New Culture Forum - October 18, 2021


George III - The Life & Reign Of Britain's Most Misunderstood Monarch -- Andrew Roberts

Migration Watch: Tory Government Is INCREASING Immigration, Which Is Already At Unprecedented Levels Sir David Amess's Friend Ann Widdecombe on His Murder, MP Safety, Religion & Online Safety Bill

Episode Stats


Length

37 minutes

Words per minute

151.46

Word count

5,712

Sentence count

208

Harmful content

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle. Now I'm delighted that my
00:00:24 guest this week has been on the channel before when he wrote an enormously
00:00:29 successful book on Winston Churchill. Andrew Roberts has just written a new
00:00:35 biography of George III, but of course he's the author of something like 18
00:00:41 books, including biographies of Lord Salisbury, Lord Halifax and Napoleon. The
00:00:48 new book is called george the third the life and reign of britain's most misunderstood monarch um
00:00:57 thank you very much for coming andrew thanks very much peter it's great to be on the show again yes
00:01:01 um most misunderstood monarch now the way that most people have seen this i would say in this
00:01:07 country at least is in sense of was he mad or what did he have some terrible illness or whatever
00:01:15 but this is wider than that isn't it much wider yes i think the three things that people know
00:01:20 about george the third was that he was he had porphyria this form of madness that he his
00:01:27 obstinacy lost us the american colonies and obviously from the declaration of independence
00:01:33 and from um hamilton the musical uh he's thought of also as a tyrant and all three of those things
00:01:39 are completely wrong. It wasn't porphyria that he had, it was manic depression and bipolar disorder,
00:01:47 which most doctors now accept. So that theory, which has been around for 50 years, in which
00:01:53 Alan Bennett and Nicholas Heitner and others, you know, made TV shows and plays about,
00:01:58 completely wrong. He most certainly was not an obstinate idiot who lost the American colonies.
00:02:06 In fact, he was a constitutional monarch, and it was the politicians and later the generals and admirals that lost that war.
00:02:14 And he certainly was not a tyrant either.
00:02:17 America, in fact, was one of the most free countries in the world in the 1760s.
00:02:21 And we know what 18th century tyranny was like from the Russians and Austrians and Prussians and so on.
00:02:28 And the way he treated America was completely different from that.
00:02:32 so basically we've got him wrong um but america has him wrong you mentioned hamilton the music
00:02:40 that um this idea of tyranny and of george being a a tyrant uh that is very much the american view
00:02:50 it's holy writ in america and understandably so every nation needs to have its creation myths
00:02:56 but it is a myth. The king was guilty of imposing taxation. It was only ever very small amounts of
00:03:04 taxation, by the way, and it was all the money that was raised was going to be spent in America
00:03:09 on Americans. But nonetheless, he did have the right to tax the constitutional right in the same
00:03:15 way that his nine predecessors since Elizabeth I did. And he also, of course, had veto powers over
00:03:21 American legislation. So that justifies, in my view, the revolution. You know, they had the
00:03:28 right, they had the ability, they had the numbers, they had the economy to set up their own state in
00:03:34 the 1770s. But that doesn't justify the propaganda, sheer wartime propaganda, of making him out to be
00:03:41 a tyrant. He wasn't. In the 28 charges that Thomas Jefferson accuses him of in the Declaration of
00:03:49 independence, only two of them are true. Apparently around this time we've had a
00:03:53 lot of statues being torn down haven't we, but his was torn down in New York wasn't it?
00:03:58 Yes it was during the revolution, in fact only a few days after the
00:04:03 Declaration of Independence. So the declaration came out on the 4th of July
00:04:07 1776 and his statue was pulled down in Manhattan on the 9th of July. There were
00:04:17 large numbers of statues that were being attacked.
00:04:20 You know, his coat of arms was pulled down.
00:04:23 They changed the names of places that had his name in it.
00:04:28 So it was a sort of general free-for-all, really,
00:04:30 in the way that you get in revolutions.
00:04:33 Would you go as far as to say that he was a great monarch?
00:04:37 I mean, you're obviously, you know, looking at him in a different light now.
00:04:41 I don't think he was a great monarch, no.
00:04:43 I think he was a great man.
00:04:45 But because he was a constitutional monarch and he only on one occasion ever actually sacked a government that had a majority in the House of Commons and appointed another.
00:04:56 And he was justified in doing that in the subsequent general election in which the incoming government won a landslide victory.
00:05:05 But he was a fine man. He was a really upstanding, splendid man in so many ways.
00:05:11 He was the man who created the Royal Academy, who created the nucleus for the British Library with his library of 80,000 books.
00:05:20 He bought Buckingham Palace and had a proper loving relationship with his wife, the only one of the Hanoverian monarchs actually to be faithful to his wife.
00:05:31 He was a good-natured man, as we see from the diaries of Fanny Burney, and he was somebody who showed tremendous sort of dignity and a sense of duty in the sense, actually, I believe that he's the founder of the modern monarchy, much more than Queen Victoria.
00:05:48 we'll probably come on to that later but so in that sense I think when we look
00:05:52 at our present Queen we see a monarch who has inherited many of George III's
00:05:58 best attributes. Yes I mean as you say we're going to talk about a bit later
00:06:04 but without which can be too frivolous you have the situation of George being a
00:06:09 very domestic man, didn't travel very much did he? No he never went
00:06:12 extraordinarily he never went north of Worcester or west of Plymouth he he was
00:06:16 king of Scotland and Ireland and never went there. He certainly didn't go to
00:06:21 America of course and he was a lecturer of Hanover and never went there either. 0.65
00:06:25 He stayed in the home counties. But you know we have an extremely worthy
00:06:30 monarch now and obviously George III had a very
00:06:36 difficult relationship with his son George IV who was more extravagant
00:06:41 should we say? Oh my god he was absolutely totally
00:06:44 He had compulsive buying disorder.
00:06:46 He was the sort of Imelda Marcos of the 18th century.
00:06:49 He couldn't see something without buying it.
00:06:51 There was one point where he was spending as much money,
00:06:54 and it's essentially taxpayers' money,
00:06:56 because he got bailed out all the time by Parliament,
00:06:59 the same amount as we were spending on the Royal Navy.
00:07:02 Yes, but do you think that, I mean,
00:07:05 Prince Charles has a kind of reputation
00:07:06 for being rather extravagant, doesn't he?
00:07:07 Whereas the Queen's very thrifty,
00:07:09 but it's not in the same league.
00:07:11 Nothing like the same league.
00:07:12 No, but George III was frugal as well, and he ate and drank very abstemiously, you know, like the Queen does.
00:07:20 So I suppose there's the outlines of an analogy there, but really not at all,
00:07:28 because Prince Charles doesn't rack up massive debts that require the whole of the sort of British economy to be rocking in dealing with.
00:07:38 um if you look back at this extraordinary period not just the american war of independence but
00:07:47 of course we had the as you say in the book the agricultural revolution the industrial revolution
00:07:51 the napoleon it was because he was up until that point the longest reigning wasn't he marlon he
00:07:56 well he still is the longest reigning king he's only king um when you said that he's a constitutional
00:08:04 monarch how did that work then and it's not really as we when we look at the monarch today
00:08:10 it seems very very clear-cut but you then mentioned there that he didn't sack a government i mean what
00:08:17 what was the role of the constitutional monarch in his time it was much more powerful obviously
00:08:23 than the one today but he didn't veto any bills for example which he had the constitutional right
00:08:30 to do, he only on one occasion appointed a prime minister who didn't have the support
00:08:35 of the House of Commons. And that was because the radical Whigs were trying to nationalise
00:08:40 the East India Company and would have therefore accreted to themselves such huge powers that
00:08:45 he thought that that was going to alter the powers in the constitution. He was able to
00:08:50 and did and was one of the last prime ministers to, sorry, the last monarch to appoint cabinet
00:08:59 ministers separately from the prime minister and and deal with them on a one-to-one basis
00:09:05 and after him everybody dealt with with governments through the prime minister so that gave him a good
00:09:13 deal of power but it's it's it's less power than the american president has today for example
00:09:19 right so if that were the case with george when would you roughly say that the monarchy as it
00:09:24 stands today in political terms would that have been victoria that that really formed yes that's
00:09:29 his that's george iii's granddaughter queen victoria who very much um was able as you see
00:09:35 in the bedchamber crisis of uh of 1843 was able to sack a government um was it 1839 as she did it
00:09:46 twice in fact um but um but she wasn't able to do that by the end of her time you know elections by
00:09:53 that stage very obviously did show the will of the people and monarchs weren't able to just ignore
00:10:02 that. I think one of the attitudes we have here towards the Hanoverian monarchs really, one of
00:10:09 the aspects of it is they're seen as being kind of alien or they didn't speak English as a first
00:10:17 language. George III was intensely patriotic, wasn't he? There's this phrase, born and educated
00:10:23 in this country, I glory in the name of Britain. Exactly. He was the first British Hanoverian
00:10:29 monarch. The first one didn't even speak English, but George spoke English without a German
00:10:37 accent. He spoke German as well, but he spoke English as his first language. And as you
00:10:41 say, he was a patriot. He thought of himself primarily as British. And indeed, he was quite
00:10:46 anti-Hanovarian in the early part of his life. When he was Prince of Wales, he called it that
00:10:52 horrid electorate. It was only much later when he was king and it was threatened by Napoleon
00:10:58 that he became a lot closer to it. Although not physically, as I mentioned, you know, he never
00:11:03 went there. Isn't it right that you had access to quite a bit of new material with this book from
00:11:10 the Wall Archives? Yes the Queen in 2015 put a hundred thousand pages of George
00:11:18 III documents, letters mainly, but lots of other kind of documents on to
00:11:24 something called the Georgian Papers Programme, a wonderful programme at
00:11:28 King's College London and so we have this vast new sort of avalanche of
00:11:33 material which was fascinating to go through because there's only been one
00:11:39 other biography of George III in the last half century and what emerged from
00:11:47 this material for you well one of the really interesting things that emerged
00:11:50 from it was that as Prince of Wales when he was writing an essay as a as a young
00:11:57 man in the 1750s he actually very much opposed slavery and he says in this essay
00:12:06 that all the arguments for slavery are ludicrous and ridiculous
00:12:10 and that it has to be held up to execration.
00:12:14 And that's why, I think, he never bought or sold a slave in his life.
00:12:18 He didn't invest in the companies that owned slaves.
00:12:22 He, of course, signed the legislation that abolished the slave trade.
00:12:26 But he was not an abolitionist himself.
00:12:28 And you have to, this is a difficult issue, really,
00:12:31 because of course we all know how evil, what a monstrous thing slavery was. And partly this was
00:12:39 because he was a constitutional monarch and there was no majority for the abolition of slavery
00:12:44 during his lifetime in the House of Commons or the House of Lords. And also he recognised that
00:12:51 about a third of the revenues that came from the West Indies, which was a huge amount of British
00:12:58 government income, really did come from stuff like sugar, which they couldn't work out a way
00:13:07 of farming without slavery. I see. So it was very much the contemporary pragmatic mindset,
00:13:16 if you like. It was realpolitik. But also, the positive side of it is that he didn't want to,
00:13:23 even if he had wanted to abolish slavery, he probably wouldn't have, because as I say,
00:13:28 He was somebody who did not want to go against the will of the House of Commons and the House of Lords.
00:13:34 It wasn't until 1829 that they got rid of slavery, and he'd been dead nine years by then.
00:13:44 Can you just tell us just some of the sort of treatments he would have been subjected to when he was...
00:13:51 Oh, so terrible. Poor man.
00:13:52 I mean, it's really, the pathos of it is overwhelming sometimes.
00:13:58 He was put in what was called straight waistcoat, what we call a straight jacket, for hours and hours on end.
00:14:10 He was physically held down in a chair that he nicknamed his throne.
00:14:16 He was gagged when he talked too much.
00:14:19 on some occasions when he had these attacks he would talk for 24 hours without stopping.
00:14:25 He was given the most incredibly painful bleeding so-called cures, which were not cures at all,
00:14:35 they just made the whole process worse, where they would put something called cupping, where they
00:14:42 They would put a glass on his thigh and his arms to sort of bring up and heat it.
00:14:49 It would then be heated and it would sort of lacerate his skin.
00:14:56 He was incredibly brave.
00:14:57 He was a brave man anyway, he survived six assassination attempts and he was immensely
00:15:02 brave in the Gordon riots and in the invasion threats and so on.
00:15:06 But never more brave, I think, than when he was the helpless spectator at his own mental
00:15:11 collapse.
00:15:12 and he did actually in the end go what we might call insane oh yes no he was absolutely this uh
00:15:19 it was a it was a bipolar disorder that um for the last 10 years of his life he had five
00:15:25 attacks of it most historians say there were only four but i've discovered a prodrome attack in 1765
00:15:33 that i'm certain was this and um and the last whole 10 years of his life uh he was he was mad
00:15:41 And he was also, poor man, senile and blind and deaf.
00:15:46 And when his blindness came on, you wanted examples of horrible things that happened.
00:15:52 Well, when his blindness came on with his first set of oncoming blindness, they put leeches on his eyes.
00:16:05 It's just unspeakable, isn't it?
00:16:07 Unspeakable, unspeakable.
00:16:09 he was also known as farmer george wasn't he and and there are some examples in the book uh of
00:16:16 really very touching uh encounters with like ordinary the public long before we had things
00:16:23 like the walkabout and everything i mean he would actually i suppose the king could walk about then
00:16:27 without necessarily being recognized well i mean other than the currency there was you know people
00:16:33 didn't know what he looked like much um there were some prints of course but uh uh you wouldn't
00:16:39 spot him um uh sort of coming down the road and see and think that's the king especially as he
00:16:45 very often went around without any entourage at all and he dressed as a normal gentleman farmer
00:16:51 um so uh at least a gentleman you know he wasn't uh he wasn't um like louis the 16th who who sort
00:16:59 completely overdressed all the time and so he would just wander around the
00:17:06 countryside sometimes and bumping into into ordinary people they he talked
00:17:12 about the price of hay and and there are lots of occasions where where the
00:17:18 person then later is surprised to to discover that she's been talking to the
00:17:23 king. These stories abound, usually at the end he gives her a guinea.
00:17:32 He seemed therefore to be popular for a lot, as you said, for long stretches, but he also,
00:17:38 there were a few attacks as you say, I think on his way particularly onto the state opening
00:17:44 of Parliament.
00:17:45 Yes he wasn't always popular at all, you know, especially in the early part of his reign,
00:17:49 appointed a Scot, the Earl of Bute, to be Prime Minister at a time that the Scots were tremendously
00:17:56 unpopular still in London because the Jacobite Rebellion had only ended in 1745. And that made
00:18:05 him profoundly unpopular. His mother was very unpopular as well, completely unfairly, that
00:18:12 people thought that Princess Augusta had been sleeping with the Earl of Bute, this Prime
00:18:17 minister, which she wasn't, but nonetheless, that brought unpopularity. So during the Wilkesite
00:18:26 riots, supporters of the journalist John Wilkes threw stones at his carriage as he went, as you
00:18:35 said, to the state opening of Parliament. And, you know, on occasion, it got pretty nasty. They
00:18:41 were full-scale riots. Do you, this goes perhaps for all your subjects, I mean, do you, have you
00:18:53 ended up liking, say like George or Halifax or sort of, ended up liking or admiring them more
00:19:01 than when you started out? Some I have, others not. Lord Mountbatten I wrote about in my book
00:19:10 eminent Churchillians, who I was expecting to like much more. And actually, I found him just
00:19:17 too much of a showman, and too obsessed with his own reputation, and too willing to manipulate
00:19:24 the evidence with regard to his own reputation. So I'm afraid he didn't really grow on me. There
00:19:31 have been a few others also. But with Winston Churchill and Napoleon, I think it's probably
00:19:38 the sense of humor they don't they were just you know very funny people they were constantly coming
00:19:43 out with with jokes that are still funny uh in napoleon's case 200 years later as it shows a
00:19:49 sort of humanity i suppose doesn't it that and and and a slight ability to take the mickey out of
00:19:55 oneself um which one doesn't automatically assume is uh there in a um a conqueror or an emperor
00:20:03 One thing that's quite interesting really is that during George's reign, it was a kind of revolutionary
00:20:09 time, there was the French Revolution, and then that obviously after he died it became more so
00:20:16 in Europe. Did he have a sense of the institution being fragile? The institution of monarchy? Yes.
00:20:23 Very much, especially after the execution of Louis XVI. He had a sort of love-hate relationship
00:20:29 ship with Louis XVI because, of course, it was Louis XVI's declaration of war against
00:20:36 Britain in 1778 that could effectively turn the American Revolution into a world war and
00:20:44 meant that it was going to be very, very difficult for us to win.
00:20:48 So France being the rival power, he didn't mind seeing a revolution there, but one that
00:20:56 started to chop off royals heads of course suddenly becomes an awful lot more uh serious
00:21:02 ideologically and um and that's why he after a lifetime of being opposed by edmund burke
00:21:09 for example once burke wrote his reflections on the revolution in france um george embraced him
00:21:15 so uh that is um that is a moment of a very worrying moment not just for george of course
00:21:23 but also for the Austrian, Prussian, Russian monarchies.
00:21:29 Do you think the monarchy now is more fragile than it would have been that?
00:21:35 I mean, you know, when we see that he went through periods of unpopularity, for example,
00:21:41 there's very, very vivid demonstrations, people actually throwing things to his carriage.
00:21:48 That would never or doesn't really happen now.
00:21:51 No.
00:21:51 But do you think the institution, if the foundations were basically laid during his reign, do you think it's in rude health?
00:22:02 I think it is with Her Majesty the Queen. Absolutely. I mean, apart from, of course, she's in her mid 90s.
00:22:09 But I think that whenever you look at the polls, the number of people who want a republic in Britain,
00:22:16 I mean, it's pretty much the same as people who want to have everyone speak Esperanto.
00:22:21 So it's a really sort of fringe interest, really, Republicanism in this country.
00:22:29 Yes. It's interesting you mentioned that when you look at the polls,
00:22:32 that the Republican percentage hasn't pretty much changed for about 40 or 50 years.
00:22:40 This is despite the ups and downs.
00:22:42 But it does seem sometimes that the rest of the establishment,
00:22:45 perhaps in a way that wouldn't have been the case in Georgia today,
00:22:47 are pretty much pitted against it in a way.
00:22:52 Well, I think that some of the newspapers can go very far in denigrating the monarchy,
00:23:01 but they certainly did in George III's time as well.
00:23:05 And when one thinks of those cartoons of Gilray and Rowlandson and so on, Cruikshank,
00:23:13 You know, they were incredibly vicious, much more vicious, actually, I think, than you get away with today.
00:23:19 So I think for the monarchy to be in danger, you would have to have one of the great political parties embrace republicanism.
00:23:27 And actually, you know, want to argue in the House of Commons and the House of Lords that this system be changed for a different one.
00:23:35 And not even the, actually, I don't know what the stance of the Greens is on the monarchy.
00:23:42 They probably are Republican, aren't they? But other than that, I don't think it's been embraced by any sort of mainstream party.
00:23:55 You don't think that there would be a possibility that, you see, there's absolutely nothing to be gained, is there, by attacking the Queen because she's universally respected.
00:24:03 But once she's no longer there, one can see sort of situation arising where people start asking for referendums, things like that.
00:24:10 And also, of course, there are going to be some Commonwealth countries, probably, that leave the Commonwealth after, or at least they don't leave the Commonwealth.
00:24:19 They will no longer have the British head of state as their head of state.
00:24:24 And that's a process that's already starting.
00:24:27 But frankly, I think the British people are so much more intelligent than they're given credit for by some people because they can tell the difference between having a person who's unpopular as king or queen and actually getting rid of an entire system that's been around for a thousand years,
00:24:48 provides a bulwark against dictatorship and over mighty politicians and which has worked extremely well.
00:24:57 And it's a very cheap form of having a power above politics.
00:25:03 So I think that even if you had, say, Prince William became unpopular, it doesn't mean that they would, the British people would get rid of the entire monarchy.
00:25:15 I think they just wait until Prince George.
00:25:18 I think what's particularly interesting in the in the context of our times this past year um what we talked about when you were last on on the channel which was uh the statue toppling that went on um the monarchy in a way is the absolute living embodiment of what is disliked by these people it is the symbol of our history it's a symbol of our imperial history and I just wonder whether
00:25:46 much more than that, also the apex of a class system, the fount of honour, the
00:25:53 centre of philanthropy, lots of things that people who want to overturn society hate.
00:26:02 What I've found is that people who were natural republicans, some of them have been on this show,
00:26:09 are sort of finding themselves sort of lining up with the monarchy because now so much is at stake
00:26:16 it seems. I mean I wanted to ask you a little about about this Andrew. I mean when you started
00:26:23 out as an historian I'm sure you wouldn't have seen yourself as being on the absolute front line
00:26:30 of an attack generally on on our past i mean in some ways you are there on the front line as an
00:26:39 historian well i don't know that i am but churchill is of course he's on the front line of the culture
00:26:44 wars and i am the most recent biographer of churchill so in a sense i'm sort of you know
00:26:50 i'm i'm pushed there um but and i'm perfectly happy to be there by the way i think the culture
00:26:56 wars are genuine it's a genuine struggle not brought on by by conservative minded people at
00:27:04 all but by ultra progressive people who want to use them as a way of destabilizing our society
00:27:12 our sense of identity our sense of where we came from and so on so I think that if you are
00:27:19 and by the way I think they'll ultimately lose the culture wars as well because the more that
00:27:24 people recognise that this is a struggle, the more ordinary, normal, sensible people come to
00:27:31 the side of the argument that says, no, we shouldn't be pulling down statues. We should
00:27:37 perhaps be putting statues in their proper context. We should be putting up more statues.
00:27:44 But if any local community is asked whether or not Buller in Exeter or Robert Baden-Powell
00:27:53 or um francis drake are going to be pulled down in their market squares i think you're going to
00:28:00 get a huge majority against it and so i'm up i'm up for these these local referenda i think the
00:28:06 more the merrier yes great when they happen um but i think what from what you know the comments
00:28:12 we get from viewers uh is there is a they're perplexed that even though there's such strength
00:28:19 the feeling popularly um somehow the steamroller seems to carry on well exactly yeah it's the it's
00:28:25 left up to the trustees of guy's hospital to to box up um uh thomas guy and not up to the people
00:28:33 around you know who ought to have a vote on it i think when when local people are given a vote
00:28:39 on these things they'll give a resounding raspberry to the people who for entirely
00:28:45 politically correct and woke reasons want to try to see um the past entirely in terms of the
00:28:52 present which is as moronic as trying to see the present in terms of the future um you know and uh
00:29:00 and you just can't do it you can't i mean we don't know what oliver cromwell would think about
00:29:06 socialized medicine it's just impossible to time travel like that but that's essentially what these
00:29:13 work people are trying to make us do I mean do you do you subscribe to the view of there having
00:29:21 been a long march to our institutions because because the reason I ask is that you know
00:29:27 you have described for example when you have spoken at various I think there was a panel on
00:29:32 Churchill that you spoke at and it seems to me the case that the people that you are with who are
00:29:40 you know attacking churchill they're doing it because he's an emblem particularly of our spirit
00:29:47 you know that's how he's seen for better or worse um and they are in these institutions they are in
00:29:53 incredibly influential universities on this occasion actually the institution was churchill
00:29:59 college cambridge where four academics i wasn't on that panel four academics uh were sort of
00:30:06 of basically egging each other on. They all agreed with one another that Winston Churchill
00:30:10 was, as one of them put it, as bad as Hitler. This was last February. And yes, there has
00:30:18 been a long march through the institutions, really since the 1960s, and not just the academic
00:30:24 institutions, but you see it really across society. I was hoping that a Tory government
00:30:31 would, certainly one that's been in power for 10 years, would have turned this back in some way.
00:30:38 I haven't seen that yet. I know that some people are involved in that and tried hard. I think Oliver
00:30:44 Dowden did a good job as Secretary of State for Culture. I've got high hopes for anybody else who
00:30:51 takes up those cudgels. But it does seem that although the British people are still willing to
00:30:58 vote Tory, there are fewer and fewer actual conservative-minded people at key places in
00:31:08 British culture and society, and it doesn't seem to be affected by who's in power.
00:31:15 But can they, for example, can a government not make sure that when appointments are made
00:31:22 to Quangos, for example, or these sort of things, that they are made by people who are more
00:31:27 sympathetic to their view because that that is that is happening but it's it's happening late
00:31:34 and it's not happening um you know aggressively um and uh and also you know there is an element
00:31:42 that if that i mean tony blair did this he he he he understood the uh the power of the
00:31:49 quangocracy and and I just think that that conservative-minded people are a bit you know
00:31:57 late to the game frankly but it doesn't mean that I've still got high hopes that that you
00:32:05 know this is not a completely lost battle. So yes I mean you certainly you we you know
00:32:11 we as it were an inverse would win this I mean I think that people need to be encouraged so much
00:32:18 Because, you know, when you walk away from the kind of discussions we have and ordinary people, you know, living their lives, you know, and see every day a little bit more being chipped away.
00:32:30 And this is utterly demoralizing, which I think is surely is one of the purposes of it.
00:32:35 Absolutely. Yes. No, I agree.
00:32:37 I think that the literal sense of demoralization of a nation is something that certainly the extreme left would love to achieve in this country.
00:32:48 But, no, the reason that I said that I think that we're winning is only if, A, people know that there's a battle going on, which I think they do now, and B, their voice is heard, especially at the ballot box, which is why, as I mentioned, I think that before any statue is taken down anywhere, there should be a vote of local people about it.
00:33:10 You're involved with a new campaign, History of Reclaim, which I think is started by Robert Toomes.
00:33:17 Yes. Well, Robert, you know, he's very much the driving force, as is David Abelafia,
00:33:23 the professor at Cambridge. But also I think they have 40 or 50 people, including me,
00:33:29 on their sort of advisory board. So it's not just beleaguered Robert, there are lots of us.
00:33:38 And this basically is, is it a website or is it something people can become involved?
00:33:43 It's a website, absolutely. It's got ambitions to be much more than that. It's got a lot of hits, actually, quite astoundingly large number of people, you know, visit it and donate to us and so on.
00:33:59 And what it's going to do is really be a quick response unit, rapid response unit, they're called, aren't they?
00:34:07 When something, you know, ridiculous and woke and untrue is said about history, about some historical figure or some historical fact,
00:34:18 it's going to come out with the truth, which is going to be properly researched and evidence based and factual.
00:34:25 and we've already tried this actually
00:34:29 and very successfully I think
00:34:31 with this Churchill conference
00:34:34 that you mentioned earlier
00:34:35 because Policy Exchange, the think tank
00:34:38 put out a, I think it's like a 20 page
00:34:44 refutation of the arguments made
00:34:47 that I wrote along with Zuditu Ghebriones
00:34:51 and together this has been put on
00:34:54 to the History Reclaimed website so anyone can read it and it's had a
00:35:01 tremendous response actually. Yes also I'm reminded of the Free Speech Union
00:35:07 it's a similar sort of thing where people go and actually have you know
00:35:12 advice. That's right well with what Toby Young is doing in the Free Speech Union
00:35:18 is a kind of more general kind of thing that History Reclaimed is doing.
00:35:28 But it actually gives you proper legal advice.
00:35:31 If you think that you've been sacked for some woke, politically correct reason,
00:35:39 if you're a Brexiteer, for example, and you've been chucked out of your job because of that,
00:35:46 then you go to Toby and the Free Speech Union, which I'm also very proud to be involved in,
00:35:53 and they will lawyer up for you.
00:35:56 So this is a fight back, really, isn't it? I mean, history reclaims.
00:35:59 A very late one. We're tiptoeing around what can be and can't be done.
00:36:05 But yes, of course, it's a fight back because you're actually fighting for something that's really worthwhile.
00:36:11 I mean, British history is not something to be ashamed of.
00:36:13 It's something to be proud of. And it's tragic that that isn't taken for granted, really, by lots of people.
00:36:22 Well, I think history, surely, you know, basically you can't, you shouldn't wipe out people's background, their memory, their story.
00:36:32 And their ancestors, you know, and their, you know, if you have a grandfather who worked in the, I don't know,
00:36:40 the Selanese police force, then you should be proud of that, because these people, 99 times
00:36:49 out of 100, were doing excellent and good work. And for them to be sort of attacked and slagged
00:36:56 off just because they were colonialists or imperialists or so on, I think is a terrible
00:37:00 way to treat people's ancestors. Well, what we should do, we'll put the link to History Reclaimed.
00:37:08 you'll see it under this video and do go look it's fantastic stuff and Andrew
00:37:18 thank you very much for that and the book again George the third by Andrew
00:37:24 Roberts the life and reign of Britain's most misunderstood monarch it is
00:37:31 majestic thank you very very much you are kind peace very much enjoyed it thank
00:37:36 you that's it for so what you're saying is we shall be back next time thank you very much