00:00:56Noble Gold Investments is the official gold sponsor of The Charlie Kirk Show, a company that specializes in gold IRAs and physical delivery of precious metals.
00:01:06Learn how you could protect your wealth with Noble Gold Investments at Noble Gold Investments.com.
00:01:51But first, here we have to get to the news, and that is breaking that the state of Utah has responded to the defense in the Tyler Robinson hearing.
00:03:02In fact, the prosecution hip checked the defense pretty hard against the boards of Utah jurisprudence.
00:03:09It was actually pretty systematic in their response.
00:03:15The evidence is overwhelming against Tyler Robinson.
00:03:18So, to me, some of this didn't probably have to happen because anybody with a functioning limbic system would know that there's probable cause to believe that Tyler Robinson killed Charlie Kirk and that there were other people in the, you know, and he did so for his political expression, which is one of the aggravators, and also that it was endangering the public, the people around Charlie Kirk or behind Charlie Kirk or in that line of Fire.
00:03:48But the prosecution took the extra step, which I think the Kirk family appreciates and everybody watching this appreciates, to explain why and explain why the arguments made by the defense were false.
00:04:04Right on down to them calling reasonable inferences, which is always a postulate in the law that is for a fact finder, and calling that such things as speculation.
00:04:17So, when I'm reading the brief, again, I'm not a lawyer.
00:04:20Blake sometimes plays one on TV, but there is a lot of ink spilled in this memo that is arguing about the difference between reasonable inferences.
00:04:33And speculation from a legal perspective, why is that important and what is the distinction?
00:04:47And this is what I would tell juries in my murder cases and my death penalty cases.
00:04:52If you went to bed and then you woke up and across your driveway there were deer tracks across the snow, you would know three things.
00:05:00Now, you weren't there, you didn't see any of the following.
00:05:03But you would be able to reasonably infer that the following three things happened one, that it snowed last night, two, that a deer crossed your driveway last night, and three, that the deer crossed the driveway after it snowed.
00:05:17And those are all reasonable inferences that none of us saw.
00:05:20None of the 12 jurors were there that day.
00:05:23And this is just sort of common misdirection by defense counsel to say, you're just speculating.
00:05:29Sure, somebody could have hung from a platform like Tom Cruise in Mission Impossible.
00:05:36In with a snow machine and planted, you know, little deer tracks in the driveway.
00:05:41That's possible, but it's not reasonable to infer that, right?
00:05:53Later on, it will be a jury to determine whether or not these reasonable inferences that people were in the line of fire or that if he had missed the, that, that, you know, he could have killed somebody else and put other people in the public.
00:06:21I mean, the fact is, yeah, he hit his target because he had political motivations to kill Charlie Kirk, but he still endangered others by taking that shot.
00:06:32There's always a risk that Tyler Robinson doesn't shoot so well that it actually lodges into the spine of Charlie Kirk.
00:06:42Such that only small particles of that 30-odd six-round, that 30-caliber class bullet, exited Charlie Kirk.
00:06:51And so, you know, the defense is doing all they can to make the argument.
00:06:57Well, to be clear, Jay, yeah, there wasn't any of those, nothing did exit.
00:07:03Apparently, the bullet broke apart, ended up in his chest cavity.
00:07:07But, yeah, he didn't know that that was going to be the outcome of that.
00:07:11Also, they made the point in the brief that.
00:07:13The questioner's head was about at the same head level as Charlie's, it was about at the same head level, if not slightly above.
00:07:20So he endangered the questioner, if nobody else.
00:07:23But obviously, then they make the point that there are other people to the left and to the right, behind, in the proximity.
00:07:29They made the point that he visited the location twice earlier that morning.
00:07:33He saw that there were people around the perimeter of that tent.
00:07:44But I think the most important thing that people care about most is.
00:07:47We have 60 or so pages between the defense filing and the prosecution filing, and maybe a grand total of one, one and a half pages dedicated to the core question of is Tyler Robinson credibly accused of murder?
00:08:03Because the defense basically didn't contest anything other than to throw out one page to say, we said some of the stuff was hearsay, just the text message Lance Twigg stuff.
00:08:13They don't address DNA, they don't address the rifle, they don't address the camera footage, whether that's Robinson.
00:08:17And that's what they say in this prosecution filing.
00:08:20Yeah, here's the opening from this prosecution memo.
00:08:26Defendant does not challenge the substance of the evidence demonstrating that he was the person who crawled to the sniper's perch on the Losey building rooftop, fired the fatal shot that killed Mr. Charlie Kirk, had the rifle in a wooded area, or hit the rifle in a wooded area, got rid of some of the clothing he was wearing, and told his roommate to delete their texts about the shooting.
00:09:01Because look, at the end of the day, right now, I think that the prosecution and the defense would agree.
00:09:08The defense is trying to save Tyler Robinson's life.
00:09:11They don't believe that he's going to be found not guilty of anything.
00:09:15And the prosecution wants to put him to death.
00:09:17And what the prosecution did just in that one sentence.0.81
00:09:21Was tamp down any ridiculous arguments that anybody is making, whether it's in the Twitter sphere or in the state of Utah, that it could have been somebody else.
00:10:07There's no evidence to suggest that at this point.
00:10:10But had that been the case, would that be something that the defense would have reasonably brought up during a preliminary hearing?
00:10:18Yes, they would have brought all of these ridiculous conspiracy theories out at the prelim because the whole goal is to not have the most significant charges like murder.
00:11:00Twiggs is going to testify under oath about the admissions that Tyler Robinson made to them.
00:11:06That's why, if you're the defense lawyer, you know that evidence is coming, which is why you're not saying, you know, well, it was somebody else, right?
00:11:15I mean, it's absolutely a ridiculous statement to make given the evidence that I've seen.
00:11:20I haven't seen a stronger murder case in the 28 years that I've served in the prosecution business.
00:11:25And I prosecuted well over 10,000 defendants and investigated and prosecuted hundreds of homicide cases to include death penalty cases.
00:11:35The only defense that I see they have left is to just try to save his life by saying he's a young man and get the jury to nullify some of these aggravators.
00:11:46But the fact is, Charlie Kirk was murdered because of his political viewpoints by Tyler Robinson.
00:11:52The evidence is overwhelming, and even Tyler Robinson's parents know this.
00:11:58Yeah, and we talked with just, I texted briefly with Andrea Burkhart, who's an online, she's a streamer, covers these cases.
00:12:05I believe she was a former, actually, Courtroom attorney.
00:12:09Anyways, she wrote back basically and said, you know, the defense brief is pretty much exactly what I predicted.
00:12:16They'd argue, and this was back when the defense brief just dropped.
00:12:20I think the one witness tampering charge gets dropped, but the aggravator sticks.
00:12:25Is that how you see this probably playing out?
00:12:26Or do you think the witness tampering is strong as well?
00:12:30I don't know why anybody would argue that the witness tampering wasn't strong because he said, delete all these text messages where I'm telling you what I did.
00:14:16Was there a greater network that radicalized him?
00:14:19Did people on the Discord chats know, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera?
00:14:23And this is the first evidence that I've seen, maybe others exist, that this investigators looked into this guy, issued a search warrant of the person that posted this, and actually went after him.
00:14:36Is this, would you expect that there's a number of these search warrants out there for people that expressed seemingly prior knowledge?
00:14:43Well, I don't know if there'd be search warrants as often as there would be.
00:14:47Law enforcement that actually just go knock on the door.
00:14:50This is making a terroristic threat or an online threat.
00:14:54And depending on the state or the jurisdiction, that necessitates law enforcement knocking on your door.
00:15:00I would bet, and Andrew, you would know this better than maybe anybody except for Erica, that every time Charlie appeared somewhere, there was a similar sort of ugly statement I hope something bad happens to Charlie Kirk.
00:15:14So I don't think it's evidence of anything.
00:15:17That second tweet, you know, let's just say something big is going to happen.
00:15:23But I don't think that that's some guy with insider knowledge.
00:15:27You know, but I think they would get to the bottom of it pretty quickly.
00:15:31This caused investigators to execute a search warrant on this guy's and the contents of his phone.
00:15:37Investigators did not believe this individual was the shooter, but he posted these things that seemed to indicate prior knowledge.
00:15:43So, that is the first piece of evidence I've seen because one of the narratives out there is that the feds looked only at Tyler Robinson, they didn't investigate anybody else, and they ignored all the other surrounding evidence.
00:16:36With Patriot Mobile, you can even have two separate networks on a single device, eliminating the need to carry multiple phones and giving you peace of mind you just can't get with other carriers.
00:20:17And what is going to give you assurances that voting Republican actually gets something done?
00:20:21This is one of the reasons why getting the Save America Act passed is not a simple matter of preference.
00:20:28No, it's existential to the midterms because if you get that passed, And we keep putting up big ICE deportation numbers.
00:20:36You're sending a message to the base, hey, we hear you.
00:20:39We know what your priorities were, and we're getting them accomplished.
00:20:42I would also add on that list getting some sort of peace resolution in Iran, which feels like the great white whale at this point, getting that wrapped up and put a bow on it because we need to see gas prices come back down.
00:20:52We need to see energy prices come back down.
00:20:54That's specifically true, Rich, in a state like Alaska, where inflation hits these guys harder than most because just the cost of getting goods.
00:21:06And explain the dynamics, by the way, Rich, with, you know, Alaska's kind of an odd duck in the sense that urban cores tend to vote Republican.
00:21:15It's the, yeah, it's the rural that vote Democrat, right?
00:21:21It's one of these amazing relics of a bygone era, which is if you go back and read Kevin Phillips, The Emerging Republican Majority, you can see it in other states.0.71
00:21:37You have indigenous and Eskimo and Native American and other tribal voters that live on the outskirts and in the rural areas, and they have been Democratic for a while.
00:22:02Yeah, she, guys, I'll tell you right now when it happened, I basically said that.0.99
00:22:08Lisa Murkowski has single handedly ensured that a Democrat will win Alaska in a bad cycle for Republicans because you need that turnout to swamp the rest of the state.
00:22:20And it's like the I don't want to say inner city because it's not an inner city like we know inner cities, but in the urban areas in Alaska, it tends to be the more big business, once upon a time, almost gentrifying these areas.
00:22:32And that used to be a Republican voting block.
00:22:34The reason it's held up until now is because of the kind of economy that Alaska supports.
00:22:40So In other states like Georgia, when you see a place like Atlanta get gentrified and more urban and population growth, Phoenix, this happened in Phoenix too, it goes blue.
00:22:54So when a Republican governor like Kemp invites a tiny tinsel town to Atlanta so they can have a mini Hollywood there, you're bringing a liberal industry, which will bring liberal jobs and liberal families and liberal people.
00:23:28Lisa Murkowski is a Democrat with an R next to her name.
00:23:30Which, let me just say, which is why we can't lose these seats, guys, because I have been told, and I don't know if you guys know this, but I have been told by more than one person on multiple occasions, Lisa Murkowski has said that if my vote is going to be the balance of power, I'm going to leave the Republican Party.
00:23:49I will caucus with Democrats and call myself an independent.
00:23:54If Susan Collins loses in Maine and then her vote matters, because that is her friend and she will take her little tantrum like the rhino establishment does all the time.0.91
00:24:03This is real, so you can't afford to lose seats like this.0.93
00:24:33You get a bad apple, but overall, they're really pleasant and interesting people to talk to.
00:24:38And I mean, simply put, guys, you could answer that very easily.
00:24:43Look what happened last week with the vice president and Secretary Kennedy.
00:24:47If Harris was elected, no matter how angry you are with Iran or anything else, if Harris was elected, do you think we would have gotten the white wolves and the wolves in white coats report?0.57
00:24:57Showing that doctors mutilated our children with these trans surgeries for profit, for the prospect of having a lifetime patient who needed to be on their care.0.80
00:25:08Like they're acting like stockbrokers or something who are trying to build a book.
00:27:13He represents the dying wing of the party that should be cast aside.
00:27:17They're Democrats anyway, and we should move forward with Trumpism in its purest form because you get so much more out of it.
00:27:24And looking at the map, that's what you see.
00:27:26You know, parts of Monroe, which is Southwestern and the Keys, of course, that's exactly where I would have expected Vinman to get some of his support.
00:27:35In some of the Tampa Bay areas where, you know, there was once upon a time Republican slides until Trump came along, you have those orphan Romney whiny voters who still think it's 1980, right?
00:27:48I mean, that's who Alexander Vinman got, and she got everywhere else.
00:29:27Three four seven, that's eight seven seven six four six five three four seven, or visit them online at Noble Gold Investments dot com Slash Kirk and find out how to protect yourself, your wealth, and your family.
00:29:38Noble Gold Investments dot com Slash Kirk.
00:29:41Election day is coming, don't let it arrive without a plan.
00:29:44And here's the best part to celebrate America's two fiftieth, just mention the Charlie Kirk Show when you call Noble Gold, and they'll send you a free ten ounce silver bar when you open a new qualified account.
00:29:55Mention the Charlie Kirk Show, that's all you got to do, and they'll do the rest.
00:30:01We turn our sights with the great Rich Bearus to Florida.
00:30:39I think, by the way, we talk about the Floridification of Arizona.
00:30:43There's something Charlie really believed in, and I think we have a great shot with Biggs, plus our get out the vote, our chase the vote operation in Arizona.
00:30:55I mean, Arizona, the primary results alone is a testament to chase the vote.
00:30:59It's a testament to what you guys are doing because in a, You know, a guy like me who does what I do in a sea of like bad news with primary turnout, Arizona was the one area where he said, Oh, thank God.
00:31:24The only way that we were able to defeat Bill Nelson and, thank the Lord, prevent Andrew Gillum, who some of us did know who Andrew Gillum was and what he did with his nightlife, by the way, the media just wouldn't cover it.
00:32:40James Fishback, we've got a couple graphs here.
00:32:42And I know the reason I want to bring this up is because you made a big deal, and rightly so, with Thomas Massey, where he lost his primary, but it was like, It was 55, 65 and over that got him over the top.
00:32:55Meanwhile, all the younger voters were voting for Thomas Massey.
00:32:59We see a similar trend with James Fishback.
00:33:01I saw this with the enthusiasm for him with younger voters in that state.
00:33:05So throw some of these graphics up where he's getting basically edging out Byron Donalds with the 35 and under crowd.
00:33:14Byron's holding his own, but he was doing well with younger voters.
00:33:18What's your takeaway from the Byron Donalds race?
00:34:14But Byron, this is the second part that's interesting.
00:34:17Byron actually did well in the areas where there's like true new MAGA that's less white.
00:34:25So even though turnout wasn't gangbuster in Miami Dade, look at how much better he did in Miami Dade.0.64
00:34:30Look at how much better he did in the Gold Coast.
00:34:33So, the reason he couldn't get above 50 is because in the Big Bend and in the panhandle and some Central Florida, he didn't do as well as he did in South Florida.
00:34:42So, had there been bigger turnout numbers among Hispanics and the new MAGA that Trump brought in in 24, Byron would have won by a larger margin.
00:34:50And by the way, just to put it all in context, any other cycle, Byron's margin would have been sufficient to be escaping any kind of criticism.
00:34:59It's just that people are going to jump on it right now because, of course, the.
00:35:04It was the narrative surrounding this race and whether or not he should have ever debated and nonsense like that.
00:35:11But any other primary, and this would have been a romping by any standard.
00:35:17I mean, he's just got work to do, and he's got to go out and talk to those voters.1.00
00:35:21Guys, I mean, dismissing people and calling them anti Semites is stupidity.1.00
00:35:49That comment there, the anti Semite stuff, I mean, none of the people we spoke to who are supporting Fishback said they were supporting Fishback because they hate Israel or they were anti Semitic.
00:37:39Of course, it's almost essentially an open seat race, but it's still a better shot at holding the seat now that Corey's former TV anchor, uh, good brand name idea in that area.
00:37:49So, uh, good communicator, yeah, it's a good communicator, Rich Barris.
00:39:06And remember, Y Refi doesn't care what your credit score is.
00:39:09Just go to YRefi.com and tell them your friend Andrew sent you.
00:39:15We have a treat in store for you, and that is, of course, Mark Halperin, friend of the show, editor in chief of Two Way TV, host of Next Up on the Megyn Kelly Network.
00:39:25Thank you for making some time for us today.
00:39:27We had a big primary night last night, and there's some underlying stories about John Ossoff, Natalie Harp, Mark Kelly, all kinds of stuff to get to here.
00:39:38But let's start with Florida and Alexander Vindman.
00:40:55And he says the flip side of this is Democrats are learning all of the resistance stuff from 2019, people who are heroes of the first impeachment, people who have made their name by kind of being these bold resistance figures against Trump in the bureaucracy or whatever, that it just doesn't have the mileage it once did.
00:43:49And he retreats into this bubble of West Wing aides who are his security blanket to make him feel good about himself.
00:44:00All right, so he kind of walks it back a little bit, but this has been all the talk right now.
00:44:04And then you've got CNN's Aaron Burnett bringing on Natalie Harp's brother.
00:44:09President Trump is calling him Pee Wee Herman.
00:44:12Everything under the surface, though, is it feels like John Ossoff is not only trying to win his Senate race, he's posturing as something of a national figure, taking on Trump directly.
00:44:24And by the way, just I think a really gross smear of Natalie Harp, who we have no indication of anything other than she's just a sweetheart that is loyal to the president.
00:44:36I don't think he's inclined to run, but I think he knows there could be a vacuum and the pull of which would be quite strong that he might have to consider it, but not till after he's reelected.
00:45:29And I'm not really sure this has any enduring meaning.
00:45:31I'd be surprised if it were alive next week as a story.
00:45:34Well, it is interesting that question of was this designed more to make MAGA matter or would it resonate with Democrats?
00:45:40Because I'll admit, I feel like I had not heard a lot of this woman.
00:45:45Like, I sort of jogged my memory once people were talking about it.
00:45:48But I guess, is this a blue sky meme, maybe?
00:45:51If you're really invested in Democrat politics, they just throw around, like, oh, Trump has this mistress who runs around with him, and they just take it as a gift.
00:45:58She looks, she's blonde and all this stuff.
00:46:01I mean, the reaction of the room suggested the people there knew.
00:46:05I'm surprised at how many people on the right say they didn't really focus on her, didn't know who she was.
00:46:12She's been written about quite a bit, primarily because of some of the notes suggesting a lot of familiarity that she's written to the president.
00:46:52Yeah, I mean, to be fair, though, with it, I mean, not to get too much into the palace intrigue of the White House, but I mean, there were people that didn't like Charlie's influence over the president, right?
00:47:03So that's going to happen anytime somebody wins the president's trust.
00:47:07But, you know, I just have to say, in general, the smearing without allegations.
00:47:15And by the way, if he didn't know that it was going to be taken as some sort of tawdry affair, a mistress of the president's, I don't believe that for a second.
00:47:54We have you on because you have insights and you have sources within Democrat politics, and you're willing to graciously share those with us here.
00:48:01Now, if you are now looking at the field, so there was this interesting quote that I saw.
00:48:08Mark Kelly was in Georgia campaigning for John Assoff.
00:48:12Somebody asked him, what about an Assoff Kelly ticket?
00:48:14And he said, why don't you reverse the names?
00:49:23It's an irony and a paradox that at a time when American Jews within the Democratic Party have never been more under siege in the modern era, you have more prospective Jewish candidates than we've ever seen, maybe total in American history, all potentially poised to run.
00:49:41I think that you have to look at candidates who can do.
00:49:45Two or three of the following things name ID, fundraising, and draw attention.
00:49:52There's only one person in the race right now who can do all three of those things, or one person who may run, I should say, who can do all three of those things.
00:50:02I'm moving her way up in my September 8 for 28 rankings, the most likely Democrats.
00:50:07I'm really thinking anew about her chances and the likelihood that she'll run because I think she and Sanders are going to sit down and talk about it.
00:50:17Probably one of the two of them has to do it.
00:50:19If they want their movement to have the person who can lead this.
00:50:25And then on the question of who runs, if you can't raise tens or hundreds of millions of dollars, if you can't get on Monday Night Football and meet the press and your show and mine, if you can't become nationally known within the party, you're going to take a good hard look at running and say, do I really have a chance to win this thing?
00:50:47Right now, I see four people who are what I call aircraft carriers.
00:50:51Who can build those three things or has them already?
00:51:00Everybody else, I think, is going to take a look at this and wonder if it's really a decent enough chance that it's worth all the things you put your family through to run.
00:51:10Is there anyone who could pull a leapfrog where, much like JD Vance was a senator only a couple of years and then he's vice president, if Abdullah Syed wins his Senate race, could he plausibly just very abruptly rise up as a potential frontrunner or any of these other high profile candidates they have running for Senate governor?
00:51:57People talk all the time about people coming from nowhere that say, well, Obama came from nowhere.
00:52:01No, when Barack Obama was at the Harvard Law School, people talked about him as a potential president.
00:52:06People say Donald Trump came from nowhere.
00:52:07No, Donald Trump talked about running for president for three decades.
00:52:11So, mark me down as a skeptic that somebody who people have never talked about running for president suddenly steps into this thing and wins the nomination.
00:52:19I think you're going to have some combination of Harris, Newsom, and Shapiro running, probably two of those three.
00:52:27And I think it'd be very hard to take the nomination away from any of those three if you've never played the game before.
00:52:33What about names I feel like I heard a decent amount in the past and yet they've fallen off, which is we have.
00:52:40Roy Cooper, who's been governor of North Carolina a long time, and is now running, exactly, Andy Bashir.
00:52:45So we have these moderate ish Democrats in purple, or in Kentucky's case, deep red states, who've been pretty politically successful.0.79
00:52:55They have, you know, they're just old white guys.0.96
00:53:46Running for Senate, running for governor, it's not the same.
00:53:48And some of these folks have things in their background that they, if they're wise, they'll know they'll have to answer for, even though they don't have to answer for them when they run for these lower offices.
00:53:57And they may not want to put themselves and their family through that.
00:54:40I know he's got some drawbacks in terms of winning votes, including a lack of support from black voters so far, but he's a very smart, able guy.
00:55:41I had the honor of a lifetime to call Charlie a friend.
00:55:46And what I remember most wasn't just what people saw on stage, it was what was behind the scenes.
00:55:52That was an unwavering commitment to his faith, his love for his family, and his genuine desire to encourage others to live with courage and conviction.
00:56:01Charlie believed that following Christ wasn't something you compartmentalize.
00:56:05He didn't put it in a box, he lived it out loud.
00:56:08It shaped how he lived, how he served, how he treated people every single day.
00:56:12Charlie Kirk, American Martyr, captures that heart.
00:56:15This documentary isn't just simply about remembering Charlie, it's an invitation for each of us to ask what kind of legacy we're building and whether we're willing to stand firm in our own faith when it's tested.
00:56:27I hope that you'll watch it with your family and have those conversations together.
00:57:21You're the guy who originally wrote an article on Substack, exposing a lot of his plagiarism, raising an eyebrow at some of his other claims.
00:57:30And you were the one doing this on Substack because at every step of the way, journalists, his own institution, Other schools, they were ignoring that he was a fabulous from top to bottom.
00:57:43And why don't you tell your story of how you ended up being the author of that piece?
00:57:50Now, by the time I published the story on July 21st, literally thousands of people had known about it for a year.
00:58:00A year ago, first, Cambridge definitely knew about it in 2023, because as soon as Jason Arday was hired, Everybody knows the youngest black professor, a DEI hire for a very, very prestigious position as chair professor at Cambridge in the Faculty of Education.
00:58:21So he's hired in 2023, clearly unqualified for the job.
00:58:26But within a few months, there was another academic at Plymouth Marijuana University in the UK who contacted the authorities at Cambridge and showed them the evidence for his plagiarism.
00:58:53They knew about the plagiarism then, for sure.
00:58:56And they would have known for sure that Jason Arde was a fabulist, too, because a year ago, he claimed that he was attacked by a racist with a knife in his office at Cambridge.
00:59:11And he said he was attacked twice, but none of this was captured on CCTV.
00:59:16So that means the administration knew he was a plagiarist, they knew he was a fabulist for years.
00:59:24And it's anybody who asks questions is intimidated, either with lawyers or with veiled threats.
00:59:32It's not just a story about Cambridge, though.
00:59:35I asked ChatGPT, so that I can't be accused of cherry picking, to give a list of all the institutions that had formal ties to Jason Arday, and it came up with 46.
00:59:51So, 46, like the Royal Society of Arts, and besides Cambridge, Glasgow University, Durham University, the BBC, where he was in a prestigious position as editor, all of these institutions.
01:00:08And he was just running around making, telling ridiculous stories.
01:00:12Obviously, many people knew, but either because of the threats that were issued by our day or his supporters, or the fact that people simply didn't want to be called racist, which was actually.
01:00:27The most effective mechanism for ensuring people's silence that kept the story from breaking containment.
01:00:39I had my own free speech issue with Cambridge.
01:00:43I got in a lot of trouble when I was an employee in the philosophy faculty in 2024.
01:00:49I wrote a Substack essay called The Guide for the Hereditarian Revolution, which questioned some of the foundations of DEI ideology.
01:01:02Particularly with respect to its claim that all groups of people are, on average, exactly the same in terms of socially relevant characteristics, the university placed me under investigation and my college terminated my position.
01:02:52And so, what sort of attacks have you yourself faced?0.98
01:02:56Because, let's be blunt, you did the work others were too cowardly to do, that you called out a fraud and a charlatan.
01:03:03Well, if you want to know why thousands of people knew about the story and didn't say anything, look at what's happening to me.
01:03:12Besides hundreds of hate letters, hate emails, death threats, there was a rally at Trafalgar Square a few days ago with 15,000 people, speaker after speaker, denouncing me by name.
01:03:27I can't walk down the street in London anymore.
01:03:36Now, even the press, everybody is looking for a scapegoat.
01:03:40Who is actually responsible for this situation?
01:03:43Cambridge, who hired Arde knowing he was unqualified, they knew since 2023 that he was a plagiarist and a fabulist.
01:03:53They had three years to find a way to let him down gently, to find some other position, some non research position for him to take or pay him to go do something else.
01:04:03But what they did is they set him up for public humiliation.
01:04:07It was totally unrealistic to think that they could bury the story for 31 years until he retires.
01:04:14So they set him up, and then, okay, so I broke the story.
01:04:22Then, after I broke the story, the British press published 249 articles about our day in 22 days.
01:04:34Far, even after he resigned from Cambridge, they were still dissecting every aspect of his life from the time he was a child.
01:04:47And even though this had no news value, because everyone on earth knew that he was a plagiarist and he had already effectively been fired from his job.
01:04:55And they weren't paying any attention to the people who were actually responsible for the situation, which were the administration at Cambridge.
01:05:04So that's how Cambridge behaved, that's how the press behaved.
01:05:07Now, the Union of British Journalists yesterday published a statement about the death of Jason Arde, and they criticize only one person by name.
01:05:50Personal attacks about all of these like fabulous stories and illnesses, and all, or did you just focus on the plagiarism aspect?
01:05:58It was very careful and factual, and it's been read by hundreds of thousands of people, and no one has found even a single comma that was a mistake.
01:06:11Uh, I at that time remember when I published this on July 21st, our day was the chair professor at Cambridge and backed by all these prestigious institutions, and you know, here I'm in Ghent.
01:06:25Postdoctoral researcher with a Substack and a Twitter account.
01:06:37I don't see how it can be true, but I can't definitively refute them without direct evidence.
01:06:45So I'm going to focus mainly on the plagiarism and the quality of his work, which are things that I can assess with the resources available to me.
01:06:57So I just showed page after page after page of his writing and earlier writing that he copies from, often verbatim or lightly paraphrasing.
01:07:09And there There was just a factual report.
01:07:15And then I, yes, I did draw some conclusions about DEI because I think this is a story about DEI.
01:07:24It's not really a story about our day and his plagiarism.
01:07:28It's about the incentive structure in the system that made our day possible and motivated the cover up.
01:07:35One of the things that makes me so angry is you have these publications in the UK and these politicians who are saying, It was misconduct because they wrote an article about him and so they placed him in danger or he was in distress.
01:07:49So they just had a responsibility to ignore that he had lied, that he had occupied a job he didn't deserve.
01:07:56And it just occurred to me, as Nathan was saying, he couldn't walk in London safely.0.83
01:08:02And I think you and I both know that if that happened, these same people who say, you have a moral responsibility to not write about this fraudulent professor, they would say, he deserved this.0.95
01:08:12Dr. Kaufness, he brought this on himself because he was.
01:08:16Well, yeah, and that exactly it's a great point, Nathan.
01:08:19If if you something terrible happened to you, and God forbid that would happen, and we'll pray for your safety, but they would say, Well, don't be a racist, then that's what they would say.
01:08:29I mean, look at this, look at this screen grab I took from Andy Nose footage of this rally that was held in Jason Arde's honor.
01:08:52He was called out to hit a diversity metric.
01:08:54It's very interesting that people are saying we shouldn't have criticized Ardai, who, by the way, held a position of great influence and prestige in society.
01:09:22But the people who are saying that we can't criticize our day because of his emotional state or whatever, no one has ever asked me about my emotional state.
01:11:04He's sort of like an avatar of a wider rot within the academy that must be exposed.
01:11:10In the United States, we had Claudine Gay, who was a plagiarist who was leading Harvard, and Christopher Ruffo helped take her down, among others, right?
01:11:21You have Ibram X. Kendi, these fake pseudo intellectuals that are actually activists that are being propped up by a whole system that wants them to be these figureheads that they're not qualified to be.
01:11:33And it actually has destructive consequences on our society.
01:11:35Give us a sense of how bad the scope of that is where you've been operating in Britain, because we know it's bad in the US, but how bad is it in Britain, the scope of that rot?
01:11:45Well, I should say that Arte suffered very severe punishment, public humiliation, ultimately paying the ultimate price, right?
01:11:58And he's not, it would be wrong to portray him as like some monster, right?
01:12:04There are thousands and thousands of people who are far worse.
01:12:09He was a man who was responding to incentives created by the DEI system, where people who occupy a certain position in the woke hierarchy due to identity characteristics like skin color are simply not held to standards that other people are, and they can just make up anything and no one will challenge them.
01:12:32Or if they are challenged, they can just call the person a racist and then they'll shut up.
01:12:44But it's not, he was not the worst criminal.
01:12:49You know, it's in my view, the responsibility lies far more with the architects of the system and the people who know better and who allow it to continue.
01:13:02By the way, which is also the media, because the media was very happy to fawn upon this man and to shower him with accolades and laud him as this great prestigious.
01:13:14Intellectual until the truth came out, and then they turned so they created the system and they supplement it, they message behind it, and they like a good story.
01:13:24The Brits love a good, you know, clickbait headline.
01:13:31So, anyways, the point is there is a lot of blame to go around, but in my opinion, sir, you deserve none of it because actually, we need people to be calling out the fraud in the system.
01:14:08By plagiarizing someone else's work, you bolster your own career, and resources are diverted to you.
01:14:17On the assumption that you're a productive scholar and they're diverted away from other people, including the people you steal from, who would actually be able to advance scholarship.
01:14:29It's just a matter also of stealing someone's intellectual property, and they have a right to get credit for that, for whatever their motivation may be.
01:14:39People have a right to know where ideas come from.