Human Events Daily with Jack Posobiec - July 07, 2026


Human Events Primetime Special of Tyler Robinson Pretrial - Day One

Topics
Hosted by
Mentioned
DAY 1: PRE-TRIAL HEARING FOR THE MURDER OF CHARLIE KIRK DAY 3: PRE-TRIAL HEARING FOR THE MURDER OF CHARLIE KIRK

Episode Stats


Length

48 minutes

Words per minute

167.77

Word count

8,204

Sentence count

466

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey guys, it's Jack. I wanted to let you know that we're starting a new push for subscriptions
00:00:06 here on Human Events Daily. So make sure that when you're listening to this podcast, you
00:00:11 hit subscribe, you download it, and you share it with five of your friends. Make sure they're
00:00:17 all going and downloading as well, because we need to get the signal out as much as possible.
00:00:22 Look, we've done so much over the past couple of years since this show started, and we're
00:00:26 only going to do so much more. Let's get it.
00:00:35 This is what happens when the fourth turning meets fifth generation warfare.
00:00:44 A commentator, international social media sensation, and former Navy intelligence veteran.
00:00:50 This is Human Events with your host, Jack Posobiec.
00:00:53 Christ is king.
00:00:55 23-year-old Tyler Robinson, accused of shooting and killing Charlie Kirk at Utah Valley University
00:01:00 last September, was in court for a preliminary hearing. The purpose of the hearing is to prove
00:01:05 to a judge that there's enough evidence to take the case to trial in front of a jury and if
00:01:11 prosecutors can't move forward in seeking the death penalty. They only have to show probable
00:01:15 cause and not proof beyond a reasonable doubt. The first witness called in the hearing was a
00:01:20 police officer who is working at the university. What did you hear again? I heard a gunshot.
00:01:26 This is going to be a rough one, a rough five days as we hear great details about
00:01:32 how this went down, what happened to Charlie, and what happened at Utah Valley University
00:01:42 last September. Charlie Kirk's widow, Erica Kirk, facing the accused killer for the very first
00:01:52 time. The week-long preliminary hearing is expected to give a detailed look at the evidence
00:01:57 and will decide whether the case against Tyler Robinson will go to trial.
00:02:01 Good morning. Mr. Robinson, good morning. For the record, the court also recognizes
00:02:07 is the presence of Ms. Erica Kirk.
00:02:09 Ms. Kirk, good morning.
00:02:13 And would you mind relating
00:02:15 what the doctor reports as the manner of death?
00:02:18 Yes, I misspoke.
00:02:19 It does say homicide.
00:02:20 And then the immediate cause of death.
00:02:22 Gunshot wound of the neck.
00:02:25 Nothing further, Judge.
00:02:26 The media was not going to film exhibits
00:02:33 and they are filming the ones that are on that screen.
00:02:37 Ladies and gentlemen, welcome aboard today's edition of Human Events Daily.
00:02:45 This is special coverage, the hearing of Tyler Robinson.
00:02:52 Today is July 3rd, 2026, Anno Domine, and we are here live in Provo, Utah.
00:03:00 Today, I was in the courtroom, seated in the front row, along with Charlie's family, Don
00:03:09 Jr., a number of other TPUSA friends and allies.
00:03:16 Also in the courtroom were Tyler Robinson's family.
00:03:20 And in fact, Tyler Robinson himself, of course, sat just a few feet away from us.
00:03:30 And you know, a lot of people I've seen online have been saying that Tyler was laughing and chuckling along with his defense team, and I saw that.
00:03:46 But one thing that I noticed beyond that was that Tyler Robinson never turned back once.
00:03:58 Kept his back to his own family, kept his back to Charlie's family, never once turned,
00:04:06 never once expressed remorse, never once acknowledged their presence,
00:04:12 never once even
00:04:15 showed
00:04:16 one ounce
00:04:19 of
00:04:20 any kind
00:04:23 of
00:04:24 human emotion
00:04:27 towards
00:04:28 the amount of lives that have been
00:04:31 destroyed by this act.
00:04:36 Charlie's wife,
00:04:38 his widow,
00:04:40 Erica,
00:04:42 it was very emotional.
00:04:46 It was very emotional for everyone.
00:04:49 Charlie's mom and dad,
00:04:51 and even Tyler's own family, I'm sure,
00:04:57 were facing a lot of emotions.
00:05:00 Saw reporters there as well,
00:05:03 and then we had the entire team.
00:05:05 And each side had their respective teams,
00:05:09 lawyers, investigators
00:05:12 and above all else
00:05:15 we need to focus on the truth
00:05:20 here. We need to push through the emotion
00:05:23 we need to push through the anger
00:05:26 and understand that the truth must come out
00:05:32 and the truth
00:05:34 of the evidence that has now begun to be presented.
00:05:40 One side is pushing to release the evidence.
00:05:43 One side is fighting that.
00:05:45 One side asks that evidence be published publicly.
00:05:49 One side fought against even having cameras in the courtroom today.
00:05:56 One side says, let's put this evidence in court,
00:06:00 the other side objects again and again and again and so on the very question of transparency
00:06:08 accuracy truth it's very clear whether you're watching at home or you're watching
00:06:15 right there like i was but there only seems to be one side that's interested in actually
00:06:24 presenting the facts, actually getting all of the information out, and presenting it
00:06:32 to the courtroom.
00:06:32 Keep in mind, the jury isn't even there yet.
00:06:35 We haven't even got to that point because of all these delays.
00:06:40 I'll tell you something.
00:06:42 No matter how long it takes, no matter how much we have to go through, we will get justice
00:06:48 for Charlie.
00:06:48 and we will do so
00:06:50 and never
00:06:53 ever relent
00:06:54 we will never give up
00:06:56 we will never surrender
00:06:57 Turning Point will never surrender
00:07:00 the mission 0.87
00:07:01 Erica will never surrender
00:07:03 and the truth
00:07:05 is coming
00:07:06 and it cannot be stopped
00:07:10 it cannot be stopped at all
00:07:12 Jack Posobiec, Human Events Daily
00:07:15 you'll be right back with the special cover
00:07:18 Nothing will stand in our way
00:07:32 And our golden age has just begun
00:07:35 This is Human Events with Jack Posobiec
00:07:37 Now it's time for everyone to understand
00:07:39 What America First truly means
00:07:41 Welcome to the second American Revolution
00:07:46 All right, folks, Jack Posobiec, we're back live here.
00:07:52 Human Events Daily, Real America's Voice.
00:07:55 I want to thank the Real America's Voice team.
00:07:56 We're shifting, of course, the time slot here of Human Events Daily
00:08:00 so that we can do these nightly recaps with you guys.
00:08:04 Obviously, I'm here in Utah, so the time change is different from East Coast,
00:08:07 where I usually do it, but I wanted to get into the meat of this.
00:08:10 I wanted to talk about what I saw, but also from the legal analysis side,
00:08:15 and we're really excited that we have Dr. Wendy Patrick. She's a former prosecutor and career
00:08:19 trial attorney joining us right now. Dr. Wendy, how are you? Oh, it's a pleasure to join you,
00:08:25 Jack. Thank you for having me. Well, thank you. So you watched the hearing on live stream. You
00:08:33 know, I watched the hearing as well, having actually been there. Tell us, you know, looking
00:08:38 at it through your lens. I mean, I can view the body language. I can see the victim's
00:08:45 family. I can see the members of the press. I can see the defendant. But, you know, give us your
00:08:50 legal analysis of how you saw today play out and what nuggets do you think that we should focus on
00:08:57 for those of us who want justice here? That's right, Jack. So the legal analysis is a lot
00:09:03 more sanitized than what you saw, which is the raw emotion that must have just filled that
00:09:08 courtroom, given the fact that Charlie Kirk is a beloved public figure, Christian leader,
00:09:13 husband, father, inspiration. Legally, you know, everybody has to take a step back and say,
00:09:19 what are the elements of the crime that we're seeking to prove? And it's true. A preliminary 0.97
00:09:22 hearing is a probable cause hearing. There's a much less burden of proof than a real trial.
00:09:29 But at the same time, the prosecution has to establish the elements of the crimes that they
00:09:33 charge, including the death penalty. So what you saw all day today was exactly that. Some may think
00:09:39 it's tedious, but this is as it should be. You had witness after witness, element after element.
00:09:45 You had all the objections you might expect from the defense attorneys who are perfecting their
00:09:49 record for appeal. One thing that really characterized the morning as well as the
00:09:54 afternoon was it seemed to be very civil. There's no such thing as a routine trial,
00:10:00 but objections can be routine in the essence that you expect them to come. You expect there to be
00:10:06 objections to the most sensational evidence. And on that note, as you asked, the most sensational
00:10:11 evidence is the shot. And unfortunately, that's a part of the trial that nobody wants to see.
00:10:17 Again, certainly not the family members of Charlie. You even saw the judge had a tough time
00:10:22 watching that video. He watched it privately, but we watched his face as he did so.
00:10:27 And as you might imagine, this is really hard to see. It's the kind of footage that you have to
00:10:32 watch once if you've got to establish the evidence being there, but you probably don't
00:10:36 want to keep watching it. And I would imagine that's going to be the judge's ruling when we
00:10:39 get to trial. But we're really warming up to creating that foundational timeline upon which
00:10:45 the rest of the evidence will be put for the rest of the week. Well, and that's something too. I
00:10:52 mean, look, I was there when the judge had that reaction. Some members of the family did, of
00:10:58 course choose to walk out prior to that video uh being played in the courtroom and uh there were a
00:11:06 few of us that stayed as well and uh went through all of it look i've seen that video before
00:11:12 and uh many many times and in fact i've watched it myself slowed down sped up all the different
00:11:19 ways you can watch it but seeing the judge's reaction it really took me back to the first
00:11:26 time that I saw it and just the abject horror and the shock of seeing that happen to a friend
00:11:33 of mine and knowing what it would set in motion and knowing that this day would come and eventually
00:11:40 the final trial itself will come. But you're absolutely correct in that we also have to
00:11:44 understand that those videos are key pieces of evidence because they give us timing. They can
00:11:51 also give us things like trajectory, ballistics. Obviously, this will come up in the autopsy
00:11:57 report as well, which the autopsy report was entered today, although they did not get into
00:12:02 detail of the autopsy report. I was able to see maybe a glance of it, but no photos were shown
00:12:11 and we could really, you know, didn't even have the opportunity to be able to read anything.
00:12:15 But again, as harrowing as all of this is, as grueling as all of these have been, and it has been grueling, this is all absolutely key for getting over that hurdle of probable cause so that a plea can be entered and that the trial machinations can begin.
00:12:32 that's right and jack that's particularly important in a high profile case like this one
00:12:38 you know there's a case where the cameras are right there in the courtroom ready to catch any
00:12:41 mistake that's made prosecutors are probably being very cautious and putting in more evidence than
00:12:46 they think they need lest they make any mistakes and have to renew everything and at the same time
00:12:51 there's no reason to be overly traumatizing with pieces of evidence you don't need for
00:12:56 preliminary hearing like the autopsy photos or other types of photos you know that is the worst
00:13:02 of a case like this is when you know you're going into a murder case, you're going to have to see
00:13:06 evidence of the actual murder, hence the showing of that video. On a more clinical side, the other
00:13:12 thing you really saw today is all the different objections that were overcome. Everything from
00:13:17 authentication, admissibility, publication, relevancy, reliability. I mean, everything that
00:13:25 both sides needed to focus on to put in the evidence or to keep out of the evidence that the
00:13:29 case may be, was kind of the underpinning of the emotion. And by the way, Jack, that is one of the
00:13:35 things that the defense was asking for before we all saw the case today, before you were allowed
00:13:39 in the courtroom, is the defense wanted it to be closed, closed to the public, closed to the press.
00:13:44 The judge, in ruling that it's going to be an open proceeding, live streamed, really reminded
00:13:49 everybody that there are plenty of other ways to ensure due process for Mr. Robinson. That includes
00:13:54 everything from making sure you spend enough time with a big enough jury pool to be able to get
00:13:59 men and women who can be fair. Everything from making sure you don't have overly gratuitous
00:14:04 pretrial publicity. There are lots of ways in which he will attempt to rein in some of that
00:14:10 press pretrial. But as far as prelim and what we're seeing this week, it's necessary to put
00:14:15 in all of the evidence and it's necessary to make all the objections to perfect the record for
00:14:19 post-trial advocacy, shall we say. Because let's face it, if the court of public opinion is any
00:14:25 guide, you're going to see that same evidence we already know about put into a court of law
00:14:30 this week. That's exactly right. And so I believe that some of the evidence will be released. Some
00:14:39 of the exhibits that have come out for publication that they will be released. However, it's not
00:14:44 going to be as immediate as it has been for maybe some of the other trials that people have seen
00:14:48 live streamed, Kyle Rittenhouse, the Johnny Depp, Amber Heard trial that people are more familiar
00:14:53 with, because that was coming out in real time. This one, there is going to be that delay. But
00:14:58 at the same time, I'm someone who stands on wanting all of the transparency that we can get.
00:15:04 In fact, Human Events was one of the very first publications to write an open letter calling for
00:15:09 cameras in the courtroom, even before the rest of the media came out in this, in which they did.
00:15:14 The media did have a lawyer there who argued strenuously for various portions of this to be
00:15:19 continued in public. Because look, on any case, especially a murder case, there's always going
00:15:25 to be certain levels of misinformation. There's going to be certain levels of just basic factual
00:15:31 errors that people make. You know, for example, I keep hearing people say or, you know, constantly
00:15:37 hear people say, oh, was Charlie wearing some type of protection? Was he wearing some kind of
00:15:43 body armor when in fact he wasn't. And so that's just a basic factual, you know, mistruth that we
00:15:51 want to get corrected so that when this goes in front of a jury, that they have the actual truth
00:15:55 out there. But then also so that the public from, as you point out, the wider public court of
00:16:00 opinion also can know the actual facts of the case. And so, you know, that's just one example
00:16:07 I can think of that when we look at this and we see the evidence coming in now where we got today
00:16:12 the screwdriver. We got the gravel on top of the roof. We're starting to now get some of the
00:16:18 videos. Now there was a back and forth about specifics on videos because one of them had
00:16:22 been annotated. So they want the raw video, not the annotated video, kind of like when
00:16:26 they do a play by play in the NFL or something like that. And they annotate the, you know,
00:16:31 the instant replay. But the fact of the matter is, is that we're also getting new video and new
00:16:38 evidence that hasn't actually come out before. To my mind, the fact that Tyler Robinson had
00:16:45 arrived on campus and traveled there four times, not just on the day of the killing, but in fact,
00:16:52 also that sort of just after midnight arrival in the neighborhood, which was north of the campus.
00:16:58 And in fact, I went with the human events team here and our field correspondent, Kevin Posobiec,
00:17:03 and walked the UVU campus yesterday so we could have that sort of picture in our own minds, that
00:17:09 physical sense, we realize how close all of these places are. And so this is going to be a huge
00:17:15 challenge. You know, we're already starting to see some of the defense strategy come out, and
00:17:19 it's going to be a huge challenge because there's even more evidence that they're going to have to
00:17:25 overcome in order to try to find some kind of reasonable doubt. But ultimately, there seems to
00:17:31 be this mountain of evidence that's now being uncovered, one of which, of course, as we're
00:17:35 learning today about these four trips to the campus by the alleged shooter.
00:17:41 Right. And, you know, you talk about the evidence and many cases you have murders occurring behind
00:17:46 closed doors, surreptitiously at night. This was a murder in broad daylight. And we start with that,
00:17:53 that that is one of the things that distinguishes this case from so many others where a defense
00:17:57 might be heat of passion or mistaken identity or so many other things. And when it comes to
00:18:02 guessing what the defense is going to do in trial and how they're going to frame their strategy,
00:18:07 they don't have to disclose that at a preliminary hearing the way the prosecutor has to disclose
00:18:11 the evidence they have. I mean, obviously, through discovery, the defense has the evidence anyway.
00:18:15 But in terms of case strategy, it's all on the prosecution side, what they have to prove to
00:18:20 meet their burden, even though it's much lesser than reasonable doubt. But yes, Jack, you are
00:18:25 correct that you do get a sense of what's going to be important in the trial simply by the
00:18:30 objections that are made, the rulings that are made, the questions that are asked on cross
00:18:35 examination. We can still get a feel for the state of the evidence. And on top of all of that,
00:18:41 you have the emotional value of the case in that courtroom, which is the one thing a jury will not
00:18:48 be able to consider. They will have to make sure when they go back in that deliberation room that
00:18:53 it does not at all enter into their deliberations.
00:18:56 All they can focus on is whether or not the evidence in the courtroom, not the court of
00:19:00 public opinion, is sufficient to prove beyond a reasonable doubt both the murder and the
00:19:06 death penalty, because that's how serious this case is.
00:19:09 So what you're seeing this week, Jack, in the courtroom is sort of a mini trial where
00:19:13 some, a lot of that evidence is being presented, the way it's being presented, because we're
00:19:19 going to see that and more when this case goes finally a trial.
00:19:22 We're getting some glimmers of that. We're getting some glimmers of that. We're on with
00:19:26 Dr. Wendy Patrick here at Human Events Daily, special coverage, Real America's Voice.
00:19:31 Today, you know, they talk about influencers. These are influencers,
00:19:36 and they're friends of mine, Jack Persovic. Where's Jack? Jack, he's done a great job.
00:19:43 All right, folks, Jack Prasovic here back live.
00:19:50 Special coverage on the Human Events Daily of the Tyler Robinson hearing.
00:19:56 Justice has begun, and I want to give a huge shout out to our good friends over at Allegiance Gold that are helping us out.
00:20:03 We've partnered with them in a major way.
00:20:05 In fact, they came in big for human events.
00:20:08 We said we wanted to come out here.
00:20:09 We wanted to do this special coverage.
00:20:10 We knew that the situation could get a little bit risky, a little bit hairy.
00:20:16 And so Allegiance Cold stepped up and said, we are willing to provide security for the Human Events team while you're out there in Provo, Utah.
00:20:25 So I want to give a huge thank you to them.
00:20:27 We know it's called ProtectWithPoso.com, so you can protect your savings.
00:20:31 They will protect your savings just as they are providing that protection to us here on the ground.
00:20:37 And we couldn't be more blessed and honored to say thank you to Allegiance Gold for doing that.
00:20:43 I wanted to just take a quick second.
00:20:44 And, you know, they said that we should show some of the great stuff that they have that we've, of course, personally, myself, the Poso family has gotten.
00:20:52 And, you know, there's a few pieces that they have, even new pieces and some old pieces that you can get for your family that we've got.
00:21:00 This is the St. Michael.
00:21:01 These are silver.
00:21:02 This is the St. Michael, one silver Troy ounce.
00:21:05 I love this engraving.
00:21:07 I love showing it to my kids.
00:21:08 This is something that we plan to keep, pass on to them, teach them about the value of precious metal,
00:21:15 keep them understanding, and really teach them how the whole industry works, how it all works together.
00:21:21 Now we've got, of course, Queen Elizabeth.
00:21:24 We've got Queen Elizabeth right here, just an incredible, incredible silver piece.
00:21:28 And then also King Charles.
00:21:31 We have the brand-new King Charles coin.
00:21:35 So this is coming out.
00:21:36 This is silver.
00:21:38 This is two ounces, so you can see how thick it is right on the side there.
00:21:42 King Charles III, the new silver piece.
00:21:45 You put that up with the Queen Elizabeth.
00:21:48 And, again, it's just something to be able to show the kids, to be able to teach them,
00:21:53 but then also for our own self to understand that it's a way to make sure that we're protecting our family's finances,
00:22:01 that we're protecting all of the hard work that we do day in and day out.
00:22:05 And these these become great pieces. They can even become family heirlooms.
00:22:09 They can become something you pass down. That's certainly what we intend.
00:22:12 And if you guys want to check them out and or, you know, just show some support to the people who are supporting us so much, go to protectwithposo.com.
00:22:20 Remember, it's protectwithposo.com.
00:22:23 So I want to get in breaking down some more of legal analysis that we're seeing.
00:22:27 We're on with Dr. Wendy Patrick. Dr. Wendy, when we look at, you know, some of the the the speed of all of this,
00:22:35 you know, I've got people like myself, you know, I want to move at the speed of Twitter. I want to
00:22:39 move at the speed of social media. I want things. I'm an East Coast guy, right? I like moving fast.
00:22:43 But, you know, we're now here in it's been almost a full year. It's been 10 months since the actual
00:22:50 shot rang out just a few miles from where I sit here in Provo, Utah. Is this something we should
00:22:56 expect? Is this expected to go on this long for murder cases or is this something that's more
00:23:02 routine? It's expected. It's routine in the sense that murder cases rarely move quickly unless
00:23:10 there's a defendant who's unwilling to waive time and have a trial sooner rather than later.
00:23:14 But in most cases, that does not benefit the defense strategy. Strategy includes having a
00:23:20 look at all of the evidence. We still, you know, there still may be angles or statements or other
00:23:27 things that are still going to be coming forward through witness testimony at a prelim. You do
00:23:31 expect that it's going to be a delay. In fact, I would say that 10 months from bullet ringing out
00:23:36 to prelim isn't bad at all in terms of everybody getting ready for a case this big, this high
00:23:42 profile and this heavily publicized. That is a really important point, too. And you mentioned
00:23:48 it. You know, you talk about you don't want people to be predisposed based on what they've
00:23:52 seen in the media. And that is exactly right, because much of what's been discussed in the
00:23:57 media is not relevant to the facts the jury is going to have to find and decide whether or not
00:24:03 he was wearing body armor, whether he should have been. You know, those are the kinds of things that
00:24:07 are not on trial. This is a murder trial. It's a death penalty murder trial. And those are the
00:24:14 elements that the jury is going to have to decide. And while no doubt all of the facts and circumstances
00:24:19 surrounding the day will come into play, that is not what they're going to be instructed to focus
00:24:24 on when it comes down to actually deciding whether or not the elements are there.
00:24:30 And so when they're digging through all of these elements, that's why essentially these,
00:24:36 you know, these objections keep coming up again and again, because all of this is going to play
00:24:42 a role into what evidence actually makes its way to that jury when they are eventually seated.
00:24:48 That's right. One of the biggest dangers when it comes to pre-trial publicity and making sure
00:24:53 everybody gets due process, is that far more evidence is, you know, sort of just released
00:24:59 into the court of public opinion shortly after the crime. And then there's only a narrow subset
00:25:04 of that evidence that becomes admissible at trial. You don't want to have jurors back there
00:25:08 deliberating on evidence that never came out in the courtroom, but rather is something that they
00:25:13 saw on TV, that they heard being discussed. And so, too, with some of the evidence that,
00:25:18 you know, that really has nothing to do with the facts of the case, but is political in nature.
00:25:23 It's not a case about politics.
00:25:25 It's not a case about Charlie Kirk being out in public and the different schedule that he had, except that it was public enough for the defendant to have used that information to plan the attack.
00:25:38 And as you just mentioned, one of the things that the judge heard is that he'd been there four times already.
00:25:43 So to that extent, it's relevant.
00:25:45 But those are some of the things that judge is going to be instructing a jury on when we get to trial.
00:25:48 We're a long way from that. But what both sides are going to be arguing at the end of this preliminary hearing is what type of facts that came out during these couple of days are most relevant to argue.
00:26:00 It either should proceed to trial or that it shouldn't. Is it the murder trial and the death penalty or is it some lesser charge?
00:26:07 That's what both sides have their ears attuned for. What facts are coming out that they can both argue.
00:26:12 right and and ultimately the facts to my mind all continue to point in one direction and in fact
00:26:22 actually dr wendy we originally only scheduled you for two seconds but if you would indulge me
00:26:27 could we how could we hold you over because i actually have some more questions i want to ask
00:26:31 you what do you say can you say on and hang on for just a little bit longer on this special
00:26:36 coverage with us on human events? Yes, I can. Thank you. Oh, that's phenomenal. So she's going
00:26:44 to hang back because there is something that I do want to ask her. And I'm looking at the clock
00:26:48 here and saying, you know what? I don't have enough time in this segment. We're going to get
00:26:50 to the next one. Again, folks, this is human events special coverage. We're talking about
00:26:55 what I saw in the courtroom coming face to face with Tyler Robinson here in Provo, Utah. Right
00:27:03 Back, Human Events Daily.
00:27:33 And Jack, where is Jack?
00:27:40 Where is Jack?
00:27:42 Where is he?
00:27:43 Jack, I want to see you.
00:27:47 Great job, Jack.
00:27:48 Thank you.
00:27:49 What a job you do.
00:27:51 You know, we have an incredible thing.
00:27:52 We're always talking about the fake news and the bad, but we have guys, and these are the
00:27:57 guys who should be getting Pulisic.
00:27:58 All right, folks, Jack Posobiec, we're back live here, Real America's Voice, Provo, Utah,
00:28:07 special coverage of the pretrial hearing in murder case of Charlie Kirk.
00:28:15 And again, I just want to thank all the partners that we're working with that are supporting us
00:28:19 and continue to support us while we're on the road, while we're doing this special coverage
00:28:23 all over the country, as you've seen.
00:28:25 And one of those great partners is, of course, our friends at Patriot Mobile.
00:28:29 So you should go and support them.
00:28:31 All patriots go and support Patriot Mobile, patriotmobile.com slash POSO, patriotmobile.com slash POSO.
00:28:38 Remember, Patriot Mobile always had Charlie's back.
00:28:43 Patriot Mobile always had Turning Point's back.
00:28:45 Patriot Mobile always has America's back. 0.98
00:28:47 They always have Christians back. 0.56
00:28:50 That's why I support Patriot Mobile. 0.92
00:28:52 Why would you use your family's money?
00:28:55 to hand over to people who hate you, who hate this country,
00:29:01 who hate the beliefs that you stand for,
00:29:03 that don't celebrate the 4th of July like they should,
00:29:06 America's 250th like they should, you know, who does Patriot Mobile.
00:29:09 And I got to see Glenn and his beautiful wife there in Washington, D.C.,
00:29:14 where they came to celebrate the 250th,
00:29:16 because that's the kind of people that they are.
00:29:19 And that's the kind of people that you are, too.
00:29:21 So you want to partner with them the same way that we have.
00:29:23 Go to PatriotMobile.com slash POSO and join the Patriot Mobile family.
00:29:29 Again, it's PatriotMobile.com slash POSO.
00:29:31 Okay, we're on.
00:29:32 Our guest has been Dr. Wendy Patrick.
00:29:35 She's walking us through all of this because this is an absolute key, an absolute key of where we are on things.
00:29:44 And so, Dr. Wendy, I wanted to ask you, how do you think this is shaping up, right?
00:29:50 You know, we've only had day one, but when we look at it in totality, do you think that the evidence that it's coming, and it is drip by drip, but do you think the prosecution is making their case?
00:30:03 Yes, because it's drip by drip.
00:30:06 They are introducing a piece of evidence, making sure that all of the proper safeguards have been followed to ensure it's reliable, it's credible, it's authentic, it's, you know, it's admissible.
00:30:17 You know, that's the biggest thing I think both sides are looking at is what's going to be admissible.
00:30:21 But, you know, as we think through the state of the evidence and we think through the emotion that you mentioned, your clip at the beginning reminded me of another thing.
00:30:29 Just as President Trump is no doubt delighted that you're covering this case, he was also delighted Charlie Kirk was doing the job that he was doing out in the community for the Christian community, for the president's agenda and for his voters.
00:30:43 And so it's notable that not only did you have Don Jr. there today, you may have other members of the Trump family, but it's one more layer that both sides probably are thinking about as they're wrangling over what pieces of evidence are going to be admissible, because there are not only emotional overtones, there are political overtones to this case as well.
00:31:05 And we would hate to see false narratives tainting the criminal process and the process of justice for both sides, justice for Charlie, due process for Mr. Robinson.
00:31:16 But it's one of the things that you just can't get away from in this courtroom.
00:31:19 And it's probably something the judge is thinking about as well as he rules on each and every one of these objections.
00:31:26 You know, you probably, as well as the rest of us, were glad when the defense established a standing objection.
00:31:31 so they didn't have to continue reiterating the same talking points again and again.
00:31:36 That's good for the defense, good for the prosecution, good for the speed of the preliminary
00:31:40 hearing to be able to get this over with and stop re-traumatizing. I would guess, and you could tell
00:31:46 me if this is your experience, many of the people in that courtroom. It is hard enough to watch it
00:31:51 on live stream. I can't imagine how tough it is for those of you that are sitting, as you said,
00:31:56 feet away from the defendant? Well, look, it's grueling, not just from taking the emotional
00:32:05 side out of it. And it is emotional. And I'm not going to sit here and say that it's not emotional
00:32:11 for me to be sitting there knowing what happened, knowing why I'm there, knowing that I'm surrounded
00:32:17 by the family members, that I'm there with the defendant. It's extremely emotional and it's not
00:32:22 easy. But when you go through and you say you just want it to be over with, you just want to
00:32:29 be able to have this is the evidence. Do you agree with it or not? Ask the questions about it.
00:32:35 But the constant objections, especially with the judge saying over and over, this is allowed by
00:32:41 the Constitution of Utah over and over the same exact over rulings. It definitely got to the point
00:32:48 where people are asking, is this all the defense team has because we want an actual trial based
00:32:56 on the facts and the evidence? And it seemed to be that they were trying to block facts and
00:33:02 evidence from getting into the public sphere, getting into the courtroom. And it's their job.
00:33:08 It's certainly their job, by the way, to present those challenges. And there was only one real
00:33:13 cross-examination that we saw today. And she presented various pieces of challenges to the 0.90
00:33:18 investigator. It was a former UVU police officer who testified she got her cross-examination in.
00:33:24 You know, she asked certain questions. Did you view this on the tape? Did you view that on the
00:33:27 tape? All of that, I totally understand that's part of the process. But my goodness, the level
00:33:34 of objections and nitpicking over every single thing. Let me ask you this question for someone
00:33:40 who's got experience in this. If that doesn't sit well with me just observing, how does that sit
00:33:47 when you act like that in front of a jury. Not well, which is why you won't see that in front
00:33:52 of a jury. That is my prediction. You're seeing a lot of the objections now to perfect the record
00:33:57 and to be able to determine what will and won't be admissible at trial because a jury's not sitting
00:34:03 there right now holding all of this against the party that keeps objecting. The jury feels the
00:34:07 same way you do. They, you know, show me the evidence, tell me the timeline, let me hear the
00:34:11 witness testify in a stream of questions and answers instead of constant objections so you
00:34:18 will not see this at trial you are seeing this now in order to make sure that the defense makes
00:34:23 all the objections legally they have to uh gets a feel for what the judge is going to do down the
00:34:29 line regardless of you know whether it's going to be two months five months a year god forbid let's
00:34:34 hope it doesn't go that long but you're getting a preview of the judge's view of what is and isn't
00:34:39 going to be admissible at trial. So they won't be expending the same amount of effort at trial
00:34:44 because they've already hashed it out, including the statutes that control some of these rulings
00:34:49 here at the prelim. In fact, you saw, Jack, that the judge took a minute to look up one of the
00:34:54 statutes very clearly because, as he said on the record, he wants to be absolutely sure that
00:35:00 everything is done correctly. Sure he does, because he doesn't want to be trying the case
00:35:04 again either. He wants everything to go smoothly and accurately the first time.
00:35:11 Absolutely. And I totally understand the judge's perspective, you know, for him playing the role
00:35:17 that he has, where he knows that in a case like this, that if there if this goes all the way to
00:35:24 go to verdict, gets the conviction and being that it's a capital case, that means that if the death
00:35:31 penalty is in fact reached and is in fact imposed here, then the very first thing that's going to
00:35:37 happen is that this defense team is going to appeal this all the way up the chain to even
00:35:43 the Supreme Court if they can. And that means that in each level of those appeals, every single one
00:35:49 of these decisions is going to be incredibly scrutinized at a microscopic level. And so it
00:35:56 seems to me that he's thinking backwards from that and saying, I want to give as much leeway
00:36:02 to the defense as I can so they can't come back and argue that I was partial.
00:36:07 Exactly. That I was partial and that I made rulings that were not supported by law. Because
00:36:12 at the end of the day, that's what a reviewing court is going to look at. They're not going to
00:36:17 look at little credibility determinations that don't themselves implicate legal rulings. They're
00:36:22 going to look at what is the law? What did the judge find? What facts did he articulate on the
00:36:28 record that supported his finding? That's why you see this going as slowly as it is. I have to say,
00:36:33 you know, we still got through a number of witnesses today. Some preliminary examinations,
00:36:38 you don't even get that far. So I suppose there is some hope that now that we've gotten past some
00:36:44 of the preliminary objects on the timeline, the killing, the autopsy, the timing, when, who was
00:36:50 where, who saw what, when. Now we're going to be filling in the blanks with some more meat,
00:36:54 shall we say. We're going to be learning a little bit more about where was the DNA found.
00:36:59 What about the statements? And you've heard a lot of objections so far, but you're going to
00:37:03 actually see some of that evidence rolling in because as you mentioned, Jack, most of those
00:37:07 objections were overruled. Precisely right. And I just want to say thank you so much for joining
00:37:16 us. I hope you'll come on later in the week, because we know there's going to be more. I'm
00:37:21 sure there's going to be lots of questions that we're going to need your legal expertise and
00:37:26 analysis on. Dr. Wendy, tell people where they can go to follow you in the interim.
00:37:32 WendyPatrickPhD.com. My PhD, by the way, is in theology. So I was a very close follower of
00:37:37 Charlie Kirk as well. But that's the best place to follow me on X Twitter or the website. Thank
00:37:42 you, Jack. Well, thank you so much for saying that. I actually hadn't realized, and I really
00:37:48 appreciate that. And in fact, it was always Charlie's—it was always his love of Christ
00:37:56 and his crusade for Christ that was his actual central animating core. It wasn't politics.
00:38:04 It wasn't elections. Those were all supplemental. It was always about Christ. So thank you so much
00:38:10 for saying that.
00:38:11 Jack Posobiec, right back.
00:38:13 Last segment here,
00:38:13 Human Events Daily,
00:38:14 special coverage, Provo, Utah.
00:38:38 So we're going to call this
00:38:39 the Jack Posobiec Appreciation Hour. I can say confidently, I believe, I think Josh Shapiro
00:38:44 would be the vice presidential nominee if it wasn't for Jack Posobiec. And that is, I'll be honest.
00:38:57 All right, folks, back live here, Jack Posobiec, Kevin Posobiec, our field correspondent
00:39:01 here, Provo, Utah. Now, Kevin, yesterday, prior to going to the court today and the hearing
00:39:09 opening up, you and I had the opportunity for the very first time ever to go over to
00:39:15 the UVU campus, and it was very good that we did in a sense that we were able to see
00:39:25 a lot of the buildings and a lot of the layout from, you know, the perspective of the case
00:39:31 today because so much of this hinges on that.
00:39:33 And I'll just say, you know, having seen it, having stood in that spot, it felt like a solemn place.
00:39:40 It felt like a place where you could tell a great act of evil had occurred.
00:39:49 And an act of evil requires a response, requires a response.
00:39:55 It does, and I'm very appreciative that we did get to go there.
00:39:59 It was a Sunday and school was out of session, so it was honestly pretty surreal that we were the only ones there for a solid hour, Jack.
00:40:09 And, yeah, I'm glad we got to do that.
00:40:12 I know, you know, we were at the Charlie's Memorial, but it was also I felt honored to be there to pay my respects in some kind of way.
00:40:21 But also from an architectural point of view, I've studied architecture and, you know, distances between objects and proportions.
00:40:29 So that really helped me as well.
00:40:31 I felt, having seen this on video a million times and in photos,
00:40:42 I felt that actually standing there and walking the walk that we did,
00:40:47 going from the spot where Charlie was seated all the way to really the roof,
00:40:53 almost exactly where this prone position was that was testified about today,
00:40:58 and we made it there in less than five minutes,
00:41:00 that I didn't realize quite how short of a distance it was.
00:41:05 It felt so much smaller to me than, you know, kind of my mental image of it.
00:41:09 I don't know if you had the same experience.
00:41:12 It was about that much, yeah.
00:41:14 It was honestly a little farther than I thought away from the distance
00:41:17 from where he was prone, where he fired the shot to the booth.
00:41:22 But also it's a staggered campus, like split level.
00:41:26 So there was about seven to eight different levels.
00:41:30 but in such a way that wherever you have a quote-unquote ground floor also doubles as a roof
00:41:36 for the lower or the next level.
00:41:40 And then the actual roof Tyler was on, I believe it was designed that way
00:41:44 because if you look in the opposite direction of all the videos,
00:41:47 you have a gorgeous view of the valley there and the lake and the mountains.
00:41:52 Yeah, Utah Lake is right there.
00:41:53 And they were even saying that the Hall of Flags, the officer testified today
00:41:56 that that Hall of Flags was specifically designed so that people could view the lake.
00:42:01 Right.
00:42:02 So therefore, it created this horizontal plane so you could see across the campus in that
00:42:09 particular section.
00:42:10 No, it's a beautiful campus.
00:42:12 It's a beautiful design.
00:42:13 And I hate the fact that we had to go there under these circumstances because if I was
00:42:21 just touring it, I'm sure I would have enjoyed it, you know, to your point, from the architectural
00:42:25 standpoint uh the courtyard itself is is it's a lovely spot yeah as far as right as far as it
00:42:32 just feels so incredibly tainted and in fact that's what um that's what satan does he takes
00:42:40 beautiful things and he he corrupts them well obviously whenever you design a building you
00:42:45 prioritizing the how secure it can be isn't high up on the list you try and make it as beautiful
00:42:52 as possible but i guess my point was we were able to tell you know okay that the roof that he jumped
00:42:58 off was about 16 feet you know just to confirm that and then was he really able to run that far
00:43:05 that fast how far away the shot was realistically it was like oh okay and actually we found out that
00:43:11 he could have had other vantage points but you know why did the sheer amount of stairwells and
00:43:19 And walkways and vantage points where you could look down into the courtyard were way more than I realized.
00:43:30 So people thinking that, oh, you know, it would have been so hard to get up.
00:43:34 No, no, it was actually very easy to get on.
00:43:37 We walked up on the roof, you know, and obviously the main portion that was testified about today with the two colors of the gravel, that was blocked off.
00:43:47 But, you know, had that fencing not been there, you could just step right around it and you'd be on the roof.
00:43:52 It was very easy.
00:43:53 It looks unnatural.
00:43:54 But then if you think, oh, they designed it so you could see the lake.
00:43:58 That was my point.
00:43:59 Yeah, the lake.
00:43:59 And so that's something that I realized that, you know, it was very easy to do so.
00:44:05 That's why, you know, and obviously there's been a lot of questions from people who haven't gone there and haven't walked the walk like we did.
00:44:13 And I think that when you actually go there and see it, it really changes your perception of the campus, and you realize, wait a minute, it wouldn't be hard at all for a person to get on top of the Losey Center, and it wouldn't be hard at all to be able to have that line of sight because, as the officer stated, Officer Bagley, that that line of sight from the top of the Losey Center on that fourth tier is straight to the courtyard.
00:44:40 That's one thing that I realized just yesterday because originally I thought it was too steep, but then once I realized how far back it really was, that angle becomes much more flat.
00:44:52 Well, and perhaps that, you know, and it seems as though the prosecution, they're saying that Tyler Robinson arrived there four times.
00:45:03 He traveled four times that day.
00:45:04 And so I'm sure that a number of those times their, you know, their argument is going to be that he was finding that perfect vantage point.
00:45:13 The vantage point.
00:45:14 And also, I would like to see more about how premeditated this was, like how smart Tyler really was.
00:45:22 Why did he pick UVU as opposed to a different campus?
00:45:25 But also, you know, we saw around UVU.
00:45:28 He said that that was a campus that was near to his area.
00:45:32 So that was why he picked it, because he felt that he had spent some time living in Salt Lake City and also had spent time in the area as well.
00:45:40 And so he felt like Charlie was, again, according to the documents that have come out, he felt that Charlie was invading Utah and creating a threat to his trans lover.
00:45:50 And so he wanted to defend his trans lover.
00:45:55 To speak to what you're saying, though, the ease of his path, you know, just behind the campus, there was like vacant lots.
00:46:03 And then it goes right into a residential neighborhood.
00:46:05 And we actually did take a drive, and just to say, we actually took a drive down there as well, and we were able, and we didn't want to put this on footage because, you know, obviously there's people who still live there, there's families that live there, but we were able to find very quickly where Tyler Robinson was on these ring cameras, the Nest cameras, where the car was.
00:46:31 Now, we also know that there was another video that came out today.
00:46:35 We didn't have that video before, I think.
00:46:37 You mentioned that, yeah.
00:46:38 In the night where he arrived.
00:46:40 They say his car arrived.
00:46:42 Someone opens it up, gets out, gets back in around, at least at 1238, so a.m. on the 11th.
00:46:49 On the 11th.
00:46:50 So that would have been the fourth time.
00:46:51 And we saw where those woods were.
00:46:53 We saw where that field was in between.
00:46:55 It's all right there.
00:46:57 It's really a small area.
00:46:58 it's not a bit it's not like some big expansive area it's it's really really self-contained i
00:47:04 mean you could see all of it um you know even if you were just walking you could probably walk the
00:47:09 whole thing in 10 15 minutes yeah as opposed to like you know on the east coast we're we're used
00:47:13 to like classic campuses with like sprawling entrances really big but this is just a stark
00:47:19 drop-off and then it's like boom like vacant lot or like right to the residential areas
00:47:25 So that was surprising for me to see. But also it seemed like, oh, wow, like all of a sudden you have the secure area, which most college campuses are nowadays.
00:47:33 And then all of a sudden it no longer is. And then it's just right into a neighborhood.
00:47:39 You know, and I think what can I say, though? It's, you know, it's our last minute here.
00:47:42 And I'll just say this. I appreciate you being here, having my back as well.
00:47:46 You know, give a special shout out to Allegiance Gold, of course, for providing us the protection that they are this week while we're out here doing this coverage.
00:47:53 and today was a quiet day in terms of that
00:47:57 and I hope it stays that way
00:47:58 but of course it isn't about us
00:48:00 it's about Charlie's family
00:48:02 and it's about getting justice for them
00:48:04 a debt is owed
00:48:06 and a debt will be paid
00:48:09 Jack Posobiec, Kevin Posobiec, Real America's Voice
00:48:12 ladies and gentlemen
00:48:14 as always you have our permission to lay a short
00:48:23 We'll be right back.