New Culture Forum - June 30, 2021


Prof. Doug Stokes: Anti-White Racism Is Rampant In Universities

What Do We Think Of GB News? Reviewing Britain's Newest News Channel My Favourite Books...with Michael Collins

Episode Stats


Length

52 minutes

Words per minute

170.56

Word count

8,913

Sentence count

—


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is. I'm Peter Whittle. Now before I introduce my
00:00:26 guest this week I would just like to ask you again as I always do but it always
00:00:30 works please do subscribe won't you by clicking the subscribe button on the
00:00:36 channel it's very easy next door there is a blue bell which is where you get
00:00:42 notifications so if you click on that that means you'll get notifications
00:00:45 coming up of all of our programs now my guest this week I'm very pleased to say
00:00:51 is Doug Stokes. Doug is professor and head of research and development at the
00:01:00 Strategy and Security Institute at the University of Exeter. He also contributes
00:01:07 to numerous publications including Spectator, The Critic and The Telegraph.
00:01:13 Thank you very much for joining us Doug. Good to see you. I wanted to ask you
00:01:19 about something very specifically, being at Georgia University. In the Queen's Speech
00:01:25 quite recently, the government made one of its, I would say, emblematic attempts to look
00:01:31 at the culture wars, and it mentioned, it introduced a bill which is called the Higher
00:01:38 Education Freedom of Speech Bill. Now, I think this is making its way through Parliament.
00:01:45 There's been so much controversy and discussion about the state of free speech on campus.
00:01:53 What does this bill actually, what is it intended to do?
00:01:58 Well I think what it's intended to do, I think a lot of the critics have misunderstood it.
00:02:03 I think what it's intended to do, institutionally at least, is to establish a new free speech
00:02:08 champion within the Office for Students.
00:02:11 The Office for Students is the regulatory body for all English universities, at least,
00:02:16 and so the bill, once it passes through the various stages it needs to go through, and
00:02:20 obviously there'll be some tussles as it moves through the various stages, so once the bill
00:02:25 goes through, it'll establish a free speech champion in the Office for Students who will
00:02:32 have the regulatory power to fine universities, ultimately, if they don't promote academic
00:02:38 freedom and freedom of speech right uh but i but i mean so and and but i think what it's about also
00:02:45 is um if we think about um how societies work you have what we might call structural
00:02:52 incentivizations various institutions right so in other words if you do xyz you get reward in this
00:02:58 way if you don't do xyz you get you know it goes bad in this way and universities like most corporate
00:03:05 entities respond very, very strongly to structural incentivizations. So I think in the university
00:03:13 system, we have, for example, the teaching excellence framework, the research excellence
00:03:18 framework, and these are various structural incentivizations set up by various regulatory
00:03:22 bodies in the university system to promote research excellence or teaching excellence,
00:03:27 et cetera. And then universities will set up a whole bureaucratic substructure to make
00:03:33 sure that their systems are in place to sort of ultimately meet what the incentives of these
00:03:38 various structures that are that are in place so i so i think the government very bravely by the way
00:03:43 i think very bravely it wasn't it was a manifesto commitment yeah but i think that the department
00:03:48 for education team has done a fantastic job in taking in taking that seriously that that that
00:03:54 commitment to freedom uh and to academic freedom so what so ultimately what you'll see then is an
00:03:59 academic freedom champion within the office for students but i but more broadly in a structural
00:04:04 level at least you'll then see universities structurally incentivized to make sure they take
00:04:09 academic freedom and freedom of speech but academic freedom is broader sense yeah uh very very
00:04:14 seriously um and to the extent that we care about um the ultimately the progress of humanity right
00:04:22 if you think about it i mean we think about the progress of humanity it's kind of a dialectical
00:04:26 process we have a sort of settled orthodoxy and new challenges or revolutionary challenges come
00:04:32 along and they overturn it i mean like galileo darwin newton we can go on and on and so so
00:04:38 essentially what the way i see this is it's an it's a government intervention for me ideally
00:04:44 it wouldn't be government or state-led but unfortunately the rot is so deep that's where
00:04:47 we are now it's a government intervention to not not to sort of come down hard necessarily but
00:04:53 to ultimately protect a beachhead that the ground a foundation stone if you will where academic
00:05:02 the academic dialectic can take place and i think that's what that's the way i see it right i mean
00:05:07 that's the way i see it's ultimately about the preservation of values that unfortunately are
00:05:13 under direct threat mostly from i would say uh university leaderships across the uk uh you know
00:05:22 crossed all kinds of very, very strange and very dodgy lines, in my opinion.
00:05:27 So that's a very... I've taken a long time to answer your question.
00:05:31 No, no, no.
00:05:32 But that's the way I see it.
00:05:33 It is interesting. I'm glad you took a long time,
00:05:36 because obviously there is a problem.
00:05:39 However, not according to Tony Blair and Lord Adonis,
00:05:44 who I believe last week said something along the lines of
00:05:49 that this was a bill in search of a problem.
00:05:52 that there was no problem with free speech in universities that's just patently absurd is it
00:05:58 not doug it's it well it's absurd on a multiple range of levels right and this is what i don't
00:06:04 get about the critics even if you think that this is some dastardly right-wing plot or some kind of
00:06:13 some bizarre machination in the in the culture wars why would you care so much
00:06:19 uh that we are protecting legislation is going through to protect the foundation stone of of of
00:06:26 this country i.e freedom of speech freedom of conscience and freedom of thought why would you
00:06:31 devote so much time to sort of trying to tear this down as if it's some bizarre right-wing plot i mean
00:06:39 so even if even if mr blair and uh lord adonis are right so what so what so you're gonna get
00:06:46 another bureaucracy and it's just going to sit there to them in its thumbs in the worst case
00:06:50 scenario but there will be a bureaucracy to ultimately protect academic freedom so that's
00:06:56 even if they're right but they're not right yeah i mean i mean you've got you know the terms cancel
00:07:03 culture and all the rest of it so but what i've seen and you've had eric carl from an honest good
00:07:09 friend and colleague and then and nigel bigger as well i mean so and there's there's so much
00:07:14 evidence for this it's it's it's you know even on the on the student unions banning speakers and
00:07:20 but for me the bigger much bigger problem and i and every time i write something it goes out there
00:07:25 i get hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of emails from some of those senior people in the country
00:07:31 by the way who say to me doug thank you so much for saying that um i i agree with you 100 but i
00:07:39 i can't say anything because i'm fearful for my career i'm fearful i had one just the other day
00:07:44 i won't name obviously we'll never name individual or even institution right but i get them all the
00:07:49 time and these aren't junior academics these aren't you know newbies these are people at the
00:07:55 very very top of the academic food chain who will not stand up basically and and put their neck out
00:08:01 but then but agree 110 with what's going on that shows you that the nature of the culture
00:08:07 in our institutions in this country yeah um it's very very worrying um you know you have all these
00:08:13 kind of faddish commitments to all these kind of taking what are in fact absolutely marginal
00:08:19 theories interesting theories like decolonization uh and which draws from post-colonial theories
00:08:26 from edward saeed and and these kind of theorists but they've in many ways they've taken what are
00:08:33 absolutely fringe theories and now impose them from the top down in the name of social justice
00:08:40 now that to me is crossing a massive line so that's it yeah yeah do you i mean do you do you
00:08:46 recognize the kind of picture that is drawn of the academic world being without sort of monolithic
00:08:56 in terms of opinion and that it is producing students of equally you know monolithic views
00:09:03 you know that there's the very place that should be full of nuance and diversity is where you find
00:09:12 it the least do you do you recognize that as a picture well it's it's not about my recognition
00:09:19 it is obviously established fact and if you look at the opinion polls over and over again you know
00:09:24 i mean and this isn't me denigrating my academic colleagues by the way i mean i i think i i see my
00:09:28 job as an absolute privilege i love you know the student engagement students on the whole are
00:09:33 fantastic and even as the staff who may disagree with me in many issues are on the whole very good
00:09:39 people these aren't bad people but absolutely if you look at the opinion polling it's quite clear
00:09:44 there is a very very hegemonic common sense to use the gramscian term kind of you know this kind
00:09:49 kind of, you know, it's pretty much established monolithic anti-Brexit, kind of very much
00:09:56 increasingly now on the kind of social justice woke, you know, I hate to use that term, it's
00:10:02 such a sort of bizarre term, but it captures something very real. So the woke, you know,
00:10:07 the woke, that is quite strong. And I do think a lot of academics, and no judgment on this,
00:10:15 by the way but I do a lot of academics see their role not so much as like guided professionals
00:10:19 although they are very professional but more they see it as a vocation in terms of social
00:10:24 transformation so if you come into in if you come into the job with that that vibe and it doesn't
00:10:30 change as you get older or more grizzled like me you know and you can't develop certain standards
00:10:35 necessarily you know if you see it if that's that's the way you are and then another broader
00:10:40 point and this is a this is a i'll shut up in a second but a broader point is any any social system
00:10:46 this is a really important point right any social system you have to think about the internal
00:10:50 mechanisms through which it learns from mistakes right now how does any social so in a market
00:10:56 system for example learning from a mistake is you don't make much money so people customers will go
00:11:01 elsewhere and so that that's the natural process of evolution so that that's how the internal
00:11:06 feedback mechanism works right in the public sector or in the universities how do you how
00:11:12 then do you recalibrate in relation to theoretical mistakes so for example you may you may be an out
00:11:19 and out marxist right and you know you believe in the proletarian revolution and that's that's one
00:11:24 way but then that hasn't necessarily keyed into the history of 20th century for example yeah or
00:11:30 or you can believe in foucault and post-structuralism uh and you know it's everything's about discourse
00:11:36 but then it doesn't key into the incredible advances we have in science and and and because
00:11:41 of the nature of the system itself it often it takes place with an academic petri dish but it
00:11:47 doesn't often have to sort of come into contact with the real world in some senses so that's not
00:11:53 me denigrating the job or my colleagues in any way i have tremendous respect for academics and
00:11:58 in academia but to answer your question absolutely it's very very very homogenous but one final point
00:12:04 if I may Peter I know I'm going on quite a lot here even if we accept which is obviously quite
00:12:09 in that there is very very homogenous this thing goes back to the academic freedom debates right
00:12:14 insofar as even if we accept it's homogenous that's in one way that's not great because
00:12:20 students aren't going to get exposed to all the diversity of viewpoints and diversity of ideas
00:12:25 and it's not heterodox in some senses and it's very much a it's very much a kind of like there's
00:12:29 a it's kind of underlying assumptions that just form the framework for all of academic discourse
00:12:34 okay and they and they just almost go unquestioned we can go on to what they may may be in a bit or
00:12:39 whatever but but that's where it's at but again i go back to my original point for me the big
00:12:44 problem is not so much the academic homogeneity but when university leadership teams come along
00:12:51 who should be impartial and say well we're going to take that marginal fringe theory and we're
00:12:58 going to impose it from the top down so it's no longer about academic contestation it's no longer
00:13:02 a pet tradition no longer and he he gave in dialectic of debate now it is from the top down
00:13:09 a technocratic imposition of a very specific worldview right and that in my opinion is an
00:13:16 absolute betrayal of the fundamental values of the university system the british taxpayer
00:13:22 that that's where it goes badly wrong so even if you have homogeneity in academia
00:13:26 when you have the imposition from the top down of a specific set of bizarre fringe theories
00:13:34 and as the as the way of operating and the way of conducting yourself that's that is a fundamental
00:13:40 betrayal of the values of the university system you're talking broadly you know it's about critical
00:13:46 race theory here um this is one critical theory generally isn't that right this is the this is
00:13:53 the sort of movement that has actually been imposed uh critical race theory is the one that
00:13:59 we are it's most to the forefront if you like um well critical race theory yeah that that's what
00:14:07 the two main ones are decolonizing the you know this decolonizing idea and critical race theory
00:14:13 now decolonizing the curriculum i've done a book on fuko and it draws on very draws on kind of
00:14:19 post-structuralism post-modernism post-colonial i won't bore your your your listeners and your
00:14:24 fantastic viewers with too much going down the the road of social theory and all the ins and outs of
00:14:29 it but it draws on um those kind of ideas and edward saeed for example did a very interesting
00:14:35 book called orientalism yeah okay and these are actually really interesting ideas and it's
00:14:40 it ultimately talks about the idea of um you know systems of knowledge uh have implicit power
00:14:46 relationships and stuff like that now utterly contestable there's been huge amounts of academic
00:14:52 debate about this stuff it's been you know pulled apart picked apart and it's and it's it is
00:14:58 ultimately a kind of one element of you know on on the end of a very broad social scientific
00:15:05 spectrum right decolonizing the curriculum but what you've had is you've had a kind of moral
00:15:10 panic amongst the the university leadership uh across the united kingdom and you saw this most
00:15:16 notably with the universities uk did a report tackling racial injustice in higher education in
00:15:22 2020 in november 2020 and i urge all of your uh listeners and readers to go and download that
00:15:29 report from the UK website. And in there, they essentially endorse critical race theory and
00:15:36 decolonising the curriculum. This is at the very top of the VC system. So this has now been
00:15:41 percolating out right across the university system. They endorse decolonising the curriculum
00:15:45 and they talk. So sticking to decolonising the curriculum. So basically, this is a very,
00:15:50 very fringe theory, right? It's interesting. It's got some really interesting points,
00:15:54 highly contestable, highly debatable, but it's just one of many, many flavours of social
00:15:59 scientific or humanities theories but what university leaderships have done as a result
00:16:03 of the uk in this kind of moral panic that we're now seeing we're importing from america kind of
00:16:08 the sort of whatever you think the sort of toxic racial positive we've imported it now
00:16:12 and these are supposed to be progressive leftists and they're kind of champion american imperialism
00:16:17 cultural imperialism importing from america the the racial discourse of america into this country
00:16:23 basically so so so so what's happened now is they've taken decolonizing the curriculum and
00:16:28 the line has been crossed you saw it for example was it stephen toop at cambridge recently he got
00:16:33 he got himself into a little bit of a hoo-ha because he put an anonymous snitching starsy
00:16:38 like portal online whereby staff and students can still submit um uh reports on on on individual
00:16:46 members of staff at cambridge that have committed a racial microaggression microaggression what
00:16:51 what actually what are we talking about what with those microaggressions what kind of things would
00:16:55 they let me give you a very good example peter all right the ehrc produced some reports in 2019
00:17:02 right and there was two sets of data reports they were absolutely terribly done but those data
00:17:09 reports i won't get too much in the rabbit hole here but those two data reports form the empirical
00:17:13 basis for the uk reports and the various reports now taken up by university leadership teams
00:17:19 okay the ehrc produced these reports that they're terrible now in terms of like their um and i've
00:17:26 written on this as well if you're interested you know you can i've done some great not not
00:17:31 blowing my own trumpet but with my great colleague one during iosia who's a road scholar here at
00:17:36 exeter we did an interesting piece in quillette if you're interested in looking at that but
00:17:40 basically the so these ehrc reports in evidencing alleged racial um injustice across the uk higher
00:17:47 education system the principle way that they do this is very amorphous very vague is microaggressions
00:17:53 let me give your listeners some examples of the microaggressions these are these are direct quotes
00:17:58 that ehrc reports say evidence of racism in uk universities right and have been used to push
00:18:06 through the critical race theory decolonizing the curriculum microaggression agenda in uk
00:18:11 university you ready one of the one of the examples of racial microaggressions a black
00:18:15 student or staff member was in the lift a white staff member went to get in the lift changed
00:18:21 their mind and went down the stairs that was the evidence of a race racial microaggression in the
00:18:26 EHRC reports a lecturer's body language a lecturer's body language and demeanor that's a direct quote
00:18:33 by the way a lecturer's body language and demeanor if they stand i don't know with your arms folded
00:18:39 or steven toop snitch portal on cambridge if somebody raises an eyebrow when you're talking
00:18:44 to somebody if if a student says something and and you raise an eyebrow that's uh alleged uh
00:18:50 racial microaggression uh discussions of brexit and i quote that have introduced a cold wind on
00:18:57 uk campuses evidence of microaggressions so if we if we think about this right think about this
00:19:04 the west won the cold war we the west won the cold war okay and we are now looking more and more like
00:19:12 east germany online portals for reporting people that raise an eyebrow somebody's body language
00:19:20 somebody that takes a lift somebody that discusses brexit and this isn't this isn't fringe stuff this
00:19:26 is the ehrc and the uuk yeah yeah very top of the food chain yes there we are isn't it i mean isn't
00:19:35 Isn't the essence of, for example, the critical race theory, that really, it's just anti-white
00:19:43 racism, isn't it?
00:19:45 I mean, isn't that the real essence of it, that by virtue of being white, you inherently
00:19:52 have this racism in you?
00:19:54 This is the point.
00:19:55 So you're actually talking about a whole group of people that are therefore just beyond
00:20:02 redemption by virtue of being what they are isn't this actually the the motivating uh engine really
00:20:12 well that that's one element of it but i mean so essentially critical race theory uh as far
00:20:17 as i can tell and it's like a lot of these grievance theories that we see i think actually
00:20:22 sorry you actually did uh you had a great term for it called the grievance industrial complex
00:20:28 i.e. not the usual military industrial complex the grievous and grieve grievance industrial complex
00:20:37 maybe you could explain that i mean i think i know what you mean but if you could explain it
00:20:41 well i i borrowed obviously from the military industrial complex the military industrial
00:20:45 complex the underlying logic of the argument is is that you have a self-reinforcing relationship
00:20:52 So you have, say, for example, the American state has strong corporate interests linked to weapons producers.
00:21:01 And so this kind of corporate revolving door then kind of, you know, inculcates its own path dependency towards war.
00:21:09 Right. So I borrowed that. I did a piece in the critical, the grievance industrial complex, where I look at what you have is you have university leadership teams.
00:21:19 And then you have various external bodies.
00:21:22 We've seen, for example, recently in Stonewall, very heavily involved in the news.
00:21:28 And Stonewall, for example, was produced, you know, it has these kind of like links to various public sector bodies and private sector bodies, universities, etc.
00:21:36 Then you have other organizations like Advance HE.
00:21:39 Now, Advance HE is a massive higher education.
00:21:43 It kind of provides training courses and workshops.
00:21:46 and they also run a thing called the Race Equality Charter and this the Race
00:21:50 Equality Charter is really is essentially is the thing now that's kind
00:21:54 of if you go on their website you can read all about it it's all about
00:21:57 decolonizing the curriculum it's open endorsement of critical race theory and
00:22:00 stuff like this so the Race Equality Charter a bit like Stonewall Charter or
00:22:06 the Athena Swan the gender equality Charter the Race Equality Charter is a
00:22:09 thing that universities now reaching for and pulling off the shelf and saying
00:22:13 Well, we're going to submit our institution through the Advanced HE's Race Equality Charter.
00:22:18 And it has bronze stars, silver stars and gold stars.
00:22:21 And then once you get your various stars, you can put them on the front of your university logo and say, we're a proud member of, you know, Advanced HE's Race Equality Charter.
00:22:30 We've achieved this gold star.
00:22:34 Now, I think nobody has any issue with anti-racist.
00:22:41 I've been anti-racist all my life.
00:22:42 um i abhor discrimination uh you know absolutely and i think you'd be hard pressed to find
00:22:50 a more progressive uh sector than the university sector you know various and when you look at the
00:22:57 actual data it really i mean so you've got this kind of in many ways in a kind of a moral panic
00:23:04 has been thrown up and but then you have these self-interested organizations for example like
00:23:09 advance he one of the ways it makes this money is to run these workshops is to run these
00:23:13 accreditation programs same with stonewalls same with other organizations right so the point i made
00:23:18 in the green's industrial complex is you have a kind of a kind of strange uh symbiotic relationship
00:23:26 between these various charities sometimes the quangos sometimes non-governmental agencies
00:23:32 university leaderships which creates its own path dependency towards certain types of corporate
00:23:38 change in corporate culture and i think that's what what that's what we're seeing in the in in
00:23:42 the uk to come back to your point about critical race theory if you will so advance he and the
00:23:48 race equality charter it kind of explicitly adopts critical race theory as its worldview
00:23:53 um you know it kind of adopts this but but maybe we can talk a bit bit about the kind of the
00:24:00 implications of that educational implications of that so what i'm so what i find absolutely so
00:24:06 shocking is as you said peter it it seems to endorse a really kind of casual anti-white racism
00:24:15 yes uh whereby whiteness so-called whiteness is is seen as this malign negative terrible thing
00:24:25 and then and then it operationalizes this concept of white privilege uh uh uh uh white fragility so
00:24:32 So basically, the white privilege, as your listeners may know,
00:24:35 essentially says all white people, as a result of their skin colour
00:24:39 and therefore their structural position within society,
00:24:43 have inherent privilege, right?
00:24:45 And if you deny this or the lived experience of the people saying this,
00:24:50 whoever they may be, then you're displaying white fragility.
00:24:54 It's a sort of self-referential logic to it.
00:24:56 Well, yes, isn't it rather like the old ducking stool?
00:25:01 is it that if if if the woman i think if the woman drowned she was guilty but if she survived she was
00:25:09 also guilty i think if the woman drowns she's innocent you gotta get her anyway yes i don't
00:25:16 know i think i think i think i think i don't think you're too far wrong or it's it's kind of like
00:25:21 kafka-esque isn't it yeah the denial of it is simply a kind of the the affirmation of one's
00:25:28 in a guild but the thing about what gets me the most about this is a lot of universities and staff
00:25:37 are drawn from often people you know they come from very elite families they come from very very
00:25:42 often very privileged backgrounds um and often universities exist in a sea of deprivation so
00:25:49 you can go a kilometer away from most campuses and you'll find very run down uh council states
00:25:57 i think there's an individual at birmingham who's like one of the sort of central critical race
00:26:01 theorists to come i think his name's professor kahindi uh i think he's uh well he can't be at
00:26:07 kahindi andrews and um you know and he's like one of the big critical race theorists and he talks
00:26:13 explicitly about whiteness as a psychosis uh but the thing about that is i what i would like to do
00:26:19 is i i maybe gb news could do this as a program or somebody but basically to take some of these
00:26:26 academics that are expounding these theories right and take them down the road to some council
00:26:32 estates or take them down the road to you know areas of extreme social deprivation and what i
00:26:40 would love to see is those academics who are on fantastic wages nice fat pensions blah blah blah
00:26:46 public sector pensions right to then explain to those individuals on those council estates
00:26:52 and tell them about their white privilege yeah i think that's what they should do and if they can
00:26:58 do that and morally accept themselves afterwards and keep doing it then you know fair play to them
00:27:05 i think their ideas are complete and i can't swear but i think they're not they're not correct
00:27:09 in any way but you see what i mean and that it's like the university campus is like a petri dish
00:27:15 and you get all these ideas and the casual anti-white racism now that we see i mean even
00:27:22 an academic i'm amazed that a lot of these academics haven't been done legally under the
00:27:27 equality act i think i think a lot of academics and a lot of university leadership teams are on
00:27:33 really really dodgy ground legally because if you look at the equality act and especially the public
00:27:39 sector equality duty section 149 explicitly states that you have to ultimately promote harmony
00:27:46 amongst protected characteristics and race is one of them so what i don't understand is you have
00:27:51 privileged academics banging on about whiteness, white privilege, structural whiteness and white
00:27:59 fragility. Right. And I'm amazed that you're not seeing hundreds, if not thousands of lawsuits
00:28:05 against institutions or against academics under the Equality Act. Because how is it not racism?
00:28:12 I don't know. It's not. But the point, surely, is that the people who maybe would bring or could
00:28:19 bring an action against them on those grounds are kind of sort of on board that's the problem
00:28:27 you know that the they uh they're full of guilt they're full of self-hatred actually um one other
00:28:37 thing i think is very important to mention when you if you go back you know doug you're talking
00:28:41 about the report that came out a couple of years ago structural racism in universities and all of
00:28:46 this the one group that is least likely to go now to university is in fact white working class isn't
00:28:53 that right white working class boys i think um but they are least likely um and this but why are
00:29:02 these facts somehow never taken on board we sort of know them but somehow the theory or the the
00:29:11 ideology is quite it's just allowed to sail on isn't it it's allowed to sail on even though the
00:29:17 facts simply don't support it well this is your listeners may have picked up your viewers may have
00:29:23 picked up i'm quite passionate about this and i feel strongly about that you could you could get
00:29:28 that vibe just now and the reason i feel so strongly about this is because i was born in
00:29:32 hackney in east london i lived there for 24 25 years i grew up in two most of my child was spent
00:29:38 in two rooms my mum my dad my brother and me my parents we all shared one tiny little bedroom
00:29:42 right i couldn't afford to do a level i had to sort of do an access course at the age of 20
00:29:48 because i couldn't afford it i came from a very poor working class family right first person in
00:29:52 my family to ever go to university right so i'm now and i'm within you know by the age of 40 i was
00:29:58 a professor uh a leading muscle group university i.e exeter okay so that that's why i'm quite
00:30:03 passionate about it that's why you can sense this kind of burning injustice in me because i think
00:30:07 that um for a start i had a very multi-racial multi-ethnic upbringing the first hands to bring
00:30:15 me to touch me was a jamaican midwife my first ever loved was a black black girl um very multi-ethnic
00:30:22 very multi-racial upbringing right and you can see that the efforts and just how everybody poor
00:30:29 people black and white and everything in between had to mix and rub and just get along get on with
00:30:34 their lives right and i see this stuff now and for me this is people often white liberals yeah
00:30:42 middle class liberals right and i think and this goes back to the politics of brexit and a lot of
00:30:47 what we're seeing now you say you say that they're guilt that they're guilt uh i think you're right
00:30:52 i think there is this kind of element of guilt but i think there's been an illusion now between
00:30:57 class privilege and a lot of these people pushing these ideas are very very privileged
00:31:00 upper middle class people highly educated from elite families very wealthy families right
00:31:06 yeah so i think you're seeing an elision now between the politics of class where the left
00:31:11 and the progressive left have kind of abandoned class if you will as the primary kind of category
00:31:16 of oppression to lift to then move on to these kind of other forms of identity politics and
00:31:23 grieving politics i.e race etc etc etc so i think it is about guilt to some extent and self-flagellation
00:31:29 but i think it's also primarily about a moral a moral economy yeah right so when when you when
00:31:38 you point the finger and you are white privilege and you've got this and you've got that you're
00:31:42 really saying i'm one of the good people i'm on a higher moral plane than you right and i'm looking
00:31:48 down and i can judge you and in in so far doing it and it's kind of on a meta meta theoretical
00:31:54 or meta-philosophical level, what you're ultimately doing there then
00:31:58 is you're reinforcing a kind of, I'd say it's kind of a lazy,
00:32:03 progressive liberalism that's floated in the ether now
00:32:07 for about 40 or 50 years on the back of the institutional settlement
00:32:11 of the Second World War, right?
00:32:13 And that's why in some of my recent pieces,
00:32:19 I talk about even the struggle over Brexit, right?
00:32:22 it wasn't it wasn't even a cost-benefit analysis in many in many ways it was far more akin to a
00:32:29 theological struggle really very much much more of a and a question of faith right and the faith
00:32:36 was in this this kind of supranational this progressive cosmopolitan ode to joy liberalism
00:32:43 right and the eu was was socially constructed as that as this thing if you look at the reality of
00:32:49 it i mean you know from the the savage debt restructuring imposed on greece to you know
00:32:55 right the way through to the you know the anti-democratic machinations in italy and the
00:33:00 the destruction of the southern mediterranean youth unemployment as a result but let's
00:33:07 ignore those facts right let's just maintain the narrative so i i so i think i think a lot
00:33:13 of this stuff we're seeing now is partly about guilt it's about uh class privilege yeah it's
00:33:21 it's about mainly also it's about a moral economy where those that adopt this are on a higher moral
00:33:26 plane and they're looking down those that they despise and have long despised i.e the british
00:33:32 working class black white and everything in between they are they are the primary target
00:33:37 they are the primary target of these people uh and i think you saw that very much through the
00:33:42 politics of brexit which was constructed as kind of like uh the gammons you know these kind of
00:33:47 unreconstructed uh racist xenophobic and you're seeing it and i think that is the discourse that
00:33:53 we're seeing is it's an elite discourse which allows those propounding it to abrogate their
00:33:59 moral responsibilities to their country to their fellow countrymen to judge them to put them on a
00:34:04 higher higher moral plane where they're kind of keying into these loose and woolly ideas
00:34:10 of progressivism etc um but and i'll quickly i'll shut up in a second the thing is those uh that
00:34:19 woolly liberalism and progressivism is very much resting on very very shaky geopolitical foundations
00:34:28 as i've argued recently in the telegraph piece right that where where we've been at in european
00:34:33 history in the last 40 odd years 50 odd years is not the norm in human history great power
00:34:38 competition is coming back right uh globalization has in many senses uh put in play a whole range
00:34:45 of structural forces within the global economy and within international relations and international
00:34:50 politics that we simply cannot ignore and that's the way in which i interpret brexit
00:34:54 as a as a kind of impulse in that changing configuration of international politics
00:35:00 about national sovereignty and the the new dispensation that i think we're going to see
00:35:05 emerging so but with this new situation that will emerge i mean how is that being reflected in what
00:35:12 we've discussed so far doug how how is that being reflected in all the issues that we're talking
00:35:17 about well i i think that um trump now whatever you think about trump i think you had victor davis
00:35:23 hansen on a few weeks ago i mean he's quite pro-trump now whatever you think about trump
00:35:28 let's forget trump for now right but let's talk about the social forces or trumpism now trump
00:35:35 he may or may not come back he that may or may not be a bad thing you know we can discuss that
00:35:40 right but the social forces that underlie what he was about or at least his message was about
00:35:47 are not going away i.e uh a rejection of globalization a rejection of the outsourcing
00:35:54 and the active promotion of post-industrial economies in America,
00:36:01 where the working class have been very much left, been left behind,
00:36:06 and the hollowing out of many communities and national life.
00:36:12 And so we go back to what I said before,
00:36:15 this commitment to this amorphous, progressivist, supranational element to it.
00:36:20 That also captures the globalization moment, doesn't it,
00:36:23 the 1990s and the noughties where we saw this this promotion of the open world open borders
00:36:29 and what that actually meant when you scratch you scratch the surface a little bit is ultimately
00:36:33 the outsourcing of jobs the sort of post-industrial decline in the anglophone economies in particular
00:36:38 in particular america right the abrogation of the quality of life for many many ordinary people in
00:36:44 america right and all done in the name of this of this kind of uh corporate uh globalization which
00:36:51 is in this kind of this borderless progressivism which which then launches various savage wars
00:36:58 uh to ultimately to to promote this this kind of bizarre idea so so i think what we're seeing now
00:37:05 the social forces that have been thrown up as a result of that change in the anglo foreign economies
00:37:10 in particular the social forces they're not going to go any they're not going to go anywhere anytime
00:37:15 soon so the so the social forces of trumpism yeah uh in terms of the return of national sovereignty
00:37:23 the rejection of globalization uh and and those kinds of those kind of elements and that may be
00:37:28 even a change in the global economy into a more u.s centered global economy and a more china
00:37:33 centered global economy i think we may we may see that too but what that's doing is it's reaffirming
00:37:40 the primacy of sovereignty and national sovereignty in the context of this changing global economy.
00:37:46 And I think that's one of the ways in which we should understand Brexit as an impulse,
00:37:52 as an instinct, if you will, of the British people in terms of where we want to position
00:37:58 ourselves going into the future and these kind of broader changes.
00:38:02 Yes. Speaking of the future, actually, you wrote recently, in fact, you wrote a piece in The Telegraph this weekend, I believe it was, in which you were talking about the nature of, for want of a better expression, the woke attack or the hard left attack on our history and culture, which is what it is.
00:38:25 But you sort of said that, look, you know, this is about erasing Western civilisation.
00:38:35 And what we've got to be aware of is that there are states in the world who have a fair
00:38:41 amount of self-belief, you know, either existing or to come in the future, who actually don't
00:38:47 have a lack of confidence in what they are.
00:38:51 are in a way up against them are we not well that's a fantastic point peter i mean you've
00:38:59 absolutely nailed it uh essentially this goes back to some of the broader themes that we've
00:39:05 just discussed i.e if we think about it right you know the the decolonizing the decolonizers
00:39:11 the post-colonialists the anti-statues all the all these all this phenomena right it ultimately
00:39:18 It takes at its heart the deconstruction, if you will, of Western civilization or elements of it, a rejection of reason in many senses, a rejection of progress in many ways.
00:39:29 And essentially what it wants to do, it seems to me at least, is to sort of inflect and generate a sense of extreme guilt.
00:39:38 Now, guilt is one of the most powerful emotions in terms of disabling you.
00:39:42 right i'm not saying it's necessarily conscious right but guilt is a highly disabling emotion
00:39:48 now the irony is this western the west uk for example you look at all the opinion polling
00:39:54 it's one of those progressive liberal multi-ethnic democracies in human history where else would
00:40:02 anybody who's gay or non-white or you know where else would you rather be and there may be somewhere
00:40:10 else but i mean you know we're not we're not too far from the top right if you look at opinion
00:40:14 polling okay and then all of our institutions uh rightfully so trying their very best to promote
00:40:21 equal opportunity uh and a kind of more and and that that kind of society right very very progressive
00:40:29 okay now to go back to my earlier point the the where we're at now in terms of the geopolitics of
00:40:36 europe and the west in general is we are seeing a rapid a declining america in many senses right
00:40:42 and you have a rising china you have china's coming up very very strong economically
00:40:47 uh and then you have on the edges of europe you have russia uh a highly uh militarily very very
00:40:54 effective state very strong economically but not very strong and it has its own demographic problems
00:40:59 but nonetheless it has a very you know militarily very powerful on the edge of europe can cause all
00:41:04 kinds of problems that we're seeing in ukraine we're seeing china very strong rapid economic
00:41:09 development now and in many senses economically we're kind of entering into a more kind of bipolar
00:41:14 international economic system sort of china and and a western-centered america but nonetheless
00:41:20 america uh seems to be very much on decline not just economically relative to china but also in
00:41:27 terms of its kind of civilizational mojo and if we cast our minds back during the cold war what did
00:41:32 we have we had anti-communism as a kind of broad discourse that helped to shape relationships in
00:41:39 the west and it worked quite well it had various security alliances within it but it worked very
00:41:44 well because essentially the the the enemy if you will from putting crude terms was real i.e
00:41:50 soviet russia you had after the end of the cold war we then had this this kind of amorphous
00:41:56 supranational global progressivism and globalization but so the point i we try to sort of making that
00:42:02 piece in the telegraph is what now binds the west what's the story what's to sort of if you want to
00:42:08 put it on more kind of grandiose terms what's the what's what's the sort of transcendent story that
00:42:14 we have that binds us spiritually if you want to put it in those kind of terms because if you think
00:42:19 about it politics isn't just about the positive the rational and cost benefit analysis it's also
00:42:24 fundamentally about identity it's about how we understand our place in space it's about how we
00:42:30 understand ourselves as a people and and that's why when you saw the uh the attacks on churchill
00:42:36 and the statues underlying that it's not just about the physical attacks on those things it's
00:42:41 about the symbolic what that means symbolically right in terms of the attack on if you will on
00:42:47 on the sort of the transcendental purpose in the history and the culture and institutions
00:42:51 of this country right so so the point in that telegraph piece is really making that
00:42:56 we we are in a very strange place progressives apparently want to tear down that you know the
00:43:01 kind of the the the the western international system that's already going down pretty pretty
00:43:05 goddamn quick right they want to tear it down and yet it's most one of the most progressive
00:43:10 societies in human history right in in human history so but and then but this is that this
00:43:17 is taking place in the geopolitical context of the rise of china which you know i have tremendous
00:43:24 respect for china and its culture and its peoples you know but if you look at it it's not you know
00:43:29 highly authoritarian one-party state uh mass technological surveillance shoveling uh uighur
00:43:37 muslims into re-education camps etc etc etc and and they're very very powerful and they're getting
00:43:43 more powerful we have a kind of a quite chauvinistic russia to some extent it has its own
00:43:49 kind of thing and then the middle east continue will continue to be characterized by bubbling
00:43:54 insurgencies state failure uh revolutionary elements to it and and so so that so that's
00:44:01 where we are and those forces and then demographic forces as well that we're seeing in the so-called
00:44:07 developing world in africa we will see we'll see a lot more migration now as we're seeing
00:44:12 a demographic bulge take place so these these are these are these these things are baked in
00:44:18 in some senses right so then it's how do we respond in a way how do we respond to this
00:44:24 so that's so that's so that i think that was really the point of the piece we have a very
00:44:28 progressive um uh society and yet we apparently want to deconstruct it and tear it down in the
00:44:35 context of of the rise of some of the most illiberal and authoritarian regimes in human
00:44:40 history it seems a very very strange thing to want to do doug before we before we uh finish
00:44:47 i'm very interested you know you talked a bit about you know where you grew up and i just
00:44:52 wondered at what point in was it in your teenage years when did you decide to take the academic
00:44:58 route you know i mean if there if you had been you know your first time at university first in
00:45:05 your family at university um i don't know what your family dynamic was like but but when did you
00:45:11 sort of decide to take the route you have well i my fam my parents would you know they they they
00:45:19 they hadn't i was the first person in my family ever to go to university uh and i i i went to uh
00:45:25 really not good inner city uh comprehend i went to uh junior infants junior nursery infants junior
00:45:33 in Hackney, just, I don't know if you know
00:45:36 the Kingsmeade Estate, do you know the Kingsmeade?
00:45:37 Oh yes, yes, yes.
00:45:38 Yeah, just, the Kingsmeade Estate
00:45:41 was the catchment area for that,
00:45:44 just literally not really explored the Kingsmeade Estate.
00:45:46 Then I went to a school called Raines Foundation
00:45:48 in Bethnal Green, which was, I mean,
00:45:50 so, you know, so I went to very sort of
00:45:52 inner city, multi-ethnic, poor, poor schools.
00:45:58 And never, and first in my family
00:45:59 I would go to university, I had no guidance really,
00:46:01 I you know there's no guidance in terms of and my parents couldn't I mean they you know it was a
00:46:05 it was a world they didn't know much about um but so so I so I did my degree uh I did it through an
00:46:12 access course when I was I think I started when I was 21 and then I did various uh things I went
00:46:17 to Bosnia for a best part of a year I worked in Bosnia which is an incredible experience helped
00:46:21 establish an NGO in Bosnia and then I came back and then I went to uh Bristol I had five years in
00:46:28 Bristol in my master's in what was called development administration and planning so
00:46:32 basically international development and then I did my PhD at Bristol in international relations
00:46:38 I looked at American counterinsurgency doctrine in in Latin America and then and so I went from
00:46:45 there really I kind of you know I really got more and more into it I never sort of planned it out
00:46:50 so is it is it correct to say therefore that you entirely was self-motivated in other words i mean
00:46:58 none of this was in the mix anyway before was it it wasn't like laid out that you would
00:47:04 automatically go to university and all that stuff so this was this was basically you just
00:47:08 decided and you you to go on that road and you did it yeah pretty much basically exactly right
00:47:15 yeah that's that's that's what happened i had nobody guiding me uh or telling me i had no i
00:47:21 mean not judging my parents but i had no educational encouragement ever ever i was always a
00:47:25 bright kid i wasn't i always loved to read even obviously now i read and write books but i've
00:47:31 always loved to read so yeah so i kind of like i sort of fell into it and i thought that that it
00:47:36 was a really interesting and i just really enjoyed it i still do i mean i still yeah but i was going
00:47:41 say the reason i i just brought that up is that at the beginning you said something i thought was
00:47:46 quite noble actually you said uh you consider it a privilege to do what you do and and i would
00:47:53 suggest without wishing to be sentimental that that comes from the way in which you came by it
00:47:57 well the thing the other i i consider it a privilege in so far as i think there's something
00:48:03 very special that young people would come to university and to me and whatever and entrust me
00:48:12 with their educational intellectual development and i think that i i see that as a real privilege
00:48:20 uh to be allowed into that position and i see i mean i see i've taught tens of thousands of
00:48:27 people over the years and you know occasion and most of them are fantastic but in occasion you
00:48:32 get those real diamonds and that that's really very special i'll also say i mean you see a lot
00:48:37 this about snowflake students and stuff like that i mean the vast majority of the students that i
00:48:43 teach i mean are just they're just lovely i mean they're fantastic you know young people very you
00:48:48 know hard-working honorable good good good young people uh so i so i think that is a real privilege
00:48:55 And I also come from, say, a family of, you know, mum was a cleaner,
00:49:02 dad was a sign writer.
00:49:03 He used to cycle 12 miles to work every day and cycle 12 miles.
00:49:08 He'd cycle 12 miles to work all weathers on an old heavy bike,
00:49:12 couldn't afford a car, do a full day's work and cycle back.
00:49:15 And I can go on.
00:49:16 I'm not going to go on too much.
00:49:17 So the way I see it is to be able to pay to read and to teach
00:49:23 to write and to engage in fantastic programs like this with you Peter is an absolute privilege I'm
00:49:29 not having to get on my bike and cycle 24 hours 24 miles every single day in the snow to do a full
00:49:36 day's work just to make a bad living so so I'm very much about I think that we have a lot of
00:49:45 this in society where people I think self-pity is a very very dangerous emotion and it can it's a
00:49:52 very debilitating emotion and it allows one to uh say it's not it's not my fault it's not my
00:49:59 responsibility it's your responsibility and i'm a victim and therefore you know on that and i think
00:50:03 that's a really debilitating thing so i so whenever i feel a bit funny or you know i think back to
00:50:11 what i had to do in the past or what my family had to do and i think myself doug you haven't got a
00:50:17 right mate you haven't got a right to feel sorry for yourself you know i mean so that that's the
00:50:22 way i see it peter and i think i think uh and i guess that's also it helps to explain some of my
00:50:27 passion around some of these issues when i see people in academia who are good people but often
00:50:34 come from very privileged backgrounds and um don't really have an idea and in still in academia is a
00:50:41 very privileged position to be in good pensions good pay you know good very good conditions and
00:50:46 would still wish to judge ordinary people on the most disgusting and horrible grounds oh i know
00:50:51 yeah the stuff the stuff you see that's so casual casually said you know um white privilege and
00:50:59 this stuff i just think it i just think it's shocking it's really shocking
00:51:03 well doug i mean it's been fantastic talking to you about it all um and uh thank you very much
00:51:10 for giving us your time i know i do believe you've got to go off now for an optician's appointment
00:51:15 i believe so all right uh doug look thank you very very much and uh i do hope that we speak again
00:51:23 very soon in the same way um you know uh events are very intense at the moment so i think there'll
00:51:29 be lots of opportunities thank you very much indeed thank you so much thank you that is it
00:51:36 uh for this week on so what you're saying is uh we shall see you next time thank you very much
00:51:45 Transcription by CastingWords