00:00:57And my initial thoughts just in watching that video is a compliant person, someone who seems to be very forthright, very truthful, doesn't seem like he's hiding anything for all that all the conspiracies that have been around Lance Swiggs.
00:01:10Who is he? Is he transitioning this and that? That aside, what I see is a compliant witness. How do you see it?
00:01:16No, he seems like a very stable minded person and just watching him cooperate with law enforcement and not hold anything back.
00:01:22He didn't look nervous, didn't look scared. He looked like he was just being forthright with
00:01:26the information that he had. And, you know, I think there's been a lot of questions surrounding
00:01:30this Lance Twiggs guy. You know, he's this transgender. He's, you know, he's mentally
00:01:34this and mentally that. But even the text messages that were shown between him and Robinson,
00:01:40you know, Twiggs seems like more of the normal one, if I have to say so myself. So, I mean,
00:01:46this, I have really no words at this exact moment. I mean, today is huge, Beau.
00:01:50Yeah, and one key piece of evidence or admission in that video exchange is Tyler Robinson asking for a Dremel, which I had never really heard of before, but it's a tool that's used to engrave bullets.
00:02:04And Tyler said it's for an upcoming camping and hunting trip.
00:02:17You know, Benny, if we're able to later in the show with some of our guests, I'd love to get into some of the Reddit and Discord culture that is really being talked about right now.
00:02:25Because I believe that is a breeding ground for where some of this radicalization could have occurred.
00:02:29But as you just said, it almost makes Lance Twiggs seem the more rational one of the two, all things considered.
00:02:37Well, you know, Lance Twiggs even said that, you know, he doesn't really follow politics and he doesn't really talk about politics and any of these things.
00:02:45And then, you know, he says that Robinson never mentioned Charlie Kirk, but mentioned Donald Trump a lot.
00:02:52And so, I mean, Twix just seems like he was almost like, what are you doing?
00:02:58I mean, these text messages are so incriminating, Beau.
00:03:01I mean, he said he left early in the morning.
00:03:03The engraving of the bullets, frequently talking about the president.
00:03:07And so Robinson just seemed very obsessed, if I have to say so myself.
00:03:11Yeah, and if you look at the compendium of the evidence, and of course, we've seen the movements of Tyler Robinson, which, by the way, I do want to clue you in that Kevin Posobiec, we're putting together this montage of footage that you're going to see later on tonight where Kevin walks the steps of Tyler Robinson through the UVU campus.
00:03:28That's an exclusive that we'll be giving to you later tonight.
00:06:59Okay. So, well, Benny, let's just, if we have some guests later, that would be great. But I do
00:07:04want to kind of recap how we got to where we are right now, because there was a very, very lengthy
00:07:08debate yesterday about whether the video statement from Lance Twiggs would be admitted. And it was,
00:07:13just so people understand, it was admitted to the court, meaning to Judge Graff there,
00:07:17in full, unredacted, completely unedited version is in front of the court for him to make the
00:07:23eventual determination about probable cause. However, due to some of the defense's objections,
00:07:28a heavily redacted version, the one that we just saw just under an hour ago,
00:07:32was presented both in the court and to the public.
00:07:35And so Judge Graff, you know, it's a redacted version,
00:07:38but you have this motion, Benny, from Erica Kirk that was filed and her personal attorney.
00:07:43And she wants all exhibits to be made public because they've waited 10 months for this trial
00:07:48and she wants everything to be put out there.
00:07:50She wants to see, her attorney said, we want to see everything that you see, Judge Graff.
00:07:55And so what Judge Graff said, and I think this is important because this is how our legal system works, that there are three tiers that Judge Graff has to consider in terms of consumption.
00:08:05One is for the court itself, and when I say court, I mean Judge Graff himself, to make his determination.
00:08:10Then you have two, the gallery in the courtroom, which is why we're not hearing some of the testimony right now.
00:08:15And number three is the public at large and the live stream.
00:08:18So those are the three tiers that Judge Graff talks about in making his rulings.
00:08:22And as we're seeing now, some of that evidence is being presented only to himself, the unredacted version.
00:08:28Some of it, okay, okay, one second, let me just finish the thought.
00:08:31The second tier is for the courtroom itself, and the third is for us to view.
00:08:34It sounds like we're able to get some more testimony now, so let's take a listen in.
00:08:375.1 to be admitted into evidence for full consideration by this court, and so that is received.
00:08:44As it relates to publication and taking in consideration the arguments by Mr. Novak,
00:08:54first noting the standing objections by defense that is overruled as it relates to the admission to 5.1.
00:09:04But going to the publication, the court understands the argument made by defense that this is going toward perhaps religion and that the enhancement, and let me just read that from the information, victim targeting enhancement in violation of the Utah Code annotated 76-3-203.14 sub 2.
00:09:30Tyler James Robinson intentionally selected Charlie Kirk because Tyler James Robinson's belief or perception regarding Charlie Kirk's political expression.
00:09:41And that was also noted as an enhancement for count two and count seven.
00:09:54The court is not going to engage. The court can weigh how this is applied.
00:10:00but it finds it relevant whether how it relates to the enhancement is for the court to weigh as
00:10:08it looks at the bind over decision and it's not engaging in that decision making today
00:10:13but finds that it is relevant it is admissible to the court and is publishable to the gallery
00:10:20as well as to the public and so if the state wishes to publish state's exhibit 5.1 it may
00:10:29do so at this time. Thank you. Yes, we do.
00:10:37Agent Davis, I apologize. I'm going to take you very
00:10:40briefly back to State's Exhibit 16.1, which is the text thread between
00:24:23Welcome back to Justice for Charlie. We have our guest, Marlee Hornick, a constitutional law0.87
00:24:27analyst and litigation strategist. Also, we have with us Benny Ray Harmony. Benny,
00:24:31go ahead and take it away. Yeah, Marlee. So Jack Posobiec right now, one of the big things he is
00:24:37on is, you know, Lance Twigg said that Tyler Robinson was going hunting and kind of, you
00:24:43know, figuratively, but also literally, you know, we've heard about this hunting trip that he was
00:24:48apparently planning, but now it's looking like maybe this hunting trip was a hunting trip for
00:24:54Charlie. So talk to us a little bit about your perspective on that and kind of just what this
00:24:59is like going forward with this wording and moving forward with trial. Sure. Well, it does seem,
00:25:06Benny, like that may have been what he was alluding to. You know, you bring up a point
00:25:10that I'm remembering now because one of the issues about the actual gun itself is that
00:25:15if it is truly Tyler Robinson's weapon, the gun would be quite unique. He refers to that in some
00:25:24of the text messages that were successfully published today and discussed, I think maybe
00:25:29even within the hour, about how the gun he used may have been modified by his grandfather.
00:25:35It was a family weapon, a family heirloom. So remember, if that's the same weapon that's in
00:25:44custody. And there's no reason to think that it's not. I mean, it's crazy to think that there's some
00:25:48other weapon because it was wrapped in a towel with him and Lance's DNA on it that the family
00:25:56is going to have a hard time. And they already were participating in helping him to go turn
00:26:00himself in. Remember, the family is going to have a hard time arguing down the idea that it isn't a
00:26:06family heirloom and a very specific weapon that only Tyler Robinson could have used. So you just
00:26:11made me think of that with the hunting illusion that you're making. I agree. It sounds like
00:26:17that's what Tyler was referring to tragically, that he thought this was some kind of a human
00:26:22hunting trip, a very, very disturbed man. And took a Dremel tool actually to engrave on the
00:26:28bullets. And we know that there were engravings on the bullets. That just adds up. Marley, before
00:26:32we let you go, just in a litigation sense, just so we're clear, anything that's being introduced
00:26:38right now for the judge is all just for probable cause. We know that's a low bar. But it's true
00:26:44that once it goes to trial, every single bit of evidence that we're seeing would also have to be
00:26:48litigated once again in terms of its admissibility. Is that accurate? That is accurate. You know,
00:26:55I want to go back to something you said before the break because you said you know this is going to
00:27:00be a lengthy trial. That is not necessarily the case. This case has such extraordinary evidence
00:27:08There is video footage of Tyler Robinson on the scene, his license plate, his car, his family heirloom gun, his DNA on the towel, his text messages, his discord chats.
00:27:23The evidence is pretty overwhelming, and it doesn't have to take a long time for a jury to decide that.
00:27:28Just to be clear, it doesn't always take a long time.
00:27:32In fact, I was trying to remember the case.
00:27:35It was a big one, and it was just decided in literally three days by a unanimous jury.
00:27:41I don't think I'm going to recall which case it was.
00:27:54I mean, I think the common sense in us would say it should be very quick.
00:27:57But unfortunately, our litigation system moves at the speed that it has to.
00:28:00And I think my point was just, I think for Erica Kirk, the family and just the public at large, nothing could possibly be too soon because we want justice and we want it to be today.
00:28:10You know, I think that's the thing is in our hearts.
00:28:21And I want to bring in Jonathan Gilliam now.
00:28:23Jonathan Gilliam is a former FBI special agent and a Navy SEAL.
00:28:28Jonathan, just real quickly, because you are a former FBI special agent,
00:28:34do you believe the FBI and the Utah State Bureau of Investigations did a good and complete job
00:28:39that won't be undermined by the defense? Are you satisfied?
00:28:42Well, I think they probably did a good and complete job, but will it be undermined by the defense?
00:28:47I'm sure of that. So, listen, I think that the reality of this, from the time the shot happened,
00:28:58and to the time that we are now, the evidence collection, the analysis, I think this has been
00:29:04exactly the way law enforcement should have done their, do carry out any investigation and done
00:29:11their work. What was bad was before the shot was taken. That was a complete failure of a threat
00:29:17assessment and a lack of awareness on where an attacker could attack from. So, you know,
00:29:24that part was a complete failure. But I think what we see with the investigators and how they
00:29:31have systematically put together this picture of the movement of Tyler Robinson, of the DNA of the
00:29:38weapon itself and where it was located and the video footage, all this stuff has really painted
00:29:46a very accurate mountain of evidence that implicates him. And I think it's not just
00:29:55enough to go to trial, but it's definitely going to be enough to convict him.
00:29:59And Jonathan, you know, one of the big things that they're talking about during this trial
00:30:05is that other bullet that wasn't shot that was found on a separate rooftop. Now, if I believe,
00:30:11right, we heard one of the investigators say that it was an unfired bullet from an officer's gun.
00:30:16or something along those lines. Do you see any issues with how law enforcement handled certain
00:30:24little things like this? I know you said you weren't very happy with the planning leading
00:30:27up to this event. Was there things that they did that are going to come out and in some way
00:30:33be on the defense's side? Well, I would think so. Look, a lot of these universities, their law
00:30:40enforcement departments aren't really up to par. I've seen it myself firsthand up close.
00:30:48And I'm not sure when that round was how it got there or when it was there. But I'll just put to
00:30:56you this way. When it comes to crime scene management, when it comes to the initial
00:31:03investigation of any type of incident like this, if you don't have experienced investigators there,
00:31:10They can taint a crime scene. They can drop things there. They can do these things. So it's very important to freeze that area as quickly as possible. And I just think that that's probably going to be something that the defense goes after.
00:31:24And listen, when I say the defense, I can clearly see what they're doing in trying to string this out as long as possible.
00:31:33They're probably looking for some type of a deal they can make with the prosecution.
00:31:38But also, I really, truly believe that like warfare with drones and social media involved now, I think lawfare and the way that the legal system works is that defense attorneys are very in tune.
00:31:53they're very in tune with how the social media rumors are playing out. And I think they're using
00:32:01that in a lot of ways to convict the law enforcement in the court of public opinion and
00:32:09mistrust. Jonathan, do you think there's any way that he cuts a deal that takes death off the
00:32:16table? Because when you look again at this compelling evidence and just everything that
00:32:20we've seen thus far. And this isn't even the trial. It's just a preliminary hearing. But based
00:32:23on what you're seeing, you're saying you think they get the conviction. To get the death penalty,
00:32:27of course, you have unanimity. But because of there's so much evidence, and maybe as Marley
00:32:31Hornick said, maybe it isn't a very lengthy trial. Do you think death is taken off the table for any
00:32:36reason? Because my understanding from criminal defense attorneys is you can take death off the
00:32:42table and get life in prison, but you can't waive every single appeal ever. He could say he has
00:32:46insufficient counsel and he can appeal, which he very well could do. So do you think there's
00:32:51any instance where they take death off the table now that we've seen so much and we haven't even
00:32:55seen everything yet? Yeah, I think it's always a possibility now with the way the legal system
00:33:01works and these prosecutors, people just don't want to go to trial anymore. I mean, there's very
00:33:05many, there's many, many reasons why that's the case. I mean, I think that a lot of prosecutors
00:33:10don't trust juries anymore because the information is so widely disseminated.
00:33:17And some of that information, obviously, is going to be rumor and gossip and conspiracy.
00:33:23So I think, you know, I think prosecutors are always concerned with that.
00:33:30And then also you have a lot of prosecutors.
00:33:32I don't know these ones in particular, but you have a lot of prosecutors who are careerists.
00:33:37And the last thing they want to do is lose any case.
00:33:41And I think it's always safer for those careerists to take a plea deal and consider that a win.
00:33:47So I think in both these circumstances and when you talk, or if they talk and consider what the Kirk family wants,
00:33:57there's, I would say, a good possibility that once this is all laid out and the defense sees that there's no room to wiggle,