New Culture Forum - November 06, 2020


Paul Embery - Why The Left Despise The Working Class

How Significant Is The 2020 US Election & What Might A Trump Or Biden Victory Mean? What Does It Mean To Be A Man & How Can Men Live More Meaningful Lives?

Episode Stats


Length

56 minutes

Words per minute

174.49

Word count

9,785

Sentence count

258


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello and welcome to so what you're saying is I'm Peter Whittle now my guest today has been a
00:00:28 firefighter for 23 odd years a trade union activist and he's now a proponent of what's
00:00:35 known as the blue labour movement uh paul embury has just written his very first book which is
00:00:41 called despised why the modern left loathes the working class thanks very much for coming
00:00:48 on today uh paul good to be with you yeah uh i read your book and it you know hugely resonated
00:00:55 with me and I think it will with many people. But I wanted to start with something you say
00:01:00 towards the end, which I think was quite profound actually. You say the British working class has
00:01:08 found its voice and that's towards the end, but it's not the Labour voice, is it?
00:01:15 No, it certainly isn't being voiced through Labour Party channels. The British working
00:01:21 class has found its voice in the sense of the Brexit vote, which I think was broadly
00:01:28 a working class vote, if not exclusively, of course. And then again in the 2019 general
00:01:34 election, where working class people who traditionally would have once upon a time been regarded
00:01:41 as Labour and felt comfortable voting Labour, decided in great numbers to throw their lot
00:01:47 with the Tory party and we saw obviously the collapse of the Red Wall, we saw a number of
00:01:53 seats which had been Labour since time immemorial fall into the hands of the Tories and it just
00:02:00 strikes me that what we're witnessing is a large group of people who, millions of people, millions
00:02:07 of ordinary working class voters who have largely been neglected and ignored and sneered at and
00:02:14 mocked over recent years have suddenly decided to fight back and they've done that in the most
00:02:21 strident way with those two particular votes. But didn't you, you sort of predicted this would
00:02:28 happen, I mean the Red War thing in particular didn't you I think? I'd been arguing for a long
00:02:33 time that the disconnect between the Labour Party and what you might call traditional working class
00:02:39 voters was becoming more and more profound. I always felt that at some point that was going
00:02:45 to manifest itself in a series of losses at the general election in terms of traditional
00:02:51 working class Labour seats, those old working class heartlands. I'm active in the Labour
00:02:57 movement. I've been a member of the Labour Party for 26 years. I've been a trade unionist
00:03:01 for longer than that. I go along to trade union meetings. I'm active to a certain degree
00:03:08 within the Labour Party, I attend Labour Party conferences each year, and I was making this
00:03:12 case to people, but it was falling on deaf ears, particularly over the last couple of
00:03:18 years where many people within the Labour Party felt that, you know, because we were
00:03:24 now the biggest party in Europe, we were a mass membership party, that somehow reflected
00:03:28 the view of the country, and, you know, they really didn't understand when someone like
00:03:34 me came along and said actually despite that we are losing we are hemorrhaging votes in working
00:03:40 class communities because our values our language our priorities is just not meeting um the language
00:03:47 and values of priorities and priorities of those those ordinary working class votes and in many
00:03:51 respects i think one of the worst things that happened for the labour party was doing better
00:03:55 than people anticipated in the 2017 general election because in many senses i think that
00:04:00 mask the the real underlying problem and there were and I used to debate with people inside the
00:04:06 Labour Party that you know they were almost jubilant at the fact that you know Labour denied
00:04:11 Theresa Mayer the majority did much better than expected and I tried to impress upon people look
00:04:17 you know at the time we're seven years into a Tory government or the first part of that was
00:04:21 obviously a coalition government during which they have been imposing austerity which has had
00:04:27 a pretty serious effect in working class communities and how is it that we still cannot
00:04:32 win a general election and this is no cause for celebration the fact that we've lost again
00:04:36 and then after that particularly I think when the Labour Party changed its position in terms
00:04:42 of the second referendum I think that really sounded the death knell and as you said I
00:04:47 predicted it just four days before the general election in December I said that I felt that
00:04:52 the red wall was going to crumble and that's exactly what happened and they didn't listen to
00:04:59 me and a few other siren voices in the Labour Party at the time who were sounding these warnings
00:05:02 they're not particularly listening now to be perfectly honest not most of them
00:05:06 so it's still it's still an uphill struggle on the left. Do you think this is permanent this
00:05:12 crumbling of the red red wall? Well I think there's a real danger for the Labour Party that
00:05:19 people inside the party think it cannot get any worse and the truth is it potentially can. I mean
00:05:27 if you look at some of those red wall seats that the Labour Party held on to some of those majorities
00:05:33 are pretty thin and it wouldn't necessarily take much for the Tories to win those seats as well
00:05:40 next time out. I think there's almost a psychological thing as well for some working
00:05:45 class voters who voted Tory for the first time in December it was a big step for many of them
00:05:49 you know there's there's a bit of a stigma attached to voting Tory in those areas and many
00:05:55 of them did it for the first time and you know we heard the stories of people feeling their
00:06:00 ancestors whispering in their ear as they went into their ballot box and voted Tory and I sense
00:06:05 that you know having having done it once that taboo if you like has been broken and they wouldn't
00:06:13 hesitate to do it again if they felt it was justified. So I think the next few years are
00:06:19 going to be really important. I think if Boris Johnson and the Tories are seen to deliver in
00:06:26 those working class communities in terms of investing in those communities, in terms of
00:06:30 regeneration, in terms of re-industrialisation, and people feel that tangibly their lives have
00:06:36 been made better by the Tories, then the chances are those people are not going to vote Labour
00:06:40 again and also that some of those seats that we did hold on to would fall so there's a there's a
00:06:45 real mountain to climb for the labour party and it's only going to win those seats back
00:06:49 if at all if it can reconnect if it starts speaking the language of those people
00:06:55 getting away from the the fringe issues that obsess so much of the left nowadays and start
00:07:00 concentrating on those core issues what i call the solar plexus issues the issues that punch
00:07:05 people in the stomach the issue that the issues that people want to talk to you about on the
00:07:09 doorstep. And the issues which, frankly, when they're raised, and I'm talking about things
00:07:15 like law and order, I'm talking about things like immigration, I'm talking about things
00:07:18 like national security, patriotism, traditional values, the family, all of this sort of stuff
00:07:23 that causes many activists in the Labour Party just to look down at their shoes and shuffle
00:07:28 them in embarrassment because they want to get off those topics and they want to be talking
00:07:31 about LGBT rights and climate change and human rights and things like that, which of course
00:07:36 have their place in the national debate, I wouldn't suggest otherwise, but are not ultimately
00:07:42 the priorities for people in those places, those Red Bull seats that voted Tories. So
00:07:47 can Labour pull it back? It's not impossible, but it's going to be very, very difficult
00:07:51 and much will hang on what the Tories do in the next five years and whether Labour can
00:07:55 go through the kind of radical shift that it needs. I suppose really that a lot depends
00:08:01 on whether as you say Boris and the Tories neglect them having won them you know and
00:08:08 whether in fact it just looks opportunistic remember Boris was saying you know thank you
00:08:15 for lending us your vote and it was all very well judged and all of this but the time seemed
00:08:20 to have changed already on that front. Delivery is going to be important and you know what
00:08:25 has really thrown a spanner in the works for the Tories is the coronavirus because you
00:08:31 You know, the thing that's going on in Manchester, for example,
00:08:35 and the government's approach to Manchester
00:08:38 and the discussions with Andy Burnham.
00:08:40 And, you know, there are other people
00:08:42 in some of those working-class communities
00:08:44 that do stand to lose their jobs.
00:08:46 You know, businesses will fail, industries will fail,
00:08:49 people will suffer financially.
00:08:51 Working-class people in those communities
00:08:53 often don't have the same opportunities to work from home
00:08:55 that people in more affluent middle-class communities might.
00:08:58 Now, I think that in response to the financial impacts of coronavirus, if the Tories think that they can get away with imposing several more years of austerity in the way that they've done over the last decade, then I think they're going to be seriously mistaken.
00:09:17 because I think people have had a belly full of that,
00:09:19 particularly in those communities.
00:09:22 So people, as I said, people need to feel
00:09:24 that their lives are tangibly better.
00:09:26 People need to feel financially better off,
00:09:29 financially more secure, culturally a bit more secure.
00:09:32 And if the Tories think they can, you know,
00:09:34 take some sort of neoliberal slash-and-burn approach
00:09:38 in response to coronavirus
00:09:39 and that those votes in those Red Bull seats
00:09:42 will still come flooding to them,
00:09:43 I think they're going to be mistaken.
00:09:44 Yes. You mentioned a cultural issue. You said cultural security. This is interesting. It's quite a buzzword, isn't it? Cultural security. There is this sort of idea that's emerged over the past few years that the way forward for any party now is to be culturally quite conservative or, should we say, security minded and economically on the left. Is that what you would call blue labour? Is that what that is?
00:10:13 I mean, because it seems to me that that's also what the Social Democrats party are also about, isn't it?
00:10:19 Yeah, I think that's probably a fair assessment.
00:10:21 There's certainly a heavy crossover between the philosophy of Blue Labour
00:10:24 and the kind of new incarnation, if you like, of the SDP.
00:10:29 Someone once described Blue Labour as socialism with a small c,
00:10:32 which I think is quite a good way of describing it.
00:10:35 And it's certainly true that there is what some people have described
00:10:39 as that sweet spot in British politics,
00:10:41 where I think millions of people, voters, including voters in those Red Bull constituencies
00:10:47 that we've talked about, fall into this category where they are left on the economy.
00:10:53 So they don't like an unfettered, untrammeled free market,
00:10:58 which just leaves people to their own devices and says, get on with it.
00:11:03 They like an interventionist state.
00:11:05 They like the idea of redistribution of wealth.
00:11:08 They like the idea of tackling regional inequalities and boardroom excesses and that kind of thing.
00:11:17 They don't like a galloping gap between rich and poor.
00:11:21 But on the cultural aspects of it, yes, they probably are a bit to the right.
00:11:26 So many of them, not all of them, but many of them could be described as socially conservative
00:11:30 on some of those issues around law and order and immigration and welfare and family, etc., and national security.
00:11:38 And this is the key point, I think.
00:11:40 Once upon a time, people who fell into that category
00:11:43 were perfectly comfortable about voting for the Labour Party.
00:11:48 And the Labour Party, frankly, was comfortable about having those people within its ranks
00:11:52 and very much the backbone of the party in years gone by.
00:11:56 But increasingly, the party looks at those people
00:11:58 as if they're some kind of embarrassing elderly relative.
00:12:01 You know, we want their votes at election time.
00:12:03 We don't really want to be seen in public with them.
00:12:05 And you can look, I mean, probably the most glaring example of that was the Gillian Duffy scenario.
00:12:11 You say in your book this is sort of emblematic of the whole problem.
00:12:14 It was, it was very symbolic.
00:12:16 I mean, if you look at Gillian Duffy, she was a traditional Labour voter.
00:12:21 She lived in a working class constituency like Rochdale, had always voted Labour,
00:12:26 but just happened on the election stump to express, not in any way in intemperate terms,
00:12:33 her concern over the number of people coming into the community and the impact that that was having.
00:12:38 Of course, as we know, Gordon Brown privately, or he thought privately, dismissed her as some bigoted old woman.
00:12:43 And the truth was, I think, that what Gordon Brown was doing is actually revealing the kind of thought
00:12:50 that many people in the Labour Party and the wider Labour movement do nowadays have about people like Gillian Duffy.
00:12:56 They do genuinely believe that people like her are bigoted.
00:13:00 They will privately mock them and sneer at them.
00:13:02 I mean, the other example was Emily Thornberry, of course, where she went to Rochester in the by-election in 2014, I think it was,
00:13:09 and saw the St George's flag outside the house in a white van and obviously thought that this was so noteworthy that it was worth tweeting about in a disparaging way.
00:13:22 And actually, the person in that house may well have been, for all she knew, someone who was sympathetic to the Labour Party, to Labour values,
00:13:30 but obviously, in her view, you know, deserve to be mocked.
00:13:34 And, you know, I do try and say to people in the Labour movement
00:13:38 that these people are, we should see them as our people.
00:13:41 Now, I've never flown a St George's flag outside my house,
00:13:45 but I understand why people might want to do that,
00:13:47 because they might, you know, in a kind of benign way,
00:13:50 want to display their patriotism.
00:13:52 And these are often ordinary working-class people
00:13:54 who we should look to bring into the Labour Party.
00:13:57 So those were two examples, really, that I think threw into sharp relief the chasm that in many respects has emerged between working class people who once upon a time were welcoming the party, but who much of the party now see as almost like museum pieces.
00:14:13 Yes, I mean, you mentioned there the St George's flag, you know, and Emily Formby, that famous tweet.
00:14:19 But in your book, also, you talk about England.
00:14:22 I think the depossession of England, I think you called the chapter.
00:14:26 But, you know, these things are not generally talked about, not even just by the Labour Party.
00:14:30 But, I mean, England as an entity is very rarely discussed.
00:14:33 But you actually do go into it, don't you, in the book?
00:14:36 Yeah, and I think there is, without question, a more acute feeling of national dispossession within England than anywhere else.
00:14:47 I mean, if you look at Scotland, Ireland and Wales, many people on the left see that kind of nationalism as more permissible.
00:14:59 You know, we can live with that sort of nationalism because we accept that it's progressive in a way.
00:15:05 but any kind of display of English nationalism
00:15:08 plainly harks back to empire
00:15:11 and can only come from some sort of innate racism
00:15:14 so we've got to try to clamp down on that
00:15:16 and I think people in these English particularly working class communities
00:15:20 who do feel a sense of patriotism
00:15:23 often feel that they're not entitled to express that
00:15:26 in any sort of explicit English way
00:15:29 and I think that's why
00:15:30 certainly in terms of the Brexit vote for example
00:15:33 the Brexit vote was higher in the English working class communities
00:15:39 than it was in working class communities in other countries
00:15:42 and in fact I refer in the book to the writer Anthony Barnett
00:15:46 who drew a comparison between Wigan in England and Paisley I think it was in Scotland
00:15:50 where he talks that in many ways these two towns were quite similar in terms of population
00:15:56 in terms of industry that was once there and which it lost
00:16:00 but when you look at the Brexit vote it was sharply different
00:16:03 with Wigan obviously being strongly for Leave and Plasily being strongly for Remain.
00:16:09 And I think that does help us to understand why the English working class particularly do feel that sense of alienation,
00:16:19 because it's almost as if their own culture is discouraged.
00:16:22 And Professor Eric Kaufman, who wrote a book called Whiteshift, describes to a certain degree this phenomenon quite well
00:16:32 when he talks about something called asymmetrical multiculturalism,
00:16:36 where he says that in some of those traditional working-class communities,
00:16:40 people are lectured about the need to kind of open themselves up to other cultures
00:16:45 and to be amenable to other cultures
00:16:49 and to see the benefits of other cultures
00:16:51 and this kind of liberal cosmopolitan vibe.
00:16:54 But when it comes to their own culture,
00:16:57 the liberal establishment takes a completely opposite view
00:17:00 and says, well, actually, that kind of old Anglo-Saxon working class culture,
00:17:05 you don't really want to display that.
00:17:07 You need to be open to everybody else,
00:17:09 but you can't really display any sense of pride in your own culture.
00:17:13 And people are not stupid.
00:17:14 They see the disproportionate focus on other cultures
00:17:21 and the sneering at their own,
00:17:23 and they think, actually, this is not fair.
00:17:25 And often the only way that people have got to manifest their anger and resentment at that is through the ballot box.
00:17:33 And that's why I think Brexit was so instructive, because in a way where with a general election,
00:17:41 people will often usually vote for one of the two parties and often there's not much difference between the two main parties
00:17:48 and people decide not to vote for those reasons.
00:17:51 or if they do, they still don't really think they can affect change in a serious way through a general election.
00:17:57 When Brexit came along, and it was a straight binary, yes or no,
00:18:01 and millions of people who, yes, were anti-EU, but often not in a vociferous way,
00:18:08 which is why I argue that the Brexit vote was as much a vote against the UK establishment as it was against the EU.
00:18:15 And people just felt, well, hold on a second, we've been given this weapon,
00:18:18 And for the first time in our lives, we've got the opportunity to really fire back at the establishment
00:18:23 and to rock the establishment in a way that they hadn't had that opportunity previously
00:18:27 and may have been their only opportunity for their lifetimes.
00:18:31 And many of them voted for the first time and thought, right, you're going to get it.
00:18:34 This is my only opportunity to tell you what I think.
00:18:36 You know, you've been treating me with disdain for the last 20 or 30 years.
00:18:41 You've been ignoring my legitimate concerns and anxieties.
00:18:45 And take that and deal with it.
00:18:47 and it was a genuine democratic revolt in that way and the left should have embraced it but it
00:18:51 didn't it tried to subvert it it rejected it tried to dismiss it as racism and it paid a huge price
00:18:56 for that well they dismissed it but also don't you think paul that since then they are bitter
00:19:03 and vengeful for having been basically tossed aside you know the establishment as it were
00:19:10 you know they have done they cannot forgive well they happened these were these were people i mean
00:19:16 I mean, if you look at the liberal establishment in this country,
00:19:19 these were people who, frankly, had had it their own way for so long
00:19:24 and were so used to dictating the political agenda
00:19:28 that all of a sudden something happened where they lost,
00:19:32 and they lost badly, and they couldn't get their heads around it.
00:19:37 It didn't compute.
00:19:38 And that's why we saw all the nonsense.
00:19:41 They couldn't understand that ordinary working-class people
00:19:43 had gone out and done something which they thought was terrible,
00:19:46 despite being advised that they shouldn't do it they said we'll stuff you we're going to do it
00:19:50 anyway we don't like the way that you've been running the country we don't like the uh the
00:19:55 way that you make us feel we don't like the sneering and the mockery and we're now going
00:19:59 to give it back to you and the liberal establishment which cut across all parties to a certain degree
00:20:04 but it was certainly part of the the left's philosophy at the time tried to explain this by
00:20:10 Well, it was the interference of Russia or, you know, you were persuaded by something you read on the side of a bus or, you know, Cambridge Analytica was misleading you on social media or Aaron Banks managed to fool you all.
00:20:24 I mean, this stuff was just complete nonsense.
00:20:27 If these people, and I had this debate face to face with many of them, if they genuinely thought that what happened on June the 23rd, 2016 just came out of a clear blue sky or was the result of something these people saw on the side of a bus
00:20:40 or you know Russia then frankly they didn't understand their own country and they didn't
00:20:45 understand what had been happening inside the country for the last 20 or 30 years where this
00:20:49 resentment and this sense of alienation was brewing and building and at some point was going
00:20:54 to manifest itself in you know something like Brexit and so because of that because they
00:21:01 convinced themselves that the working class really didn't know what they were voting for
00:21:05 or the working class was somehow duped they just decided that we're not going to implement the vote
00:21:12 you know or we're going to do everything we can to get it overturned and I have to say that that
00:21:18 the left that the labor movement or large parts of it at least were complicit with this was I still
00:21:25 believe absolutely disgraceful that here you had a big democratic exercise one of the biggest
00:21:32 democratic exercises in our history we had the debate and millions of people 33 million people
00:21:38 or whatever it was in total went to the polls and a majority of those people uh said you know after
00:21:44 the debate this is what we want we want to leave the european union it was a straightforward answer
00:21:48 um and that the the the left who has got a duty in my view to be the voice of the working class
00:21:55 and to listen to the demands of the working class um tried to subvert that and tried all sorts of
00:22:02 disingenuous ways to force people to vote again and to make sure that that vote wasn't implemented
00:22:07 was disgraceful and I think people who were part of that really ought to look themselves in the
00:22:12 mirror and there's no question in my mind that that was a big part of why the left now is flirting
00:22:17 with irrelevance, why it is now hated, and I don't use that word loosely, hated in some of those
00:22:24 working class communities that voted Tory for the first time. I mean I speak to people in those
00:22:30 communities quite often and before now you know if people were anti-Labour they still had a sort
00:22:36 of residual sympathy for the for the Labour Party but the vitriol that people felt towards the Labour
00:22:41 Party over the last couple of years was was quite staggering actually and that's why I think you
00:22:47 know there needs to be a mea culpa on the part of the left and we've seen Keir Starmer make some
00:22:52 moves in that direction but there's a huge way to go. Were you were you surprised by the you talked
00:22:59 about them uh you know thinking the working class people have been duped the implication being is
00:23:04 that they're stupid right um and it wasn't just labor saying this i it was a liberal establishment
00:23:09 but were you surprised by the level of snobbery that emerged during that time i i was i thought
00:23:17 i just it was a part of the country i just thought i don't quite recognize this but it was
00:23:22 sort of absolute blatant snobbery now you know in relation to brexit yeah i think i think that was
00:23:29 very much a part of it and I think the the left was very much part of that snobbery as well
00:23:33 and I think to a certain degree that can be explained by you know the shift in the demographic
00:23:39 on the left over recent years I mean and I'll talk about this in the the book I mean certainly
00:23:45 when you used to look at Labour Party conferences for example on the TV you would have an array of
00:23:50 accents from the rostrum you would have delegates from constituency Labour parties and trade
00:23:56 Unionists who were genuinely and proudly working class,
00:24:00 had come from those working class communities,
00:24:01 often had blue-collar jobs come up through the trade union movement,
00:24:05 and even, to a certain degree, MPs.
00:24:07 I mean, you would have MPs, the Labour benches would be made up of many people
00:24:13 who could say, yeah, we've done a proper job.
00:24:16 Eric Heffer, you know, think of people like, I'm thinking back to the 70s, 60s and 70s now.
00:24:21 Of course, big beasts in some cases, you know, people who had worked down mines
00:24:24 or in shipyards or in docks and factories and things like that.
00:24:28 Now, obviously, to a certain degree, that can be explained by de-industrialisation,
00:24:31 the fact that some of that heavy industry simply doesn't exist anymore.
00:24:35 But, of course, we do still have things like call sensors.
00:24:38 We do still have things like warehouses where people are working on low wages
00:24:44 and zero-hours contracts and precarious employment.
00:24:47 so that kind of low wage industry occupations do still exist
00:24:55 but these people are just not coming through into the Labour Party
00:24:58 and because of the shift in the demographic in the Labour Party
00:25:02 where it has become much more of a kind of bourgeois, metropolitan, liberal, student-y type party
00:25:10 then that I think explains some of the snobbery
00:25:15 You know, in many respects, a graduate party as well, a party of the cities, particularly the university cities.
00:25:22 And they look down at the working class in a way that previous generations of Labour activists and MPs simply wouldn't have done.
00:25:29 Do you think that Keir Starmer gets this?
00:25:34 I mean, you know, he talked recently about that Labour shouldn't be, say, shy on patriotism.
00:25:40 he made various sort of sympathetic noises about the last night of the proms you know
00:25:47 all those sort of issues do you think that's do you think he really understands it is his heart
00:25:52 in it do you do you think that there there is a sort of change that's not just simply cosmetic
00:25:59 I don't think it's instinctive with Sakhir I think it's what you might call realpolitik I think he's
00:26:07 got people uh close advisors some of them are pretty good i think who are telling him the right
00:26:14 things and are saying look unless you start talking about some of this stuff then we're finished and
00:26:19 i don't think it's in his gut i think it's more in his head i think it's a calculated decision
00:26:24 to realize that this needs to happen in order to reconnect with working class communities
00:26:29 I mean, the truth is, Keir Starmer is very much part of that demographic that so many people in those traditional working class constituencies see as alien.
00:26:43 You know, he is a North London lawyer. I think instinctively he's a Blairite, you know, he's middle class.
00:26:50 I don't think he instinctively understands those communities.
00:26:53 But I am, you know, I'm heartened by the fact that at the very least, and I know it's a bare minimum, but at the very least he is starting to speak the language of patriotism, the language of national security, the language of family, and not obsessing about some of those fringe issues which the Labour Party has dominated thinking and discourse in the Labour Party for so long.
00:27:16 What I would say, however, is people are not stupid
00:27:19 and they're not going to be duped just because someone decides
00:27:22 for electoral reasons that they're going to start talking about issues
00:27:26 that people feel are relevant to their lives.
00:27:29 People need to see a culture change inside the Labour Party.
00:27:32 They need to see a radical shift in ideology.
00:27:35 They need to see the change not just in messaging.
00:27:40 They need to see the change in policy as well.
00:27:42 and they need to see a change in the demographic of the party.
00:27:46 They need to see MPs who look and sound like them,
00:27:48 who speak their language, who come from their constituencies,
00:27:51 who know their communities,
00:27:53 who understand their desire for a sense of place and a sense of belonging,
00:27:57 the kind of stuff that middle-class people within the Labour Party
00:28:00 now really don't understand because they've been to university
00:28:03 or they've had good jobs or before they've come into Parliament
00:28:08 they've been well paid, they're part of the professional class
00:28:11 or there have been research assistants for MPs
00:28:13 and they haven't worked in those jobs and those industries
00:28:16 and lived in those communities often that these people are living in
00:28:20 and those occupations that people are working in.
00:28:23 So unless people out there, the millions of working-class voters
00:28:26 who have abandoned the Labour Party,
00:28:28 see a real deep-rooted shift which goes beyond language,
00:28:33 then no, I don't think they're going to come flocking back.
00:28:35 So there's a huge job for Secure Starmer to do.
00:28:38 There are two things here which I say you should cover.
00:28:41 one of them in the book uh is about the need for to build up our manufacturing industry again and
00:28:46 why this shouldn't even have been uh well on such a scale in terms of destruction um that it wasn't
00:28:53 necessary i think a lot of people on the right would agree with you there um and i just want to
00:28:59 there's that but then also we're recording this on friday just yesterday um jeremy corbyn was
00:29:08 suspended by the Labour Party because of the anti-Semitic report and all of that doesn't that
00:29:17 give people like you sort of you know a kind of an opportunity if you know a clean brush is
00:29:25 supposedly going to be going through the party it might even split who knows I mean what what do
00:29:32 you think is the future in that way well I hope the Labour Party doesn't split I've been in the
00:29:37 Labour Party for 26 years. I love the Labour movement, you know, I'm part of the Labour
00:29:43 movement. I love the history of the Labour movement. I love the traditions of the Labour
00:29:47 movement. You know, if you look at things like the Durham Miners Gala, for example,
00:29:52 which has been going for, I think, over a century, where people come together and you
00:29:58 see the banners and, you know, there's the service at Durham Cathedral and then you have
00:30:02 the speeches afterwards and all of that, that history of the labour movement which is about
00:30:08 people working together, which is about solidarity, which is about realising that we're part of
00:30:13 something greater than ourselves, which is about understanding that society isn't fair
00:30:18 and if we're going to challenge the unfairnesses and the inequities within society in terms
00:30:22 of income and wealth and opportunity then we have to organise through our own institutions,
00:30:27 be they trade unions or whatever on the left, in order to advance our cause
00:30:32 and in order to win concessions for ourselves.
00:30:34 So, you know, that's a history of the labour movement that I adore in many ways.
00:30:40 And, you know, I get angry when I look at how people on the modern left today
00:30:45 have very little affinity with that history of the labour movement
00:30:50 and are obsessed with the fringe issues, are obsessed with ID politics,
00:30:55 are obsessed with turning people against each other,
00:30:59 have very little affinity for the idea of class
00:31:01 and the need for people on a class basis to organise themselves together,
00:31:05 are more interested in fragmenting people
00:31:07 on the basis of their distinctive biological traits,
00:31:11 and particularly, I think,
00:31:15 have kind of set a whole atmosphere on the left and wider society
00:31:19 where unless you sign up to the precepts
00:31:22 of their kind of liberal, progressive cosmopolitanism,
00:31:25 then you have no place on the left, you should be silenced, there's this council culture
00:31:29 that they're responsible for. So I resent most people and what they've done to the movement
00:31:33 and they haven't even been anywhere near successful, they've helped to destroy the labour movement
00:31:37 and set us back years. And frankly I wish they'd show some humility, instead of telling
00:31:42 people like me that I don't understand the modern working class and I've got a nostalgic
00:31:47 view of the working class, they should look at what they have created and perhaps be a
00:31:51 little bit more humble about the whole thing.
00:31:53 it's astonishing actually that they should call you nostalgic or romanticizing i mean that's
00:31:58 extraordinary that they should do that about supposedly people that they're meant to uh
00:32:03 actually represent i mean the the labor that you are um describing that you like and that you feel
00:32:11 very fond of that is the labor party my parents voted for you know back in the 40s 50s 60s 70s
00:32:19 right through to thatcher actually and they felt then that it was sort of
00:32:23 changing but all of these questions like patriotism cultural being culturally
00:32:29 secure they were never on the cards and they you could take for granted I mean
00:32:34 you know my parents they were working class people very patriotic like the
00:32:39 Queen and everything but they just certainly had a very strong sense of
00:32:44 um economic um shall we say unfairness very you know they had a very strong sense
00:32:50 you know aspirational but they certainly weren't kind of crazy for the market as such
00:32:56 they all they are your people that you're talking about right and and they are still
00:32:59 there now in abundance and many of them actually voted tory because they they felt that the tories
00:33:04 were were offering them economic security and were also offering them cultural security i mean
00:33:09 The point that I make in the book is that the Labour Party historically was always an electoral compromise between its traditional working class base and a layer of more middle class liberal people who felt that it was right to have a fairer economy and tackle the inequalities in society and were willing to sort of pay more tax in order to achieve that.
00:33:35 And I kind of describe it as, you know, mainly Hartlepool, but with a good dash of Hampstead thrown in.
00:33:46 And I think Labour was at its most successful when it was able to hold that coalition together.
00:33:51 I think the problem in recent years is that coalition has become so unbalanced.
00:33:58 So the party has become almost all Hampstead, but with very little Hartlepool.
00:34:02 and you know I think that any political party if you're going to be successful you have to start
00:34:08 from your base and build outwards and that's when Labour has been its most successful I think
00:34:14 what the Labour Party over recent years and I think this phenomenon predates Corbyn a point
00:34:19 I make in the book is anyone who thinks that the disconnect between Labour and the working class
00:34:23 began and ended with Corbyn is seriously mistaken what happened is that that Labour
00:34:28 tried to you know it kind of embraced the social and economic liberalism a poisonous brew of social
00:34:35 and economic liberalism and hoped that throughout that period and I'd sort of trace this to the
00:34:42 late 80s and then through Blair I think it intensified throughout the last 15 years
00:34:46 and and hope that the working class just stayed with it and for a part of it the working class
00:34:52 did, but then when the working class started to see huge rapid demographic change in their
00:34:59 societies and expressed unease and were told that they were racist, and when they started to
00:35:03 see the impacts of austerity and low wages and poor housing, etc., that's when the working
00:35:12 class base started to desert Labour. And actually, Labour hasn't won the popular vote in England
00:35:17 since 2001 um you know it's completely lost in england and when you when you combine that with
00:35:22 the the wipeout in scotland as well you can see that that was only heading in in one way so for
00:35:28 labor to so so that balance that i talked about that historical electoral balance between hamster
00:35:33 and hartlepool that pendulum needs to to shift seriously back in the other direction um and it's
00:35:39 not it's not a forlorn task i think it's possible to do it but it's going to mean an absolute culture
00:35:44 change inside the Labour Party. You talk very vividly about growing up in Dagenham and the kind
00:35:53 of society, working class community it was and you also say that basically it was at the very
00:36:02 beginning of this century, so century 2001-2010, there were huge changes that happened. I think
00:36:09 There's one statistic you mentioned, which is that foreign-worn people in Dagenham went up by 205% or something like that.
00:36:17 But anyway, lots of changes happening.
00:36:20 And I'm right in saying that that's when you really realised something was very much up with Labour Party and its support, wasn't that?
00:36:28 Yeah, I mean, the change Barking and Dagenham was profound and actually had a huge influence in my thinking because some of those changes that began around the turn of the century, and particularly the speed of the change as much as anything else, just left people bewildered and disorientated.
00:36:52 and that bewilderment and disorientation was dismissed as racism and bigotry
00:36:59 and, you know, I'd grown up in the area, I was living in the area at the time
00:37:03 and I have to say, you know, as someone on the left at the beginning, I was quite relaxed about it.
00:37:07 I bought into the whole idea of, you know, liberal cosmopolitanism
00:37:10 and, you know, this is vibrant and we should embrace it
00:37:13 and I'm pro-immigration, you know, I believe immigration has been good for our country.
00:37:18 I believe that we should embrace it but like all good things, I believe it needs to be managed
00:37:22 and I think you can have too much sometimes of a good thing
00:37:25 and the complete lack of management of the system
00:37:28 I think has really disorientated some of those working class communities
00:37:33 like Barking and Dagenham
00:37:34 and as these changes in Barking and Dagenham started to happen
00:37:38 I began to realise that simply lecturing people
00:37:42 about the benefits of cosmopolitanism and multiculturalism
00:37:46 was not good enough
00:37:48 because when people felt that their sense of order had been violated
00:37:52 It wasn't, as I say in the book, it wasn't that their sense of race had been violated.
00:37:57 It was simply that their sense of order had been violated.
00:38:00 Things that they'd known were changing very rapidly around them.
00:38:03 Whole streets were changing.
00:38:05 Different languages were being spoken.
00:38:07 Shops were now selling things that they didn't need.
00:38:11 And that sense of familiarity and belonging, which is actually really important in working class places,
00:38:17 because you find that where people have less money
00:38:21 and their horizons are not as extensive and they have less opportunity,
00:38:27 then the whole concept of family and place and community and belonging
00:38:30 becomes more important, I think, to them often
00:38:33 than if you're a middle person, a graduate, and you can travel and you can work
00:38:37 and you can take gap years and you can move when you want to
00:38:39 and you can be more transient in that way.
00:38:43 And that's why I came to the view that actually you need to be really careful
00:38:47 And I'm pretty certain that the vast majority of people in Barking and Dagenham were not racist,
00:38:52 but were just really uncomfortable about the pace of change,
00:38:55 about an area that many of them had lived in all of their lives,
00:38:58 suddenly being subjected to rapid cultural transformation.
00:39:03 And whenever they said, look, we're uneasy about this, can you just slow it down?
00:39:07 They were told, no, actually, this is good for you.
00:39:10 And it's good for you culturally, but also economically,
00:39:12 you might be a tenner a month better off as well,
00:39:15 which is almost like a Thatcherite argument.
00:39:17 You say to people it's all about the economy when actually that person's sense of place and community was much more important to them.
00:39:25 And I think the really sad thing about what happened in places like Barking and Dagenham,
00:39:29 where the BNP, for example, were elected and became the official opposition on the council in 2006,
00:39:35 and it really didn't have to be that way.
00:39:37 If we'd had a proper system that managed numbers properly,
00:39:41 had a proper system of dispersing migrants throughout the country
00:39:46 so that undue pressure wasn't put just on already hard-pressed working-class communities,
00:39:52 we could have had a much more sensible debate
00:39:55 and we wouldn't have ended up in the toxic debate that it became.
00:39:59 By ignoring people, by lecturing people, the whole debate became toxified effectively
00:40:04 and immigration turned into a hot potato and it really didn't need to.
00:40:08 And I think that's a tragic thing because most people who, like myself, are very open to the idea of immigration and absolutely believes in defending the rights of migrants and challenging any prejudice and that type of thing.
00:40:24 You know, people of that view were just alienated and the whole thing became very divisive because people in places like Barking and Dagenham were just not listened to.
00:40:34 But therefore, Paul, I mean, what do you think, when you look at the Labour Party now that you're active in,
00:40:40 what do you think are the chances of re-establishing a more reasonable attitude, say, to immigration in the Labour Party now?
00:40:51 Well, I think Brexit gives us that opportunity to a certain degree.
00:40:56 The Labour Party cannot any longer use the excuse that, well, there's nothing we can do about free movement
00:41:01 because we're in the EU, they don't have that luxury.
00:41:07 So I would like to see a Labour Party that takes a sensible view
00:41:11 and says, look, we're pro-immigration, we'll always defend it,
00:41:14 we'll always challenge prejudice, we'll defend migrants,
00:41:17 but we understand that we can't have an open borders policy,
00:41:20 we can't have a policy where we don't regulate the labour supply,
00:41:23 where we have people coming in large numbers to already hard-pressed
00:41:27 working-class communities like Barking and Dagenham
00:41:29 or working in sectors where there's already pressure on wages
00:41:33 and that just exerts further pressure on wages.
00:41:36 We need to manage the thing properly, we need to regulate the thing properly,
00:41:39 and that's what we're going to do as a Labour Party.
00:41:41 And I use the example in the book of Japan.
00:41:46 And Japan has a pretty strict immigration policy
00:41:49 and doesn't have open borders or porous borders,
00:41:54 manages the thing properly,
00:41:56 takes a modest number of immigrants each year doesn't obsess about promoting multiculturalism
00:42:03 and you know emphasizing the the difference and separateness of people says look you know you
00:42:10 can come here but we're japan we don't really want to be anything other than japan you know
00:42:14 we'll we'll make you welcome um and i i think the thing is if you argue for that sort of policy
00:42:20 in britain if you say look numbers should be modest and manageable um and you know we don't
00:42:26 obsess about multiculturalism we should make people welcome but you know this is britain and
00:42:31 we shouldn't be ashamed to say that this is britain and we expect people to assimilate oh you'd be
00:42:36 dismissed as some sort of rabid bigot and you know xenophobe if you were to argue but no one
00:42:41 would argue that japan is anything other than a highly civilized well-governed safe country
00:42:49 clean country which has a sensible policy on on immigration and welcoming people and it doesn't
00:42:58 hide its patriotism it's quite culturally conservative in in many ways actually if you
00:43:03 look at the japanese economic miracle it was by by no means what you would now call a neoliberal
00:43:09 country in any way or a right-wing country much of its approach for a large period after the war
00:43:15 was very much an interventionist Keynesian approach which was responsible for the major
00:43:20 success of the Japanese economy. Why can't the left embrace that sort of thing in Britain?
00:43:24 There's no reason why it shouldn't apart from the fact that it's dominated now by people who think
00:43:28 that that type of approach is deeply racist and objectionable. And also I think something that
00:43:34 people really pick up, and this isn't just Labour actually to be fair, the establishment generally,
00:43:40 liberal establishment what people really pick up is that the arguments for sort of mass migration
00:43:46 not immigration i don't i don't think i know anyone who's against immigration as such but the
00:43:50 mass migration term the arguments for it was sort of tinged with a very strong general dislike of
00:43:57 the people here you know um that whether it was as you remarking that you talk about in the book
00:44:02 the andrew nether incident during the blair years this was the man who blew the gaff without meaning
00:44:09 to on Labour sort of actually wanting to change the kind of you know the makeup of Britain
00:44:15 but even right down to the present when you look at this whole statues issue that's going on
00:44:21 we've become quite involved in that all the councils wanting to take things down are all
00:44:27 Labour and you know 130 of them it's that impulse isn't it that's going to be so hard to dislodge
00:44:36 isn't it? Well Labour has got to decide whether it is going to continue listening to a very
00:44:43 forceful and vocal minority on some of these social issues in which case if it does then it
00:44:50 hasn't got a cat in hell's chance of winning back the working class vote or whether or not it's going
00:44:56 to try and connect with the mainstream and face people down and say actually you know your demands
00:45:00 on some of these things are unreasonable.
00:45:03 Yes, we defend fairness.
00:45:04 Yes, we absolutely stand steadfastly against racism.
00:45:08 But if you come to us with unreasonable demands,
00:45:12 if you think it's okay just to go and tear down statues,
00:45:15 we're not going to buy into that.
00:45:17 Not just because it's wrong on principle,
00:45:19 but because electorally it's just going to be a nightmare for us.
00:45:22 And I think the problem with Labour...
00:45:25 One thing David Cameron got right when he was in power,
00:45:27 when he said Britain and Twitter are not the same thing,
00:45:29 And it's absolutely true. I mean, if you go to most working-class communities in Britain, most people are not on Twitter.
00:45:35 Well, they can't because of the jobs they're doing.
00:45:36 Yeah, and some of them don't even know what it is.
00:45:39 But the problem is, you know, a layer of Labour politicians and activists think that that is genuinely reflective of Britain,
00:45:48 that if you can win a debate and win likes on Twitter, that actually that shows that you're winning Britain.
00:45:55 And, you know, the 2019 election showed that that wasn't the case at all.
00:45:59 So Labour has got to decide whether or not it's prepared to face people down,
00:46:04 whether or not it wants to continue being a party of social activists and students and people in the cities
00:46:11 and people who are vocal but making unreasonable demands,
00:46:16 or whether it's prepared to say, actually, we need to reconnect with the values of working-class communities,
00:46:20 and that means sometimes saying no to the virtue signallers and the woke who expect us to fall into line every time.
00:46:27 We're going to have to go to battle with those people sometimes
00:46:29 and we're not going to be afraid to do it.
00:46:32 Have you ever stood for the Labour Party to cancel?
00:46:35 No, I don't think they'd have me.
00:46:37 Really?
00:46:37 I don't think there's any chance of that.
00:46:39 I mean, I've been in the Labour Party, as I said, for 26 years.
00:46:45 I can't really imagine any constituency Labour Party who...
00:46:51 Why would that be, though, Paul?
00:46:52 Well, I think because the demographic of the party is not conducive to somebody like me who articulates some of those more traditional Labour values.
00:47:04 I mean, not that I'm fussed about that because I'm not particularly seeking to be a representative of the Labour Party in any way.
00:47:08 But I think, you know, the whole party from top to bottom is largely infused with those kind of liberal, urban, middle class, bourgeois values.
00:47:22 And when someone like me comes along, and, you know, there are people like me still in the party, but we're few and far between.
00:47:31 Is there anybody you particularly would point out or admire at the moment, you know, in the party that you say, actually, that's what we should be doing?
00:47:38 I think there are some people within the party who understand it.
00:47:43 Blue Labour, for example, which is the group that I'm involved in, I think gets it.
00:47:47 People within Blue Labour predicted the Labour meltdown long before it happened,
00:47:53 said there is going to be a break between the Labour Party and the working class
00:47:58 because we've bought into the market too much,
00:48:01 we've bought into radical social liberalism too much,
00:48:04 we've bought into the idea of globalism
00:48:07 and we think these sunlit uplands of liberal cosmopolitanism and progressivism
00:48:12 are the way forward.
00:48:15 and, you know, if people in those working-class communities don't quite get it yet,
00:48:19 they will eventually get it, but they clearly don't get it
00:48:21 and they're not going to get it because those values are not reflective of their own values.
00:48:26 So there are people, there's people like the English Labour Network, for example,
00:48:29 there's some Labour MPs, the likes of John Crudus and Stephen Kinnock
00:48:34 and one or two others have been articulating the need to become
00:48:38 perhaps more communitarian and less cosmopolitan
00:48:42 and that's a prerequisite for reconnecting with those working-class communities.
00:48:49 Frank Field, who is obviously no more active in the party,
00:48:54 but was someone who did get it.
00:48:56 Kate Hoey was another one who got it.
00:48:59 And in many respects, that's the sad thing.
00:49:01 If you look at the number of Labour MPs who voted Leave, it was tiny.
00:49:05 If you go back to the common market referendum in 1975,
00:49:10 I mean, no was very much a mainstream position on the left.
00:49:15 You had huge numbers of MPs, the likes of Tony Benn and Michael Foote and Peter Shaw,
00:49:20 who articulated the case for coming out of the common market.
00:49:24 A majority of trade unions wanted to come out of the common market.
00:49:28 And it was seen as an argument about democracy,
00:49:32 an argument of the right of elected governments to be able to set their own economic policy
00:49:35 to determine the policy of their country without undue intervention from technocrats and corporations,
00:49:43 completely in keeping with the left's idea about democracy and self-government, etc.
00:49:49 And then, for reasons that I detail in the book, it became very much a fringe position.
00:49:56 And people in working-class communities saw that.
00:49:59 They thought the vast majority of Labour MPs are voting Remain.
00:50:04 this is a party that doesn't really speak for me and um and you know that was just one manifestation
00:50:09 of this huge schism that's occurred you look back to that time around about the 1975 referendum
00:50:16 and onwards and the caliber of people in labor like peter shaw or tony ben as you mentioned
00:50:24 arguing these cases against the eu uh extraordinary you realize actually not just for labor but how
00:50:31 generally the the level and quality of our public discourse has declined you know the extraordinary
00:50:38 beautiful arguments they put incredibly erudite um you also had a run in yourself didn't you um
00:50:47 with your own union isn't that right when you spoke uh at a brexit rally a cross-party rally
00:50:55 uh when was that would have been about two or three years ago that that was well actually it
00:50:59 it was about 18 months ago it was on the it was on the 29th of march 2019 and this is one with
00:51:05 claire fox and yeah and others so it was it was a cross-party rally organized by leave means leave
00:51:12 and it was held on the day that we were originally due to leave the european union but teresa may's
00:51:17 government had sought and got an extension so there was quite a bit of anger about that and so
00:51:23 the rally really became a pro-democracy rally. It was attended by thousands of people in
00:51:29 Parliament Square, many working class people, and there were speakers from the left and
00:51:33 speakers from the right. And I spoke at that rally, not on behalf of my union. There was
00:51:39 no mention of my union when I was introduced, no mention of the union.
00:51:42 This is the Five Brigades Union.
00:51:43 This is the Five Brigades Union. I sat on the national executive at the time. And the
00:51:46 Union itself had been pro-Remain back in 2016, but we'd lost the vote, frankly, and we should
00:51:54 have got on with implementing the result. And the rally took place on a Friday evening in my
00:51:59 own time. I spoke on behalf of a group called Trade Unionists Against the EU, which is a group
00:52:04 whose main backer is the RMT Union, actually, and I'm their national organiser, Trade Unionists
00:52:10 Against the EU. And we'd always had a rich tradition in my trade union, as there is across
00:52:15 the Labour movement of allowing open discussion and debate and even sometimes if you are going
00:52:22 against the official union line, if you're doing it in a personal capacity or on behalf of other
00:52:26 organisations you represent and you're not trying to imply you're speaking for your union then that
00:52:32 was always perfectly permissible. But I made a specific criticism within the speech which is
00:52:37 available on YouTube where I said that the leaders of the Labour movement were in danger of making
00:52:44 the movement irrelevant if they are seen to be taking the side of the
00:52:48 establishment over the people in trying to subvert the Brexit vote. People can
00:52:54 disagree with me that's fine I've no issue with that but it was a legitimate
00:52:57 argument to make I think but the the Union leadership decided that that was
00:53:03 somehow amounted to an attack on the whole Fire Brigade Union itself that I
00:53:08 had undermined the Union and caused prejudice to the Union and they decide
00:53:13 I decided in a complete break with tradition and custom in our union to kick me out of office.
00:53:23 And, you know, that was disappointing and it was wrong.
00:53:26 I think most people now see that as wrong, but they took the decision and they've got to defend it.
00:53:31 So that's ongoing, is it?
00:53:33 It's ongoing. There's a tribunal which is due to take place in February where I'll have my day in court.
00:53:39 I don't know if I'll win. I don't know if I'll lose, but I'll make the arguments that I want to make.
00:53:43 and they'll be forced to defend their position and um and yeah that will be interesting but you uh
00:53:50 obviously you're still a firefighter but you're increasingly writing commentating you're right
00:53:55 you write for unheard don't you yeah i'm a i'm a regular columnist for unheard which is uh which
00:54:01 is a website which gives a platform i mean it's a play on words obviously unheard um and uh unh
00:54:09 ERD so it's about not going with the herd but also giving a platform to people who previously
00:54:14 were unheard and you know to less prominent voices if you like and covers a range of issues
00:54:22 doesn't fall into one particular category there's people on the left and people on the right who
00:54:26 write for it so so that's good but yeah as you say my main my main role is as a firefighter I've
00:54:32 been doing that for 23 years that's my primary occupation that comes above everything else but
00:54:35 I try to fit in the writing and a bit of media work around that
00:54:40 and to argue my case, and I'm always pleased for the opportunity to do that.
00:54:44 Do you still like your job? Do you still like being a firefighter?
00:54:49 I love it. I joined the fire service when I was 22 years of age.
00:54:56 I've always enjoyed it. I became active in the FBU pretty much straight away.
00:55:01 I enjoyed riding fire engines, although I'm not doing that at the moment.
00:55:05 I've got a desk job which is a little bit more comfortable and less dangerous
00:55:08 but yeah I mean it's a very rewarding occupation you know being in the front
00:55:14 line serving people is a great thing to do and I've got no
00:55:18 I've got no intentions of leaving anytime soon. Well you are going to be
00:55:23 putting out or starting fires all over the place with your writing books.
00:55:29 Paul thank you so much for coming in thank you. I should mention again the
00:55:32 book is out uh it's november 27th november 27th so you can pre-order it on amazon it's called
00:55:40 despised why the modern left loathes the working class by paul emery um i will certainly uh
00:55:49 recommend it uh paul thank you very much and uh all the best to you and uh that's it for this week
00:55:55 so uh we shall see you next time and uh please do subscribe won't you i say every week thank
00:56:02 Thank you very much, bye.