00:00:00We hear it all the time. Men must take responsibility for ending sexual violence.
00:00:07A lie repeated as if it were a self-evident truth. And it's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:24I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:27Many commentators more knowledgeable than I have already weighed in on the fallout from the Harvey Weinstein scandal in which a blizzard of allegations criminal and trivial have been directed not only at Weinstein but also at many other entertainment industry and public figures.
00:00:44Even President George Bush Sr. was forced to apologize recently for allegedly touching women on the buttocks when he was 89 and 92 years old,
00:00:56confined to a wheelchair and suffering from Parkinson's disease.
00:01:01I don't claim to have insight into Hollywood culture and I haven't followed all the twists and turns of Weinstein's story,
00:01:07but it doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that when even a 93-year-old former president
00:01:14with Parkinson's disease receives public scrutiny as a sex predator and when the accusations take
00:01:21up more space in his Wikipedia entry than his role at the CIA, we're in the middle of a full-scale
00:01:27moral panic in which public concern far outstrips objective reality. Every time I hear about yet
00:01:36another woman coming forward and being applauded for her courage, I am struck by how quickly
00:01:42our society accepts that most men are guilty. While it's true that not all the outrage has
00:01:51focused on men as perpetrators, there has been some analysis of Hollywood women's role and
00:01:56some discussion of young men and boys as victims, the dominant story has been the supposed
00:02:02ordinariness of Weinstein. Actress Alyssa Milano, for example, claimed that men like Harvey Weinstein
00:02:08are around every corner, from which it follows that women have the right and even perhaps the
00:02:15moral duty to treat every man as a stand-in Weinstein. Typical of this trend was a remarkable0.73
00:02:24October 11th article by Suzanne Moore, who's a columnist with The Guardian newspaper, titled0.79
00:02:30My life has been marked by sexual harassment just like all women.
00:02:35Even for The Guardian, which for years now seems to have acted on the principle that anti-male animus is always a winning proposition,
00:02:43Moore's piece is hyperbolic and desperately unkind.0.74
00:02:49I'd like to say the following to feminist journalists.1.00
00:02:51If you think it's right to fill a column with every inappropriate touch or unwanted sexual proposition you've ever received,0.97
00:03:00and call that journalism well please don't pretend that you speak for all women moore
00:03:07details the ways men have allegedly terrorized her over the years and concludes by condemning
00:03:14even the pro-feminist male editor at her pro-feminist newspaper this man made the mistake
00:03:21of saying that sexual harassment was a quote dreadful business and said that he was quote
00:03:28glad it doesn't happen here his statement is presented ironically by moore as a symbol of men's
00:03:36willing ignorance we're supposed to understand that this man is actually enabling sexual
00:03:43harassment by not seeing that it is happening in his own office now that's the power of female
00:03:51victimhood in a nutshell. You can libel your own male colleague as an enabler of harassment and0.99
00:03:58he simply has to proofread the libel and keep his mouth shut. There's nothing unusual about Moore's
00:04:06anti-male tirade unfortunately. In an article for Odyssey magazine entitled Harvey Weinstein
00:04:13proves that rape culture is still prevalent in 2017, student writer Kate Marlett doesn't waste
00:04:21many words moving from the alleged crimes of one Hollywood movie mogul to the crimes of all men,
00:04:27and she urges women to take pleasure in insulting any man who annoys them, no matter how small the
00:04:34provocation. It's all part of feminist resistance, don't you know? Quote, make it your mission to make1.00
00:04:41men squirm she fulminates give them your best death glare when they tell you to smile more
00:04:49end quote well of course it's not clear at all how glaring at a man for talking to a woman will
00:04:56stop real sexual predators but this article like so many of the bombastic outpourings that have
00:05:03emerged in the wake of Weinstein isn't really about stopping sexual predators at all it's about
00:05:08legitimizing the hatred and abuse of all men. And it does that partly through the false assumption
00:05:17that it is men's responsibility to make the world safe for women. So Matt Damon should have saved
00:05:24Gwyneth Paltrow from Weinstein and deserves condemnation because he didn't. And Quentin
00:05:30Tarantino should have done something about Weinstein decades ago and must apologize now
00:05:36for failing to act. And pretty much every feminist anti-violence website includes some version of the1.00
00:05:44assertion that, quote, men have a responsibility and the power to end sexual violence. Except
00:05:53it isn't true. The statement about men's power is a sleight of hand that conflates the simple truth
00:06:00that yes, individual men have the power and responsibility not to commit sexual violence
00:06:05and to report any crimes they witness, with the false claim that individual or groups
00:06:11of men have the power and responsibility to stop sexual violence altogether.
00:06:19By making sexual violence against the law?
00:06:21Well, of course, men in Western cultures have already done that.
00:06:26making sexual violence socially unacceptable they've already done that too so what more
00:06:33according to feminists men can help end sexual violence by critically examining their own
00:06:39masculinity which essentially means shaming themselves and other men for non-criminal
00:06:45behaviors such as laughing at sexual jokes or making sexual advances and more worrisomely by
00:06:52acting on hearsay, rumors, and allegations to extrajudicially punish men accused of
00:06:59criminal and non-criminal behaviors. The first strategy, which conflates normal
00:07:05male sexuality with criminal deviants, is irrelevant to ending sexual violence because
00:07:11criminals will still rape no matter how many good men are shamed. And the strategy of applying0.96
00:07:17community sanctions to accused men, which is now being celebrated as a productive response to the
00:07:23Weinstein case, is a shocking assault on the principles of Western justice, such as the
00:07:29presumption of innocence and commitment to due process. And it is extraordinary how many
00:07:36commentators, and not just feminist commentators by a long shot, are enthusiastically in favor of
00:07:43punishing and humiliating men for unproven sexual crimes and misdemeanors so how did we get to this
00:07:51point a must read for anyone who wants to understand the relationship between the present feeding
00:07:58frenzy and decades-old feminist propaganda is feminist activist andrea dworkin's short and
00:08:06absurd 1984 article originally titled talking to men about rape which begins from the premise that
00:08:14men believe they have the right to rape this is how she says it quote it is an extraordinary thing
00:08:22to try to understand and confront why it is that men believe and men do believe that they have the0.98
00:08:30right to rape. The piece is supposedly a challenge to men to end rape or failing that at least to
00:08:37bring about a 24-hour truce during which there is no rape and this became eventually the title of
00:08:43the now classic piece. When I applied to work at a women's shelter and rape crisis hotline in the
00:08:49early 1990s the piece was required reading for those who were taking the training. So how exactly
00:08:56Could men end rape, according to Dworkin, easy, by caring about women's pain as much
00:09:02as they pretended to, and calling off their predator friends?
00:09:07This is how she says it, quote, and I want one day of respite, one day off, one day in
00:09:15which no new bodies are piled up, one day in which no new agony is added to the old,
00:09:23I'm asking you to give it to me. And how could I ask you for less? It is so little. And how could
00:09:30you offer me less? It is so little. Even in wars, there are days of truce. Go and organize a truce.
00:09:39Stop your side for one day. Well, as any reasonable person would realize, Dworkin's eloquent demand is
00:09:49pure, hollow grandstanding. It's like challenging parents to end child abuse on the ground that
00:09:56all parents are part of a culture where children are abused and therefore all parents, even the
00:10:01best ones, are somehow complicit in the fact that some parents abuse their children. Dworkin sets
00:10:08men a humanly impossible task while pretending that it is a reasonable request and then uses
00:10:14the fact that men do not end rape can't end rape even for just 24 hours as proof that all men are
00:10:21complicit in it and this strategy of shaming men for failing to do what is impossible in the first
00:10:29place has been used by feminists largely unopposed ever since Dworkin's piece and is now received
00:10:36wisdom near the end of her essay after defaming all men dworkin noted that she and other activists
00:10:44continued to speak to men because against all the evidence they still quote believed in men's
00:10:52humanity against all the evidence big of her wasn't it this element too the self-satisfied
00:11:02conviction of women's superior humanity has unfortunately become a standard part of modern1.00
00:11:08feminist rhetoric which can barely keep up the pretense of believing in men's humanity
00:11:16in the same period that the weinstein scandal was being talked about everywhere men were engaging
00:11:24in quiet acts of heroism to no fanfare at all. Just to take a few examples, in late October of
00:11:32this year, a man in Yarmouth, Nova Scotia, Canada drowned while trying to rescue a number of
00:11:38shellfish diggers who appeared to him to be stranded on a Nova Scotia island. Just two weeks
00:11:45earlier, a Florida man, Delbert Blair, ran into the ocean to save a drowning man and suffered a
00:11:50heart attack after being caught in strong currents. In the previous month of September,
00:11:55a man died in North Carolina while attempting to rescue a struggling swimmer at Cape Hatteras
00:12:00National Park. A month before that, a young Illinois man died after rescuing a swimmer in
00:12:05distress off Honolulu, Hawaii. And these aren't the soldiers, firemen, or other professionals who
00:12:12risk their lives as part of their jobs. These are ordinary men at the beach responding when
00:12:18they see people in trouble. None of the reports of their deaths makes a connection between their
00:12:24self-sacrificing courage and their maleness, though men are more likely than women to risk
00:12:31their lives to help complete strangers. In contrast, very few of the Weinstein commentators
00:12:38miss a chance to emphasize how, quote, utterly common, end quote, his male sexual predation
00:12:45supposedly is. That reference to Weinstein as, quote, utterly common comes from a prominent
00:12:52opinion piece titled Dear Men, It's You Too, published on October 19th in the New York Times,
00:12:58and it's the last article that I'll mention. This is a piece of vindictive rage masquerading as
00:13:07reasonable argument demanding that men finally, here we go again, take responsibility for ending
00:13:14sexual violence. The piece is by Roxanne Gay, who is an associate professor of creative writing and
00:13:20English at Purdue University. And in the article, Gay alleges that men's constant harassment of0.91
00:13:27women is even worse than women have so far reported. Apparently, women minimize and lie0.86
00:13:32to themselves all the time because, quote, if we were to face how bad it really is,0.99
00:13:37we might not be able to shoulder the burden for one moment longer end quote gay spared us an
00:13:45account of the burden she has shouldered she says she's been hurt too many times to count but
00:13:50certainly she has a lot to say to men about what they collectively owe women which is primarily a
00:13:57lengthy confession of their sins the final paragraph of her article outlines how men
00:14:05should respond to the building crescendo of female accusations she says quote men can start putting
00:14:12in some of the work women have long done in offering testimony they can come forward and say
00:14:19me too while sharing how they have hurt women in ways great and small they can testify about how
00:14:28they have cornered women in narrow office hallways, or made lewd comments to co-workers,
00:14:34or refused to take no for an answer, or worn a woman down by guilting her into sex, and on and0.89
00:14:41on and on. It would equally be a balm if men spoke up about the times when they witnessed violence
00:14:49or harassment and looked the other way, or laughed it off, or secretly thought a woman was asking for
00:14:57it. It's time for men to start answering for themselves because women cannot possibly solve0.98
00:15:04this problem they had no hand in creating." This piece is a really compelling example of how a0.87
00:15:15socially sanctioned hatred can blunt the critical faculties of a presumably able mind. Gay doesn't1.00
00:15:24even try to claim that she believes in men's humanity. It actually doesn't seem to have0.76
00:15:30occurred to her that many men haven't done any of the things she lists, or that many men have
00:15:37experienced harassment and sexual assault themselves. According to Survivors UK, a British
00:15:43organization, the number of male victims is comparable to the number of female victims,
00:15:48Or that her bigoted slur on all men is itself a form of sexual harassment, perhaps we should call it gender slander, that in my opinion is far less excusable than what she calls guilting someone into sex, which at least might have a positive outcome for both people, unlike a piece whose entire shameful point is that men are deficient in their souls.
00:16:13Note, by the way, the specifically religious language in Gay's piece of, quote,
00:16:18offering testimony and providing a, quote, balm for healing.
00:16:23In the worldview of someone like Gay, men are tainted by the secular equivalent of original sin,0.58
00:16:29and such sin can never be cured, only atoned for over and over again.0.91
00:16:37I don't believe it's an exaggeration to say that the consequences of gay's worldview, a worldview we now see all around us, are disastrous.0.98
00:16:48Because if all men are responsible for sexual violence, then no man is truly innocent,0.88
00:16:55and therefore the damage to men caused by vigilante justice, false allegations, or even just a general climate of suspicion and disgust,
00:17:04it's not serious. It's even deserved. From the feminist perspective, there really are no false
00:17:13allegations. I want to end by speaking briefly about my father, who died a few months ago,
00:17:22and who had his own experience with a false accusation. At age 84, he was accused of bullying
00:17:30a secretary at the credit union where he was chairman of the board of directors and the
00:17:35investigation into the case consisted of a human resources lawyer being brought in to do interviews
00:17:40with my father my father's accuser and a few other people though there were no actual witnesses
00:17:46to the alleged bullying which my father's accuser claimed had consisted mainly of his
00:17:52raising his voice and speaking to her very disrespectfully. The lawyer found the woman's
00:17:59victim story more believable than my father's unwilling self-defense. The lawyer wrote a report
00:18:07and that was the end of it. My dad was essentially disavowed by most of his
00:18:13fellow board members and forced to step down from his position.
00:18:18Now, I know that in the grand scheme of things, my dad got off lightly.
00:18:23He wasn't criminally charged and prosecuted.
00:18:25He wasn't fined or even publicly denounced.
00:18:29In fact, he was even publicly thanked at the year's AGM, where his resignation was acknowledged.
00:18:38merely because a woman didn't like how she claimed he had spoken to her.
00:18:42And even if there were proof that he had done exactly what she claimed, it's outrageous in my opinion that his decades of volunteer service to the board of directors would be repaid in such a manner.
00:18:56we need to challenge the false claim that all men are responsible for ending sexual violence
00:19:04it's pure propaganda and whether intentional or not it undermines men's humanity and widens an
00:19:11already wide empathy gap by positing male complicity in evil unlike professor roxane gay
00:19:21or any number of commentators who've been emboldened in bigotry in the wake of Weinstein
00:19:27and who openly state that there are no innocent men.
00:19:30Unlike them, I would never claim that all women are false accusers
00:19:34or even that most women enjoy the attention and sympathy they get from their accusations.
00:19:40But I certainly do allege that all women in our culture have acquired a deadly weapon in the claim of abuse
00:19:49and that a significant minority are willing and even eager to use it,
00:19:55and that men now have little recourse other than to beg for forgiveness once the denunciations begin.