New Culture Forum - September 13, 2021


Victor Davis Hanson - 9⧸11 - 20 Years On - Are We Any Safer?

Rod Liddle On BBC Bias & His Time As Editor Of Radio 4's Flagship Today Programme Jeremy Black on James Bond - A British Icon - Is Today's James Bond Still James Bond?

Episode Stats


Length

37 minutes

Words per minute

149.93

Word count

5,641

Sentence count

261


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 Hello and welcome to So What You're Saying Is, I'm Peter Whittall. Now my guest today
00:00:29 has been on the channel before, very pleased he's come back to speak to us again. Victor Davis Hanson
00:00:36 is one of America's pre-eminent conservative commentators. He's also an historian, military
00:00:42 historian and a classicist and he is senior fellow at the Hoover Institution. He's the author
00:00:49 as well of numerous books including the best-selling The Case for Trump. His new book is called The
00:00:56 Dying Citizen. It's out on October the 4th. You can order it on Amazon, and he's with me now.
00:01:05 Thank you very, very much for joining us, Victor. Thank you for having me. Now, we'll talk a bit
00:01:10 about your book a bit later on, but I just wanted to start by asking you, because today, of course,
00:01:17 is the 20th anniversary of 9-11 what were your own personal memories of that day
00:01:27 well i'm in hillsdale college and 20 years ago i was on the way to hillskill i teach three weeks
00:01:36 a year during my vacation in military history i teach here at hillsdale college and i was in the
00:01:42 air and we got a notice over the sierra nevada mountains i was leaving from central california
00:01:48 that a light plane had crashed into the tower and it was a it was a minor accident but nevertheless
00:01:58 for some reason the pilot couldn't figure out we had to go back to the central california airport
00:02:03 at fresno so we got there and then we were told we were locked out
00:02:08 locked down and no one knew what was going on. And then after two hours, they released people
00:02:15 from the airport. I drove to work. I was at the time teaching at Cal State Fresno. And for the
00:02:20 first time, the editor of National Review Magazine called me and said, Rich Lowry, would you write
00:02:26 about this? And I had gone to the lounge in the faculty area and looked at the TV coverage. And
00:02:36 i wrote my first column about it i think the day of the attack and i i did that for the next 20
00:02:43 years until this year so it was a life-changing and it was quite stunning nobody really knew what
00:02:51 it was it's easy to look back and critique our reaction to it but in that general turmoil of
00:02:59 the times there was a sense that whatever the west in general and the united states had done
00:03:04 in particular in retaliatory action toward these acts of terrorism whether that was the marine
00:03:11 barracks explosion of 1983 where we withdrew and then we bombed with the new jersey
00:03:17 areas in the becca valley or we attacked the tanzania i mean east africa bombings or
00:03:24 we were retaliating against the coal that either that had wet wetted the beak of the terrace we
00:03:29 thought and that there was a new move that even the anti-nation builder george bush would critique
00:03:36 the clinton uh administration for going into the balkans and rather than just bombing try to be
00:03:42 engaging suddenly it was 180 degrees that quasi republican isolationists were saying bombing
00:03:49 doesn't work with these people you've got to go in on the ground and physically remove them
00:03:54 And then somehow that morphed into you have to physically go in, remove them and then create the conditions on the ground that they will not come back.
00:04:05 And then finally, you have to go into the ground and create some type of simulacrum of a Western government, because to do anything else would be imperialistic or something.
00:04:16 And that was that devolution that we went into where we ended up bogged down in these countries.
00:04:23 And now we're going back, apparently, to the pre-9-11 mindset of retaliatory, tit-for-tat, whack-a-mole, or whatever you call it.
00:04:32 Carrying on from that, I think you've written in one of those columns, or a recent column,
00:04:37 that it was quite astounding how America did bounce back, actually, after that, economically.
00:04:45 Yeah, it was, because we went into a recession, not unlike or perhaps greater than the COVID
00:04:52 lockdown recession.
00:04:55 And yet you could make the argument that within a year we were booming back.
00:05:01 We had taken out, we had gotten consent from the Congress.
00:05:06 We being the American government, the administration of George Bush, he had gotten consent from
00:05:12 the Congress and from the UN to take out the Taliban, the abettors, and the harbors of Al-Qaeda
00:05:18 along the Pakistani border in Afghanistan. We took them out in six weeks, contrary to expectations.
00:05:25 And we then had created a sense of deterrence in the Middle East where people were very careful
00:05:30 about United States power. And there was sort of a unification, not just within the United States,
00:05:37 But I think also within Europe, the United States, there were NATO troops in America that we had quasi evoked Article five of the NATO clause.
00:05:47 And Americans were quite happy about that.
00:05:51 And then in defense of America, you could make the argument that if you had said on September 11th that this day, 20 years later, we would not have had a foreign attack, I think people wouldn't have believed you.
00:06:06 We were talking about serial attacks until we knew what we were doing.
00:06:11 Now, it's certainly true that we've been attacked by the Sardinai brothers, the Chechen immigrants, the Boston Marathon bombers, the San Bernardino bombers or the Fort Hood bombers.
00:06:21 But they were of a different caliber, a different species of either American citizens or American residents or immigrants.
00:06:29 but they didn't pull off the horrific magnitude that the 9-11 bombers.
00:06:36 So whatever we did, for all of it's our fault, we have not had a similar attack.
00:06:41 And that's across four different administrations.
00:06:47 There is an argument being made now, which I've read,
00:06:52 that 9-11 in some ways was a cul-de-sac in history.
00:06:59 in the sense that I remember at the time for me it is the defining event of certainly my adult life
00:07:06 and everything was looked at through the prism of 9-11 and and what you're talking about now
00:07:13 but that now that whole that whole paradigm to use that terrible word has changed it's all about
00:07:19 China now and that all the things represented by 9-11 are of secondary importance I mean do you
00:07:26 think that that is a valid argument there's elements of truth to it but remember it's a
00:07:32 a dual argument because it assumes that china has grown far more powerful than it was 2001 and
00:07:42 remember at that time they had the veneer of conciliation they were coming to britain or
00:07:48 europe or the united states with their idea that we are impressed by you we want our students to
00:07:53 come to universities. Although we had Tenenman Square, we want to liberalize. That's what
00:07:59 people thought, that the existing fallacious ideology among Western elites were the more
00:08:05 that we give concessions to this new capitalist China, the more that democratization will follow
00:08:12 economic liberalization. We never in our mind, I mean, some of us did, but nobody thought that
00:08:18 this magnanimity would be interpreted as weakness to be exploited, we thought it would be reciprocated
00:08:24 and sort of an arrogant idea that they want to emulate our political, cultural, social
00:08:29 institutions as well. And that didn't turn out to be true. So China is much more hostile,
00:08:35 much more powerful beyond anybody's imagination 20 years ago. And then the flip side is it would
00:08:42 assume at your proposition, which I think is correct, it would assume that Islamic terrorism
00:08:49 is somewhat less powerful. And I think that there are cosmic events in the Middle East,
00:08:55 the Abrams Accord, where we have Arab countries that are closer to Israel due to their common
00:09:01 hatred or fear of Iran. The Palestinians have lost some of their international luster.
00:09:06 and until recently, Iran was sort of a Chinese vassal. It still is, but it was suffering from
00:09:14 COVID, the sanctions, it was weakened, Hezbollah. And so I think we could say that China is a
00:09:22 dynamic enemy and that radical Islamic terrorism, while it's always going to be a threat to the
00:09:29 and we saw that in Afghanistan more recently, it's more of a, it's sort of like mowing the
00:09:36 grass with them. It's a manageable problem. If we're alert and we're deterrent, we can handle
00:09:42 it. We don't know quite what the future holds for 1.4 billion people who are hostile to the
00:09:48 United States, and they've created a new fusion between communism and state-run market capitalism.
00:09:56 Before we leave this point about 9-11, I just wondered, is there a greater understanding, popularly speaking, of the Islamic threat in America?
00:10:08 I mean, one gets very exasperated, at least here, with the same kind of articles that come around time and time again that you read in the press, which seems to not really understand the very basis of the attack, you know, from Islamism.
00:10:25 I just wondered if that was the case in America, too. Do you think there's still a naivety there?
00:10:32 I do. I think almost immediately there was a fault line that developed among the left and participants of what I would call the isolationist right.
00:10:44 And they made the argument that while it may not have been wholly deserved, it was at least in part deserved because of our intervention in the Middle East or the 1990, 91 Gulf War or foreign U.S.
00:11:01 They were trying to find some culpability on the part of the United States to justify this.
00:11:06 And then they immediately exaggerated the reaction in the terms of we were racist, we're anti-Muslim.
00:11:15 We got some pretty crazy reactions in this country.
00:11:19 And remember at the time, bin Laden and Dr. Zawahiri were saying incredible things, why they had done it.
00:11:26 It was women were walking in the Middle East, Americans, women were walking without covering.
00:11:31 We were not involved in climate change.
00:11:33 They took everything out of the progressive book.
00:11:37 The other side said, either we have nothing to apologize for, given that our society is a far more humane one than theirs, and we have no desire to take over their society, and we don't really care what the reason is.
00:11:53 We're just going to retaliate to recreate deterrence.
00:11:56 And their concern was, for whatever reason, whether it was material or psychological or spiritual or civilizational, the West had lost deterrence and had given the false impression that it was weak, it was decadent, and people could blow up warships, they could blow up embassies.
00:12:14 And then the next logical acceleration of that was the Pentagon, the Twin Towers, indeed, the foreflight had hit the Capitol.
00:12:23 And they were intent on correcting that misassumption on the part of the terrorists.
00:12:30 And I think they did that at least up until 2006 when we when we got stagnant.
00:12:38 There was a stagnation in Iraq.
00:12:39 Do you think now, if we come right up to date with what's happened just with the withdrawal
00:12:47 in Afghanistan, what implications are there, do you think, now for our security? I'm talking
00:12:55 about terrorism.
00:12:58 It's been a non-godly disaster in every sense of the word because the Taliban pre-9-11 were
00:13:06 not very well armed they were sort of esoteric renegades in the middle east they were not
00:13:13 the avatars of radical islamicism now they are drunk on victory they're boasting that they
00:13:20 and they alone after defeating the soviets drove the united states out in shame and humiliation
00:13:26 and defeat and they have there's a fierce controversy here in the united states over
00:13:33 the actual amount of hardware they have given some of it is over 20 year period and encompasses
00:13:39 built-in cost of training but if you were to use the high figure 80 to 85 billion that's the
00:13:45 largest transfer in the history of civilization of military weaponry that is uh 80 of all the
00:13:53 amounts that we gave to israel during the history of the jewish state over 70 years plus that would
00:14:00 pay for 900 F-35s, six fleet carriers. So these pre-modern terrorists now have created a virtual
00:14:09 arms mart in Central Asia where China, Iran, Iran will be buying weapons and China and Russia will
00:14:16 be examining weapons to reverse engineering them. And we're going to be hearing from this,
00:14:22 these people for the next generation. And more importantly, we're going to have a series of
00:14:27 Bo Bergdahl incidents where Americans began popping up in twos and threes. And we should
00:14:32 expect that they'll be paraded on television. They'll confess to pseudo sins that they've
00:14:37 done. And we're either paying them bribes now or we will shortly to get them home. So
00:14:43 the humiliation will be measured and serial and insidious to weaken us. And then as far
00:14:50 as all of you guys in the UK and NATO, remember we asked you to come there. And whether it
00:14:57 was fair or not you saw us as the greatest military power as sort of the
00:15:03 leader spiritually militarily and monetarily and we provided the greatest
00:15:09 amount of troops but we only had anywhere from 35 to 2,500 troops you guys
00:15:15 had 8,000 we didn't consult with you we left Bagram Air Base in humiliation in
00:15:24 the in the middle of the night we left you people there we didn't coordinate with you and so you
00:15:32 you i'm being generic now as far as nato members you told us that donald trump's uncouthness
00:15:40 in leveraging another hundred million dollars to enhance nato readiness was wrong it alienated but
00:15:47 But despite his personal invective, he did make the alliance stronger by that fact.
00:15:54 But the adult in the room who returned the bipartisan foreign policy established in America is so welcomed in the UK and Europe has done more damage, if not essentially destroyed NATO for a generation.
00:16:09 And I don't know how anybody's going to trust this.
00:16:11 So I think we should anticipate very quickly that China will be flying in and out of Taiwanese airspace.
00:16:19 Its ships will go into their sea space.
00:16:21 I think North Korea will be testing again.
00:16:24 Iran will be accelerating its nuclear development.
00:16:28 Russia will have a hard look at NATO countries on the front line, the Baltic states.
00:16:33 And they're going to have all wait and see.
00:16:36 They're going to be provocative.
00:16:37 They're going to say, you know what?
00:16:38 the only way the United States can restore deterrence is to do some physical material act
00:16:43 because we don't believe they will. And that's where you get dangerous. It's very easy to lose
00:16:48 deterrence, but it's costly and dangerous to restore it. Somebody in this country is going
00:16:53 to have to store it because we are a strong country. We have the strongest economy in the
00:16:59 world. We've got the top rated universities. We've got the best military, but we're suffering
00:17:04 from a crisis of leadership. And people make the wrong assumption that we're therefore weak as the
00:17:10 Germans, the Japanese did in your case and in our case. We were much stronger than the Japanese and
00:17:16 Hitler, but they didn't believe it because our leadership did not convey that reality. And so
00:17:21 people miscalculate it. So somebody in this country has got to be in an adult room. And I'm
00:17:27 very worried about that because when you look at Kabul today, and I see we had a gender studies
00:17:34 program at the university. We had a rainbow pride flag at the embassy. We had George Floyd murals.
00:17:42 Those are all the ruffles and flourishes of a triumphant occupying power insensitive
00:17:48 to a traditional Islamic culture. But a weak power who's on the eve of defeat and humiliation,
00:17:58 that adds insult to our injury. What arrogance to think that we had that power when our military
00:18:04 was a shell and our commanders had not a clue. And we're saying the most absurd things that we
00:18:10 have shared agendas with apparently a new, kinder, softer Taliban that wanted us out as much as we
00:18:18 did. And we worked together in partnership, which was absurd. They wanted us out with humiliation
00:18:22 defeat we did not uh you mentioned their weak leadership obviously um profoundly weak um but
00:18:32 the fact is victor as well isn't it that it's an establishment-wide thing brought on one would say
00:18:40 by well maybe you could call it wokeness or or whatever but it's even uh affected the military
00:18:48 in america hasn't it and there one could say that this action or lack of action in afghanistan is
00:18:56 exactly the kind of thing that an administration establishment like that would do i.e they just
00:19:02 simply do not have um don't believe actually in victory they don't believe in strength
00:19:09 yes and we know historically that the worst thing whatever the system constitutional totalitarian
00:19:17 when you start ideologically purifying the ranks, and as remember that General Austin,
00:19:22 our Secretary of Defense said, he was going to go through the ranks and look for whiteness
00:19:27 and white race. That's what General Milley's exact words were. And same thing with Chief
00:19:32 of Naval Operations Gildade. Why they were lecturing us on this and why we had these
00:19:38 murals and pride flags. We know that Joe Biden was lying to us when he said,
00:19:43 we've made a lot of progress. They have 300,000 people. They can't collapse. And at that very
00:19:47 moment, he was calling the president in Afghanistan and saying, even if you're going to collapse,
00:19:53 you've got to lie about it, because basically, I've got to get out of here. And he tried to
00:19:56 leverage him, essentially saying, we can provide air power, but you've got to lie.
00:20:01 So there's something wrong when we have the refugee flights come. Remember the commentary,
00:20:07 I almost fell over. We want to assure Americans that we have proper gender ratios on the flight.
00:20:14 We want to assure Americans when the refugees land, they're going to have culturally sensitive
00:20:19 food. And I said to myself, you are requiring, I think wisely, every American in the military
00:20:26 to be vaccinated. You're not requiring any of these people to be vaccinated because you've
00:20:32 deprecated the value of citizenship. A citizen has less prerogatives than a foreign national.
00:20:39 And so there's so many things wrong. And I don't want to be hysterical, but when Joseph Stalin
00:20:46 went into the Red Army in 37 and 38 and cleansed all of the military talent and reconstituted
00:20:53 with ideological hacks, that was one of the reasons he lost deterrence and invited German
00:20:59 attacks five years later. If China believes that we are making decisions strategically,
00:21:06 tactically, operationally, and our personnel on the basis of race or gender or some extraneous
00:21:13 circumstances other than military efficacy, then they're going to be emboldened. I don't want to
00:21:21 be too eccentric or hysterical even, but the military leadership that we see today, Milley,
00:21:29 Gilday, Austin, and the command, is not the military leadership that we saw on 9-11.
00:21:38 That group was very accomplished. They went in and they got rid of the Taliban. You can even
00:21:43 argue they got rid of Saddam Hussein in three weeks. Now, later on, it was a misadventure.
00:21:51 But it was very different. We weren't doing this thing 20 years ago. And we don't know the full wages of this. How absurd, isn't it, for the Secretary of Defense and the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs say they want to explore the toxic nature of whiteness, when in Afghanistan, 74% of all the combat deaths were white males, and they died in proportion of double their numbers.
00:22:21 in the general population. And in Iraq, it was even more disproportional. And put that in the
00:22:27 context of Secretary Austin saying, well, we wanted everybody in the military to be
00:22:33 proportionally represented by race and promotions and flights and everything. I'm thinking,
00:22:40 when I heard that, I thought, okay, are you going to tell white males of the middle and lower
00:22:44 classes? You have died in twice your numbers in Iraq. It's time to pull you out and let other
00:22:49 people have a chance to die in their proper ratios because that's where this absurdity
00:22:54 the logical trajectory ends do you think that finally when it comes to biden and who i see as
00:23:02 being the symbol of all of this uh has the penny dropped you know on a wider basis in america
00:23:09 uh or are the media i mean are the media still apologizing for him or you know uh putting a spin
00:23:17 on him or or what has the mood changed at all of it it has initially they were outraged for a
00:23:26 variety of good and bad reasons and then they closed ranks on him within a week but now in the
00:23:33 last week they are critical and they're critical i think maybe for three reasons that come to me
00:23:37 all of a sudden. One, he is starting now in his cognitive state of, I don't know what I could
00:23:48 politely call it, but he's cognitively challenged. He's starting to tell the world at large the media
00:23:56 prompts. He said, they will not let me answer questions. Or I'm looking here and I find out I
00:24:02 have to ask you the question or here's the order they gave me and so what it suggests is that he's
00:24:09 not full control of his own destiny but more even damning that there's some type of media government
00:24:17 fusion where they've kind of collaborated in secret to not report his frailties in fact to
00:24:24 guide or script his press conference and yet he's telling the world this and that is so embarrassing
00:24:31 for these media people to be told that they know the script in advance of the very press conference.
00:24:38 The second thing is he hit 29, excuse me, 39% in the YouGov poll today. So the media is now
00:24:47 looking around saying, as progressives, we got a big midterm election coming up. He's down below
00:24:55 Donald Trump's levels, 39%, this man has the ability to destroy the entire democratic and
00:25:02 progressive agenda within 18 months. And so we've got to finesse this and criticize them and either
00:25:09 pave the way for Kamala Harris, which they're not necessarily looking forward to all that much,
00:25:15 given she got zero delegates when she ran for president, or they want some solution to this.
00:25:22 And then third, this is not an isolated event. When he had promised the country that by July there would be no COVID, they would be celebrating July 4th. And he made this astounding announcement that the 300,000 plus deaths under Donald Trump in the previous year were entirely attributable to the chief commander in chief. That was his response.
00:25:48 Trump killed. Well, now more people have been lost on his watch and far more per day if they're
00:25:56 probated. So all of these things, and I'm not even mentioning the 2 million people who are walking
00:26:02 across a border this fiscal year that was secure and closed, and the inflation rate at 6%.
00:26:09 So the border, the inflation, the racial animosity, the critical race theory, the Afghanistan problem,
00:26:14 the end of deterrence, the resurgence of COVID, misdirections at the CDC, the whole
00:26:21 Anthony Fauci disinformation about the origins and the gain and function research that we
00:26:26 subdivided. These are force multipliers of his inability. And so people now are saying,
00:26:33 this is not funny anymore. Ha ha, Joe Biden called me by a different name. Joe Biden,
00:26:39 And, you know, he had a little bit of egg on his chin and he licked it up.
00:26:43 Ha ha. This was sort of a blood sport for conservative commentators.
00:26:47 Now people are starting to say there is a pattern in this astounding first eight months.
00:26:53 And it's his cognitive inability to to do much of anything.
00:26:56 And we want to know who's running the country because he's sort of like the last nine months of Woodrow Wilson's administration,
00:27:04 where he was non-Compostmentes and his wife was sort of running the United States.
00:27:09 And you can make the argument in 1919.
00:27:13 Some of the things you mentioned in that list of the things facing America,
00:27:17 and you mentioned immigration, for example.
00:27:20 These are themes as well in your forthcoming book, aren't they, The Dying Citizen?
00:27:26 And you mentioned earlier as well about the soldiers, you know,
00:27:30 when you were talking about sort of having to be vaccinated.
00:27:34 um that somehow there is this devaluing of citizenship going on um this is crucial isn't
00:27:42 it this is the theme of your book the dying dying citizen it is i would argue that the nexus of all
00:27:48 these things that you and i've discussed the real cause of it is that we do not have a powerful
00:27:54 idea of citizenship as as the founders envision in which we had held for 220 years
00:28:00 We don't have a strong enough middle class.
00:28:04 Middle class from Aristotle to Tocqueville said
00:28:06 they lack the envy of the poor and the subsidies of the poor,
00:28:11 and yet they're not crony capitalists, so to speak.
00:28:14 They don't unduly influence government.
00:28:16 They're autonomous or independent folk.
00:28:19 And when you have $1.7 trillion in debt,
00:28:21 or when the average American dies with a net worth of $10,000,
00:28:25 globalization hollowed out the interior of this country.
00:28:29 We also don't have a border. And yet emblematic in Western civilization is from the Greeks on, you have to have your own place, your own particular space. People fought to the death over borders because they knew if they did not have borders, the people could not unite. They couldn't reinforce their constitutions with customs and traditions that were unique to their physical space.
00:28:54 Instead, we've allowed people who are not U.S. citizens, and we've extended them every right of a citizen, but no responsibilities.
00:29:03 By that, I mean they can leave the country in and out without a passport.
00:29:08 They serve in the military.
00:29:09 They're eligible for every type of entitlement.
00:29:12 The only thing that is left of the shreds of citizenship are voting, and there are illegal aliens that vote in local elections now, and the final one is holding office.
00:29:24 I think that domino will follow.
00:29:27 And then we have this woke movement, and that's a pre-civilizational, pre-modern idea that we're going to all resort to our ethnic or racial identities as essential rather than incidental to who we are.
00:29:39 We know one of the reasons Rome unwound is that people that were stationed in the Danube felt more German than they did Roman, and they did not want to go fight in North Africa.
00:29:53 or the Huns or the Goths or the Vandals, all of these tribal peoples were not going to be
00:29:59 assimilated. And the culture lost the confidence and its own ability to assimilate people.
00:30:07 Multiracial constitutional systems are almost unheard of in history. And it's a very fragile
00:30:13 idea. And we were doing a pretty good job of it 50 years out from the civil rights movement. And
00:30:17 we threw that away with a woke movement. And then finally, there is not a pre-civilizational
00:30:23 movement, but a postmodern effort among our elites. We have a huge administrative state,
00:30:32 as you do. These are unelected officials in the IRS, the FBI, the Pentagon, the woke Pentagon,
00:30:40 James Comey, Mr. Mueller. They run investigations. They tamper in elections. They fabricate
00:30:50 documents. They violate the uniform code of military justice that says retired military
00:30:56 officers cannot criticize the president. Our last president was called Hitler, Mussolini by retired
00:31:02 officers. So these people are judge, jury, and executioner, judicial, executive, legislative.
00:31:08 We have all of that power in the hands of sort of a huge Versailles, and that's what we have.
00:31:14 We have people who are evolutionaries.
00:31:16 They're so angry they have not been able to get the power they wanted that they're not satisfied with changing the demography of the country.
00:31:23 Two million a year will do it very quickly in certain states under our electoral college.
00:31:28 They flipped California.
00:31:30 They flipped Nevada, Colorado.
00:31:32 They may have flipped Georgia and Arizona, and that's because of demography.
00:31:37 But they want to change.
00:31:38 the electoral college of 232 years, abolish it. They want to bring in
00:31:43 two new states and abolish the 60-year-old idea of a 50-state union. They want to destroy
00:31:50 a 150-year tradition of a nine-person Supreme Court. They want to destroy a 180-year filibuster.
00:31:57 They want to destroy the constitutional precept that individual states create their own laws for
00:32:05 national election. And then finally, we have a lot of cosmopolitans, and I mean that in the ancient
00:32:10 literal sense of the word. They're globalists. They're formal allegiances to some quasi-Klaus
00:32:17 Schwab, Great Reset Davos idea. When Secretary Blinken, Secretary of State Blinken invites the
00:32:24 UN to come in and investigate whether we're culpable for racism, then he's really bordering
00:32:31 on the idea that we're all to be world citizens and subject this unique experiment in the United
00:32:36 States to what? The consensus of the United Nations Committee on Human Rights or something?
00:32:42 And that's quite dangerous, I think. And I think everybody, especially in the West,
00:32:47 should realize that every time there's been an attempt at world governance,
00:32:51 there's no mechanism, whether it's Hitler or Mussolini during the League of Nations
00:32:58 or during the UN during the Cold War. There's no mechanism to go after real bullies.
00:33:03 So as we talk about we're all going to have kumbaya at the international level,
00:33:08 then we just blink when China subverts the World Health Organization or in a reckless fashion has
00:33:14 a gain of engineering virus escapes because we're afraid of its power. And nobody wants to bell the
00:33:20 proverbial China cat. None of it we mice. We all know we need to do that. But when somebody says,
00:33:27 because who's going to put the bell around the Chinese cat so we know when it's coming
00:33:31 in terms of ESIP? No one will do it. You do, though, finally, Victor, offer some
00:33:39 possible ways out of this, don't you? Yes, I do. I don't end on a pessimistic note.
00:33:47 I try to suggest that for all of the power of institutional wokeness or anti-citizenship
00:33:54 movements we're talking about essentially a communication a cultural problem it's hollywood
00:34:03 it's professional sports it's academy it's k through 12 it's the corporations it's the pentagon
00:34:11 it's the media but it is not 51 of the american people all of these issues that you and i have
00:34:17 discussed do not even pull close to 50 approval whether it's open borders or the economic policies
00:34:23 or critical race theory, or the way we got out of Afghanistan. But the people, traditionalists,
00:34:29 and you can see that in your own country with Brexit, they're not in the habit of rocking the
00:34:34 boat. They don't. But if you push them far enough, they will start going to school board meetings
00:34:40 and say, we're not going to allow critical race racism, or they will start to manifest themselves
00:34:45 in registering to vote and get out. And that's happening. And I think we're going to have a huge
00:34:51 correction i think also that people think if you allow the cancel culture and the social media
00:34:59 media electronic guillotine to have full sway then they're going to devour it's a frankenstein
00:35:06 monster that's going to devour themselves so we're starting to see particular ethnic groups
00:35:11 mexican-american people who are not for this we're starting to see particular liberal academics
00:35:17 that said i have i'm afraid i'm being watched in class you're starting to see very wealthy
00:35:23 liberal parents who say i'm i'm woke but if you're only letting in 13 of your entering class in
00:35:32 harvard or stanford or princeton is white males and my son is a brilliant white male with perfect
00:35:37 credentials and it's very important to my sense of self that he goes to stanford or
00:35:42 and that's not happening to you then you're going to see privately at first defections from this
00:35:49 minority woke view these people have no ideology and i'll just finish with a cynical observation
00:35:54 that if you look at the architects miss quellers of blm the cultural march is on her fourth house
00:36:01 she's now bought she lives as a resident and essentially all white topanga canyon
00:36:06 And if you look at Professor Kendi, he's now charging $330 a minute in his $20,000 Zoom chats for penance for guilty corporate grandees.
00:36:18 And if you look at Todd Nahisi Coates, who was one of the early architects, he's writing comic books now and comic book scripts for Hollywood.
00:36:28 He's a multimillionaire.
00:36:29 So a cynic would say that this top-down, elite-driven woke revolution is really an attempt of corporate, government, academic elites that are trying to re, I don't know what we call it, reformulate the deck chairs on the corporate Lido deck.
00:36:50 That's what they're after.
00:36:51 It's about power.
00:36:53 They have no saleable agenda that the people want.
00:36:57 So we're a sleeping dragon and they've been poking it and poking it and poking it and they think it's toothless.
00:37:03 I think it's going to wake up.
00:37:06 I sincerely hope so, Vicka.
00:37:09 Look, your book again is out on the 4th of October, isn't it?
00:37:13 And yes, I think if anyone who wants to, you know, make sure that the dragon is prodded, then they should read it, I think.
00:37:24 Thank you very, very much for joining us.
00:37:26 thank you for having me and i hope it's not that long before we see you again thank you very much
00:37:30 victor same here thank you that's it for so what you're saying is so we shall see you next time
00:37:36 thank you very much