00:00:00Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now you of all people will know
00:00:27that on this program we speak to a lot of academics, we speak to comedians, we speak to
00:00:32authors, even we can suffer the occasional politician. What we don't really speak to very
00:00:39much are people involved in the arts, so I'm delighted that today we have one of Britain's
00:00:45most successful artists joining us from Bath. Jonathan Miles-Lee has made an extraordinary career
00:00:54from painting some of Britain's historic country houses and gardens. He also paints
00:01:00abstracts and portraits. His clients have gone from Oprah Winfrey through to the Prince of Wales.
00:01:07Now at a time when our heritage is very much under attack it's very good to hear someone
00:01:14and speak to somebody from the arts who actually cares about it. Jonathan thank you so much for
00:01:20joining us today. I want to just sort of start by asking you as an artist you know practically
00:01:27speaking how does it work for you during lockdown? I mean do you still work? Do you still work?
00:01:33Well yeah of course I'm working flat out the only thing I miss is the gym because I love going
00:01:38swimming but and I'm quite a hermit anyway and I can work for eight months to a year on a painting
00:01:45so I'm quite used to spending really prolonged periods of time on my own.
00:01:50The big difference I've noticed is that my friends are phoning me a lot more
00:01:53because they're at home and you know they're wondering you know what they should do when
00:01:58they're not watching Netflix. I want to start really by actually putting you in the deep end
00:02:04a bit actually immediately. You have done these wonderful paintings of Britain's historic country
00:02:13houses and the gardens and ground surrounding them but of course country houses have sort of
00:02:21been drawn into what i would call a cultural onslaught this year and i wonder what your
00:02:29feeling was about that because we're hearing about the national trust uh basically now re-evaluating
00:02:35the histories of their country houses how do you feel about that oh outraged no i mean i have the
00:02:42same feeling that most people would have who've been committed members of the National Trust for
00:02:47you know the last 30 years or so and unfortunately most of the people I speak to are so upset about
00:02:54the new developments that they've given up their membership so they must be losing a lot of income
00:02:59and it's really tragic. I suppose it came about as a measure to try and encourage more people to
00:03:05visit the properties but there's a couple of experiences I had which which made me feel a
00:03:11a bit alienated from the National Trust. I think Hanbury Hall in Worcestershire had an
00:03:16exhibition of feminist, there seemed to be placards everywhere displayed around the
00:03:23building with feminist quotes and all of the sort of tweedy National Trust, the normal1.00
00:03:31visitors were being sort of jostled out of place by these quite hefty girls with blue1.00
00:03:36hair and big cameras and dot martins who wanted to photograph these statements these feminist0.85
00:03:42statements and put them on their instagram accounts so it changed the atmosphere and i
00:03:45mean obviously they're trying to broaden the appeal but it made the experience entirely different i
00:03:50think a lot of people go to a national trust property to in order to slip back into the past
00:03:56and the purpose the remit of the national trust was to preserve and protect britain's heritage for
00:04:03you know in continuity another experience was at um hardwick hall in derbyshire where i think we
00:04:10talked about this privately i went in for the first time it never seemed to be open whenever
00:04:14i went to hardwick hall i wanted to see the long gallery with the great sort of uh you know the
00:04:18vistas and great old portrait paintings hung on tapestry and half of the paintings have been
00:04:24removed uh and replaced by uh um all all women sort of strident feminists and television
00:04:33presenters amongst them being kathy newman well this was like set yeah this was like setting up
00:04:39a firework for me because it was very shortly after the jordan peterson interview in which
00:04:44she'd used all of these appalling techniques and just fell flat on her face you know by saying so
00:04:49what you're saying is a totally misrepresenting Jordan Peterson and I think that's what gave the
00:04:55name for your interview series so what you're saying is so I left Hardwick Hall without having
00:05:02my sort of basil and tomato soup and a lovely relaxing cup of tea and I went red in the face
00:05:08I think I just sort of strode back to the car and fled so I think they need to do a big rethink
00:05:14I think as well, coming up to date, Jonathan, last week, it was reported in the press that
00:05:22apparently younger people are going to be, as it were, sort of lecturing people at the National
00:05:31Trust on our colonial past. I mean, this is pure kind of Maoism, isn't it?
00:05:39Yeah, it is. Well, we are in the middle of a cultural revolution. It's a culture war. It's
00:05:43heating up and the and the people are picking their sides they've already
00:05:46picked their sides and I think we we've talked about you know where does all
00:05:52this come from and I was thinking about this the other day because we know all
00:05:56about the long march the through the institutions that Mark Sidwell has
00:06:00written that wonderful book about but I think we'll both remember occasions
00:06:07say 20 years ago when you go and visit your friends at Christmas or Easter and
00:06:11and you'd be having a nice drink in the dining room or the sitting room and you'd ask their sons
00:06:15and daughters who'd become six foot in 10 minutes so you're at university what are you what are you
00:06:20studying and they'd say oh i'm doing uh social justice and uh public policy or i'm doing uh
00:06:27gender race sexuality and social justice and you'd sort of go goodness and you'd sort of move on and
00:06:35and you never really question what on earth was that that they're studying but now we know they
00:06:41weren't really studying anything at all apart from identity politics and they were being drummed with
00:06:47this sort of marxist heavy marxism no matter what background they came from they left university
00:06:54with these very militant ideas that all hierarchies are a result of the patriarchy
00:06:59and that uh being white and male was the worst thing you could be and then those people left
00:07:05university and of course they had no skills in anything apart from making a nightmare of
00:07:10themselves to other people so they couldn't get jobs in anything particularly interesting0.79
00:07:14apart from the hr departments so there they were stuck in their offices thinking how can i use my
00:07:22social justice and my my identity politics here every single day being progressive and active
00:07:27so what they did is started you know attacking the organizations themselves they work for
00:07:32and the people who use those institutions and organizations and now unfortunately they're the
00:07:37gatekeepers of the organizations and i just wanted to add something here i remembered
00:07:41very recently that a friend of mine sent me an application to be an advisor to the arts council
00:07:48about two years ago and i thought oh that sounds fantastic and then i read the in the information
00:07:53the unpaid role well it's fine still do that and then I got to the bottom of the form I'd filled
00:08:00everything out and I thought this is fantastic I'd love to have my voice heard in the Arts Council
00:08:05and right at the bottom it said now in your own words write an essay about your personal
00:08:11commitment throughout your career to diversity and inclusion and equality and at that point I
00:08:18i just thought oh god you know i'm not i'm not going to do this i spoke to the friend who sent
00:08:23me the application for he said no no no just do it but this is how the the gatekeepers only make
00:08:29sure that you know the the like-minded people um enter the organization i mean obviously that's
00:08:36extremely familiar a scenario that you know you're counting there but are you still nevertheless
00:08:43jonathan surprised at the speed with which the institutions capitulated over the past year
00:08:51yes yeah it was odd wasn't it that they all capitulated and what really upset me after the
00:08:57the blm squares was the all of the uh the museums and the galleries that i love even the one here
00:09:03in bath who've blocked me from their instagram um started parroting the the same phrases and i
00:09:11thought how extraordinary it was that they didn't just go on the blm website to see that they wanted
00:09:16to you know destroy the nuclear family get rid of the police and overthrow capitalism um why don't
00:09:22people google more or bing more perhaps they should bing more um so yeah i i'm not sure exactly what
00:09:30that was what that's part of whether they're judging the general mood of the population
00:09:34thinking oh we we better go that direction um or whether there are these this group has been
00:09:40activated amongst the institutions through the twitterati to say you know you need to get on
00:09:46board with this otherwise we're going to de-platform you we're going to black in your name we're going
00:09:50to picket your museums some something's obviously going on because the speed with which it happened
00:09:56was it was pretty terrifying actually i think it's almost you know to to carry the country
00:10:02house metaphor a bit it's a bit like if you know death wash beetle has been in a place for long
00:10:08enough and then bang it suddenly collapses you know it's a virus isn't it i forget who it was
00:10:13that i was watching online who who explained the whole uh the you know the infestation um
00:10:19of identity politics it's it's an anti-cultural anti-art um anti-beauty movement which is
00:10:28infesting the the host body and corroding it from within and it takes very strong personalities and
00:10:36strong voices of which there are fewer and fewer because they're all being eradicated from their
00:10:41jobs and from even from social media they're being censored from social media but those are the
00:10:46people who need to hold things together i worked with the national trust many many years ago
00:10:50making maps of places like stow landscape gardens and cliveden and uh there was a number of places
00:10:57but meticulous maps and i was commissioned by a man called gervais jackson stops who was the chief
00:11:01advisor to the national trust and he was very erudite wrote beautiful books on country houses
00:11:05and gardens, sadly passed away when he was relatively young. But he said, when you design
00:11:11this map for us, I don't want it to look like it was designed by the Ministry of Agriculture.
00:11:15I want it to have some style. I want it to have an essence of the period. So I included
00:11:21in the map, which I did in an engraving style with meticulous, tiny little dots, as though
00:11:28it was done as an engraving. People in period costume, walking up the hills, meeting friends,
00:11:34dogs with tricorn hats and big hooped dresses and you know I tried to create
00:11:40the atmosphere of the period which I think was more what the National Trust
00:11:44was trying to do back then they were they were giving you a very special
00:11:48experience rather like a period movie I suppose whereas now as we've discussed
00:11:52many times politics is rammed into every aspect of your life you can't escape it
00:11:58whether you're buying shoes or going to a restaurant you know there has to be
00:12:02something there plastered in front of you, forcing you to contemplate, you know, feminism
00:12:08or transgenderism, whatever. All great issues, but not when you're, you know, not every moment
00:12:15of the day. Actually, you mentioned restaurants there, Jonathan. There's one particular issue
00:12:22as well, we talked about the National Trust, but there's one particular issue as well in
00:12:25London, and that's to do with the Tate Britain, used to be the Tate Gallery, you know, now
00:12:30Britain has this very famous mural by a British artist Rex Whistler in fact I
00:12:36think you've been called the success natural successor to to Rex Whistler but
00:12:42it's a it's a very famous mural kind of fantastical and it's it goes all the way
00:12:47around the restaurant now there are various images in that which have caused
00:12:52offence which are of their time but I think isn't it right that there is now
00:12:57a real doubt over this very famous iconic piece to work as to whether it
00:13:02will actually survive. Yeah I mean it that just shows the sort of period the
00:13:08bizarre clown world period we're living in that a mural by Rex Whistler can be
00:13:14regarded as unequivocally offensive which is what the chair of their ethics
00:13:18committee at the Tate said unequivocally offensive what is it's an amazing piece
00:13:23of artwork for somebody who was 21 when he executed it he was paid five pounds a day
00:13:28and imagine the excitement it must mean to get a commission like that um and um they've spent a
00:13:34great deal of money restoring it it's a stunning thing i loved it so much and it sort of fitted my
00:13:39my aesthetic that i had my 40th birthday party in in in that room you can you can rent it out
00:13:45but um they said that the the offense is compounded by the fact that it's used as a restaurant so
00:13:52you know the fact that there's a very there's a tiny uh i think there's a child a black child
00:13:57chained and you have to look very hard to find it so whoever's been in that room with a you know
00:14:03bubbling up with resentment and and rage towards the bourgeoisie has spent a long time looking
00:14:08for something to be annoyed about in that room and you have to look pretty hard so um i mean
00:14:14there's been a lot of media attention about it i think it i think the media get on board because
00:14:19they're using their platform to kind of punish us punish the middle class for for you know not
00:14:25editing our heritage significantly enough to eradicate all images of barbarity in Britain's
00:14:32dreadful past and so these are the walls that we have to pass through you know these very militant
00:14:40journalists and people in the HR departments and the curators of museums who are really putting
00:14:48impediments to our enjoyment of everything by again politicizing everything don't you think
00:14:54that you know it will be a huge massive and long project to somehow turn around what appears to be
00:15:04a cult of self-loathing yes well roger scrutin talked about this i think even in your interview
00:15:12about the the uh what did he call it the culture of repudiation i think that's it the culture of
00:15:19repudiation which is very very sad i mean um i don't have any children but i work and stay with
00:15:24a lot of my clients over a period of time and even in you know quite affluent families you'll find
00:15:30that the children have adopted this very radical politics from their schools or later when they go
00:15:36to university so you'll hear something at the breakfast table or at the christmas table oh
00:15:41goodness there's no cranberry sauce the father will say and the son will say oh that's a very
00:15:46that's a very first world problem and it's a little indication of what sort of where what
00:15:52the angle of their education is and lying behind that will be you know the fact that some cities
00:15:57are too white or um you know the university is not diverse enough or something like this um
00:16:05I was trying to remember what you asked me just before that.
00:16:08Yes, no, basically, I think this problem of self-loathing, that basically this is going to take a long time.
00:16:17Yeah, no, culture of repudiation, it's been going for a long, long time.
00:16:23And again, it's corrosive and there's so much energy and time wasted on this energy of destruction that very little is being produced.
00:16:33I can't think of any truly great classical composers or even pop music or writers of great note.
00:16:42I mean, I like Robert Harris's trilogy of Cicero and his book about Pompeii.
00:16:47But there doesn't seem to be a very vivacious culture at the moment.
00:16:52And in my more depressed moments, I've said culture is dead, R.I.P. culture, you know, because it looks so bleak.0.98
00:16:59all the things that we we used to feel so excited about are now being replaced if you look at the
00:17:05media by identity politics and for instance if you if you watch a sports report now it's never
00:17:14about sport it's about racism in sport or if you and you very rarely hear anything on the media
00:17:20about an orchestra unless someone's been unfairly dismissed because of some sort of sexist comment
00:17:26So all of this noise is crowding out what should really be in its place, which is creativity and, you know, development and, well, creativity, really.
00:17:39I think it stymied creativity because if you feel fearful, which most people do in their places of work, you can't think creatively, can you?
00:17:47You're just completely paralysed. And when I speak to people about politics, I'm lucky.
00:17:52I'm like the sort of court jester or you know as an artist you're able to get away with a lot more
00:17:57saying a lot more but when I try to talk to friends about political issues they actually
00:18:03become quite stiff and terrified and they don't know what to say there is something I wanted to
00:18:08say about the civil service as well I have a friend who works for the cabinet office and it
00:18:13took him about six months to reveal what he actually does because I think they have to sign
00:28:36They feel it as being an attack on themselves.
00:28:39And I think in some ways they're right that that is actually the intention.
00:28:44But when it comes to, if you like, a sort of political point of view, you would think
00:28:50that Conservatives would make sure to conserve and to protect that culture, but when we look
00:28:59at the current Conservative Party, it doesn't seem to be the case, does it?
00:29:05This is a bit of a bold thing to say, but I think a lot of people who go into politics,
00:29:08they're very protective of their lifestyle and reputation, and to be bold and tell the
00:29:15truth about a major issue or to make a stand can threaten that so it's
00:29:20difficult they're being pushed by the civil service and they're being squeezed
00:29:24by their PR consultants I'm sure a lot of the time and I think as you know I
00:29:29was a big fan of Margaret Thatcher even when people hated her in the 19 you know
00:29:33I was 10 when she came to power in 1979 so I think she was in powers at nine
00:29:37years and I used to include 11 years was it yeah so it was partly because I0.98
00:29:45responded to her rhetoric and of course she looked fabulous she was always1.00
00:29:48immaculate she was very media savvy but my mother had done an open university0.81
00:29:55one year humanities course I think before she went on to Bath University
00:29:58actually and included in the material that was sent to her was a long playing
00:30:02disc you know the vinyl discs of speeches from Shakespeare and also
00:30:06political speeches by people like Michael Foote the previous leader of the Labour
00:30:14party ben uh richard burton reading shakespeare king lear and so i realized at that point the
00:30:21great power of rhetoric and the power of the word to move great numbers of people and of course that
00:30:27was some that was a classical tradition because when you studied the trivium trivium and the
00:30:31quadrivium back that ended in 1920 about 19 that was your education for 2000 years you would
00:30:38basically start study the speeches of cicero next year the speeches and letters of cicero and cicero
00:30:45isn't really a very well-known character today uh generally but basically you your education would
00:30:50have been composed of uh speeches so it taught you how to express how to think basically margaret
00:30:57thatcher was aware of that and she was asked in an interview you know how important do you think
00:31:01the classical classical education is in education she said it is everything because a classical
00:31:08education tell teaches you how to be and how to think and how to express your ideas and um
00:31:16so i think i'm on some level i responded to that in margaret thatcher because i found
00:31:20her she was a real um conviction politician was indeed and an incredible incredibly quotable i
00:31:28I remember her battles with Jacques Delors and her sort of standing at the dispatch box saying, no, no, no.
00:31:36You know, she was a formidable force, especially as she was one woman in this sea of men who were all wearing black suits at the time.
00:31:43It's very different from today. And I thought, those are my role models, people who can speak their truth, even when they know they're going to be hated for it.
00:35:40And that's what's happened. So we have lots of people who are very careful with their children and they can't give them and no nuts, they'll have a terrible nervous shock or something like this. And it's the same with ideas. And if you shelter people from complicated or really distressing ideas, you end up with people who the snowflake generation and safe spaces in schools and universities.
00:36:06And the reason I find that particularly weird and anomalous is because when I was at university, I was very lucky.
00:36:14I became a member of the Colony Room, which is an old drinking club in Soho.
00:36:18It started in the 1950s by a woman called Muriel Belcher, which I thought was a great name for somebody who sold booze.
00:36:24And the tradition was that she used to hand it on the ownership to a barman.
00:36:29So she handed it on to a man called Ian Board, who ran it for many years.
00:36:33And I was taken there by the boss from Channel 4, Ken Thompson.
00:36:38Because you worked in television, didn't you?