The Fiamengo File - July 17, 2017


Poor Me Feminism - TFF Episode 70

Toxic Masculinity and Suicide - TFF Episode 69 Professor Dennis Gouws, A Case Study in Feminist Harassment - ep. 71

Episode Stats


Length

16 minutes

Words per minute

133.66

Word count

2,152

Sentence count

79

Harmful content

Misogyny

27

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00 Does an ancient Roman grammarian hold the key to modern feminist complaints? 1.00
00:00:07 That's my subject on today's Fiamengo File.
00:00:20 I'm Janice Fiamengo of the University of Ottawa. 1.00
00:00:23 Poor me feminism. It seems never to abate, deluging us in a tsunami of advertisements,
00:00:32 hashtags, government reports, articles, and celebrity stunts cheering on women for waging
00:00:38 war against the innumerable sexist barriers, anti-female bias, and omnipresent misogyny 0.50
00:00:45 that purportedly confronts women in our culture. Yet, when one looks into feminist accounts of 0.96
00:00:52 systemic discrimination and rampant gynophobia, it's more and more difficult to find any 0.75
00:01:00 legitimate source of outrage. The expressions of self-pitying anti-male resentment without
00:01:07 any perceptible basis in reality and the deep respect with which these are received in our
00:01:13 society to such an extent that a hush seems to fall over a room whenever a woman stands up to
00:01:19 tell her story of suffering. Well, these have become so remarkable over the past year in
00:01:26 particular that I believe the phenomenon deserves its own linguistic designation,
00:01:31 and I'm going to offer one at the end of this monologue if you'll bear with me while I look
00:01:35 at a few examples. Three, to be exact. The first one, rape culture. Every fall,
00:01:44 a chorus of voices denounces the supposedly normalized sexual violence that makes university
00:01:50 campuses so unsafe for women, even though the rate of rape and sexual assault for university-age
00:01:57 women sits at 0.6%, according to the reputable National Crime Victimization Survey.
00:02:05 This past September, there was an article about rape culture at the University of Pennsylvania
00:02:11 with the Huffington Post reporting that a, quote, gross, unquote, email had been sent to some first
00:02:18 year female students from an off-campus and unofficial fraternity, inviting them to a frat
00:02:24 party. Horrors. Some women then plastered the email all over campus with the words, 0.97
00:02:31 this is what rape culture looks like. Feminist activist Amanda Silberling was the leader of 1.00
00:02:38 the campaign, and she wanted freshman girls to know, quote, they don't have to give in 0.85
00:02:43 to the culture they're thrown into, end quote. And university officials predictably fell all 1.00
00:02:50 over themselves, applauding Silberling's feminist defiance and denouncing the offensive email.
00:02:58 A university official asserted that, quote, sexual harassment and sexual assault
00:03:02 will not be tolerated on campus. The university's intra-fraternity council president said,
00:03:09 quote, we categorically denounce the behavior this email so brazenly perpetuates, end quote.
00:03:18 Word of the anti-rape culture campaign even reached Pennsylvania Governor Tom Wolfe and 0.87
00:03:25 Senator Bob Casey, both of whom expressed their strong support for the feminist students and 0.99
00:03:31 their abhorrence of rape culture. By the way, what did the email say? You might be wondering,
00:03:38 did it suggest that women deserve to be raped or that rape doesn't really do any harm? Well, 0.99
00:03:45 not exactly. Here's what the email is reported to have said, as quoted in the Huffington Post.
00:03:53 quote may we have your attention please we're looking for the fun ones and say f off to a tease
00:04:03 wednesday nights will get you going with bankers flowing all night tonight is your first showing
00:04:11 so please wear something tight end quote well at first i thought perhaps the huffington post
00:04:20 had switched in the wrong email, one intended for the arts and culture page to represent perhaps the
00:04:25 unfortunate effects of metrical irregularities in attempts at poetic verse, but luckily for benighted
00:04:32 individuals like me, the Huffington Post author explained the egregious harm of that email, saying
00:04:39 quote, this sort of language is extremely damaging. It encourages the idea that women are objects for
00:04:46 the taking, and that their bodies are purely for others' consumption. These attitudes are 1.00
00:04:52 particularly dangerous on college campuses where sexual assault is a major issue." 1.00
00:04:57 That's a word-perfect summation of the standard feminist position on rape culture and standard
00:05:05 feminist exaggeration of the prevalence of rape on university campuses, but the email doesn't 0.98
00:05:11 express the idea that women are objects for the taking. It merely tells college girls what they 0.98
00:05:17 probably already know, that college boys like it when they wear tight outfits and
00:05:21 don't like girls who tease, and that some girls are easy, they're bankers, and others aren't.
00:05:29 Yeah, it's crude, in a happy days sort of way, and the fact that such a tame and entirely
00:05:35 non-threatening bit of verse doggerel would inspire such Olympic-sized hyperventilating outrage 0.54
00:05:41 shows us that American college campuses are the exact opposite of rape cultures. They are places 0.92
00:05:47 where even the slightest hint of male sexual bravado is thunderously denounced by everybody
00:05:54 breathing. If this is the worst that feminist students could find, they don't have anything 1.00
00:05:59 legitimate to complain about. So, that's Exhibit A. The second example, Women in STEM. Recently, I 1.00
00:06:10 read an article published as a guest blog in the journal Scientific American called
00:06:17 One More Barrier Faced by Women in Science. This issue is, of course, one of the most popular
00:06:24 subjects of feminist grievance nowadays, the supposed bias facing female scientists, 1.00
00:06:29 even though a recent Cornell University study has shown that women are twice as likely as equally
00:06:36 qualified men to be hired for academic positions in STEM.
00:06:41 But for this author who researches climate change in the Arctic, no inconvenience is
00:06:47 too small to figure as part of a vast patriarchal design to exclude women.
00:06:52 She essentially admits as much when she tells us at the beginning of the article that, quote,
00:06:58 gender barriers in science don't always take an obvious form, and they get especially perilous
00:07:05 in below zero temperatures, bit of a non sequitur there.
00:07:09 She goes on, some of these, these barriers involve individuals malice or misogyny.
00:07:16 But there is another set of barriers that simply result from being a woman in a male
00:07:21 dominated field, end quote. 0.88
00:07:24 In this case, the barrier relates to the difficulty of peeing in the Arctic research field without
00:07:31 conventional toilets.
00:07:33 where the sexist discrimination comes in has to do with the fact that most overalls or bibs worn
00:07:39 by the researchers are designed for men well actually there are a few designed for women but
00:07:44 apparently they're more expensive and this strikes our writer as a patriarchal capitalist conspiracy
00:07:49 par excellence to deny her biological reality as she informs us with the zeal of a five-year-old 0.96
00:07:56 who has just had her first session playing doctor she tells us quote unfortunately most bibs are
00:08:03 designed with a fly, which is useless when my urinary tract doesn't end in a conveniently
00:08:08 directable hose, end quote. Well, Freud would have had a field day with that, but never mind.
00:08:15 I suppose suggesting that this woman might have remade the overalls to accommodate her anatomy, 0.96
00:08:20 or might have spent a bit of money to take them to a professional seamstress, well, 0.99
00:08:23 I guess that would be denying her lived experience of oppression. Incidentally, 1.00
00:08:28 the British novelist Ian McEwan in his hilarious novel, Solar, makes the case that peeing in the
00:08:34 Arctic isn't that easy for men either, as a freezing hose, so-called, can cause prodigious
00:08:41 discomfort. Nonetheless, the author describes her peeing troubles in elaborate detail and feels
00:08:47 deeply, deeply, story for herself. I'm just glad we were spared the problems associated with number
00:08:54 two. If this had been a humorous article telling about the unexpected difficulties encountered by
00:09:00 an intrepid scientist studying permafrost, it would have been great. But our author didn't
00:09:04 bring her funny bone on her research trip, and one gets the sense reading her article that she's
00:09:09 far more interested in feminist grievance politics than in actual science. So that's exhibit number 1.00
00:09:15 to one last example male privilege where you'd least expect it an article from the wesleyan 0.56
00:09:25 recorder by a female college student complains about her experience in seminars where she has
00:09:31 discovered in typical feminist manner that a gendered disparity exists between the verbal
00:09:36 contributions of men and women according to this girl men speak more than women in the university
00:09:44 classroom, and she's outraged about that. This story is really something. At least in
00:09:52 the former examples, trivial as they were, something could be pointed to as a tangible
00:09:59 irritation. There were pants made for men or a crude email. But in this case, there's
00:10:06 nothing whatsoever. There are young women, supposedly equally capable and intelligent,
00:10:13 choosing not to speak when they could. And there are young men, their numbers plummeting on
00:10:20 university campuses all across the Western world, yet still speaking in class. Is there any evidence
00:10:27 that the men are actually preventing the women from speaking? No, of course not. According to
00:10:34 the author, there is some evidence that, quote, instructors at virtually every grade level have
00:10:41 been found more likely to call on boys, more likely to tolerate interruptions coming from
00:10:48 boys, more likely to address boys by name, and more likely to give long, thoughtful responses
00:10:54 to boys' questions and comments." We're to understand that this tendency creates in girls 0.54
00:11:01 diffidence and self-doubt. Well, this is very, very hard to take seriously, because if it were
00:11:11 Were the case that instructors have an unconscious bias against girls, as this author asserts,
00:11:17 would that not also translate to a general tendency to work against girls' academic
00:11:22 success, resulting in lower grades given to girls, fewer scholarships created and given
00:11:28 exclusively to girls, less public encouragement of girls, and so on, when in fact, of course,
00:11:34 the exact opposite is the case.
00:11:38 I suspect it's quite possible that teachers spend more time answering boys' questions,
00:11:44 if it's really true that they do, because, well, perhaps boys' questions and contributions
00:11:50 inspire more substantial answers.
00:11:53 It's impossible to know how to interpret the data, if it's even reliable data.
00:11:57 And in any case, the situation of young women today who are clearly outpacing young men
00:12:03 at every academic level going to university in greater numbers, graduating from university
00:12:08 in greater numbers and so on, it hardly supports the contention that female students are the 1.00
00:12:14 unwanted sex. But self-pity always finds a way. 0.75
00:12:21 I could go on ad infinitum. I've come to believe that this phenomenon of complaining
00:12:27 about extremely minor or non-existent sexism and deploying masses of government money and
00:12:33 media space to publicize it should be understood as a type of logical fallacy, springing from
00:12:39 a mental derangement that is unfortunately as widespread as it is difficult to diagnose
00:12:45 or treat, which I've speculated about in past videos. Suffice it to say here the illness
00:12:50 manifests in bizarre arguments about male privilege and female disadvantage in which
00:12:56 the speaker's premise is identical to her conclusion, and both premise and conclusion
00:13:03 are excluded from any reasonable consideration through the self-cancelling illogic of the
00:13:09 argument. If we really lived in a rape culture, a ridiculous stunt over a bit of crude verse would 0.98
00:13:16 not elicit the applause of the state's governor. If women were really excluded from STEM, a humorless 1.00
00:13:23 complained about female urination would not be featured in Scientific American, and if young men 0.99
00:13:30 were really favored over young women at college, pathetic grousing about the other sex contributing 0.97
00:13:35 more wouldn't be given respectful attention in a university publication. The fact that the 0.98
00:13:42 complaints are so inconsequential and that the complainants seem incapable of perceiving their
00:13:48 inconsequentiality proves the opposite of what the complaints allege. These are all privileged,
00:13:54 not oppressed young women, thinking they're tiny inconveniences worthy of outrage.
00:14:02 In the interest of precision, I believe we should name what we're witnessing as a form of logical
00:14:06 fallacy called the excludendum a priori, or fallacy excludendum for short, giving it the
00:14:12 appropriate Latin designation. Now, if I'm remembering correctly, the term was first
00:14:17 formulated by the ancient Roman grammarian Hadrianus, who lived in the Roman city of
00:14:23 Caserta in the third century AD. He wrote an extensive treatise on this subject that,
00:14:29 unfortunately, has come down to us only through the accounts of his contemporaries. Copies of
00:14:34 the treatise are thought to have been deliberately destroyed by the wives of Roman leaders of the
00:14:40 time. Hadrianus was born into a wealthy aristocratic family, but he isolated himself from his three
00:14:46 constantly complaining pampered sisters, eventually spending all of his days writing on a tablet in a
00:14:52 remote cave, lacking all conveniences, a situation that he initially bore with uncomplaining
00:14:58 stoicism. Unfortunately, it is also believed that he himself went mad attempting to document
00:15:04 the particular expression of madness he had discovered in his sisters. He is said to have
00:15:09 ended his days alternating between periods of deep silence, bouts of raucous laughter,
00:15:15 heart-rending groans, and imprecations so vehement and coarse that they were said to
00:15:20 echo down into the nearby town and send people running for cover. So I recommend that when you
00:15:27 encounter someone practicing poor-me feminism, complaining bitterly about minor or non-existent
00:15:34 sexism, call that person out on the excludendum fallacy, but then leave it at that. Don't
00:15:41 engage too extensively, lest you end up like poor Hadrianus.
00:16:04 You