New Culture Forum - May 17, 2021


Peter Hitchens On His Experiences Living In The Soviet Union & Marxist Ideology In Britain

Great American Race Game - New Documentary By UK Filmmaker Martin Durkin Alex Kaschuta - Why The West Isn't Having Children

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

154.62

Word count

7,238

Sentence count

343


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. Just wanted to say
00:00:27 before I introduce my guest this week that I want to say a great thank you to you for continuing to
00:00:34 subscribe in such numbers every day. It goes up. That's great news. We're hugely appreciative of it
00:00:42 and indeed of the donations that you sent. Enormously helpful to us and vital, in fact.
00:00:49 And so thank you very much for that. My guest this week was last on the programme in December
00:00:56 got huge views
00:00:58 and then was taken down by YouTube
00:01:00 so let's see how we get on this week
00:01:03 with Peter Hitchens
00:01:04 I'm delighted he's with us today
00:01:06 Peter obviously columnist for The Mail
00:01:09 on Sunday and also an author
00:01:11 of numerous books and is very well
00:01:13 known to you all
00:01:14 Peter
00:01:16 thank you for coming again
00:01:18 and I hope that we stay
00:01:21 up longer this time
00:01:22 I can feel even now
00:01:24 or somebody poised over his algorithm machine
00:01:28 to try and make sure that as few people as possible
00:01:31 ever get to see this.
00:01:33 Watch it quickly, everybody.
00:01:34 Don't hang around.
00:01:36 You never know how long you've got.
00:01:39 I wonder, there's actually a theme to that segue,
00:01:44 in fact, in a way when we think about it.
00:01:46 But this is going out on Sunday.
00:01:48 Last week, we had the May Day bank holiday.
00:01:54 And you pointed out that you were on social media, on your Twitter feed,
00:02:00 that you were at the, I believe, the last May Day parade in Moscow would have been in 1990.
00:02:10 1991, the last Soviet May Day.
00:02:15 I was at the last Revolution Day in the previous November of 1990.
00:02:19 And they're at the last Soviet May Day, just about Soviet.
00:02:23 It was a bit chaotic and a mess, but they were still trying to hold the Soviet Union together.
00:02:28 It collapsed, if you remember, after a drunken, unsuccessful put in August 1991,
00:02:34 and the whole thing ended.
00:02:36 But I managed to see both of the last two.
00:02:39 And as an accredited Western correspondent, you got quite a good,
00:02:43 you didn't get a seat, but you got to stand quite close to Lenin's tomb
00:02:47 while the parades went by.
00:02:49 It was an enthralling.
00:02:50 Were you just there for that moment?
00:02:52 or were you, because you were in...
00:02:54 I was living in Moscow from June 1990 to October 92.
00:03:00 And can you give us an impression of what it was like at the time?
00:03:05 Well, it was the end. It was obviously the end.
00:03:07 They were taking everything down.
00:03:10 Even when I arrived in June of 1990,
00:03:14 the symbols of Soviet power
00:03:18 were the great big hammers and sickles all over everything
00:03:21 were being removed.
00:03:23 I saw them being carted off
00:03:24 in some scruffy-less hunks of grey metal.
00:03:28 The building in which I lived,
00:03:30 which I shouldn't have been living in,
00:03:32 had once contained Leonid Brezhnev
00:03:35 and his family and Yuri Andropov.
00:03:38 The plaque commemorating Brezhnev's tenancy there
00:03:41 had been removed a few months before I got there,
00:03:43 but the Yuri Andropov one was still there.
00:03:47 Nothing was really working.
00:03:49 Command economies work, really, when you've got enough terror.
00:03:53 And the problem was that the terror had pretty much collapsed,
00:03:56 and indeed at general levels of fear it collapsed.
00:03:58 The party was still technically in control, but everything was coming to bits.
00:04:03 I remember going to a great congress in the hideous modern congress hall inside the Kremlin
00:04:09 and seeing a Soviet admiral going along the buffet with his briefcase,
00:04:14 scooping up hors d'oeuvres and dropping it with his briefcase to take them home.
00:04:18 it had come to that
00:04:20 they all knew it was over I think
00:04:22 but it took some time for it actually
00:04:24 to happen and it
00:04:26 was a complicated end
00:04:27 no one I think would have predicted exactly
00:04:30 what form it would take but the last
00:04:32 last revolution day with the
00:04:33 with the red army and the tanks and the
00:04:36 missiles I saw
00:04:38 and the last May day which was a bit more balloony
00:04:40 and supposedly festive
00:04:42 the May in Moscow is actually quite
00:04:44 chilly
00:04:44 I also saw I still got the passes
00:04:48 Was it a surprise to you what happened then?
00:04:51 Well, not really.
00:04:52 I'd been sent there by an editor who was hoping that I would be there to see it collapse.
00:04:58 And that's fundamentally what I was there for, to be there when it collapsed.
00:05:03 And by luck rather than judgment, I actually was there when it collapsed.
00:05:09 When the putsch happened, the tanks came up my street.
00:05:13 I walked out, having heard on the radio
00:05:16 that Mikhail Gorbachev was ill, supposedly,
00:05:19 which he, of course, wasn't.
00:05:20 And for a moment, I believed it.
00:05:22 And then I thought, no, of course not.
00:05:23 It's not ill.
00:05:24 I walked out on the street, and the tanks
00:05:26 were coming up the street in the slanting August sunlight.
00:05:30 It's rather beautiful, actually, surprisingly so.
00:05:33 But if you had gone back, say, 10 years,
00:05:37 would you have thought that the Soviet Union
00:05:40 would be collapsing in a decade?
00:05:42 Ten years, I don't think I'd have had a clue. But I had been spending quite a lot of time in the other Eastern European countries from about 1988 onwards. And you could feel a strong sense it was there. And really the most obvious place where it was coming to end was East Germany, where, quite amusingly, the reading room in the Soviet embassy on the Internet was off limits to East German citizens because the stuff on display was much too radical and too anti-communist for them.
00:06:11 And again, I went to a visit that Mikhail Gorbachev made to Prague,
00:06:16 which I think would have been in the, I think that was April 89,
00:06:22 but I wouldn't absolutely swear to it.
00:06:23 And it was, again, obvious that he was seen by the people in Prague
00:06:28 as the potential saviour from their own Czech regime.
00:06:33 All the Warsaw Pact regimes, possibly with the exception of Hungary and Poland,
00:06:38 had become more hardline than the Kremlin by then
00:06:42 and were terrified that the Kremlin
00:06:44 would pull the rug out from under them.
00:06:45 So you could see it coming,
00:06:47 though I don't think anybody would have said
00:06:49 it would have happened so fast or so dramatically
00:06:51 or that the disintegration of Soviet power
00:06:56 would be so complete.
00:06:57 And I went down in the summer of 92 before I left
00:07:04 to Sevastopol, which had been up until then
00:07:07 closed city foreigners couldn't get into it and all the creeks and inlets around the naval base
00:07:13 were full of scuttled warships actually the someone pulled the plug they were they were half
00:07:20 sung i wish i had pictures of i had no camera they were the next time i went they'd long ago
00:07:26 been being sold off for scrap and turned into washing machines and razor blades but they were
00:07:31 actually there this the whole project of the global soviet navy had been abandoned and very
00:07:37 very short period
00:07:37 It's often sort of said that
00:07:40 if you take this as being
00:07:43 the end of the Cold War
00:07:44 you know
00:07:45 for argument's sake
00:07:48 that we had no
00:07:51 victory parade for the end of the
00:07:53 Cold War so therefore
00:07:54 it basically was
00:07:57 allowed to sort of
00:07:58 simmer on ideologically speaking
00:08:01 Well I don't know about that
00:08:03 Do you think?
00:08:04 There were a lot of pronouncements of victory and a lot of action
00:08:06 of deliberate humiliation of the Russians
00:08:11 and the Soviet Union.
00:08:12 The dismantling of the Soviet Union
00:08:14 was done in a way which was deeply humiliating
00:08:18 to Russia and Russians.
00:08:19 And you could tell that they felt that way.
00:08:22 So they certainly felt that we'd not exactly shown
00:08:26 magnanimity and victory.
00:08:28 And then the other thing which happened,
00:08:29 which to this day few people understand,
00:08:34 is that the fall of the Berlin Wall
00:08:36 released the Western left
00:08:41 from a terrible restraint
00:08:43 which had been on them
00:08:44 up till then they had been
00:08:45 whether they liked it or not
00:08:47 the defenders or the sympathizers with
00:08:50 ultimately of something
00:08:52 which had to keep its own people
00:08:53 in with a concrete and barbed wire barrier
00:08:55 when that was over
00:08:57 they had had a huge propaganda victory
00:09:00 they simply were not the enemy anymore
00:09:01 and in my view
00:09:04 The rebirth of the Western European left, which had begun in 68, took off after 89 because suddenly they no longer had that great albatross of the Berlin Wall around their necks.
00:09:18 When you were a Marxist, was it an albatross? Did you feel that?
00:09:25 Well, that's why I was a Trotskyist. The whole point about Trotskyism is it disclaims, to a greater or lesser extent, responsibility for the Soviet disaster.
00:09:34 My particular brand of Trotskyism,
00:09:36 if you're interested in this minute theology,
00:09:39 the international socialists, as they were then called,
00:09:42 referred to the Soviet Union as state capitalist.
00:09:44 We didn't even acknowledge that it was in any way a socialist country.
00:09:48 We said the whole thing was a complete failure economically and politically,
00:09:52 and we weren't going to make any apologies for it.
00:09:54 And our slogan was neither Washington nor Moscow,
00:09:57 but international socialism.
00:09:58 I think this was quite cheap and cowardly,
00:10:01 a refusal to take responsibility
00:10:03 for the results of our own ideas
00:10:05 but we did actually disown it
00:10:08 but the main currents of communism
00:10:11 and even some Trotskyists
00:10:14 still ultimately believed
00:10:16 in the defence of the Soviet Union
00:10:17 as something they felt they had to do
00:10:20 You said recently that you were a Trotskyist
00:10:26 but you said that Marxism
00:10:28 actually I don't want to misquote you
00:10:30 So I've written it down.
00:10:32 Don't let it worry you, everybody else does.
00:10:34 Most people who have encountered Marxism as a way of thinking
00:10:38 will continue to be influenced by it.
00:10:40 I think it's often the key to understanding politics.
00:10:45 Why is that?
00:10:46 Well, partly I suppose it's a modern Machiavellianism.
00:10:48 It's a very hard set of attitudes,
00:10:51 a very realistic set of attitudes towards the exercise of power,
00:10:55 how it's to be done, how other people will do it to you.
00:10:58 he's extremely realistic about that
00:11:01 and although in some cases
00:11:04 it's crude materialism
00:11:05 is too coarse
00:11:07 and brutal a weapon
00:11:08 to be used in sophisticated politics
00:11:10 quite a lot of the time
00:11:11 it works
00:11:12 it also teaches you a lot
00:11:15 about the nature of ruthlessness
00:11:17 and Lenin was the most ruthless
00:11:19 politician who ever lived
00:11:21 and the one who had the shortest distance
00:11:23 between thought and action
00:11:25 and if you're in serious politics
00:11:27 and you need to strike hard and strike fast,
00:11:29 which everybody does at some point
00:11:30 if they want to get what they want,
00:11:31 then any sort of learning this training
00:11:34 is going to be helpful to your doings.
00:11:35 I think the most obvious example of this
00:11:37 in modern British politics was Dennis Healy,
00:11:39 an extremely effective politician,
00:11:43 witty, realistic, convincing, persuasive,
00:11:47 but ultimately one could tell
00:11:49 when one was dealing with him,
00:11:50 someone who had a lot of thought
00:11:51 behind what he was doing.
00:11:52 He had the complete Marxist training
00:11:55 and it showed, it put him in some ways
00:11:57 way in front of a lot of his Labour Party colleagues
00:12:01 and he could make mincemeat out of those Tories
00:12:03 because he simply understood the world
00:12:05 as it really is, better.
00:12:08 Marxism may be utopian
00:12:10 but it's not sentimental.
00:12:15 You've said as well, I think,
00:12:17 when we interviewed you before actually
00:12:18 that the Blair class, if you like,
00:12:24 that the Blair government was far more radical
00:12:27 in a kind of Trotsky's vein.
00:12:29 Well, I've said it, but I'm merely quoting other people.
00:12:32 And one of Blair's closest political allies, Peter Hyman,
00:12:35 has said that Blairism was far more revolutionary
00:12:38 than Jeremy Corbyn.
00:12:40 An old friend of mine, who I can now name
00:12:43 because he's no longer with us, Philip Bassett,
00:12:45 who was for a long time an industrial correspondent
00:12:47 for the Financial Times and the Times,
00:12:49 who I knew quite well, told me we had a farewell lunch
00:12:53 when he went off to work for the Blair machine,
00:12:55 he said, you have no idea how extensive
00:12:58 the Blair project is, the new Labour project is.
00:13:02 And if you look carefully at the origin
00:13:06 of the most supposed Blair thought,
00:13:09 the magazine Marxism Today,
00:13:11 which is actually technically a Communist Party magazine,
00:13:14 this was full of people who were Marxists,
00:13:17 post-1968 Marxists, who understood
00:13:19 that the battles in the modern world
00:13:22 were not about nationalizing the whelk industry
00:13:25 or anything of that kind.
00:13:26 They were about morality.
00:13:28 They were about the family.
00:13:29 They were about education.
00:13:31 They were about controlling the television studio,
00:13:33 not the barracks.
00:13:34 They understood that the battle
00:13:36 was to obtain power over the mind
00:13:41 by cultural revolution
00:13:43 and by changing the nature of society.
00:13:46 And they've been extremely clever.
00:13:48 Let me look at them anyway.
00:13:49 So many of them, Alice Darling, Alan Milburn, Stephen Byers, John Reed, Peter Mandelson, Blair himself have 1960s Marxist backgrounds of one kind or another.
00:14:03 You say, well, so do you. And I do. But here I am. Do you ever hear any other 60s Marxists say, I was one of those. I'm not any longer. This is why I'm not.
00:14:13 Most people who were in that wave of enthusiasm for revolution,
00:14:18 when they went into the world of work,
00:14:20 they didn't fundamentally change their desire for revolution.
00:14:22 They just became more subtle about the kind of revolution they wanted.
00:14:26 And as they moved upwards in the long march of the institutions,
00:14:30 about 25 years after that was over,
00:14:32 most of them were in positions of considerable influence,
00:14:35 whether it be in the legal profession or the civil service or the police,
00:14:38 or particularly in education and broadcasting and the media.
00:14:41 And that had begun to show in a big way by 1997.
00:14:46 And then in 1997, it obtained political power as well.
00:14:49 And it was actually a revolutionary moment.
00:14:51 Yes, it was far more so than you mentioned Dennis Healy in the 1970s,
00:14:57 who was a communist.
00:14:59 But somehow there was something completely different about Labour then.
00:15:02 Well, yes, but Healy was an ex-communist.
00:15:05 He'd crossed the Arthur Kersler Bridge from communism to social democracy.
00:15:09 he'd actually given that stuff up
00:15:11 but he still remembered the method
00:15:13 what I'm talking about here
00:15:15 is someone like John Reid
00:15:17 I was fascinated once on the
00:15:19 Today program on Radio 4
00:15:20 just before I had the discussion
00:15:22 on why the left should have been more pleased
00:15:24 about how successful they'd been
00:15:26 they'd had an interview with John Reid
00:15:27 he was bound to have been
00:15:29 in the Communist Party of Great Britain
00:15:31 and was now Defence Secretary
00:15:33 and he said during his interview
00:15:35 oh well, pessimism of the intellect
00:15:37 optimism of the will
00:15:38 And there was nobody in the studio who recognized, it's a quotation from Antonio Gramsci, the great thinker behind all this Euro-communism struggle for social and cultural power.
00:15:53 They didn't even know it.
00:15:54 And if you hadn't had a Marxist training again, you wouldn't spot it.
00:15:56 But there you had a British defense secretary, more or less in charge of the nuclear deterrent, quoting directly the words of an Italian Marxist of the 1930s.
00:16:07 I didn't realise actually
00:16:09 I know the quote
00:16:10 but I didn't realise
00:16:10 it was Gramsci actually
00:16:11 do you hold with the idea
00:16:15 of the Long March
00:16:16 being an utterly deliberate thing
00:16:18 it's not so much deliberate
00:16:21 if you have a generational upheaval
00:16:26 at a certain time
00:16:28 then it will make itself felt
00:16:30 so for instance
00:16:32 just to take for a parallel
00:16:34 say there had been
00:16:35 in the universities
00:16:36 and the churches, as there was in the 19th century,
00:16:38 a great revolution in the interpretation of Scripture,
00:16:41 the view of what was actually authentic and what wasn't.
00:16:45 20 or 30 years later, the whole nature of religious observance
00:16:49 and belief in the societies where that happened had changed
00:16:52 because those people had moved upwards from their early years
00:16:58 into positions of importance.
00:17:00 This is much wider because this is about theories of education
00:17:07 of social organization, of the family and marriage,
00:17:10 of sexual relations, of all the things which are most intimate in our lives.
00:17:15 And of course it was also hostile to the previous canon
00:17:19 of what was thought to be good to know,
00:17:22 whether it be literature or history.
00:17:26 And those things were changed.
00:17:28 Universities may seem arcane and obscure places,
00:17:31 but if the whole idea of what people think is good and important
00:17:35 is altered in a generation,
00:17:36 then the society in which that happens will change.
00:17:39 Yes, yes.
00:17:40 As did.
00:17:42 Same happened in the United States.
00:17:45 Actually, speaking of the United States,
00:17:47 there was recently Governor of Florida,
00:17:53 Ron DeSantis, called the...
00:17:57 Again, I'm going to quote,
00:17:59 so let's be quite clear about this.
00:18:02 He called critical race theory
00:18:04 a race-based version of Marxist ideology.
00:18:09 Now, in the context of what we're talking about,
00:18:12 would you think that that is a fair definition?
00:18:16 Probably not.
00:18:17 I think Marxism can be spread pretty thin and pretty widely,
00:18:22 but I think things like critical race theory
00:18:24 are of their own, have their own origins.
00:18:26 I mean, I can see why a Marxist who wanted to use others
00:18:32 to obtain his own ends
00:18:33 might look at something like
00:18:35 Ray Steering and think it might be useful to him
00:18:37 I think it would be a bit of a stretch
00:18:40 to find any point
00:18:42 at which it meshes with the actual
00:18:43 sayings and thoughts of Karl Marx
00:18:46 What do you think when you look
00:18:50 at what's been happening in America
00:18:52 over the past
00:18:52 six months or so, or actually for a long
00:18:56 time, but as it is now
00:18:58 I'm astonished by
00:19:00 what appears to be a transformation in the place.
00:19:03 I lived in the USA for two years under Bill Clinton.
00:19:09 I learned a bit about it.
00:19:11 I probably, as a result, know a little bit more about it
00:19:13 than most British people,
00:19:14 but I really don't claim any expertise.
00:19:16 And since then, I felt I've known less and less about it.
00:19:20 And certainly in the Tea Party and Trump era,
00:19:25 I just felt that the country had taken a completely wrong turn
00:19:30 and that if it had ever been any kind of arsenal of hope
00:19:34 for conservatives, it certainly wasn't now.
00:19:37 Conservatism had become completely mixed up
00:19:41 with all kinds of things which weren't, in my view,
00:19:43 really conservative.
00:19:44 And so I'd look at American politics
00:19:46 with something close to despair and a lot of confusion,
00:19:52 but I really couldn't give you
00:19:54 any kind of expert assessment of it.
00:19:55 I suppose it's always because, you know, there was always the view I had, you know, somehow if things got really sort of bad here, there was always America.
00:20:06 You know, it somehow was Israel, if you like, it was our version of Israel.
00:20:12 But I don't feel this anymore.
00:20:14 Well, one of the things about America is because it is based fundamentally on a Republican revolution and was one of the great 18th century revolutions.
00:20:24 Its conservatism, so-called,
00:20:27 is always going to be very different
00:20:28 from an English conservatism
00:20:30 which ultimately rests on the crown
00:20:33 and on the church,
00:20:35 which in the United States it didn't.
00:20:37 One of the fascinating things
00:20:39 in the history of the United States,
00:20:40 look at what happened
00:20:41 in the years immediately after Yorktown
00:20:45 to those who had remained loyal to the crown.
00:20:48 They were not tolerated.
00:20:50 They were not treated
00:20:52 as a reasonable opposition.
00:20:54 They were treated with considerable savagery.
00:21:00 And we owe the foundation of the dominion of Canada
00:21:03 to the maltreatment of so many of the former supporters
00:21:13 of the British crown who were more or less driven out.
00:21:16 It was a genuine revolution.
00:21:18 It had social as well as national characteristics.
00:21:20 and that lingers in the spirit and nature
00:21:26 of the United States as a country.
00:21:29 So if you're a conservative like me,
00:21:31 you don't, well, there's a lot to like about the United States.
00:21:34 There are a lot of things about it
00:21:35 which are not quite so appealing.
00:21:37 When you look around the British scene at the moment,
00:21:41 do you see specifically sort of Marxist ideas in operation?
00:21:50 Oh, no.
00:21:50 No, no, no. There are very few people who would be equipped to do that.
00:21:56 But it doesn't really matter very much that people are not specifically Marxist
00:22:03 if the things that they're pursuing are hostile to and destroy conservative institutions and thought.
00:22:11 What I do find, I mean, one of the things about Marxism which I found fascinating,
00:22:15 again since 1968 and 1989 it's shifted away from the the priorities of the late 19th and early
00:22:23 20th century which were fundamentally economic and about the ownership of means of production
00:22:27 and class politics and and return very much to its origins which really are in the 1792-3 the
00:22:37 the most radical part of the french revolution and these are social things these are the
00:22:42 the de-christianization, the desecration of churches,
00:22:45 the overthrow of former morality and rules,
00:22:49 and a complete utopianism,
00:22:54 a desire to begin the world ever again in every aspect.
00:22:59 And much broader and much more dangerous
00:23:03 than the cruder, narrow Leninist form of Marxism,
00:23:08 which could never once had taken power in Russia and the Soviet Union,
00:23:13 really get itself much beyond those limits.
00:23:16 Well, wasn't that to do with Gramsci, wasn't it?
00:23:19 No, well, Gramsci was one of the first European communists.
00:23:23 He went to the Soviet Union, I think, in the 20s,
00:23:25 and he came back and he said to his comrades in Italy,
00:23:28 this is a disaster.
00:23:30 We will never get the educated Christian working classes of Europe
00:23:36 to accept this kind of government.
00:23:38 It's a millstone.
00:23:40 We need a different approach.
00:23:42 We need to capture,
00:23:44 we need to find some other way
00:23:45 of capturing the minds of those
00:23:46 we want to support our revolution.
00:23:48 That was his cleverness.
00:23:50 And in 1968,
00:23:51 when the only answer the Soviet Union had
00:23:56 to the rather attractive radicalism
00:23:58 of Alexander DubÄŤek was tanks,
00:24:01 an awful lot of intelligent left-wing people
00:24:03 on both sides of the Iron Curtain
00:24:06 said, well, that's enough.
00:24:07 This can't continue.
00:24:08 And that's when 1968 is still so important.
00:24:11 Both sorts of the radicals inside the Soviet empire
00:24:15 and outside it rose, it couldn't go on like that.
00:24:17 They had to turn in some other direction.
00:24:19 And they did, and it's been very successful.
00:24:22 Look around you, see how successful it is.
00:24:25 Indeed, a lot of younger people now, it appears,
00:24:31 who don't know very much about communist history
00:24:34 because they haven't been taught it,
00:24:36 are receptive once again to these ideas?
00:24:38 Of course they are.
00:24:40 People, they believe that the world can be begun over again.
00:24:44 It's a normal thing for young, inexperienced people to think.
00:24:51 And without the burden of having to defend the Soviet Union,
00:24:57 it's easier to do.
00:24:58 Many of them probably know rather little about the French Revolution.
00:25:01 And if they knew more about it,
00:25:02 they would see more and more reason to hesitate.
00:25:06 or some of the other radical outbreaks that have been.
00:25:10 But utopianism is, especially once religion
00:25:14 has more or less died in society,
00:25:15 utopianism is to be expected
00:25:16 and there will be people who embrace it over and over again.
00:25:21 In every generation, utopianism either has to be defeated or endured.
00:25:26 Interesting point, actually, you made earlier, Peter,
00:25:30 about, going right back to the beginning,
00:25:33 about the Soviet Union disappearing,
00:25:40 meaning that, in fact, it gave a kind of big boost to left-wing thought.
00:25:45 The fall of the Berlin Wall liberated the left.
00:25:48 They were the first people to escape.
00:25:52 Some of the ideas that we were talking about earlier,
00:25:54 before we came on, but which were sort of informed by Marxism
00:25:59 or a sense of equality, egalitarianism,
00:26:03 which always sounds very benign, doesn't it?
00:26:06 But they sort of permeated at least...
00:26:08 It doesn't sound benign to me, actually.
00:26:10 No, but, well, actually, I remember growing up, egalitarian,
00:26:14 it was used in a...
00:26:16 It wasn't necessarily a bad thing.
00:26:19 I mean, it used to be used in art and just being a good thing.
00:26:23 Certainly in terms of one of your particular interests is education,
00:26:27 what's happened in education.
00:26:28 and it was
00:26:30 absolutely went through the whole thing
00:26:32 you know that it's about
00:26:34 equality essentially
00:26:36 of opportunity
00:26:38 which is a great thing
00:26:39 it did not say
00:26:42 on the banners of the French Republic
00:26:44 liberty, equality of opportunity
00:26:46 and fraternity, it said liberty
00:26:48 equality
00:26:49 fraternity
00:26:51 there was nothing about opportunity
00:26:53 at all
00:26:55 equality of opportunity is a very
00:26:58 different thing from equality and conservatives use it as a sort of slogan to make out that they're
00:27:03 in favor of well that they're nicer than you think they are which is in most cases true because
00:27:10 people think conservatives are so horrible it wouldn't be very difficult for them to be nicer
00:27:13 than other people think they are but equality of opportunity is not the equality that the left
00:27:17 or any radical dreams of it's equality of outcome that they want. Well isn't that what we're having
00:27:22 now? Well I think it's what's being attempted it will never happen it never has it never will
00:27:26 And the Soviet Union, when I was there, was one of the most unequal societies I'd ever seen.
00:27:31 It was a special hospital the size of a major provincial city's general hospital
00:27:36 behind a 12-foot wall in its own wood in the Lenin Hills in Moscow,
00:27:41 reserved entirely for members of the Central Committee of the Communist Party,
00:27:44 and nobody else could go there.
00:27:46 Special waiting rooms in airports and stations.
00:27:49 I lived in this, per se, this marvelous nomenclatura block of flats
00:27:53 with 12-foot ceilings and oak parquet floors
00:27:55 and lovely views and no smell on the staircase.
00:27:58 And that wasn't available to anybody but the elite.
00:28:02 A large number of my neighbours worked for the KGB.
00:28:08 Special hospitals were school number one in Moscow.
00:28:12 One of my translators and fixers in Moscow,
00:28:19 a wonderful one, Olga, who's now left Russia,
00:28:23 She went to school number one in Moscow,
00:28:25 superb school, English medium,
00:28:29 and her grandfather was a Red Army general
00:28:32 who hated corruption and was a real Bolshevik.
00:28:36 The only time he ever used his pull,
00:28:38 what they call blat in Soviet Moscow,
00:28:41 was to get her into that school
00:28:42 because it was such a fantastic privilege.
00:28:50 Officially, of course, it was just like all the others.
00:28:51 officially my flat was just like all the others
00:28:54 I remember one day all my ration cards
00:28:57 arrived
00:28:57 in the post box
00:29:00 a ration card for so much vodka
00:29:02 so much tobacco, so much lard
00:29:04 whatever it was, it just came in
00:29:05 because officially I was a normal Soviet citizen
00:29:08 I never dared
00:29:10 collect the vodka ration
00:29:11 I thought if a foreigner had turned up in the vodka ration
00:29:13 in that period of Soviet history
00:29:15 I'd probably been lynched
00:29:16 Of all the places that you did travel
00:29:19 and where you report it from,
00:29:23 what state in your mind is being,
00:29:26 that is the most important to me?
00:29:29 Is there one?
00:29:30 Sorry, what is...
00:29:31 As a journalist, when you were being a correspondent,
00:29:36 when you were in Russia,
00:29:38 which stands out to the most?
00:29:41 Living in the Soviet Union changed my life.
00:29:43 I'd known in theory all the things about it
00:29:47 that I then found out in practice.
00:29:49 But I didn't know a lot of other things.
00:29:51 One associates in a secret police,
00:29:54 privation, queues, grayness, filth,
00:29:57 air pollution, failure
00:29:58 in almost every aspect of everything,
00:30:02 oppression, inability to travel, gloom.
00:30:06 But what I didn't realize
00:30:07 was the huge hostility of the Soviet system
00:30:11 towards the married family
00:30:13 and towards what we would regard as Christian morality
00:30:16 that became evident to me.
00:30:18 It was all failing by the time I was there,
00:30:21 but I'm pretty certain that at the time I was there,
00:30:23 for instance, there were more abortions
00:30:25 than live births in the Soviet Union.
00:30:28 I hardly knew any Soviet person of my age
00:30:33 or anything around it who hadn't been through a divorce.
00:30:36 It was almost universal.
00:30:38 Child care was basically a system
00:30:40 whereby the state didn't pay you enough
00:30:43 for one parent to stay at home and raise the children,
00:30:46 so both had to go out to work
00:30:48 and could then take advantage of cheap childcare.
00:30:50 Well, does this remind you or anything?
00:30:52 But those aspects of it,
00:30:56 the social, cultural, familial aspects of it,
00:30:59 and the deep hostility to religion,
00:31:02 which was just collapsing,
00:31:03 Gorbachev was bringing it to an end,
00:31:05 but which had been there very strongly until then,
00:31:08 was also an extraordinarily strong part of it.
00:31:12 They knew that Christianity was a very strong rival
00:31:15 to the sort of society they wanted to have,
00:31:17 and they weren't going to have any of it.
00:31:18 Thank you very much.
00:31:20 Do you think actually that Christianity, therefore,
00:31:22 religious belief, is in fact the most effective resistance
00:31:30 to that form of totalitarianism?
00:31:33 In other words, people often say, we have got to, for example,
00:31:37 they say, we have got to utilize and protect
00:31:40 enlightenment values against this.
00:31:44 But in fact, you would say Christianity is actually the only way.
00:31:47 Well, it depends what you mean by resistance.
00:31:49 The trouble with power of this kind
00:31:51 is that it's almost impossible to resist.
00:31:55 They crushed almost all resistance
00:31:57 to everything they did for 70 years.
00:32:00 It says people offering examples of themselves
00:32:04 for how one could live better.
00:32:06 Then yes, but in terms of resistance,
00:32:09 you're not going to overthrow an iron-banned state
00:32:13 like the Soviet Union by going to church
00:32:15 or professing religious belief.
00:32:17 you might as well try and overthrow it with poetry
00:32:21 it's not going to happen
00:32:22 ultimately what I overthrew it was its failure
00:32:25 to produce consumer goods
00:32:26 the horror of China is that China
00:32:30 is an equally hideous police state
00:32:32 but it can produce consumer goods
00:32:34 so it's proved that
00:32:36 what we used to think
00:32:38 that you couldn't have prosperity
00:32:40 without freedom
00:32:41 it's proved that isn't true
00:32:43 you can have prosperity and tyranny
00:32:46 and they've got it
00:32:47 I mentioned
00:32:49 I was just mentioning a bit earlier
00:32:51 education and you were writing
00:32:53 recently about Shirley
00:32:55 Williams who was the former
00:32:57 Labour Minister for Education
00:33:00 in the 1970s
00:33:01 late 1970s who you knew
00:33:03 Well I met her
00:33:05 when I was oddly enough
00:33:08 an education reporter on the Daily Express
00:33:09 back in the 70s I met her
00:33:12 for the first time and discovered
00:33:14 that she was a delightful person
00:33:16 and capable of disinterested kindness.
00:33:18 I won't describe the incident where I discover this in detail,
00:33:21 but I have no doubt that it's true.
00:33:23 She's a very likable person.
00:33:26 And it's an interesting illustration to me
00:33:29 of how much you can simultaneously like a person
00:33:31 and think they're completely wrong.
00:33:33 And also how maybe good people can do bad things.
00:33:37 They often can, yeah.
00:33:38 I mean, I should explain to people,
00:33:40 is that her name is synonymous with
00:33:43 the introduction of comprehensive education, really, in Britain, isn't it?
00:33:49 She was deeply involved in it.
00:33:51 She believed it was a good thing.
00:33:55 There were two phases in which she was politically deeply involved in it.
00:33:58 One, when she became, when Ashley Crossland,
00:34:03 he did have a predecessor, but who doesn't really matter,
00:34:06 when Ashley Crossland in 1965 began the process of destroying
00:34:10 the selective secondary state education, the grammar schools.
00:34:15 She, in 1967, became his minister for schools,
00:34:18 so she was deeply involved in that very destructive process.
00:34:22 She then stood for election in 1974
00:34:25 on a programme of abolishing a particular type of grammar school
00:34:29 called the direct grant school,
00:34:31 many of which were still remaining at the time.
00:34:34 She supported that election pledge
00:34:37 while her own daughter, Rebecca, was attending such a school,
00:34:41 Godolphin and Latimer and Hammersmith.
00:34:44 And there's been some interesting correspondence in The Spectator Lady
00:34:48 about that particular incident.
00:34:51 But she then went on to become Education Secretary in, I think,
00:34:56 76, I think, when Jim Callaghan took over from Harrow Wilson.
00:35:01 And she then was the person who was in charge of abolishing
00:35:06 the last remaining direct grants
00:35:07 and getting rid of as many more grammar schools
00:35:10 as she could do.
00:35:11 So to her dying day,
00:35:13 she never expressed any regret over this.
00:35:15 She continued to believe
00:35:16 that the abolition of selective state secondary schools
00:35:19 had benefited the poor,
00:35:21 which I think is a demonstrably false belief.
00:35:24 But she did believe it.
00:35:27 Well, yes,
00:35:27 it's this idea that somehow or other
00:35:30 this brings about,
00:35:32 comprehensive education brings about social mobility
00:35:34 seems to be entirely disproven, you know,
00:35:37 that I was a grammar school boy.
00:35:40 And I remember, you know, when my school went comprehensive,
00:35:45 Shirley Williams was this kind of hate figure
00:35:47 because she was symbolic of it.
00:35:50 But during that period, which was the 70s,
00:35:53 was a period of great social mobility on the whole.
00:35:56 You know, kids from grammar schools going to universities and things.
00:36:01 That's ground to a halt pretty much, hasn't it?
00:36:04 Well, yes, a lot of other things have changed.
00:36:08 This was a much more class-driven society at that time than it is now.
00:36:13 So it's different.
00:36:14 What I would say is that the Sutton Trust has done some very interesting work on this,
00:36:19 which it doesn't publicize very much because the Sutton Trust isn't in favor of selection in state schools.
00:36:25 But it has shown that the most successful comprehensive schools tend to be the most socially selective,
00:36:33 that is, say, the biggest concentration of well-off pupils.
00:36:36 So it certainly hasn't created some kind of egalitarian paradise.
00:36:43 Much more important to me, and this is evident to anybody
00:36:47 who studies the examination system in this country,
00:36:49 is that the straightforward levels of secondary education have fallen so much
00:36:53 that even judged by the rather low standards of good grades
00:36:58 in a central set of GCSEs,
00:37:02 the achievement of comprehensive schools in this country
00:37:06 is only marginally higher than that of the remaining secondary moderns
00:37:10 in areas where there are still grammar schools.
00:37:14 So basically, instead of creating grammar schools for all,
00:37:17 which was the Labour Party pretend slogan,
00:37:20 a bit like Mark Suspensers, exclusively for everyone, rubbish,
00:37:24 instead of creating grammar schools for all,
00:37:26 what the education system has created
00:37:30 is secondary moderns for all.
00:37:32 But I'd add to that,
00:37:33 probably not as good as many of the secondary moderns,
00:37:36 which was much smaller schools than comprehensive schools
00:37:39 and so more disciplined,
00:37:41 and also tended to teach people practical skills,
00:37:43 which they tend not to do now.
00:37:45 So the whole education system has been trashed
00:37:48 for anybody who isn't rich.
00:37:50 And even the rich, the grammar schools,
00:37:53 and particularly the direct grammar schools,
00:37:55 kept the private schools honest.
00:37:58 Their standards were extremely high.
00:38:01 And once they'd gone,
00:38:04 once the grades had been telescoped
00:38:05 and the whole levels had been reduced,
00:38:07 any private school pretty much
00:38:10 could claim to have fantastically high educational standards
00:38:13 because it really doesn't take all that much effort
00:38:16 if you've got a reasonable amount of discipline
00:38:19 in smaller classes
00:38:20 to get your pupils through the lower grade exams we have now
00:38:27 and to look really good.
00:38:28 But they haven't, they don't remotely approach the standards
00:38:30 which they used to have before 65.
00:38:35 The history of the GCEO level is very interesting.
00:38:40 First of all, it's the lowering of its standards
00:38:44 and the telescoping of its grades.
00:38:46 And then it's replacement by the totally different GCSE,
00:38:49 which is an exam of a different character
00:38:51 and nothing like this demanding,
00:38:53 tells you almost all you need to know about large standards.
00:38:57 Well, yes, and also just the sheer number of A grades.
00:39:01 Well, so that's just the telescoping of grades.
00:39:05 People just didn't get even A grades or grade ones
00:39:09 or whatever the equivalent were in the early 60s
00:39:11 in anything like the numbers they do now.
00:39:13 They were quite rare.
00:39:15 Same with universities,
00:39:16 which were a first class degree
00:39:18 was really quite a hard thing to get
00:39:20 whereas now they are
00:39:21 I won't say they can't with the rations
00:39:23 but they're much more easily obtained
00:39:24 than they were 40 years ago.
00:39:26 Do you think there would ever be a time
00:39:28 where widespread selective education
00:39:31 could make a return?
00:39:33 Well it has done in Germany
00:39:35 when the East German communist regime
00:39:38 fell in 1989
00:39:39 and East Germany was almost wholly comprehensive
00:39:42 they had one very good
00:39:45 elite school in Germany
00:39:46 there was a great deal
00:39:53 of petitioning in all the new states
00:39:55 of the New East Germany
00:39:56 for the return of
00:39:58 grammar schools
00:39:59 and of gymnasium
00:40:01 as they call them
00:40:02 and I've been to one of them
00:40:05 in Wismar in the Baltic
00:40:06 it's exactly what you want
00:40:09 I spent a day with the English class
00:40:11 and the pupils were a mixture of the children of dockers and doctors.
00:40:17 It was exactly what you want.
00:40:18 It wasn't a class-based school.
00:40:21 It was an achievement and standards-based school.
00:40:24 And so they've got the back.
00:40:25 I think in all the states of East Germany,
00:40:29 you can bring them back if you want to.
00:40:32 So it could be done.
00:40:33 I think the fact that the private schools in this country
00:40:36 are rapidly becoming so expensive
00:40:38 that only Russian oligarchs can afford to send their children to them
00:40:40 is going to mean that the middle class of this country
00:40:42 is going to be much more interested
00:40:44 in the standards of state schools,
00:40:46 much more closely interested in the coming years.
00:40:50 But at the moment, everything has to be seen
00:40:51 through this great impenetrable fog of the academies.
00:40:55 It's almost impossible to tell from outside
00:40:57 whether they're as good as they claim to be.
00:41:00 But does Germany have the same sort of educational blob,
00:41:05 as they call it, as we do here?
00:41:07 I don't believe so.
00:41:08 So education in Germany is run by the states
00:41:11 rather than by the central government.
00:41:12 And it does vary from state to state.
00:41:14 In some of the more left-wing states,
00:41:16 they've got a mixture of comprehensive
00:41:17 and selective education.
00:41:20 In Bavaria, generally the gymnasium,
00:41:23 the grammar schools are supposed to be better
00:41:25 than most of the rest of the country.
00:41:27 It varies.
00:41:28 But most, I think, of the German-speaking countries
00:41:30 in Europe, Switzerland, Austria, Germany,
00:41:34 have still retained some sort of selection,
00:41:36 though they don't use an 11 plus examination
00:41:38 they tend to use assessment
00:41:39 and they have something approaching the
00:41:42 tripartite system which we attempted to build
00:41:44 in 1944 and never really
00:41:46 did
00:41:47 I have to ask, well I don't have to ask
00:41:52 I want to ask
00:41:53 as we sort of
00:41:55 this is the beginning of May
00:41:57 we've got about a month left
00:41:59 a month and a half left
00:42:01 before the country is supposedly
00:42:03 opening up Peter
00:42:04 I mean you've been talking very consistently right throughout this whole period this past year
00:42:12 what are your general feelings about Britain as we enter our supposed the end of the whole
00:42:19 pandemic thing I you know have you I know you're pretty pessimistic about Britain but do you think
00:42:28 that we have actually permanently
00:42:31 given away rights and freedoms now?
00:42:34 Well, rights and freedoms
00:42:35 is the wrong way of putting it.
00:42:40 Freedoms are a different thing from rights.
00:42:42 So it should be distinguished.
00:42:43 Rights are more or less things
00:42:45 invented by the state,
00:42:47 which are then handed to us
00:42:49 as things which the state has codified.
00:42:51 Freedoms are things which existed
00:42:52 in all times,
00:42:56 which we had,
00:42:57 and which have to some extent
00:42:58 being taken away from us by the state or surrendered to the state.
00:43:02 I would say you look at the history of the 20th century in this country,
00:43:06 you see a long tally of freedoms being handed over by the people to the state,
00:43:13 particularly during wartime, which were to a great extent not handed back.
00:43:18 But they don't tend to be codified as you can't do this, you can't do that.
00:43:22 What happens is that people become more used to seeking government approval
00:43:26 for something that they do and more used to the idea
00:43:31 that what they do is controlled by somebody else
00:43:33 and regulated and the assumption which existed largely
00:43:37 in this country until just before 1914
00:43:41 that really the state had very little business
00:43:43 in your life has gone.
00:43:45 We just assume that we will be governed
00:43:48 and told what to do by a stronger and stronger state
00:43:50 and I think the state grew a lot stronger
00:43:53 during the period of the shutdowns
00:43:57 because the civil society and the people in general
00:44:02 showed so little spirit in defence of those freedoms
00:44:05 which they still had.
00:44:06 I think that's a permanent effect.
00:44:08 Once people have ceased to act like free men,
00:44:11 they cease to be free men.
00:44:13 I think people didn't act like free men and women
00:44:15 during that period.
00:44:17 So, in fact, we are diminished.
00:44:20 I think so.
00:44:21 I think you can get into the habit of being more of a serf
00:44:25 than you were before, and I think that's what we did.
00:44:29 I look at the mask wearing, for instance,
00:44:31 and people they're wearing in the street.
00:44:34 Nobody even says that you should do that.
00:44:37 No one has ever said, actually, that you need to do that.
00:44:40 But they do.
00:44:42 And in many cases, they look askance at those who don't.
00:44:47 Speaking as one who doesn't wear a mask in the street,
00:44:49 You know, so people will go around you.
00:44:53 You did wear a gas mask.
00:44:54 I was taking what is called Mickey when I did that.
00:45:02 You've had the vaccination, didn't you?
00:45:04 I had the first one, yeah.
00:45:06 Yeah, I had the first one.
00:45:09 So that wasn't part of what you would consider to be?
00:45:12 I had never said anything about vaccination.
00:45:16 I hadn't said I wouldn't get it.
00:45:18 I haven't said other people should get it.
00:45:20 A lot of people who feel very strongly about it,
00:45:24 it's a perfectly legitimate position to hold,
00:45:27 got angry with me because I had done what they didn't want to do,
00:45:31 which seems to me and still seems to me to be completely unreasonable.
00:45:34 But people get unreasonable under these circumstances.
00:45:38 I suppose they're entitled to.
00:45:40 It's never been a thing which has particularly troubled me.
00:45:44 Well, no, it seems to be quite distinct
00:45:46 from what we were talking about with freedoms.
00:45:48 I think so.
00:45:49 I mean, yeah, it was, in my case,
00:45:52 it was a practical choice
00:45:54 with particular personal reasons to it,
00:45:55 which I could make life a lot easier for myself
00:45:59 if I specified exactly what they were.
00:46:02 But I'm damned if I'm going to go into that much detail
00:46:04 of my private life in public.
00:46:07 Well, look, thank you once again for coming on.
00:46:13 And I hope you'll join us in another six months, Peter.
00:46:16 well I look forward to it if we're not
00:46:18 if we're not algorithmed out of existence
00:46:20 between now and then
00:46:21 I can't see why they would possibly have a go at this one
00:46:24 because I'm on it
00:46:26 yes
00:46:27 anyhow I'm taking the risk
00:46:30 anyway thanks so much
00:46:32 thanks a lot
00:46:32 that's it for what you're saying is
00:46:35 and we shall see you next time
00:46:38 thank you
00:46:46 You