The Fiamengo File - August 07, 2017


Professor Dennis Gouws, A Case Study in Feminist Harassment - ep. 71

Poor Me Feminism - TFF Episode 70 Are Men Responsible For Ending Sexual Violence? TFF 72

Episode Stats


Length

18 minutes

Words per minute

134.8

Word count

2,522

Sentence count

65

Harmful content

Misogyny

9

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 why do so few university professors dissent from the campus orthodoxy well because even the mildest
00:00:08 form of ideological non-compliance such as teaching a men in literature course with
00:00:13 warren farrell on the reading list can bring years of persecution that's my subject on today's
00:00:20 Fiomingo File.
00:00:32 I'm Janice Fiomingo of the University of Ottawa.
00:00:35 We're constantly being told that women make better bosses than men.
00:00:40 An article in the Independent of April 2017 claimed that female bosses
00:00:47 excel at encouraging employee engagement and an engaged employee is a productive employee 0.99
00:00:55 you certainly wouldn't know that from examining the career of professor of english 0.98
00:01:01 dennis gowes whose female bosses have spent the last few years doing everything they can
00:01:07 to prevent him from being productive in the department of humanities at springfield college 0.85
00:01:13 which is an idyllic looking little college in springfield massachusetts professor gowes had
00:01:19 created and successfully taught a men in literature course eight times since 2005
00:01:27 and he only began to receive negative attention from his superiors when it became clear that he
00:01:34 was a non-feminist in 2013 professor gowes had helped to found the springfield college
00:01:41 men's group, and some within the department and college administration didn't like that.
00:01:46 At around the same time, in response to feminist posters being put up around his department,
00:01:51 Professor Gowes had put up posters about false rape claims on his own office door and elsewhere
00:01:57 in the department which led to allegations both that he was contributing to a hostile environment
00:02:03 and that a voice for men which had designed the posters was a hate group. In 2014, there were a
00:02:10 small number of student complaints about one of Professor Gao's assignments in a writing course.
00:02:16 And there was also a never-specified complaint about his Men in Literature course, and that
00:02:22 complaint resulted in demands, beginning in the spring of 2015, that Professor Gao's change Men
00:02:29 in Literature to make it more literary, taking out the non-fiction texts such as Warren Farrell's
00:02:36 the myth of male power. Despite the fact that he made the changes, adding more literature to the
00:02:43 course, he wasn't allowed to keep teaching it. And at the same time as the controversies about
00:02:49 his teaching methods and approach were heating up, his sabbatical application to work on a male
00:02:54 studies book project was denied in 2014 on the thinnest of pretexts. And since that time,
00:03:02 Professor Gaus has been scrutinized, criticized, harassed, and threatened with disciplinary action
00:03:09 by members of his college administration. Before I get started on this subject, I admit that there
00:03:15 are genuine concerns to be raised about the relationship between ideological advocacy and
00:03:20 course material. Personally, I'm very wary about using the classroom as a place for advocacy at
00:03:26 all, even the kind that I strongly agree with. But it's clear to me that what Professor Gaus has
00:03:33 experienced at his school has everything to do with the fact that he's taken a non-feminist,
00:03:38 male-positive approach to the study of literature and men's issues, and that the various attacks on
00:03:44 him as a teacher and scholar, which have been remarkably petty and persistent over the years,
00:03:50 simply wouldn't have happened if his work was feminist in orientation.
00:03:56 And as an English professor myself, I have an intimate understanding of how English departments
00:04:00 tend to function and how unfair and unnecessarily unpleasant Professor Gao's experience has been.
00:04:07 I should mention that Peter Wood, the president of the National Association of Scholars,
00:04:11 has written two articles on Professor Gao's case that I would encourage you to consult
00:04:16 for further detail. It's a very complicated case. In this video I just
00:04:22 want to say a few words about two of the actions that have been taken against
00:04:26 Professor Gowes out of a plethora that could be mentioned. First, the denial of
00:04:31 his sabbatical application and second, the extensive policing of how he teaches
00:04:37 his courses. So let's start with the sabbatical application. A sabbatical is
00:04:45 period during which an instructor is freed from teaching and other duties to work on a big project
00:04:50 such as a book. In order to receive a sabbatical the applicant has to write a pretty substantial
00:04:55 explanation of what he or she is going to do during the period of leave and people at various
00:05:02 levels in the administrative hierarchy at his college have to approve it. So the first stage
00:05:07 at Springfield College is getting the approval of one's department head or department chair as
00:05:12 they're sometimes called. In my experience, department heads are generally very enthusiastic
00:05:17 in their formal evaluation of any sabbatical application. Basically, so long as the department
00:05:23 member is active in their field, or even if they aren't particularly active, department heads
00:05:29 generally go out of their way to give their support. It's not really the department head's
00:05:34 job to decide who should or shouldn't receive the sabbatical. Moreover, Professor Dennis Gaus was an
00:05:41 ideal candidate for the sabbatical. He had received a book contract from the Australian
00:05:48 Institute of Male Health and Studies. This is a multi-disciplinary non-governmental organization
00:05:55 that, among other things, publishes books related to the well-being of men and boys.
00:06:02 Professor Gao's contract was to edit a collection of articles, the first of its kind, on male studies
00:06:09 to be co-edited with Myles Groth, the esteemed professor of psychology at Wagner College on
00:06:17 Staten Island. And Professor Gowes was himself contributing an essay to the collection on
00:06:22 male positive approaches to literary studies, one of his areas of expertise.
00:06:29 It's just not every day that one begins work on a book project with a publishing contract
00:06:34 already in hand. Lots of us write books and then hope to find a publisher. And that subject,
00:06:41 male studies, was something Professor Gowse had been teaching for years, and it was definitely
00:06:45 an original contribution to knowledge because, as we all know, the study of men has been
00:06:50 dominated by feminist approaches since forever. So this was a no-brainer for approval as an
00:06:59 excellent sabbatical project but his reviewers didn't see it that way.
00:07:05 The sabbatical was unenthusiastically reviewed by his department head
00:07:11 Dr. Joyce Zewinski and by the Dean of the School of
00:07:15 Arts, Science and Professional Studies Dr. Anne Herzog and both
00:07:19 didn't recommend approval. They were critical of the fact that the material
00:07:25 in the proposed book had a sociological slash psychological focus rather than a strictly
00:07:31 literary one and that therefore the project was not exactly relevant to Professor Gao's teaching
00:07:37 and research areas. This is what they said anyway and it's no exaggeration to say from my opinion
00:07:45 that this is an astounding reason to decline to support the project. I've been a professor of
00:07:51 literature for nearly 20 years. I've read dozens and dozens of proposals for
00:07:57 various types of projects in English Studies and I've seen how they were
00:08:01 evaluated. I've been part of committees making recommendations regarding
00:08:07 sabbatical proposals for many years and I've never witnessed this kind of an
00:08:12 objection raised as the reason for refusal. This practice of borrowing from
00:08:18 other disciplines like sociology or psychology which is sometimes called interdisciplinarity
00:08:24 it's a very common practice in english literary studies and it's generally highly commended and
00:08:30 certainly not a reason to refuse the approval of a project moreover it's a huge deal to have one's
00:08:38 sabbatical application turned down it's essentially a vote of non-confidence from one's school so it's
00:08:45 not usually done lightly. The real kicker in one of the reviewers and Herzog's comments is a
00:08:53 paragraph expressing surprise that Professor Gowes isn't making use of standard feminist approaches
00:09:00 to his subject and suggesting that by not doing so he somehow puts himself out of serious contention
00:09:05 for approval. She says, quote, there have been volumes of gender-focused work published in
00:09:11 literary studies over the past 25 years under the umbrella of the modern languages association the
00:09:16 recognized professional organization that routinely supports and promotes gender-focused
00:09:21 projects within literary studies it is surprising to me that dr gauze is not drawing from this rich
00:09:27 history of resources and instead is focusing his scholarly efforts on the australian institute of
00:09:32 male health and studies an organization that appears to be very much outside of his discipline
00:09:38 end quote well yeah she's surprised that dr gauss isn't drawing on anti-male feminist scholarship
00:09:46 for his male positive project that's rich professor gauss had explained in his proposal
00:09:53 that male studies is entirely different from conventional pro-feminist masculinity studies in
00:10:00 in which masculinity is claimed to be toxic.
00:10:06 Well, it's really hard to avoid the conclusion
00:10:10 that Professor Gao's evaluators simply didn't like
00:10:13 having a colleague who wasn't beating the drum 1.00
00:10:16 for feminist approaches to gender.
00:10:19 And they believed that their personal dislike
00:10:24 of his approach justified their recommending
00:10:28 against the approval of his sabbatical.
00:10:32 To say that their decision was unprofessional and petty
00:10:36 would be an understatement.
00:10:38 In fact, it was vindictive and it struck a harsh blow
00:10:42 against Professor Gao's research career and reputation.
00:10:47 So much for engaging employees.
00:10:52 Now, if it had been only this, and that's a huge only, 0.68
00:10:57 Professor Gaus would have had every right to feel that he'd been treated very badly by these two female superiors.
00:11:04 But the denial of the sabbatical was only one part of the harassment that he's experienced at Springfield College.
00:11:13 At least equally, maybe even more pernicious, has been the extremely heavy-handed scrutiny that his teaching has received.
00:11:22 As a result of one unspecified complaint about his course, Men in Literature, and he never knew
00:11:28 exactly what the complaint was, Professor Gowes was forced by his department head and the dean
00:11:35 to revise the course in its entirety. And over many months, he tried to work out what he needed
00:11:44 to do in order to keep the course he wanted to teach while satisfying his department head and
00:11:49 dean who would never put anything in writing and were quite evasive about what actually they were
00:11:55 requiring of him until finally in early 2016 he submitted a new course outline with more literary
00:12:01 texts added which was what they had specified but that was rejected when he raised the matter
00:12:08 of what he believed to be unfair treatment with the president of the college he found himself on
00:12:13 receiving end of a heavy-handed letter from the provost and vice president for
00:12:19 academic affairs jean wild who sided with his chair and his
00:12:25 dean in finding his course unacceptable she
00:12:29 actually singled out in a letter she wrote to him
00:12:33 objectionable texts on the course syllabus such as the myth of male power
00:12:38 by warren farrell and the war against boys by christina
00:12:42 hoff summers she reminded him that it was quote inappropriate for any instructor to intrude material
00:12:52 into a course that has no relation to the subject now in my experience it's pretty unusual for the
00:13:01 provost of one's college to be involving herself so extensively in the readings assigned for a
00:13:10 single course, and the insistence that a literature course should never include
00:13:15 non-literary material, that's pretty astounding. A mere glance at other course
00:13:22 titles and descriptions in the list of courses in the Department of Humanities
00:13:27 at Springfield College clearly demonstrates that a significant
00:13:32 proportion of these courses have some sort of non-literary sociological or
00:13:38 other component and that that's generally considered relevant to a literary subject
00:13:44 there is for starters women and literature english 275 which highlights its social and
00:13:52 cultural emphasis there's also african-american literature and there's even sports gambling and
00:14:02 the media english 217
00:14:08 these are not courses with an exclusively literary
00:14:13 focus
00:14:17 in general it has simply not been the case for many decades
00:14:22 that all literature courses focus solely and exclusively on literature and in
00:14:27 fact some of professor gau's own colleagues
00:14:30 in the humanities department at Springfield are on record as favoring the use of non-literary
00:14:36 materials in their teaching. For one eye-opening example of one such instructor's methods,
00:14:42 take a look at an essay on teaching by Springfield College instructor Justine
00:14:49 Diamond, which is entitled Don't Shoot the Messenger, The White Instructor, and Ethnic
00:14:56 literature this article was published in the winter 2007 edition of a journal called teaching
00:15:03 american literature a journal of theory and practice here professor diamond makes it crystal
00:15:09 clear that teaching american literature requires a lot of discussion teaching and assignments about
00:15:15 race identity social justice and so on she states up front that quote the teaching of literature
00:15:22 in my opinion necessarily includes the teaching of cultural and historical context end quote
00:15:32 her course on american literature this was i should stress at the university of massachusetts
00:15:38 where she taught before coming to springfield but still her course investigated quote the discrepancy
00:15:45 between received mythology about race and ethnicity and the more complex and challenging
00:15:51 real experiences of people in the u.s end quote and she describes in this article in detail how
00:15:58 her courses quote incorporate a variety of performance on a continuum from low stakes
00:16:04 activities to formal assignments having to do with physical movement in the classroom what she calls
00:16:10 i statements dialogue and creative art assignments she also drew heavily she explains on legal texts
00:16:19 so what i'd like to know is did justine diamond now an associate of professor gow's at springfield
00:16:27 college did she or anybody else in the department of humanities stand up for professor gow's
00:16:34 academic freedom to teach his course as he saw fit well we know the answer to that of course not
00:16:42 because this whole case isn't about whether an instructor can include non-literary texts in a
00:16:49 literature course which is standard practice this is about whether a male positive instructor can
00:16:56 teach without constant interference and roadblocks from his feminist bosses and that's where it 1.00
00:17:04 stands now it seems that professor gowes will remain vulnerable to the petty tyrannies of his 1.00
00:17:11 department chair dean and other higher ops who will likely continue to make his work life as
00:17:17 unpleasant as possible professor gauss has informed me that he continues right up until this
00:17:24 day to receive onerous directives and negative reviews of his teaching and the point is too
00:17:31 that what's happening to him is undoubtedly happening to many other academics those who
00:17:36 are marked out not only as different, but as wrong according to our era's rigid political
00:17:42 morality.
00:17:43 It's a morality that has given small-minded administrators a self-flattering excuse to
00:17:49 exercise their power at others' expense.
00:17:52 Okay, there's no surprise there, I suppose that is human. 1.00
00:17:57 But as noted at the beginning of the video, feminists have been telling us for decades 1.00
00:18:03 that women in positions of power tend to be so much better than men, so much more humane, 0.99
00:18:10 more cooperative, less competitive, less punitive, less hierarchical, more understanding, more
00:18:18 empathetic. Unfortunately, ladies, your actions show that it just ain't so.
00:18:25 if you enjoyed this video.
00:18:28 Please support us on Patreon.
00:18:32 If even half of our subscribers gave us 1 dollar per month, we'd be well on our way
00:18:37 to creating more and better content!
00:18:39 And don't forget to subscribe for us on Studio Brulee.