New Culture Forum - March 15, 2022


Defending Masculinity & Tackling The Male Crisis

Inside Putin's Mind: His Goals, Motivation & World View - What The West Needs to Understand Konstantin Kisin on Russia, Ukraine + Western Response

Episode Stats


Length

34 minutes

Words per minute

188.74

Word count

6,543

Sentence count

154


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now my guest today is the
00:00:26 philosopher and author Nina Power very pleased that she's joining us she has
00:00:31 just written her latest book what do men want masculinity and its discontents
00:00:39 timely I think you look great you know why did you write this book well I think
00:00:47 increasingly it was partly to do with this kind of feeling I was getting that
00:00:52 men were being kind of demonised increasingly like left-wing and liberal
00:00:56 press and I'd already written quite a bit about feminism and I think a lot of
00:01:01 what describes itself as feminism today isn't actually feminism but rather a
00:01:04 kind of sort of superficial ideological cover story for other things that are
00:01:10 going on so I actually wanted to write something that was reasonable and
00:01:15 balanced I wanted to look at some of the supposed complaints of so-called men's
00:01:19 rights activists and see if there was what was going on with them rather than just do this kind
00:01:24 of dismissive demonization which i think we see a lot particularly in the last five years yep it
00:01:32 what i found interesting is you you wrote what men really want could a man have could a man write a
00:01:39 book with that title do you think well i mean the the title is obviously a joke a reference to freud
00:01:45 in two ways so obviously famously or infamously Freud says what does woman want and he doesn't
00:01:50 know the answer yeah um so i thought i would make a joke about that and of course sometimes some
00:01:57 people have responded uh in an upset way to the title is it how dare you you know um well you mean
00:02:04 how dare you presume to know yes exactly and of course i say that i don't answer the question i
00:02:09 mean i have a list in the book where i've asked my male friends and they've given me like a one
00:02:13 or two word answer like a beer or a shed or to be left alone and these kind of things um but of
00:02:19 course there is no one answer to this question but i wanted to pitch it in that way because
00:02:23 i wanted to talk about desire and this more kind of psychoanalytic level to some extent like to get
00:02:28 beneath the kind of culture war stuff um either the sort of demonization of men or of the kind of
00:02:34 i don't know uh maybe sometimes overly simplistic idea that men are one thing and that one thing
00:02:41 would be what? Yeah, I suppose, well, to be honest, the more I wrote the book, the more I found that I
00:02:48 had sympathy with a certain kind of masculinist discourse, actually, which is about what it means
00:02:53 to recover manhood or masculinity in an era which seems like it wants to destroy it, you know, and
00:03:01 that would go in relation to being a good man, to being a father, you know, to simply being somebody
00:03:07 who looks after themselves and looks after other people and sort of takes responsibility so actually
00:03:12 it became more of a book about those bigger questions about almost like moral virtue to
00:03:18 some extent and the way in which being a good man seems to be occluded or obscured in our kind of
00:03:24 liberal degenerate world but I also it also became a book about the relationship between men and
00:03:31 women as well um so i talk about this idea of hetero sociality like we're in this very mixed
00:03:37 world you know all of these kind of separate spheres have been eroded and we're together all
00:03:42 the time at school at work and you know in in general and and i suppose it's like uh it's a
00:03:48 question about the limits of that mixed liberal project it's like you know and i think a lot of
00:03:53 people are asking themselves these questions you know how have we gone too far in certain ways and
00:03:59 And are there ways in which we can preserve difference, sexual difference, for example, where it's important to do so?
00:04:06 You know, and we see these kind of tensions, these blurring of the boundaries constantly, and they're causing a kind of great deal of upset.
00:04:12 So, I mean, I wanted to write something that was reasonable and balanced, which I think in the current climate is almost provocative because everything seems to have to be polemical.
00:04:20 Yeah. You know, and I didn't want to do that.
00:04:22 You actually make the point at the beginning, which I think is very important.
00:04:25 You said, I'm going to use the words sex throughout the book as opposed to gender.
00:04:30 This is one of the big things, isn't it?
00:04:32 I mean, basically biological sex as opposed to gender, which is where so many of the arguments now stem from.
00:04:41 Yeah, for sure. So, I mean, I think gender, it was a mistake in a way to ever use that word.
00:04:45 it came from john money who is you know a kind of disgraced um researcher who tried to use it to
00:04:52 say that there is a difference between sex and and the social reception of sex and he he thought
00:04:57 that he could um bring up boys as if they were girls and that this wouldn't have any uh when
00:05:02 was that actually i didn't realize when did he do this um i'm not sure of the dates but it's
00:05:08 there were a couple of boys one of whom lost his genitals in an accident and john money decided to
00:05:13 with the parents consent to bring up the boy as if he were a girl um and but a lot of his practice
00:05:19 was extremely unethical and both of the boys um ended up committing suicide and john money is
00:05:25 really very disgraced figure but i so basically and then you know some of the second way feminists
00:05:31 use gender as a way of talking about social expectation and social constructs you know the
00:05:35 idea that on top of sex there is expectation that is particularly narrow so that boys must behave
00:05:41 in one way and girls must behave in another and obviously they wanted to challenge that and then
00:05:45 for both boys and girls and to say no social expectation should be kind of um abolished or
00:05:52 eliminated and that everybody should be free to express themselves however they want and that
00:05:56 historically this has been particularly detrimental uh for girls who have been kind of channeled into
00:06:01 narrow you know roles um so there was a kind of strategic use of gender at a particular point
00:06:08 in the 70s and i think that filtered down as someone who was at school in the 1990s you know
00:06:13 there was a kind of uh ambient second wave idea not explicitly but the idea that you could be
00:06:18 anything it didn't matter if you were a girl you could you know be interested in things that were
00:06:23 historically boy things or whatever you know so but since then there's been this kind of i think
00:06:28 very regressive move towards thinking of gender as something that is a feeling you know that something
00:06:35 like a almost like a gnostic idea of like the soul it's like your true self is this yeah um
00:06:41 and it's kind of completely detached from your your body as if you're not your body um and so
00:06:47 we've entered into this kind of uh weird paradigm in which the choosing of the self has become this
00:06:54 kind of liberal apex um and that we must all kind of go on this bizarre journey to discover our
00:07:01 individuality which is completely compatible with consumer capitalism and
00:07:05 the liberal individualism at its worst yes so I think along with a lot of
00:07:10 women in particular but not only I think that I wanted to be strategic as well in
00:07:16 my use of saying like being very clear and saying like sex is real you know
00:07:19 men exist women exist you know it's important to recognize these things and
00:07:24 not drift off into some kind of fantasy that we can all choose our sex that
00:07:28 doesn't mean that people can't express themselves wherever they want you know
00:07:31 but it's it's just not to go so far into this fantasy you know where I think
00:07:38 people are encouraged to live in a way that is actually very detrimental to
00:07:43 themselves you know but rather accept a certain level of basic reality which has
00:07:48 social and political consequences for all of us. I think actually what's
00:07:52 interesting about that you alluded there is that you know the whole the whole
00:07:56 idea you know oh well you you don't have to the girl doesn't have to like pink the boy doesn't
00:08:00 have to automatically like blue growing up that sort of almost seems quaint now because what's
00:08:06 happening now particularly with the trans lobby is that they're they're looking at a boy who only
00:08:11 likes pink and and and maybe dolls and they're saying well he's obviously a girl then this is
00:08:17 we've sort of gone back it's like you know what are you talking about i mean you know the old
00:08:22 old liberal position was hey you know what's wrong with a boy liking that now it's well looking at
00:08:27 him saying well actually to all intents and purposes you're obviously a girl so let's start
00:08:31 giving you uh you know puberty blockers or whatever it is no it's insane i mean it's child
00:08:36 abuse and it's completely regressive um it also um punishes children who may be gay who are gender
00:08:42 non-conforming you know a lot of people have been pointing at this out lgb alliance um defending
00:08:47 same sex on the basis of, you know, sex as sexual attraction. I think, you know, making children
00:08:55 make decisions about their fertility when they don't even maybe know what that means
00:08:58 will be looked back upon with kind of horror. You know, we already see a lot of people
00:09:04 de-transitioning. I think there'll be a lot of legal cases about this. And of course,
00:09:10 like many people, especially women, have been severely punished for saying anything about this,
00:09:15 whether it's to do with the importance of sex in law or women's sports, which is also kind of being destroyed by narcissists.
00:09:23 And I think, you know, one of the problems we've got is a culture that actually rewards forms of parental narcissism and even like Munchausen by proxy.
00:09:31 You know, you like you can get a lot of attention if you say that your kid is trans, you know, and it's there's a kind of social contagion aspect to it.
00:09:38 But I think this is, you know, ultimately, there's there are lots of terrible aspects to this and lots of horrifying aspects.
00:09:45 And I think the way the idea that children can be trans and, you know, if a child says, I prefer doing this thing than another,
00:09:53 then therefore they must be the opposite sex is one of the most regressive ideas that has emerged in the past few years.
00:10:00 One of the ideas that has emerged is this whole phenomena of supposed toxic masculinity.
00:10:06 Yeah.
00:10:07 Now, it's interesting, you know, because quite recently I was at dinner and there were other
00:10:11 people at the table and, in fact, Ollie, our cameraman was with me so he can attest to
00:10:17 this.
00:10:18 Basically, we were sitting at a table and there was a young woman and she was explaining
00:10:24 to her friends there why everything had gone wrong with her relationship.
00:10:29 And she kept referring to toxic masculinity.
00:10:32 What I found odd about that was that she put it down to some objective thing as well.
00:10:38 I mean, I don't know what was wrong with the relationship.
00:10:40 Obviously, I don't know them.
00:10:41 But it was very interesting that she used that phrase.
00:10:45 Do you think we should just stop using this phrase?
00:10:48 Yeah.
00:10:49 No, for sure.
00:10:50 I mean, I think there's, you know, one of the things I try and talk about in the book is like, you know, often when relationships break down, it's not particularly anyone's fault.
00:10:57 And a lot of the time people are looking to be the victim when actually it might just have been a bad relationship.
00:11:02 And but I think it's very morally important that we say that everyone is capable of harm.
00:11:07 Right. Everyone is capable, men and women, of both causing harm and also being harmed.
00:11:12 Right. Because if the moment you start saying, well, women are always the victims, then you kind of deny the moral agency.
00:11:17 And we're back to, you know, some very, very hierarchical model.
00:11:21 Right. Which I totally want to avoid. Like I think life is is risk.
00:11:24 You know, someone like Camille Paglia is amazing on this stuff, you know, and I think I agree with her on this this question of risk and reality.
00:11:32 And yes, I think it's it's just a very easy way of saying of kind of releasing oneself from any culpability.
00:11:40 If you can talk, you know, appeal to this supposed ontological thing, it doesn't mean that men can't behave badly, but but so can women, you know.
00:11:50 Do you think there do you think there is such a thing as toxic femininity?
00:11:52 Yes, I do. I mean, I think if we're going to say there's toxic masculinity, if we are, yes, I mean, it might be things like the kind of the HR woman or, you know, the kind of, I don't know, the feminisation of particular institutions, which I think has been severely detrimental for, you know, again, a sort of acceptance of risk and the grey area and playfulness and the fact that people make mistakes.
00:12:17 you know i think i think there are tendencies um in both sexes that we might want to i don't know
00:12:23 discuss but in a more light-hearted way yes you know i mean like there's there's always a kind
00:12:28 of game and a playfulness like between the sexes you know and it's not always to do with sex it's
00:12:32 to do with discourse and and how we get along you know but i think yeah it's it's always this kind
00:12:38 of question of balance and i think in some ways some things have been overly feminized right to
00:12:44 you know what would those things be i mean i think i know like you're talking about risk averse thing
00:12:49 right um if one's going to talk about classic things it would be maybe um a very strong sense
00:12:55 of safety for example would that be a fact would that be a feminine thing do you think or not yeah
00:13:00 potentially i mean i think in some senses it makes sense you know if you if you want to protect your
00:13:05 children and so on it makes sense to be able to understand which men might be predators right
00:13:10 But this is actually something that's also being eroded by our kind of liberal culture, which is to do with female intuition and who isn't and who isn't isn't trustworthy, you know, and if you're being told, no, you're not allowed to say that, you know, about particular men, then you're also eliminating that.
00:13:26 So I think, but I don't know, I think like primary schools, for example, was a classic example of where women dominate and often this seems to mitigate against young boys in a way being allowed to behave in the way that they do without being punished, if you saw what I mean, or what without being put on drugs for their supposed bad behavior.
00:13:49 I mean, I increasingly think that probably schools should go back to being segregated for everyone's sake.
00:13:53 Right. OK. OK.
00:13:54 Yeah.
00:13:55 Mine was. I mean, was yours?
00:13:57 No, I went to a comprehensive school.
00:13:59 Well, mine was just an old-fashioned grammar school.
00:14:01 Yeah.
00:14:01 But it was sort of segregated.
00:14:06 I think what's interesting, there's another point that came up in reading the book,
00:14:11 is that we're going to talk a bit about your politics,
00:14:15 but broadly you might say it would be considered not a left-wing,
00:14:19 well, yes, partly a left-wing perspective,
00:14:22 which is that a lot of this has come down to the dominance of hyper-individual capitalism,
00:14:30 that basically we're all just consumers and it doesn't really matter.
00:14:34 So you talk about these various institutions, well, such as family, honour, religion,
00:14:40 those sort of things, has been washed away by consumer capitalism.
00:14:46 And this is what has brought about, in some ways, this problem for men. Is that right?
00:14:51 Yeah, partly. I mean, I think I'm very influenced by people like Ivan Illich, who's a kind of renegade Catholic thinker who wrote some very brilliant books that were critical of institutions, but also kind of defended ideas of conviviality and of a kind of social life and a spiritual life outside of the institution and outside of this kind of, you know, increasing individualism and so on.
00:15:16 So, yeah, I like these kind of renegade thinkers who are hard to pin down politically as well.
00:15:23 Like, it's difficult to say whether Illich is left, centre or right in lots of ways.
00:15:28 And there are elements of all of those thinking in his own.
00:15:35 Yeah, so I think, I don't know.
00:15:37 I mean, there is a kind of complexity in talking about capitalism.
00:15:41 I mean, I suppose I mean a particular kind of capitalism, which which emphasises the kind of consumer individualism.
00:15:48 You know, I don't have I mean, it may be we could talk about markets against capital or something.
00:15:52 I'm not not against markets as such. I think they're a kind of deep anthropological feature of our history.
00:15:59 You see, the thing is the reason I asked you this is I think it's a fascinating point, actually.
00:16:04 I can absolutely see the logic of your argument.
00:16:06 But coming from my political perspective, it seems to me that they might have worked in an unholy alliance, but that the destruction of those things I mentioned has come almost entirely from the left.
00:16:19 you know that sort of the destruction of a sense of communal patriotism family all the kind of
00:16:28 attacks have basically become what effectively to begin with ideological in many ways and indeed
00:16:36 feminism that in fact they've come from the left and where they've been given this strength is by
00:16:41 the extraordinary economic dynamics of our time so would you accept that or not really
00:16:48 No, there may be a point of disagreement here, but it's because when I think of conservatism, I think of preservation, I think of slowness, but I don't think that's what actual conservatives did, if you see what I mean.
00:17:00 I think, in fact, they were in hock to the free market and destruction and the destructive element of that, rather than saying, you know, why don't we protect our sovereignty and produce all our own food and be self-sufficient and respect our own heritage and all of those sorts of things.
00:17:17 So I think free market ideology in practice is not conservatism, as I understand it.
00:17:24 No, but this is a point. This is a big point. You would know.
00:17:26 I mean, it's one of the big arguments on the right, if you would like.
00:17:30 I mean, when I look at people who are absolute free market purists, they are a million miles from me, for example.
00:17:39 Right.
00:17:39 Not because I don't believe in capitalism, because I do, but I see a lot of them.
00:17:44 They don't really care, for example, much about patriotism. Not really.
00:17:47 don't care about immigration for example very much you know it's all a matter of the market
00:17:52 is dominant so that has this effect does it not on traditional kind of ideas of how we see men and
00:18:00 women yeah i mean i think maybe it's coming from both the left and the right if you saw i mean i
00:18:05 you know i'm increasingly interested in what it means to talk about place i'm very much interested
00:18:09 in questions of heritage i think the left have made mistakes in in terms of giving up any
00:18:13 discussion of of belonging and the land you know they've seeded all of that discussion to to the
00:18:19 right and to this kind of often a very flimsy idea of what they think patriotism or nationalism is
00:18:24 i mean well it suits them to be patriotic for countries like ukraine at the moment but
00:18:30 you know i i think there has been a kind of an absence of a real discussion about what it means
00:18:35 to to belong to feel proud to you know in in the sense of i mean i grew up in wiltshire which is a
00:18:41 beautiful place that has enormous amounts of prehistory you know they're extraordinary places
00:18:46 and i think the idea that anyone who's kind of interested in history or heritage must therefore
00:18:51 be reactionary or right wing is just like completely misplaced um and yeah so i i don't
00:18:58 know but i do think there's a particular kind of consumer capitalism which is extremely destructive
00:19:03 on these relations and whether we see that as left or right or just something else maybe slightly
00:19:07 inhuman you know I mean like for example some of our viewers for example might get in touch
00:19:14 or have done in the past to express their anger at the way that men are portrayed say in ads
00:19:22 yeah for sure now but that is a commercial consideration just as much as it's anything
00:19:27 I you know they're saying men are always seen as stupid yeah it's true you know especially white
00:19:32 men uh you know you know what's going on but the thing is no one is going to do this if it doesn't
00:19:40 get the money or profit surely yeah for sure i mean i i totally agree with that diagnosis though
00:19:45 i mean i think it's absolutely ill dignified the way that you know men are portrayed in mainstream
00:19:50 culture you know it's as if yeah men are like always foolish or idiotic or you know there's
00:19:56 no respect for fathers in particular and i think there's also no respect for mothers i think
00:20:01 mothers are also scapegoated horribly as well, like actual mothers, if you see what I mean,
00:20:05 the figure of the mother. So I think we need to resurrect a respect for our elders, right?
00:20:10 Whether they're our actual parents or our ancestors or all of those things. I mean, again,
00:20:15 it makes no sense to pretend that we're somehow cut off from all of these ties or as if our
00:20:20 ancestors didn't have wisdom. And, you know, I make that point in the book. And so, yeah, sure.
00:20:26 I mean, it maybe it's profitable to portray men in this way, but but it's still wrong. Yeah
00:20:33 I mean, it's a moral question. You know, I think I suppose it's just I
00:20:37 I think well the things that people really care about right. I don't think our money that they are social relations
00:20:43 They are the people that you love your friends. They are things that you value like nature
00:20:48 You know outside of those economic bonds and to see everything in an economic way is just I don't know
00:20:54 so it's kind of horrific actually well it is kind of horrific but also you know over the past few
00:20:59 years we see just example after example after example brexit i feel would be one of the perfect
00:21:05 one still to this day many remainers the remainer arguments still cannot quite understand all the
00:21:14 non-economic arguments people might have because you can't often prove them can you in the sense
00:21:19 that you know they are there's something in the air you know a sense of community and locality
00:21:25 and all of this it's very important i've sort of like assumed your left wingery um but i think i'm
00:21:32 i mean what is your what would you call yourself if you have to call yourself anything now i mean
00:21:36 and did you start off as something else you know i mean a lot of people who've come through this
00:21:41 studio um have been on journeys you know in some ways you know there's that terrible cliche you
00:21:47 you know, Simon, what is it, Piers Morgan journeys or whatever.
00:21:51 But have you had one?
00:21:53 Yeah, I guess so.
00:21:54 Although I do think that most of my intuitions, at least,
00:21:58 are the same as they were when I was about 15.
00:22:01 But I think the various Overton windows have shifted in such bizarre ways since then.
00:22:07 So, you know, I'm very much interested in community, sociability, humour,
00:22:13 free expression in defense of arts and culture you know all of these things that i think make
00:22:18 life worth living and i think the left used to be much much better on on freedom of expression or
00:22:24 at least the left that i remember um so i so i don't know it's very hard for me to say where i
00:22:30 am now like in some ways like old left but i mean probably now by you know but then for some people
00:22:37 i would be kind of far right or a nazi even you know and some idiots that takes in probably 90
00:22:43 percent of the world now if you listen to these people no exactly so i mean i don't you know so
00:22:47 so that's not true either obviously um and it's just a you know word that people toss around
00:22:53 everyone they don't like um so i don't know i mean i tried in a way to be kind of more or less
00:22:57 not very political in that book i try to kind of almost be centrist in the kind of approach
00:23:02 which is to say like um to listen to both sides and to look at you know what's really going on
00:23:08 with men and how this relates to how we might rethink our relations um i mean i'm very interested
00:23:14 in talking to anybody and everybody right i think one of the the things that the left increasingly
00:23:19 did was to say no we can't listen to this person we've got to no platform that person you know and
00:23:24 this happened to a lot of women who wanted to talk about you know proposed changes of a gender
00:23:28 recognition act and you know i myself got kind of like cancelled and mobbed and people emailing
00:23:34 Well, tell us what happened there.
00:23:36 Oh, I mean, like, it was very silly.
00:23:39 Like, I posted something on Facebook about how,
00:23:42 because I used to be a member of the Labour Party,
00:23:43 and I'm not anymore, obviously, but I'm not a very active member.
00:23:47 But, you know, I was very involved in the student protests
00:23:48 and defending people who'd been prosecuted from them.
00:23:52 And I was very committed to the idea of free education.
00:23:57 And I posted something about what was going on in the Labour Party
00:24:01 where various women were being kind of interrogated,
00:24:04 literally, about their things they'd said in relation to the proposed change to the Gender
00:24:08 Recognition Act. And I thought these women are being treated appallingly, like this, you know,
00:24:13 these secret kind of, yeah, like really, they were interrogations, and they'd leaked some of
00:24:18 the transcripts. And I read them, and I just thought, like, I don't want to live in this world,
00:24:23 you know, where women are being hauled over the coals for asking perfectly reasonable questions
00:24:26 about policy you know and so I thought like and you know I could see this issue
00:24:32 maybe becoming something that like really sadistic people were using to
00:24:37 attack others and I there was a lot of this going on and yeah so I suppose I
00:24:42 I posted something thinking oh like this will probably get some you know
00:24:48 negative reaction but I didn't realize what would actually happen which is like
00:24:51 you actually get targeted by specific activists and you know and then people
00:24:56 kind of denounce you and yeah like they write to everyone you've ever worked with or they
00:25:01 you know they try to get your work removed or they try to get your book cancelled or
00:25:04 they try to stop you from speaking like i've been i gave talks about the masculinity project
00:25:10 um at university and the university was so scared that i would be attacked that they
00:25:14 hired security guards to protect me you know you know and it's and this isn't uncommon you
00:25:18 know people like selena todd and kathleen stark and you know all these women who said a lot more
00:25:22 than I did you know we're really brave or look at the way JK Rowling has been treated
00:25:27 you know and it's kind of insane right it's just so that was like a real experience of of the
00:25:33 reality of I don't know some of today's horrors do you in the in the book you know you put forward
00:25:40 some ideas what should happen I don't mean to wrongly summarize it but it seems to me we've
00:25:48 just got to come together and basically talk more um but how do you think how can that be done i
00:25:56 mean particularly now that we're becoming more and more atomized more and more isolated you know
00:26:02 dating such like this you know you hear horror stories about it now i mean how the hell can we
00:26:08 do that well i think in the first place it's about recognizing these forms of division and how these
00:26:13 technologies and like the last two years of covid are basically like you know technologies to kind
00:26:18 of separate us and to make us feel that we've got less in common and i think this rhetoric that you
00:26:23 know against men and dividing men and women has been going on for a long time um so i think in
00:26:29 the first place it's about recognizing those um forces that seek to divide people yeah and to
00:26:35 prevent dialogue and to prevent you know people who people who disagree from talking to each other
00:26:40 You know, I'm not like I'm a philosopher. I believe in dialogue, you know, and reason and these sorts of things
00:26:46 And again, I suppose it's like that I talk about this idea of eutropelia
00:26:50 Which I take from Illich who takes it from the Greeks
00:26:52 Which is this idea of graceful play that actually one of the ways of interacting that's most beautiful is to
00:26:58 engage in a form of like beautiful play
00:27:00 Which is to do with how we speak to each other and you know that we have time and we listen to each other and we talk
00:27:06 and so I think in the first place it's maybe about a generosity like if
00:27:10 somebody's you know like if men are saying look we're upset about this thing
00:27:14 or you know access to children or you know the suicide rate or these very
00:27:19 serious things it's like saying rather than just this sneering dismissive
00:27:23 attitude it's like saying well how can we actually listen to people see what's
00:27:28 going on you know then come to some negotiation or this discussion so that
00:27:32 we can make as many people happy as possible. I'm not utilitarian, but, you know, to actually
00:27:37 take seriously the fact that everybody suffers. You know, I think one of the dominant implicit
00:27:43 ideas of recent years has been this idea that only some people suffer, you know, and that like
00:27:48 if a white man says he's suffering, it's not really, you know, which is just horrific. I mean,
00:27:52 it's just like inhuman, you know, it's like everybody suffers by virtue of being alive,
00:27:57 you know being alive is difficult but we do live don't we in remarkably ungenerous times yeah i
00:28:05 mean harsh isn't it yeah and i think it's like identifying who benefits from that or why this
00:28:12 rhetoric is increasingly dividing people you know like that's what i mean about the old left i think
00:28:17 the old left was not divisive in this way it was like even if people disagree or if they have an
00:28:21 idea about immigration or something it's like you talk to everybody you listen to people you know
00:28:25 you hear their concerns and you try to understand them you don't you know like a steamroller in
00:28:32 and say this is the right line and anyone who disagrees must be a nazi you know i mean the left
00:28:37 have lost the working class like they don't you know over brexit over i don't know the canadian
00:28:42 truckers you know every time the working class actually does something which is quite left-wing
00:28:47 actually yes or historically would have been perceived that way they're just uh i ignored it
00:28:52 or actually demeaned oh I'd say more than yeah I mean demonized you know utterly demonized um
00:29:00 I know your book isn't you know your book is a a serious discussion it's not a self-help book
00:29:06 or anything but um you know one thing that does come a lot of coming up in one's own life you
00:29:13 know talking to friends and that and that is that younger guys now feel really inhibited
00:29:19 about you know dates and very very concerned and worried about dating because they just think you
00:29:26 know they're going to if they put a foot wrong you know um do you think that they exaggerate that
00:29:33 or do you do you think they've got a point i think they have a point i mean i think if you
00:29:37 you know most people for example used to meet this a lot of people met their spouse at work
00:29:41 now if you flirted with someone at work you wouldn't because you'd be worried about being
00:29:45 hauled up on a sexual harassment charge you know so that's about the HR thing
00:29:48 in this kind of you know creating this suspicious world in which everyone's
00:29:51 motive is somehow like evil or you know negative and particularly men right so I
00:29:56 think yeah if you're a young man today I it would be very terrifying and I talk
00:30:01 about this paradox of like the pro-ritannical like the idea we both live
00:30:06 in like this really hedonistic culture that encourages people to get drunk and
00:30:09 take drugs and have sex but on the other hand if you make a mistake and you're
00:30:13 not even clear what the rules are, you are like absolutely punished and condemned, you know. So
00:30:19 obviously I think the implicit effect of that is one of fear and suspicion because nobody wants to
00:30:26 be the person who's, you know, done something wrong, who, you know, who might be accused of
00:30:31 abuse or sexual harassment, you know. On the other hand, everybody's made mistakes, you know,
00:30:35 everybody is like kissed the wrong person or been a dick or gotten drunk, you know what I mean?
00:30:39 And I think there used to be more, I don't know, acceptance of that grey area, the fact that social life is really difficult sometimes, that, you know, like sometimes people have an argument and then you've got to apologise later and, you know, everyone is capable of being an idiot.
00:30:53 And so I wanted that sort of generosity to come back.
00:30:58 But I do think more practically, I mean, I joked about this earlier,
00:31:01 but the technology, these dating apps, they mitigate against risk in real life,
00:31:07 like the random encounter.
00:31:09 Let's say with someone you completely disagree with,
00:31:11 the apps screen for disagreement over difficult issues.
00:31:16 And I think that isn't why you love somebody.
00:31:19 It isn't why you like them or isn't why you fancy them either.
00:31:21 And so I think what is important is these other alternatives that are real life, like going to church or being involved in, I don't know, like education, evening classes or like places where you meet people.
00:31:37 Yeah, volunteering, like, you know, where you might get to know somebody in real life, you know, rather than the enforced date, which I think makes people extremely jaded.
00:31:46 You know, people start to think of each other as things, you know, as commodities, more or less exchangeable.
00:31:52 People are not fungible. You know, everybody is like unique, you know, in an individual.
00:31:58 And the reason why we love people is for that uniqueness, you know, not because they fulfill a need or they are exchangeable with someone else.
00:32:05 I think, you know, you're that point about doing something outside of yourself.
00:32:10 Yeah, I think it's so important. I say almost for all relationships, not just between men and women.
00:32:15 You know, some of the best friendships I've made have been where there is a common purpose outside, to use that expression, outside of both of us, maybe political or maybe charitable, something like that.
00:32:30 It just seems to bring people together, I think, far more.
00:32:35 You know, this is now, this is like got the air of auditions about it, hasn't it?
00:32:39 Yeah.
00:32:40 The dating thing.
00:32:40 no for sure and it's like you know people get too obsessed with themselves and that's actually
00:32:45 really bad it's boring you know and destructive and it makes people depressed well if you don't
00:32:50 want to be depressed uh you should read the book um what do men want masculinity and its discontents
00:32:56 by nina power it's in bookshops presumably and on amazon right yes yeah definitely um
00:33:03 nina thanks so much coming in and talking all about it it's lovely and um all the very best
00:33:11 and um i know that this will i'm sure have quite a market so uh you'll do well thank you very much
00:33:16 indeed um that's it for so what you're saying is this week uh for our members uh we have some
00:33:23 exclusive content so i'm going to be asking nina a few more questions but to everybody else we
00:33:29 We shall see you next time on So What You're Saying Is. Thank you.
00:33:33 Hello, if you're enjoying the New Culture Forum channel and you believe in our mission,
00:33:39 may I invite you to join our membership scheme at the link below or on our website, newcultureforum.org.uk.
00:33:48 Our work is more important now than ever and we have great plans ahead for the future,
00:33:54 but we can't do it without your support.
00:33:56 From as little as £3 per month, you can help ensure that we continue on our mission.
00:34:02 As a member, you'll receive a range of benefits, including access to exclusive content,
00:34:08 invitations to our private events, including here at our studios,
00:34:14 free copies of our books, and much, much more, including, of course, our famous NCF mug.
00:34:20 If you aren't able to become a member, then please help us by clicking this button and subscribing to our channel.
00:34:29 It's completely free. Just remember to also click the bell icon so that you can get notifications when we post new videos.
00:34:39 Thank you.