New Culture Forum - July 30, 2021


How to Stop Migrant Crossings? Vaccine Passports: Chinese-style Social Credit System by Stealth?

Nick Timothy - Elites Regard Englishness As Dangerous & Embarrassing Carl Benjamin (Sargon Of Akkad) - An Elegy For England & English Morality

Episode Stats


Length

39 minutes

Words per minute

183.43

Word count

7,320

Sentence count

135

Harmful content

Hate speech

22

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to the second episode of Widdicombe, Webb and Wobberts. I'm Emma Webb
00:00:16 and I'm here with the former Shadow Home Secretary and Brexit Party MEP Anne Widdicombe and comedian
00:00:23 Abby Roberts. And throughout the show you can send us your questions through the live stream
00:00:29 or via Twitter using the hashtag NCFWWW or you can send us an email via contact at
00:00:37 newcultureforum.org.uk. Since our last show there have been, to say the least, a lot of developments
00:00:44 particularly on the vaccine front. So I think that is where we will begin with this article in
00:00:51 the spectator by ross clark who i mentioned in the last episode had written this interesting
00:00:55 article in the telegraph about the potential for vaccine passports to become some kind of
00:01:00 broader electronic id has now written in the spectator about the government's moves towards
00:01:08 transforming vaccine passports into some kind of overall health passport that would do things like
00:01:13 record your fruit and veg intake your the amount of exercise that you do and to give you credit
00:01:21 like this chinese social credit system to reward you for good behavior and presumably to penalize
00:01:28 you for bad behavior as well and he was talking about the potential of this to affect people's
00:01:33 you know access to everyday life so i thought given that we were fighting about this last time
00:01:39 round, we should bring this one up again. So Anne, if you would like to begin by savaging
00:01:45 me. First of all, there is no law on earth which compels you to download an app. Absolutely
00:01:51 none. You don't have to prove your vaccination status via app. You can do it as I've done
00:01:56 it through letter. There's nothing wrong with that at all. Secondly, I don't quite get
00:02:00 this. So you're going to be rewarded if you buy some fruit and veg. What happens if you
00:02:04 then go next door and buy a great sticky bun? Who's going to know about that? I mean, are
00:02:08 we're going to have ccdv cameras linked up to the camera society they can see when you buy that
00:02:13 as i said last week you know i think there is a fine line um between uh seeing an encroachment
00:02:20 of liberty and just getting into conspiracy theories so you know if the government wants
00:02:24 to monitor my intake of veg it's going to have an exceptionally hard job to do it because i
00:02:28 simply won't download the app it's so difficult about that but i think the fact that we are
00:02:33 even discussing this i mean i think a few months ago i was i said you know so jokingly on twitter
00:02:39 oh what next you know are we going to be told off what we eat everyone went oh you're mad
00:02:44 what a surprise i mean the thing is once once an app one i mean we won't we won't have the app
00:02:50 because we're sensible rational people but many people will just go well it's what the government
00:02:54 wants and of course the next thing you know they're tracking what you eat who you sleep with
00:02:59 your medical history oh no I've started early this time I'm scandalising Anne but then and also
00:03:06 couldn't you just strap your phone to your dog and then get it just to run at a great distance
00:03:11 this was a point that this was a point that Ross Clark made in this spectator article is that
00:03:16 they're already trying to look at ways to stop you from being able to send your phone on a jog
00:03:21 with a friend while you chow down on a pizza but I think the concern is that we've seen this with
00:03:28 because you say that you know this wouldn't be an issue if like with the nhs app people are just
00:03:33 offloading it now to get around the issue of the pinged pandemic people are coming off
00:03:37 but there are but there are signs that there will be circumstances in which
00:03:42 yes now it's not mandatory to have the app but it could be so for example we've seen with care
00:03:48 home staff that vaccinations have become mandatory there are discussions underway
00:03:51 that were announced this week that boris johnson is apparently discussing making vaccine passports
00:03:56 mandatory for students or vaccines mandatory for students but it will be done through vaccine
00:04:01 passports um and so that there and also we've seen it with you know discussions about the premier
00:04:07 league whether unvaccinated fans should be banned so if we're already talking about making um vaccine
00:04:13 passports mandatory in certain circumstances it's easy to see how that could become a slippery
00:04:17 slope where the government have access to other not just even medical it is we made this point
00:04:22 before it's a point of medical confidentiality but also having access to your your health and
00:04:27 behavior records in other contexts political views they can sort of like tap you and sort of you know
00:04:33 so where are we going with this well everybody knows what my political views are why would i
00:04:37 because you choose why would the government want yeah i mean because you choose to reveal them
00:04:41 you know you choose to but i mean but we've already got inquiries into political views you
00:04:46 have things called opinion polls you have things called a canvas and just about everybody in the
00:04:51 whole of the country has been canvassed at some point you know I just calm down everybody calm
00:04:57 down and focus on what is actually happening and what is important and let me say right from the 0.93
00:05:04 start I think there are circumstances in which it is reasonable to require vaccination care homes
00:05:10 and hospitals being two of them so let's let's just have a quick look at some of the statistics
00:05:15 here because um there was a survey done by the british chamber of commerce they surveyed a
00:05:21 thousand firms and they found that 31 of firms um with more than 50 employees had suggested
00:05:29 considering vaccine passports so could you imagine do you think it's possible that we could imagine
00:05:34 a situation in which firms could you know require evidence of your broader health rather than just
00:05:39 oh but they do anyway a lot a lot of firms have medicals a lot of firms make they do that anyway
00:05:45 come on let's stop inventing stuff but the thing is in 2020 2019 we were the uk you know doing well
00:05:53 civil liberties talking to each other i mean things were in the background maybe going down
00:05:56 a bit of a weird slope with sort of woke left stuff but suddenly 2020 we've we've become
00:06:02 communist china well sorry but we've become a completely different country we have a comment
00:06:07 here from um maggie from plymouth who says boris is going to become the prime minister he always
00:06:13 warned against do you think that this is you know i mean there have been lots of people who have been
00:06:18 making this point but he's incredibly for a conservative government and you've got a communist
00:06:22 well we haven't got a communist but he's incredibly weak and i incredibly weak and i don't think that
00:06:29 that that he stands up for actually what he believes in which is free britain do you remember
00:06:33 him right at the beginning of this pandemic right right at the beginning uh when advising people to
00:06:40 stay at home and television interviewers said why don't you make it mandatory oh this land of liberty
00:06:45 well where is the land of liberty now where is the land of liberty exactly and also i mean you
00:06:50 could i suppose argue this government is more is communitarian in it but communitarian is just a
00:06:55 polite word for communist no it's not well i mean we we're but but the thing is now now let's not
00:07:01 make communitarian a dirty word even though you know tony blair was one but anyway um the fact
00:07:06 when you have a when you have a vaccine as well you can still get the virus so what's the point
00:07:12 of having vaccine passports because that's literally like showing your you've had a vaccine
00:07:17 and then going but i've also got covid vaccine passports but not negative tests and also come
00:07:23 september despite the fact that we've seen the most substantial decline in covid cases
00:07:27 without lockdown over the past week.
00:07:29 There's also been, yesterday, a study done
00:07:33 that showed that the tests couldn't tell between COVID and flu.
00:07:38 So a lot of people that were in hospitals...
00:07:41 We've been suspecting that for a long time.
00:07:43 ...actually had flu.
00:07:44 So the numbers are completely wrong on this virus.
00:07:48 The fact that the numbers have been wrong
00:07:49 has been evident for a while.
00:07:51 I mean, the question is by how much are they wrong?
00:07:53 Yes, by how much.
00:07:54 And also how many other diseases,
00:07:55 How many other coronaviruses, of which there are hundreds and hundreds in the human body,
00:08:01 are we then going to shut down entire economies for?
00:08:04 How many more?
00:08:06 It's worth pointing out that when you look at those statistics for the numbers of deaths from COVID,
00:08:12 it clearly says underneath it, the government makes it very clear underneath it,
00:08:16 deaths for any reason within 28 days of a positive COVID test.
00:08:21 It says for any reason.
00:08:22 now neither the BBC nor ITV ever read out for any reason they always say deaths within 28 days of
00:08:31 a positive the implication being you've died of COVID and we know that there is a complete muddle
00:08:37 between dying of COVID i.e. COVID caused your death and dying with COVID and you've come into
00:08:43 hospital because you know you've got some serious respiratory problem yeah you test positive for
00:08:48 covid three days later it doesn't actually follow that you've died of covid because you may almost
00:08:53 certainly have got covid in hospital so i would say it's the hospitals and care homes we need to
00:08:59 be looking at what are they doing to to minimize any um transfer of transmission of viruses
00:09:06 whatever they may be that moves us very swiftly on to talking about nhs reform because this leaked
00:09:12 data in the last couple of days suggested that over half of COVID hospitalisations tested positive
00:09:19 for COVID in hospital so they were hospitalised first so as you say these are people who have died
00:09:25 within 28 days of receiving a positive test may have gotten that test in hospital and so
00:09:32 the discussions this morning have been all around whether or not this raises questions also about
00:09:36 nhs reform with mike graham on talk radio saying that the nhs is essentially analog in a digital
00:09:43 age um and that we should be discussing all of this you know all of the stuff around um nhs
00:09:50 capacity the fact that the beds are currently socially distanced and so on and and the fact
00:09:56 that i think it was only one or two people in each hospital around the country very small
00:10:01 proportion of beds are actually going to COVID patients? Look, COVID apart, COVID apart, the NHS
00:10:07 needs reform. It wasn't designed to cope with what we've got today. The founding fathers of the NHS
00:10:19 made three completely incorrect assumptions. And the first and most crucial one was that because
00:10:26 we had an NHS, we'd all get healthier, which we have. And that because we all got healthier,
00:10:30 this is a crucial thing demand would decline so you've got a system based on declining demand
00:10:38 yeah whereas in fact demand is going towards infinity and that is because bevan could not
00:10:44 have foreseen we're talking about the 1940s he could not have foreseen the explosion of medical
00:10:49 and surgical science which was going to take off in the 60s and keep going ever since and that is
00:10:55 very simplest before you had hip replacement surgery you didn't have any cue for hip replacement
00:11:01 so there was no demand because the thing that is demanded wasn't there and therefore it's gone
00:11:07 into complete reverse we don't tackle it because we're afraid of public opinion when i say we
00:11:12 i mean politicians in general all parties are afraid of public opinion on this one and then
00:11:18 very quickly the other two errors were that longevity would stay roughly the same well
00:11:22 now we've got 16,000 centenarians and everybody takes it for granted you can get into your 90s
00:11:27 and the third was that national insurance would contribute a significant portion of the cost of
00:11:32 the NHS which is now a joke it's 80% of it comes from general taxation and it caused a spike in
00:11:37 population because the population increases did they presumably they didn't predict that by
00:11:42 improving people's overall health they would therefore live longer and there would be more
00:11:45 people well as I say they didn't get longevity they were busy rebuilding I suppose the country
00:11:50 after the second world war so there was all that as well wasn't there they had a 1940s perspective
00:11:54 yeah i mean in 1950 the average age of women was 69 years old that is you retired at 60
00:12:02 and you only got your pension for nine years before you died um and people forget now because
00:12:09 we understand longevity we think oh well it must always have been obvious it wasn't always obvious
00:12:14 it wasn't obvious yes simone from surrey says uh people earning over 500 000 pounds a year
00:12:21 presumably uh should uh should have to go private freeing up the nhs for those uh who don't have
00:12:28 the money oh i've said for a long time those who can afford to pay and i don't think you need to
00:12:31 get half a million before you can afford to pay those who can afford to pay should and that is
00:12:36 why um until i could not get the vaccine because i was in the private sector um that is why i have
00:12:43 not dealt with the NHS for about 40 years I was in my 30s when I left the NHS and went to the
00:12:50 private sector I've recently had to re-register and fill in a 10-page form in order to get the
00:12:56 vaccine because my private sector doctor wasn't allowed to feed me in at the appropriate time
00:13:01 I got it about three months after my age group and that's the other crazy thing isn't it is that
00:13:05 the um because I've had personal very awful experiences with the NHS but also the private
00:13:10 sector and what people i i can never understand why people don't want to tackle this is that
00:13:15 most of the nhs consultants work in the private sector so in fact really they're just sort of the
00:13:21 same thing um the other thing i was going to say is that this sacred cow um would would only be
00:13:26 appropriate calling it a sacred cow apart from the fact that the nhs is a cow with three legs
00:13:30 half an udder and one eye and if that was a cow called daisy and that was in my field i'd say
00:13:37 sorry days you know what your days are your daisies are numbered move along sorry i had to put that in
00:13:45 but in all seriousness what the nhs is letting down the poorest in our society this is what i
00:13:51 cannot understand we've got a two-tier system two-tier system well actually we've got a three-tier
00:13:55 system yeah and and you have people going to the nhs you know i don't really understand what's
00:14:00 happening you have consultants who frankly are in my experience condescending beyond belief
00:14:07 So they don't understand what their illnesses are.
00:14:10 They don't have people...
00:14:11 We need to have a completely gut it,
00:14:14 completely gut our health system.
00:14:16 What we have to ask before we do any gutting is,
00:14:19 if we were designing a health service now,
00:14:24 knowing what we now know, what would we do?
00:14:29 But even having asked that question,
00:14:31 you then have to say,
00:14:33 but you need to design something which can change.
00:14:37 And, for example, in 1998, when I was Shadow Health Secretary, and I was saying all of this then in 1998, you know, we need to ask ourselves that question.
00:14:45 I was proposing workplace health schemes analogous to workplace pension schemes with similar reliefs.
00:14:51 Now, of course, occupational pensions have died a death as far as final salary schemes go.
00:14:58 And we have the gig economy, which means an awful lot of people are not in a workplace in that sense.
00:15:03 so that would have had to change and our problem is we've got a system which was based on
00:15:10 presumptions that no longer hold good yeah and it can't change we haven't got change built in
00:15:15 and it's always absurd bizarre to me that it's the the left whenever the right says this the
00:15:21 left always says oh but that's because you know you just want to sort of get people to you know
00:15:24 be take that what do you have or pay all their money that they can't afford a health service
00:15:28 it's like well actually no this this this will change the lives everyone's lives for the better
00:15:34 i've never why do you think the nhs has become this sacred cow why what what has led us to this
00:15:42 situation where we you can't question that you can't even talk about it's political it's a
00:15:45 political consequence you know the labor party always say that we want to that the conservatives
00:15:50 either want to destroy the nhs or want to privatize the nhs or whatever it might be
00:15:54 And it's become something that the public is so scared of happening.
00:15:58 And as soon as you talk about insurance, they don't look at Germany.
00:16:01 They don't look at France.
00:16:02 They look at America.
00:16:03 America.
00:16:04 And say, oh, we don't want to be like America.
00:16:07 And I say, I'm not asking you to be like America.
00:16:09 And it is a debate that we desperately need, a grown-up debate,
00:16:13 because we've got a three-tier health service.
00:16:15 On the top tier, you've got the people who get their NHS treatment
00:16:18 or they choose to go private.
00:16:20 On the next tier, you've got the people who don't get their NHS treatment
00:16:23 because there's postcode prescribing or whatever it might be.
00:16:26 They just accuse it too long, they'd be dead by the end of it.
00:16:29 And they don't choose to go private, but they can.
00:16:31 Sometimes it's a big sacrifice.
00:16:33 And on the third tier, the very people for whom the NHS were set up
00:16:37 in the first place, the people who don't get their NHS treatment
00:16:40 and if they starved themselves for a year,
00:16:42 still couldn't afford to go private, they are dispossessed.
00:16:46 And this system is being defended.
00:16:49 Yes, exactly.
00:16:50 And the left still say, but let's keep it as it is.
00:16:53 I mean, it's kind of bonkers, not to mention the fact that the NHS, during COVID, has just sort of gone, let's just leave cancer and heart attacks to one side.
00:17:05 I mean, my late husband, God bless him, died of cancer at the end of 2018.
00:17:10 I mean, I am apoplectic with rage, as I know people like Carol Sikora, Professor Carol Sikora, that cancer undiagnosed and late treatment has led to, I mean, the numbers are boggling and we don't even know.
00:17:26 And something that no one is talking about is the fact that, and I know this from the horse's mouth, that cancer patients are getting pinged by the NHS app and not getting their chemotherapy as a result because they're having to stay at home and isolate.
00:17:37 I mean, why is nobody in the mainstream media holding the government to account in front of, you know, in an account.
00:17:45 Because it means criticising the NHS and we mustn't do that, must we?
00:17:49 And we must do it.
00:17:49 That must change.
00:17:50 We must do it.
00:17:51 To draw an analogy on the point of systems that were set up potentially to help people who need it and actually end up disadvantaging them because everybody else is taking up those services.
00:18:05 the migrant crisis because um that's something that's been in the news this week with um you
00:18:12 know people who are coming over economic migrants who are obviously taking up resources and spaces
00:18:17 that could be given to genuine asylum seekers um it was reported uh this week in the mail
00:18:22 that record numbers of migrants have been coming over nigel farage has been out there
00:18:26 in a boat looking very dishy with a kerchief 0.68
00:18:31 Brexit suits him well.
00:18:33 He's like a ring swept.
00:18:35 Nigel, I see you in a new light.
00:18:37 And he's been reporting that the French vessels, as we all know,
00:18:42 French military vessels have been escorting migrants into British waters
00:18:46 rather than taking them back to French shores.
00:18:49 And that we've had hundreds of boats coming in every day.
00:18:53 These are people that are presumably economic migrants.
00:18:56 and now because the crisis is so bad airport border staff have been redeployed from the
00:19:02 airports um at a time when apparently according to the times one in ten people from the border
00:19:08 force have have been pinged and have to isolate um because of the nhs app so really it's an
00:19:14 absolute shambles on every possible level um so yes what what are your thoughts on what's going
00:19:22 on is priti patel or talk do we need a similar reform of our immigration system to what you're
00:19:28 discussing to do with the nhs there is only one way you you get out of this and i mean i said this
00:19:33 again 1999 a shadow himself else own secretary then yeah i said very clearly the only way you 0.99
00:19:39 get out of this and there is a way out of it is that every new asylum seeker must be detained in
00:19:45 a secure reception center not a prison but a secure reception center so that we know where 0.96
00:19:51 they are, we can deal with their cases, and we can turn them around if we're going to
00:19:57 say no. Now, what actually happens is the complete opposite. The message that's going
00:20:02 out is if you get to Britain, if you can actually get into Britain, they're not going to be
00:20:06 removed because we don't have national identity cards. We don't routinely practice detention.
00:20:12 We do have a flourishing underground economy. And so it's the easiest place in the West
00:20:18 just about in which to disappear without trace so when we come to reject the application
00:20:24 where are they don't know where they are and we do continue also to pay i think it's only a couple
00:20:30 of pounds less in money to people whose applications get refused so they're only really losing a
00:20:38 couple of quid a month and also there are a lot of people getting very rich aren't they from these
00:20:43 these people trafficking companies like circo as well yeah the companies and they're not on the
00:20:47 boats of course they're not exactly of course they're not you know risking their lives um you
00:20:51 know uh in in dinghies although the dinghies are getting a lot more not just like little tiny
00:20:56 dinghies i mean they're getting proper hundreds of people wooden boards yeah absolutely um i mean
00:21:01 i god i completely agree with ann um that's a you know the the rational um what's the word 1.00
00:21:08 compassionate way forward I think now we need the army on the on the shores if you've got the army
00:21:16 I'm sorry this is this is where we don't get it if you've got the army on the shores
00:21:21 the boats still land yes and they still say I claim asylum and they can still disappear
00:21:28 because they just have to get to the boat and where would they all they got to utter is three
00:21:31 words I claim asylum that's all they got to do sure and where would the asylum would these centres
00:21:37 be sort of you know on the on the shore or somewhere somewhere we'd have to work out where
00:21:44 to put them i had a couple in mind at the time that i was shadow home secretary you you take out
00:21:48 you take on existing structures yes yeah um and you use those uh and it's perfectly possible to
00:21:55 do um i know because at the time i looked at it in some detail yeah but after me oliver letwin
00:22:01 who then took over a shadow home secretary actually proposed and that proposal has been
00:22:05 revived by Priti Patel that you could actually process them offshore. Yes, that's what I was
00:22:11 going to say, like offshore wind farms, offshore migrant farms. Mark from Middlesbrough. Sorry,
00:22:16 you've got to find somebody willing to do it. That's the only thing. Well, Mark from Middlesbrough
00:22:20 agrees. He says, I agree with Anne. Why don't we process them on the Shetlands or one of the
00:22:25 unpopulated British overseas territories, which is obviously something Priti Patel has suggested.
00:22:30 He says, maybe we can make them stay there. That would stop them coming.
00:22:33 it would certainly have a deterrent effect and um you know that is the idea it is to deter
00:22:42 what you should not be doing which is what priti patel is doing is paying the french
00:22:46 millions of pounds to do the thing that under their international obligations they should be
00:22:52 doing well one argument is that by paying we paid the french 20 odd million in october and now we're
00:22:58 paying them another 50 odd million yeah but by doing so when they keep failing to do the job 1.00
00:23:02 We're just incentivising them to do the job badly
00:23:04 because we'll keep paying them tens of millions of pounds
00:23:07 if they keep messing it up.
00:23:09 They want to pass their problem on to us.
00:23:10 And also, it's like, why did we leave Europe 0.89
00:23:12 if we're still paying the French to do their job? 0.98
00:23:15 It's absolutely ludicrous. 1.00
00:23:16 I don't mind contributing to some joint efforts
00:23:19 if they're genuinely joint efforts.
00:23:20 This isn't. This isn't.
00:23:22 This is saying to the French, we'll pay you all this money 0.99
00:23:24 to do something which you should be doing 1.00
00:23:26 and which you're not going to do anyway.
00:23:28 Ken from Penzance says,
00:23:30 these aren't refugees they're economic migrants most of them are young men who've left women and 1.00
00:23:34 children behind deport them to the last country they left why can't we do that easier said than 0.98
00:23:39 done and and this is where you have to understand some of the problems um you get it particularly at
00:23:45 the airports for example you get people turning up at the airports without documents and saying
00:23:51 they've come from such and such a country yeah where there is a record of persecution now in
00:23:56 order to return immigrants or anybody else for that matter in order to return people to the
00:24:02 country of origin that country of origin under international law has to accept them as nationals
00:24:09 and they don't always do that and sometimes it's quite so it's easy to say but the Dublin
00:24:15 convention says you have to claim asylum in the first safe country you come to well if we know
00:24:20 they've been through France that was as safe as houses that was there yes that's where they should 0.64
00:24:24 stay yes so why why is it that we can't just simply when they reach our waters put them on a
00:24:29 boat send them back to france well a the will is not there um but b france could very simply say
00:24:35 well you know they they didn't land here they may have come through our waters but they've come
00:24:39 through you know they've come somewhere else a very difficult to prove a where they've been
00:24:44 b where they came from yeah and the genuine ones of course they aren't they're very few and far
00:24:49 between but they're the ones who supply all the information because they are genuine refugees and
00:24:55 you can test it but we have people saying they're children when in fact they're quite visibly
00:25:00 pensioners it's true you may not but it's true it's true you have people saying they've come
00:25:07 from somalia and they can't speak a word of the language you know you just yeah i i don't think 1.00
00:25:13 anybody realizes what it's like on the ground that's why i say contain them all because then 0.99
00:25:17 what are they coming to detention yes and if we're going to have a job proving
00:25:21 that they're the national of a particular country and then they stay
00:25:25 there it sounds harsh but it might be the only way to actually tell the
00:25:28 difference between genuine you have proper proper secure facilities you
00:25:33 know which can cater for children where necessary yes I cater for women you know
00:25:37 proper decent facilities with education and all the rest of it it's not harsh
00:25:42 yeah it's just the extraordinary thing I suppose that we've got to this stage and
00:25:45 And I suppose it's because successive governments have, you know, yourself excluded, have...
00:25:53 I wasn't in government at the time of this, yeah.
00:25:54 I should say politicians then, have just sort of shrugged their shoulders, said if it's going to be, it's going to be.
00:26:02 You know, well, there are people coming to this country who don't like the West very much,
00:26:07 don't like, you know, our values and Judeo-Christian traditions.
00:26:11 that's where i'm appalled that no that very few people have have said enough i mean this has been
00:26:19 happening isn't it for like 20 20 odd years and you get a lot of talk i mean pretty is a very good
00:26:24 example of somebody who talks very big indeed and delivers precious little you know and that 54
00:26:29 million that we've just paid france we could have put towards constructing reception centers
00:26:34 yeah practical practical practical more useful yeah so something else that has been in the news
00:26:40 this week um quite horrifying uh a lady called hatton tash a 39 year old lady at speaker's corner
00:26:48 um she appears to have been stabbed in the face and there's a horrendous video of it
00:26:53 um and this lady she's a she's a convert from christianity to islam she preaches at
00:26:58 speaker's corner regularly from islam to christianity no other way yes from islam to
00:27:03 christianity sorry sorry did i say it wrong way around um and so she she she preaches there
00:27:08 regularly she's previously had threats against her as well the Metropolitan Police had to ferry
00:27:14 her away at one point because there were threats against her life and at the time Sadiq Khan made
00:27:22 a strange equivocating statement where he said that he thought that the police had to balance
00:27:29 the right to free speech with the right to of the police to manage behaviour that could lead to
00:27:35 public disorder so rather than criticizing those who is your speaker's corner yeah speaker's corner
00:27:41 has never yet been charged with breach of the peace no and and you know you must have
00:27:45 statements likely to cause a breach of the peace every day in speaker's corner because that's what
00:27:50 it's for that's what it's about exactly it's about people being able to say anything yes but i
00:27:56 wouldn't read too much into that attack that is a lone attack oh yes it happened you know it
00:28:02 we mustn't get things out of proportion that was an attack uh of an by an individual on an
00:28:11 individual and unless the police can show otherwise it's got to be treated that way
00:28:15 so she was also she was one of the other points is that she was wearing a charlie eddo t-shirt
00:28:20 and um we obviously know what has happened previously with the teacher in batley and
00:28:25 with samuel patty in france and given that she'd already received threats and actually the free
00:28:29 speech union had written to the met saying asking for her to receive proper protection because she'd
00:28:35 been threatened before um and there's a video for uh also from the same day with that was going
00:28:40 around on social media with some people in a group near speakers corner saying that she had it coming
00:28:46 so it looks as if it isn't just some sort of like freak out they just targeted her and decided to
00:28:51 sort of stab her in the face and i think as far as i'm aware the police haven't arrested anyone yet
00:28:55 this person just ran away again we've given extremists in islam we've given them an inch
00:29:04 and now they've taken the whole cow shed i don't know if that's offensive i don't really care um
00:29:08 i i it's unacceptable in this country for somebody to at speaker's corner to be wearing a t-shirt 0.54
00:29:17 of a magazine where 12 individuals were murdered by islamists to to for the press to be silent
00:29:24 about it is even more worrying and what's happened is we've again we've done this well which is
00:29:30 ironically a bit of a french gesture we've kind of gone oh you know that's why we're getting and
00:29:36 it hasn't just this isn't um an isolated incident this is going to happen again and again and again
00:29:42 if we keep apologizing for these this kind of behavior whether it's woke left you know sort of
00:29:48 stopping people saying things or whether it's somebody with a knife stabbing your speaker's
00:29:54 Joanna Williams tweeted earlier this week
00:29:57 saying that this was the armed wing of cancel culture
00:30:00 or something to that effect.
00:30:02 I just think we need to be careful.
00:30:04 I mean, if you think of the murder of Joe Cox,
00:30:06 it was very much portrayed as this is the result of, you know,
00:30:10 right-wing activism, et cetera.
00:30:12 It wasn't.
00:30:13 It was one man who held those views who did that.
00:30:16 And when it happens on the other side,
00:30:18 we must also allow for exactly that same possibility.
00:30:20 Now, if the police can find the man
00:30:22 and he has been radicalised, then that is different.
00:30:26 Then you've got to trace the radicaliser.
00:30:29 But with Joe Cox, I would argue that there aren't men
00:30:33 like the man that committed that crime against Joe Cox.
00:30:36 There's not, what's the word, that's not systemic.
00:30:41 I would argue that the crime against this woman at Speaker's Corner
00:30:44 is part of a systemic problem within Islam, within one religion. 0.52
00:30:49 And what they want, because they haven't been through an Enlightenment, and I know there are many Muslim scholars that would say the same thing, because they haven't been through the Enlightenment, like Christianity, and Judaism, of course, and Judaism, that is why we are where we are. 0.94
00:31:05 because we're dealing with people that don't understand no this is not the country if you 0.60
00:31:11 want to do those by all means go to a country that will um execute you if you blaspheme
00:31:17 you that's not the united kingdom and somebody what we all needed to say no enough i wonder
00:31:24 whether so um obviously we've seen recently that there are lots of people who are willing to for
00:31:31 example commit criminal damage or other acts of violence not just in relation to what you would
00:31:36 say maybe like blasphemies against any particular religion but also um blasphemies against certain
00:31:43 taboos certain either spoken taboos or um in alignment with wokeism however you want to
00:31:50 describe it um because earlier earlier today i saw um on twitter there was a clip from a lecture
00:31:57 given at LSC. It was someone from the Department for Gender Studies, a student presented a paper
00:32:03 at a conference and I'm going to read out the quote to see what you think of it. So this student
00:32:09 said, and it said so in quite a poetic way, I'm not going to manage to capture that, said
00:32:14 we go unnoticed right up until the moment they scream for mercy. Am I a threat to you? Do I send
00:32:22 chills down your spine picture this i hold a knife to your throat and spit my transness into your ear
00:32:28 does that turn you on are you scared i sure effing hope so um and according to this tweet this was
00:32:37 obviously in the context of talking about turfs so i guess my question to you is you know obviously
00:32:44 we know all of the context around hatted tash and charlie abdo it's something that's been going on
00:32:49 for a long time all the way from Salman Rushdie, Theo van Gogh, you know, so many different
00:32:55 cases and the Charlie Hebdo satirical cartoonists themselves being gunned down in 2015. We know
00:33:02 the context of that. We know that, you know, Islamists want to physically harm people who 1.00
00:33:10 blaspheme against their ideology. But my question to you is more, are we seeing a sort of
00:33:18 worrying drift towards an intolerance against other taboos as well or other people who hold
00:33:24 other views um how concerned should we be about you know potential violence against say turfs
00:33:31 very um now i don't think that that necessarily exemplifies it because i haven't seen the whole
00:33:36 paper i don't know in what context those particular lines appeared um you know it was a paper from a
00:33:43 student it isn't as if this is you know a sanctioned university course or whatever it might
00:33:48 so i just want to be very careful about drawing from that but i think should we be worried um
00:33:54 about um violence towards people whose views are deemed unacceptable to the wokerati i think the
00:34:01 answer is yes because i think that's the path we're now going down um you know it began with
00:34:07 social condemnation then it went to cancellation where your actual livelihood can be under threat
00:34:12 You know, the next stage is probably some sort of violence.
00:34:18 Now, I'm not saying that everybody who holds both views would approve of that,
00:34:22 but everybody doesn't have to.
00:34:24 It will be sufficient if some do.
00:34:26 Yes, exactly.
00:34:27 And also these strange, these TERFs, I mean, I've been called a TERF.
00:34:30 To start, I'm not trans-exclusionary, and I'm not a radical feminist.
00:34:35 So it's sort of like... 1.00
00:34:37 So it's all wrong, isn't it?
00:34:38 So it's all wrong.
00:34:39 it's no i believe there are two biological sexes i'm i'm i'm an adult um human female that's my
00:34:46 i happen to be white uh but that and that's that's who i am but i don't i don't um it's this
00:34:52 it's this grouping together of people even if it's inaccurate that's the funny thing is like
00:34:57 i'm not gender critical i do believe that there are with within men and women and they've done
00:35:02 experiment you know obviously with chimps baby chimps that a male chimp will go for the building
00:35:07 blocks and a female tiny baby chip will go for the go for dolls i mean they've done many
00:35:11 experiments where that is sort of your behavior is sort of aligned with your gender so that's
00:35:18 that's that's another thing which but again the left love to sort of put people into into groups
00:35:24 um without looking at individual views they just sort of go well that's you then so to wind up
00:35:31 briefly um i also wanted to put to you some statistics from a poll that was published in
00:35:35 the spectator um through steer pike apparently um 40 of the public would support the government
00:35:43 censoring books with content that is sexist homophobic or racist so they serve according
00:35:49 to whose definition yeah and 29 said that they don't know whether they would agree with that
00:35:54 and so some of the other stats here um 62 said that they would support social media companies
00:36:00 censoring similar content 57 said that ofcom should have greater powers to find broadcasters
00:36:06 who make offensive comments and 51 said that they agreed that the government should stay neutral in
00:36:11 societal debates on cultural issues like taking the knee so my question is twofold firstly um
00:36:19 has the conservative government on these cultural issues misjudged the mood of the public if this
00:36:24 poll is correct and also given what we were just talking about in terms of the growing intolerance
00:36:29 towards particular views particular taboos does this suggest that actually the british public
00:36:35 would be more tolerant of the government taking a role in censoring those views
00:36:40 than perhaps we thought well i think one of the if i've read that a poll correctly first of all
00:36:46 this is not a poll of just young people you know this is a poll right across the generations and
00:36:50 something like 40 40 think it would be okay for the government to act as censors on things like
00:36:58 racism and homophobia and all the rest now according to whose definition um is not entirely
00:37:05 clear now we've already got a situation in which you don't even have to objectively prove that an
00:37:11 offense has taken place somebody can claim that an offense has taken place um and that is enough
00:37:17 to have you uh with a police record i mean not a criminal record can be convicted anywhere but
00:37:22 it's enough to have you on some police register now you know it's getting dangerous it's getting
00:37:29 dangerous and yes there is a pushback you know we've got this we've got um gb news we we we've
00:37:37 got we got free speech union we've got a pushback going on but oh boy has it now got something to
00:37:44 push back against and maybe we should have had this pushback 10 years ago yes absolutely couldn't
00:37:50 agree more. We're seeing, I mean, the fact that we're almost certainly going to have
00:37:56 free speech legislation, which I very much back, by the way, is an interesting indicator
00:38:01 because, of course, we have an unwritten constitution. So we have a social contract with each other
00:38:07 that we've had, which has worked very well as the envy of most of the world. Now we're
00:38:13 seeing the the idea that the government are going to be more are going to sort of interfere more in
00:38:19 our lives um which i i will push back against with you know with every breath that's left in my body
00:38:27 i'm not going to have you know what's going to just five final thoughts um do you think that
00:38:34 this trajectory towards and i don't just mean on free speech but also when we were talking about
00:38:38 vaccine passports and so on do you think that we are hurtling towards a culture both in terms of
00:38:45 the relationship between the individual and the government but also people's views in general the
00:38:48 government's views also hurtling towards worrying restrictions on our liberty and whether do you
00:38:54 think that that's reversible it is reversible but it's not going to be reversible overnight
00:38:59 it will need more than just legislation it will need sheer social unacceptability yes directed
00:39:06 towards intolerance and until we have that which we once had and took utterly for granted
00:39:12 yeah where did it go yeah were we not alert when it was going completely agree and we need we need
00:39:17 to be intolerant of intolerance absolutely none of this sort of like well you know we might allow
00:39:24 that no no no we won't allow that because you give them a little tiny bit and then all of a sudden
00:39:28 you know we're all riding bicycles wearing maoist uniforms on that note wearing masks
00:39:35 on that note thank you Anne thank you Abby and thank you for watching as well so please do go
00:39:44 on hit the subscribe button and like and see you next time thanks very much or dislike we believe
00:39:51 in free speech not sure there is a dislike button