familiar, Dale?
00:00:21 Thanks, Bet365.
00:00:22 Must be 19 or older, Ontario only.
00:00:24 Please play responsibly.
00:00:25 If you have questions or concerns about your gambling
00:00:26 or the gambling of someone close to you,
00:00:27 please go to connexontario.ca and see supply.
00:00:30 It's the Family and Friends event at Shoppers Drug Mart.
00:00:33 Get 20% off almost all regular-priced merchandise
00:00:36 Monday, September 21st to Wednesday, September 23rd.
00:00:40 Open your PC Optimum app to get your coupon.
00:00:48 This is about sovereignty.
00:00:52 Our ability to live as we wish.
00:00:56 Prime Minister Mark Carney saying that the push to draw Canada closer to the EU is all about sovereignty.
00:01:03 That was during his speech to the European Parliament last week,
00:01:06 the speech where he talked about the thing he denied was ever going to happen,
00:01:09 the potential of Canada becoming the first ever associate member of the European Union.
00:01:14 What does that mean?
00:01:15 Well, no one's really quite sure because it doesn't exist yet, but we're hoping to find out.
00:01:20 Hello and welcome to the Full Comment podcast.
00:01:22 My name is Brian Lilly, your host, and this week we're going to try and delve into what this means in terms of the politics of it, but also the trade realities.
00:01:31 We've got a couple of experts lined up to discuss those issues with us.
00:01:35 But before we get to that, let's talk about the politics a little bit, because when you listened to Carney's speech, yes, he talked about the need to draw together financial regulations,
00:01:47 have a single financial services market,
00:01:50 the desire to open up trade and natural resources, and more.
00:01:55 But there were also a lot of political cues throughout his speech.
00:01:59 The economics of this are clear.
00:02:01 The leverage of the powerful in an exploitive relationship
00:02:04 collapses well before complete independence is achieved
00:02:09 because diversity confers advantage.
00:02:13 The objective is not self-sufficiency.
00:02:16 it's collective resilience. He talks about how he's not doing this in response to the United
00:02:24 States and then talks about the Americans without naming them as an abusive relationship. Later in
00:02:30 the speech, he went on to talk about how, well, we have better manners than the Americans. I also
00:02:36 want to be precise about what I am not proposing. I'm not proposing a third block in order to be
00:02:46 And again, lots of laughter, lots of applause for Carney.
00:02:56 His biggest applause lines came when he was attacking the Americans.
00:03:01 But for him, this is not just about trade, as I said.
00:03:06 It is about, well, to quote Pierre Trudeau, a just society.
00:03:10 We are not fair-weather allies.
00:03:14 We do not pursue zero-sum deals.
00:03:19 Our commitment to the rule of law and our unyielding defense of human dignity, individual freedom, and democracy share the same deep roots, the same unwavering dedication.
00:03:33 We hold common values for which we have always fought and in whose defense we must always remain vigilant.
00:03:45 We believe that a strong economy is not an end in itself, but a means to a just society.
00:03:54 You can see the political thread throughout Carney's speech.
00:03:56 And of course, that's against the backdrop of Donald Trump saying that he would impose tariffs on the EU and Canada if this was seen as a hostile act or coming from a bad place.
00:04:07 We'll have to wait and see what Trump's reaction to all of this is long term.
00:04:12 He's probably waiting for details just like the rest of us are.
00:04:15 But what to make of the trade side of this?
00:04:18 Well, Anand Menon is a professor of European politics and foreign affairs at King's College London and director of the UK and a Changing Europe initiative.
00:04:27 He's someone who's studied Brexit closely.
00:04:30 He knows how the EU operates and he has some thoughts that might help Canadians try and understand what we're entering into.
00:04:38 Here is our conversation.
00:04:39 So Mark Carney, using the term associate member of the European Union, the thing he had previously said wasn't actually going to happen. Anand, what do you say to Canadians who are looking at this and cheering it on and saying everything's going to be rosy, everything's going to be good?
00:04:57 I firmly believe in expanded trade with the European Union, but I know there's obstacles in
00:05:03 the way from regulations that would block us to regulations they would say, if you don't adopt
00:05:09 these and do things our way, you can't trade. I mean, the first thing I'd say to Canadians is
00:05:14 you clearly have a prime minister who's very good at politics, because in terms of politics and in
00:05:19 terms of symbolism, the speech by Ursula von der Leyen yesterday and by Prime Minister Carney
00:05:24 today were very, very effective. The salutary note I'd add on to that is associate membership
00:05:31 doesn't actually mean anything. There is no such thing legally. It is a term that the
00:05:35 commission president literally made up yesterday. And we'll have to wait and see over the months
00:05:42 and years to come as negotiations start between the EU and Canada, what, if anything, it means
00:05:46 on substance. But I'm a strange person. And so I like reading source documents and legally
00:05:53 binding agreements and you can look to things like the agreement between the european economic
00:05:58 area so norway iceland lichtenstein you can look at the agreement with switzerland
00:06:05 you don't we've already got a free trade agreement with the eu you don't get deep trade access beyond
00:06:14 say something like cita without agreeing that well the bureaucrats in brussels are going to
00:06:20 make the decisions for you. That's been the experience of Britain. Britain has said no to
00:06:25 allowing Brussels to resume its role in regulating British life. And so you don't have the deeper
00:06:31 trading relationship that Britain has sought. Can Canada get one when Britain can't, when Norway,
00:06:38 Iceland, Lichtenstein, Switzerland could not without ceding sovereignty? I mean, there are
00:06:44 many, many layers to your question. The first I'd say is, once you get to the nitty gritty of
00:06:50 trade negotiations all EU member states have to sign it off so all EU member states have to feel
00:06:56 they're getting something and not being damaged by that deal and as we saw with CETA it's very
00:07:01 very hard to get all EU member states to sign a trade deal with anyone so that's the first thing
00:07:06 is there a practical difference the second thing is geography the biggest single determinant of a
00:07:11 country's trade pattern is geography and whether you like it or not your biggest trading partner
00:07:17 is the United States. And I suspect whether you like it or not, your biggest trading partner will
00:07:21 always be the United States, just because if you look at a map, you can see why. In the same way
00:07:27 that the United Kingdom's largest trading partner is the European Union, whether we're in the EU or
00:07:31 not, because they're next door. That means several things, I think. Firstly, you'll never have massive
00:07:37 volumes of trade with the European Union. They might go up slightly with the trade deal. They
00:07:41 won't go up enormously. But secondly, given that, it probably isn't worth Canada's while
00:07:47 thinking about regulatory alignment with the EU, because if you align in regulatory terms with the
00:07:53 EU, then first, as you quite rightly say, you'll be a rule taker because the EU won't let you
00:07:56 shape those rules. It'll impose them on you. But secondly, it might get in the way of trade with
00:08:02 the United States if your standards suddenly start to diverge from US standards and move
00:08:06 towards european ones so it makes sense for norway because norway's in europe okay and they've made
00:08:11 the calculation we're perfectly happy accepting a load of eu rules in return for access to the
00:08:18 market and it kind of works for norway because norway has a ridiculously simple economy and
00:08:22 it's only real exports of fish oil and a few metals it's not a very complicated economy so
00:08:28 being a rule taker with the eu doesn't matter canada is a whole different kettle of fish
00:08:31 in what way i mean some would say we're just drawers of water and hewers of wood that's
00:08:38 always the knock that canadians make on um on our own economy i i would disagree with that but how
00:08:45 is canada are we much more uh diversified in terms of our economy more advanced well we're getting
00:08:52 very close to the point where i'm going to say to you you need to get an expert on canada on your
00:08:55 show rather than me but what i would say is you know canada is part of a load of complex supply
00:09:01 chains with the united states for the auto industry uh and those things really really
00:09:06 matter and actually one of the striking things and one of the reasons why i think president
00:09:10 trump is going to struggle to make his rhetoric turn into reality is there are many many people
00:09:15 in new york state in michigan in those u.s states where there is a load of cross-border trade with
00:09:20 the canadians who are seriously worried about the prospect of deteriorating trading relations
00:09:25 because they depend on that relationship as much as the Canadians do.
00:09:30 You were speaking with my colleague at National Post, Tracy Morin,
00:09:34 and you talked about the geography part of this.
00:09:39 You mentioned that you won't be eating frozen Canadian fish anytime soon.
00:09:43 Why? Do you have a problem with frozen Canadian fish?
00:09:46 No, I think what I said was I don't see an immediate prospect of me eating fresh, non-frozen.
00:09:55 canadian fish okay because the distance is so large and that's the difference isn't it is
00:10:00 if you're next door the sheer density and sort of heterogeneity of your trade can be so much higher
00:10:07 because for instance fresh food and drink can cross the border and actually in a way what
00:10:12 britain is finding is that makes your life more difficult because the eu will insist on regulatory
00:10:16 alignment with us if we want to deal with them on agriculture simply because we're so close simply
00:10:22 because it is possible for a British cow to cross the border into the Republic of Ireland.
00:10:27 They are all the more alive to the dangers of leakage into the single market and will 0.69
00:10:31 insist on us following their rules.
00:10:33 You have a slight advantage in that sense, being a long way away, in the sense that they
00:10:37 can afford to be a bit more lax because distance plays in the favour of that.
00:10:42 You mentioned that trade may go up by a little bit.
00:10:44 I'm looking at a document on the Library of Parliament website, our Library of Parliament.
00:10:50 And in 2016, our exports to the EU were $22.9 billion.
00:10:56 This is in Canadian dollars.
00:10:57 They're now $42.7 billion.
00:11:01 Once you factor in inflation, that's only gone up by about $12 billion in current dollar terms.
00:11:08 Our imports from the EU went up from $52 billion to $91 billion.
00:11:13 We're still importing far more than we're exporting.
00:11:16 You look at our largest exports, oil and gas, and Prime Minister Carney has said, well, we'll build pipelines to export liquefied natural gas, which Europe desperately wants, which our former prime minister said there was no business case for.
00:11:34 But our second biggest export after that are autos.
00:11:39 I know Britain's not in the EU anymore,
00:11:42 but we're not going to make left-handed cars,
00:11:45 or right-handed cars, sorry.
00:11:48 You drive on the wrong side of the road where you are,
00:11:51 but Europe drives on the same side.
00:11:53 They're still not going to buy our cars, are they?
00:11:54 They're buying cars from either their own makers
00:11:58 or smaller groups in Hungary or Chinese cars.
00:12:03 i mean i think this isn't like i mean i think basically europeans will buy good value cars
00:12:12 but the problem for the canadians i suppose is you're never going to replicate the complex
00:12:16 supply chains that see cars manufacture bits of cars manufactured in loads of different european
00:12:21 member states with the canadian because of that issue of distance you're not going to have a
00:12:26 complex just-in-time supply chain that involves a transatlantic shipping journey it just won't be
00:12:31 as efficient. It's just not as predictable. So I think that's the real issue is, you know,
00:12:36 in Europe, you have tight integration of national economies, which kind of works because stuff goes
00:12:41 across borders a lot, even during the manufacturing process. The Canadian situation is very, very
00:12:45 different. It's worth bearing in mind. I mean, trade is not just about trade, it's about politics.
00:12:50 And as I said, the politics of this are really quite impressive. You know, for the watching
00:12:54 world out there, Mark Carney got to show that he's getting a special deal from the European
00:12:57 Union, even if that's not true. Ursula von der Leyen got to illustrate that the EU is still
00:13:02 attractive globally. So there were real political benefits on both sides to doing this. It's just
00:13:08 been very, very interesting to see over the next few years whether anything of substance comes of
00:13:12 it. And my hunch is most of the stuff of substance we're going to see with Canada over the next few
00:13:16 years will relate to security rather than economics. It might be Canadian membership of
00:13:21 the Joint Expeditionary Force, which Mark Carney talked about with our Prime Minister Andy Burnham
00:13:25 today. It might be cooperation on rare earths or critical minerals that Europe is desperate for,
00:13:32 and you have more of than we do. I think they're the areas to look out for rather than sort of
00:13:36 normal trading goods and services. You mentioned the politics of it, and
00:13:42 it was interesting to listen to both Ursula von der Leyen and Mark Carney talk about progressive
00:13:50 values and they really leaned into the fact that they're all on that same part of the political
00:13:58 spectrum um and well europe could change quickly the afd is rising in germany i'm not sure if
00:14:08 they're going to take over more than what they have within regional elections but uh marie le
00:14:13 pen in france that could change things are they still interested in a progressive canada if
00:14:21 suddenly there is a populist right-wing shift in in on the continent that would upend some of this
00:14:31 i mean there are two things at play there's politics and you're quite right that politics
00:14:36 in europe is changing rapidly i don't foresee the afd coming to power in germany anytime soon
00:14:40 but in France it's a real issue. But there's also geopolitics. And even though no one dared
00:14:46 say it out loud yesterday or today, the geopolitics is fear about the United States,
00:14:51 distrust of Donald Trump, and a desire to de-risk by doing more amongst other nations that share
00:14:57 interests rather than being totally reliant on the United States. And my hunch is that even
00:15:02 under Marine Le Pen in France, Europe will keep wanting to do that because actually the
00:15:07 Heliment National is very anti-American as well. So there are real geopolitical reasons why that
00:15:13 cooperation might survive changes of government to the radical right in Europe because there's
00:15:19 a shared interest in de-risking when it comes to the United States. You heard Donald Trump say
00:15:25 that this could result in heavy tariffs on both Europe and on Canada. And if it's from a place
00:15:36 of bad intent. Now, I'm not saying that the Prime Minister, Prime Minister Carney, is doing this for
00:15:41 bad intent, but his speech did have very many shots aimed at the United States, so this could
00:15:48 end up disintegrating. Carney has leaned in heavily on this middle powers philosophy. It's what he
00:15:54 spoke about at Davos. And as much as people will applaud and say nice things about it, it's not as
00:16:03 if European countries have come to Canada's defense in the trade war with the U.S. or
00:16:08 when Trump's made threats about annexing Canada, they have, for the most part, sought to make
00:16:16 their own deals with Donald Trump.
00:16:17 So despite all the pomp, the circumstance, the flourish, the rhetoric, is there actually
00:16:24 support for what Mark Carney is saying among European leaders or are they just saying,
00:16:31 yeah, we like this, but we don't want to anger Donald Trump.
00:16:35 There's support for it as far as it goes, which is we share the same concerns about the United States.
00:16:40 No one's going to be willing to stick their neck out and sacrifice their national interests, I don't think. 0.97
00:16:45 And it was very striking that even after Mark Carney made his speech about middle powers,
00:16:48 the first thing he did was he didn't criticize Donald Trump over what happened in Venezuela,
00:16:52 and he was quite supportive over Iran, which took quite a lot of people in Europe by surprise.
00:16:56 So everyone, you know, this is a subtle game.
00:16:59 You can't just say we're not dealing with the United States and everyone makes their own calculations. So in that sense, I think there are going to be limits to middle power solidarity. My hunch has always been that actually your geography is a more fundamental determinant of your geopolitical interests than your size. And there you see European states share fundamental geopolitical priorities in a way that they don't necessarily do so with the Canadians.
00:17:24 yes. There's been talk of combining the EU, Canada, the Trans-Pacific Partnership. And
00:17:35 I find that difficult to take seriously, in part because of what you're talking about,
00:17:41 geography. Is that a realistic idea, making this massive trading block of the TPP,
00:17:49 the EU, Canada, as a counterweight to the United States, considering the vast distances
00:17:57 between all these countries. Look, we've been doing global trade for hundreds and hundreds of
00:18:02 years, but we always do more trade with people closer to us. I hate to keep coming back to the
00:18:07 geography thing, but it is a major factor. But again, this isn't just about trade and
00:18:12 economics. It's about geopolitics. It's about security. And you forgot a crucial element there,
00:18:17 which is I think those sorts of groupings are not just about de-risking from the United States
00:18:22 they're also about a shared concern about the rise of China and I think in that sense you can
00:18:27 see a rationale for that kind of body and for those sorts of partnerships springing up because
00:18:32 we share with Australia and New Zealand perhaps not as acutely as those countries because they're
00:18:37 closer a fear of what a rising China might mean a concern that China might represent a threat to
00:18:43 our interest. So, yes, I can see a lot of these kind of things springing up. But again, going back
00:18:47 to your point, none of them are going to fundamentally alter the nature or the direction
00:18:52 of global trade because geography is such a powerful factor. But they might lead to stronger
00:18:56 security alliances. I mean, think about the United Kingdom. We signed trade deals with Australia,
00:19:01 followed by the AUKUS agreement with Australia and the United States. So, in that sense,
00:19:04 trade was inextricably linked to geopolitical bargains as well.
00:19:08 roberta uh metzula the president of the european union parliament uh different than the president
00:19:16 of the european commission but president of the parliament she gave an interview where you just
00:19:22 mentioned new zealand and australia she gave an interview where she said well if canada becomes
00:19:26 an associate member we could soon look at new zealand and australia becoming associate members
00:19:31 uh it is the eu just suddenly looking to be open for business i mean the eu is looking for partners
00:19:40 the eu is looking to demonstrate to the world that it's still attractive to people outside of
00:19:44 europe that it still has something to offer so in terms of pr those things sound very appealing but
00:19:49 going back to where we started i still don't know what associate membership means i don't think
00:19:54 roberto mitzola knows what associate membership means mark carney gave every indication of not
00:19:59 being entirely sure what associate membership means. We'll have to wait and see, because if
00:20:04 they're serious about this, it means treaty change in the European Union to admit or to
00:20:08 have a new class of partnership. And there's no treaty change going to happen in the European
00:20:11 Union anytime soon. We're going to have to see what deeds flesh out these words in the years to
00:20:16 come, because it might be that I'm being overly cynical and they achieve a lot. But for the
00:20:20 moment, all we have is a label without any substance to go with it. Well, I mean, you're
00:20:25 right to be cynical the uh trade agreement with the mercosur countries took what close to 25 years
00:20:31 to negotiate um that's that's moving pretty slowly i mean the european union is many things but it's
00:20:37 never quick mark carney seems to want to move quickly yeah i think mark carney might end up
00:20:43 getting quite frustrated though because you know the eu machinery moves slowly you need the board
00:20:48 you need the buy-in of all 27 member states the eu has other priorities as well that it needs to
00:20:54 focus on. We'll have to see. I mean, if there is the political urgency, particularly amongst the
00:21:00 biggest member states, this might move quickly. We haven't yet had responses formally from some
00:21:05 of the larger member states. What we hear on the grapevine is that many of those member states
00:21:09 weren't briefed about this idea of associate membership. So some of them, I think, are probably
00:21:12 desperately on the phones of Brussels trying to figure out what the hell that means.
00:21:15 10 of the 27 countries have yet to fully ratify and implement cita um so you know a 10 year old
00:21:25 free trade agreement with the european union and a third of the members have not signed on to it
00:21:31 fully in part due to dairy which you know you could speak to your own government about the
00:21:36 frustrations of dealing with canada and dairy and cheese it's why we don't have a free trade
00:21:42 deal with britain so you know if we can't have a free trade deal with britain i'm finding it hard
00:21:47 to figure out how we're going to get deeper integration with the eu but let me ask you about
00:21:51 deeper integration with britain australia new zealand um you know daniel hannon has written
00:21:59 about this many times and was sending me his piece again uh in the telegraph about it's time
00:22:04 for kansuk is there any appetite for something like kansuk aligning canada new zealand australia
00:22:10 in the UK? I mean, there's a certain strand of political opinion on the political right that's
00:22:16 quite fond of the white Commonwealth and sees the English language as a great factor bonding 0.74
00:22:22 them together and thinks that they can work together. I think they run up to the difficulties 0.91
00:22:26 of geography straight away. I think a lot of the Brexiters like Daniel Hannan were at best very
00:22:31 naive when they claimed that trade with the rest of the world would compensate for the impact of
00:22:35 leaving the European Union. It hasn't, and it almost certainly won't. Having alliances with
00:22:41 those countries makes perfect sense, again, because we have some shared interests in common. 0.79
00:22:45 Not the same level that Europeans have shared interests in common, because Europeans share
00:22:50 a geography, and therefore share an exposure to Russia, to instability in the Middle East,
00:22:55 that the Canadians, the New Zealanders, the Australians simply don't share.
00:22:57 no we are far removed from that uh any advice um as someone who uh you know is from a country that
00:23:07 was part of the eu has gone through the exit package and has watched the frustrations of
00:23:13 trying to sign a new deal with europe any advice for canadians as we embark on this uh unknown path
00:23:20 i think what i would say is if canadians have reached the point where they need advice from
00:23:25 made and things are worse than they thought. All right, Anand, thank you very much for your time.
00:23:32 My pleasure. All right, when we come back, we're going to connect with Carlo Dade. He is at the
00:23:37 University of Calgary School of Public Policy, a trade expert in his own right. He fully understands
00:23:43 what it means for Canada-EU trade going forward, but also what the impact on Canada-U.S. trade
00:23:48 will be. But before we go, let me remind you that we've got merch. Have you checked out Postmedia's
00:23:54 merch store yet you want a national post hoodie you want a toronto sun ball cap a calgary herald
00:24:00 tote bag perhaps you can find it all at postmedia.store you can find your favorite local
00:24:06 journalism brand there get the merch show your support visit it today postmedia.store that's
00:24:13 postmedia.store recently our company softball team lost the big game by one run then dale
00:24:20 tried to console us with the quote,
00:24:22 winning isn't everything.
00:24:24 Well, Dale and I are very different.
00:24:27 I get early payout from Bet365.
00:24:29 If my team goes up big, I get paid out instantly,
00:24:32 even if they blow the lead later.
00:24:34 Sound familiar, Dale?
00:24:36 Thanks, Bet365.
00:24:37 Must be 19 or older, Ontario only.
00:24:39 Please play responsibly.
00:24:40 If you have questions or concerns about your gambling
00:24:41 or the gambling of someone close to you,
00:24:42 please go to connexontario.ca, TNC Supply.
00:24:45 You're a political junkie, right?
00:24:46 I mean, that's why you're listening to this podcast.
00:24:48 But if you're not in the loop with PostMedia's VIP Political Hack, then you're not getting even close to the whole politics story.
00:24:58 I'm Stuart Thompson, Parliamentary Bureau Chief.
00:25:01 And I'm Political Analyst Tasha Carradine.
00:25:04 We head up the team that brings Political Hack members the exclusive political intel that goes so much deeper than the news.
00:25:10 With inside stories, sharp analysis, and behind-the-scenes scoops from Parliament Hill and beyond.
00:25:16 With our twice-weekly newsletters, exclusive reports from Washington, D.C., early access to John Iveson columns, and subscriber-only videos and events,
00:25:27 HAC members get insider insight into the minds of the strategists, policy gurus, and power brokers shaping Canada's political future.
00:25:36 You don't want to miss all that, do you?
00:25:37 I sure don't.
00:25:39 And you can get all now for less than a dollar a week.
00:25:43 Just go to nationalpost.com slash newsletters to sign up.
00:25:49 That's nationalpost.com slash newsletters.
00:25:53 So much is happening in politics right now.
00:25:56 Rising tensions with the U.S. on trade and defense.
00:25:59 Not one, but two provincial separatist movements gaining real ground.
00:26:03 The liberals trying to hang on to a razor-thin majority
00:26:07 as the economy stumbles and with the cost of living still rising.
00:26:11 It's exciting.
00:26:12 Extremely exciting.
00:26:13 But the only way to get behind the scenes and right into the source code of what politicians and the people around them are really thinking is to get political hack.
00:26:21 Go to nationalpost.com slash newsletters.
00:26:25 And join us.
00:26:26 This is Tristan Hopper, the host of Canada Did What?
00:26:29 where we unpack the biggest, weirdest, and wildest political moments in Canadian history you thought you knew and tell you what really happened.
00:26:37 Stick around at the end of the episode to hear a sample of one of our favorite episodes from season two.
00:26:42 And if you missed it, there are even more episodes from last season.
00:26:46 So make sure you subscribe to Canada Did What? everywhere you get podcasts.
00:26:50 Canada and Europe can join forces to develop AI safety protocols,
00:26:55 coordinate common standards, and strengthen transparency.
00:26:59 All well-developing applications so that our governments and our companies can serve our citizens better.
00:27:05 prime minister mark carney during his speech to the european parliament talking about common
00:27:13 standards that has been one of my biggest questions since this idea of becoming an
00:27:18 associate member of the european union or perhaps just having a unique alliance or an alliance for
00:27:24 the future call it what you will the eu does not give out easy access to their trading markets
00:27:30 without the countries that want that access adopting EU standards?
00:27:35 Are we going to be rule makers or rule takers?
00:27:39 Joining me now to talk more about this is Carlo Dade.
00:27:41 He is a trade specialist.
00:27:42 He's at the University of Calgary, School of Public Policy.
00:27:45 Carlo, when you and I talk, it's normally about cross-border trade with the U.S.,
00:27:49 but let me get your initial reaction towards this push,
00:27:53 not just for more trade with the European Union, which I think is good,
00:27:57 But the idea that we'll have some sort of official alignment membership, maybe not membership, in the world's second largest trading bloc.
00:28:07 Well, it sounds like the ideas I typically come up with in my work at the cutting edge,
00:28:15 the bleeding edge of new thinking, response to crises, response to opportunities by pushing
00:28:23 the envelope in ways where you're building the airplane on the runway. This sounds like one of
00:28:30 mind building the airplane on the runway ideas. Again, the whole notion of what an associate
00:28:37 status means. I mean, the EU has done this before, but it was with colonial Africa making amends for 0.78
00:28:46 the past history of colonialism, a developmental project with the EU. Obviously, this is completely
00:28:53 different. As you indicated... Although there is a colonial aspect about Europe and Canada as well,
00:28:59 though. I wasn't going to go there. You did. I was hoping just to glide past that. But the issue
00:29:08 here is the point you clearly identified, and rightly so. You have to think of this from the
00:29:16 European member perspective. Countries surrendered sovereignty. Leaders had to take really tough
00:29:24 things back home to their domestic constituencies and explain why they made concessions to come
00:29:31 together for this larger agreement. You multiply that across all the members of the EU, and you
00:29:38 have a body that's deeply, and rightly so, deeply invested in not simply turning what is a prefix-a
00:29:46 menu at the EU into a buffet where countries can pick and choose and not have to make the same
00:29:53 sacrifices. So structurally, you start with the question you raised. How much do you have to
00:30:01 surrender to become part of a club to which, by geography, you can never become a full member?
00:30:09 The EU is for European countries, countries tied to the continent. That does not apply to Canada
00:30:16 unless you take Pierre and what's the little island? St. Pierre and Michelang, yeah.
00:30:21 Yeah, thank you.
00:30:22 It's French territory.
00:30:25 It's French territory, but it is in North America.
00:30:29 But, I mean, are we thinking that creatively?
00:30:32 Are we thinking that far outside the box that we're into triangles, pentagons, and whatever, octagons, that we're so far out of the box?
00:30:43 Those are the issues in the short term.
00:30:45 But point up front, there is a short-term tactical play to what the prime minister is doing.
00:30:53 There's potentially a larger, longer-term strategic play.
00:30:58 The two are not completely different, but we haven't had the conversation or thinking about the longer-term strategic play.
00:31:08 I think there's potential brilliance in that, but the short one is where the danger lies.
00:31:14 So what's the short-term play and what's the long-term play?
00:31:18 The short-term play is a tactical response to the U.S., an attempt to, A, signal the
00:31:23 Americans in the current negotiations that we are serious about diversification, as opposed
00:31:29 to 1971 under Nixon, where we made a lot of noise and there was no smoke, let alone
00:31:35 fire, really, in our diversification efforts.
00:31:38 71 was when Nixon imposed the surprise 10% surcharge, took the U.S. off the gold standard, threw us, Europe, Japan into a tailspin.
00:31:50 They single unilaterally rewrote trade rules.
00:31:54 That shock in 71 convinced us we had to diversify.
00:31:58 You can see the results of 50 years of those attempts.
00:32:02 I think this is a signal that, no, this time we're serious.
00:32:05 We're talking about increasing relations with the EU, with the trade bloc, to integrate, to really jumpstart that addition to the U.S., giving us a firm foot, not a rhetorical foot, but a firm foot in another path.
00:32:24 There's also a desperate attempt to trade with a market that's not complementary to us, that's proved exceedingly difficult.
00:32:32 So if you talk to farmers out here on the West and you say which market's more difficult, China or Europe, you're going to get a pause while the Greek gears grind and they work through and they think through it.
00:32:45 If you're trying to sell durum wheat, you're probably having an easier time selling wheat to China than you are to Italy.
00:32:50 So the short-term issues are complicated, but the longer-term issue, the, I think, strategic brilliance in a bad idea is something I wrote 14 years ago in the Globe and Mail.
00:33:10 It was an article about using Latin America to engage Asia.
00:33:16 The idea was, at the time, you had the rise of the Pacific Alliance trade bloc.
00:33:22 Four Latin American nations along the Pacific Rim that were banding together unified rules, policy reforms,
00:33:30 they were going to get serious about catching up with Asia and integrating with Asia.
00:33:35 For Canada, 14 years ago, that was struggling to enhance its ties with Asia, this offered an opportunity to link our Latin American ties with this budding movement to create a new way to integrate with Asia.
00:33:52 Fast forward to Prime Minister Carney in Davos.
00:33:56 He's desperately seeking a third path between China and the United States.
00:34:02 two hostile entities to Canadian trade interests that are attempting to rewrite global trade rules.
00:34:10 The brilliance of this idea potentially is that Canada serves as a bridge between the EU and the CPTPP
00:34:18 and countries in Asia that are also seeking a third path.
00:34:22 Your trade numbers suddenly get turned on their head.
00:34:25 The size of the bloc goes from being smaller than the U.S. share of global trade or China's share of global trade to being, I think, twice as large as the American share and three times as large as China's share.
00:34:40 This is a massive, incredible undertaking. But if we can serve as a bridge between Asian efficiency and European equity, European rules and Asian sort of directness in terms of economic growth, etc., we could really create something interesting.
00:35:02 Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe started this idea when he rescued the TPP in the first Trump administration.
00:35:10 There's a chance, a very difficult, very hard, very costly chance for, I think, Canada to take leadership.
00:35:20 Are you talking about the Trans-Pacific Partnership when you talk about this third wave?
00:35:24 Because, look, we signed on to that under Prime Minister Harper.
00:35:28 It's been in effect since the early Trudeau days, much like CETA.
00:35:32 It's about a decade old.
00:35:35 I don't see it having had the impact that we would have hoped.
00:35:39 I mean, you said in 71, we got that shock.
00:35:43 We talked about diversification.
00:35:44 We didn't do much.
00:35:45 I know Pierre Trudeau traveled around the world.
00:35:47 That was mostly to talk about peace, not trade.
00:35:50 Harper actually signed a ton of trade deals with all kinds of countries, took us to close to 50.
00:35:56 Now we're over 50 countries covered by trade deals.
00:36:00 And, well, until Donald Trump started putting tariffs on, it was still 76% of our exports just traveled south.
00:36:09 So, I mean, governments have tried this before.
00:36:13 The market and the business community haven't followed.
00:36:17 I would have hoped TPP would have been much bigger than it is.
00:36:20 So do any of these really, we're exploring free trade with Mercosur as well in South America.
00:36:27 Do any of these really end up having the impact that we hoped?
00:36:31 I pulled the numbers on EU trade.
00:36:37 We're at about 31 billion U.S. of exports.
00:36:42 66 billion U.S. that we import from them, but 31 billion of exports.
00:36:46 we export 403 billion to the u.s and in that 31 billion is after a big increase over the last
00:36:56 decade we're not replacing the americans are we no and the goal is not to replace the americans
00:37:03 it's the u.s based on some of the rhetoric yeah the rhetoric i think especially as it
00:37:09 flows into the media as it flows into public discourse as it flows into channels of communication
00:37:17 where you have five seconds three minutes uh seven if you're lucky on a radio hit or a tv hit
00:37:26 uh to try and work through the nuances um you know chase producers uh editors of papers they need
00:37:34 Not nuance. They need the point. And that broader point, the nuance is critical here. We are not going to outgrow or leave the U.S. market. The growth of our diversification strategy is to have the rate of increase in trade with the U.S. exceeded by the rate of growth of increase of trade with other countries.
00:38:00 It's a dual strategy.
00:38:02 The U.S. is next door.
00:38:03 It's still the richest, easiest, fattest market around.
00:38:07 Businesses are not going to choose to leave.
00:38:10 The goal of diversification of the markets is to make other markets easier.
00:38:15 You do not do that by signing individual bilateral agreements with a different set of rules for Honduras,
00:38:23 a different set of rules for Korea and a different set of rules for the EU. You need
00:38:31 large agreements. What makes the U.S. work is not just geographic proximity. It's one set of rules
00:38:38 for the U.S. and Mexico, which makes the cost of compliance and working out supply chains worthwhile.
00:38:45 So I think if we get to a point where we have a large enough market with one set of rules and you have the ability to buy, sell, make things together with a larger market, you create an economic and trade gravity to increase the likelihood of businesses taking part.
00:39:07 It's an agreement that doesn't open up the EU or the CPPP for you. It opens up, what are we talking, 40, 50 countries with one set of rules, one set of rules of origin, one set of rules for phytosanitary potentially. It lowers the cost and creates an alternative to balance the U.S.
00:39:31 The other reason for the past underperformance, some would say, is on the one hand, you had the U.S. that was slightly difficult, but a hell of a lot less difficult than Honduras.
00:39:45 I mean, we signed a trade agreement with Honduras.
00:39:47 How many companies, Canadian companies, that weren't selling potatoes were going to abandon Houston to run down to Honduras?
00:39:56 True.
00:39:57 Even with a new trade agreement.
00:39:59 But the rise of what the Trump administration is doing
00:40:05 People are seeing our take on the generational change in the U.S.
00:40:10 The chaos, the turmoil will not end until the ability of the president
00:40:16 The powers that the president has to disrupt trade are constrained by Congress
00:40:22 No one but no one thinks that's about to happen
00:40:25 not with the dsa getting ready to come in in dc we're looking at getting 10 dsa congress people
00:40:32 it's not going to get better on the trade front it's going to get worse they they actually just
00:40:37 want to rip up the whole agreement they they don't want to make things better they don't want to get
00:40:42 rid of tariffs they want out it's it's nuanced on their end but your point is correct it's not
00:40:49 good news coming down the pike. So if folks are finally understanding that Nixon took four months
00:40:56 to rewrite global trade, to get the Japanese, the Europeans, and Canada to the table to reset the
00:41:04 rules, Trump is dragging this out. Nixon did it with brutal efficiency. Trump is doing it with
00:41:11 gratuitous chaos and economic violence. These are so different in degree that it's a difference in
00:41:18 kind. I think that that difference and companies beginning to realize that this, I can't wait till
00:41:26 the midterms. I can't wait till the next administration, which may be worse. I can't
00:41:30 wait for the administration after that. I think these qualitative changes on the part of business,
00:41:38 realizing that this isn't a one-off, I can't hunker down and hide, but we need longer-term
00:41:43 solutions may convince companies to start thinking about longer-term sunk cost investments
00:41:51 to enable trade. The other issue we have is we built our entire trade infrastructure,
00:41:58 you know, Port of Vancouver a little bit, St. Lawrence Seaway a little bit, but really our
00:42:02 infrastructure is built to move goods to the U.S. Where do we have two-lane roads that get blocked
00:42:09 when Buddy moves the tractor on the road? It's across Canada. Where do we have four-lane highways
00:42:15 with no tractors on the road? That's down to the US. Where do we have roads that get shut down in
00:42:22 the winter? It's moving stuff across the country. Where do we have roads that never shut down in
00:42:27 the winter? It's to the US. So correcting that problem is going to be a massive infrastructure 0.84
00:42:34 investment, and that's a huge sunk cost. You're not going to make it unless you're looking at
00:42:39 generational change in the U.S. and a market that's big enough to convince Canadian companies
00:42:46 and governments to make these infrastructure investments. So you're talking about turning
00:42:51 the QE2 here, and you're not going to turn the QE2 unless you're sure that you absolutely have to.
00:42:58 I'm glad that you're put in in terms of generational change because I don't see it
00:43:03 going back to normal no matter who wins the next election, never mind the midterms. And
00:43:08 I can't believe how many smart people I know still believe that if the Democrats win in the midterms, everything will change. They have not read the text of the Trade Expansion Act of 1962. And it might be boring, but sometimes that's what you have to do to know what you're dealing with.
00:43:26 And there's nothing, barring a supermajority in Congress for the Democrats without the DSA, there's no chance of them repealing that legislation, which gives the president, whoever it is, unfettered powers to bring in tariffs under national security reasons.
00:43:43 And that's what we're dealing with.
00:43:45 If you haven't read the Green New Deal, if you haven't read the Red Deal, this is work that we're doing.
00:43:52 Just as we talked to MAGA before and looked at it before Trump came in and we were working on it, we're now turning our attention to the to the to the DSA.
00:44:05 Interesting. We will have to have you back on about that.
00:44:08 Let me ask you about the you talked about this bigger market with one set of rules on things like rules of origin.
00:44:18 It's incredibly difficult to do that with just the United States.
00:44:22 Is it feasible to be able to trade and continue to have a free trade agreement, such as it is with the United States, and have this very complex deal that works at scale with all of these other countries, the EU or the TPP?
00:44:40 I don't know that we have a choice. It's a rock in the hard place. Forgive me for my faulty memory of Greek mythology, but everyone who saw Odysseus, the whirlpool, and the monsters in the rock, Cyrus, and anyway, but it's the literal rock in the hard place.
00:45:00 We really don't have a choice. There are no easy alternatives. There is no easy path out of this.
00:45:07 This is not a TV sitcom where we wrap things up before the last commercial. This is going to
00:45:13 require some tasks that seem almost impossible. The scope and scale of what we have to do in
00:45:19 terms of infrastructure in this country, the scope and scale of what it would take to do this type
00:45:25 of negotiation is, I don't know that we can do it, but I also don't know that we have any choice
00:45:32 but to try. The EU took 25 years to negotiate a free trade deal with Mercosur. Now, we already
00:45:40 have a free trade deal with the EU. Mark Carney seems like someone who is definitely in a hurry.
00:45:46 He wants to move fast. Do you think that he can move fast in dealing with a 27-country
00:45:53 bureaucracy that isn't known for its speed or agility.
00:46:00 Have conditions changed enough for practice to change? Have conditions changed enough?
00:46:08 Are countries worried enough about what we're seeing with the U.S. and China to finally have
00:46:15 their come-to-Jesus moment about the past riding the future. If that's the case, then the situation
00:46:25 is as bad and dire as we think. If it's not the case that we can't do this, that the Europeans 1.00
00:46:30 can't change, that we can't change, that we can't start building infrastructure in this country,
00:46:36 then we've misread the extent of the current crisis. All right, Carlo Day, thanks again for
00:46:42 the time. Always a pleasure.
00:46:45 Full Comment is a post-media
00:46:47 podcast. My name's Brian Lilly, your host.
00:46:49 This episode was produced by Andre Proulx.
00:46:51 Theme music by Bryce Hall.
00:46:52 Kevin Libin is the executive director.
00:46:55 Remember to hit subscribe,
00:46:57 share this on social media, and let your
00:46:58 friends know about us. Thanks for listening.
00:47:00 Until next time, I'm Brian Lilly.
00:47:05 Here's that clip from Canada
00:47:06 Did What? Season 2 that
00:47:08 we promised for you.
00:47:11 And I will tell you
00:47:12 that there was, the vast majority of the people that we went to look for, that we went to locate,
00:47:22 we had no problem finding them. Approximately a third of them we found literally in the phone
00:47:28 book. These were, these people were not afraid. They knew that nobody was effectively hunting
00:47:36 them. They knew they had escaped justice, that they were going to die in their beds, and they
00:47:41 felt comfortable. The usually cited figure is that several hundred Nazi war criminals settled
00:47:47 in Canada after 1945. After the war, you have massive streams of refugees moving into countries
00:47:53 in the Western Hemisphere. The term at the time was displaced persons or DPs. We'll get into this,
00:48:01 but a lot of these war criminals weren't German. The Holocaust was disproportionately committed by
00:48:06 non-Germans acting under German orders. The Nazis show up, they enlist whatever police force or
00:48:12 militia groups are around into helping the occupation, and it's those groups that are 0.98
00:48:16 ordered to round up and murder Jews. After the war, Europe, particularly Eastern Europe, is
00:48:22 completely in ruins. If you were a Nazi collaborator, it was a very easy place to take 0.63
00:48:27 off your uniform, rip up your identity cards, and pretend to be someone else. As refugee streams 1.00
00:48:34 moved into places like Canada,
00:48:36 there were groups at the time warning
00:48:37 that it was a perfect conduit
00:48:39 for war criminals looking to escape justice.
00:48:42 The Canadian Jewish Congress
00:48:44 specifically told Ottawa
00:48:45 that even though Canada was barring immigration
00:48:47 to veterans of the German military,
00:48:50 any number of these foreign collaborators
00:48:52 could be slipping in.
00:48:54 But as will be a theme of this podcast,
00:48:57 Ottawa didn't listen to them.
00:48:58 If you want to hear the rest of the story,
00:49:01 make sure you subscribe to Canada Did What?
00:49:04 everywhere you get your podcasts.