New Culture Forum - April 19, 2021


English Or British? What Is The Future For England And The United Kingdom?

Prince Philip: An Example For Woke Prince Harry. Has Traditional Britain Died With Prince Philip? Great American Race Game - New Documentary By UK Filmmaker Martin Durkin

Episode Stats


Length

36 minutes

Words per minute

153.26

Word count

5,634

Sentence count

224

Harmful content

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to Counterculture. I'm Peter Whittle. Now before we go into this week's
00:00:18 discussion, please do subscribe, won't you? I'm saying this every time but it's paying off because
00:00:24 we've had 5,000 subscribers in just three weeks. What you do is you press the subscribe button
00:00:30 and next door to that there is a little blue bell and if you press that too then that's
00:00:36 notifications. It means you get notified of every new program as it comes up. So please do that
00:00:42 won't you and that'll be great. Well today on Counterculture we're going to be discussing
00:00:48 England, Englishness and what happens to the Union. This is a very very popular subject with
00:00:56 our viewers and it's one that we have covered a bit in the past but we want to look really at
00:01:02 what the future is really for this thing called England politically and culturally. I'm very
00:01:10 pleased to discuss this today. We have Robin Tilbrook who is the chairman and indeed the
00:01:16 founder of the English Democrats, Emma Webb from Civitas, and Nigel Jones, who is a biographer,
00:01:25 historian, and commentator. Can I start, first of all, by asking you, Robin, what is it that
00:01:33 the English Democrats want? So our primary campaigning position is that we want independence
00:01:39 for England. Obviously, that necessarily means dissolution of the United Kingdom.
00:01:43 we did we did campaign for about 15 years on the idea that we should have an english parliament
00:01:50 with the first minister and government with at least the same pounds of scottish ones within
00:01:54 the federal uk um but what we were finding was that but basically the british establishment
00:02:01 want to break england up and their their agenda is to break england into these sort of bogus
00:02:05 regions that have no sort of historic meaning to them um and uh so consequently the choice really
00:02:13 becomes is england broken up or is the uk broken up and obviously as english nationalists english
00:02:20 patriots we're concerned to make sure that england remains uh its sort of historic unity yes um and
00:02:28 of course there are many other points that arise because england is actually quite unfairly treated
00:02:35 in terms of the way the British state looks after it.
00:02:39 We're the only part of the United Kingdom
00:02:42 where the British government has direct rule over us.
00:02:46 We've seen this very clearly with the whole coronavirus crisis
00:02:49 where the British Secretary of State for Health, Matt Hancock,
00:02:54 is the one issuing all the orders,
00:02:56 whereas in Scotland, where it's Northern Ireland,
00:02:58 they've got their own governments
00:02:59 and they're obviously focusing a bit more on the needs of their nation.
00:03:05 We've just gone through the 1st of April, where every year in England, the prescription charges go up.
00:03:12 But in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, they're free.
00:03:16 And there's now a lot more discussion about the fact that quite a lot of the money that's raised in England
00:03:23 is actually spent in subsidising to an extra extent what happens in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.
00:03:30 And for instance, there was an article in the Telegraph only a couple of days ago pointing out that
00:03:34 the spending in Scotland is 30% on average above what it is in England.
00:03:40 And the reason for that is that English taxpayers through the Barnett formula are paying for it.
00:03:45 The Barnett formula, just in case people don't know, this is the, can you explain very briefly?
00:03:49 Yes. So back in the 70s, there was the first Secretary of the Treasury in the Labour government
00:03:55 and called Joel Barnett. And he invented more or less on the back of a fag packet, literally, 0.98
00:04:01 A formula whereby the Scots, in particular at that time, were going to get at least 10% extra out of the block grant, which is the way that the state allocates money for subsidies. 0.92
00:04:19 And the result of that, of course, is that you wind up getting at least 10% extra spent in Scotland for anything.
00:04:26 And that includes, for instance, even capital projects, so money spent in London for the crossrail project or the proposal to spend a vast amount of money on building a railway up to Birmingham or Manchester, wherever it's going to go in the end.
00:04:43 and even though the Scots may not have actually a project to suspend it on
00:04:49 they still get a lump sum of billions, about 10%
00:04:55 handed to them as part of the Barnet consequentials.
00:05:00 Does that manifesto resonate with you, Nigel?
00:05:06 I have to say not particularly
00:05:09 because I think England as the most populous part of the United Kingdom
00:05:14 has always had certain advantages.
00:05:17 Perhaps now it's coming back to bite us
00:05:20 in that I think because we've been, as it were, the top dogs in the UK,
00:05:27 I think we haven't thought very much about questions of English patriotism
00:05:31 and English nationalism
00:05:32 or the fact that the Scots get, if you like, a free ride.
00:05:39 on the English taxpayer, because we have had a certain...
00:05:42 When I say we English, I'm half Welsh,
00:05:45 so maybe we'll come on to discuss how this affects people
00:05:49 who are a bit of both, who are half Welsh, half Scottish, half Irish, whatever.
00:05:55 But I think that England did have an inbuilt sense of superiority,
00:06:00 and that was, I think, tied up with the empire.
00:06:03 And I think when the empire dissolved in the 40s, 50s, 60s, England was England was left a bit bereft because the British Empire had gone.
00:06:16 And what was Britain? That was the question.
00:06:19 And I think it was Dean Acheson, the American diplomat and politician, said England has lost an empire.
00:06:26 Britain has lost an empire. There I am. You see, I'm using the two things interchangeably.
00:06:31 Britain has lost an empire
00:06:34 has not found a role
00:06:36 and then our ill-fated
00:06:38 attempt to link ourselves
00:06:40 with Europe and the EU
00:06:42 which has occupied us for the last
00:06:44 40-50 years
00:06:45 and now
00:06:48 now that we're out of the EU
00:06:50 and unlikely to go back
00:06:52 I think that the question
00:06:55 of England is a
00:06:57 big one, is arising especially
00:06:58 as I see Scottish nationalism
00:07:01 and, to a certain extent, Welsh nationalism,
00:07:03 largely composed of anti-Englishness. 0.91
00:07:07 Yes, I'd just like to say I totally agree with Nigel
00:07:10 about the role of empire in the creation of the United Kingdom.
00:07:15 I mean, that's what it was all about.
00:07:17 I mean, the United Kingdom wasn't created
00:07:18 because ordinary people wanted a United Kingdom.
00:07:22 The ordinary Scots, ordinary English did not want the Act of Union.
00:07:28 In fact, the Scots, I think, marked that rather clearly
00:07:31 by making the place where the Act of Union agreement was signed
00:07:35 into a public toilet in Edinburgh.
00:07:39 Really?
00:07:40 Yes, so I'm told.
00:07:42 But the point is in 1707, England and Scotland, for that matter,
00:07:49 were at war under one crown, Queen Anne, with Louis XIV.
00:07:56 And, of course, the Act of Union with Ireland, 1801,
00:07:59 we were at war with Napoleon Bonaparte.
00:08:03 And so in both cases, those acts of union were about empire
00:08:07 and about world power and realpolitik, as it were,
00:08:10 rather than about what ordinary people wanted.
00:08:13 And I think we've got an opportunity now, as all of that's gone,
00:08:18 to focus more on what people want
00:08:20 rather than on imperial politics and power.
00:08:24 I think that's an interesting point, actually,
00:08:25 that leaving the EU has, it'll take a while perhaps,
00:08:31 but it's actually going to, you know, highlight all of these issues.
00:08:34 I mean, we've been preoccupied with this pandemic and everything, haven't we?
00:08:38 But this is going to come to the fore.
00:08:40 I mean, do you, would you call yourself British or English?
00:08:43 English.
00:08:44 English.
00:08:45 Yeah.
00:08:45 Is that sort of a conscious thing?
00:08:49 I don't think so.
00:08:50 But because I would, I would regard myself as probably more of a unionist.
00:08:55 um and perhaps politically unionist but culturally English and so um I think there are there are
00:09:04 benefits to the union and that's one reason why at least at this point in time I'm inclined
00:09:09 towards the arguments to try we sort of almost uh with any means to try and keep it held together
00:09:17 for political reasons but culturally I think there is there is a very good point there that
00:09:22 you mentioned that Scottish and Welsh nationalism as with many other ideologies that we're constantly
00:09:30 being bombarded with are distinctively anti-English and we've suffered in many ways from
00:09:36 the fact that you know the benefits of us being so culturally and politically influential from
00:09:42 the empire and within the union that we have an almost blindness towards English culture and
00:09:51 english issues um and i think probably the the interplay between the cultural concern there and
00:09:58 the political is what will turn out to be um important and i don't think that although their
00:10:03 intention i don't think that necessarily necessarily um you have i think that there
00:10:10 is that you can strike a balance there in the way that i do personally as a unionist who identifies
00:10:14 as being english um and i think perhaps one solution is to um try to find ways to um bolster
00:10:26 people's national identity in a healthy way within different parts of the union without
00:10:32 necessarily having to make the argument for breaking the union apart finding a way to make
00:10:38 it a little bit less dysfunctional and um see if their marriage can be made to work well the thing
00:10:43 this is the problem isn't it because 0.94
00:10:45 Scottish and Welsh
00:10:48 nationalism is always seen as kind of
00:10:50 like cool and
00:10:52 essentially progressive
00:10:54 this word progressive i.e. left wing
00:10:56 right left wing
00:10:57 English nationalism is seen as
00:11:00 somehow thuggish automatically
00:11:02 and somehow
00:11:04 fascist yes and certainly
00:11:06 with more stances
00:11:07 the skinheads are more
00:11:10 stances
00:11:11 I was going to say in response to what Emma was saying
00:11:15 that actually the British state, as it's working at the moment,
00:11:20 is quite focused on trying to sort of clamp down
00:11:23 on any idea of Englishness.
00:11:25 The whole way in which the political correctness agenda is working
00:11:29 is basically to say that you're not allowed to say you're English.
00:11:32 And if you do try and say you're English,
00:11:34 then all sorts of inquiries should be made into why you're saying that
00:11:39 and perhaps along the lines of what you're saying.
00:11:42 But that is completely untrue of Scottish or Welsh
00:11:47 or Irish nationalism, funnily enough.
00:11:50 I mean, if you think about Irish nationalism, 0.63
00:11:54 which has involved plenty of violence over the years, 1.00
00:11:58 that's OK.
00:12:00 But English nationalism, which hasn't involved that violence,
00:12:05 somehow that's not OK.
00:12:06 Yeah, I think the problem is, as I was saying,
00:12:09 that England is very much the dominant partner in the Union.
00:12:13 And I think whenever you get a minority,
00:12:16 particularly a strong minority, who resent the domination,
00:12:20 I mean, God hope this will never happen to England.
00:12:24 But let's take the example of former Yugoslavia,
00:12:27 where the Croats were a substantial minority
00:12:30 vis-à-vis the Serbs, who were the major force.
00:12:34 And the Bosnian Muslims were an even smaller minority 0.99
00:12:37 in the Slovenians were even smaller than that and I think they always resented the dominance of the
00:12:43 major group the major majority population the capital was in Serbia Belgrade similarly I think
00:12:51 that there's resentment among the Scots the Irish and the Welsh of the dominance of this the fact
00:12:58 that our parliament the only parliament before devolution is centered here in London a few yards
00:13:04 away from here in Westminster, I think that is a major force behind this resentment. And
00:13:11 any display of English nationalism, the St George's flag that you're wearing in your
00:13:16 lapel, provokes either contempt, i.e. Emily Thornbridge sneeringly tweeting the picture
00:13:24 of the St George's flag. I've just been spending Easter in a seaside town in Sussex called
00:13:29 It's Celsi, which is a sort of microcosm of English nationalism.
00:13:33 And there are lots and lots of union flags.
00:13:35 There are also lots and lots of St George's flags there.
00:13:38 So I do think that English nationalism is a sleeping giant
00:13:42 which has been prodded into life by the nationalism
00:13:46 of the smaller components of the UK.
00:13:48 But, guys, before we go on to discuss that, I just want one thing.
00:13:52 You're talking about the dominance of England when it came to the empire.
00:13:57 Hang on, the Scots, their role, was it phenomenal in the empire, wasn't it?
00:14:05 I mean, they seem to have really forgotten.
00:14:08 And also they even wanted to start their own empire, didn't they?
00:14:12 It meant famously before the kind of British Empire.
00:14:16 There was this sort of attempt, wasn't there, in South America or something?
00:14:19 The Darien scheme in Central.
00:14:20 That's what caused the Act of Union, because they were bankrupt because of the failure of the Darien scheme.
00:14:25 So what is all this, like, let's all blame the English thing?
00:14:29 I mean, the Scots were very much there, weren't they?
00:14:32 They were.
00:14:33 We do have an odd situation, though, with Celtic nationalism,
00:14:37 because both, well, the SNP, Clyde Cumberland, and also Sinn Féin,
00:14:41 they've all become basically Marxist, or at any rate, far left.
00:14:50 They're not nationalists.
00:14:51 They're sort of trading on nationalism.
00:14:53 And in fact, in the run-up to the last general election, I noticed that Nicola Sturgeon said that she wanted to see Scotland to be an independent, internationalist country within the EU, which sounded to me completely cuckoo, but that's what she said.
00:15:09 yes yes good luck with that um how would you robin how would you define therefore we've talked about
00:15:18 you just mentioned english culture there how would you define english culture if you had to
00:15:24 because one of the questions that we always find ourselves talking about here is is basically you
00:15:29 you know that the left will quite sneeringly say well what is british culture anyway they
00:15:34 say things like that you know when you're talking about british values british culture what is it
00:15:38 anyway. What do you think is
00:15:39 distinct about English culture?
00:15:41 Can I, as a lawyer
00:15:44 therefore interested
00:15:46 in how this works out in court.
00:15:48 We're fine with lawyers on this show, don't worry.
00:15:50 Because the
00:15:52 Labour
00:15:53 inspired as it were and written
00:15:55 Equality Act
00:15:57 has actually offers a
00:16:00 sort of definition, a multi-layered
00:16:01 definition.
00:16:04 So
00:16:04 a national identity
00:16:07 like english can be a national identity which is to a large extent about where where you feel you
00:16:16 belong so to answer nigel's point he you know he could be english and welsh and feel strongly
00:16:23 about being english which would make him by national identity english um there's also been
00:16:30 court cases in fact funnily enough involving the BBC where English was defined as being a racial
00:16:39 group and there's also English as an ethnicity because ethnicity has been defined by the courts
00:16:48 as being a sort of subset of things so English is a the subset of British and therefore is an
00:16:55 ethnicity um but then you then you got sort of cultural origin which i think is what what you
00:17:02 were referring to um and cultural origin um obviously it's it's what it's what people
00:17:08 associate with being english as much as anything as anything you don't you don't really get you
00:17:13 i don't think any nation gets a sort of definition of of what it is to be of that nation but of
00:17:20 course people recognize it and they know what's meant by it um but the some some people on the
00:17:27 left of course are trying to sort of deconstruct the whole idea of nation um and um for instance
00:17:33 i saw one of the squad um before the american presidential election saying that it wasn't just
00:17:39 trump's wall that was racist but but the very idea of borders was racist um you know obviously
00:17:46 such people um they they are going to come up with purely instrumental points to try and uh
00:17:52 delegitimize what they regard as a as a hostile thing which is the very idea of nation but for
00:17:58 those of us that actually care about our nation we don't we don't really need a definition about it
00:18:02 it's in our hearts you know we we love our country we want we want to see it do well
00:18:08 i find actually a bit like you know i find that i call myself english now and i mean one thing i
00:18:14 found quite interesting is that my my uh my parents uh lesson when they you know they were
00:18:18 always British you know and they talked about Britain and then there's just kind of imperceptible
00:18:22 every period of time they started calling themselves English and I think it's because
00:18:26 there was this feeling that somehow something was being lost yeah yeah absolutely I think
00:18:32 um with any nation not just the English it is something that is comes out of attachments it's
00:18:38 something that grows up organically it's why when Orwell um he gave what could sort of his
00:18:43 closest definition to Englishness was just a set of impressions things like the the nun riding her
00:18:49 bike along the cobblestones and things like that it's it's things that you're attached to and and
00:18:53 it it plays into everything like the common law our institutions things that can't be man-made by
00:19:00 one generation but just accumulate over many and therefore particularly precious and people have
00:19:04 an inexplicable attachment to them that can't possibly be explained it's not something that
00:19:09 can be pinned down in a definition it's a reason why firstly it's so difficult to protect and also
00:19:14 why it's so vulnerable against ideologies like we're currently seeing with some of these sort
00:19:19 of post-modernist deconstructionist marxist ideas that want to tear down all of our institutions
00:19:26 because they say that they're systemically racist or they're systemically misogynist or they're
00:19:30 systemically something evil and i think that that is one of the reasons why along with other things
00:19:36 like a sense of loss of place the transience of communities because of globalization and
00:19:41 mass immigration people feel the sense of loss um that may it creates a need to identify yourself
00:19:48 as english in a way that you wouldn't have felt before but again it's not as we discussed in a
00:19:53 previous um counterculture it's not because of a sort of xenophobia to anything outside or to the
00:19:59 to the threats but a response to the affection towards the things that you love in the same way
00:20:05 that you would love your own family or your own children or your own home.
00:20:09 I think there is this thing, isn't it, Nigel,
00:20:11 that the left tend to portray it as being a kind of aggressive thing.
00:20:18 But in fact, you know, often it's just like people wanting familiarity.
00:20:23 There's a sense in which people now are told,
00:20:26 and this is certainly London telling the country, you know,
00:20:29 that familiarity is wrong, that it's provincial,
00:20:32 or that it's, you know, it's small-minded.
00:20:36 And it's always applied to the English, is it not?
00:20:39 It is.
00:20:40 And the danger of that, of course,
00:20:43 is that the English are then going to feel threatened
00:20:46 and going to react by perhaps conforming to the stereotypes
00:20:53 that has been put on them.
00:20:56 Alternatively, they could ask themselves, as Emma said,
00:20:59 What do we mean by English, by being English?
00:21:03 What are the associations that we have?
00:21:07 And I don't think that whatever the court said about race and ethnicity,
00:21:12 I don't think Englishness is a question of race.
00:21:15 For example, David Lammy, the very left-wing, black Labour MP for North London,
00:21:21 got very aerated with a caller who said, well, you're not English.
00:21:25 And he said, well, actually, I am.
00:21:26 I was born in England, brought up, I identify as English, as a black Englishman.
00:21:33 And I think he was right.
00:21:34 I mean, I don't often agree with David Lammy, but I think he was absolutely right to make that point.
00:21:40 And what do I think of?
00:21:42 I think it's places, it's culture.
00:21:46 It can range from anything from cricket to roast beef to Morris Men, as you say.
00:21:53 Not that that's a particular thing, but it's a whole range.
00:21:56 it's Peter Cook, it's Ray Fulham Williams' music.
00:21:59 It's an absolute medley of impressions, memories, words.
00:22:06 A country, in other words.
00:22:07 A country and a culture.
00:22:07 It's also local nationalism as well.
00:22:09 People, in the same way that they are in Scotland or in France,
00:22:13 people are particularly, you know, they identify and feel affection
00:22:16 towards particular areas, particular towns, particular regions,
00:22:19 the landscape.
00:22:20 I mean, the pastoral scenes are something that's very associated
00:22:23 with Englishness.
00:22:24 And I think that English, I'm not going to say nationalism, but I think English patriotism is much more associated, firstly, with country than nation, which is a distinction that Roger Scruton also makes.
00:22:37 but is almost an inherent disadvantage
00:22:41 because Scottish nationalism and Irish nationalism particularly
00:22:44 and maybe to some extent just the Celtic nationalisms
00:22:47 they have a sort of revolutionary fervour to them
00:22:51 whereas English nationalism or patriotism
00:22:54 seems to be somehow more inherently conservative
00:22:57 because it hasn't needed to because of the power dynamics
00:23:00 it hasn't needed to assert itself in a kind of revolutionary way
00:23:05 because it wasn't the counterculture.
00:23:08 And so it doesn't have any of the sort of like fashionable thrill
00:23:13 that you get with being part of a kind of revolutionary counterculture.
00:23:16 I think one of the key things about English patriotism or nationalism
00:23:20 is that it's very old.
00:23:23 If you think Germany was united in 1871, in Italy 1863,
00:23:29 england was united in 927 on the 12th of july 927 for those that uh what the date at the council
00:23:40 of eamont up near penrith uh under king athelstan um and and so actually you know on on we we see
00:23:50 the world i think english people at any rate do see the world through the idea and prism of
00:23:54 nationhood whereas if you if you were german for example that's much more um or italian
00:24:02 arguable or italian yes i mean in italy they've still got some of the laws that passed during
00:24:09 muscolini's time requiring school kids to speak of of all the italian languages to speak only italian
00:24:16 in school because they were trying to create a sense of of nation from something that had been
00:24:22 previously you know right back to classical times had been has been separated into different
00:24:30 nations or different states at any rate and had different languages
00:24:37 so venetian wasn't the same as milanese and those languages still exist and are still spoken by
00:24:45 people living in those in those some areas but italian has been is a sort of project
00:24:52 to try and create a united italy and a sense of italianness whereas that isn't true of
00:25:00 of englishness englishness is is much older um and um it it never really was sort of divided in
00:25:09 in the way that we get with most of the European states.
00:25:14 If you go back 100 years or so,
00:25:16 I'm reading a book about the Austro-Hungarian Empire at the moment.
00:25:20 The curious thing there is that actually the empire itself
00:25:23 more or less created the nations
00:25:25 by insisting upon people being taught in their own local languages
00:25:30 rather than having an overarching language.
00:25:34 but English has been the language that everybody has spoken in England
00:25:40 for many, many centuries
00:25:42 well before Shakespeare
00:25:46 and no doubt even before Chaucer
00:25:50 but our unity is something that we just simply assume
00:25:56 Can I come back on one other thing that Emma was saying about Britishness
00:25:59 because obviously I've spoken to a lot of British politicians
00:26:04 over the years and one of the things I find quite interesting is that they never come up with any
00:26:09 argument for the union apart from it enables us to punch above our weight on the world stage
00:26:14 I don't know about you but I don't particularly want to punch any sort of weight on the world
00:26:20 stage if at all possible I'd rather have a you know rather have a state that where we were
00:26:24 we were less ambitious to be punching our weight on the world stage I think I think it's interesting
00:26:30 that little Englander is always used
00:26:32 as a sneering political insult.
00:26:35 I don't really see anything wrong
00:26:37 with being a little Englander.
00:26:39 I remember David Cameron said at one point,
00:26:42 well, we don't want to become like Switzerland,
00:26:44 as though Switzerland was a horrible little thing
00:26:47 on the bottom of his shoe, 0.63
00:26:48 whereas Switzerland is an example
00:26:51 of a multi-ethnic, certainly multi-lingual society
00:26:55 that has maintained independence
00:26:58 without going to war with anyone,
00:27:01 Proudly, sturdily, I think Switzerland is pretty good.
00:27:04 It's terribly dull.
00:27:05 It's kind of boring.
00:27:06 It's boring, but it's...
00:27:08 It's kind of boring.
00:27:09 Chocolate and clock.
00:27:10 Okay.
00:27:12 I'm not trying to make a case for Swiss nationalism.
00:27:15 Well, you are actually not.
00:27:16 But at least it's not revolutionary.
00:27:19 No, no.
00:27:21 What about this?
00:27:22 There is this very inchoate, but nevertheless very strong feeling about,
00:27:28 which I subscribe to
00:27:30 which is that I like the United
00:27:32 Kingdom but
00:27:34 frankly if we are
00:27:36 so hated and if they want to
00:27:38 get us so much then 0.87
00:27:40 fine by me, just go off
00:27:42 you know, as an Englishman
00:27:44 I'm not sure that we should buy the
00:27:46 SNP's narrative
00:27:48 as being representative of the feelings
00:27:50 of the Scottish people though, I don't know how
00:27:52 representative they actually are, they didn't actually
00:27:55 win when they put
00:27:57 it to the vote and I think like you were saying most people even though I identify as English
00:28:04 and I've got Welsh heritage I might have a little bit of Scottish in there most people have a mix
00:28:10 and the same is true in Scotland and the lowlands are very different politically from the highlands
00:28:16 and the cities are very different from the rural areas and so you know I think it's important not
00:28:22 to buy into the SNP's narrative and to bolster them by responding
00:28:27 as if they are actually representing the feelings of the Scottish people
00:28:31 because I think it's so much more complicated than that.
00:28:34 Well, I noticed an interesting opinion poll after the referendum in Scotland
00:28:39 which was saying that, in fact, the majority of ethnic Scots
00:28:44 had actually voted for independence.
00:28:46 What tripped them back into getting a no result? 0.98
00:28:52 was actually English immigrants into Scotland,
00:28:55 of whom there are nearly a million,
00:28:58 and over 80% of those voted no.
00:29:04 So that was, I thought, an interesting insight into what had gone on there.
00:29:08 I tend to agree with what Peter said,
00:29:10 that let's compare it to an unhappy marriage.
00:29:14 If one partner can't stand it and wants to get away and wants to break away,
00:29:20 And I agree with Emma, we shouldn't necessarily assume that the majority of Scots do buy into this SNP narrative.
00:29:28 But if they do, or if they in five years, 10 years time do, I think most English people would say, go.
00:29:38 I don't think there would be a great battle, sad to say in some ways, to save the Union.
00:29:44 I think in that sense, Britishness has weakened over the last 50 years.
00:29:48 The British state has actually been, in effect, trying to bribe Scots to vote to keep the Union.
00:29:54 That's what the Barnet Formal is partly about.
00:29:56 And it was actually expressly about, at the time, it was about trying to undermine the appeal of Scottish nationalists.
00:30:04 If I could just say that the one thing, or one of the things, that seems to be keeping the whole thing together actually is the monarchy, is the institution of monarchy, in a way.
00:30:14 Now, if Scotland got independence or if English got independence, would we just have an English monarchy?
00:30:24 Would it actually go back to being possibly with Elizabeth II, Elizabeth I was the last purely English queen, wasn't she?
00:30:33 Yes, she was. And of course, the Act of Union in 1707 did actually create, and it says so, the United Kingdom of Great Britain.
00:30:43 So for Scotland to go, that's got to be repealed.
00:30:47 And the two political constitutional entities that were brought together in the Act of Union
00:30:54 was the Kingdom of England and the Kingdom of Scotland.
00:30:58 That's what the Act of Union was about.
00:31:02 As far as the Welsh concerned, the Welsh Wales had been incorporated into the Kingdom of England in 1536 under the Tudors.
00:31:11 But of course, if you repeal the Act of Union, then you have the crown, the king or queen of England.
00:31:22 But I don't think it necessarily has an impact on the monarchy beyond that,
00:31:30 because if you think about it, after all, the queen is also the queen of Canada.
00:31:35 She's the queen of Australia.
00:31:37 Yes, but the interesting thing is that this might seem like a small point,
00:31:40 But I mean, you know, the time being as it is, the Queen is not going to be here for many, many, many years.
00:31:48 You could have a situation where Scotland says, actually, that's fine.
00:31:51 Now, with her going, we do not want, you know, King Charles III, or as he would be, Charles II, wouldn't he be in Scotland, I think?
00:31:59 Yes.
00:32:00 That could actually be a major symbolic thing, could it not?
00:32:03 I mean, it's breaking a tie.
00:32:05 It's breaking one of the things that keeps the union together.
00:32:08 yeah i think the i think there will be questions when the present queen goes um and um maybe this
00:32:18 is why prince charles likes to wear a kilt so often so frequently and or maybe likes yeah
00:32:25 cross-dressing anyway um but i think i think the monarchy is a symbol of union and um it was
00:32:32 significant, one of the
00:32:34 diplomatic lapses that David Cameron
00:32:36 meant, when he relayed the result
00:32:38 of the Scottish independence
00:32:40 referendum to the Queen,
00:32:42 he said she purred with delight, all words
00:32:44 to that effect. That won't be forgotten.
00:32:46 And that won't be forgotten, absolutely.
00:32:49 No.
00:32:50 We still don't have a public holiday
00:32:52 for St George's Day, do we?
00:32:54 This must be one of your lesser
00:32:56 demands. Yes, we
00:32:58 do say there should be a public holiday for
00:33:00 St George's Day. It is extraordinary, isn't it?
00:33:02 No, we don't have a public holiday.
00:33:04 We don't have any public holiday.
00:33:05 It's specifically about England or the English,
00:33:08 unlike the Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland,
00:33:11 who have separate holidays.
00:33:13 And England, of course, has, curiously, three saints.
00:33:18 We have St George for England.
00:33:21 We have St Edmund for the English.
00:33:24 And we have St Edward the Confessor for the English monarchy.
00:33:28 and so you could have any one of three saints days or in fact you could have a secular
00:33:35 date which would be the date of our unification 12th of july yes although some uh alsterman might
00:33:43 argue about that date can you think of uh just to finish off i mean i i i glory in being an
00:33:49 englishman actually i mean i love even saying it i love saying i'm an englishman you know i do
00:33:54 in Gilbert and Sullivan's
00:33:56 Despite All Temptation, He Remains
00:33:58 in English.
00:34:00 But is there something
00:34:02 you can feel that is
00:34:03 tokenistically or in
00:34:06 essence English for us to finish a program
00:34:08 with St George's Day just around
00:34:10 the corner? What would
00:34:12 you say is an English
00:34:14 thing that you could do
00:34:16 or a feeling
00:34:18 you have? Oh, that's actually very English.
00:34:20 For me, it's humour
00:34:21 without question, the sort of humour.
00:34:25 Yes, we have an unusual sense of humour, I think, at English.
00:34:30 And pragmatism.
00:34:31 We are pragmatics as well.
00:34:33 And I think the sheer length of our history
00:34:36 makes us not so revolutionary, as you were saying,
00:34:40 but more sort of able to take a long view on things.
00:34:44 Cool-headed.
00:34:44 I think the English language.
00:34:46 Language.
00:34:47 And associated with it, arguably the greatest literature,
00:34:51 the greatest writer in the world
00:34:54 and it's a language which has travelled
00:34:56 everywhere, it's now the universal
00:34:58 language, so that would be my
00:34:59 system of Englishness
00:35:01 For me it's the landscape
00:35:03 so I think
00:35:05 that there are some places
00:35:08 particularly that have that
00:35:10 ancient feeling to them
00:35:11 and I think most
00:35:13 people would be pretty hard pressed to go
00:35:16 to those places and to not feel
00:35:18 places like Lindisfarne
00:35:19 even to some extent I feel the same way about Scotland so maybe it's not perfectly
00:35:26 distinctively English but I think there's something about the way that places and you
00:35:31 know places in Suffolk and there are some places that just feel distinctively English and pastoral
00:35:37 and they have that deep sort of ancient wild feeling alongside the kind of gentle pastoral
00:35:45 nature that seems to sort of fit the English
00:35:48 character. And sometimes even
00:35:49 the English landscape is
00:35:51 summed up in a piece of music, like
00:35:53 Vaughan Williams' Fantasia
00:35:55 on a theme by Thomas Towers. Whenever I hear
00:35:58 that I think of English
00:36:00 hillsides in English. I remember
00:36:02 going to, when I was on a holiday in the Morven
00:36:03 Hills once, went to the top there,
00:36:06 it's very corny, but played the Enigma
00:36:07 variations, but it was
00:36:09 very much of a time. The fact is,
00:36:11 to finish it, how
00:36:13 easy it was for us to come up with those
00:36:15 things. Humour,
00:36:17 landscape and language. It took no
00:36:19 time at all, did it? So that
00:36:21 shows the strength of something, I think.
00:36:24 Anyway, on that
00:36:25 note, thank you very, very much, Robin.
00:36:27 Thank you, Nigel. And
00:36:29 we'll see you next time, but
00:36:31 also celebrate St. George's
00:36:34 Day when it comes.
00:36:36 And we certainly will be.
00:36:38 Okay, so see you next time.
00:36:40 Thank you.
00:36:43 No, no, no.