Human Events Daily with Jack Posobiec - July 10, 2026


DAY 5: THE MOMENT THE SHOT THAT KILLED CHARLIE KIRK WAS FIRED

Topics
Hosted by
Guests
Mentioned
DAY 4: PRE-TRIAL HEARING FOR THE MURDER OF CHARLIE KIRK THE SHOT

Episode Stats


Length

49 minutes

Words per minute

181.72

Word count

8,989

Sentence count

433

Harmful content

Misogyny

4

sentences flagged

Toxicity

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey guys, it's Jack. I wanted to let you know that we're starting a new push for subscriptions
00:00:06 here on Human Events Daily. So make sure that when you're listening to this podcast, you
00:00:11 hit subscribe, you download it, and you share it with five of your friends. Make sure they're
00:00:17 all going and downloading as well, because we need to get the signal out as much as possible.
00:00:22 Look, we've done so much over the past couple of years since this show started, and we're
00:00:26 only going to do so much more let's get it never ever stop fighting no matter what
00:00:34 we will achieve american greatness we are just getting started
00:00:39 did he spend spend the night in the apartment the night of september 9th
00:00:53 into september 10th yeah he did uh yes do you know when he left the apartment on september 10th
00:01:01 um i don't know an exact time i just know he left early uh i heard him leaving and he just said he
00:01:08 had a like a long drive to work that day so he was leaving early um and he asked me for a if we
00:01:15 had a like a dremel to because he said he wanted to create messages on bullets and i want to point
00:01:21 on to the court, Ms. Kirk has been very 1.00
00:01:23 adept at holding press conferences 0.56
00:01:25 at which she has revealed
00:01:26 evidence. She has
00:01:29 represented that the state
00:01:31 is her attorney.
00:01:33 She has access to all the
00:01:35 evidence that the state
00:01:36 has publicized,
00:01:38 and that the media and her own
00:01:41 lawyer argues is already in the 0.98
00:01:43 public domain.
00:01:45 What are we looking at here in Exhibit 19?
00:01:48 This is the
00:01:48 cartridge case that was recovered from the gun.
00:01:51 and what position was this in in the gun this was the or this is what was in the chamber
00:01:58 when they got to the the point discussing the rifle that was used uh tyler robinson was squirming
00:02:05 apparently uncomfortable swinging in his chair scratching his nose he looked uncomfortable with
00:02:10 the texts that were being discussed also erica kirk uh was looking down leaning forward not
00:02:16 looking at the screen showing those texts. Our reporter also said Erika was audibly crying
00:02:21 throughout the proceeding today.
00:02:36 Having considered the arguments presented by counsel and having reviewed the events
00:02:41 that occurred yesterday, the court finds that its order prohibiting the publication
00:02:45 or broadcast of Exhibit 16 by the media camera was violated.
00:02:51 The court agrees with defense.
00:02:53 This constituted a violation of the court's order.
00:02:57 Compliance with court orders is essential in all proceedings
00:03:02 and is of particular importance given the nature of these proceedings.
00:03:07 With respect to defense's request as a sanction
00:03:09 that the court reverse its ruling on defense motion 305,
00:03:14 motion to exclude cameras,
00:03:15 The request is respectfully denied.
00:03:18 The analysis underlying the court's prior ruling remains unchanged,
00:03:22 and the court adheres to its reasoning and conclusions.
00:03:26 And welcome to Justice for Charlie, an hour of thoughtful analysis.
00:03:30 Human Events Daily will be airing tonight.
00:03:32 As usual, as the preliminary hearing of Tyler Robinson has actually come to a close,
00:03:37 I don't know, guys, if we have the clip ready yet,
00:03:40 But Judge Graff has ruled that this is going to be ending as of now.
00:03:46 So let's take a look at that clip right now.
00:03:48 Your Honor.
00:03:50 All right.
00:03:51 So this preliminary hearing is continued to September 1st at 10 a.m. for an in-person hearing.
00:03:58 The court will allocate up to four hours total for argument.
00:04:01 That's encompassing both parties.
00:04:04 Does the defense request that Mr. Robinson be physically present for that hearing?
00:04:09 Yes, Your Honor.
00:04:10 All right, we'll make the recording.
00:04:12 Thank you.
00:04:14 The court appreciates the professionalism, civility, and respect shown by counsel, the parties, and all persons in attendance throughout these proceedings.
00:04:22 As there are no further matters before the court, this proceeding is adjourned until September 1st at 10 a.m.
00:04:29 Good afternoon to you all.
00:04:31 All right.
00:04:33 And I'm joined by Benny Ray Harmony.
00:04:35 Benny, well, there you have it. Five days, not even five full days of the pretrial hearing of
00:04:40 Tyler Robinson is now complete. It's in the books. Judge Graff has said the next hearing will be
00:04:46 on September 1st, which seems like an eternity from now. I'll be honest. I think we have had a
00:04:52 lot of conjecture about why this has taken so long, while it would continue to feel so long.
00:04:57 You know, we're not Judge Graff. We're a public method of judging, shall we say. We've seen the
00:05:04 evidence. Uh, we've seen what the judge has seen or most of it. And I think most of us have made up
00:05:09 our minds. I would think, uh, those rational among us, but Benny, I just want to get your
00:05:13 take on that because we've gone through five days of trial now, not trial pre pre-trial hearing.
00:05:18 It's important to note that. Uh, and it's going to still take a bit of time before we know whether
00:05:24 there's probable cause, uh, your thoughts on that. Yeah. Well, well, quite frankly, I, you know,
00:05:29 you know we aren't the judge we aren't the judge and we we don't know the amount of of all the
00:05:35 things that he has to go through but it's quite frustrating that it's coming up on a year since
00:05:40 Charlie's death and you know September 1st for the decision that's an entire it's two months away
00:05:47 you know I respect the judge and how he said he wants to make sure he he has thought everything
00:05:53 through he's viewed everything he doesn't want to rush it I appreciate that but what about Erica
00:05:59 What about she's been there sitting there for five days, all the TPUSA, you know, employees and people that have been waiting for so long to get more than this.
00:06:11 And so I'm a little disappointed that there wasn't a ruling today.
00:06:15 But, yeah, September 1st at 10 a.m., that's that's what he said.
00:06:18 And and he'll issue his decision.
00:06:21 Well, I think what probably most of us are thinking, and if you're watching right now, you're probably thinking this.
00:06:26 From a legal perspective, the bar is very low to get probable cause.
00:06:29 A lot of states have a grand jury indictment.
00:06:32 In the case of Utah, they have this pretrial hearing.
00:06:34 Not all states have that.
00:06:35 But when you listen to five days of pretrial hearing, when you see the evidence, when you see the movements of Tyler Robinson,
00:06:42 when you see the bullet casings, when you see that he was asking for a tool, a Dremel, to engrave them.
00:06:47 They have it all, though.
00:06:48 It's all there.
00:06:49 And again, I know that we're not the judge, but when you look at the totality of the evidence,
00:06:56 I believe he could have made that judgment, that determination for probable cause today.
00:07:00 This is not the trial. All they're determining is probable cause to go to trial.
00:07:04 An idiot could figure that out. And I'm sorry, I'm not calling Judge Graff an idiot. 1.00
00:07:08 I just believe that we have made that determination collectively as a nation. 0.97
00:07:12 What more do you need to see?
00:07:13 Yeah. I mean, a year, Bo, a year that it's 10 months since, you know, Erica and I just,
00:07:20 my heart, it just, it keeps going back to Erica because, you know, at the beginning of this,
00:07:25 she asked for a speedy trial. She asked for a speedy decision.
00:07:30 It was an accident. But as a result of that, Judge Graff felt there had to be some level of
00:07:34 measurable sanction for that. His ruling on that today, Benny, was that there were no video
00:07:39 exhibits that could be seen not only by us at home, but also within the courtroom, meaning
00:07:44 Erica Kirk can't see them. Jack Posobiec can't see them. We would only be hearing audio only of
00:07:48 those exhibits. Now, thankfully, the previous four days have permitted us to see many of these
00:07:54 exhibits, including, you know, obviously the video, the video confession. I'm sorry, not the
00:07:58 video confession, the video of Lance Twiggs talking about the confession. We've seen a lot
00:08:02 of those text messages. So this was the last day of the pretrial hearing. So there wasn't a ton of
00:08:07 evidence for us to physically view. I just think it's a shame that Judge Graff felt the need to
00:08:12 discipline the state for something that was an accident. Well, Bo, quite frankly, I think that
00:08:19 the defense has been waiting for something like this to happen. Of course. From day one, they have
00:08:24 argued no cameras in the courtroom. This is not, you know, the public should not, this should not
00:08:28 be broadcasted across the world. So I think when the defense woke up this morning, they were so
00:08:32 excited that they got to go in there and finally feel like they got their way.
00:08:37 One win.
00:08:39 Yeah, one win.
00:08:40 That's about all they have so far.
00:08:41 And I don't think they're going to be getting much more.
00:08:44 But, you know, Judge Graft, he can't, you know, there has to be some balance of fairness,
00:08:49 right?
00:08:49 And so even though there is a lot of evidence, if he just continues to rule in favor of the
00:08:54 prosecution again and again and again, and yes, there was a mistake that happened.
00:08:58 But like you said, it was three, not it was like three and a half seconds or something crazy, you know, and and everyone took responsibility for that.
00:09:07 But I do believe the defense has been waiting for that.
00:09:09 And they are going to nitpick those things throughout this entire trial and every single thing they will find to try to pull the threat apart.
00:09:17 Right. And I do want to bring in our guests now.
00:09:19 We do have Will Chamberlain, the senior counsel for the Article 3 project.
00:09:22 Will, thanks for being with us today.
00:09:25 You know, just on the heels of what Benny and I were just talking about,
00:09:28 pretrial hearing is over.
00:09:30 I want to get your observations on it.
00:09:32 And just some of the thoughts that we've had thus far,
00:09:34 I know we're all impatient.
00:09:37 Everyone's being impatient because we believe there should be swift justice for Charlie.
00:09:41 We believe that there is a totality of evidence that cannot be denied.
00:09:45 We believe there's a totality of evidence that would convict him.
00:09:48 I believe there's a totality of evidence to go for the count one,
00:09:51 for the targeted enhancement, for the death penalty.
00:09:54 How do you see it?
00:09:56 I mean, I think that's all obviously true.
00:09:58 I mean, the evidence presented that we saw in the last four days was overwhelming.
00:10:01 I understand why the judge is doing what he's doing, honestly.
00:10:03 I'm personally surprised that the judge allowed so much to be published to the public because, you know, basically the analogy here with these preliminary hearings is like a grand jury indictment.
00:10:13 In other states, they don't do a public preliminary hearing.
00:10:16 They do a grand jury indictment in secret.
00:10:18 Part of the reason that you have secret proceedings is that the idea that people, the grand jury, can see the evidence, whatever it is, in secret, and that evidence is not published to the public that could potentially contaminate a jury trial.
00:10:28 Whereas in Utah, they do it differently, and there's obviously this deep risk that when you allow evidence in and before you have determinations of admissibility, you're going to have evidence that the potential jury pool is aware of that a judge later thinks shouldn't be evaluated in the context of the trial.
00:10:45 So it was always surprising to me that, you know, in this context, he'd be willing to let so much be shown to the public.
00:10:50 But to his credit, he did.
00:10:52 That said, you know, once you have, you know, he made a call that something shouldn't have been shown to the public and the media screwed it up and did show it to the public.
00:10:59 I can certainly understand his attitude that the whole experiment of letting exhibits be published needed to be come to an end.
00:11:06 Because ultimately, the only determination that needed to be made from a legal perspective here was the judge's own determination that there was probable cause.
00:11:13 So nobody else really needed to see this evidence from a legal perspective.
00:11:16 Obviously, you know, there's a, you know, the victim's rights and the right of the public.
00:11:20 I mean, I wouldn't even call it the right of the public.
00:11:22 There's a public interest in having all this information be there, but there's no right to it.
00:11:27 As for the sort of speed of things, I think, yeah, things are going slowly because the defense wants them to go slowly.
00:11:32 But ultimately, it's the defense's core right to a speedy trial, right?
00:11:39 Like, I think that, you know, there's an interest in a speedy trial from the victim's perspective, but there's a right to a speedy trial from the defense.
00:11:46 Like, if the defense gets up and says, you need to try me ASAP, that actually can force the prosecutors to bring the case almost immediately.
00:11:51 That's not true from the victim's perspective.
00:11:54 And so as a result, if the defense says, look, there's a huge amount of complicated evidence that we need to master and understand, and as a result, you know, you need to set an extended trial timeline so that we can competently represent our client,
00:12:05 It's going to be very hard for a judge to look the other way because, again, you've got to think on appeal what happens if the judge says, no, we need to go to trial immediately.
00:12:14 And the defense had already objected, saying, no, we need a lot more time to evaluate.
00:12:19 There's this massive amount of evidence that's been thrust upon us by the prosecution.
00:12:24 That would be a very bad situation on appeal.
00:12:26 It could lead to the whole trial getting thrown out.
00:12:28 So it's not surprising to me, again, on this as well, that the judge is being conservative here, making sure the defense has no complaints, that they get as fulsome a preliminary hearing as they apparently wanted, I think a mistake on their part, and that they get a substantial amount of time to prepare for trial.
00:12:43 But the end result here is, I mean, it's going to be a guilty verdict.
00:12:47 The evidence is overwhelming.
00:12:49 And, Will, is there any world in which he calls them back sooner?
00:12:54 You know, I don't know a lot about the legal system when it comes to these types of things, but is there in any world, is this a possibility?
00:13:01 Seems pretty unlikely to me. I mean, September 1 is seven weeks, something like that.
00:13:06 It's actually not, I mean, it seems, you know, we're in the middle of summer, so we don't think, you know, September's this whole season, but it's actually, it's only about seven weeks away.
00:13:13 That's not unheard of for kind of, you know, because there's some briefing that needs to happen here too, apparently, right?
00:13:17 Like the prosecution needs to put out a brief based on all the evidence presented that there is probable cause, the defense gets to write some briefs that there aren't.
00:13:24 And the prosecution gets a reply, and then the judge needs to evaluate it and write an opinion.
00:13:28 So all that – seven weeks is a reasonable period for all that briefing and the opinion to issue.
00:13:36 In terms of the trial, again, I mean, as I say, like I don't expect – I expect the judge to be conservative here.
00:13:42 I think he doesn't want to have to do this again.
00:13:43 I think that's his sort of interest, right?
00:13:45 And from his perspective, you know, he has other business he can attend to in the interim while the defense lawyers are –
00:13:51 everybody gets to master the actual material pretrial. But he doesn't want to, you know,
00:13:56 if you're thinking like from the judge's perspective, you know, this trial is going
00:14:00 to be a weeks long affair. Having to repeat weeks long events is an extraordinary expense for the
00:14:05 court. So they do what they can to avoid that. Well, I want to ask you just so our audience
00:14:10 understands, because it was a little difficult for me to understand. I understand why Judge
00:14:13 Graff ruled the way he did with respect to prohibiting future exhibits. But how does the
00:14:18 display of the photo of Robinson's confession violate his civil rights, his constitutional
00:14:25 rights, if most of the text is already public? I mean, I got the defense's objection saying it
00:14:31 is permanent because it is a permanent photo that will forever be out there. But how does that
00:14:36 violate his constitutional right if most of what was in that photo, not the photo itself, but the
00:14:41 text is already out there? And does that have any bearing on the trial itself? So I think here's
00:14:47 here's the way to think about it what is the right that's being protected is that the right
00:14:51 is that the defendant is being tried by getting a fair trial and a fair trial in our system is one
00:14:58 where the jury evaluates admissible evidence and admissible evidence only so that's that's what a
00:15:03 fair trial is yep um and so i think the way that the judge has approached approached this question
00:15:10 of publication because if you recall there's these interesting debates about for example why is the
00:15:14 Lance Twig's video being shown. Um, and a lot, you know, Candace among others has complained is
00:15:20 like, Whoa, you can't show the video. He needs to come in and testify. That's not true. The 0.93
00:15:23 preliminary hearing stage, because guilt isn't being adjudicated. It's, it's only probable cause.
00:15:28 So you can have, you can bring in evidence that wouldn't be admissible at trial because at trial,
00:15:34 uh, the defendant will have a constitutional right to confront their accuser. So, um, as a result,
00:15:41 you have situations where there's evidence that would be admissible at a preliminary hearing,
00:15:46 but it's not going to be admissible at trial. And if it's going to be published, then the fear is
00:15:52 that that evidence is going to have been seen by the jury and then used as part of the determination
00:15:59 improperly. So that's the basic metric. That's what the judge is trying to avoid. So then you
00:16:04 go to this specific question. I don't know exactly what the issue would have been with this particular
00:16:08 piece of paper. It's possible there's a hearsay issue. I think the more likely thing is that
00:16:14 because it's like a handwritten piece of paper, there's going to be some authentication questions
00:16:18 that haven't been resolved yet. I assume that eventually at trial, that piece of paper will
00:16:21 come in. But I think from the judge's perspective, perhaps there's like, well, it's not 100% certain
00:16:27 that'll come in. And if I let the public see this and it gets widely distributed, then that's a big
00:16:34 risk to the ultimate trial fairness. So I have to, I can evaluate it now on the probable cause
00:16:39 basis, but I don't want the public seeing this yet because of the possible, you know, the small
00:16:44 possibility that it will be found inadmissible. And that's sort of his perspective, I think,
00:16:49 likely. And so if he made that order and then the media violated it, well, it's likely not to do any
00:16:55 actual harm again, because most likely that piece of paper will come in as evidence. But it just
00:17:00 indicates to the judge that his protective rulings to sort of protect, you know, evidence
00:17:06 where there's some question of admissibility for being seen by the public, if those rulings
00:17:10 won't be obeyed, then none of it. He just needs to not let anything be seen by the gallery.
00:17:15 And Will, you know, my question, we've seen a lot of evidence these past four or five days,
00:17:21 you know, is this common for prelim hearings? You know, because I'm hearing a lot of people say
00:17:26 that the amount of evidence that is being introduced isn't maybe as typical as it is
00:17:31 in other trials. But you also brought up the inimissible perspective. And for our viewers,
00:17:37 what types of evidence do you think will be allowed versus the stuff that won't? Will there
00:17:43 be things that we saw and heard during the preliminary that absolutely will not be introduced?
00:17:49 Kind of break that down for us. I think the only thing I remember seeing during the preliminary
00:17:54 that I am sure will not be in the trial is the video recording of Lance Twiggs' interview with
00:18:01 the police. And that is because, you know, one, that's hearsay. And there's no good, reasonable
00:18:07 exception for just, you know, hearsay, right? A recording of somebody saying something.
00:18:14 It's not the best evidence because Lance Twiggs exists and can testify, and it would violate the
00:18:18 confrontation clause rights of Tyler Robinson. He has the right to confront his accuser. So all
00:18:22 those things mean there's no way that video would come in. And as a result, I mean, what's going to
00:18:28 happen at trial instead, that doesn't mean that Lance Twiggs' testimony won't be in a trial. It
00:18:32 certainly will. He'll show up. He'll be subpoenaed and he'll have to testify under oath. But he'll
00:18:36 also be then subject to cross-examination, right? But you can't cross-examine a video. You can cross-
00:18:40 examine a humor. So that's the big thing I noticed that was shown that, like, will not appear at
00:18:46 trial. And so I was actually kind of surprised that he let any of that video be published. I
00:18:50 I really was. I mean, it's good because it really does put the nail in the coffin of all these conspiracy theories.
00:18:55 I'm glad it did. But I was surprised because I thought, you know, there would be some fear about jury contamination.
00:19:03 So, Will, on that note, and we don't have we might have to hold you through the break, but you're saying that he could be subpoenaed.
00:19:09 Does that change anything for prosecution or defense in terms of Lance Twiggs being there in person facing his, I guess, former lover?
00:19:17 does he have the gall does he have the constitution to be able to say the same things he said and
00:19:23 possibly more and withstand cross-examination because this seemed like a very tame interview
00:19:30 you know i mean he seemed calm he seemed collected no one's giving him tough questions
00:19:33 about no wait a minute you know and i'm just thinking what a defense strategy would be
00:19:37 is there are there vulnerabilities to the state's case if lance twigs testifies
00:19:42 i suspect that there will not be much on cross-examination from the defense of lance
00:19:48 twigs uh and the reason being that you know what would you be trying to get out of him well maybe
00:19:53 you'd be trying to extract more information about his own culpability but all that would do is sort
00:19:58 of reinforce the underlying guilt of your client too because if lance twigs was somehow involved
00:20:03 in motivating tyler robinson to do this well guess what tyler robinson still pulled the trigger
00:20:07 that would just be more evidence hurting you so i i suspect that you know if i'm sitting there as
00:20:12 defense counsel, it's one of those situations where there just aren't going to be a lot of
00:20:15 good questions for me to ask Lance Twiggs that help exonerate my client. But that sort of is
00:20:21 part of a really broader problem in this case is that there's not a lot of great questions and
00:20:25 there's not a lot of great strategies here for the defense in terms of like what it can do to
00:20:29 really create meaningful doubt in a jury. So if anything, him being put on the stand would be
00:20:33 even more damning for Tyler Robinson in this case. I mean, yeah, I would assume so. And he would,
00:20:39 you know, the prosecution would get a long time to think about all the questions they want to ask,
00:20:44 right? They get to prepare too. So this isn't just a police interview where they're just asking
00:20:47 kind of questions and sort of exploring. They will have like a very sustained, prepared list
00:20:53 of questions and thoughts that they want to extract. Okay. Well, Will, if we could keep you
00:20:58 on after the break, that would be wonderful. We'd love to continue the conversation. So we'll be
00:21:01 right back with more justice for charlie never ever stop fighting no matter what we will achieve
00:21:10 american greatness we are just getting started
00:21:13 never ever stop fighting no matter what we will achieve american greatness we are just getting
00:21:29 started. Welcome back to Justice for Charlie. We still have Will Chamberlain on with us,
00:21:39 senior counsel for the Article 3 project. Will, before we went to break, we were talking about
00:21:43 Lance Twiggs. We only saw a heavily redacted video. We don't know everything that's in that
00:21:48 video testimony, but he was given partial immunity. Talk about that level of partial immunity,
00:21:53 because my understanding is that he can't be prosecuted for anything that he said in that
00:21:58 particular interrogation. And we don't even know the totality of what he said, but I'm just wondering
00:22:02 what else could be in there and what he could be getting immunity for potentially.
00:22:07 All right. So, uh, you know, understanding there's two basic types of immunity, there's
00:22:11 use immunity and there's transactional immunity. So use immunity is the more limited form that
00:22:15 Twiggs was given. That's about saying that we can't use the testimony that you gave us or the
00:22:20 fruits of that testimony. Like if, if we are able to do some investigation that was catalyzed by
00:22:26 have an admission you made, uh, then that also doesn't count. Transactional immunity is broader
00:22:31 at saying literally anything that is the subject matter of your testimony, uh, will in the entirety
00:22:37 of the transaction is the way to think about it. You are now immune from. So even if we have an
00:22:41 independent way to prove you committed a crime in this, in the context of this event, uh, that
00:22:47 would mean that we wouldn't be able to, the prosecutors wouldn't be able to bring a charge.
00:22:50 This is the more limited form. I expect that the prosecution, you know, there might well be a day when Lance Twiggs gets prosecuted for his conduct here.
00:22:59 If the prosecutors in Utah believe they have him, he's been kind of hiding the ball and is more culpable than he's been willing to admit.
00:23:08 But I suspect that, you know, that's in the future. The first thing, obviously, is to get the guy who pulled the trigger convicted.
00:23:15 yeah and well you know i've been seeing a few things online about how that testimony from twigs
00:23:23 for this prelim could have i mean the prosecution probably could have got by with just using that
00:23:28 obviously there was so much more evidence and so obviously bring that forth um but do you think
00:23:34 that you know it is damning enough do you think that that by twigs is damning enough yeah well i
00:23:41 that on its own, it's probably sufficient because it reveals at least two distinct confessions by
00:23:47 Robinson on its own, right? I mean, it reveals the confession over text and that it reveals the
00:23:52 confession in the form of the note that he left handwritten under his keyboard, the sort of
00:23:56 advanced confession. So, I mean, independent of really everything else, I mean, a jury could
00:24:01 honestly, even without any other evidence involved, a jury could look at that and decide that
00:24:07 beyond a reasonable doubt tyler robinson did it um and that's beyond you know we're not even
00:24:11 talking about all the video evidence physical evidence dna evidence you name it um so yeah
00:24:17 it's it's a very damning video it also it it corroborates a bunch of interesting facts like
00:24:21 talking about how early in the morning uh robinson would have left their st george apartment
00:24:25 you know it's like around four or five in the morning which makes it matches the timeline
00:24:29 exactly um and i think jack basobic pointed out something very interesting you know when
00:24:34 Robinson was uh allegedly hiding in the neighborhood at in the evening after the
00:24:40 shooting trying to get an opportunity to go get his rifle back um he texted uh that twigs about
00:24:47 how the crickets were super loud and apparently the nest video that captured Robinson's car
00:24:52 at the time uh mentioned exactly that what actually not didn't mention it but the nest video
00:24:57 has loud crickets going off in the background right at the time and right at the time that uh
00:25:02 text was sent. So there's a lot of little individual corroborating facts that Twiggs
00:25:09 provides here. He's the person who can authenticate the note. That's a really important piece of how
00:25:14 that note comes into evidence, right? Because think about it, in the absence of anybody
00:25:18 explaining what this note is, you don't know that Tyler Robinson wrote it. You don't know when he
00:25:22 wrote it, et cetera. So it really does require Twiggs to be on the stand explaining the context
00:25:27 in which he was told to look for the note where he found it and who could have possibly written
00:25:32 That's all important information that he's going to be a necessary witness for.
00:25:35 And he also didn't delete it, as Tyler Robinson said he should.
00:25:38 He did not delete the exchange, and he did cooperate with law enforcement.
00:25:43 I'd love, Will, for you to get into Tyler Robinson's frame of mind right now.
00:25:46 And I don't know how this will play out in the trial in terms of how the jury would convict him or sentence him,
00:25:51 because I know there is that threshold for count one in terms of the targeting enhancement.
00:25:56 But as I looked at those text messages, Twigs, you weren't the one who did it, right, Robinson?
00:26:01 I am, I'm sorry. Now, we've mentioned, I think, even Jack Posobiec yesterday that there seems to 0.87
00:26:06 be no remorse. No, no. That apology to me, you tell me how you read it, is not I'm sorry for
00:26:11 what I did. I'm not sorry I just killed Charlie Kirk. It's I'm sorry to you, Lance, for involving
00:26:17 you or the fact that I might not see you again. I don't know if it went through his mind. I might
00:26:23 be put away for life or I might be put to death by firing squad. But that level of I'm sorry has
00:26:29 no remorse whatsoever. He was more concerned about his grandfather's hunting rifle than he was about
00:26:34 what he'd done. That seems to be the frame of mind. I'd love to get your assessment of that
00:26:39 and how that could play into how a jury will view the actions of Tyler Robinson.
00:26:43 I think that's exactly right. I think, you know, he's saying I'm sorry to his boyfriend
00:26:48 on the grounds that, you know, I'm sorry that I have now committed a serious crime that's going
00:26:53 to lead me to be apart from you. That's sort of how I read that, as opposed to being, you know,
00:26:58 there was no expression of remorse to the family of of erica kirk i mean he's he's pled not guilty
00:27:03 he hasn't said anything on that front uh i think in terms of his mindset now i mean he's just
00:27:08 i i heard yesterday jack described uh about how you know the media who are in the jury box and
00:27:15 able to see his facial expressions apparently said that he was grimacing and really kind of
00:27:19 you know not comfortable when when the twigs video was being played i think he knows that he's in
00:27:25 serious trouble. And, uh, he just, you know, like as, as much as we are annoyed that this continues,
00:27:30 like he's, he's not going anywhere. He's sitting in jail and he's going to keep sitting in jail
00:27:34 until trial. And then unless, you know, he manages to get acquitted, which he almost certainly won't,
00:27:38 he's just going to spend the rest of his life in jail and probably, and his, that life may be
00:27:43 much shorter than the average life because he may well be put to death. Will, do you, do you think
00:27:49 he gets put to death? I know I've, I've asked this, I've asked it pretty much of every guest,
00:27:52 But the reason why I ask is because I'm looking at that jury pool, what it could be, you know, Utah heavily LDS community.
00:27:58 I'm not saying every person on that jury is going to be LDS, but I'm just wondering about getting the unanimity for that count.
00:28:04 Does the state go for that? Does somehow Robinson work out a plea deal of life without parole, even though certain elements are not what certain appeals are not waivable?
00:28:11 What do you think? I think this I mean, I think he gets the death penalty.
00:28:15 I think that they're, you know, whatever, I mean, the death penalty exists in Utah for a reason.
00:28:20 I think even if there are some people reluctant to do it, I think, you know, there's nothing that is more deserving of it than political assassination.
00:28:27 It's just totally antithetical to the way our country needs to work.
00:28:30 It's the kind of thing that needs to be deterred with a maximum possible sanction that we have.
00:28:34 And death is the maximum possible sanction.
00:28:36 All right. Well, Chairman, thank you so much for speaking with us today.
00:28:39 That was that was incredible.
00:28:40 And I also want to let you guys know that coming up, we have something called Justice for Charlie, The Missing Minutes.
00:28:46 It is a wonderful expose where Kevin Posobiec goes behind the scenes and retraces the step of Tyler Robinson.
00:28:52 We'll be seeing that right after the break.
00:28:54 So do not go anywhere.
00:28:55 You won't want to miss The Missing Minutes just ahead.
00:28:57 Stay with us.
00:28:59 Never, ever stop fighting no matter what.
00:29:04 We will achieve American greatness.
00:29:07 We are just getting started.
00:29:10 never ever stop fighting no matter what we will achieve american greatness we are just getting
00:29:23 started welcome back to justice for charlie we want to show you a very special presentation
00:29:33 by kevin pasovic called justice for charlie the missing minutes how do you want to be remembered
00:29:39 I mean, if I die, everything just goes away.
00:29:41 How would you, if you could be associated with one thing, how would you want to be remembered?
00:29:46 I want to be remembered for courage, for my faith.
00:29:50 That would be the most important thing.
00:29:53 People say, are you going to run for Senate or Congress?
00:29:55 I'd say, listen.
00:30:01 All right, we're going to get started, everybody.
00:30:05 Oh my God.
00:30:06 Go, run, run.
00:30:09 This is Kevin Posobiec, RAV field correspondent, continuing exclusive footage from this week's
00:30:22 coverage, okay? And as you can tell, I'm at UVU campus. Today, we're going to do a short
00:30:28 walkthrough of the path of the alleged assassin. And just yesterday, day two, we had a presentation
00:30:35 of where the steps were.
00:30:38 They are right here.
00:30:39 This is the actual one.
00:30:40 I mean, this campus is full of staircases
00:30:43 and split-level areas, tunnels, whatnot.
00:30:48 So, but we were able to find it, okay?
00:30:50 And this is the retaining wall.
00:30:52 And for context, I'm six foot two, okay?
00:30:55 So imagine if you can, I'm walking down
00:30:59 and we have a production camera here.
00:31:02 It's actually right next to the security camera.
00:31:04 it's still up and so slightly slightly different angles that one of course is more of a bulb lens
00:31:11 uh almost like a 0.5 if you will using an iphone so it's slightly altered and yeah so we're just
00:31:18 going to follow along as close as we can uh for for more uh edification for everyone here
00:31:24 okay so now we're in proximity to the end of this short tunnel where tyler robinson uh the alleged
00:31:36 assassin would have came and imagine if you will of course a rifle on the right leg uh i won't
00:31:42 recreate the gait here for you but we're just doing a general overview of the path that he took
00:31:48 um keep in mind too like behind me in the corner there's a security camera and we'll show you up
00:31:54 staircase here there's another camera there's many in on this campus okay so
00:32:01 alternate angles so he would have came here grabbed the railing and then gone up this way
00:32:09 and this up here is where you would see the other
00:32:15 photography uh still frames came out in proceedings as well
00:32:19 not to be mistaken with uh any any other um produced pictures uh that's where a lot of the
00:32:29 confusion may be coming from there's many similar staircases it's a commercial kind of it's just
00:32:35 it's just a regular parking lot but there's several all around the campus and um but yeah
00:32:41 we're trying to give you a little more clear uh production obviously it's a very nice camera
00:32:47 as opposed to maybe something
00:32:49 that might be a little less quality
00:32:51 like these security cameras.
00:32:57 Okay, so now we're outside of the parking lot.
00:33:01 Just over my shoulder there
00:33:03 is where he would have parked the Challenger.
00:33:06 So we're walking along.
00:33:08 And keep in mind, so it's July right now.
00:33:10 This is September 10th.
00:33:12 So it's still hot and humid.
00:33:13 And I got to think to myself,
00:33:14 like, why would he be dressed like that?
00:33:16 you know it's like of course like in in so so inconspicuously of course he's in trying to be
00:33:23 incognito but it's it's hot that's my point okay so he comes there's the sorenson center to our
00:33:30 right and in there is where the chick-fil-a is where he had lunch allegedly and i had the question
00:33:38 as well uh because this is a secure campus and most modern campuses are uh if he had needed
00:33:44 access with a key card because it is so open as opposed to maybe some other more private colleges.
00:33:52 But being that it's a cafeteria style, it's probably just open to the public. We could
00:33:59 double check, but I think easy access, unfortunately, in this case. So, and then we are continuing on to
00:34:07 the Lossie Center. Right. So just for reference again, we're not on the exact path because we
00:34:14 We don't really know exactly which way he went, but we're getting towards the Lossie Center.
00:34:18 The Sorensen Center is right there, but I wanted to show you there's multiple utility ladders here up along these roofs for access, maintenance access and whatnot.
00:34:30 Again, though, there's I would say maybe six, seven split levels here, and some are, it's also the ground, okay, the ground, and then it turns into a roof for the next level and so on.
00:34:42 so there's about five or six of those here with these utility ladders and as we wrap around we
00:34:50 will come up on the scene but yeah again for reference the sorenson center is is right in
00:34:56 the line of sight where the chick-fil-a is okay so now we're almost at the vantage point here
00:35:01 the roof of the lotion center is right there okay and that is the the railing that he rolled over
00:35:12 okay to get into position this fence here is a construction fence probably because so many people
00:35:18 want to come and retrace the steps as well that's new but I want to pay attention also to this
00:35:24 staircase here which you may have come up again just to get even more cover the only other route
00:35:31 would have been to go the distance of this this level of the roof so we're going to walk up here
00:35:37 as well. And then we'll show you also where the camera was that has been presented where he jumped
00:35:44 off the roof. We're atop the Losi Center here along this walkway. Again, so this is a ground
00:35:56 level but also the roof. So this becomes on the edge out there is the roof and the corner where
00:36:04 the alleged shot took place okay and then if you pan with me here we can also see from this point
00:36:12 to this elevation the corner of this building you can see the statue there and that far corner there
00:36:18 is where the jump off point is and i was there on sunday i estimated to be about 16 feet it's
00:36:27 quite a drop okay and he didn't jump off uh gracefully let's say okay kind of just fell
00:36:35 straight down i'm surprised he didn't break his leg or anything like that and then if you pan a
00:36:42 little farther you could see there's still a security camera on the upper level of this
00:36:48 building behind us which is where the footage was taken from of you know this this raised
00:36:55 walkway here and running across the roof again uh we're not trying to really split hairs on
00:37:03 anything i'm just here to give you contextual footage uh you know during day three here
00:37:09 for the rav audience um you know from a personal standpoint it's very surreal to be here
00:37:16 and um it's it's kind of hard to be here too uh walking through it so i appreciate y'all
00:37:22 being with us and so after this we're going to head down uh to the actual amphitheater
00:37:28 all right so we are at the amphitheater now uh it's kind of self-explanatory but i wanted to show
00:37:35 uh the vantage point to my left here uh to the top of the low sea center it's the top roof there
00:37:43 and sweeping down, um, all the way to the amphitheater itself here. I originally thought
00:37:52 it was higher. Okay. But, uh, being here, being the carpenter myself and, you know, it gave,
00:37:59 gave me an appreciation of, so the farther away you are, the shallower the angle. Okay. So it does
00:38:07 make a lot more sense now. And then with this like pointy roof of the Rosenstein Center, I said,
00:38:12 well maybe you know so i've been a little skeptical of these kinds of things but
00:38:17 being here on the ground has uh cleared that up for me in particular so uh again i i want to thank
00:38:25 you guys for being here with us is very sensitive topic uh it's it's been a very heavy three days
00:38:32 here um witnessing everybody coming in like charlie's parents even tyler's parents you know
00:38:39 um and and just the resolve they have uh to get through this erica and don um i can't imagine
00:38:48 i've spoken briefly with jack as well he's been in there uh grueling it out he's got his rosary
00:38:54 with him and um but yeah i just wanted to come here i was at the charlie's memorial and in
00:39:01 Arizona there but uh you know just to help closer for myself and anyone else uh that follows me you
00:39:09 know it's good to just show up it's more trad I guess uh just to be there you know so uh if you
00:39:16 will I maybe say a little say a little prayer here as we recap um uh dear lord we just want
00:39:24 to thank you for everything you blessed us with uh please continue to guide us protect us and
00:39:30 provide for us in ways that we can for ourselves. And we are grateful for everyone that's here
00:39:38 to see this thing through. And we pray for your justice to be served. In Jesus' name, amen.
00:39:46 never ever stop fighting no matter what we will achieve american greatness we are just getting
00:40:03 started
00:40:03 welcome back to justice for charlie i'm bo davidson along with benny ray harmony we do
00:40:13 have Kevin Posobiec with us live from Utah. Kevin, first of all, kudos to such a beautiful
00:40:19 and intriguing piece that caused us to reflect. I think that yearns for justice. I love the fact
00:40:28 you ended it with a prayer, which I think solemnly is how and reverently how you should end it.
00:40:33 Let me just ask you what it was like to retrace those steps because I was in Dallas recently and
00:40:39 And it had been a while, but I retraced the steps of what would have been the grassy knoll, the book, the depository, you know, with the JFK assassination.
00:40:49 And it's eerie sometimes to walk the steps of someone who has committed such an atrocity, whereas if it had never happened, it would just be just another street.
00:40:57 It would be just another campus. It'd be just another stairwell.
00:40:59 But in your case, you're retracing steps that someone had to methodically plan, premeditate to go hunting, as he would say.
00:41:07 So I just want to get your take on what that was like to have to go back and retrace those steps.
00:41:14 Well, Bo, it was harrowing to be there.
00:41:17 It was my second time.
00:41:19 We went right there after we landed, Jack and I.
00:41:22 And that was not recorded, but we were also praying there then.
00:41:26 And I said, you know what, I want to give further justice here and retrace the steps.
00:41:31 It was hard.
00:41:32 And I got to say, I wasn't there, but you got to take into context.
00:41:36 Like, there's actual students that have been traumatized by this that have sought counseling from the effects of all this.
00:41:43 You know, school had to continue on.
00:41:46 Their classes are still in session.
00:41:47 You know, life goes on, but especially from a campus perspective, I'm saying, you know.
00:41:53 And so it has to go on.
00:41:55 But undeniably, this is going to remain a legendary spot in American history.
00:42:01 So the campus is actually struggling to, you know, there's a petition now for a statue of Charlie to be there, you know, so either way, it will have lasting effects on the campus itself.
00:42:16 But, yeah, I don't want to discredit any students, you know, what has happened to them in the, you know, narrative of today where we have an escalation of school shootings, in particular trans shootings, okay? 0.80
00:42:32 That was the motive here.
00:42:34 And you referenced the Aubrey Hale case, for instance, a shooting against a Christian school, right?
00:42:40 so for establishing motive and all that like it is very prominent is very relevant for what we're
00:42:48 seeing here in regards to tyler robinson i want to see if we can get jack over here actually
00:42:53 because he just was on the phone with me he has some exclusive uh context to give us and believe
00:43:01 me it is uh blowing up right now he's he's in an interview behind me regarding the actual video
00:43:08 of the shot okay so i gave you guys the context yesterday yes benny oh no keep going so
00:43:19 so yeah i gave the context uh yesterday in this exclusive so now jack was telling me
00:43:28 that that is what was played okay because we had the sanction to have no exhibits delivered
00:43:36 visually or audially today um however that was so he hasn't gotten quite the opportunity yet
00:43:43 let's see if i can uh actually one second hey jack see if we can wave him over here kevin while
00:43:50 we're waiting for jack to get no sorry benny i want to let you hop in no yeah kevin you know
00:43:56 i know this week has been really hard for a lot of for for specifically you and jack but but all
00:44:01 of us who have known Charlie and been around Charlie. I'm curious, you know, being there in
00:44:06 Utah, how have you felt God this week in these moments and in these proceedings? The Holy Spirit,
00:44:14 you know, how has that impacted you? Well, I 100% believe in the power of prayer, okay? And,
00:44:23 you know, Jack and I, we keep a pretty regimented schedule of prayer, you know, daily prayer,
00:44:30 and we try and go to church every Sunday, you know, just like every other great American.
00:44:35 But in particular here, I mean, we're of the school of thought where if you believe in angels,
00:44:40 you have to believe in demons as well, okay?
00:44:42 So it's a heavy kind of presence here.
00:44:46 It's been very tense, kind of cold.
00:44:48 I mean, it's a courtroom.
00:44:49 So taking that into account, I've been praying extra every night and usually before Jack goes in.
00:44:57 um yeah so the presence of god is has you know been on on my heart as well but you know charlie
00:45:05 said you know i want to be remembered for the courage for my faith okay so on top of all that
00:45:10 we're here okay we're here on top of everything just being there for charlie you can see jack
00:45:18 surrounded by about 40 people right now you know he's not he's not stepping back from this okay
00:45:25 Well, Kevin, let me ask you this.
00:45:27 It just speaks to a personal character.
00:45:28 Let me ask you this, because I was going to go down the road right now,
00:45:32 because I know you've covered so much Antifa and getting into the dark web.
00:45:36 I really wanted to cover that with you earlier, but we only have about three minutes left.
00:45:40 We're going to be running this amazing package about Charlie.
00:45:43 So let's get away from the darkness for a moment.
00:45:45 Let's get away from the darkness we've experienced this week
00:45:47 and focus a bit on the legacy of Charlie Kirk, the husband, the father, the speaker,
00:45:53 the intellect, the influencer that he was. And I don't mean that in terms of someone pulling up a
00:45:59 phone and getting on Instagram. I'm talking about true influence here before the word influencer
00:46:03 was a word. Talk about just the light, the light and the darkness that Charlie provided before we
00:46:11 get to this clip as we close out the show in just a minute. Yeah, so today is the 10-month
00:46:20 anniversary and the light that charlie brought uh i believe i referenced it i don't know i didn't in
00:46:26 that exclusive but charlie early on i saw his videos he provided the grounds for debate on
00:46:33 college campuses that wasn't present when i was there and that hit my heart directly back in
00:46:38 around i want to say 2020 era uh back you know and i was involved when jack was getting the
00:46:45 initial interviews with turning point to get on and he inspired me so much to not only
00:46:54 to not only just speak up believe in my own voice on college campuses but also
00:47:01 from a from a christianity angle you know we're told to go out into the world and preach the
00:47:06 gospel not just sit sit at home or be a keyboard warrior getting into arguments but i and i've had
00:47:12 extensive experience in you know the kensington area philadelphia and antifa rallies because at
00:47:18 the end of the day it's like yeah it's great to get people on content causing riots but
00:47:22 when you're really there staring somebody in the face it's almost like the the meme where it's like
00:47:27 you take two dogs off the leash and then they don't really fight each other but you can really
00:47:33 challenge someone's beliefs in such a kind and loving way as christians to to convert them and
00:47:38 And that's the light, though, is that being here in person does de-escalate people and bring them to a grounds of neutrality where we can turn their hearts.
00:47:50 We can change our hearts and minds.
00:47:52 And whether that's to a certain political party.
00:47:56 But at the end there, I personally believe that's what Charlie was transcending into.
00:48:01 It's just going out there and saving souls and showing college students like, hey, there's a better way to live.
00:48:06 and there's a better way to think and be educated,
00:48:09 critical thinking skills,
00:48:11 that is absolutely the light that I've got.
00:48:13 Yeah, and you and Jack and Don and Eric
00:48:17 and everybody that's been there have been the light.
00:48:19 There's a darkness in that room with Tyler,
00:48:20 but there's a light that has been shining all over the world.
00:48:24 And Kevin, I salute you and Jack for that.
00:48:26 So thank you so much, Kevin,
00:48:27 for all the great work you've been doing.
00:48:29 And I want to toss now to a special honorary piece
00:48:32 about Charlie Curtin.
00:48:33 I want to be remembered.
00:48:34 If I die, everything just goes away.
00:48:36 How would you, if you could be associated with one thing, how would you want to be remembered?
00:48:41 I want to be remembered for courage, for my faith.
00:48:45 That would be the most important thing.
00:48:48 People say, are you going to run for Senate or Congress?
00:48:50 I'd say, listen, honestly, I think the impact we're making is bigger than sometimes some of the U.S. Senators.
00:48:54 I don't know if you guys agree or not.
00:48:56 I do.
00:48:56 But, again, I'm not trying to be braggadocious, but I can say what I want to say.
00:49:02 We have a very successful podcast.
00:49:03 Our campus tours are sweeping the country, billions of views.
00:49:08 I've got over a thousand employees.
00:49:09 I'm the most blessed.
00:49:10 I have to pinch myself when I wake up every single day,
00:49:13 but I get to be able to do this as my job.
00:49:15 And so I never want to lose that.
00:49:17 I always just want the highest and greatest.
00:49:19 Never, ever stop fighting, no matter what.
00:49:24 We will achieve American greatness.
00:49:26 We are just getting started.