New Culture Forum - September 27, 2021


BBC's Shameless Double Standards In Coverage Of Trump Versus Biden - Sarah Elliott

WWW Ep2: Climate Extremists, Shemima Begum, Puberty Blockers & Police Free Speech Wokery British Police Have Transformed Into A Tool For Enforcing The State's Will -- Peter Hitchens

Episode Stats


Length

28 minutes

Words per minute

151.38

Word count

4,267

Sentence count

255

Harmful content

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Sarah, I think you told me on the phone that you were not a natural Trump supporter, but that when
00:00:11 he got elected, you sort of came round to him. Just tell me about your political journey in that
00:00:17 sense. Sure. I mean, Trump came on the scene as the non politician, the non Republican. I mean,
00:00:23 he was a New Yorker. He was from Queens. He had Hillary Clinton to his wedding. He had given to
00:00:29 Democrats and Republicans alike. And as a conservative and a constitutional conservative,
00:00:34 I was thinking, how is this guy ever going to deliver on anything I like? He doesn't live a
00:00:40 conservative life. I'm not sure I trust him on the social issues or, you know, yes, he's a
00:00:47 businessman, but he's, you know, he likes to spend. You know, I wasn't sure about him.
00:00:54 But you came round to him, did you?
00:00:56 I did. I didn't vote for him. I didn't vote for Hillary. I left it blank because my conscience in 2016 couldn't decide. But then he started to form his team around him after he got elected. And I must say that when he was elected, I think it was one of the most memorable and happiest times that Hillary Clinton lost.
00:01:16 And so I think I probably was a Trump voter, but didn't know it because I wanted Hillary
00:01:21 to lose so badly.
00:01:23 But he did form a conservative cabinet and brought some really interesting people in,
00:01:29 such as Larry Kudlow, who was Ronald Reagan's cabinet secretary for Office of Management
00:01:35 and Budget.
00:01:36 And with Larry Kudlow at the helm, I knew that the economic policies were going to be
00:01:40 fantastic.
00:01:41 And sure enough, supply-side economics dominated the Trump administration in the first term,
00:01:47 which started to turn my head.
00:01:50 And when the tax cuts happened, I was so chuffed, as the English say.
00:01:55 I knew that the economy would bounce back.
00:01:58 And then, I have to say, it was his judges to the Supreme Court, particularly his defense
00:02:04 of Brett Kavanaugh, who had completely unsubstantiated claims against him ruining his life and his
00:02:13 reputation, hard earned. And I like the fact that Donald Trump stood behind him and got
00:02:19 him on the court. You began to see, did you, let me put words into your mouth, but did it become
00:02:28 clear to you that in the culture war, the wider culture war, Trump was on the right side of things
00:02:33 as far as you were concerned. Yeah, I mean, he immediately came out of the gate as pro-life.
00:02:39 He attended the pro-life march the first time a sitting president in his first term has ever
00:02:46 attended. I mean, he was passing executive orders for freedom of speech, protection of freedom of
00:02:52 speech. I mean, yeah, I mean, he clearly was embracing the cultural right. And, you know,
00:03:00 I couldn't be happier, really. As a Republican over here in Britain,
00:03:08 during the Trump presidency, what was the commonest attitude you came across
00:03:18 amongst British people towards Trump? Was he popular? Did he seem popular to you or not?
00:03:23 I mean, I think it depended on who I was speaking to and where I was geographically.
00:03:30 Because if I left the M25, people tend to give them more the benefit of the doubt and
00:03:35 say, you know what?
00:03:36 No, that Mr. Trump, he's good for America.
00:03:38 I can see what he's doing.
00:03:40 He cares about America.
00:03:42 But then if I, you know, talk to the metropolitan elites of London or what have you, it says, 0.99
00:03:48 oh, that ghastly man, that ghastly orange man, 1.00
00:03:51 and took us out of Paris Climate Accords, 1.00
00:03:53 and, you know, oh, what is he saying about NATO now?
00:03:58 And I'd kind of like to remind them
00:03:59 that he actually increased the NATO war chest
00:04:02 quite significantly by, you know, promises up to 400 million.
00:04:07 So, oh, sorry, billions, actually.
00:04:12 400 billion.
00:04:15 So, you know, it really depended on where I was,
00:04:17 but I think people could see that America was doing well under Trump, even if they didn't like
00:04:22 the man. They heard about the economy and the unemployment. They saw the peace deals happening
00:04:29 around the world, engaging North Korea, coming twice to the United Kingdom. I mean, more than
00:04:36 any other country. I mean, he was an Anglophile, the most Anglophile president we've had in decades,
00:04:43 probably since Reagan. So, I think people didn't want to give him the benefit of the doubt or give
00:04:50 him a nod because it was socially unacceptable, but they could tell things were doing well.
00:04:55 What about the BBC? What attitude do you think they took towards Trump?
00:05:00 A long exhale, a long sigh. They didn't want to deal with him. They didn't want to have to
00:05:06 cover him. They were disgusted. I did many interviews at the BBC and where the producers
00:05:11 and the TV crew would just roll their eyes when they watched the tape or would just go,
00:05:18 oh, gosh. I think there was an overall disdain for him.
00:05:25 And that started, did it, as soon as he was elected? Was that the sort of view from the
00:05:34 outset, would you say? I mean, yeah, they took their cues from the mainstream media in America,
00:05:40 you know, which was not positive. I mean, straight out of the gate, Trump was, you know,
00:05:47 going to be impeached. That's what everybody was saying and that the Russians actually stole the
00:05:52 election and who repeated those lines like a parrot, but the BBC. I mean, the BBC didn't seem
00:05:58 to be doing any sort of independent journalism. They were taking their talking points from the
00:06:03 Washington Post, The New York Times, ABC, NBC, CBS, CNN. I mean, they were just getting talking
00:06:14 points. And I don't think they were getting at the root of why people voted for Donald Trump.
00:06:21 You know, did they go to Wisconsin and really find out why did this state turn red for the
00:06:28 first time in 30 years. Two stories which figured large in
00:06:34 the immediate aftermath of his election in 2016 and running into
00:06:38 2017. One was the so called Muslim travel ban. The other was
00:06:42 the immigration issues on the southern border. They figured
00:06:47 quite large in the BBC's coverage, didn't they? I wonder
00:06:50 if you could just contrast that with now, how Biden is now the
00:06:57 Biden administration is struggling with the same issues. But there's a difference, isn't there?
00:07:02 Yeah, I mean, of course, they wanted Trump to be a racist, because that, you know, that's the
00:07:07 worst thing you can be. And they wanted to put that on, on him, and characterize him as a monster.
00:07:15 So of course, he would, he'd hate Muslims. You know, at the time, it was a security issue.
00:07:23 So whenever we have a security issue, you know, is it always going to be put through the lens
00:07:27 of racism. Well, it isn't when the Democrats are in power. When Joe Biden's in power and he's
00:07:32 thinking, oh, we're in the middle of a pandemic, maybe we shouldn't have people from China coming,
00:07:36 you know, oh, it's not xenophobic now. So, you know, I mean, if anybody is a Republican,
00:07:43 they're already deemed a racist. I know when I go into the BBC studios, I'm looked at as a white
00:07:48 supremacist and I'm looked at an oppressed, a very misinformed or misguided woman, especially 0.96
00:07:55 on women's reproductive rights, that there's something wrong with me. They do have me on, 0.99
00:08:01 which I appreciate because they are giving the other side a voice. So I will give the BBC credit
00:08:07 for that. But it's the lead in, it's the headline, and it's the omission of the stories. It's also,
00:08:14 I was constantly on the defensive in all my BBC interviews. It was, you know, I was even asked
00:08:19 one time, is Donald Trump a monster? Like, at what high level thinking is that? You know,
00:08:25 I'm sure the viewers are wanting to know, you know, what I think, is he a monster or not?
00:08:32 It's silly. But it's also, you know, when it comes to the immigration, like southern border
00:08:38 immigration issues, like, yes, we were having a humanitarian crisis at the time that was
00:08:44 completely overwhelming the system. And we didn't have enough judges to process all these children 0.98
00:08:49 and families, you know, but we weren't going to let, you know, Donald Trump wasn't going to let
00:08:54 them just wander into the country, hoping they show up for their court date. He wanted to be
00:08:59 tough on immigration. And he believed in that. And people love, I mean, America is the land of 1.00
00:09:05 immigrants, but we believe in legal and fair immigration. And that's what he, that was a real
00:09:10 pillar of his presidency. You know, it happens under Joe Biden, even more than what's happened
00:09:15 under Donald Trump. And there's no wall-to-wall coverage. There are no children in cages,
00:09:21 which they're in the same facilities as they were two years ago.
00:09:24 You know, so it's, they never take, just you're always, it's always an uphill battle if you are
00:09:31 centre-right. What accounts for this double standard? I mean, why would it be that the BBC,
00:09:40 see, which hasn't got skin in the game when it comes to American presidential elections,
00:09:47 why does it take the side of the Democrats in that way? Explain that to me.
00:09:54 I think the American experiment is really unique in world history, and I think being
00:10:00 a conservative, a limited government, constitutional conservative, you don't find that in any other
00:10:06 country around the world. So, you know, we were founded for freedom and liberty, to maximize
00:10:13 individual freedom and liberty, and it's based around a very important document that preserves
00:10:18 those rights and freedoms. And so, for conservatives, that's, you know, we live and die by that.
00:10:26 We want to protect it and pass it on to our children. We realize how special and unique it is.
00:10:31 I think it was Margaret Thatcher that said that America is created by philosophy, not history.
00:10:35 Europe is created by history so there it's a purpose driven nation I think
00:10:40 people on the left tend to be more internationalist tend to like to do
00:10:47 things the way that say Europe does things we'd like to see more of a social
00:10:52 net a nanny state or a welfare state whereas conservatives want to be left
00:10:57 alone to raise their kids and their family and and just have the freedom of
00:11:01 speech and the freedom of religion and conscience rights these are all
00:11:04 all prevailing themes amongst Republicans. And the Constitution enables that.
00:11:12 You touched on the issue previously. You said that you were interested in women's
00:11:18 reproductive rights issues. And you yourself are pro-life, are you not?
00:11:22 Do you think that plays into the BBC's attitude in these things? Was that an issue with Trump?
00:11:30 do you think? Well, I mean, if you remember on inauguration day or around the time of the
00:11:34 inauguration was the big women's march where everyone's wearing the pink hats. I won't even
00:11:38 say the word of what they were, but they, the pink hats and they were, oh, rah, rah, rah. And what was
00:11:44 it? And it was basically a pro-abortion rally of women and feminists and Madonna. And then,
00:11:53 of course, the wonderful Palestinian activist, Linda Sarsour. I mean, you love it when you're
00:11:59 in the company of people who've been accused of terrorism before, you know, you just got to love
00:12:03 that. But they were real cast of characters. And I know that it was portrayed over here as a real
00:12:11 positive thing that women were fighting back against the big bad orange man. And that doesn't
00:12:17 categorize all women. In fact, I think it was white women that Hillary Clinton lost. More white women
00:12:24 voted for Trump, which of course the left can only see through the eyes of race.
00:12:30 But I think it does have to do a lot with cultural values and, you know, the younger
00:12:36 generations, especially with the aid of technology, are seeing that, you know, life does begin
00:12:42 at conception and life can survive out of the womb much earlier and much earlier.
00:12:49 So you know, the younger generation are coming around to a more pro-life position, even if
00:12:54 they may hold economic left-wing views or environmentally left-wing views, when it comes
00:13:01 to the right to life, I think it's winning. And that is never portrayed on the BBC. The largest
00:13:10 peaceful protest in America on the coldest day of the year, mind you, every single year is the
00:13:16 March for Life. And 100,000 people or more gather, mostly over, I would say, 65% are young people.
00:13:25 Constant reference to this particular debate was made every time the question of
00:13:32 candidates for the Supreme Court came up during the Trump years. It was something which was
00:13:38 seen as being a very negative thing as far as the BBC was concerned.
00:13:42 Yes, and that's exactly where the bias is there. Whenever he put up a court nominee, it was
00:13:49 was always put in the negative light because he probably was going to vote down Roe v. Wade.
00:13:56 Again, getting their talking points from the left-wing American media.
00:14:00 This is why they went after Brett Kavanaugh with such fervor,
00:14:04 even though completely unsubstantiated claims against this man.
00:14:08 And I participated in many BBC debates on this, particularly BBC World.
00:14:14 I appreciated that opportunity to defend it.
00:14:18 I wish it was actually done more on BBC Woman's Hour or BBC One would be nice.
00:14:27 But, you know, and then, of course, when Ruth Bader Ginsburg dies, it's a coronation.
00:14:32 I mean, it's almost like a state funeral for her, you know.
00:14:36 And the fact is, I mean, granted, she has paved the way in many ways for women.
00:14:41 But I can tell you when Amy Coney Barrett dies, it's not going to be the same coronation for her because she was, you know, she's right wing.
00:14:51 I mean, she was a Catholic professor with five plus children, several adopted.
00:14:58 That seems to be something to be respected and admired.
00:15:01 But it was Ruth Bader Ginsburg's feminism and her work at the ACLU that enamored the BBC with her, as well as everybody else in American media.
00:15:13 And so, you know, RBG shirts come out.
00:15:15 Listen, I think she, I respect a lot about what she has said in the court and in interviews, but I disagree profoundly with her on the right to life.
00:15:28 So a centre-right woman will never have, I mean, look at how they've treated Margaret Thatcher.
00:15:34 I mean, you're never going to get the same awe and coverage.
00:15:40 The BBC, of course, sells itself, and many people still believe that it is an impartial organisation.
00:15:48 From the way you're talking, it seems obvious to me that you don't think that at all.
00:15:53 I mean, what do you make of the BBC's claim to be impartial, even-handed, fair-minded?
00:16:03 I think because they put people like myself on, and they do try to tick the boxes of putting a pro, anti, etc. on,
00:16:12 they feel they've done their job, they've done their bit.
00:16:15 But the problem is either they're too surrounded by people like themselves, and they haven't really immersed themselves in the communities they're broadcasting to, so they don't understand how their questions and how their storylines and their headlines can seem biased to others.
00:16:36 So maybe it's naivete, but they also have really big degrees and come from really big
00:16:42 universities.
00:16:43 So I don't want to give them too much of the benefit of the doubt because they have
00:16:47 a job to do, and they need to go into the hinterlands and really understand, you know, 0.55
00:16:54 why is it that the GOP is now turning into the party for the working class, you know?
00:17:02 Why is it that, you know, you look at a map after an election and it's solid red except
00:17:08 for the coasts and the cities?
00:17:10 Is this really a good long-term election strategy for Democrats?
00:17:14 Is focusing on identity politics, aka diversity, the environment, feminism, like, you know,
00:17:22 really good for them?
00:17:23 But they can't question that because they've embraced these identity politics topics as
00:17:30 well not only in their hiring but in their reporting I mean when Prince
00:17:33 Philip died the I don't know the name of the journalists he's very famous you
00:17:38 would know who he is he was just commenting over and over again don't
00:17:43 you think that the Duke's legacy is his conservation is his focus on
00:17:48 conservation don't you know what about his work on the environment wasn't that
00:17:52 just amazing with every interviewee he made even though he weren't making that
00:17:57 point at all when he was talking to friends of the Duke and people who knew him. So I just think
00:18:04 that when you embrace identity politics as an organization, it's very hard to report how other
00:18:13 people view that in a non-biased way. The 2020 election, which Trump of course famously lost,
00:18:20 there were aspects of the reporting of that which struck me as odd I don't know what you made for
00:18:29 instance of what about tell me about your view of the way for instance the BBC covered that election
00:18:35 in particular some of the stories that arose during it you know the the way the Black Lives
00:18:41 matter thing was used as an issue, the Hunter Biden story, and Tifa. Do you think the BBC did
00:18:50 a fair job on those things? I mean, I was a full-time spokesperson during the campaign,
00:18:58 and my biggest press hits were when we're the first debate with Chris Wallace, and it was all
00:19:06 about, do you denounce Proud Boys? I had never even heard of Proud Boys. Didn't know what this was.
00:19:13 And then the second time was, oh, the president has COVID. Don't you think his COVID policy was
00:19:19 wrong? Look, now he's a victim of it. So it was always negative, negative. But they never harped
00:19:25 on Biden in that first interview when he said, oh, Antifa is just an idea. Antifa had murdered
00:19:31 people by this point. They had destroyed, I mean, billions worth of property. They had taken over a
00:19:39 whole section of Seattle, which most Brits don't even know, that became literally Lord of the Flies
00:19:44 with rapes and murder. They are still attacking on a nightly basis courthouses and police stations
00:19:51 in Portland, Oregon. To me, the complete silence over Antifa and the violence of the Black Lives 0.99
00:20:01 Matter protests over 75 cities in America, America, we all thought, to people who were
00:20:08 alive in 1968, they said, this feels like 1968, like completely unstable, like another virus
00:20:17 other than COVID had just run rampant and had taken over cities and nobody felt safe. Defund
00:20:23 the police? What are you talking about defunding the police? Are you insane? That's not mainstream.
00:20:30 And all of a sudden these topics were mainstream and they were never challenged. They were never
00:20:34 properly challenged. Biden was never held to account for his comments on that. And then the
00:20:39 Hunter Biden story came out about his emails. The New York Post published it completely centered by
00:20:46 twitter not even mentioned um in in debates or interviews and um i mean people thought if you
00:20:56 brought it up you were fringe right wing it was insane because they treated it as like oh these
00:21:01 are like the emails from wikileaks with hillary and that's what damned the last election well
00:21:06 clearly you're interfering with the election if you're not reporting on it because you're afraid
00:21:11 that it might go the way you wouldn't like. That looks like systematic censorship almost,
00:21:17 doesn't it? Oh, yeah. I mean, I think definitely. And Donald Trump did not have a fair
00:21:22 field to play on when it came to the press or the media at all.
00:21:28 Does the BBC have much influence in the US? The BBC has a great reputation.
00:21:35 I don't think people go to it for news. The BBC World News Service, perhaps,
00:21:40 but they always think of it
00:21:43 and I think Americans always think of Brits
00:21:45 as having higher IQ
00:21:48 based on their accent alone
00:21:50 so there is a lot of respect
00:21:54 and awe for it as an organization
00:21:55 its depth and breadth of an organization
00:22:00 and the period dramas that it produces
00:22:03 they love them
00:22:05 so there is a fondness for the BBC
00:22:08 and if someone says oh I'm from the BBC
00:22:09 everyone kind of sits up a little taller and tucks their shirt in. But I don't see it as taking cues
00:22:17 like in the media from them. But amongst people like yourself, politically aware people,
00:22:23 and particularly people who are on the right, what would their view now be American people
00:22:28 like that? What would their view of the BBC be, do you think? I mean, they probably think it's
00:22:34 It's part of the mainstream media that has enacts a grind with the right.
00:22:39 I mean, I think if anybody turns on the BBC now, any of my friends, they'll say, oh, this is just as bad as American news, you know, or, oh, this topic, or why aren't they talking about this?
00:22:52 I think they'd be very disgruntled with it.
00:22:54 And I think for most people on the right, Republicans who are very engaged, they have
00:23:01 there's a cynicism to any mainstream news media, doesn't matter, really, where it's from.
00:23:09 And on the specific point of voter fraud, and the claims made by Trump, that the election was
00:23:20 stolen. How much credence do you give that? And how well do you think the BBC treated with that
00:23:31 issue? I think it was a very awkward and difficult time to be a Republican after the election,
00:23:40 and particularly after January 6th.
00:23:45 And, you know, I think to many Republicans,
00:23:48 we don't put it past the Democrats to stealing an election,
00:23:52 especially when they're one-party cities.
00:23:56 You know, the cities themselves are dominated by one party.
00:23:58 So it's very easy to manipulate votes,
00:24:01 especially when everybody wants to do a mail-in ballot, you know,
00:24:04 and the chaos that that has ensued.
00:24:08 I don't think that there is clear, decisive evidence that proves Biden stole the election.
00:24:16 I don't think that was proven.
00:24:18 And it wasn't proven in the allotted time that the law allows.
00:24:22 So, you know, even if you go to court and you are found guilty, but you are innocent,
00:24:28 you still have to serve a sentence.
00:24:30 And I think as a land of laws, we have to respect the rule of law.
00:24:35 And if the Electoral College still voted to elect Joe Biden, then he is the president-elect.
00:24:43 If there was not evidence that was put forward that was convincing enough at the time, then you have to accept the outcome.
00:24:51 I hope we learn lessons from the chaos of mail-in voting, voting machines that may have mysteriously gone, lost power at certain times of the night.
00:25:04 I hope we can hold to account. That has to happen at the state and local level.
00:25:09 And I think it is happening. I mean, there are audits taking place. There are new voting laws
00:25:14 where you need to have ID to vote. Very basic stuff. And so hopefully it can be improved from
00:25:23 here on out. The BBC kept saying, didn't it, throughout that episode that there was no
00:25:28 evidence of voter fraud. Was there any evidence of voter fraud? Yes, yes. We know that people who
00:25:34 had died voted. We know that criminals with felonies who cannot vote voted. We know that
00:25:43 people voted multiple times because multiple ballots got sent to their house. So, but was
00:25:49 there enough fraud to sway the election the other way? That's the question. And, you know, Trump's
00:25:55 did not prove that in the time allotted. Now, you can say maybe we should streamline the voting
00:26:02 process for a presidential so that all ballots look the same and are counted the same. So then
00:26:07 if we have discrepancies or we have questions about legitimacy, it's much easier to then validate
00:26:13 it. But these are lessons that we will learn after the fact. But I think the way the president
00:26:20 behaved, stirring up emotion, questioning the republic, questioning our election integrity
00:26:28 to a great extent, really was very damaging, will have lasting effects. And of course,
00:26:35 I think led to losing the two Senate Georgia runoff seats for the US Senate. And then of course,
00:26:42 January 6 riot on the Capitol building. Do you think it's fair to say actually
00:26:47 that trump in some ways was his own worst enemy yeah definitely i think sometimes your greatest
00:26:54 strengths can be your greatest weaknesses i think it's very hard for him to lose
00:27:00 it made it it made it very easy didn't it for his enemies to portray him as
00:27:05 a bad and discredited man yeah exactly see we told you we told you all along this is what
00:27:11 what he was like. We knew this about him. You're naive. You couldn't see, you know,
00:27:17 kind of thing. And the issue is, is over four years of pretty intense four years as a, you
00:27:25 know, as president, he didn't crack like that. And he fulfilled his campaign promises. So
00:27:33 I stand by my decision for voting for him on the information that I had when I voted.
00:27:39 Sarah Elliott, thank you.
00:27:41 Thank you.