Human Events Daily with Jack Posobiec - July 08, 2026


Human Events Primetime Special of Tyler Robinson Pretrial - Day Two

Hosted by
Mentioned
Human Events Primetime Special of Tyler Robinson Pretrial - Day One DAY 4: PRE-TRIAL HEARING FOR THE MURDER OF CHARLIE KIRK

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

161.81

Word count

7,484

Sentence count

352

Harmful content

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Hosts, guests, and mentioned names generated with spaCy (en_core_web_sm), reconciled against Wikidata.
00:00:00 Hey guys, it's Jack. I wanted to let you know that we're starting a new push for subscriptions here on Human Events Daily.
00:00:09 So make sure that when you're listening to this podcast, you hit subscribe, you download it, and you share it with five of your friends.
00:00:16 Make sure they're all going and downloading as well, because we need to get the signal out as much as possible.
00:00:22 Look, we've done so much over the past couple of years since this show started, and we're only going to do so much more.
00:00:29 Let's get it.
00:00:34 This is what happens when the fourth turning meets fifth generation warfare.
00:00:44 A commentator, international social media sensation, and former Navy intelligence veteran.
00:00:50 This is Human Events with your host, Jack Posobiec.
00:00:53 Christ is king.
00:00:55 Were you able to determine at what time or times Mr. Robinson visited the UVU campus on September 10th?
00:01:06 Yeah, we were able to establish that Mr. Robinson had been on campus approximately four times throughout the day, twice before the shooting, the time of the shooting, and then after the shooting later in the evening into the early hours of the 11th.
00:01:25 Now what do we see? This is Mr. Robinson returning to the campus on foot from the
00:01:32 neighborhood to the Northeast. You can see he's wearing the same clothing as in
00:01:36 the previous video and he's carrying a blue backpack. Describe the clothing.
00:01:41 It's a maroon colored t-shirt with gray or olive colored shorts and then
00:01:49 Converse Shoes.
00:01:50 Yes, who is that? I believe that's
00:01:53 Tyler Robinson.
00:01:55 Where does he go from there?
00:01:57 He heads out of the parking
00:01:59 garage on foot into the campus
00:02:01 and
00:02:03 actually goes to the quad area of the campus.
00:02:06 At that time, he
00:02:07 makes contact with
00:02:08 some representatives from TPUSA. 0.73
00:02:12 Male DNA
00:02:13 was obtained from item 7
00:02:14 sub 1. Item 7
00:02:17 Sub 1 was interpreted as originating from two individuals, one of whom is twigs.
00:02:22 The DNA results from item 7 Sub 1 are 1.7 octillion times more likely if twigs and T. Robinson are contributors
00:02:31 than if twigs and an unknown, unrelated person are contributors.
00:02:35 As the state is turning this into a question of whether Mr. Robinson's views, identity, life are anti-Christian.
00:02:52 And that's a huge problem.
00:02:54 And the state has created that problem.
00:02:57 And this hearing is being broadcast to the entire jury pool.
00:03:01 And that's what Mr. McBride just did, is he turned this case into whether Mr. Robinson's life is inconsistent with what Mr. Englehart calls orthodox Christian views.
00:03:18 human events daily we're here live in provo utah our special coverage of the charlie kirk
00:03:32 murder hearing and today is july 7th 2026 ano domini special shout out of course to our partners
00:03:43 at Allegiance Gold who are providing security for us and for the team throughout all of the
00:03:50 endeavors while we're here. There's more people now showing up at the courthouse, outside the
00:03:55 courthouse. It's starting to get packed. It's starting to get heavy. The tension outside is
00:04:02 building as is the tension inside. And what can I say? Sitting there just feet away from
00:04:08 Charlie's parents Erica sitting quietly but you can see the emotion I had my
00:04:16 rosary out other people had wrote the rosaries out as well Tyler Robinson's
00:04:23 parents just about one row away there are SWAT officers all over the courtroom
00:04:32 in the seating area, in the gallery, and then there's sheriffs up in the front area.
00:04:40 And just on the other side of the bar, a couple seats, a couple chairs,
00:04:49 and right in the middle, dead center, was the accused assassin himself, Tyler Robinson.
00:04:57 And today in court, the evidencing that it's piling up, it's just piling up.
00:05:04 There's the surveillance footage, the digital footprints, now the DNA, the forensics coming in,
00:05:11 the 95% match of Tyler Robinson's DNA on the towel, then another 89% match on the screwdriver.
00:05:21 Again, these are huge numbers that the FBI was putting up in terms of the analysis of those documents.
00:05:30 I'm just going over some of my notes here, but this was a huge day.
00:05:35 And the biggest piece, I think, that came out today was there was a Bible verse that the defense was very, very, very adamant did not be read in court today.
00:05:49 because, of course, it speaks to the motive, the motive of killing Charlie.
00:05:54 And, in fact, it was a defense lawyer who became very flustered when he was losing the argument.
00:06:00 And he stated that the state is making it out that the motive was anti-Christian,
00:06:10 the anti-Christian motive for murdering Charlie Kirk.
00:06:17 I want to read that Bible verse to you.
00:06:19 The defense tried so hard to block.
00:06:23 It's Matthew chapter 19, verses 4 and 5.
00:06:28 Have you not read that the one who made them at the beginning
00:06:31 made them male and female, and said, 0.93
00:06:35 For this reason a man shall leave his mother and father
00:06:38 and be joined to his wife, and the two shall become one flesh?
00:06:44 and we're asking about is there an intersection of politics and
00:06:50 religion and i'll tell you right now obviously obviously there is an intersection
00:06:59 and we are going to discuss that whether or not the defense likes it because it is part of this
00:07:07 case from the start and all the way through to the bitter end jack so big real america's voice
00:07:13 I want to thank them for all their support here at Provo, Utah.
00:07:17 We'll be right back.
00:07:18 Special coverage.
00:07:43 All right, folks, Jack Posovic, we're back live here, Provo, Utah, special coverage,
00:07:51 Human Events, Daily Real America's Voice. And we want to welcome you back in to the Human Events
00:07:57 special primetime coverage of the Tyler Robinson hearings. And we are covering, of course, one of
00:08:02 the most high profile murder trials in the country. And when something like this happens,
00:08:07 it is a reminder of just how much personal information is sitting out there for anyone
00:08:12 defined. There are hundreds of data broker websites publishing your name, your address,
00:08:17 your home address, your phone number, your family members, and even old addresses, email,
00:08:23 everything, pretty much everything that's been leaked about you online. Unless you take action,
00:08:27 it's going to stay out there. Someone who knows what they're doing can piece together where you
00:08:31 live, where you have lived, who you're related to, and even public property records. If you're
00:08:36 politically active, you work in the media, you attend public events, or you simply value your
00:08:40 family's privacy. It's not something to take lightly. If you don't want strangers finding
00:08:45 your information, tracking down your social media accounts, or combining your personal details
00:08:50 with information from data breaches, you can do something about it. Patriot Protect helps remove
00:08:56 your personal information from these data broker sites before the wrong people get their hands on
00:09:01 it. This isn't something you do after you become a target. It's something you do beforehand. Other
00:09:07 services tell you after something has already gone wrong. Patriot Protect helps make you much
00:09:12 harder to find in the first place. A single phone scam or identity theft incident can cost thousands
00:09:18 of dollars. It's a lot less expensive to protect yourself now. Go to patriot-protect.com or call
00:09:24 1-833-367-8787 and use promo code POSO to save 15% off. Take control of your privacy, add some
00:09:33 digital camouflage to your life and make yourself much harder to find online all right we're bringing
00:09:40 now will chamberlain from the article 3 project to go through some of this legal analysis of
00:09:46 course i can present my perspective from having been in the courtroom seeing what i saw but will
00:09:52 is able to come in here as he always does and has been doing from hearing to hearing to hearing on
00:09:57 the actual um on the actual the legal side of all this will how are you i'm doing great jack good to
00:10:05 be with you well how would you score the uh the first two days of the hearing day one day two now
00:10:13 uh this is this is just an overwhelming presentation of evidence uh by the prosecution
00:10:18 i think the robinson defense as far as i can tell didn't score a single point that was relevant
00:10:25 There's just an overwhelming amount of evidence of different kinds that all matches the basic story that we've heard for since 48 hours after the shooting, which is that Tyler Robinson did this, you know, managed to bring a .30-06 rifle to the roof of this building, take a shot and then get away.
00:10:44 And, I mean, we have the combination of video evidence of him showing up on campus four different times, including a few times on the same day.
00:10:55 We have the car that he drove in being registered to him.
00:10:58 We have the physical evidence.
00:11:00 Obviously, you talked about the DNA evidence of the towel that the gun was found wrapped in, the screwdriver found on the roof in the sniper's perch.
00:11:07 And we haven't even gotten to the text communications and the fact, you know, the involvement of his parents in terms of identifying him yet and the whole story of how he ultimately turned himself in.
00:11:19 This is this is overwhelming evidence. It's surprising. It's surprising to me that the defense decided that it was a good idea to have a preliminary hearing.
00:11:28 I think in their spot, you know, the only burden here that needs to be met is probable cause.
00:11:32 and it's been met in spades already.
00:11:34 It's kind of interesting that this hearing is continuing on for days and days
00:11:37 because if I was in the judge's shoes, I'd feel no problem about going forward
00:11:41 and saying there's probable cause here, let's set a trial date.
00:11:47 Well, and it just goes to show you that, look, for example,
00:11:52 in the second half of the day today, we have this DNA evidence that's introduced.
00:11:58 the forensic tech shows us that, okay, there's two individuals that were found on these two
00:12:06 items. This was the screwdriver and then the towel. And she's saying, look, there's a 95%
00:12:13 match to Tyler Robinson on one, 5% to Twigs. Then the other one was 89% Tyler Robinson. The second
00:12:21 Someone was the minor contributor.
00:12:22 That was 11% again to Lance Twiggs.
00:12:27 And so we get that piece of information in, and then the defense spends, I'd have to go
00:12:33 back and look, almost three hours of time just filibustering about whether or not DNA
00:12:41 evidence itself, the science of DNA, can be used to match someone and the standards of
00:12:48 the FBI lab at Quantico and over and over and over. And I have to say, I think the FBI tech
00:12:53 handled herself very well. And to me, she gave a masterclass in, I guess what I would call
00:12:59 positive demeanor, the power of positive demeanor in that she was never competitive.
00:13:06 She was never argumentative, but she was firm and she was positive. She was always very polite.
00:13:12 You know, she would sort of say, no, I don't agree with that actually. And she would walk
00:13:17 through her reasons why but never snapped never lost her temper and clearly someone who's highly
00:13:24 skilled highly capable and very proud of the work that she did so again to your point i don't think
00:13:30 the defense scored points there i think they lost points clearly with the judge who you know i don't
00:13:36 know if you could see on live stream as much but in person he seemed to be getting extremely
00:13:40 frustrated with the defense oh i'm sure he was i mean the the idea that you know you're you're
00:13:46 going to waste my time in a preliminary hearing. It's not even the trial yet. You're not talking
00:13:49 the jury. You're literally trying to persuade me, the judge, that there's no probable cause. That's
00:13:54 theoretically what you're trying to accomplish here as the defense. And your way of doing that
00:13:58 is to try and tell me that DNA evidence isn't real and that DNA's technology is fake. And that's
00:14:03 your argument for probable cause. And you don't have an expert coming up to testify to that effect.
00:14:08 No, it's just you, the defense lawyer, trying to tell me about how DNA is fake. I mean, think about
00:14:13 two things, right? Think about, first off, how many criminal trials has this judge dealt with
00:14:19 over his career? I mean, he's probably dealt with dozens, maybe hundreds. Many of them will
00:14:25 have involved DNA evidence. So he's going to be personally quite familiar with the science of DNA
00:14:30 evidence, actually, because he's probably heard a lot of experts testify about it. And he's probably
00:14:34 going to have sent a lot of people to jail on the basis of DNA evidence. So for the defense lawyers
00:14:38 to think it would be a really good strategy to just attack DNA evidence as a general matter,
00:14:44 as a general idea, and attack the underlying science of DNA evidence, broadly speaking. 0.61
00:14:50 The idea that that would be a useful way for him to spend time is ridiculous.
00:14:53 So I'm not surprised that the judge would have betrayed some impatience with this line of questioning.
00:15:00 Certainly, and the extensive, extensive nature of it, bringing up textbooks, studies from 20 years ago.
00:15:07 And I might add, and something that a few of us noted, that he brought up, I guess, a commission from the Obama Department of Justice that was pushing back.
00:15:19 And I thought, my goodness, here's something for us to maybe dig in on a later episode to see exactly what the Eric Holder Department of Justice was trying to do in undercutting DNA evidence, because that's clearly what they were trying to do.
00:15:32 And I I really did appreciate how the FBI tech just Amanda Baker just just really dismissed it out of out of hand.
00:15:38 Those aren't experts. That was political.
00:15:40 You know, it was like it was just just completely, completely rejected that entire line of argument.
00:15:47 Yeah, I mean, I think that this is obviously going to go nowhere.
00:15:50 And in particular, it's not going to go anywhere at a preliminary hearing in front of a judge.
00:15:54 You know, maybe they can find a juror who's skeptical of this stuff.
00:15:57 And maybe that's the point. 0.94
00:15:58 Maybe this is all to further sort of online conspiracy theorizing, giving something to the baying mobs to say, ah, you can you could ignore this DNA evidence and continue spewing your nonsense on podcasts. 0.92
00:16:11 You know, maybe that's the point of these lines of questioning. 0.57
00:16:14 If the audience is not the audience is actually the few podcasters and diehards who really do want to continue this narrative that Tyler Robinson didn't do it.
00:16:23 I think that that might be what the defense is trying to accomplish here to sort of, you know, continue to muddy the public waters in this respect.
00:16:30 But certainly I don't think the judge is impressed in the slightest.
00:16:33 no and and and neither were really anyone in the courtroom that i spoke with and it it really seemed
00:16:43 to be an exercise in what can we do to delay what can we do to obfuscate rather than actually focus
00:16:51 on the very clear evidence that is now coming out and one of which and i i would love and i can't
00:16:59 can't wait for it to come out online, but the fact that it remains to be seen that we
00:17:04 now have 4K quality footage of Tyler Robinson, it's obviously him, walking around on campus,
00:17:13 walking around on the day of, changing his outfits, and the judge didn't play it in court,
00:17:19 but zoomed in footage of him prone in the sniper position, crawling across the roof,
00:17:27 Taking the shot and then running back across the roof to jump down.
00:17:32 I mean, well, I've been heard a lot of people, you know, kind of saying that people who are on the fence, that that footage, just the high quality footage of him walking around campus really started to change their minds.
00:17:44 Yeah, I should hope so.
00:17:46 I mean, it's and this is not this is just the beginning.
00:17:50 I mean, we're still the preliminary hearing.
00:17:51 We haven't even gotten to the trial presentation of this stuff.
00:17:54 My goodness.
00:17:54 you got to think about how much else they're going to have how you know when they get to the real
00:17:58 live testimonial evidence you know it sounds like they're also going to be putting twigs his
00:18:03 boyfriend on the stand what's twigs going to say i mean nothing nothing twigs said to robinson is
00:18:09 privileged i just real quick on that i believe they are going to be doing a taped testimony
00:18:17 and playing a tape of that here at the preliminary hearing uh to your point obviously yes he will
00:18:22 go on the stand at the trial but that's something where and we'll see um whether or not that
00:18:28 actually gets played this week because uh certainly things are taking their time here
00:18:35 in provo utah special coverage human events prime time the tyler robinson hearings right back jack
00:18:42 Posobiec, Real America's Voice.
00:18:55 Influencers. These are influencers.
00:18:58 And they're friends of mine.
00:19:00 Jack Posobiec. Where's Jack?
00:19:03 He's done a great job.
00:19:09 All right, folks.
00:19:10 Jack Posobiec back live here.
00:19:13 Welcome back to Human Events' special primetime coverage of the Tyler Robinson hearings.
00:19:19 We are live in Provo, Utah.
00:19:21 This is day two.
00:19:24 I want to say thank you again to our special sponsor this week, which is Allegiance Gold.
00:19:31 And before we get into that, we really, really need to thank them for making all of this possible.
00:19:37 Look, covering a trial like this from the scene and in this point, even in the room, it takes a lot.
00:19:43 From behind the scenes, including the security that's been required for our team to be here safely,
00:19:48 their support from Allegiance Gold is a big part of making it possible, and we're so grateful for it.
00:19:55 Spending time here also reminds me that security means different things to different people.
00:19:59 For us this week, it's physical security, while we are, of course, right here on location.
00:20:05 But for all of us, it's also about financial security, doing what we can to protect our families and what we've worked hard to build.
00:20:13 That's why I'm especially thankful for Allegiance Gold, and we've been working together with them for the past five years now.
00:20:20 Relationships like that are not built overnight.
00:20:22 They're built on trust, consistency, and showing up for one another.
00:20:26 We appreciate their support for this special coverage, and we're so proud to have them standing with us.
00:20:31 If you would like to learn more, here's what you do.
00:20:33 You go visit protectwithposo.com.
00:20:35 That's protectwithposo.com or give them a call, 844-577-POSO, and you will learn more.
00:20:43 I want to get Will Chamberlain back on here.
00:20:46 And, Will, there's so much that's come out in terms of all of this, the video, the surveillance footage, the digital prints.
00:20:56 And one thing that I want to point out, there was something, it was just a little tidbit that Agent Hull had mentioned early on, the former SBI special agent.
00:21:08 But one of the things that he mentioned was that, just a new nugget of information, but that Tyler Robinson ate Chick-fil-A prior to going and getting the rifle from the car and coming back to campus.
00:21:19 Now, I'm sure that's something that people can make a lot of hay about, but there's actually something significant there, and it's similar to this report that he was at a Dairy Queen afterwards.
00:21:33 Afterwards, if he was making purchases there using a credit card or a debit card that can be tied directly to him,
00:21:43 which means that aside from just having this high quality footage, we can also see things like having his credit card and debit card, finding that digital transaction.
00:21:55 We can then use those finances to say, yes, this was his card in the same way that having the police officer with that interaction late at night had the license plate, which was independent.
00:22:06 And I guess, well, what I'm saying is, is that there are going to now be more ways to even further corroborate this bombshell video that's coming out in court today.
00:22:16 That's right. You know, I think I didn't actually think of that personally, but yes, you're right.
00:22:20 If he was, you know, any sort of financial transactions, which is as simple as buying food or buying gas, is going to, if he used his credit card or the credit card of somebody, his family, it's going to place it at the scene or, you know, on campus.
00:22:34 And remember, I mean, he lives multiple hours away.
00:22:36 There's no reason for him to be there.
00:22:37 Why is he, you know, why is he showing up four times in a day?
00:22:40 What's he doing if not this?
00:22:42 so you have i mean you just have and that's going to be layered on top of if he brought his phone
00:22:48 then is there's going to be a whole phone signature about where his location was vis-a-vis the phone
00:22:53 records um so you're going to have all these different layers of evidence that are going to
00:22:58 place robinson at the scene and put the gun in his hands and you know i think what the defense
00:23:04 is going to try and do it's like okay maybe you ask your question about one individual piece of
00:23:08 evidence like okay you try and say dna evidence is fake and we don't know that it's real okay but
00:23:12 but then you've got four or five other layers of evidence that place him on that roof so you're
00:23:17 are those all fake too you know is everything fake none of that's going to work and it's not
00:23:23 going to work on a normal jury um it's certainly not going to persuade a judge you know they're
00:23:28 really just at this point the judge is just going to keep being annoyed if the if the defense is
00:23:32 just going to you know basically going full-on epistemology like how do we actually know that
00:23:37 dna evidence works how do we know that do you you know who was behind the camera how do you know
00:23:42 this video evidence is real etc etc etc that's just not going to impress anybody
00:23:46 no again and and you know little things like saying well can you really see the uh the markings
00:23:55 on that shirt or i think uh kathy nester at one point was asking um the agent you know did you
00:24:01 tell if if anyone had gone up on that roof after you had left the roof and they secured it but
00:24:06 before this video i mean just just nitpicking these these little things that don't actually
00:24:13 add up to anything because we can see on the video that there's nobody else on the roof it's right
00:24:18 there on video so no he didn't need to go and physically look himself because it's right there
00:24:23 on video so people can can see all this and so will to your point uh any of the the points that
00:24:28 they think they're going to be making are actually all falling by the wayside or ultimately just uh
00:24:35 just delaying the inevitable because this evidence is all going to be presented they're not going to
00:24:41 get rid of the dna evidence they're not going to get rid of the ballistics evidence they're not
00:24:46 going to get rid of the autopsy and so even though these things okay we can't publish it publicly
00:24:50 etc etc yes okay that's okay that's you know perhaps a a fleeting victory for you right now
00:24:57 but ultimately that's still evidence in court that's going to be building a case that is very
00:25:03 much sacked against your client. Yeah, I mean, this is one of those circumstances where it's
00:25:09 going to be extremely difficult for them to tell a competing story. That's normally what
00:25:13 good criminal defense lawyers look like for this. Like, you know, you have all this evidence that's
00:25:18 going to be admitted. And if it points to your client, you need some sort of alternate explanation
00:25:22 for why it's true, you know, or what happened that is innocent. And there is no, the problem
00:25:29 is there is not going to be an innocent explanation for the overwhelming mountain of evidence that's
00:25:33 points to ty robinson being the shooter here uh and so as a result you know this is the kind of
00:25:38 case where you know if you're a defense lawyer in a normal world you're trying to tell your client
00:25:43 to plea out i think it's it's kind of you normally don't see cases like this with such an overwhelming
00:25:47 amount of evidence go to trial there's sort of an understanding that these these cases need to be
00:25:52 put out by the defense lawyer i think the unique thing here is because this was a public assassination
00:25:57 of a major political figure in our friend certainly you know yeah certainly we will see
00:26:02 will chamberlain where can people go to follow you at will chamberlain on x and you can follow
00:26:06 what the article three project is doing at a3paction.com all right check them out folks
00:26:12 human events primetime continues
00:26:13 where's jack where is he jack i want to see you
00:26:29 great job jack thank you what a job you do you know we have an incredible thing we're always
00:26:37 talking about the fake news and the bad but we have guys and these are the guys should be getting
00:26:42 all right jack posobik we're really excited to welcome you back to human events prime time
00:26:53 here on Real America's Voice.
00:26:55 Want to give a shout out as well
00:26:57 to the Real America's Voice team
00:27:00 for all of their support
00:27:02 in allowing us to do this out here
00:27:05 in Provo, Utah.
00:27:07 I want to bring on now our next guest,
00:27:09 Andrea Burkhart of Andrea Burkhart Law.
00:27:11 Andrea, how are you?
00:27:13 Thank you, Jack.
00:27:17 Well, thanks so much for joining us.
00:27:19 Now, you know, I'm here in the courtroom,
00:27:21 so I'm not able to be able to watch
00:27:22 your live streams, which is normally how I really enjoy to watch these. So I wanted to say thank
00:27:28 you for putting them out there. But it also, of course, means I miss your analysis. So I wanted
00:27:33 to get you on here to hear how is it that you're sort of scoring these first two days of the
00:27:38 hearing thus far? Do you think the prosecution is doing what they need to do? And what's your
00:27:44 sense of how the defense is? Yeah, absolutely. I think that at this point, there's very little
00:27:49 question, the prosecution is going to mean its burden to show probable cause to justify the
00:27:54 charge. It's not a particularly high burden, especially in Utah with some of the just legal
00:28:01 nuances that apply to the standard there. That said, I do think the defense has
00:28:07 taken the opportunity to try to point out some open questions, some possible holes that may need
00:28:16 to be closed or at least examined at some point in the investigation. So it's giving us a little
00:28:22 bit of a clue about how they may be working towards generating a probable cause, I'm sorry,
00:28:30 a case for reasonable doubt. Well, and that does seem to be what they're attempting to do. And so
00:28:39 while that doesn't obviously matter in terms of the jury, because there is no jury yet,
00:28:44 clearly it's intended for public consumption. And again, to your point, kind of showing the
00:28:51 cards of this is going to be what we're going to hear more of in the evidentiary hearings and then
00:28:57 eventually the trial itself. Yeah, very much so. And frankly, I think you're correct that a lot of
00:29:08 what the defense is doing in this process is really geared towards the public perception of
00:29:12 the case and the case for guilt, the possible arguments for innocence. What the defense is
00:29:19 notably not doing is aligning itself with any kind of alternative theories of what happened.
00:29:27 They aren't buying into like some of the narratives that we see online in the commentary and so forth.
00:29:33 They really aren't asserting an alternative viewpoint at all at this point. And that's
00:29:39 really not surprising because it's a card that they're going to want to hold as close to the
00:29:46 vest as they can for as long as possible. But we are seeing the way that they are trying to chip
00:29:52 away at the cracks. And in so doing, I think trying to shift the narrative at least enough
00:29:59 to encourage prospective jurors to keep an open mind. There may not be full answers to every
00:30:07 question at this stage. And I think that is an important reminder that we do need to wait to
00:30:14 hear what the defense has to say before we reach definitive conclusions. But that said, in terms of
00:30:21 the goals of this particular hearing and establishing the legal justification to move
00:30:27 forward to trial, I don't think that's going to be a difficult question at this point.
00:30:31 no it seems as though the judge is um you know is is playing it as fair as he can um in terms of
00:30:42 what he's allowing what he's not allowing he's clearly allowing pretty much everything into
00:30:47 evidence the question of course is uh and i think of you every time he says that uh something can't
00:30:52 be shown on the uh on the public live stream i said oh andrea's probably scowling about that
00:30:57 Thank you. Yeah, no, I think that Judge Graff has shown an enormous amount of grace and generosity towards the defense in this case.
00:31:09 We saw this, I think, most notably this afternoon with the questioning of the DNA analyst. This was really an accommodation from the state to kind of allow this analyst to be called by the defense in the first place.
00:31:24 And then to kind of permit this very extended questioning that under the specific rules that apply to Utah and the defense's right to present witnesses really doesn't seem to fit squarely within that.
00:31:40 So he does seem to be exercising an abundance of caution to make sure that he is as fair to the defense as possible.
00:31:47 And he's giving them ample opportunity to make their position known.
00:31:54 Well, he is. But I would note that towards the end of the end of the session today, he really started pointing out the clock.
00:32:03 He started reminding them that, you know, we're winding down, talking about, hey, you have now spent two, almost three hours going down the line here.
00:32:13 What what exactly do you want? I got the sense that he was pretty much done.
00:32:19 oh i think so too but you notice it wasn't a hard yank on the leash he did not lay down the law
00:32:27 or stop the process or anything like that he really kept inviting uh mr burt to uh you speed
00:32:34 things along wrap it up uh the closest he really got was um uh putting some limits on on some of
00:32:42 the questions that that mr burt wanted to ask when mr bride would object and say all right i'll let
00:32:47 you ask this one and then we're going to move on. So really, I think trying to always find that
00:32:53 middle ground between what he really wants to do and what is going to leave the defense with
00:32:59 the fewest arguments that they didn't get a fair shake in this process.
00:33:06 Yeah, that's right. And I thought that Mr. McBride responding there did very well with his
00:33:12 objections to speed things along saying, look, this is, you know, the relevance here is not
00:33:17 germane to these proceedings. This is something for an evidentiary hearing. This isn't really
00:33:21 what this preliminary hearing is all about. We're just trying to determine probable cause here. We
00:33:26 don't have to have this whole argument about whether DNA science is real or not, which is
00:33:30 clearly what Mr. Byrd was trying to do. But I also thought that earlier in the day regarding that
00:33:41 that 1102 that Mr. Novak on the front of the defense team had argued against. And again,
00:33:46 Mr. McBride presenting his his attempt to and really did, by the way, I think, overcome the
00:33:54 objection regarding a certain 1102 statement, getting into the motives or potential motives of
00:34:00 the defendant here talking about how how Turning Point has a a Christian mission, a political
00:34:07 mission. And I thought that actually it was sort of interesting because it seemed like the judge
00:34:14 was going to rule in favor of the objection at first with Mr. Novak, but then it almost felt
00:34:21 like Mr. Novak kind of just talked himself out of the win and talked himself, just went way,
00:34:27 way further than he needed to getting into these really philosophical questions of politics and
00:34:34 religion and where does it all mix? And I think at that point, that's where he lost the judge.
00:34:38 I think you might be right. I'm a Mr. Novak fan myself. I've reviewed a lot of his history,
00:34:46 his practice, the work that he's done. And as a fellow defense attorney, I have great admiration
00:34:51 for a lot of things that he's accomplished. But I do have to agree that I think Mr. Novak
00:34:57 may have a tendency to be his own worst enemy sometimes when it comes to brevity.
00:35:03 The problem is the more you talk, the greater opportunity you give, number one, the other side to think of their response to what you're saying, but also the judge's opportunity to kind of process it as well and come up with objections.
00:35:18 I think the initial point that Mr. Novak was making, the state charged Tyler Robinson under one very specific aggravator that deals with political expression. There is a separate aggravator specifically for religious motivation. It wasn't charged. For whatever reason, that was the decision.
00:35:38 And I think had he made that point and kind of left it there, we might have gotten a different outcome. But the problem is, is that just through the digging into it and the continuing to speak, it gave the judge a lot of time to start thinking about, well, but isn't there a lot of overlap between these things?
00:35:58 And I think ultimately that's what led him to rule the way he did, is that it's simply not as clear and fine a distinction as it might be when you're writing it down in a statute on paper.
00:36:12 and that was my that was my thinking as well and and it really you know allowed the opportunity to
00:36:19 bring in so many of those questions uh gender issues and christianity and politics and marriage
00:36:26 and all of these things that probably wouldn't have been talked about otherwise uh we're taking
00:36:31 a quick break here we're on with andrea burkhart from andrea burkhart law this is
00:36:36 human events primetime special coverage real america's voice
00:36:39 I can say confidently, I believe, I think Josh Shapiro would be the vice presidential
00:36:57 nominee if it wasn't for Jack Posobiec.
00:36:59 And that is, I'll be honest.
00:37:04 You testified about Exhibits 7 and 8, that they both had mixtures.
00:37:09 excuse me yes item seven and eight and you're testing the the of these items
00:37:14 that they both had mixtures and you state I want to make sure I understood
00:37:17 this you stated I believe that the minor sample the minor contributor was less
00:37:23 than 20% and it was actually 5% the ratio is 5% to 95%
00:37:27 yes you remember that yes does that mean the 5% was from twigs and the 95% that
00:37:33 that 95% is assumed from the defendants be the Robinson when I calculate the
00:37:39 statistic. Twigs' DNA profile aligned with the 5% contributor and Mr. Robinson's DNA profile aligned
00:37:44 better with the 95% contributor. Okay, same question with regard to eight. I think you said
00:37:48 the ratio was 11% from the minor and 89% from the major. Is that Twigs being the 11% and 1.00
00:37:54 Robinson being the 89%? Yes, Twigs better aligned with that 11% contributor and Mr. Robinson better
00:37:59 aligned with that 79% contributor. All right, Jack Posobiec back, Human Events,
00:38:05 Primetime special coverage here on Real America's Voice.
00:38:09 I want to say special thanks again to Allegiance Gold as well as Sov Media,
00:38:15 our great friends over there, putting together all of the package that we have for supporting us
00:38:21 and allowing us to have our security team and all of the production that we're able to do.
00:38:27 So shout out to the SIGs as well, Parker, Rob, the entire team for affording us this ability to be here.
00:38:34 And we're on again with Andrea Burkhart from Andrea Burkhart Law.
00:38:37 She is one of the best YouTubers out there.
00:38:40 LawTube, they call it, to make sure you go and check it out.
00:38:43 But it is not for the faint of heart because she is going to give it to you the way she sees it.
00:38:49 She does not take sides, and that is why we like her so much.
00:38:53 Andrea, before we go today, you know, I guess one of the things that I wanted to ask is that, you know,
00:39:00 Here we are day two. Tomorrow's a half day in court. I'm hearing I hear things in the courtroom, hear things in the courthouse that the people had expected to be further along than we are already.
00:39:16 We've really only had three witnesses thus far. Do you think there's a possibility that this goes beyond Friday?
00:39:25 It is possible. I would have said up until this afternoon that I would have considered them to be approximately on schedule, just given the number of witnesses that they anticipated and the time that's been allocated.
00:39:38 But I do think that this afternoon likely came as a bit of a surprise to everybody in the courtroom about how long the defense was expecting to spend on this one particular issue and this one particular witness.
00:39:56 I'm anticipating the court is already looking down the road to the defenses planning to call
00:40:03 two other experts. And, you know, if they give them the similar treatment that they gave this
00:40:08 expert today, then yes, we could be significantly behind schedule in terms of being able to wrap
00:40:15 things up. So because of that, I kind of anticipate that we may see a tighter leash on that in the
00:40:22 coming days, just to ensure that if at all possible, they're able to get things done by Friday.
00:40:31 Yeah, I noticed that as well, because it's something where the, you know, the clock
00:40:36 management is really coming into play and where, you know, clearly the prosecutors are wanting to
00:40:43 present their evidence. They want to get it out there. They want to show it to the judge in terms
00:40:47 of his magisterial role of providing, of getting that. And by the way, I really like the fact that
00:40:54 this is done in a public setting as opposed to a grand jury, because a grand jury, that means all
00:41:01 of this would be behind closed doors. And in fact, it is more beneficial to the defendant as well,
00:41:08 because it allows for cross-examination, which doesn't exist in a grand jury situation. And of
00:41:13 course, for those of us who want everything to be public and want this transparency.
00:41:17 We are getting that at the same time, though, again, to your point that there really are
00:41:23 these questions of the limitations of time and the fact that we only have two and a half
00:41:28 days left.
00:41:29 That is the tradeoff.
00:41:30 I mean, when you give the defensive voice, they're going to use it.
00:41:33 And again, Judge Graff is, I think, doing everything reasonably within his power to
00:41:40 make sure he's giving the defense every opportunity so that they can't come back at some future point
00:41:46 and suggest that they weren't able to make their record or make their case on on a particular
00:41:51 issue. So it's it's not ideal. Time management is always a challenge in in the court process
00:41:58 because you can't control what the other side is doing. The judge has a little bit more control
00:42:03 over everybody, but even him, he can't you know, he runs the risk of violating important procedural
00:42:10 rights if he cuts people off kind of arbitrarily or gives them a preset time and they realistically
00:42:17 need more. So I think he's he's trying to walk the tightrope here as best as he can. But
00:42:23 efficiency is always a concern in our extremely busy courtrooms across the country.
00:42:32 No, it certainly is. And and to that point, you know, even given the high profile nature of this,
00:42:37 it goes to show that there's still a lot of work that needs to be done. There's a lot of work that
00:42:42 needs to go into it, and they are clearly doing so. What do you think that we should expect to
00:42:48 look for in the next coming days? Well, what seems to be the way that the state is presenting
00:42:55 their case here is they're presenting it kind of chronologically showing how the investigation
00:43:01 unfolded. So they've already shown us the shooting, the scene, the kind of immediate
00:43:07 response, the surveillance. And we've only just barely started to touch on the evidence that
00:43:13 they obtained once Mr. Robinson did surrender. And then they were able to have the conversations
00:43:20 with Mr. Twiggs. They were able to get the photographs of the evidence from the telephone
00:43:25 and things along those lines. So I expect that's what we're building up to over the coming days.
00:43:30 The question just kind of from a logistical standpoint is really where they intend to work in these other anticipated to be federal expert witnesses that the defense intends to call.
00:43:45 They're always going to work around witnesses like that because they're flying in from the East Coast.
00:43:50 They're going to want to accommodate that.
00:43:53 So they'll kind of build the schedule around when those folks are available.
00:43:58 And that's just a piece of information that we don't have.
00:44:03 That's exactly right.
00:44:05 And, you know, when we look at it as well in terms of what's coming in and how long,
00:44:12 I will say today that we did seem to have fewer objections that, again, McBride, he's my star of the day,
00:44:19 just in terms of process and getting things going.
00:44:23 that, you know, right at the very start saying, look, you guys made your blanket objection.
00:44:28 It's a standing objection. We get it. You don't have to keep getting up and doing it over and
00:44:32 over and over. And by the way, that's certainly something that if you do in front of a jury,
00:44:36 I can't imagine is going to win you any points. Yeah, I think that was a big improvement to the
00:44:42 day. And I also think, frankly, it was helpful that it was Mr. Burt who fielded that objection
00:44:46 for the defense and not Mrs. Nestor, who was the one who, you know, did most of the objecting
00:44:54 in the previous parts of the hearing. But it really does. I understand why the defense
00:45:01 was doing that. There are so many procedural pitfalls when it comes to preserving your
00:45:07 rights for future review. And they just want to be super careful that there is no argument,
00:45:12 that they have waived something because their objection wasn't specific enough or, you know,
00:45:18 didn't clearly apply to this piece of evidence that is being addressed in court. So I do understand
00:45:24 that. But at the same time, it is extremely aggravating for everybody to kind of have to
00:45:29 endure it. So the judge's ability to kind of talk them off the ledge with that is something that
00:45:36 we're i think all a little grateful for i couldn't i couldn't agree more especially uh especially
00:45:43 being there and and uh you know just wanting to wanting to get the story out wanting to get the
00:45:48 procedure going andrew burkhart we have to run we're out of time where can people go to follow
00:45:52 you uh find me on andreaburkhart.substack.com that's where i have the archive of the legal
00:45:58 documents that i'm collecting in this case you can also find me at aburkhartlaw is my handle
00:46:05 You can find me under that handle on YouTube and Twitter.
00:46:09 Thanks.
00:46:10 All right.
00:46:11 Thank you so much, ladies and gentlemen.
00:46:13 As always, you have our permission to lay ashore.