New Culture Forum - May 17, 2021


Ann Widdecombe: We're Fed Up With Woke Minority Bullies + Labour's Lost Touch With Reality

Great American Race Game - New Documentary By UK Filmmaker Martin Durkin Alex Kaschuta - Why The West Isn't Having Children

Episode Stats


Length

28 minutes

Words per minute

159.98

Word count

4,567

Sentence count

134

Harmful content

Hate speech

2

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now my guest today last appeared
00:00:27 on the programme last year, hugely popular, as indeed she should be. Anne Widdecombe is a fixture
00:00:34 in our public life. She was also, of course, Shadow Home Secretary for the Conservative Party
00:00:39 and more recently Brexit Party MEP in the European Parliament. Good morning to you, Anne.
00:00:48 Morning. Good to see you. Let's go in at the deep end. We recently had the local elections
00:00:55 and the mayoralty elections and a by-election so-called super thursday um there's been a hell
00:01:02 of a lot of comment about this in the press do you think this is the end for the labour party
00:01:08 i doubt it very much i can remember in uh 1992 when we had won an unprecedented fourth term
00:01:18 and uh everybody had been expecting us to lose they'd been expecting labour to win
00:01:24 we had a boundaries review coming up. And the conversation in the House of Commons at the time
00:01:30 was, well, it's difficult to see how Labour can ever win again, because if they couldn't
00:01:34 win in those circumstances, when can they win? And the boundaries review will be in favour of
00:01:40 the Conservatives. And so that's probably the end for Labour. Well, as we all know,
00:01:46 five years later, Blair came in with a record landslide and stayed there for another 13 years,
00:01:52 or Labour stayed there for another 13 years. So I'm very cautious about saying of any
00:01:58 political situation prevailing today, this is it, and this is going to prevail forever more.
00:02:05 However, if you're asking me, is there the possibility that this is the end for Labour,
00:02:14 then I would say, I will say that when you tell me what you are going to put in its place,
00:02:19 we're not going to have a one party state so what are we going to have as the official opposition
00:02:27 i think the bigger question is what is the future role for labor i mean at the moment it's resolved
00:02:34 itself into a sort of a woke role if you like it speaks for a metropolitan elite it speaks for
00:02:41 remain. It's miles, miles away in understanding from its own heartlands. And this was really
00:02:51 exemplified in Hartlepool. Hartlepool was the seat that voted 70%, I mean 70% huge, to leave
00:03:00 in the 2016 referendum. And then in the 2019 general election, Hartlepool actually gave the
00:03:09 the Brexit Party candidate more than 10,000 votes. And if you added those on to the Conservative
00:03:14 vote, it comfortably exceeded the Labour vote. So you would have expected Labour to say, right,
00:03:19 what do we have to do to address the concerns of this seat? Instead of which, they put in a
00:03:25 Remain candidate and a really, you know, very, very strongly Remain candidate, not somebody who
00:03:32 just sort of been vaguely either way, somebody who supported a second referendum, they put in
00:03:37 remain candidate. Now that is as good as saying, we don't care what you think, we know better.
00:03:42 We are the elite. You don't know your place. That is Labour's problem. The role of representing the
00:03:51 working man, as was vitally necessary at the turn of the last century, had by the turn of this
00:04:00 century pretty well disappeared, had become redundant because there is now a general acceptance
00:04:10 about welfare and benefits and looking after people and jobs. There is now a general consensus
00:04:17 across the parties. Labour lost its unique position. Now it's got to find another unique
00:04:23 position. But if you ask me if it's the end, then my answer would be, do you really think
00:04:29 will become a one-party state and i don't i think and also uh around about uh the turn of the century
00:04:38 people were actually writing off the tory party as being in you know in an impossible position i
00:04:44 remember there was a book came out which was called the strange death of tory england by
00:04:49 jeffrey reetcroft uh it was very much you know this was it this was the new country under blair
00:04:56 So, and in fact, then what happened is the Tory party came back admittedly under a coalition to begin with.
00:05:02 What what do you make of Keir Starmer? What's your personal opinion of Keir Starmer?
00:05:07 I think he is not going to be an effective leader for Labour.
00:05:11 It's very difficult to know what he does stand for.
00:05:14 And let me say right at the outset, I do understand why at the beginning of the Covid crisis,
00:05:22 he more or less had just accepted everything that Boris was saying.
00:05:25 I understand that because if you have a war or you have some big international catastrophe,
00:05:31 then traditionally the parties do stand together in the national interest. But as time went on,
00:05:37 it became obvious Boris was making mistakes. Boris was flip-flopping between policies. Boris
00:05:44 was fludging. Boris was flailing. And yet Keir Starmer never used that to press home the questions
00:05:53 which the nation was asking.
00:05:56 So there we were, all the nation wanting to know
00:05:58 why we can't come out of lockdown earlier
00:06:01 because of the success of the vaccines.
00:06:05 And what does Keir Starmer use Prime Minister's question for?
00:06:10 Talk about wallpaper.
00:06:12 I mean, wallpaper.
00:06:14 As if they gave tuppence for the wallpaper in Hartlepool.
00:06:19 They're completely disconnected.
00:06:21 It's Westminster Village stuff.
00:06:23 Westminster navel-gazing, and Keir Starmer just cannot connect with what his own people want.
00:06:31 Yes. What do you think as well, something that seemed to really make people angry,
00:06:38 was when he took the knee, you know, during the Black Knives Matter protest.
00:06:44 And also for that matter, we have this sort of thing whereby a frontbench spokesman for Labour
00:06:49 was talking about the fact that when babies are born, they don't have a sex.
00:06:54 Things like this.
00:06:55 I mean, surely this this kind of thing is what turns people off entirely.
00:07:01 That is absolutely true.
00:07:04 And in fact, the Conservative Party was infected with this not so very long ago.
00:07:09 And I think Boris has at least managed to turn the emphasis away from that.
00:07:14 But it's quite true that what Labour do is that they adopt every fashionable cause that is going and focus on that.
00:07:25 And they don't understand that out there where people are worried about jobs and keeping their houses and their mortgages, where that's what people are worried about.
00:07:35 They don't understand, they don't give toughens for this talk about, well, you're not born in any particular sex, you know, which to most people is arant nonsense.
00:07:45 Vining is an arant nonsense.
00:07:47 In fact, yes, it is nonsense.
00:07:48 But what do you think of the view that this vote was not just about the vaccination?
00:07:58 It wasn't just about, well, the residuals of Brexit even,
00:08:01 but that in fact it was also a vote against what people hear on a daily basis,
00:08:09 the woke agenda, what's happening in our schools, what's happening in our universities,
00:08:14 that this is what actually they're also protesting about.
00:08:16 Yes, I mean, I think that is undeniably true. I think that Tabor has lost all contact with the realities that most people are facing. And I think people are concerned about free speech, for example. They're concerned about the stories they read in the newspaper, JK Rowling, for example, BNT platform, or people trying to say she shouldn't be allowed to publish a fairy tale because she said something about transgenderism.
00:08:46 and no connection between the two I think people are fed up with being bossed about by the woke
00:08:53 minority and it is a minority and that is something which I think neither major political
00:08:59 party has understood yes actually and that takes me on to a an important point you say both parties
00:09:07 haven't kind of realized this this this is an extraordinarily important thing what should the
00:09:12 So what would you like to see the government doing or the Conservative Party doing to counter this agenda?
00:09:22 When we last spoke, we were talking about the hate crime bill going through Scotland and you were very clear about that, about not being able to talk about what you want in your own home.
00:09:35 What would you like to see them do to actually counter this apparent, insistent agenda which seems to book no opposition?
00:09:47 Well, they've taken a sort of half step, if you like, in the Queen's speech,
00:09:53 where they're going to actually come down quite hard on universities which deplatform and discriminate against people on the basis of their views.
00:10:00 But why on earth just the universities?
00:10:04 Now, I know that's where it can be at its worst and that it's very dangerous if young people get
00:10:09 into that habit. I do understand that. But nevertheless, this is something that affects
00:10:15 everybody. People can't get gigs if they say the wrong thing. Their theatre tours, and don't I know
00:10:22 it, are cancelled if they say the wrong thing. And so we need this to stretch well beyond the
00:10:29 universities there has to be a free speech guaranteed by law which once i would never
00:10:35 have thought we would have had to say in this country now we do we need to guarantee free
00:10:40 speech by law and that must be backed up with penalties which will really bite and make people
00:10:45 think twice have you been cancelled or de-platformed down yes i have um only once on any scale
00:10:54 but it was shortly after the elections for the European Parliament in 2019 and I was interviewed
00:11:04 on Sky and I was asked in the course of that interview about my views on gay rights and
00:11:14 specifically, very specifically, about whether people should transition sexuality and I said,
00:11:21 you know well it can't be done at the moment but we once thought that you couldn't um change a man
00:11:27 into a woman or a woman into a man so presumably you know at some stage science might be able to
00:11:32 that was all i said i didn't pass a value judgment on whether it would be a good thing or a bad thing
00:11:38 i certainly never used the word cure i wouldn't have drunk of it uh and uh but it was reported
00:11:44 in inflated terms i mean really inflated terms and i suddenly started losing i was doing a theater
00:11:51 tour. I suddenly started finding my theatre appearances cancelled, because people had
00:11:57 protested that I should be invited. Now, what was I talking about on those tours? Strictly
00:12:02 Come Dancing. I wasn't talking about that issue. And if I hadn't been asked about it
00:12:11 in the interview, I would never have raised it, wouldn't have dreamt of raising it. And
00:12:15 I didn't say the things that people believe I said, even though it's there on the record,
00:12:21 they can check for themselves. And in fact, I was doing an interview some months afterwards
00:12:27 with Ian Dale, who is of course openly gay. And he and I are friends. And I said to him
00:12:33 on air, I said, Ian, if I thought one quarter of what people say, I think, would you want
00:12:40 to know me and he said no uh and you know but i couldn't help the exaggeration that was not
00:12:48 within my uh control uh but i had to pay the penalty now i think the law should have protected
00:12:55 not only me because i'm retired and these things you know they are not going to determine my
00:13:02 livelihood or my ability to pay a mortgage or to keep my family in food not going to do anything
00:13:09 like that but for hundreds of people that's exactly the impact it would have you mentioned
00:13:17 there about the various legislation or proposed legislation the government's bringing in about
00:13:24 universities but what about our schools and i am concerned by the level of quite blatant
00:13:32 indoctrination happening how on earth do you tackle that how would you tackle that
00:13:40 well the problem with what is going on in our schools is that it actually it is deleterious
00:13:45 to young minds uh young minds should be taught rigorously how to analyze and deduce and argue
00:13:53 with people who take a different view um without seeking to suppress different views that that is
00:14:00 what education should do it should train you to analyze reach your own conclusions whether they
00:14:06 are shared by the vast majority um or whether they are only shared by a tiny minority but reach your
00:14:11 own conclusions but defend other people's rights to reach their conclusions that is what education
00:14:19 should be about and but the thing is is that it appears that children are now sort of leaving
00:14:26 almost you know well they're being told what to think as opposed to how to think i i think this
00:14:34 is one because education is at the root of all of this is it not yes it's absolutely the root of it
00:14:40 um connected to that we have this leveling up agenda by the government this is the one that
00:14:48 the media likes because the media hates talking about cultural issues on the whole uh or rather
00:14:53 doesn't think they're important but they certainly do think economic ones are um would you say that
00:14:58 for example one way of leveling up would be to make sure that every town or every city had a
00:15:04 grammar school for example oh i think you must have been reading my express column which i wrote
00:15:10 on wednesday yes i think you did uh and as i said on wednesday um grammar schools provided a route
00:15:20 and possibly the only route that there was for the bright child in a deprived background
00:15:25 to get out of that rut and to get on. And I was very fortunate when I was a Member of Parliament
00:15:33 that I represented a seat which still had the 11 plus and grammar schools.
00:15:37 And when the Labour Party took power, they wanted to ballot areas which still had grammar schools
00:15:44 to ask if they wanted to keep them they couldn't even get enough signatures to trigger the ballot
00:15:51 because there was huge support for the grammar schools by parents whose children hadn't gone to
00:15:56 them but who wanted to feel that if they had made the grade they could have had that education
00:16:02 and i used to go into grammar schools be children from all sorts of backgrounds there
00:16:06 um the thing that united them was intelligence and they were being given an education that
00:16:12 reflected that and if you want to get on education is the first big step and so yes I as I said on
00:16:22 Wednesday I think we should have a grammar school in every single town but if Boris wants to get
00:16:29 started and he can't do it all in the lifetime of this parliament he wants to get started let's
00:16:34 start putting them in the northern towns yeah yeah there's got to be a will hasn't there this
00:16:40 is the point and there's there's got to be the will to do this this is where one gets frustrated
00:16:44 often it appears the will is will is very weak you know um staying on the elections a little bit
00:16:53 uh you know we've had this extraordinary uh success where do you think this leaves the
00:17:00 smaller parties um am i right you can tell me you you supported in london lawrence fox i believe
00:17:07 right? I did. Yeah. Well, there's Reform UK, there's Reclaim. It wasn't an impressive showing,
00:17:14 was it? No, and it never is for little parties. Little parties and the Brexit party was really
00:17:22 quite instructive as an exception to the norm, which is that little parties don't do well,
00:17:28 because what people are asking themselves in a general election, particularly, and this is why
00:17:33 Brexit party couldn't translate its success into the last general election. What people are asking
00:17:40 themselves is, who do we want to form the government? And if I vote for a little party,
00:17:48 maybe the wrong big party will get in. Maybe I should give my vote to the party I want to get in,
00:17:56 which is a perfectly reasonable way of approaching things. I met it on the doorstep. I was standing
00:18:00 as a brexit party candidate i met it a lot on the doorstep and however frustrated i was by it i
00:18:06 understood it fully fully understood it so little parties don't have much success but while we're
00:18:12 talking about little parties you know the other day i really had to stop and think for the space
00:18:17 of several seconds who was the leader of the liberal party because they've just they've just
00:18:25 one somewhere i don't know where uh and um so uh i i don't see a future for small parties
00:18:33 regrettably in many ways regrettably by the way i'm sorry by the way who is it actually
00:18:39 ed david oh right isn't it
00:18:45 um so uh as for reform
00:18:49 um i um was hugely admiring of all that the brexit party did which is why i left the conservatives
00:18:57 after 55 years and joined it and i still am hugely admiring uh of the way that nigel
00:19:05 never having served in parliament nevertheless managed to get this country out of the eu 0.54
00:19:10 uh and so i'm i'm hugely admiring of all of that but i think the reform party is going to struggle
00:19:17 What does it stand for? Well, it doesn't stand for Brexit anymore, because in most people's eyes, that's been achieved. I mean, you and I might have views on how it's been achieved, but it's been achieved. Anti-lockdown, well, lockdown's about to finish. So what is the Reform Party's agenda?
00:19:35 Well, it is at the moment electoral reform, you know, reform of the House of Lords and reform of the voting system. Joe Bloggs in Hartlepool isn't interested. And that, I think, is something that has to be faced up to.
00:19:51 Lawrence Fox
00:19:53 I couldn't vote for him in London
00:19:55 because I had no vote in London
00:19:56 but I would have done
00:19:57 had I had such a vote
00:19:58 Lawrence Fox is campaigning for free speech
00:20:01 now I think that will eventually strike a chord
00:20:04 but he's not going to form a government
00:20:06 you know
00:20:07 so we have to face up to the fact
00:20:10 that to get anything done
00:20:12 you have to persuade one of the big parties to do it
00:20:15 and that I think is what Lawrence must concentrate on doing
00:20:18 we must force this government
00:20:19 to go farther than it's uh signaled in the queen's speech and to protect free speech and as i say
00:20:26 i would never have thought that we would have had to say that in this country we were once
00:20:31 the very essence of free speech the bastion of free speech the country where you could say
00:20:35 anything you liked however much people disagreed with you i i would agree with you there and i
00:20:42 think that the role say like for lawrence and the reclaim party would be uh best almost like
00:20:48 you know the brexit party but for cultural issues such as free speech you know to act as a huge like
00:20:55 pressure on the government because i've i can't help but feel that they will get soft on this um
00:21:00 not that they've been that hard i have to say um we you know you you're not in london um but
00:21:08 do you think what do you think of the mayoralty sort of system we have at the moment a lot of
00:21:15 people you know you hear these views i've just finished um basically i've just finished a stint
00:21:20 on the london assembly i should just declare that but a lot of people are saying oh this system
00:21:26 doesn't work we should get rid of you know the london mayor we should get rid of the assembly
00:21:31 all of that a bit like thatcher did with the gglc would you agree with that or not i um am in two
00:21:39 minds about the system of elected mares i was very very enthusiastic both about elected mares
00:21:46 and about elected police and crime commissioners uh when it was first introduced because i was uh
00:21:54 greatly impressed by what Giuliani managed to do in New York, where he got crime down
00:22:01 to a fraction of what it had previously been, used to be the highest crime rate in the world
00:22:06 almost. And he got it right down. And it was by imposing the zero tolerance policy. And
00:22:13 the word there is impose. He had that sort of power. Our mayors and our police commissioners
00:22:22 do not have that sort of power and i think that is what has gone wrong so they're just another
00:22:31 layer of government you know you've got your county councils you've got your district councils
00:22:37 you've got your parish councils you've got your police and crime commissioners and you've got your
00:22:42 elected mayors and so on it goes and it's just another layer whereas if a mayor had real serious
00:22:49 giuliani style power i would be all in favor of it and then you could hold him to account because he
00:22:54 either could or couldn't deliver well speaking of layers of government uh to finish off and
00:23:00 this is obviously a another very big issue at the moment that's the future of the union
00:23:04 you know of the united kingdom of great britain northern ireland um yeah do you think there should
00:23:09 be an english parliament no i do not think there should be an english parliament if you want to
00:23:15 complete the breakup of the united kingdom just have an english parliament and that will do it
00:23:22 it is crucial that we have um i mean if you look at the vote on welsh devolution
00:23:29 you know only 25 voted for an assembly 75 either voted against or stayed at home didn't vote at all
00:23:37 uh and so um and in other words you feel strongly at all uh and i strongly believe in the united
00:23:44 Kingdom, and I don't want it fractured any further. And I think the union is in peril.
00:23:49 And oddly, I'm less worried about Scotland than I am about Northern Ireland.
00:23:54 Because what Boris has done is create a, and it is Boris, you know, this was his deal,
00:23:59 create a border down the Irish Sea. And effectively now, Northern Ireland is being treated as if it's
00:24:07 part of the EU instead of part of the UK. And you know, it's easy to see that in a few years time,
00:24:14 people might say, well, you know, if we're not part of the UK, why pretend a bit? Why pretend a bit?
00:24:19 So I am severely worried about Northern Ireland. I'm much less worried about Scotland, because I
00:24:25 think Scots are canny, actually. When it comes to it, you'll get exactly the same result as you got 0.82
00:24:31 last time. And people will say no, you know, they didn't, they don't want to leave. But also, there
00:24:37 is a principle at stake with the Scottish referendum, which is the one that we had to face
00:24:42 down over Brexit which is that abuse of referendums as far as I'm concerned whereby you go on having
00:24:49 them until you get the result you want and that we must not count on us you have a referendum
00:24:55 that's it it was said that would settle it for a generation it didn't go beyond a generation fine
00:25:01 that should now settle it for a generation we've had the referendum yeah but I think one of the
00:25:07 worrying trends generally in our democracy is the kind of delegitimization of votes isn't it
00:25:13 it there is this kind of we just simply don't accept and you know with the you obviously you
00:25:18 were at the forefront with the Brexit campaign after the referendum and as well where people
00:25:25 were talking about oh well this generation's now died and so you know in fact we've just reached
00:25:30 the tipping point I mean it was in fact extraordinarily cruel actually what the way
00:25:35 that people would talk yes I mean it was appalling the attitude of the
00:25:42 Remainers from the very moment that they lost the referendum was that somehow
00:25:46 this isn't valid either the majority wasn't big enough well no majority was
00:25:53 ever specified we didn't say you have to get a two-thirds or you have to get you
00:25:57 know 56% we didn't say anything like that so perfectly valid absolutely valid
00:26:01 then when they moaned about the the narrowness of the majority then it was a well patronizing
00:26:08 attitude again from the metropolitan elite oh well people didn't really know what they were
00:26:13 voting for that is why i said at rally after rally to enormous cheers up and down the country
00:26:18 we knew exactly what we were voting for and and then there was this attitude well you know let's
00:26:26 have another referendum just to confirm that referendum no no when the people speak the
00:26:32 politician's duty is to implement well i mean i have to say my feeling is that the hell frankly
00:26:40 that they put us through for those four awful years after the vote uh i don't think they should
00:26:47 ever be allowed to forget it you know you know revenge is a dish best served cold they say i
00:26:56 I mean, I have to say that, you know, when you think of all the claims that were made,
00:27:01 not one of them has come true, you know, of Project Fear.
00:27:06 And I think they shouldn't be allowed to forget that.
00:27:10 Do you think that's being vindictive of me?
00:27:12 Yes, I do.
00:27:14 I am a Christian.
00:27:16 I'm never going to talk about vengeance as a Christian.
00:27:18 But what I am going to say is this.
00:27:20 I actually think now, you know, we should take the line.
00:27:24 the battle has been won i mean i've got serious doubts about the irish border but the battle has
00:27:30 been won uh and therefore we must now move on and i think there is a gradual growth in the country
00:27:36 not amongst the fanatical remainers or now they're the rejoiners there never will be amongst them
00:27:42 but i think amongst the country as a whole largely due to the vaccine debacle that we saw in europe
00:27:47 um then they were going to close the irish border without even asking the t-shirt
00:27:51 then they were going to turn the lights off in jersey and the more they go on like that
00:27:56 i mean i cheer them more power to their elbow because the more it will convince people in
00:28:02 this country oh boy thank heaven we got out and on that note and uh we will talk to you again i
00:28:09 hope maybe in about six months time um thank you very very much um and um i always draw attention
00:28:16 i know but to this wonderful background of yours which is like a bit like the monarchy it's sort
00:28:21 of secure and continuous and it never changes thank you very much and thank you thank you um
00:28:28 that's it for this week on so what you're saying is um and we shall see you next time thanks