00:25:23and how can you make demand that everybody pays for it if what they're getting is not
00:25:29is in fact partial just so obvious such an obvious moral point it seems to me totally
00:25:35indisputable and that does mean that there are constraints on the type of journalism that you
00:25:41can do which are different from the constraints on me at the daily telegraph or whatever it's
00:25:47because of the fact that people have to pay for it and also that it's supposed to serve everybody
00:25:52So not only by being impartial, but also trying to cater for the right range of interests and occupations and regions.
00:26:03And I don't think most BBC people at the top really think that way.
00:26:12They sort of try to, most of them, but actually they don't.
00:26:16They're more carried away by what they care about.
00:26:20And the way King C. Amos always used to put it, the novelist used to put it like this, he said, what people are obsessed with in the BBC is what he called, how will it go down at the club?
00:26:34Meaning, what will my colleagues think about it?
00:26:44and you i mean i'm always amused me the bbc uses the word brave when talking about themselves which
00:26:50shows confirms this very much a program they will say is brave is one which runs no risk at all
00:27:00within the organization for the person making it because they will he will be congratulated by
00:27:04colleagues because it'll be about you know how awful um boris is or something like that um uh
00:27:10And, you know, or exposing something which we all know is bad, like racism or being very challenging in your questions to a conservative minister or something like that.
00:27:24That's brave. I remember picking this up years and years ago.
00:27:29I was invited to a religious broadcasting conference and everybody there was from religious broadcasting, mostly from the public sector, except for me and one or two others.
00:27:39and they kept saying this was in the late 80s they kept saying how brave they were because on
00:27:43all these religious programs they made programs which was were in favor of aid sufferers um
00:27:50and the implication being they were defying a sort of massive um uh anti-gay um consensus which
00:28:01you know was really putting them at risk but there wasn't that massive anti-gay consensus
00:28:10and there was a there was very widespread compassion for age sufferers and it wasn't
00:28:19brave it might have been right but it wasn't brave to make these programs and in fact what
00:28:26would have been brave in a religious program would be if they got on a sort of tub thumping
00:28:30damn sodomy type character who, you know, I don't think such people are good people,0.89
00:28:39but, you know, they could put that religious position, that's religious broadcasting, if you
00:28:43like, because you would never get that. You'd never ever get that. Now, that would have been,
00:28:47suppose you'd have one person on Thought for the Day who said, actually, you know, if people didn't0.69
00:28:53have gay sex, they wouldn't get AIDS, and God condemns it and all the rest. Now, that would0.90
00:28:58have been very unattractive but brave and and do you see what i mean so they kept thinking what
00:29:06courage they were showing but they in fact led very protected lives um it's interesting you talk
00:29:11a touch on the religious issue because we interviewed um someone from a small charity
00:29:16called aid to the church in need yes very good yeah um and um he was talking about a specific
00:29:22concern of his, which is that the BBC seems to give very little attention to, put very little
00:29:32effort into, the persecution of Christians in countries like Iraq or in Pakistan, where some
00:29:39terrible things have happened. I just wondered if the same thing strikes you too. I am very struck
00:29:45by the extreme sensitivity about what might be called Islamophobia and the lack of interest
00:29:52in the plight of Christians in persecuted countries.
00:30:01And while I think it's absolutely right to be very careful about being unfair about any
00:30:07great religion, I think it does prevent, first of all, the Christians are suffering in many
00:30:14of these places and this is unheard their cries are unheard and secondly I think there are
00:30:22definitely new situations in which the BBC doesn't tell you what's explain what's going on because
00:30:27it's frightened of saying something which might offend in their view offend Muslims and I've
00:30:31noticed recent examples of this what's happening in Africa where Islamist violence has been
00:30:39described in other ways and I and I noticed for example that there was a lot of kidnapping this
00:30:46was I think earlier this year of children in Nigeria and when this was first reported on the
00:30:55BBC I noticed specifically that they didn't mention the possibility of an Islamist motive
00:31:02and so there was talk about criminals or ransoms or that sort of thing and it emerged later
00:31:10reporting other sources that it was indeed Boko Haram I think and that it was a religious motive
00:31:18which by the way doesn't necessarily exclude ransom because Islamists believe in ransom as
00:31:24a religious duty in some situations and gradually what tends to happen in those situations the BBC
00:31:31ends up reporting it but only when it's got the cover from other people doing so and similarly
00:31:34it's reporting on Mozambique recently where they were chopping off the heads of people on the beach
00:31:39Islamists was a bit like that though it got to the truth a bit quicker but you know it's um
00:31:45you can see that hesitancy and I and back home you can see it so um this teacher who had to leave0.92
00:31:52the school in Batley um because he'd shown the uh pupils the Charlie Hebdo cartoons all the sort of
00:32:01presumption of innocence was not given to him his motives were called in question
00:32:10it was suggested that he might be islamophobic or you know incredibly ill-judged or something like
00:32:16that and they didn't make inquiries about who these people are who are attacking him which and
00:32:23i looked some of it up and you could see that the under the sort of rather thin veneer of
00:32:28charities very small charities you would find people who are putting forward very extreme views
00:32:33who were imams or sort of um that sort of thing um uh uh condemning the man so they're very
00:32:45uninvestigative of you know they love investigation sometimes but not of things like that and what do
00:32:51think explains that I mean this sort of this as it were this protective attitude towards Islam
00:32:58and yet this indifference to verging sometimes even on hostility to Christianity what what
00:33:06explains that well whatever explains it it's not that many people on the BBC are Muslims because
00:33:13not many of them are and it's not because they wish to advance Islam in that sense I think it's
00:33:20combination of um fear um of being accused really of racism because often the whole question about
00:33:30islam is seen in race terms which is quite wrong but it is um uh and also of a assumption of
00:33:39who's bad in the world and who's good and this is becoming more explicit now with critical race
00:33:44theory which is itself racist because what it what it so for example a thing put out by
00:33:50cambridge university vice chancellor last week made this clear that um what he called whiteness
00:33:55was actually bad in itself which seems to me that is a racist theory i mean that's like saying
00:34:03that's like the south african apartheid theory the other way around um and um therefore and i
00:34:11think the BBC sort of some vague inarticulate way subscribes to something like that so unless
00:34:18proved otherwise the white person and particularly the white man is guilty in any situation if all
00:34:25you can see is you know one brown person or one black person and one white person
00:34:29who's guilty it'll be the white one and that's where they start of course they don't always come0.65
00:34:37to that final conclusion I mean they're not completely crazy but that's how they start and0.74
00:34:41And that's why, for example, they capitulated abjectly to Black Lives Matter after the death of George Floyd in all their coverage was entirely uncritical of Black Lives Matter and treated it as the authentic expression of all blacks, really, and indeed of all right thinking people.0.72
00:35:01um and therefore you know when they started knocking down statues and having rats and all
00:35:08that sort of thing no effort was made to work out who are these people what's their ideology
00:35:12whom do they represent um their their right and you sort of and often within the bbc staff
00:35:21organizations that sort of thing are now very powerful and often seem to dictate content which
00:35:27should surely be decided by editorial not by staff organizations um uh insist on one way of
00:35:34looking at it and so again though the bbc gradually this unscrambled a bit over time and they've said
00:35:40a little bit more about um about this essentially their encourage their coverage of black lives
00:35:47matter has been unilluminating and biased but isn't it extraordinary that an organization which is
00:35:55I think still one of the largest, if not the largest, employer of journalists in the world
00:36:00should have such incuriosity about something so salient to our society today.
00:36:13Yes, and I think there's a lot of very able and well-informed people in the BBC,
00:36:17and I think a lot of them do feel oppressed by this.
00:36:19In fact, I know they do, because I sometimes talk to them.
00:36:20um they might not share my particular obsessions and political views i don't know but they but they
00:36:27a lot of people then want to be fair and they also have as you say intellectual curiosity
00:36:32but but bureaucracies operate by fear to a very large extent and
00:36:37what they're frightened of is being accused of something like islamophobia much more than
00:36:43they're frightened of being accused of bias um and so they do have very unenquiring minds it0.84
00:36:50It comes back to something I was saying about my objection to them in the Thatch years was simply not explaining.
00:36:55I would also say this about the after events, everything that's gone on since 9-11,0.70
00:37:02that I've had very few, some very good people who have done something like this, like John Ware, for example.
00:37:08But on the whole, the distinction between Islamism and mainstream Islam is never properly explained on the BBC.
00:37:20And therefore, in some curious way, the BBC is fulfilling the right wing view that the sort of uneducated right wing view that all Muslims are extreme because the people it gets on all the time are pretty extreme.
00:37:33And and there's no actual interest in the theology of Islam, the differences between different sects and parts, the more quietest spiritual traditions of Sufis and so on and so on.
00:37:47it's it's um it's just we let's get a muslim let's get a muslim on and of course which muslim
00:37:57they get on the whole the ones who shout the loudest um which and if you think about it that
00:38:01is a racist idea you don't say let's get a white man on um you don't even say let's get a christian
00:38:07on you'd say you probably say let's get a bishop on or an anglican bishop on or a catholic bishop
00:38:14or something like that um so you get absolute misrepresentation and the misrepresentation is
00:38:25very great but it's done out of a misunderstanding which is actually rather unsympathetic to
00:38:33islam john pontifex of acn said that this was a matter of what he called religious illiteracy
00:38:40yes and that of course is a much wider problem than the bbc there's a general religious illiteracy
00:38:47um i remember a um a white christian friend of mine in the media or theoretically christian
00:38:56friend of mine in the media i was given a um for her child a a little catholic kiddies book
00:39:03with pretty pictures and things like that and it say it said um at one point pray for us sinners
00:39:09us sinners now and at the hour of our death which is of course from the ave maria and she said why
00:39:15do they have to mention why do they all go funny these religious things why do you have to mention
00:39:18death in a book for children and had no idea that this is the main prayer of catholics and um and
00:39:25um so it's a very widespread problem and bbc's not alone in that but given its immense resources
00:39:32this is another of my frustrations only the bbc because of its huge journalistic resources could
00:39:37do these things in depth actually in modern times they're the only organization who could
00:39:42and they don't um finally let's just look to the future a bit um we've got the advent of this new
00:39:50station gb news um two things in general terms do you welcome that and do you think that it might
00:39:59conceivably have an impact on the bbc well i certainly do welcome gb news and i welcome um
00:40:05all sort of entrance to the market from wherever they come um i don't look forward to
00:40:12the sort of slugging match if that's what it becomes like fox news versus cnn or something
00:40:19like that because i don't think fox news spread i mean it certainly spreads more heat than light
00:40:25but um it it must surely be better if there is competition um and out of competition not always
00:40:34not every time and not necessarily quickly but on the whole comes something better so
00:40:40the BBC perhaps in reacting to if if GB news is a success perhaps the BBC will come to
00:40:49look to its own lights and perhaps set about competing on that new territory which GB news