New Culture Forum - August 23, 2021


Charles Moore On BBC Bias - 'BBC Assumes White People Are Bad & Black Or Brown Are Good'

A Journey Across Muslim Britain - Why Prof. Ed Husain Is Worried Online Safety Bill Is A Fundamental Threat To Free Speech & Must Be Opposed.

Episode Stats


Length

44 minutes

Words per minute

154.75

Word count

6,958

Sentence count

89

Harmful content

Hate speech

11

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Lord Moore you are famous of course for being the biographer of Mrs Thatcher and I wonder if we
00:00:13 could start by asking you what was Mrs Thatcher's view of the BBC and did she see it as having
00:00:25 failed in some way um she was always uh hostile to the bbc um and her husband dennis even more so
00:00:34 uh he tended to say things like that stinking stinking stinking bbc would be the sort of way
00:00:39 he would put it um uh but in a way a lot of that hostility was the simple hostility that politicians
00:00:46 feel when they sense they're being attacked um so there was an element of sort of unreflective
00:00:51 quality about it and I don't think she thought deeply about what was on the television didn't
00:00:58 really watch it very much she did however attempt reforms and they were quite important one was
00:01:07 opening up the market much more because the era of satellite broadcasting was beginning
00:01:11 and that was a very important change to permit that and the other was that the only way the
00:01:18 government can legitimately intervene in the BBC in terms of what's going on is by who it appoints
00:01:24 as chairman and she appointed Marmaduke Hussey after there being a most tremendous bust up with
00:01:31 the Director General Alistair Burt and that did make a difference and Hussey who was basically a
00:01:39 traditional British establishment figure rather than a Thatcherite radical but he was quite tough
00:01:43 and he did see that the BBC needed some internal discipline.
00:01:50 And by putting him in, she achieved what in her view was some sort of modus vivendi.
00:01:58 I mean, there was somebody she felt she could trust to behave responsibly
00:02:03 and everything died down a bit.
00:02:06 She sometimes had wider ambitions to change the whole system.
00:02:10 But as has always been the case every time this has come up,
00:02:13 But in the end, politicians don't quite think it's worth their while.
00:02:17 And the attack they'll get from the media will be so great.
00:02:22 And it's also complicated and so noisy that in the end, they leave it alone.
00:02:27 Because the BBC has very powerful allies and friends, doesn't it?
00:02:31 It would be a brave politician who would take the BBC on.
00:02:35 In particular, in her case, the Home Secretary, who in those days was the minister responsible for the BBC,
00:02:40 was also her deputy Willie Whitelaw, who she trusted very much, but who was always very much
00:02:46 in favour of the status quo at the BBC. So there was never really the right tools to hand to sort
00:02:53 this out. But I think she did change the landscape. And of course, the rage at the time that she was
00:02:59 allowing Rupert Murdoch to start a satellite channel was beautiful to behold. Because I was
00:03:05 a I was in the ranks then at the BBC and as a reporter and it always seemed to me there was a
00:03:11 very clear hostility to everything that Mrs Thatcher stood for within the BBC itself do you
00:03:18 think that's fair yes I do think that's fair I don't think it was party political I don't think
00:03:23 it was that they were all Labour and she was Tory I think it was more of a cultural attitude that
00:03:28 she's a right she's right wing lower middle class and a woman and those are all bad in their view
00:03:39 at that time and they my biggest criticism of them in that period was not so much that they
00:03:49 were hostile to her though they were but that they could not understand or explain her to the
00:03:55 viewer that's the key thing you you if you just depended on the bbc in that time you wouldn't
00:04:01 have known what all this is about what what's she doing why is she doing it um it was sort of
00:04:06 mysterious um and that's the biggest that's one of the biggest failures of bias i think
00:04:11 is that it gets in the way of understanding change that's very interesting you should say
00:04:18 that we've just come from interviewing um a representative of republicans abroad
00:04:22 and we were talking to her about the way the BBC tackled the Trump phenomenon what you've just said
00:04:30 I think could be said of that also of him also don't you think yes I mean I think Donald Trump
00:04:38 was much more so genuinely problematic than Margaret Thatcher but I think the same thing
00:04:44 applied which was that if you just watch the BBC you think how is it possible that this man has
00:04:51 become president i mean it doesn't make any sense whereas if you sort of good reporting would explain
00:04:57 why there were a lot of reasons um and that extraordinary though he is trump you there were
00:05:06 powerful points about why trump was president and to some extent what he was trying to do i mean he
00:05:12 was much less coherent than mrs thatcher but nevertheless um and that's really you know that's
00:05:19 again what a particularly a national broadcaster set up by law financed by law
00:05:26 and told by law to be balanced it's got to elucidate things not sort of
00:05:35 just fill that fill the whole scene with the smoke of battle but of course the point you
00:05:43 touch on there is that if the BBC approaches an issue like Trump from an ideological point of view
00:05:54 it actually militates against understanding doesn't it I mean that is really the problem
00:06:00 with bias and maybe the same thing was at work when the BBC so badly misjudged its tone on Brexit
00:06:08 it do you think? I think there is respect in modern political and media culture which has
00:06:15 made this worse because some things are considered so wicked in what you might call the woke way of
00:06:22 thinking that such people actually think it's their duty to be what you or I might call biased
00:06:28 so for example if they think someone is a racist and some of them thought that
00:06:32 Trump was a racist, they feel because it's so terrible to be a racist, they must say he's a
00:06:40 racist. It's in their view, their duty to the truth. Whereas I would say you should never
00:06:48 describe someone really as a racist unless it's sort of overwhelming evidence, such as they say
00:06:53 they're racist, for example, or they say absolutely blatant things. Those judgments are very severe
00:07:01 judgments to pass on people and they've got to be objectively correct um but they don't really
00:07:07 think that because they think and the same i think to some extent do with sexist or what is called
00:07:12 homophobic possibly islamophobic uh and so on there are things that are just so out of order
00:07:19 in their minds that they regard the restrictions on bias as being a way of caging the truth
00:07:27 and indeed they might say they were even designed to cage the truth
00:07:35 and therefore of course to most viewers I would think they were failing in their duty
00:07:41 you had the interesting experience of being in house at the BBC a couple of years ago when they
00:07:48 invited you to be guest editor didn't they at Christmas one year yes tell me what your
00:07:54 impressions were of that experience for you did it did it um did it uh did it reaffirm you in your
00:08:03 view did you did you come away um thinking anything different or was your experience of that
00:08:09 well obviously when they invited me to be guest editor of the today program um it was nice of
00:08:15 them to do so they didn't have to do that um and but what i did notice is that i think the guest
00:08:20 editor the day before or the day after was Greta Thunberg and she got an easier ride than I did
00:08:25 let's put it that way and in particular I noticed that the person interviewing me really did
00:08:34 everything he could to wrong foot me which is an odd thing to do with a guest editor because
00:08:40 the idea is that the guest editor comes forward and guest edits instead of which it was more like
00:08:46 being in a sort of interrogation chamber and bringing up things that he thought I'd thought
00:08:52 30 years ago and that sort of thing. That seems strange to me, but I can't complain. I was allowed
00:08:58 to do at least a certain amount of what I wanted for an hour and a half or whatever, which is
00:09:03 a great privilege. But I did also notice the way the system works so that there were all sorts of
00:09:11 things I asked for that I was told I couldn't do because, of course, the idea of guess anything is
00:09:15 just simply that you speak but you invite x and y in and so on um so for example i wanted to
00:09:21 interview the person who i think is probably the most biased of all the uh correspondents um
00:09:27 on anything on the bbc who is roger harrib in the environment correspondent who seems to be just a
00:09:33 spokesman for extinction rebellion and so on and um uh they wouldn't allow that um and they say
00:09:41 extraordinary things when you ask about they say things like he can't answer back um uh it's one
00:09:47 of the things they love saying if you criticize a bbc journal it seems to me he gets a chance to
00:09:50 answer the whole time all day um on all channels so um it's about time that the positions were
00:09:56 reversed did it feel like being in the enemy camp well no i mean there are a lot of people i like
00:10:05 very much um on the bbc and a lot of very talented people and they don't all have the same view um
00:10:11 And I particularly like the people you never see.
00:10:13 I mean, there are a lot of very nice young producers
00:10:15 and assistants and, but so I didn't feel
00:10:21 that I was suffering persecution at all,
00:10:24 but you certainly feel that you are regarded
00:10:29 as a very strange creature. 0.99
00:10:31 Well, I suppose that might be true.
00:10:33 And that you sort of shouldn't be there really.
00:10:41 um that point you raised about roger harabin um and the way that you were not allowed to
00:10:48 to cross question him or talk to him at all actually talk to him at all yeah um or get
00:10:53 anyone else to i should add i mean i suggested why doesn't he talk to i think i wanted him to
00:10:58 talk to matt ridley um who's a brilliant commentator on the environment but no no but um this touches
00:11:06 on a more general point which is the way the BBC avoids engaging with its critics would you agree?
00:11:13 Yes I mean like all bureaucracies it has a tremendous palaver of engagement so there are
00:11:21 all sorts of sort of feedbacky type systems but also like all bureaucracies it knows how to suffocate
00:11:27 these things so it's very difficult to have a true engagement in these matters on air
00:11:39 i did one thing i did once that struck me about that was i appeared on question time and
00:11:47 fiona bruce was in the chair and it was after the brexit result sometime after the brexit result
00:11:53 and early on I said I would just like to say I'm honoured to be here but I would just like to say
00:12:01 that of the five panellists I'm the only person who voted for Brexit and 51% of the British people
00:12:10 voted for Brexit but only 20% of the people on the panel and this doesn't seem to be unusual
00:12:16 seems to be what you do almost every week and obviously they couldn't actually stop me saying
00:12:23 that but i've never been asked on the program again no they don't take kindly to that kind of
00:12:27 public criticism but the brexit issue which you raised i think was a point at which for quite a
00:12:34 lot of people the the penny dropped about the bbc because um i don't know if you'd agree but
00:12:39 the the bbc's coverage of brexit seemed to me so obviously lopsided that um you know more people
00:12:49 suddenly became aware of the problem um well i would like to divide the bbc's coverage uh on
00:12:56 brexit of brexit into two because i think it tells you something about how it all works and how bias
00:13:01 works during the actual campaign referendum campaign they were in fact quite fair because
00:13:07 there are very strict rules which go down to counting by seconds how many seconds or minutes
00:13:14 each side can have and they're quite easy to enforce you just have to be very careful about
00:13:19 doing it and the BBC is good at that sort of thing that they can work that out and it's fine
00:13:22 but the moment the result came in and then you had a tirade and torrent of opposition to Brexit
00:13:33 going on for months and months and months first of all just expressing utter shock that it could
00:13:38 have happened because they truly truly didn't believe it could have happened and then as they
00:13:42 began to concert with others to come to believe that they could reverse it by some means perhaps
00:13:49 the second referendum perhaps judicial reversal perhaps a general election where it would go the
00:13:54 other way whatever and there the BBC was more biased than I've ever seen it I would say as a
00:14:01 general proposition and and then you're right I think that this became very apparent to the public
00:14:08 and was very significant in Boris Johnson
00:14:12 becoming leader of the Tory party
00:14:15 and leading the Tories to a huge victory
00:14:18 at the December 19th election.
00:14:22 And how systematic do you think
00:14:25 that sort of bias is at the BBC?
00:14:29 I mean, how is it that on an issue of that scale,
00:14:35 After all, the major cleavage in British politics over the past 50 years, really, the European issue.
00:14:44 Why is the BBC so out of sync with public opinion?
00:14:51 Well, of course, some of it, to use the cliches, is to do with a particular sort of what people used to call a clerisy
00:15:00 of people educated in the same places
00:15:05 with the same views,
00:15:06 almost sort of hereditary caste.
00:15:12 Then I think there is,
00:15:16 therefore there tends to be a common view
00:15:18 and therefore they tend not to notice
00:15:19 what else is happening.
00:15:21 So I think one mustn't underrate
00:15:21 the extent of shock at the result,
00:15:25 not just that they didn't like it,
00:15:26 but they were absolutely amazed by it
00:15:28 because they really hardly ever met people who wanted brexit i mean of course i exaggerate but
00:15:36 not very much actually particularly not met socially you know they perhaps would have met
00:15:39 someone interviewing them for some news event or something but um and so they they couldn't
00:15:47 couldn't cope with it and in a funny i think that shows that they are rather a ruling caste
00:15:56 because one of the things about a ruling caste is it doesn't feel the need to question
00:16:00 itself much because it's ruling so if you're if you're ruling things must be quite good mustn't
00:16:07 they and so i'm a bit like when you know the foreign office completely misjudged the state
00:16:12 of iran before um the fall of the shah because the shah was uh pro-british and he seemed quite
00:16:19 a charming chap and everything and his opponents seemed to be maniacs and a lot of them were
00:16:24 unfortunately um and so they would keep on reporting that um the foreign office would that
00:16:30 you know it was all fine and then suddenly it happens um and it's happened ever since for the
00:16:36 since 1978-79 and um so there's a sort of conspiracy an unintended conspiracy against
00:16:44 understanding in the bbc i mean the popular way or the fashionable way of talking about this is to
00:16:50 say that uh you know people exist within their own intellectual social bubble and that is maybe
00:16:58 the explanation of the bbc yes and i think this is particularly true if you're because of the way
00:17:07 it's funded that might sound might it might sound strange to say that because you would think that
00:17:13 a license fee paid for compulsory by everybody would make the bbc very attentive to everybody
00:17:18 but it doesn't work like that because you know you're going to get the money come what may
00:17:22 and um you can't lose the audience or you can lose the audience but you can't lose the money
00:17:28 and um so you can um keep cracking on with whatever it is that obsesses you
00:17:34 and within very broad limits you will go on being allowed to do that whereas whatever the faults of
00:17:41 a newspaper if you're talking rubbish that readers don't like or even if you're telling
00:17:46 the truth which the readers don't like um you will lose the readers um what did you make of the
00:17:54 of the the scandal we're still sort of seeing unfold before our eyes that the bashier scandal
00:17:59 i mean that is um well let me ask you what do you think that tells us about the bbc
00:18:06 when the bashier scandal um finally completely broke and we got the dyson report
00:18:14 tim davy the new director general um of the bbc who i believe is sincere in trying to
00:18:20 restore impartiality was interviewed on the today program and he said some good things but i thought
00:18:26 he made a bad mistake because he said um that the bbc investigates itself more than any other
00:18:34 media organization in the world which is a very very strange thing to say about something which
00:18:39 has taken 25 years to come out so for a quarter of a century theoretically it did investigate
00:18:45 itself because it had an original internal inquiry at the time but actually it didn't
00:18:49 and it's pretty clear that it deliberately didn't and it's pretty clear that in 2016 when it
00:18:56 rehired Martin Bashir it was not repentant about the whole thing and indeed it may possibly been
00:19:04 trying to cover up something about Martin Bashir or keep him quiet by rehiring him
00:19:08 so the truth about self-investigation I mean yes he's right the BBC is obsessed
00:19:19 with process and it incessantly has inquiries about this that and the other
00:19:22 but when it considers that its vital interests are at stake it has a brilliant
00:19:29 way of glossing over whatever that problem is so the Jimmy Savile case would
00:19:34 be another very important one and the typical reasons why it would gloss over would be the
00:19:40 protection of a box office success such as Jimmy Savile or the protection of its own reputation
00:19:48 such as Bashir or the obsession with a scoop which is also to some extent Bashir
00:19:57 and there is a potential conflict between the charter of the BBC and scoops not complete of
00:20:06 course but one of the things that often happens with the scoop is that you have to obtain it very
00:20:12 fast and by very unusual means now the BBC obviously shouldn't rule that out but the danger
00:20:19 with such scoops is that they suspend the ethics of your process which are particularly important
00:20:26 in a license-feeing situation.
00:20:30 And that they make you exaggerate the importance of what you've got
00:20:34 so that you don't apply a calm news judgment to it.
00:20:39 And I think both of those things were going on in that case.
00:20:42 And it is very, very, very iniquitous what happened.
00:20:44 I mean, it's particularly iniquitous in relation to the monarchy and the royal family
00:20:49 because the unspoken deal, almost a spoken deal,
00:20:56 is that because the BBC is the national broadcaster,
00:20:59 it always broadcasts all state occasions
00:21:03 involving the monarchy uniquely
00:21:04 and has a trusted role in all of that.
00:21:09 It would therefore, you would expect,
00:21:10 deal with the authorities properly and fairly.
00:21:15 And it must be remembered that when Diana gave this famous interview,
00:21:18 she was still royal.
00:21:19 She hadn't yet divorced the Prince of Wales
00:21:22 and she was protected by the royal system
00:21:24 in terms of private secretaries, press secretaries, where she lived, everything.
00:21:32 And they chose to conceal the whole thing from Buckingham Palace and all the system.
00:21:40 So they were breaching trust in that respect,
00:21:42 and they were completely forgetting their role as a national broadcaster.
00:21:46 You can't, there's this constant desire in the BBC to have it both ways.
00:21:51 And this, of course, breaks trust.
00:21:53 do you think that there's a suggestion there of a sort of incipient republicanism within the bbc
00:22:01 no i wouldn't say there was incipient i'm no doubt some are republican what i think
00:22:07 there is is a sort of sneer about patriotism so you have absurd i mean it really did turn out to
00:22:17 be true that the bbc was trying to get rural britannia out of the proms for example i mean
00:22:20 just ludicrous i mean i don't regard this as a deeply important story because the fundamental
00:22:26 thing about the proms is music not um patriotic display but there's a long tradition of the last
00:22:32 night of the proms it's very popular it's absolutely fine um it's not hostile racist
00:22:38 or anything like that it's jolly and the idea that they the british broadcasting corporation
00:22:44 should be trying to slough this off pretending it wasn't um it's just ridiculous and that's the
00:22:54 sort of thing it's not um some very ideological political agenda about we we should be a republic
00:23:02 it's not sort of careful marxist uh stuff it's it's a sort of snobbery um and an embarrassment
00:23:12 about the idea that we should be proud of our country 0.85
00:23:15 and particularly that we should show we're proud of our country.
00:23:18 It was George Orwell who said, wasn't it,
00:23:21 that English intellectuals would be more embarrassed
00:23:25 to stand up for God save the Queen than they would be to...
00:23:28 So tell me this, you mentioned Tim Davy
00:23:33 and he has been saying the right things, hasn't he,
00:23:36 about restoring impartiality.
00:23:38 and there seems to be a reform program that he has in mind do you think the bbc is reformable
00:23:47 well there are two separate questions about reform of the bbc um one is the sort of question
00:23:57 of how does it behave and be run and all that sort of thing and the other is whether you get
00:24:02 rid of the license fee how is it financed which relate but are different and I do believe that
00:24:11 the license fee will was always wrong but was enforceable and now it's still wrong and it's
00:24:18 not enforceable so it will have to go I mean it's lasted a very long time longer than I expected
00:24:26 they're very clever at perpetuating it um and it's only recently that license fee i think it
00:24:32 was last year perhaps or the year before that license fee revenue fell for the first time
00:24:35 um but it must go um because of technology because the whole younger generation doesn't
00:24:43 buy television licenses all that sort of thing um it will go it's just question of when um
00:24:49 and how you construct the sort of financing way out of it nobody has really yet worked out though
00:24:55 I think Tim Davey is something he's thought about quite a lot.
00:24:59 Then there's the question of how should they behave.
00:25:03 And it seems to me that if you justify some unique advantageous system of financing,
00:25:08 whether it's a license fee or something else, there, and here Mr. Davey is quite right,
00:25:14 impartiality is the absolute key to it.
00:25:17 Because what is it otherwise that you bring to the party that you can't get,
00:25:22 that you can't guarantee any other way?
00:25:23 and how can you make demand that everybody pays for it if what they're getting is not
00:25:29 is in fact partial just so obvious such an obvious moral point it seems to me totally
00:25:35 indisputable and that does mean that there are constraints on the type of journalism that you
00:25:41 can do which are different from the constraints on me at the daily telegraph or whatever it's
00:25:47 because of the fact that people have to pay for it and also that it's supposed to serve everybody
00:25:52 So not only by being impartial, but also trying to cater for the right range of interests and occupations and regions.
00:26:03 And I don't think most BBC people at the top really think that way.
00:26:12 They sort of try to, most of them, but actually they don't.
00:26:16 They're more carried away by what they care about.
00:26:20 And the way King C. Amos always used to put it, the novelist used to put it like this, he said, what people are obsessed with in the BBC is what he called, how will it go down at the club?
00:26:34 Meaning, what will my colleagues think about it?
00:26:38 Not what will the viewers think about it?
00:26:44 and you i mean i'm always amused me the bbc uses the word brave when talking about themselves which
00:26:50 shows confirms this very much a program they will say is brave is one which runs no risk at all
00:27:00 within the organization for the person making it because they will he will be congratulated by
00:27:04 colleagues because it'll be about you know how awful um boris is or something like that um uh
00:27:10 And, you know, or exposing something which we all know is bad, like racism or being very challenging in your questions to a conservative minister or something like that.
00:27:24 That's brave. I remember picking this up years and years ago.
00:27:29 I was invited to a religious broadcasting conference and everybody there was from religious broadcasting, mostly from the public sector, except for me and one or two others.
00:27:39 and they kept saying this was in the late 80s they kept saying how brave they were because on
00:27:43 all these religious programs they made programs which was were in favor of aid sufferers um
00:27:50 and the implication being they were defying a sort of massive um uh anti-gay um consensus which
00:28:01 you know was really putting them at risk but there wasn't that massive anti-gay consensus
00:28:10 and there was a there was very widespread compassion for age sufferers and it wasn't
00:28:19 brave it might have been right but it wasn't brave to make these programs and in fact what
00:28:26 would have been brave in a religious program would be if they got on a sort of tub thumping
00:28:30 damn sodomy type character who, you know, I don't think such people are good people, 0.89
00:28:39 but, you know, they could put that religious position, that's religious broadcasting, if you
00:28:43 like, because you would never get that. You'd never ever get that. Now, that would have been,
00:28:47 suppose you'd have one person on Thought for the Day who said, actually, you know, if people didn't 0.69
00:28:53 have gay sex, they wouldn't get AIDS, and God condemns it and all the rest. Now, that would 0.90
00:28:58 have been very unattractive but brave and and do you see what i mean so they kept thinking what
00:29:06 courage they were showing but they in fact led very protected lives um it's interesting you talk
00:29:11 a touch on the religious issue because we interviewed um someone from a small charity
00:29:16 called aid to the church in need yes very good yeah um and um he was talking about a specific
00:29:22 concern of his, which is that the BBC seems to give very little attention to, put very little
00:29:32 effort into, the persecution of Christians in countries like Iraq or in Pakistan, where some
00:29:39 terrible things have happened. I just wondered if the same thing strikes you too. I am very struck
00:29:45 by the extreme sensitivity about what might be called Islamophobia and the lack of interest
00:29:52 in the plight of Christians in persecuted countries.
00:29:59 I think it's very marked, actually.
00:30:01 And while I think it's absolutely right to be very careful about being unfair about any
00:30:07 great religion, I think it does prevent, first of all, the Christians are suffering in many
00:30:14 of these places and this is unheard their cries are unheard and secondly I think there are
00:30:22 definitely new situations in which the BBC doesn't tell you what's explain what's going on because
00:30:27 it's frightened of saying something which might offend in their view offend Muslims and I've
00:30:31 noticed recent examples of this what's happening in Africa where Islamist violence has been
00:30:39 described in other ways and I and I noticed for example that there was a lot of kidnapping this
00:30:46 was I think earlier this year of children in Nigeria and when this was first reported on the
00:30:55 BBC I noticed specifically that they didn't mention the possibility of an Islamist motive
00:31:02 and so there was talk about criminals or ransoms or that sort of thing and it emerged later
00:31:10 reporting other sources that it was indeed Boko Haram I think and that it was a religious motive
00:31:18 which by the way doesn't necessarily exclude ransom because Islamists believe in ransom as
00:31:24 a religious duty in some situations and gradually what tends to happen in those situations the BBC
00:31:31 ends up reporting it but only when it's got the cover from other people doing so and similarly
00:31:34 it's reporting on Mozambique recently where they were chopping off the heads of people on the beach
00:31:39 Islamists was a bit like that though it got to the truth a bit quicker but you know it's um
00:31:45 you can see that hesitancy and I and back home you can see it so um this teacher who had to leave 0.92
00:31:52 the school in Batley um because he'd shown the uh pupils the Charlie Hebdo cartoons all the sort of
00:32:01 presumption of innocence was not given to him his motives were called in question
00:32:10 it was suggested that he might be islamophobic or you know incredibly ill-judged or something like
00:32:16 that and they didn't make inquiries about who these people are who are attacking him which and
00:32:23 i looked some of it up and you could see that the under the sort of rather thin veneer of
00:32:28 charities very small charities you would find people who are putting forward very extreme views
00:32:33 who were imams or sort of um that sort of thing um uh uh condemning the man so they're very
00:32:45 uninvestigative of you know they love investigation sometimes but not of things like that and what do
00:32:51 think explains that I mean this sort of this as it were this protective attitude towards Islam
00:32:58 and yet this indifference to verging sometimes even on hostility to Christianity what what
00:33:06 explains that well whatever explains it it's not that many people on the BBC are Muslims because
00:33:13 not many of them are and it's not because they wish to advance Islam in that sense I think it's
00:33:20 combination of um fear um of being accused really of racism because often the whole question about
00:33:30 islam is seen in race terms which is quite wrong but it is um uh and also of a assumption of
00:33:39 who's bad in the world and who's good and this is becoming more explicit now with critical race
00:33:44 theory which is itself racist because what it what it so for example a thing put out by
00:33:50 cambridge university vice chancellor last week made this clear that um what he called whiteness
00:33:55 was actually bad in itself which seems to me that is a racist theory i mean that's like saying
00:34:03 that's like the south african apartheid theory the other way around um and um therefore and i
00:34:11 think the BBC sort of some vague inarticulate way subscribes to something like that so unless
00:34:18 proved otherwise the white person and particularly the white man is guilty in any situation if all
00:34:25 you can see is you know one brown person or one black person and one white person
00:34:29 who's guilty it'll be the white one and that's where they start of course they don't always come 0.65
00:34:37 to that final conclusion I mean they're not completely crazy but that's how they start and 0.74
00:34:41 And that's why, for example, they capitulated abjectly to Black Lives Matter after the death of George Floyd in all their coverage was entirely uncritical of Black Lives Matter and treated it as the authentic expression of all blacks, really, and indeed of all right thinking people. 0.72
00:35:01 um and therefore you know when they started knocking down statues and having rats and all
00:35:08 that sort of thing no effort was made to work out who are these people what's their ideology
00:35:12 whom do they represent um their their right and you sort of and often within the bbc staff
00:35:21 organizations that sort of thing are now very powerful and often seem to dictate content which
00:35:27 should surely be decided by editorial not by staff organizations um uh insist on one way of
00:35:34 looking at it and so again though the bbc gradually this unscrambled a bit over time and they've said
00:35:40 a little bit more about um about this essentially their encourage their coverage of black lives
00:35:47 matter has been unilluminating and biased but isn't it extraordinary that an organization which is
00:35:55 I think still one of the largest, if not the largest, employer of journalists in the world
00:36:00 should have such incuriosity about something so salient to our society today.
00:36:13 Yes, and I think there's a lot of very able and well-informed people in the BBC,
00:36:17 and I think a lot of them do feel oppressed by this.
00:36:19 In fact, I know they do, because I sometimes talk to them.
00:36:20 um they might not share my particular obsessions and political views i don't know but they but they
00:36:27 a lot of people then want to be fair and they also have as you say intellectual curiosity
00:36:32 but but bureaucracies operate by fear to a very large extent and
00:36:37 what they're frightened of is being accused of something like islamophobia much more than
00:36:43 they're frightened of being accused of bias um and so they do have very unenquiring minds it 0.84
00:36:50 It comes back to something I was saying about my objection to them in the Thatch years was simply not explaining.
00:36:55 I would also say this about the after events, everything that's gone on since 9-11, 0.70
00:37:02 that I've had very few, some very good people who have done something like this, like John Ware, for example.
00:37:08 But on the whole, the distinction between Islamism and mainstream Islam is never properly explained on the BBC.
00:37:20 And therefore, in some curious way, the BBC is fulfilling the right wing view that the sort of uneducated right wing view that all Muslims are extreme because the people it gets on all the time are pretty extreme.
00:37:33 And and there's no actual interest in the theology of Islam, the differences between different sects and parts, the more quietest spiritual traditions of Sufis and so on and so on.
00:37:47 it's it's um it's just we let's get a muslim let's get a muslim on and of course which muslim
00:37:57 they get on the whole the ones who shout the loudest um which and if you think about it that
00:38:01 is a racist idea you don't say let's get a white man on um you don't even say let's get a christian
00:38:07 on you'd say you probably say let's get a bishop on or an anglican bishop on or a catholic bishop
00:38:14 or something like that um so you get absolute misrepresentation and the misrepresentation is
00:38:25 very great but it's done out of a misunderstanding which is actually rather unsympathetic to
00:38:33 islam john pontifex of acn said that this was a matter of what he called religious illiteracy
00:38:40 yes and that of course is a much wider problem than the bbc there's a general religious illiteracy
00:38:47 um i remember a um a white christian friend of mine in the media or theoretically christian
00:38:56 friend of mine in the media i was given a um for her child a a little catholic kiddies book
00:39:03 with pretty pictures and things like that and it say it said um at one point pray for us sinners
00:39:09 us sinners now and at the hour of our death which is of course from the ave maria and she said why
00:39:15 do they have to mention why do they all go funny these religious things why do you have to mention
00:39:18 death in a book for children and had no idea that this is the main prayer of catholics and um and
00:39:25 um so it's a very widespread problem and bbc's not alone in that but given its immense resources
00:39:32 this is another of my frustrations only the bbc because of its huge journalistic resources could
00:39:37 do these things in depth actually in modern times they're the only organization who could
00:39:42 and they don't um finally let's just look to the future a bit um we've got the advent of this new
00:39:50 station gb news um two things in general terms do you welcome that and do you think that it might
00:39:59 conceivably have an impact on the bbc well i certainly do welcome gb news and i welcome um
00:40:05 all sort of entrance to the market from wherever they come um i don't look forward to
00:40:12 the sort of slugging match if that's what it becomes like fox news versus cnn or something
00:40:19 like that because i don't think fox news spread i mean it certainly spreads more heat than light
00:40:25 but um it it must surely be better if there is competition um and out of competition not always
00:40:34 not every time and not necessarily quickly but on the whole comes something better so
00:40:40 the BBC perhaps in reacting to if if GB news is a success perhaps the BBC will come to
00:40:49 look to its own lights and perhaps set about competing on that new territory which GB news
00:41:00 maybe, gathers to itself.
00:41:06 You have to get a lot of scale
00:41:08 to compete with the BBC on these issues.
00:41:11 And because of our broadcasting system,
00:41:14 if you break through to that scale,
00:41:17 you come under the same bureaucracy
00:41:18 and you start to move in the same circles
00:41:22 and you repeat the same attitude.
00:41:24 So actually, Sky nowadays and ITV
00:41:27 rather are not super different from the BBC they have many similar problems and they behave in a
00:41:33 similar way and Channel 4 in particular is quite preposterously biased though it's theoretically
00:41:40 under the same impartiality rules so I think the problem now is you have a sort of big television
00:41:48 establishment which is dominated by the BBC but it's not solely the BBC and then you have minnows
00:41:54 coming in from the outside who are genuine competitors but very hard for them to get the
00:41:58 scale so um i don't expect some sort of great breakthrough about that soon what i think
00:42:03 will definitely happen but quite when is that the fundamental monopoly about the money will
00:42:11 will go um as conservatives we're supposed to want to conserve things and we want to conserve
00:42:19 institutions. Are you one of those who could be brought round to thinking that the BBC
00:42:30 should be abolished? Or do you take the view that it is such a valuable cultural resource
00:42:37 in the country that it must be reformed and we must work hard to achieve that?
00:42:45 i think it would be fair given the importance of the bbc in british history and the way
00:42:53 many aspects of it are still admired and enjoyed to give it a chance so um therefore
00:43:01 i was pleased when tim davy was appointed rather than thinking wouldn't it have been better if
00:43:07 they'd appointed an extreme lefty and then we could the enemy would have been in more plain
00:43:11 sight do you see what i mean i wish him well um uh it may be possible to at least to make the bbc
00:43:19 better before it eventually breaks up um worth a try um but uh it can't really last and probably
00:43:28 it would have been better not invented because it's a fundamentally monopolistic idea and it's
00:43:35 as the technology has changed it's become that's become clearer and if you think of it in other
00:43:40 forms of expressions I suppose you'd only had the British publishing company and that had to
00:43:44 maintain that only the British publishing company could publish a book and it could publish as many
00:43:50 books as it liked because they'd get the money anyway and whatever book it wanted and no other
00:43:54 books you could immediately see that this was wrong this was a affront to freedom and a suppression
00:44:02 of creativity and for all its definite historic virtues that's what the BBC is it's an affront
00:44:09 to freedom and a crush of creativity and um you notice and though i said just now that
00:44:18 the big competitors tend to be too close to it in some sort of way this isn't so true of things
00:44:23 like netflix so one of the big things that's always said about the bbc was um you know you
00:44:28 can't have these marvelous drama series if you can't get all the money in for the license it
00:44:32 turns out not to be true at all you can have very very good drama series in other ways of
00:44:36 reaching people such as modern technology. So I don't hate the BBC root and branch at all,
00:44:46 but I think it betrays its duties. And I also think it is a model which is out of date.
00:44:55 Lord Moor, thank you.