New Culture Forum - November 29, 2020


Ann Widdecombe - Boris Is Weak, Brexit In Peril, Covid Shambles, Free Speech Spies & Culture Wars

What Does It Mean To Be A Man & How Can Men Live More Meaningful Lives? Julia Hartley-Brewer On The Culture Wars, Media Bias, Covid, Free Speech & Boris's Lame Leadership

Episode Stats


Length

40 minutes

Words per minute

168.53

Word count

6,829

Sentence count

184


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello and welcome to so what you're saying is i'm peter whittle now you might have noticed since
00:00:28 we've been doing this show, what is it, nearly two years now, that we very rarely have politicians
00:00:33 on and there's a very good reason for that. Most of them are very predictable and indeed boring
00:00:38 and they certainly don't implant themselves in the public mind and imagination. Well you certainly
00:00:45 can't say that about my guest this morning. Anne Whittacombe entered Parliament in 1987. She rose
00:00:52 to become Shadow Home Secretary.
00:00:55 She left Parliament in 2010
00:00:57 and after a bit of a break came back
00:00:59 and became an MEP for the Brexit Party
00:01:04 and in between times became something of a bona fide TV star
00:01:09 with appearances ranging from Strictly Come Dancing
00:01:12 right to Celebrity Big Brother.
00:01:16 Anne, thank you very, very much for joining us this morning.
00:01:20 Hello, it's a pleasure to be here.
00:01:21 I have to say, before we go on, that's a pretty impressive library you've got there. What is it?
00:01:29 Those are Hansards that you can see behind me. That is the verbatim record of every word that is said in Parliament, that is in the Chamber, every word that is said throughout the course of a parliamentary year.
00:01:45 and so I've got every single thing here from the moment I entered Parliament in 1987
00:01:51 to the moment I left in 2010 so if anybody writes to me and says oh but you said or you voted or
00:01:58 you did this or you did that I can check it out just as I can also check out you know anything
00:02:04 from the history of those years. Do they still produce it actually in hard copy? I suspect not
00:02:11 I mean, obviously, my entitlement to it ended when I left Parliament.
00:02:15 But I suspect that these days it's probably all done remotely.
00:02:21 And people don't have rather splendid libraries like this.
00:02:24 The Lords used to get exactly the same.
00:02:26 Theirs were red.
00:02:27 Yes.
00:02:29 I have to start, really, with the subject of Brexit,
00:02:32 because obviously time, you know, the clock is running down yet again.
00:02:35 I wondered, Nigel Farage recently said that he thought Brexit was in peril, in more peril, in fact, than he could remember in the past year.
00:02:48 Would you agree with that?
00:02:51 Well, I think I think Brexit has always been in peril.
00:02:55 But I think Nigel's observation is based on the fact that there's precious little time left now.
00:03:00 and I think most observers are expecting a sellout
00:03:05 because the fact is that if Boris was serious
00:03:08 about leaving the talks if they weren't making progress
00:03:11 he would have left at the end of June
00:03:13 and we would have had a deal by now
00:03:15 because that would have signalled to the EU
00:03:16 that we would only be serious
00:03:18 and we were only going to negotiate as a sovereign nation
00:03:21 not as some sort of semi-detached member of the EU
00:03:25 he didn't walk out at the end of June
00:03:28 he didn't walk out at the end of July
00:03:29 he didn't walk out on the 15th of october let's face it he ain't gonna walk out um and the time
00:03:36 now for british business to get ready for an australia style deal um is now so short that
00:03:43 he will be able to argue it's no longer feasible and it's all due to covid and it's nothing to do
00:03:49 with his own lack of will and and so i suspect yes i suspect any true brexit is now very seriously
00:03:57 in peril because the deadline's looming there's no real side there's a much talk i you know always
00:04:02 grant boris he does a lot of talking but there's no evidence of real action what about the what's
00:04:08 happened in america i mean what difference do you think that will make i mean we're hearing a lot of
00:04:14 press uh comment about it but what's your view on that i think it's going to make a a a big
00:04:20 difference the fact is biden is anti-brexit um and believed it was his business to say so at the time
00:04:27 but far more dangerous than that uh biden um is a very clear uh about the situation in ireland about
00:04:36 what he wants to see he doesn't care if there's a border down the irish sea uh and uh so what
00:04:42 he's effectively talking about although he would never phrase it in such a way is the breakup of
00:04:47 the uk so i think that we are in quite a serious situation but on the other hand you know we have
00:04:52 a special military relationship um with uh the states we've been for years the only country
00:04:58 that has paid its full back of nato um i think they know that we are pretty essential to them
00:05:05 uh but nevertheless you know whereas trump was pro brexit pro an independent britain um wanted
00:05:11 a united kingdom biden's the opposite so it could be dangerous but on the other hand if a deal or
00:05:19 probably a surrender but if something is done by the end of the year it will be a fetter complete
00:05:25 and biden doesn't become president until january when you think back to 2016 the and the referendum
00:05:33 i mean would you have thought that you and i would be sitting here now talking about the
00:05:39 possibility of not having a Brexit? I would have been appalled and I wouldn't have thought it. No,
00:05:45 that is not what I predicted. All the parliamentary leaders were saying they're going to abide by the
00:05:51 result of the referendum because they all expected it to go the other way. When most
00:05:56 inconveniently for them, it did not go the sort of metropolitan elite way at all, then
00:06:04 I think we would have had a series of excuses anyway, but Theresa May and her appalling leadership
00:06:11 and the loss of the parliamentary majority, which meant effectively that even if she'd had the will
00:06:16 to do it, she was too hampered by Parliament to be able to effect a proper Brexit. All that has
00:06:23 conspired to this very, very prolonged timetable. I mean, we have left the EU, but if we're in any
00:06:32 way kept bound by their rules uh or uh bound um by their justice by their courts uh then we
00:06:41 haven't actually left um in any meaningful way and my fear throughout has been um a half brexit
00:06:50 would you and would you would you go along with the view that uh simply that the establishment
00:06:56 for want of a better word, simply just was determined that whatever happened, we wouldn't
00:07:02 really leave. We might leave in word, but not in spirit. I mean, do you go along with that? Or do
00:07:07 you think it's purely political incompetence? Oh, I think it's a mix. I mean, I think there
00:07:13 was an initial reluctance to accept the fact this was really going to happen. We were going to leave.
00:07:18 I think there was that reluctance. But I also think it was largely incompetence. I mean,
00:07:23 If Theresa May had had the sort of majority that Boris has got
00:07:26 and had been genuinely committed to Brexit,
00:07:29 which I think there's a very big question mark over that,
00:07:31 but if she'd been genuinely committed to Brexit
00:07:33 with a strong parliamentary majority,
00:07:35 then it could have been carried through.
00:07:38 The fact is she wasn't that committed
00:07:39 and she didn't have a strong parliamentary majority.
00:07:42 So it's been a mixture of incompetence, lack of will,
00:07:47 and yes, some part resistance, but not, I think, a great deal.
00:07:51 I think when we left on the 31st of January, there was then, even if with a sigh and a raising of
00:08:00 eyebrows, I think there was then a general acceptance by the establishment we're going.
00:08:05 And Wiserhead said, or rather we've gone, Wiserhead said, OK, if this now is really the situation,
00:08:12 time to accept it and to make sure we get a good deal for Britain. And everybody should have been
00:08:17 united around that but i'm afraid there are still elements that hope that one day you know we'll
00:08:22 reapply to join and therefore that the closer we stay to them now the better and that view is around
00:08:28 when you look at the government now um and you here we are with the government's got an 80 seat
00:08:36 majority uh it appears to be frittering it away or at least not using it what do you do you know
00:08:43 boris johnson and what's your view of him did you know him personally i don't know boris johnson
00:08:50 personally not in terms of you know social friendship of course we overlapped in parliament
00:08:55 i had plenty of time to observe him as a member of parliament i can remember his performances on
00:09:01 one particular committee which i chaired uh which were very funny yeah but not necessarily
00:09:08 terribly deep and i think the problem with boris is he is chaotic and he is utterly reliant on
00:09:14 people around him to keep everything on the road to keep the show on the road to keep him where he
00:09:18 ought to be at what time he ought to be there uh he is chaotic um now i think he is a genuine
00:09:25 genuinely pro-brexit i certainly think that at heart he is still a libertarian uh but um
00:09:33 And he's been captured, basically. He's been captured. And I think COVID has thrown him completely. But also, COVID is, of course, a very good excuse for those who didn't particularly want to get on with it.
00:09:48 And now I think he's in a weak position. When he came in, he said, right, you know, everybody who stood as a Conservative MP was signed up to keeping no deal on the table.
00:09:58 You know, he had the big majority. His slogan through the campaign had been get Brexit done. The people had spoken yet again.
00:10:05 Yes. And I think that if he'd gone in with that sort of will then and said, right, this is it. Brexit. We're leaving at the end of June if there's no proper progress.
00:10:15 We have red lines. We're not departing from those red lines.
00:10:18 We're a sovereign state. We control our own waters.
00:10:21 Of course, you can fish in them, but only to the extent that we actually say so, because we are a sovereign state.
00:10:26 No, we're not going to be governed by your rules on state aid because we are a sovereign state.
00:10:31 If he'd taken that line and really stuck to it, Parliament, I think, or certainly the Conservative Party in Parliament,
00:10:39 would have been behind him because he would have been delivering on what he promised.
00:10:44 But he's gone from Tigger to Eeyore. And he, I mean, his whole management of COVID, which of course has a read across to everything else, because his MPs are looking to him for leadership. If he's not giving it on COVID, then he won't, they won't be following him on other things. And his whole management of COVID has been flip flop.
00:11:07 you know one day a lockdown is not in the national interest the next day a lockdown is
00:11:11 and most people in this country probably haven't a clue what the rules are at the moment because
00:11:18 they've changed every day prime minister's got it wrong occasionally chief constables have got it
00:11:23 wrong changes every day it hasn't been strong firm leadership in the face of adversity it has been
00:11:33 cannot. Absolutely. Do you go along? There is this view that around about March, just before
00:11:39 the first lockdown, that in fact there was a tremendous loss of nerve, you know, that in fact
00:11:45 Boris's instinct was not to go over the lockdown. There's that view. And then there's the other view
00:11:51 that in fact he was just personally affected by having COVID. I mean, do you sort of line up with
00:11:57 one or other of those views? I don't think they're mutually exclusive. I mean, he was obviously very
00:12:02 bad hit. I mean, COVID nearly killed him. I mean, let's not forget that he was in hospital
00:12:07 and at one stage it looked very much in the balance. We tend to forget that. We tend to
00:12:13 think, oh, he's had COVID, but he had it phenomenally badly. And I think that did affect him. Maybe
00:12:20 it has affected subsequent decisions, but I doubt it. I think it's just weakened him further
00:12:25 combined with a brand new baby and a wife who was demanding that he... and a fiance who was
00:12:31 demanding that he that he changed the nappies and he had an awful lot all together and a strong
00:12:40 person a churchill would have just gone through that and would have said right what's important
00:12:45 yeah i think one of the most important things to say about boris and lockdown is the option was
00:12:50 never just let it rip you know this is the nation that came through the blitz we didn't say just let
00:12:56 bombs drop we had air raid warnings we had air raid shelters we had blackout lines and all would
00:13:02 you be fined if you saw an even chink of light we had a civilian force to watch the fires
00:13:09 we did all that we could we took all the precautions that we could but we didn't give in
00:13:15 and that has been very much the line that other countries like sweden have taken for example they
00:13:20 didn't just say let it rip they've taken a lot of precautions but they didn't actually give in
00:13:26 crash the economy and stop everything in its tracks because that doesn't work it just starts
00:13:33 again and we cannot go on just stop starting stop starting now my view and i said this in march so
00:13:41 i cannot be accused of hindsight my view clearly expressed in my daily express column very good one
00:13:47 by the way every wednesday my view is expressed then was look 90 it's now 95 but then we thought
00:13:55 90 90 of all those who've died were either in advanced old age or they already had underlying
00:14:03 health conditions in other words they were weakened in one way or the other so my line
00:14:08 always was they're the people we've got to protect lock them down tell everybody else it's their
00:14:13 duty to keep the economy going and then for heaven's sake concentrate on how we support those
00:14:19 people because you can't just lock them down and forget them how we make it possible for some
00:14:23 socialization how we make it possible for family contact we didn't ask those questions because we
00:14:29 were too busy taking a blanket approach yes do you do you also uh feel strongly about loss of
00:14:37 civil liberties uh are you one of the people that actually is looking at this in is appalled at the
00:14:43 way in which freedoms have been curtailed i don't think that is the end game i mean i i absolutely
00:14:51 reject that if you like the conspiracy theory that really you know this is a totalitarian
00:14:55 government and they're just softening us up don't agree with that at all there has been a massive
00:15:00 loss of civil liberty there always is when there's a crisis of some sort government's got to say
00:15:05 you must do this as long as it doesn't change his mind every five minutes uh and i will accept that
00:15:10 as long as it's very temporary but as i say i don't think on purely practical grounds that we
00:15:17 needed to lose civil liberty to the extent that we have and that's what i focus on uh if i thought
00:15:25 that lockdown was going to be highly effective and was the ultimate answer i wouldn't be too
00:15:30 worried about civil liberties but i don't and therefore we shouldn't be losing those liberties
00:15:36 and when you're actually telling families you know they've got to kneel down on the pavement
00:15:41 to peer through railings to see their loved ones in care homes we have gone completely bonkers
00:15:47 and we mustn't get into the habit of accepting that from government but as i say we wouldn't
00:15:53 have had to lose those liberties in the first place if we'd had a more sensible approach
00:15:58 will you get involved in uh the new what is it were the reformed brexit party i called reform i
00:16:05 mean will you therefore be involved i mean in that well the two big objectives of that party
00:16:11 at the moment to get a proper Brexit deal and to oppose a universal lockdown. And I support
00:16:19 both those aims, as you know, would argue very strongly. And therefore, yes, at the moment,
00:16:23 I am certainly supporting that new party. However, when Brexit is done one way or the other,
00:16:31 and when the vaccines have been implemented and lockdown is no longer an immediate problem,
00:16:40 that time will come. If that party then concentrates on electoral reform,
00:16:48 now, I believe in reducing the size of the House of Lords to half, actually. I believe in
00:16:52 strongly reducing the size of the House of Commons. I would probably cut it by a third.
00:16:58 But if there is any suggestion that I would ever sign up to a party which believed in abolishing
00:17:07 first past the post, then I cannot do that. I believe most electoral systems are bad,
00:17:13 but that that is the best of a very bad bunch. Perpetual coalitions mean you don't get any
00:17:19 direction. You don't get any direction. And we don't need to be in that sort of stymied situation
00:17:26 as we were throughout Theresa May's latter period, and as we have been in the past before.
00:17:36 So I couldn't sign up to abolishing first-past-the-post.
00:17:41 But the other aims that they have, I'm with.
00:17:45 And as I say for the moment, it's about Brexit and lockdown,
00:17:48 and they're the only people who are actually enunciating what I believe.
00:17:53 What does this mean?
00:17:55 I mean, obviously, I'm with you on that, on the lockdown bit, absolutely.
00:17:59 We're hearing at the moment about Christmas,
00:18:01 And actually, the language in which it's discussed is that we are being allowed Christmas, maybe.
00:18:08 Or, you know, there's going to be an exchange. You go into lockdown in January and all of this stuff.
00:18:13 What will you be doing at Christmas? I mean, will you sort of be abiding by the rules insofar as we even know what they are?
00:18:22 Well, that's a very good qualification if we do know what they are and if they're clear.
00:18:28 The answer is I shall do what I have done throughout this, right back from March. And I
00:18:33 have applied common sense, proportionality and humanity. And I have said throughout, I will do
00:18:41 what I believe meets those criteria. So, for example, when I had been locked down for 14 days
00:18:48 and hadn't seen a soul, other people who'd been locked down for 14 days and hadn't seen a soul,
00:18:54 and therefore neither of us could give it to each other i was perfectly prepared to
00:18:57 get together with those people and i did they said don't drive you know only walk on exercise
00:19:04 i use the common sense up here if i drive i encounter nobody yes if i walk i pass people
00:19:10 all the time it is insane so i have applied my own sense of proportionality and i should
00:19:17 be doing that at christmas and actually i think this is one that boris has got to accept the
00:19:21 The British people won't be told what to do at Christmas, or at least most of them won't.
00:19:24 Only the very timid will. And people will get together.
00:19:28 I mean, you've had people like Belle Mooney saying it's 14 at her Christmas table.
00:19:32 People will get together. And again, I use common sense.
00:19:37 My family, if they meet en masse, and it doesn't always happen because they're all going to their own in-laws and all the rest of it.
00:19:44 But if my family meets en masse, there are up to 12 of us.
00:19:48 but hang on you know those 12 who would be getting together have already got together
00:19:56 in mixed in other mixes yes so that um my nephew's family for example will have already had my
00:20:04 sister-in-law around for christmas so if they and she come to me we've already mixed yes so again
00:20:11 i apply proportionality common sense and that is what i would urge i wouldn't urge people to say
00:20:17 let it rip it doesn't matter you know nothing's happening it is happening but say i will apply
00:20:24 common sense what is uh the main criterion that i don't give it to anybody else and that as far
00:20:31 as possible i don't get it from anybody else where are the risks and that's the question people have
00:20:37 got to answer and it isn't in meeting your family we've already all met each other anyway and you
00:20:41 happen to exceed the magic number and i would have thought as well you're you're a person of
00:20:47 considerable faith aren't you um i would have thought that at christmas time well not that you
00:20:53 don't throughout the year but that's the time when a lot of people go to church or they go to service
00:20:58 or something um have you been uh disappointed in the general reaction of the church throughout
00:21:06 this whole period because you know we've had people on this channel who've been appalled
00:21:11 actually the way in which the church has more or less rolled over would you would you agree
00:21:16 without this isn't this a time where people really need spiritual comfort I think the churches did
00:21:22 roll over in the first lockdown no doubt about that at all they rolled over this time in the
00:21:27 second lockdown they've tiffened a different line and there's a very good reason for that it's that
00:21:32 in between the lockdowns they all worked out their systems to make sure that you had social
00:21:36 distancing i mean i'm in a little country church uh we have to sit with a pew's width between us
00:21:42 um there's then an empty pew in front of us and then the backs of the people at a pew's width
00:21:48 ahead of that you couldn't if you tried give anybody covid we're all in masks anyway
00:21:53 they've worked out a circular route to the communion so that you don't pass each other
00:21:58 and therefore they have and this is where common sense and proportionality comes in
00:22:04 They have met the criteria for trying to prevent the transmission of COVID.
00:22:09 That is proper social distancing. They've met it. They've done it. We can do it.
00:22:14 And most churches have managed that. And therefore, in the second lockdown, first of all,
00:22:18 the Catholic bishops complained bitterly to the government, formal protest, and said it's
00:22:22 unnecessary. Then the Anglicans did exactly the same. Government hasn't listened, of course,
00:22:29 hasn't listened at all, hasn't even had the courtesy to listen.
00:22:33 Now, I think Christmas services should go ahead.
00:22:37 And I, you know, they should just go ahead.
00:22:40 What are the police going to do?
00:22:42 Go into every church and arrest all the priests on Christmas.
00:22:46 Nonsense.
00:22:47 Well, no, maybe nonsense, but I'm afraid it's becoming more and more feasible,
00:22:51 the idea of that.
00:22:53 Has it been different?
00:22:54 I mean, you're a member of the Catholic Church.
00:22:56 Has it been different between the Catholic Church and the Church of England?
00:23:00 It seems to me that the most supine has actually been the Church of England.
00:23:04 Well, it always is, of course. Church of England is always pretty supine.
00:23:08 The Catholic Church, by its very nature, isn't, because it has a strong belief in, you know, this is right and that's it.
00:23:16 As I say, during the first lockdown, there was a great spirit of cooperation.
00:23:20 But I mean, I live streamed the mass from Westminster Cathedral.
00:23:24 great big cavernous westminster cathedral you could easily have had a socially distanced
00:23:30 um congregation in there easily easy peasy uh and yet it wasn't done uh and uh i think that
00:23:39 um the churches need to get a bit more in the right sense of the word militant not the wrong
00:23:45 but in the right sense of the word we need the church militant back again uh and i mean at least
00:23:51 as a Catholic, I did get Westminster
00:23:53 Cathedral. The Anglicans
00:23:55 had to put up with Justin Welby in his kitchen.
00:23:57 Yes.
00:23:59 Speaking of churches and
00:24:00 wokeness and
00:24:03 the rest of it, you recently wrote in your
00:24:04 column in the Daily Express, very good column, out
00:24:07 on Wednesdays, as you just said.
00:24:08 You recently wrote
00:24:11 about free speech.
00:24:13 Now, in amongst
00:24:15 COVID, something that has really
00:24:17 preoccupied us here on this
00:24:19 channel is these extraordinary
00:24:21 cultural issues going on at the same time right very big I would say the most important ones
00:24:26 you were talking in the column about the attacks on free speech in particular
00:24:30 coming from the law commission can you explain a bit about that because a lot of people won't
00:24:37 be familiar with what that was about but this is really very worrying is it not oh it's hugely
00:24:42 worrying and what is more worrying is that Boris didn't just say no at the outset and so we're not
00:24:48 doing that. The proposal, in essence, is that the hate laws, that's laws which prevent homophobia
00:24:57 and racism and sexism, that those laws, hate speech laws, should be applied to conversations
00:25:07 in our own homes. That is the serious proposal. Now, an Englishman's home is his castle,
00:25:15 and the one place we have been free to say anything we like has been
00:25:19 but in future if this proposal were to get through parliament and god forbid that it should
00:25:27 in the future we would actually be answerable to the state for what we say in our own homes now
00:25:35 that is where the word totalitarian is not misapplied yes exactly because the only
00:25:41 The only type of state that ever seeks to control what an individual says and does in his own home, as long as it's not breaking some other law, like conspiring for an act of terrorism or something.
00:25:53 The only states that have ever tried to impose that sort of uniformity are the Soviet Union and the Nazis, totalitarians.
00:26:02 Yes, it is extraordinary, as you say, that this has come from a respected body, the Law Commission.
00:26:08 And as you say, Boris has not actually even dismissed it out of hand.
00:26:14 This general attack on free speech, this general cult of woke, you know, it has seemingly intensified over this whole period of COVID.
00:26:28 Do you take this as seriously as I do?
00:26:32 And I mean, you know, it seems to have captured virtually all of our institutions.
00:26:36 yes i take it very seriously i'd expected the opposite to happen if i'd been making
00:26:42 predictions back in march why was that why well i would have said right we're now faced with a
00:26:47 real crisis um it's probably the biggest crisis since the blitz uh and um people will have no
00:26:55 patience at all with the whingers uh who are worried about sort of um statues and things like
00:27:01 that um they'll have no um time for that because they will say look you know we're talking about
00:27:08 life itself we're talking about our quality of life we're talking about our way of life
00:27:13 we're talking about our elderly um vulnerable uh that's what we're talking about we're talking
00:27:19 about sick children uh this is serious so go away stop talking about statues you know it doesn't
00:27:24 matter that's what i expected to happen the exact opposite has happened now partly that was because
00:27:30 of george floyd um but the exact opposite has happened and it seems that the woke agenda is
00:27:37 more prevalent than ever and the you know there is an answer to it which is that authority
00:27:43 has just got to get used to standing up against it but how do they do that how do they do that
00:27:52 look when you know pa oxford students say you've got to take down rhodes's statue
00:27:57 their response should be get a life yeah yeah get a life we've even today i read in the press
00:28:04 there's even a movement amongst the students at leicester uh to try and tear down uh the statue
00:28:11 of simon de montfort now arguably he's the father of english democracy the father of english
00:28:17 democracy but because in the 13th century um he uh you know was in favor certainly didn't stand
00:28:26 against slavery and held other views um and particularly in his case because he was anti-semitic
00:28:34 in the 13th century now yeah we've got to get a sense of perspective here when you look at say
00:28:44 edward colston's time they still had hanging drawing and quartering and he was supposed to
00:28:50 have developed an individual empathy that made him anti-slavery of course he wouldn't wasn't
00:28:55 the culture of the time and the idea that in the 13th century people uh particularly at a time
00:29:04 uh when there had been the uh the crusades and and where you did have tension uh between uh
00:29:11 christians and jews regrettable though that was you can't say i expect him to have taken a 21st
00:29:20 century um perspective because he wouldn't have had it he couldn't have had it uh you know i mean
00:29:26 for heaven's sake you think of the punishments that were inflicted on people in the 13th century
00:29:30 the barbarity of the military campaigns in the 13th century you're talking about a completely
00:29:38 different social time but the thing the thing is now it's extraordinary that we're even having to
00:29:44 say this isn't it i mean you know something that would strike most people as being complete common
00:29:48 sense of course it's it's extraordinary that we're even having to say this i mean
00:29:54 do you think i do that really this is not just about slavery actually slavery has been a way in
00:30:00 it's it's actually an attack really on british history and brit britain's sense of itself
00:30:07 oh of course it is i mean of course it is because i mean anti-slavery if you like is just the
00:30:13 the conduit. The anti-Semitism of Simon de Montfort is the conduit. It's not the root
00:30:19 problem. And that is why I say authority from government to universities to local councils
00:30:26 to the police, whoever it is, people who are in positions of authority should actually
00:30:32 say, get a life, not bow down to it. Now, when you see the police standing there watching
00:30:37 statues being torn down want an acts of vandalism doing nothing about it then you do start to wonder
00:30:46 so i think it isn't just the woke agenda you know they've got freedom of speech which i would
00:30:52 defend let them say all those things let them contest all those things not against them saying
00:30:57 it at all but why on earth everybody else is expected to bow down to it um the council culture
00:31:05 is rampant i mean people are afraid for their jobs they're afraid for their livelihoods if
00:31:10 they stand against this woke agenda but of course if enough of them did um you know there would be
00:31:16 nothing the woke people could do because uh if everybody in entertainment is saying well sorry
00:31:22 just not going along with that there's nothing they can do so i i i feel very strongly that this
00:31:28 isn't just about what is being done it's back resistance but wouldn't it be good as well to
00:31:33 hear a bit from the government i mean this is a conservative government uh you know boris finally
00:31:38 said something about statues didn't he uh after quite a long period yeah but it would be nice
00:31:43 would it not to actually hear the sort of words that we've heard from macron for example about this
00:31:50 i i mean i think it would be a very big start if boris said tomorrow morning we are not going to
00:31:57 implement that proposal of the law commission yeah i know um you certainly have free speech
00:32:03 uh you can think what you like uh you can say within certain limits because you certainly
00:32:08 should never be allowed to stir up uh hatred or violence i mean i think we'd all agree that's wrong
00:32:13 uh but within certain limits uh you can say what you like and when you're at home
00:32:18 and nobody can hear what you say um then it doesn't matter because that is the way
00:32:23 you develop thoughts. I mean, I have a mental scenario of you have a dinner party of friends,
00:32:30 they all know you, they know what you think anyway. But one of them brings along an unexpected guest
00:32:35 to the party. And that guest takes offense at ideas which are put forward. Now, that is an
00:32:45 absolute lunacy. We already have laws saying you can't engage in criminal conspiracy at home any
00:32:52 more than you can anywhere else that's fine i think we'd all agree with that you can't engage
00:32:56 in criminal conspiracy beyond that you should be free to speak the crucial thing is surely as well
00:33:03 that with the hate speech which i know a fair amount about being in the london assembly because
00:33:07 uh you know it's a big issue there is that it requires no evidence this is extraordinary isn't
00:33:14 it it requires it is entirely based on the person who decides that something is hate speech and it
00:33:20 doesn't even have to be the supposed victim it can actually be anybody else this is quite
00:33:25 extraordinary is it not it is and as i observed in my express column very good column every wednesday
00:33:31 um in every other part of the law intention plays a massive part i mean if you accidentally kill
00:33:38 somebody you're not going to be charged with murder because everybody accepts you didn't intend to do
00:33:42 it uh if i pick up somebody else's handbag and mistake for my own even if i get all the way
00:33:47 home before i've realized nobody's going to prosecute me for theft because they understand
00:33:52 that was a mistake um but you don't have to show intention when it comes to the laws on hate speech
00:33:59 it is enough for somebody else and as you rightly say it doesn't even have to be the victim and
00:34:04 inverted commas it is enough for somebody else to say that is hate speech for it to be assumed to be
00:34:10 yes we need actually to uh to get some really good libertarian law into this country as i say
00:34:18 i don't want to silence anybody uh who's on the work side of this what i do want is for them to
00:34:24 respect the fact that i won't be silenced either speaking of which i mean have you actually you
00:34:30 haven't you're not on twitter are you and you don't do twitter no no absolutely not but you
00:34:34 haven't been cancelled have you ever been no platformed i certainly have um there was a terrific
00:34:44 to do in may 2019 when i was interviewed on the sophie ridge program on sky and right at the end
00:34:51 of it they threw back at me an article that i'd written in 2012 uh which was about um whether or
00:35:00 not uh people who are gay uh could in the future possibly transition uh to not being so and all i
00:35:08 said on that program was and i never talked about gay cures and never said anything like that
00:35:13 uh what i said was once we thought that if you were a man or a woman that was it final end of
00:35:18 story uh then uh science made it possible for people to transition between the two and we've
00:35:24 never stop them doing that. And I just said maybe some stage in the future science will
00:35:30 find it possible to enable a gay person to transition. Transition will not be cured.
00:35:37 Cue uproar. I was then on a theatre tour all over the country and some of those theatres cancelled
00:35:46 on the basis of the uproar. There were a few. The Lowther Pavilion, for example, up in Blackpool,
00:35:52 went ahead uh and as a result had a huge attendance because people came in from
00:35:58 neighboring theaters which had actually cancelled uh but yeah i was cancelled not even for something
00:36:05 i said but for an interpretation that was put on what i had said um but i just carry on now
00:36:14 of course i can carry on i'm semi-retired anyway i've got my column in the daily express
00:36:20 um i wasn't going to be pushed into poverty if i couldn't perform in theaters and of course
00:36:26 they got over it and eventually i was performing again um but there are people you know who can
00:36:32 lose their jobs who can lose their livelihoods because they have said something sometimes
00:36:37 something as simple as god bless to a patient who then takes offense can actually lose livelihoods
00:36:44 can lose livelihoods now this is completely wrong and it is giving too much power to one
00:36:52 side of the argument i don't want the power to cancel anybody however profoundly i may disagree
00:36:59 with them i don't want that sort of power you mentioned there that you're semi uh semi-retired
00:37:06 and uh you don't seem semi-retired i have to say uh but what actually motivates you to keep going
00:37:14 I mean, you know, you're pretty much always there.
00:37:17 I mean, if you if you do end up being part of the new Reform Party, say, presumably you might, you know, stand for something there.
00:37:26 I don't think I shall stand for Parliament again, if that that was what was behind your question.
00:37:30 Yeah. I didn't really want to stand for Parliament last time at all.
00:37:35 But what happened was that I, who was, I thought, retired from politics at any rate.
00:37:41 you know, I'd been doing the reality shows, the TV quiz programs, you know, I was going around the
00:37:45 country doing funny speeches and theatre evenings and things. And I thought I'd retired from the
00:37:50 serious life, if you like, other than my Express column. But then I became so outraged about the
00:37:58 efforts to thwart Brexit and about the mess that Theresa May was making of it, about the complete
00:38:08 um unbelievable um stand of jeremy corbyn on on a large range of issues and i said at the time i
00:38:18 said we've got the worst prime minister since anthony eden we've got the worst leader of the
00:38:23 opposition in the entire history of the labor party we've got the worst parliament since oliver
00:38:29 cromwell and with that combination we were engaging in the most important international
00:38:34 negotiations for 50 years so i got more and more outraged and eventually i decided um i would act
00:38:42 upon the outrage rather than uh just yelling from the sidelines so i to my utter amazement
00:38:48 i could never have predicted it even a few weeks before it happened i joined the brexit party and
00:38:53 i stood for the european parliament with a specific aim of achieving brexit i certainly
00:38:59 never wanted to return to Westminster but we had to put up a campaign and there was no chance of
00:39:08 winning once Nigel had decided that we weren't going to contest all the Tory seats we obviously
00:39:12 couldn't form a government there was no chance that we would win but nevertheless it was important
00:39:17 just to to do the message if you like to put the message out so but I don't think that situation
00:39:24 is going to arise again that was a very specific situation uh so i don't see myself um standing for
00:39:31 parliament um but i will certainly campaign um for things that i believe in brexit was one
00:39:39 anti-lockdown is another i will campaign for those things well look and i'm sure you know
00:39:45 you're not going to drop from our screens anytime soon uh but uh i'm going to say thank you very
00:39:51 much giving us a lot of time this morning um and um well if i don't speak to you which i'm sure
00:39:58 i won't uh between now and then very happy christmas to you for when it comes um thanks
00:40:05 very much indeed anne and um hope to see you on the show maybe uh in the new year thank you thank
00:40:10 you very much that's it that's it for to for today on so what you're saying is uh we'll be back next
00:40:17 week. In the meantime, please remember, do subscribe, won't you? Thanks very much.