New Culture Forum - September 13, 2021


Lessons From History - Hidden Heroes From The Past And What We Can Learn From Them

Rod Liddle On BBC Bias & His Time As Editor Of Radio 4's Flagship Today Programme Jeremy Black on James Bond - A British Icon - Is Today's James Bond Still James Bond?

Episode Stats


Length

23 minutes

Words per minute

201.17

Word count

4,728

Sentence count

—


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittle.
00:00:29 Now, I think you'd agree one thing we all need to do is learn the lessons from history.
00:00:33 So I'm very pleased that my guest today has written a book about exactly that.
00:00:39 Alex Dean, who is a consultant and a lawyer and whom you might know from his appearances on Sky News, GB News and Times Radio,
00:00:47 has just produced this book, Lessons from History, Hidden Heroes and Villains from the Past and what we can learn from them.
00:00:56 um thanks for joining me alex thank you very much thanks for having me this has just come out hasn't
00:01:00 it yep just out this week yeah and so tell me as i understand it this started off as something else
00:01:06 didn't it online oh yeah it's very much a thing of the 21st century this i started telling these
00:01:12 stories on twitter during lockdown i was um searching for things to do as people were um
00:01:19 my father wasn't very well so i was staying back with my my parents um and at a loose end surrounded
00:01:24 by his works of history absent an audience to inflict things on in person i started telling
00:01:30 these stories on twitter and i had no expectation or idea it would go anywhere it was a bit of a
00:01:35 lark and important caveat i'm not an historian you know i just have that most english of things
00:01:40 an enthusiastic amateur so you know no background in it not even history degree um just history is
00:01:45 something i love started telling these anecdotes on online and very quickly and very flatteringly
00:01:52 they started getting for me anyway huge numbers of hits and and views and retweets and comments and
00:01:58 so very quickly they got past a million views for the stories and uh now well north of that but um
00:02:04 it was that that encouraged people to say that people were saying why don't you put these into
00:02:08 a book the other thing that was interesting was people started suggesting the stories
00:02:12 so sort of the first that bits me and the rest of that is sort of crowdsourced it's people coming up
00:02:18 with their own stories that they wanted to hear and i tell them firmly with my tongue in my cheek
00:02:23 so i hope that was part of why they wanted me to tell their story but a lot of it is absolutely
00:02:27 crowdsourced well it's fascinating i mean there's this nearly 100 chapters that's just slightly
00:02:33 misleading because in fact they're very short aren't they i mean they're very they tell particular
00:02:37 i when i was reading it i was thinking that the one thing that seems to uh unite them all is
00:02:44 well perhaps you tell me if i'm wrong but it's a kind of it's the human spirit the resilience
00:02:49 of the human spirit do you think that's i think that's very kind of you to try and find a thread
00:02:53 that goes all the way through it yeah i mean it's it's almost but if there is a design by design
00:02:58 it's eclectic and it's eccentric and it's tales from all parts of history uh but yes resilience
00:03:04 is certainly something i was aiming for from the story of the soviet doctor who removes his own
00:03:09 own appendix which one i rather enjoy to adrian cartons of art who you know bites off his own
00:03:14 fingers because the surgeon refused to amputate them and says well on the whole i rather enjoyed
00:03:20 the war uh there is a certain resilience there but there's also i think and hope some political
00:03:25 resilience too and that's something worth bearing in mind at a time when to think about the forum i
00:03:30 started the books on yeah there's a certain share of voice which is very loud and very angry and
00:03:35 constantly criticizes sometimes you've got to keep going if there are volumes two three four of
00:03:40 lessons from history if someone else does it in years to come i'm sure they'll tell anecdotes
00:03:44 about the resilience of people who for example yes saw through brexit yeah or stayed the course
00:03:49 with conservative views and values even though they were getting brick bats from it seemed the
00:03:53 world yes because of the left-wing dominance of the social media sphere so um resilience is a
00:03:58 thoughtful way of thinking about it you've put more thought into it than i have but yes i accept it
00:04:02 No, no, you're way too modest. I thought it was great. This was, I mean, I want to ask you a few of your particular favourites, but basically, one that I particularly liked is actually, he's not an unsung hero, but it's about Ronald Reagan and the air traffic controllers.
00:04:18 this i mean and what's the lesson we draw can you just explain what happened what's the lesson we
00:04:22 draw sure um well reagan uh was confronted with a strike by a union i've got the one here the
00:04:27 story here that reagan was confronted with a strike from a union of the professional air
00:04:31 traffic controllers who'd been militating about pay and um i think they thought they had a stronger
00:04:37 hand than they did they threatened to withhold their labor um which is their right and uh reagan
00:04:43 said very well then you are dismissed rather than giving in and rather than um trying to find ways
00:04:48 around um their position this has echoes of course with our train drivers you remember aslev held
00:04:53 britain hostage for a while um patco the the union lost they lost in court they were ordered to
00:04:59 return to work over 11 000 of them refused and that was the point at which reagan uh fired them
00:05:04 so he followed just en masse he followed due process they had their day in court they lost
00:05:08 they still refused to go back and so he dismissed them the other thing that i was thinking about
00:05:13 not to make it too political but the other thing i was thinking about as i was telling this story
00:05:16 hinted at at the the end of it and as you say they're only short twitter threads was um what
00:05:22 we're going to do with people who refuse to get vaccinated in the uk because the point is ronald
00:05:27 reagan had a plan b his plan b was bring in the military bring in staff and make the staff who
00:05:31 were bureaucrats man the air traffic control hoping it's safe of course man the air traffic
00:05:35 control systems if you're going to get rid of people if you're going to move people on because
00:05:39 won't do what you want them to do you have to have a plan b because somebody may call your bluff yeah
00:05:45 that's the lesson from that one for me what what about this vaccination thing now i mean what do
00:05:50 you what's your view on it well the debate has now become in my view far worse because of what
00:05:55 we're talking about with children um i can just about see although i think it's vast state over
00:06:01 each per se to say that something should be compulsory some medical treatment should be
00:06:06 be compulsory i'm deeply uncomfortable with that per se but when you start saying as young as 12
00:06:11 or even younger as the debate is now moving you're getting into a much worse discussion we're away
00:06:16 from the book now but the point is that you know the point isn't whether and these are theoretical
00:06:20 children i don't have any the point isn't whether i want my children to be vaccinated that's not the
00:06:24 issue it's not even if i want your children to be vaccinated it's if i think the state shouldn't be
00:06:30 able to vaccinate my children without my consent why should that principle change when it comes to
00:06:35 your children because i think there's a great deal of people saying well i think that my children
00:06:40 should get vaccinated therefore so should yours and any right you might have to um refuse medical
00:06:46 treatment for your children is overridden because of my views that if they stop and think for a
00:06:51 moment that can't be right can it no it can't i think um one of the things that has struck me
00:06:58 throughout this whole pandemic thing is and it is related to this is that we have become maybe over
00:07:06 a period of decades risk averse i mean it's all about utter safety now you know safety trumps
00:07:14 everything freedom of speech freedom to do this and one thing that about your book that struck me
00:07:20 was that the incredible unfettered freedom with which some people did actually behave yes some of
00:07:27 some of the actual deeds they did.
00:07:29 I mean, there was one,
00:07:30 I think his name is the Baron de Lanchamp.
00:07:33 Ah, yes. Towards the end.
00:07:35 I think it's chapter 89.
00:07:36 Ah, good. Chapter 89.
00:07:39 I'd love to be able to write that one day.
00:07:41 But he was extraordinary.
00:07:43 He wanted to get revenge
00:07:45 for the death of his father, didn't he?
00:07:46 Can you just explain to us what happened?
00:07:49 I mean,
00:07:50 he was a grandnephew of the king as well,
00:07:53 of King Leopold of Belgium.
00:07:54 So he had a pretty bad war,
00:07:56 obviously if you look at what happened but he had a very good war he was in the belgian cavalry when
00:08:00 the second world war broke out and they saw some real fighting um which of course inevitably failed
00:08:06 we now we now know given the franco german armistice but then he um came to the uk via
00:08:11 morocco determined to fight joined um the raf in which he served bravely but he wanted to avenge
00:08:18 the death of his father who'd been killed by the germans in his hometown of brussels and he
00:08:23 requested and quite understandably was denied permission to go on a solo mission to beat up
00:08:28 the um the gestapo hq so on a particular day following his orders to a certain point doing
00:08:34 an attack run he then veered away from uh the rest of his colleagues and went solo to brussels
00:08:41 and um flew down the avenue um avenue louise which famous and of course you want to see it
00:08:47 you come out of the euro star in brussels so he's actually down the middle of the street
00:08:52 in brussels which is by the way is a perfectly nice town which has done nothing to deserve what's
00:08:56 been inflicted on it um down the street and machine gunned gestapo hq i'm talking about
00:09:02 precision building to the left untouched building to the right untouched building the middle
00:09:06 absolutely marmalized and then pulls up and kills a bunch of nazis pulls up and away and then the
00:09:12 pièce de résistance opens his cockpit and litters uh the ground with tiny british and belgian flags
00:09:18 just to make just make sure you know who'd done this and and so the word i mean the deed itself
00:09:23 is fantastic but the the broader message to the belgians to keep going and to keep their heads up
00:09:28 people tried the the germans tried to keep people away from the street that day so as not to see
00:09:33 what had happened but crowds came in droves to see what this man had done now he was reprimanded
00:09:39 by the raf but i dare say his commanders had a glint of positivity in their eye as they did it
00:09:44 It reminded me a bit of the story about Colonel Blood or Captain Blood and the Crown Jewels,
00:09:50 where basically he did something that was on the face of it, you know, it was bad.
00:09:54 But in fact, the king was so impressed by his daring do that I think he nobled him or something.
00:10:00 But I thought about that particular story, and in fact, many others in the book,
00:10:04 these are movie scripts waiting to happen, aren't they?
00:10:08 Yes, so there's only one that I know has been turned into a film.
00:10:11 and uh it's the story of the calcutta light horse um which uh which is a bunch of i mean now they'd
00:10:17 be called gammon's by our uh by our friends in uh i know i'm i'm i'm definitely a gammon now
00:10:24 um you're of course too too svelte and handsome but i'm definitely a gammon sweating under these
00:10:27 lights um but um the calcutta light horse were a bunch of old duffers they were a bunch of
00:10:34 chaps in their 50s and 60s at best um who had been put on reserve their unit been on reserve
00:10:39 since the boer war it was a polo club and um special operations executive um uh were trying
00:10:46 hard to to prevent u-boat sinking of our shipping and um they realized quite quickly that the
00:10:53 germans were communicating via a boat which had been interned in goa neutral under the portuguese
00:10:58 old world's oldest continuous alliance britain and portugal we certainly didn't want to violate
00:11:03 portuguese neutrality not least because we needed to keep them on side they were using the americans
00:11:08 were quietly using the azores or nodding a wink the portuguese were cooperating with us in lots
00:11:12 of different uh ways quite quietly we didn't invoke the alliance so they could maintain their
00:11:17 neutrality and we certainly didn't want to breach it so we needed what we now call plausible
00:11:21 deniability and soe went in this sort of boy's own heady adventure said to these old duffers on the
00:11:27 wrong side of india will you come along and help us out come along on a boat sail a barge around
00:11:33 india plainly unsuited for it we'll put one of your chaps on the street in advance who'll pay
00:11:37 all the brothels in the area to give a free night out for sailors on the basis that he's an old
00:11:42 sailor and wants to show them a good time hopefully getting some of the crew off sail your barge up to
00:11:45 the german ship get the code books kill the germans sink the ship if confronted um throw your guns
00:11:52 over the side and say that you're a businessman out on a frolic of your own a premise by by the
00:11:56 way that they supported by pouring whiskey all over themselves before going on this mission
00:12:00 but every aspect of that plan is preposterous and it worked completely every single aspect of it
00:12:06 and then my favorite part is they go back to having done this not one casualty they go all
00:12:10 the way back to um not only do they sink the german ships an italian ship scuttles for good
00:12:15 measure just joins in uh they they go back to calcutta and their commanders say by the way
00:12:20 chaps uh not a word of this please portuguese wouldn't like it you see and they go to their
00:12:25 graves every single amount of them without saying a word about this remarkable act of heroism which
00:12:30 saved hundreds of lives and thousands of tons of shipping shipping tonnage which when desperately
00:12:35 needed for us during the war yeah so um i like that story but that's been turned into a film with
00:12:40 roger moore and gregory peck and david niven it didn't do that well and it might do you remember
00:12:45 what it's the sea wolves is the name of the film and it sort of injects an unnecessary love interest
00:12:50 and so forth that's typical hollywood type approach but it's not a bad movie but the real
00:12:55 thing is much better you know i think as well this is not meant in any way uh to diminish it
00:13:00 this is a great one for if you want to read history to kids isn't it i mean yeah that's
00:13:06 that's true i hope i didn't say i didn't say you you obviously are interested in history was this
00:13:14 something you were as a child you were interested yeah i always loved it and typical boy at least
00:13:18 of my age of military history was a particular interest i mean lots of these stories are about
00:13:22 the military but that was one of my driving interests and the thing about it these stories
00:13:27 that for me has been so pleasing is that a large part of the audience has said if I was taught
00:13:32 history like this at school I'd have been interested instead of not if my kids were taught
00:13:36 history like this they wouldn't hate it they'd really enjoy it so yeah there is a part of that
00:13:41 without I hope being too preachy and the other thing about it being good for kids is they're
00:13:45 short but the length of twitter anecdotes a page or two quick story of heroism derring do
00:13:50 and then on to the next one or if you're on the loo you know pop it back on the shelf for the next
00:13:54 present yes um on that point you know this is actually i wonder whether in fact these sort of
00:14:04 books the book you've written and there are others as well coming out all about history because
00:14:09 history is suddenly at the very very forefront this subject of history i mean yeah it's very
00:14:13 very much at the forefront of what we might call the cultural war um when it comes to teaching
00:14:20 history in school i mean uh you know i've got nieces and nephews and i know what they're sort
00:14:26 of taught it's pretty inadequate isn't it um so i first of all of course my i'm the son of teachers
00:14:33 i greatly respect the teaching profession and someone who's devoted their lives to teaching
00:14:37 history i i respect not least because they're a professional at it and i'm an amateur that said
00:14:43 it does seem to me that we could do with a bit more i think tell i think people get interested
00:14:48 in history by telling stories and by hearing stories and listening to them and not only does
00:14:53 it seem from what i gather our history curriculum is a great deal of world war ii and the tudors and
00:14:58 that's about it the other thing it's about increasingly for some people at least is saying
00:15:04 how racist and bigoted britain is you know where everyone in our past is on some some point of the
00:15:09 spectrum of bigot and it's just working out quite how bigoted they are or were and um i think that
00:15:16 probably turns people off learning from history and it probably puts people who have a natural
00:15:20 passion about stories and a passion about their country and an enthusiasm for those things it
00:15:26 probably makes them think this isn't for me when i think it unambiguously is you know i mean i i live
00:15:32 in south london and as a kid we used to drive past dettford i think it's dettford town hall
00:15:37 you know on the way into london and they've got these statues of these great british heroes you
00:15:44 like uh nelson and for the moment for the moment they've got them it was in the paper yesterday
00:15:50 goldsmiths uh college which is nearby is going to have some kind of public consultation as to
00:15:55 whether they should be removed now i don't know about you i get viscerally so angry at that kind
00:16:02 of news these are heroes great story you know francis drake with the bowls and and nelson and
00:16:10 you know kiss me harder yeah um i mean it's just appalling isn't it it is appalling and it there's
00:16:17 only ever a ratchet effect on these things because no one's going to put up a new statue of these
00:16:21 people right it's only defending and preserving what we've got and i think we probably are in a
00:16:26 culture war it's not between the left and the right it's between destroyers and preservers
00:16:30 and um lest people think to themselves what do i care i never really noticed the statue in the
00:16:35 first place i would say what starts with statues is not going to end with statues if you give way
00:16:42 on this stuff they'll come for books next they'll come for old rate and we already see it with the
00:16:47 archives of tv comedy and people getting non-persons because they held views that are now
00:16:51 regarded as unacceptable and it's a great shame to me not least because i do believe that we should
00:16:57 encourage people to think of certain examples from history as heroes as people to look up to
00:17:02 literally on a pedestal but it also depresses me because I think that this attitude that we're in
00:17:10 some sort of glorious year zero in which everyone before us is some kind of moron and we're just
00:17:15 trying to work out what how moronic they were it is facile and and not least because there are going
00:17:22 to be generations that come after this supposedly uniquely enlightened generation we are who are
00:17:26 going to regard us as some shade of moron as well so if you encourage that sort of thinking it's
00:17:31 reductive and will destroy ourselves in the end this position will eat itself no one will meet
00:17:36 the standards of current um whatever we call it woke identity no one will meet the standards
00:17:41 of acceptability because except all our demands today we'll have some new ones tomorrow yeah and
00:17:47 that means we've just got to resist it pretty much in every instance and wherever it comes up
00:17:51 what about this thing that's happened whereby uh we have now something called retain and explain
00:17:58 which is where they put a plaque on so for example down in on Plymouth Ho this statue of Francis
00:18:05 Drake which he's now going to have sort of like he brutally you know suppressed it yeah along with
00:18:13 the wonderful things he did I mean to me that's the worst of both worlds no it's not for me the
00:18:19 worst of both worlds is the arbitrary destruction of things the worst of both worlds for me is
00:18:23 people going having run a campaign in Bristol to take a statue down and having lost it they just
00:18:28 go and tear it down anyway and then people ignore the rule of law that's the worst thing the thing
00:18:32 about retain and explain is i can at least hope maybe a lost hope maybe forlorn but i can at least
00:18:37 hope that somebody in future current times will think better and get rid of that retain and
00:18:42 explain or at least provide a different one that has a bit more context and is less sort of history
00:18:47 bashing or you know seeking virtue signaling and um has less of the offense archaeology that we're
00:18:52 seeing going on at the moment a future generation might say to itself all right yeah granddad thought
00:18:57 this woke stuff was relevant but i don't really at least they'll still have the statue if we allow
00:19:02 these people to get rid of things then then you won't i'm not completely against the retain and
00:19:07 explain position not me think about the great fire of london and uh we have there where it started
00:19:13 and pudding lane an enormous monument to the fire of london which calls out the catholics and then
00:19:18 there's a um retain and explain of 100 years ago that says well not really uh this was of its time
00:19:24 and at least they didn't destroy that or at least they didn't pull down the monument to the great
00:19:28 fire um so you know it's not a new thing either no no that's an interesting point about the monument
00:19:33 but i suppose my feeling really about that is that i look at the people who are critical of
00:19:38 statues and they're happy with retain and explain and therefore it must be wrong and therefore i
00:19:43 think wait a minute you feel this is do you think generally uh the government has been
00:19:50 rigorous enough on these questions do you think the trouble is there's a lot going on right and
00:19:56 when you govern you've got an agenda of umpteen things and at any one time think of the government
00:20:01 as we sit coronavirus raging the afghan fallout not completely unrelated to that a migration
00:20:08 problem that is increasingly harming its support in its base debates about statues are going to be
00:20:16 second order to that. And the thing about this sort of woke agenda of destruction is that its
00:20:22 acolytes are absolutely fervent. It's a bit culty. They care about that and nothing else.
00:20:27 The closest equivalent I can get to thinking about in modern discourse is people who were
00:20:31 obsessive about cycling, which is a perfectly good form of transport that's done nothing to
00:20:36 deserve the weirdos who now obsess about it and insist that anyone who doesn't love cycling is
00:20:40 some kind of maniac. In the same way, the people who care about this statue agenda care about it
00:20:46 to the exclusion of almost everything else. And if you've got people who are obsessive like that,
00:20:50 you tend to find that a small, concentrated minority will prevail over a large, diffuse
00:20:57 majority that cares less. That happens pretty much all the time. So it's no wonder that the
00:21:03 government's agenda isn't focused on it. What it needs is a fifth column of young fogies and old
00:21:08 fogies who care enough about it, as happened in your example at Plymouth Ho, where people went
00:21:12 round and surrounded the statue of Drake and said, you're not taking this down. And so people thought
00:21:16 twice about it. And that's why they went retain and explain in the end. They'd have preferred to
00:21:20 pull that down, you know, but they lost. I think whenever they do public consultations on any of
00:21:25 these things. You're nine tenths to losing already once it starts. Yeah. Not to say that there's
00:21:32 anything political about this, by the way. Sure. It seems pretty straightforward. I don't think I
00:21:37 i mean i i tell a couple of stories about margaret thatcher that some people might not like very much
00:21:41 but on the other hand i tell us one well i mean so the only story that is from my my own life
00:21:47 except for um having a go at jeffrey howe uh which is also in here um the only story i tell from my
00:21:53 own life is that i took a friend to an event uh that margaret thatcher was speaking at and she
00:21:57 has this remarkable persona that i've only ever seen both women interestingly i've only ever seen
00:22:02 with the Queen where someone comes into a room and a room feels like a pinball table that's
00:22:07 suddenly on tilt and all of the energy, all of the balls is rolled to one corner. Thatcher came
00:22:13 into the room and Brits love queuing and an impromptu welcoming line was constructed and
00:22:21 greeting line and it was my friend's turn and he was a big Thatcher fan, erudite guy,
00:22:27 partner at a law firm completely lost for words and she held his hand for i promise you a minute
00:22:33 which does not sound like long but if you're in public like it is forever yeah and he finally
00:22:39 said you saved our country and she kept just holding his hand she looked him in the eye and
00:22:44 she said in her low voice i agree so i'm sure that i've been woke like that but i also tell
00:22:53 couple of lbj stories and you know these titans from history these big figures um had a lot to
00:22:59 them and uh it's i don't think it's inherently political to tell stories like that no i uh we
00:23:06 can't really top that one actually i think um all the very best for the book thank you very much
00:23:11 yeah lessons from history it's available obviously on amazon but also in bookshops isn't it yes yeah
00:23:18 so uh in all good bookshops as they used to say um thanks very much indeed thank you um and um
00:23:24 all the best of it uh that's it for this week we shall see you next week so thank you very much