New Culture Forum - June 30, 2021


Yasmine Mohammed - How Western Liberals Empower Radical Islam

What Do We Think Of GB News? Reviewing Britain's Newest News Channel My Favourite Books...with Michael Collins

Episode Stats


Length

59 minutes

Words per minute

142.18

Word count

8,495

Sentence count

263


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00 hello and welcome to so what you're saying is I'm Peter Whittle now I know I
00:00:28 say this every week but it's because it's important please do subscribe won't you to the
00:00:34 channel it's very easy you just go to the subscribe button and press that next door there is a bell
00:00:40 if you press that that means you will get notifications of all of our programs as they
00:00:46 come up so i hope you do subscribe now my guest today has been called by the writer iyan hershey
00:00:54 Ali, one of the bravest people of our time. Yasmin Mohammed is a former Muslim. She is
00:01:02 now an activist and writer. She's been very critical of Islam. She's the author of a book
00:01:09 called Unveiled, How Western Liberals Empower Radical Islam. And she's also the founder
00:01:16 of an organization which fights for women's rights called Free Hearts, Free Minds.
00:01:24 Thank you very much for joining us today, Yasmin.
00:01:29 My absolute pleasure. Thank you for having me, Peter.
00:01:32 You have been quite remarkably outspoken for a number of years now.
00:01:41 When I say that, it's not that you are being unreasonably outspoken.
00:01:46 and you just have exercised your free speech.
00:01:50 I wonder if I could start by asking you about something,
00:01:53 because this is something, sort of an issue that you have remarked on many times before.
00:01:57 In Britain at the moment, we have a situation.
00:02:01 We have a school in Yorkshire, Batley Grammar School,
00:02:04 where a teacher showed a cartoon of Mohammed to his pupils.
00:02:11 As a result, the school pretty much seems to have disowned him.
00:02:15 he's gone into hiding and and you know frankly in danger um that's a sort of situation which is
00:02:24 becoming all too common is it not yes absolutely it's it's really sad to see
00:02:32 when a country like britain gets it so unbelievably wrong in a situation like this
00:02:39 We have to be really careful to respond in a way that lets people who want to enact blasphemy laws or people who want to stand in the way of free speech or free expression, we have to react in a way that lets them know that that's not possible in the West, that we have already fought these fights.
00:03:08 we have already won these fights we have already agreed we are already of the mindset that freedom
00:03:16 of expression is paramount and we are not going to go backwards on these issues um of course when
00:03:25 it happened after charlie hebdo you had all sorts of responses where people said things like oh well
00:03:32 they shouldn't have printed those cartoons with you know the teacher samuel petty getting beheaded
00:03:38 in the middle of the street on his way walking home to his wife and children you had outlets
00:03:44 you know like the new york times saying things like oh the police kill a man yes in france
00:03:57 the headline is referring to the jihadi to the murderer as opposed to the the teacher
00:04:04 um the victim in in this situation so there's there's a very
00:04:10 not only is it disheartening it's terrifying to see the west getting these issues wrong
00:04:19 i mean there are the countries exist countries like pakistan and saudi arabia and bangladesh
00:04:25 In all of these countries, we know what happens to people who try to free their minds in any way, anybody that expresses themselves in any way other than what is deemed appropriate by the state.
00:04:42 We see what happens to those people in those countries, and it's really terrifying to see that in the West, it's not a safe place for people to have free discussions, because the same people that will murder them or that will terrorize them in countries run by Sharia are the same people, the same groups of people,
00:05:10 that will control free Western democracies.
00:05:15 And that's very, very terrifying.
00:05:18 What should the reaction, therefore, be to the situation, say, in Batley?
00:05:23 I mean, I know you talked about what they should do after Charlie Hebdo.
00:05:27 What should the West, what should the British government be doing?
00:05:31 We should 100% support this teacher.
00:05:34 What I really liked was in one area of France in Montpellier after the tragedy with Samuel Petit, who was another teacher, similar situation to the teacher in Batley Grammar School, and that he was having a discussion with his class.
00:05:53 And in the discussion, he showed a caricature of Muhammad.
00:05:58 What they did after that was they took those caricatures and they basically had them on buildings all around Montpellier.
00:06:14 Big, huge screens were showing these pictures, you know, 10-foot screens.
00:06:22 screens that was a great response because it was a response that did that showed power and that
00:06:30 showed that you were resolute in your values but you are not being aggressive you are not being
00:06:38 violent you are not responding in kind but you are saying these are our values this is what we
00:06:44 believe you will not stop us you will not force us to abide by your rules
00:06:51 I think it's pretty much inconceivable that something like that would happen in Britain
00:06:58 actually the idea you know that these things would be displayed even to reproduce the Charlie Hebdo
00:07:06 cartoons was seen as an act of extraordinary bravery on the part of you know certain people
00:07:12 in the uh in the media here um you mentioned the teacher there samuel pete who was decapitated
00:07:20 are you surprised or not surprised jasmine by you know the fact that we barely seem to hear
00:07:28 about it now i mean you know there's been almost no real ongoing trauma about this
00:07:37 and yet we've had extraordinary trauma with george floyd
00:07:42 Yes, absolutely. This is something, unfortunately, the media really chooses what it wants to focus on and what it wants us to forget or not even know about. It's, you know, it's deliberate.
00:07:58 and it's the same sort of thing that you see happen all the time where you know women in
00:08:05 muslim majority countries are suffering daily from you know they can't even choose what clothing
00:08:13 they want to wear without being imprisoned but you don't hear about those kinds of situations
00:08:19 you don't hear about the fact that marital rape is still legal in most muslim majority countries
00:08:25 um you know there are there are women's groups that will choose to focus on let's say trans
00:08:35 women in sports or something like that something that affects you know 0.001 percent of the
00:08:40 population but then you have you know like almost 90 percent of women in egypt are subjected to
00:08:48 female genital mutilation but women's groups don't want to talk about that and in the same vein if
00:08:54 we look at lgbt groups you know they will be very keen to put rainbow flags all over the packaging
00:09:02 of all sorts of you know chocolate bars and ice cream and cereal and everything else but will they
00:09:07 raise their voice just to to speak about the fact that 15 muslim majority countries will execute you
00:09:14 for being gay that doesn't come up and unfortunately that kind of situation happens
00:09:19 You know, it happened in the UK, too, recently, where you had a curriculum called No Outsiders that was encouraging British children, whether they be straight or gay or Muslim or Christian or, you know, black, white.
00:09:37 It doesn't matter.
00:09:38 There are no outsiders.
00:09:39 We are all British.
00:09:41 And it was a, you know, it's a beautiful lesson to teach children.
00:09:46 but instead you had hundreds and hundreds of parents, Muslim parents, out in front of the
00:09:53 schools chanting being gay is not okay and pelting parents with eggs if those parents were trying to
00:10:01 post rainbow flags or any kind of support for gay kids in the school. You kind of find yourself
00:10:09 at a crossroads where you know who who are you going to support or what are you where when will
00:10:16 you stand up for your values you know you can't just continue to um ignore the things that you
00:10:24 want to ignore like you know the anti-semitism for example the way it's been rising so much
00:10:30 in europe and we we don't want to talk about it because the anti-semitism is coming from islamists
00:10:36 So it's like you constantly find yourself at this crossroads where you have to, the West needs to figure out, are we going to have values that we are going to proudly, you know, defend?
00:10:55 or are we going to capitulate to people who might respond with violence and so we fear that
00:11:08 and so we're going to continue to allow them to bully us and to submission i mean there needs to
00:11:13 be i believe um there needs to be a response to that and the media is not helping with the way
00:11:20 that they're constantly couching things in a narrative
00:11:26 that always portrays a Muslim person as a victim,
00:11:33 even if they are a jihadi.
00:11:39 Yes, it is quite extraordinary.
00:11:41 You mentioned there about the lack of protest
00:11:46 about you know female genital mutilation and or the lack of emphasis on it or in the lgbt case you
00:11:55 know the lgbt lobby in britain i'm sure it's the same in america you know very very strong going
00:12:01 on after russia maybe but you almost never hear them talking about these countries ever um i
00:12:08 wonder what you thought therefore of like something like the me too movement which got enormous
00:12:13 enormous purchase didn't it in the media this is sort of like a kind of not exactly a displacement
00:12:22 activity but it's sort of it's about well dare I say it sort of basically privileged women
00:12:28 you know in Hollywood maybe this is the point yes you're absolutely correct and you mentioned
00:12:35 Dayan Hirsi Ali who is my personal hero she wrote a book recently called Prey which basically talks
00:12:43 about how the me too movement was very very big and um for exactly how you what you just described
00:12:51 for privileged women in hollywood it was very helpful for them but when it started to you know
00:12:58 when we start looking at women less um privileged women in other parts of america or in other parts
00:13:07 of europe there is not nearly that kind of support for those women in fact the opposite is true so
00:13:17 again if we talk about all of the rape gangs in the uk the reason why those women were ignored
00:13:24 for so long um was because they were on they were not privileged women that was part of it and the
00:13:32 other part of it of course is because most of the perpetrators were were pakistani muslim
00:13:37 so these women were were thrown to the wolves essentially they were ignored by the system
00:13:44 there were politicians there were journalists there were all sorts of people who tried to blow
00:13:48 the whistle on the situation but they were called islamophobes they were called racists and so these
00:13:54 women were you know they did not get to be valued the way other women were the the hashtag me too
00:14:02 movement did nothing for them they were they were ignored and so that's a sad reality i mean i think
00:14:08 that they yes exactly ignored i mean i think maybe one of the problems with this is that as you say
00:14:14 the idea of muslim people as being victims but also it's sort of like this fear of being called
00:14:19 a racist uh which of course is actually nothing to do as you've pointed out you're talking about
00:14:24 a religion you're not talking about a race are you no you're absolutely not and it's important
00:14:30 to note too that within that religion there are people who are political muslims so they are
00:14:39 called islamists so it's not just in an in an immutable characteristic or or somebody's faith
00:14:48 this is a political decision this is like saying this person is you know a communist or whatever
00:14:55 Like, this is a political affiliation, an Islamist is somebody who is really trying to spread Islam in a nefarious way.
00:15:07 So when you, when, so I will give you a good example.
00:15:12 There is a book written by Majid Nawaz, who he is from London.
00:15:17 His book is called Radical.
00:15:19 And he was part of Hezbollah Tahrir, which are an Islamist group.
00:15:23 And he describes, you know, in explicit detail how when he was an Islamist, he used all of these supports for Muslims or this narrative of Muslims being victims or this attack of anybody who says anything about Muslims, attacking them as racists or bigots.
00:15:45 They used all of that as a means of protecting themselves so that they could do their nefarious work quietly without being, you know, subjected to authorities paying attention to what they were doing.
00:16:04 He tells a story of how they even had pictures of a woman in Naqab carrying a machine gun, and they were posting those pictures up around the university, and when the dean of his department or somebody called him into their office and said,
00:16:26 look, you can't be putting these pictures up. This is violent. This is pushing a political
00:16:32 agenda. He accused the school administration of being racist. And so they backed off. And they
00:16:42 said, okay, sorry, sorry. Keep those up. Keep those things up. And they were allowed to roam
00:16:48 free in his university until somebody was killed in the quad, in the middle of their university
00:16:56 somebody ended up being stabbed to death and so then the university finally said okay okay
00:17:02 enough we can't allow these Islamists to continue to um to run free yes and that's kind of what you
00:17:10 see happening in France as well there's this constant no no no it's not happening it's okay
00:17:16 just ignore it until things get worse and worse and worse and worse and worse France is only
00:17:21 reacting now after rivers of blood? How many hundreds of people have been killed in France
00:17:27 in the past decade due to jihadis? Innocent people going to a theater. Same thing happening
00:17:35 for you in the UK. You had the Ariana Grande concert. You have all sorts of attacks on the
00:17:41 different bridges across your country. These are continually ignored, ignored until things get so
00:17:50 bad that people will finally be forced to react and you know that's not the best case scenario
00:17:57 that can be very ugly if you let things fester for that long yes i mean on that point actually
00:18:04 before i ask you a bit about yourself uh you know how does islam and criticism of islam fit into the
00:18:14 current woke onslaught i know you've been talking about it for you've been talking about islam for
00:18:19 long time but but i mean what we i'm basically talking about the last year black lives matter
00:18:26 the woke agenda all these things have come to the fore where does islam sit in that
00:18:31 well it's anti-west so they they are you know standing hand in hand in their in their both
00:18:39 have hate for the west and for western values and for you know liberal values and democratic values
00:18:47 so they support each other in that way and unfortunately we've seen these alliances
00:18:52 happen before we've seen it happen in iraq we've seen it happen in iran we've seen it happen in
00:18:57 syria and it always turns out very badly for the far left they you know they're obviously just um
00:19:05 you know the enemy of my enemy is my friend they are short-term um buddies or allies for the time
00:19:12 being. But, you know, Islamists, of course, disagree with anybody on the left. You know,
00:19:19 Islamism is a very, very, it's a fascist ideology. I'm going to plug a third book for you
00:19:27 called Islamofascism, written by Hamid Abda Samad, who is an Egyptian-German,
00:19:34 and where he talks about that, just the parallels, just to let people see that there is
00:19:42 fascism within this ideology of political Islam, because people just tend to see it as
00:19:49 an Eastern religion like Buddhism or Hinduism or something like that. They see it as something
00:19:56 exotic and kind, and they're unwilling to see, to recognize, to acknowledge what these Muslim
00:20:07 majority countries look like, what people living under Sharia, how they are living,
00:20:12 especially women, how are they surviving? So for them to think that it's just a docile,
00:20:21 benign religion or benign ideology that we shouldn't be concerned about, it's a choice
00:20:31 to be that ignorant it's yeah i think that what what happens here um is a if example if there is
00:20:39 a terrorist attack um it will be you can almost set your your watch by it there within about a day
00:20:48 uh the prime minister or a major figure will say this is a a perversion of islam and then also
00:20:56 islam is a religion of peace um and and and we must not therefore start uh towing everyone with
00:21:02 the same brush all of these things um but the point is people have kind of got slightly wise
00:21:08 to this you know now but it doesn't change anything but these are the responses we have
00:21:15 yes it's very orwellian to me it's very you know slavery is freedom war is peace yes um i understand
00:21:23 why they would want to say that. I understand that they do not want people to be bigoted
00:21:32 towards your average Muslim woman in a hijab riding the tube or something like that. I
00:21:39 understand that. But to pretend that it is a religion of peace or to pretend, I mean,
00:21:47 we all know we don't it's it's almost insulting to try to convince people that you know that islam
00:21:56 is not at the root cause of the islamic state of iraq and syria you know of of al-qaeda of boko
00:22:07 haram of you know hundreds and hundreds and hundreds of of islamist you know islamic terrorist
00:22:15 organizations we understand that there is a connection between the two and continually
00:22:21 trying to tell us that there isn't is going to make people untrusting of whoever it is that's
00:22:30 trying to tell them that and it's going to make them even more nervous of muslims because they're
00:22:36 feeling like hang on a minute why are you trying to pull the wool over my eyes you know so there
00:22:42 should be an honest discussion there needs to be an honest conversation and that's not happening
00:22:49 unfortunately they keep on going to this binary of all or nothing and i mean you see it quite often
00:22:55 with the woke right all white people are racist like there's there's a very um absoluteness with
00:23:04 with their the way they speak which is so incredibly childish it's it's it's disney-esque
00:23:10 with this binary of you know good guys wear white hats and black and bad guys
00:23:15 wear black hats it's it's not like that Islam is a religion and Muslims are
00:23:22 within a spectrum and that spectrum can be anywhere from somebody like Majid
00:23:27 Namaz author of radical that I mentioned all the way to Osama bin Laden or you
00:23:35 know, the Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi leader of ISIS. So we have to have a conversation that includes
00:23:45 that nuance. Because those people that, like, how many people were responsible for what happened
00:23:52 to Samuel Petit? It turns out there was like over 50 people responsible. There were parents,
00:23:57 there were kids, there were imams from the mosques, there were all sorts of, you know,
00:24:02 a Muslim organization spreading Samuel Petit's picture
00:24:05 and his address on social media.
00:24:08 This was a, you know, it was not as they always like
00:24:12 to placate the public by saying, oh, it was a lone wolf.
00:24:17 Oh, it was just another lone wolf.
00:24:19 Oh, look, another lone wolf.
00:24:21 You know, they just happen to keep on having
00:24:23 a bunch of lone wolves, you know,
00:24:26 because they want people to feel.
00:24:28 You know, sorry, the other one we have here a lot
00:24:30 is uh mental health problems yes yes yeah and it's it's it's insulting it's insulting to the
00:24:39 to the citizens and people deserve to be treated with respect and um the conversation needs to
00:24:48 happen where people do express that there are of course many most human beings are good people
00:24:58 right within any ideology or within any race or with any religion or within whatever we
00:25:06 most human beings are good people but we cannot pretend that there is not a group of people that
00:25:18 are inspired by their ideology to pick up a knife and stab people or to cover themselves in a
00:25:26 suicide vest and go kill infidels these things happen all the time because there is a root cause
00:25:33 for it and that discussion needs to happen most first and foremost it needs to happen within the
00:25:39 muslim community themselves and i do see that happening sometimes so if there was one imam in
00:25:46 france who was trying to speak up when the samuel petit tragedy happened and of course he's now in
00:25:55 hiding, similar to the Batley Grammar School teacher. And his life was also, they threatened
00:26:01 his life and his family's life. But he was still speaking up. As a Muslim imam, it means a lot for
00:26:08 him to speak up. And there, you know, there are a lot of Muslims who are trying to fight this
00:26:17 violent ideology within their own camp but they unfortunately are not being supported by the wider
00:26:26 society the wider society is instead calling them native informants uncle toms you know all sorts of
00:26:36 slurs and we want to stick to the binary of no no no no all muslims are good people islam is a
00:26:45 religion of peace. Don't listen to these Muslims who are trying to speak out against the violence
00:26:51 in their camp. I'm trying to remember the name of a man in London who just recently wrote a book
00:26:59 where he went around to a whole bunch of different mosques all around the UK, and he was exposing
00:27:09 what that was happening in those mosques what children were being taught what people were
00:27:15 being taught when they went for their friday prayers during the sermon during the chukba
00:27:19 i'm sorry i can't remember his name but he is a co-founder of an organization called quilliam
00:27:24 which is a counter-terrorism group yes yes yeah so he he's a muslim again speaking up
00:27:30 he is saying these things are true stop saying it's a religion of peace stop saying it's racist
00:27:36 to speak out against these violent Islamists.
00:27:40 This is a problem.
00:27:41 We need to address this problem.
00:27:43 We need to teach our children differently.
00:27:45 We need to stop thinking that anti-Semitism is okay
00:27:48 because we're trying to free Palestine.
00:27:51 These are conversations that need to happen
00:27:53 within the Muslim community,
00:27:55 and this is why the subtitle of my book
00:27:57 is How Western Liberals Empower Radical Islam,
00:28:00 is because the Western liberals think
00:28:02 that they're doing a good deed
00:28:03 by shutting down this conversation, by shutting down this criticism that is so dire.
00:28:12 This criticism needs to be voiced. It needs to be voiced.
00:28:16 We need to listen to the voices within the community that are speaking up,
00:28:20 and we need to support them.
00:28:22 We should not be shutting them down and continuing to support the conservative Muslims
00:28:28 or the fundamentalist Muslims instead.
00:28:30 has your own life been uh under threat that's been as a result of what you say and what your
00:28:41 activism yeah so as i describe in my book i didn't you know initially when i started to do
00:28:51 to write my book i was anonymous and i wanted to stay that way because
00:28:58 the man that I was forced into a marriage with is a terrorist. He's currently in prison in Egypt,
00:29:04 but he's a member of Al-Qaeda. So I didn't know where his friends were or if his friends would
00:29:11 be able to get to me or to get to my daughter. We had a daughter together. So I was very scared
00:29:18 to speak out. And I knew that if I came out publicly, that it would be a risk.
00:29:27 and it was a it was a risk I was willing to take because there are there are countless
00:29:35 countless people living in Muslim majority countries who would love to be as vocal as I
00:29:40 am right now but they simply cannot they have so many more restrictions on them they would
00:29:46 you know I'm living in a free country and so I'm privileged to be able to
00:29:54 be sitting here with you right now and being able to have this conversation with you
00:29:59 um you know in bangladesh people get hacked to death in the streets with machetes in saudi
00:30:06 arabia you get lashed you know with whips by the the government um in pakistan you could get beaten
00:30:13 to death etc etc etc so i feel like um sorry it's okay
00:30:23 I feel like despite the, despite the risks, I'm compelled to do this work.
00:30:32 Can I ask you a bit about, you know, your own background has been quite extraordinary.
00:30:40 And obviously, as I said at the beginning, you are an ex-Muslim, which, of course, in scriptural terms, puts you in a bit of a difficult position before anything else.
00:30:51 um but can you tell us a bit about your family you know you mentioned earlier a big spectrum
00:30:58 you know going from one side right to ice to another where did your family sit on that
00:31:04 spectrum i mean was it a very strict upbringing or or or a relatively liberal one no it was not
00:31:10 liberal at all it was it was a very strict upbringing um but because it was all i knew
00:31:16 i didn't realize it was such a strict upbringing well i let me i'll explain so um my parents
00:31:26 divorced when i was about five or six years old and my they had been living in san francisco and
00:31:34 they had recently moved to canada and so my mom found herself with three children
00:31:41 in a new country and she went looking for support she went looking for community
00:31:46 and unfortunately she went to the local mosque and she is egyptian and she found another egyptian man
00:31:54 there who was already married already had three children but offered to take her on as his second
00:32:00 wife so technically in canada polygamy is illegal but they turn a blind eye um so
00:32:08 So she became his second concurrent wife and he started to demand all of the changes to
00:32:21 our lives.
00:32:22 First of all, my mom started wearing this gray cloth on her head.
00:32:31 He broke all of her records.
00:32:33 She used to have these records of Dolly Parton and Kenny Rogers.
00:32:37 broke them all because music is haram music is forbidden he didn't allow me to play with the
00:32:43 neighbor's children anymore because interacting with non-muslims is haram is forbidden um i was
00:32:52 no longer allowed to ride my bike i was no longer allowed to go swimming i was suddenly forced to
00:32:59 read this you know strange language I had to start reading the Quran and I even though I knew
00:33:08 Arabic it's a you know a classical Arabic and it was it was very odd to me and it was a completely
00:33:17 different language not that I could barely speak or read or write English yet at that point anyway
00:33:22 I was so young. And I had to pray five times a day. And my siblings and I would be punished harshly
00:33:32 if we didn't memorize the Quran or if we missed any of our prayers. So, you know, Islam did not,
00:33:39 it was not a positive thing coming into my life by any means. It was very scary. It was very
00:33:48 violent. It was very negative. And I fought against it for a long time. But by the time
00:33:57 I was nine years old, I was put into an Islamic school. I was put into hijab myself. And then
00:34:04 you're a child and you just eventually stop fighting. You know, there's, you're not going
00:34:08 to, you're not going to win this one. And so even though internally I was unhappy and I wished for
00:34:17 my life before this man entered it, I was too scared to rebel. I was too scared of him because
00:34:26 he was very violent. And I was too scared of Allah. I was too scared of burning in hell for
00:34:33 eternity. And so, you know, that was my life. My mother was the head of the Islamic studies
00:34:43 department at the Islamic school. So she was a, you know, a pillar of the community when it came
00:34:48 to, you know, who to look for as an Islamic resource, because she was a student of Al-Azhar
00:34:54 University, which is, you know, the most prestigious Islamic university. And so we lived this life.
00:35:05 And when I ended up getting forced into a marriage, it wasn't a surprise by any means
00:35:13 The year prior, they had forced me, tried to force me to a marriage with my second cousin, and I got out of that, and so, you know, it was almost like, at least this time, they're forcing me to marry somebody who isn't my cousin, you know?
00:35:31 and so you know he barely spoke English he was 15 years older than me I didn't know anything
00:35:41 about him he was chosen by them and my mom told me that he was somebody who would be
00:35:47 strong enough to control me she felt like I needed someone strong enough to control me
00:35:53 because even though I was too scared to rebel,
00:36:00 she still considered me the black sheep of the family.
00:36:05 And she would tell me that I was the black sheep of the family
00:36:08 because I was constantly questioning things.
00:36:11 Things made me uncomfortable.
00:36:13 Things weren't logical.
00:36:16 And so just the fact that I was questioning things
00:36:21 made me the black sheep yeah did when did you then make the break yes i mean with this on when
00:36:33 did you when did you discard it i mean it's huge step if you're if you if you're told that you
00:36:39 you know it's not just a case of being excommunicated you could be killed
00:36:44 absolutely yes and and you you're told that you know that you understand that that's the risk
00:36:50 that you're taking. For me, it was actually having my daughter. So once I had my daughter
00:36:58 and I was holding her in my arms, she was barely a week old. And, you know, her dad came
00:37:05 up from behind me and he looked down at her and he said, when are we going to get her fixed?
00:37:13 I said, what do you mean? He said, when are we going to get her cleaned?
00:37:17 And I was like, well, I just gave her a bath.
00:37:20 I don't understand.
00:37:22 And then my mom pipes up and she says, oh, no, no, no, no.
00:37:27 We'll do that later when she's five or six years old.
00:37:29 We'll take her to Egypt and we'll get it done.
00:37:32 And that's when I understood that they were talking about FGM.
00:37:38 So when you are a parent, you will, you know, especially a brand new parent,
00:37:44 You're filled with this overwhelming desire to protect your baby.
00:37:51 And it was at that moment when I decided, you know, there was nothing that was going
00:38:01 to stop me from protecting my daughter from being mutilated by these people.
00:38:07 And in my mind, I thought to myself, well, I have a window of about five or six years
00:38:13 to get myself together and to get her out of here before that happens now i had a high school
00:38:20 education and this these were the days before you know social media so i'd lost contact that's
00:38:26 that's what an abusive man does or in an abusive relationship that's what they do
00:38:32 first step is to separate you from anybody who could support you
00:38:37 so i had no connection to any of my friends anymore and so i was alone in the world
00:38:43 with a high school education and a daughter so it was a it was a daunting thing for me to consider
00:38:49 how was i going to escape with her especially without the support of my my mom i knew for sure
00:38:56 that i would never get her support because being divorced as a muslim woman
00:38:59 is a shame on the honor of the family and so i hesitated i didn't move quickly enough
00:39:10 and i ended up getting pregnant a second time and when i got pregnant the second time i
00:39:21 i lost it because i felt i was so angry at myself for not getting out when i had the chance and i
00:39:28 thought well now i have two kids so that's it i'm just gonna have to go to the shower like he wants
00:39:36 which is, you know, he wanted to be a jihadi in northern Pakistan, and he wanted to have a whole
00:39:42 bunch of kids there that were going to be jihadis as well. And I was, you know, I submitted,
00:39:50 which is the definition of the word Islam. I submitted at that point, and I said, well,
00:39:54 that's it. I give up. There's no way I'm going to be able to survive with two kids.
00:39:58 I missed my window of opportunity. And then I went to have an ultrasound and it turns out that
00:40:09 the baby didn't have a heartbeat. And so now here I am, of course, first and foremost,
00:40:17 I'm drowning in guilt because I feel like I killed my baby by not wanting it. And by thinking that
00:40:25 this baby was the key in the lock and that was, you know, the nail in the coffin for my life. So
00:40:31 I thought that was my fault. I was the reason why the baby didn't have a heartbeat. But at the same
00:40:37 time, I felt like this is my chance to save my living child. And so when the nurse turned to me
00:40:47 and said, we're going to do the DNC surgery and you're going to go under general anesthetic
00:40:53 and then you're going to need somebody to drive you home. Obviously, she didn't realize that
00:40:59 I didn't drive. I wore naqab at this time, so everything was covered, even gloves.
00:41:06 And you're going to need someone to help you with your little daughter
00:41:09 for the next 24 hours or so because you might be groggy. Well, I just
00:41:14 saw that as my new window and I told him the nurse says I'm going to need a week to recover
00:41:23 I'm going to go need to stay with my mom for a week otherwise you're going to have to help me
00:41:27 with the baby for a week and I knew he would never agree to that and so he said yeah sure
00:41:32 you can go stay with your mom for a week and I was thinking that it would be much easier to get
00:41:38 away from my mom than it was to get away from him and so that's why I wanted to do this
00:41:42 and you know miracle miracles is completely by the skin of my teeth this was it was complete chance
00:41:50 and um i went to my mom's apartment and the next day she got up to go to school because like i
00:42:00 mentioned she was uh you know at the islamic studies or sorry at the islamic school
00:42:04 and i flipped through the yellow pages and i found a lawyer who would be willing to
00:42:13 um give me a divorce a restraining order and full custody of my daughter and i needed all three
00:42:23 things and i had no money but they were willing to this i had to find a lawyer that was willing to
00:42:32 give me a half an hour consultation for free. And so when I went, walked into the lawyer's
00:42:39 office, covered head to toe in black, carrying a nine month old baby with me,
00:42:46 she immediately took care of everything. She immediately gave me, you know, did up all the
00:42:56 paperwork. And I told her, you can't phone me. Again, these are the days before cell phones.
00:43:00 so the only phone number was my mom's and there was no way that i wanted her to to call the
00:43:06 apartment to have my mom pick up the phone so i said you cannot contact me um but these are
00:43:12 the things that i need this is the information that i have and and that was it and then i went
00:43:18 back quickly before my mom got home from school and after a few days we hear he comes to the
00:43:28 the apartment and he's screaming in Arabic, give me back my wife. And I was petrified that somebody
00:43:42 was going to let him into the building. But, you know, he's a six foot four Egyptian man screaming
00:43:48 in Arabic. People knew better. So they didn't let him into the building. And I called 9-1-1,
00:43:54 of course and they were aware they said yes we've you know officers are on their way
00:44:03 and that's when i discovered that he had been served with the divorce papers and they explained
00:44:09 to me that a restraining order only means that they can restrict him from coming i think it was
00:44:14 like 150 meters or something to my mom's apartment but that's it since i didn't go to school i didn't
00:44:20 I didn't go to work. I didn't do anything else. They couldn't stop him from going to any other
00:44:24 buildings. And they explained to me that, you know, if I were to go to the park with my daughter,
00:44:30 if I were to go to the mall or food shopping, there was nothing that they could, they can't
00:44:35 restrict him from, you know, they can't protect me if he happens to find me in those places.
00:44:41 And so I put myself under house arrest and I stayed there until I was contacted by the Canadian intelligence CSIS, who came and showed me a picture of him behind bars in Egypt and basically told me, you're you're you're free to leave the house now.
00:45:03 you're um uh he's behind bars and so first thing i did was start applying to university and i got
00:45:12 student loans and me and my daughter got out of my mom's house and we started our lives all over
00:45:19 again and when i was in university i took a course called history of religions um simply because i
00:45:26 knew one third of the curriculum and so i thought well i'm going to ace the islamic part so i'll
00:45:32 take this course. And in that course was the very first time that I was able to critically
00:45:38 analyze this. I was allowed to question it. I was allowed to criticize it. And I'd never been
00:45:49 allowed to do that before. And I was so starving for that. I've been wanting to do that for so long.
00:45:55 And so while that was happening, simultaneously, 9-11 happened.
00:46:02 And so I was bombarded both emotionally and intellectually.
00:46:07 And so by the time that year was up, I no longer identified as a Muslim.
00:46:12 It was, I was absolutely, you know, 9-11 brought out the worst in the Muslim community.
00:46:23 not only my Muslim community, but all over the Muslim majority world, because it gave them this
00:46:30 sense of such a morale boost. And they were handing out candies and singing in the street
00:46:39 and very proud and happy at the fact that all of these thousands of innocent people had just died.
00:46:47 And so I was so disgusted at that and horrified that I identified as the same group as the people that were acting like this,
00:46:57 that that pushed me very quickly out of wanting to identify as a Muslim.
00:47:07 So after that, really, is it right to say that you almost became an activist, not exactly by accident,
00:47:17 but it wasn't something you were planning to do.
00:47:20 I mean, I know that with the book, which came out, I think, two years ago now,
00:47:24 the book Unveiled, which you can presumably get on Amazon.
00:47:28 Correct.
00:47:29 Amazon, definitely.
00:47:31 Obviously, which is very much like a memoir, too.
00:47:35 I remember you said that there was an incident some years on.
00:47:38 It was just a TV incident, which I saw, actually.
00:47:43 because I saw it actually I think live it was a Bill Marsha and this is I wonder whether you
00:47:49 could just tell us that I know you've told the story before but this is what really thought
00:47:53 right I've got to put this I've got to write something yeah so that was many many years on
00:48:00 so my daughter was all grown up I'm remarried I have a new daughter I've never spoken a word of
00:48:06 anything to anybody. I've kept it all to myself. I hadn't even really expressed everything that
00:48:13 had happened to me in therapy. You know, like it was just completely just moving forward with my
00:48:20 life. And this episode of Bill Maher that you described, so Sam Harris was the guest and Sam
00:48:28 and Bill were lamenting the fact that liberals are not standing up for liberal values when it's
00:48:36 coming from the Islamic context. And the example that they brought up was that 87% of people in
00:48:43 Egypt believe that anyone who denounces the religion of Islam should be executed.
00:48:51 Now, that's what the religion teaches anyway. So that number was not surprising to me.
00:48:56 And but what was surprising to me was that there were these two American men on television talking about it as if we mattered, as if my life was important, as if this was an atrocity worth criticizing, because up until that moment, I didn't think of it that way.
00:49:21 i just thought of like well we don't matter anyway we are we
00:49:24 we are people who leave islam are considered traitors rats you know just this
00:49:34 they're described in the quran over and over again as um the worst of humanity like non-believers
00:49:44 the worst of humanity etc etc so you kind of internalize those feelings and that self-hate
00:49:52 without even realizing that you're doing it and so when sam and bill started to talk about us as
00:49:59 if we matter and it felt very personal because i my family is egyptian and i left islam so it felt
00:50:06 like they were talking about me. And of course, Ben Affleck at that point piped up and started
00:50:16 to call them gross and racist, and he shut down the conversation. And he really was the epitome
00:50:24 of the Western liberal empowering radical Islam, because here are these men trying to speak up
00:50:29 against radical aspects of the religion, violent aspects of the religion, illiberal aspects of
00:50:36 the religion and here he was the white knight coming to the savior to muslim people by saying
00:50:42 no no no no you know you shouldn't be talking about that so essentially what he was saying
00:50:48 was ignore people like yasmin she doesn't matter and the next day on facebook you know in my
00:50:58 personal facebook i didn't have i did had no public anything it was just you know meet my
00:51:03 friends, they were, the videos, you know, clips of this episode were all over the place. And
00:51:09 everybody was just so proud complimenting Ben Affleck for shutting down these two gross and
00:51:16 racist men. And I just felt like I was in the twilight zone. I was like, what, what is wrong?
00:51:25 How are you people, my friends? How are you people I've known for 15, 20 years, people that I've
00:51:29 worked with people that I've gone to school with how could you get this so wrong and that's when I
00:51:36 realized that it was my fault because I'd never said anything about it I had never even told them
00:51:43 anything about my life and so I thought well you know what I'm going to have to set the record
00:51:49 straight and that's when I started to write my book and I really did want to just put my book
00:51:54 out there, but not have my self out there, not have my face out there, not have my voice out
00:52:00 there. But I just wanted my story out there, of course, because I was afraid for my life.
00:52:07 But yeah, that's how it happened. And no, I definitely did not set out to be an activist
00:52:13 at all. It was something that I just felt compelled to do because I was inundated with
00:52:19 messages. As soon as I started posting chapters of my book on Tumblr, I was getting inundated
00:52:24 with messages from people all over the world specifically from women all over the world um
00:52:32 telling me their stories
00:52:36 telling me how they relate to my story um asking me for support asking me to
00:52:46 to up to to get the world to notice their fight yeah um from something
00:52:52 you know all across the spectrum from women being forced into marriages to women being uh you know
00:53:01 forced to wear hijab from you know from women their families finding out that they're not
00:53:08 muslim anymore and um giving them three days to repent before they have them killed you know just
00:53:16 all sorts of messages all the time and I had no choice but to speak out because if they try to
00:53:29 well they simply can't they're not in the situation where they can at all I was in a
00:53:35 situation where it would be dangerous for me but at least it was an option for me
00:53:40 it's not an option for them well I mean it's an extraordinary brave unbelievable story
00:53:48 I mean I just really wanted to to finish by asking you a question which I think that
00:53:57 Ayaan Hershey Ali has actually talked about do you think that there is the chance for
00:54:02 or reformation in Islam, or even if that's the right word, actually?
00:54:11 Because reformation tends to be going back to basics, actually.
00:54:15 Maybe I don't mean that. Maybe I don't mean reformation.
00:54:18 An enlightenment, maybe.
00:54:21 Yeah. I don't think that the religion itself will ever change
00:54:27 because Muslims view the Qur'an as the literal word of Allah.
00:54:31 It's not like the Bible in that it is, you know, metaphorical or that these are stories.
00:54:36 This is the literal word of Allah.
00:54:38 So when he says, if you fear arrogance or disobedience from your wife, beat her, then he means beat her.
00:54:46 He doesn't mean anything else.
00:54:47 And so there will always be a percentage of Muslims who will follow the Quran literally.
00:55:01 But I do believe that if there is secularism in the Muslim-majority world, if there is a separation of mosque and state, so right now Sharia is in the laws of all of these 50 Muslim-majority countries.
00:55:20 They're not absolute sharia like Iran and Saudi Arabia, but, you know, even countries like, I was just reading about Egypt this morning, marital rape cannot be criminalized there.
00:55:32 They're unable to make it illegal because people keep, the religious scholars keep referring to the religion and saying it's a man's right to take his wife whenever he wants to.
00:55:45 So humans cannot make illegal what Allah has made legal.
00:55:49 So as long as the laws have 1,400-year-old edicts in them, then those societies will never progress.
00:56:02 They will always be like a rubber band pulled back into ancient times again.
00:56:08 So I think that if there is a separation of mosque and state, if the laws of the country, the education of the country, the government of the country can be secular, and if people aren't forced to abide by sharia, then I really do believe that most people will choose freedom.
00:56:32 Because I lived in Egypt for three years. I lived in Qatar for eight years. I've been, of course, you know, surrounded by Muslim people my whole life. And people are just people, you know, and especially when you think of women. Women are just, they all want to be free. They all want their autonomy. They all want their independence. Not all as in every individual woman, but all as in women from all over the world.
00:56:57 So quite often you see women covered in burqas in Afghanistan or in a naqab in Saudi Arabia in 40, 50 degrees Celsius heat, and people say things like, oh, she likes to wear it.
00:57:10 It's feminist.
00:57:11 It's empowering.
00:57:13 That's absolutely ridiculous.
00:57:15 These are human beings.
00:57:18 Human beings do not want to be covered in body bags while they are still breathing.
00:57:23 And to make that kind of assumption is insulting.
00:57:30 You're talking as if these are some sort of subhuman beings,
00:57:34 that they wouldn't have the same feelings as the rest of us.
00:57:38 They do.
00:57:40 And if we were able to allow these women the option of traveling on their own,
00:57:50 working if they want to, being independent, wearing what they want, without threats of
00:57:55 imprisonment or asset attacks or being discarded by their family and friends and community and
00:58:05 society, then these women would take that option. They want to be free. The same is true for men,
00:58:12 same is definitely true for minority groups like LGBT Muslims or Ahmadi Muslims or Sufi Muslims.
00:58:18 people want their freedom
00:58:21 people want to be able to think and feel
00:58:23 and believe and act as they want
00:58:25 without their state controlling them
00:58:28 and so I think that's where the hope for me lies
00:58:33 if there can be secularism in the Muslim world
00:58:36 then the people will choose freedom over Sharia
00:58:43 but as you know
00:58:46 Yusuf al-Qaradawi who is a member of the Muslim Brotherhood as he said a few years ago
00:58:52 if we did not have execution as the punishment for denouncing Islam there would be no Muslims
00:58:59 interesting they know full well that they're keeping these people hostage
00:59:05 well they haven't kept you hostage so you know your organization is called isn't it Free Hearts
00:59:14 free minds if people want to find out more um i have to thank you so much for sharing that
00:59:21 you know your story and what you feel with us uh thank you so much for coming on yasmin and
00:59:27 i really do wish you all the very very best you know for what you're doing uh going forward maybe
00:59:32 speak to you again next year i hope so thank you thank you so much thank you i look forward to it
00:59:37 Thank you. That's it for this week. So what you're saying is we shall see you next time. Thank you very much. Bye.