00:00:00Hello and welcome to Counterculture, I'm Peter Whittle. Now a recent report from Ofcom
00:00:18suggested that comedy was an endangered species when it came to BBC output. Certainly in the past
00:00:2610 years comedy as programming on the BBC has actually decreased by something like 40 percent.
00:00:34This is extraordinary. What does this actually mean for comedy in the state of comedy? And indeed
00:00:41since we last discussed this on counterculture the whole issue of woke attitudes and indeed the free
00:00:47speech issue has intensified hugely and these have major consequences for comedy now with me
00:00:56to talk about this i'm very pleased we have abby roberts comedian and writer hi peter
00:01:03hello simon evans who's a comedian and writer who's has been on live at the apollo and indeed
00:01:10was host of a show called simon evans goes to market on radio four and emma webb who's
00:01:17Associate Fellow at Cintas. First of all, I'd like to ask you, Abby, is comedy an endangered
00:01:26species, at least when it comes to the BBC? I think the BBC is an endangered species
00:01:31at the moment, in broader terms. I mean, I should explain, I've been out slightly of,
00:01:40I'm on stand-up as well, but I've been slightly out of the picture because my husband, who was
00:01:45also my manager uh passed away at the end of 2018 so i had um i had time away to observe
00:01:53with horror what what started to happen in in comedy um and i just i was just about to film
00:02:00my special an hour special called angli chanka um i speak russian i'm a fluent russian speaker
00:02:06so i went to moscow did two shows in moscow so this is a bit basically my cv for anyone who
00:02:12doesn't know me um and uh i i came back uh yeah i sort of like recovered from my grief um after a
00:02:21year um only to find out that we are actually now living really in in the soviet union right uh it's
00:02:29quite extraordinary so that's really a long and short way of saying i've been grieving for my
00:02:33husband and also grieving for comedy um and i i mean i should explain i mean i know russians i've
00:02:39been i've been to russia since the late 80s um my stepdad was a a spy sorry diplomat and um we uh
00:02:46so i used to go to russia a lot and i met i met solzhenitsyn i've met um israel berlin they were
00:02:53good friends of my my dad and honestly if if solzhenitsyn could hear what was happening in
00:02:58the uk now i mean he'd probably want to go back into a gulag right just for the hell of it um so
00:03:05I'm, yeah, in other words, there's a lot, there's, I don't even know if I've answered your question, Peter.
00:03:11Well, no, I think I get a very good, I mean, that opens up all sorts of areas.
00:03:15When you talk about, you know, Russia, I totally get that, and we will certainly come back to those.
00:03:20Simon, you know, do you think that this Ofcom thing, saying that, you know, comedy is an endangered species on the,
00:03:29specifically on the bbc i mean or even for that matter on itv or any channel do you think that
00:03:35there is a truth in that or or is it just hot air what well endangered species is a obviously quite
00:03:44a loaded term to use but if they're if they're quoting a 40 reduction in the or you're quoting
00:03:48a 40 reduction in the amount of output that's obviously pretty significant it doesn't necessarily
00:03:52need a descriptor like that to to give it weight i mean i'll be honest with you i'm i'm not great
00:03:58you know predicting the future if i were i'd be a bitcoin billionaire and and i wouldn't be
00:04:03bothering to appear on podcasts in the middle of the afternoon you know we can thank you too
00:04:07limitations i feel so much better simon the truth the truth i can't imagine any of us would really
00:04:16but um no in all seriousness it's very hard to see what's coming next but i think the
00:04:21the future for the bbc has probably never looked quite as uncertain as it does at the moment and
00:04:27And I don't think it's simply that it's downplaying its comedy credentials or indeed that it's necessarily that it's completely in hock or has been captured by, you know, the woke interests and the woke mindset.
00:04:39I think it is largely due to the fracturing of the media offer, you know, the amount of different platforms available and the amount of different outlets and routes to comedy and routes to other kinds of content.
00:05:15And during lockdown, which among all the other things that I didn't anticipate coming, primarily, you know, as you say, the re-emergence of identity politics in a much stronger strain and so on, competing for our attention with the virus itself.
00:05:31One of the things that's been most noticeable is that it's probably been the non-professional comedians who've given the best value.
00:05:37You know, the things that people share on WhatsApp, for instance, vastly funnier than the sort of watered down versions of panel games and sort of celebrity led stuff on the TV that has been enabled.
00:05:47As soon as you drain those sort of things of the studio audience, you see them, as people have said, during the, you know, during the 2008 financial crash, when the tide goes out, you can see who's swimming naked.
00:05:57and it was it was a good comment then but it was never it was never so powerfully
00:06:01apposite as it was in describing a lot of tv where once the studio audience had been drained away
00:06:08emma do you ever watch the bbc for comedy the last time i did it was nish kumar's um what's it
00:06:16yeah well quite um but i i think um the the it's not just comedy the writing of um tv dramas in
00:06:28general seems to just that the quality of scripts is just awful like and and there is a there is a
00:06:35lot of really great comedy um out there like comedy unleashed and there are people who are
00:06:40doing content independently online, on YouTube, on Instagram and on TikTok and things like that.
00:06:46There is really good comedy, but it doesn't seem to actually make it onto television, onto not just
00:06:52the BBC, but Channel 4 ITV. They noticed that there was the same polling that found the 40%
00:06:58decline on the BBC also said that there was a slight rise in some of the other channels, but
00:07:03that the BBC was still producing the most, most comedy. But the decline seemed to be mostly amongst
00:07:10sitcoms. And I think it's, at least from from my perspective, it the comedy is just not funny
00:07:18anymore. The sitcoms and the writing of it are just not particularly witty. There's nothing
00:07:23clever about it. And it is, I think, because you can't really make woke compliant comedy.
00:07:31it's unless it's heavy self-aware satire um you can't you can't really make it work and still be
00:07:38funny and and i think no one's willing to take the risk to make the interesting shows that will
00:07:43really grab people that will become beloved you know favorites like faulty towers or only fools
00:07:49and horses because um the risk is that the cost would just be too high well i think that say
00:07:55Only Fools and Horses would not be made now, would it?
00:13:11It's interesting hearing what Emma has to say about comedy clubs there
00:13:13and whether people are checking each other out.
00:13:15You know, I mean, I will defend comedy clubs to some extent.
00:13:19I recognise the phenomena that Emma is talking about, a degree of anxiety.
00:13:23But actually, that's always prevalent in comedy audiences.
00:13:27It was it's not it's not limited to, you know, the last two years of British comedy in the Soviet era.
00:13:33It was that they've done various sort of research experiments among audiences in British comedy clubs for decades,
00:13:41analysing the process by which laughter spreads throughout an audience and it is fascinating to
00:13:47see who laughs first and with confidence and who waits to see whether it's okay to laugh
00:13:51traditionally for instance and this is something that a lot of comedians have long been aware of
00:13:56perhaps even only subconsciously women are far more confident about laughing and deciding whether
00:14:01they like someone or not and their boyfriends and wives tend to keep an eye on them and let them
00:14:05take the lead men can easily be shut up in the crowd if their wives and girlfriends are looking
00:14:11at them in a certain way when they laugh too obviously in a way that women are not quieted
00:14:16by their men glancing askance so when you get an act like jenny eclair who was capable of you know
00:14:23peeling paint with the with the vulgarity and the the uh you know the sort of uh self0.95
00:14:30debasement of her material about the various sort of indignities of post-birth uh anatomy and so on0.95
00:14:35that was the sort of thing that women could just laugh at with with uh with like you know cackling
00:14:40hyenas and men who found it absolutely tokeningly embarrassing in respect were completely unable to
00:14:47have any impact on the degree to which women and so the audience all just melts you know
00:14:52it's quite interesting and i will say i think in the early days of what you know is now fondly
00:14:57remembered as alternative comedy the sort of alexis sale and uh and um kevin day and uh you
00:15:04know the the early days of of the comedy store with rick mayle and so on it wasn't terribly
00:15:10terribly brilliantly funny then either if you look back at it you know there was probably an
00:15:14absence of wit there was a lot of sledgehammer comedy a lot of sledgehammer punchlines and the
00:15:18political satire was pretty heavy-handed as well but it had a sort of energy to it it had a kind
00:15:23of punk energy that just carried the night everyone felt terribly excited I think as much as anything
00:15:29in comedy right now if I'm honest I think as much as anything it's slightly exhausted I don't think
00:15:34it's just that it's woke politics I think it's prey to woke politics partly because it's not
00:15:39strong enough to defend itself it doesn't have the sheer chutzpah to just brush that aside in
00:15:45the same way that certain musical genres are now becoming very introspective and anxious about their
00:15:50lyrical content yet you won't see that with hip-hop you'll still get a song like wet ass pussy that
00:15:55will get a billion views on youtube you cannot imagine a white sort of folk rock singer song
00:16:01writers you know penning something as as lascivious and as brazen as that but because the hip-hop
00:16:06genre still has lots of energy and confidence and a lot of a lot of fuel left in the tank and so
00:16:11these things power forward whereas live comedy it's probably due for a pretty major overhaul you
00:16:16know it probably needs a real shot a real kind of change something to really shake it up and
00:16:22reinvest it with some purpose and some self-confidence otherwise it will just yes
00:16:26endlessly go around in in ever decreasing circles this interesting but um abby i mean how is it you
00:16:33you said you've pretty much seen the death of comedy or rather that's what you implied at the
00:16:38beginning or at least yeah certainly in a in a kind of suspended animation but what is it like
00:16:44actually if you are a stand-up comic now i mean there's no way of doing it is there a part unless
00:16:50you go online what no i mean i i um i did my um after a period of time i did my first live gigs
00:16:59um just before christmas this last year and then boris johnson announced the second lockdown
00:17:05so i was like oh great uh oh fantastic thanks thanks boris and i have to say they were they
00:17:10were it was honestly it was oh i cried with joy being back on a stage being able to drip
00:17:16you know like sam kidderson all over the front row i didn't even care if i got coronavirus i was
00:17:20like oh this is just fantastic um and then to have it taken away is um is dreadful i really pray that
00:17:28this i mean with all due respect i love i mean this is nice but i mean please god let not zoom
00:17:33be where life where comedy is going because you have to you have to that's the beauty of it the
00:17:40warmth the kind of seeing the whites of the eyes the the slight thing i mean that's just me when i
00:17:44do comedy there's that feeling of the bristling you know in the audience i love that so i hope
00:17:50it doesn't die isn't that actually what we're all missing in our lives generally at the moment i
00:17:54mean basically and that is human interaction you know I just wonder you know generally with our
00:18:01culture you know this sort of when we come back you know people all tell me when it's finished
00:18:06when we're coming back whatever that is because the goalposts seem to be moving an awful lot
00:18:10whatever your your view on COVID you know the culture itself will be altered won't it it will
00:18:18be changed surely won't it i maybe it's wrong wrongly placed optimism hope that i mean in the
00:18:26in the interlockdown period and sorry to keep going back to comedy unleashed i just think it's
00:18:31the best thing that's happened in the last year and a half um but the the energy and the thrill
00:18:37of people in that audience having a laugh and seeing people that they hadn't seen in ages
00:18:43was so overwhelming that I just, I hope that when this is over,
00:18:49when people can actually go back into places like comedy clubs
00:18:52and see things live, that the sheer sort of warmth of the audience
00:19:00and the need for the social interaction and for a good laugh
00:19:05will overwhelm whatever incentives there are for,
00:19:11I presume the gatekeepers of comedy, and they must be, particularly with the BBC, to give people what they actually want.
00:19:18And I'm hoping that the energy and the weight of the deluge of people wanting this will force them to sharpen things up and have a bit of a revolution in funniness.
00:19:32Simon you know is it sort of I mean how I don't mean to pry into your personal
00:19:39finances or whatever I mean you wouldn't you wouldn't tell me anyway but I mean how the hell
00:19:46it wouldn't be much of a pry how the hell do comedians make a living at the moment I mean
00:19:55it's it's it's impossible is it not yes like abby i had a few gigs um and in brighton because it's
00:20:03um by the seaside and because it has that kind of mindset they did a few outdoor gigs some gigs on
00:20:08the beach we have an open air theater and there were a few and it was a wonderful um brief lacuna
00:20:13and um i had friends my wife brought friends along mainly through the school and so on who
00:20:18came in quite large groups and they were literally in tears afterwards they had enjoyed it so much
00:20:24They had felt that release that, you know, you can only really get from communal laughter.
00:20:43But really laughing, belly laughing, losing your shit over something that someone has said on stage to the point where you really are afraid you might wet yourself when you're middle age.
00:20:53you know there is nothing like that there's nothing so cathartic and and people have been
00:20:58denied it exactly when they've needed it most you know because we're we've we've and in this regard
00:21:04i do agree with abby we are living under what are really feel superficially phenotypically rather
00:21:10soviet you know experiences however well intentioned and indeed justified they may be
00:21:16you know i remain to be entirely convinced that we've taken the right right route but certainly
00:21:20people need to be able to share their kind of befuddlement and anxiety and irritation and rage
00:21:25and they've been denied all of that you know but yes you're also right of course comedians have
00:21:29been denied the right or the ability to earn a living I've been very lucky in this regard I have
00:21:34a wife who has a professional um you know who works in a in a sort of fairly sort of senior
00:21:40level in the public relations industry and has and has kept working very hard throughout you know
00:21:45and um god bless her she has kept the family afloat you know and it's it's i don't know what
00:21:50i would do if it if it were just me i suppose i would essentially be living on on some sort of
00:21:55handout but of course a lot of stand-ups fall between the cracks in that regard because they're
00:22:01often self-employed but of course they arrange their tax in such a way as to minimize you know
00:22:06income tax so they're encouraged to sort of set up uh corporation and then they find that they
00:22:12you know which is all you know that's just the the how it goes you you make decisions about how
00:22:17to present yourself for revenue purposes and then sometimes those turn out in the long run not to
00:22:22have been as useful as you might have hoped but you know there we go uh but uh i'm not i certainly
00:22:29wouldn't want to make this turn this into any kind of charity appeal for stand-up comedians
00:22:32and there are those among us i mean i've been doing it for 25 years i'll be brutally honest
00:22:36there are those among us of that vintage who quietly hope that perhaps it has lost its appeal
00:22:43to those who are superficially interested in it and see it as a sort of short ladder to some sort
00:22:48of celebrity status who think that you do half a dozen circuit gigs get on a panel game do a tour
00:22:52get your own show do you know what i mean there's it had become a little bit possibly it had become
00:22:58a little bit overpopulated as an industry and um i mean i started in 1996 comedy clubs were opening
00:23:05faster than comedians could be trained up to perform at them you know and that was a fantastic
00:23:10thing to to to experience comedy at that point it had kind of gone into reverse a bit in that
00:23:15regard and was a bit clogged so maybe some people who weren't entirely committed to it will have
00:23:20found other things to do now maybe that's not the end of the world i don't know can you uh give us
00:23:24names simon sorry could you give us names oh god of the of the of that the fame-seeking
00:23:32bye simon i'm gonna hand your list over to the kgb i can i can certainly think that's very much
00:23:39that's very much a subjective judgment but i'm sure it's not one that eludes some people
00:23:43you know when they see the various platforms that promote that do you think do you think
00:23:49as well on top of this that um i mean do you think yeah do you think that covid is just simply not
00:23:58funny i mean brexit brexit uh managed to spawn whatever we might have think about it you know
00:24:06some quite good humor some would became quite well known we had one guy on who did the famous
00:24:11burger king brexit thing which was a alice williams i think it's very very funny yeah it was
00:24:17But generally speaking, it was a source of laughter.
00:27:31And I think that is like almost a response of,
00:27:34I never want to say you've got to talk about these things.
00:27:36But comedy as an industry, you know, it really it has the capacity to address those issues in a way that very few other mediums really do.
00:27:43Because you can you can use a little bit of hyperbole and you can allow yourself to become too enraged.
00:27:49And, you know, the kind of physical the frustration of it, you know, the kind of basal faulty, impotent rage kind of vibe that you can give off is cover for saying some things that actually do need saying.
00:27:59I think you can you can you can sort of envisage or at least like a comedy from maybe in the 1980s
00:28:06or 70s being applied to this situation I mean I can almost visualize it uh you know uh the thing
00:28:13with masks you know there'll be a lot of comedy around masks and things like that slapstick style
00:28:18exactly but I just sort of feel that that is off limits now for many people so I Simon I think hit
00:28:24on this earlier when you said something that implied there's like a lack of self-confidence
00:28:29and it's the same thing with our reaction to coronavirus we're not really sure and when when
00:28:34and this might seem like an abstract point but when we're not sure about things we tend to
00:28:38make them fuzzy and blur them and it's the same with languages like the use of language like when
00:28:44politicians will speak in a way that intentionally obfuscates what they're saying so they've always
00:28:49got plausible deniability but if you have comedy that isn't straightforward and doesn't speak in a
00:28:54straightforward way it seems to be reflective of a society that has just lost its self-confidence
00:29:00like one example I'm thinking of is um like the the way that if you look at really really good
00:29:08stand-up it's it doesn't see it's not really on the right or on the left or it you know it just
00:29:14kicks in every direction up down left right it doesn't matter whatever's funny is is fair game
00:29:20um and i i can't remember exactly what the the initial tweet was but i had a bit of a twitter
00:29:26spat with al murray a while ago um where he was saying something along the lines of um good comedy
00:29:36punches up but of course his understanding of what is up and down is very different to my
00:29:40understanding of what is up and down but going back to the self-awareness point this is a man
00:29:46who kind of ripping off the character of Alf Garner has made his entire career out of taking
00:29:54the mick out of white working class people as a posh boy. And he thinks that he can give people
00:30:00advice that they mustn't punch up in comedy. But the point is that I don't agree with him
00:30:04politically, but I find Al Murray very funny. And I find the character of the pub landlord very
00:30:10funny, even though it's definitely from his position punching down. And it's this combination
00:30:15of a self-aware lack of self-awareness uh maybe like a crisis of creativity in the way that
00:30:20language is used it's just used in this kind of like blurry um and and obfuscating way um and
00:30:28also that that lack of like self-awareness of you know where you are positioned within things and
00:30:35and taking the mick out of yourself and not taking things too seriously and not worrying about the
00:30:39consequences because we're all sort of locked inside of our homes quivering with fear that
00:30:45we might we might wrong think or wrong speak or you know uh but this is the point this is that you
00:30:50this is what i think this is crucial with the whole woke thing which i mentioned at the beginning
00:30:55the whole work this is sort of different it's not like being pc and this is this has got a
00:31:03religious fervor about it it seems to me and the last thing that religion does is tend to crack
00:31:09jokes about itself would you agree abby oh god i mean yeah there's a zealotry there's a zealotry
00:31:17certainly about the about the woke um brigade i think it's a lot more actually when people say
00:31:22woke i found myself thinking it's more serious than that i mean it really is something that's
00:31:28poisoned so much of so much thought um uh and you know uh free free thinking um but the the of
00:31:36of course the thing that it never does is forgive or um seek um redemption at all and that's the
00:31:45one thing that the woke will never have i don't think i think that's an excellent point i mean i
00:31:50would totally totally agree with that i mean do you think would you would you go along with that
00:31:56simon i mean look let's face it it's you can't make jokes about genders and sexes where
00:32:02people are quite genuinely saying there are a hundred genders or whatever that
00:32:08and that is a position in an argument how can you make a joke about that then
00:32:13well i suppose it depends on the format and the platform you're talking about i think on twitter
00:32:19there are a lot of exchanges about that idea and there have been a certain number of jokes that
00:32:23have become kind of tired and stereotypical and repetitive in their own way like i identify as a
00:32:28an attack helicopter and all that kind of thing. I think in the real world, very few people are
00:32:33still quite as aware of it, but they perhaps sense that a different mood has overtaken things
00:32:38and they're not quite sure what is the defining change. I think most people, to be honest with
00:32:45you, generally experience a certain kind of haze of nostalgia for the TV comedy of their youth
00:32:50at a certain point. I think if you go back and watch some of it, you might be surprised to see
00:32:55that it's not all quite of the same sort of standard
00:33:06Not necessarily progress, I agree with you.
00:33:09There is also the capacity for humanity to go into reverse
00:33:15in many important regards and to become more suspicious
00:33:18of its fellow human and so on that things undermine comedy.
00:33:22But I think the problem with the lockdown era is that we have also gone into a kind of hunkering down mentality that was already there as well.
00:33:32And I think that possibly is I think that is a potentially very dangerous combination that there's a kind of there's a there's an activated and motivated and and overconfident minority who want to use all available media, including television comedy for a sort of program for an agenda.
00:33:53they do have a kind of re-education program and then there's a collapse of confidence and a collapse
00:33:59of appetite for self-expression and so on among a larger majority what used to perhaps one time
00:34:05being called the silent majority who just kind of feel slightly put upon and depressed and weary
00:34:11and tired and just go oh it's not worth watching the telly there's never anything on you know
00:34:15rather than take the fight to those people and so that's happening I think at that point and yet
00:34:21it's not so much that there's like you it's not so much that it's kind of like you can't joke about
00:34:26certain woke ideas it's it's that they of course think that there are more important things to
00:34:32joke about they don't feel the sort of people who make the comedy you don't like they don't it's
00:34:37not that they feel that you mustn't joke about 58 genders is that it's much more important to joke
00:34:44about the clear dishonesty lying racism etc that they think they see in boris johnson
00:34:49the calamity of Dominic Cummings the failure of of Michael Gove the idiocy of Brexit they think
00:34:58all these things you know and perhaps with some justification depending on where you come from
00:35:01they think those things are more important and so you get a kind of relentlessly hectoring slightly
00:35:07juvenile student agenda about what is funny it's not that they're denying there's anything funny
00:35:12about their shibboleths it's just that they don't feel inclined to sort of draw attention to them
00:35:17really this is exactly you say student there Simon I mean it's I would also call that middle
00:35:22class actually I that's comedy seems now to me to be much more of a middle class thing than the
00:35:29comedy of my youth again yeah I know that I agree with that as well yeah I think that is true but
00:35:35it's a combination it's kind of graduate you know I think it's juvenile and and humanities students
00:35:41In that immaturity as well is the inability to see what is funny from someone else's perspective. So they don't find anything about themselves funny or anything about their own side funny. They only have the ability to laugh at the people that they disagree with. But that's not that's not a good foundation for comedy at all.
00:35:59No, the initial thing, and this does get very tiresome, is that nothing is judged on whether it is funny and whether it's a good observation or whether it was well worded or even whether, you know, the construction of the joke was good because the funny word came last and, you know, the spring was sprung in the right way.
00:36:13the question is does does this endanger somebody does this hurt somebody does this cause you know
00:36:20and I've had I've had people I mean and I could name I won't name names but I do have specific
00:36:25individuals in mind on this occasion who have said that jokes even told in a comedy audience in front
00:36:30of a comedy in a comedy club in front of adults who are paying and have given their permission to
00:36:34be you know confronted with stuff can still be dangerous and must still be considered by the
00:36:38comedian before they say it because it's a powerful spell it's like an incantation and once
00:36:43it's out there it can it can seep into people's minds it can alter their opinions and they'll
00:36:48repeat it in other workplaces and in pubs and possibly in front of their children when they
00:36:52get home and then repeat it in the playground in front of people who will get hurt I mean it's
00:36:57insane you start thinking like that and you are destined for the madhouse very quickly even if
00:37:02you're not a comedian you know that that is like the I wouldn't even put those kind of restrictions