00:02:59and they're obviously focusing a bit more on the needs of their nation.
00:03:05We've just gone through the 1st of April, where every year in England, the prescription charges go up.
00:03:12But in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, they're free.
00:03:16And there's now a lot more discussion about the fact that quite a lot of the money that's raised in England
00:03:23is actually spent in subsidising to an extra extent what happens in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.
00:03:30And for instance, there was an article in the Telegraph only a couple of days ago pointing out that
00:03:34the spending in Scotland is 30% on average above what it is in England.
00:03:40And the reason for that is that English taxpayers through the Barnett formula are paying for it.
00:03:45The Barnett formula, just in case people don't know, this is the, can you explain very briefly?
00:03:49Yes. So back in the 70s, there was the first Secretary of the Treasury in the Labour government
00:03:55and called Joel Barnett. And he invented more or less on the back of a fag packet, literally,0.98
00:04:01A formula whereby the Scots, in particular at that time, were going to get at least 10% extra out of the block grant, which is the way that the state allocates money for subsidies.0.92
00:04:19And the result of that, of course, is that you wind up getting at least 10% extra spent in Scotland for anything.
00:04:26And that includes, for instance, even capital projects, so money spent in London for the crossrail project or the proposal to spend a vast amount of money on building a railway up to Birmingham or Manchester, wherever it's going to go in the end.
00:04:43and even though the Scots may not have actually a project to suspend it on
00:04:49they still get a lump sum of billions, about 10%
00:04:55handed to them as part of the Barnet consequentials.
00:05:00Does that manifesto resonate with you, Nigel?
00:14:53And in fact, in the run-up to the last general election, I noticed that Nicola Sturgeon said that she wanted to see Scotland to be an independent, internationalist country within the EU, which sounded to me completely cuckoo, but that's what she said.
00:15:09yes yes good luck with that um how would you robin how would you define therefore we've talked about
00:15:18you just mentioned english culture there how would you define english culture if you had to
00:15:24because one of the questions that we always find ourselves talking about here is is basically you
00:15:29you know that the left will quite sneeringly say well what is british culture anyway they
00:15:34say things like that you know when you're talking about british values british culture what is it
00:22:24And I think that English, I'm not going to say nationalism, but I think English patriotism is much more associated, firstly, with country than nation, which is a distinction that Roger Scruton also makes.
00:29:10that let's compare it to an unhappy marriage.
00:29:14If one partner can't stand it and wants to get away and wants to break away,
00:29:20And I agree with Emma, we shouldn't necessarily assume that the majority of Scots do buy into this SNP narrative.
00:29:28But if they do, or if they in five years, 10 years time do, I think most English people would say, go.
00:29:38I don't think there would be a great battle, sad to say in some ways, to save the Union.
00:29:44I think in that sense, Britishness has weakened over the last 50 years.
00:29:48The British state has actually been, in effect, trying to bribe Scots to vote to keep the Union.
00:29:54That's what the Barnet Formal is partly about.
00:29:56And it was actually expressly about, at the time, it was about trying to undermine the appeal of Scottish nationalists.
00:30:04If I could just say that the one thing, or one of the things, that seems to be keeping the whole thing together actually is the monarchy, is the institution of monarchy, in a way.
00:30:14Now, if Scotland got independence or if English got independence, would we just have an English monarchy?
00:30:24Would it actually go back to being possibly with Elizabeth II, Elizabeth I was the last purely English queen, wasn't she?
00:30:33Yes, she was. And of course, the Act of Union in 1707 did actually create, and it says so, the United Kingdom of Great Britain.
00:30:43So for Scotland to go, that's got to be repealed.
00:30:47And the two political constitutional entities that were brought together in the Act of Union
00:30:54was the Kingdom of England and the Kingdom of Scotland.